Juno News - November 22, 2025


Can Alberta Save Healthcare?

Topics
Mentioned
Trudeau-era minister given cushy UN role Alberta introduces “Peterson Law” to protect free expression

Episode Stats


Length

22 minutes

Words per minute

192.55

Word count

4,284

Sentence count

313

Harmful content

Misogyny

6

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Our story of the day comes from Alberta, where a new bill is being introduced that could pave the way for two-tier healthcare in the province. It s a game changer, and Alberta is calling on all of us outside of the province to join in.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Alberta is calling, and gee, it's looking like those of us outside of the province should
00:00:07 consider answering. And at the very least, push our premiers to follow Daniel Smith's
00:00:12 lead on so many files, particularly healthcare.
00:00:14 Hi, Juno News. I'm Alex Brown, director of the National Citizens Coalition. Great to
00:00:19 be back with you to end the week. Love speaking to this audience, love all your comments.
00:00:24 Please subscribe and take advantage of our promo code at junonews.com slash not sorry for
00:00:30 20% off. Our story of the day, and it's a big one, a big week coming out of Alberta and
00:00:34 its governance and the principled and courageous actions taken by its premier, Daniel Smith.
00:00:40 Alberta isn't just fighting for a new deal to get a pipeline to the BC coast through needlessly
00:00:44 hostile and disloyal NDP territory. The province is standing up to protect vulnerable children
00:00:50 from an affirmation industrial complex, which has been quick to jump the gun on permanent
00:00:54 decisions and even standing up for women in sports. And now they're lighting the way for
00:01:00 dire healthcare reform. All provinces should take note and follow suit. Take a look at this
00:01:05 clip. A recent survey of wait times for elective surgeries in 10 of the world's wealthiest
00:01:09 countries, Canada finished dead last, trailing the UK, Germany, France, Australia, New Zealand,
00:01:16 Sweden, Switzerland, the Netherlands, and even the United States. Simply put, our wait times
00:01:21 in Canada are well above what medical experts say is an acceptable amount of time to wait
00:01:26 for a surgery without risking other difficult physical and mental health challenges.
00:01:30 We're calling it the dual practice surgery model, and here's how it will work. The Alberta
00:01:35 government will introduce legislation to permit surgeons and supporting surgical professionals
00:01:40 like anesthesiologists to perform both publicly and privately funded knee, hip, eye, shoulder,
00:01:46 and other elective surgeries. Surgeons who elect to be part of this dual practice model
00:01:51 must commit to performing a minimum amount or ratio of publicly funded surgeries each year
00:01:57 to qualify. So for example, a surgeon could choose to perform publicly funded surgeries during
00:02:02 regular business hours while performing private surgeries after regular business hours or on weekends,
00:02:08 should they wish. So instead of a surgeon being limited to performing say a thousand surgeries
00:02:14 a year due to health system funding constraints, that doctor could also perform an additional two
00:02:19 or three hundred more surgeries for patients who can afford to pay for the cost themselves or that
00:02:24 have an employer insurance plan that covers the cost. To be clear, the UCP public health guarantee
00:02:29 continues to be in full force. No one will ever be forced to pay out of pocket for a needed hip,
00:02:34 knee, or other surgery. Everything your Alberta health insurance covers today remains covered.
00:02:40 The only difference is you will likely get that public surgery more quickly than you do now.
00:02:44 And surgeries for life threatening conditions such as cancer or emergency surgeries will remain entirely
00:02:51 publicly funded with no privately funded option available. This is a game changer. As a high ranking
00:02:56 healthcare source just told me, I love it. This is seriously great news, but now the hard work begins.
00:03:02 We need to make sure this is implemented properly. Our Medicare stalwarts will point to this as a
00:03:08 failed experiment if it doesn't work out. This is our chance to join our peer nations across the world
00:03:13 in two tier care. This failing status quo in Canada, it can no longer cut it. No province is on the cutting
00:03:19 edge quite like our energy province and wild rose country. Let's talk to Colin Craig from Second Street,
00:03:25 one of Canada's leading advocacy groups who have been all over the healthcare reform file. This is
00:03:30 incredible news and exciting time. Alberta needs our support. First, a word from our sponsor.
00:03:36 Folks, I want to take a minute to thank today's sponsor which is Macamie College. So Macamie College
00:03:41 has an applied politics and public affair program. It's a two-year evening online program available
00:03:47 across Canada. Students have the opportunity to learn to run political campaigns, organize grassroots
00:03:52 movements, and push policy in the right direction. Students will also have hands-on placements in their
00:03:57 community or with the party they believe in. So when they graduate, they have real job-ready experience.
