Juno News - October 04, 2025


BC Conservatives fire Lindsay Shepherd for Expressing her Opinion

Topics
Mentioned
Trans regret and the growing wave of detransitioner lawsuits Alberta takes lead on new West Coast pipeline

Episode Stats


Length

38 minutes

Words per minute

178.19

Word count

6,860

Sentence count

331

Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

13

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this week's episode, True North Sports takes a look at the NHL playoffs, Lindsay Shepard is fired for telling the truth, and the Canadian flag flies in front of a fake flag in honour of Canada's First World War dead.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Baseball is an insanely long season.
00:00:02 It's 162 games, I think.
00:00:04 All year round, right?
00:00:05 It's like you've got to just be hot at the right time, right?
00:00:07 Like, are you hot going into the playoffs?
00:00:09 The Jays aren't that hot right now,
00:00:11 but they could become hot tomorrow, you know?
00:00:14 So it's like you've got to hit that streak.
00:00:16 That's why I've always appreciated hockey
00:00:18 because I think hockey is the most unpredictable sport
00:00:20 in terms of results.
00:00:21 Like, it's the only American sport
00:00:23 where a team has come down from a 3-0 deficit, you know?
00:00:27 Reverse sweep, yeah.
00:00:28 Yeah, you just don't know.
00:00:32 You never...
00:00:32 Yeah, well, you rarely see it happen still,
00:00:35 but I guess it's possible.
00:00:36 You think hockey is the most unpredictable?
00:00:39 I think so.
00:00:40 I think so compared to basketball.
00:00:41 Basketball has been very consistent
00:00:43 when it comes to certain logic
00:00:44 because when you play like seven times,
00:00:46 you really get to see what team is superior in most cases.
00:00:50 Yeah, but hockey series are seven games as well.
00:00:53 Yeah, so looking side by side,
00:00:55 you can kind of see many more instances of a team
00:00:58 with, let's say, an inferior regular season record
00:01:03 go over to, you know, the seeding, for example.
00:01:07 The seeding results have less weight than, for example, the NBA.
00:01:10 If you're the first seeder, 0.73
00:01:11 probably getting to the conference final.
00:01:13 In the NHL, the guarantee is much less statistically backed,
00:01:17 I would argue, without even looking at the numbers.
00:01:19 I've seen that happen in enough examples
00:01:22 that feel confident all throughout.
00:01:24 I mean, the ice is much more unpredictable
00:01:26 than, you know, the hard court.
00:01:29 It really is.
00:01:30 Yeah, we'll have to get a True North hockey party going
00:01:34 and we'll see what happens on the ice there.
00:01:35 We're going to have the sports reporting.
00:01:37 I'm sorry, but I feel like there's more stories
00:01:39 in sports than meets the eye.
00:01:40 I'm telling you...
00:01:41 Yeah, I'm always on the beat
00:01:43 looking for politically motivated sports stories
00:01:48 that they happen, definitely,
00:01:50 but obviously the hockey season's about to start again,
00:01:52 so we'll see what comes of that.
00:01:55 Yeah, it'd be great to get, like, a designated
00:01:56 kind of sports show that we start to put out
00:01:58 or something like that,
00:01:59 because I think we have, you know,
00:02:00 a lot of our audience wants to hear
00:02:01 about these types of things,
00:02:03 and, like, the only thing we're really covering is,
00:02:05 I guess, was, like, the, like,
00:02:06 trans and women's sports angle,
00:02:08 and so it'd be nice to dig a little deeper into that.
00:02:12 Yeah, like I said, I'm always open to it,
00:02:14 but I think the stories are too sporadic.
00:02:18 It's, like, hard to do it on a weekly basis,
00:02:19 you know, because it's, like...
00:02:21 That's true.
00:02:21 Obviously, the hockey can and stuff is a crazy story,
00:02:23 but it's, like, that's, like, an anomaly, right?
00:02:25 Not the norm.
00:02:26 My name's Isaac Lamer.
00:02:27 I'm here with my True North colleagues.
00:02:29 We'll lead Tam-Tam and Jeff Knight.
00:02:30 Let's hop into that first story right away.
00:02:32 So, yeah, just for our first story,
00:02:35 we obviously have a pretty big one
00:02:38 that touches close to home
00:02:40 for a lot of us at True North
00:02:41 because any older fans of the organization
00:02:45 and of the shows will remember, of course,
00:02:48 former True North journalist, Lindsay Shepard,
00:02:52 who is, of course, married to our managing editor,
00:02:56 Cosmin Gerja,
00:02:57 who, by the way, had no role in pitching, editing,
00:03:02 signing, anything to do with this article.
00:03:04 But the big news came out there
00:03:07 that Shepard was fired for telling the truth.
00:03:10 I mean, absolute insanity.
00:03:12 I don't know how else to word it.
00:03:14 She was fired for telling the truth in a tweet
00:03:16 by John Rustad there
00:03:18 because she tweeted on Truth and Reconciliation Day.
00:03:23 I'll just read the tweet.
00:03:25 The orange shirt and the orange flag
00:03:28 perpetuate untruths about Canadian history,
00:03:31 such as the grandest lie of all
00:03:33 that 215 children's graves were unearthed in Kamloops.
00:03:38 It is a disgrace that this fake flag
00:03:40 flies in front of the provincial parliament buildings,
00:03:43 and it is a disgrace to see the shirt of lies
00:03:46 framed prominently and permanently
00:03:48 beside the coat of arms
00:03:50 so that locals and tourists cannot view our insignia
00:03:53 without having their eyes drawn
00:03:55 and redirected to the orange shirt.
00:03:57 So this was deemed unacceptable, I guess, by Rustad.
00:04:02 As I know, or as I understand,
00:04:05 Shepard faced very minimal backlash against this.
00:04:08 The CBC wrote a hit piece on her, basically,
00:04:12 but I think it was actually authored by a chief
00:04:16 who was married to an NDP MLA in BC.
00:04:20 So, surprise, surprise.
00:04:22 And then two NDP MLAs in BC, I think that's it.
00:04:25 Two people apparently talked bad about Lindsay
00:04:29 saying that she should be fired,
00:04:31 and that's all it took for Rustad to fire her
00:04:33 for telling truths.
00:04:34 I mean, this is absolutely insane,
00:04:36 and it gets worse because, of course,
00:04:39 Lindsay said she's a mother of two children
00:04:41 and 32 weeks pregnant,
00:04:42 so she was about to go on maternity leave, 0.51
00:04:44 and then Rustad shows her the door.
00:04:47 So, yeah, if either of you guys want to answer,
00:04:50 I mean, what is the irony here
00:04:52 where we're talking about Truth and Reconciliation Day,
00:04:55 that's the title of this so-called holiday,
00:04:58 and then Shepard is fired from the BC Conservative Party
00:05:01 for telling the truth.
00:05:03 I mean, literally, it's insane to me.
00:05:06 I think...
00:05:06 Oh, sorry, go ahead, Will.
00:05:08 I think the lack of backlash is actually a sign
00:05:10 that, frankly, Rustad's move is a very poor one
00:05:15 in terms of a reward.
00:05:16 I mean, because I think, frankly,
00:05:17 the reason why there might be a lack of media coverage,
00:05:20 specifically from more liberal-oriented
00:05:22 or mainstream media,
00:05:24 would be the fact is they don't want to give credit
00:05:25 to Rustad for being politically correct.
00:05:28 I guess that's maybe the case here
00:05:30 because, essentially, here,
00:05:31 you have a very, you know, low-level...
00:05:34 You know, because, again,
00:05:35 not many people are paying attention
00:05:36 to what this individual was tweeting,
00:05:38 but, of course, there's always going to be
00:05:39 a few progressive exceptions
00:05:40 of people that will be looking for every opportunity
00:05:43 to snap onto a narrative
00:05:45 that, you know, conservatives are hateful,
00:05:47 and then the staffer is leading this campaign
00:05:50 to say this and that.
