Juno News - May 13, 2024


Are anti-Israel encampments a free speech issue?

Mentioned
Indigenous conservatism, reconciliation & racist white liberals (ft. Jennifer Elle) The truth about "safe supply" - Interview with Dr. Sharon Koivu

Episode Stats


Length

41 minutes

Words per minute

167.86

Word count

7,015

Sentence count

315

Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged

Toxicity

6

sentences flagged

Hate speech

10

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

This week on The Andrew Lawton Show, we talk about the ongoing anti-protest at Canadian universities, the return of the Teddy Awards, and the immigration mess that the Trudeau government is trying to fix. We'll also hear from the Canadian Taxpayers Federation's annual honour of the worst of government waste.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to Canada's most irreverent talk show
00:01:15 this is the Andrew Lawton show
00:01:18 brought to you by True North
00:01:20 hello and welcome to you all
00:01:26 Canada's most irreverent talk show
00:01:28 here the andrew lawton show i am back did you miss me no no no don't don't answer that my
00:01:34 delicate tender ego can't take it if you say no uh it is monday may 13th 2024 it is just after
00:01:41 one o'clock eastern time 11 a.m mountain time 10 a.m in beautiful british columbia and if you
00:01:47 want to get the atlantic provinces uh sorted out too we can do that as well just for you just for
00:01:52 today it is just after two o'clock on three of the four atlantic provinces all three maritime
00:01:58 provinces but in Newfoundland a delightfully charming 2 30 p.m trying to show us all uh off
00:02:05 with the show off to us all with the half hour time zone but wherever it is for you whether
00:02:09 you're listening live or pre-tape uh all of it is an option available to you through our podcast
00:02:15 which you should subscribe we welcome you nonetheless I was away on vacation last week
00:02:20 I don't really have anything to report I decided to I had a bunch of like air miles so my wife and
00:02:25 i were like and we had some time so we were just trying to get uh so far away as far as we could
00:02:30 get on the air miles basically while still being able to get back and i and i'm off and i'm away
00:02:34 next week but that is something that is related to my work at true north so i'll have an update
00:02:39 for you on that very shortly but it means we have to make the most of the time we have together
00:02:44 this week and a couple of big things that i wanted to point out here number one and i'm going to be
00:02:51 talking about this a little bit later on in the show. We have this ongoing standoff between
00:02:56 universities and these encampments. I was actually on my alma mater's campus, Western University,
00:03:02 and took a little stroll there. They had an encampment set up on the weekend.
00:03:07 It was pretty quiet and sleepy. I was there at about 8 a.m. in the morning. I should have just
00:03:12 brought a bullhorn and started blasting classical music or something like that, but I didn't have
00:03:17 my bullhorn or my... Are there still boomboxes? Are boomboxes still a thing? I didn't have a
00:03:22 bullhorn or a boombox with me, so I had to just walk by and sort of deal with it there. But in
00:03:27 Alberta, it was a very different story. So we're going to talk about whether this is a legitimate
00:03:32 form of protest or perhaps something that is illegitimate. The police are right to step in
00:03:38 and dismantle the way they have. Also later on in the show, we'll be talking about the return of
00:03:44 the Teddy Awards. This is the Canadian Taxpayers Federation's annual reward of the worst of
00:03:51 government waste and it is a bit of a doozy this year but just before we get into that I want to
00:03:57 talk about this creative math that we've seen from the Liberal government here. Now you may recall
00:04:03 it was a couple of weeks ago that Justin Trudeau gave what was a rather stunning admission that he
00:04:07 has bungled the immigration file. He says yes Canada has clearly accepted more in the way of
00:04:13 immigrants than Canada can sustain, more than Canada can absorb. This was a, again, stunning 1.00
00:04:20 admission from the federal government, especially because it has been Justin Trudeau at the helm
00:04:24 for the last nine years. So if there is a problem with the immigration system in Canada,
00:04:29 that is his and his immigration minister's faults. But he made this admission nonetheless.
00:04:35 And we talked about it on the show, and Mark Miller, who's the immigration minister now,
00:04:39 has made similar concessions that we have had too many specifically foreign residents so these are 0.99
00:04:44 the people that come in either as temporary foreign workers or as international students
00:04:49 he said maybe just maybe we have too many of these people in the country and you think okay great the
00:04:56 liberal government's paying attention to this they see there's a housing crisis they see there are
00:05:00 long lines at food banks of many in many cases international students trying to get access to
00:05:06 food because they can't afford it. He's seen all of these problems and he thinks, okay, great.
00:05:11 They're listening. They're finally, finally listening. What are they going to do about it?
