Juno News - December 13, 2023


Canada endorses UN pledge to phase out oil and gas

Topics
Mentioned
Almost 250k signatures for anti-Trudeau petition, but does it matter? Jordan Peterson offers to take over as Harvard president

Episode Stats


Length

44 minutes

Words per minute

169.45

Word count

7,512

Sentence count

366

Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

12

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of the Whatever Day I Have No Idea What Day It Is, Andrew Lawton talks about the climate conference in Dubai, and why we need to teach climate action to run. He also talks about why we should all be working on a "dead sprint" to phase out climate change.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:20 north hello and welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show on the
00:01:31 whatever day i have no idea what day it is it's wednesday i think uh this we're now getting to
00:01:35 the point of the year where no one has any idea what day or time it is at a certain point we'll
00:01:40 all just be in that weird twilight period between christmas and new year's in which we really have
00:01:46 no idea if we are even still alive, but we're not quite there yet. It's Wednesday, December,
00:01:51 something or other. It doesn't really matter too much. I know most of you have probably listened
00:01:54 to the podcast anyway, in which who am I to presume that you are listening to it on the day
00:02:00 that I am recording it on. So with that out of the way, I will say it is the finale of COP28,
00:02:06 which is the big giant climate confab in Dubai. Now they don't do these things by Zoom because
00:02:11 everyone knows if you want to save the planet and have people reduce their emissions, you all have
00:02:16 to fly on your planes from around the world to one particular country and have 100,000 people there
00:02:23 in that city who are using all the hotel rooms, who are eating all the fancy steak dinners, who are
00:02:29 consuming all of the resources that are required for a conference of this nature. That is the way
00:02:34 you solve the climate crisis. Don't let anyone tell you otherwise. Well, COP28, it's easy to
00:02:40 look at this as being one big giant gab fest but the problem is that when the countries get together
00:02:45 to gab it comes at a cost to the rest of us the things that they talk about there are things that
00:02:51 are implemented as policy in countries around the world that want to go along with dismantling
00:02:57 their economy and their reliance on oil and gas for this weird almighty climate goal all the while
00:03:04 places like China and India just kind of sit in the room and nod along knowing that they're going
00:03:09 to continue to industrialize and build and develop and emit and they will be the ones that get to
00:03:14 benefit when Canada decides that we need to phase out oil and gas. Now this year there was a little
00:03:20 bit of pushback to this phase out. It's often spoken about by the climate elites as though it's
00:03:26 an inevitability. We're just going to get rid of oil and gas. It's not a question of if but when
00:03:31 and we should do it sooner rather than later. But this time there were some people in the
00:03:35 delegations that said, maybe I don't actually want to do that. Maybe I, I mean, there was the one guy
00:03:41 who was the president of the conference in the United Arab Emirates who said earlier on, yeah,
00:03:46 there's no scientific basis for this phase out. Although as we'll be talking about in a few
00:03:50 moments with Mark Murano, he was very quickly slapped for being as honest as he was in that
00:03:57 moment. But it's important to understand the ideological outlook that the UN and the people
00:04:04 that are running these conferences have. Now, this is where I go back to the very beginning of this
00:04:09 when Simon Steele from the United Nations kicked things off with a very grim picture about how
00:04:15 things are. Take a look. We must teach climate action to run because this has been the hottest
00:04:25 year ever in humanity so many terrible records were broken and we are paying the price with
00:04:34 people's lives and livelihoods we're standing at a precipice facing the global stock take
00:04:45 and we've got two options either we can note the lack of progress tweaking our current best
00:04:53 practices and encourage ourselves to do more at some other point in time or we decide at what
00:05:04 point we'll have made everyone on the planet safe and resilient we decide to fund this transition
00:05:12 properly including the response to loss and damage and we decide to commit to a new energy system
00:05:23 If we do not signal the terminal decline of the fossil fuel era as we know it,
00:05:31 we welcome our own terminal decline.
00:05:35 And we choose to pay with people's lives.
00:05:41 Ooh, wow, quite the motivational speaker there.
00:05:43 He's a regular Tony Robbins.
00:05:45 It's basically, you're all going to die unless we in this room decide to save you.
00:05:51 But the only way we do that is by teaching climate action to run.
00:05:55 This is like the new UN children's book, See Spot Run.
00:05:58 See climate action run, see climate action walk, see climate action crawl.
00:06:03 But you only get to finish the book if the climate action is running.
00:06:06 It needs to be in a dead sprint, which means they need to accelerate all these things they
00:06:10 were talking about.
00:06:11 No tiptoeing around and saying it's not working.
00:06:13 You've got to go faster.
00:06:14 You've got to go harder.
00:06:16 And again, all of us around the world are the ones that have to pay for it.
00:06:20 What they're talking about here is monumental changes.
00:06:23 They're talking about wealth redistribution.
00:06:25 They're talking about, as they agreed today or yesterday, to a phase-out of oil and gas.
00:06:32 There was a bit of pushback, a bit of debate about this.
