Juno News - February 12, 2024


Auditor General blasts ArriveCan waste and mismanagement

Topics
Mentioned
Energy CEO reacts to NDP bill to jail oil and gas advocates Here’s how the legacy media is misleading you

Episode Stats


Length

49 minutes

Words per minute

171.36

Word count

8,429

Sentence count

313

Harmful content

Misogyny

7

sentences flagged

Toxicity

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

7

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

The day after the Super Bowl, Andrew Lawton talks about Taylor Mahomes and Lady Gaga's incredible halftime performance in Japan, the proposed ban on American Super Bowl ads in Canada, and the burning of a Catholic church in Canada.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:20 north hello and welcome to you all this is canada's most irreverent talk show monday february 12 2024
00:01:32 the andrew lawton show here on true north the day after the super bowl i know you all know i am a
00:01:39 huge sports fan i i watched the uh kansas city 89ers square off against the san francisco chiefs
00:01:46 It was an absolute bang-up game.
00:01:50 There was a guy named Patrick who was involved.
00:01:53 Travis Swift also did a tremendous job as the tight end, I want to say.
00:02:00 There's a spider crawling up my camera right now.
00:02:03 So if you saw a nondescript blur, that was why.
00:02:07 But anyway, I thought Taylor Mahomes stole the show.
00:02:11 And I loved her concert in Tokyo, by the way.
00:02:14 I didn't get a chance to see it, but I saw some clips going on.
00:02:16 No, no, no.
00:02:17 Before you all tune out, sometimes the sports fans get really mad when I do this.
00:02:21 I do know what the Super Bowl is.
00:02:25 It isn't just the haircut that I had when I was a kid.
00:02:28 I even watched the Super Bowl.
00:02:30 And not just for the halftime show.
00:02:32 I watched it, watched it.
00:02:33 Because football is, by virtue of me having played it in high school,
00:02:37 the only sport that I can understand and explain.
00:02:39 And next to my wife.
00:02:40 Because I know like this much, she knows this much.
00:02:43 So it's like the only sport where I get to explain it to someone else and then, you know, just, you know, quickly, discreetly Google if she asks a question I don't know about.
00:02:51 But nevertheless, I hope that all the teams had fun. Isn't that what you say? I hope that all the teams enjoyed themselves.
00:02:58 It was it was a good game. It was a bit of a nail biter.
00:03:01 My little political interjection on this, and I tweeted this yesterday, is that basically we need to see a conservative party or any party that is poised to take over for the liberals,
00:03:12 which right now is only the Conservatives, run on the most populist policy imaginable,
00:03:18 which would be a policy saying that the CRTC is banning its requirement of SIM subbing. Do you
00:03:26 know what SIM subbing is? It is when the Canadian outlets, news like outlets like CTV, have to sub
00:03:33 in their crappy Canadian feeds when you're trying to watch CBS. So you don't get to watch the
00:03:39 American Super Bowl ads, you have to watch, you know, some like weird Southern Ontario technical
00:03:43 colleges commercial instead of some star-studded American Super Bowl ad. So that would be like a
00:03:49 sports policy I could get behind. Let Canadians watch the American Super Bowl ads. Although I
00:03:55 shared this and one response just said, or how about we just abolish the CRTC altogether, which
00:04:00 is also an acceptable populist policy that a party may wish to run on. So perhaps that can be the one
00:04:07 area of overlap between me and the sports fans, which is ending the ban on seeing American football
00:04:12 ads. Nevertheless, hope you had a wonderful weekend. Not as good for the Liberal government
00:04:18 right now. We'll get in a few moments time to the Auditor General's report. She has come out with
00:04:25 what I would call a scathing indictment of the Liberal government's handling of this file. It's
00:04:31 boondoggle that's even more expensive than we had previously understood and that is insofar as she 0.97
00:04:37 was able to figure it out because it was so mismanaged and the records were so poorly kept
00:04:42 the auditor general doesn't even know exactly how much was spent on the arrive can app but i
00:04:48 wanted to begin by talking about this horrendous display that took place over the weekend i'll
00:04:53 share a clip of it this was a an attempted arson i mean successful in the sense that there was
00:04:59 actually vandalism, but an attempted arson against a Catholic church in Regina, Saskatchewan.
00:05:29 that was horrendous and i apologize about the profanity there we
00:05:58 usually try to censor that out for the nice virgin ears that I know tune into this show. But 0.97
00:06:03 in this particular context, we made an exception because I think it's important to see how vile
00:06:08 these people are as they sit there callously and try to burn down a Catholic church. Now,
00:06:15 church burnings in Canada are not anomalous. There have been dozens of graffitis, attempted arsons,
00:06:21 in many cases, successful arsons that have taken place, all going back with alarming frequency to
00:06:28 the announcement of unmarked graves at Kamloops, which triggered a process by which people take
00:06:35 out their anger on Christianity against churches that have had nothing to do with anything
00:06:41 to do with anything. And that is worded deliberately in that way because this is
00:06:46 inexplicable and absolutely tragic. Now, you'd think that we could all as a society get around
00:06:52 and say, okay, I oppose burning churches. I oppose burning mosques. I oppose burning synagogues. I 0.87
00:06:57 oppose vandalizing these institutions. And yet there is radio silence from many people in media
00:07:04 and the political establishment when it is a Christian church that is targeted. Now take for
00:07:09 example that church in Regina. There has been a comment condemning it from conservative leader
00:07:14 Pierre Polyev. I checked just a moment ago, absolutely no response whatsoever from Prime
00:07:20 Minister Justin Trudeau. And you may think, okay, well he can't respond to just anything and
00:07:24 everything that happens. Well, whenever something has happened to do with a mosque or many cases a 0.99
