Juno News - December 14, 2025


Another MP Crosses the Floor

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Majority in BC "concerned" about private property rights U.S. Ambassador weighs in on collapsed trade talks and steel layoffs

Episode Stats


Length

54 minutes

Words per minute

188.68

Word count

10,213

Sentence count

626

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

10

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Isaac Lamoureux, Alex Zoltan, and Waleed Tam discuss the latest NHL news, including Carter Hart's return to the Vegas Golden Knights, the latest on the Hockey Canada trial, and more!

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 So, Alex, a lot of NHL news, especially with the big trade we saw today between Pittsburgh and Oilers,
00:00:06 but more interestingly, a story you've been all over this week and perhaps the biggest Vegas fan in Canada
00:00:11 because you've been watching all the games of Carter Hart there,
00:00:14 who was the first of the World Juniors accused and not guilty that returned to the league, I believe.
00:00:21 So, yeah, how's Hart been doing in Vegas as a goalie down there?
00:00:24 Pretty good. I mean, he hasn't played for two years, which is a really long time.
00:00:28 So, I'm surprised at how quickly he's acclimatized back to the NHL.
00:00:32 He's won two out of three games. All of them have gone to overtime.
00:00:36 So, yeah, he's done pretty good.
00:00:38 Yeah, do you think there are some, not only Canadian teams, but teams looking at his performance
00:00:43 and kind of regretting the decisions they made because a lot of teams were skeptical to re-sign him given the controversy?
00:00:51 I mean, I guess that would be a question for those teams' management, right?
00:00:54 I mean, I don't know for sure.
00:00:56 There's also, of course, all of the kind of PR nightmare that comes with, you know, the backlash.
00:01:02 I think Canadians pay a lot more attention to hockey than Americans do,
00:01:05 although Vegas does have a pretty committed fan base.
00:01:09 Here's a question you might actually know.
00:01:11 The other individuals that were involved in the Hockey Canada trial, where are they at?
00:01:16 Like, are any of them expected to come back to the league soon or anything around those lines?
00:01:20 So, Cal Foote, who is the defenseman accused of doing the splits over the complainant, which is kind of just ridiculous,
00:01:29 he has signed with the Chicago Wolves, which is an affiliate, I believe, of the Carolina Hurricanes.
00:01:34 I think it's an AHL contract, so I don't think that he can be called up to the NHL team at this time,
00:01:39 but still promising to see him back playing again.
00:01:42 Michael McLeod, he was the only player charged with two offenses.
00:01:46 He was also charged with party to an offense for inviting other players over for a three-way quick.
00:01:53 Also invited them over for food, interestingly enough.
00:01:57 He is playing in the KHL in Russia.
00:02:01 I actually, for reasons that I don't really want to get into, don't think that he'll ever play in the NHL again.
00:02:05 And Dylan Dubé is the only player who is an unrestricted free agent.
00:02:10 Doesn't seem like anybody in any league is interested in him for some reason.
00:02:14 He's the player accused of being the laugh, leave the bar, and also losing the championship trophy.
00:02:20 That seems a lot to me because I feel like Dubé was a good player.
00:02:24 So, do you think that these teams maybe know more information and that's why they're skeptical?
00:02:28 I don't know.
00:02:29 Yeah, it's hard to say.
00:02:30 I mean, yeah, it's really tough to say.
00:02:32 There's one other player, Alex Formington, he's playing in Switzerland, which is interesting for a lot of different reasons.
00:02:38 He actually has a pending lawsuit with his agent for like $21.5 million.
00:02:43 So, his courtroom drama is not quite over yet.
00:02:47 Well, I know people will be mad if we stay and sit for an hour and talk about hockey.
00:02:51 So, I'm Isaac Lamoureux.
00:02:53 I'd like to welcome my colleagues from True North, Alex Zoltan, and Waleed Tam Tam.
00:02:56 And let's hop right into things.
00:02:57 So, we'll start right off with the big, great thing story.
00:03:06 Another Conservative MP crossed the floor to the Liberals.
00:03:09 And, of course, this brings the Liberals within one seat.
00:03:15 And this was Ontario MP Michael Ma, who said, this is the most interesting part to me, Waleed.
00:03:21 He wrote this, but I'll say a few things.
00:03:23 He said it was because his constituents were telling him that, more or less.
00:03:29 But then I was like, okay, let's see if that tracks.
00:03:33 So, I looked at polling today on 338 Canada to see if, for example, in the riding, Markham Univille, the Liberals skyrocketed.
00:03:41 And that was not the case at all.
00:03:42 Between, for example, November 30th and then last week, the Conservatives went down 1%, and they're still clearly leading the Liberals.
00:03:50 So, I think that would be an unfair claim for him to make, at least based on polling.
00:03:55 Yeah, what else went on here, Waleed?
00:03:57 Yeah, well, this is a very interesting story because I would say, I mean, Chris Dantremont, the last forecaster, was known.
00:04:06 I mean, we knew who he was.
00:04:07 He was running as a Conservative for a number of elections, including the last one under Pierre Faliev.
00:04:13 He ran provincially for the PC party in Nova Scotia.
00:04:17 So, he has a career that has sustained, you know, actually a few decades.
00:04:21 In the case of Michael Ma, I think a lot of people are learning his name for the first time.
00:04:25 And looking at his background, I mean, this is his first time sitting in the House of Commons.
00:04:30 So, Pierre Faliev essentially gave him the job when they got him in the writing, and he won.
00:04:35 And, of course, this was the writing, if you guys remember, that had the concerned candidates, the two Chinese descendant candidates,
00:04:42 one of which was fired or resigned forcefully from his role as the candidate because of his ties to Beijing and to Beijing Front-linked organizations.
00:04:53 And, of course, even his book of commentary about how the Conservative candidate, Joe Tay, should have been or could have been taken into a Chinese consulate for a bounty on his head.
00:05:05 So, this was that situation going on.
00:05:07 And, of course, the writing elected him as a Conservative.
00:05:10 And, like you said, Isaac, I mean, the polling isn't looking too bad for those situations.
00:05:14 I actually think that both Dr. Ma and Michael Ma could last as Conservative if an election was held today.
00:05:20 I just think there's a bit more to the story.
00:05:22 And what's interesting about this one is that, I mean, this was just the day before where he had the Christmas party with the Liberals.
00:05:30 The day before that, he had a Christmas party with the Conservatives.
00:05:34 And he had a picture with himself, his wife, smiling with Pierre Paliev and Anida Paliev, Paliev's wife.
00:05:40 And, of course, you know, looking like everything was well in the House.
00:05:44 You know, he's pretty much a backbencher, nothing too crazy for a first-term MP.
00:05:49 But, overall, there's never really been a sign.
00:05:52 I mean, looking at the region, I think if you're thinking about Conservative defectors, you're looking at Quebec and the Atlantic East.
00:05:58 Specifically, you can see that's where you have the most amount of what you call red Tories.
00:06:03 Or at least those that are affiliated provincially with a more progressive tone of Conservative politics.
00:06:08 I mean, you know, Tim Houston doesn't go out and rally for Pierre.
00:06:12 Doug Ford doesn't either.
00:06:13 So, I guess you could even say the same thing about Ontario to that extent.
00:06:16 But I really feel like this was one where, you know, a lot of people didn't see it coming.
00:06:20 Because, like I said, we don't know who Michael Malm was.
00:06:23 So, I guess maybe not just listen to constituents, but maybe even someone on his team or himself just feel comfortable, you know, being on the government benches instead.
