Juno News - March 03, 2025


Canada wants to kick Trump out of the G7?

Topics
Mentioned
“Common sense legislation” forthcoming Trade War reaction ⧸ Trudeau LIVE press conference ⧸ Are the polls legit (ft. Hamish Marshall)

Episode Stats


Length

45 minutes

Words per minute

205.24

Word count

9,395

Sentence count

250

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

10

sentences flagged

Hate speech

18

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

On this episode of The Candace Malan Show, host Candice Malan is joined by Alex Zoltan, a crime reporter at True North, and Marty Belanger, a reporter at the Toronto Star, to discuss President Donald Trump's meeting with Ukrainian President Vladimir Zelensky.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hi, I'm Candace Malcolm, and welcome to The Candace Malcolm Show. We have a great episode
00:00:08 for you. I hope everyone had a wonderful weekend. Hope you had some time with your family and
00:00:12 friends and a nice relaxing one. And we're back into a crazy week. We're still reacting to what
00:00:17 has happened on Friday when President Donald Trump welcomed Ukrainian President Vladimir
00:00:23 Zelensky into the Oval Office. And well, let's just say things didn't go very well in that
00:00:28 meeting. So we're going to watch that clip, break it down. We're going to talk about the Canadian
00:00:33 reaction, which folks, it is just increasingly deranged. The idea that democracy is embodied by
00:00:41 Ukraine and Vladimir Zelensky is somehow the leader of the free world is just the most insane 0.83
00:00:47 thing that I have seen. And so we're going to talk about that. I am joined by two guests today. I'm
00:00:51 very excited about this conversation. So first, we have Alex Zoltan, who is a crime reporter at
00:00:56 true north and also marty belanger first time on the show he's known online as marty up north so
00:01:03 gentlemen it's great to have you thanks for joining the show hey good to be here okay so
00:01:08 let's go back to friday afternoon and we sort of had this historic moment this this this oval
00:01:15 office address uh this is this is something kind of fun about the white house uh about the trump
00:01:19 white house is that you some you sort of have access to things that we would have never normally
00:01:23 had access to so i don't know whose idea it was to have this sort of bilateral agreement being
00:01:28 negotiated sort of live on television but things just sort of got deranged very quickly got derailed
00:01:35 sorry very quickly and it turned into quite a heated uh reaction and back and forth i'm sure
00:01:40 you've seen this clip by now but just want to show you to answer before you get to the clip to answer
00:01:44 one of the questions right like trump 2.0 is different than trump 1.0 um i i did not i and
00:01:52 And I thought Trump 2.0 would be a little bit calmer than the first one.
00:01:56 But man, we're like, he's off to a great start.
00:01:59 And that's the context for the clip, I think.
00:02:01 Like when he got elected, right?
00:02:02 Remember a month ago, he was crazy with executive orders and getting stuff done.
00:02:08 And I remember joking, saying, what's he going to do next?
00:02:11 And we joked about he's going to do peace in Ukraine and peace in Israel, like, you know, big other big things like that.
00:02:17 And he's doing that, but he has a very crazy, weird way of getting stuff accomplished, I think.
00:02:24 It's totally unpredictable. You're right. And I mean, to be honest, I'm almost surprised that this hasn't been dealt with already.
00:02:29 I thought that this was going to be something that Trump was able to skillfully put together kind of day one, like bring Putin and Zelensky to the table.
00:02:36 Nobody wants this war to go on. Everybody just I mean, from my perspective, I don't want wars.
00:02:41 I don't like wars. I don't like the idea of young men out there getting drafted onto the front line and killing each other,
00:02:46 especially Ukrainians and Russians who were more or less like brothers or cousins. I mean,
00:02:51 it's so awful. I completely agree. We all thought he was going to solve the war in Ukraine on day 0.99
00:02:58 three of his presidency. Yes. So obviously, they're having some issues. And I think from
00:03:02 this exchange, I mean, we'll show it. It seems to me that it might be Vladimir Zelensky who is
00:03:06 the obstacle to peace. So let's play this clip. Do you think that it's respectful to come to the
00:03:13 Oval Office of the United States of America and attack the administration that is trying
00:03:17 to prevent the destruction of your country.
00:03:19 A lot of questions.
00:03:21 Let's start from the beginning.
00:03:22 First of all, during the war, everybody has problems, even you, but you have nice ocean
00:03:28 and don't feel now, but you will feel it in the future.
00:03:32 God bless.
00:03:33 You don't know that.
00:03:34 God bless.
00:03:34 God bless.
00:03:35 You will not have the war. 0.92
00:03:36 Don't tell us what we're going to feel.
00:03:38 We're going to feel very good.
00:03:39 You will feel influenced.
00:03:40 We're going to feel very good and very strong.
00:03:42 You will feel influenced.
00:03:43 You're right now not in a very good position.
00:03:46 You've allowed yourself to be in a very bad position.
00:03:49 And he happens to be right about it.
00:03:50 From the very beginning of the war, Mr. President, I was...
00:03:52 You're not in a good position.
00:03:53 You don't have the cards right now.
00:03:56 With us, you start having cards.
00:03:57 I'm not playing cards.
00:03:57 Right now, you don't...
00:03:58 I'm very serious, Mr. President.
00:04:00 You're playing cards.
00:04:01 You're gambling with the lives of millions of people.
00:04:05 So, I mean, you know, obviously, it's part of a much longer exchange.
00:04:09 I think it was like an hour long back and forth.
00:04:11 And at first, it seemed like it was going to be OK.
00:04:14 I look at Zelensky's body language there, and he just seems like a petulant child, like
00:04:18 arms crossed, huffing, kind of rolling his eyes, very angry.
00:04:22 From my perspective, it's like, you know, the Americans have invited you in.
00:04:25 Trump wants to have peace.
00:04:28 That is his objective.
00:04:29 That is his goal.
00:04:30 And I think that's laudable.
00:04:31 And, you know, he's already pledged that they're going to have some kind of an economic deal
00:04:34 afterwards.
00:04:35 So Trump is there trying to negotiate.
00:04:38 and it seems to me that zelinski just i don't know if it was performative or he he just there
00:04:43 was some kind of a language barrier alex i want to bring you in on this like what was your sort
00:04:46 of takeaway from friday afternoon i thought everybody was really rude across the board
00:04:52 really um yeah i thought the suit comment was particularly rude do you own a suit i thought
