Juno News - April 18, 2024


Calgary's mayor wants you to own nothing and be happy

Topics
Mentioned
Alberta refuses to be bribed by Trudeau Sports gambling ads need to stop

Episode Stats


Length

47 minutes

Words per minute

183.02

Word count

8,647

Sentence count

357

Harmful content

Misogyny

6

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

8

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

A fireside chat with New Brunswick Premier Blaine Higgs. And a look at why young people in large numbers in Canada are rejecting the idea of owning a home because they prefer to rent. And why that's a good thing.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:19 north hello and welcome to you all it is another fantastic edition i hope anyway of canada's most
00:01:30 irreverent talk show here on this thursday april 18th 2024 good to have you aboard as we
00:01:37 wind down the week at least insofar as the show is concerned as promised a little bit later on
00:01:43 we'll have my fireside chat from last week's canada strong and free network conference with
00:01:47 New Brunswick Premier Blaine Higgs. I'd actually never spoken with or met him before. We had a
00:01:54 little introductory chat before our interview and then we had our time on stage and it was great
00:01:58 fun, but it was quite good because obviously we've been following on this show a lot of what New
00:02:03 Brunswick has been doing on the parental rights front, on the carbon tax front, so it was good to
00:02:08 have the chance to speak with Premier Higgs about that, especially as he gears up for what's
00:02:13 shaking out to be a rather tense and hotly contested election in just a couple of months,
00:02:19 and it was quite fun. I should have pulled the tweet ahead of time, but the New Brunswick
00:02:23 Liberals, after Premier Higgs appeared in Ottawa, put out this attack tweet that, well, Premier Higgs
00:02:29 was meeting with fringe groups in Ottawa, the leader of the New Brunswick Liberals. I think
00:02:34 her name is Susan Holt, if I recall. To be honest, I've already forgotten it, but she was, you know,
00:02:39 out doing the work in New Brunswick. And when it was like describing, illustrating who the fringe
00:02:44 groups were that Premier Higgs was meeting with, it was a picture of him and me. So I'm glad that
00:02:50 the New Brunswick Liberals, I'm the face of fringe groups. I don't take this honour likely. I thank
00:02:55 you very much for it. And I hope to live up to your expectations of me and your lofty goals of
00:03:00 me. But all that notwithstanding, we'll have my chat with Premier Blaine Higgs a little bit later
00:03:04 on in the show. I wanted to begin, we'll go west for the beginning here. I don't know if you've
00:03:09 seen this, but Jody Gondek, who is the mayor of Calgary, she just evaded a recall petition, which
00:03:16 again, I mean, it did fairly well. It had, you know, 70 some odd thousand signatures, but
00:03:21 was nowhere near the threshold to turf her and have another election. But Jody Gondek,
00:03:27 she is the mayor of Calgary still, and she is the mayor of a city like many other communities in
00:03:32 canada filled with young people who cannot afford to buy a home now this is what she describes
00:03:38 when she is talking about the plight of young people who can't afford to buy a house in this
00:03:44 economy to see a segment of the population reject this idea of owning a home and they're moving
00:03:51 towards rental because it gives them more freedom they can travel to different places they can try
00:03:56 out different communities their job may take them from place to place and so people have become much
00:04:01 more liberated around what housing looks like and what the tenure of housing looks like but as
00:04:06 municipalities we haven't kept pace with that change we're still stuck in the 40s 50s and 60
00:04:13 okay there's a lot in that 30 seconds there she says municipalities haven't kept pace with
00:04:25 this move that she says is totally real of young people in large numbers rejecting
00:04:31 homeownership because they prefer to rent. They find it gives them more freedom. They find it
00:04:37 liberate. She used the word liberated. And she said, oh, municipalities. So she's basically
00:04:41 saying that homeownership is an antiquated, outdated concept. The idea that people should
00:04:45 own homes, that's just something of the 40s, 50s, and 60s. And that instead we should all just rent.
00:04:51 Now, the thing about renting is that it enriches someone else.
00:04:54 Renting does not abolish property ownership.
00:04:57 Renting means that only a few people are the property owners and everyone else is enriching
00:05:03 their bottom line.
00:05:04 This is why renting is, and I was a renter for many years, it's why it's so infuriating
00:05:08 because you spend money that gives you a roof over your head, but you amass no equity, you
00:05:13 have nothing to sell at the end of it.
00:05:15 And sure, maybe it means that you don't have to deal with some of the capital expenditures
00:05:18 that the owners do, but your money, you are investing in someone else's company and someone
00:05:25 else's business. And they're the ones that get to reap the rewards. They're the ones that get to
00:05:30 take the returns from that. Now, again, you may choose for whatever reason to rent for a short
00:05:35 period of time. Maybe you are more transient. Maybe you are a student. But for the most part,
00:05:41 the people who rent are people who cannot afford to buy. And this is true time and time again in
00:05:48 surveys. I just pulled up a sampling of stories. Young people pessimistic about chances of owning 1.00
00:05:53 a home poll. This is a CTV story. It was a poll done by the Ontario Real Estate Association
00:05:59 found that three quarters of recent university and college graduates want a home. Three quarters
00:06:04 want one, but 40% don't think they can ever afford one. Another story in the Globe and Mail. Young
00:06:11 adults are giving up on home ownership and a lot of them are furious about it. The list goes on and
00:06:17 on and on. Young people who deselect, who self-select out of the housing market are not
00:06:22 doing so because they feel they are freer and more liberated. They're doing so because they have not
00:06:28 been able to live this part of the Canadian dream. And this is not just, you know, people that are
00:06:33 working part-time, people who work full-time jobs, who have stable, steady incomes, what we would