00:04:02 Applicants only need a high school diploma or homeschooling equivalent to apply. Intake starts
00:04:07 in September and January. And folks, we are very excited to announce that anyone who who applies and
00:04:14 is successful in enrollment will get a $500 scholarship from Juno News. So apply using our link. It's in the
00:04:21 description. You can go to CandiceMalcolm.com slash MACAMI. That's M-A-K-A-M-I. And if you apply through
00:04:28 that link and you're successful, you get a $500 Juno News scholarship. You know, I went to the
00:04:34 University of Alberta and studied political science. And the thing you realize when you're doing a
00:04:38 university degree is that it doesn't lead you to a job. And so for me, after three years of being a
00:04:43 political science student, I looked around and realized I had no job skills. I had never worked in
00:04:48 politics. Everything was theoretical. It was all in the classroom. And I had to start working on
00:04:53 political campaigns just to get my foot in the door. The hard thing about politics is that you need
00:04:57 experience to get a job, but jobs require experience. And so doing something like this, I mean, the fact
00:05:02 that you can do it online, the fact that you could do it on the evening is really helpful. If you're
00:05:06 interested in politics and you're watching the show, I presume you are, this is something that you
00:05:09 really might want to consider, or, hey, maybe, maybe one of your adult children might be interested
00:05:14 in doing something like this. So again, check out this link at CanadaSmoke.com slash
00:05:19 Mackamee College. Colin Craig joins the show. Colin is the president of Second Street, one of Canada's
00:05:25 leading advocacy groups. They've been all over the healthcare reform file. Colin, thanks for joining us.
00:05:30 Well, thanks for having me, Alex. It's a big day. And you were in some ways ahead of the curve on our
00:05:35 news of the day. On November 17th, you and Second Street released new public opinion research that shows a
00:05:42 majority of Canadians now support more choice in healthcare, hiring non-government providers to
00:05:47 deliver treatment. The poll was conducted by Leisure between October 31st and November 2nd.
00:05:53 You're quoted as saying, it's encouraging to see the support for several European-style health reform
00:05:58 options that have proven to deliver better results for patients. If more politicians get on board with
00:06:03 that change, then our public system could improve. Well, we are seeing a politician get on board with
00:06:08 this, Daniel Smith in Alberta. Tell us more about the results of your findings there and why you're
00:06:13 encouraged by Alberta's move to modernize healthcare with a dual practice model.
00:06:19 Sure. Well, I don't think it's any secret that our system is in crisis. We're having
00:06:24 huge problems across the country. Governments have spent 30 years throwing money at the system,
00:06:30 hoping something would work. And if we really stand back and be objective as possible about this,
00:06:37 it doesn't matter if it's a conservative, liberal, NDP government at the helm.
00:06:41 We really haven't had a leader in healthcare. And what I mean by that is a province that is delivering
00:06:46 consistent, top quality care to patients, short wait times, access to family, doctors, whatever.
00:06:55 We're talking about like a very well-run system. We haven't had that in Canada for 30 years,
00:06:59 and it didn't matter which party was in charge. And the reason is because it didn't matter the party,
00:07:05 they all kept the same structure of the system. They just kept throwing money at the system.
00:07:10 And so, you know, insanity is the, you know, the idea that you're going to keep doing the same thing
00:07:15 and expecting different results. So the good news in all this is that if you look to European systems,
00:07:21 they have what Canadians want. They have public systems, universal, everyone's covered.
00:07:25 You know, you get, you get in right away. It's quality treatment. Maybe not always. I mean,
00:07:30 no system's perfect, but it's, it's quality. And when patients are walking out the door,
00:07:35 they're not facing an enormous bill. So when you look at European systems and say, well,
00:07:42 how are they able to do what we want, but we can't do it? You have to look at the differences
00:07:47 between them. And when we polled Canadians on a few of those differences,
00:07:51 what you find is a large support. So one key difference in European systems, patients have a
00:07:58 choice. They can use the public system or they can pay privately. And in Canada, government barriers
00:08:04 generally prevent patients from doing this. You can go to another province and pay, but you cannot pay
00:08:09 in your own province. Quebec being one exception. So Canadians like the idea of being able to pay in
00:08:16 their own province if they don't want to use the public system. So that choice came in at about 59%
00:08:22 support. We pulled on that many times. It tends to range right around that 60% threshold. So, you know,
00:08:31 Canadians very much support moving forward with that, that change. Another key difference with Europe,
