Juno News - November 01, 2023


ARC Forum attendees reject wokism and Marxism

Topics
Mentioned
Public support for mass immigration plummets Trudeau adding MILLIONS of new immigrants to Canada by 2026

Episode Stats


Length

43 minutes

Words per minute

158.87

Word count

6,877

Sentence count

306

Harmful content

Misogyny

5

sentences flagged

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

20

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of The Andrew Lawton Show, host Andrew Lawton reflects on his trip to the Alliance for Responsible Citizenship's first ever forum, the Arc Forum, in which he was invited to speak to 1,500 people from 72 countries.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:20 north hello and welcome to you all canada's most irreverent talk show here the andrew lawton show
00:01:31 coming to you live from london in the wonderful country of the united kingdom a city i've had the
00:01:38 good pleasure of coming to on a couple of occasions and have never quite seen as much
00:01:44 in the way of freedom-loving people in it all at one time anyway, as I have this week.
00:01:50 That is because if you've been following along with the show, you'll well know I've been here
00:01:54 for the ARC Forum, the first ever forum of the Alliance for Responsible Citizenship,
00:01:59 an organization in part led by Jordan Peterson, by Canadian Conservative MP Les Lewis, by
00:02:06 folks like Michael Schellenberger and Baroness Stroud, Philippa Stroud, who has been very
00:02:13 prominent in the speaking lineup. I felt bad for her yesterday. I can't remember if I mentioned
00:02:18 this, but she was interviewing on stage. This is like a British baroness. She's, you know, 1.00
00:02:23 the elite of the elite, I guess. And she was interviewing Willie Robertson and Corey Robertson
00:02:28 from the American show Duck Dynasty. And I was watching this feeling like she had never heard
00:02:34 about them until five minutes before she was told she had to go on stage and interview them. It was
00:02:39 a great contrast this you know prim proper baroness sitting down with this very bearded duck dynasty 0.95
00:02:46 star from rural i think they're louisiana if memory serves and she was like talking about them like
00:02:52 having you know tried to really immerse herself in the wonders of rural america uh to do a bang
00:02:58 up job and i said where else but the arc forum are you going to see a baroness interview the
00:03:03 duck dynasty guys so that was a fun little takeaway from the program or yesterday for the
00:03:08 arc forum today things have wrapped up entirely the arc forum concluded after its third and final
00:03:16 day and uh about uh what time is it right now it's nine o'clock so i think just uh about five
00:03:23 minutes from here at the o2 arena in london jordan peterson is on stage with douglas murray
00:03:30 doing kind of a public finale they sold like 20 000 tickets for this thing it's insane
00:03:35 a public component, a public finale to the ideas that have been discussed at the ARC Forum among
00:03:41 the 1,500 invited folks there from 72 countries, of which I was very fortunate to be one. And one
00:03:49 thing that was quite interesting here, I spent a bit of time on Monday kind of doing the contrast
00:03:54 between the ARC Forum and its logical counterpart in some ways, the World Economic Forum. These are
00:04:01 both global summits with leaders from various fields that are coming together to talk about
00:04:06 ideas. And the key contrast between the two, I think, is that the ideas here at the ARC Forum
00:04:12 are rooted in the value of the individual, the celebration of humanity and Western civilization.
00:04:19 The ideas you hear about at the World Economic Forum are nihilistic and cynical and very
00:04:25 anti-human and certainly anti-individual. And I think there's, generally speaking,
00:04:30 a broader understanding of that here. It was a very optimistic place. Now, politics has not been
00:04:37 an optimistic place in the last few years, and I would say for good reason. We've had some of the
00:04:41 most incredible, incredible incursions on our civil liberties, not just our own bodily autonomy,
00:04:47 but our freedom of speech, our freedom of movement. And politics has become a lot more reactive as a
00:04:54 result. So I worried that everyone coming together would kind of be more grievance oriented in their
00:05:01 way. And I was quite pleased. And I will say pleasantly surprised to see that was not the
00:05:06 case. There was a message of hope. Now, that doesn't mean there aren't some skeptics among us.
00:05:12 I had a few little snide conversations on the sidelines, not snide, I should say, but a few more,
00:05:17 I'll say, cynical conversations on the sidelines with people. But of all the backgrounds we saw,
00:05:23 people from the US, the UK, Canada, Spain, Germany, Austria, Australia, people from media,
00:05:30 people from politics, all of this. People had their own approaches, their own backgrounds,
00:05:35 their own challenges. There was one common thread that I saw in almost everyone there,
00:05:42 which was a rejection of wokeness and a rejection of wokeism. That to me is so key here. And I think