00:06:39 have called a strong middle-class income a few years ago, are still priced out of the housing
00:06:46 market. And there are a number of layers to this problem. Yes, interest rates are a big issue. That
00:06:51 wasn't the case a few years ago. You also have the case where homes are not being built. And this is
00:06:58 where, I mean, whether you like Pierre Paliere or not, his crusade against so-called municipal
00:07:02 gatekeepers is an important one because you do have a lot of NIMBYs. I mean, the provincial 1.00
00:07:06 government in Ontario, for example, has allowed NIMBYism to prosper at the municipal level by not
00:07:12 allowing the development of fourplexes which again might not be the most desirable for people
00:07:17 but they give you a way into the market they give you a way in and these things are allowing renters
00:07:25 to rent and that's good we need to encourage it they're also encouraging investment in housing
00:07:31 they're encouraging building and construction so the reason I bring that up and the fourplex debate
00:07:37 is a different one here but we need to have people building homes you need to have people building
00:07:41 homes that people can then buy. And you're going to have, as supply goes up, you're going to have
00:07:47 demand start, not necessarily go down, but over time it will, because there will be people now
00:07:53 able to bid. And you're not going up against 30 people for a house. You're going up maybe against
00:07:58 five. And this is, I think, something that is going to not even reduce the cost, the value of
00:08:05 your house compared to what you bought it for. It's going to slow the increase. And this is the
00:08:10 problem is that you have people that have gotten very wealthy on their homes and they don't want
00:08:15 any policy mechanisms that are going to reduce what they believe, reduce that price for when
00:08:21 they eventually sell it. And I understand that argument. I understand why there's that aversion
00:08:25 here. But I also understand that we can have an economy and a society in which the next generation
00:08:32 and the generation after that are unable to ever have a home. People are living in their parents
00:08:37 basement indefinitely or they're renting indefinitely and again they are now they are
00:08:42 now the product of someone else's bottom line they are the provider of someone else's revenue stream
00:08:49 instead of being able to produce for themselves now all of this is i think to say you should have
00:08:54 a choice if you want to rent for whatever reason yes you should have a choice and i i believe
00:09:00 there's probably one or two people out there that have the view that jody gondek does that
00:09:05 maybe renting is easier it's low stress i get to be more transient i get to be a nomad but
00:09:11 the vast majority of people who cannot afford homes are people who would love to be able to
00:09:17 but aren't they'd love to be able to buy a home but cannot do it because of the economic climate
00:09:24 and when she talks about home ownership as being this 40s 50s 60s concept she's giving a huge
00:09:30 middle finger to her young constituents who would love who don't view that as being antiquated who
00:09:35 view that as being part and parcel of their own life and i mean look there's a libertarian and
00:09:40 conservative argument here which is that if you don't have property you don't actually have
00:09:45 anything if you don't have your own land your own home your own property your own little piece you
00:09:49 can't do anything so someone who rents it gives them so much more freedom but like as someone
00:09:55 pointed out on twitter they can't even necessarily put up a tv mount on the wall like how much
00:10:01 freedom is that really if you don't own your own abode if you don't have control over your abode
00:10:08 and you know it's funny when she talks about this in terms of oh it makes you so much happier it's
00:10:14 freeing it's liberating it's all of that it just comes remarkably similar do you remember that old
00:10:19 thing that the world economic forum was being dragged for there was a i believe she was an 0.72
00:10:23 Estonian or Danish member of parliament something like that but there was a an essay that she wrote
00:10:30 Danish uh yeah there we go welcome to 2030 I own nothing have no privacy and life has never been
00:10:36 better this was the essay published by the World Economic Forum now it wasn't like Klaus Schwab's
00:10:43 personal prescription that you'll be happy but it was an idea that was advanced by the WEF as this
00:10:50 you know, sort of 2030 world in which we all just borrow and rent everything. No one owns anything
00:10:56 except, okay, well, if we're all borrowing and renting, who's the one from whom we're borrowing
00:11:01 and renting? Oh, the state. So this is why that idea, that concept of owning nothing and being
00:11:07 happy was so absurd because if you own nothing, someone else is going to be happy. You are
00:11:11 probably not going to be happy. But Jodi Gondek is the one who's now saying we should all own
00:11:17 nothing and be happy. She is unironically saying that we should all be the beneficiaries 0.99
00:11:22 of this weird world in which other people hold the power, other people hold the land,
00:11:29 and we just live in it at their privilege. Now, interestingly enough, Sean points out,
00:11:34 because I said, you know, Sean, go and get that. And it took him, you know, I don't know,
00:11:37 three and a half days to find that article. Probably not actually, but they pulled it offline.
00:11:41 So you have to go to like an archive. Oh, there it is. Oh, you're prepared today, Sean. I like this.
00:11:47 You have to go to an archive site to find the article
00:11:49 because they were tired of getting dragged for it.
00:11:52 So even the own nothing and be happy people
00:11:55 are taking advantage of owning their domain name
00:11:57 because you couldn't delete it if you didn't own the website.
00:12:00 So take that, Klaus Schwab.
00:12:01 And actually, we have a new photo that we came across of Klaus Schwab
00:12:06 that we wanted to share with you.
00:12:09 Oh, you are looking lovely there, Klaus.
00:12:13 Yes, you will own nothing and be happy.
00:12:15 renting is liberating yeah that is uh no that's mayor jody gondag but she i will say she actually
00:12:21 looks quite good sporting the infamous uh klaus schwab convocation gear so take from that what