00:05:16 And then Mark Miller gives us this answer. Maybe we can just decrease the number of temporary
00:05:22 residents by converting them to permanent residents. Yeah, this is literally Mark Miller's
00:05:31 position here. We can decrease the number of temporary residents in the country. Okay,
00:05:35 you're great you're on side you're with them you support that by just like moving them from column
00:05:41 b to column c if you just make them permanent residents then boom ta-da you've reduced the
00:05:46 number of temporary residents this is like it's hilarious because this is like the type of thing
00:05:51 that if some first-year statistics student at i don't know some like terrible podunk university
00:05:57 in the middle of nowhere tried to do this they would be failed and flunked out and maybe even
00:06:02 accused of academic misconduct because you are just fudging and molesting your data by just moving
00:06:07 things around changing the labels but not dealing with the substance of the problem the issue is not
00:06:14 which column people are in the issue is the fact that we have had more people in the country at a
00:06:20 more aggressive rate than the country and the economic climate of the country have been willing
00:06:27 to withstand now miller met with his provincial counterparts so these are the ministers in
00:06:32 ontario's government quebec's government vc's government and so on for the first time and this
00:06:38 is to announce a plan for the temporary resident problem and so he has this opportunity he has all
00:06:43 of these provincial ministers that are saying to him okay yes we really want to find a way to do
00:06:48 this and he says okay so the issue is that we have high immigration okay what if we just call
00:06:56 it a different type of immigration and you're like well well minister the people are still
00:07:00 in the country the the food bank line is still long okay what what if we put up a a mirror of
00:07:08 some sorts and we make it look like the line is shorter than it actually is that this is like
00:07:14 basically the type of nonsense he's suggesting here this is the the guy that we're supposed to
00:07:19 look at to have these solutions to the problem and he is instead deciding to aggravate and
00:07:25 exacerbate the problem now this is what he has said here and i want to keep the most important
00:07:31 quote of this the fact people are already here their impact on affordability has already been
00:07:39 baked in so it's smart it's smart to do it he's and he walked it back a little bit he said well
00:07:46 it doesn't mean by extension that everyone's entitled to stay here or be here in canada but
00:07:51 but they want to take all the people who are here who came to Canada on a temporary basis.
00:07:56 The basis of their entry, the condition of their entry was that they would be here temporarily
00:08:01 to either complete their studies, to work for a period of time on this farm or in that service environment,
00:08:08 whatever the case may be.
00:08:09 They already knew that was temporary.
00:08:12 And his answer to there being too many of them by his own government's admission
00:08:15 that have come in in too short a time is that, well, maybe we should just turn it around
00:08:20 and move them into the other column.
00:08:22 And you wonder why the liberal government
00:08:24 is cratering in the pool.
00:08:26 You wonder why no one is looking to the liberals now
00:08:28 and saying, these guys really seem to have a handle
00:08:32 on what's happening.
00:08:33 I'm trying to like come up,
00:08:34 we should just come up with some meme of sorts
00:08:36 where, you know, find ways that we could say
00:08:40 that the liberal government is actually coming up with.
00:08:42 For example, I've got a Mark Miller solution here.
00:08:45 So I was reading, I read this book a while ago,
00:08:47 but let's say I hadn't.
00:08:48 This is a delightful book, Eric Fromm's Escape from Freedom.
00:08:52 Let's say I had to read this for an assignment
00:08:54 and I had to get through all, how many pages is it?
00:08:57 All 296 pages of the book
00:09:01 because I had to read the entire book.
00:09:03 And oh no, I'm only at page 75 in the classes tomorrow.
00:09:06 Mark Miller says not to worry.
00:09:08 Just rip off the back half. 1.00
00:09:09 The book only has 75 pages now.
00:09:11 Congratulations, you've done it.
00:09:13 You've managed it, you've conquered it.
00:09:16 You're having trouble conquering Everest?
00:09:18 ah, just lop off the top of Everest and ta-da, you're there. This is Mark Miller's idea of
00:09:23 achievement. And I'm sorry, it is hilarious in some ways, but it wouldn't be for long if this
00:09:30 guy has his way for, you know, the years and years that the liberal government tends to think
00:09:35 it's going to be in power. Absolutely absurd. One thing I wanted to just pivot to here is the
00:09:43 ongoing uh well in some cases dismantling of these encampments on university campuses there
00:09:49 were a police movement in Alberta on the weekend uh one well share a couple of clips
00:09:55 Sean it's your choice which one we do first uh from the dismantling in Alberta
00:10:13 you see just in the background there the number of police officers involved tearing down the
00:10:21 scaffolding pretty anticlimactic in a way uh this was one though that i found was a little