00:05:52 I just think it's, you know,
00:05:54 if the media is not covering that much,
00:05:56 if there's not that much talk about it,
00:05:57 then I guess the potential impact
00:05:59 of him shielding his image
00:06:02 to a certain audience
00:06:03 is just really there, you know.
00:06:05 He's not getting the reward.
00:06:06 He's not getting the, you know,
00:06:07 the daytime news coverage
00:06:10 that's kind of, you know,
00:06:11 showing him that he doesn't tolerate
00:06:13 whatever it is that he's firing Lindsay for.
00:06:16 So I guess this is the challenging
00:06:19 of the mainstream narrative in this case,
00:06:21 which I'm surprised that the BSC Conservative Party
00:06:23 is so strong on upholding to the point
00:06:26 of, you know, squashing internal dissent.
00:06:29 But off to you, Jeff.
00:06:31 Well, yeah, and, I mean,
00:06:31 it just seems like there's probably
00:06:32 a lot of conversations happening
00:06:34 behind the scenes
00:06:35 that we're not privy to, right?
00:06:36 Because it's, like you said,
00:06:37 it's very confusing
00:06:38 as to why the BSC Conservatives
00:06:39 would push this.
00:06:40 And like Isaac said,
00:06:41 especially, you know,
00:06:42 with the name Truth and Reconciliation,
00:06:45 and now so much of the focus
00:06:46 of the day is on a falsehood
00:06:49 that, you know,
00:06:51 is basically designed
00:06:52 to separate the First Nations communities 0.99
00:06:54 with, I guess, European descent Canadians.
00:06:57 And I think a lot of people
00:06:58 are seeing that and being like,
00:07:00 well, what's the roadmap
00:07:01 to actually getting
00:07:02 to a place of reconciliation?
00:07:04 Because so much of the efforts
00:07:06 seem to be just in dividing us
00:07:08 and really being like,
00:07:09 well, look how horrible
00:07:09 we were to First Nations.
00:07:10 And it just doesn't seem to me
00:07:12 to be a path
00:07:13 that's going to create unity
00:07:15 and create, you know,
00:07:16 there's been a lot of great things
00:07:17 Canada's done with First Nations, 1.00
00:07:19 like, you know,
00:07:20 like the establishment of Nunavut,
00:07:21 which happened within my lifetime.
00:07:22 And I would love for the focus
00:07:26 to be on some more positive stories
00:07:28 like that,
00:07:29 the type of things
00:07:30 that could bring Canadians together
00:07:31 rather than, you know,
00:07:33 here we are still four years out
00:07:34 from the Kamloops story
00:07:37 and people still believe it.
00:07:38 People still think it's true
00:07:40 despite the fact that, you know,
00:07:41 there's been years of research
00:07:43 into it and millions of dollars spent
00:07:44 and they haven't found any bodies.
00:07:47 True North has put out a whole,
00:07:49 has published a book on this
00:07:51 called Grave Error
00:07:51 that has all the facts
00:07:52 laid out for people.
00:07:54 So, you know,
00:07:54 I encourage anyone
00:07:55 who doesn't really know
00:07:56 too much of the details
00:07:58 to check that book out
00:07:59 because right now
00:08:01 what we're seeing
00:08:02 is just a lot of effort
00:08:04 put into the feelings
00:08:06 around the emotional impact
00:08:07 around that story
00:08:08 that it had on people.
00:08:09 And so many people
00:08:09 did have such a strong
00:08:10 emotional impact to it
00:08:11 that now we're finding out
00:08:13 that it's not necessarily accurate.
00:08:15 It's very hard to let go
00:08:16 of those feelings, I think.
00:08:19 And it's something
00:08:19 we definitely need to do
00:08:20 as a nation.
00:08:22 Yeah, well,
00:08:22 just jumping on that, Jeff,
00:08:24 it is something
00:08:25 we're sort of doing.
00:08:27 Well, and this might,
00:08:28 this covers a few things
00:08:29 because we were,
00:08:30 Waleed was talking there
00:08:31 about mainstream coverage a bit.
00:08:32 And this may be why
00:08:34 it's not as prevalent
00:08:35 as we've seen
00:08:35 because a recent Leger poll
00:08:38 showed that only 44%
00:08:39 of Canadians,
00:08:40 so less than the majority,
00:08:41 want more government action
00:08:43 on reconciliation.
00:08:44 So Canadians are kind of 0.99
00:08:46 turning away from that.
00:08:47 And this was,
00:08:49 of course,
00:08:49 compared to 88%
00:08:50 who wanted the government
00:08:51 to improve on health care
00:08:52 and 86% who wanted the Liberals
00:08:55 to work on the cost of living.
00:08:56 So obviously,
00:08:57 while Canadians are 1.00
00:08:58 caring less about reconciliation,
00:09:01 they care about,
00:09:03 more about things
00:09:03 that are really affecting
00:09:04 their lives,
00:09:05 which is,
00:09:06 unsurprisingly,
00:09:06 health care
00:09:07 and the cost of living.
00:09:09 But just touching on
00:09:10 the book there,
00:09:11 Jeff,
00:09:11 that you mentioned,
00:09:11 Grave Error,
00:09:12 of course,
00:09:13 published by True North.
00:09:14 Recently,
00:09:15 the Toronto Star
00:09:16 published an op-ed
00:09:18 with various false claims
00:09:21 about True North.
00:09:24 This was an op-ed
00:09:25 written by Michelle Good,
00:09:27 who she advocated
00:09:29 for a federal ban
00:09:30 on residential school denialism
00:09:33 in a book that she wrote
00:09:35 called Five Little Indians.
00:09:37 And she said various things
00:09:38 about Grave Error
00:09:40 that were just not true.
00:09:41 Like, one thing
00:09:42 that would take two seconds
00:09:43 to disprove.
00:09:44 She claimed it was self-published,
00:09:46 which is not true, obviously.
00:09:48 True North helped
00:09:49 publish the book,
00:09:50 so it's not self-published.
00:09:52 Yeah, no,
00:09:53 there was a lot of things
00:09:54 in there that she
00:09:56 claimed weren't...
00:09:59 I mean, look,
00:10:00 Grave Error is essentially
00:10:01 a research study.
00:10:02 There's 800 footnotes
00:10:03 in the book.
00:10:03 It's all research-based.
00:10:05 It's all cited information.
00:10:07 It's not fictional
00:10:08 in any way, shape, or form.
00:10:09 It's essentially
00:10:10 a detailed research study,
00:10:11 in my opinion.
00:10:13 So to refute
00:10:15 the research is...
00:10:17 I mean,
00:10:18 to use a word
00:10:21 that the lefty
00:10:22 loves to use,
00:10:23 anti-science, really.
00:10:24 You're saying,
00:10:25 oh, yeah,
00:10:25 it's anti-science.
00:10:27 Because it's like,
00:10:27 oh, yeah,
00:10:27 I don't trust your research.
00:10:28 It's like,
00:10:29 what don't you trust
00:10:30 from the 800 citations
00:10:31 in the footnotes?
00:10:32 What do you mean?
00:10:33 It's not really trust
00:10:34 when we're talking
00:10:35 about facts here.
00:10:37 And, of course,
00:10:37 the book had
00:10:38 Grave Error.
00:10:39 It's kind of a
00:10:40 multi-author book
00:10:43 because there was
00:10:45 13 authors,
00:10:46 including retired judge,
00:10:47 lawyers,
00:10:47 journalists,
00:10:48 and university professors
00:10:49 across several disciplines.
00:10:53 So, yeah.
00:10:55 Were you guys surprised
00:10:56 that the Toronto Star
00:10:57 published an op-ed
00:10:59 ironically claiming
00:11:01 that Grave Error
00:11:02 was full of lies
00:11:03 when the op-ed itself was?
00:11:07 I mean, no.
00:11:07 It's kind of like
00:11:08 part of the course
00:11:09 for Toronto Star
00:11:09 at this point, right?