00:07:29 synagogue, Justin Trudeau cannot denounce it quickly enough. This was one such denunciation 1.00
00:07:35 when there were threats against a mosque. I want to start this morning by addressing the
00:07:41 unacceptable threats that were sent to a Toronto mosque over the weekend. Islamophobia and right 0.99
00:07:47 wing extremism have no place in our country or our communities. We must always stand united
00:07:54 against hate or intolerance of any kind. No issue whatsoever with that statement. There was a threat
00:08:02 it was reported on in the news. Justin Trudeau says absolutely we denounced this 20 seconds that
00:08:07 was all it took. There was also a case a few years ago you may recall when a young school girl in
00:08:12 Toronto, a hijab wearing Muslim claimed that she was targeted because of her Muslim faith by
00:08:19 someone. And this was a case that was very quickly questioned by a lot of people. There were a lot
00:08:26 of things that did not add up about this, but that didn't start, that didn't stop the unsubstantiated
00:08:31 allegation from making waves around the country. And again, warranting a denunciation from Justin
00:08:36 Trudeau. My heart goes out to the young girl who was attacked seemingly for her religion.
00:08:44 I can't imagine how afraid she must have been. Is there a danger in responding so quickly and
00:08:50 seizing upon these events as the symbols of our tolerance? Unfortunately, we've seen a pattern
00:08:56 over the past months of increased hate crimes against religious minorities, particularly
00:09:04 particularly against young women of racialized backgrounds.
00:09:13 This is something that we need to take very, very, very seriously.
00:09:17 And the pattern and the trend lines that we're seeing is something that,
00:09:22 as you pointed out, is one of those warning signs around increased intolerance
00:09:27 and reminding people that we are a country that defends freedom of religion,
00:09:33 that defends freedom of expression, that defends people's rights to go to school and not be
00:09:40 fearful or harassed is fundamental to who we are.
00:09:45 The second part of that quote was after Toronto police had come out and said,
00:09:50 yeah, this didn't really happen. There's no evidence of this. In fact, there was evidence
00:09:54 suggesting it was untrue. But he does the old Dan Rather fake but accurate thing there where he says,
00:10:00 Oh, well, yes, but there, I mean, it could have been true.
00:10:03 All of these other things have happened.
00:10:05 There's been an alarming, and we always stand up for this.
00:10:07 But again, why are you silent when a church is burned?
00:10:11 Now, there is a subset of people in this country, delusional radicals,
00:10:16 like the burn-it-all-down lady, that are celebrating the burning down of churches.
00:10:22 I think Jerry Butts had made, if I'm recalling correctly,
00:10:25 a comment seemingly justifying the burning of churches.
00:10:29 I have to look up the exact wording of it, but it was something that I recall being really,
00:10:35 really icky and going down that road of justifying or coming close to it.
00:10:39 And when I point that out, this is not a contest.
00:10:43 I'm not saying that Justin Trudeau should not condemn acts of violence or threats or
00:10:48 graffiti and vandalism against Muslims, against Jews.
00:10:51 Absolutely not. 0.98
00:10:51 I'm saying why on earth not do it when it's against Christians? 1.00
00:10:55 Now, he proclaims to be a Catholic.
00:10:57 He proclaims to be a Christian.
00:10:59 Apart from the Harsha Walia burn it all down, folks, most people in this country, I think, 1.00
00:11:03 could generally agree, I would hope, that we shouldn't target religious institutions in
00:11:08 general in this way. Now, you know, maybe I could be proven wrong on that point. I shudder to think
00:11:14 that perhaps I would be. But it is incredibly, incredibly disgusting that we have a political
00:11:22 class that is so either anti-Christian or so desiring of appeasing the people who are 0.99
00:11:29 anti-Christian that they won't stand up and say that 20-second condemnation, this should never
00:11:35 happen. Absolutely absurd. One of the other things that is absurd, to attempt a segue there,
00:11:41 a smooth transition, is the report from the Auditor General this morning. She was appearing
00:11:47 before the Public Accounts Committee. She'll be holding, actually I believe right now she's holding
00:11:51 a press conference. But if you chose me over the Auditor General, I thank you so much. Not that
00:11:56 she's not a lovely lady, I'm sure, but I like to think we offer a little bit more excitement on
00:12:01 this show than an accountant speaking. But nevertheless, don't answer that if you disagree.
00:12:06 This was the finding here, and there were a lot of them, but I'm going to play a couple of clips
00:12:10 from her appearance before the committee that I think capture and encapsulate what it is that
00:12:17 she found when she tried to dig in deep with ArriveCAN. This is her getting a very simple
00:12:23 and point-blank question from Conservative MP Michael Barrett about whether it was worth the cost.
00:12:28 Auditor, thank you very much for being here today. Did Canadian taxpayers get value for money from
00:12:34 Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's government on the $60 million ArriveCAN app?
00:12:39 So we concluded that the public service did not ensure that Canada received best value for money.
00:12:46 I would tell you that we paid too much for this application.
00:12:51 We paid too much.
00:12:53 Now, anyone who saw the price tag when this came up a while back,
00:12:56 that it could have been done for $80,000 and ended up costing tens of millions,
00:12:59 probably could have figured that out.
00:13:00 But it's good to have, from a nonpartisan figure, the official finding of such.
00:13:05 And this was, I think, a point that was important to stress in relation to that,
00:13:09 because there were also scathing indictments of mismanagement,
00:13:12 of records not being kept not even the basic fundamental level of due diligence
00:13:17 and the government's excuse here oh it's just covid everyone was working from home it was
00:13:21 difficult line wires got crossed so conservative mp kelly block tried to probe that point with
00:13:27 the auditor general karen hogan oh time and time again we have heard that we should cut the public