00:06:34 They weren't all entirely on board with doing this.
00:06:36 But in the draft agreement that all countries, including Canada, signed on to,
00:06:41 they said they are going to commit to a transition away from oil and gas, a phase-out of oil and gas.
00:06:47 Now, this may not be breaking news.
00:06:49 Justin Trudeau has used this language in the past, but it certainly re-ups and reiterates
00:06:54 that commitment. Now, Stephen Gilbeau, the environment minister who's been in Dubai,
00:06:59 I didn't know you could travel when you have a criminal record, but I guess he could.
00:07:03 He's been just downright giddy about this. There was the head of Greenpeace Canada posted this
00:07:08 tweet thread that I wanted to share with you. Keith Stewart says, is that tang in the post
00:07:14 cop 28 morning air from the salty tears of oil lobbyists or from the blood in the water
00:07:21 that is their balance sheets weighted down by what are now inevitably stranded assets he says this
00:07:27 is historic oh by the way still insufficient because they need to do more and uh need to do
00:07:33 more aggressively what they're trying to do now and then he lauds of all the people there
00:07:38 Stephen Gilboa in particular. Now, Stephen Gilboa, of course, responds to this, has a little bit of a
00:07:44 Twitter bromance with the Climate Radical. Thank you so much. And yes, probably a mix of all of
00:07:50 the above. Winky face emoji. Oh, just so cute. Isn't it nice to see Climate Radicals all singing 0.71
00:07:56 from the same songbook in this? Well, we're going to talk about this in a bit more detail, but I
00:08:02 first wanted to bring in Mark Morano, who has gone into the belly of the beast once again. He was in
00:08:07 dubai at cop 28 he's been uh we had him on last year when he was at what he termed the
00:08:11 charmel shakedown in egypt mark good to talk to you thanks for coming on today thank you andrew
00:08:17 happy to be here i'm finally back from dubai one of the greatest cities i've ever visited by the
00:08:21 way yeah so last year you uh rode in on the camel at what you dubbed the charmel shakedown in egypt
00:08:28 today it's uh or this time it was dubai uh what's been the the overarching theme of it what was the
00:08:34 flavor of the conference this year? It was, I would say, delusion, insanity, and a complete
00:08:41 lack of any basis in grounded reality. So that was the theme. And what I mean by that is they
00:08:47 literally are demanding everyone, and including the final text, say that we need to phase out
00:08:52 fossil fuels for the world. They are literally believing their own bullshit. They're believing 1.00
00:08:59 that solar and wind are going to replace fossil fuels, and they need to formally enshrine it now
00:09:05 in United Nations climate agreements. It got so bad that the president of the COP pushed back on
00:09:11 this with the former president of Ireland, Mary Robinson. And he said, of course, there's no
00:09:16 science to support that. And he was right. The UN's own documents from ClimateGate, Phil Jones,
00:09:21 the lead UN scientist, admitted that the whole net zero, 1.5 degree, 2 degrees Celsius temperature
00:09:26 goals. We're pulled from thin air. They're just political goals. But they want to make it sound
00:09:31 as though they're apocalyptic scientific predictions. He had to back down from his
00:09:36 predictions. Saudi Arabia, if you want to know who the hero of this conference was, Saudi Arabia
00:09:41 is the one who said, this is just delusional. We're not going along with this. Guess who was
00:09:45 doubling down and pushing us to this renewable replacing fossil fuel? China. China at this 0.79
00:09:52 conference literally said, literally doubled down and wanted to make sure that the United States
00:09:58 relied more on China because China was the one pushing us. If they get us off more and more 0.99
00:10:03 fossil fuels and more on renewables, guess what? It makes us the once free West more and more
00:10:08 dependent on China, which essentially has a monopoly now, either through China and through
00:10:13 their African subsidiaries with the underage kids and poor human rights and low environmental 1.00
00:10:18 standards, all the mining. So that was the theme. It's literally the end of fossil fuels. And then
00:10:24 of course, the secondary themes included things like our vice president, Kamala Harris, showing up
00:10:28 and pledging $3 billion plus to the UN Climate Slush Fund. And guess what? This money, guess
00:10:36 who the highest attending delegations are historically? African nations, South American
00:10:41 nations, the poorest nations are in high attendance at these conferences. Why would that be? You may
00:10:46 ask. Very simple. They are out there to suck at the teat of the United Nations. And here's the
00:10:52 thing. I talked to a development activist, Leon Lowe in South Africa at a previous UN climate
00:10:56 summit. He said this will money will go to the country's leaders who are best able to keep their
00:11:02 citizens locked in poverty. So if you're a socialist dictator, authoritarian in Africa, 0.87
00:11:07 you are now going to be getting the most UN cash, more than other leaders, because you can
00:11:12 keep your citizens locked in poverty. Aside from that, even the Financial Times thought this was
00:11:17 going too far. They had an entire feature article during the Dubai UN Climate Summit
00:11:22 about how Western carbon offset companies to assuage us, the white liberal, not liberal,
00:11:29 but the white guilt association and the wealthy nations was buying up sometimes 25% of land
00:11:34 in African nation after African nation to literally set it aside so they can't develop it. 0.93
00:11:40 so white liberals can feel good about themselves in other countries.