00:04:59 that that was kind of belittling um but i also completely agree with you guys i want the war to 0.87
00:05:03 end yeah i mean like like i you know if i got invited to the white house at the if i'm zelinski
00:05:11 and i get invited to the white house this week i'm only i'm i'm only thinking one thing oh good
00:05:16 you know trump wants to talk and he i've heard trump talking about wanting peace i'm getting
00:05:20 invited to have that discussion i'd be a little bit um disappointed that trump didn't use his power
00:05:27 to bring putin and me zelinski in the room together but but yeah i got invited to to meet
00:05:34 with trump so i'm going to go there and listen to him and then try and figure out how we advance
00:05:38 this he looked like a man who like you said who who either went there naively thinking oh i'm
00:05:45 going to get more money for my war i'm going to convince them that uh i'm the good guy like he
00:05:50 they they misread each other is is how i interpret this and then and then somehow along the way they
00:05:56 They misread each other. There's definitely a language barrier. I mean, when, you know, when Zaleski says things like I had to listen to him two, three times to try and figure out what he meant in some instances.
00:06:05 Like, you know, you got oceans, you're going to feel the what he's saying is you're not threatened by Russia because you have an ocean between you and them. 0.74
00:06:13 But, you know, yeah. And but then I agree with Alex. After a while, when you watch it, you go, OK, somebody should have called a timeout because it does happen in business and in politics.
00:06:26 you get a little bit too emotional and too passionate and then somebody needs to call a
00:06:29 timeout and everybody needs to regroup but they let this thing escalate so at the end they kind 0.93
00:06:34 of all looked a bit foolish you know especially because they're they're supposed to be um leaders
00:06:40 yeah well and and like okay again from perspective so we had zelensky in there and yeah he wasn't
00:06:47 wearing a suit which to me it seemed a little weird and then i mean you go back and you look
00:06:51 and it seems to be how he always dresses he's wearing this sort of national ukraine outfit
00:06:55 okay we can forgive him for that but there were other points to it uh alex like he kept referring
00:07:00 to the vice president by his first name jd which to me was so disrespectful like you know vance
00:07:07 himself was calling him mr president and then in response zelinski was calling him by his first
00:07:12 name which to me was sort of like pejorative right and so i i mean whoever's idea it was to have it
00:07:17 out in front of the press like there's no way to really call a time out because the press is there
00:07:21 and they're egging them on um but it just it just to me it's to me like i watched the exchange and
00:07:27 just from my perspective it seemed to me that zielinski was just lacking any kind of like
00:07:32 gratitude or graciousness or like even not the recognition of the support that the americans
00:07:36 have given it a few times he said we're completely by ourselves we're at this alone and it's like
00:07:41 well it's not really true when the united states has pledged what hundreds of billions 250 billion
00:07:45 dollars. And so to me, I mean, everyone can view that differently. It seems that I am on the
00:07:51 opposite side of the Canadian establishment because just about every Canadian leader
00:07:55 came out with the opposite side saying that Zelensky was right. So let's just go to Justin
00:07:59 Trudeau. He wrote on X following exchange. He said, Russia illegally and unjustifiably invaded
00:08:04 Ukraine. For three years now, Ukrainians have fought with courage and resilience. Their fight
00:08:08 for democracy, freedom, and sovereignty is a fight that matters to us all. Canada will continue to
00:08:13 stand with Ukraine and Ukrainians in achieving a just and lasting peace. Not surprising there,
00:08:19 I guess, because that's sort of been his position all along. Pierre Pauling of the conservative
00:08:22 leader similarly put out a similar message, maybe not as strong, but he said, as leader of Canada's
00:08:28 common sense conservatives, I've always been clear. We stand with Ukraine in its defense
00:08:31 against Vladimir Putin's illegal invasion. I also firmly believe that the future of Ukraine must be
00:08:36 determined by the Ukrainian people. Conservatives will always stand on the side of freedom and
00:08:41 democracy now that seems a little simplified for me right like no one's denying that vladimir putin
00:08:46 invaded and that it was illegal and it was reckless and it was horrible like putin's not in the right
00:08:50 here but this idea that ukraine is like the personification of freedom and democracy like
00:08:56 i'm sorry i don't buy that i don't think that ukraine is a democracy they were supposed to
00:09:00 have elections last year in april 2024 and they canceled them because they have martial law
00:09:04 because they're in this war so the idea is like let's end the war let's end the war let's find a
00:09:09 way to negotiate peace and not prolong this awful war. And let's stop pretending that Ukraine is 0.92
00:09:15 the leader of the free world, that Vladimir Zelensky is a leading democracy. Go ahead, Marty.
00:09:21 If we put it into a weird context, well, not weird, but Ukraine is a proxy war.
00:09:26 Like these little, I mean, like if you play the game of risk, Ukraine is one of the strategies. 1.00
00:09:31 You win risk by controlling Ukraine. And it's a proxy war, but it's an interesting time because 0.61
00:09:38 in this uh we've had proxy wars like this for the last 50 years and people usually took the
00:09:44 american or the russian side this is an interesting one because people are taking
00:09:48 the ukrainian side the the the guys that are being played and in every proxy war we've had whether
00:09:53 it's afghanistan iraq vietnam cuba places like that the middle guys have always been um fairly
00:10:02 innocent the people but the leaders on the inside that are used in these proxy wars they've always
00:10:09 been evil like easily manipulated who've thrown their own people under the bus so i'm i'm trying
00:10:14 to weave a story i i don't think you it's weird that we are suddenly calling ukraine um yeah
00:10:20 democratic like the pattern does it repeats itself and there's nothing there's nothing uh democratic
00:10:26 about what's going on in ukraine wasn't prior to and hasn't been since in the last three four years
00:10:31 like nothing democratic what's your take alex yeah so there's also kind of this weird um fallacious
00:10:38 opinion i'm seeing especially on the political left that we have never made concessions to
00:10:43 russia before um i don't know if they've ever read a book on world war ii but we gave russia