00:13:34 service or servants some slack because it was during the pandemic and we even heard it today
00:13:41 in in regards to public servants working from home. Do you believe the glaring disregard for
00:13:48 basic mismanagement and contracting practices as well as the lack of documentation can be
00:13:55 sufficiently excused by the fact that it was during a pandemic?
00:14:02 I know I said it in my opening remarks I do not believe that an emergency
00:14:07 is an excuse for throwing out the rules throwing the rules out of the window these are some really
00:14:14 basic elements that i would have expected to see documenting a decision on who is being selected
00:14:21 and why why they have the skills to carry out the work that you need done basic bookkeeping
00:14:29 factors that i would expect to see invoices well supported making it clear
00:14:34 what work should be charged to what project that's ongoing.
00:14:39 I think that my advice to public servants would be to document as you go.
00:14:43 And we saw other contracts throughout the pandemic,
00:14:47 while had opportunities for improvement,
00:14:49 were not as glaring as the lack of documentation that we see.
00:14:55 Thank you.
00:14:56 So the crucial part of this is that public servants
00:14:59 were not trying to get value for money.
00:15:01 They weren't making an effort of adequately tracking how much was being spent.
00:15:06 They didn't do their due diligence.
00:15:08 They didn't do basic management.
00:15:09 And it's not enough just to blame it all on COVID.
00:15:12 And this is what the government has tried to do.
00:15:14 And you could even see in the liberal questions that were being put to Karen Hogan this morning
00:15:19 on committee, they were trying to just pass the buck anywhere and everywhere, but on the
00:15:23 government.
00:15:23 So at a certain point, CBSA is going to be made out to be the fall guy and some lowly
00:15:28 bureaucrats going to be made to be the fall guy. 1.00
00:15:30 But it really is the government that has to own this.
00:15:31 because the bureaucrats were implementing a government program, this unnecessary app,
00:15:37 which we're just talking about the mismanagement of it, not even the fundamental question
00:15:41 of whether this app was just and constitutional and violated or violated people's civil liberties,
00:15:48 which I suspect it did, but that wasn't part of what the Auditor General was delving into.
00:15:53 But the real takeaway here, even with the benefit of hindsight, she could not adequately figure out
00:16:00 the cost of this thing. She could not adequately figure out how much Canadians spent on this. She
00:16:07 did her best, came up with a figure of around $60 million, way more than the $54 million that was
00:16:13 initially said, and way more than the $80,000 it was supposed to be. But she's had to do some
00:16:20 guesswork because of how shoddy the records are. Aaron Woodrick is the head of the domestic policy
00:16:26 program over at the McDonald Laurier Institute and joins me on the line now. Aaron, always good
00:16:32 to talk to you here. I mean, at a certain point, you have to wonder, did any of this go the way
00:16:37 it was supposed to? And it really doesn't seem like it. No, it doesn't. I mean, it's not every
00:16:42 day that you have the Auditor General coming out and saying, you know, I can't even tell you how
00:16:45 much this costs. There's so little of a paper trail. And I think her comments are just damning.
00:16:51 Look, it is possibly true that during a pandemic and, you know, people were panicking.
00:16:56 Remember, this is early 2020.
00:16:58 People are in a real hurry.
00:16:59 OK, so maybe everything isn't exactly by the book.
00:17:02 But her point is, in some cases, there's not even the most basic notation, aren't even basic invoices.
00:17:08 This is not just a matter of, you know, rushing through the process because you think that the sky is going to fall.
00:17:14 They just completely gave up on some of the most basic safeguards.
00:17:17 And the result is, you know, tens of millions of dollars wasted for taxpayers.
00:17:22 And again, you know, this is just one aspect of spending during the pandemic.
00:17:26 This is just an example of the lack of safeguards in place.
00:17:31 And, you know, Canadians have just paid an eye-watering sum for basically nothing.
00:17:37 Yeah, and I mean, obviously, she was focused just on a rive can here.
00:17:40 But I have to assume, and you would know this better than I would, given your work,
00:17:45 but I have to assume that there is underneath this revealing, I think, a bigger problem with
00:17:51 procurement in Canada because something like jumps out here and says that this to me is not
00:17:57 an aberration. This is probably business as usual. The fact that there's an entire company set up
00:18:02 that doesn't produce anything that just cashes a huge fat check and then finds other people to do
00:18:07 the work strikes me as evidence that this is pretty much business as usual in Ottawa.
00:18:12 Yeah, it's a serious problem.
00:18:14 And there's a bunch of layers, I would say, with respect to procurement that are the problem.
00:18:17 I mean, you do have this sort of basic ignorance of the rules.
00:18:21 You have people issuing, you know, sole source contracts when they should be open to competitive bids.
00:18:26 You also have in a lot of areas, you know, very sort of strange political layers to rather than getting sort of the best bang for your buck.
00:18:34 And I'm thinking particularly for military procurement.
00:18:37 You have government trying to fiddle with making sure that, well, they got to be made in Canada.
00:18:40 They have to create a certain number of jobs in this region.
00:18:43 And anyone who's followed, for example, our disastrous shipbuilding program, I mean, if you think wasting $50 million on a phone app is bad, wait till you hear about the tens of billions of dollars that we're getting for not receiving ships yet.
00:18:58 I mean, these are just eye-watering sums of money.
00:19:01 And procurement in this country is badly, badly broken.
00:19:04 There needs to be a real top-to-bottom rethink about how we can ensure this process is fair, it's competitive.
00:19:10 and it is immune from political interference.
00:19:14 Yeah, and I think that is where we get to the point here
00:19:18 of whether this was a bureaucracy run amok
00:19:21 or is this something that is laid at Justin Trudeau's feet.
