Juno News - December 10, 2025


Canada’s lead negotiator QUITS as trade talks stall

Mentioned
Liberals REJECT pipeline motion as caucus rift grows Carney eyes MASS IMMIGRATION ARCHITECT for U.S. Ambassador role

Episode Stats


Length

17 minutes

Words per minute

149.92

Word count

2,680

Sentence count

158

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

6

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Kristin Hillman, Canada s lead trade negotiator and ambassador to the United States, is leaving post in the new year. The man who is next in line for the job of Canada s chief trade representative to the U.S. is a sharp critic of Canada's regulated dairy industry.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 The man who is next in line for the job of Canada's chief trade representative to the
00:00:09 United States is a sharp critic of Canada's regulated dairy industry. The Globe and Mail
00:00:16 is reporting Kristen Hillman, Canada's lead trade negotiator and ambassador to the United States,
00:00:22 to leave post in the new year. The Prime Minister had this to say about her departure.
00:00:27 The ambassador has done a fantastic job for Canada for six years, four as ambassador,
00:00:39 a little more than four as ambassador, and then two before that, across a huge range of issues.
00:00:45 Obviously, we always have a huge range of issues with the United States, and particularly in the
00:00:50 most recent time, during an intense period of discussions, as everyone knows, with the US.
00:00:55 There's a window now. We've finished our consultations on Kuzma. The Americans are 1.00
00:01:02 just starting. The review process will gather for us in the new year. So there's a window.
00:01:09 And an exceptional public servant, we're all in our debt, and I just want to thank her again for
00:01:16 her contribution. Now, the Globe also reports that Mark Wiseman, a friend of the Prime Minister,
00:01:21 could replace her. He's been an advocate for pushing Canada's population to 100 million by the year 2100.
00:01:28 In the past, he's also been a harsh critic of Canada's regulated dairy industry, says Wiseman.
00:01:35 Looking to our agriculture sector, the sacred cow of supply management, through its import restrictions,
00:01:43 production quotas, and price controls, secures the market for a protected group of settled players,
00:01:51 impeding innovation and keeping prices artificially high for Canadian consumers.
00:01:57 Is it possible his appointment might signal the Karni government is ready to ditch supply management
00:02:04 in order to get a trade deal with the Trump administration? During the election campaign,
00:02:09 Karni said he would defend supply management, which was critical to his voter support in Quebec.
00:02:14 The Karni Liberals also denying they are out to criminalize Christianity and other religions.
00:02:21 faith leaders are worried about plans to strip the criminal code of protections for free religious
00:02:29 speech in Canada. They fear being prosecuted simply for practicing their faith, that it opens the door
00:02:38 to criminalizing prayer and religious texts. Justice Minister Sean Fraser was asked about Bill C-9.
00:02:45 I'd like to know why are government MPs going to be supporting the amendment from the bloc to remove
00:02:58 religious defenses from the willful promotion of hate in the criminal code when the government has
00:03:03 heard loudly from Muslim and Christian and other religious groups that this could insert uncertainty
00:03:09 into their teaching and preachings of religious texts and potentially children's speech?
00:03:13 Thank you. And look, I will address the question head on. I do think it's important that we reflect
00:03:20 on the reason we're here today to address a piece of legislation targeting gender-based violence,
00:03:24 but I appreciate there are multiple priorities, all of which are important. So let's be clear about
00:03:31 what's being proposed and what's not. The amendment that the bloc is proposing will, in my view,
00:03:37 in no way, shape or form prevent a religious leader from reading their religious texts. It will not
00:03:43 criminalize faith. And to suggest otherwise, in my view, is a perversion of the values that the major
00:03:50 religions in this country and around the world stand for. As somebody who grew up in the Catholic
00:03:54 Church and read scripture on Sundays my whole life, I can tell you that I don't remember any messages
00:04:00 about religion telling you to hate thy neighbor. But according to Mark Miller, Minister of Culture,
00:04:05 certain biblical passages could run afoul of the hate laws and be subject to prosecution. Let's listen.
00:04:13 If someone were literally invoking a passage from, in this case, the Bible, but there are other
00:04:18 religious texts that say the same thing, and somehow constantly say that this is good faith, I mean,
00:04:23 clearly there are situations in these texts where these statements are hateful, they should not be used
00:04:29 to invoke or be a defense, and there should perhaps be discretion for prosecutors to press charges.
00:04:36 Now Christine Manguin is Litigation Director at the Canadian Constitution Foundation. She'll be joining us
00:04:42 shortly. Conservative leader Pierre Polyev ridiculed a Calgary Liberal MP over his opposition to a motion
00:04:49 supporting pipeline construction. Liberals voted down a motion to build a pipeline to the Pacific, and MP
00:04:57 Corey Hogan was among them. I welcome the progress made in the amendment, but I am very, very curious how
00:05:04 it did not mention industrial carbon pricing and the increase of the industrial carbon price as part of
00:05:09 this amendment, one of the most important parts of the MOU. Would the member be willing to consider