00:10:50 all of eastern europe um really less than one lifetime ago so if we were to give them donbass
00:10:57 i mean i think that that would be a terrible defeat for the ukrainians and i still have a
00:11:00 a lot of sympathy for them, because as Marty mentioned, they're the victims in all of this.
00:11:04 But it's certainly not historically unprecedented. It's an interesting take. Yeah, I mean, I tend to
00:11:09 agree that I think that like, at the beginning, so this has been going on for three years, right?
00:11:13 For me, I had a bit of skepticism at the very beginning, because it seemed like all of the
00:11:17 people who are being like, particularly insane and nasty over COVID, and the trucker convoy,
00:11:23 the freedom convoy, all of a sudden, like overnight, all those people started putting
00:11:26 Ukraine flags in their bio and you saw the same sort of propaganda machine in the CBC and Canadian
00:11:30 media like telling us that we had to support Ukraine. Whenever that happens I'm like a little
00:11:35 skeptical. We did a bit of a deep dive here at the Candace Malcolm show on Chrysia Freeland and her
00:11:39 ties to Ukraine nationalists and this whole idea of like Nazi strongholds in that country and there's
00:11:44 a lot of validity there. Like I don't think that Ukraine is necessarily a good actor but this idea 0.96
00:11:49 that it's three years later and we're still litigating the same thing we're still like
00:11:54 pretending i mean i'm just going to go through some of the particularly bad takes and then i'll
00:11:57 get to you marty but okay this is on the canadian political right these are conservatives these are
00:12:02 people who are supposed to be in favor of like freedom and i mean i just think they're wrong
00:12:08 so we'll start with spencer fernando who is a conservative writer he puts this on x ukraine is
00:12:13 now leader of the free world okay i've never seen a post get ratioed quite like this one but it's
00:12:19 so it's just a strange thing i mean i get it yeah vladimir zelensky put on a show in the oval office
00:12:24 and a bunch of people in the eu like every eu leader came out in support where you see like
00:12:29 leader after leader after leader throwing their support behind vladimir zelensky calling trump
00:12:34 a bully and saying that they side with zelensky in this war not surprising uh trudeau also jumps
00:12:40 in on that but you know this idea that a country like ukraine is a leader uh adam zivo who writes
00:12:45 for the national post he had he had a column over the weekend and he just writes that zelinski's
00:12:50 visitor white house imploded friday after trump and vance berated and gaslit the wartime leader
00:12:55 the behavior demonstrated yet again how the trump administration cannot be trusted as a reliable
00:13:00 security partner then of course andrew coin with the globe and mail writes uh never better display
00:13:05 of zelinski's courage than today never clear that trump vance are on the side of the kremlin never
00:13:11 more obvious that the democratic world must unite in defense of ukraine and in defiance of the united
00:13:16 states so america's now the enemy i guess in ukraine is this like wonderful partner kaveh
00:13:22 shiru who i usually have a lot of time for uh he was uh attempted conservative candidate and he's a
00:13:28 scholar uh very good on iran but this is this is what he says today about ukraine he says ukraine
00:13:34 is the moral test of our time standing with with ukraine means standing for the most basic moral
00:13:40 principles that the powerful shouldn't be able to just take what belongs to the weak whenever they
00:13:46 wish anyone against ukraine today can't be an ally in any democratic cause i mean that just seems like
00:13:55 very extreme like i think like even for me look i don't claim to be the like moral arbiter in this
00:14:01 dispute i just happen to be skeptical of ukraine and i don't want to fund wars i don't want to
00:14:06 fund them and i think that this is over now like we need to find a way to have peace even if we
00:14:10 don't agree with the borders i'd rather have that but this idea that like if you if you don't agree
00:14:15 with these people on ukraine that you can't even be part of the conversation on democracy it just
00:14:19 seems like really we'll get back to this but let me so let me let me weave this story right so
00:14:24 first of all let's go back quickly to the interview uh to the to the discussion it should have been
00:14:29 held then private first and then they should have come out in front of the media trump has a very
00:14:33 particular way of doing things if he loves you like the prime minister of japan he invites you
00:14:38 he puts you on a podium brags about you he takes the selfie and he shares it if he doesn't like you
00:14:44 like trudeau he makes you sit over there and you take the selfie and you know do whatever you want
00:14:49 so if so trump in this instance it's it to me it's clear that he was sending a message to
00:14:56 zelensky he brought him he brought him to the carpet and he gave him a um a beat down now why
00:15:03 back to my theory on proxy wars there have been proxy wars in the past between russia and the
00:15:09 americans and eventually the the poor scapegoat in the middle how does it end for them how did it
00:15:16 end for momar qaddafi for saddam hussein for those guys they didn't get an invitation to the white
00:15:20 house to to be you know um beat down they got terminated and so zelensky is kind of in that
00:15:29 situation but the difference between zelensky and the other guys is that zelensky uh his his war
00:15:35 was in an era that's different than the others and he got to play the media and he got to play
00:15:40 all sorts of things and he got sympathy so he does appear as a good guy and canadians and lots of
00:15:47 people in the world as we know are easily conned so this has been going on forever so one of the
00:15:52 last tweets you said there were uh you know that said it's kind of a moment in history perhaps the
00:15:57 moment in history here is that we might finally get to see that the Americans and Russians have
00:16:01 actually been fighting each other for a long time and maybe we will finally get a real peace um but
00:16:07 but I I think um I think Zelensky in Ukraine is no different than what we've seen many many times
00:16:13 in the past, except that Zelensky managed to get a lot of sympathy from a lot of people.
00:16:18 And a lot of money, too.
00:16:19 And a lot of money.
00:16:20 They always do.
00:16:20 What do you take away from all of these sort of conservative voices?
00:16:26 Not only, I think, kind of taking the wrong position on this exchange, kind of the Trump
00:16:31 derangement vision of this exchange, but saying that if you're not a reliable ally on this
