Juno News - November 19, 2025


Carney's budget passed. What happens next?

Topics
Mentioned
Carney’s budget NARROWLY PASSES + B.C. calls drug stigma “colonialist” Liberals don’t track immigrant doctors finding jobs

Episode Stats


Length

23 minutes

Words per minute

189.08

Word count

4,529

Sentence count

254

Harmful content

Misogyny

8

sentences flagged

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

10

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In the latest episode of Not Sorry, host Alexander Brown sits down with the National Citizens Coalition's Wyatt Claypool to talk about the Liberals' Budget, and why it passed the House of Commons by the slimmest of margins.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hi, Juno News. Alexander Brown joining you for another week. I'm the director of the
00:00:07 National Citizens Coalition. I am your host here of Not Sorry, airing three days a week.
00:00:11 I'm a writer, a campaigner, a communicator, a podcaster. Thrilled to be with you. And while
00:00:16 you are here, please take advantage of our terrific promo code, junonews.com slash not
00:00:22 sorry for 20% off. There's so much great reporting here, so many great hosts, everyone working
00:00:28 on a big tent effort for common sense. And it means a lot to us to have you here. And I love
00:00:33 reading your comments. Please leave them in the YouTube. I go through all of them. And I'm really
00:00:37 enjoying hearing your perspective and your feedback on our episodes and our chats with our guests.
00:00:43 And so, hey, topic of the day for us is that the budget passed. It passed narrowly, but passed
00:00:49 nonetheless by the slimmest of margins. Mark Carney's liberals managed to push through and eke out
00:00:56 their 2025 budget in the House of Commons late Monday, thanks only in large part to two NDPs who
00:01:03 conveniently abstained from the final 170 to 168 vote. Two conservatives also abstained,
00:01:11 while the rest voted against. Conservative MP Matt Gennaro, who is resigning, who had previously
00:01:16 announced that he was leaving in the spring, was not present. What that says about whether he
00:01:21 supported it or not, your imagination can fill that void, nor did he cast a vote. Conservative MP
00:01:27 Shannon Stubbs was on approved medical leave after surgery and has since reiterated with remarks from
00:01:33 her office with more information on that medical leave, surely entirely legitimate. The liberal budget
00:01:40 passed, surviving the final hurdle after two earlier confidence motions on that budget bill. Tonight,
00:01:47 the House of Commons has voted to pass budget 2025. Prime Minister Mark Carney said in a post to X,
00:01:53 using more of his team's trademark chat GPT speak. It's time to work together to deliver on this plan,
00:02:00 to protect our communities, empower Canadians with new opportunities, and build Canada strong.
00:02:06 The truth of the matter is that the Conservatives and most common sense Canadians, for all their
00:02:12 misgivings about the size and the scope of the deficit and the expansion of central planning in
00:02:17 that carny budget, they know, we know, that the modern polling dynamics that continue to see the
00:02:23 Liberals popular with those who no longer wholly participate in the Canadian economy, who got in before
00:02:29 housing went to the moon, and who don't interface with the public decline each and every day,
00:02:34 they're still leaning firmly liberal at present. If the budget failed to pass, there was a very good
00:02:39 chance. We're looking at a liberal majority that's next to impossible to hold in check.
00:02:45 On behalf of, you know, young and working Canadians, we can work with a minority, as frustrating as it 1.00
00:02:50 is. What we couldn't work with is a return wholly and quickly to more of the same from 2015. So I'm
00:02:58 counting on you, the viewer, to continue serving in unofficial opposition. It's a critical role to fill
00:03:05 as our entrenched and out-of-touch interests seek the permission to again ignore you entirely.
00:03:11 Let's get this country back on track. Let's talk to Wyatt Claypool. And first, a word from our sponsor.
00:03:17 This is a campaign called Unsmoke. Look, folks, it's time to modernize Canada's rules on nicotine.
00:03:23 Alternatives to cigarettes like heated tobacco vaping products and oral smokeless products don't burn
00:03:27 tobacco or produce smoke. They aren't risk-free, but the growing body of scientific evidence shows that
00:03:33 they have the potential to be substantially less harmful than smoking. Despite this, Canadians are 1.00
00:03:37 banned access to critical information and even some products. Nicotine pouches remain banned in