00:12:28 you will but my goodness what a slap in the face to young calgarians i suspect if you run that
00:12:32 uh recall petition again you would perhaps find a little bit more support from some of the young
00:12:37 people that are now being told no no you're just uh just enjoy the freedom you have by
00:12:42 not having to mow your lawn or any of that stuff but I would also point out here and I was going
00:12:48 to mention this she owns two properties so I'm assuming maybe she lives in both I don't know
00:12:54 this is her council disclosure statement she owns one home in Panorama Hills in Calgary and another
00:13:01 in the East Village now maybe she just flips back and forth between them or maybe one of them is a
00:13:07 rental property and the more that young calgarians decide to rent the better it is for jody gondike
00:13:14 because those rent payments that some young calgarian couple that can't afford their own 0.87
00:13:17 house pay go right into her bank account so uh take from that what you will but my goodness what 0.92
00:13:23 a disgusting and tone-deaf comment from someone who should be at the front lines of making it
00:13:28 possible for people to have homes making it possible for people to buy letting building
00:13:33 take place, letting there just be this unleashing of construction and development. And instead,
00:13:39 she's saying, yeah, yeah, you should all just rent instead. My goodness. So without further ado,
00:13:44 we'll go from west to east. I wanted to share with you my sit down, my fireside chat with New
00:13:48 Brunswick Premier Blaine Higgs. Thank you very much. Thank you. All my life, I've wondered how
00:14:00 to get a standing ovation, and apparently it's to walk on stage with Premier Higgs, so thank you
00:14:05 for letting me bask in that, and thank you to everyone for being here this morning. I love the
00:14:10 format of the fireside chat, mainly because it's Ottawa and you need to be by the side of a fire to
00:14:16 survive for nine of the 12 months of the year, but also we get the chance, especially in front
00:14:20 of an audience like this, to delve into some of the issues that I don't think you get on your
00:14:24 average CBC panel, and that doesn't mean we're going to give you a totally easy ride on this
00:14:30 premier but I do want to give you the chance to talk about issues that I know matter to people
00:14:33 in this room and those watching from beyond and normally you try to warm up to the controversial
00:14:39 stuff but I feel like you can take the controversial stuff because you've been quite a leader on this
00:14:43 issue so let's start with transgender issues and parental rights because let's start there and
00:14:52 then we'll see how it goes because this is an issue that we understand why other premiers have
00:14:59 taken actions they've taken in the last few months on this.
00:15:01 In a lot of cases, it was because you had,
00:15:04 and they had their own supporters pushing them to do very similar things.
00:15:08 You were the first one.
00:15:09 So let me just ask you, when you put that policy forward
00:15:12 that required parental consent for gender changes,
00:15:16 for re-identifications at school, why did you go there?
00:15:20 Well, thank you for the question, Andrew.
00:15:21 I guess the point was that we,
00:15:24 throughout this whole duration of being in politics,
00:15:27 I came at a time when I'd already had a career.
00:15:29 And I wanted to bring a lot of ideas that I learned and decision processes that I learned,
00:15:34 but also on the foundational principle that you do what's right and the rest will fall in place.
00:15:38 Now that doesn't always work in politics, it seems, but nevertheless that's the philosophy we live by.
00:15:43 And through this whole discussion, it became a policy that kind of got into our educational system
00:15:49 without a whole lot of discussion or detailed discussion with our caucus.
00:15:53 And after the election of 2020, and then a little while after, I started asking questions about it in detail.
00:16:00 And then when I read the paragraph that basically caused teachers to hide information from parents
00:16:05 and to do so as part of the request of the policy, you know, this just wasn't right.
00:16:12 This isn't the foundation of families that we build on.
00:16:16 And it was interesting. My wife and I talked about this prior to making it an issue.
00:16:21 And by the way, we've been married, I believe, 46 years this summer.
00:16:25 And four daughters, five grandchildren.
00:16:29 We're very close to our family.
00:16:31 And the idea that we would hide information, we thought, how would we like that if that happened?
00:16:37 So then we started bringing it as a question.
00:16:39 And then we saw some of the curriculum that was being taught on a parent or a school day, a school teacher's day.
00:16:46 And you'd say, or professional development day is what it's called.
00:16:49 So anyway, you'd see, wow, where's the curriculum here that involves math and science and literacy
00:16:55 and numeracy, where's that in all this?
00:16:59 So the challenge was, how do you have the debate on a sensitive issue, recognizing the
00:17:05 reality of it all, but finding a path to do it?
00:17:08 And I think that we have walked away from too many controversial issues, and that is
00:17:12 why we've seen kind of an erosion of what we might have always considered standard.
00:17:18 It becomes normalized, and it's not because it's normal, it's normal, it's different.
00:17:22 And we are a society that absolutely recognizes and supports all of our differences.
00:17:29 But let's not exclude family as part of that process.
00:17:33 It was an issue that, for someone like me who doesn't follow New Brunswick politics explicitly,
00:17:40 and I'd say probably has done so a little bit more thanks to you and stuff you've been doing there,
00:17:45 It was not something that was really accurately defined by the media, what you did.
00:17:51 I think before I read the actual...
00:17:53 Yeah, it is.
00:17:54 Well, as we heard from the last panel, it's okay.
00:17:56 They should have just been watching, reading The Line and other outlets like that.
00:18:00 But you were doing something that was a relatively moderate proposal.
00:18:05 And even a lot of people that are in the parental rights space that have been advocating for something similar were saying,
00:18:11 well, it's a compromise, he's not going far enough, it's a good start.
00:18:16 But you were, to the activists that were against you,