00:11:11 To, you know,
00:11:12 just be very hard-headed
00:11:15 about it.
00:11:16 And it's funny that,
00:11:18 you know,
00:11:18 there's no repercussions
00:11:19 for them to kind of
00:11:20 be pushing forward lies
00:11:22 and stuff like that.
00:11:23 But, you know,
00:11:23 they're very adamant
00:11:25 that, you know,
00:11:26 people who would suggest
00:11:28 that the Kamloops thing
00:11:29 wasn't true
00:11:30 face, like,
00:11:31 criminal prosecution
00:11:32 or outright firing
00:11:35 from their jobs
00:11:35 or anything like that.
00:11:36 And it's just,
00:11:37 it all seems very ironic
00:11:38 to me.
00:11:39 Yeah.
00:11:40 And Tom Flanagan,
00:11:41 who, of course,
00:11:41 co-edited the book,
00:11:43 he told us that
00:11:44 the author of this op-ed
00:11:45 didn't even reach out
00:11:47 to him for comments.
00:11:48 So, not exactly
00:11:50 journalism there.
00:11:52 And we know
00:11:53 that Leah Gazzin,
00:11:54 the NDP MLA,
00:11:55 she wanted to
00:11:56 have that bill
00:11:57 to criminalize
00:11:59 residential school denialism.
00:12:00 So, essentially,
00:12:02 who knows
00:12:03 what would have happened
00:12:04 if that bill passed
00:12:04 because what does
00:12:06 that mean?
00:12:07 You're telling the truth
00:12:08 and you go to jail
00:12:09 for telling the truth.
00:12:11 We're seeing other
00:12:12 similar bills
00:12:13 be debated
00:12:14 in Parliament
00:12:15 right now,
00:12:16 essentially,
00:12:16 about online censorship,
00:12:17 the Online Harms Act,
00:12:19 which could criminalize
00:12:22 people for telling
00:12:22 the truth.
00:12:23 We're seeing what's
00:12:23 happening in the UK.
00:12:24 People are going to jail
00:12:26 for tweets
00:12:27 and Facebook posts.
00:12:29 I mean,
00:12:29 it's absolute insanity.
00:12:30 We're just liking
00:12:31 the Facebook posts.
00:12:32 You know,
00:12:32 it sounds like
00:12:32 Leah Gazzin
00:12:33 and perhaps
00:12:34 other progressive
00:12:35 NDPers 0.98
00:12:36 that supported
00:12:36 that whole bill
00:12:38 were trying to
00:12:39 criminalize
00:12:40 what they call
00:12:41 genocide denial
00:12:42 in the case
00:12:43 of indigenous peoples
00:12:44 in Canada.
00:12:45 It sounds to me
00:12:46 that that's a path
00:12:47 for a book ban.
00:12:48 And I know
00:12:48 they've been screaming
00:12:49 about free speech
00:12:50 and book bans
00:12:51 because they want
00:12:51 essentially pornography,
00:12:55 graphic pornography
00:12:56 on children's books
00:12:57 to be in libraries
00:12:59 because otherwise,
00:13:00 if premieres
00:13:01 are moving
00:13:02 to change laws
00:13:03 and change regulations
00:13:04 to remove those books
00:13:05 from libraries,
00:13:06 well,
00:13:06 then they're banning books
00:13:06 and they're censoring.
00:13:08 This is the traditional
00:13:09 medieval censorship,
00:13:10 banning of books.
00:13:11 I guess that would be
00:13:12 a path to ban a book
00:13:13 like the ones
00:13:14 that True North
00:13:14 have produced.
00:13:15 So, definitely
00:13:16 very concerning to me
00:13:17 if we continue
00:13:19 that in that path,
00:13:20 whether digital
00:13:21 or even physical material
00:13:22 to be potentially
00:13:24 criminalized
00:13:24 because of its content
00:13:25 of argument
00:13:26 or content
00:13:26 of nature.
00:13:28 It's insane.
00:13:30 Yeah,
00:13:31 and we obviously
00:13:32 talked at length
00:13:33 over the last
00:13:33 several months,
00:13:35 I guess,
00:13:35 about the book ban
00:13:36 in Alberta
00:13:37 and the whole
00:13:38 controversy there.
00:13:39 But moving to a different
00:13:40 Alberta story,
00:13:42 this one about pipelines.
00:13:44 Alberta is leading the way
00:13:47 on getting a pipeline
00:13:49 to BC.
00:13:50 and to be fair,
00:13:53 it's not as simple
00:13:54 as you might think.
00:13:55 There's a lot of controversy
00:13:56 already around this
00:13:57 because essentially
00:13:59 Alberta is just
00:14:01 starting an advisory group
00:14:03 to get this thing
00:14:04 to the starting line
00:14:05 because they're saying
00:14:07 that, look,
00:14:08 private investors,
00:14:10 private companies
00:14:11 are not going
00:14:12 to put money forward
00:14:12 with the federal
00:14:13 regulatory hurdles
00:14:15 and burdens in place
00:14:17 because,
00:14:18 well,
00:14:18 take your pick
00:14:19 of past billions
00:14:20 of dollars
00:14:21 of loss
00:14:21 by private industry
00:14:22 because of
00:14:23 anti-energy laws
00:14:25 like Bill C-69,
00:14:26 Bill C-48,
00:14:27 the tanker ban.
00:14:28 The list is lengthy,
00:14:30 but essentially
00:14:30 Alberta is going
00:14:32 to do some consultations
00:14:35 on this pipeline,
00:14:36 kind of get all
00:14:37 the details,
00:14:38 and then pitch it
00:14:38 to the new
00:14:39 federal major
00:14:41 projects office.
00:14:42 And they're hoping
00:14:43 to get that application
00:14:43 done by spring 2026.
00:14:47 So Smith was,
00:14:49 I have to say,
00:14:49 I watched the press conference
00:14:51 in its entirety
00:14:52 and one of the first
00:14:53 things I noticed
00:14:54 was I was like,
00:14:54 Smith looks elated,
00:14:55 really.
00:14:56 She was very joyful,
00:14:58 which is surprising.
00:14:59 I don't know.
00:15:00 She's very more,
00:15:01 she's a lot more hopeful
00:15:02 that this project
00:15:03 will succeed,
00:15:04 I think,
00:15:04 just based on even
00:15:05 analyzing her emotions
00:15:07 and how she was
00:15:08 presenting herself
00:15:09 than I would be,
00:15:10 especially because
00:15:12 BC NDP Premier
00:15:14 David Eby,
00:15:15 the very same day,
00:15:16 was saying that
00:15:17 we're not going
00:15:17 to do this.
00:15:18 And to be fair,
00:15:19 his press conference,
00:15:20 which I think you
00:15:21 watched,
00:15:21 Waleed,
00:15:21 was filled with lies,
00:15:23 pretty much.
00:15:24 He was saying that
00:15:25 taxpayers are going
00:15:27 to pay for this,
00:15:28 but look,
00:15:28 I was in the media
00:15:29 briefing with the
00:15:30 Alberta energy officials
00:15:31 and watched the
00:15:32 press conference,
00:15:32 and they repeated
00:15:34 over and over
00:15:34 and over and over
00:15:35 again,
00:15:36 in no way,
00:15:36 shape or form
00:15:37 will taxpayers
00:15:37 be paying for this.
00:15:39 They're just trying
00:15:39 to get it
00:15:40 to that office.
00:15:41 Alberta has
00:15:42 announced $14 million
00:15:46 for the application,
00:15:47 so taxpayers are
00:15:48 paying for it in a sense,
00:15:48 but I mean for the
00:15:49 actual pipeline.
00:15:50 They're just trying
00:15:51 to essentially get it
00:15:52 to the major
00:15:53 federal office there
00:15:55 that does the projects,
00:15:56 and then
00:15:57 taxpayers will not
00:15:59 be on the hook for it
00:15:59 because they expect
00:16:00 private investors
00:16:01 to step in
00:16:01 once it gets to that stage.