00:06:32 What's most interesting about this is, like it says in the title, one more seat and they can get a majority.
00:06:37 And that's going to change the dynamics of Parliament. 0.88
00:06:40 That's going to set the election date three more years or four more years further than it would have been given where we are now in the minority situation.
00:06:49 Even then, you know, we could argue that the Greens or the NDP or the Bloc or whoever wants to take a turn at it can still prop the government up for their own interests.
00:06:56 As we've experienced between 2019 and 2021, those sections where we had minority governments that probably outlasted their terms.
00:07:07 But, yeah, so it's all interesting stuff.
00:07:09 But, again, I think with consumers right now, they have a quite sour taste of the mouth.
00:07:13 Kind of wondering, you know, like how many of these people are properly politically vetted in the sense of, you know, do they really believe in the values that consider the party in leadership of Pierre Paliyev?
00:07:22 Or are they just like installed as candidates? And this is the question that I think a lot of disenfranchised conservative people have in Canada.
00:07:29 I'm sure you're here for this PPC argument about how the, you know, there's a union party in Canada.
00:07:34 Well, I think this argument is becoming more popular because, you know, you're looking at people like Chris D'Entremont and Michael Ma and asking yourself, you know, like what really makes these people stand out as conservatives?
00:07:43 If that's how easy they can flip off to a new party, to a new direction, under a new government and have major consequences.
00:07:49 I mean, Chris D'Entremont was budget time. Michael Ma is now post-budget time up leading up to leadership review of Pierre Paliyev.
00:07:56 I think Pierre is still safe as leader, but I still think that this is going to piss off a lot of conservative, you know, volunteers, donors, supporters.
00:08:03 Because the fact of the matter is they put a lot of energy and faith behind Pierre and the party and the party still made significant gains.
00:08:10 But to see the cracks open up and two MPs leave in a span of a month and a week, it kind of shows the fact that maybe there are some people that are on the ballot and there are some people who are in the House who aren't exactly subscribed to what they're advertising on their campaigns.
00:08:24 Yeah, Alex, I'll ask you something quick to loop you in here, because we've seen a lot of Canadians raise concerns about the fact that MPs can just cross the floor and there is no by-election forced.
00:08:38 Because I think that would change these dynamics, as you said, Waleed Ma, or the Conservative Party, more specifically, in that riding, would likely win an election.
00:08:45 So if a by-election were on the table, if you were to cross the floor and that was forced, I don't think that these two MPs may have made that decision.
00:08:53 And this is, in my opinion, a subversion of democracy, because how Canada politics work, you're not voting for the MP.
00:09:00 Like, let's be realistic. No one in that riding knows who that guy is.
00:09:03 They're not voting for the MP. They're voting for the federal Conservative Party.
00:09:05 Like, the MP is just kind of, like, in most cases, and I would say at least the majority of voters, specifically for myself, like, I would say many of these voters don't even know who the MP is.
00:09:17 It's like, I'm just going to vote for the Conservatives because I want, they're supporting the leader, Pierre Paliyev, and the party as a whole, more so than the MP.
00:09:23 So, Alex, I'm just surprised that, obviously, we've had our democracy as it is for some time or for a long time.
00:09:32 And I'm just surprised that this issue has never gotten big enough that it has been changed where a by-election is forced.
00:09:37 So, Alex, do you think maybe going forward that that would ever happen?
00:09:41 Because, obviously, the Liberals in their position, who are going to be the ones who benefit from this stuff happening, aren't going to change this law.
00:09:48 But do you think there's any way where we could, I guess, strengthen democracy and somehow pass a bill to force a by-election when someone crosses the floor?
00:09:58 I don't know. I mean, that would be kind of a higher level question.
00:10:04 I mean, a by-election is triggered if somebody resigns as opposed to crossing the floor.
00:10:09 So, there's already that function.
00:10:11 Is this, so I'm a little bit new to this story, so forgive me.
00:10:14 Is this the same writing that Han Dong used to represent?
00:10:18 Is this Dawn Valley North?
00:10:19 No, this was Markham Unionville.
00:10:24 Markham, okay.
00:10:24 Okay, but it's kind of in the same area, though.
00:10:26 It's like a very Chinese writing.
00:10:30 Is that right?
00:10:31 Yeah, you're absolutely right, 100%.
00:10:33 Yeah, because I do remember Paul Chang was the Liberal candidate, and he got turfed, as you were mentioning, Waleed, 1.00
00:10:39 because of the controversy where he said he was going to, yeah, collect a bounty on the Conservative candidate.
00:10:46 And what happened to the Conservative candidate, John Tay?
00:10:50 I believe, oh, actually, that's interesting.
00:10:53 Yeah, Joe Tay, wasn't that his name?
00:10:55 Did he not step aside, maybe?
00:10:57 I'm not sure, because there was a Conservative security at some point in time.
00:11:03 Interesting, interesting story.
00:11:05 Let me...
00:11:06 Yeah, because I feel like, wasn't it John Tay that was running against Paul Chang, and then, like, I'm just confused about where he went.
00:11:12 And, sorry, again, I'm not as familiar with this story as I probably should be.
00:11:17 So, exactly.
00:11:18 Actually, so this is where we got to correct the course.
00:11:20 So, this is Markham Union, the candidate that discussed the openness of, look, you can collect a bounty on Joe Tay's head.
00:11:28 That guy was running in the same writing as Michael Ma against Michael Ma at some point in time before he resigned.
00:11:34 Joe Tay was running in a different writing.
00:11:36 So, it wasn't his direct writing opponent, but it was definitely a partisan opponent.
00:11:40 And, for sure, on the most important frontier, definitely a dissident of the Chinese regime coming out of Hong Kong.
00:11:46 So, that's probably what matters the most.
00:11:48 But Michael Ma is a Hong Konger as well, no?
00:11:51 Yeah, he was born in Hong Kong, yes.
00:11:53 Yeah, no, Joe Tay was running in Don Valley North, but...
00:11:57 Okay, so that's where I got the confusion with the hand on, because that was previously his writing.
00:12:01 Okay.
00:12:02 We'll move on to our next story, which is, well, it was super interesting to me, at least, because...
00:12:08 And I'll ask a few things of you guys here, but the Liberals faced extreme backlash over an ex-post that was promoting free speech.
00:12:17 And they even had the hashtag, think before you share, on the post, which was super ironic, considering they got community noted for their post.
00:12:27 Because the post, essentially, and the video, which just, it didn't really have audio, just sound, or music, sorry, but it had text.
00:12:36 So, it was talking about foreign regimes, mass reporting posts to take them down, coordinating harassment, filing baseless legal threats, and essentially silencing online posts.
00:12:48 But then, of course, the community note there, as you showed, Jeff, it said, hey, the Liberals are actually doing this with Bill C-9.
00:12:56 So, kind of ironic there.
00:12:58 And then the thing I focused on for this article was the reaction to the post, because it got so widespread.
00:13:04 Even Conservative leader Pierre Pellievre commented on it, he quote-tweeted it, and he literally not just mentioned Bill C-9, but Bill C-11, which grants widespread censorship powers.
00:13:13 Bill C-18, the reason you can't see news on social media in Canada, and he went on and on.
00:13:18 So, I mean, other Conservative MPs did too.
00:13:22 Michelle Rempel-Garner, she shared a clip of a Liberal immigration head trying to essentially suggest that they should stop allowing MPs to share posts from the House of Commons, which is just absolutely ludicrous.
