Juno News - November 17, 2026


Carney's immigration claims COLLAPSE as real numbers emerge

Americans are losing patience with Carney over China Trump adviser BLASTS Carney over Canada’s China strategy

Episode Stats


Length

21 minutes

Words per minute

181.53

Word count

3,914

Sentence count

173

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

19

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 The Carney government has been less than honest about the number of newcomers it's allowing into
00:00:10 the country. BlackLock's reporter has released new numbers, revealing the government let 42%
00:00:17 more landed immigrants into Canada than it claimed last year. After claiming he dealt
00:00:24 with out-of-control immigration under the previous government, the Trudeau government,
00:00:27 We now learn that Kearney hid the real numbers from Canadians.
00:00:32 The story in the National Post says the new immigration spike will instantly erase any gains on jobs, housing and health care.
00:00:41 Our guest is the writer of that piece, Tristan Hopper. Welcome to the show.
00:00:46 Hello.
00:00:48 All right. What made you want to write about this?
00:00:51 Just looking at the numbers, which if you read the federal budget, it's surreal because the language in the text part of the budget will mention frequently.
00:01:03 They're like, well, Canadian productivity has gone down because we've allowed businesses to get lazy and rely on sort of a cheap labor base of temporary workers.
00:01:14 Housing has become unaffordable because we've crammed too many people into the system.
00:01:18 So the text of the budget is saying all the things that I've been saying because it's just simple arithmetic. I mean, the immigration spike of the post-COVID era was the largest in our history. And just doing very basic back of the napkin math. Yeah, that's why rents, affordability, unemployment, everything went straight to hell because you're standing a million people into the country per year. 1.00
00:01:43 it's obviously going to overwhelm capacity. And even in other Western countries that are having
00:01:49 issues with migration, Canada's numbers are nowhere near where they were. I mean, there was one year
00:01:54 where the raw number of people that entered Canada was the same as the raw number of people
00:01:58 who entered the United States, a country that is 10 times our size. So it's just, we are nowhere
00:02:03 close to what the rest of the world is doing. So writing this piece was just, so you look at the
00:02:09 budget. And then they get into the numbers. And some of these numbers are sort of hidden in
00:02:13 supplementary appendices and estimates. And they say the numbers for this year are going to be
00:02:18 380,000 permanent residents in addition to a one-time top of another 200,000. So that's the
00:02:24 most permanent residents in an entire year ever, plus another 380,000 permanent residents. And
00:02:31 you could say, well, those permanent residents, those are replacing people that are leaving,
00:02:36 But that evidence is not there. I mean, at the moment we are speaking, the number of temporary workers in the country, so workers in the country on a work permit, that's higher than it's ever been.
00:02:46 So you essentially have the government saying, yeah, immigration is way too high. Anyway, here's record numbers of everything for the next year.
00:02:52 So this story was just looking at raw, you know, I'm not going to talk about cultural compatibility and all that stuff, just just on the basic arithmetic of the capacity of Canada to absorb this many people in a year.
00:03:07 So you just look at electricity demand, you look at schools, you look at roads, infrastructure, hospitals, homes, and how do those numbers compare to bringing in this many people?
00:03:20 Because when you actually think of, you just hear these numbers like 600,000.
00:03:24 600,000 is Halifax, a city that has existed for hundreds of years.
00:03:30 It's bigger than Halifax, that has grown over hundreds of years, slowly built itself out, added capacity.
00:03:35 here's a hospital here here's a school here bit by bit by bit and you're just boom here's a halifax
00:03:40 in an entire year so i mean one way i i ask people to sort of put it in perspective is uh you know
00:03:47 this you i don't know if you you've discussed the stellantis controversy on your show now the
00:03:53 stellantis controversy this is weeks and weeks of hand wringing and we gave billions of dollars to
00:03:58 stellantis to save some jobs and now they're getting rid of the factory but at the core of
00:04:01 the controversy is 2,000 jobs at this Stellantis factory. Now, at the current rate of permanent
00:04:08 immigration, that's about three days worth of jobs. And you also saw this during the Trudeau