00:16:03 And in fact,
00:16:04 Smith said that
00:16:05 she expects
00:16:06 this project
00:16:07 to be on the list,
00:16:10 the second wave
00:16:11 of projects
00:16:11 that Carney's
00:16:12 expected to announce
00:16:14 in November there
00:16:14 at the Grey Cup.
00:16:16 And then I'll just
00:16:17 give a few data points
00:16:18 that are interesting
00:16:19 because while we're
00:16:20 talking about pipelines,
00:16:21 of course,
00:16:22 I referenced
00:16:23 earlier failed projects
00:16:25 a few minutes ago,
00:16:27 and some of them
00:16:28 include Energy East,
00:16:29 Northern Gateway,
00:16:30 Keystone XL.
00:16:31 Smith said
00:16:32 Canada's GDP
00:16:32 would be $55 billion
00:16:34 higher every single year
00:16:36 if these projects
00:16:37 went forward.
00:16:38 So if the federal government
00:16:39 didn't get in the way
00:16:40 on these projects,
00:16:41 our GDP would be
00:16:42 $55 billion higher
00:16:43 every single year.
00:16:45 And then
00:16:46 energy officials
00:16:47 in the media briefing,
00:16:48 they said
00:16:48 that $11.5 billion
00:16:50 of capital
00:16:51 has moved
00:16:52 from Canada
00:16:53 to the U.S.
00:16:54 over the last three months.
00:16:55 Three months,
00:16:55 $11.5 billion.
00:16:56 It's insane
00:16:57 because
00:16:58 unsurprisingly,
00:16:59 U.S. President Donald Trump
00:17:01 is making
00:17:02 a positive
00:17:03 investment environment
00:17:04 where projects
00:17:05 can be pitched
00:17:06 and built
00:17:06 and progress
00:17:08 quickly,
00:17:09 whereas in Canada
00:17:10 it takes years.
00:17:11 But I guess
00:17:12 I'll start with you,
00:17:13 Waleed,
00:17:13 because you kind of
00:17:14 watched EB here.
00:17:15 Yeah,
00:17:15 do you think
00:17:16 Smith was right 1.00
00:17:18 to be enthusiastic,
00:17:19 I guess,
00:17:20 about this project
00:17:20 going forward,
00:17:21 or do you think
00:17:22 that it may not
00:17:23 even make it
00:17:23 to the starting line
00:17:24 as the Alberta
00:17:25 government wants it to?
00:17:26 Well,
00:17:26 I'll be very critical
00:17:28 in asking these questions
00:17:29 when Smith comes
00:17:30 to Ottawa this week,
00:17:32 a coming week,
00:17:32 actually,
00:17:33 he should be here.
00:17:33 for sure on Tuesday
00:17:34 and I'll be looking
00:17:35 at if I can catch up
00:17:37 with her
00:17:37 and ask her questions
00:17:38 about this,
00:17:39 this kind of
00:17:40 this triangular
00:17:40 dynamic of
00:17:42 BC, Alberta,
00:17:43 and Ottawa
00:17:44 and Ottawa
00:17:44 somehow being
00:17:45 in between.
00:17:46 I actually spoke
00:17:47 to Pierre Paliyev
00:17:48 and I got
00:17:49 a different question
00:17:50 out,
00:17:50 but before
00:17:51 having my question
00:17:52 asked,
00:17:53 I probably have
00:17:54 spoke about
00:17:54 this issue
00:17:55 on the BC,
00:17:56 Alberta conflict
00:17:57 journeys,
00:17:58 talking about
00:17:58 how Ottawa
00:17:59 itself should be
00:18:00 getting out of the way.
00:18:01 now,
00:18:02 in this case,
00:18:03 I think
00:18:03 Smith,
00:18:06 and I'm not sure
00:18:07 why,
00:18:07 has shown
00:18:08 some sort of
00:18:09 hopeful feeling
00:18:11 after a meeting
00:18:12 she had with Connie
00:18:13 at some point
00:18:13 in time.
00:18:14 I think she
00:18:14 had her hopes up.
00:18:16 I think she's trying
00:18:16 to, you know,
00:18:17 give some optimism
00:18:19 to her base
00:18:19 that something
00:18:20 will be moving forward
00:18:21 because, look,
00:18:21 whether it's Ottawa's
00:18:22 fault or her fault,
00:18:23 no pipeline means
00:18:24 no jobs,
00:18:25 no means,
00:18:25 no economic growth.
00:18:27 It simply
00:18:28 just demoralizes
00:18:29 Albertans further.
00:18:31 Essentially,
00:18:32 what I'm seeing
00:18:33 is this dynamic
00:18:33 of BC versus
00:18:34 Alberta.
00:18:35 I'm looking at,
00:18:36 you know,
00:18:36 Ottawa essentially
00:18:37 has a referee
00:18:37 position in this case.
00:18:39 Ottawa will lean
00:18:40 towards Alberta
00:18:40 because she's been
00:18:41 more optimistic.
00:18:43 I mean,
00:18:43 you remember
00:18:43 the whole first
00:18:44 ministers meeting
00:18:46 back, I think,
00:18:46 over the summer
00:18:47 in June?
00:18:48 You had
00:18:48 Eby in Tokyo
00:18:49 promoting, like,
00:18:52 BC-made chips
00:18:53 and snacks
00:18:54 in some random
00:18:55 grocery store
00:18:56 in Japan
00:18:57 while the first
00:18:59 ministers,
00:18:59 every other premier
00:19:00 was meeting
00:19:00 with Carney
00:19:01 on the roundtable
00:19:02 talking about everything.
00:19:03 So I guess
00:19:04 what I'm trying to say
00:19:05 is somehow
00:19:06 Smith might just
00:19:07 have a better
00:19:08 phone with Carney
00:19:09 than even
00:19:10 Eby is concerned.
00:19:12 And perhaps
00:19:13 there might be
00:19:13 something there,
00:19:14 but for now
00:19:14 there is no evidence
00:19:15 of that.
00:19:15 So I'm going to be
00:19:16 catching up
00:19:17 with Smith's thing.
00:19:18 She's a bit optimistic
00:19:19 about Ottawa recently,
00:19:20 even though the track
00:19:21 record has been
00:19:21 very bad on oil
00:19:22 and natural resource
00:19:23 investment
00:19:23 and exactly what
00:19:25 she's seen
00:19:28 from Carney
00:19:28 that leads her 0.89
00:19:29 to believe
00:19:29 that Ottawa
00:19:30 will have her back
00:19:31 when it comes
00:19:31 to this specific
00:19:32 project proposal
00:19:33 of the West Coast
00:19:34 Pipeline.
00:19:34 It has to go
00:19:35 through the NDP
00:19:36 province.
00:19:38 Yeah, and Jeff,
00:19:38 something I forgot
00:19:39 to mention
00:19:40 about this announcement
00:19:42 and this project
00:19:44 was Alberta
00:19:45 had a lot of focus
00:19:47 on the Indigenous
00:19:48 aspect of this project,
00:19:50 how Indigenous
00:19:51 will be co-owners
00:19:52 and they're basically
00:19:54 trying to partner
00:19:54 with them
00:19:55 from the start
00:19:56 because essentially
00:19:58 this pipeline
00:19:59 will have to run
00:19:59 through various
00:20:00 reserves.
00:20:01 So they basically
00:20:02 need the Indigenous 1.00
00:20:03 leaders to
00:20:04 approve it basically
00:20:06 because they could,
00:20:07 not just the federal
00:20:08 government being a hurdle,
00:20:09 but the Indigenous
00:20:10 tribes could similarly
00:20:11 be a hurdle.
00:20:12 So do you think
00:20:12 that that is cause
00:20:14 for concern, Jeff?