00:05:50 there's actually a fair bit of hope in all of that, that you can bring together so many people
00:05:55 from around the world and everyone says, all right, we may disagree on this policy or that policy. You
00:06:00 may be from the British House of Lords and I may be from Duck Dynasty, but surely we can all agree
00:06:05 we don't want wokeness. Now, what is wokeness? Well, you ask some different people, you're going 0.99
00:06:10 to get different answers. One of the things that I will point out, though, is that there was a
00:06:14 rejection of this idea that children should be taught just untenable things about the world which
00:06:22 are simply not true. Like, oh, I don't know, there are 47 genders instead of two biological sexes.
00:06:28 That parents are not the ones that should be responsible for their children's education. That
00:06:34 we should allow grievance and microaggressions to govern speech and discourse rather than
00:06:40 just allowing humans to govern themselves and be civil, and if they're offended, to just not
00:06:46 want the state's intervention. I mean, these are all very anti-woke values, which shouldn't be
00:06:51 left versus right, but have increasingly been so. And I had a number of conversations where I wasn't
00:06:58 even intending to set out down this road, and one of them I did, and that was with James Lindsay,
00:07:03 who you may know from X or Twitter, as we used to call it back in the day, by which I mean
00:07:07 like two weeks ago. James Lindsay, who goes by Conceptual James on Twitter and actually
00:07:13 was speaking to a very large crowd in Alberta a few weeks ago. And I was trying to get him on
00:07:19 the show then and we just weren't able to work it out time wise. But I sat down with James Lindsay
00:07:24 and I wanted to talk about wokeness in that proper context here, where it comes from and more
00:07:29 importantly, what on earth we do about it. Not sure if you can distill this big question down
00:07:36 into a simple soundbite answer, but I'll give you an opportunity to do so. Where does wokeness come 0.86
00:07:41 from? Hell, no, it's the evolution of Marxist thought into the Western context. The Western
00:07:51 context is not suited to an economic Marxism because the Western world, with its access to
00:07:58 liberty and markets, has enabled upward mobility economically. So it's very hard to say that the
00:08:04 worker is intrinsically oppressed and motivate a workers party when the worker can look at his
00:08:09 buddy who said, well, they'll just work harder and you can move up and you can start your own
00:08:13 company if you want and everything. And so they had to modify it in thought. You see this in the
00:08:18 60s. They say that we have to move from the working class as our base for revolution and
00:08:24 into identity politics. We have to look for a new basis for this energy because the West wasn't
00:08:29 suitable to it. So that's where it comes from. The oppressor-oppressed dynamic makes for some
00:08:33 very weird and inconsistent positions I mean you were just in Canada recently you know that
00:08:39 you know Muslim families were leading the charge on the parental rights battles kind of getting
00:08:45 gender ideology out of schools you fast forward a couple of weeks and all of a sudden now Muslims 0.99
00:08:49 are the oppressor or the oppressed group instead of the the oppressor if you talk to some of the
00:08:55 people on the left and the people on the left don't seem interested in trying to reconcile
00:09:00 these inconsistencies yeah that's because this oppressor oppressed thing is a useful kind of
00:09:08 naming heuristic but what really it is is the people and groups and situations that are advancing
00:09:14 leftism are good and the situations and circumstances and groups that are hindering
00:09:19 leftism are bad this is explicit and i think this is a maoist project woke is a maoist project come
00:09:25 to the West, Mao actually says, and he gave a lecture in 1957 or a public speech on the
00:09:33 correct handling of contradictions among the people, and he says immediately, well, who
00:09:36 are the people and who are the enemies of the people?
00:09:38 Let's distinguish.
00:09:39 And he says very clearly, the people who are advancing the cause of building socialism
00:09:43 are the people.
00:09:44 The people who are hindering the cause of building socialism are the enemies of the
00:09:46 people.
00:09:47 So it's very clear that which they can use to advance leftist agendas, oppressed.
00:09:53 that which they can't use or that's stopping them from advancing, oppressor, bad, destroy.
00:09:59 People on the right oftentimes want to deal with this by going after the institutions that tend
00:10:05 to give the wokest their support. Is that the right approach? Where do you think the way in
00:10:10 is to start pushing back against this? I mean, they've infiltrated so thoroughly that it's very
00:10:16 difficult. We do need to start working our way back toward reclaiming which institutions we can.
00:10:22 that's going to happen through personnel in other words firing woke people when they abuse their
00:10:29 positions in power which they are want to do eventually and replacing them with people who