00:18:19 it was as though you had gone so far, you had done something so radical,
00:18:22 you had done something so far-right is the term.
00:18:25 I mean, did you ever imagine that you would be labeled as far-right
00:18:27 when you were elected as Premier, you know, going back to 2013?
00:18:31 And why is this issue one that has been maligned in that way?
00:18:36 Well, just recently I was asked about a case of the far-right,
00:18:39 And isn't it amazing that in today's world, far right is having parents involved with their kids?
00:18:45 Isn't that amazing?
00:18:46 So I say that tells you how far the spectrum has actually moved and how we need to find a path forward.
00:18:51 But in analyzing kind of what we wanted to bring forward is let's address this.
00:18:56 And then looking abroad, looking at what's going on in Europe, particularly what's going on in Europe,
00:18:59 about how they manage real issues around gender dysphoria,
00:19:03 but how they look at it as, you know, getting the right process for treatment
00:19:06 and through psychologists, psychiatrists, to understand, okay, how do we manage this?
00:19:10 Because in some cases it's very real, but in other cases it's a process of kids growing up,
00:19:15 and that's where parents are that one continuum in their life.
00:19:19 And so we just say, okay, we want parents to be involved.
00:19:22 And no, I didn't imagine it would be such a controversial issue
00:19:26 because it seems like such a basic, fundamental principle that we all cherish.
00:19:33 One of the things that I find interesting, though,
00:19:36 is that there are a lot of issues that tend to be within the domain
00:19:40 of what we would call social conservatives.
00:19:43 And these issues tend to get treated as political third rails.
00:19:46 You can't talk about this, you can't talk about that.
00:19:49 This is an issue that I think is very much in a line
00:19:51 with where a lot of social conservatives wanted to take society.
00:19:54 But it seems to have a broader appeal.
00:19:57 I mean, the number of folks that I've spoken to
00:19:58 that have supported what you've done in New Brunswick
00:20:00 or what Premier Danielle Smith has done in Alberta
00:20:03 that would not identify as pro-life,
00:20:06 would not identify as anti-gay marriage.
00:20:09 But on this issue, they're there.
00:20:12 What do you make of that?
00:20:12 I mean, how has there been a coalition
00:20:14 that does seem to be very large,
00:20:16 not just within the conservative movement,
00:20:18 but even within society itself,
00:20:20 behind some of these policies?
00:20:22 I think the risk we're facing in Canada
00:20:25 and the risk that we see in the U.S.
00:20:28 is we've drifted so far from what people look at as common sense
00:20:33 and how to manage the next steps.
00:20:36 And we've drifted ideologically so far
00:20:38 that all of a sudden people kind of say,
00:20:41 whoa, this has to be addressed.
00:20:44 So I think what we're seeing is, okay,
00:20:46 here's something that's so basic, so fundamental,
00:20:48 and yet it's an issue.
00:20:49 But it will cause us, I think, to all be part of the solution.
00:20:54 And when I think that we put teachers in a position
00:20:56 to not be truthful with the child's parents,
00:20:59 why aren't teachers speaking up and saying, you know, we need to be part of this?
00:21:04 And when we talk about, okay, this can be irreparable surgeries
00:21:10 that could happen to young children, why aren't doctors speaking up
00:21:13 and saying, okay, we believe we need to manage this,
00:21:16 we need this how it needs to be done?
00:21:18 I refer to the European model now that Sweden, Norway, Denmark, the UK
00:21:23 have all changed their policies to look at a different way
00:21:25 to deal with a problem. Always recognize there's a problem and always recognizing there's a way
00:21:30 to protect every individual in their beliefs and how we manage through that. But not just
00:21:37 ignoring the reality of what makes sense and what's real. So I think that's the purpose for
00:21:44 me is that we need to find the moderate approach here. And sometimes the definition, because you
00:21:49 saw what happened in New Brunswick. So we are a progressive conservative party, but people jump
00:21:56 on one side or the other wholeheartedly without trying to find the balance in the middle. And
00:22:00 that's what we're trying to find. And sometimes it creates a bit of a firestorm. My wife will 0.95
00:22:04 often say when I come home at night, what fire did you start today? And she said, I was reading
00:22:09 the news. I said, that's your first problem. You shouldn't do that. As long as it's true north, 0.98
00:22:14 we'll forgive her. All right. Fair enough. There's one. Good for you. Let me ask you,
00:22:17 Before we get on to that definitional problem, which I think is tremendously important,
00:22:21 did you anticipate that you were starting something that would become a pretty national wave?
00:22:27 And I'm curious if you had other conversations with premiers on either way that say,
00:22:31 hey, thank you for breaking the seal on this so we can, or what the hell are you doing?
00:22:35 Do you realize what my caucus expects me to do now?
00:22:38 Well, yes, we certainly have talked amongst colleagues,
00:22:42 And certainly, you know, I had discussions with many, many, and many have different views,
00:22:49 and that's what we are in Canada.
00:22:51 But I certainly look at what Saskatchewan is doing and what Daniel Smith is doing in Alberta.
00:23:00 And I guess I'd like to think that at the end of the day,
00:23:03 we'll find a solution that doesn't seem to be far right.
00:23:07 It just seems to be really right.
00:23:08 and I mean by that it's such a correct path forward. And so in those discussions, did
00:23:15 I think it would turn into a national thing? No, that wasn't a discussion. When my wife
00:23:19 and I talked about this and I said, you know, this is going to be the week, we're going
00:23:22 to talk about this, we both realized this could be the issue that either continues us
00:23:31 in government or takes us out. But we were both prepared to say, fair enough.
00:23:36 And so, and I think there lies the whole challenge that we have as a society, as politicians,
00:23:46 as members of any profession, which I just stated with health care and with education,
00:23:51 is to say I will do what I believe is correct.
00:23:55 I will voice my opinion in a very respectful, mannerful way to improve what I believe needs to be improved.
