Juno News - March 12, 2024


CBC paying out millions in bonuses while laying off staff

Topics
Mentioned
Canadian farmers are FINALLY RISING UP against the government! Do Canadians want Trudeau's censorship bill?

Episode Stats


Length

45 minutes

Words per minute

171.42

Word count

7,782

Sentence count

283

Harmful content

Misogyny

5

sentences flagged

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

3

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In the first episode of 2020, Andrew Lawton talks about the growing pains of being a customer service executive at the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation and why the government should just pay for it. Plus, why the CBC is paying out millions in bonuses while crying poverty.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:19 i am victorious i wanted to actually do we are the champions by queen on today's show but every
00:01:31 time you play a song uh youtube doesn't like it and they demonetize you but i will gloat a little
00:01:38 bit this is a victory for the little guy so when i do this show i always make a point because we
00:01:44 are sticklers for internet quality of plugging in the computer you don't want to rely on wi-fi
00:01:48 you want to use the ethernet cable now stay with me here because something happened on my computer
00:01:54 which is actually a relatively good quality computer because i i put it through a lot doing
00:01:59 this show the ethernet port stopped working now this is the second time this has happened
00:02:04 in six months the first time it was under warranty the second time it was not so i took my trusty
00:02:11 computer the other day to the apple store and they wanted to like literally this is apple for you
00:02:16 They wanted to charge me $2,300 to replace a part that they replaced six months ago
00:02:23 and, or at least claim they replaced six months ago.
00:02:26 And I was like, well, I'm at that point, like, what do I just have to do this like twice
00:02:29 a year to keep using this computer?
00:02:31 And so anyway, so I did the whole like Karen routine and I asked to speak to the manager
00:02:36 and the manager held firm.
00:02:37 And then I took the computer home and I called Apple and they said, well, we can't do anything.
00:02:42 And then I Karen'd again, this time by phone.
00:02:46 And today, like the chief, well, they're not the chief Karen.
00:02:49 I guess I'm the chief Karen.
00:02:50 But today I found out they were going to cover it.
00:02:52 I just have to pay $160 for labor.
00:02:55 So that is a victory.
00:02:56 And the goal with customer service is that it's a battle of will.
00:03:01 They're trying to wear you down.
00:03:03 So you just have to wear them down instead, where it's like, all right, we'll just pay for the computer.
00:03:07 So anyway, this is something we can all relate to.
00:03:10 So hopefully you are having a wonderful day. It is Tuesday, March 12th here on The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:03:15 Here's the segue because not everyone has the budget that CBC does.
00:03:21 CBC wouldn't have blinked twice at a $2,300 computer repair.
00:03:25 In fact, they probably would have just bought a new computer because that's what I would do if I had $1.4 billion a year coming to me without really having anything to show for it.
00:03:37 But one of the big points that I wanted to raise here is that CBC has been paying out
00:03:43 millions of dollars in bonuses while also crying poverty, basically.
00:03:49 You may have seen in the past, Catherine Tate, the head of CBC, who runs Canada State Broadcaster
00:03:55 from some fancy condo in Brooklyn, I think, or something to that effect.
00:04:00 She has lamented the financial strife of CBC.
00:04:04 Take a look.
00:04:04 Each year, with cuts to our budget.
00:04:09 Unlike the private sector, we cannot manage fluctuations through loans or bridge financing.
00:04:14 We must balance our budget each and every year.
00:04:18 Over the three years of the pandemic, as revenues plummeted, most media companies had to lay
00:04:24 off staff.
00:04:25 We shifted resources to maintain services and to protect jobs.
00:04:30 we benefited from $21 million in additional government funding for each of the past three
00:04:36 years. But today, our ability to shift resources and find savings is no longer sufficient to meet
00:04:43 the growing deficit. Oh, it's so difficult. They start every year with cuts. Well, CBC's budget
00:04:51 actually doesn't get cut. That was a bit of misinformation, courtesy of the woman that 1.00
00:04:57 holds herself up as being the chief, not the chief news reporter, but the head of the agency
00:05:01 that presents itself as being the chief news reporters in this country. And we know that
00:05:06 CBC is actually laying people off. They did a big round of layoffs in 2023, just before year end,
00:05:12 but they also found it in their budget to give $14.9 million in bonuses. Now that was as of the
00:05:21 end of October. It could actually be with the next two months of data that that increase,
00:05:27 that number increases. These figures come courtesy of the Canadian Taxpayers Federation,