00:10:26 bit more forceful where you had basically the anti-israel encampment uh form of hold the line
00:10:33 do not let them surround our camp do not let them take down the walls
00:10:40 So we basically have her say, no, no, no, don't let them do it.
00:10:56 Don't let them do it.
00:10:57 And there was one video I saw where like one officer single-handedly took down an entire wall.
00:11:10 he was actually the uh captain of the calgary police dominoes team by the way so that he put
00:11:28 that all to good use uh he just knocked the one down the other side uh those officers like each
00:11:33 one took one pallet he was able to like knock the whole pallet down on his own so uh good on that
00:11:38 officer there. But this was what happened. Police moved in. And in Montreal, we have a bit of a
00:11:43 different case. McGill University is going to the, well, it's in court today, asking for permission,
00:11:49 basically. They're asking for an injunction to be able to remove these encampments. And look,
00:11:54 I have very little time for the message being espoused by the people at these encampments. I
00:12:01 have seen symbolism that is, in my mind, and I think very demonstrably supporting literal terrorism.
00:12:08 in terror groups. I have in other cases seen rhetoric that I don't think is glorifying
00:12:12 terrorism, but I think is nonetheless callous and anti-Semitic. And there are other people
00:12:17 that probably just don't know why they're there. This is the trendy thing. This is the cool thing
00:12:21 to do, the cool place to be. And that's why they are there. People who are wearing keffias,
00:12:26 they don't even know anything about a keffia. They were just handing them out outside the quad
00:12:30 and they put them on because the cute girl they like from their gender studies class is wearing
00:12:36 one as well and they wanted to fit in. That is the campus activist mindset in a lot of cases. But
00:12:41 I'm also very aware of the fact that a lot of the people who are cheering the dismantling of these
00:12:46 encampments were people who may have been supportive of the Freedom Convoys continued
00:12:52 presence in Ottawa a couple of years ago and vice versa. People on the left who wanted police to
00:12:57 barge in and break down the Freedom Convoy are telling police they should stay outside of these 0.69
00:13:04 little activist safe spaces on campuses now when it comes to these encampments and it's why when
00:13:10 the freedom convoy happened I was so insistent on the need to come up with a universal rule
00:13:16 a universal rule for protest that we could apply regardless of cause find the limit because
00:13:23 remember people like Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez have come out and said in unequivocal terms
00:13:28 protest is meant to be disruptive so disruption alone is the point well not alone but disruption
00:13:33 is the point. So you can't even say if a protest is disruptive, it's unlawful. And I wanted to
00:13:40 just have a legal analysis of this, if you will, not from a boring dry perspective, but just in
00:13:46 the climate in Canada that we are at now, is this a legal, legitimate, defensible protest? Or are
00:13:53 police justified in barging in? Or is the answer somewhere in between? Wanted to welcome into the 0.93
00:13:59 show, Josh Tahaz, who is the lawyer extraordinaire. Well, he's our lawyer extraordinaire with the
00:14:04 Canadian Constitution Foundation. Josh, always good to talk to you. Thanks for coming on today.
00:14:09 Thanks for the invitation.
00:14:12 So let me ask first and foremost, in law, how clearly defined is that line between
00:14:19 an unlawful and a lawful protest? Setting aside the kind of the inconsistency that we'll get from
00:14:25 media commentary on this. Is there actually a really clear line in the law on this?
00:14:30 No. So it's a really difficult question. There are a bunch of different factors you need to
00:14:38 consider here. And if we're talking about the protests on campus, for example, one of the
00:14:44 questions is whether the charter even applies because campuses are in many ways considered
00:14:51 private property. And therefore, you know, if they're trying to get rid of an encampment on
00:14:56 campus, then they may just be trying to enforce their private property rights. And so the charter
00:15:02 might not even come into play. But if you look at the Supreme Court's jurisprudence over the years,
00:15:09 they've said some rather confusing things on what counts as expression. You know, the first case
00:15:16 where they sort of developed the free expression test was called Irwin Toy. And in that case,
00:15:20 they said, on the one hand, certain forms of expression. So, you know, if you punch someone
00:15:26 in the face, that's an expressive activity, you're trying to convey a message and usually
00:15:32 pretty effectively, but that's not covered by the free expression guarantee because of the form of
00:15:38 that expression. And yet at the same time, in that case, they said, you know, if you go park your car
00:15:43 as a protest in a parking lot, I know this is a weird example, but it's the example that they
00:15:51 used. If you're doing that as a protest against reserving parking spots for certain people,
00:15:56 then that is an expressive activity and the chart and your expression is protected. And if you look