00:10:34 are not woke and having policies arranged to push in that direction or push back in that direction
00:10:39 and simultaneously through changing what I refer to kind of broadly as the liability field
00:10:44 what I just talked about you're it's a liability to get hired it's a liability to keep your job to
00:10:49 be woke, blah, blah, blah. That's part of the liability field. But usually I'm talking about
00:10:53 lawsuits where there are, you know, discrete harms that are so egregious in a place like Canada.
00:10:59 It's got to be so egregious that the courts can't ignore it. The U.S. is a little more friendly to
00:11:05 that. I also think, by the way, that the U.S. and Canada, just to remark, should keep bouncing the
00:11:09 energy against woke ping pong ball across the 48th parallel because we're doing a great job
00:11:14 motivating each other. I think we're actually a wonderful pair for once.
00:11:18 there is an anti-woke left i'd say it's probably not as large as it should be
00:11:22 and a lot of the people in it tend to get typecast as being you know evil right-wing
00:11:26 racist nazis and whatever but is there a concern that that coalition among the anti-woke will be
00:11:33 too thin to survive if you drill down and you know people who are in the trenches saying yeah
00:11:38 we don't like wokeness don't really agree on anything else um the thing is that the anti-woke
00:11:43 left is beholden to the power center of the left by virtue of the fact that they still commit to
00:11:49 the left. And the power center of the left currently is woke. So they are caught between
00:11:53 a rock and a hard place and sort of almost a black hole that either sucks them in or flings
00:11:58 them completely out into, like you said, right wing nut job land, even though they're kind of
00:12:03 determined leftists. And it's a very big challenge that this group has to deal with, that
00:12:12 But they would also benefit from woke losing its influence over the left in a, you know, whether sane is the right word or not, but a non woke left emerging back into the, you know, the ecosystem of left wing thought that's permissible would be beneficial for them.
00:12:30 And I think that under present circumstances, unless woke has actually dealt itself a fatal, self-inflicted wound with this supporting Palestine-Hamas thing, 0.60
00:12:41 I think that that's going to be a very challenging thing for the left to do.
00:12:44 The woke are going to have to be discredited on other terms. 0.98
00:12:48 Do you think gender is the issue that's going to destroy that leftist coalition?
00:12:53 Because it seems to be the one that has the most broad support for the anti-woke position,
00:12:59 The idea that there are two sexes, if you talk to ordinary people on the street, that's a relatively universal thing, but you wouldn't see that reflected in the institutions.
00:13:07 Well, until three weeks ago, I would have said most definitely because I hadn't quite considered how powerfully the anti-Semitism would manifest itself.
00:13:18 And that seems to be waking people up much faster, and in particular waking up people with money who are very concerned about what they're funding.
00:13:24 I think there's a little bit of irony. We've had such a robust education in the West about Nazis and how bad Nazis are and everything, which is good for that, so that we're very sensitive to recognizing those trends and we're very sensitive to wanting to shy away from them immediately.
00:13:38 but on the other hand we've learned virtually nothing about communism so now we find ourselves
00:13:42 in the position where the left is championing something that's calling i mean at times
00:13:48 explicitly for gassing jews and all of a sudden this is a shock moment that's breaking people 0.92
00:13:54 open as for gender though it's the most obviously most untrue position it's the one that touches the
00:14:01 most lives being a parent is not a political position unlike what the feminists want to say 1.00
00:14:06 that the personal is political. Parenting is not a political act, and most parents don't think of
00:14:10 it as a political act. They think of it as a get through the day and make these kids have enough
00:14:15 to eat in the best environment that they can on a day-by-day basis with just the challenges of
00:14:21 parenting. And so what it threatens to allow and what it is allowing, like we saw in Canada with
00:14:26 Muslims and Sikhs and Christians and agnostics and Jews all coming together up until this recent
00:14:31 conflict what we saw was that parenting transcends all the other boundaries political religious
00:14:38 and it gives the ability to build a gigantic coalition plus to start shaking people loose
00:14:44 from from the cult and thinking something's badly wrong here we're doing to be as generous as
00:14:51 possible highly aggressive surgical interventions of mentally unwell children as the pathway to
00:14:57 treatment that's the primary pathway to treatment and threatening to take parents parental rights
00:15:02 away from them through the state if they don't go along with this this is a scary moment for
