Juno News - September 27, 2023


Anthony Rota's resignation doesn't end shameful Nazi scandal

Mentioned
Liberals scapegoat Anthony Rota for honouring Nazi veteran Danielle Smith says booster plans are none of the media's business

Episode Stats


Length

44 minutes

Words per minute

179.0

Word count

8,006

Sentence count

379

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

11

sentences flagged

Hate speech

7

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

On today's show, Andrew Lawton talks about the latest in fake news stories, including a report that police found cocaine on a plane carrying Prime Minister Justin Trudeau. And he talks about a story about Nazi veteran Yaroslav Hunka's recognition in the House of Commons.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:20 north hello and welcome to you all this is another edition of canada's most irreverent talk show here
00:01:31 on true north i'm so sorry we were almost starting a few minutes late you see i was a bit delayed
00:01:36 uh you wouldn't believe it a bunch of these uh police and dogs just got on my plane on the way
00:01:42 here and they accused me of all sorts of horrific things they uh suggested i might have had cocaine
00:01:47 on board. But no, nothing like that happened. In fact, I've never heard of anything like that
00:01:52 happening anywhere in the news as of late. I am kidding. Of course, the people in the live,
00:01:58 I wasn't even going to mention this story, but people in the live chat apparently are demanding
00:02:02 like Trudeau detained in India because of cocaine stories. And I am a firm believer in giving the
00:02:08 people what they want. Let me just say there is zero evidence so far to support this claim that
00:02:15 was made on Indian TV by some former Indian diplomat that Justin Trudeau's plane didn't
00:02:20 have mechanical failures. It was that police from India boarded and found cocaine or something like
00:02:26 that. I saw this thing like swirling around on Twitter a few days ago and didn't really pay
00:02:32 much heed to it. I looked into it and couldn't find anything to substantiate it. And then the
00:02:36 Toronto Sun picked it up, not saying authoritatively that it happened, but just saying that India had
00:02:42 accused it of happening or some people in india and i i have heard from one reporter that was on
00:02:48 the trip who i i know and trust that no one boarded the plane at all and you know journalists
00:02:54 were on the plane so i feel like it would probably have gotten out even with how sycophantish some of
00:02:59 them are if like drug sniffing dogs had gotten aboard and and whatnot but it's a fun story
00:03:05 alas it appears to be at this point fiction so don't get too too excited just you don't here's
00:03:11 the thing about Justin Trudeau. He wins when the fake news stories circulate because he gives
00:03:16 enough real news stories to justify criticizing him. You don't need the fake news stories. But
00:03:21 when there are these faker stories that go around, it allows them to kind of hide behind it and say,
00:03:26 oh, well, it's all just fake news and misinformation and all that. And that is not what we try to do
00:03:32 on this show. In fact, we try to do the opposite. And I'll say I never like doing this too much,
00:03:37 but I've been working on a story about Chrystia Freeland that I'm going to have coming out
00:03:42 afterwards. I'm just waiting to, you know, get a couple of my ducks in a row. And at a certain
00:03:46 point, like this government has done enough that we don't need to manufacture stuff. So that is my
00:03:53 little PSA here. Sorry to be a buzzkill. I know you probably were so excited. I was going in one
00:03:57 particular direction at the beginning, but I am going to be talking a little bit more on this
00:04:02 program about the recognition of that Nazi veteran Yaroslav Hunka in the House of Commons
00:04:08 on Friday, a chapter that has, as we say in the media business, legs. This is a story that keeps
00:04:15 on going. It keeps on delivering. And it's one that the government has not been able to just
00:04:21 shake. They have tried to shake it. They've tried to basically claim that this was all just Anthony
00:04:26 wrote us doing the speaker of the house and now as of yesterday he is outgoing his role is going
00:04:32 to be filled by someone else on tomorrow's or in tomorrow's sitting in the house of commons but
00:04:38 i'll play a little bit from his resignation announcement for you
00:04:43 is above any of us therefore i must step down as your speaker
00:04:48 I reiterate my profound regret for my error in recognizing an individual in the House
00:04:56 during the Joint Address to Parliament of President Zelensky.
00:05:00 That public recognition has caused pain to individuals and communities,
00:05:05 including the Jewish community in Canada and around the world,
00:05:08 in addition to survivors of Nazi atrocities in Poland, among other nations.
00:05:13 i accept full responsibility for my actions my resignation is effective at the end of the
00:05:22 sitting day tomorrow wednesday september 27th to allow preparations for the election of a new
00:05:28 speaker until that time the deputy speakers will chair the house proceedings thank you merci
00:05:36 we saw the deputy speaker who's actually a conservative chris d'antremont take over
00:05:44 yesterday during question period which is usually presided over not by one of the deputy speakers but
00:05:49 by the speaker of the house himself so he is outgoing and look he clearly made a grievous
00:05:55 error in judgment and as he was reading i don't we don't have the clip today and i don't need to
00:06:00 play it again but as he was reading that recognition of Yaroslav Hunka it looked at a
00:06:06 certain point like he was kind of just taking that moment of okay he fought against the Russians
00:06:12 maybe there's something there but then he kept going he called him a Ukrainian hero and a Canadian
00:06:18 hero and he paused for members of that chamber to stand up and give Mr. Hunka that standing ovation