00:11:43 So we're doubly harming development in African and poor nations in South America.
00:11:48 We're paying their leaders, giving them the most money to those who don't develop.
00:11:52 And we're stopping them from developing by buying up massive carbon offsets.
00:11:57 And sure, it'll give a little bit of cash to the country now,
00:11:59 but it's going to hurt them long term.
00:12:01 It's just insanity from beginning to end.
00:12:03 Let me go back to that comment you alluded to by the president of COP.
00:12:07 This was Sultan Al-Jabbar, I believe.
00:12:10 who comes out representing the UAE and says that,
00:12:13 oh yeah, no, there's no science, it doesn't make sense,
00:12:16 this whole phase out of oil and gas,
00:12:18 which is a very consistent position with being the guy
00:12:22 who is tasked with handling this file on a very oil-rich nation.
00:12:27 Last year, the conference was in Egypt.
00:12:29 Again, Egypt is not a country that is not making money off of its oil reserves here.
00:12:35 I think it has like the sixth largest in Africa or something like that.
00:12:38 and the UAE, an even larger supply.
00:12:40 So, I mean, these countries hosting these summits in the first place,
00:12:44 like, is it just paying lip service?
00:12:46 Like, are they even true believers in this?
00:12:49 No, no.
00:12:50 The way this works is I've been to 18 out of the last 20 since 2014.
00:12:54 And I've also been to two UN Earth summits.
00:12:56 But the way they do it, they just pick countries.
00:12:59 And they usually pick countries that are hostile.
00:13:02 Now, we've had it in Poland three times.
00:13:04 you may ask, why is Poland hosting a UN climate summit pretty relatively close together? It's
00:13:09 almost like 2008, 2013, 2017. I can't remember the exact, 2018 or something. And the reason they
00:13:18 pick these countries is they try to go all around the world. They're going to be going to Australia.
00:13:21 They're going to be going to India. But they try to pick countries where they try to woo them in.
00:13:26 So they want to give them business. But just hosting a UN climate summit, this was the largest
00:13:30 ever. It's 100,000 plus people. So first of all, it's good PR for the UN to these countries. It's
00:13:36 a sort of payout saying we're going to bring in an unbelievable amount of business. Think of 100,000.
00:13:41 Oh, yeah. Well, when they had it in Glasgow, there was not a single hotel room available
00:13:44 in the entirety of Scotland that week. It's the biggest thing going. I mean,
00:13:48 I can't think of any other corporate, World Economic Forum, even I don't even think the
00:13:52 who is this. This is probably the largest international conference that I'm aware of.
00:13:56 Anyway, 100,000 plus petitions, this was a record.
00:13:59 So that's one thing.
00:14:00 And then they bring in all the people
00:14:03 and they sort of shame the countries.
00:14:04 That's what they did with Poland. 0.99
00:14:06 And I went to Polish minors 1.00
00:14:08 and the Polish government was never that happy,
00:14:10 but they're always willing to host them.
00:14:12 So they figured they're having a dialogue.
00:14:14 So what happens here is they've had it
00:14:15 in the Middle East a couple of times.
00:14:16 They've had it in Qatar, in Doha, a couple of places,
00:14:21 a couple of other locations in the Middle East.
00:14:23 And they're going there because they want to highlight
00:14:25 that they can be part of this UN Climate Summit.
00:14:29 And a lot of times, the way they get the developing world 1.00
00:14:31 is they're paying their leaders to come.
00:14:34 The way they get the developed world 1.00
00:14:36 and even the oil-rich nations
00:14:37 is they're going to woo them in.
00:14:39 They're going to give them a lot of money
00:14:40 in terms of all this business.
00:14:42 And they're going to bring them
00:14:43 into the community of nations.
00:14:44 And it works because, you know,
00:14:45 Sultan al-Jabbar literally did not want to fight.
00:14:49 Once he made his comments,
00:14:50 his spokesman immediately backed down.
00:14:52 He backed down.
00:14:53 They're not interested.
00:14:54 they're interested in the virtue signaling. They may not follow through on it with, you know,
00:14:59 even if they make a pledge, they may not follow through an action. But unfortunately, they're
00:15:03 still allowing this fraudulent process to go. What I think needs to happen, we need a coalition. I'd
00:15:09 call it a Clexit. You had the Brexit. We need a climate exit from the UN treaty. We need countries
00:15:14 to band together and just say, hell no to net zero. It's anti-human. It's insane. It's Soviet 0.98
00:15:20 style central planning. We're done. We're not part of this anymore. Donald Trump, of course,
00:15:25 tried it, but he did it tepidly. He just withdrew us. He didn't withdraw us from the whole United
00:15:29 Nations climate process. He didn't withdraw us from funding the UN panel and all that stuff.
