Juno News - January 09, 2020


Andy Ngo Speech Cancelled at UBC! - Interview with Angelo Isidorou

Topics
Mentioned
Canadian city wants federal funding to combat “rumours” about immigrants The UN thinks pipelines are racist…somehow

Episode Stats


Length

15 minutes

Words per minute

179.91

Word count

2,764

Sentence count

201

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

6

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, Lindsay Shepard speaks with the Executive Director of the UBC Free Speech Club, Angelo Isidori, about the cancellation of an Antifa-themed lecture by American writer and journalist Andy Ngo at the Robson Square campus.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hi everyone, it's Lindsay Shepard, Investigative Journalism Fellow with True North, and today I
00:00:10 have Angelo Isidori with me. He is the Executive Director of the UBC Free Speech Club. Now, the
00:00:16 Free Speech Club, on January 29th, so later this month, they were going to host Andy Ngo at the
00:00:24 UBC Robson Square campus. So Andy, he is an American writer and journalist. He's currently
00:00:30 editor at the Post Millennial. Now, he's well known because in June 2019, he was attacked by Antifa
00:00:37 members in Portland, Oregon. He got a milkshake thrown at him, he was kicked, he got a brain 0.85
00:00:43 hemorrhage, and he had his GoPro camera stolen from him. He was to present on Understanding Antifa
00:00:50 Violence, a lecture on radicalism, on January 29th. But UBC actually cancelled the UBC Free
00:00:59 Speech Club's booking. So, Angelo, first let's start off, what is the UBC Free Speech Club's
00:01:06 mission or mandate, and what sorts of events have you hosted in the past?
00:01:10 So, our mandate is to essentially platform different people with different ideas. We are essentially
00:01:17 event promoters. We want to really appeal to our members, who are at this point are in the
00:01:24 thousands, and just create interesting content, diverse content with, you know, lots of different
00:01:29 speakers that have interesting takes on things. So, for example, we began by hosting Jordan Peterson,
00:01:37 who we went on to host, I think, like five times overall. Then we've hosted Ben Shapiro, Stephen Hicks,
00:01:43 ContraPoints, a few others. And now what we were hoping to do in 2020 is do a lecture series on
00:01:50 radicalism, which we would upload to our YouTube. We upload everything to our YouTube. And Andy was
00:01:56 our first event, and he was going to talk about Antifa violence, since that's sort of what he's most
00:02:02 acquainted with. And, you know, in the ultimate form of irony, his talk on Antifa violence was
00:02:07 canceled because of Antifa violence. So, this situation is sort of problematic for us because
00:02:15 we rely on, like, public institutions, publicly funded institutions to host these events. A lot
00:02:21 of these events are controversial, so we know not to go to a private venue because they might just not
00:02:26 want to do it. Whereas with publicly funded venues, they have a mandate, they have a legal
00:02:31 responsibility to not be biased in their booking. So, this is going to become a problem for us for
00:02:38 the foreseeable future. So, with the Andy Ngo talk, when did you do the room booking? Was this,
00:02:45 like, a couple months ago or back in December? Yeah, I think we did the room booking in November,
00:02:51 and we did it for the Robson Square venue, which we've used tons and tons of times before. We're
00:02:58 super friendly with the people who work there. And we've actually never had problems there before.
00:03:02 We haven't even had security there. Just a couple months before that, we did Yasmin Mohamed.
00:03:07 We did her book launch there. So, you know, we booked it. It was approved. We paid the down payment.
00:03:14 We signed the contract. And it was all fine for a good while. Then, at some point, I think,
00:03:20 on right before Christmas Eve, actually, I get a call from the chief risk officer, which I missed the
00:03:26 first call. And then, the second call, he left a voice message that was very frantic, saying,
00:03:33 look, I have to get this message to you. The executive is just canceling this event, and that's
00:03:38 that. So, then I called him back, and we had about a half-hour chat about it. And, you know,
00:03:44 in the past, we always budget for security, because I know, even when I got this call, like,
00:03:50 okay, here we go. I'm going to get a call from the school that says, pay us a bunch of money for
00:03:55 security. So, I was totally prepared for that. But never in a million years did I think they were
00:03:59 going to be like, no, security is, like, not even an option. We're, our new take on this is just to
00:04:04 outright cancel stuff, because we have this Antifa problem now on campus.
00:04:11 And so, do you know what kind of threats they might have been getting?
00:04:15 You know, were they getting?
00:04:16 They didn't give me any specifics. They just said, if we look at the precedent recently with
00:04:24 Jen Smith and other speakers, we've been noticing more and more violence on campus from these groups.
00:04:32 And essentially, we don't feel comfortable doing this because we don't know how to secure it.
00:04:37 And so, that's that. And he even apologized, because essentially, we've had such a good
00:04:44 relationship with UBC Robson Square that when we book something, they just approve the event right
00:04:49 away. A, because I guess they like us, and B, because they have to, because they're a publicly
00:04:54 funded institution. So, I guess it took a while for that approved contract to get to the desk of