00:05:15 further amending his motion to do the entire MOU, rather than again cherry picking the things that his caucus
00:05:21 seems to be willing to support? Madam Speaker, I think we just saw the member for Cal, the Liberal member for
00:05:26 Calgary Confederation saying that he opposes a pipeline to the Pacific unless it includes a massive
00:05:34 crippling carbon tax on his own province. Madam Speaker, Conservatives want a pipeline without a tax,
00:05:42 that Liberal member for Calgary Confederation wants a tax without a pipeline. The motion was defeated by
00:05:47 a vote of 196 to 139 with only the Conservatives voting in favor. I'm now joined by Christine Van
00:05:54 Gein, Litigation Director at the Canadian Constitution Foundation. Welcome to the show. Hi, thanks for having
00:06:01 me. Let's talk a little bit about the freedom to practice religion without fear of being prosecuted for
00:06:07 hate violations. Now you've identified some major red flags around this, thanks to a law that the
00:06:14 Liberals, the government is looking to amend. Could you talk about that? Yeah, so what is happening is
00:06:20 the Liberals proposed a piece of legislation called Bill C-9, the Combating Hate Act. And this legislation
00:06:28 would increase the scope of the criminal law to regulate speech. But what happened at committee is the Bloc 0.53
00:06:35 Quebecois have made their support of this legislation contingent on the government removing from the
00:06:42 criminal code something that exists right now, which is under the criminal code right now, you cannot be
00:06:49 convicted of the willful promotion of hatred if you have expressed a good faith belief, a good faith
00:06:58 religious opinion or an opinion based on religious text. That defense exists in the criminal code right
00:07:06 now. The Bloc wants it removed and they've made their support of that bill contingent on removing that
00:07:15 defense, the religious freedom defense. And last night at committee, the Liberals agreed to an amendment that would
00:07:22 remove that defense. This puts millions of religious Canadians at risk of prosecution for expressing good
00:07:30 faith religious belief. It will leave the interpretation of religious opinion and speech up to prosecutors and
00:07:38 courts and judges, many of whom don't understand the nuances of religious speech. It's incredibly damaging.
00:07:46 It's very divisive. I think it is likely unconstitutional and puts the entire scheme of hate speech law in Canada
00:07:57 in constitutional jeopardy. According to ministers, Sean Fraser, for instance, there was no intention here to
00:08:05 restrict religious freedom. And, you know, if you're just suggesting that it's going to go beyond
00:08:13 anything that's going to criminalize faith and that's just wrong, do you disagree with his interpretation?
00:08:22 Of course. This wasn't even the Liberals' proposal. It was the Bloc's proposal and they are just trying
00:08:28 to get their legislation passed. The PMO originally did not even support this amendment based on reporting from
00:08:34 the CBC. It almost killed the bill. But I just do not take Minister Fraser at his word that this
00:08:42 will not have implications for religious Canadians because it's not up to Minister Fraser. It's up to
00:08:48 the text of the bill, which is interpreted by judges who I think, you know, it's really a roll of the dice
00:08:56 about what a judge will decide what this legislation means. I actually think removing the defense could 0.68
00:09:03 undermine the hate speech laws more generally. I think that it might make the whole scheme unconstitutional
00:09:10 because when they were first introduced, the hate willful promotion of hatred charges in Section 319
00:09:17 of the Criminal Code were challenged in a case called Arran Keegstra that went to the Supreme Court.
00:09:22 And the Supreme Court held that hate willful promotion of hatred as an offense is a minimally impairing
00:09:28 restriction on the right to free expression because there exists these defenses of truth and religious
00:09:34 opinion. Remove those defenses. And I think the constitutional floor on these offenses collapses and makes the whole
00:09:39 scheme liable to be struck down. Yeah, I think it's particularly cynical to hear people like
00:09:45 John Fraser and Mark Miller refer to their own faith, you know, as some kind of defense, you know,
00:09:50 that gives them a pass to push through this bill. Have you noticed that, that both Miller and Fraser referred
00:09:58 to their own past as, you know, devout Christians and those choir boys or whatever they used to do?
00:10:05 I mean, who am I to comment on the faith of another person? Only they know what's in their own heart.
00:10:11 But I would say that Chair Miller brought this issue up himself in committee when he said that portions of
00:10:20 the Bible are hateful and said this to a representative of a Christian organization. I don't think he would
00:10:30 say this to the member of any other religion. I think that it would only happen to a Christian. And I think 1.00
00:10:38 that his comment is incredibly misguided and misunderstands his own faith. I do not think
00:10:45 that it's correct to say that the Bible is hateful. It is not hateful. And his statements are quite offensive
00:10:53 to Christians. I think that it shows the danger in giving interpretation of religious texts to 0.65
00:11:03 politicians, police and judges, because these are individuals who generally don't understand faith very well,
00:11:10 including in Mr. Miller's case, his own faith. The only people who can respond correctly to the abuse of
00:11:17 scripture, because of course, scripture can be abused. But the only response to that is for people of
00:11:24 faith to rebut incorrect uses of religious texts, not for the government to do that. The government