00:03:42 convenience stores. And current laws ban communication about the risks of these products
00:03:47 compared to cigarettes. It's unbelievable. The evidence is here. The tools exist. Canadians should
00:03:51 have the freedom to know. You can learn more by visiting unsmoke.ca. Wyatt Claypool joins the show.
00:03:57 Wyatt is a popular YouTuber. He's with the National Telegraph and 1BC. He's got a great setup and
00:04:03 his hotel room at present, which I saw in a tweet from the other night where you're playing the
00:04:06 classics on PlayStation. So you're a man after my own heart. Wyatt, thanks for joining us.
00:04:12 Yeah, I refuse to buy just some simulator on a computer. I have to haul around the PS1 with me.
00:04:18 I have one of those simulators on the computer, so I understand it's better to play the OG. Wyatt,
00:04:25 we could talk about the things that our audience would roll their eyes at, or we could talk about the
00:04:29 budget, which passed by the slimmest of margins yesterday. Does this narrow victory signal early
00:04:36 trouble for the liberals, or did this break the way you expected? I think it does signal early
00:04:42 trouble, not because it almost didn't pass. I think everyone knew that it was going to pass.
00:04:48 This was procedural, and it would have been foolish for the opposition to actually unite and kill the
00:04:53 budget and force a Christmas election. Who wants to be the Grinch forcing people to go and vote when
00:05:00 they just want to be with their families? The thing is that all the parties were effectively
00:05:04 positioning themselves on where they stand on this liberal government through the guise of voting on
00:05:11 the budget. So we had four abstentions. Really, you just needed two, and then Elizabeth May to go and
00:05:17 vote with the liberals, and the speaker still could have tied the vote. So all those saying,
00:05:21 oh my goodness, two conservative MPs betrayed us. It doesn't matter. And by the way, do you want the
00:05:27 liberals to win a majority government in a Christmas election? No. What the parties are doing is that
00:05:34 the conservatives are signaling, absolutely, we will take a spring 2026 election, or sometime in
00:05:39 2026. The bloc have set their narrative that this government doesn't care about Quebec enough, and the
00:05:44 NDP are basically saying, this party hates workers, and they've gone too far, but because we're in a
00:05:49 leadership race, we need to give them a little bit more rope before we come and hang them. 0.99
00:05:54 Yeah. And no, that New Year's Day hangover coming out of a potential carny majority, I think that 1.00
00:06:01 would have been tough for the country to stomach. And I appreciate, for example, our friends in
00:06:06 Alberta would sorely want an election right now because they're worried about keeping the blockades in 1.00
00:06:13 BC not being still heard by Ottawa. But the dynamic here, the polling dynamic was difficult. It was a
00:06:19 continuation in some ways of elbows up where we're seeing these, the sort of over 55 voter age
00:06:26 demographic is still overwhelmingly leaning liberal. Everyone else is pretty popular, you know, the
00:06:31 conservatives are pretty popular with. And so it was a be careful what you wish for. I think the
00:06:36 conservatives were adjusting for that and maybe feigning a little bit of gamesmanship. And who
00:06:43 knows what's going to happen? What a showdown. But I don't think they wanted it. I don't think the
00:06:46 liberals wanted it. How do you think the conservatives are feeling right now? I mean, they're going to
00:06:51 maybe, from a comms perspective, show that they're disappointed that they couldn't topple the
00:06:56 government. But if you were them, would you be relieved to avoid a snap election that they might not
00:07:01 have been at full strength for? Oh, yeah, I want some more time to prepare. Oftentimes, when I start
00:07:07 talking about politics with people, I start talking about it in military terms, because you get some
00:07:11 people on social media upset that they didn't topple the government and they didn't take the absolute
00:07:16 first opportunity to fight the liberals in a new election. And I'm just sitting there thinking like,
00:07:21 guys, just because the general doesn't want to hard charge up a hill towards an encamped liberal
00:07:28 opponent doesn't mean that they don't want to beat the liberals. Really, what Polyev is doing
00:07:33 is he is not going for the short term election. And instead, he's, you know, maneuvering around
00:07:39 slower to go attack the liberals in the medium term. Because again, you don't charge up a hill at your
