Juno News - January 08, 2026


Are Indigenous rights creating two-tier justice in Canada?

Topics
Mentioned
EXCLUSIVE: Poilievre sits down with Juno News to make the case for pipelines Carney UNDER FIRE as looming China trip raises security concerns

Episode Stats


Length

25 minutes

Words per minute

138.92

Word count

3,565

Sentence count

182

Harmful content

Hate speech

8

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

What if the house you bought, paid a mortgage on, and raised a family in was never really yours to begin with? A British Columbia court ruled this summer that land property owned for 150 years may never have been legally owned at all. And that s because the court accepted an indigenous oral history and 170-year-old journal entry as grounds to invalidate today s property titles. Now that s certainly curious because typically courts would reject evidence that can t be substantiated. In my latest episode of Disrupted, I speak with retired lawyer and author Peter Best about a ruling that could reshape Indigenous title law, property rights, and the very meaning of ownership in Canada.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 What if the house you bought paid a mortgage on and raised a family in was never really yours
00:00:06 to begin with? A British Columbia court ruled this summer that land property owned for, I don't know,
00:00:13 150 years or so may never have been legally owned at all. And that's because the BC court accepted
00:00:20 this indigenous oral history and 170 year old journal entry as grounds to invalidate today's
00:00:27 property titles. Now that's certainly curious because typically courts would reject evidence
00:00:32 that can't be substantiated and that's for very good reason. So in my latest episode of Disrupted,
00:00:38 I speak with retired lawyer and author Peter Best about a ruling that could reshape indigenous
00:00:44 title law, property rights and the very meaning of ownership in Canada. Now this ruling affects
00:00:51 or could potentially affect every Canadian who thinks that when you buy something you should
00:00:56 probably own it. So check out the link in the description to watch the full conversation now on
00:01:01 Juno News. Peter, thanks for joining me today. Thank you. Pleasure. I, well, no, it's the pleasure
00:01:11 is mine. I was reading your article in the C2C Journal about how Canada's courts promote indigenous
00:01:18 radicalism. And certainly on my show, I talk a lot about how different institutions are promoting
00:01:24 various forms of radicalism. So that really caught my attention. But especially you make the point that
00:01:30 reconciliation has become kind of like a one way street where the law, it seems to be giving way
00:01:39 every time there's conflict with different ideologies. And in this particular instance, we're talking about
00:01:45 land back ideology or the land back movement. And just to make that a bit clear for people, if we think
00:01:50 about the land acknowledgements that we were told to say all the time that are mandated within government
00:01:56 institutions, the idea behind that is we keep repeating that this land belongs to a certain
00:02:01 group of people, a certain ethnos, and it might have been unseated, for example. And the implication here
00:02:07 is that it was stolen and things that are stolen possibly need to be returned. And so that, I mean,
00:02:13 that's just a generalization here. But we're also seeing that the courts are accepting
00:02:19 this concept we call indigenous ways of knowing as a legal argument. So that's kind of what we're
00:02:24 talking about here a little bit. But maybe if we start from the basics of the case and what you wrote
00:02:29 about, could you walk us through a little bit of the history that grounds this case and why it matters?
00:02:37 Well, there's different cases that the Supreme Court of Canada has handed down that generally show,
00:02:43 in my opinion, a bias in favor of aboriginal peoples. Section 35 of the Constitution talks about
00:02:52 the rights of the aboriginal peoples of Canada are hereby recognized and preserved. So the court has
00:03:00 taken that, in my opinion, to adopt a stance that in all cases, in most cases, between the Crown,
00:03:09 between the people of Canada and an aboriginal group, the court, in my opinion, shows bias
00:03:17 in favor of the aboriginal peoples. It's basically on the basis that, as they've said in several cases,
00:03:25 they were the, in substance, victims of colonialism, that victims of imperialism,
00:03:33 and victims of residential schools. Each time the court makes these declarations,
