Juno News - December 11, 2025


Canada’s Health-Care System Is Collapsing

Topics
Guests
Mentioned
Canada’s lead negotiator QUITS as trade talks stall Majority in BC "concerned" about private property rights

Episode Stats


Length

19 minutes

Words per minute

181.89

Word count

3,509

Sentence count

214

Harmful content

Misogyny

5

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Just when you think Canada s dire healthcare situation can t get worse, along comes the tragic and harrowing case of Jolene Van Alstyne, a Canadian woman forced to seek out assisted suicide because she cannot find a surgeon to treat her rare but treatable illness within her provincial healthcare system in Saskatchewan.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hi, Juno News. Alexander Brown here back for another episode, host of Not Sorry. Thrilled
00:00:07 to be here with you three times a week. I'm the director of the National Citizens Coalition. I'm
00:00:12 a writer, campaigner, communicator, jack of all trades, master of none. Love reading all your
00:00:17 comments. And while you are here, go to junownews.com slash not sorry for 20% off. There's
00:00:24 also a great deal heading into the holidays. There's so much great reporting, so many great
00:00:28 shows here. So do subscribe. Just when you think Canada's dire healthcare situation can't
00:00:34 get worse, along comes the tragic and harrowing case of Jolene Van Alstyne, a Canadian woman
00:00:40 forced to seek out assisted suicide because she cannot find a surgeon to treat her rare
00:00:45 but treatable illness within her provincial healthcare system in Saskatchewan. In a quickly
00:00:51 developing story, Van Alstyne was told she would need to go out of province for the surgery,
00:00:56 but she first needed a referral from an endocrinologist. However, none are accepting new patients. She did
00:01:03 what she was supposed to. She told the CBC the pain had become so unbearable that she applied for
00:01:08 assisted suicide with her appointment scheduled for January 7th next year. Understandably, the public
00:01:15 has been appalled. This is failing state levels of bureaucratic just collapse, healthcare collapse,
00:01:22 but in a remarkable and compassionate turn, popular American commentator Glenn Beck has stepped up in
00:01:29 an effort to fund her surgery. Our system has truly become a global embarrassment. I want you to watch
00:01:36 Beck talk about this extraordinary case in a clip from his show on December 10th.
00:01:41 She has now just been approved for MAID, assisted suicide, doctor-assisted suicide.
00:01:46 And, you know, I have been talking about what's happening up in Canada. It is so bad. So bad. They
00:01:53 are, it's the third largest killer now. Doctors are the third largest killer in Canada. This is what
00:02:01 happens when you get socialized medicine. This is why part of Obamacare includes the Complete Lives Act,
00:02:09 the Complete Lives Plan. It tells you when you can cut people off from medical care. She needs to 1.00
00:02:16 remove the remaining parathyroid gland. Well, there's nobody in Saskatchewan, no doctor that does
00:02:22 that. This is not a tough call here. But there's nobody in Saskatchewan that does it. Nobody able to
00:02:30 perform the surgery. Well, she can go out of Saskatchewan and get that, but she needs a recommendation. Well,
00:02:38 she can't get to a doctor to make the recommendation that she needs that surgery. 1.00
00:02:43 And so she could go leave the province to go get it someplace else. She's scheduled for assisted suicide 1.00
00:02:48 on January 7th. And now she doesn't want that. She'll gladly delay if she can live.
00:02:59 But she can't afford the journey. So I said, I'll fly her in. We'll find a way to take care of the
00:03:03 hospital costs. I mean, I'm going to need probably some help because I don't know how much this is going to be.
00:03:08 But, you know, if you would like to help give, we'll give you some, you know, give you a give,
00:03:12 send, go or something to do. What a wonderful gesture. What a shame that it
00:03:18 is necessary. The average Canadian needs to understand, and the average Canadian to their
00:03:23 credit, and they occasionally get things wrong, cough elections, needs to understand that it is
00:03:29 Canada that is hanging on by a thread to this failing socialist healthcare model,
00:03:35 not our progressive allies, not our Canada-like friends and neighbors. It's not just about
00:03:42 criticizing America for its model, which is far more accessible. You know, our countries we look to