00:15:07 parents and scary moments wake people up yeah i particularly enjoy him saying there that parenting
00:15:17 is not political and i think this is something that when we talk about politics and what engages
00:15:25 people, what activates people. I think it's when the state ends up at your doorstep when you never
00:15:32 asked for it, that the government has to worry. And that was, I think, the story during COVID,
00:15:36 where people who didn't really care about politics or didn't feel the need to get involved in
00:15:40 politics felt very personally affronted by politics when government was regulating their
00:15:45 liberty in a way that had never been done before in their lives. And parents' rights issues,
00:15:50 very same dynamic. People that just want to raise their kids, feed their kids, get their kids a good
00:15:54 education are now finding the state pushing this indoctrination quite frankly what else do you call
00:16:01 it on their children and thus they're like all right we're going to take a stand here and I think
00:16:06 that it is interesting to talk about where the greatest victory is likely to come or the first
00:16:12 big victory to chip away at wokeness and I think there's a lot of truth to the idea that gender is 1.00
00:16:17 the one although as he said the anti-semitism aspect is incredibly key and you know we've been
00:16:23 talking on the show since October 7th, since the day Hamas launched this latest round of attacks
00:16:28 on Israel about this idea. And it wasn't just the attacks by Hamas on Israel and on Jewish people,
00:16:35 but I think it's the continued attacks and assaults on Jewish people and their rights,
00:16:39 their identities, their existence that has become so normalized in communities across the country.
00:16:46 On the weekend, 100,000 people took to the streets of the city I'm in right now, 100,000 to get, I
00:16:53 mean we thought the freedom convoy was great because of how many people it brought out but
00:16:56 100,000 people on the streets many of whom were very explicitly supportive of violence against
00:17:05 Jews and violence against Israelis I'm not going to say every one of the 100,000 was but enough 1.00
00:17:10 were that it should give a lot of cause for concern so you can make an argument that is a
00:17:16 logical argument even if you disagree with it that people who are of Muslim background Arab
00:17:21 background would have a reason to align with the Palestinian cause. Why do people on the left
00:17:29 outside of that? Why do people on the so-called queer left who would have no home in Gaza that 0.73
00:17:36 would be particularly comfortable with them do that as well? I wanted to talk about that and
00:17:40 this idea of coalitions, which are really at the core of why wokeness has been so powerful.
00:17:44 And I did so with Andy Ngo, who is a fantastic contributor. He's a great exposer of the far left and has risked his own safety on a number of occasions to do what he does. And it was interesting that his take on that very dynamic.
00:18:00 We've seen, obviously, pro-Hamas or pro-Gaza protesters who are Muslim,
00:18:07 in which I think we can understand a little bit of where they're coming at it.
00:18:10 But we've also seen supporting Gaza and Hamas,
00:18:13 people on the far left that are in these very weird coalitions,
00:18:16 people that wouldn't really get along very well in Gaza.
00:18:19 And I'm wondering, with your experience covering far-left protests,
00:18:23 how these people rationalize support for a society
00:18:26 that doesn't really have a place for them in it?
00:18:28 I think the narrative that the public has been sold on the very complicated conflict involving Israel and various Palestinian militant factions is that it's about oppressor versus oppressed, which is this cliche that you hear brought out a lot.
00:18:50 But really, that's simply sort of the way it's framed.
00:18:54 So to a leftist mindset, they want to be on the cause of the oppressed.
00:19:06 But there's also been quite, I mean, it's not quite as simple as that.
00:19:10 There's a long, we've had years now of radical leftist ideologues, many of them academics, pulling in the Palestinian-Israel conflict, weaving it into the decolonization theory and ideology, I would say.
00:19:34 and
00:19:35 that
00:19:38 we're also now
00:19:41 more than three years
00:19:43 after George Floyd
00:19:44 in America you have
00:19:46 a
00:19:47 generation of young people
00:19:51 who were radicalized
00:19:52 and now
00:19:55 they've been mobilized again
00:19:56 to sort of be the foot soldiers
00:19:58 the ideology is like
00:19:59 the thread that runs through
00:20:02 BLM 1.00
00:20:03 Antifa, decolonization, critical race theory, Israel hatred, it's a very, it's a threat of bloodlust.
00:20:15 The ideologies for each, these different things are quite different.
00:20:19 I mean, you have to wonder what does, what does Palestinian nationalism and radical Islamic politics have to do with Antifa or BLM?
00:20:31 Well, really very little other than the fact that they would like to see America suffer
00:20:38 and its friends and allies internationally suffer as well.
00:20:42 Do these people understand or have an ability to rationalize this internal cognitive dissonance if pressed?