00:16:03 at something like an occupation or an encampment, it's hard to know whether that's protected
00:16:11 expression or not and you can look at some of the later case law there's a case called
00:16:16 montreal city where they get into okay which places does the charter protect expression
00:16:22 in and which places are excluded from protection and they say you know look at the historical
00:16:27 and actual use of the the place is it a place where historically we would expect expression
00:16:33 like a a public park or is it a place where we historically wouldn't like the secure areas of
00:16:39 an airport is one example they used. And in terms of actual function, okay, well, is it compatible
00:16:46 with the function of the place? And you can look at something like the University of Toronto campus
00:16:51 and you say, assuming that it is public property, which I think might not be correct, then the
00:17:01 actual function of that space, well, what is it? It's to, you know, play Frisbee, it's to sit on
00:17:06 grass but it's also to protest so you have to accept some degree of protest there in that type
00:17:13 of space and the question then becomes is an occupation where you're there night after night
00:17:19 for weeks on end is that compatible with the function of that space and there's good arguments
00:17:25 that it isn't that it you know destroys the grass or it keeps anybody else from
00:17:29 uh using that public space so these are really tricky questions to resolve
00:17:34 Well, and this came up to some extent with the Freedom Convoy, and I wanted to get your
00:17:38 perspective on this. Does the length of time have any bearing on whether something is legal?
00:17:43 You know, so for one of these encampments, could it be that it's legal if you do it for Saturday
00:17:48 and Sunday, but if you do it for three weeks, it's not, even though the activity itself and
00:17:52 the location are the same? Well, I think legally, we don't know with any certainty the answer to
00:17:58 that question we do know that to some degree uh there are sort of time-based restrictions so
00:18:04 this came up in the Occupy Toronto case where uh protesters occupied uh St. James Park in
00:18:12 downtown Toronto and they said um our protest is our expression and therefore if you say we can't
00:18:18 uh camp here overnight for weeks on end uh you're you're completely uh you know quashing our
00:18:26 expressive rights. And the court said they thought this was a form of expression to pitch tents and
00:18:32 all of that. But they said, no, the city can place limits on that. That's justified in a
00:18:38 free and democratic society. This is not what freedom of expression protects. So I do think
00:18:44 that time is a factor that courts would consider if they're trying to decide whether or not these
00:18:49 protests are illegal. Just to go back to the university question, I've spent far too much of
00:18:55 my life in recent years trying to figure out the answer to the charter applicability question on
00:19:00 university campuses. And it's really a mixed bag across the country, as I understand it. And
00:19:06 ironically, in Alberta, I think there is the strongest protection in the kind of the established
00:19:12 court ruling on there being charter rights on campuses. But Alberta was also where police
00:19:17 moved in at two of the province's big universities over the weekend.
00:19:21 yeah so there are differences and it depends on uh provinces uh in ontario there's a lot of case
00:19:28 law that suggests that university property is generally private and that universities are
00:19:34 autonomous institutions and the way they they look at that the courts the court says okay well
00:19:40 let's look at the acts that created these universities and they say pretty clearly that
00:19:44 they're meant to be autonomous and you know they receive public funding so we think of them as
00:19:50 public universities and we call them that. But in the case law, there's an argument to be made
00:19:55 that they're essentially private property. And so the charter wouldn't even really apply if that's
00:20:01 the case. In Alberta, like you say, there is a different case. It's a case involving a right to
00:20:07 life group that wanted to protest on campus. And in that case, the judge reviewed the case law and
00:20:14 said, look, if the university is implementing essentially a government program on the government's
00:20:21 behalf, then they are part of government. And as we all know, the charter applies to government. It
00:20:26 doesn't apply to private actors. So in that case, it did apply to the particular student group in
00:20:34 that particular case. And that was about discipline for their freedom of expression. So it's a little
00:20:42 bit of a tricky question and it might depend on which province you're in. So one of the most
00:20:47 frustrating things, and this comes up anytime there's a discussion about free speech or an
00:20:52 legal context, freedom of expression is that so many people are unable to separate the legality
00:20:58 from their own value that they attach to whatever the speech is. And this is sort of as I led into
00:21:03 this segment, the issue where I have to be fully candid. You know, I have very different views
00:21:07 about the value of the Freedom Convoy protests and the value of these protests. But I have to
