Juno News - March 21, 2024


Antisemitism is the new normal – the Liberals are making it worse

Topics
Mentioned
Trudeau is gaslighting Canadians about the carbon tax The CBC tries to be funny

Episode Stats


Length

46 minutes

Words per minute

165.22

Word count

7,673

Sentence count

343

Harmful content

Misogyny

5

sentences flagged

Toxicity

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

20

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

On this week's episode of The Andrew Lawton Show, we take a look at a report from the Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP) warning that Canadians may revolt when they realize how bad things are for them. And how does this square with Justin Trudeau's incessant claims that Canada is not "broken"?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:19 North. Hello and welcome to you all. This is Canada's most irreverent talk show, the Andrew
00:01:29 Lawton Show on True North, closing out the week on this March 21st. What is March 21st? It's the
00:01:38 fast of Esther, I know, for the Jewish people. I thought there was some other commemorative day
00:01:43 that I had remembered that I've now forgotten about. But Sean says it's the day after his
00:01:48 birthday. Yeah, that's what I meant there. Happy day after the birthday to all of you
00:01:54 Sean Thompsons out there. In any event, it is good to have you aboard the... It's the first
00:01:59 day of spring. That's what I was missing. Let me just check this. First day of spring,
00:02:04 because sometimes it's, I think, the 20th. No, that was the 19th, Sean. Will you get with the
00:02:08 program? All right, I rescind my belated birthday celebration. I actually didn't know that spring
00:02:14 started on March 19th. So anyway, do you feel edified by me just like desperately trying to
00:02:21 figure out in real time what's going on, where I am? I don't even know what my name is at this
00:02:25 point. Welcome everyone to the Rosemary Barton Show. This is CBC's The Nap... No, sorry, no,
00:02:30 Andrew Lawton. All right, well, moving along then. This is a fascinating, fascinating story. The RCMP
00:02:37 typically mired in politics. It's their favorite pastime to just focus on politics and wokeness
00:02:45 at the higher level. I'm not talking, of course, about frontline officers, but they inadvertently,
00:02:51 I think, stumbled on something that is very politically and socially salient here. Now,
00:02:56 whether that was their intention or not, I have no idea, but there was a secret report that was
00:03:01 intended for, oh, there we go, it was intended for police and senior members of the government
00:03:06 to kind of just figure out the threat assessments of the world.
00:03:10 But this report, as the National Post frames it,
00:03:13 was warning that Canadians may revolt when they realize how broke they are.
00:03:18 One of my colleagues, Quinn Patrick, over at True North Wire,
00:03:22 he had posted something, well, he had read the report himself
00:03:25 and drew some other aspects from it,
00:03:27 such as the fear that RCMP was putting to lawmakers of a paranoid,
00:03:33 I'm doing the lopsided air quotes because I don't want to keep punching the mic,
00:03:36 Paranoid populism sweeping the country.
00:03:40 That was the RCMP's concern also in the report.
00:03:44 So it's quite fascinating here.
00:03:45 What police are saying is that, hey, things are so bad for Canadians.
00:03:50 Things are so terrible for people in this country that you may find,
00:03:54 if you're a government official, that the peasants might start revolting.
00:03:57 That's revolting.
00:03:58 That's basically the police's warning here.
00:04:01 You think the Freedom Convoy was something,
00:04:03 you could see a full-on paranoid populist rebellion.
00:04:06 against the government. Now, some people might just look and say, all right, well, bring it on.
00:04:11 But I kind of take a bigger view of this, a bigger picture view, and say, how does this square with
00:04:17 Justin Trudeau's incessant claims that Canada is not broken, that it is, in fact, offensive or
00:04:24 insensitive to say that Canada is broken, which has become a common refrain from Pierre Polly
00:04:31 and the Conservatives that Canada is broken. Now, this does not mean Canada is beyond fixing. It
00:04:36 just means that things in the country are not working the way they're supposed to. And Justin
00:04:41 Trudeau, who always says, oh yes, I support law enforcement and I defend their investigative
00:04:46 autonomy and authority and all that jazz. He now will have to answer, okay, how do you square your
00:04:53 message that Canada is not broken? It's all hunky-dory. Everything's fine. A-okay. And the
00:04:59 police saying, okay, things are a little bit rocky. Actually, things are really rocky. Actually,
00:05:05 you may find that you're dealing with a full-on rebellion on your hands because Canadians are not 1.00
00:05:12 going to put up with how bad things are. So that is effectively what we're seeing unfolding here.
00:05:18 The police are warning that things are just so untenable that they are going to rise up. Now,
00:05:24 an uprising could look very different in different contexts. It could just be a big, large protest.
00:05:29 It could be general unrest. It could be a little isolated protest. Now, I mean, take the Freedom
00:05:34 Convoy is one example. This was a nightmare for law enforcement. They just completely had no idea
00:05:39 how to deal with it. It was, for the most part, one main protest in Ottawa. Yes, you had the Coutts 0.94
00:05:46 protest, which was its own thing. You had, for a time, Windsor, and you had little pop-up ones.
00:05:51 But imagine if the organic growth that the Freedom Convoy had in Ottawa was actually in every
00:05:59 province across the country. That would actually be incredibly difficult to rein in. That's actually
