Juno News - January 08, 2020Canadian city wants federal funding to combat “rumours” about immigrants
Episode Stats
Words per minute
141.15012
Harmful content
Hate speech
2
sentences flagged
Summary
A Canadian city is looking to the federal government for money to help combat rumors about immigrants. This comes on a City Council agenda in Sault Ste. Marie, Ontario. In this episode, Andrew Lutton talks about the pros and cons of the proposal.
Transcript
00:00:00.000
A Canadian city is looking to the federal government for money to help combat
00:00:10.560
rumors about immigrants. This comes on a City Council agenda in Sault Ste. Marie,
00:00:16.560
Ontario. The city is pitching to the federal government a proposal that would
00:00:20.940
get it $33,000 in what Sue today calls anti-blabbermouth measures, an
00:00:27.400
initiative that the city is running called Change Starts Here which has noble
00:00:32.080
intentions. It's to combat racism, to ensure better cohesion, interfaith and
00:00:37.280
intercultural dialogue. These are all very good things but there's one
1.00
00:00:41.380
particular caveat of this and the city does not seem to know how it's going to
00:00:46.180
accomplish it and that is to combat rumors that are being spread in society
00:00:51.760
about people of different ethnic identities. According to the document put
00:00:56.640
towards the City Council in Sault Ste. Marie, the initiative is proposing a
00:01:01.360
strategy to foster peaceful coexistence and cohesion among all community members
00:01:06.540
through engaging activities that reduce the quote lack of knowledge of the other
00:01:11.900
as well as current rumors, stereotypes and prejudices about the other unknown
00:01:17.400
person. That's from a source document called Cities Free of Rumor, How to Build an
00:01:23.040
Anti-Rumor Strategy in My City. Now this is inspired by a European program and in
00:01:29.460
Europe the models have very much been about not protecting free speech which
00:01:33.840
is why I get very leery of any proposal like this. Remember it was not that long
00:01:39.180
ago that the UN Global Compact on Migration which Canada signed had this line
00:01:44.500
in it. Promote independent objective and quality reporting of media outlets
00:01:49.300
including internet-based information including by sensitizing and educating
00:01:54.180
media professionals on migration related issues and terminology and it
00:01:59.440
specifically takes aim at outlets that it says systemically promote
00:02:03.280
intolerance, xenophobia, racism and other forms of discrimination towards migrants. We
00:02:09.740
also know that the Justice Department in Canada and the Justice and Human Rights
00:02:14.240
Committee of the last Parliament put together a proposal that basically would
00:02:18.440
call for the regulation of online speech if it was meeting a definition that
00:02:23.480
hasn't yet been determined for hate speech that falls short of the criminal
00:02:27.080
definition. Now again there's nothing wrong with a local city council saying we
00:02:31.280
want to combat racism. I think that's very good. The problem is when this at all has a
00:02:36.200
whiff of being anti-free speech and we have to be on guard for that given all the
00:02:40.780
proposals and policies that are being entertained and enforced by governments
00:02:45.140
that do have that impact. For example in that European document I spoke about
00:02:49.700
cities free of rumors, one of the policies that has been employed by 11 European
00:02:55.340
cities is dispatching anti-rumor agents. Agents is their word to diffuse
00:03:01.600
prejudicial comments. The strategy says it's not about blaming but seducing the
00:03:07.420
majority and this is incredibly important to note here that we're talking
00:03:11.620
about importing from Europe what is one of the most dangerous parts of European
1.00
00:03:16.840
governance which is a lack of protection for freedom and free speech and
00:03:20.320
saying that this is going to help ease racial tensions that exist here. Now I
00:03:24.980
don't know much about the culture of Sault Ste. Marie. I've been there once it's a
00:03:28.720
lovely city and again I'm sure that the city councillors are trying to do the
00:03:32.440
right thing here. But like a wolf in sheep's clothing a lot of these global
00:03:36.460
initiatives are far from being noble or pure intentioned. In fact they take
00:03:40.780
advantage I think of the good graces of those in local communities to ram these
00:03:46.120
things that are part of these larger picture discussions down their throats.
00:03:50.680
And this is what we see here so you have to look at the UN Global Compact on
00:03:54.600
migration in the same context as the government's online hate. In the same
00:03:59.160
context of Canadian cities wanting to bring an anti-rumor strategy to combat
00:04:04.320
anti-migrant or anti-immigrant sentiment. Which is to say focus very much on how
00:04:09.660
they aim to accomplish it not just what the stated outcome is. Unless there's a
00:04:14.640
roadmap anything like this should be a firm no. For True North I'm Andrew Lutton