00:03:51 and respect, they've all moved on and we have to move on too. We have to better balance our healthcare
00:03:56 model. As we're taping this at press time, Beck is even having to work around the apparent fact that
00:04:05 Ben Allstein does not have a passport to gain legal entry into the US. But his team has been in touch,
00:04:10 even with President Trump's State Department, to show just how extraordinary this effort has been.
00:04:16 As Beck says, all I can say for now is they are aware of the urgent lifesaving need, referring to the
00:04:21 State Department, and we had a very positive call. For all the generosity on display here that we
00:04:26 should be thankful for, that this is what it takes to do right by Canadians utterly abandoned and push 1.00
00:04:32 to government suicide over timely care, it's ghastly. All our status quos are failing all at once.
00:04:39 This is very much downstream of the liberal decision to break immigration of an aging population,
00:04:44 but there are also provinces that fail to innovate and we have clear momentum to drive healthcare
00:04:50 change as tens of thousands die needlessly on wait lists and we are offering suicide for the holidays.
00:04:57 Every policymaker and bureaucrat involved in this mess should be ashamed of themselves.
00:05:02 In a new report from the Fraser Institute, our healthcare wait times on referral have hit the second
00:05:07 worst ever at an astonishing 28.6 weeks that shouldn't be acceptable. Alberta is working to 0.99
00:05:15 modernize. All should join them. Let's talk to Nadeem Esmail, director of health policy at the Fraser
00:05:21 Institute, who helped co-author this study. And first, a word from our sponsor.
00:05:26 I want to give a quick word from our sponsor, Albertans Against No-Fault Insurance. So did you
00:05:32 know that the Alberta government is overhauling its auto insurance system under a new model called
00:05:36 Care First? Coming into effect in 2027, most Albertans injured in car accidents will no longer
00:05:41 be able to sue the at fault driver. Instead, decisions about your care and compensation will
00:05:45 be made by the insurance company, not your doctor, not the courts. Critics say this system puts insurance
00:05:50 companies first and removes key rights from victims and their families. Nadeem Esmail, director of health
00:05:56 policy at the Fraser Institute joins the show. Nadeem, thanks for being here. Thanks for having me on the show.
00:06:01 Nadeem, I wanted to start with a news of the day piece here before diving into this important
00:06:06 Fraser Institute study. Jolene Van Alstyne, this poor woman in Saskatchewan being led towards
00:06:12 assisted suicide because she's trapped in a failing healthcare bureaucratic nightmare. Glenn Beck is
00:06:18 stepping up. Canadians are trying to step up. What does it say about our system that she seemingly had
00:06:24 no options here, but the worst possible option? It's remarkable. And her story is not unique. We hear
00:06:29 these stories all across the country, all the time in the media. The woman in New Brunswick who was going
00:06:35 into MAID, but then finally was able to get her surgery in the United States, the individual who
00:06:39 left emergency and died on top of the 1.3 million Canadians who walked out of emergency rooms last
00:06:45 year. This is a healthcare system that is not living up to the needs of Canadians in spite of the fact that
00:06:51 taxpayers are paying for one of the most expensive universal access healthcare systems in the developed
00:06:56 world. It's a tragedy. It is. And I was reading that Second Street study as well from a couple weeks
00:07:04 ago where it's, gosh, it was tens of thousands of Canadians died on wait lists last year. And we're
00:07:10 all just supposed to, you said before we hopped on the call, this sort of tyranny of the status quo,
00:07:16 that that has become acceptable in any sort of way is so unfortunate. When it comes to the Fraser study,
00:07:22 which came out a day ago as of taping here, it's not good news, but maybe I'm stretching for a silver
00:07:29 lining to a cloud here, but it's not all bad news. What factors contributed most to the decrease
00:07:36 in a national median wait time from 30 weeks in 2024 to still 28.6 weeks in 2025?
00:07:44 I think the simplest way to put it is it's hard to spend this much money on healthcare without
00:07:48 getting a little something in return. That was mostly a gain on the specialist to treatment
