Juno News - October 19, 2019


Are we going to see a Liberal-NDP Coalition?

Mentioned
Barack Obama endorses Justin Trudeau Toronto Public Library’s stand for free speech

Episode Stats


Length

4 minutes

Words per minute

176.2

Word count

768

Sentence count

43


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In the final stretch of the federal election campaign, there's a growing number of voices in the media and political circles saying that if Andrew Scheer wins a majority government, then Jagmeet Singh should try to form a coalition with Justin Trudeau to block him from becoming Prime Minister. Is that even possible?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 We're at this interesting point in the last leg of the federal election campaign when it looks
00:00:13 like pretty much any result could happen. Well, not quite. In fact, a lot of people are ruling
00:00:18 out majorities. The numbers do not suggest that anybody will get a majority government,
00:00:23 not Justin Trudeau, not Andrew Scheer. So it looks like we're in a situation where we'll
00:00:27 have a liberal minority, in which Justin Trudeau remains prime minister, and a conservative
00:00:31 minority, in which Justin Trudeau remains prime minister. No, I didn't misspeak. Yeah, that's
00:00:38 actually what we're hearing right now from a whole lot of voices, particularly some of the people at
00:00:43 the top. NDP leader Jagmeet Singh musing, although he's since walked back, the idea that if Andrew
00:00:48 Scheer wins the most number of seats under the conservative banner, then Jagmeet Singh will form
00:00:54 a coalition with Justin Trudeau to block that from happening, to thwart Andrew Scheer from
00:01:00 becoming prime minister. Can you do that? Is that legal? Is that even a thing? Now, we have this
00:01:06 sort of thing happen a lot. We have a lot of majority governments, but we do have parties like
00:01:12 the NDP prop up minority governments. We saw it happen with Paul Martin recently. We saw it happen
00:01:18 for a couple terms with Stephen Harper, where they don't have enough to have a majority, so they get
00:01:22 support from another party, like the NDP, to pass their main confidence motions, their throne speech,
00:01:28 their budget bills, and so forth. But what we don't have is a case where you go and you use a
00:01:35 coalition to thwart the person who did get the most seats from forming power. Those examples I just gave,
00:01:43 the Paul Martin case, the Stephen Harper case, they did win the most number of seats. They won a plurality.
00:01:48 They just didn't get a majority. In fact, the situation that Jagmeet Singh is proposing,
00:01:53 it's only been done once before, about 100 years ago. In most cases in the past century,
00:02:01 well, every case except that one example, when there has been a situation where there's a prime
00:02:06 minister in office, and then there's an election, and that prime minister finds that they no longer
00:02:12 have the most seats, that somebody else has more seats than them, they resign. That's what Paul
00:02:19 Martin did back when he lost to Stephen Harper. That's what Pierre Elliott Trudeau did when he
00:02:24 lost to Joe Clark. Now, I'm already hearing a lot of chatter out there where people say, no, no,
00:02:29 it's perfectly fine for Justin Trudeau to remain as prime minister, even if he only gets the second
00:02:35 most number of seats, because the rules actually say that in that case, the prime minister has the
00:02:41 ability to go to the governor general and say, oh, hold on, I still got this. I can still command
00:02:45 the confidence of the House. I can still have a majority because, hey, I got my friend Jagmeet Singh
00:02:50 with me, and he's going to vote for it. Now, that is true. Academics, experts, they'll say, yes, that is
00:02:56 the way the system can work. But here's the thing. It's not the way the system has worked, and it's not
00:03:03 the way most Canadians think the system works. So what does that mean? Does that just mean that people have
00:03:09 been misinformed, that they haven't been spending enough time in civics class dusting off the rule
00:03:14 books and learning about the nuances of it? No. It's a little thing called tradition. It's a little
00:03:20 thing called, this is how we've agreed we're going to do things for the past century. So it's very
00:03:26 troubling right now to hear Justin Trudeau, who back in 2015 told Peter Mansbridge, the party that gets
00:03:33 the most amount of seats, gets to govern. Is your belief that whatever party has the most number
00:03:39 of seats has the right to try to govern at that point? Yes, that's the way it's always been. Whoever
00:03:49 commands the most seats gets the first shot at governing. That's not always the way it's been.
00:03:56 It's troubling to hear that this same individual, I mean, we're hearing it from Jagmeet Singh,
00:04:01 we're not hearing it from Justin Trudeau, but we're hearing it from that, from the circle,
00:04:06 the media circle, various people in political circles saying, oh no, it's perfectly fine if this
00:04:11 happens. Look, just because something can be done, just because you're allowed to do it,
00:04:17 just because it's legal, doesn't mean you should. It doesn't mean it's right.