00:19:25 Now, there's an argument that Justin Trudeau has to own
00:19:27 what the bureaucracy does when they're implementing his strategies,
00:19:30 but what's your read on that from what's come out so far?
00:19:33 Well, they certainly, as you mentioned,
00:19:36 they're trying to barge pull away from this. 0.58
00:19:38 And I mean, part of that is just basic politics.
00:19:39 This is a government that's in very deep trouble in the polls, so they're not obviously looking to take ownership of any more problems, but there's no getting around it.
00:19:47 I mean, you are responsible at the political level for the mistakes of the department underneath you.
00:19:51 And that's one of the questions that I have here.
00:19:53 The money's already gone, and that's unfortunate, but will there be any consequences?
00:19:57 Is anybody going to get fired?
00:19:58 Is anybody going to get reprimanded?
00:20:00 Is any minister going to resign for this?
00:20:02 I do think is something that's extremely frustrating for a lot of Canadians right now is that even when you make mistakes, it used to be just assume that someone would take responsibility.
00:20:11 There would be some consequence to failure or stealing or mismanagement.
00:20:16 We don't have that anymore.
00:20:17 We have, you know, the best you're going to get is a minister go out solemnly before the cameras and say, you know, I take full responsibility and then they won't do anything.
00:20:26 They'll just say those words.
00:20:27 And they sort of, that's almost worse doing it that way, Andrew, because it deprives them of any meaning.
00:20:32 What is the point in saying you take responsibility if there's just no consequence other than having to say the words?
00:20:37 Yeah, and I don't want to compare apples to oranges here because there was a lot going on with ad scam back in the day that I have not seen evidence of here.
00:20:45 But just to compare the numbers here, the ad scam was, I think, about $2 million in contracts without a proper bidding system.
00:20:53 With ArriveCAN, we're talking about something that went up to $60 million.
00:20:58 Yeah, look, it's a lot of money.
00:21:00 And it's funny how in this country, scandals over waste often don't depend on the amount, right?
00:21:05 Everyone will remember BevOda's orange juice.
00:21:07 That was only $16, right?
00:21:09 Whereas in other cases, I just mentioned the shipbuilding procurement.
00:21:12 Now you're into tens of billions of dollars or these subsidies for electric vehicle batteries.
00:21:16 So sometimes it's not the dollar.
00:21:18 It's just the egregiousness of how it's done.
00:21:20 And I think Arrive Can in that respect is particularly controversial because, as you mentioned, a lot of people were very put off, you know, by the nature of this app, you know, this sort of, you know, whether or not it was violating Canadians' rights, it was very draconian.
00:21:37 So you add that layer onto it, it wasn't just that $50 million was wasted, it was in service of something that was pretty dark in and of itself.
00:21:45 So explain to me what could come of this.
00:21:48 I mean, obviously, the Conservatives are making a bit of hay about this, as I think is reasonable enough to do.
00:21:53 The Liberals, it seemed like, from the little bit of the committee that was on earlier, are desperately trying to just to shove the blame somewhere in a corner, like some random procurement officer with CBSA.
00:22:05 They want to own this whole thing.
00:22:07 Where do you think it will go?
00:22:09 Yeah, I mean, I don't see anybody resigning.
00:22:11 And it would be nice if someone actually had the dignity to resign over this, a minister or even civil servants, or whether it would be investigations of the specific individuals responsible for this.
00:22:22 I just don't see that happening in a lot of cases.
00:22:26 You know, the tactic, first of all, is to deny and then to stall in the hopes that something else will pop up in the news cycle and people will lose interest in this.
00:22:34 And I unfortunately think that there's not a non-zero chance that that's what's going to happen here.
00:22:40 So one thing that I would be very curious about it as well to get your take on it is
00:22:45 whether this you think is the tip of the iceberg because you alluded earlier to this is just one
00:22:50 aspect of pandemic spending. We had billions and billions of dollars going out the door.
00:22:56 We've already seen with CERB there were a lot of people that got it that didn't have to. CRA has
00:23:02 had mixed success in collecting that but you go to other programs and other spending and there's
00:23:06 never really been a deep dive into it. No, and I think that there needs to be a top to bottom
00:23:12 review of all of that spending from the pandemic period. And I mean, in addition, we've called for
00:23:17 a review of all the COVID-19 pandemic measures generally, right? So not just the spending,
00:23:25 but all the programming decisions, all the policy decisions taken during that time. We all know what
00:23:29 some of those are that were some of them very controversial to this day. But this was a lot
00:23:33 of money that went out the door. And I think a lot of people at the time said, okay, we're willing
00:23:38 to lower our standards because it's an emergency, but not indefinitely and not without a review
00:23:46 after the fact. And I still think that needs to happen. We're not talking about a little bit of
00:23:52 money here. We're talking about a significant amount of money. And if for no other reason,
00:23:56 then to make sure that this stuff doesn't happen again, because some of these problems
00:24:00 can't be attributed to the pandemic.
00:24:02 It's just, there's just poor mechanisms in place
00:24:05 to ensure that money can't get wasted this easily.
00:24:09 Aaron Woodrick is the Domestic Policy Program Director
00:24:13 over at the MacDonald-Laurier Institute.
00:24:15 Thank you very much, sir, as always, for your time.
00:24:17 Thanks a lot, Andrew.
00:24:18 All right, Aaron Woodrick, thank you, as always.
00:24:20 Good to talk to him.
00:24:21 Now, one thing that I wanted to bring up here,
00:24:24 I actually had this story on Friday
00:24:26 and just by virtue of the show schedule,
00:24:29 We'll have to wait a whole weekend to talk about it.
00:24:30 But it's been making a bit of waves around the internet, this story.