00:16:36 one issue, you can't be part of the discussion anymore.
00:16:39 Yeah, well, I'll give Adam Zeevo some credit because he went there to Ukraine and he experienced
00:16:45 it himself. So I'm not speaking about him when I make these comments, but I am speaking about
00:16:49 the others. It's really easy to support a war that's halfway around the world that involves
00:16:52 nobody you know or anybody in your direct circle, or even by several degrees of separation.
00:16:58 If the Americans were to put people on the ground like they did in Vietnam, 0.99
00:17:02 you'd see people getting pretty upset pretty quickly.
00:17:04 okay and and then what about what about to adam zivo like just because he went there you think
00:17:10 that he's more credible like what what about what about his thing that you had here i think it gives
00:17:15 him some authority certainly as you can see i'm in ukraine right now my lights just went out
00:17:19 that's not funny i shouldn't say that so my cat just um yeah i mean he went there so kudos to him
00:17:26 um it's an important thing to to do on the ground journalism and i think that that was very brave of
00:17:31 him and i think that does make him a bit of an authority on the subject i can't necessarily say
00:17:35 the same thing about the others though but but your question was specific candace right you're
00:17:39 you asked specifically about the conservatives like can you can you rephrase your question or
00:17:44 ask it again like yeah i'll put it to you marty so you know i would kind of expect this from trudeau
00:17:50 trudeau just seems to be like the current thing guy that like whatever the popular thing on the
00:17:54 political left to progressives are he's going to be the champion of that thing whether it's like
00:17:57 like progressive politics, or I mean, the Ukraine stuff.
00:18:01 I mean, he seems to have a personal friendship
00:18:03 with Vladimir Zelensky.
00:18:05 But then on the right side,
00:18:06 like in the United States with the Republicans,
00:18:09 it seems like there's almost now a consensus
00:18:10 that they think this is a waste of time and money
00:18:12 and they just don't really want to fund it anymore.
00:18:14 And yet in Canada, when it comes
00:18:16 to more conservative minded, like leaders,
00:18:19 I would say people like, I don't know
00:18:20 if you can consider Andrew Coyne a conservative anymore.
00:18:22 He was long kind of thought about that way,
00:18:24 but I don't think he can be anymore.
00:18:25 People like Spencer Fernando,
00:18:26 who has long been like a writer and advocate
00:18:29 for small C conservative values in Canada,
00:18:32 him taking this position, and then some of the others.
00:18:35 I mean, I saw Adam Ziva's point, we can disagree.
00:18:38 Kaveh Shiraz is another one,
00:18:39 like he works with the Mignol laureate.
00:18:41 If you don't put the names of the people
00:18:43 making those posts, you'd have a hard time knowing
00:18:45 what side of the political spectrum they're on.
00:18:48 Right, yes.
00:18:49 In Canada, more than, yeah.
00:18:51 My question is like, why is it that
00:18:53 conservative establishment is on the same side with the left on this issue well when it comes
00:18:59 to adam's i just wanted like i don't agree with what he says but i think when you stand in the
00:19:03 firing line you get the privilege of kind of being able to say whatever you want yeah no i'm not
00:19:08 talking about him sorry i'll put that question to you marty so so why is it that the canadian
00:19:12 conservative leaders have the same position as the left on this issue i i i think it i think it's
00:19:18 they're looking at the popular opinion and they're just like Canadian conservatives are always afraid
00:19:24 to be conservative and to go against the popular opinion. I mean, everything they say is based on
00:19:30 polling. I'm convinced of that. So, you know, and they're battling the liberals right now. We see
00:19:36 it in the polls. So they're moving to the center and their opinion is hard to distinguish.
00:19:43 i i that's one aspect i think the other aspect too is you know it's easier to say uh to fool
00:19:49 someone than to get them to admit that they've been fooled and so this is a hard pill for a lot
00:19:53 of people to swallow including senior politicians like poiliev or whoever are making these comments
00:19:58 that um they're not going to suddenly say you know oh we got fooled and ukraine's the bad or
00:20:05 zelinski's the bad guy in this one so it's it's just it's one it's one aspect of politicians that
00:20:10 i that i detest which is they're they they're so reluctant to admit that they were wrong well i
00:20:15 want to go so on sunday pier poliev was speaking at a press conference in ottawa he was specifically
00:20:20 asked about this question on this issue and he uh well let's play the clip and then we can react to
00:20:26 it do we have that clip we support ukraine and its right to defend itself and to be independent
00:20:36 the aggressor in this conflict is russia russia carried out an unprovoked invasion of ukraine
00:20:42 an invasion that has been mercilessly prosecuting for the last three years
00:20:47 and ukraine has been the victim of that invasion all democracies need to stand with ukrainians
00:20:54 and their right to defend themselves and reclaim their territory and any suggestion to the contrary
00:21:01 is wrong. So kind of just repeating what he put in his in his tweet there and I think later on he
00:21:09 did talk about the need for basically like Canada could have played a bigger role in this had we
00:21:15 agreed to like sell our oil like we could have used Canadian LNG and energy to so that Europe
00:21:23 didn't have to buy Russian oil and gas and and basically this idea that we could have lowered
00:21:28 Europe's energy costs, lower their reliance on Russia, and created jobs at home if we had just
00:21:34 done something different. So I think it's good to sort of pivot away from the issue when Poliev
00:21:38 senses that it could be divided, because I don't think that the consensus is there in Canada like
00:21:43 it is in the US. Maybe it's because we have a larger Ukrainian population in Canada. I don't
00:21:47 know. That's a good, actually, that's a point, the fact that we have a large population. But
00:21:52 think about Poliev's comments. Like imagine if we go back to, I don't know, 2002, when Russia
00:21:58 invades afghanistan would poiliev has stood there and said hey you know uh russia's the aggressor
00:22:04 and everybody has the right to defend themselves and blah blah blah the difference would have been
00:22:07 back then that afghanistan was considered uh not a democracy and perhaps more of an enemy
00:22:13 so then poiliev defends it he's defending ukraine and he's using the excuse that ukraine is a
00:22:20 democracy and which is also an interesting thing because that's what if i was talking to poiliev