00:06:04 the kind of thing that would have caused the federal government, I suspect, to bring in the
00:06:08 military, which, again, we wouldn't put it past them. Marco Mendicino and David Lamedi were just
00:06:14 yucking it up in a signal chat about bringing in the tanks. And, oh, well, I think one might do
00:06:18 was, I can't remember if it was Mendicino or Lamedi, but both have been fired now, so it doesn't really
00:06:23 matter. But this is, I think, a really significant problem. Now, it doesn't take a genius and it
00:06:29 doesn't take even the most perceptive person to look around the country and say, hey, people are
00:06:33 struggling. Things are not working for people. And this warning from police, while it may be
00:06:38 a little bit on the nose, it's touching on something incredibly important that everyone
00:06:44 in the country except Justin Trudeau and the liberals seems to realize, which is how bad
00:06:49 things are for the average person. And to be honest, that ties in quite well, not that it's
00:06:56 a favorable segue or a nice segue by any stretch, with what the Jewish community in this country is
00:07:02 facing. Yesterday, I spoke about this cartoon that was published in La Press. It was a vampire
00:07:08 Nosferatu play on Benjamin Netanyahu, the Prime Minister of Israel. It was, I think it was Nosferin
00:07:15 who, or Nosferinyahu, or Nosferyahu, whatever they called him, but it was this trope, this trope of 0.57
00:07:21 the blood-sucking vampire Jew, an anti-Semitic trope that goes back to anti-Semitic Germany in
00:07:28 the early part of the 20th century, Nazi propaganda and the like. And it was a cartoon that passed by 0.96
00:07:35 several members of the editorial team of La Presse and was eventually pushed out. And then they get
00:07:41 caught and see the backlash and everyone's like, oh, I'm so sorry. I had no idea what we shouldn't
00:07:45 have done. But they did it. They did it. They chose to do it. And I don't see this as being an error
00:07:51 in the crafting of the cartoon. I see it as being an error in saying the quiet part out loud and
00:07:57 being revealing of what many people would argue, certainly with having seen what's unfolded since
00:08:03 October 7th, as being a tragically widespread sentiment among many people in this country,
00:08:09 and I guess editorial cartoonists are not immune from that. Now, what was interesting is how the
00:08:15 government chose to respond to this. Now, to be fair, Pascal Saint-Ange is the heritage minister.
00:08:22 It's not the job of the heritage minister under normal circumstances, I would say, to start
00:08:27 criticizing, oh, I didn't like this column. I didn't like that column. That's not the type
00:08:32 of thing that we want the minister or any government official to do generally. I will
00:08:36 concede that point. And I also want to make it abundantly clear, as disgusting as I found this
00:08:41 cartoon, I do not support censorship. I do not believe there was anything illegal about it.
00:08:46 and I would reject fully any attempt or any effort by someone to use the weight of the state
00:08:52 against La Presse or the cartoonist. I believe the way you condemn and criticize these things
00:08:57 is simply by criticizing them and condemning them. You don't need to censor it. In fact,
00:09:03 that only turns your foes and opponents into martyrs. But I also think when the minister
00:09:09 is going to weigh in, it's interesting to see how she did it. 0.81
00:09:13 Have you seen this cartoon? What do you make of it?
00:09:17 Well, as Heritage Minister, I'm going to be very prudent around the independence of the press.
00:09:23 But what I am going to say is that, of course, with everything happening right now in the Middle East
00:09:30 and the tension that it's bringing in Canada as well because communities are feeling this conflict very profoundly,
00:09:38 um that it's normal that there's critiques with such uh such a cartoon
00:09:43 okay so on one hand listen i'm the heritage minister i support independence the press i'm
00:09:50 not commenting on it had she stopped it there we might be having a different conversation but then
00:09:56 she went one step further and said oh it's normal it's it's normal now was this a translation issue
00:10:02 like when trudeau said he found his job boring i don't know i mean she seems to speak english very
00:10:06 capably. This was, of course, to the Conservatives seen as highly inadequate. This is MP Michelle
00:10:13 Rempel-Garner from the Tory benches speaking out with Pierre-Paul Housse at her side.
00:10:20 Earlier today in a scrum exiting the Liberal caucus, the Minister of Canadian Heritage
00:10:25 failed to condemn a blatantly anti-Semitic trope that was published this morning by La Presse.
00:10:32 In fact, she said that discussions around this topic, in response to a question on this, required compassion and respect.
00:10:41 There is nothing compassionate or respectful about what La Presse published this morning.
00:10:46 It was a Nazi-era anti-Semitic trope, and the Minister of Canadian Heritage had a duty to condemn it.
00:10:54 Canadian Jews are facing massive rising levels of anti-Semitism,
00:10:58 and for the Minister of Canadian Heritage to say this was about the freedom of the press
00:11:03 was an abject failure in her part to address anti-Semitism and to condemn it.
00:11:10 There's nothing about freedom of the press.
00:11:13 That was Michelle Rempel-Garner's response to it.
00:11:17 Now, to the government's credit, Justin Trudeau did have firmer language when he was asked about it.
00:11:22 It's a short clip. If you blink, you'll miss it, but here it is.
00:11:26 First of all, on the La Presse caricature, it is unacceptable to bring back anti-Semitic tropes and allusions like that.
00:11:37 It is distasteful and exactly the wrong thing to do, particularly in these times.