00:07:44 enemy. And that would be what a Christmas election would represent. What you would rather have, and I
00:07:49 think the conservatives probably feel at least relaxed right now, knowing that they can just do a bit
00:07:54 of wait and see, they would rather a bad economic update come out or something to that nature, a big
00:08:01 broken promise to have happened. And then they launched them into an election. Because the budget
00:08:07 not passing, the liberals could basically say, look at all these obstinate parties who won't even let us
00:08:12 pass our first budget. They've been haranguing us to pass a budget for months. And now we finally do it.
00:08:17 And they don't like it, even though we try to please everyone. Is the budget a hot mess? Yes. But
00:08:23 the average voter doesn't really engage in politics in that granular of a level to understand all of
00:08:30 the debt and the deficit in the budget and how they've miscategorized a bunch of operating expenses
00:08:37 and infrastructure, pretend like they're investing. Do you think anyone knows that? I barely even
00:08:42 recognize that that happened. Like it takes, it even takes you as a commentator a while to really
00:08:47 kind of dig into the budget to understand what it is. Yeah. And it's not even as if they went through
00:08:53 any sort of real effort to, I mean, their role with this, with a budget, with this budget in a
00:08:58 minority parliament is like to make it work for everybody is to, to bring people to them instead 0.95
00:09:03 of using it kind of, are you going to call our bluff or not? Like the numbers, the numbers weren't good,
00:09:09 but they knew that from a comms perspective, they could, they could quickly turn to, yeah, see,
00:09:14 you know, we're trying, they're not listening. You know, they're being disloyal at this moment of
00:09:18 crisis. You know, how could they not be on team Canada? Meanwhile, team Canada is as disparate and,
00:09:24 and there there's as much infighting as ever that the role of the NDP here, we had two in
00:09:29 abstention. They have 23 million in debt as a party after Jagmeet Singh assaulted the earth for the
00:09:36 former party of the worker. And now the party of the teacher's lounge, are they capable of showing a
00:09:41 backbone going forward here? Do you see this as like a smart strategic move to buy themselves time?
00:09:47 Are they capable of getting it together federally or, or I guess the worry would be among some,
00:09:52 is this the start of more of the same of just endlessly propping them up?
00:09:56 No, I don't think it is. I think that if it was Jagmeet Singh, he would have just had every single
00:10:01 NDP MP vote for the budget and signaled that, okay, well, we've gotten enough out of this thing
00:10:07 to keep them going. Even if he got absolutely nothing. I think that the way that the funny thing is
00:10:13 this cohort of NDP is far more left wing than the previous crew. The ones that are remaining are
00:10:20 really the hyper progressives occupying these deep urban ridings. And so I do think that they're
00:10:26 slightly crazy. It's like if the Democratic Party in the US was only run by the squad, 0.58
00:10:31 that's what the NDP is right now. And the thing is, it doesn't matter how much debt they have. I think
00:10:35 they do have less than 23 million now because there is a rebate that all the parties end up getting for
00:10:40 their spending and whatnot. But the party doesn't even need that much cash in order to double their
00:10:46 seats. Because all you have to do is defend seven seats. And then you just need to go and try and
00:10:51 maybe target seven more or a few more than even that. But the leadership race should be helping
00:10:57 them out with their spending, with their money problems, because every single candidate that gets
00:11:02 into the race has to put up hundreds of thousands of dollars to enter. And then at the same time,
00:11:07 just having a new leader in general is going to massively increase their donations, especially
00:11:13 if Mark Carney ends up taking off the NDP voters that he needed in the last election. If they start
00:11:20 going back over to the NDP and the, you know, the, I guess the, the donor engine of the NDP is
00:11:26 restored, they may actually be a threat to the liberals again.
00:11:29 Yeah. And on the NDP front, I mean, there are those who like to say, I think there were so many
00:11:36 lousy debriefs coming out of the election, but there are those who like to say that the CPC blew a
00:11:42 20, 20 point lead. Like they were the Falcons against the Patriots in the Superbowl, but they went