00:15:34 We need actually Donald Trump to triple down. And hopefully if he gets elected, he will. I don't
00:15:38 know who elected, but that's the problem. So what's happened here is all this virtue signaling
00:15:43 for decades in the green agenda, they got away with. But now we're hitting where the rubber hits
00:15:48 the road solar wind collapsing we have at least a dozen offshore wind collapsing in the us the ev
00:15:54 mandates collapsing all the global automakers saying no it's not working they're piling up on
00:15:59 our lots we're not going to do more you have the energy collapse in europe with hastened by the
00:16:04 russian war now israeli conflict all of this is just they can't afford the virtue signal anymore
00:16:09 but the un knows how this works it's a campaign cost so they double down and face of all of this
00:16:15 insanity, they wanted to phase out of all fossil fuels. And by the way, I went to fashion shows
00:16:21 there. They had red carpet events, sustainable clothing and fashion. I asked the spokesman there
00:16:27 at the UN with their keynote speaker about the C40 Cities report sponsored by Google, Ikea,
00:16:33 funded by Mayor Bloomberg, who was the chairman, about the limit of three new items of clothing
00:16:37 per person per year by 2030. And their answer is, well, it depends. If you're getting synthetic
00:16:43 clothing, yes. If you're buying hemp-made organic clothing, maybe from the skin of a cockroach,
00:16:51 then yeah, you can get more than three. This was an insane conference. They had children's events,
00:16:56 all the usual stuff you would expect, but everything is just so much more insane.
00:17:00 And the overriding theme, by the way, was this bypassing a democracy. Because right before it,
00:17:05 the 200 medical journals wanted to declare climate a public health emergency. The Biden
00:17:11 administration is being urged to do it. What that would do is take this even further out of
00:17:15 democracy. Because remember, we didn't vote to ban gas-powered cars. We didn't vote to ban meat
00:17:19 eating. We didn't vote to ban agriculture, restrictions on high-yield agriculture. But
00:17:24 it's all just happening because of corporate government collusion through edicts. And if
00:17:28 they get a climate emergency, whether it's through the WHO or whether it's even in the United States,
00:17:32 it gives Biden 130 new executive powers. NBC News actually said it would give him COVID-like
00:17:38 powers, what mayors and governors had. And he's a lame duck. So this is always a tool on the table. 0.98
00:17:43 Anyway, that's what the UN wants. It is, I call it the Great Reset Summit, because none of it had
00:17:48 to do with democracy. All of it had to do with rationing energy, food, transportation, freedom
00:17:53 of movement, so that they could be more in charge. And it was just nuts. And you had King Charles
00:17:58 there, you had Al Gore, you had John Kerry, a funny stat. On John Kerry, though, let me bring
00:18:05 this up because John Kerry is an example of how ideological this all is and you see the moving
00:18:10 goalposts it used to be about emissions and then it became about temperature and now it's just about
00:18:16 phasing out fossil fuels so the reason I bring up John Kerry here you have the oil and gas sector
00:18:20 trying to meet them halfway and say well we're going to invest in carbon capture and John Kerry
00:18:24 comes out oh no that carbon capture is nothing I think he called it the great facade because he
00:18:29 just wants the industry to be obliterated and effectively outlawed. He absolutely does. John
00:18:35 Kerry, first of all, his speech here before the conference was all about shutting down not only
00:18:42 U.S. coal, but we had the petition to do the natural gas by U.N. delegates targeting the
00:18:48 United States. So they take away coal and gas and we're left literally a whimpering nation begging
00:18:53 China for what scraps, begging Venezuela, the Middle East. John Kerry has no problem with any
00:18:58 of that because in his mind, ideological mind, his legacy for the world is going to be saving
00:19:05 the planet. And he really thinks that in order to do that, you're going to break a lot of eggs
00:19:10 to make this beautiful utopian omelet of some kind of world. And he's pushing that. He's also
00:19:15 pushing, as you mentioned, carbon capture and storage. And the money going into that is insane.
00:19:20 But here's the thing you have to understand. The Inflation Reduction Act, so-called in the United
00:19:25 States was probably the most evil genius bill that we've ever seen passed by the United States
00:19:31 Congress, certainly in the green energy environment. Unlike the President Obama's
00:19:35 green stimulus of 2009, which was a boatload of money, I think it was like $70 billion.
00:19:40 It got dispersed and then it sort of died out. So you had a lot of success stories and then
00:19:45 these companies would go bankrupt and disappear and, you know, Solandra, et cetera. Yeah. But
00:19:49 the difference with this, and here's the thing, Politico has a whole article there. European
00:19:54 nations want to model. The difference with the Inflation Reduction Act, it bakes in for decades
00:19:59 green mandates, subsidies, regulations that just keep kicking and kicking and kicking and kicking.
00:20:05 So you're going to have companies, governors, legislators, states, everyone just sucking at
00:20:12 that teat for decades to come on this money that's going to be completely reauthorized and reauthorized
00:20:17 and reauthorized. And it makes the green agenda not go away like we had under Obama once the
00:20:22 money runs out because the money is designed never to run out and this is what you use this this wealth
00:20:27 transfer from the west to the south as being a feature and not a bug of this all yeah not yeah
00:20:33 Otto Edenhofer who years ago said this was not about environmental policy this was about
00:20:38 redistributing wealth by climate policy this has nothing to do with environmental I mean he was
00:20:43 very explicit the whole IPCC basis and the climate treaty basis this is not about environment at all
00:20:51 It's about creating what they see as equity in the world.