00:08:37 and this is significant, is that they fund their hospitals and the healthcare sector differently.
00:08:43 So what we do is we send a big check to a hospital each year and we say, good luck.
00:08:51 Doesn't make much sense. There's no accountability there.
00:08:54 No. And tons of administrators gobble that up as well. 0.96
00:08:57 Yeah, exactly. I mean, a lot gets eaten up in administration. There's no incentive to help more
00:09:01 patients because every patient walking in the door, it just means your budget goes like this and this.
00:09:06 And so you don't want patients. You know, one doctor famously said, like, the last thing a healthcare
00:09:11 or hospital administrator wants is a patient coming in the door because it's going to be done to budget.
00:09:17 Well, how does Europe do it? Well, like I said, they have a public system. So patients are getting
00:09:21 that quality care. What they do is they say, no, what we're going to do as a government is we're going
00:09:26 to give you a hospital money every time you help someone. And so they have a fee scale where they will pay
00:09:32 different amounts depending on what you're getting done. You know, you get like a small little
00:09:37 surgery on your finger or whatever. It's different than getting like open heart surgery, obviously,
00:09:41 right? When it's more, more complicated. So if you're a hospital and, you know, someone comes in
00:09:46 for a knee operation, let's say I'll make up a number here. They might get $20,000 for it. And then
00:09:53 another patient comes in and they need the same thing. They get another $20,000. So those hospitals are
00:09:58 incentivized to try to help as many patients as possible. Whereas our system has no incentive to
00:10:04 encourage you to just keep helping more and more patients. So, I mean, that's one key reason why they
00:10:10 have much shorter wait times. And then maybe a third thing that's very significant is they're not really
00:10:20 ideological like we are. We have this great debate about public and private and whatever, right?
00:10:25 And the union or stubborn, I think stubborn. They do this completely radical thing there, Alex,
00:10:32 their system focuses on what's best for the patient. Imagine that, imagine that a healthcare
00:10:36 system focused on what, what, what is best for the patient. So what I mean by that is their government
00:10:41 looks at it and says, it doesn't matter if a patient goes into a private clinic or a nonprofit or for
00:10:46 profit or whatever, we're, we as a government are going to pay the same amount. So let, you know,
00:10:50 I give the example of $20,000 for the, the knee operation. So if, if you need your knee done and
00:10:56 you live in whatever country, they will, that $20,000 will follow you into whatever facility
00:11:02 you believe will help you the best. So now you've got a bit of competition happening too.
00:11:08 Yeah. And, and these, these clinics are incentivized to make sure the money is spent on services that 0.99
00:11:14 can help you, the patients. So doctors, you know, surgeons, everything related to providing that
00:11:20 service to you, not adding another vice president or having more administrative staff or all these
00:11:27 expenses that don't actually help patients. So, some pretty radical differences there between us and
00:11:34 them, but like I say, generally European countries deliver better care. And when you ask Canadians
00:11:39 about each of those policies, I mentioned a majority support them. So yeah. And the framing has always
00:11:44 been dishonestly. It seems you either get the wild west of the American model where everything,
00:11:50 every hospital visits going to cost you 25 grand and it doesn't, if you have a proper healthcare plan,
00:11:55 you know, or you have ours, but it's like, no, there's clearly a middle ground. These are,
00:11:58 these are similarly progressive countries that, that share our, our values and our, our Canadian
00:12:03 mindedness. Like we can follow places like in Europe and Japan. Like before we get more into
00:12:10 this, I want to refer our audience to a terrific video you produced in Japan and, and I'll link it
00:12:15 in the show notes. I mean, gosh, getting healthcare right away. Imagine that. What was, what was that
00:12:20 experience like? And, and what did you learn? Yeah. So we, we went over there to learn about their
00:12:24 system. Um, and one of the interesting things is that there was a report by, I believe it was the OECD.
00:12:30 We referenced it in the video and anyone can watch the video it's on our YouTube page. Um, so it's
00:12:34 available for free, but the, the OECD report looked at a whole bunch of systems and they looked at
00:12:42 different categories of treatment and they were trying to look at where are the problem areas.
00:12:48 And then they showed it by country. So you could see for Canada, there was like a dot beside every
00:12:54 category, meaning we had problem, wait times for like everything, literally everything dots across
00:12:59 the board. Yeah. And then you look at Japan and it's like, there's no dots. There are no problems
00:13:05 with waiting for like, you know, cardiac surgery or to get a diagnostic scan or to get orthopedic
00:13:11 surgery, whatever, no dots, no wait time problems. So we went there to learn more about their system.