00:11:47 from 43% to 41%. That's historic high to still historic high. Obviously conservative.
00:11:53 You don't measure also polls from the very highest point to the very lowest point that you can find.
00:12:00 There were never 20 points ahead. They were probably like 13 or something like that. That's
00:12:05 probably more reasonable lead for the conservatives. It's just in the absolute dog days of the liberal
00:12:11 administration. Yeah. You had some shock polls that came out where it was looking so bad that
00:12:16 they were behind the NDP. If an election happened, you would have had the kind of the rally around
00:12:21 Trudeau effect. And he probably would have been able to tighten it up even to five or eight points
00:12:25 or something like that. It would have gotten destroyed, but he would have been able to tighten
00:12:29 it up because politics is boring and people tend to default back to their boring political opinions.
00:12:35 Yeah. And it's the dynamics of polling too. I don't think the general public totally understands
00:12:40 whether it's a push pull or something else. It's like, you're having a bad day. You've read some bad
00:12:45 news and then someone calls you and goes like, Hey, isn't this bad? Like, it's like, yeah,
00:12:49 you're going to say, you're going to say, you know, what, what you're being sort of probed to,
00:12:53 to give them back there now. But, but the conservatives would surely greatly benefit
00:12:58 from the NDP getting off the mat. Like, do you think that, you know, now they're crazier? I guess
00:13:04 that's the concern. Uh, it is just the, the watermelon, you know, crew. It is just the CAFIA crew.
00:13:10 Like, are we trending towards a two-party system or, or do you think that they can cobble together,
00:13:15 you know, 12 to 15 seats from just being crazy in urban centers?
00:13:20 I genuinely do because there, there is a, uh, there is like a demographic of voters that this
00:13:26 appeals to. And in places like Vancouver and Victoria, Toronto and whatnot, there is people
00:13:32 who vote for this stuff. Uh, Winnipeg as well, where Leah Gazan, probably the craziest MP in the 0.99
00:13:37 entire country is. Uh, and I think that this is mostly going to be good for the conservatives
00:13:42 if they end up, you know, getting up off the mat. Uh, the problem for the end, uh, really the only
00:13:48 person that the conservatives wouldn't want to become the NDP leader is Rob Ashton, since he
00:13:53 actually does represent, uh, whether I agree with him or not more of a worker focus, you know,
00:13:59 he respects blue collar people and that's kind of the John Horgan, Wob Canoe or Jack Layton energy
00:14:07 that would probably help out the federal NDP actually win back places like Windsor West.
00:14:12 Hey, I don't want them to win back Windsor West, which is great because Heather McPherson and Avi
00:14:17 Lewis are more likely to win. And those are your downtown hyper-progressive Hamas supporters. 0.83
00:14:23 Yeah. They'll win, you know, out by UBC, you know, they'll, they'll, they'll,
00:14:27 they'll take Kensington market in Toronto, but yeah, they'll, they'll win Naomi Klein support that
00:14:34 they already had. But so why the, the budget greatly skimps on housing solutions. That's,
00:14:41 you know, uh, you're a young guy. We have a crisis clearly tied to mass immigration and exorbitant 1.00
00:14:47 development costs. The, the conservatives claimed to aim to build 2.3 million homes. They, they,
00:14:53 they have in theory, better immigration targets that they're advocating for. The, the liberals
00:14:58 presented a kind of side dish to the budget, um, with, with what sure look like sort of window
00:15:04 addressing changes to immigration. Like, why do you think Polyev's policies on, on say housing,
00:15:09 where it's more about sort of cutting red tape would better effective, effectively tackle the
00:15:14 affordability crisis than, than these vague efforts and these like really unencouraging signs from the
00:15:20 liberals that they're, they're coming nowhere close on housing or understanding the root cause
00:15:24 of the housing crisis. Well, they did end up slashing TFWs in the budget by about half, which is a big
00:15:31 signal that, that people who've been advocating for lower immigration are winning. Uh, Polyev who I
00:15:37 would say actually kind of had a disappointing immigration stance during the election where it
00:15:41 was, you know, it's a hundred thousand less people, permanent residents than what the liberals were
00:15:45 saying. But, you know, come on, it has to be so much more of a gap that people notice. And since
00:15:52 the election, he has taken the stance that we want net negative migration. Perfect. That's great. 0.99