00:07:55 wait time. The wait to see a specialist actually went up. So it's a little longer to see a specialist
00:07:59 now, but once you've got into that specialist office, it seems to be a little shorter. But
00:08:03 let's remember, this is the second longest wait time we've ever measured in the history of the
00:08:07 report since 1993. And we're still up at more than three times the weight that it was back in 93. So
00:08:13 we're still spending an awful lot of money on healthcare to get some of the worst waiting 0.84
00:08:16 lists in the developed world. Yeah, I recently, to be relatable to the audience, I had my own
00:08:25 circumstance where I was and I'm and I'm okay now, but I was I was passed along for for a referral. And
00:08:31 I had the doctor at this clinic, because I don't have a family doctor, I'm a young Canadian,
00:08:36 so I don't have a family doctor, like all but broke down saying like, I want, you know, you to get
00:08:41 this checked out as soon as possible, but it is going to be months and months and months. And we
00:08:46 were lucky that in that long period, that you know, things were benign. But the fact that that is the
00:08:52 norm is so unfortunate. Nadim, I want to touch on a number that jumps out for me jumps out to me from
00:08:59 your study. Across 10 provinces, the study estimated that patients in Canada were waiting for 1.4 million
00:09:06 procedures in 2025. Embedded in this report is the line, even if one debates the reliability of waiting
00:09:12 list data. This survey also reveals that wait times in Canada are longer than what physicians
00:09:17 consider to be clinically reasonable. What would be clinically reasonable? We do ask physicians each
00:09:24 year, not only what are the weights to get into their their services, but what would they consider
00:09:28 to be clinically reasonable? Now, let's be clear. Clinically reasonable is not reasonable for the
00:09:32 patient. Clinically reasonable means a woman with a lump in her breast can wait four weeks and 0.84
00:09:38 epidemiologically will have no difference in outcomes having experienced that delay. But
00:09:42 imagine waiting four weeks with a lump in your chest that might be trying to kill you.
00:09:47 These are medically reasonable wait times that in theory do not have a meaningful impact on the
00:09:51 outcome from the service. And even there, we are substantially longer than what physicians
00:09:56 think is clinically reasonable, at least 50% longer. And what's particularly alarming about that,
00:10:01 of course, is physicians' measures of clinical reasonableness have been getting
00:10:04 more relaxed over time. Physicians used to be much stricter in earlier years of the survey about
00:10:09 what they thought was clinically reasonable. They now are more willing to accept longer wait times
00:10:13 than they were in the past, which I don't think Canadians have changed in the last 30 years,
00:10:17 but physicians' acceptance of waiting time sure has. Yeah. And that's an interesting
00:10:23 feature for the study that you also have one of the key subjects here is adjusting for disappointment,
00:10:30 in a sense, that they're working within a system that they know rife with delays. And so it might
00:10:38 not be, I guess, clinically reasonable as sort of in the eye of the beholder. It's like whether they like
00:10:42 it or not, it's maybe this is the timeframe they anticipate. Now, why would the wait times vary so
00:10:49 significantly in the study between provinces? So Ontario is at 19.2 weeks versus New Brunswick,
00:10:56 which if you look at the graph too, it's mind blowing. It's like 60.9. What the heck's going on
00:11:01 there? We've always historically seen longer wait times in Atlantic Canada relative to central Canada.
00:11:07 Is that an aging population thing? It could be an aging population thing. There are also some
00:11:13 some smaller differences in terms of how the healthcare bureaucracies are structured in the
00:11:16 internals of the healthcare systems between the provinces. So we will see different levels of
00:11:21 efficiency, which a number of reports have looked at where you do have differences in spending and
00:11:25 access across this country. But historically, we've always seen Atlantic Canada lagging when
00:11:29 it comes to wait times. The prairie is not doing particularly well. And then central Canada is
00:11:33 doing a little bit better. It's when we step back and recognize that, in fact, the nation as a whole
00:11:38 is doing quite poorly. But certainly within this country, we don't have equal access to healthcare.