00:11:44 It is a good thing that it was pulled. It was a good thing that they've apologized.
00:11:49 But it never should have happened in the first place.
00:11:51 Now, if I were Justin Trudeau, I would be looking through my wardrobe collection to make sure I
00:12:00 didn't have the vampire outfit that they used in the cartoon that I was whipping out at parties
00:12:05 for the better part of my 20s and 30s. So Justin Trudeau, again, always has to be very circumspect
00:12:10 on anything to do with tropes and costumes and outfits and all that. But at this point,
00:12:15 let's assume he hasn't been doing Nosferatu face in his spare time. He came out and said
00:12:19 it was unacceptable, which again, I think is a reasonable condemnation of it. But I think we
00:12:26 need to talk about the government's conduct in all of this, because this is the same government
00:12:30 that the same week as this unfolds, votes against or votes in favor of an NDP motion that at first
00:12:37 was trying to immediately and unilaterally recognize the Palestinian nation or region as a
00:12:43 state that was also going to call for this ceasefire, which again only emboldens and empowers
00:12:50 Hamas. We saw the Liberals do a victory lap when they had managed to just soften the edges of the 0.99
00:12:56 motion a little bit, but they still ended up supporting it with only Anthony Howe's father,
00:13:02 Marco Mendicino, and Ben Carr having the, I'll say, courage and moral clarity and conviction to stand
00:13:08 up and vote against this resolution, against this motion from the NDP. But then you look at the NDP
00:13:15 revealing where its loyalties are here. Now, this is Brian Massey, who is an MP in, I believe it's
00:13:22 Windsor to come see your Windsor Essex. It was one of the Windsor ridings in southwestern Ontario,
00:13:26 not far from the US border. This is his take on antisemitism. We've seen a rise of antisemitism
00:13:35 in the past in this country as well.
00:13:37 And I want to note that, Mr. Speaker,
00:13:39 because I understand the pain and suffering
00:13:41 because I've seen it in my own community
00:13:42 long before even this where swastikas are painted
00:13:45 on sidewalks or in front of people's homes
00:13:47 and all that still exists in our society
00:13:49 and it's something we have to continue to fight against
00:13:52 every single day.
00:13:54 But we're not going to be able to fix anything right now
00:13:58 until there's a ceasefire.
00:14:00 and if we can help move other countries in that direction then we can save lives
00:14:07 and that's the most important thing that i'll continue to resort to with
00:14:12 anti-semitism will continue until israel stops its defensive strikes against tamas that's what
00:14:23 he's saying there that we cannot combat anti-semitism until there is a ceasefire as though
00:14:29 targeting Jews in Canada is conditional on Israel's military decisions. That is his belief.
00:14:36 Quite, quite insane that he was doing this. Now, he has apologized. He says, quote,
00:14:41 I am deeply sorry about my comment in the House of Commons linking the ceasefire with tackling
00:14:46 anti-Semitism. We must confront anti-Semitism at all times and without preconditions.
00:14:51 I want to apologize to all who have been impacted by this comment. I'm committed to repairing the
00:14:56 harm that was caused. The rise of anti-Semitism in Canada is not a new problem, but the crisis
00:15:02 in the Middle East has made it even worse. As a leader in my community, I have a responsibility 0.98
00:15:07 to do everything I can to address it. Sounds great. You know what would have been better in
00:15:11 the first place? Not saying what he said. I don't believe this was a misspeak or a gaffe. I believe
00:15:17 that this was fully an example of him saying what I referred to earlier, and I'll refer to again
00:15:25 as the quiet part out loud. This is him being just a little bit too honest about what he thinks,
00:15:31 that it is actually incumbent on the Jewish people of Canada to bear the responsibility for
00:15:38 what people may take issue with as far as Israel's decisions as a nation, as a state. Now again,
00:15:44 I've said time and time again, it is completely fair game to criticize Israel as a country. It's 1.00
00:15:49 a fair game to debate a two-state solution, whether that's effective or viable and what it
00:15:54 would look like. It's certainly fair to criticize Benjamin Netanyahu. He is a prime minister. He's
00:15:59 a politician. He is no more immune to criticism than a politician in Canada or any other Western
00:16:07 country should be. But what's basically at stake here is that Jewish people are seen by this
00:16:18 increasingly, I'll say increasing in size and increasing in, what's the best word to put it,
00:16:25 increasing in brazenness group in Canada that believes they are fair game, that believes
00:16:30 a Jewish person in downtown Windsor is a fair target for your issues with the Zionist project 1.00
00:16:39 in the Middle East. That is what these people are saying. And when I have said to people in
00:16:45 private conversation, and I've said on the show in the past that anti-Semitism is the new normal 1.00
00:16:48 in Canada, there are a lot of people, certainly Jews in this country, who take issue with that
00:16:53 because they say, well, this isn't new. This isn't a new problem. You're seeing it for the first time,
00:16:58 and I think that's an entirely fair criticism. There are a lot of people. I've generally paid
00:17:03 attention to Israel and Jewish issues. It's always been an interest of mine, but there are a lot of
00:17:07 people in this country that are completely blindsided by what we've seen in the last
00:17:12 several months. And I would go and say that I'm not at all by any stretch perfect. I would say