00:24:36 So the World Health Organization every year,
00:24:39 one thing that UN and WHO and all these bodies do,
00:24:42 they love creating a convention, a treaty, a framework, whatever it is.
00:24:46 And then every year they have the same conference to talk about it.
00:24:51 And they call it Conference of the Parties or COP.
00:24:53 Now, we usually hear COP in terms of the COP28-29 climate summits, but there's COP this, COP that.
00:25:02 Every one of these agreements has a COP.
00:25:04 Now, the World Health Organization, they're up to COP11 on their tobacco control conference.
00:25:10 And every year, countries send delegates from around the world.
00:25:13 They gather in a lovely location, spend a bunch of money, and they talk about ways that they can go back and restrict or end tobacco usage.
00:25:19 Now, I have never covered one of these things, but I was alerted to a presentation that the Canadian government delegate or one of the delegates, a Health Canada tobacco control czar, gave a few weeks back ahead of the COP11 summit this week in Panama.
00:25:37 but actually wrapped up on Saturday.
00:25:39 And I'm going to share a couple of clips here
00:25:41 because when I learned what was being floated
00:25:45 as reasonable tobacco control measures,
00:25:49 I was quite baffled that this had not received more coverage.
00:25:53 This is a very, very lovely lady.
00:25:55 Laura Smith is her name.
00:25:56 She's with Health Canada's Tobacco Control Directorate.
00:26:00 But this was her listing just some of the available ideas
00:26:03 that governments have.
00:26:05 so let's start to look at some of these examples under 2.1 measures relating to article 2.1 can
00:26:14 be quite diverse and we've already heard some examples here this morning but here are a few
00:26:19 more that could be in line with article 2.1 so smoke-free private spaces involve the regulation
00:26:27 of smoking in private places such as homes vehicles multi-unit housing government subsidized
00:26:33 housing, balconies, patios, and yards belonging to housing complexes. Another measure involves
00:26:40 designating specific stores to sell tobacco, such as selling tobacco products only in specific
00:26:46 specialist stores. So those were ideas that she says are consistent with 2.1, section 2.1 of the
00:26:56 framework for tobacco control. Now, to be clear, she is not saying that Canada is going to do those
00:27:01 things but what she is saying is that these are these are policies these are measures that are
00:27:07 consistent with what canada has agreed to do and this fed into a motion that canada introduced a
00:27:13 draft resolution that canada introduced which i as i understand it was passed was adopted by other
00:27:18 countries to strike a task force to come up with a list of these things so that we could have
00:27:24 countries do more of them so it's one of the ideas she's putting to countries to say hey you guys can
00:27:29 do this. We can all do this. Not allowing smoking in private homes, sometimes even in patios and
00:27:35 driveways is one of the examples. And then she also used this to transition into what are called
00:27:41 end game strategies. These are policies that governments could embrace to abolish smoking
00:27:46 altogether. Here were some of those that she listed as examples. So as I mentioned, there are
00:27:52 also some examples of measures that may align with article 2.1 and also relate close more closely to
00:27:59 end game strategies so one again we've heard already today about the introduction of tobacco
00:28:06 free generation legislation which involves restricting the acquisition of tobacco and
00:28:11 tobacco products to all those born after a specific year with the intent of phasing out
00:28:17 tobacco sales and preventing young people from starting to use tobacco. Another strategy also
00:28:23 includes phasing out tobacco sales and that's the sinking lid strategy which has an end date in
00:28:29 mind. This approach involves regularly reducing the amount of tobacco that is allowed to be sold
00:28:35 each year to achieve a specified level of commercial sales. Such a measure could also
00:28:41 be aided through continuously decreasing the number and density of tobacco retailers
00:28:47 overall retail availability would decrease thereby decreasing initiation and marketing exposure
00:28:54 and increasing long-term cessation
00:28:58 so a couple of ideas there number one is making it so that the age to smoke is let's say uh 21
00:29:05 this year and then next year it's 22 and next year it's 23 and then 24 and in 30 years you
00:29:12 need to be 54 years of age to buy tobacco products so i i can only imagine when you know tom's uh
00:29:20 70 year old friend has to like go into the convenience store uh because tom is uh 68 and
00:29:26 his friend uh you know can show his id and get cigarettes and then pass them off like you know
00:29:31 know the 19 year olds and the 16 year olds used to do now it's going to be uh sexagenarians and
00:29:36 septagenarians that are doing that in the back alley behind the variety store so i don't have
00:29:42 skin in the game here i am not a smoker i enjoy the odd cigar i have never smoked a cigarette in
00:29:47 my life i'm not bragging i'm just saying as a matter of fact i don't actually care for any
00:29:51 personal reasons about how available smoking is i must admit i like the idea of going into a
00:29:56 restaurant and not having to smell cigarette smoke, but I would firmly defend the right of
00:30:01 any restaurant if they wanted to in my libertarian utopia of saying this is a restaurant that allows
00:30:07 smoking. This is a restaurant that allows smokers. If you don't like it, you can go somewhere else.
00:30:12 So let's be real. Smoking and, well, smokers have become a group that it is very easy and very hip
00:30:19 and trendy to discriminate against and the last safe place that a smoker has is their own property
00:30:28 their own home now many smokers choose not to smoke in their home because they know it damages
00:30:32 the home it affects resale value they choose not to that's a choice they make but if you buy a
00:30:36 house you own a house it is yours the idea that any government bureaucrat would be entertaining
00:30:42 a ban a statutory regulation on your ability to do what you want in your own home with a substance
00:30:49 that by the way is still legal to purchase and consume at least for now is absolutely absurd