00:21:12 take that out when I'm talking about the merit of their legal right to protest. And I'm wondering
00:21:18 from what you've seen, and I realize all these encampments are different and the rhetoric at
00:21:22 them is different. And sometimes the universities themselves may choose to avail, may choose to use
00:21:28 their property rights and may choose not to. And a university has that right. What's your general
00:21:34 read on where a court would take these? So my general read is that it's pretty hard to tell,
00:21:43 but I think if you're talking about Ontario... This is why lawyers always win,
00:21:47 because you can make an argument for or against anything, right?
00:21:51 You really can, but this is... I was debating this with a couple of my colleagues early this
00:21:56 morning, and you really can make the argument on either side. My personal view is that I...
00:22:04 I hate seeing protests broken up.
00:22:07 I don't agree with the message of this protest.
00:22:10 I generally think they're wrong,
00:22:12 but universities are places traditionally
00:22:14 where people express themselves on all manner of topics
00:22:19 and they're entitled to be wrong about those things.
00:22:22 And we need disagreement and debate on campus.
00:22:25 So I don't like seeing police go in and break them up.
00:22:28 But I think if you're talking about Ontario
00:22:31 and the university trying to enforce its property rights,
00:22:35 I think they're on pretty, fairly solid ground
00:22:38 that they could, you know, say trespassers,
00:22:41 especially the non-students, you know,
00:22:43 get off our lawn, you've been here long enough.
00:22:46 And in other cases, you know, the courts might say,
00:22:50 okay, well, this was a, take for example, Alberta,
00:22:53 this was violating their expression to say
00:22:56 they can't, you know, use this space,
00:22:58 But there were genuine safety risks here or there are other factors that make this a justified limit on the charter rights.
00:23:08 So I think that they, you know, those universities in Alberta might also potentially win.
00:23:12 But there's conflicting case law. That's the reality.
00:23:15 These things come up not all that often in the courts and different judges say different things.
00:23:20 So it's not always all that clear.
00:23:22 Well, and I would hope and assume that there could be some middle ground here.
00:23:26 I mean, for example, I played some clips a few moments ago of police taking down what looked like, again, not terribly permanent or terribly well-constructed fences, but there had been efforts to literally build a fence around this.
00:23:38 And we've heard reports from some of these cases of them trying to block people from walking through.
00:23:44 Like, I would be more amenable to this if a university were to say, listen, you can be there, you can set up your tents, you can sleep there, you can chant, but you can't commandeer this entire space.
00:23:55 If someone else wants to walk through that space and exercise their own free speech rights there, they should have that right. Similarly to, you know, the Freedom Convoy, if, you know, the government had said, listen, you can stay here as long as you want, but move the trucks, that would have changed the calculation a little bit, I think.
00:24:10 Yeah, I agree. I think that there are ways you can put reasonable limits that can allow people to continue to express themselves without actually, you know, commandeering the space, like you say, or creating some of these other risks.
00:24:25 And in fact, we have seen universities do that in this case. They have said things like, look, you can protest here every day and you can use up a large amount of space. You can be as loud as you like. But if you start impeding people walking to class, that's a potential violation of our student code of conduct.
00:24:44 and and there will be consequences for you know impeding other people trying to get just get to
00:24:50 class or you know you can you can be here all day but you can't stay overnight um and i think that
00:24:57 might be a type of limit that um makes sense considering the extent of our charter um if you
00:25:04 look at the ottawa protests the same thing too like if the city maybe found places where the
00:25:09 trucks could park so that people could do their protests day in day out every day. That's one
00:25:16 thing. But, you know, blocking a street might be legally a different thing, right? So I think
00:25:21 that's a good way to look at it is that we should be able to try and find ways to accommodate
00:25:25 people's expression, but not go overboard to the point where it's creating serious harm to other
00:25:32 people. There's one thing I wanted to ask you about, Josh, is, you know, whether just moving
00:25:38 forward here and whatever the next thing is the next protest if let's say that a pro-life group
00:25:43 is not allowed to demonstrate in the same space at you know university of toronto or whatever the
00:25:49 school is that this encampment is in and the university cracks down on them as has happened
00:25:54 to pro-life groups does this actually help them in a way can they turn around and say well hang
00:25:58 on you know last year you were fine when uh this protest was there
00:26:02 interesting because when these uh protests started up in the united states and you saw