00:17:18 that I have been astonished by the scale of it and by the breadth of this. And, you know, I probably
00:17:25 wouldn't have seen if you had asked me before October 7th, that individual businesses would
00:17:32 be fair game. I mean, I would have never predicted Cafe Landwehr being targeted in Toronto. I would
00:17:37 never have predicted Mount Sinai being protested. Again, just a couple of years ago, we had people
00:17:42 saying it's outrageous to protest a hospital when people were protesting over vaccine mandates. But
00:17:47 when you're protesting it because it has Sinai in the name, and that's just a little bit too
00:17:51 Jewish for our sensibilities, people are saying that is fine. So this is, to be honest, disgraceful.
00:17:58 And the Canadian government has a role to play in this. The Canadian government has a role to play.
00:18:03 They have made their decisions on Israel, but they have been equivocal at virtually every step.
00:18:11 They have been equivocal in terms of their calls for a ceasefire.
00:18:14 They've been equivocal in terms of whether they even condemn this, whether they call them terrorists.
00:18:20 They were equivocal and ultimately took the wrong position when there was misinformation circulating that Israel had purportedly bombed a hospital,
00:18:28 but it was actually an errant Hamas rocket, an errant Hamas rocket that had landed in the parking
00:18:34 lot adjacent to a hospital. But this was used to justify anti-Israel propaganda. And the part of
00:18:44 this that all people in this country need to realize is that this is going to continue. And
00:18:50 again, it was very difficult to be an anti-Semite on October 7th, October 8th, October 9th, because
00:18:56 there was so much public support for Israel and the Jewish people in the imminent aftermath of it.
00:19:02 But the longer it's gone on, the more people have been able to drop that pretend support and let
00:19:08 their true colors shine through. And many of those true colors are actually just wrapped in keffias
00:19:15 like the NDP members of parliament were who decided to stand up and vote for something that so few
00:19:21 people had the courage to say and call out for what it was, which was an anti-Israel motion,
00:19:27 an anti-Israel resolution. And I know that there are people that in the audience that don't love
00:19:34 it. I get accused of being a Zionist shill from time to time. And I say, you know, whether I'm
00:19:39 shilling or not, you can decide for yourselves. But Zionism, it should not be the dirty word
00:19:43 that so many people have tried to make it out to be. And I played that clip yesterday with
00:19:47 Anthony Howe's father, and he was saying that very thing, that he is a Zionist because Zionism was 0.56
00:19:53 the way to give the Jewish people a safe haven in the world that they didn't have anywhere else.
00:19:58 And I think there are far too many Canadians that probably wanted to rest on our laurels as a
00:20:02 country and say, oh, well, we're a safe place. You can be Jewish here. What's the big deal? 0.51
00:20:06 And well, how's that working out for people? It's been a tragic display, and so few people are even
00:20:12 now opening their eyes to this. I want to welcome into the program Shimon Koffler Fogel, who is
00:20:17 is the president and CEO of the Center for Israel and Jewish Affairs. Shimon, I know this has been
00:20:23 such a tremendously difficult time for your community over the last several months now,
00:20:28 but I wanted to ask you about this resolution, because a lot of the language that the NDP
00:20:34 used in this, that the liberals ended up using, on the surface lacks the, if you don't know what
00:20:41 you're looking for, it could look like it's a reasonable motion. Yeah, I think that was the
00:20:48 intent to make it sound like motherhood and apple pie. But, you know, words have meanings and they're
00:20:56 code for lots of different things. And this was not a motion that was advanced with a righteous
00:21:05 spirit. There's an agenda. It includes trying to marginalize and isolate Israel within the 0.96
00:21:14 international community. Israel isn't just a place and Zionism isn't just a movement to find safe
00:21:21 haven for Jews. It's about repatriation to their ancestral homeland after forced exile for 2,000
00:21:28 years. Canada saw fit to endorse the idea of the Jewish state. They did it in 1947. Lester Pearson
00:21:36 was actively involved in advancing it. And all of a sudden, we get to a place I couldn't help
00:21:44 but you describing some of the MPs in the House. Many of them, our detractors, are also wearing
00:21:52 these new necklaces that have a map of Palestine on it, which would be fine, except that the
00:22:01 map that's represented in the piece of jewelry is the entirety of that real estate.
00:22:09 So it doesn't really leave any place for a Jewish state.
00:22:13 And I think that that's really the most telling interpretation or understanding of this chant
00:22:21 that has become their mantra from the river to the sea.
00:22:24 It means not having a Jewish state. 0.99
00:22:27 It means destroying the Jewish state. 0.99
00:22:30 And I think that Canada is a country
00:22:33 that should be standing up unequivocally
00:22:35 along with its democratic ally in the region.
00:22:38 And unfortunately, we haven't seen that much.
00:22:42 Well, you raise an important point.
00:22:45 And oftentimes people in the Canadian government
00:22:48 will restate the Canadian government's position
00:22:50 of a two-state solution and, you know, not delving into the weeds on the very, very complex history
00:22:56 of negotiations and talks over the last few years. A lot of these activists are going very much
00:23:01 further than that. They want a one-state solution, and that is one singular Palestinian state. 0.83
00:23:06 So I think that's exactly right. A two-state solution was attainable not once or twice or