00:20:15 Because obviously
00:20:16 Smith, as I said,
00:20:18 was very enthusiastic
00:20:19 and some of the chiefs
00:20:20 have already pledged
00:20:22 their support
00:20:22 for this pipeline,
00:20:23 but of course
00:20:24 we don't know
00:20:25 the exact route yet,
00:20:26 so it's hard to say
00:20:28 which tribes
00:20:29 will be involved
00:20:31 and whether they'll
00:20:33 all have to approve it.
00:20:33 Do you think that's
00:20:34 something that's likely
00:20:35 in your eyes?
00:20:37 Well, I mean,
00:20:37 I don't know
00:20:39 exactly what they're
00:20:41 talking about
00:20:41 behind the scenes
00:20:42 and stuff like that,
00:20:43 but it kind of ties
00:20:44 into what I was saying
00:20:45 before earlier
00:20:45 where I'd love to see
00:20:47 more focus on projects
00:20:48 where the Canadian
00:20:49 government worked
00:20:49 with First Nations
00:20:50 to achieve a positive result.
00:20:52 And in my opinion,
00:20:53 what would be
00:20:54 a more positive result
00:20:54 than making all Canadians 0.95
00:20:56 a little bit richer, right?
00:20:57 Because whatever
00:20:59 your opposition is
00:21:00 to the pipeline,
00:21:00 if it's like an environmental
00:21:01 one or something like that,
00:21:02 if you are richer,
00:21:04 if you have more wealth,
00:21:05 you can put that wealth
00:21:06 towards environmental causes.
00:21:08 You can put it towards
00:21:08 whatever you believe in
00:21:10 that you think
00:21:10 is going to strengthen
00:21:12 the country
00:21:12 and make the world
00:21:13 a better place
00:21:14 and all that kind of stuff.
00:21:15 And also,
00:21:16 I know a couple guys
00:21:17 up in the oil pipelines
00:21:19 up in like Fort McMurray
00:21:20 and stuff like that.
00:21:20 And they've shown me
00:21:22 the pictures of these sites
00:21:23 once they've laid pipelines
00:21:24 and stuff like that.
00:21:24 It's like pristine.
00:21:26 There's so much red tape
00:21:26 that they have to go through
00:21:27 to actually get this stuff done
00:21:28 that they can't leave behind
00:21:30 this kind of like,
00:21:31 you know,
00:21:32 what you'd imagine
00:21:33 based off of the way
00:21:34 that these things
00:21:35 are talked about,
00:21:35 like this wasteland
00:21:37 of like oil,
00:21:38 you know,
00:21:38 like wildlife,
00:21:40 you know,
00:21:40 struggling to get out
00:21:41 of pools of raw oil
00:21:43 and stuff like that.
00:21:43 No,
00:21:43 it's like this beautiful green
00:21:45 scene that's left behind
00:21:48 once they're done.
00:21:48 So,
00:21:49 you know,
00:21:49 again,
00:21:50 I am always in favor
00:21:52 of Canadians
00:21:53 being more rich.
00:21:54 I'm always in favor
00:21:55 of Canadians
00:21:55 accomplishing projects
00:21:57 that is going to
00:21:58 improve our bottom line.
00:22:00 And this is good
00:22:01 for Canadians.
00:22:02 This is good
00:22:02 for the Indigenous
00:22:03 First Nations.
00:22:04 So,
00:22:04 you know,
00:22:04 I know there have
00:22:06 historically been
00:22:07 a lot of pushback
00:22:08 on these types of projects,
00:22:09 but I certainly hope
00:22:11 that with Daniel Smith's
00:22:13 enthusiasm that
00:22:15 indicates that
00:22:17 these First Nations
00:22:18 groups are on board
00:22:20 and that this can be
00:22:22 looked back on
00:22:23 as a successful
00:22:23 operation between
00:22:25 the Canadian government
00:22:25 and First Nations groups
00:22:27 to,
00:22:27 like I said,
00:22:28 make all Canadians
00:22:28 wealthier.
00:22:30 Yeah,
00:22:30 at the root of the
00:22:31 environmental concerns,
00:22:33 let's say,
00:22:34 is a lie,
00:22:34 of course,
00:22:35 and to be fair,
00:22:37 at the root of many
00:22:37 left-wing,
00:22:39 even most left-wing
00:22:40 arguments,
00:22:40 are lies
00:22:41 because,
00:22:41 of course,
00:22:42 this oil has to
00:22:43 come from somewhere.
00:22:44 We have the cleanest
00:22:45 oil in the world,
00:22:45 so if you build
00:22:46 this pipeline,
00:22:47 you are helping
00:22:48 the world
00:22:48 on an energy
00:22:50 perspective.
00:22:51 Emissions will go down
00:22:52 because the alternative
00:22:53 is getting coal
00:22:54 from China.
00:22:55 I mean,
00:22:55 what are we talking
00:22:56 about,
00:22:56 right?
00:22:57 So,
00:22:58 you know,
00:22:58 the oil has to
00:22:59 come from somewhere.
00:23:01 The left's,
00:23:01 like,
00:23:01 whole MO
00:23:02 is kind of being,
00:23:03 you know,
00:23:04 having grievances
00:23:04 and being victims
00:23:05 of this or that,
00:23:06 right?
00:23:06 And so,
00:23:07 you know,
00:23:07 a lot of their careers
00:23:08 are tied in with it
00:23:08 as well.
00:23:09 So,
00:23:09 of course,
00:23:09 they're going to keep
00:23:10 kind of pushing
00:23:10 those types of narratives
00:23:11 because it literally
00:23:12 puts food on their place.
00:23:14 And that's something
00:23:15 that I,
00:23:15 you know,
00:23:16 I worry about
00:23:17 with the future
00:23:18 where it is,
00:23:18 you know,
00:23:19 how I was saying earlier
00:23:19 is there going to be
00:23:20 an end game
00:23:21 to this truth
00:23:21 and reconciliation?
00:23:22 Like,
00:23:22 are we actually
00:23:23 going to reconcile
00:23:23 at the end of it?
00:23:25 And it's hard to kind
00:23:25 of see it going
00:23:26 in that direction
00:23:27 when people are
00:23:28 literally making
00:23:28 their livings
00:23:29 based off of it
00:23:30 not going in that direction.
00:23:32 Yeah,
00:23:33 it makes sense.
00:23:33 A lot of people
00:23:34 would be out of work
00:23:35 if these issues
00:23:37 were resolved,
00:23:38 right?
00:23:38 So,
00:23:39 then you have to
00:23:40 keep the issues going.
00:23:41 Otherwise,
00:23:41 you literally
00:23:42 don't have a job
00:23:43 or even a career
00:23:44 in some senses,
00:23:46 especially when it comes
00:23:47 to environmentalism.
00:23:48 Yeah,
00:23:48 it's like how some people
00:23:49 say that,
00:23:50 you know,
00:23:50 they won't cure cancer
00:23:51 because the money's
00:23:52 in the treatment
00:23:52 rather than the cure,
00:23:53 right?
00:23:54 It's kind of the same
00:23:55 idea here.
00:23:55 speaking of jobs,
00:23:59 we'll move over to
00:24:00 the Alberta teachers.
00:24:02 Just,
00:24:03 I'll try and get through
00:24:05 this without getting
00:24:07 too angry,
00:24:07 but this is
00:24:08 absolute insanity
00:24:10 coming out of Alberta
00:24:11 because Alberta
00:24:12 teachers are going
00:24:13 to walk off the job
00:24:15 on October 6th
00:24:16 after almost 90%,
00:24:18 89.5% of teachers
00:24:20 voted against
00:24:21 the settlement
00:24:22 with Alberta
00:24:23 despite the government
00:24:24 not only giving them
00:24:26 everything they asked for
00:24:27 but more.
00:24:28 I mean,
00:24:28 this is absolutely
00:24:29 insanity.
00:24:30 I can't even
00:24:31 just,
00:24:32 I've been going
00:24:33 through this for a while,
00:24:33 but I just can't even
00:24:34 comprehend the level
00:24:35 of indoctrination
00:24:36 happening with the unions
00:24:37 to these teachers
00:24:38 because they all seem
00:24:39 to have completely
00:24:40 lost the plot.