00:06:26 which is very undeserved, and virtually every MP, if not every MP who was part of it, has said so
00:06:32 in the days since. This happened five days ago. Originally, it was from a couple of these corners
00:06:40 of the internet that are often disregarded that we're talking about this. Of course, because
00:06:45 Jewish people were in the throes of Shabbat at first, and then preparations for Yom Kippur,
00:06:50 They probably didn't tweak to it as early as they would have.
00:06:54 And what was interesting is that all of this effectively came down to people in independent media that noticed this and eventually sought for some accounting on this.
00:07:06 And the government has ever since tried to devote 100% of the blame on Anthony Rota.
00:07:12 They've tried to make him a black box of shame here so that nothing penetrates into their side of the aisle.
00:07:20 The Conservatives, as I mentioned yesterday, have been the ones trying to throw Anthony
00:07:24 Rhoda a bone. 0.93
00:07:25 This is ethics critic for the Conservatives, Michael Barrett, doing just that in the House
00:07:29 of Commons this week.
00:07:31 Time and time again, this Prime Minister and his Liberal House leaders say, I had no idea
00:07:36 it didn't involve me.
00:07:38 Time and time again, this Liberal Prime Minister fails in his duties to Canadians and has someone
00:07:45 else take the fall.
00:07:47 This week, it looks like he's going to come to you, Speaker, and ask you to leave
00:07:51 and to take the garbage out with you on the way out.
00:07:53 Is that really what this government wants to show to Canadians?
00:07:58 The Honourable Government House Leader.
00:08:02 Mr. Speaker, again, that Honourable colleague would have seen your statement yesterday,
00:08:07 heard your apology in the House today, where the Speaker confirmed that this was his decision
00:08:14 and his decision alone to invite this individual from his riding
00:08:18 to acknowledge him in the gallery, we were all caught off guard by this.
00:08:25 We all stood and applauded because we were led to believe
00:08:29 that this was an individual who he was not.
00:08:32 And that is something that hurts all of us and embarrasses all of us.
00:08:37 But there was no prior knowledge from the government.
00:08:39 we were caught off guard how could we have known now karina gould as we learned was one of the few
00:08:49 mps to actually have a photograph taken up close and personal with yarislav hunka she was uh standing
00:08:56 oh my i didn't even tell sean i was using that he just like plucked that out in like one second's
00:09:01 notice good job sean uh there she is with her hand clasping mr hunka's hand smiling with anthony
00:09:07 Rhoda smiling with, I believe, Yaroslav's son, who we're told initiated this exchange with Anthony
00:09:14 Rhoda that got that man invited in the first place. So Karina Gould has actually had more
00:09:19 interaction with this guy than anyone else in the House of Commons so far as we know. So for her to
00:09:25 say, I mean, what were they talking about? Like, seriously, did she just walk by in the hall, pose
00:09:30 for the photo and leave without speaking to him? Did she stop and ask him about his service? Did
00:09:35 Did she say, oh, wow, you know, he, sir, when, how, how did he fight against the Russians?
00:09:39 When, when did he fight against the Russians?
00:09:41 Anything prior to 1945 should have made even the biggest failure in the high school history class realize, well, hey, okay, but, but the Russians in, in World War II, they were on, like, and I'm not saying Karina Gould was a failure in history.
00:09:59 She is a very smart and intelligent woman, which is why it's all the more shameful that she, like others, is saying, well, how could we have known?
00:10:08 And she has decided to blame.
00:10:12 People have pointed to conservatives and said, well, you know, they were up there cheering, too.
00:10:17 Absolutely. Because at that point, you know, I don't blame individual members of parliament, individual MPs for clapping when they're being introduced to this guy.
00:10:27 he didn't say during World War II in his remarks that I can recall. So I can understand them just 0.95
00:10:32 saying, oh, well, he's up there. He's a veteran. We're being told he's a Ukrainian veteran who
00:10:36 fought off the Russians. Okay, great. He must be a good guy. And it's in that moment where I don't
00:10:42 necessarily blame people for clapping, but it's beyond that. Anyone who was speaking at any point
00:10:50 with this guy or with his family or with Anthony Roda that should have been part of a pregnant 0.99
00:10:55 pause on what this guy was. I was, for this story I have coming out at two o'clock Eastern today,
00:11:01 I was speaking with a Ukrainian professor who's a very pro-Ukraine guy, and he said this is
00:11:07 shameful. He said, Ukrainians, no Ukrainian in their right mind, he told me, would support
00:11:13 honoring someone in this. He said, yes, there's a complicated history, and yes, Ukrainians have
00:11:17 had to undergo a historical reckoning to that effect, but it's because of that that no one
00:11:22 would celebrate someone in this way in the right mind. Now, I should say I had one person tell me
00:11:29 that they were suspecting it was so, so clear and so obvious and so brazen that this must have been
00:11:35 a setup. Now, I don't know who they're blaming for the setup. Was it Pierre Polyev? There's been
00:11:39 some of the true anons on Twitter making that claim. Was it Russia that, you know, got this guy
00:11:45 to call up Anthony Roda and got Anthony Roda to issue the invitation? Who knows? Maybe there was
00:11:50 some four-dimensional chess, or maybe it was just this shameful and regrettable aberration in Canada.
00:11:56 But the thing is, when we were talking about India, which was the big story for all of five
00:12:01 minutes, we said, or I said on this show, that Justin Trudeau has surrendered the benefit of
00:12:08 the doubt. And I keep coming back to this because it's so important. His record on governing in