00:26:10 you know university presidents being called before congress they they uh went back to principle and
00:26:16 they said look we're a university campus people should be able to say um extreme uh points of
00:26:22 view as long as they're not you know harassing a particular student over and over again and that
00:26:28 was the right principle. But for many years before that, universities had the opposite principle,
00:26:33 which was, oh, no, no, we need to protect student safety. Students can't be exposed to
00:26:38 controversial ideas they don't like because, you know, everything is discriminatory or
00:26:44 hurts their feelings. Yeah, the iHeart JK Rowling encampment wouldn't have lasted this long a year
00:26:49 ago. No, I don't think it would have. I don't think it would have. I think you're right. So
00:26:54 hopefully now we've got the right principle, which is that you should be able to express yourself
00:27:00 regardless of the content of your ideas, but certain forms of expression like violence or
00:27:06 maybe entrenched encampments go too far and they're not covered by your speech rights. But
00:27:12 whatever the principle is, we need to know that in advance. We need to apply it equally regardless
00:27:17 of whether we like the message of the protesters or we don't. Well, fascinating stuff. And I
00:27:24 I understand you have an op-ed coming out
00:27:26 about something very similar, hopefully soon, correct?
00:27:29 I hope so.
00:27:30 Not sure where yet, but we'll see.
00:27:33 All right.
00:27:33 Well, if everyone else rejects it, send it my way
00:27:35 and True North will publish it there.
00:27:37 But always good to talk to you, Josh DeHaz from the CCF.
00:27:40 Thank you very much.
00:27:41 Thanks, Andrew.
00:27:42 All right.
00:27:43 Always good to get the level-headed view of things there.
00:27:46 Wanted to turn to one thing,
00:27:49 the thing we can always, always, always count on.
00:27:52 Well, what are the two things?
00:27:53 Death and taxes, right?
00:27:54 We'll focus a little bit more on the second one here because government was, government loves patting itself on the back, but a couple of days ago, government was honored in a way that only the Canadian Taxpayers Federation is able to do.
00:28:09 It was Teddy Award season. 0.98
00:28:11 This is the, some of you like the Oscars, some of you like the Grammys, some of you like, what are the weird Canadian, the stupid Canadian ones that no one watches? 0.99
00:28:20 Is it the Gemini's? 0.99
00:28:22 No, not the Juno.
00:28:23 People like the Junos, Sean.
00:28:24 Let's not crap on the Junos too much.
00:28:26 It's the Gem, but I don't even know what the Geminis are 1.00
00:28:28 because there's also something called
00:28:30 the Canadian Screen Award.
00:28:32 So maybe I'm mixing up two awards, but either way,
00:28:34 it's the thing that like that CBC show
00:28:36 with the non-binary anti-colonial tomato
00:28:39 or whatever gets nominated on.
00:28:40 But anyway, but the award that I like,
00:28:43 the awards that I follow are the Teddy Awards
00:28:45 courtesy of the CTF.
00:28:47 I believe we have our good friend Franco Terrazano here
00:28:51 that he is with Teddy and he's holding a Teddy.
00:28:55 So this is like a Teddy-ception there.
00:28:58 And if you want to get a sense of how Franco feels
00:29:01 about a government waste,
00:29:02 I think this photo generally tells us that.
00:29:06 Yeah, that's also how he feels
00:29:08 whenever I ask him to come on the show, sadly.
00:29:10 But he's here now, nonetheless,
00:29:11 Franco Terrazano, federal director for the CTF.
00:29:14 Happy Teddy season to you, Franco.
00:29:17 Happy Teddy season to you
00:29:19 and all the big spending politicians and bureaucrats out there so give me a little bit
00:29:24 of the backstory here every time we do this we have to remind people of where the teddy came from
00:29:29 well we've been doing it we just had our 26th uh teddy ceremony you know celebrating the worst and
00:29:36 funniest examples of government waste uncovered over the last year let me tell you folks let me
00:29:40 bring you all behind the curtain it is a very very competitive field in government waste over the
00:29:46 last year let me tell you but the whole ceremony where we dress up with you know a bow tie black
00:29:52 suit uh it all started when well it was named after ted weatherall who is a former federal
00:29:58 appointee he was canned over his dubious expenses including a 700 lunch for two back in the 90s
00:30:05 so for the last 26 years we've been poking fun mocking these politicians and bureaucrats for
00:30:11 wasting people's money. And just reminding folks out there that the reason you are all paying too
00:30:16 much tax is because the government is wasting too much of your money. Oink, oink. All right. Well,
00:30:22 very, very well said there. Let's go through some of the winners because you're very good at not
00:30:27 just keeping it all focused on the federal government. You have municipal, provincial,
00:30:30 and federal categories, and of course, the Lifetime Achievement Award. So let's go through
00:30:35 the list here. Municipal, you went to Prince Edward Island, as I understand it.