00:24:02 And it doesn't have to be protests and blowing horns and jumping on the street.
00:24:06 but it has very adult discussions that say,
00:24:08 I'm not afraid to talk about it.
00:24:10 Let's talk about that progressive conservative name
00:24:14 because that's always been to many people
00:24:16 an inherent contradiction.
00:24:18 And you have some people in the conservative family
00:24:20 in this country that say,
00:24:21 no, I'm a proud progressive conservative,
00:24:23 and that means something very specific to them.
00:24:25 You have others that just sort of tolerate it
00:24:27 because that's the name of the party.
00:24:29 And we also don't have in Canada
00:24:31 the harmonization of the federal and provincial
00:24:33 right-leaning parties,
00:24:34 which is why you have this patchwork from BC, where you now have two warring parties that are
00:24:39 going for right-of-center votes, and you have in Alberta a complete unique situation there.
00:24:44 I'm curious how that... I was just trying to gloss over that, but I heard a laugh... That was
00:24:48 apparently a laugh line for someone from Alberta, but I'm curious about your perspective on that in
00:24:53 New Brunswick, because you're a progressive conservative premier, and I think that a lot
00:24:56 of people would say that you are putting forward very ironclad, small-c conservative principles,
00:25:01 with no need for a qualifier there.
00:25:03 But how does that affect your navigation of that coalition that you have in New Brunswick
00:25:08 and also how New Brunswick fits into the Canadian conservative family?
00:25:12 Well, it adds in kind of a new dimension of, I won't say confusion,
00:25:17 but certainly an irony there that exists with the two, with the progressive conservative
00:25:21 because some people will grab a hold of the progressive piece
00:25:24 and some people will grab a hold of the conservative piece
00:25:26 and then you have to kind of bridge that within caucus.
00:25:29 And as you know, back last June, I didn't bridge that very successfully
00:25:33 because I had six members of caucus that basically stood against the government
00:25:37 and voted against the government.
00:25:39 So it does bring an issue.
00:25:43 But I think at the same time, it's how do you have the discussions?
00:25:48 And coming from a business world, and I know people say,
00:25:51 well, you know, sometimes you just move along too fast.
00:25:54 I'll have a lot of meetings, a lot of debate, a lot of discussions,
00:25:57 a lot of discussions and there comes a point in time where you just got to get on with it.
00:26:01 And so we got on with it last June after numerous meetings and caucus and such, but there were
00:26:06 six individuals, maybe eight, that were not happy with that and it causes angst.
00:26:14 So you can see the political upheaval that kind of creates and we were joking here coming
00:26:21 in talking about, because I did in a state of the province, I did this, people didn't
00:26:26 know if i was going to run again and i put a song at the end of it an old clash song that said should
00:26:30 i stay or should i go and and uh kind of danced off the stage but this this time uh when we did
00:26:37 the state of the province there's a lot of great things to talk about in the province and and i
00:26:40 was thinking my song should be the elton john one that uh i'm still standing uh because but but i
00:26:47 was recommended against that but well premier higgs is leading karaoke in the shore club
00:26:51 downstairs at uh at 10 o'clock eastern time but i'll ask you on that premier when you mention
00:26:57 those six members that left your caucus do you view that as being
00:27:03 if i could just use a blunt word a failure of your leadership to keep your party together or
00:27:07 do you believe that the coalition was too broad and those people really didn't belong
00:27:11 in your party in the first place no it's a challenge that i you know probably if my interest
00:27:18 was how do I survive the next election,
00:27:20 then I probably would have found a different way
00:27:24 to try to manage through it,
00:27:25 but I wouldn't have had the same result.
00:27:27 And that, I think, is what happens to many of us
00:27:30 as we get watered down in our own beliefs
00:27:32 because we're trying to appease the masses.
00:27:37 We had diverse opinions, but that goes two ways.
00:27:39 It goes two ways that, okay,
00:27:41 if I have 80% of caucus that are on side
00:27:43 and want to move forward,
00:27:44 and I have 20% that don't,
00:27:46 It's rare if ever you get a consensus within caucus of unity, it just doesn't happen,
00:27:52 or extremely rare.
00:27:54 So the point that, okay, we have the majority of caucus, we're ready to move on this, and
00:27:59 the Minister of Education, he and I, we're ready to move, we've presented, we've
00:28:02 talked, it was time.
00:28:04 So yeah, we could have talked about it a lot longer, but I didn't see an end in sight.
00:28:10 was going to be, we were never going to convince some, all the while we had, we had full support
00:28:16 of, as I say, 80% of the caucus. But let me extend that thought to its logical conclusion here,
00:28:22 because if it sounds like, I'm going to do one of those, it sounds like you're saying things
00:28:25 that like Kathy Newman and Jordan Peterson, but I'm, I'm going to try to actually represent what
00:28:29 you're saying, or at least as I understand it, that there's a risk for conservative parties of
00:28:34 trying to be too many things to too many people. And that this big tent, which is often viewed as
00:28:39 feature of the conservative movement actually carries its own cohesion challenges oh it does
00:28:44 absolutely does and what you're seeing is i mean we see the liberal party i mean if you want to
00:28:48 talk about far left i mean how far can you get um and this isn't a political don't challenge
00:28:56 this is not a political discussion is it i agree um but but the idea and you see to your point you
00:29:01 raised earlier that that's where the spectrum is going and everybody everybody has taken oh well
00:29:06 I'm way over here on the left side and and I think that is our job as Conservatives to find
00:29:13 the the the way to have the detailed discussions and the frank discussions and I'm saying that
00:29:18 and what I'm excited about and he'll be here a little later Pierre Pauliev what I've seen from
00:29:22 the rallies he's had in in New Brunswick and the people that are showing up we went to a rally the