00:24:42 just getting into
00:24:43 what they were offered,
00:24:46 I mean,
00:24:47 it's insane.
00:24:49 So yeah,
00:24:50 of course,
00:24:50 the Alberta government
00:24:51 offered to hire
00:24:52 3,000 new teachers,
00:24:53 1,500 new educational
00:24:55 assistants,
00:24:55 a 12% wage increase
00:24:57 over four years,
00:24:58 but it's actually
00:24:58 a 17% wage increase
00:25:01 for more than 95%
00:25:02 of the teachers.
00:25:04 And the CTF,
00:25:06 they've done a really
00:25:07 good job
00:25:07 breaking it down.
00:25:09 They had a Facebook
00:25:10 post there and it kind
00:25:12 of broke it down.
00:25:13 I mean,
00:25:13 look,
00:25:14 I'm going off memory
00:25:16 because I don't have
00:25:16 the post in front of me,
00:25:17 but a first year teacher
00:25:18 is making like 70 grand.
00:25:19 Then less than 10 years,
00:25:20 it was,
00:25:21 you're up to like 110 grand.
00:25:23 The top scale teacher
00:25:24 is making like 115 grand
00:25:26 a year.
00:25:27 This is healthcare,
00:25:28 defined pension,
00:25:30 benefits,
00:25:31 summer's off.
00:25:32 I mean,
00:25:33 the list goes on.
00:25:34 It's hardly
00:25:34 that they're struggling here.
00:25:36 And the premier
00:25:37 and the officials
00:25:39 at the Alberta government
00:25:39 were saying,
00:25:40 this raise
00:25:41 would have made them
00:25:41 the highest paid teacher
00:25:42 in Western Canada,
00:25:43 saying,
00:25:44 of course,
00:25:44 that it's higher
00:25:45 than even in BC
00:25:45 where the cost of living
00:25:48 is like five times higher.
00:25:49 So you're getting paid more.
00:25:51 And I don't,
00:25:53 I don't really,
00:25:53 I just,
00:25:55 it's hard.
00:25:55 Yeah.
00:25:56 Have you guys been paying
00:25:57 attention to the teacher strike?
00:25:59 Waleed,
00:25:59 I know you want to move
00:26:01 to Alberta.
00:26:01 Have you been looking
00:26:03 at that news at all?
00:26:04 Well,
00:26:04 I know viewers always
00:26:06 see the flag behind my head,
00:26:07 but it's typically
00:26:07 more of a symbolic gesture
00:26:08 from a distance.
00:26:10 I'm not really looking
00:26:11 at moving Alberta
00:26:11 in the immediate future
00:26:12 because honestly,
00:26:13 it's such a big move
00:26:14 and,
00:26:15 you know,
00:26:15 to the hour difference
00:26:16 time zone.
00:26:17 I think Eastern Time
00:26:17 is what rules the world.
00:26:19 And obviously,
00:26:20 Ontario still has,
00:26:21 you know,
00:26:22 something interesting about it.
00:26:23 But I will say
00:26:24 on the terms
00:26:25 of the teacher strikes,
00:26:27 I find teacher unions 0.85
00:26:28 to be some of the most
00:26:29 hostile to the public
00:26:32 interest unions
00:26:34 that we have out there
00:26:35 because they really are
00:26:36 just leveraging the fact
00:26:37 that they're providing
00:26:39 some form of daycare
00:26:40 for children
00:26:41 and they're providing
00:26:42 some sort of education
00:26:43 that's something
00:26:43 that our society
00:26:44 values very much.
00:26:45 I don't think
00:26:46 there's ever been
00:26:46 this argument
00:26:47 of defunding education
00:26:48 at effectively any level
00:26:49 for at least
00:26:51 mainstream society.
00:26:52 people really buy
00:26:53 into the fact
00:26:53 they want to have
00:26:54 their kids in schools
00:26:55 and public schools
00:26:56 for the most part.
00:26:58 And I just find
00:26:58 the fact that,
00:26:59 you know,
00:27:00 the students keep asking
00:27:01 for more and more money,
00:27:02 more and more salary
00:27:03 while leaving our kids
00:27:05 behind day after day
00:27:06 because I'm assuming
00:27:06 the strike will,
00:27:07 you know,
00:27:08 essentially cease operations.
00:27:09 I remember in our school
00:27:10 as well,
00:27:11 when I was growing up
00:27:11 in Ontario,
00:27:12 that, you know,
00:27:13 that meant we lost
00:27:14 some of our sports seasons
00:27:15 because teachers
00:27:16 were complaining about
00:27:16 how they were spending
00:27:17 an extra hour or two
00:27:18 after school
00:27:19 without paying
00:27:20 to coach that sport
00:27:22 or whatever.
00:27:23 So, I mean,
00:27:23 I guess the spirit
00:27:24 of volunteerism
00:27:25 is kind of gone
00:27:26 out of the window
00:27:27 there as well.
00:27:28 But I find
00:27:29 that teacher unions
00:27:30 are really just weaponizing
00:27:32 the vulnerable situation
00:27:34 that parents have
00:27:35 where they just need
00:27:36 child care
00:27:37 for the eight to two
00:27:38 or eight to three
00:27:39 and a little bit before,
00:27:41 a little bit after.
00:27:42 And then, of course,
00:27:43 hopefully a half-decent education.
00:27:46 I don't know,
00:27:46 maybe the school,
00:27:47 maybe they should just
00:27:48 contract the drag queens 1.00
00:27:49 to cover up a bit more
00:27:50 because, I mean,
00:27:51 that's already a big element
00:27:53 of education these days.
00:27:54 You just can't get rid
00:27:55 of the drag queens 0.85
00:27:56 story hour scenes
00:27:57 anywhere,
00:27:58 let alone even
00:27:59 in the most conservative
00:28:00 province of Alberta.
00:28:01 So, it's quite interesting,
00:28:03 frankly.
00:28:03 But I hope that they can get
00:28:05 a resolution to the table
00:28:06 and hopefully,
00:28:07 let's just say,
00:28:08 for the future outlook,
00:28:10 we can have a system
00:28:11 where the unions
00:28:12 have a little bit less power
00:28:13 over the public
00:28:14 because it's a little bit
00:28:16 too much.
00:28:17 Yeah, Jeff,
00:28:17 obviously hard to deny
00:28:20 that the unions
00:28:20 don't really care
00:28:21 about what happens
00:28:22 to kids at this point.
00:28:24 They're pretty much
00:28:25 just being selfish.
00:28:26 But the Alberta government
00:28:27 does and, in fact,
00:28:29 will provide $150
00:28:30 per week to students
00:28:32 with, sorry,
00:28:34 to parents of students
00:28:35 with that being students
00:28:38 aged 12 or less
00:28:39 that go to public,
00:28:41 separate,
00:28:41 or Francophone schools
00:28:42 and are affected
00:28:43 by the strike.
00:28:43 And then they also,
00:28:46 the Alberta government,
00:28:47 they released a parent toolkit
00:28:50 in both French and English.
00:28:52 So, it's basically
00:28:52 just online learning
00:28:53 because it will go
00:28:54 through the curriculum
00:28:55 for them.
00:28:56 So, what do you think
00:28:58 of the package
00:28:59 that the Alberta government
00:29:00 is giving here?
00:29:01 Is it enough?
00:29:02 And, I mean,
00:29:04 unsurprisingly,
00:29:05 the teachers in the union
00:29:06 aren't doing this.
00:29:07 The government
00:29:08 is literally stepping in
00:29:09 to teach kids here.
00:29:11 So, yeah,
00:29:11 what do you think?
00:29:13 I mean,
00:29:13 I've got pretty
00:29:14 complicated feelings
00:29:15 about the teachers union
00:29:16 and their relationship
00:29:17 with students in general.