00:05:00 the executive, because UBC Robson Square and UBC Campus are a little separate. And when it got
00:05:06 finally to the desk of the executive, which was on the 22nd of December, they immediately had a
00:05:13 meeting and canceled it and told the chief risk officer to inform me of that. So, we weren't even
00:05:22 consulted on it. Security wasn't even an option. They're just saying, look, we don't know how to
00:05:27 handle these groups. And we're going to see. We're not saying Andy, no, never. But for the foreseeable
00:05:34 future, we want to see if maybe if we cancel these events and don't host them for a while, 0.99
00:05:39 Antifa will simmer down and go away, which I thought was stupid. But, you know, to each their 0.87
00:05:45 own, I guess. Has there actually been any UBC policy change on room bookings? Have they formally
00:05:52 changed any policy? No. And no, if anything, they floated that they've gone the other way with it,
00:05:59 where they, you know, they have this panel now on academic freedom. You know, they've essentially
00:06:05 said we're totally for free speech and all that sort of thing. But for now, this is the new direction.
00:06:12 We're going to see what happens. If this doesn't work, then we'll speak to the RCMP and maybe go
00:06:17 the other way. My take, and I think most people who understand how this works, is that if you cancel
00:06:23 events, you're emboldening people, you're emboldening protesters who are violent, and you're
00:06:28 making them think that they have power. So I told them they're not going anywhere. And I wanted to
00:06:33 know specific examples, because I mean, we've gotten threats ourselves. But I wanted to know if the
00:06:40 school has specific threats, and they wouldn't say so, you know, right now, my curiosity is mostly
00:06:47 associated with, did the school actually get threats, and they felt they couldn't secure it
00:06:53 and cancelled it? Or did they just cancel it because the school is worried about their image
00:06:57 problem, and wants to get back into the pride parade or whatever? You know? Well, I mean, actually,
00:07:01 you could probably file a freedom of information request regarding that. So maybe that's something to
00:07:06 do in the future. Absolutely. And so you mentioned one of the precedents to this might have been
00:07:13 the Jen Smith talk. So Jen Smith is like a local transgender activist. Their name is Jen, but they 0.99
00:07:20 go by he, him pronouns. I was aware that Jen did a talk at UBC, but wasn't the only incident that
00:07:27 happened was maybe one protester kind of waved a flag in someone's face. And that was it. I didn't
00:07:32 think anything actually happened. Yeah, that was. Yeah. No, no. But I think they were surprised by the
00:07:38 fact that there were protesters. Because this guy, the chief risk officer even mentioned, like,
00:07:42 we secured your Ben Shapiro event, we did your other events. Like, we've never really had
00:07:48 protesters before. We've had teach-ins, which aren't really problematic, but we've never really
00:07:53 had a big protester problem. Jen Smith was like the first example where there were hundreds of 1.00
00:07:58 protesters. And the school at UBC. Right. So the school was kind of, you know, if you look at videos,
00:08:05 they weren't really great at securing the venue. And then, I mean, that was amplified by the fact
00:08:12 that then UBC had this whole media issue where they got kicked out of the pride parade because they
00:08:18 platformed Jen Smith, which again, the school doesn't really have a say. But then that went on to the 0.83
00:08:25 other event, which I think was Ricardo Deschamps. And that one had some issues as well with tons of
00:08:33 protesters. So, you know, what peeved me about it is that if you look at our event in between those
00:08:38 events, the Jen Smith and the Ricardo Deschamps, we had Yasmin Mohamed. There were no issues at all.
00:08:44 There's nothing. I think you were at the Yasmin Mohamed event. There's nothing wrong at all with it.
00:08:49 So, you know, it's one of those things where it's kind of stupid. But then, look, I am aware that they 0.99
00:08:56 probably would have protested the Andy no one because he's controversial. He represents everything
00:09:02 they sort of hate and fear. So we were prepared for that. We had a budget for that. But, you know,
00:09:10 when the executive makes this decision, it becomes a problem because who are they to decide what's
00:09:17 controversial? You know, they essentially said, look, just bring someone who's not controversial.
00:09:22 And, you know, they said, well, we'll take bookings from you. Just don't bring anyone who
00:09:27 pisses off Antifa. And then Antifa wins, of course, with that. Yeah. Well, then they basically are
00:09:34 holding the school hostage. Yeah. So, I mean, Ron Holton. So he's the UBC chief safety officer. He
00:09:40 released a statement. Part of it said, based on this assessment of increased risk, we have canceled
00:09:46 the January 29th event booked by the UBC Free Speech Club, a group independent of the university,
00:09:52 in order to safeguard the safety and security of our community. And they always try to do this thing
00:09:56 where they distance you. Right. I think they call you a group independent of the university,
00:10:00 but aren't you composed of basically 100 percent people who are from UBC or alumni of UBC, that kind
00:10:07 of thing? Yeah, I mean, almost 100 percent. It's hard to say because we base it off of the Facebook. So
00:10:13 we'll definitely have like alumni and stuff like that. But I think they love to tout the fact that we
