Juno News - March 17, 2025


BREAKING: Mark Carney sent daughter to discredited U.K. Tavistock Transgender Clinic

Mentioned
Carney's cringe factory tour Carney SNAPS at Liberal media

Episode Stats


Length

19 minutes

Words per minute

183.32

Word count

3,603

Sentence count

139

Harmful content

Misogyny

8

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

9

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Sasha Carney is a writer, a former student activist, and as the prime minister s daughter, one of four kids. She s had quite a public footprint, and we decided to investigate some of her writing. We found an essay in which she discusses gender dysphoria at a young age, and during that time, she went to therapy at the Tavistock Clinic. We are joined by the reporters who broke this story, Caitlin Durante and Alex Szoltan.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hi, I'm Candice Malcolm and this is The Candice Malcolm Show and we are breaking some news,
00:00:12 an exclusive story that just came out on Juneau News that Mark Carney, Canada's new Prime Minister,
00:00:18 sent his daughter, his eldest daughter, Sasha, to the Tavistock Clinic, the transgender clinic
00:00:24 in the uk for treatment with regards to gender dysphoria this happened when sasha was a teenager
00:00:31 she lived in the uk from age 13 to 17 and during that time she went to the tavistock clinic we are
00:00:39 joined today by the reporters who broke this story true north's cosmon jersey and alex zoltan
00:00:45 alex cosmon welcome to the show thanks candace thank you okay so i'll go to you first cosmon
00:00:51 Can you tell us about the story, what happened, how we found it, and tell us a little bit about the Tavistock Clinic for those who don't know.
00:00:59 Yeah, that's right. So Sasha Carney, who was born Sophia Carney, that's her birth name, is quite a public figure in her own right.
00:01:07 She's a writer, a former student activist, and as the prime minister's daughter, one of four kids, she's had quite a public footprint.
00:01:17 So we decided to investigate some of the things that she's written, and there's quite a lot of it.
00:01:23 And part of that was this essay in which she discusses transgender issues.
00:01:28 A lot of her writing is actually about LGBT and transgender issues.
00:01:32 But in this particular piece, she discusses how she went to therapy at the Tavistock Clinic.
00:01:38 And the Tavistock Clinic, for those who aren't familiar with it, was shuttered by the National Health Service in the United Kingdom
00:01:45 because of several exposés that revealed that clinicians were rushing children as young as six
00:01:53 years old and under into life-changing, life-altering gender transition treatments, as they 1.00
00:02:01 called it. And it was over 300 kids that were under six years old that were being pushed into
00:02:06 this type of medicalization based on this idea that they somehow had gender dysphoria at this
00:02:14 young age and it caused lawsuits and this is why this clinic was eventually shuttered and it
00:02:20 eventually led to the cast review which is that famous review that came out of the UK disproving
00:02:26 some of the claims that transgender community makes about the so-called effectiveness of this
00:02:32 treatment well it's it's really remarkable I mean you have to sort of feel bad for a person like
00:02:38 this I'm talking about Sasha because this was happening to her when she was a teenager and
00:02:43 you know, a parent's role in life is to help guide their children, particularly through some of the
00:02:48 most difficult issues that they face in their teenage years. And so I mentioned off the top
00:02:52 that Sasha lived in the UK with her dad when Mark Carney went to take that job for the governor of
00:02:58 Bank of England. She was a teenager. We found that information because she has, like you said,
00:03:03 she's a writer, she's a prolific writer, and she's been receiving a lot of publicity. So you can go
00:03:09 back to when she was 13 years old, she was writing short stories. And there was a profile of her on
00:03:16 an Ottawa blog that mentioned that she was 13 years old. And at that point, she was still going
00:03:20 by Sophia, that she moved to the UK. And by the time she started at Yale University in 2017, when
00:03:26 she was 17 or 18 years old, at that point, she was already going by Sasha. Alex, why don't you talk a