00:29:18 Like, it seems like
00:29:20 over the last few years
00:29:21 there's this weird
00:29:21 culture of secrecy
00:29:23 between parents
00:29:24 and teachers.
00:29:25 As for whether
00:29:25 the money is enough
00:29:27 or not,
00:29:27 I mean,
00:29:28 I think the real issue
00:29:29 for parents
00:29:30 is going to be
00:29:31 daycare
00:29:32 for having,
00:29:34 you know,
00:29:34 now they have to
00:29:35 take care of these kids
00:29:35 who can't be left
00:29:36 at home alone
00:29:37 and a lot of parents
00:29:38 aren't able to be
00:29:38 home all day.
00:29:40 So, you know,
00:29:41 I don't think
00:29:42 $150 a week
00:29:43 does cover daycare.
00:29:44 From what I've heard,
00:29:44 daycare expenses
00:29:45 are quite high.
00:29:46 And so I think
00:29:47 this is going to create
00:29:48 a financial issue
00:29:49 for a lot of parents
00:29:49 for sure.
00:29:51 Yeah,
00:29:52 and just getting
00:29:52 into a few more things,
00:29:54 you touched on one of them,
00:29:55 but the premier did say
00:29:57 that the province
00:29:58 is spending
00:29:59 $8.6 billion
00:30:00 in new school construction
00:30:02 to build 130 new schools,
00:30:04 which would add
00:30:05 200,000 spaces
00:30:06 for students
00:30:07 by 2030.
00:30:07 because,
00:30:09 look,
00:30:10 the issue here
00:30:10 is obvious.
00:30:11 There's way too many
00:30:12 people immigrating
00:30:14 to Alberta.
00:30:15 Smith said
00:30:15 that over the last
00:30:17 three years,
00:30:17 80,000 new students.
00:30:19 So this is the problem.
00:30:19 The teachers are complaining
00:30:21 that their classes
00:30:22 are too big.
00:30:22 Well,
00:30:23 it's like,
00:30:23 what do you think
00:30:24 caused that?
00:30:25 It's not from
00:30:26 Albertans having children.
00:30:28 We've seen the birth rates.
00:30:29 It definitely is not that.
00:30:30 It's because
00:30:31 people are immigrating here,
00:30:32 not just from
00:30:33 other countries
00:30:35 and continents,
00:30:36 but from Canada
00:30:37 because Alberta
00:30:38 has led the country
00:30:40 in interprovincial migration
00:30:41 time and again
00:30:42 because our cost of living
00:30:43 is so low
00:30:44 and you can actually
00:30:45 make money here
00:30:45 that you can live with.
00:30:50 And then,
00:30:51 I don't know if I said this,
00:30:52 but again,
00:30:53 the two agreements
00:30:57 that the unions denied,
00:31:00 like,
00:31:00 they were literally accepted
00:31:01 among the Alberta
00:31:02 Teachers Association
00:31:03 and the TEBA.
00:31:04 I mean,
00:31:05 I don't understand this at all.
00:31:06 They got everything
00:31:07 they asked for
00:31:08 and then the teachers
00:31:08 voted against it.
00:31:09 So like I said,
00:31:10 the indoctrination going on,
00:31:11 I can't imagine
00:31:12 what it is.
00:31:13 But look,
00:31:15 some of the teachers
00:31:15 are really close
00:31:16 to figuring out
00:31:17 what the real problem is
00:31:17 because they're talking
00:31:18 about how big,
00:31:19 how overflowed
00:31:20 their classrooms are
00:31:20 and it's like,
00:31:21 hmm,
00:31:21 I don't think it's funding
00:31:23 that's the issue here.
00:31:24 I think it's the fact
00:31:25 that 100,000 kids
00:31:26 came in three years.
00:31:28 That's what Smith said.
00:31:29 Look,
00:31:30 you can't build new schools
00:31:31 out of thin air.
00:31:32 They don't just appear
00:31:33 out of nowhere.
00:31:33 Even when you're investing
00:31:35 billions into them,
00:31:36 which the province is,
00:31:37 it takes time
00:31:38 to build schools.
00:31:40 Obviously,
00:31:41 you can't just
00:31:41 3D print a school.
00:31:44 That's what we need, eh?
00:31:45 If you could 3D print schools,
00:31:46 we wouldn't have this problem,
00:31:47 eh, guys?
00:31:48 There's such a focus
00:31:50 on how we need
00:31:51 so much more immigration
00:31:52 to, like,
00:31:52 replace our dwindling population,
00:31:54 I guess,
00:31:55 as it ages,
00:31:56 but no focus on
00:31:57 if we actually have
00:31:58 the facilities able
00:31:59 to support
00:31:59 this many people coming in,
00:32:01 which we clearly don't.
00:32:03 So,
00:32:03 it's kind of a mess
00:32:04 in more areas
00:32:05 than just the school system,
00:32:07 that's for sure.
00:32:07 Yeah,
00:32:07 no,
00:32:08 we always focus on that
00:32:09 with healthcare,
00:32:09 but then we forget about,
00:32:11 oh,
00:32:11 the schools are overflowing,
00:32:12 too.
00:32:12 Well,
00:32:13 surprise,
00:32:13 surprise,
00:32:14 especially when we have
00:32:15 some families
00:32:16 coming in here
00:32:17 where they don't have,
00:32:19 they're from countries
00:32:20 without birth rates
00:32:21 of 1.2
00:32:22 or whatever ours is,
00:32:23 and they have actually
00:32:24 eight kids,
00:32:24 and it's like,
00:32:25 oh,
00:32:25 where do you think
00:32:26 school, right?
00:32:29 Absolutely.
00:32:30 I think it was back
00:32:31 in my class
00:32:32 when I was in the,
00:32:33 well,
00:32:34 frankly,
00:32:34 from the 6th
00:32:35 to the 8th grade,
00:32:35 so my end of my
00:32:36 elementary school career
00:32:37 was when we had
00:32:38 about five students,
00:32:40 and this was back
00:32:41 in the,
00:32:42 you know,
00:32:42 this was after
00:32:43 the war
00:32:44 in Afghanistan,
00:32:46 so this was
00:32:47 around the time
00:32:47 when we were receiving
00:32:48 a lot of Afghan refugees
00:32:49 in Canada.
00:32:50 Five kids came up
00:32:51 in,
00:32:52 like,
00:32:52 just into my class
00:32:53 from 24 the previous year
00:32:56 to about almost 30,
00:32:57 adding two exchange students
00:32:59 from Colombia as well,
00:33:00 so it's a very interesting
00:33:02 situation
00:33:02 where we see
00:33:03 the population growth,
00:33:05 even in areas
00:33:06 where there haven't been
00:33:07 that massive population growth.
00:33:09 I mean,
00:33:09 I feel like there's been
00:33:09 probably be
00:33:10 greater rates of mass migration
00:33:12 in Canada's
00:33:12 other major cities
00:33:13 and urban areas
00:33:14 besides just the east
00:33:15 end of Ottawa
00:33:16 where I was at the time,
00:33:17 but when you're seeing
00:33:18 classrooms get to the size
00:33:19 30,
00:33:20 31,
00:33:20 32 kids,
00:33:22 you know,
00:33:22 with the same amount
00:33:22 of teachers,
00:33:23 same amount of resources,
00:33:24 same amount of textbooks,
00:33:25 and you're having to share
00:33:25 more and more
00:33:26 across the table,
00:33:27 we also had a lot of,
00:33:29 I think we had a total
00:33:29 of about 14 or 15 portables,
00:33:33 portable classrooms
00:33:34 on the outdoors
00:33:34 because we had displaced
00:33:35 some of the younger kids,
00:33:37 3,
00:33:38 4,
00:33:39 5th,
00:33:39 6th grade,
00:33:40 and put them in portables
00:33:41 so that we had more
00:33:43 classroom space
00:33:43 because of that increase
00:33:45 of size as well.