00:30:56 and people can raise questions about oh well it's not really enforceable oh well they're not really
00:31:01 talking about doing it but this is again this is a policy that they say is consistent with an
00:31:06 international convention that canada has adopted that canada has signed on to so this is when i
00:31:12 talk about why global treaties are so dangerous this is exactly what i mean because you have a
00:31:18 treaty that tries to pull a country in a direction into a domestic policy direction that it wouldn't
00:31:23 normally go to and and interestingly enough this i just shared the the clips from her presentation
00:31:29 you can watch the whole thing we link to it in our article over at true north i don't know
00:31:34 if they would extend this to vaping as well. Because I mean, if you want to vape in your own
00:31:40 home, who that cares? Again, I've never vaped. I know people who do, and I know people who swear
00:31:45 by it as a tool that helps them or has helped them mitigate smoking. I also know people who
00:31:50 have never smoked that have started vaping, and that was their introduction into tobacco. So I'm
00:31:55 not going to claim that this is 100% a positive. All I can share is the anecdotal, the anecdata
00:32:01 I've collected from having looked at this issue in the past.
00:32:04 But again, if they're going to put restrictions on smoking, it stands to reason they would
00:32:09 probably extend them to vaping as well, because many of the restrictions that already exist
00:32:13 on where you can smoke do apply to e-cigarettes and vaping.
00:32:17 So even your private home, even your private home is no longer available to you if some
00:32:23 of these bureaucrats have their way. 1.00
00:32:25 Now, on that panel discussion that Laura Smith from Health Canada did, there was a one
00:32:31 focus one woman from a European agency I think it was DG Sante and I it's like the you're one of the
00:32:38 European health agencies and she was saying well you know I know it's controversial we aren't moving
00:32:44 on it just yeah but she was almost like joking about it as though oh yeah people people take
00:32:48 issue with this but at a certain point I am confident that someone is going to in Canada
00:32:52 put this forward as a serious policy proposition so I can say I can do the old you heard it here
00:33:00 first line and this is i think where we get into the global compact for migration the pandemic
00:33:07 treaty that the world health organization is pushing a lot of these other international
00:33:10 organizations that have these agendas and everyone says oh well you know what's the big deal they can
00:33:15 talk about whatever they want abroad well these policies that we see in canada coming domestically
00:33:21 are oftentimes justified because a government wants to comply with a treaty it signed abroad
00:33:27 So it might even be worth, I should look up where COP12 is. It might even be worth going to
00:33:33 see this Tobacco Control Summit in action next time. I'm just imagining, again, I'm not a smoker,
00:33:38 but if I were to go to the Tobacco Control Summit, I'd have to just get a big giant
00:33:42 cartoonish-sized pipe and just smoke it outside the main door just to be a contrarian because
00:33:48 that's where we've gotten in the process of politics, just smoking to own the globalists
00:33:53 or something like that.
00:33:54 Kids, I'm not recommending you do that.
00:33:57 Anyway, I wanted to talk about this story
00:34:00 that came out kind of under the radar here
00:34:02 because CBC, you may recall,
00:34:03 was paying a lot of money in executive bonuses
00:34:06 while implementing and imposing layoffs
00:34:08 on its own people.
00:34:10 CBC, it's hard to believe
00:34:12 with their $1.4 billion a year subsidy
00:34:14 that they are ever going to be cash strapped,
00:34:16 but they talk about their budget
00:34:18 as though the sky is falling,
00:34:20 as though they're bleeding,
00:34:21 they're starved, they have no money.
00:34:23 and yet and yet courtesy of black locks reporter and then it was picked up by the western standard
00:34:30 catherine tate who is the ceo of cbc who makes i believe about half a million dollars a year
00:34:38 running cbc she claimed in the span of one year november 1st uh 2021 to november 1st 2023
00:34:45 according to ATIP records $119,000 in expenses for junkets these very glitzy foreign trips
00:34:55 including to Prague in the Czech Republic and Hollywood in California this was all being done
00:35:02 but well CBC was claiming a budgetary shortfall of about 125 million dollars and warning of employee
00:35:09 job cuts which we saw of course last year implemented now Catherine Tate was saying oh
00:35:14 yes, you know, we're facing rising costs of operations and productions. And let's be real,
00:35:18 her $119,000 junkets did not break the bank, but it certainly shows the imbalance of it. Now,
00:35:26 there are a lot of private media companies that are not doing this sort of stuff. And there are
00:35:30 a lot who are, but you know what, at least if they're doing it privately, it is shareholders
00:35:33 who are the ones ultimately responsible for assessing how well or poorly the company is
00:35:38 being managed. CBC is a crown corporation. We, the Canadian taxpayers, are the shareholders,
00:35:46 yet we don't really have a say. In fact, we don't have a say at all in how CBC manages its funds and
00:35:51 manages its assets. We're just supposed to sit back and accept that this is all happening. Now,
00:35:57 private media is hemorrhaging. Private media has had to get government bailouts to continue to run.
00:36:03 CBC just goes to the government hat in hand and generally gets what it wants. You may recall
00:36:08 Justin Trudeau famously giving CBC reporter David Cochran a poutine while proudly telling him
00:36:14 that a liberal government will always look out for CBC. Well, maybe Catherine Tate needed a 1.00
00:36:20 few more poutines to make up for the $119,000 she was spending on these business class travel 1.00
00:36:27 junkets. We did see last week mass layoffs from Bell. Bell has had a number of issues in the past.
00:36:35 they sold off a ton of radio stations now that's near and dear to my heart as a former talk radio
00:36:40 guy and they continued that sell-off last week uh shutting down or getting rid of a number of