00:03:32 little bit about the specific essay that you found that she talks about the Tavistock Clinic? What
00:03:38 does she say? What does the essay tell us about this young woman? Yeah, so she speaks a lot about
00:03:46 not feeling trans enough, which I thought was really interesting. Clearly, you know, a young 1.00
00:03:52 person going through identity issues. Yeah, it's quite, it's a very short essay. It's only, you
00:03:58 know, a couple of pages long. But as Cosmin had mentioned, she does have a really prolific
00:04:03 online presence. And so there's a lot of other information out there. She's very political,
00:04:08 which kind of adds to the mystique and intrigue of why she isn't a part of Carney's campaign,
00:04:15 like his other daughters. And I think that's kind of interesting as well.
00:04:19 Well, you mentioned it. So the youngest daughter, Cleo, people might recognize her because she was
00:04:25 the one that was out introducing her father at the liberal convention. You can see her on the
00:04:29 screen there. She is a first-year university student, a freshman at Harvard. Obviously a
00:04:35 super impressive young woman. She spoke very eloquently. You saw how proud she is of her dad
00:04:40 and it kind of gives you like a warm feeling of like what a lovely family, like look at this
00:04:44 daughter, they must be so proud of her. And she also earlier appeared in a campaign ad for Mark
00:04:50 Carney just talking about why she thinks that her dad will be a great prime minister. She's sort of
00:04:56 an influencer in her own right, and she's involved in a lot of left-wing environmentalists advocacy
00:05:01 as well. But in light of the story about Sasha that we now know, it's like, you know, they have
00:05:07 this one daughter that they're putting out in front of the campaign to try to focus attention
00:05:11 over here. And then you realize this other story about their other daughter. And it is kind of sad.
00:05:17 I want to point to this essay that was in Authenticity. We saw the headline of it. And one
00:05:24 the things i'll just read a passage from it um she writes that i watched as a friend after a year
00:05:31 of weekly appointments trying desperately to get an official diagnosis of gender dysphoria
00:05:36 was denied the diagnosis and with it any hope of top surgery because they sometimes wore skirts 0.85
00:05:43 so from that quote i sort of see that these young women are almost trying to game the system like 0.97
00:05:49 they go to therapy and they're trying to convince a therapist that they have gender dysphoria because
00:05:54 they want to get top surgery like a body altering surgery to make young women look more masculine 0.97
00:06:00 and more like boys i'll continue to read she said that i felt a fierce surge of jealousy every time
00:06:07 i walked into tavistock for therapy and saw patients turn left towards the medical spaces
00:06:13 i didn't feel trans enough to enter so judging from this passage it appears that she was there
00:06:21 for therapy obviously but that she wasn't on a pathway to being transitioned because she said
00:06:27 you know the other people turn left those are the ones that were getting to go to medical spaces for
00:06:31 like more trans people and that she was just going there for therapy and so to me that means that
00:06:38 either the the therapists or perhaps her parents weren't allowing her to go down that path but
00:06:43 yet they were still allowing her to go to tap suck and she mentioned earlier in the essay that she
00:06:46 lived a block away from it and so you have to wonder you know age 13 to 17 still very much 0.81
00:06:52 under the guide of your parents um that her mom and dad allowed her to do this allowed for this
00:06:57 to happen and um you know now we we see sasha continuing in public life she's a very prolific 0.99
00:07:05 writer as you mentioned she endorsed bernie sanders uh for president the sort of far left
00:07:09 democrat even though she's canadian i don't think she's american um cosmon what else has your
00:07:14 research found yeah in that essay she also discusses uh and advocates for child use of
00:07:22 puberty blockers she says that children have a right to puberty blockers have a right to hormone
00:07:29 therapy so it's very evident that that was her intention is was to go down the medical transition
00:07:35 route but as you pointed out perhaps it didn't look like that happened she was just there for