00:13:17 And for me personally, I had lived there 20 years ago, teaching English as a young and so to go back
00:13:23 to the country, it was, uh, uh, it was, it was great. Um, but it, the, the culture shock I experienced
00:13:30 was learning about their system because I didn't really use it when I was young, when I was living
00:13:35 there, I used it a couple of times, but for nothing major, but to go back and just hear again and again,
00:13:40 and again, oh, you need your knee done. Well, you could probably get in next week, the week after
00:13:44 we'll get you in within the month. This is what people in the healthcare system were telling us.
00:13:49 And it didn't matter if it was a, uh, a university hospital or a private hospital. I mean, that was
00:13:55 sort of the, the reality there, they can get you in right away. And, and one head of a, uh, hospital
00:14:03 in Tokyo, the university hospital there, it's in the video. This guy was shocked when I explained to him,
00:14:08 it's going to take a year to get your knee down. He's like, I loved that part. There was
00:14:12 bewilderment. Yeah. Like this guy was shocked, but this is, this is what you hear when you go
00:14:17 to other countries and you start talking about our system. Like they are shocked. They're like,
00:14:22 what Canada, you're a developed nation. Why are the wait times so long?
00:14:26 And we had, I think this is a recent, I think this is the correct stat. I was, I was reading it
00:14:30 recently. It was like, we had, I think Canada had 500,000 people walk out of emergency rooms last year,
00:14:36 having not received care. That's huge. It's something like that. MEI, the Montreal
00:14:41 Economic Institute, they've crunched that number. They do great work in that. Cause that's an
00:14:44 important question. And it's true. People are, they're walking out. The other thing that's just
00:14:49 as bad as a lot of people just aren't going in the first place. Yeah. It's not worth it. It's
00:14:54 going to take a day. Like if I ever have an ailment where I think, you know, uh, oh, this is an
00:14:58 emergency that the first thing I do is like, I grab a book. I charge my cell phone. It's like,
00:15:04 that's not actually emergency minded behavior. It's this is going to take a day. Let's let's
00:15:09 buckle down here. Oh yeah. Yeah. I mean, you know, thankfully you're still with us,
00:15:14 but some people aren't with us because they had to wait so long.
00:15:17 I know they go in for a heart complication. They're, they're sitting in a hallway. They
00:15:20 eventually go home. They've hit their head. It it's terrible. And then if they even get a consult,
00:15:25 it could take months. And then whatever the issue is, is metastasizing, you know, it, it, it, it's so
00:15:31 disappointing and we can't, we can't run a healthcare system on spite and we can't run it
00:15:36 on, on that stubbornness. Now, what kind of stories, obviously the news of the day ending
00:15:42 the week here is, is Alberta is Daniel Smith's sort of standing a thwart managed decline and
00:15:50 status quo and, and their decision to, to try to implement these changes. What kinds of stories
00:15:54 have Albertans shared with second street about traveling abroad for healthcare? How do you think
00:15:59 allowing this local private sort of payment option would benefit both patients and the economy?
00:16:05 Yeah. So it's fantastic. But Daniel Smith has announced, I mean, what the government is doing
00:16:09 there, they're leading the country when it comes to health reform. And what they're doing is trying
00:16:14 to take Alberta system closer and closer to these European models that I described. They're going to
00:16:19 allow choice. So Albertans no longer have to leave their province to pay for treatment. If they don't
00:16:24 want to use the public system, they can pay in Alberta, which is good for Alberta's economy on top of it.
00:16:29 It's good for the economy. It's good for those that don't pay because they're going to wait on,
00:16:35 wait for the public system. But these people that do pay will take pressure off of the public system
00:16:41 because every, you know, every time someone doesn't need the public system, then that's good
00:16:45 for the public system. It can concentrate on helping people that don't have that, that opportunity to,
00:16:50 to pay. So that is a good one. They're also changing how they fund the system in Alberta too.
00:16:55 They're going to be copying what I was talking about where they're funding procedures and services
00:16:59 to patients rather than sending big checks into healthcare systems and hoping that somehow the
00:17:04 money makes its way down to helping patients. So big changes in Alberta, two thumbs up. We're
00:17:10 going to have to wait and see how well this gets implemented, of course, but what they're promising to
00:17:14 do is really good. When you ask about patient stories, I mean, we've talked to lots of patients from
00:17:20 Alberta. We talked to a, a lady that was bouncing around in the Alberta system. This was several 1.00
00:17:26 years ago now, but she'd been bouncing around for like seven years, chronic pain, finally went to
00:17:31 Germany to get some surgery done. I believe it was on her neck and it helped a lot. She was able to get