00:04:13 era. He would give a ribbon cutting at an affordable housing project. And I say, well,
00:04:18 okay, you know, assuming two people per unit of these units, he cut the ribbon on a place with
00:04:23 100 units. This is going to cover 16 hours of immigration. So the amount of time it took him
00:04:29 to drive there, cut the ribbon and leave, it's already overwhelmed by the amount of immigration 0.97
00:04:33 he's bringing in. So just pure arithmetic, you know, and, you know, this isn't about whether,
00:04:40 you know, what color you want your neighbor, you know, whether someone speaks English,
00:04:44 all of these other issues, which you can also discuss. It's just, can Canada absorb this level
00:04:49 of people this quickly? And everywhere you look, it was actually shocking to me, you know, how
00:04:56 quickly we're overwhelming our existing capacity so it's being reflected in obviously we're not
00:05:00 building we've added about 5 million people in the last five years the population is 37 million
00:05:05 population estimate so it could be even worse 37 million at the beginning of covid now it's 42
00:05:11 million so have we added 5 million people's worth of hospitals 5 million people's worth of schools
00:05:17 5 million people's worth of electricity no in a lot of areas those have actually gotten worse
00:05:21 So you're seeing it reflected in wait, the worst wait times, more overcrowded schools, higher unemployment and increased rents when you just jam people into a system.
00:05:33 I mean, if you have a nightclub that's rated for 300 people and you jam 600 people in, the service is going to suck.
00:05:38 It's just basic math.
00:05:39 Yeah, I would suggest that the increase in crime is also the result of that because, I mean, some of the people we've brought in, I mean, let's face it, they're not necessarily upstanding citizen type people.
00:05:52 Yeah, the vetting. That's another thing I try and get people to appreciate, is that you're used to the immigration system that reigned from, you know, 1975 or whatever, up until basically 2016, 2017. 0.71
00:06:05 So, you know, everybody who's coming in is highly vetted, you know, has met all these points.
00:06:12 They speak perfect English, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. 0.70
00:06:14 And I think it's hard for people to appreciate that, no, this is a massive opening of low-skilled labor that is predominantly male. 0.75
00:06:23 This is another thing.
00:06:24 This isn't my reporting, but there's been a few stories that have come out pointing out that the male-female imbalance in many of Canada's major cities is now more out of whack than it's been since the fur trade.
00:06:34 Because a lot of the foreign students coming in, temporary foreign workers, are men.
00:06:40 So you're getting like now there's 127 men for every 100 women.
00:06:43 That hasn't been true for 250 years. This has always been a country in which there's more
00:06:48 women than men. So what do we know about societies that have way too many men? They start getting 0.99
00:06:55 more violent, to your point. Let's be real. Crime is up. Repeat offenders are released on bail.
00:07:02 Police responses are slower than ever. And in many places, law-abiding citizens are expected to just
00:07:09 hope nothing bad happens. That's not good enough. And that's why I'm very pleased today to be
00:07:13 telling you about Berna. And I'm so pleased to have this partnership with Juno News because I
00:07:17 actually own one myself. I bought one before we ever had this deal with Berna. So what is Berna?
00:07:22 It is a non-lethal self-defense launcher that gives you real protection without carrying a
00:07:29 firearm. It looks like a firearm. It kind of feels like a firearm, but it's not. It's non-lethal. So
00:07:33 Berna launchers look and feel like a real handgun, but they don't use bullets. Instead, they fire
00:07:38 powerful kinetic rounds designed to stop a threat from a distance up to 60 feet without
00:07:43 lethal force. Here's why it matters. You don't need a firearms license. You don't need a
00:07:49 background check. There's no waiting period. There's no permanent life-altering consequences
00:07:54 if you're forced into the situation where you have to defend yourself. Use the link in the
00:07:59 description or visit junomarketplace.com slash Berna for special offers. Make sure that you're
00:08:04 prepared it's better to be safe than sorry yeah a bunch of low-skilled people from the third world 1.00
00:08:10 who probably have little inclination to assimilate into a new country i mean what could possibly go 1.00
00:08:16 wrong right but we've got the bank what's interesting you know as i write okay go on
00:08:21 well it's okay um i was just gonna say that it was the bank of canada that has come out and