00:20:55 And unfortunately, even though I would say climate skeptics, if you will, are winning.
00:20:59 We just had a Nobel Prize winning scientist, Dr. John Clouser, who won the Nobel last year, come out and say climate basically is a is a he didn't see the word hoax, but he said basically was pseudoscience and it was nonsense.
00:21:10 And he went on in The Washington Post actually featured it, you know, Nobel winner dissents on climate.
00:21:16 I mean, I bet the reporter and editor who allowed that article to go with that headline has lost their job or been demoted.
00:21:22 But none of that matters because they now post-March 2020 know the game plan forward.
00:21:29 And the game plan forward is not about public opinion.
00:21:31 They could care less that recent public polling, at least in the U.S., is showing skepticism and reaching new heights.
00:21:36 People don't trust the institutions.
00:21:38 They could care less about what people don't trust, whether it's public health now or the climate agencies, because they have their model.
00:21:44 They're going to bypass democracy. 0.99
00:21:46 They have corporate government collusion. We now have banks who are joining up saying they're not going to give car loans to people who want to buy gas powered cars in working in collusion with the ESG, with the BlackRock, with the United Nations and the World Economic Forum.
00:22:00 And so we are citizens facing perhaps something we haven't ever faced this nakedly.
00:22:05 They are just doubling down on raw power and bypassing a democracy with corporate government collusion.
00:22:10 And that's what this UN conference was celebrating. That's why if you watched it, you were just like, this is insane.
00:22:16 They're talking about phasing out fossil fuels.
00:22:18 They're talking about billions here.
00:22:19 They're talking about Soviet-style central planning for decades into the future with
00:22:23 all this net zero.
00:22:24 I mean, again, regulations on every aspect of your life down to how many clothes you
00:22:28 can buy, to the cars, to your thermostat, to your diets.
00:22:32 The World Economic Forum was there.
00:22:34 The World Health Organization was there.
00:22:35 It's just incredible.
00:22:36 And by the way, one little note is the British Foreign Secretary, Richie Rich, as Mark Stein
00:22:41 calls him richie sunak and king charles all flew on three separate private jets to the conference
00:22:47 but it's okay because they're important the same conference by the way which cnn coincided an
00:22:52 article literally cnn travel article and i have as my headline at climate depot carbon passports
00:22:59 uh are the thing of the future for travel they're talking about massive restrictions on international
00:23:05 travel when we need carbon passports limits when you hit your max you can't travel we have
00:23:09 activists saying under declared climate emergency you can't just fly whenever you want it has to be
00:23:13 quote morally justified this was all the sentiment at this un conference they have like the diplomatic
00:23:19 passport equivalent of the carbon passport on theirs it's a very much a different rule they
00:23:24 have a higher limit or no limit at all well you did great work they're glad you made it out alive
00:23:28 mark morano you can check out his work over at climate depot.com thanks so much mark
00:23:33 thank you and we also did a protest which you can go to climate depot and see we did a
00:23:37 just say no style protest we blocked traffic and we said no to net zero and no to meat bans so did
00:23:43 you destroy any priceless art no we didn't yeah okay all right well you have some standards unlike
00:23:48 the uh the other folks you're up against mark thanks very much thank you andrew appreciate it
00:23:53 always always good to talk to uh mark baron actually i think we have we have the video
00:23:57 of his little pro i yeah i think we have the video of the protest right sean can we play that
00:24:01 Seafact, in the tradition of just say no to oil, decided to just say no to net zero by
00:24:11 by conducting a bus blockade at the UN Climate Summit in Dubai.
00:24:41 stop net zero save red meat you know what i'd vote for anyone that runs on that platform alone
00:25:04 right there uh stop net zero save red meat yes save the red meat you know all these climate
00:25:10 bureaucrats when they go to these conferences are eating a healthy diet of red meat. I'm actually
00:25:14 going to be going back to Davos in January with Sean and with our reporter and editor Cosman
00:25:20 Georgia. We're going to be reporting from WEF and I assure you they may love writing about and
00:25:25 talking about fake meat but there is absolutely real meat on the menu whenever you go to those
00:25:31 swanky Swiss alpine restaurants over there as I'm sure there was in Dubai, there was in Egypt,
00:25:37 There will be next year in Australia and all the like.
00:25:41 So you can catch up with Mark Morano's coverage over at ClimateDepot.com.
00:25:45 Wanted to turn from the global to the provincial, but to further complicate things,
00:25:50 the provincial tends to be the national in this particular context.
00:25:54 Ontarians are very, very, very familiar with a guy by the name of Mike Harris.
00:26:01 Mike Harris was elected Premier of Ontario just under 30 years ago, back in 1995.