00:07:39 therapy. But on a larger scale, Mark Carney has never addressed this issue, what he thinks about
00:07:47 the transgender issue, whether biological men should be in women's spaces. He's made a brief
00:07:54 comment talking about it, you know, America's war on woke, and he's also, but he's never gotten
00:08:00 any further into that. And we need to know where Mark Carney stands on these issues,
00:08:04 because he's going to go up for an election he wasn't he's an elected yeah absolutely well we
00:08:10 have that clip so let's let's play this because this i did just to just to uh key it up key it up
00:08:14 to the viewer uh this is something that mark carney said that he's never been pressed on right he
00:08:19 comes out and he says the americans are fighting a war on woke we're going to continue to fight for
00:08:23 inclusivity which to me means that he is pro-woke like he is woke if he's opposed to the americans
00:08:29 fighting war and woke um then that would mean that he's probably but no journalist has been
00:08:33 able to ask him about this and this makes me wonder if this is the reason why true north and
00:08:38 juno news and other independent media outlets have not been allowed anywhere near mark carney
00:08:43 because they're worried that he might get pressed on this important issue that canadians do deserve
00:08:47 to know where does he stand on the trans issue does he believe that boys should get to play in
00:08:52 girl sports does he believe that children should be able to access life-altering medications and
00:08:57 surgeries like this is a huge topic right now and he hasn't answered so uh well let's let's
00:09:03 first show that clip that you're referring to cosmon there's a fever gripping america
00:09:09 and while it rages canadians will remain resolute and true to our values
00:09:16 while america engages in a war on woke canadians will continue to value inclusiveness
00:09:23 now it's interesting that he said that because that obviously stood out to all of us
00:09:27 And at the time, I thought maybe someone on his campaign had written the line, and it had kind of gone over poorly, so they never mentioned it again, because it almost seemed out of character for Mark Carney. He doesn't seem like a radical. He doesn't seem like a leftist. And yet he said that, and he didn't say anything else like that ever again. Like I said, the media never pressed him on it. But given this new information that's come to light about his own daughter, it does sort of say, okay, well, he is on that side. He does believe these things. He lived them in his own family and allowed this to happen with his daughter.
00:09:56 So obviously he is woke. What do you think, Alex?
00:10:01 Yeah, it seems like a very radical departure from the Trudeau liberal leadership because Trudeau never neglected an opportunity to put himself behind.
00:10:11 I'll just call it the rainbow agenda, I guess you could call it, whereas Mark Carney almost seems to be running away from it.
00:10:18 And this woke comment is really the only glimpse of what we might know about his actual opinions on the subject.
00:10:24 He's been very evasive. And so, you know, if Trudeau were in charge and Sophia was his daughter,
00:10:29 I feel like, you know, he would be using her as center stage for his political campaigning. So I
00:10:36 find this is kind of an interesting departure. Well, it's interesting, but I think that times
00:10:40 have changed. I really believe that most people in the West, most Canadians are not on board for
00:10:45 this kind of thing. Like they see it as an issue of fairness. I certainly do. I don't want little
00:10:49 boys playing sports against my daughters. I just don't want that. And when I go back to my own
00:10:54 childhood, like one of my best memories was playing sports. And being a girl, playing sports
00:11:00 is an opportunity that you only get because of girls leagues. And if all of a sudden you're
00:11:04 allowing boys to go in there, allowing boys to invade female spaces, like locker rooms, bathrooms, 1.00
00:11:09 even women's shelters and female prisons. I mean, we've seen all kinds of horrors happen
00:11:15 in those environments over the last decade. And I think enough people are saying like enough
00:11:19 with this stuff. It's not a good idea, particularly around children. Remember Danielle
00:11:23 Smith, premier of Alberta, banned this kind of, these kinds of things, puberty blockers and