00:08:28 admitted that the numbers are problematic so yeah there's plenty of uh yeah high level sort of rbc
00:08:37 reports td bank reports bank of canada reports uh saying the same thing it's uh you know we
00:08:42 built 250 000 housing units uh last year so this year uh you're gonna bring in permanent immigration
00:08:51 380 000 plus 200 000 who already presumably still have homes and then 300 000 so you know just on
00:08:56 those raw numbers, even the most conservative estimate I could find, you're just exacerbating
00:09:01 the housing shortage, which is going to be reflected in prices and a shortage of units.
00:09:06 But to your point about the large numbers of young men coming in, a little inclination
00:09:13 to sort of work within the existing system, when I write about these issues, my inbox
00:09:19 is filled with, I would say predominantly, people who have immigrated within the last 0.95
00:09:24 10, 15 years, and I think are more alive at the potential consequences here than, you know,
00:09:30 your standard old stock Canadian, because they've, their entire adult life has been,
00:09:34 immigration generally works for Canada. And so I would say the highest levels of skepticism
00:09:40 are from recent immigrant communities. I think because they're at the sharp end of these 1.00
00:09:44 consequences. The best example being, you live in Surrey, you know, I haven't had a gun pointed
00:09:49 in my face by the Bushnoy gang. But if you want to break shop in Surrey, that's probably happened
00:09:54 to you a few times. And there's any number of examples of that. You came to Canada in 1987,
00:10:01 in 1995, in 2005, you built a small business, you assimilated, you learned the language.
00:10:07 And then you're seeing just a whole bunch of people you remember from your youth,
00:10:11 from your home country, you know, you're like, oh, they shouldn't be here. Who's letting them in? 0.99
00:10:15 And, yeah, you're starting to notice it at a street level. 0.99
00:10:22 You can use immigration to paper over the cracks in the economy.
00:10:26 I mean, if you speculate, what is the benefit to the government?
00:10:33 As the government looks at, you know, how is this going to help us?
00:10:35 Sure, it might help some companies that want the cheapest possible labor.
00:10:39 Unfortunately, you know, they're bringing people in at wages that Canadians won't work for.
00:10:45 But rather than these companies raising salaries that they're offering Canadians so that they'll get people to work for them, they'd rather bring people in and pay them less money, you know.
00:10:54 So it's depressing wages.
00:10:56 And this is something that has been mentioned in several Bank of Canada reports.
00:11:02 I think it's Richard Diaz.
00:11:03 Am I getting his name right?
00:11:04 He's a better analyst on these issues than I am.
00:11:08 And he put together a master list, put on a viral social media post.
00:11:12 And he just said, here's all the times the Bank of Canada.
00:11:14 The Bank of Canada put out a report saying, yeah, when you just have a large, endless stream of low skilled labor pumped into an economy, you decrease productivity because you're essentially telling businesses you don't have to be creative about retaining talent, you know, and you're allowed to become inefficient.
00:11:34 And Economics 101, when inefficiency is built into the system, by any means, you know, usually the one that gets mentioned is tariffs.
00:11:42 When you put high tariffs, it causes everybody to become lazy.
00:11:46 You know, like supply management, you don't have to be an efficient dairy farm because you're protected from outside competition.
00:11:51 Similarly, if you have just a bottomless flood of temporary work, you know, you're we've all seen the lines.
00:11:58 maybe we haven't all seen the lines, but starting around 2023, you started having job fairs in
00:12:04 Ontario where a grocery store opens and they're hiring a hundred people. And there's thousands
00:12:08 of people snaking around the block to get a job. Many of them here on student visas,
00:12:14 temporary foreign workers, whatever. So if you're running a business and the minute you post a job,
00:12:21 there's hundreds of people willing to take that job. Yeah. Your incentive to be efficient and
00:12:28 retained talent is completely gone and the fact that the government hid the real numbers that we
00:12:33 now saw in the black lock story you know saying that they brought in 42 percent fewer than they
00:12:40 actually did that tells you that they are aware that potentially this could be an explosive issue
00:12:47 the canadians have already been polled we used to be totally open to immigration yes but very
00:12:52 recently they're gone those days are gone so here's the here's the government hiding the real
00:12:58 numbers um presumably because they don't want to pay a political price for the immigration and yet