00:03:40 they're not based on evidence that was adduced in the trial that they're dealing with in their
00:03:46 judgment. The conclusions they're drawing are based on newspaper articles, based on the Truth and
00:03:54 Reconciliation Report, based on statements made by aboriginal advocates. The court is taking, making
00:04:03 conclusions based on evidence, not evidence, because evidence means, uh, means, means testimony and
00:04:11 documents properly put before the court in a trial. And the court makes these historical, social, political
00:04:20 conclusions based not on evidence, but on, I suppose, their, uh, their personal dispositions and personal
00:04:28 beliefs. And that's where I'm saying that, uh, the courts have become radicalized and that they're making
00:04:35 judgments based on evidence not before them, rather based on the general sentiments that they have
00:04:43 based on what they absorb from politicians and from the media. Um, the Restoul case went to the Supreme
00:04:51 Court of Canada and the Supreme Court basically approved the conduct at trial, whereby the aboriginal
00:05:00 trial litigants who were suing the Crown and eventually got billions of dollars from the Crown, based on the
00:05:06 judge's decision. The, uh, the judge called it not a trial, which lawyers know what a trial is. It's, uh, it's a form of
00:05:18 civilized combat that is conducted pursuant to pre-set rules. The court called it not a trial, but a proceeding of
00:05:29 of reconciliation, which is radical, which is unprecedented for a judge to say, this is not
00:05:39 me presiding over the resolution of a dispute between two adverse parties. This, because there's
00:05:46 aboriginals involved, is a proceeding of reconciliation where niceness and good intentions are going to
00:05:55 govern rather than the cold hard law and rules of evidence. So in that case, the aboriginals were allowed 1.00
00:06:03 to, um, install a pole with feathers on it, a spirit pole or something in the well of the courtroom,
00:06:13 in front of the lawyers. That area is normally reserved for his majesty, the king and his judicial
00:06:22 magistrates. And it, it's an area of neutrality where the, where the king presides over a neutral, uh,
00:06:32 resolution of a dispute between citizens. Here, the court, uh, uh, uh, made it into a reconciliation
00:06:41 forum and the Supreme Court of Canada approved it. So in the court, uh, the Supreme Court is
00:06:50 telegraphing to all the judges. Apply different rules when, when there's an aboriginal issue before
00:06:59 you. And that is one of the main basis of why I say the courts are becoming radical, uh, not neutral,
00:07:09 and they're becoming seen to be biased because it's not whether they're actually biased. It's whether they're
00:07:17 giving off the appearance of bias. And that's what lessens social trust in the justice system. When people
00:07:24 feel, uh, you know, the, uh, the playing field is uneven from the get go. That's what the court is doing.
00:07:32 Yeah. There's a few things that you mentioned in there. Maybe we can dig into a few of them. You talked a
00:07:36 little bit about the, uh, what, what I'm calling the indigenous ways of knowing, which is, I guess,
00:07:40 the technical, uh, term for a lot of, of these things being introduced into the courts. And you
00:07:44 talked a little bit about, um, the, the fair, the fair application or equal application of the law. And
00:07:50 those are two things I'm kind of interested in. But if, if I dig into here a little bit, one of the,
00:07:54 the indigenous ways of knowing is this oral history telling, which, um, a lot of indigenous, uh,
00:07:59 cultures didn't have a written language. And so they, they rely on oral history, but when oral history is
00:08:04 allowed to be, uh, in used as evidence, essentially the argument that you make is that's basically
00:08:10 hearsay. And we don't use hearsay within, um, the, the, I guess, traditional liberal court system
00:08:16 that is supposed to treat everyone fairly, uh, as part of rule of law because it's unreliable evidence.
00:08:22 But this is sort of what's happening in this case. What do you think about that?
00:08:25 Yes. Uh, the oral hearsay exception for aboriginals arose in about
00:08:33 1997 when a Supreme Court of Canada justice says, well, if you don't let them give hearsay evidence
00:08:42 because they were, they were all preliterate cultures, none of the indigenous tribes of Canada
00:08:50 had written languages. And the judge came to his conclusion already being suffused with bias in
00:09:00 favor of the aboriginal side. He seems to have wanted them to be able to win their cases. So he invented 0.99