00:22:26 on the stage right now like how how can you make that stretch how can you say that ukraine is a
00:22:30 democracy like based on what well okay let's look let's get into this because marty you shared this
00:22:36 clip from the joe rogan podcast episode 1880 with tulsi gabbard which was recorded eight months ago
00:22:42 and in this they go to is this super interesting they go to a clip of stephen uh colbert report
00:22:48 colbert report where he is talking to an editor and sort of like an insider in the obama administration
00:22:55 uh so 2014 kind of almost like predicting this war and and and talking again about how
00:23:01 i mean to me this is this is not predicting it he's explaining it he's selling it he's selling
00:23:06 it on the on the news he's what he's doing yeah yeah so like this idea that ukraine was a buffer
00:23:11 state right it's like it's like between europe and russia and it's going to remain neutral and
00:23:17 it has to always remain neutral so that the two the two sides can never clash and then this is
00:23:22 basically him saying you know our american strategy is to break that that neutrality push
00:23:28 our people and push our side and you know replace any kind of like russian government with a pro
00:23:34 america like like this is this is the kind of stuff that that i think part of the reason that
00:23:39 trump has been elected in the united states because people don't want these like regime change
00:23:44 machines happening in washington they don't want the american government to basically dismantle
00:23:50 a foreign government so they disagree with so anyway we'll we'll watch this clip it's super
00:23:54 interesting and then we'll react i think it's on the longer side i think it's two or three
00:23:57 minutes here but let's play the clip and then i'll get your reaction
00:24:03 do we have that clip sean rose mr rose thank you so much for being here
00:24:09 there's the magazine foreign affairs now now now now gideon uh help me out here we've got
00:24:16 We've got a battle, the Ukraine, some of them want to go into the EU, the European Union, 0.76
00:24:22 and some of them want to stay with Russia.
00:24:24 If the Ukraine's not in Europe right now, what continent is it on?
00:24:27 Well, it's part of Eurasia, but it's part of Eastern Europe and the former Soviet bloc.
00:24:31 It's basically Robin to Russia's Batman. 0.79
00:24:35 And the challenge here, the challenge here is to try to attract it to the West, to get 0.92
00:24:40 it to flip sides.
00:24:41 So the rebels in the streets, what are they fighting for?
00:24:45 They're fighting for a better future.
00:24:46 Countries have a development...
00:24:47 That sounds like a political speech.
00:24:48 No, but it's actually true.
00:24:50 Countries have to develop over time.
00:24:52 And Ukraine basically, after the end of the Soviet Union, faced two tracks.
00:24:56 It could stay a sort of stagnant, corrupt, authoritarian country tied to Russia, or it
00:25:02 could essentially join the West.
00:25:04 It could modernize, liberalize, become a democracy.
00:25:07 At the last minute, when it looked like it was going to trade up from its sort of abusive
00:25:11 relationship with its a boyfriend from the hood to a nice yuppie uh you're not loading these choices
00:25:17 in any way whatsoever it's actually true when it looked like it was going to trade up to a better
00:25:21 uh environment uh at the last minute putin offered a bribe how much 15 billion uh it's a lot of cash
00:25:28 it's a lot of cash and the president who himself was tied to the old elites and the eastern part
00:25:33 of the country who ties to russia decided to back off the change and go you know how many pirate
00:25:38 themed restaurants you can buy with 15 billion dollars the problem was the western parts of the
00:25:43 country and the younger parts of the country and the more modern liberal parts of the country
00:25:47 basically knew that they had no future being russia's russia's vassal do we know they took
00:25:51 to the streets is america taking sides in this in any way if these people the the rebels are
00:25:57 winning right now right yes just recently why isn't obama spiking the ball in the end zone
00:26:01 and calling putin and saying hey you might have won the medal count but we won the country count
00:26:06 beyond okay so that was gideon rose who was the uh editor of foreign affairs magazine and he was
00:26:14 a member of the council on foreign relations talking about a book i mean it's so weird to
00:26:18 see them kind of making light about it and joking about it but this is the kind of stuff that
00:26:22 happens and this is i think something that so many people especially on the political right but
00:26:25 it used to be an issue of the political left i mean i remember when i was in university and the
00:26:30 iraq war and the afghanistan war the people that opposed those wars were on the political left now
00:26:34 it seems that they're on the political right um but this idea that that america like basically
00:26:39 meddles with the playing field and installs these governments and then goes on tv and
00:26:44 laughs about it i mean it's infuriating what do you what's your take marty it's exactly that i
00:26:48 mean it's it's fascinating to see these old clips that that i love the internet for that you can
00:26:53 find these old clips that that uh gideon is basically yeah he's an insider who's going on
00:26:58 the on the new on the talk show a comedy talk show and the light banter is it's all scripted
00:27:05 and he's basically uh telling people what they're about to do and and and and they went and did it
00:27:10 i mean yeah like ukraine is the bread basket of of of europe i mean the the amount of food that
00:27:16 comes in there like i said it's on it it's so strategic i was surprised that the russians let
00:27:22 it go when they did when the federation broke apart because all the rich uh uh russians had 0.94
00:27:29 properties on the black sea and on and like the resorts are there i mean we never even knew about
00:27:34 those resorts until after like you know uh just before the war in ukraine it was popular to go
00:27:40 there and visit these resorts are gorgeous and and it was super corrupt i i just want to bring
00:27:45 out one other thing one really really weird thing but you know when covet ended when the war in
00:27:51 in Ukraine started as soon as the war you as soon as the war in Ukraine started we stopped talking
00:27:56 about you uh COVID and all the people pushing the COVID narratives went oh thank God it's over we
00:28:01 can move on and now you're seeing that with the war in Ukraine a lot of people that are I'm surprised
00:28:08 that the conservatives are not flipping quickly and and going with Trump but you know get on the