00:26:08 And what was interesting about the Harris years is that they're held up as being by so many people in the province,
00:26:16 especially teachers and basically just teachers, as being this great villain.
00:26:21 I mean, his name is a curse word.
00:26:23 But you talk to ordinary people, you talk to Conservatives, and Mike Harris is an absolute hero.
00:26:29 And I think Mike Harris, for a lot of the time, has not really had his story told the way it needed to be.
00:26:36 And by that I mean he revolutionized politics in Ontario.
00:26:39 He took a party, the Ontario Progressive Conservatives, which was always a very squishy, moderate, elite party.
00:26:47 And he turned it into one that was very grassroots oriented.
00:26:49 He had the Common Sense Revolution, a rather legendary roadmap and platform that was unafraid to tackle some very difficult challenges.
00:27:00 And the Common Sense Revolution turns 30 years old, and Mike Harris's legacy is finally being put in what I think is an appropriate context here in a new book, which has been quite well-hyped, which is good for a political book, called The Harris Legacy, Reflections on a Transformational Premier.
00:27:16 You can see it there and get it on Amazon and other places fine books are sold.
00:27:21 It has some fantastic contributions from a number of characters, many of whom will be
00:27:24 familiar.
00:27:25 And it was edited by my favorite Alistair Campbell.
00:27:29 No, not that hack that works for Tony Blair, but the much superior Alistair Campbell who
00:27:34 joins me on the line now.
00:27:36 Alistair, good to talk to you.
00:27:37 Thanks for being with me today.
00:27:39 Absolute pleasure.
00:27:40 Thanks for the invitation.
00:27:41 So let's start with the why now, because Mike Harris has for decades now, but now
00:27:46 of public life every now and then he may pop up in an interview but why did you feel this was an
00:27:51 anthology that 2023 warranted so i think uh the urgency of this uh maybe didn't get felt by others
00:28:00 but during the period when premier ford named uh mike harris to be a member of the order of ontario
00:28:08 it was his mini tempest in the media teapot and it became very clear that the only historical legacy
00:28:15 that the mainstream media wanted to cover was Walkerton and Ipperwash. And I felt strongly
00:28:23 that the real history was being kind of cancelled. And so, at the side of my desk during COVID,
00:28:29 I started recruiting different specialist authors to help me kind of write the true historical
00:28:37 record of the time, policy area by policy area. And I was able to recruit some fantastic talent
00:28:44 from David Frum, through Jack Mintz, through Bill Robson. But I didn't just kind of ask Tories.
00:28:51 I asked liberals, I asked Greens, I asked academics, I asked journalists who were nonpartisan.
00:28:57 And the core takeaway is maybe the most intriguing part of this legacy. It turns out almost nothing
00:29:04 he did was reversed. And so maybe all of this kind of mainstream take of, you know,
00:29:13 Paris is a brief blip in the otherwise benign progressive trajectory of Ontario politics
00:29:19 isn't right and that in fact through education and welfare and tax rates all the way through
00:29:26 municipal reform and parkland creation and protection of the Oak Ridges Moraine just on a
00:29:33 consistent policy area by policy area basis what Mike did turned out to be permanent and we're
00:29:40 actually living in uh harris's ontario today i ran as a pc candidate in the 2018 election and and
00:29:49 what was always so fascinating is you'd knock on doors and you'd walk up to this giant giant giant
00:29:55 mansion of a house i'm exaggerating a little bit but by london ontario standards a mansion and
00:30:00 you know the person would come to the door and be like i'm a teacher and we still haven't
00:30:04 recovered from mike harris i'm i'm and you'd look at well you know your husband looks like
00:30:08 like he's in the pool back there. And, you know, this house is pretty big, like, but there does
00:30:12 seem to be this very revisionist approach that unions, public sector unions have about Mike
00:30:18 Harris, in particular, which was that, you know, he just decimated them and crippled them. And
00:30:22 when you say that nothing has been reversed of his legacy, I guess maybe there, there's a bit
00:30:27 of truth that there is still some lingering effect in the public sector from what he did. But
00:30:31 but where does that come from? Because I can't think of a politician that still has as much
00:30:36 venom 30 years after the fact. I mean, even George Bush, I think, was viewed more favorably
00:30:41 by people that hated him more quickly. But Harris never really got that.
00:30:46 The intensity of the public sector union resistance to the changes that were implemented
00:30:51 during the common sense revolution was visceral. And it actually started before Harris. The
00:30:59 MVP government of Bob Ray tried to introduce something called the social contract, which was
00:31:05 effort to save union jobs, but still control government spending. And it ripped that party 0.96
00:31:10 apart. And in the course of that, I think he discovered he probably wasn't actually an NDPer
00:31:14 himself. So the war began before we got there. And it just intensified when we did. Somehow the
00:31:22 teachers union leadership convinced themselves they were all Arthur Scargill and Mike was
00:31:27 Margaret Thatcher and they were the coal miners. And if they didn't fight back, they would be 0.75
00:31:31 exterminated which of course given the critical function the public sector teachers unions perform
00:31:38 in our system is absurd but somehow they've managed to maintain this intensity the core
00:31:44 point in bill robson's excellent chapter on education is in fact that ontario kids scores
00:31:51 on exams relative to other provinces and other countries in the world improved during this time
00:31:56 and what's lasted standardized testing grade three grade six grade nine published results
00:32:03 mandatory literacy exam before you graduate all of that component of what was in the Harris
00:32:09 reforms of the time hated by the teachers or not it's still there and even when the teachers got
00:32:16 what they thought was a more benign regime and McGuinty and when those things were not changed
00:32:22 And nor was the centralized negotiation between the province and the unions, which was a revolutionary part of what Harris did.