00:11:43 It is certainly better depending on where you happen to live.
00:11:46 Yeah, we have equal access to wait lists is the joke I hear, not equal access to healthcare.
00:11:52 What explains the large increases in wait times for specialties like an elective cardiovascular
00:11:58 surgery, as if there is such a thing as an elective cardiovascular surgery? But what are you seeing
00:12:04 there that explains that? I think if we look at the distribution of wait times, what we see is those
00:12:09 things that won't kill you will tend to have longer waits than those things that just might. So very short
00:12:14 wait times for cancer surgeries, medical oncology, radiation oncology, cardiovascular surgery, elective
00:12:21 cardiovascular surgery, so non urgent, but still important is sitting at about 20 weeks nationally.
00:12:26 And then we get into the almost one year long waits where we're looking at medically necessary plastic
00:12:31 surgery, neurosurgery, orthopedic surgery, patients could be debilitated, patients may die from that same
00:12:38 cause, or maybe an unrelated cause, but they had a worse life as they went to their final days.
00:12:43 But these are generally speaking, not things that are going to result in immediate death. So
00:12:47 they wait. And unfortunately, that's how the Canadian healthcare system works. It's
00:12:51 fairly good at dragging people back from the brink of death, it's just going to treat them terribly,
00:12:55 if not inhumanely in the process of doing so.
00:12:57 Yeah, when I have friends from other countries ask about Canada's healthcare and like the actual
00:13:02 unvarnished reality, it's like if you're dying right away, you know, it has its advantages. But
00:13:08 if you're in any sort of mushy middle ground, you're in for it. And that remains a concern.
00:13:15 Why are diagnostic wait times like 18.1 weeks for MRIs continuing to rise? Is that,
00:13:22 is that population numbers? 18.1 weeks?
00:13:26 And I guess separate question, does the Canadian public know you can get same day
00:13:30 non-emergency MRIs in the United States?
00:13:33 Or indeed, same day non-emergency MRIs in Quebec or in Alberta and Saskatchewan where you're allowed
00:13:38 to purchase them, just not in other provinces. I think Canadians would be blown away to know you
00:13:43 get same day MRIs in Germany as a universal access healthcare system public patient. But this is the
00:13:48 Canadian experience.
00:13:49 We certainly have expanding wait times for diagnostics. In part, this will be population
00:13:53 growth. Obviously, it'll be aging of the population. It'll be the public system not
00:13:57 keeping up with the investments it needs to be making in spite of spending a lot of money.
00:14:02 There's also a reality that over time, medicine is becoming more reliant on diagnostics. Physicians
00:14:06 want more information about what's happening and more routine follow-up information. That increased
00:14:11 demand is going to drive increased use of services, which unfortunately in a ration system is going to mean
00:14:17 more waiting for healthcare.
00:14:18 Yeah. Nadim, one thing I've been curious about, how do inconsistencies in provincial
00:14:25 data reporting affect the accuracy of a study like this in national comparisons? I know that
00:14:32 from reading that Second Street study recently on the amount of Canadians who died on waitlists
00:14:37 included the caveat that BC and Quebec provide less timely numbers, so they're viewed as potentially
00:14:44 influencing that final number. How do you adjust for that? What's the big difference looking from
00:14:50 province to province?
00:14:51 Our study uses proprietary data, so we actually survey medical specialists across the country
00:14:56 and ask them specifically for their wait times in their practice, which we then aggregate up using
00:15:01 the number of procedures actually completed to give us specialty, provincial, and national medians.
00:15:06 We have used the same procedure since 1989 when we first began measuring in British Columbia.
00:15:11 1993 was our first national measurement, so this is Canada's only comparable, comprehensive,
00:15:16 and national measurement of waiting times for medically necessary services. Even if you disagree
00:15:21 with the numbers specifically, the consistency of the methodology allows us to very clearly trend
00:15:25 growth and reduction, which means even if you don't agree it's 28.6 weeks this year, it is substantially