00:23:13 three times. Five very specific and precise plans had been put forward with the endorsement
00:23:21 of the Americans, of other segments of the international community. They were rejected
00:23:26 each and every time by the Palestinian leadership. So there has to be some agency. There has to be
00:23:33 accountability for the decisions that they make. Their situation is of their own making. They're
00:23:39 the authors of it, just as Hamas is the author of the misery that is now being experienced 0.99
00:23:45 in Gaza. And I think that there has to be a consistency in countries like Canada demanding
00:23:54 accountability and recognition of at whose feet does the situation lay.
00:24:03 your organization has has done for years a lot of legwork on engaging with politicians I know
00:24:11 you've always prided yourselves on doing it in a very respectful way you don't like being you
00:24:16 don't like immediately going to these public confrontations and condemnations of these people
00:24:20 you like to educate and inform and I know you've brought members of parliament from I don't know
00:24:25 about all parties but certainly from multiple parties to Israel in your conversations when you
00:24:31 square those up that you've had with people to what you see from them publicly. I'm curious if
00:24:36 you have a read on whether these are people that are just simply against Israel or whether there
00:24:42 are people that, you know, that privately they've been on side, but now it's not trendy to support
00:24:46 Israel or to support the Jewish community. Yeah. So I think unpacking that is a little 1.00
00:24:52 complicated because there are a few things going on. First, there are those that are simply hostile.
00:24:58 They bought into the anti-Israel narrative that has been promoted by our cousins, but it has also been picked up by the radical left, those who have been promoting this woke ideology, which divides the world into two.
00:25:19 You're either part of the oppressed segment or you're the oppressor.
00:25:24 And Israel and the Jewish people, for that matter, are the poster children for that white privilege that, if you can imagine, attaches importance to things like meritocracy and accountability.
00:25:40 So you have this movement that has been just unrelenting in its attacks on the Jewish community, the Jewish state.
00:25:51 That's one piece.
00:25:52 The second piece, and I think that it was insightful for you to flag that, is that group of individuals who are inclined to be supportive, but who have been intimidated and chilled and are afraid of being targeted themselves and canceled for fear of coming out and expressing their views.
00:26:14 So essentially, they've been silenced. What they do isn't entirely what they say. And, you know, it's something that we, the Jewish community, may be the canary in the coal mine for, but we had better wake up because this is a challenge fundamentally to Western civilization, to the values that have informed our society here for hundreds of years. 0.72
00:26:43 and they're under challenge by those who espouse this Marxist Leninist view. They got it wrong
00:26:50 every iteration so far. They've now stumbled over a new configuration that they think is going to
00:26:59 get them some purchase. One question I have to ask you about Shimon is how oftentimes Jewish 1.00
00:27:06 people are used as a bit of a shield in this debate. There have always been some Jewish
00:27:10 organizations that have been very anti-Zionist, even though they're certainly a minority of the
00:27:16 Jewish community. And then you have, even in Parliament, Yara Sachs, who last week was holding 0.98
00:27:21 hands with Mahmoud Abbas in the West Bank, and this week voting in favor of this motion, a Jewish
00:27:27 woman representing a riding with a large Jewish community. And I've seen online that being used 0.95
00:27:32 as, again, I'll say the word again, a shield by people that say, oh, well, even Yara Sachs is
00:27:37 supporting it. So no, it's not anti-Jewish. Yeah. So I would make a distinction between
00:27:42 Yarra Sachs and some of those groups. And that's fair. That's fair. Yes.
00:27:49 Because they're Jewish by accident of birth and they're doing exactly what you just described. 0.97
00:27:54 They are being used to insulate the haters and say, well, I can't be an anti-Semite because I
00:28:01 have Jewish groups that are joining with me. But nobody is really giving a sense that they represent
00:28:06 not even a fraction, but a fraction of a fraction of malcontents who don't identify as Jewish in
00:28:14 any other way except to give cover to those that want to dump on Israel. In the case of Yara Sachs,
00:28:20 and I don't hold the brief for Yara, but, you know, from her perspective, she comes by this
00:28:26 honestly. She is absolutely committed to a safe and secure Jewish state, but she positions herself
00:28:35 on the far left. She has a particular orientation. She's not alone. There are others like that, too.
00:28:42 The challenge with Ayara Sachs is that because there are so few Jews in Parliament, there's the
00:28:48 expectation that she would reflect the views of the vast majority of the Jewish community.
00:28:55 I'm not sure she always does that or that she's successful in doing that, but certainly you have
00:29:02 to make a distinction between her and folks at Independent Jewish Voices who are anything but
00:29:09 independent because they get all of their direction from the haters. Jewish only by accident of birth
00:29:16 and their voice is really just a platform to broadcast the hate and toxicity that's coming
00:29:23 out from our adversaries. Yeah, it's very, very well said. And again, my condolences to all that
00:29:29 your community is enduring. But the one thing I've learned in my study of the history of the
00:29:33 Jewish people and of Israel has been the story of resilience. So I know that you will get through