00:09:11 a new rule of evidence whereby only they only aboriginals were allowed to, um, to offer as proof of their cases
00:09:24 what their ancestors told their grandparents, who in turn told their children, who in turn told the
00:09:31 witness in the stand. Classic hearsay, which for 400 or 500 years, you know, has never been allowed
00:09:40 because of its inherent obvious unreliability. Uh, uh, uh, the idea behind the hearsay rule is
00:09:48 you can't testify what someone told you unless the person who told you that is going to be in court to
00:09:55 be cross-examined. So they created this exception and the judge said, well, how else can they prove their
00:10:05 case unless we make a new rule so they can prove their cases easier? Whereas the rest of us who have to go to
00:10:12 court, we have to prove our case with acceptable traditional evidence. And if we can't, too bad, you
00:10:21 lose. And we all have to face the fact that we want to have justice, but if we don't have traditional
00:10:30 evidence that's acceptable, we can't have justice in the court. So, um, and, uh, the principle underlying
00:10:41 the manufacture of the hearsay exception for indigenous cases, it, it's just the sentiment of
00:10:49 the court to give them a better opportunity to prove their cases. But it's just, it is discriminatory
00:10:57 because none of the other races or ethnic groups in Canada have that benefit. Why should they have it? 1.00
00:11:05 They say they should have it because they've been historically treated unjustly, which is a political,
00:11:14 uh, conclusion drawn from out of court evidence, not expert evidence, just stuff they take from the
00:11:22 media air and apply in court cases. It results in the uneven application of the law and the loss of
00:11:32 trust and faith in courts by non-Aboriginal litigants who have to go against Aboriginals where they get the 1.00
00:11:40 benefit of this rule, which is, is exploited and, uh, dealt with in bad faith all the time. Why not? I mean,
00:11:50 why wouldn't you take advantage and make up evidence and say someone told you something if
00:11:57 the payoff is millions of dollars in judgments or the acquisition of unprecedented new rights for your
00:12:05 particular race? So it's a bad rule that creates animosity. Yeah. Yeah. But even, even if everyone was honest all the time,
00:12:16 uh, and let's be, uh, uh, let's be generous. Let's say everybody's honest all the time and nobody lies.
00:12:24 What the danger here is also that we end up with multiple different types of legal systems that apply
00:12:29 to different cultures. We have this term, uh, that I come across all the time, culturally appropriate,
00:12:34 right? We, or culturally safe. Um, and so the implication here is that different cultures have different needs.
00:12:39 And if you apply that to the legal system, in this case, we're doing this with indigenous groups,
00:12:43 they have their own particular need for the courts to apply or to adapt their particular culture.
00:12:49 And therefore now we have a different legal system or a different legal process for them.
00:12:53 Well, what's stopping, you know, all preferred client groups getting their own, uh, particular
00:12:59 legal adaptations. Uh, but that, I mean, that, that's a whole thing we could talk about for, for hours.
00:13:04 You also mentioned, uh, something, uh, reconciliation proceedings, this idea, it's not a trial, it's
00:13:10 reconciliation proceedings. And, but that does that imply then that we don't, we don't really, again,
00:13:17 it's sort of on the same top. We don't really have a rule of law here. We have, um, legal proceedings
00:13:23 specifically adapted for this reconciliation, uh, truth and reconciliation process.
00:13:27 Yes. And reconciliation, it started off defined by the Supreme court as a way of meshing aboriginal
00:13:38 rights and crown colonial rights in a way that each, each of the sets of rights is, uh, interfered with
00:13:49 as least as possible. It applied to a specific fact-based legal situation, reconciliation.
00:13:57 The Supreme court has forgotten the legal precise nature of reconciliation. And they're now using
00:14:07 the term in the sense of reconciliation being a social political movement to
00:14:16 increase the nation to nation relationship between the supposed
00:14:22 relationship between the crown and 625 different Indian bands or first nations, as they call them. So,
00:14:31 uh, the court has lost sight of what reconciliation is. And the court, in my view, has taken on the role
00:14:40 of the legislature, has crossed over into activism to, to bring about some undefined political