00:12:12 Canada, his record on foreign policy is such that no one can look at him and say, well, I'm sure he
00:12:18 meant well anymore because there has been blunder after blunder after blunder. And why that's so
00:12:24 important here is because when something comes up of this nature on this scale, no Canadian is buying
00:12:30 into the idea that the most micromanaging, centralized, powerful PMO was not involved in
00:12:38 many stages of the vetting process of who was up in the House of Commons in the coveted speakers
00:12:45 gallery. That's what's happening here. No one believes what Trudeau is saying. Now, I'm not
00:12:49 saying Justin Trudeau personally had knowledge of or orchestrated this guy's invitation or
00:12:54 recognition, but I do think it's very implausible that no one outside of Anthony Roda and a couple
00:13:01 of the staffers that he may have in his office was aware of this given the nature of it. And if not,
00:13:06 the most charitable interpretation, the most charitable response to all of this 1.00
00:13:11 is just how profoundly dumb people in that office are. 0.99
00:13:15 Like, that's how bad things are with this government, 1.00
00:13:18 that they have to be like, okay, okay,
00:13:20 the issue is not that we're evil, 1.00
00:13:21 the issue is that we're morons. 1.00
00:13:23 And that's sadly where we are here. 1.00
00:13:26 Peter Coleman is the head
00:13:28 of the National Citizens Coalition,
00:13:29 a group that has a long history
00:13:31 in this country of political advocacy.
00:13:34 He said in a missive that went out today
00:13:37 that there is really at its core here,
00:13:39 another example of the virtue signaling we've come to know and expect from this government.
00:13:44 Peter joins me now. It's good to talk to you again, sir. Thanks for coming on.
00:13:48 Thanks for having me on, Andrew.
00:13:50 Let's talk about that for a moment. I mean, virtue signaling has been, I'd say, the most consistent
00:13:54 thing resembling ideology that this government has been bound by. And you're saying this is
00:14:00 really the consequence of that on full display here yet again.
00:14:04 Everything they seem to do is virtual signaling. The government's incapable of apologizing to make
00:14:09 mistakes as you said um the pmo's office had to know what was going on with this i mean that's
00:14:14 as you said it's a very tightly controlled group so he doesn't get the benefit of your comments so
00:14:19 true andrew i mean there's been scandal after scandal after scandal the country's becoming an
00:14:23 international embarrassment and trudeau just doesn't get it and he doesn't care and i don't
00:14:27 think he andrew isn't capable of apologizing i don't think it's in his blood yeah and i was
00:14:33 wondering if you could extrapolate on that or elaborate on that rather a little bit more
00:14:37 Because that's, I'd say, been one of the very recurring themes in this government is that the level of shamelessness when they have been caught in one of the myriad scandals going back to, you know, vacationing with the Aga Khan, which seems just quaint by today's standards of scandal and even SNC-Lavalin and getting caught in blackface. 0.86
00:14:55 Like somehow it becomes a learning opportunity and a growth opportunity for everyone but Trudeau.
00:15:01 But that's just it.
00:15:02 I mean, the quality of people like Philippot and Raybalt and Morneau and all the people that have to leave that party because of mistakes that Trudeau make, he's incapable of taking blame. 0.92
00:15:12 He's just shameless.
00:15:13 I mean, the thing that strikes me with Trudeau is he's too cute by half. 0.71
00:15:17 He thinks he's the smartest person in the room.
00:15:20 And I would say a lot of times he's far from that to be charitable.
00:15:23 And every scandal that's gone on, it's always been it's a learning issue for Canadians, like the same thing with Rota having to retire a Speaker of the House.
00:15:30 It has nothing to do with Canadians, other than we're being embarrassed and shamed.
00:15:34 It's all to do with Trudeau making a mistake of a massive scale.
00:15:38 As you said, it's on the heels of the debacle in India.
00:15:41 Everything he does is through such a narrow prism of things that he thinks are important to the country.
00:15:46 And the country deserves better.
00:15:47 This isn't the way a country should be run.
00:15:49 He should care what Canadians feel as far as our values, and he could care less.
00:15:53 Well, at one point, and I'm going far afield here, so feel free to rein me back in if you need to, Peter.
00:15:58 But this is a government that has often not focused too much effort on the idea of promoting any sort of nationalism or nationality for Canadians.
00:16:06 The idea of citizenship, which used to be a very core concept in Canada, certainly under conservative governments, is no longer regarded as such by this government.
00:16:16 And it's odd how that sort of creeps up in weird ways.
00:16:19 So this Nazi veteran was being introduced as a Canadian hero.
00:16:24 Well, we have statues being torn down of what I would call bona fide Canadian heroes all across this country.
00:16:32 Yeah, it's just amazing.
00:16:34 You look through the prism of all these things and you wonder what's going on in Trudeau's head.
00:16:38 I mean, the party can't like what's going on because it goes from scandal to scandal to scandal.
00:16:42 But the country deserves better.
00:16:44 We deserve common sense.
00:16:45 We deserve free speech.
00:16:46 We deserve free enterprise to thrive.
00:16:48 We deserve the solid resources of the world.
00:16:50 and all Trudeau cares about in his narrow prism is gender equality and climate change and those
00:16:55 two issues while they're important are not the top issues for most Canadians are trying to get by
00:16:59 and they're getting screwed by carbon taxes and things that make no sense and they're driving up
00:17:04 food prices but he's incapable Andrew of doing anything about it because he believes in his