00:13:36 I mean, and it went on and on and on, even fans of, or colleagues of True North, like Rod Giltaka, the CEO, of course, of the Canadian Coalition for Firearms Rights.
00:13:48 He was saying, he said, isn't this exactly what you're doing to the Liberals?
00:13:52 And then a few Canadians too that I highlighted in the article.
00:13:56 For example, one user said, quote, it's what communists do, accuse others what you're guilty of.
00:14:01 And then there was the whole convoy aspect too.
00:14:05 Sheila Gunn-Reed, she went into it with some evidence.
00:14:08 She was talking about them suppressing evidence.
00:14:11 And then, of course, Tamara Leach got involved. 0.79
00:14:13 She was giving specific anecdotes, specific examples, like, here's what I went through.
00:14:17 Here's how I was suppressed by the Liberals.
00:14:19 Here's what the government did to me.
00:14:21 And, of course, Waleed, you've been on the Bill C-9 beat a lot.
00:14:24 But I did want to ask you guys something a bit more chill beforehand, because I see posts, and I'm sure you do too, every day that are from not just political parties, but politicians that are so clearly not true.
00:14:38 And they're not community noted.
00:14:40 So, yeah, what do you guys think of the whole community note in general on X and maybe the consistency of it and what we see from it?
00:14:47 Well, I will tell you, and I'll speak on behalf of myself, because I, myself, am actually a member of the community note kind of, I don't know, feedback team or, but I'm someone that typically awaits the effectiveness and purpose of community notes, which effectively gives it its placement on some posts.
00:15:06 So, for those that are not, you will either see a community note if it's already been given the thumbs up.
00:15:11 But I can say sometimes, well, it's still in the process of being built up by the user base and the algorithm.
00:15:16 So, I think, frankly, from an informational standpoint, I don't think it takes as long as, and this is the condition for me, as long as it doesn't take away from the original content.
00:15:26 So, if you have a photo of something, even if you want a meme, troll, spread disinformation, or spread real information, where you might be accused of disinformation in some cases, especially in the political sphere, you have your image, you have your text, you have your information.
00:15:39 But then you have an additional subtext somewhere outside of the frame of the message or the image or the text, which can then provide for the context for the reader.
00:15:49 I think it's fine because one doesn't take away from the other.
00:15:52 Now, what information is coming from the text also matters by itself.
00:15:57 So, the formatting is one thing.
00:15:59 The next part that concerns me as well is, you know, because we saw YouTube apply a very similar policy where they had, you know, information, but it wasn't based off of user data or based off of open source data.
00:16:09 It was typically based off direct government interference.
00:16:13 The governments of some countries would like to indicate information to the users about COVID.
00:16:16 So, if ever you had mentioned anything about COVID during the video, you'd have that COVID-19 sublet.
00:16:21 You had something about climate change.
00:16:23 I know because my last couple of videos at COP30 last month had that little climate change UN link attached right on the bottom, which I'm sure a lot of our users weren't happily or our viewers rather weren't happy to see because, of course, that's straight up, you know, institutional propaganda at that point.
00:16:38 So, I think what really matters is where is that information coming from and how is it being displayed?
00:16:43 I think Twitter is getting the, or X rather, is getting the model right because it's being a bit more democratic than any other platform that I've seen at that similar scale.
00:16:51 So, I think for the most part, it's been good.
00:16:53 Sometimes, you know, you want to get close to information and understand exactly if this is like, you know, some rage bait, as we say nowadays.
00:17:00 I don't know if people are very familiar with the trend, but whenever someone says feeling absurd just for the sake of provoking, you know, an angry reaction from the user base, you know, you want to get to the facts real quickly.
00:17:09 That can be helpful sometimes.
00:17:10 Other times, there might be things where context matters, you know, there might be some accusations out there.
00:17:15 And I think sometimes even users that have posted false information accidentally could appreciate it because while they might be ratioed, while there might be like, you know, those retweets where they, you know, gotcha, at the end of the day, it gives you the opportunity to take down or to react responsibly over what you're actually posting out there.
00:17:31 So, I think the community health model is good, I think, and I hope, hopefully, it will stay.
00:17:36 And other platforms might consider that as an alternative to the other more draconian, top-down approaches of just feeding us government propaganda.
00:17:44 Yeah, Alex, I'd love to get your thoughts because you're sort of an ex-celebrity.
00:17:49 But, no, something that just came to mind when Waleed was talking there is last week, for some reason, everyone was, or I kept seeing the NHL video from 2021 where they were doing some sort of Indigenous thing based on the graves.
00:18:02 Of course, they were never found.
00:18:04 There is no graves.
00:18:05 No bodies have been found at these residential schools.
00:18:07 And this was based on, of course, the CBC article that itself, I think, got community noted because they were saying that there were graves, and that's not true.
00:18:16 But the NHL video, interestingly, this was from May 2021, and it was, yeah, some Indigenous celebration at some game was not community noted, so I found that interesting.
00:18:26 But, yeah, Alex, given your presence on X, I'm wondering if you have any similar anecdotes or thoughts.
00:18:32 Yeah, I mean, I'm also a community note.
00:18:34 I don't know, is there a name for it, like, curator?
00:18:39 So, yeah, I mean, I don't typically rate the notes very often.
00:18:44 I do find community notes a little annoying sometimes.
00:18:46 Like, opinions belong in the replies.
00:18:49 And a lot of times, community notes will just be opinions, which I find kind of defeats the purpose.
00:18:56 Bill C9, if we can kind of return to that.
00:18:59 I just think that's, like, super, super interesting.
00:19:01 I don't know if anybody's been watching the Justice Committee where this bill is being debated, but it is by far the funniest and most dysfunctional House Committee of all time.
00:19:11 It has reached such a plateau of absurdity that, like, all of the conservatives have brought in their holy books, which is, like, quite interesting.
00:19:21 I don't know if that's against House rules to bring in props, but, you know, like, Andrew Lawton's got his holy Bible and Roman Baber has his Torah.
00:19:29 And it's really, really interesting because, basically, what they're doing is they're bringing in the holy books to show that this Bill C9 is an attack on free speech and, in particular, free speech that is, I guess you'd say, espoused in the context of religious text.
00:19:45 And so, yeah, I just think that this is such a funny thing that, you know, the government of Canada, on the one hand, is saying that they're a proponent of free speech, but then, on the other hand, they're also trying to censor Canadians, including, like, what should be a fundamental right, which is your ability to speak to the text that you believe in, right?
00:20:06 I mean, faith is a fundamental freedom.
00:20:10 Anyone claiming the liberals are a proponent of free speech, I mean, you've got to be, you've lost the plot.
00:20:15 That's just not the case.
00:20:16 I mean, there's ample evidence against that not being the case with Bill C9 and Online Harms Act.
00:20:22 And, I mean, there's just so many examples.
00:20:24 I mean, over the years, it's just not been true.
00:20:26 But think, we would like to move to our, oh, sorry.
00:20:30 Yeah, just if I can add one more thing.
00:20:31 I mean, it's kind of interesting because Bill C9, it really seems aimed at banning swastikas. 0.98