00:14:51 and social goal of reconciliation. Of course, nobody ever defines what reconciliation is. It's usually a term
00:15:02 used by Aboriginal interests to gain an advantage, to cause the crown or the non-Aborigines of Canada 0.84
00:15:12 to give up something and give it to them. The other phrase that is used with reconciliation is the honor of the crown.
00:15:22 And it used to mean the crown must act honorably when they're carrying out treaty obligations or other
00:15:30 obligations owed to Aboriginal peoples. It's specific to an existing treaty or Aboriginal right that is being enforced.
00:15:40 It now means, honor of the crown now means whenever there's, whenever there's a dispute,
00:15:46 the crown, the crown, the people of Canada are not allowed to fight hard for their side of the dispute.
00:15:54 They have to throw in the towel because it would be not honorable to fight Aboriginal claims, even when 1.00
00:16:02 the claims have no basis in history or a weak basis in history. A weak basis in law are novel claims claiming new,
00:16:11 you know, new rights that are going to cost millions and millions of dollars to finance if they're granted.
00:16:23 So the argument is, oh, it's a guilt trip word, honor of the crown. Reconciliation is a guilt trip word,
00:16:31 where non-Aboriginals against whom claims are being made are guilted into acceding to the claims
00:16:38 because not to do so would be dishonorable or would would be not promoting reconciliation. Of course,
00:16:47 they've completely abandoned the meaning of reconciliation that the Supreme Court set out
00:16:52 10 years or so ago that was fact specific. And the honor of the crown now can mean almost
00:16:58 anything an Aboriginal claimant says it means. It just means be nice and keep your pocketbook open for
00:17:05 us. That's what honor of the crown is coming to mean. Don't ever say no to us.
00:17:11 Yeah. Many Canadians seem to really be paying attention to this particular issue because they're
00:17:15 worried that this could apply to their own property. So if the property that I bought in good faith,
00:17:22 thinking that it was mine, as soon as I paid off my mortgage, etc. If, you know, if the courts turn
00:17:28 around and say, well, actually, that wasn't yours this entire time. And we've just decided it's going to
00:17:32 go to this particular band or that particular band or that particular nation, right? That's a real worry
00:17:37 for a lot of Canadians. And do you think there's a legally coherent alternative to this? And what can
00:17:43 Canadians do if they want to possibly look into this a little bit more or even challenge it?
00:17:50 Well, in my opinion, the only solution to this, to stopping these endless claims against the
00:17:58 Canadian taxpayer, endless claims against the citizens of Canada, who, in my book, there is no
00:18:05 difference, I argue, relatively speaking in history, the Great Britain treated the Aboriginal peoples of
00:18:12 Canada relatively decently, relatively honorably. There's no slaughters, there's no genocides,
00:18:20 tried to educate them in residential schools. And I've read a lot about these things, and the people
00:18:29 our ancestors were honorable and decent and tried their best. And so don't think that we have any
00:18:40 reason to feel guilty. If you look at the expanse of history and see how conquered peoples throughout
00:18:46 history were treated, they were murdered, raped and despoiled. And none of that happened in Canada. And the
00:18:56 kind of terminology being used for my ancestors and yours, maybe, is disgraceful by our leaders. And
00:19:06 uh, they should be defending the decency with which our ancestors treated Aboriginal peoples. Nothing's 0.99
00:19:16 perfect in history. Some people say every page of history is blood soap. Well, not every page of Canadian
00:19:22 history is. Relatively speaking, we have a lot to be proud of in Canada. And uh, and the honor of the crown
00:19:31 has been more than fulfilled by present-day Canadians and our ancestors. And uh, I wrote my book and I wrote the
00:19:43 article to point out to the courts, stop sacrificing present Canadians on the altar of false and unjustified
00:19:55 guilt. And stop making court decisions based on, on uh, faulty historical reasoning about colonialism and
00:20:06 imperialism and cruelty towards Aboriginal people. Open your eyes, read real history books and see what
00:20:12 real cruelty is. We've, we've been really decent as Canadians over the last 150 years.
00:20:21 Yeah. Yeah. I, I think you're expressing a lot of the things that, um, I'm very concerned about is that