00:20:51 Or is it that they genuinely are never pressed and they do not give it any intellectual weight whatsoever
00:20:56 about how they can support these two things that are contradictory or that have nothing to do with each other?
00:21:01 they're not pressed in their circles, for one.
00:21:05 So I think they generally don't have to really think about it.
00:21:13 Or they've been radicalized to become the faithful and the devout,
00:21:20 that it doesn't matter actually what countering evidence you present to them.
00:21:24 They're able to reject it.
00:21:28 What is, I guess, the logical outcome of this?
00:21:30 I mean, a few weeks ago, we had in Canada a lot of Muslims and evangelicals linking arms,
00:21:36 supporting parental rights, speaking up against transgender ideology.
00:21:39 Now, you know, two groups that are on this different side on Israel-Palestine.
00:21:44 I mean, are we just going to see more and more of those fractures?
00:21:47 Or do you think the left will just keep getting larger and larger
00:21:50 as that sort of amorphous protest blob that I know you've seen?
00:21:56 Well, what's been happening with the left is that their alliances and their coalitions have been growing.
00:22:00 It hasn't gotten smaller.
00:22:03 They've added to the long list of people who have grievances.
00:22:06 It's only grown.
00:22:08 I mean, you know, first it was about black grievance.
00:22:14 Then it's about brown grievance. 0.68
00:22:16 Then queer and gay grievance, trans grievance. 0.50
00:22:20 It just keeps growing.
00:22:21 And the danger of all this is that present within that type of worldview, there's a lot of support for the use of extreme violence and terrorism.
00:22:38 terrorism. And I think what surprised me a bit about some of the rhetoric that's
00:22:44 come out in the last three weeks since the 7th of October is that how open they
00:22:51 are about their incitement to violence. Before, during the George Floyd-inspired
00:22:57 BLM Antifa riots, it was a bit more subtle. It wasn't, when I say a bit more 0.61
00:23:03 subtle, it wasn't subtle then, but there was a bit of enough plausible deniability,
00:23:07 Sort of like when people were smashing up businesses and setting fire to police stations, they were saying they were doing it for racial justice or out of rage because of what's been happening to blacks in America.
00:23:26 that it justifies this type of reaction now it's like
00:23:30 the sentiment is people expressing the support for the actions of hamas like that is uh
00:23:40 they've crossed the line and uh some of them have been called out for it but a lot of them have
00:23:50 been called out and their response is yeah and so what yeah and i think that is the real takeaway
00:23:58 of all of this these people are not called on it they don't feel the need to explain themselves
00:24:03 because they know they have to go back to my discussion with andrew with james lindsey
00:24:07 this uh institutional backing and they they have a media that's generally in their corner they have
00:24:14 in many cases a political establishment that's in their corner and that is i i think the real
00:24:20 reasonable reason that you need to, I don't want to say upend institutions, but certainly reclaim
00:24:25 them and take them back. And I think the one thing that the left has always done very well
00:24:30 is fight on multiple fronts. They fight on multiple fronts. And they also don't take
00:24:36 a beat after one win. They move immediately into the next one. And that is so incredibly,
00:24:43 so incredibly important. Apparently in the comments section, some of you were like,
00:24:48 not even paying attention to the interview. And we're just like looking at who you could
00:24:51 recognize in the background. So maybe we'll have to do like a Where's Waldo thing. Sean tells me
00:24:56 there's a woman named Angela Williams, who's been like, you know, identifying everyone in the
00:24:59 background. So they all get like credit as being extras on the Andrew Lawton show, which I believe
00:25:06 is actually worth nothing. So maybe we don't give them credit for it. But nevertheless, it was
00:25:10 actually a lot of fun. And the one I mean, I sort of joked about Davos that in some ways,
00:25:14 it's like just a normal convention because you're just you know seeing people milling about but it
00:25:18 happens to be you know oh the prime minister of Belgium uh this was a weird one like that because
00:25:23 it was like all these kind of conservative or conservative adjacent celebrity types where you
00:25:27 look at them and you're like oh that's uh oh that's Dr. Oz oh yeah actually I was chatting
00:25:32 with Dr. Oz today we we didn't do an interview uh because I don't really know if I can share this
00:25:37 story but I guess I I will now I was like asking him you know I I wanted to do an interview and I
00:25:42 said, hey, I just want to run this topic by you. I would love to talk about trust in the medical
00:25:47 community post-COVID. And his response was just laughing at me. Not laughing at me, but I think
00:25:53 laughing at the idea as if to say he realizes that that is pretty much impossible because of