00:29:39 this and you do have allies, even though it doesn't always feel like it. So Shimon Koffler-Fogel,
00:29:43 thank you for coming on today. My pleasure. All right. Thank you. And I should just say,
00:29:48 just by way of disclosure, I had the great privilege in 2015 of going on a Center for
00:29:54 Israel and Jewish Affairs hosted visit of Israel. And it was my second trip to Israel. And I'm very
00:30:00 grateful for the opportunity. And it wasn't tied to, you know, it wasn't tied to you have to say
00:30:05 this or believe this or even write about it. It was just an opportunity to expose it. And
00:30:09 I actually went with Candace Malcolm, who was also on the trip. We went into Bethlehem
00:30:14 just on our own. We took a taxi and went across into the West Bank and saw the other side of this.
00:30:19 And it was a fascinating experience. And I think a lot of people who weigh in on this and other
00:30:23 issue should try to see it for themselves before they do. I want to bring things back home a bit
00:30:29 more though not that what we were talking about doesn't have a very significant Canadian context
00:30:34 but you've heard me for weeks now talking about Bill C-63 which is the Liberal government's so
00:30:40 called Online Harms Act a bill that among other things will introduce a new category of so-called
00:30:45 hate speech and crack down on anyone who dares to utter it online which effectively means the
00:30:51 government is going to be the arbiter of what you can and can't say. And as we've seen, they are
00:30:57 wildly inconsistent in when and how they flex this power. Now, I've often said that to understand
00:31:03 how bad things are here, we need to take a look around the world and see where things are worse.
00:31:08 And the UK has been one of the worst examples of this. You have police knocking on people's doors
00:31:14 if they misgender someone on Twitter. They have this pervasive non-crime hate incident reporting
00:31:21 system where you can do nothing illegal, but you still have a police record because you've
00:31:25 perpetrated a non-crime hate incident. And I thought things were pretty bad in the UK,
00:31:30 but I believe Ireland has come out with the Trump card. I'm not sure if you followed this or not,
00:31:36 but Ireland has a new law purporting to rein in hate speech online. You have a couple of
00:31:42 politicians that say Ireland's approach should actually be a model for all of Europe. And if
00:31:46 that happens, I actually don't think it's going to be all that long before we see that brought
00:31:52 to Canada. So I wanted to actually delve into what's happening in Ireland in a little bit of
00:31:58 detail here, because this bill is called the Incitement to Violence or Hatred and Hate Offenses
00:32:05 Bill. And it is one of the most Orwellian and draconian attempts at this so-called hate speech
00:32:11 discussion i've ever seen uh ben scallon has been on top of this he is a senior or the senior
00:32:17 political correspondent at gripped which is a fantastic independent media organization in ireland
00:32:22 and he joins me now ben it's good to talk to you thanks for coming on today very good to talk to
00:32:27 you today andrew how are things good very well thank you although in both of our countries not
00:32:31 exactly great on the free speech front so for canadians who have not paid attention to this
00:32:37 at all what's like the the basic primer on what this bill is and why it's been erasing so many
00:32:42 alarms so in essence if i had to describe why the irish hate speech bill is so controversial
00:32:50 is it's the incredible vagueness of the text of the legislation to the point where the very serious
00:32:58 crime of uh you know convicting somebody of a hate offense can be defined as almost anything
00:33:04 So I'll give you an example. For example, the text doesn't refer to hatred with any kind of specific definition.
00:33:13 It says that hatred means hatred on the basis of X, Y and Z characteristics, which is obviously a circular definition.
00:33:20 So how is that to be defined? I guess it's up to the courts or the police or whoever happens to be offended by your remarks at the time.
00:33:30 so people have been saying this is so open-ended it could potentially catch anyone and everyone in
00:33:36 its dragnet if we're making a very benign statement another example would be the fact that
00:33:42 according to the legislation it's seeking to protect genders other than that of male or female
00:33:47 but it doesn't enumerate what those are and when I asked our Taoiseach which is like the Irish
00:33:52 Prime Minister how many genders are there in your view because previously the leader of our Senate 0.97
00:33:57 said that there were about nine genders so that could be about nine they don't even have the
00:34:03 definitive list exactly it's it's a ballpark figure you know thereabouts and so i asked how
00:34:08 many genders are there and what is covered by this legislation and he said well we don't have
00:34:13 an official position on that and i'm sure that'll all be figured out during the debates and they
00:34:17 haven't been still that was months ago so that that should kind of give you just a sense of
00:34:22 why people are so concerned about this kind of thing they're trying to protect genders they can't 1.00
00:34:26 even define against hatred that they can't define. And it seems like the entire implementation of
00:34:33 this legislation would just be totally up in the air. And how do you stay on the right side of a
00:34:37 law that is so vague and nebulous? That's effectively the main concern that people have
00:34:41 with it. There are a lot of people that are not familiar with the evolution of Irish politics over
00:34:48 the last, I don't know, half a century that are probably perplexed by Ireland's descent into