00:36:46 stations including in small and medium markets and even their large uh operations their major
00:36:51 newsrooms in toronto have had to trim down significantly on staff in fact when you looked
00:36:56 at the list of jobs it was hard to imagine there being anyone left after cutting 4 800 jobs the
00:37:04 largest round of layoffs one article said in 30 years ending multiple shows now i have had a lot
00:37:12 of criticism about legacy media but i do not at all celebrate the decline of media i don't celebrate
00:37:18 4 800 people being out of work i i do think that when people try to cling to an old approach to
00:37:25 things that isn't working it's not healthy or constructive but i don't celebrate it and the
00:37:30 liberal government has wanted to make bell the scapegoat here justin trudeau had this to say on
00:37:36 friday on the bell canada layoffs of 4 800 people across the country your heritage minister accused
00:37:43 bell canada of breaking its promise to invest in local news after receiving 40 million dollars in
00:37:48 regulatory relief funding what is your view of that company's layoffs and what is your commitment
00:37:55 into future government support with that company?
00:37:59 I'm furious. 0.99
00:38:01 This is a garbage decision by a corporation that should know better. 0.99
00:38:06 We have seen over the past years journalistic outlets, radio stations, 0.98
00:38:12 small community newspapers bought up by corporate entities
00:38:16 who then lay off journalists, you know, change the offering,
00:38:23 the quality of offering to people,
00:38:24 And then when people don't watch as much or engage as much, the corporate entity says, oh, see, they're not profitable anymore.
00:38:31 We're going to sell them off.
00:38:33 This is the erosion, not just of journalism, of quality local journalism at a time where people need it more than ever given misinformation and disinformation.
00:38:44 But it's eroding our very democracy.
00:38:47 So, yeah, I'm pretty pissed off about what's just happened.
00:38:50 and look i i think that a lot of the criticism is warranted bell media cashed a lot of money
00:38:57 from the government and there was i think an expectation there that okay you're doing this
00:39:01 to protect jobs and journalism and then to turn around and say we're getting rid of this tv was
00:39:06 very hard hit uh is uh something that is going to sting but a lot of the problems that have
00:39:12 happened here have been because the government was getting into and meddling in this idea of
00:39:17 subsidizing media in the first place. When government starts to say, we're going to give
00:39:21 you this money in regulatory relief, we're going to mandate this much money from Facebook and Google,
00:39:26 all of a sudden you're creating this framework where government has an expectation that private
00:39:30 companies are operating in ways that they would not operate without government's hand being there.
00:39:36 And these companies are looking and saying, okay, yeah, this little pittance we're getting from
00:39:40 Google, courtesy of Bill C-18, isn't enough to overhaul or isn't enough to underwrite this
00:39:46 division of our operation that is not profitable. I've told my story on the show time and time again
00:39:53 about how bloated CBC is, about how many people they have doing jobs that even their private
00:40:00 sector competitors at CTV and Global do not have, let alone independent media startups like yours
00:40:06 truly and true north but the reason i bring that up is to say that these these operations have not
00:40:11 done in many ways the work that they've needed to do to downsize and trim down in a sustainable way
00:40:20 now again i don't celebrate people being out of work but you know what the folks that uh you know
00:40:25 run the printing presses are not as valuable as the folks that run the digital for newspapers a
00:40:30 lot of uh tv reporters have to shoot their own videos so there are not a lot of jobs for camera
00:40:35 operators compared to what they're usually where there used to be historically and at some larger
00:40:40 players they may be all of this is tragic for individuals but it is part of an evolution and
00:40:45 when you get government trying to delay the inevitable it is a recipe for exactly what
00:40:51 happened on friday so government i think has to take its hands off now that means that companies
00:40:57 will either sink or swim i have a hard time believing the doomsday scenario that there is
00:41:02 no business model for news i think the existence of organizations like true north proves there is
00:41:07 a business model for news but you have to be creative you have to be nimble and you cannot
00:41:11 rely on the state and you cannot rely on old practices now uh this is something that i think
00:41:18 the government desperately desperately needs to learn as a lesson we just have a few minutes left
00:41:23 in the show here but we'll bring in our friend chris sims from the canadian taxpayers federation
00:41:28 Chris, you know, I think there's a cautionary tale in all of this that government is delaying
00:41:32 the inevitable.
00:41:33 And when government gets involved in subsidizing, all of a sudden it adds a new dimension into
00:41:38 business decisions, which is that the government can turn around and point to Bell and say,
00:41:42 well, hang on, you don't have the right to do that because we've been giving you money.
00:41:46 So this is entirely inevitable in my view.
00:41:49 Yes, you must be shaking your head because I think you and I have had this warning conversation
00:41:53 now for the past five, six, maybe more years than this.
00:41:57 This is what happens when you start relying on the government for your payroll. It's even worse, Andrew, when you have a trade like journalism. We have a calling like journalism. So I know a lot of us who went to journalism school and some of us who didn't, who truly feel journalism is a calling, we want to speak truth to power. We want to comfort the afflicted. We want to find the answers to our W5 questions. Let that show rest in peace.
00:42:22 very sad to see that show go but then you become beholden to the very thing you're supposed to be
00:42:28 holding accountable the state and look what's happened um full disclosure i worked for ctv
00:42:35 for many years the vast majority of the time everything went really well so it's not a sour
00:42:40 grapes thing i'm appealing though to my former colleagues some of whom have lost their jobs