00:29:27 average age was probably 35,000 1200 people I think that's just wonderful to see young people
00:29:33 coming into our party and getting involved since you mentioned pierre pauliev who will be here at
00:29:41 11 30 and not right now as some people were disappointed to see me on stage but he has been
00:29:47 touring the country on his it started as the axe the tax rally and now it's the spike the hike
00:29:52 rally and i think there's going to be another rhyme next week but uh the galvanizing issue for
00:29:56 the federal conservatives right now has been opposing the carbon tax and this has been an
00:30:01 issue in uh certainly in your province as well we've seen provinces sue the federal government
00:30:06 we've seen the supreme court side against provinces on this and then i think for the
00:30:10 most part the federal government's carbon tax was pretty safe until they decided that you know
00:30:14 atlantic canadians with home heating oil needed a bit of a carve out and then it sort of undermined
00:30:18 their their whole premise here and i'm curious for you first off how much of an issue is that
00:30:24 uh electorally speaking as you gear up for an election for for people in new brunswick this
00:30:28 this carbon tax but but also how do you anticipate this going when you have a federal government that
00:30:35 right now doesn't even want to meet with premiers on this issue which is i mean justin trudeau loves
00:30:40 talking and he loves people having to hear him talk but this is like one opportunity to sit down
00:30:46 that he doesn't want to take because he doesn't want to hear what the premiers like you have to
00:30:49 tell him well it's it's disappointing but you get used to it um so you so sometimes you don't bother
00:30:57 but we are bothering so there was a question asked that oh well if other provinces have a
00:31:01 solution then then let us know so so the the idea for us in new brunswick and worldwide really is to
00:31:08 is for canada to punch well above its weight in terms of reducing world emissions we can talk
00:31:13 about our 1.8 percent of world emissions and we can cause everybody in every household across this
00:31:18 country to spend more and and have less and do less or we can say we've always been a nation
00:31:24 that's rich in energy, it has given us the lifestyle we have,
00:31:28 but it's also given us the ability to help others.
00:31:30 So isn't it sad?
00:31:31 When I was in Europe a few years ago,
00:31:34 I was talking to different people that was after the invasion in Ukraine,
00:31:39 and they're saying all through this,
00:31:40 we're absolutely shocked that a country as rich as Canada
00:31:45 is not supplying any energy to Europe to offset Russian oil and gas.
00:31:51 Absolutely shocked.
00:31:51 So when you think about that for a minute, we've spent how many millions or billions to help Ukraine?
00:31:59 So on the one hand, we supply arms to the war, which we're not begrudging.
00:32:04 We want to do that.
00:32:05 But then on the other hand, we're forcing them to buy Russian oil and gas and finance from the other side.
00:32:12 So then you look at what can we do about that in addition to supplying what we have here.
00:32:17 On the world emissions side, we in New Brunswick, we have 77 trillion standard cubic feet of natural gas sitting, waiting to be developed.
00:32:24 Out west, this is happening.
00:32:26 We have an LNG plant that is waiting to be converted to an export facility.
00:32:31 It is an import built back 15 years ago.
00:32:34 So we have supply.
00:32:35 We have market.
00:32:36 We have four countries, right without even asking, saying we'll sign up for a 20-year deal.
00:32:41 We have 174 coal plants in Europe.
00:32:44 We have China building coal plants at the rate of two a week, 100 a year.
00:32:49 They operate 1,100 coal plants.
00:32:51 For every coal plant that's shut down by natural gas, we reduce emissions by 50%.
00:32:55 So you say, wow, we have an opportunity right here in New Brunswick to shut down coal plants.
00:33:01 Total Energy, one of the world's largest energy companies,
00:33:04 said one of their key pillars, of their four pillars,
00:33:09 is to develop as much natural gas worldwide as they can
00:33:11 and shut down as many coal plants as they can
00:33:13 because it'll have a bigger impact, quicker impact
00:33:16 than anything else that is happening.
00:33:18 And at the same time, the affordability issue in our country
00:33:21 goes away or diminishes greatly
00:33:23 because we'll use those same resources to fund technology,
00:33:26 research, development.
00:33:27 And when do people start using and acting differently?
00:33:30 You know, I think years ago about the film industry
00:33:32 when digital photography come along,
00:33:34 where would you find a film camera now?
00:33:36 And the same thing with the LED lights?
00:33:38 Well, now you just look for LED lights
00:33:39 because of their brightness.
00:33:41 and their energy consumption. When we have the ability to have that sort of technological
00:33:45 advancement, people will change their ambits. We will be able to meet the requirements which
00:33:50 we cannot meet today from the federal policies. We are putting forward a policy to the, and
00:33:55 I actually have it coincidentally here with me, but, and it's called No Tax Required,
00:34:02 just support us developing gas and shutting down coal plants in the process. And I'm submitting
00:34:07 that letter to the Prime Minister and saying, here's an option, you wanted a solution?
00:34:11 Here it is.
00:34:12 But think out of the box.
00:34:13 Think bigger.
00:34:14 Think of the impact that this country can have on worldwide emissions, not in our own
00:34:18 little bubble of 1.8%.
00:34:21 I must say, I've been quite surprised that Justin Trudeau keeps inviting European heads 1.00
00:34:30 of government and state here, because every time they come, they all do an interview with
00:34:34 you know, Vashi Capellos or something and say, oh, I'd love to buy LNG. And then Justin Trudeau
00:34:38 has to come out and say, oh, there's no business case. But it is quite, I mean, it's a joke, but
00:34:42 I mean, a lot of the government's a joke, but there's a particular absurdity to this and that
00:34:48 you have people literally lining up to buy something. You have industry lining up to sell
00:34:53 something. And the only to appropriate the language of one of our next speakers, the gatekeeper,