00:30:40 No, that was last year. This year's we have the city of Regina. I know there's so much waste out there. It's hard to keep track of it. But this year's winner was the city of Regina. And, you know, Regina wanted to give the city a rebrand. So tourism Regina became experience Regina. And they came up with slogans like this. Now, folks, I didn't make them up. Here are the slogans they chose. Regina, the city that rhymes with fun.
00:31:07 Yeah, bureaucrats actually made that up. Regina, this city that rhymes with fun. And yeah, sure,
00:31:13 it's fun until you're paying for college 18 years later. Or how about this slogan? They came up with
00:31:19 this one as well. Show us your Regina. Yep, that was an actual slogan from the city of Regina.
00:31:25 They spent $30,000 on this rebrand for those slogans. And then after some blowback, obviously,
00:31:34 they quickly uh you know canned the rebrand it cost them 30 000 bucks so taxpayers are out tens
00:31:41 of thousands of dollars and we didn't even get to keep the rebrand i actually i didn't mind the 0.98
00:31:46 i didn't mind the slogans i thought it was like the most interesting thing to come out of vagina 1.00
00:31:50 in quite a while uh i just didn't like that they rolled on it and then pretended oh we didn't know
00:31:54 how it was going to go over it you're literally your whole premise is about comparing your city
00:31:58 to female bodily autonomy you have to be prepared for the pushback that's going to well andrew you 1.00
00:32:02 You know, apparently it's the most press Regina has experienced since college.
00:32:09 There you go.
00:32:11 I don't even have anything on me.
00:32:12 You've successfully silenced me.
00:32:14 So well done there.
00:32:15 All right.
00:32:16 Then we go to the provincial category.
00:32:17 And this is your own former province here, Alberta.
00:32:21 It's sad.
00:32:22 It's sad that the province of Alberta is winning an award here, folks.
00:32:25 So the Alberta Foundation for the Arts, they spent $30,000 flying a Lethbridge artist.
00:32:32 you know where my family's from flying a lethbridge artist to places like south korea
00:32:36 and new york you know one of these artists paintings can best be described as uh ants
00:32:42 on a pop tart you know that's the name that i've given that painting uh but then also in south
00:32:46 korea she did like an eight minute video i guess of her flopping around on a futon uh you know
00:32:53 you know i got away the alberta government can save some money instead of paying this artist 30
00:32:58 grand to fly around the world they could have just set up a beach for the next time that i had
00:33:02 or set up a camera for the next time I head to the beach in Mexico.
00:33:05 Yeah.
00:33:06 And the one thing that annoys me here is that like,
00:33:08 these are the people that told us that you can do everything by zoom.
00:33:12 You can do everything remotely and everything virtually.
00:33:14 And we all, you know,
00:33:15 had our zoom meetings and everyone built video conferencing programs.
00:33:18 And then it's like, we need to fly, fly you around the world here.
00:33:22 We can't just upload a video on YouTube and, you know, run, you know,
00:33:25 20 bucks worth of YouTube ads for this.
00:33:27 No, but folks, like, I wish I had the video to play for you right now.
00:33:30 it's so crazy that this artist literally took off her flip-flops and then just spent about
00:33:37 eight minutes rolling around on a futon like that is the best way that I can describe it
00:33:41 and you know this whole grant system it ended up costing taxpayers $30,000 like you gotta see the
00:33:48 video the painting like I said best be described as ants on a pop tart but really it really just
00:33:54 boils down to the fact that like why are taxpayers paying for this artist to travel around the world
00:34:00 to produce art, I guess, uh, that no, that very few people would actually willing to pay, uh,
00:34:06 themselves. Yeah. And I'm also like wondering, yeah, I I'm with you. Like I can't even get onto
00:34:12 the artist train, let alone the flying around the world thing. It's like, you know, I guess
00:34:16 this is like, this is making Yoko Ono look like Da Vinci basically. It's, it's bad. And here I
00:34:23 gotta, speaking of bad, I gotta go now to the federal waste award. Let's see the lifetime
00:34:26 have achievement for the end because it's absolutely crazy but hey the federal waste
00:34:31 award winner this year of course CBC president Catherine Tate very well deserved right because
00:34:37 if you'll remember at the end of last year just weeks before Christmas Tate announced that the
00:34:42 state broadcaster was laying off hundreds of employees then Tate you know did the rounds
00:34:47 claiming that the CBC is chronically underfunded begging for more taxpayer cash more more more more
00:34:53 more. So did the CBC end the bonuses that they were handing out if they were laying off hundreds
00:34:58 of staff, if they were claiming the cupboards were bare? No, of course not. The CBC still handed out
00:35:04 $15 million in taxpayer-funded bonuses last year. All told, the CBC has been handing out $114 million
00:35:12 in those taxpayer-funded bonuses since 2015. So for handing out those bonuses, for claiming that
00:35:18 they're somehow underfunded, although they take like $1.4 billion a year from taxpayers,
00:35:24 CBC President Catherine Tate, a worthy, worthy recipient of the federal Teddy Waste Award.