00:25:59 how little trust there is. And I would say deservedly so. But nevertheless, Dr. Oz and I
00:26:03 had a nice little chat, was chatting with Peter Boghossian, who you may recall, I was actually on
00:26:09 his show, he did a little gag, which, well, not really a gag. It's like a thought experiment that
00:26:14 I hope to share some footage of when it is published, whenever that is. But I'm trying
00:26:20 to think of what else was going on today, because some people are just curious about the feeling in
00:26:24 the atmosphere. And I go back to the fact that it was hopeful, which is incredibly, incredibly
00:26:30 important, and I think probably unexpected, because we really didn't get the sense that
00:26:35 there was much to be hopeful about. Now, we did speak about Israel and Hamas with Andy Ngo. And
00:26:43 why this is a bit important, I will point out here that the dog whistles we've heard from people
00:26:51 on the pro-Hamas side or the anti-Israel side have become, in some cases, a lot less oblique,
00:26:59 a lot less subtle. People have been very explicit. I mean, when protesters chant from the river to
00:27:04 the sea. Palestine will be free. What they are saying is that they want Israel to be annihilated.
00:27:08 They want from the Jordan River to the Mediterranean Sea to be all a Palestinian Muslim 1.00
00:27:14 land. When people talk about gas the Jews, there isn't really a hidden symbolism there. They're
00:27:19 saying they want to gas the Jews. But there are some coded words that you hear. And one that I 0.98
00:27:26 need to call out is the so-called ceasefire. This has become the rallying call of the left,
00:27:32 the NDP in Ontario, labor unions, leftist activists, they say, oh, ceasefire, ceasefire,
00:27:38 ceasefire, as though Israel is the problem and Israel needs to lay down its arms here.
00:27:44 That is the call we hear from people. Now, the one thing that I will point out here is that
00:27:50 ceasefire involves a two-way exchange of ceasing fire. Hamas is still holding more than 200
00:27:57 Israelis captive. They're still holding hostages. And Hamas has broken every ceasefire it's had
00:28:03 with Israel. Remember, there was a ceasefire in place until October 6th. And then on October 7th,
00:28:09 we know what happened. This is one clip which I need to share with you that has been making
00:28:15 the rounds here of a Hamas official on Lebanese television, Gazi Hamad.
00:28:27 And ...
00:28:57 out
00:29:00 relatively
00:29:04 .
00:29:18 .
00:29:19 .
00:29:20 .
00:29:20 .
00:29:20 .
00:29:20 .
00:29:22 It is justified. 0.83
00:29:36 If you don't speak Arabic and you're listening to the podcast and not watching where you'd
00:29:44 be able to see the captions, I'll tell you that he did all the greatest hits.
00:29:48 Literally called for Israel's annihilation, said we'll do this again and again,
00:29:52 over and over, we'll keep doing it, said that the people of Palestine are the victims here. So 0.76
00:29:58 everything they do is justified. And of course, you know, just to remind you the again and again
00:30:04 bit, that is not exactly the language of a group with whom you could have a meaningful and reliable
00:30:11 ceasefire. Yet I haven't seen that clip circulating among the same left-wing folks that have been so
00:30:17 keen to call for a ceasefire in the first place. And this is why a lot of them fundamentally
00:30:21 are not interested in peace, although they claim that. They are interested in peace
00:30:26 on Hamas terms, peace on Palestinian terms. And while it doesn't fit into the broader discussion
00:30:32 of wokeness that I was having on the show, I did want to take a bit of a stop and just talk about
00:30:38 Israel, because I ran into Dennis Prager, who's been one of the most consistent and clear voices
00:30:43 on Israel. Now, he's a Jewish man, a conservative lion in American media, but his stand for Israel
00:30:51 is not just because of his own Judaism. I spoke about that for a few minutes with him the other
00:30:55 day. Let me just first ask you, how would you rank the world's support of Israel right now,
00:31:02 left and right? I mean, in one sense, we see, you know, Democrats, Republicans,
00:31:05 liberals, conservatives saying the right things, but is it authentic in your view?
00:31:09 uh i i'm not a uh pursuer of the question is it authentic uh i i care how people act and speak
00:31:21 how authentic it is let god judge my i only care about what people do and what people say publicly
00:31:29 so if we live in a world where people feel
00:31:34 that they have to come out and support Israel, but they really don't believe it?
00:31:41 That's fine with me.
00:31:43 It's hard to imagine such a world.
00:31:46 Does everybody who supports Hamas, which is the same as saying I support the Palestinians right now, 0.51
00:31:54 are they mean it or are they just reflexively anti-West?
00:32:01 It doesn't matter.
00:32:02 It matters what you do.
00:32:04 So, as I said, I don't know about the authenticity issue.
00:32:09 I only care about the moral clarity issue.
00:32:13 If you can't say Hamas is evil and Israel is good relative to their enemy, your moral compass is broken.
00:32:23 Why is it that so many on the left have such difficulty with that?