00:17:10 views nobody in the party's strong enough to stand up to the guy and say look at you're on the wrong
00:17:14 track they're all afraid of getting re-elected and that's a symbol of politician that days are
00:17:18 past. I mean, eight to 10 years in politics, people are tired of seeing your face. They're
00:17:23 tired of Trudeau, clearly. Well, you say that about, you know, gender equality and climate
00:17:28 change, and it's actually disgraceful how correct you are. Like if Hitler had committed to gender
00:17:33 parity in the SS leadership, Justin Trudeau would say, well, you know, you got to hand it to him.
00:17:38 You know, it's actually not that big of a joke if you think about it, given how the government
00:17:43 talks about china which is you know one of the big villains in the global geopolitics today but 1.00
00:17:50 they say oh well you know they're partners in climate at least yeah but they're not china's
00:17:54 not doing it but if we want to solve like we're 1.5 of the world's greenhouse gases if we want
00:17:59 to solve that problem we'd ship natural gas to china we're never going to go to zero and it's
00:18:03 a mug's game to think we're going to do that and until china and india get on board we we can't
00:18:08 get there and if we want our country to thrive oil and gas has to thrive too because it creates a lot
00:18:12 of high paying jobs, pays a lot of taxes. And this 2030 nonsense as far as being net zero is
00:18:18 absolute nonsense. Anybody with a brain knows that's not possible. Yes, we should do our piece 0.73
00:18:23 to try and reduce our emissions. And we are probably the cleanest developer of natural
00:18:28 resources in the world. Why don't we start doing what's right as far as climate change instead of
00:18:32 gerrymandering just nonsensical agreements and deadlines that just don't make any sense and will
00:18:36 not work. One of your predecessors at the National Citizens Coalition is a man that some people may
00:18:42 know, by the name of Stephen Harper, who did a great deal of work in the NCC role and then
00:18:48 eventually in government in Canada. And, you know, there were obviously negative news stories about
00:18:53 Stephen Harper. No government is immune from scandal. No governments were ever able to get
00:18:59 through without some criticism. I mean, Stephen Harper had the Mike Duffy scandal as being a
00:19:03 notable one, which I thought was blown way out of proportion. But that's a story for another day.
00:19:08 The thing about it, though, is that there seems to be a relentlessness in the Trudeau government, who's been in power now for two years fewer than Stephen Harper was.
00:19:20 And the number of big scandals that have rocked this government has vastly expanded that of Stephen Harper's time.
00:19:28 But, of course, with the media's approach to that, there's a bit of a double standard.
00:19:32 It's true. I was talking with Stephen Harper in the summer. I said, where do you think we are on the international stage?
00:19:38 He said, he said, the worst thing is our allies don't respect us anymore.
00:19:43 And there's problems with that, too.
00:19:44 And the only good thing is there's groups like True North that actually do hold the feet to the fire of politicians,
00:19:50 because the mainstream media has been bought and paid for by Trudeau for so long.
00:19:55 They seem unable to deal with the real issues and know the real problems are.
00:19:58 But fortunately, the crack seems to be showing a bit, Andrew, where even the mainstream media can't cover for this guy anymore.
00:20:03 And I hope that that continues.
00:20:05 But you look at Harper's record and compare it to Trudeau's, people could dislike Harper for all kinds of reasons, I guess.
00:20:11 I was never one of them, but his record is clear.
00:20:15 Responsible, accountable.
00:20:16 He took care of the Canadian people.
00:20:18 He cared about them. 0.63
00:20:19 Trudeau doesn't give a damn about Canada. 0.65
00:20:21 These days, I think he hates the country, the way he treats us.
00:20:25 Let's go back to basics here.
00:20:27 You're a grassroots organization, the National Citizens Coalition here.
00:20:31 Do you think stories like this actually make a difference on the ground?
00:20:36 Because there is a bubble mentality in a lot of news where you get a story that to people
00:20:40 that, you know, like you and I, that are freaks who just, you know, spend our lives immersed
00:20:43 in politics, they matter to us, but, you know, they're not a thing that's discussed around
00:20:48 the kitchen table.
00:20:49 I know this story is being discussed around the tables of a lot of Jewish families in
00:20:53 Canada.
00:20:54 So I can say first and foremost that it's got legs there.
00:20:57 But do you think this is the type of thing that actually matters to real Canadians beyond the Jewish community?
00:21:03 Yeah, I think it does, because people are offended by one of their most holiest of holidays.
00:21:08 This thing pops up and just an incredible embarrassment to their community and what happened to their people in World War II and other times.
00:21:15 And I do think it does, because if I was a liberal MP right now, Andrew, that won my riding by 5% last time, I'd be looking for a new job.
00:21:23 The media tried to vilify Paulio for the longest time, and he's got some growing to do too,
00:21:28 but I like the way he's headed. He's talking about common sense issues that people care about.
00:21:32 And I do think that people are saying, he's been around for eight years, I can't really
00:21:37 count on what he's going to do going forward. But I do know his past means he's not going to
00:21:41 do much proper for Canada going forward. So I'm prepared to look at the alternatives. And I think
00:21:46 Paulio is doing a good job of that with his platform and what he's saying.
00:21:49 yeah and i i would actually extend expand on that a little bit because one of the big challenges
00:21:56 we're seeing here in in this country is that the government very much talks down to canadians