00:33:46 So,
00:33:47 you know,
00:33:47 I mean,
00:33:48 I wasn't personally
00:33:49 that much against portables.
00:33:51 I kind of think it was
00:33:51 a pretty good idea
00:33:53 in terms of expanding
00:33:53 the school without having
00:33:54 to build a new one,
00:33:55 but with 14,
00:33:57 15 different portables,
00:33:58 it kind of becomes
00:33:59 a bit of an absurd scene
00:34:00 where a lot of what was
00:34:02 formerly outdoor yard space
00:34:04 for us to play
00:34:04 and get active
00:34:05 and play tag
00:34:06 now became a bunch
00:34:07 of these,
00:34:08 you know,
00:34:08 buildings propped
00:34:09 onto the ground
00:34:09 and,
00:34:10 you know,
00:34:10 the whole school
00:34:12 becomes,
00:34:13 you know,
00:34:14 a mess
00:34:15 when that many kids,
00:34:17 you know,
00:34:17 it's not meant
00:34:18 to be a university.
00:34:19 It's meant to be
00:34:20 a elementary school
00:34:21 to serve its local community
00:34:22 and not meant
00:34:23 to serve the globe,
00:34:24 unfortunately,
00:34:25 although,
00:34:26 of course,
00:34:26 immigration is a big part
00:34:27 of our legacy.
00:34:28 I just think we've gone
00:34:30 beyond the means
00:34:31 of what we can afford.
00:34:34 Well beyond.
00:34:36 And yeah,
00:34:36 I mean,
00:34:37 look,
00:34:37 we'll see how long
00:34:38 this strike lasts for.
00:34:39 I'm generally in favor
00:34:41 of privatizing everything.
00:34:42 It's not so simple
00:34:44 with schools,
00:34:45 especially elementary schools
00:34:47 and stuff.
00:34:47 It's a topic
00:34:49 we could probably talk
00:34:50 for hours alone on.
00:34:52 But instead of doing that,
00:34:54 I think it's best
00:34:55 to just wrap up the show
00:34:56 and remember,
00:34:57 everything you heard today
00:34:58 was off the record.
00:34:59 I was there
00:35:04 yesterday morning
00:35:04 on the hill
00:35:05 on the outside.
00:35:06 I got in
00:35:07 past deployment security
00:35:08 when they stopped me
00:35:09 for a few minutes
00:35:10 and then former colleague
00:35:11 MP,
00:35:12 Andrew Lawton,
00:35:13 helped me up
00:35:13 to the stairs
00:35:14 so I can get past
00:35:15 that blockade
00:35:16 of the potential
00:35:18 censorship,
00:35:19 frankly.
00:35:19 But anyhow,
00:35:20 not to be petty about it
00:35:21 because all the guys
00:35:22 were pretty nice
00:35:23 with me
00:35:23 and as per usual,
00:35:27 I asked a question
00:35:28 at the PRS press conference
00:35:30 that was on originally,
00:35:32 crime.
00:35:33 The question I asked
00:35:34 was his stance
00:35:35 on the canola China
00:35:38 EV tariff situation.
00:35:40 Now,
00:35:40 I've heard that he's
00:35:41 vouched for support
00:35:43 to support the government
00:35:45 to support the farmers,
00:35:46 help them brace
00:35:47 the period of time
00:35:48 that they have to deal
00:35:48 with these China tariffs
00:35:49 and in fact,
00:35:50 that we will try not
00:35:51 not going to be purchasing
00:35:51 nearly as much canola.
00:35:53 You know,
00:35:54 you see big losses
00:35:54 in their very key industry
00:35:56 and that industry
00:35:57 is primarily key
00:35:58 in the West.
00:35:59 So you're talking
00:36:00 about Saskatchewan,
00:36:01 Alberta,
00:36:01 even Manitoba
00:36:02 and British Columbia
00:36:03 and so of course
00:36:04 those premiers
00:36:05 were advocating
00:36:05 and Premier Scott Moe
00:36:07 actually over the course
00:36:08 of the summer
00:36:08 was talking about,
00:36:10 you know,
00:36:10 urging the government
00:36:11 to drop those EV tariffs
00:36:13 because,
00:36:14 well,
00:36:14 in his view at the time,
00:36:15 well,
00:36:15 you know,
00:36:16 if we're going all
00:36:16 on this EV game
00:36:18 and we're tariffing
00:36:19 these EVs
00:36:20 that could possibly serve
00:36:21 at the marketplace
00:36:21 while also
00:36:23 causing some strain
00:36:25 with our relationship
00:36:26 with Beijing
00:36:26 to the point
00:36:27 where we wouldn't
00:36:27 be able to be
00:36:29 selling our canola,
00:36:30 well,
00:36:30 then it seems
00:36:31 like an easy trade-off.
00:36:32 Now,
00:36:32 since September,
00:36:34 I think mid last month,
00:36:35 he changed his posture
00:36:37 on that scenario.
00:36:39 He kind of explained
00:36:40 how it was a bit
00:36:40 more complicated
00:36:41 than what he previously thought.
00:36:43 so I guess
00:36:44 he's adjusted his tone.
00:36:46 Smith as well
00:36:46 previously
00:36:47 held the same view
00:36:47 as Moe
00:36:48 where she felt
00:36:49 that those tariffs
00:36:51 should be dropped
00:36:52 on Chinese EVs
00:36:53 allowing China 1.00
00:36:54 to flood the market
00:36:54 with cheap EVs
00:36:55 like BYD
00:36:56 and their models.
00:36:58 Very cheap devices,
00:36:59 by the way,
00:37:00 of course,
00:37:00 because they have
00:37:01 a completely unfair
00:37:01 practice of business.
00:37:03 And I guess
00:37:04 I wanted to know
00:37:05 what Polly Offsense 0.56
00:37:06 was on the,
00:37:07 first of all,
00:37:08 the EV tariffs themselves,
00:37:10 but then hear about
00:37:11 what he had to say
00:37:12 on trade
00:37:12 and he told me
00:37:14 that he wouldn't want
00:37:15 to drop the EV tariffs
00:37:17 that he would look
00:37:17 for alternative means
00:37:18 to support the canola farmers
00:37:20 but he just went on
00:37:21 on this rampage
00:37:22 on Cardi's trade record
00:37:23 where he just said
00:37:25 that Cardi should
00:37:26 lock himself
00:37:26 in a room somewhere
00:37:27 in Ottawa
00:37:28 and not leave
00:37:29 and not travel
00:37:30 not because he has
00:37:31 an issue with the travel
00:37:31 but because he has
00:37:32 an issue with the result.
00:37:33 Every time he gets
00:37:34 on a plane,
00:37:35 he went to London
00:37:36 or the UK twice
00:37:38 and the marketplace
00:37:40 is still blockaded
00:37:42 from Canadian meat production.
00:37:44 He went to Europe
00:37:45 and he got all these
00:37:46 MOIs,
00:37:50 no real deal,
00:37:51 no real legally binding deal.
00:37:54 So wherever he travels,
00:37:56 it seems that his results
00:37:57 according to Polly Off
00:37:58 are lackluster at best.
00:38:00 So I guess Polly Off's message
00:38:02 is to ground the plane,
00:38:03 stay at home
00:38:04 and better nothing
00:38:06 than what he's been giving
00:38:07 thus far.
00:38:09 Yeah, every time
00:38:09 he travels too,
00:38:10 he gives hundreds of millions
00:38:11 to some foreign agency
00:38:13 or government.
00:38:15 That's where we're at
00:38:16 in Canada.
00:38:17 No prime minister,
00:38:18 literally if we had
00:38:19 no prime minister,
00:38:20 we'd be better off
00:38:21 than with the one
00:38:22 we do have,
00:38:23 which every time
00:38:24 he leaves the office
00:38:25 basically puts us
00:38:26 in a worse position
00:38:27 than we were in,
00:38:28 which is essentially
00:38:28 what Polly Off
00:38:29 was saying there.