00:15:31 longer than it was just five years ago and much, much longer than it was 30 years ago.
00:15:36 Yeah, and speaking of that substantial increase, I mean, what future trends do you anticipate for
00:15:43 wait times here, given the 208% increase since 1993?
00:15:47 The reality is ours is a healthcare system offering low expectations, cloaked in lofty
00:15:53 rhetoric. Nothing is changing on the ground outside of Alberta making some very important reforms.
00:15:58 Largely across Canada, the healthcare systems are as they were, and these wait times are not the result of
00:16:03 a lack of spending. We have some of the highest expenditures for healthcare in the developed world.
00:16:07 They're the result of poor policy choices, and those policy choices are going to drive
00:16:12 ever longer waiting times until we resolve them. Let's look internationally. Australia, Sweden,
00:16:18 Switzerland, Germany, the Netherlands, higher performing universal access healthcare systems in ours,
00:16:23 more timely healthcare, and all of them, 100% of them, have user fees, cost sharing for access to the
00:16:29 healthcare system, private competition in the delivery of hospital services, and a private
00:16:34 parallel option like exists in Quebec and like is soon going to exist in Alberta, but that doesn't
00:16:39 exist anywhere else in this country. So we've chosen the wrong set of policies. Those policies have
00:16:44 resulted in very long wait times, and by doing nothing about it, we're just going to get longer wait
00:16:48 times next year and the year after. Yeah, and the myth of what we're protecting too, like it's us and
00:16:55 the our worldly progressive allies. It's like we are like increasingly out on the on a melting ice
00:17:01 flow when it comes to this stubbornness. It is, yeah, it's all those countries you mentioned, it's
00:17:06 Japan. And then there's us, where it's like us, Cuba and North Korea are like, you know, from our
00:17:11 actual cold dead hands, we're not giving this up. Now, should we just what's the what would be the your
00:17:17 recommendation coming out of coming out of this paper? Like, should we just be going down the Alberta
00:17:21 route? Should we be following Daniel Smith's lead? Should we be? Is there a specific European
00:17:26 nation or Asian nation that offers the path forward? What would you like to see as sort of
00:17:31 the director of health policy here with Fraser Institute? The reality is waiting has become a
00:17:36 defining characteristic of the Canadian healthcare experience, and it is one of Canada's most solvable
00:17:40 healthcare problems. We can fix this. Premier Smith is certainly moving in a great direction, but
00:17:45 it's not far enough. Let's look at Switzerland. This is a healthcare system that delivers some of the
00:17:51 most timely access to healthcare in the developed world, some of the highest quality universal access
00:17:55 healthcare in the developed world, and does it for about the same as we spend. They have a very
00:18:00 competitive system. They have private insurance actually delivering the universally accessible
00:18:05 insurance product. As an individual, you buy insurance from a mandatory insurer, and that insurer
00:18:10 looks after you, not the government. The government just makes sure you have the insurance. There's a
00:18:14 competitive hospital sector. There's cost sharing. You have to pay a deductible before your insurance
00:18:18 kicks in, and you have to pay user fees after that to another limit before the insurance takes over
00:18:23 completely. In Switzerland, patients are not prisoners of the bureaucratic will. They can buy
00:18:27 any healthcare services they wish if they simply desire to do so for their own preferences. This is
00:18:33 a healthcare system that functions so much better than the Canadian model. Yes, Premier Smith's reforms are
00:18:38 moving us in that direction, but we can go much, much further and really solve this waiting times
00:18:43 problem. It's notable that Netherlands in the 1990s had a waiting times problem. Nowhere near as bad
00:18:48 as ours, but they did have one. They decided to copy the Swiss model, and now they don't have a waiting
00:18:52 times problem. In fact, their wait times are now shorter than those in Switzerland who they copied.
00:18:57 Wow. So there's the model. It's terrifically important work from the Fraser Institute. I'm going
00:19:02 to be sharing this in the show notes. I hope everyone checks it out. Nadim, thank you so much for
00:19:07 joining us today. Thanks for having me on the show.