00:22:02 and it goes back to that pattern i was talking about with scandals whenever the government is
00:22:06 immersed in them is that it's a learning opportunity for everyone else they kind of
00:22:10 believe they occupy this moral high ground well it's astounding i mean you saw these
00:22:15 rabbis in the past week with the muslim groups being supported by mennonites and marching to say
00:22:20 we want to protect our children and save our children and that group was vilified as a far
00:22:24 right-wing group i wouldn't think that's the case whatsoever and it's just everything he does
00:22:28 you're right if he doesn't agree with you is sort of turned back in their face and vilified but
00:22:33 he is incapable as a leader of listening to what people's points of view are that don't agree with
00:22:37 him and it's very clear that's the case now and there's nobody in the party that's capable it
00:22:42 seems to sing Justin this needs to stop it just goes on and on and on and Canada deserves better
00:22:48 well we know for a fact there were I don't know if you saw this there were some tweets
00:22:53 uh last night of outside the uh parliamentary precinct where the liberals had some emergency
00:22:59 a cabinet or caucus meeting at like 9 30 p.m at night so you don't normally have meetings at 9 30
00:23:05 p.m at night that are not really announced with any notice unless you are in crisis and I mean
00:23:11 And at a certain point, I'm looking at all the liberal MPs that are in that situation you just described, that maybe they're not true believers, maybe they're softer liberals, or maybe they're in very tight ridings that are looking at these poll numbers, showing the conservatives at well over 40 percent, saying, OK, we can't just keep lecturing people in the way we have for the last eight years.
00:23:30 We've got to offer something new. And, you know, to be honest, I'm actually amazed it's taken so long for the liberal caucus to grow a little bit of a spine and start asking some questions of its leadership right now.
00:23:41 Yeah, well, we've got tens of thousands of members across the country,
00:23:44 and you hear all the time as far as when are we getting back to normal basic values?
00:23:48 But what strikes me, Andrew, as an issue is when John Kretchen was prime minister,
00:23:53 like we're a fiscally conservative organization that believes in free speech
00:23:56 and a strong military and responsible spending.
00:23:59 Well, Kretchen had guys like Manly and Martin and McKenna that were capable people.
00:24:02 So even a conservative person like me would say they're doing a decent job
00:24:06 because at the end of the day as a Canadian, you want the country to succeed
00:24:09 whether the guy in power is who you support or not there's just no sense there's anybody around
00:24:14 them that can do what's right uh on issues or values or international relationships and
00:24:19 i don't know where it ends for for trudeau but it's not going to end up well that's for sure
00:24:23 because elections two years away i'm shocked that singh is still propping him up but um
00:24:29 as it goes on and on and on gets further i don't see how true it can get out of this
00:24:33 it's just it's just who he is yeah i mean dragnit singh found his spine when he was standing up to
00:24:39 give that ovation on Friday, but he hasn't found a spine at any other point in the last two years
00:24:43 of Canadian politics. Peter Coleman is with us from the National Citizens Coalition. Good to
00:24:48 talk to you, Peter. Thanks for coming on today. Thank you, Andrew. Take care of yourself. All
00:24:52 right. Thank you, sir. Yourself as well. We've had a few questions in the comments. One of them
00:24:58 in particular I found interesting, and I've seen this asked a lot in various forms. Roger says
00:25:03 deportation from Canada of every Nazi and their family member should be considered
00:25:07 as a corrective action of this disgraceful event
00:25:11 enabled by the current leading minister's actions.
00:25:14 Your thoughts?
00:25:15 It's a complicated question
00:25:17 and I don't consider myself an expert
00:25:19 in every aspect of this.
00:25:21 I've certainly become more familiar with it
00:25:23 in the last five days as I've looked into this,
00:25:25 but I do know that there has been a difference
00:25:27 in the way that certainly German soldiers have been treated
00:25:30 who are generally not regarded as Nazis or criminals
00:25:33 versus members of the SS
00:25:35 who do not have the ability to hide behind. I was just a frontline soldier, nothing to do with the
00:25:40 Holocaust, nothing to do with war crimes. And the challenge here is that the Ukrainian unit in 0.89
00:25:48 question, the 1st Galician Division, has been treated a little bit differently. There was a
00:25:53 report in 1986, which was done by the Deshane Commission, as it was called, that looked into
00:25:58 this and found they couldn't just en masse call anyone who was a part of this a war criminal. Now,
00:26:04 there were two parts to this report. One of them was public and people can see it now. And it's
00:26:10 where the commissioner made the finding that this division was not itself complicit in war crimes
00:26:15 that you could say applied to everyone or was not a criminal organization. And the other side of it,
00:26:21 part two, actually had a very detailed accounting of every identified Nazi in Canada. This has to
00:26:30 this day in the last 37 years, never been published. Jewish groups have called for it to be
00:26:36 published, but it has not happened. Christopher Freeland was actually asked about this, whether
00:26:41 it was time to reopen the report. I've been a breath to reopen a report by the Duchesne Commission
00:26:48 so that Canadians can know how many veterans who fought with the Nazis are here in our country.
00:26:54 Will the government do so? And what is your response to that?
00:27:00 I think, you know, let me just start by reiterating, and I don't think it can be said