00:32:27 I mean, you look at, you know, queers against Israeli apartheid being one of the most absurd examples of this. 1.00
00:32:32 people that would not be able to be who they are in Gaza, but are still believing that Israel is
00:32:37 the oppressor. I mean, how on earth do they reconcile that in your view? How do they reconcile
00:32:42 saying men give birth? How do they reconcile saying America is systemically racist? How do
00:32:48 they reconcile saying defund the police? The left is always wrong. That is a rule of life. It has
00:32:56 been true since vladimir lenin till till today not liberals liberals are wrong for voting for the
00:33:03 left but liberal values are the antithesis of left-wing values the left is always wrong and
00:33:09 all the touch everything it touches it destroys so when you ask how does a gay uh become pro 0.95
00:33:16 palestinian when they they might not live a week if they were openly gay in gaza whereas they'll 1.00
00:33:23 have a parade for them in Tel Aviv. It is not a matter of reconciling. They hate what is good.
00:33:32 All leftists hate what is good. They hate what is beautiful. They hate Shakespeare. I mean,
00:33:37 they hate. These are lost souls. Every civilization seems to produce some,
00:33:45 and they have unfortunately become dominant. Why is, just in closing, Israel so important,
00:33:52 and why should it be supported? Well, there are many separate issues here. Why should Taiwan be
00:34:00 supported, okay? Taiwan is not the cradle of Western civilization that Israel is. It all 0.85
00:34:07 comes from the Hebrew Bible, everything in the West. But I would be as adamant about supporting
00:34:15 Taiwan, to be perfectly honest. The idea that you don't support any other country until you're
00:34:24 invaded is not a moral position, in my opinion. You're the strongest country on earth and you
00:34:34 only protect yourself. You don't protect the little guy. But Israel is of incredible strategic
00:34:41 it comports to America. It is America's ally in the Middle East, a pretty important part of the
00:34:46 world. Plus, if you believe in values, that's the cradle of Judeo-Christian values. There's your
00:34:53 Judeo. I think that's pretty significant. That was American broadcaster, author, and Prager
00:35:02 you founder, as the name might suggest, Dennis Prager. He's actually fantastic. I interviewed
00:35:08 him a few years back when he was doing a big speech in canada very very gracious i i he was
00:35:14 like he acted as though he remembered me but i think he was just being very polite so he's you
00:35:17 know he's a good schmoozer but uh that was i think an important topic and it was interesting you know
00:35:23 the whole point of this forum and i'm gonna have some more interviews next week that i won't have
00:35:28 time to get all today uh just to kind of sprinkle it out but one of the things that was interesting
00:35:33 is it was about ideas more than it was about individual politics and individual policies.
00:35:40 And I had a lovely email from someone, if I can find it, I want to share from a listener who said,
00:35:46 just want to drop you a note to say that your ideas from the UK have been, in my view,
00:35:49 some of your best work or your recent broadcast from the UK. The guests have been compelling,
00:35:55 the subjects varied, and your questions have been very astute and germane. Oh, well, thank you,
00:35:59 you flatter me you have tended to concentrate on universal issues philosophies and ideals which
00:36:04 makes for deeper conversations and i there's more to the email i'm going to respond to the the
00:36:10 person directly after the show but i i quite enjoyed that because every now and then we get
00:36:15 so focused on the nitty-gritty we lose sight of the bigger picture and i i think politics uh is so
00:36:21 often important but often meaningless as well and i how do i square these two seemingly i'm being
00:36:27 like the leftists I talk about, saying things that are seemingly incompatible. And what I mean is
00:36:32 that politics matters. And I think politics is one of the most direct ways in which all of us
00:36:37 can make a difference. We go to the ballot box, we cast a ballot, and we, along with tens of
00:36:42 thousands of other people, elect a member of parliament who, along with 337 other people,
00:36:47 can vote on policy. So your fractional share of influence is very, very small. It's very,
00:36:55 very small. I mean, statistically speaking, most people, if they as individuals stayed home,
00:37:00 it would make no difference in what happens in the course of the country. But it's all of us
00:37:05 together doing that, that makes change. But at the same time, it's not the only thing we can do.
00:37:12 And I think people that focus only on politics are not really in the business of making change.
00:37:18 There was a time in which I stood for political office, and I thought that was a way I could
00:37:22 perhaps make some change. I know now that perhaps being in the Ontario legislature from 2018 to
00:37:28 2022 would not have been a period in which I probably would have been with my libertarian
00:37:32 bona fides particularly welcome. I maybe could have pushed back in some ways verbally, but I