00:20:27 many of these ideas that may have started from a place of, uh, genuine, genuinely wanting to, to do well,
00:20:34 uh, turns into maybe or creates maybe a sense of tribalism that wasn't there before. It was less
00:20:41 pronounced. And I'm concerned that continuing doing this might move that, uh, might create more of that
00:20:47 in the long run. For example, if we don't have any guardrails and we have special treatment for certain
00:20:52 ethnic groups in the law, uh, how do we know that more and more land is not, is not going to be, uh, given to
00:21:00 indigenous tribes and maybe people live on that land and maybe they might, they might be dispossessed.
00:21:04 There's certainly, I don't, you know, there are certainly individuals out there, uh, radicals out
00:21:09 there who would like to see that happen. And, and how do we prevent those things from happening? And,
00:21:12 and I think people's trust in the system is maybe diminishing day by day. Uh, but I, I really appreciate
00:21:18 you joining the show, Peter today. And I, everyone should go read, uh, read his article. There'll be a link
00:21:23 in the description, but, um, yeah, thank you. Thank you so much for joining me today.
00:21:27 Just one more comment. The solution is amend the constitution to repeal section 35.
00:21:36 That is the source of a racial division that is increasingly happening because can you just,
00:21:43 can you just say what is section 35? Just so social people know it's the provision that was put
00:21:48 in the constitution in 1982 that says that the rights of the Aboriginal peoples of Canada are hereby
00:21:56 recognized and preserved. And based on that section, the Supreme Court of Canada has declared
00:22:04 Aboriginal title, which has taken ownership of properties in Richmond, BC from the true owners
00:22:14 and handed them to an indigenous band on Vancouver Island. So what you mentioned has already happened.
00:22:21 People have been deprived by a trial court of ownership of their property of their homes and businesses.
00:22:32 There are claims for similar Aboriginal title over all of British Columbia and over most of New Brunswick
00:22:40 and other parts of Canada where there was no treaty. So all of this, all these claims, all this racial division
00:22:48 and dissension has originated from the way the Supreme Court of Canada has interpreted section 35 of the constitution.
00:22:57 So, um, it's become a section of the constitution that is creating racial tension, racial division,
00:23:07 and is harming the economy of Canada greatly. So my, I've given up on reforming section 35 because
00:23:20 the Aboriginal demands are relentless and they're getting, you know, their appetite grows with their feeding, 1.00
00:23:28 and they've been so successful that they want to feed more against the interests of all Canadians.
00:23:36 So, yeah, well, that appeals to me. Repeal, repeal, repeal is what I, what I like to hear. I think we need to
00:23:42 have a lot more appealing of a lot of things going on in Canada to set the record straight.
00:23:47 Well, it would be like, like Lincoln amending the American constitution to reduce slavery. It would be like
00:23:55 the constitution being amended to give the vote to women. Sometimes constitutions need to be amended
00:24:03 to bring about a reforming purpose. And this section and the way the courts have determined it has
00:24:12 created racial tension and racial ill will vastly greater than anything I've ever seen in my life.
00:24:20 And so reconciliation is not happening. Rather, whatever the opposite of reconciliation is,
00:24:26 that's what section 35 is causing. And it needs to be repealed.
00:24:32 Well, that's all the time we have for today. Thank you so much for joining me, Peter. And like I said,
00:24:38 everybody should go read the article. Thank you. It's really difficult not to view this situation
00:24:42 cynically at this point. You really have to ask yourself if we can rely on a rule of law that
00:24:48 predictably applies the rules equally, as in equally to each individual, rather than equitably, which is
00:24:55 treating different client groups differently on the basis of their cultures to somehow create some
00:25:01 form of equality, or if the courts are becoming a vehicle for preferred ideologies under the hammer of
00:25:08 activist judges, regardless of the consequences on everyone else. And if what you believed was your
00:25:15 legitimate property may only remain your property at the pleasure of the courts, perhaps this may be just the
00:25:22 thing that ignites a fire among the silent majority. For True North, I'm Melanie Bennett.