00:27:12 too many times, how hurtful for so many people in Canada and around the world
00:27:24 what happened
00:27:27 was and has been and continues to be.
00:27:38 As MPs,
00:27:40 in our capacity as MPs,
00:27:42 it's important for appropriate next steps
00:27:46 in the House to be taken,
00:27:48 and I think that is our immediate focus.
00:27:51 and as a government we're going to be very thoughtful about any further steps that need to
00:28:02 be taken i'm sorry i don't recall anything resembling an answer coming out in that it was
00:28:12 you know reiterating the deep regret and sympathy and embarrassment and all of that and then saying
00:28:16 that we're going to be very careful about those next steps we had actually tried to get someone
00:28:20 from B'nai B'rith on the show today.
00:28:23 I think we're going to move on with that tomorrow.
00:28:26 We weren't able to make the scheduling worked out
00:28:28 because they've been calling for this.
00:28:30 And Michael Barrett,
00:28:31 from whom I played that clip earlier in the show,
00:28:33 had introduced a motion in committee in April
00:28:36 calling for the release of the second part of that report.
00:28:41 And that motion never ended up getting voted on
00:28:44 so far as I'm able to tell.
00:28:45 And I'm not sure if that was
00:28:46 because it was blocked by the government
00:28:48 or there was some other procedural reason
00:28:50 why. I haven't been able to get a satisfactory answer. I emailed Michael Barrett. He never
00:28:55 responded to me, so I don't know. Maybe I'm on the naughty list, or maybe it's just a busy week in
00:28:59 Ottawa. I'm kidding. Don't worry. But nevertheless, we will follow the story, and I suspect we'll have
00:29:05 a bit more on this tomorrow, so I would encourage you to stay tuned on that. I wanted to turn to
00:29:12 local politics. I mean, all politics that matters is local in some form, but we have seen increasingly
00:29:17 in Canada, and we can go back to the Freedom Convoy and many years beyond that, a very strained
00:29:23 relationship between governments and freedom of speech, freedom of expression, the right for you
00:29:29 not only to have a political opinion, but to express it and even to protest. Protest is one
00:29:35 of the most important aspects of freedom of expression because freedom of expression is a
00:29:41 vehicle by which we can seek change in society. We can seek change from government and we can
00:29:46 seek change from other groups that are doing things we believe are protestable. But some people
00:29:51 don't like that. And as we've reported at True North, in the city of Calgary, there is a bylaw
00:29:58 that is now facing a legal challenge. It's a bylaw that establishes a so-called buffer zone
00:30:03 between protesters and some events. Let's be real, it's not in the bylaw, but this came about as a
00:30:10 direct response to protests of drag story times and it's a bylaw that restricts your ability to
00:30:18 protest any event that effectively the government the municipal government deems to be protected
00:30:24 it's not allowing you to protest with if they believe you are engaging in quote hateful
00:30:30 messaging we fast forward to another story out of waterloo ontario where there's a proposal
00:30:36 not yet a bylaw, but a proposal to ban communication that makes people, quote,
00:30:43 feel harassed, unquote. That's literally from the text of the report, quote, that makes them feel
00:30:49 harassed. There's a great story up at True North from my colleague, Cosmin Georgia, that I would
00:30:54 encourage you to take a look at. But to go back to the Calgary bylaw, it's being challenged by
00:30:59 the Canadian Constitution Foundation. Joanna Barron joins me now, the executive director over there,
00:31:05 And also one of the co-authors of a great new book about the COVID era policy, which I will certainly have her and her co-author, Christine Van Gein, on to talk about.
00:31:14 But all that aside, it's good to talk to you, Joanna. Thanks for coming on.
00:31:18 Great to be here with you, Andrew.
00:31:20 So let's talk about the reality, I mean, the subtext of this bylaw here, because they're not just going after protest in general.
00:31:26 You know from the context and the wording, they're going after a very particular type of protest, and they're really targeting it to a very particular type of viewpoint, I would say.
00:31:37 Well, yes, although it's not as narrow as you would think.
00:31:40 You're certainly correct that this came out as a response to protests around Drag Queen Story Hour.
00:31:46 However, the text of the bylaw says bans protests on issues relating to gender, national identity, a whole category that could apply to many things.
00:31:57 So my colleague Christine pointed out that if you wanted to have a protest about against female genital mutilation, since that is understood to be a cultural and religious practice, that would be caught under the bylaw.
00:32:11 And so it's actually a sort of wide swath of categories. Even, you know, protesting against climate change would be caught by the bylaw. And so it's a whole category of things. But as you say, the important part to remember is that this is sort of demarcating different types of protests that Calgary City Council are saying are permissible and not permissible, whereas the Supreme Court of Canada has been very clear that the guarantee of freedom of expression is content neutral.
00:32:40 The state doesn't get to say what I can demonstrate and protest about.
00:32:45 Well, and on that note, I would also point out here that political speech is the most protected, basically.
00:32:52 It's deemed the most important.
00:32:53 It's, you know, free speech isn't just your right to say, I prefer milk to cream in my coffee or something like that.
00:32:58 And that's where, you know, the things that need the most protection are the things that are the most prone to being censored or to be reined in.
00:33:07 Yeah, absolutely.