00:15:56 That's all I need to hear on that. Uh, but with, with housing, the thing with the liberals is that
00:16:01 weren't they the ones who just had to count, uh, cancel a tree planting program? They couldn't even
00:16:07 plant a tree. And now they're going to attempt to actually build substantial amounts of makeshift
00:16:12 units in order to house more people. I think this is going to be one of those things that in the next
00:16:18 six months or a year, whether we have an election before then or not, you're going to have a lot of,
00:16:23 like, I think the conservatives are going to have a strong ability to start badgering the liberals
00:16:27 about having probably never built a unit or they only have a handful of units built because if
00:16:32 they're making pre prefabricated houses and you can't build a lot of them, that's kind of on you
00:16:39 because that's sounds like something that nobody could screw up. It's idiot proof being able to put 0.99
00:16:44 up prefab prefab houses. But I think we're going to find that the liberal bureaucracy is going to 1.00
00:16:51 prevent them from succeeding. Yeah. And I think, I think there's only going to be like 4,000 of
00:16:55 those prefab houses too, as if that's going to fit, uh, like we're still welcoming in like north
00:17:01 of 2 million people over the next three years, including temporary streams. And that's if they
00:17:05 even stick to that. So where are we going? Maybe this is going to keep, uh, people from coming to
00:17:10 Canada when they realize that the housing options look like a, uh, a carnival concession stand.
00:17:15 Yeah, no, it's, it's like that portable that you used to be stuck at in elementary school with it
00:17:21 on a sweltering hot day. And looking at some of the green initiatives and the stranglehold on our
00:17:27 energy industry, um, the liberals commit vaguely to a balance of climate targets they've never hit
00:17:32 in, in, in the budget and lessening, uh, the emissions cap, but the bad bills and the picking
00:17:37 more losers than winners, it remains in place. The carbon tax has just been shifted to the business
00:17:42 side. If you are the conservatives, so how would you balance communicating the Canadian public's
00:17:48 want for economic environmental stewardship with, with communicating like the need that like we have
00:17:54 to get projects to market and more of the same, isn't going to cut it right now. The, the, I would
00:17:59 actually say the answer on, on having to balance, uh, trying to get the economic economy, uh, kickstarted
00:18:05 and balancing environmental stewardship. Honestly, I don't even think you had to do the balancing of
00:18:10 environmental stewardship simply because I think Canadians are so sick of the liberal policies
00:18:15 that they're not really looking for poly, uh, for the conservatives to say anything, you know,
00:18:19 about environmental conservation. Now that's already always still in their platform. They would speak
00:18:24 on and that there's, there, there's like, you know, a certain world where it's important to speak
00:18:27 out on that stuff. But, uh, I think that really on this issue, they just need to rip apart all of the
00:18:34 liberal, like, like regulations, just keep targeting them as the actual woes of the economy, not any
00:18:41 sort of thing to do with Donald Trump. It has to do with domestic policy on the great rhetorical line,
00:18:48 because they used to say with, uh, with Justin Trudeau, oh, it's the Trudeau Singh government.
00:18:53 It's the liberal MVP government. This is the liberal green government. They bent over backwards to get
00:18:59 Elizabeth May's vote on the budget. They literally promised to keep going with the Paris climate
00:19:05 targets. You could have just bought her a drink. Yeah. You could have just bought her a drink and 1.00
00:19:09 she would have said yes. So yeah, you could, you could, and you could have gotten it at any local
00:19:13 pharmacy that's around you. You don't even need to actually go to a liquor store apparently, but
00:19:18 anyways, yeah, you could easily like this is going to be a very, I think this is going to be a good
00:19:23 rhetorical line for the conservatives that they actually partnered up with May. They kicked the NDP out of
00:19:29 the bed and they brought in Elizabeth May's green party to dictate their environmental policy, 0.89
00:19:34 uh, for the book, like for their, for the next year, uh, or for the, basically their entire term
00:19:39 in order to keep her on side. Yeah. Yeah. Uh, the, the strange bedfellows now you're,
00:19:45 you're a young guy, you you're huge on YouTube. Um, I think, and I've been talking to folks on,