00:28:13 right side of history and Trump is exposing what's going on and and if you continue down this path 0.98
00:28:19 you're going to be you're going to be a fool well i agree i think that was the first thing that gave 0.98
00:28:23 me skepticism was i was watching the trucker convoy and all the people who were trying to 1.00
00:28:28 say that these people are mega funded and they're extremists and they're nazis or whatever it was
00:28:32 like the same exact accounts suddenly like turn on a dime and start pushing this ukraine thing
00:28:38 and from my perspective like as soon as i just like someone sent me a tip showed me this picture
00:28:42 of christia freeland um with this kind of ukraine nationalist um scarf on and i and i posted it and
00:28:48 And I'm like, you know, this is a extreme group in, you know, the Banderas and having a bit of the context of like who that was, Ukrainian leader who collaborated and worked with the Nazis.
00:28:59 And then this is who Chrystia Freeland is promoting. 1.00
00:29:02 And then all of a sudden I'm called a Putin shill.
00:29:04 And I had like people in the government and people in the liberal establishment saying that I must be funded by Putin.
00:29:09 I'm like, I don't like Putin. I'm not a fan of Putin.
00:29:10 I'm just raising questions here. And a lot of it coming from tips from viewers.
00:29:14 And to me, that really showed like it was like it was you could see the work of a propaganda machine, propaganda campaign at work playing out online.
00:29:23 And that to me, that was what made me skeptical of it. Alex, I want to bring you in on all this.
00:29:28 Like when you when you look back and you see clips or I mean, even the idea that it was the Biden administration and Kamala Harris that were kind of like openly talking about bringing Ukraine into NATO, into the European Union.
00:29:41 The idea that it's supposed to be a neutral buffer zone and they're just kind of like, no, that's not going to be the case anymore.
00:29:47 I'm not saying that I support Putin at all.
00:29:49 I think the war has been terrible and obviously it's an illegal invasion, but it's not it's not as black and white as they paint it.
00:29:56 Yeah, I mean, it's definitely surreal to see, as Marty had mentioned, the political right now becoming the peaceniks versus the political left.
00:30:04 But I wonder how much of that is just a byproduct of the American political system and the two party system.
00:30:08 they do tend to flip flop on a lot of different issues over time. So I don't know if that's
00:30:14 terribly surprising. If I could backtrack just slightly to Paul Yev's position on the Ukraine
00:30:18 war, I think what's happening here, and again, I don't necessarily agree with his position,
00:30:22 but I think it's some good political calculus. Because let's be honest here, 99% of the people
00:30:27 in Canada who support Trump are already voting for Paul Yev. He doesn't need their vote. He needs
00:30:33 votes from the middle. And so it's really quite smart for him to position himself as somebody who
00:30:39 Trump doesn't like, right? That's how he's going to secure a lot of those 65 and older, you know, 0.99
00:30:45 the grandma vote, let's be honest here, who think that he's extreme right and so on and so forth.
00:30:49 I just, I think that's wrong. I think that that calculation, I mean, like in order to win an
00:30:54 election, you have to motivate your base. And it's the base that are going to go out, they're going
00:30:57 to make phone calls, they're going to volunteer, they're going to drive people to the polls. Like,
00:31:00 like the people that you really need are your strong. And I think if anything, what the
00:31:04 conservatives should have taken away from the last two election defeats is that when they alienate
00:31:08 that base to try to move to the center, it doesn't work out for them. They don't actually win. Like
00:31:12 to me, I would rather see a strong, like unequivocally conservative government. And
00:31:18 otherwise, I mean, you even, you have the PPCs, right? So people, they have another place to go
00:31:22 or they can stay home. We saw this in Ontario, just, you know, the voter turnout for Doug Ford
00:31:26 was abysmal, right? It was like 46% of the province came out and voted. So Conservatives
00:31:31 stayed at home. Now, for Ford, he didn't need that extra 10% of the base because there's no
00:31:36 real opposition. But in Canada, there is. I mean, maybe if it was Trudeau, and it was going to be a
00:31:41 walk in the park for Paulia, but he has a serious contender now in Mark Carney. And I don't think
00:31:46 that he can just rely on the staunchly conservative people to show up. I don't know that they will.
00:31:50 Yeah, I agree. I mean, I don't think that's the theme of the show for today, but we'll go there
00:31:55 for a few minutes. I mean, I think moving to the center, if both parties move to the center and
00:32:00 they make this an election about resumes and personalities, Carney could win this one on
00:32:06 personality and resume and credentials. But and I agree, I'd love I'd love conservatives,
00:32:12 Canadian conservative leaders to be like Ron DeSantis or somebody like that, that have proven
00:32:19 that you can be conservative and win an election. But there's a I think conservatives in this
00:32:23 country are afraid that being conservative won't win you an election i i completely agree okay i
00:32:29 want to go back to this like switch because i i we still have a couple things to get to i want to
00:32:33 first play uh this is tulsi gabbard on tiktok um just kind of going through zelensky and saying
00:32:40 like this guy is not your ally like this is not a good model for like freedom and democracy in the
00:32:47 West. Let's play that clip. Ukraine's President Zelensky has just banned yet another political
00:32:53 opposition party, one that questioned his legitimacy as president and used Ukraine's
00:32:59 Department of Justice to mandate the seizure of this party's members' assets. Now, this is just
00:33:05 the latest of Zelensky's actions to do this sort of thing. He began banning major political
00:33:09 opposition parties in 2022 when he also started banning TV channels that were associated with his
00:33:16 political opponents. And he took over total control of Ukraine's largest television networks
00:33:22 now controlled by their government. Zelensky's presidential term ended on May 20th. He canceled
00:33:28 elections in the name of martial law, suspending Ukraine's constitution so that he could stay in
00:33:34 power. So this is the perspective, obviously, of the Trump administration. So on Sunday, we had the
00:33:41 2025 London summit on Ukraine. So Western leaders quickly got together, European leaders, plus
00:33:47 there's Justin Trudeau. They're all standing with Vladimir Zelensky. And just again, to counter the