00:34:52 wokeness when this used to be this you know traditional catholic uh society and country
00:34:57 i mean where did things all go so wrong because i mean even like you look at refugee policy in
00:35:02 ireland for example and i this has been a very very strange uh decline in a lovely country
00:35:10 i think there's a few factors going on i mean of course as you say ireland has always been a very
00:35:14 historically deeply catholic conservative country there's the kind of old trope of catholic families
00:35:20 with, you know, 50 kids running around and an icon of the Virgin Mary on the wall.
00:35:25 And that's sort of the image that most people have had of Ireland
00:35:29 for most of this country's existence.
00:35:32 But I think obviously things like the the abuse scandals
00:35:36 in the Catholic Church did enormous damage and hurt trust with a lot of people.
00:35:41 And so that that hurt religiosity and mass attendance.
00:35:45 And so I think in our our haste to escape
00:35:50 the church and and to try and bury that part of our past because of all the scandals and
00:35:56 controversies that came out of that i think people have overcompensated and gone too much the other
00:36:01 way i think also um ngos have played a big role in the liberalization of society i don't know how
00:36:08 many people know this but ireland is a country of only about five million people the republic
00:36:13 of ireland anyway and yet we have about 30 000 different ngo organizations not even employees but
00:36:21 different groups and these groups are heavily state funded most of them uh in fact some of them
00:36:27 they receive 96 of their funding from the government so it's a strange kind of non-governmental
00:36:33 organization that's almost entirely reliant on state funding but there you go so um these groups
00:36:39 are there mainly to promote uh lgbt rights or immigrant rights or women's rights or whatever it
00:36:48 might be but in many cases uh that leads to problems because if you're an organization
00:36:55 that's set up to fight the boogeyman of racism let's say for example the problem is ireland
00:37:00 isn't that racist of a country we're actually a very tolerant country and so you're out of the
00:37:05 job in this in the same way if you don't have leaky pipes and you don't need a plumber if you
00:37:09 have a racist society that you don't need professional anti-racist campaigners and so
00:37:14 these groups have had to try and manufacture the idea that ireland is this horrendous place where
00:37:21 women are treated as second-class citizens and gay people are seriously oppressed and everyone's a
00:37:26 racist when that's not the case but they have to do that in order to perpetuate their existence
00:37:32 and so we have this kind of multi-billion euro ngo board conglomerate that exercises a lot of
00:37:39 of power over our discourse and our politics. And I think that also has played a big role
00:37:43 in the liberalization of this country. Well, and to bring it back to the hate speech bill,
00:37:47 those groups you just mentioned are the ones that have skin in the game under these sorts
00:37:52 of regimes, because they're the ones that typically will systematize and weaponize these
00:37:57 complaints processes, where you're going to have one of these NGOs just trolling Twitter
00:38:01 for hours and hours every day, finding, oh, this person misgendered someone. And
00:38:05 from what i've read that could actually be a violation of this law well uh the justice
00:38:11 minister has said that it won't i asked her can she guarantee that nobody will be convicted for
00:38:16 misgendering and she says oh absolutely that'll never happen that's not what the bill is intending
00:38:20 to do whether she's correct or not whether people believe her is up to them i won't i won't weigh in
00:38:25 on that that's what she's claimed we've seen how these laws have been implemented in other
00:38:28 jurisdictions but she would probably say oh those are different pieces of legislation and we're
00:38:33 going to do it properly and yada yada but the defense is basically just trust us you just have
00:38:37 to trust that the government won't abuse this power effectively yeah and and i think as well
00:38:43 um you know one of the interesting things about it you said that it's in these ngos interest to 0.99
00:38:49 try and promote this the government did a public consultation i think in north america you guys
00:38:55 might call it a comment period where this was several years ago they floated the idea of hate
00:39:00 speech laws. And they said, hey, you know, Joe Public, we want to know what you think,
00:39:04 weigh in with your thoughts. And they received thousands of responses from individuals and from
00:39:10 groups. And then very shortly afterwards, they came out and they said, you know, we've received
00:39:15 the feedback and now we're going to be going ahead with this legislation. Well, I actually,
00:39:19 in a journalistic capacity, read through every single one of the responses, thousands of them,
00:39:25 It took me hours and hours to do. And at the end of this research, I found that 73 percent of individuals had said that they didn't want it.
00:39:34 It was they were negative responses saying, don't do this.
00:39:38 The overwhelming consensus was mostly, of course, if somebody is engaging in violent rhetoric where they're calling for the public to attack an individual or a group or race or something like that, of course, that should be illegal.
00:39:50 And that already is illegal. You know, in Simon, the violence has never been covered under free speech.
00:39:55 that's clearly not what we mean when we say free speech. And so that's already done. But other than
00:40:01 that, if somebody is just merely expressing an offensive opinion that hurt somebody's feelings,