00:11:30 surgeries for minors. And, you know, I think a lot of people were expecting like a huge blowback and
00:11:35 it just didn't happen because people want this. Like even people on the political left that I
00:11:39 talk to, they don't, they're not on board with this kind of thing. They think it's wrong,
00:11:42 particularly with children. And so maybe Mark Carney's just reading the political environment.
00:11:47 Now, just to disclose to the viewer, we don't, we're not reporting at all that Mark Carney's
00:11:52 daughter transitioned or that she took any kind of puberty blockers or pharmaceutical drugs or had
00:11:58 any kind of surgery. That's not confirmed at all. That's not what the story is. The story is simply
00:12:02 that she went to this gender clinic for therapy. She wrote about it in an essay and that that gender 0.99
00:12:08 clinic has since been closed due to completely unethical practices and whistleblowers basically
00:12:13 showing that young children were forced, were rushed into transition. So really interesting.
00:12:21 if you go through her bio as well, when she was attending Yale University, she was interviewed
00:12:26 for an article, I believe we have a picture of it here, that Yale University decided to give
00:12:33 students the option of identifying as non-binary. So Yale gives students three gender choices. And
00:12:41 Sasha Carney was quoted heavily in this piece, talking about herself as a transgender person
00:12:48 and um as being non-binary and so that is quite interesting and we also found a record of a
00:12:56 official name change so she she changed her name legally from Sophia Carney to Sasha Carney
00:13:04 in 2021 but we can tell by her writing that she went by the name Sasha Carney from a much younger
00:13:09 age but she legally did it interestingly that she did it in New York given that I believe she's a 1.00
00:13:14 a Canadian and a citizen of the UK, or maybe she's not a citizen of the UK, but she lived in UK for
00:13:19 high school, but she currently lives in Brooklyn. So, I mean, it sort of seems like she's having
00:13:25 some kind of an identity crisis. What do you think, Cosman? Yeah, but she's also a student
00:13:30 activist. From the pieces I've read of her time at Yale and at university, she was pretty much
00:13:37 pushing for these issues at the student level. And it's, it's, you know, we're talking about
00:13:43 Mark Carney, I think Mark Carney is attempting to portray himself as a conservative. And that's
00:13:49 why he won't touch this issue. And on the other hand, it's also the rabid nature of transgender 1.00
00:13:55 activists who would totally skewer him if he went in any other direction than the one they approve
00:14:03 of. And I doubt, yeah. Yeah. Well, I was going to say, including presumably his own daughter,
00:14:08 because she does seem to be quite an activist. Like some of the other positions that she advocated
00:14:13 for in these essays that she wrote, like the abolition of prisons, like all prisons, basically
00:14:18 all criminals should be allowed out on the street. Obviously this was in the context of like the
00:14:22 Black Lives Matter, like defund the police, but she went even further, right? Most people were 0.99
00:14:26 just saying, most radical leftists were just saying defund the police, but she was saying
00:14:30 and abolish all prisons. And like you said earlier, she advocates for children receiving
00:14:35 these life-altering pharmaceutical drugs and surgeries. You can continue, Cosme.
00:14:40 Yeah. And it's important to ask these questions. This is our prime minister and nobody else is
00:14:46 doing it. The legacy media refuses to ask him any tough questions or try to get his views about
00:14:52 anything other than what he wants to talk about. And Mark Carney has been totally silent on this
00:14:58 in terms of getting responses to us.
00:15:00 We've repeatedly tried to reach out to Mark Carney
00:15:03 to offer him an opportunity to explain himself
00:15:06 and to tell Canadians where he stands on these issues.
00:15:10 And he has refused every attempt.
00:15:12 He's thrown out our reporters.
00:15:14 He's thrown out other independent media reporters.
00:15:17 And, but this is our job.
00:15:19 This is the job of journalists
00:15:21 to look into the most powerful person in this country.
00:15:24 Well, and particularly his daughter.
00:15:26 And also of note, the story that we're talking about did happen when she was a teenager.