00:34:59 is the federal government. And we're not even looking for an issue here. It's not an issue
00:35:04 where someone is looking for a subsidy,
00:35:06 they're looking for permission.
00:35:08 Exactly.
00:35:08 And that's the sole absurdity here.
00:35:12 It's actually quite despicable.
00:35:13 You have industry, you have buyers,
00:35:15 you have an economic argument for it,
00:35:17 you have an environmental argument for it,
00:35:18 and a federal government standing in the way.
00:35:21 And, I mean, as a premier,
00:35:22 do you feel like this is just bad policy
00:35:25 or do you feel this is illegal policy?
00:35:26 This is government actually violating
00:35:28 its constitutional requirements
00:35:29 to respect what's supposed to be your domain.
00:35:32 All the above.
00:35:34 and it's not the only one right and there's um it's kind of we're getting used to the bad policy
00:35:40 phenomena from from ottawa the the the concept i think of of this is for us is that we don't
00:35:46 need federal money to your point it's a business case out west they didn't need federal money it
00:35:50 was bad law that that caused them to have to buy a pipeline and that was what four or five times 0.85
00:35:54 more in the expense to taxpayers we don't want them to have any part of this we wish to just
00:35:59 leave us alone but you can't put rules in place that say if you're if you don't have a plant up
00:36:03 and running by 2030 or whatever the number 2028 then it can't run for more than five years or
00:36:10 it has to be shut down like there's a there's a new clause in that that basically developers
00:36:13 say no no i need a 20-year runway here so so you can't do that so policy is causing a problem and
00:36:20 then and then the reality people generally people are starting now with the affordability issue all
00:36:25 of a sudden wow this is uh this is kind of bite and and and your point about um about the the
00:36:32 the break on the, it said, well, polls trump climate change, didn't it? Really, that's
00:36:36 what it said. The big message is that, oh, if you can do it in eastern Canada, why can't
00:36:40 we do it elsewhere? But I think the bigger message is, why can't we do something better?
00:36:45 And that is the challenge. And the Prime Minister is in this ideological frame of mind that
00:36:50 better just doesn't register. And so I keep pushing that give us the ability and be part
00:36:57 of the solution to help promote the right legislation. But also, then that gives the
00:37:01 First Nations more of an understanding of, okay, I can be part of this now. Because obviously to
00:37:08 do a development like we want to do in New Brunswick, we need First Nations to be part of
00:37:12 that. And they will be major, major benefactors of that. And so I'm excited about that. And we're
00:37:20 working through that with them. But again, it requires policy that says it's okay.
00:37:25 So what relationship would you like to see? Because, and I'm going to be speaking with
00:37:30 Premier Smith tomorrow, and I think Alberta has generally, as a matter of survival, had to be a
00:37:35 lot more forceful against Ottawa for, you know, much of the last several decades. But when you
00:37:40 look at that relationship that you would like to see, the one that you have now, the one that
00:37:43 possibly Pierre Polyev, assuming he's elected, would be able to provide you as a Premier, and
00:37:48 assuming you win your re-election, what should that look like? Well, I've always been a strong
00:37:54 for good reason, not only the national pride of our nation, but also because, and I also
00:38:00 believe that Alberta and Saskatchewan, but Alberta particularly has been paying the bills
00:38:05 for a long time in this nation.
00:38:06 I think they would agree as well.
00:38:10 And I know several years ago as a, you know, a Maritimer that you all know, we were a recipient
00:38:17 of transfer funds at about 30% of our budget, but you know, I'm not proud of that. I'm
00:38:22 honored to be part of it because it makes the lifestyle in our province equitable with other
00:38:26 parts of the country. But this project that I'm talking about to develop, I've always said, and I've
00:38:31 said it for many years and nationally and when I'm in the meetings with my colleagues, I don't
00:38:36 believe that we should be in a position not developing resources that we have, which are the
00:38:42 very ones that we're relying on from Alberta to pay the bills. I just don't think that's fair.
00:38:47 I actually think they moved Danielle Smith to tomorrow
00:38:52 because they were worried if you were here the same day
00:38:54 she would ask for the money back
00:38:55 I think that might have been the risk there
00:38:57 but as we talk about the road forward
00:39:01 I know you and Premier Smith have actually had quite a good relationship
00:39:04 and for a lot of reasons you've had a common foe
00:39:07 in the federal government in Ottawa
00:39:09 I wanted to ask about a policy that you're championing
00:39:12 in New Brunswick that is coming up
00:39:14 that I know Alberta has done as well
00:39:17 and is also one of these issues that I think is becoming one where there's a fair bit of national momentum.
00:39:22 And I don't know how much is public, so I think you know what I'm talking about, though,
00:39:25 so I'll just give you the floor on this.
00:39:27 Well, and it's our Compassionate Care Intervention Bill that we plan to bring forward in the legislature in May.
00:39:34 And it is a tough one because we've had some very significant incidents on the homeless side in our province over the last few months.
00:39:42 We've had, you know, homeless individuals that have lost and had to amputate their legs because they've frozen.
00:39:49 We've had two deaths here recently, back about maybe two or three weeks ago,
00:39:54 that basically were tent fires and people trying to keep warm.
00:39:58 And I called the daughter of one of the victims that died in the fire, about a week after or less.
00:40:08 And I know that he will certainly be upset for good, good reason.
00:40:12 But, of course, it's all kind of, you know, things we could do better as government,
00:40:17 and I don't deny any of that because we shouldn't have the situation.
00:40:21 But I'd made a statement about how do we convince people to come off the street 0.97
00:40:25 when you know they are not capable of making the decision on their own,
00:40:29 you know their life's at risk,
00:40:32 and how do you find a path to say, wow, safety has got to play a role here.