00:20:37 And that, to me, is, like, really amusing.
00:20:39 Not because swastikas are amusing. 1.00
00:20:41 Of course, they're a terrible symbol, and they have a terrible history.
00:20:44 But swastikas are already illegal.
00:20:47 There's a really great example, actually, from Andrew Lawton, a True North alumni.
00:20:50 His writing, somebody mowed a swastika into their front lawn, and they have been charged with hate speech.
00:20:59 So, the law is already adequate enough.
00:21:02 I don't know, like, how, what is the purpose of this bill, exactly?
00:21:05 To make swastikas more illegal than they already are? 0.98
00:21:09 Yeah, no, it's funny you mentioned that, too, Alex, because there was a story from Brooks in Alberta that dropped last week.
00:21:14 It was the same thing.
00:21:14 Like, people were drawing swastikas, and they were, like, charged, I'm pretty sure.
00:21:18 Like, you just can't do that.
00:21:19 And it may have been more than just a swastika.
00:21:23 Like, there may have been actually Nazi symbolism, because a swastika in itself, while symbolizing the Nazis, has other meanings, as we know historically.
00:21:29 Yeah, of course.
00:21:30 Yeah, it's a holy symbol for some religions.
00:21:33 Hinduism, as a good example. 0.99
00:21:36 So, yeah, I mean, but that's one of the reasons that people are against this bill, including Hindus, right? 1.00
00:21:41 They're saying that, especially if you remove this religious exemption for free speech, I mean, are Hindus going to go to jail because they're displaying swastikas, even though it's completely out of context?
00:21:50 Like, it has nothing to do with Nazi Germany.
00:21:52 I just don't know what the purpose of this bill is.
00:21:55 And there are so many other priorities that we should be looking at in terms of criminal justice and human rights.
00:22:02 It's just the most baffling thing I've seen.
00:22:05 If I can chime in, I just want to say that I think there's always a great discrepancy between the raison d'etre or the reason why this bill is being pushed by so-called liberals.
00:22:17 And, of course, this is, I think, where liberals have lost credibility in terms of deliberalizing social media, the media overall, and, of course, the public domain of expression.
00:22:28 Whether we're talking about swastikas or not, I already think the laws are probably a little bit too far in some cases.
00:22:32 I mean, being charged for symbolism, even as hateful as it can be, I think, is still, it's a bad direction to be heading in.
00:22:40 But now you have, of course, it is true.
00:22:42 You've seen, you know, we've all observed from different studies and different reporting that we've covered even ourselves,
00:22:48 that there has been a rise of anti-Semitic incidents in Canada.
00:22:51 There has been a rise of hate crimes for warts in communities in some cases.
00:22:55 I mean, there just has been this pool of sectarianism, partially, in my opinion, flooded by demographics.
00:23:01 Because now you have, the minorities aren't actually so small as they used to be. 1.00
00:23:05 And they're actually much more frequent.
00:23:07 And their counterparts from wherever they're from are also here.
00:23:10 And there's those dividing lines of nationality, religion, ethnicity.
00:23:13 Wherever they happen to be in the world, they happen to be present in Canada.
00:23:16 I think every country, every major country on earth, at least, and every major religion on earth, has a diasporic presence in Canada.
00:23:22 Which means, for all the conflicts that are out there, there's somewhere where that show can start to play off in Canada.
00:23:30 And that's actually a very important thing to understand in terms of how we're heading towards a country without borders.
00:23:36 I mean, yes, we might have kind of some set of a frontier, you know, ports of entries, airports, you know, a border marked on a map.
00:23:43 But in terms of how we're able to fend away the kind of, you know, nonsense, sectarianism, hatred, ideologies that are, you know, ruining other parts of the world.
00:23:54 It's becoming very hard because, of course, like, you know, we've covered many times, these diaspora groups are well pronounced and are in big numbers with a lot of power, politically speaking.
00:24:05 And they're able to operate the way they were operating before.
00:24:08 Or actually, in some cases, as we discussed, especially on the Sikh issue or other kinds of issues, even more.
00:24:13 Because of our liberal democracy, they're able to amplify their voices more and say, I mean, incredible nonsense.
00:24:19 I mean, there was that Sikh activist I covered, I think it was two or three weeks ago, that spoke on the CTV talking about, you know, the whole Khalistan Sikh referendum that happened in Canada.
00:24:30 I think 50,000 people voted in Ottawa.
00:24:32 But specifically that individual, someone that has called on, like, the death of the Indian Prime Minister, who was called for the deportation of Hindus from Canada and telling them to go back to their country, although he shares the same country of heritage as them.
00:24:45 I mean, it's really funny stuff sometimes, but ultimately, taking it back to the point of hatred, I mean, hatred is there, it's increasing, and definitely there might be an appetite to see things change.
00:24:55 But that's not the way you're going to get any change.
00:24:57 I don't think C9 or taking down a few people, you know, to a jail cell for a swatika or for a tweet or for reciting certain verses of any religious text is going to make much of a difference, 0.75
00:25:08 provided that it is enforced the way they were telling us it's going to be enforced.
00:25:13 As it's written in paper, and as the C9 amendment that Bloc and Liberals have agreed on now, I actually think it's completely a Quebec-based theory of religious hatred is the source of what we're dealing with here.
00:25:27 That is, in some case, but it's not the whole story, unfortunately.
00:25:30 And I'm sorry to continue beating this dead horse, but this Bill C9 thing, there's often a discussion in legal circles when a bill is being proposed, is this supposed to be a shield or a sword?
00:25:42 And in this case, it does seem like the Liberals are designing Bill C9 to be a sword rather than a shield.
00:25:49 And a good example of that was when Mark Miller said that sections of Leviticus, which crosses across two religions, because it's in the Old Testament,
00:25:57 he says that Leviticus is hate speech.
00:26:01 And that there are certain sections of Leviticus, specifically that like, you know, man shall not sleep with man or whatever it happens to be in my Bible.
00:26:08 Knowledge is not as sharp as it should be.
00:26:10 But this is what I find just completely absurd, right?
00:26:13 I mean, it almost seems like the government is not using this to shield people from hate speech.
00:26:18 They're using it to attack people who espouse speech that they don't like.
00:26:22 Yeah, Alex, you said it's a sword.
00:26:24 To me, it's more like a bludgeon, and they're going to hammer us over the head with it.
00:26:28 But sticking with law in a way, Alex, you wrote an interesting piece about BC and safe supply.
00:26:36 And look, Alex, honestly, man, over the years, I've heard time and again, BC is changing course or backtracking on safe supply.
00:26:45 But it's just not the case, because it still is there.
00:26:48 So it's like, what is actually going on?
00:26:50 And talk to us, too, about this charter challenge, the constitutional aspect of it.
00:26:55 What's happening there in BC right now?
00:26:57 Oh, man, how much time do we have?
00:26:58 I'm so neck deep in this story.
00:27:02 I've been attending this trial every day for the last two or three weeks.
00:27:06 So it relates to a group called DOLF.
00:27:09 And DOLF stands for the Drug User Liberation Front.
00:27:12 So this was two individuals in Vancouver.
00:27:15 They're actually very intelligent and very well-spoken.
00:27:19 I watched them be cross-examined at the BC Supreme Court.
00:27:22 They're a little eccentric.
00:27:23 I mean, one of them, his name is Jeremy Vladimir Calicum.
00:27:26 He's very, very clean cut.
00:27:28 But I don't even think, like, he doesn't present as a drug user.