00:10:19 aren't part of the Alma Mater Society, which thank God we aren't, because if we were, they could have
00:10:24 just unilaterally canceled every event we ever do. So I think they hate the fact that we're a private
00:10:30 organization that is utilizing the public space. And they try to do that as much as they can. I mean,
00:10:36 the safety thing, it sucks that that guy is getting pulled into it so much because he was actually quite 0.97
00:10:41 cordial with me on the phone and even conceded to the fact that Antifa are basically violent thugs.
00:10:47 Um, but it's interesting because he's the chief risk officer. And yet, um, he told me that he was
00:10:55 just the messenger. So it's not that he did some kind of an appraisal. He said this came from the
00:10:59 executive, from the president, vice president, et cetera. And they said they don't want to do it.
00:11:04 They did their own assessment and they found that he was too controversial and they don't want to,
00:11:11 they don't want the school to host it. So if we're going into that territory, they're basically
00:11:14 treating the school like it's private property, um, or like they own it. And I think what people
00:11:20 need to understand and what they need to understand is that it's not any venue that is funded with
00:11:25 taxpayer dollars is technically, basically owned by all of us. It's owned by the government. So you
00:11:31 can't be politically biased in who you, who you book. Now their tact is, oh, well, health and safety,
00:11:37 you know, it's the, we got to protect our students first. Well, if we're going to do that now, if it's
00:11:42 going to be like the heckler's veto, you can bring anyone, you can bring Oprah to the school and people
00:11:48 could, I can get together and get people to make anonymous profiles and make a controversy out of
00:11:54 it. Like it's not, if that's the tact we're going to take, you basically can never host an event
00:11:59 again. You know, I think Chelsea Handler is coming to the Chan Center. It's like, what's stopping you
00:12:05 from a group of people from doing the same shit. So that doesn't really work. And what we're hoping 0.97
00:12:12 is, uh, well, we're hoping they would rescind the decision. Um, but at this point I'm down.
00:12:17 Yeah. So, yeah. So let's talk about, um, what you're doing next to try to get them to rescind this
00:12:22 decision. Um, so you've teamed up with the justice center for constitutional freedom. So they're a
00:12:27 Calgary based legal advocacy group, uh, full disclosure for viewers. I am a contract worker with the JCCF.
00:12:33 I'm their campus free speech fellow, but I'm not involved in any legal work. Um, so what is the,
00:12:38 the JCCF, the justice center doing for you at this point?
00:12:43 Well, they're officially representing us in this. What's great about them is that they do pro bono.
00:12:49 So they're, they're basically donations based and they know how important this battle is. And they
00:12:55 represent groups like myself and other groups that need help, um, with free speech issues. And they sent
00:13:02 a demand letter to UBC, which we haven't gotten an answer to other than the generic thing that
00:13:07 they're sending to the media about safety. Um, and they said, look, we're all on this. The entire
00:13:12 law firm is on the same page. If they don't rescind the decision, this is going to have to go to court.
00:13:18 We're going to have to take legal action for the sake of setting a new precedent, because a lot of
00:13:22 people are saying, well, why don't you just book another venue, go book the library and do it there.
00:13:27 Well, the issue is now that you have a public institution that has set sort of a, a social
00:13:33 precedent or an institutional precedent that the library could simply follow just because UBC did.
00:13:39 And we're going to see what happens, right? Like what we need to do now is we can't do the event
00:13:44 until we get a court ruling, until we get a judicial review that says, look, like you can't do that.
00:13:51 This is a freedom issue. It's the heckler's veto. We're fully prepared to, to take it, uh,
00:13:56 it's a legal action. Well, that's definitely going to be something to watch. Um, so yeah,
00:14:01 we'll, we'll keep our eye on this, this case with the justice center. I hope you actually get a reply,
00:14:05 um, to that letter and we'll see where this goes. And I hope that Andy is rescheduled eventually.
00:14:12 Would you have a plan to do that if, if you, uh, win this case, let's say? Oh, a hundred percent.
00:14:18 I think we have to do that. If we win this case, that'll be the ultimate victory, right? And I think we
00:14:23 will win. If you look at all the signs of how a free society works, you know, we're, we're going to win it.
00:14:30 It's just going to be a real headache, but you know what, if we do win, it'll set a legal precedent
00:14:35 across all Canadian campuses. So this could be a silver lining, um, for a big legal battle. So we'll see
00:14:42 what happens. I'll keep you in the loop. Great. Uh, thank you so much, Angelo. You mentioned you post
00:14:47 all of the free speech club talks on the YouTube channel. So I'm guessing just look up UBC free
00:14:52 speech club on YouTube and viewers can watch the free speech club, the free speech club.
00:14:56 So like in your background there. Yeah, exactly. Perfect. Right, right over there.
00:15:02 All right. And of course, uh, you can check us out true north at tnc.news or on the true north
00:15:07 YouTube channel, which is where you're watching this video right now. All right. Thanks so much,
00:15:11 Angelo. And bye for now. Thank you. Bye everyone.