00:32:30 It did not go back to negotiation with 78 amateur boards of education up against the strongest and smartest and most sophisticated public sector unions in the world, I think.
00:32:41 there was a time i mean if you go back now you know 20 20 some odd years where people were
00:32:47 pushing him to move to federal politics and mike harris was being courted to run for the leadership
00:32:53 of the canadian alliance now i mean obviously we i think a lot of people were probably happy with
00:32:58 what ended up happening stephen harper winning and then eventually merging the parties but
00:33:02 what was it that you think prevented him from trying to really parlay what he had done into
00:33:08 in Ontario into something bigger? Because I think he did have an opportunity to do something. I mean,
00:33:14 even if he didn't end up leading the alliance, he probably could have been a federal cabinet
00:33:18 minister and had a bit of a different trajectory than he chose to, which was transitioning into
00:33:22 relative obscurity after office. Yeah, so I think a couple of thoughts there. First of all,
00:33:28 a key contribution of the Harris legacy was three of the most outstanding cabinet ministers of the
00:33:33 Harper Governor, Flaherty, Baird and Clement, all of whom were blooded in the revolution and made,
00:33:41 I think, significant contributions because they had already done big change at the government
00:33:48 level in Ontario. I think, honestly, people underestimated just how hard the job was of
00:33:55 implementing that common sense revolution. And when Mike stepped down, when asked if he had any
00:34:00 regrets at that final Queen's Park press conference. And he answered, yes, he should have done more
00:34:05 faster. But I think he was genuinely done. I think he felt like he had come with a mission
00:34:12 he'd executed against the plan. As we now know in this book, what he contributed has led to the
00:34:21 Ontario that honestly remains one of the most attractive places to move to in the world,
00:34:26 if you can get here. And that's a lasting legacy, and I don't feel like he needed to do more in his
00:34:33 own head. You will also see in this book two excellent contributions on what he did in federal
00:34:39 provincial relations, one by the late Hugh Siegel and one by a former bureaucrat, Craig McFadgen,
00:34:45 that shows, in fact, that Mike had a huge impact on the rebalancing of the Canadian Federation
00:34:50 itself after the near fateful experience of the Quebec referendum. And that Mike had already
00:34:57 done an awful lot on the federal stage as well without ever having, I think, felt the need to
00:35:03 run himself at that level. I know you were obviously involved heavily in the 95 campaign
00:35:10 in particular. Well, your bio says you were the message guy. Everyone knows titles are always a
00:35:15 bit murky on campaigns. But I did want to ask you about his approach to messaging, because
00:35:20 one of the criticisms that I've heard about Mike Harris, and I don't know if you would agree with
00:35:25 it or not, is that he was so focused on the policy that he often didn't think about as much
00:35:31 the messaging of it and the packaging of that policy. And I'm curious what your take on that
00:35:36 was with your involvement in that campaign. And just in general, a 30,000 foot view now that you
00:35:41 have the benefit of hindsight on his government.
00:35:44 So I think the messaging of Harris was actually one of his strengths.
00:35:51 Somehow he radiated kind of a sense of a normal guy who was tackling big projects and trying
00:36:00 to get things done and then did what he said.
00:36:04 It wasn't just the shock of coming from 30 points behind in six weeks to a landslide
00:36:09 majority in 95. What you've got to remember was that in 99, there was effectively a second election,
00:36:15 which was really a referendum on the Harris Conincense Revolution, and he won a bigger
00:36:21 majority. And the messaging of Harris, I think, was tight and effective. But you're right,
00:36:29 he was a policy premier. And that's not always the way to win. Some people can do it with the
00:36:38 right image or the right tone uh i think of a politician who promised sunny ways and you can't
00:36:45 remember much else uh and we may be all paying a price for uh falling for that uh but in the end
00:36:52 uh harris had i think excellent messaging and strong policy and as we're watching the term
00:36:59 common sense be uh given a new lease on life uh federally by uh the conservative leader now
00:37:07 I think it's important to reflect on how the brand needs to be connected to content
00:37:15 in order for it to be as effective as it was when Mike Harris used it.