00:27:31 And then he's got this friend who's, you know, this trans individual who's really kind of kooky, I guess. 1.00
00:27:38 Eccentric is probably the best word to use, which is kind of a mess.
00:27:42 And between the two of them, they're really weird bedfellows.
00:27:46 They decided that they were going to procure cocaine, heroin, and meth off of the dark web
00:27:51 and then test it to ensure that the drugs were pure and then sell it to a cohort of individuals.
00:27:56 So they would be less likely to overdose.
00:27:59 There is actually some logic and reasoning here because one of the reasons that so many people are overdosing,
00:28:04 specifically in BC, is because of the volatile street drug supply.
00:28:08 So as an example, if you're a cocaine user, which I don't recommend,
00:28:12 5% of your cocaine, if it's laced with fentanyl, and then the next week it's laced with 35% fentanyl,
00:28:20 you don't really know how to dose.
00:28:22 And that's especially true with drugs like heroin.
00:28:24 And so there is some logic here.
00:28:27 And really, it's, like, kind of modeled after the BC government's Safe Supply Program,
00:28:31 which offers typically pharmaceutical synthetic opioids like hydromorphone or Dilaudid.
00:28:36 I've learned a lot about drugs through this case.
00:28:39 Like, I feel like I have, like, a degree in drug dealing just from attending this court hearing.
00:28:45 You get a degree in that now?
00:28:47 Yeah, if you wanted to learn how to become a drug dealer, this would be a really great trial to follow.
00:28:52 So basically what happened, they're guilty.
00:28:54 I mean, they've both been charged and convicted of three counts each,
00:28:58 one for each of the drugs, cocaine, heroin, and meth.
00:29:01 But they're presenting now a charter challenge.
00:29:04 So their sentencing is held in advance.
00:29:06 And the charter challenge is basically two-pronged.
00:29:08 The first prong is under Section 7 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms,
00:29:12 which allows everybody to have the life, liberty, and security of person.
00:29:16 It's kind of our equivalent to the American life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.
00:29:20 Is that right?
00:29:21 False.
00:29:22 Yeah.
00:29:22 So, yeah, they were basically saying that to deprive drug users of the right to do clean drugs,
00:29:30 which I'm putting in very bold bunny ears,
00:29:34 is to deprive them of their Section 7 right to life, liberty, and the security of person.
00:29:38 There's also an auxiliary charter challenge under Section 15,
00:29:41 which is that individuals are free from discrimination,
00:29:44 including discrimination on the basis of disability.
00:29:47 Interesting fact, I learned as well through this trial,
00:29:49 severe substance abuse disorder, which basically means being a drug addict,
00:29:53 is classified as a disability in Canada.
00:29:56 And it has been for a very long time.
00:29:58 And so the implications of this case are huge.
00:30:01 Because if the charter challenge stands, it would almost suggest,
00:30:05 and I'm not a lawyer, and I'm not an expert in drugs,
00:30:08 but it would almost suggest that individuals would be protected under the charter
00:30:11 for dealing drugs as long as they were properly tested.
00:30:16 Just tell me, Alex, how this intertwines with safe supply.
00:30:20 Sure.
00:30:20 So what, like, obviously based on what the ruling is,
00:30:24 how that will affect safe supply and taxpayer-funded drugs in B.C., right?
00:30:29 Yeah, that's a really good question.
00:30:31 So what is happening with this case is, and actually it has come up many times,
00:30:36 is they're essentially trying to enshrine at the judiciary level
00:30:39 the right for governments to provide safe supply.
00:30:42 So this is another really, really bizarre part of this case,
00:30:46 is that these two individuals, they're very well educated.
00:30:50 They applied to the Health Canada for a Section 56 exemption.
00:30:55 That's the same exemption that is given to institutions like Insight, for instance, right?
00:31:00 That's why the police can't go into, you know, Insight.
00:31:02 That's a safe injection site.
00:31:04 Again, it's an oxymoron, I know.
00:31:06 There is no such thing as safe injection, but whatever.
00:31:08 I'm going to use their nomenclature because I'm not aware of any other phrases
00:31:13 on how to describe these things.
00:31:15 You'd call it a drug den.
00:31:17 It's probably more accurate, a shooting gallery, whatever.
00:31:20 So basically the government can't go in and arrest everybody in a safe injection site 0.74
00:31:25 because they have the Section 56 exemption.
00:31:27 So they applied for that, and Health Canada said no.
00:31:30 So then they went to the provincial government, and they said,
00:31:32 would you support this project?
00:31:33 And the David E.B. NDP government was like, sure.
00:31:36 And then they said, can we have $200,000?
00:31:40 And the B.C. government said, sure.
00:31:41 What do you want that for?
00:31:42 They said, well, to buy cocaine, heroin, and meth, of course.
00:31:45 And the government said, yeah, no problem.
00:31:48 What?
00:31:49 Yeah, so they paid these two individuals to do this,
00:31:53 and now they're charging them criminally, and they have been convicted.
00:31:57 And now we have this charter challenge, which is probably costing the taxpayers a small fortune.
00:32:03 Is that not a good enough defense?
00:32:04 I mean, the provincial government paid us to do this, and now you're charging us.
00:32:07 This is insane.
00:32:08 Yeah, and just to be clear, just to be as factual as possible about this,
00:32:13 in the trial they said that the $200,000 was used purely for staffing.
00:32:17 It sounds like they raised the money to buy the drugs through almost like a co-op model.
00:32:21 It's kind of like a credit union for cocaine.
00:32:23 It's really, like, it's just the strangest case.
00:32:27 And, yeah, so in terms of safe supply, we do have a safe supply program in B.C.
00:32:33 where individuals can get a prescription.
00:32:35 You know, if they do have a severe opioid use disorder,
00:32:39 they can get a prescription from their doctor, and they can be given Dilaudid.
00:32:42 The issue with that was diversion, right?
00:32:46 A lot of people were taking their Dilaudid and selling it on the street or selling it to kids,
00:32:51 which is incredibly dangerous, and then using the money that they got from their Dilaudid to buy fentanyl.
00:32:57 This brings up another major issue with DOLF, which is that DOLF is almost already outdated.
00:33:02 The drugs have basically outpaced DOLF.
00:33:05 So a lot of the – they did these studies, these qualitative studies.
00:33:09 They basically did a survey of the DOLF cohort group, and they said,
00:33:12 do you enjoy this program?
00:33:15 And unsurprisingly, most of the drug addicts did.
00:33:17 But some of them, actually more than half, I believe it was, that bothered to answer the survey,
00:33:23 said that the drugs weren't strong enough.
00:33:25 They said, we don't want heroin, we want fentanyl.
00:33:27 And we don't want cocaine, we want crack.
00:33:31 Crazy stuff. 0.80
00:33:32 But switching from shooting up drugs to just shooting bullets,
00:33:36 yeah, there was perhaps an unlikely area, let's say, or location that people might think of
00:33:44 when you're thinking of the federal firearms confiscation program.
00:33:47 But an interesting story came out of Charlottetown when their city council voted 10 to 0
00:33:52 against essentially implementing the federal gun confiscation scheme.
00:33:57 And I was looking at this, the motion, the vote, the debate.
00:34:00 It was pretty interesting. 0.87
00:34:02 There were a few ridiculous things in the motion.
00:34:05 For example, it claimed that the participation in the program would be fully compensated.
00:34:10 The city would not incur any costs.
00:34:12 I mean, maybe true but misleading because we're all federal taxpayers.
00:34:16 So if the taxpayers are paying federally, you are paying as a city.
00:34:19 The municipal police force would have to be implementing it.
00:34:22 So they're at the very least reallocating their resources.