00:33:54 point that you were trying to make there, Alex, you had Maxi Bernier come in and posted the
00:33:59 following on X. He wrote of these leaders, he said, these globalist losers fatally weakened 0.92
00:34:05 their economies and societies with wokeism, mass immigration, unsustainable spending, 1.00
00:34:09 destructive energy policies and climate hysteria now they want to ramp up a pointless war against
00:34:14 russia while antagonizing the u.s suicidal well what's your what's your take from that alex what
00:34:20 do you what do you think of bernier's response i like bernier's response for sure but i think
00:34:26 that the ppc is a terrible party to vote for i mean you might as well do a write-in ballot for
00:34:30 yourself at that point and they're kind of irrelevant and unelectable yeah you can say
00:34:35 all sorts of things that i like it doesn't mean that i would vote for him because at the end of
00:34:38 day it's it's political right like you politics is a game about winning it's not about a game about
00:34:44 what saying the best things if you replayed that clip don't replay but if you replayed that tulsi
00:34:50 clip the last one and you replace the word uh ukraine with uh canada and you replace the word
00:34:57 zelensky with trudeau it would ring true like you know she's she's critical of a of a of a
00:35:03 country that has censored uh its people remove politicians that are that are problematic uh
00:35:11 like all those things we've you know the liberals have done all of that um max is critical of the
00:35:17 liberals and he's spot on when he does that i mean the you know and so which also explains why
00:35:24 of course if you're a liberal in canada right now you're going to try and defend um ukraine
00:35:30 and praise zelensky because you're praising a man who's doing exactly what your party is doing and
00:35:36 so you can't come out and criticize zelensky if a liberal came out and criticized zelensky for
00:35:40 censorship or or jailing dissidents or freezing bank accounts what would we do we go well you did
00:35:46 all those things so they're caught in uh which again i'm surprised like if i was a conservative
00:35:52 i would be hammering on the liberals and zelinski all through this but i don't know why they didn't
00:35:57 I, I tend to agree with that. And I want to bring this in because Jagmeet Singh in the midst of all of this, right? So, you know, prepare us before you show up, it's frustrating enough to have Justin Trudeau who should be on his way out. Like he, I just don't like him going and spending all of his time on international stage representing us. Like, okay, that's bad enough. But then on top of that, you have sort of his partner in crime, Jagmeet Singh, who in a regular world wouldn't really have any voice. He wouldn't have any standing in on an international stage.
00:36:27 stage in representing Canada, but because of the situation where he props up the liberals, 0.98
00:36:31 he has this importance and you have to take what he says seriously, but he's crazy. I'm sorry. He's
00:36:37 very fringed on this issue. So he wants to kick the U.S. out of the G7. He's calling on Trudeau
00:36:44 to not allow Donald Trump into the country, saying no to President Trump. He is saying that he should
00:36:49 not be allowed to attend the G7 Leaders Summit, which is coming up in Cannabascus, Ontario.
00:36:55 uh sorry kind of baskets alberta we have a clip from him and here he is basically just saying
00:37:00 that trump is a fascist and we shouldn't let him into canada here's that clip i also believe
00:37:05 we need to ban donald trump from attending the g7 summit donald trump should not be welcome here 0.96
00:37:13 why would we invite someone who has threatened our very democracy our very sovereignty
00:37:20 so um justin trito to his credit said that that singh is being irresponsible and that's obviously
00:37:29 not going to happen but at the same time you know we're talking about it and so we have to take
00:37:34 seriously what this individual has to say my perspective is that canada needs to deepen its
00:37:38 ties with the united states and we should make greater efforts to be a partner and to be part
00:37:43 of the north american team uh what's your position marty hard to be a bigger partner i mean we're
00:37:49 already like their biggest partner i mean you know 70 of their trade is with us we're like it
00:37:54 or not we're in bed together yeah but non-rhetoric i mean the fact that our leader i'm part of part
00:37:58 of the reason that oh yeah okay is because justin trudeau takes every opportunity he can
00:38:03 to criticize and to make like disparaging comments towards president trump at this point i you know
00:38:10 you you you're right i mean when when when trudeau handed in his resignation like in the private
00:38:16 sector if he handed in his resignation and said i'm going to stay on for another two weeks i would
00:38:20 have said no here's your two weeks of pay get the hell out we're letting him go around and do things 0.59
00:38:24 which is crazy and dangerous and i and i don't believe yeah and i do believe there is a scorched
00:38:30 earth uh kind of policy at this point that that that trudeau is going to continue to aggravate
00:38:35 trump because it helps uh his party long term um you know in and and then back to sing i mean you
00:38:44 like saying again the hypocrisy of him saying that uh trump is a a threat to democracy i'm like
00:38:52 come on saying like you mr saying you you you propped up a minority government for four years
00:38:57 for your own benefit like you're the threat to our democracy in this country so um 100 i i can't
00:39:05 take saying with any kind of i've had people try to convince me that he's actually an intelligent
00:39:09 man and he's just really really really good at playing politics and i'm like you're playing
00:39:16 politics with people's lives at this point it's not it's it's not good politics it's bad politics
00:39:21 i i can't buy that argument because if he was actually good at politics he wouldn't be driving
00:39:25 around ottawa in a maserati he wouldn't have a rolex watch collection he wouldn't be in these
00:39:29 tailored suits like he's not he's not good at this he's not very smart my my two cents alex
00:39:34 what do you think yeah so again i'm taking off my subjective citizen hat here and i'm putting
00:39:38 on my political war room hat. I totally agree with both of you guys on Ukraine and the entire
00:39:43 subject, really. But if Max Bernier's political decision to be the contrarian and to be the only
00:39:49 one who's opposing Trump amongst all the leaders is a good political decision, why isn't it moving
00:39:54 the needle? I mean, the PPC, it doesn't look like they're doing any better than they were two weeks
00:39:59 ago. And while it may be offensive to us on, you know, the political center of right, let's say,