00:33:08 Absolutely. And moreover, where there's, as you mentioned, there's buffer zones that are identified in this bylaw, which tend to be, you know, areas of 500 meters close to recreation centers and libraries.
00:33:21 And first of all, it's hard if you know downtown Calgary, there isn't many areas where you wouldn't find a library or rec center somewhere within 500 meters.
00:33:29 And like those are the places where civil society tends to gather. So it's a terribly draconian bylaw.
00:33:37 I would also note that it carries a penalty of up to $10,000 or a term of imprisonment.
00:33:43 So actually, one of the arguments at the Canadian Constitution Foundation that we're making is that this is, in substance, a criminal law, which city councils is a matter of federal jurisdiction.
00:33:55 So city councils actually outside of their jurisdiction, not to mention acting unconstitutionally on freedom of expression grounds.
00:34:03 One of the challenges that comes up here is that when there is, as broadly as it's put, as you shared, Joanna, this bylaw in place, it effectively leaves everything up to discretion, which means it's up to bylaw enforcement to decide on a case-by-case basis whether they want to.
00:34:21 and it's very East Germany in the sense that they have a law that basically lets them go after
00:34:28 anyone and everyone and we're just to expect that, well, they'll pick and choose and they'll
00:34:32 really only go after the people who deserve it. Who is it that gets the authority to decide
00:34:36 when to apply this? Yeah, completely. The discretion will be left to the police and it
00:34:43 will be them that decides whether to go ahead and lay charges and we can assume that certain
00:34:49 politically correct demonstrations that Calgary City Council perhaps agrees with, because this is
00:34:55 a very clear signal. And we do know from the debates at City Council that indeed they brought
00:35:00 this about in response to concerns of protests about drag queen story hour. Whereas just to be
00:35:05 clear, this is not about us taking a position for or against drag queen story hour. I would also add
00:35:11 that if you were to protest drag queen story hour, and you wanted to run a counter protest in favor
00:35:17 of drag queen story hour guess what that's also relating to gender and sexuality so that also
00:35:24 would be prohibited by the bylaw now whether you would be charged we don't know i'll say i know
00:35:30 you have a big audience but i'll say that within the team of the ccf we talked about maybe if we
00:35:35 go out to calgary and do our own protest against for example female genital mutilation let's see
00:35:40 if we get arrested. But we elected not to, and we elected to just seek public interest
00:35:47 standing to challenge this bylaw. Well, let me ask you about that legal challenge. I mean,
00:35:54 do you need to wait for someone to be, in your view, unfairly prosecuted or charged under this?
00:36:01 Or can you affect, it's not a legal term, but can you challenge it on spec? Say, you know,
00:36:05 irrespective of how and when this is used, it's bad on its face and needs to go.
00:36:09 So we can say as a public interest charity, and we are a legal charity that has a long track record of fighting for the enforcement of constitutional rights in court, that no, that harm has existed, has happened since this became law.
00:36:23 And so we're challenging it on the basis of you should be able to look at this law facially, see that it is not content neutral, that it singles out different types of peaceful, constitutionally protected expression, as well as the guarantee for freedom of assembly.
00:36:39 And you should be able to determine that that is contrary to the Constitution.
00:36:44 So you can, you know, seek public interest, standing in challenge.
00:36:47 I wouldn't quite say on spec because there is an important chilling effect, right, that whether or not somebody is actually charged, isn't it disturbing that somebody would have to think, well, I'm not sure if, you know, this, I want to protest Israel or Palestine, either one, for example, but I'm not sure if the Calgary police are going to arrest me.
00:37:10 we would say at the CCF, you've already done the damage. You've already chilled what is legitimate
00:37:15 political protected expression. That's actually quite an important point. And I mean, I remember
00:37:22 when the COVID stuff was going along, I mean, I've never been too much of a rabble. I guess I've 1.00
00:37:26 roused a bit of a rabble in my day. But when there was talk of Ontario potentially doing a curfew, 0.99
00:37:32 I was like, I'm going to be out on the streets at 9pm every night. Like I'm in bed at like 9.30.
00:37:37 So, like, I would have been doing it purely to be a disturber of the fecal matter.
00:37:41 But some people would have done the opposite.
00:37:43 As you've said, say, oh, well, I don't want a ticket, especially when in COVID, as I know
00:37:47 you'll be writing about in your upcoming book, some of the fines were so steep.
00:37:51 A lot of people that, you know, just might have been tempted to do something would say,
00:37:55 you know, I don't want to risk the penalty.
00:37:57 And I can see that exact thing happening here.
00:37:59 Someone who says, well, you know, I'm all for protesting, but I don't want to break
00:38:02 the law.
00:38:03 I don't want to deal with that.
00:38:05 Yeah, exactly.
00:38:05 It just like, you know, people said to us that they didn't want to donate to the CCF after the Freedom Convoy, because even though they were pretty sure it was okay, who wants to risk having their bank accounts frozen? And we talk a lot more about that in Pandemic Panic, which is available for pre-order on Amazon now.
00:38:22 Well, definitely we'll have you and Christine back on that. Let me just ask you about the process here as best as you've been able to unearth it, because I know the federal government in particular, they'll run every bit of legislation by the Department of Justice and supposedly charter proof it or offer recommendations on how to immunize it to some extent against a charter challenge.