00:34:26 So again, I mean, that was a bit questionable.
00:34:29 And of course, this vote came just weeks after the federal gun program was piloted in Cape Breton,
00:34:35 which was an absolute atrocity.
00:34:39 They collected 22 firearms, which costed taxpayers around $7,000 per firearm collected
00:34:46 because of the total cost.
00:34:47 And they only got 22 of them.
00:34:49 Because of course, as we know, the liberals have been saying this is voluntary.
00:34:52 But of course, when the amnesty ends, you will be liable to five years in prison for possessing an illegal firearm.
00:35:00 And a few other interesting things.
00:35:03 The Charlottetown Council there, they revealed that they have 927 POWs in the city and an estimated 132 restricted firearms.
00:35:11 So again, even if they did enforce this, I'm sure they would have collected like a handful of firearms out of 132.
00:35:21 But it was interesting watching the city council debate because a lot of the councillors seemed pretty knowledgeable of the program,
00:35:27 which I think is important, especially for True North and where we've been throughout this program in our reporting
00:35:36 and how vocal we've been about it.
00:35:38 For example, one of the councillors, Justin Mudart, he said that there was considerable misinformation in the media
00:35:46 and on social platforms regarding the program, specifically around what assault-style firearms are.
00:35:53 Because of course, we've seen the liberals say that this is going to ban assault-style firearms.
00:35:57 But then we've seen experts like Rod Giltaka, who I mentioned earlier, the CEO of the CCFR,
00:36:02 he said there are no assault rifles that are on the list.
00:36:05 So it's really hunting rifles, sports shooting rifles.
00:36:08 These aren't M4 automatic rifles that you're thinking about in video games.
00:36:13 It's not the case at all.
00:36:16 And yeah, no, there was, I mean, I could talk about the firearm program forever.
00:36:21 But what I did find interesting, because this is a Charlottetown city council,
00:36:26 like I don't imagine they have people going to these hearings in person.
00:36:30 But for this one, there was a small gallery, a small crowd, which may have been the first time that that ever happened.
00:36:38 And there was an applause when they voted 10-0 against the motion.
00:36:43 Do we have that clip that we can?
00:36:45 In relation to the assault firearms compensation.
00:36:48 So it's affirmative resolution.
00:36:51 All those in favor of it.
00:36:53 All those against.
00:36:55 10-0.
00:36:56 So yeah, I'll ask you guys this, because we've obviously seen,
00:37:16 and this is another thing one of the councillors mentioned,
00:37:18 every jurisdiction in Canada, aside from two, have said no to this.
00:37:22 Provincial police organizations are saying no.
00:37:24 Provinces as a whole, Saskatchewan, Alberta, the list is lengthy, saying no.
00:37:28 Now municipalities, saying no.
00:37:29 Everyone's saying we're not doing this.
00:37:31 The federal government, the Liberals, specifically Public Safety Minister Gary Nandasangri,
00:37:35 are still trying to push forward with it, but it's not entirely their jurisdiction per se.
00:37:41 So what do you think it says about the fact that we're just seeing,
00:37:45 from every jurisdictional aspect aside from the Liberals,
00:37:48 are saying no to this program, that all we've seen is waste taxpayers' money
00:37:53 and fail in almost every metric.
00:37:57 Hasn't this costed like a billion dollars?
00:38:00 Yeah.
00:38:00 Well, they're saying it's going to cost, the costs vary,
00:38:04 but some people say like $750 million, some it's in the billions.
00:38:07 It's already costed hundreds of millions.
00:38:08 And of course, what have they collected so far?
00:38:10 22 firearms?
00:38:11 That's over like five years.
00:38:12 They haven't collected any, and it's costed hundreds of millions
00:38:15 in administrative, bureaucratic, like ridiculous fees.
00:38:19 But I mean, look, it's the federal government, guys.
00:38:21 What do you want me to say?
00:38:23 There is no such thing as a project that a private company could not do
00:38:27 like a tenth of the cost of the federal government.
00:38:29 All they do is bloat costs.
00:38:32 That's the main skill that they have.
00:38:35 So yeah, no, it's going to cost billions, Alex.
00:38:37 Also in the Justice Committee, I believe it was the head of the Toronto Police Association
00:38:42 who said that this gun confiscation program will have absolutely no impact on crime.
00:38:48 Well, Alex, that's what all the police associations have been saying,
00:38:50 and the data supports it.
00:38:52 When you look at the crimes, and I'm sure you have the crimes,
00:38:54 it's like 99%, 99%, 99% illegally smuggled firearms from the United States.
00:38:59 These are not, the last time even a law-abiding firearm owner committed,
00:39:02 I mean, it's such a small, like we're talking about less than a percentage,
00:39:06 like in the 0.00 percentages of legal firearms ever being used to commit a crime.
00:39:11 That's not what the problem is.
00:39:13 And this is more or less from what we can tell at this point
00:39:17 to appease Quebec, to appease Natalie Provost.
00:39:20 There's no one else who wants this to happen.
00:39:22 Let's be realistic.
00:39:22 Well, wasn't this program originally spearheaded by Bill Blair
00:39:25 in response to the Nova Scotia shooting?
00:39:28 Yes.
00:39:28 Which is, sadly, I mean, so many people died.
00:39:32 It feels like a distant memory now.
00:39:33 Yeah, and yeah, obviously, Provost was deeply affected by that,
00:39:38 which is why she's so passionate about this,
00:39:39 but that her emotion doesn't change the facts,
00:39:42 which is that this is utter failure and will do nothing to address crime
00:39:45 when we could actually be addressing crime by implementing bail reform.
00:39:49 I mean, let's be realistic.
00:39:50 That's what the problem is.
00:39:51 The people committing crimes can't be sent to jail.
00:39:54 The police are saying we have no power.
00:39:55 The judges are saying we have no power.
00:39:57 The criminals are not in jail.
00:39:59 They're committing crimes.
00:40:00 It's the same people over and over again,
00:40:01 and they keep getting let out, I mean.
00:40:03 And as for the guns, yeah, like I said,
00:40:06 these are not legal firearms, so.
00:40:09 But I'm happy to see from an anti-federal gun confiscation scheme aspect
00:40:15 that Charlottetown, because, you know, it's Charlottetown.
00:40:19 I don't know that I would consider them conservative by any means,
00:40:22 and them voting against this was something.
00:40:28 But sticking with eastern places, I guess.
00:40:33 Yeah, no, the CTF is warning the Ottawa residents, I suppose,
00:40:41 that the Ottawa senators are trying to force the city, the province,
00:40:45 or whomever, to pay for the arena, which this stood out to me, of course,
00:40:51 because such a similar situation occurred in Calgary
00:40:54 when they were building their arena and trying to get funding by the city
00:40:59 and the province, which they did, by the way.
00:41:01 And that arena is expected to cost, in Calgary,
00:41:03 more than $1.2 billion,
00:41:06 which was funded $537 million by the city
00:41:10 and $356 million from the owners of the Flames.
00:41:13 That's for the one in Calgary.
00:41:14 As for the one in Ottawa,
00:41:16 I think it's expected to cost similar.
00:41:20 And it's funny, the senators as a whole,
00:41:23 the team itself, is valued at $1.2 billion.
00:41:26 So I guess that might double their value,
00:41:32 if you count the assets, I don't know.
00:41:34 But, yeah, obviously we saw the CTF pushing back on this
00:41:37 because they're calling for taxpayer money to offset expenses
00:41:42 that would otherwise be covered by the team.
00:41:44 And we've seen this, as I said, be a recurring theme in the NHL
00:41:47 where these billionaire owners don't want to build the arenas.
00:41:51 They want the taxpayers to do it for them,
00:41:54 which is at the very least questionable from a taxpayer perspective.
00:41:59 A few things that the CTF highlighted,
00:42:02 the Canadian Taxpayers Federation, some data.