00:40:04 in kind of our exosphere, if that's even a thing,
00:40:09 we sometimes forget, and it's easy to lose context,
00:40:11 of how leftist Canada really is.
00:40:15 I mean, Paul Yev, just on policies alone,
00:40:17 is probably left of Bernie Sanders.
00:40:21 Totally.
00:40:22 I mean, just on healthcare alone,
00:40:24 I mean, on lots of different policy issues.
00:40:26 And so he needs those votes.
00:40:28 I'm glad you went there.
00:40:29 I agree with that. 0.99
00:40:30 I've been taking a lot of crap lately 0.96
00:40:32 for daring to say that the polls are probably telling some truth right the polls that show 0.97
00:40:38 that the liberals are regaining some some popularity and that the conservatives are
00:40:43 losing it but it goes to that to to alex's point we are you know what we've been liberal 70 percent
00:40:48 of the last 157 years and we love to think of ourselves as progressive so um it it is uh yeah
00:40:56 that's a reality and good point that you know so i i just want to explore that with alex so do you
00:41:01 think? Because I often hear that the PPC people say the PPC have a nice platform and they're
00:41:06 conservatives. Do you think it's because of the person that given a different leader? Would the
00:41:14 PPC? I just want to push back on one thing, because I think that when it comes to the policies,
00:41:18 like each country, like you operate within the context of your own country, right? So like,
00:41:22 if Bernie Sanders was a politician in Canada, he would be to the left of the NDP. But he's working
00:41:28 in like the realm of what's possible universal health care is left-wing in the united states
00:41:33 in canada it's just the the basic like it's it's it's we've moved past that a long time ago yeah
00:41:39 yeah and so like i think that polyev to his credit his instincts are conservative and i think he's a
00:41:44 conservative individual but he's obviously making calculations as the leader of a political party
00:41:49 and doing things and saying things that he has to i would just disagree with that strategy and i
00:41:53 would say that i think people want authenticity they want something different so yes canada's
00:41:57 default liberal country i i'll take that even though i do think that there are deep conservative
00:42:02 principles that exist that a leader has to tap into in order to win and you can like even in
00:42:06 centrist like progressive mainstream conservatives who get their news unfortunately from the cbc
00:42:11 like if you show them a different perspective and show them a different path they would give
00:42:15 it a chance right they would say like if if pauliev came out and took a lot of the positions
00:42:19 say that maxim bernier is taking that that that he could be doing better in the polls that's that's
00:42:24 my position i'll let you uh put your question to alex here and then we'll wrap up the show
00:42:29 marty well i did put the the question i had to alex is is i don't think we want to go there too
00:42:35 deeply but is it is the ppc would the ppc do better with a change in leadership i mean it's
00:42:40 hard to say it's a hypothetical but but to address both of your points if a party were to direct its
00:42:47 entire platform towards bringing over the more conservative the more american conservative voter
00:42:53 base in canada um maybe it's a failure of max bernier as a leader but it doesn't appear as though
00:42:57 it's getting a lot of traction why that is i don't know it could it be the leader could it be
00:43:03 bad press i have no idea but it doesn't seem to be ranking higher than what two percent three
00:43:08 percent not a single seat in the house of commons so there was a by-election here recently in
00:43:13 clover they received 125 votes i remember as a kid the communist party used to get more votes than
00:43:19 125 um so yeah it just doesn't seem to be popular amongst canadians i don't know why
00:43:26 were you at the uh i was gonna get yeah so okay well i mean we'll have to have you gentlemen
00:43:32 back and we can talk a bit more about conservative strategy but i think i think it's a bit unfortunate
00:43:36 that uh we still have to beat this drum and when there is criticism of like the uniparty
00:43:41 in canada i think that this is one of the issues they point to on ukraine it's like
00:43:44 why do we have to yeah why do we have to put appointments and and before we and i know we're
00:43:49 running out of time but i i want to just maybe talk about this real quick i hope there is peace
00:43:54 in ukraine and there was and we forgot to talk about that i mean there was progress made so you
00:43:59 know trump and and putin sort of had a deal and and there were deals on the table so i what's your
00:44:05 thoughts on the events of friday did it completely kibosh a peace deal or was it just a temporary
00:44:12 setback i think there's a fundamental difference of agreement right the disagreement when it comes
00:44:17 to what the security guarantees are going to be like i think trump was taking it for granted that
00:44:21 he was going to get putin and zelinski to just agree that we need to stop the war and then at
00:44:26 that point trump wanted to go in and look at mineral rights and and make a deal to kind of
00:44:30 like rebuild ukraine but you can't start you can't have an economic deal until you have the security
00:44:34 deal and just it doesn't seem like they're there yet that doesn't mean that they're not going to
00:44:37 get there like maybe they're working behind the scenes and maybe diplomats are working hard to try
00:44:41 to you know fix things and get everyone back together and say like no no we do want this
00:44:47 agreement to happen but from what i saw friday in the fallout from it uh yeah yeah i mean zelinski's
00:44:53 playing it up right like zelinski's playing the victim in this and he's got he's garnering a lot
00:44:59 of sympathy from a lot of people so in a sense this might have backfired on trump it'll be
00:45:03 interesting kind of like his approach to trudeau and you know the way the liberals are soaring in
00:45:08 the polls right it did i i've asked that question right was he doing it because he's he's definitely
00:45:13 giving a bump to the liberals i don't think he did it intentionally um but yeah he's definitely
00:45:18 giving a bump to the liberals yeah if you if you were like really cynical you'd almost think that
00:45:23 trump and trudeau had some kind of a deal like because every time trump says right
00:45:27 all right gentlemen thank you so much for joining the show it's been a lot of fun that's marty up
00:45:30 north and uh alex lenski uh sorry all right cheers everyone thanks for joining us bye
00:45:40 great thank you so much for tuning in we'll be back again tomorrow with all the news i'm
00:45:43 I'm Candice Malcolm.
00:45:44 This is The Candice Malcolm Show.
00:45:45 Thank you and God bless.