00:42:46 to take a look at this funding structure and realize what has happened
00:42:50 in that your mother corporation okay has taken money while saying unless you do this we're going
00:42:56 to cut jobs and news and they've turned around and done that anyway two weeks after i don't know if
00:43:01 you noted this earlier in your show andrew two weeks after bell let's talk right what worse
00:43:07 thing for mental health happens than losing your job very few things and it used to be a little
00:43:13 thing among the newsrooms it was kind of grim and macabre but they used to joke among the rank and
00:43:19 file workers of oh oh bell let's talk days coming up because they knew that's often when the company
00:43:25 would time layoff notices after right after i'm not joking so it's i've have care i've carried
00:43:32 that bag out of my drawer at my desk i've cleaned that out many times quite often leaving bell again
00:43:38 not fired but laid off downturned furloughed all those things and so we're in a massive change
00:43:45 right now when it comes to government okay we're seeing the state broadcaster cbc coming under
00:43:51 heavy fire for taking all this government money and still blowing canadians money on bonuses and
00:43:57 wastefulness with their ceo we're seeing more and more mainstream journalists going on government
00:44:02 payroll and we're seeing trust just take a nosedive people aren't watching they're not listening
00:44:07 they're tuning out of mainstream media and here on the other side hopefully we're seeing a rebirth
00:44:12 we're seeing a resurgence of independent journalism that's my hope is that we can get
00:44:17 shows like this becoming viewed more and more often yeah and and look i mean one of the things
00:44:23 that i would point out here for people is that there is money available in media you look at the
00:44:28 number of people that are making uh big money on substack you look at people that are i wouldn't
00:44:34 say making big money but people that are able to to make a decent living through uh podcasting and
00:44:40 through other work and it's different and and you know there there are questions that you can raise
00:44:44 about the journalistic rigor of all of that is you know barry weiss's substack uh to the same standard
00:44:49 as glenn greenwald's the intercept to the same standard as your local paper and and these are
00:44:54 questions that consumers i think that readers have to adjudicate for themselves so i i think
00:44:59 the problem here is that there's been a lot of coasting on legacy credentials that have been
00:45:04 taking place where we are the baseline we are the benchmark we are the gold standard and
00:45:09 that i think there's a bit been a bit of denial there which has contributed to where we are
00:45:13 yes yes and it's hard because i've been back and forth i've done mainstream media i've done
00:45:20 kind of this mix of independent and mainstream which was sun news network which has given birth
00:45:24 to a lot of different new independent shows and so i've been through that rigmarole and i've been
00:45:30 through the agony of losing your job having your network shut down crtc getting involved all that
00:45:35 stuff happening and so again my hope is that both through okay here's one thing i think we need to
00:45:42 take a long hard look at the clubs that are journalists within capital cities okay that
00:45:48 includes the parliamentary press gallery of which i was a member for many years we need to break up
00:45:53 those cool kids clubs because it causes groupthink okay it makes them think that number one they all
00:46:00 need to say the same thing and ask the same and write questions and if you don't you're not a
00:46:05 cool kid okay because you get peer pressure there two it kind of insulates them from the realities
00:46:12 and the storms of what is going on in the rest of the media world and it makes them start thinking
00:46:17 that they don't need to change and that they don't need to alter their formats and they don't need to
00:46:22 change their command structure and they do they clearly do and that going to government is not
00:46:27 going to help them it's not going to save them uh pierre polyev just addressed a lot of this
00:46:32 conservative leader opposition leader addressed a lot of this in the last press conference he just
00:46:37 did on arrive can and he held forth on the problem of the government handing over millions of dollars
00:46:43 to the media yet the media turning around and axing people's jobs anyway and this is not cbc
00:46:50 again i can't believe we're having this conversation this is supposedly private media corporations so
00:46:56 i can see all of this kind of coming to a pointy end within the next year or so i think you're
00:47:01 going to see a big a big shake up yeah very well said we'll have you back on next week as always
00:47:07 although it's family day in ontario so next monday so we'll have to can we get you on next tuesday
00:47:12 i can do monday or tuesday my kids can wait they're good well i'm not doing monday so
00:47:17 you'll be here wondering where the show is uh to introduce you but we'll figure it out chris
00:47:22 sims from the canadian taxpayers federation always a pleasure chris thanks for coming on
00:47:26 likewise thanks andrew all right yeah i forget how many provinces do family day because we do
00:47:31 i'm just looking at my calendar here so i think it's it's family day in alberta bc and ontario
00:47:39 and it is nova scotia heritage day it's islander day in prince edward island and it's louis real
00:47:45 day in manitoba which i don't approve of for reasons i may share with you next week if i
00:47:50 decide to unload on that but nevertheless yeah no no louis real day we don't do on the andrew
00:47:56 lotten show but sean is just happy he has monday off so uh sean whether you're doing louis real
00:48:00 day or islander day or family day no you don't need to come to work next monday so all right
00:48:05 that does it for us for today we will be back in uh 23 hours and uh 50 minutes no 23 hours and 10
00:48:11 minutes here on The Andrew Lawton Show, Canada's most irreverent talk show. Thank you, God bless,
00:48:16 and good day to you all. Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:48:20 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.
00:48:41 We'll be right back.