00:37:39 wouldn't have been able to stop these things that I found so horrible. I like to think that on my
00:37:43 show, I was able to wield a bit more influence by talking about this, by telling the stories
00:37:47 of real people. And this is where we choose our battlefield. Do we want to battle on the floor of
00:37:54 the House of Commons or the legislature of our province? Do we want to battle in the marketplace
00:37:59 of ideas? Do we want to battle in the classroom? Do we want to battle in civil society in some
00:38:03 other way? And I do think that oftentimes, you know, this policy, oh, we're going to do tax
00:38:09 credits for parents to enroll their kids in sports programs. Well, that's a policy that means
00:38:15 something to people. It's a policy that may save people a couple hundred dollars a year,
00:38:20 even the carbon tax. It's a policy that means something to people. But does any of that matter
00:38:25 if the core foundations of our civilization are being eroded every single day?
00:38:34 And that's where I think you need to do both. And I think sometimes you need to get down to
00:38:38 the nitty gritty and sometimes you need to talk about the big ideas. So I really enjoyed being
00:38:43 able to do that this week. And I'm going to, I don't know if I want to say I'm going to make
00:38:47 this the big ideas forum on my show, but I would like to, if I take that email from that gentleman
00:38:52 to heart, find ways to incorporate at least every now and then some of these bigger ideas that
00:38:57 separate us from the day-to-day of politics. That's a bit of a, I don't know if it's a pledge
00:39:02 there, but I guess a bit of a thought there. Just before we wrap things up, we were going to be
00:39:07 talking about the Alberta election, or I guess more of the UCPAGM. The election's already come
00:39:13 and gone. This is quite a fascinating story. The United Conservative Party of Alberta is having its
00:39:18 AGM this weekend. I'm going to be there. So I'm actually like taking a bit of a detour on my way
00:39:23 back tomorrow. I'm flying to Calgary for the UCPAGM. And this is going to be fascinating because we
00:39:30 have a few resolutions that are up for debate that are dealing with some of the issues we've
00:39:34 talked about on this show, notably parental consent and gender stuff. But you have also
00:39:40 pushing 4,000 people, 4,000 people that are registered and will be attending this. Now,
00:39:47 that's largely due to the organizing work of Take Back Alberta. We were supposed to have
00:39:51 David Parker, who is the founder of that, but he has not dialed in for the interview. And I don't
00:39:57 think at this point we're going to be able to get him in time if he does. So it's unfortunate. I was
00:40:02 looking forward to speaking to David about this, but the folks in Alberta are going to have, it
00:40:09 looks like, the largest political party convention Alberta has ever seen. Now, why are people so
00:40:14 involved? Is it just because there was an organizing effort to get people in? Is it because they feel
00:40:20 they can wield some real influence in the UCP and by extension the Daniel Smith government? I don't
00:40:25 know, but that's going to be one of the things to talk about here. What has activated thousands of
00:40:31 people in Alberta to want to go to a political party convention where they have to spend money,
00:40:36 book a hotel when they could be doing anything else. And this is where I go back to what it is
00:40:42 that motivates people. I mean, hurting libertarians has got to be the most thankless task imaginable.
00:40:47 And the people in Alberta have had that happen. There was a mobilization effort to vote out Jason
00:40:53 Kenney, which was ultimately successful, a mobilization effort to elect Danielle Smith. 0.97
00:40:57 and now even though she's there there's an effort underway to make sure that party maintains its
00:41:03 grassroots mandate and doesn't become exactly what a lot of these critics thought and claimed
00:41:09 the Jason Kenney government had become certainly by the end of it so that's going to be something
00:41:13 we are keeping an eye out for tomorrow we'll have something very special for you I'll give
00:41:19 you more of an update on that it's going to be pre-recorded because I'll literally be in the air
00:41:22 during the showtime, and my last few attempts at using Air Canada Wi-Fi have not given me
00:41:27 confidence that I could, you know, live stream a show from wherever I am on the plane. So we will
00:41:33 find a way to bring you that, but it's going to be lots of fun, and then I'll have a full report
00:41:36 on the UCPA GM over the weekend, and a bit of a recap on Monday's show. So lots of good stuff,
00:41:43 as Justin Trudeau's team would have said back in the day, sunny ways ahead, except this time,
00:41:47 I mean it. And it's not Sunnyways on Justin Trudeau's terms. So with that, I will bid you
00:41:53 farewell. Thank you. God bless. And good day to you all. Thanks for listening to the Andrew
00:41:58 Lawton Show. Support the program by donating to TrueNorth at www.tnc.news.
00:42:17 We'll be right back.
00:42:47 We'll be right back.