00:42:04 They, of course, highlighted, and as we well know,
00:42:09 that federal government debt is expected to reach $1.35 trillion
00:42:12 by the end of this year,
00:42:14 and Ontario government is $459 billion in debt.
00:42:17 So going further into debt to pay for this arena,
00:42:20 I'm not sure what the ROI on that will be like.
00:42:24 And, of course, yeah, Doug Ford,
00:42:26 he's always been in controversy when it comes to taxpayer spending too.
00:42:30 Do you guys think there's any chance, I guess,
00:42:35 that pushback from taxpayer advocates like the CTF
00:42:39 actually affect the outcomes of these funding arrangements?
00:42:44 I think it brings a lot of awareness,
00:42:46 and that's what I really appreciate from a taxpayer's perspective,
00:42:50 the fact that you have this conversation happening.
00:42:52 You know, we had this situation with the Olympics at a certain time.
00:42:56 The World Cup is bringing up these anxieties to some people in Vancouver and Toronto.
00:43:00 It's like, you know, for all the greatness in the sports industry,
00:43:03 it's a mega-rich industry.
00:43:04 There's massive capital in that industry from only,
00:43:07 not only the fans, but from advertising companies,
00:43:09 from businesses, from the TV and media business.
00:43:12 And it's like, you know, do they really need that money in the first place
00:43:15 is the big question a lot of people have.
00:43:17 And, of course, priorities as well.
00:43:19 I mean, looking at Ottawa, in particular, the capital,
00:43:21 where I've lived for so long,
00:43:22 I think there's a lot more things you can spend our money on than a stadium.
00:43:26 I think the Ottawa Senators have a fine arena in the West End.
00:43:30 Probably the best thing about the stadium is that it's actually outside of the city
00:43:34 a little bit, so it doesn't have to, you know,
00:43:36 it depends on where you're coming from,
00:43:37 but you may not always have to experience traffic when driving to the stadium.
00:43:41 Of course, again, exiting the sports sphere,
00:43:44 because this really is not a sports topic.
00:43:46 This is much more about the economic standpoint of the city
00:43:49 and whether or not these subsidies make sense.
00:43:51 I think sports companies, in many cases in the United States,
00:43:55 do ask and sometimes do get grants from the government.
00:43:58 But very often, you know, that's because that franchise has a great anchor to the city.
00:44:04 I think the Senators do.
00:44:05 So, you know, you've seen teams move around before
00:44:07 in North American sports from city to city sometimes,
00:44:10 but it doesn't really happen anymore.
00:44:11 I think the Senators are grounded,
00:44:12 and I think this definitely is not a hard move.
00:44:15 I mean, because, you know, if you're in Ottawa
00:44:16 and you're not so far away from the Fed,
00:44:18 and you can get these kinds of money and grant approvals
00:44:21 quite easily through the political backdoor, as they say.
00:44:24 So, I can expect that this deal could somehow still include element of public funds,
00:44:30 unfortunately, for the taxpayers of Ottawa,
00:44:32 but, of course, for the cost of the country
00:44:33 and cost of the province of Ontario as well.
00:44:36 But, again, I think with declining viewership,
00:44:39 I don't know what the fiscal situation of the NHL is,
00:44:42 or the Senators specifically.
00:44:43 I don't know if they're doing worse financially today.
00:44:46 I haven't followed them since Eric Carlson left,
00:44:49 so I would assume that if they're asking for this money,
00:44:52 because they're, yeah, exactly.
00:44:53 It's been a while, hasn't it?
00:44:55 The NHL is doing fine, but, yeah, as for the Ottawa,
00:44:58 the NHL has, like, an extra billionaire, as for Ottawa.
00:45:03 I don't know what the cash flow is looking like for the Senators,
00:45:05 but regardless, I mean, if a team does bad,
00:45:08 or, you know, if sports business isn't doing well,
00:45:10 it is not at all the responsibility of the general taxpayer.
00:45:14 They already have members, they have corporate sponsors,
00:45:17 they have fans, and that should be enough to hold them up.
00:45:20 And if they can't be held up enough,
00:45:22 then, you know what, it's time to pack the bags and move elsewhere.
00:45:24 I don't think the Senators are leaving anytime soon,
00:45:26 but I definitely think that the tax dollars are wholly unjustified.
00:45:30 And this goes, by the way, for every single sports venue
00:45:33 that we have in the country.
00:45:35 None of it should be publicly taxed.
00:45:36 Yeah, Willie, we had a very similar controversy in Edmonton, of course,
00:45:40 because Daryl Cates is the owner of the Oilers,
00:45:42 and he's probably, like, a top 10 richest person in Canada.
00:45:45 So people are like,
00:45:46 you're trying to get the taxpayers to pay for this?
00:45:47 You're a multibillionaire.
00:45:48 I mean, you are one of the richest people in the world, even.
00:45:52 So I don't know who owns the Ottawa Senators,
00:45:55 but I'm guessing just because you own an NHL team,
00:45:57 you're probably a billionaire as well.
00:45:59 So, and again, like I said,
00:46:01 if you want a new arena for whatever purpose that would be,
00:46:03 you have to do the fiscal analysis,
00:46:05 the return on investment, and then make that decision.
00:46:08 Yeah, that was kind of what I was going to ask,
00:46:10 because I find that these headlines are often very cost-centered,
00:46:13 and they don't do a very good job, maybe, of explaining the benefits, right?
00:46:17 Because, you know, an NHL club and a large arena
00:46:20 does bring a lot of economic activity to a city.
00:46:23 So I'd be interested to see, like,
00:46:24 what the full holistic cost-benefit analysis looks like.
00:46:28 But also, I mean, we have so many stadiums here in Vancouver.
00:46:32 We're dealing with a similar situation with the Whitecaps,
00:46:34 where apparently they need a new stadium in order to remain in MLS.
00:46:37 I'm not a big soccer fan.
00:46:38 I think that's the correct league.
00:46:41 Sorry?
00:46:41 Really?
00:46:42 Yeah, yeah.
00:46:43 This just came out a couple of days ago,
00:46:44 and they're thinking, I think, of building a new stadium
00:46:46 where the Hastings racetrack used to be.
00:46:49 But what I find interesting,
00:46:51 so I was actually mentioning just before we went on
00:46:53 that I used to do writing.
00:46:55 I used to do sports journalism,
00:46:56 and I used to cover the Vancouver Giants,
00:46:58 and they used to play in Memorial Coliseum,
00:47:00 which is a very old stadium.
00:47:02 But the stadium was functional.
00:47:03 It worked just fine.
00:47:04 I don't understand.
00:47:05 Like, is this just, like, a vanity thing?
00:47:07 Like, who cares if the seats are a little old
00:47:09 or, you know, the Jumbotron is a little outdated?
00:47:12 Like, ultimately, you're there to watch the game.
00:47:14 You're not there to, like, stare at the score clock anyway.
00:47:17 I would actually add a point that I haven't said before
00:47:21 is that there are indeed benefits.
00:47:23 I think the sports industry has been a massive benefit
00:47:26 to every economy that can hold a franchise of any major sport.
00:47:30 But typically, the discussion that will be had is,
00:47:32 what more can the franchise do with this new stadium
00:47:35 to provide more jobs locally to its own community.
00:47:38 So teams all over the world,
00:47:40 whether soccer teams in Europe or even in this case,
00:47:43 you're right, Alex,
00:47:44 the Vancouver Whitecaps recently signed an MOU.
00:47:47 We've heard that term.
00:47:49 MOU. Nice.
00:47:51 Kind of a Mark Carney MOU
00:47:52 where the thing actually never happens.
00:47:54 But I actually think this might be a bit more
00:47:55 of a more credible kind of deal.
00:47:57 I know, it's a beautiful term, right?
00:47:58 MOU, Memorandum of Understanding.
00:48:00 So I guess there is somehow an understanding
00:48:03 that the Whitecaps need a bigger stadium
00:48:05 or their own stadium.
00:48:06 I'm not sure what the Bell Centre relationship is
00:48:09 with the franchise, with the Whitecaps.
00:48:10 But, I mean, they brought in a big player from Europe,
00:48:13 I guess, looking for expansion of opportunities.