00:13:04 they're still hell bent on doing it i know has you it's very confusing i think a more direct
00:13:10 example is just go on google and search uh recent numbers of asylum seekers recent numbers of
00:13:17 temporary workers and you know the first hit on google is probably going to be an ircc immigration
00:13:21 Refugee Citizenship Canada website. And you will go to this website, and they've recently
00:13:26 changed it all. And you will be faced with a lot of charts that I would call lying by omission,
00:13:31 because you'll see a bunch of charts, and they all start 2003-2024. And every single chart on
00:13:38 IRCC looks like this, or what I'm just angling it. So, you know, 2003-2024, unbelievably record
00:13:46 high. We've never been this high. Oh, it's fine now, because now we're slightly lower. But if you
00:13:51 look at the wider numbers and they're still out there it takes it's harder to find them um you
00:13:56 have to get them through stats can or through our archival stats uh you'll see that you know on a
00:14:01 broader uh perspective we're still at utterly record highs everywhere it's just that 2003 23
00:14:08 2024 are so much higher that they can credibly claim yeah with the reduction and all the you
00:14:14 know we're bringing in less asylum seekers we're bringing less that's all correct uh but we're 0.58
00:14:19 still really, really high. I mean, the example I always use is the last year of Stephen Harper's
00:14:24 government, 2014. And Stephen Harper was a high immigration prime minister. There was stories
00:14:29 written about him in the international press saying, there's this conservative leader,
00:14:33 Canada, and he's super pro-high immigration. What up? And the immigration figures, the permanent
00:14:40 immigration figures in his last year, which at the time, StatsCan was saying, this is the highest
00:14:44 in 100 years. Since the First World War, this is the highest move ever brought in. And I think it
00:14:48 was 250,000. So our reduced and permanent immigration and much, much, much lower temporary
00:14:55 immigration. And now our reduced figures, super reduced, everything's under control, don't worry,
00:15:00 is 380,000 plus 200,000. So with that, it's double what it was. This crazy high number
00:15:06 that was getting mentions in the international press in 2014 were double that just in permanent
00:15:11 immigration. And then the valves are completely open. We didn't used to have in this country
00:15:16 three million non-permanent residents that's not something we ever did um and now that's that's
00:15:24 the status quo do you think the century initiative is a real thing that it's a real thing it has a
00:15:30 it has a website no no um i'm often asked this like oh this is this is all you know there's
00:15:36 puppet masters they're pulling the strings on this uh from from they just want to jam people
00:15:40 into the country bring up the gdp and then that creates a dependent class so you know you can
00:15:44 it's so unreasonable when you actually look at the figures it's comforting to think that
00:15:50 oh yeah mark carney there was there was a meeting in 2022 and they all got together and you know
00:15:55 you're gonna go back and become prime minister and you're gonna i'm i'm always less inclined
00:16:00 to adopt those um but i i would just say yeah there is the century initiative is an organization
00:16:06 that sees it as a good thing uh to drive up uh canada's overall population to 100 million by
00:16:14 the end of the century. So they've been around, I think, even since the Harper era. Two of the
00:16:18 main figures in that are within the Kearney government. So you could see this as like a
00:16:25 sub-Rosa attempt to sort of, you know, spin the wheels of Canada and get to this hundred million
00:16:31 figure. Or you can just see it as these are people who fundamentally think, for whatever reason,
00:16:37 that, you know, if you see Canada as just a risk board or a game of Settlers of Catan or whatever,
00:16:43 just like well 42 million good 100 million would be even better we'd be one of the largest countries
00:16:49 on earth um so i can remember the first time i i what doesn't the first time i heard of the
00:16:54 century initiative i was like well that sounds interesting i could i could die in 100 million
00:16:58 a country of 100 million so i i'm more inclined to think there are just people at the top
00:17:04 uh who are just not alive to the consequences of these because they never see it um i mean they
00:17:11 they do think you can just have two percent uh you know a rate of immigration that equivalent
00:17:17 to two percent of the population in perpetuity and there are not going to be consequences
00:17:22 for doing that uh you know housing will catch up uh jobs will be fine the gdp is good and