00:40:38 And of course the question is, well we can't do that.
00:40:42 They don't want to come, they don't want to come.
00:40:44 So where does our humanity kick in and you say,
00:40:47 I know that individual won't be alive in the morning.
00:40:50 So what we're trying to say, there are extreme cases
00:40:53 that we can analyze and find a solution
00:40:57 so a person does not suffer the life-changing issues
00:41:01 that they suffer from being exposed to the elements.
00:41:04 And then of course it's the whole concept
00:41:06 about how do we find a path out of drugs and addiction.
00:41:10 I am not a supporter of continued drug,
00:41:14 being on a program that continues
00:41:17 to keep a person addicted to drugs.
00:41:20 I believe in recovery.
00:41:25 You obviously could not be geographically further
00:41:28 from British Columbia.
00:41:29 I would argue politically further
00:41:31 from British Columbia too.
00:41:32 But do you look at British Columbia
00:41:34 and see a very useful model for everything
00:41:38 to do the opposite of?
00:41:40 You know, it's funny you say that
00:41:41 because that's exactly what I was going to say.
00:41:45 They have been a perfect example of what not to do.
00:41:48 And so why do we pretend otherwise?
00:41:54 And I had, just this week, met with several people
00:41:57 that are serving the homeless in the Fredericton area.
00:42:01 And we talked about some of the challenges.
00:42:03 But for me, it's like, hey, how do people get here?
00:42:06 And how do we find a way that we can find them out?
00:42:09 How do we find a way to help them return to a normal life?
00:42:13 And what is normal could be very different for different people.
00:42:16 But the interesting part came back to, well, if someone doesn't want to go,
00:42:20 you know, they can't give them help.
00:42:21 And I asked the question because we're looking at a mental health
00:42:25 and addiction treatment center.
00:42:26 Because along with addiction, the mental health plays a big role.
00:42:29 And we're working to develop that, and we have a building and such.
00:42:33 But the point that they were raising, well, if someone wants to go to be treated,
00:42:39 they've got to have a place to go immediately.
00:42:40 As soon as they say, okay, I'm ready, they've got a place to go.
00:42:43 So I said, okay, so that's Friday night.
00:42:46 What if they say Saturday night or Sunday night or Monday morning,
00:42:49 no, I don't think this is for me.
00:42:50 I don't think I want to stay here.
00:42:52 What do you do then?
00:42:52 Well, you have to let them go.
00:42:54 Well, I said, how many cycles do you get into for that?
00:42:57 Because you just keep going around and around and around.
00:42:59 So it is in one of those tough discussions.
00:43:02 But we know homeless situations are increasing.
00:43:04 We know New Brunswick affordability has played a role.
00:43:06 We've had an increase in population like we haven't seen for 100 years.
00:43:10 And property values have gone up.
00:43:12 Nothing like we'd have here in Ontario, mind you,
00:43:15 just for anyone who wants to move to New Brunswick.
00:43:18 But the idea is that it's a case where people generally have seen a step change
00:43:23 in their ability to afford where they were.
00:43:25 So we need to not lose sight of them
00:43:27 and have them be exposed to the situation
00:43:30 that we don't want them to live and become accustomed to.
00:43:33 And so we have to react quicker.
00:43:34 We have all kinds of social assistance caseworkers.
00:43:38 And when I asked the question,
00:43:41 okay, so what relationship do our caseworkers have
00:43:44 with the individuals on the street?
00:43:46 How often do you see them?
00:43:48 And one of the answers I got, well, monthly.
00:43:51 Monthly?
00:43:52 Yeah, when I'm handing out the check.
00:43:53 that's not servicing the needs of the people
00:43:58 with the people we have in the system.
00:44:01 I would like it noted he ended as the timer hit five seconds.
00:44:05 You would have a great career in radio, Premier,
00:44:07 if the next election doesn't work out well.
00:44:09 You'd get out in time for news and traffic.
00:44:11 Well, Premier Blaine Higgs,
00:44:13 you have put New Brunswick Conservatives on the map
00:44:15 for a lot of people across the country,
00:44:17 and I know it's been a pleasure, I suspect, for everyone in the room.
00:44:20 It has certainly been a pleasure for me, so thank you very much.
00:44:22 Thank you.
00:44:23 thank you that was new brunswick premier blaine higgs and uh my friend dr roy yipin in the last
00:44:33 frame there he uh stood up to like bolt out the room uh when it was over but we'll have to get
00:44:38 roy on there dr roy is fantastic he ran in montreal i forget i think it was ndg i can't
00:44:44 remember for the montreal for the quebec conservative party very very good guy uh he is a physician and
00:44:49 he's very opinionated on a lot of the trans issues because he has a red line like so many 0.92
00:44:55 others do on the treatment of children. And I was interested after the Blaine Higgs panel,
00:45:00 I spoke to a transgender conservative activist, Blaine Baduk, who you may see on Twitter from
00:45:06 time to time. And there was the two Blaines. And I was curious how Blaine thought of these
00:45:11 policies. And it was incredibly supportive because again, most sensible people, and that includes
00:45:18 transgender people do not want children to be in this place where they're living this double life 1.00
00:45:23 at school that is hidden from their parents and that the school is enabling that the school is
00:45:29 then keeping it from them so the idea that these policies which are really about parental consent
00:45:33 and information are transphobic just does not hold water whatsoever so good on premier higgs he
00:45:40 started a national conversation it's one that's carried on through other provinces and seeped
00:45:44 into the federal realm as well.
00:45:46 So that does it for us
00:45:47 for the Andrew Lawton Show this week.
00:45:49 We'll have off the record on tomorrow.
00:45:52 I was sorry, I forgot what day it was for a second.
00:45:53 And then we'll be back on Monday
00:45:54 with more of Canada's most irreverent talk show.
00:45:57 Thank you, God bless and have a wonderful weekend.
00:46:00 Thanks for listening to the Andrew Lawton Show.
00:46:03 Support the program by donating to True North
00:46:05 at www.tnc.news.
00:46:14 We'll be right back.
00:46:44 We'll be right back.