00:05:32 so we thought we'd bring back our old chum, Franco Terrizano, to delve into this. Franco,
00:05:37 quite the scoop you guys have got here, not hugely surprising, but it does really take the wind out
00:05:43 of this big routine they do all the time when they're appearing before MPs complaining about
00:05:48 their budget yeah i mean look uh you just saw tate there crying about the cupboards apparently
00:05:53 being bare at the cbc well i guess not bare enough to not give out 15 million dollars in bonuses in
00:06:01 2023 to about 1100 staffers the average bonus was uh just over 13 000 smackers right doesn't sound
00:06:10 doesn't that sound nice but here's the thing right she mentioned these tough times in recent years
00:06:15 the pandemic yada yada yada but every year the cbc is handing out taxpayer funded bonuses right
00:06:21 so 15 million dollars in bonuses in 2023 uh could easily be higher than that but look 114
00:06:29 million dollars in bonuses paid out at the cbc since 2015. and of course that is all coming from
00:06:37 taxpayers so there you have it folks your hard-earned money paying for these bonuses at the cbc
00:06:44 Yeah, that is quite significant over the course of just shy of a decade, $114 million in bonuses.
00:06:51 We have a budget that really continues to go up.
00:06:55 I mean, we're looking at $1.4 billion.
00:06:57 Now, where is it that she's getting this idea that they start every year from a place of cuts from?
00:07:03 I have no idea, Andrew.
00:07:06 She must be reading CBC then.
00:07:08 I have no idea.
00:07:09 I mean, look, another sleight of hand is coming from the federal government.
00:07:13 when they say that they're finding savings,
00:07:15 yet their annual spending is increasing
00:07:17 by billions and billions of dollars.
00:07:19 Now look, Tate, as the president and CEO of the CBC,
00:07:22 her annual pay is somewhere between $470,000
00:07:26 and $620,000.
00:07:29 Now that includes salary, bonus, other types of benefits.
00:07:34 They won't actually say exactly what Tate's annual pay is,
00:07:38 but that's the range.
00:07:39 So look, Tate should have done the right thing.
00:07:41 she should have been at committee and said there will be no bonuses at the CBC. Obviously,
00:07:46 she's not willing to end the gravy train. So the question is, who in government is going to do
00:07:51 that? Now, the Canadian Heritage Minister, Pascal Saint-Ange, she should step in. But even beyond
00:07:56 that minister, Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland, her budget is April the 16th.
00:08:02 In her last budget, she said she would find a billion dollars in savings in these crown
00:08:07 corporations like the CBC, I believe over a four-year period. Well, Andrew, it seems pretty
00:08:13 obvious to me that the very first place to find savings is to stop rewarding these failing crown
00:08:19 corporations with taxpayer-funded bonuses. Yeah, very well said. Great work on this. Franco
00:08:24 Terrizano, we'll check in with you again in the future, I'm sure. Thanks for coming on.
00:08:28 Hey, thanks, Andrew. Yeah, and failing is right. And I just want to make this point here because
00:08:33 we're not talking about a network that's being rewarded for being relevant. We're not talking
00:08:37 certainly about bonuses that are coming because viewership is so high ad revenue so high and it's
00:08:43 not even like we're talking about a culturally relevant entity to a lot of Canadians or certainly
00:08:48 anyone outside the country this I was going to play yesterday and I'm glad we didn't get around
00:08:52 to it because it fits in well today uh did you watch the Oscars on Sunday no didn't think so
00:08:57 uh it was uh there was some movie about uh Barbie developing a nuclear weapon that did I don't know
00:09:04 something weird like that but uh there was a whole thing the oscars the world's uh famous actors
00:09:09 descend they all award each other and compliment each other and uh presumably make jokes about
00:09:14 trump and the the big focal point is always the red carpet you walk the red carpet you shout out
00:09:20 who are you wearing who are you wearing and uh let's look at cbc on the red carpet at the oscars
00:09:26 red carpet is open you can maybe hear some cheering we don't have the rights so
00:09:34 that is as close as i'm getting to the red carpet right now this uh white wall of of canvas but
00:09:42 over there is actually the press center so i'll be i'll be hanging out backstage i'll be fine
00:09:47 oh well that's nice cbc sends its crack journalists there who is uh basically just
00:09:54 forced to report on the red carpet from some parking lot across the street, but they let him
00:09:58 into the media center at least. So you don't need to shout, who are you wearing from there? You can
00:10:02 just walk up the escalator and try not to get shanked by a homeless guy in Los Angeles. Thank
00:10:07 goodness we have CBC with its budget to send someone to cover the red carpet without actually
00:10:12 being on the red carpet. That is the CBC experience for you in a nutshell. Now, I shouldn't be too
00:10:19 judgmental because I have definitely covered things that I haven't been invited to in the past,