00:40:05 tough luck, we all get offended. Sometimes that's not something that the government should be
00:40:08 legislating. And that was the general sentiment of the responses. And yet, the government went
00:40:13 ahead with it anyway, despite the fact that one of the groups they cited, they said, Oh,
00:40:18 we got some positive responses. It was from these state funded NGOs. So effectively,
00:40:23 the people that you pay who that's like me saying uh i'm the most handsome man in ireland because
00:40:28 that's what my granny says you know it's not really the most persuasive of sources you're
00:40:33 using there that uh you're appealing to people who you pay their salaries and fund them and keep
00:40:38 them in existence and lo and behold they just so happen to agree with you and your policy agenda
00:40:43 amazing how that works i i mentioned in in the intro uh sinead gibney who i i think is the she 1.00
00:40:49 she's running as the MEP, I think it's the Social Democrats. And she is saying that she
00:40:54 wants to basically export this to all of Europe. And I think it would probably be an easy sell to
00:40:59 do that. Yeah, I think, I think that's, she said when I was interviewing her earlier in the week
00:41:06 that she would be willing to support any legislation similar to the hate speech bill
00:41:11 at a European wide level. And we already have something like that, the Digital Services Act,
00:41:15 which many people will be familiar with well and that was the model of of what canadian government
00:41:20 officials were kind of using which when i heard them say they were going to look to europe for
00:41:24 best practices i was like oh please don't yeah that's uh that's not what you want to hear
00:41:28 definitely with uh the current state of european politics where um the the amount of people who
00:41:34 are willing to argue against some of these policies on principle are few and far between
00:41:40 that's a big thing that i think is missing from this debate as well is that even some of the
00:41:44 politicians who will speak out against the legislation will speak out against its uh
00:41:50 practicalities they'll say that you know it'll be very hard to implement and uh logistically
00:41:56 i don't think it'll work so on that basis i'm opposing it and i'm thinking how about it's bad
00:42:00 because it's wrong to censor people in general you know maybe maybe we should start talking about
00:42:05 even if you could get the wording exactly right and hammer out this beautiful piece of legislation
00:42:11 that covered all your bases maybe maybe we still shouldn't do it even under those circumstances
00:42:16 because it's actually wrong to put people in jail for their opinions even when their opinions are
00:42:21 not uh views that you or i would necessarily find palatable but that doesn't seem to come
00:42:26 up during any of this discussion so obviously irish people as you mentioned were against this
00:42:32 when it was floated to them but i haven't seen mass outrage in the more recent months
00:42:39 There have been there were some protests, but have people just generally gone along with it or do they just not care enough?
00:42:44 Why has there not been or has there been maybe I'm wrong?
00:42:47 Why has there not been a major pushback to this?
00:42:49 There has been a major pushback.
00:42:51 And the reason we know that is because several government politicians, some of them who are veterans who have been around for years,
00:42:58 have said in our Senate, basically, that they've received more correspondence about the hate speech bill than any other issue or piece of legislation in their political career.
00:43:07 so it's obviously something that people are really incensed and energized about and uh it
00:43:13 hasn't been mentioned so much in the last couple of months only because it's being supplanted by
00:43:17 other controversies like immigration and we have a huge immigration crisis at the minute in this
00:43:22 country and a massive influx of asylum seekers we have tent cities popping up in the capital
00:43:27 city because there's nowhere to put uh uh some of these individuals who are arriving and there's
00:43:32 more arriving every day. We had a couple of progressive referendums there a couple of weeks
00:43:37 ago, which were defeated. The government side of that debate was defeated comprehensively. So
00:43:42 there's been other chaotic things happening that may have taken attention away from the hate speech
00:43:49 bill, but the government have not pursued it, which I think is sort of an indication that they
00:43:55 know they're losing momentum on it. They meant to pass it last summer. They didn't do that. Then
00:44:00 they said oh we'll pass it after the summer they didn't do that and then they said oh we'll pass
00:44:03 it by the end of the year and we're now in march and still no sign of it so they keep kicking the
00:44:08 can down the road hoping the pressure will alleviate but i think if they tried to sneak
00:44:12 it through people might have something to say about that especially with upcoming elections
00:44:16 later in the year well let's hope they will keep kicking and kicking and kicking and eventually
00:44:21 it'll just be lost forever uh ben scallon with gripped great to have you on and demystifying
00:44:26 this for those of us across the Atlantic thank you so much thank you so much great to be here
00:44:30 all right that does it for us for today we'll be back with no we won't be back tomorrow but I will
00:44:36 be on off the record tomorrow with Candace Malcolm and Harrison Faulkner then back with another
00:44:40 edition of the Andrew Lawton show on Monday so thank you God bless and have a great weekend
00:44:45 thanks for listening to the Andrew Lawton show
00:44:48 support the program by donating to true north at www.tnc.news
00:44:56 We'll be right back.
00:45:26 We'll be right back.
00:45:56 We'll be right back.