00:35:30 But not as fun as the Lifetime Achievement Award.
00:35:34 Okay, so the Lifetime Achievement Award. Now, I'm going to preface this with folks,
00:35:38 this actually happened. This isn't me just coming up with jokes, okay?
00:35:42 I have verified this, by the way. He's not lying to you here.
00:35:45 the lifetime achievement award goes to the now killed mission cultural fund okay so we first
00:35:52 heard about heard about this fund when we heard that the prime minister flew a canadian chef to
00:35:58 india to cook indian food so that's when our uh taxpayer spidey senses started going off about
00:36:04 this mission cultural fund because you know the first thing that came to my mind is like well
00:36:09 how else are you supposed to get indian food in india you know what i mean yeah they just call it
00:36:14 food there you don't even need to work that hard for it but but here's some of the other things
00:36:18 or here's some of the things that the mission cultural fund was spending taxpayers money on
00:36:22 uh like a ten thousand dollar birthday party for margaret atwood in new york or a uh fifty two
00:36:29 thousand dollar photo exhibit for rock star brian adams so he could show off his totally awesome
00:36:34 photos like one of justin trudeau but now it gets really crazy okay folks because the mission
00:36:41 Cultural Fund, which was the federal slush fund, spent more than 8,000 bucks on a sex toy show
00:36:48 in Germany. Now, Andrew, maybe I'm a little old school, man, but if the Germans want to have a 0.99
00:36:54 sex toy show in Germany, they could pay for it themselves. You know, that's all I'm asking for 0.99
00:36:59 here. Or this one. And this is just a description from the government. They had a musical, I guess,
00:37:06 some type of play that highlighted, you know, these lesbians who are dressing up as male pirates 0.99
00:37:13 who found each other and fell in love. That was a musical paid for by the taxpayer. Yeah,
00:37:19 you might not have even known about that. Now, even after all of this crazy spending,
00:37:23 the Mission Cultural Fund, they hung on. They stuck with it until one thing finally put it
00:37:30 over the top. So what was the thing that finally killed the Mission Cultural Fund?
00:37:34 sex stories from senior citizens in other countries okay the fed spent 12 grand paying
00:37:41 senior citizens in other countries to talk about their sex lives in front of live audiences now
00:37:47 andrew these weren't even canadian seniors we were outsourcing old people sex stories
00:37:53 they should have just gotten up and talked about the city of regina
00:37:56 there you go we currently saved saved you know maybe 20 000 of that hey or why couldn't the
00:38:03 senior citizens just like go to the german sex toy show why did this need to be two line items
00:38:08 and it wasn't even a canadian jobs program these were these were these were seniors in other
00:38:13 countries oh hang on i'm trying so i just i want to understand this i i try to look through the
00:38:19 lens of the the government bureaucrats that are doing this so these were non-canadian citizens
00:38:25 talking about their sex lives in non-canadian countries like and i'm assuming it wasn't like
00:38:32 limited to that time i had sex in canada so i'm failing to see why the canadian government had
00:38:37 pardon the language skin in the game here
00:38:40 spreading canadian diplomacy abroad or something like that now folks now spreading something
00:38:48 i knew you're gonna say that uh so this thing folks they had these seniors in other countries
00:38:54 They had to talk about their first time, their last time, their best time.
00:39:00 12 grand.
00:39:01 You know what would have been a better use of 12 grand?
00:39:03 Paying those seniors to talk about literally anything else.
00:39:07 And maybe just do 10 grand.
00:39:09 You don't even need to do the full 12.
00:39:11 They're retired.
00:39:12 Let them just, oh gosh.
00:39:15 Canada.
00:39:17 Canada's back.
00:39:17 This was Justin Trudeau's promise when he was elected.
00:39:20 Canada's back.
00:39:21 Canada's backside.
00:39:23 Anyway.
00:39:23 All right.
00:39:24 well happy teddy season to you hope i mean you've killed the mission cultural fund so the award is
00:39:29 working yeah yeah i mean hopefully we can kill some more of this wasteful spending in ottawa and
00:39:35 across the rest of canada uh but you know folks um it's it's always a really fun time and it's
00:39:40 really to highlight the fact that like you are paying too much tax because these bureaucrats
00:39:45 are wasting so much of your money all right well uh keep up the good work there franco terrizano
00:39:50 from the Canadian Taxpayers Federation.
00:39:52 Always a pleasure, sir.
00:39:53 Hey, take care.
00:39:54 All right.
00:39:55 Oh boy, what a great, what a great story.
00:39:58 And by great, I mean like great for show value,
00:40:00 not for Canadian taxpayer value.
00:40:02 But all right, that will do it for us for today.
00:40:04 We will be back tomorrow
00:40:05 with more of Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:40:08 Same time, same place.
00:40:10 Thank you, God bless, and good day to you all.
00:40:12 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:40:15 Support the program by donating to True North
00:40:17 at www.tnc.news.
00:40:47 We'll be right back.
00:41:17 We'll be right back.