00:48:15 But essentially, the discussion will be,
00:48:16 okay, well, with this bigger capacity,
00:48:18 we can then afford this much more staff,
00:48:20 this much more jobs.
00:48:22 And, you know, look,
00:48:22 the other day we had a bit of confusion
00:48:24 between NVIDIA and Nokia,
00:48:25 but it was Nokia that offered that big, big, big subsidy
00:48:30 or got a big subsidy on the behalf
00:48:32 of the Canadian taxpayers by the government of Canada
00:48:34 because they were able to, you know,
00:48:37 open up or plan to open up an AI centre
00:48:39 that will give, you know, a couple dozen jobs,
00:48:41 maybe a couple hundred jobs.
00:48:42 Nothing too significant.
00:48:43 But again, if this is the government's kind of
00:48:46 willing game to play ball for, you know,
00:48:49 corporate subsidies and bailouts,
00:48:50 then I think Whitecaps pretty much
00:48:52 will get what they want.
00:48:53 Unless, of course, the stadium happens to be
00:48:55 going through unceded territory,
00:48:57 which in this case it probably is
00:48:58 because, I mean, the entire section of British Columbia
00:49:01 is apparently belonging to a specific ethnic group
00:49:04 that may not be happy to have anything
00:49:06 besides a piece of, you know,
00:49:08 rock built on top of the land.
00:49:10 But again, looking at the Whitecaps,
00:49:13 I mean, that situation,
00:49:14 or even the senators as well,
00:49:16 I mean, these are franchises
00:49:17 that are locked into the local economy.
00:49:19 These are major franchises
00:49:20 that have a lot of, you know,
00:49:21 fan base, fan support, private investment,
00:49:23 especially when it comes to the MLS
00:49:24 because unlike the NHL,
00:49:26 we're kind of deprived from MLS.
00:49:28 We actually just have two teams, I believe.
00:49:29 It's the Toronto FC and Whitecaps.
00:49:32 So, again, I don't think there's going to be
00:49:34 any hope for taxpayers to see
00:49:37 a complete deduction of taxpayer funds
00:49:40 in these projects and these initiatives.
00:49:42 Well, also, I think, like,
00:49:43 what is the life cycle of a modern sports arena?
00:49:46 Let's say it's 10, 15 years.
00:49:48 I think a way that you can maybe sell this
00:49:50 to taxpayers is if you had a plan
00:49:52 on how to repurpose the arena
00:49:54 when it's no longer viable
00:49:56 as a professional sports arena.
00:49:58 So, for example,
00:49:59 like, what are they going to do
00:49:59 with this addledome?
00:50:01 Are they just going to tear it?
00:50:02 Well, Alex, that's kind of what,
00:50:03 that was a terrible thing
00:50:04 that was happening in Edmonton
00:50:06 because we had Rexall Place
00:50:07 when we built Rogers Place.
00:50:08 Rexall Place is the old building.
00:50:10 There was people suggesting that
00:50:11 they should be housing homeless people there. 0.72
00:50:14 I mean,
00:50:14 I actually don't think
00:50:16 that's the worst idea ever.
00:50:17 And maybe they did, too.
00:50:18 And then they did a bunch
00:50:18 of other stuff with it, too.
00:50:20 So, like, it is still, I think,
00:50:22 functioning in some way.
00:50:23 Like, and of course,
00:50:24 there's the racetrack there
00:50:26 for horses and stuff
00:50:27 at the Coliseum there.
00:50:28 But I don't know exactly
00:50:30 what they do on a day-to-day basis,
00:50:32 but I do believe that building
00:50:33 is still functional.
00:50:35 Or maybe they...
00:50:35 I think it would be
00:50:36 an interesting pitch to taxpayers
00:50:38 if you said, well,
00:50:39 when, you know,
00:50:40 at the end of the 15-year
00:50:41 life cycle of this arena,
00:50:42 we can easily repurpose it
00:50:44 into housing,
00:50:45 market housing.
00:50:46 You know,
00:50:46 not necessarily fill it up
00:50:47 with homeless people
00:50:48 like the,
00:50:49 what was that arena
00:50:50 during Hurricane Katrina?
00:50:52 I don't know why I'm laughing.
00:50:53 There's nothing funny
00:50:54 about Hurricane Katrina.
00:50:56 But, you know,
00:50:58 like, I think that,
00:50:59 like, that actually
00:51:00 may be a good pitch
00:51:01 to taxpayers,
00:51:02 especially because
00:51:02 not everybody likes sports.
00:51:04 Right?
00:51:04 That's a very tough pill
00:51:05 to swallow if you're,
00:51:06 you know,
00:51:07 somebody paying thousands
00:51:08 of dollars every year
00:51:09 in property tax
00:51:10 and you have no intention
00:51:11 of watching a hockey game.
00:51:12 Yeah, they are saying
00:51:15 Rexall Place now.
00:51:16 They are talking about
00:51:18 doing demolition on it,
00:51:19 so I don't actually know.
00:51:20 But, yeah.
00:51:21 That seems very wasteful
00:51:22 to me, right?
00:51:23 Because I assume
00:51:23 that the building
00:51:24 is mostly functional
00:51:25 and I don't think
00:51:26 it would be,
00:51:27 I mean,
00:51:27 I'm not an engineer,
00:51:28 I'm not an architect,
00:51:29 but I imagine
00:51:30 that you could probably
00:51:31 repurpose it into
00:51:32 some type of market housing.
00:51:33 Same thing with a lot.
00:51:34 Well, when it comes
00:51:34 to housing,
00:51:35 the insurance on a foundation
00:51:37 is 100 years.
00:51:38 So if you assume
00:51:39 the same thing here
00:51:39 or even a bit less,
00:51:40 let's say 75,
00:51:41 it would be fine
00:51:42 to last that long, right?
00:51:43 Like, it's not going
00:51:43 to just fall over.
00:51:47 Yeah, it's almost like
00:51:48 we're treating these arenas
00:51:49 like Vegas casinos, right?
00:51:50 Although,
00:51:50 I'm reading this article now,
00:51:51 Alex, about Rexall.
00:51:53 It does say,
00:51:55 this is an interesting aspect
00:51:56 you have to consider,
00:51:57 it costs the city
00:51:58 over $1.2 million a year
00:52:00 to keep the dormant
00:52:00 facility running.
00:52:01 So it does cost money
00:52:03 to just keep it there
00:52:04 as opposed to demolition.
00:52:07 You, of course,
00:52:08 eliminate that cost.
00:52:10 Yeah, you need security
00:52:11 as well to avoid people
00:52:12 from getting in there
00:52:14 and just squatting
00:52:14 and living in there.
00:52:15 So you're spending money
00:52:17 to keep people out
00:52:18 from what could potentially
00:52:19 serve as housing
00:52:20 rather than just
00:52:21 converting it to housing.
00:52:23 That seems just
00:52:24 incredibly wasteful to me.
00:52:25 They are saying
00:52:28 they are redeveloping it
00:52:29 into a plaza
00:52:30 and a high-density
00:52:31 residential development.
00:52:32 So in a way,
00:52:33 there you go, Alex.
00:52:33 Your wish is granted.
00:52:35 This is housing.
00:52:36 But I'm going to,
00:52:38 speaking of memorandum
00:52:38 of understanding,
00:52:39 let's do a memorandum
00:52:40 of understanding
00:52:40 with the audience
00:52:41 and understand that
00:52:42 everything you heard today
00:52:43 was off the record.
00:52:48 Nicely played.
00:52:49 Funny.
00:52:51 Oh my God.
00:52:52 I mean,
00:52:52 I thought it was funny
00:52:53 when I made that whole joke
00:52:55 but the stadium
00:52:56 potentially never getting built
00:52:57 because again,
00:52:58 you know,
00:52:58 you have this great
00:53:00 big resistance out west
00:53:01 or actually out
00:53:03 in British Columbia.
00:53:04 I shouldn't say out west
00:53:05 because I think Alberta
00:53:05 and Sichuan
00:53:06 want nothing more
00:53:07 than shovels in the ground.
00:53:09 Even Manitoba
00:53:10 might be more open
00:53:10 than BC.
00:53:12 I think BC
00:53:12 is really an exclusive case
00:53:14 when it comes to
00:53:14 its anti-pipeline,
00:53:16 anti-energy standpoint,
00:53:18 frankly.
00:53:19 But it would be interesting
00:53:21 to look at the environmental
00:53:22 costs of having a stadium
00:53:24 in the city of Vancouver.
00:53:25 You know,
00:53:25 or on the outskirts
00:53:26 of the city as well.
00:53:26 I'm sure there's
00:53:27 a great financial cost
00:53:28 and perhaps an argument
00:53:30 that maybe David Eby
00:53:31 should be having
00:53:32 instead of deducting
00:53:33 a whole pipeline project
00:53:34 with massive economic potential
00:53:36 of exporting more oil
00:53:38 to the Asian markets
00:53:40 on the west coast.
00:53:42 stopping by the Turkish
00:54:02 of the Classroom
00:54:03 coming from soprano to the
00:54:04 the Mississippi
00:54:06 on the north side of Delcoe.