00:17:36 like a good portion of her life back. Yeah. Uh, we talked to, uh, another lady, I think she went to 0.99
00:17:42 Mexico for her back surgery. I sat in, um, Calgary. This was, uh, I can't remember when it was several
00:17:52 months back. The video is on our website, but I sat down with four women from Alberta who had all
00:17:58 traveled all the way to Lithuania to get hips, hip operations. Like it's crazy. If you pull out a
00:18:06 globe or a map and you look at how far it is from Calgary to Lithuania, it's something like 7,000
00:18:10 kilometers. It is crazy far away. And these were women, they were in such bad shape that they wanted, 1.00
00:18:18 they needed to get their hips done so they could get their lives back. So they went all that way. 1.00
00:18:23 Um, you know, I know a guy I'm in the lower mainland and I know, uh, uh, uh, the guy who,
00:18:29 who blew his, uh, ACL, uh, ACL, MCL, uh, skiing. Okay. And he, he was told like two years and like,
00:18:36 you can't stay hobbled for two years. That's we used to push elders out on ice flows for less than
00:18:42 that. Like that is, uh, you know, foundationally sort of crippled and, you know, ended up having to go
00:18:48 to the BC lower mainland. I suppose has their, their one example of this private is that the can be 0.88
00:18:53 surgery clinic where he was able to go and actually be taken care of. But generally speaking,
00:18:58 if you're, you're in a pinch now in Ontario, it's, it's not even a dirty little secret. You go to
00:19:02 Buffalo or if you're in the BC lower mainland, you go down to Bellingham, you, you know, cannonball
00:19:07 run down to Washington. Yeah. Yeah. It's, uh, it's crazy. No other country does, but we do.
00:19:15 I should say no other developed country does this. There's some debate.
00:19:18 Yeah. We do the Cuba. We do the Cuba model. So it's us in Cuba. Congratulations.
00:19:23 Yeah. There's some debate about Cuba. I don't know. I mean, we, we, we have my colleague called
00:19:27 down there. She speaks Spanish and she asked a clinic and they said, no, you can't pay locally.
00:19:31 Someone else tells us, no, you can. I don't know. I mean, it's crazy when you're even having to ponder,
00:19:35 like, are we the exact same as Cuba or not? North Korea being the other ones. I mean,
00:19:40 Oh, good company.
00:19:40 North Canada. I mean, one of these things is not like the other.
00:19:43 Yeah. Or, or shouldn't be. Yeah. I think our, I think our economies, uh, are growing probably
00:19:49 the same amount at this point too. Now, how do we, how do we ensure this actually gets implemented
00:19:53 properly? I, I, there are regulatory boards that, you know, that need to buy in you. We have our
00:19:58 Medicare stalwarts that need to buy in it. Do you know of how the heck we, we ensure that this is a
00:20:05 success? Because I think my worry goes to my, my comms brain starts turning, which is, you know,
00:20:10 if there are some early hiccups, you're going to have the status quo folks turn around and go,
00:20:14 see, huh? We, we tried it. It didn't work. Let's go back to everyone dying on a wait list.
00:20:20 Yeah. Uh, very, very good question. I mean, the first thing I would do to, uh, for anyone that's
00:20:25 watching who thinks this is a good idea, all these changes I'm talking about, uh, take this video once
00:20:31 it's posted and share it with all your friends. The more Canadians that understand that the suffering
00:20:37 that's going on in this country doesn't need to be like it is that there are better systems that
00:20:43 we can copy and then deliver better results for Canadians, the better. So make sure that your
00:20:47 friends and family know about what's going on. So spread this clip around. Um, if you're, uh, you know,
00:20:54 if someone feels so inclined, share it with your local elected officials, your, your MLA is especially
00:20:59 because healthcare's provincial responsibility and make sure they understand these different changes
00:21:05 that can be done that help move our system towards what Canadians actually want. You know,
00:21:10 a universal model where everyone's covered, wait times are reasonable, uh, cares delivered in a
00:21:17 quality manner and people aren't facing NASA bills. So, you know, I think that's really important to,
00:21:23 you know, talk to your elected officials, let people know about what, uh, what's going on so that the
00:21:28 public understands, Hey, these governments on the road, you know, in the case of Albertans,
00:21:32 especially the provincial governments on the right track, you know, like I say, two big thumbs up.
00:21:36 They're what they're saying they're going to be doing. It's good. It's excellent. It's about time
00:21:41 we see this happen in this country. And, you know, I will be watching to make sure they implement it.
00:21:46 Right. But yeah, definitely want to see them, uh, keep moving in that direction.
00:21:50 No, we all need to get to get behind them on this. Cause it's some status quos are, are worse than others.
00:21:55 This one, you know, is we're needlessly losing people. We're making ourselves sicker.
00:22:01 Colin Craig, thank you for all your terrific work on this file and thank you for joining us.
00:22:05 Okay. Thanks a lot, Alex. Take care.