00:17:29 which they just see themselves as canada is built on i mean i often remind people of this
00:17:36 We are built on jamming unsustainable numbers of the people into the country to, you know, serve corporate interests.
00:17:44 I mean, that's if you've been to the prairies, that's what happened. 1.00
00:17:47 You know, you set aside the prairies, you build a railroad, you cut a deal with the steamship companies and to bring in all the Ukrainians in the world to settle it overnight. 0.95
00:17:57 So this is in our DNA that you just have Ottawa. 1.00
00:18:01 OK, as many as many as possible.
00:18:03 Oh, they don't like it. I don't care.
00:18:04 You know, just keep shipping them in.
00:18:05 And, and so, I mean, this, this has happened before, but, um, yeah, I, I think they're
00:18:10 just not, um, they do think, and I've heard this, I was at a gala in Ottawa and I was
00:18:16 sitting next to this, this, this guy was an American gentleman and I won't say who he
00:18:19 was, but I was trying to tell him what I'm telling you. 0.98
00:18:22 And he was just, they're going to turn into Canadians.
00:18:25 Uh, they're going to assimilate, uh, you know, their children, children will be Canadians.
00:18:29 This is fine.
00:18:30 This is good.
00:18:30 This makes for a bigger, stronger, better country.
00:18:33 And just when I try to say, you know, we're overwhelming the capacity, like, just think
00:18:38 of the schools, man.
00:18:39 And he's like, yeah, yeah, we'll deal with it because he probably lives a life where
00:18:43 he doesn't have to deal with those consequences.
00:18:45 That's exactly right.
00:18:45 Kids aren't going to a school in which suddenly you have five ESL kids in the class and it's
00:18:50 holding everyone else back or, you know, an 18 year old is graduating and can't find a
00:18:55 job to save their life and definitely can't find a place to rent.
00:18:59 Yeah.
00:18:59 I mean, last question.
00:19:00 I mean, you talk about consequences.
00:19:01 given the disaster that we've seen play out in the UK and Germany and France where you've had an
00:19:08 explosion in rapes for instance in the UK and other grooming gangs I mean our government is
00:19:15 not ignorant about what's going on over there they can see the riots they can see the problems 1.00
00:19:21 as a result of bringing in too many people yes a certain level of immigration makes sense but too 1.00
00:19:27 much of that causes problems and it's we're already seeing the cracks in canada oh well 1.00
00:19:34 there's things yeah there's things that have happened i mean it's very easy uh to say like
00:19:39 well there there are just things that do not happen in canada so i mean if if 10 years ago
00:19:44 i had said yeah maybe there's going to be uh you know muslim men blocking streets in montreal to
00:19:49 have you know prayer service street prayers they'd be like that's never gonna that's not
00:19:55 going to happen to Canada. Or there's going to be Calistani rallies, you know, depicting,
00:20:00 you know, glorifying the assassination of Indira Gandhi, just straight up on the, in Brampton,
00:20:06 in Vancouver, like, no, that's not going to happen. So I do think, rather than the theory
00:20:11 that this is all just, you know, scheming bureaucrats behind the scenes trying to tear
00:20:16 our country away from this, I really do think there is just this overwhelming naivete. You can
00:20:22 look at the riots uh in france or you know you can see the unrest in europe and you can just think
00:20:27 that's not going to happen to us that's something they have to deal with that's something the
00:20:32 americans have to deal with and we're canadians we're special i mean i see that in a lot of
00:20:36 problems i sort of probe into you know be it harm reduction uh be it made um a lot of these things
00:20:43 when they were brought in um you you can you can look through the transcripts of how they were
00:20:47 debated and you just have lawmakers conservative and liberal and ndp saying you know what uh we've
00:20:54 heard about your concerns with maid or harm reduction or you know self-identified gender
00:20:59 um and i just don't think i think everybody's just going to be nice and it'll be fine
00:21:03 um because we're coming off 60 70 years of a canadian uh experiment in which everything
00:21:09 generally has been fine but that doesn't mean uh it's going to be continuing to the future
00:21:14 Absolutely. Tristan, thank you so much for coming to the show.
00:21:17 Thank you.
00:21:18 Great. Great stuff. If you enjoyed the show and appreciate independent journalism,
00:21:23 please consider becoming a premier member of Juno News by going to junonews.com backslash
00:21:29 straight up. It helps us do what we do here. Thank you so much for tuning in. We'll see you next time.