Juno News - July 04, 2019


Britain versus Tommy Robinson: Day 1

Hosted by
Mentioned
Vetting and integrating immigrants will be an election issue Tommy Robinson found guilty. Andrew Lawton reports.

Episode Stats


Length

4 minutes

Words per minute

167.36

Word count

767

Sentence count

38

Harmful content

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In the first day of Tommy Robinson's new trial, the defense and prosecution argue that he was doing what any concerned citizen journalist would do: reporting on a critical issue facing the community of Huddersfield, England. And in reporting on that issue, he was subject to a reporting restriction.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 I'm outside the Old Bailey in downtown London, England, my third time coming to
00:00:12 this country for the very same reason to cover the ordeal that the legal system
00:00:16 in Britain is putting Tommy Robinson through. It stems back to a contempt of
00:00:22 court allegation against him for which he was convicted, jailed, then that was
00:00:27 overturned on appeal but then the Attorney General ordered a new trial on
00:00:31 it which brings us to what's happening this week. A two-day trial prosecuted by
00:00:36 a lawyer for the Attorney General basically that could put Tommy Robinson
00:00:41 back to jail again. What we saw emerge today in the first day of the trial was
00:00:45 the theme unfolding about the defense strategy and also the crown strategy in
00:00:50 prosecution. Tommy Robinson is saying two main things chief among them that he was
00:00:56 reporting. He was doing what any concerned citizen journalist would do,
00:01:00 bringing attention to a critical issue facing the community of Huddersfield and
00:01:04 that was the gang rape, the sex grooming gangs that existed in there that were
00:01:09 targeting young girls. And in reporting on this he was outside the courtroom hosting
00:01:13 that infamous live stream in which he filmed defendants who are now convicts
00:01:19 heading into the court. He said look I'm reporting but more importantly I wasn't
00:01:23 reporting on anything that wasn't in the public interest. His argument,
00:01:26 his lawyer's argument is that the public interest, the public domain, these things
00:01:32 are exempt from the contempt of court and the reporting restrictions that the
00:01:36 government is trying to claim here. So he was reporting on something in the
00:01:39 public domain, reporting in the public interest, but moreover Tommy said that he
00:01:43 has out of an abundance of caution gone through a number of what were called
00:01:47 checks, verifications to ensure that there wasn't a reporting restriction that
00:01:53 would impact him. And we heard a few key ways where he said he did this. Number one,
00:01:57 he went in and asked a security guard, this is not in dispute. Number two, he looked at
00:02:02 the court website, it did not say there was a reporting restriction. And number three,
00:02:07 he had a colleague of his go in and actually look at the courtroom door and
00:02:11 the monitors in the courtroom and those did not have the indication of a
00:02:15 reporting restriction. Now the British judicial policy is that a reporting
00:02:19 restriction is published in all of those places. And what happened? The Crown's
00:02:25 star witness, a woman by the name of Michelle Dunderdale, testified and her
00:02:29 word is that the court failed. That's what she said, the court failed at doing this.
00:02:34 The process has failed, the internal process has failed, and she says that this is
00:02:39 something they've had to come up with another way around, a new process, they've
00:02:42 needed to change it up. But there's an admission from the government that this
00:02:46 reporting restriction was not notified. Now a couple of things happened to
00:02:51 combat this. The Attorney General's lawyer said, number one, that it doesn't matter
00:02:56 anyway because, you know, the reporting restriction exists whether you are 0.96
00:02:59 negligent or not, whether you're ignorant or not. But also, and this is the most
00:03:04 important thing, he accused Tommy Robinson of making it up. He said to Tommy, I
00:03:08 believe you've created these stories about going through these checks after the
00:03:12 fact. Tommy said that's incorrect. And what did the lawyer for the Attorney
00:03:15 General say? I will quote exactly, oh well. So this is what's happening here. You have
00:03:21 the government of the United Kingdom, the Attorney General of this country, of
00:03:24 England and Wales, saying to Tommy Robinson, we believe you've made it up, you
00:03:29 didn't go through these checks, even though the government admits, the
00:03:32 government's witness admits that these things did not happen, these things that
00:03:37 were supposed to happen. Now there are obviously going to be a lot of
00:03:40 arguments about the law itself, not the facts of the case, but the law. And we're
00:03:44 expected to hear more of those when day two of the trial kicks off. I'll be in
00:03:48 the courtroom again if you want to follow my tweets starting from about 4.30 a.m.
00:03:52 Eastern Time. If you're an early riser, you can do so. My Twitter name is
00:03:56 across the bottom there, at Andrew Lawton. Back in court tomorrow for day two of the
00:04:01 trial of Tommy Robinson. For True North, I'm Andrew Lawton.
00:04:07 Lawton
00:04:09 Lawton
00:04:10 Lawton
00:04:12 Lawton
00:04:14 Lawton
00:04:17 Lawton
00:04:18 Lawton
00:04:20 Lawton
00:04:21 Lawton
00:04:22 Lawton
00:04:23 Lawton
00:04:24 Lawton
00:04:26 Lawton
00:04:26 Lawton
00:04:27 Lawton
00:04:28 Lawton
00:04:29 Lawton
00:04:30 Lawton
00:04:31 Lawton
00:04:32 Lawton
00:04:33 Lawton