00:15:31 She was 13 to 17 when she was in the UK, and that is when she went to the Tavistock Clinic.
00:15:36 But she's now an adult.
00:15:37 She's a 24-year-old.
00:15:38 She lives in Brooklyn.
00:15:39 She's a public figure because she writes prolifically, including about personal details
00:15:43 of her own life.
00:15:44 So we're not pulling anything that's not already published in the public domain already.
00:15:51 Now, Alex, you reached out to Sasha Cartney.
00:15:53 Did she reply to you?
00:15:55 No, she did not.
00:15:56 and she's also removing some of her other socials as well so i think she's trying to
00:16:00 you know evade public scrutiny as is her right yeah i mean she's a she's a private citizen but
00:16:06 her her father is the prime minister of this country and i think that it's completely fair
00:16:11 game to ask him what his positions are given what happened with his own daughter and and interestingly
00:16:19 as well uh you know this is this is sort of an interesting thing she she says like in every
00:16:24 every time she's profiled every time she's interviewed she says that she goes by they them
00:16:28 pronouns but yet she's still referred to as mark carney's daughter so maybe maybe this is like my
00:16:34 own ignorance i don't quite understand like she considers herself non-binary but she still
00:16:41 considers herself to be mark carney's daughter um alex can you explain that to me no actually i can't
00:16:48 i was thinking about that last night as well i don't know if gender neutral folks go by daughter
00:16:53 or son right i mean what would you describe them as as a child i i don't know frankly sorry yeah i
00:17:01 don't know either cosmon do you know well i would assume the neutral term would be mark carney's
00:17:07 child but that's also like infantilizes it a little bit but uh yeah it's and there's not a
00:17:13 lot of clarity i i think there is a lot of confusion that comes across in her own writing
00:17:18 right, this need to meet society's standards, the standards that I guess the transgender 1.00
00:17:26 community has set for themselves. There is this expectation to go become medicalized and do the
00:17:34 full thing, have a full cross gender operation. I think most transgender people set that bar and
00:17:44 look at themselves and consider whether they're going that direction. But from her own writing,
00:17:49 it's a lot about, well, you know, am I trans enough? Am I meeting these expectations? But
00:17:54 it just goes to show how agenda driven and almost this like sort of like cult-like status the
00:18:03 transgender community has imposed on the people who have fallen into it. Yeah, it's so strange 1.00
00:18:09 because when I was reading about her as well I noticed the demand for they them pronouns but
00:18:15 then anytime I read about her like the CBC she won some poetry prize back in 2019 or she was
00:18:19 nominated for one and there's an article about her in the CBC and they refer to her as they
00:18:25 which as a reader I just get confused like I don't understand how a single person can be they
00:18:30 I know that they insist on she insists on using they them but it doesn't make sense from a written
00:18:36 perspective, which is why I noticed in our piece at Juno News, we still refer to her as she because
00:18:43 she's born a woman. And I think she is still a woman, just a confused one. Sadly, what a sad 0.99
00:18:49 story. I can't help but feel bad for this young woman. And I feel a little bit of like anger and
00:18:55 frustration at her parents for allowing this to happen to her. Well, Cosme and Alex, thanks so
00:19:00 much for joining us. Really appreciate you highlighting this, you spending the weekend
00:19:04 obviously researching and putting this information out so thanks so much for all your work thank you
00:19:11 candace thank you all right folks uh head on over to junonews.com you can see the full article and
00:19:16 i encourage you to subscribe to juno as well and help support independent journalists like cosman
00:19:22 and alex and all the work that they do at true north and candace malcolm this is the candace
00:19:26 malcolm show we'll be back again tomorrow with all the news updates we'll talk about mark carney
00:19:30 and his trip to europe his new cabinet him abolishing or at least saying he's getting rid
00:19:34 rid of the carbon taxes and much, much more. So we'll be back tomorrow with all the news.
00:19:38 Thank you and God bless.