00:11:31 should stay a million miles away from analyzing ancient texts aimed at the human soul.
00:11:39 What are we headed for here in terms of what the government has in mind down the road? I mean,
00:11:48 I'm asking you to maybe speculate. I mean, could the government deem parts of the Bible, you know,
00:11:58 prone to censorship? You know, could books be banned? I mean, is that where they're going,
00:12:04 do you think? Is there a possibility that we're opening the door to that?
00:12:07 I think that the road that we are going down is a dangerous one. I think it shows the problem from
00:12:13 first instance, which is that we should never have criminalized opinion to begin with.
00:12:20 The whole notion that we should be putting people in jail for their thoughts and that somehow makes us
00:12:27 safer is diluted. We are not safer because we don't know what other people think. Knowing what people
00:12:35 think actually keeps us safer. So the idea that we are removing this defense of good faith, religious
00:12:43 opinion puts millions of religious Canadians in jeopardy. And it does so for no good reason,
00:12:51 because the courts have interpreted this defense very narrowly. In the research that I did, I could
00:12:56 never find an example of an example of it actually being successfully invoked. And the court that did
00:13:03 interpret it, the Court of Appeal, rejected a use of that defense in a case called RN Herding, where the
00:13:12 accused had embedded a hateful message in religious language. And the court said, you know, the defense doesn't
00:13:19 operate that way. So it isn't even posing a huge problem, this defense. So it doesn't make sense
00:13:28 that it needs to be suddenly eliminated. The problem with these speech laws is that they only ever expand.
00:13:36 They only ever grow more and more. The limits on speech just continue to expand. The government never
00:13:45 repeals any of these things. So how long until we're back in parliament, because this wasn't enough,
00:13:52 C9 didn't go far enough, and the removal of the religious amendment didn't go far enough. How long
00:13:58 until we actually are talking about portions of religious texts that are being banned by the government?
00:14:05 You know, that's maybe not where we are today, but I see a really dark road that we're going down.
00:14:09 Yeah, thin edge of the wedge. Do you know what the bloc is thinking, you know, around this?
00:14:15 Why they're pushing this amendment, which the Liberals apparently didn't put up too much of a
00:14:20 struggle in pushing back against? Yeah. So the bloc has supported this for a long time.
00:14:26 You know, to give my best faith interpretation of the bloc's approach is it's a nationalist, secular
00:14:36 kind of movement that wants neutrality of the state. And they want to remove
00:14:42 special protections for religion. You know, some might say that there's an element of Quebec society
00:14:48 that has more than an emphasis on secularism, but it's more of a hostility to religion. I'll leave
00:14:55 that to others to debate. But the example that the bloc member at committee kept going back to
00:15:02 was this speech from a radical imam in Montreal who gave a group prayer where he prayed for Allah to,
00:15:15 I don't have the quote in front of me, but it was something like, strike down the Zionists wherever you 1.00
00:15:20 find them and to spare none of them. And, you know, we can say perhaps Zionist is a code word. 0.98
00:15:26 I think it very well could be. And we can say that it's evil and wrong and immoral to pray for the death
00:15:31 of others. But I don't think that we can, as a society, criminalize the prayer, the form of a prayer,
00:15:38 especially when many elements of many religions speak about sort of cosmic justice in a grand scheme.
00:15:49 I think where we need to limit speech is when you are calling specifically and making specific threats
00:15:57 of violence. That can be criminalized. I don't think it's appropriate to criminalize the form of a prayer
00:16:03 as worthy of that prayer may be if for condemnation.
00:16:07 So where are we headed going forward? I mean, you continue to oppose with your organization
00:16:12 the amendment?
00:16:13 Yes. So we're sending out an urgent action request for all of our supporters today to write and call their
00:16:20 member of parliament. You can do that at the ccf.ca slash withdraw bill C9. We are asking,
00:16:29 we have always been asking for the government to withdraw this piece of legislation, but it is
00:16:34 even more urgent now that we know that this protection for religious Canadians is being removed.
00:16:40 So please write to your member of parliament. The website is the ccf.ca slash withdraw bill C9.
00:16:49 You can pick up your phone and call your member of parliament.
00:16:52 Right now, it's just in a bill stage. So there's no law for us to challenge yet,
00:16:57 but I can guarantee you that we will be involved in litigation if this passes.
00:17:02 And how do people support the great work you do there at the Canadian Constitution Foundation?
00:17:07 Yeah. Thanks so much for asking. So we are a national charity. So any donations to us are tax
00:17:12 deductible. You can donate at the ccf.ca slash donate. And we do have a fund matching campaign going on
00:17:19 right now at year end. So any donation up to, I think it's $250,000 will be matched. It might be
00:17:28 $150,000. Donations will be matched up to that amount if you make that donation before the end of
00:17:34 the year. Fantastic. Christine van Gein, thank you so much for coming on the show.
00:17:39 And that's it for this edition of Straight Up. Appreciate you tuning in, my friends. Let's do it
00:17:43 again soon, shall we? Bye-bye for now.