00:37:20 One of the big challenges in federal politics for the Conservative Party has always been the
00:37:26 factionalism. You have to unite Quebec Tories and Atlantic Canadians and Albertans and rural,
00:37:33 red Tory, urban, blue Tory, all of this. Ontario doesn't have as much factionalism. There still is
00:37:40 some. And I'm curious, especially with where he came in the history of the PC party, a party that
00:37:46 had had the much discussed dynasty and was not really a hard line, what we would call blue Tory
00:37:55 party. How was he at that party unity factor? How well did he bring his supporters and members
00:38:01 behind what he was doing? Well, it's probably one of the more controversial chunks of the book,
00:38:06 but the discussion about how he unified the party by winning a one-member-one-vote convention,
00:38:12 the first of those, was actually critical. He went into that first election in 1990,
00:38:19 barely survived, picked up a handful more seats, but was still in third place.
00:38:24 But because he had won in a one-member-one-vote system, he actually had the full support of the
00:38:29 party. He did a masterful job between 90 and 95 in bridging the different factions of the party
00:38:37 by bringing the top talent from across the different factions into his campaign team.
00:38:42 And then I think allowing that team to create a strategy that worked for his personality,
00:38:52 met his demand for policy content and then allowed the campaign to focus on things that
00:39:00 unified conservatives lower taxes balancing the budget significant welfare reform significant
00:39:10 education reform pretty meaty content but stuff that as conservatives it spoke to everyone
00:39:17 and then there were some surprises in that that people forget now we swept the 905 uh it turned
00:39:24 out that you know mandatory work for welfare was incredibly powerful policy in new immigrant hindu 0.53
00:39:32 muslim sikh communities that i honestly i'm not sure we pulled accurately on that before
00:39:38 because it spoke to their community values in the same way that it spoke to ontario's
00:39:42 community values uh and what harris was able to achieve in bringing a whole ontario together
00:39:49 and a whole party together by focusing on stuff that actually works for everyone
00:39:56 except perhaps some teachers uh was pretty potent and uh and actually can and will work again
00:40:03 i i was in school during the harris years and i remember the teacher just seething as they were
00:40:11 handing out those what were they called the my ontario books these little books that uh hair the 0.97
00:40:16 harris government had printed to give to every student and in retro as a kid i didn't really
00:40:20 care one way or another it was just you know 10 minutes out of class that we had to do this but i
00:40:23 recall that was again one of the other things the teachers really i didn't like but again a way to
00:40:28 go directly to the people which is uh something that we see politicians doing more of now bypassing
00:40:33 the media here's a book about our province and i think that uh what we achieved right from the
00:40:39 start putting out the platform a year in advance. We printed two and a half million copies of that
00:40:45 platform. So everybody could read it for themselves, do the math, kick the tires, look under the hood
00:40:51 and decide whether they liked it or not. And when he held it up at that debate in 1995 and says,
00:40:56 I will resign if I do not keep the promises in this platform, it was incredibly powerful.
00:41:02 And it resonated because there was this kind of deep, visceral distrust of politicians.
00:41:08 And here was one saying, I actually believe this stuff.
00:41:12 I will really do this stuff.
00:41:14 And if you don't like it afterwards, you can vote me out.
00:41:17 And in fact, in 99, many of the people who voted to reelect him didn't like all of what
00:41:23 he had done, but they really liked a politician who honored their vote by doing exactly what
00:41:32 he promised.
00:41:33 yeah i mean even from critics of him that was one thing i i've heard you know going back to his
00:41:39 years say well he did what he said he was gonna do uh and that's the thing he had been remarkably
00:41:44 transparent about his agenda ontarians gave him a mandate and he he very much did it well
00:41:48 it was a very i'll say in the the canon of ontario politics your book which you edited was a
00:41:54 tremendously refreshing read and i i know it delves into the policy at times which for people
00:41:59 like me is good, but it's important, I think. So the book is The Harris Legacy. You can see it up
00:42:04 on your screen in a second there. Reflections on a Transformational Premiere edited by Alistair
00:42:09 Campbell. Alistair, thank you so much. Really appreciate it and well done on this. Thanks. I
00:42:13 appreciate the opportunity to chat. All right. Thanks very much. And that does it for us. I've
00:42:18 been telling you this week we are going to do next week a Letters to Andrew show. You can get
00:42:23 your questions in by emailing andrew at truenorthcanada.com. I'm not going to reply to
00:42:29 them this week, so you don't need to resend them. I'm going to put them all in a little bundle and
00:42:32 we'll do a special edition of the show next week in which we will answer some of your questions,
00:42:37 however fun, wacky, odd, or off the wall they are. But don't make it like three and a half pages
00:42:41 long. I got one of those and I'm like, it would take the whole show just to read the questions.
00:42:45 So nothing good takes that long to say. That's my motto. Well, I've just came up with it now,
00:42:49 but maybe it would be a good motto.
00:42:51 In any case, we will all have a great time
00:42:53 with that next week.
00:42:54 Hope you have a wonderful rest of the day.
00:42:56 We will see you tomorrow.
00:42:58 Same time, same place here on True North.
00:43:00 Thank you, God bless and good day to you all.
00:43:03 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:43:05 Support the program by donating to True North
00:43:07 at www.tnc.news.
00:43:19 We'll be right back.
00:43:49 We'll be right back.