00:38:42 municipalities aren't as well resourced but do we think there was any legal input at all on this
00:38:49 that we've been able to see where a lawyer gave them the case for why this was justifiable so we
00:38:54 know for example in terms of process this was rammed through in a single session an extended
00:38:59 debate on the merits of the bill which we know certain councillors did raise concerns about the
00:39:04 constitutionality perhaps ones with a legal background but this was pushed through in a
00:39:09 single session without any extended debate. So we are inclined to think that they did not give
00:39:15 this extensive legal consideration. And they were quite surprised when we challenged it right out
00:39:22 the gate. Have you had a chance to review, I know it's not made it into a bylaw yet, but what they've
00:39:28 proposed in Waterloo, which strikes me as very similar and just the epitome of subjective here,
00:39:34 things that make you feel harassed. Like I feel harassed sometimes by an ad that I might not like,
00:39:39 but I don't believe it should be taken down with any force of law.
00:39:43 Yeah. So the report, the Waterloo report defines being harassed as feeling tormented, troubled,
00:39:48 worried, plagued, or badgered. And we are actually talking about this this morning on our podcast,
00:39:53 not reserving judgment. I mean, who doesn't feel badgered on a daily basis? I live in downtown
00:39:58 Toronto. It's kind of part of the game. That doesn't...
00:40:00 I feel badgered by charity fundraisers sometimes that you run into in downtown Toronto, but they
00:40:05 have a right to be there. Well, exactly. So I would say this bylaw is quite bad, but it's actually
00:40:11 not as bad. Calgary actually has an identical version on street harassment, very similar
00:40:17 language, but it actually applies everywhere in Calgary, from the sidewalks to the restaurants.
00:40:23 So it's actually even worse. And we've focused on the protest bylaw, but we certainly are studying
00:40:29 this. And just to be clear, in a recent case, early 2022 case, the Supreme Court of Canada
00:40:35 has said that there is no right not to be offended. This is the Mike Ward case where there
00:40:40 was the Quebec comedian making these edgy jokes. Supreme Court said, you know, you may find this
00:40:45 distasteful, but in a free society, you have no right not to be offended. That is not a thing.
00:40:51 And so governments should certainly not be in the business of enacting laws that punish people who
00:40:56 merely offend others. And my colleague was talking about this morning, how this street harassment
00:41:02 bill played out in Calgary is kind of funny. There was an argument at a public pool over
00:41:08 trans people being able to use change rooms of the sex they identify with. And so some individuals
00:41:14 were protesting against this policy. And then there were counter protesters protesting the
00:41:19 protests. And so they all ended up offending each other and harassing each other. And both sides
00:41:25 ended up with street harassment fines, which begs the question, why should the police have been
00:41:30 involved in this at all? Mutually, yeah, mutually assured destruction there is the way it tends to
00:41:35 come out here. I'll just make a point here and get you to weigh in as we close, Joanna, because
00:41:40 oftentimes whenever you talk about free speech or freedom of expression, whether you mean it in a
00:41:45 legal sense or just the moral sense, you'll get the very predictable response, which is, well,
00:41:49 that's different than hate speech. And free speech is not the same as hate speech. And, you know,
00:41:54 obviously there is a criminal prohibition on hate speech in Canada, but what people forget is that
00:41:58 that still applies without this bylaw. Like if speech is crossing that boundary where it is
00:42:04 meeting that very high bar to be criminalized, the law already applies. Police already have the
00:42:09 ability to deal with that. So necessarily a bylaw like this is trying to lower that threshold and
00:42:15 cover more speech. Yeah. Well, hate speech is already problematic enough because it's such a
00:42:22 subjective definition, but it is speech that reaches a certain threshold of encouraging
00:42:27 really hate and perhaps violence against certain groups. But that's already a very problematic
00:42:33 standard. And so, yes, if you're going to water it down further and say, well, what if you made
00:42:38 me feel badgered? What if you made me feel harassed? You're just like bringing in more and more
00:42:44 barriers to free expression, which I totally agree with what you said at the outset. This is how
00:42:49 free expression is how we work things out in a free society. If we can't work things out through
00:42:54 conversation, we have to work things out through fists. And that doesn't seem like a particularly
00:43:00 acceptable solution. Now, is it October 31st? Your book comes out, right? Yes. All right. Nice way to
00:43:07 scare yourself on Halloween by reading about the dismal state of civil liberties in Canada. It is
00:43:11 called Pandemic Panic. It is written by Joanna Barron and Christine Van Gein. And I believe I
00:43:17 am cited in it, if I'm not mistaken. So you were mentioned many times. Well, that's rarely good,
00:43:22 but I appreciate it very much. And I did have a chance to review an advanced copy and it's a
00:43:27 wonderful read. So people should definitely check that out. Joanna, thank you so much for coming on.
00:43:32 Thanks, Andrew. All right. Thank you. That was Joanna Barron from the Canadian Constitution
00:43:37 Foundation. We will end things there. My thanks to you all for tuning in. We will be back in 23
00:43:43 three hours and 15 minutes here on Canada's most irreverent talk show on true
00:43:48 North, the Andrew Lawton show. Thank you. God bless. And good day to you all.
00:43:52 Thanks for listening to the Andrew Lawton show.
00:43:54 Support the program by donating to true North at www.tnc.news.
00:44:13 We'll be right back.