00:19:53 on the inside and we all have our sources and, and we all like the, I would say the,
00:19:59 the blunt aspect of conservative communications. You have to be a feisty opposition, but I think
00:20:05 there's this sort of undeniable reality that are over 55 voters in, in, in, in, in that key
00:20:11 demographic, they, they seem to be put off by tone. They seem to want to tone police the young when they
00:20:18 get all uppity and complain about the conditions of their captivity. How would you, or would you
00:20:23 strike a better balance as, as the opposition, uh, trying to maybe appear more stately while also
00:20:31 being critical? Like, would you change anything or would you just accept that? You, you know,
00:20:36 you, you've got your people, you're popular with your people, uh, and not everyone's going to like you.
00:20:41 Genuinely. I think they actually just have to kind of stick to their guns.
00:20:44 The, the, the conservatives, as much as people talk about how much the liberals do well with
00:20:49 over 55 voters, they are starting to slowly come down with that demographic. It's holding pretty 0.57
00:20:54 well, but again, we haven't had as much bad news hit the headlines, uh, about this liberal government
00:20:59 yet. And obviously it's very early going and the media has always been allies of the liberals. So
00:21:04 they tend to like to announce all the things or like, you know, report on all the things the
00:21:08 liberals are announcing with no follow-up on whether or not that stuff's actually going to happen or not.
00:21:12 But the conservatives do really well with middle-aged voters. A voter who is above the age of 30,
00:21:18 but below the age of 55 is the key demographic for the conservative party. And it also happens to be
00:21:23 the largest portion of the Canadian population. And so the conservatives are doing better with 18
00:21:31 to 30 voters as well, 18 to 29, because they've done much better with especially younger men.
00:21:37 But at the end of the day, it's the kind of family demographic vote they're doing really well
00:21:42 with. The people who the kids are still in the house, those are the people who vote conservative.
00:21:47 And I think if they do want to win voters back who are above the age of 55, it has less to do with
00:21:53 tone. I think it has to do with policies. Uh, I've told even members of the conservative team
00:21:58 that what you, in a certain sense, uh, how you win back a lot of, especially women over the age of 55,
00:22:04 run a soft pro-life policy. Because more than just marketing yourself as shiny, happy people,
00:22:11 you actually have to go after the liberals as being pretty nasty when you actually dig into
00:22:15 their policies. These are people who all universally voted against upgrading criminal
00:22:21 sentencing for murdering a pregnant woman. Oftentimes you have to go after a voter's stomach
00:22:26 when it comes to voting for the other guy and exposing that they have some very immoral positions.
00:22:31 So going more on letting, uh, basically biological men ruin women's sports, uh, going after the 1.00
00:22:38 liberals, absolute zero restrictions on abortion type policies, including not even protecting pregnant
00:22:43 women from crime. That's the stuff where if you go to older voters that can kind of clue them back 1.00
00:22:49 into, yeah, these guys are not the ones fighting against Trump and the evil orange man. These are the
00:22:55 people who actually have these far left, uh, crazy social opinions and they want your daughter's
00:23:01 basketball league ruined. Yeah. Think of the protecting the family unit, crime and safety,
00:23:07 issues of order. Uh, it's all right there. Uh, Wyatt, tell us a little bit about how things are going
00:23:12 at 1BC right now. Oh, everything's always chaotic at the legislature. I can actually tell you this rumor
00:23:18 right now. So apparently there's going to be another new political party at the legislature.
00:23:24 This is all rumors at the moment, but it's looks like Eleanor Sterko and Amelia Boltby might be
00:23:29 starting their own party and I invite them to do it. There needs to be another center left party. 0.66
00:23:33 That's going to hurt the NDP. But at 1BC, we're just hard charging on all the policies we care about,
00:23:38 like, uh, ending drip on undrip and all of the, uh, uh, indigenous type, uh, restrictions that are
00:23:44 making it impossible to actually build anything in this province. Impossible to build homeowners are
00:23:49 deeply concerned about, you know, whether they are even keeping their fee simple. Wyatt Claypool,
00:23:54 thanks for joining us today. Thank you for having me on.