00:10:22 But I believe I have more access in Davos when I'm outside the perimeter than Eli seemed to have there.
00:10:29 I forget his last name, Eli Glasner, it is, than Eli Glasner did covering the Oscars.
00:10:35 Now, the Conservatives have, of course, been unrepentant on this pledge from Conservative leader Pierre Paulyev to defund the CBC.
00:10:44 He has time and time again said that he's going to cut their budget.
00:10:47 He even makes that joke, which I heard him make again the other day, where some Canadian family, some newlywed couple is going to go to their new condo in the former Front Street headquarters of CBC in Toronto.
00:11:00 But right now, I mean, I'm with Franco. 0.67
00:11:02 The $15 million is an easy way to find saving.
00:11:04 Let's not give executive bonuses to this failing government subsidized outlet. 0.97
00:11:10 But more importantly, let's just get rid of the whole darn thing. 0.95
00:11:13 This is not a difficult decision. 0.94
00:11:15 and by the way i'm not saying we should shut the doors on cbc i'm not saying we should lock
00:11:20 everyone out i'm saying just cut their budget down to zero let them occupy i mean i look i would say
00:11:26 sell them off but i worry that no one would want to buy cbc certainly there's no business case for
00:11:33 it in its current operation so however you get there whether you sell it off whether you just
00:11:38 cut the budget whether you make sure it's no longer a crown corporation this is absolutely
00:11:43 easy. And you know what? Most Canadians would not even miss it. BBC is paid for by a license fee.
00:11:50 And this is something that people have to, and they periodically complain about it. Like you
00:11:55 could be sent to jail if you don't pay your license fee in the UK. But BBC, whatever issues
00:12:00 I have with its editorial bias, is actually a much higher quality outlet. It's a much higher
00:12:05 quality network than CBC. You look at legendary programs that have come out of the Beeb in a way
00:12:10 that CBC has not. CBC has given you a little mosque on the prairie and being Erica, which I
00:12:18 know are tremendously culturally relevant years later. I will say Schitt's Creek is a bit of a
00:12:22 win, but you know what? I'm convinced Schitt's Creek could have been done and would have been
00:12:25 done by the private sector had CBC not been there. So with $1.4 billion, they aren't even performing
00:12:32 well, but they are certainly patting themselves and each other on the back as these executive
00:12:38 bonuses indicate. So I think if anything, Pollyev's pledged to defund them, we'll probably find
00:12:43 it. Well, it'll be an easier sell to Canadians when more stories like this come out. We are
00:12:49 going to pivot from CBC to BC here because you may have caught this announcement last week
00:12:54 from the RCMP that they had seized large quantities of drugs, which I mean, it's BC,
00:13:01 calciferase but 10 000 prescription drugs that had been originally distributed through government
00:13:08 safe supply programs so-called safe supply programs and we can get to that shortly but
00:13:14 these guns these drugs were put out through this channel and then they were diverted and end up in
00:13:21 the hands of organized crime which are of course selling these opioids for profit now following
00:13:27 this we have the premier of british columbia and the attorney general and solicitor general of bc
00:13:33 saying oh we've never really seen evidence of too much diversion it's all just no big deal here that
00:13:38 was effectively premier david eby's point on this but diversion has been something the critics of
00:13:43 these so-called safe supply programs have been sounding the alarm about for quite some time
00:13:49 one of these is journalist adam zivo from the national post who joins us once again adam good
00:13:54 to talk to you thanks for coming back on oh thanks for having me back on the show so how does diversion
00:14:00 work first and foremost because i i know this is something that people that have you know blissfully
00:14:04 not been in this world might not realize or understand well so safer supply is a program
00:14:10 where we give out free pharmaceutical opioids and stimulants as a way to dissuade people from using
00:14:16 the illicit street supplies so for example if you're addicted to fentanyl you don't know what's
00:14:20 in it could be contaminated with benzodiazepines or xylazine uh the dosage is unpredictable so you
00:14:26 can easily take too much which causes you to overdose and die so uh the concept behind safer
00:14:30 supply is that if we give you uh government funded drugs that you'll know what you're getting and
00:14:36 therefore you'll stay alive until you can seek treatment and that sounds great in theory but in
00:14:40 practice a significant portion of those drugs are actually sold on the street so that drug users
00:14:46 can make money to buy stronger substances which means that not only were we not mitigating
00:14:52 these substances in that market we're actually uh subsidizing it and flooding
00:14:59 diverted drugs so is this a case of drug users people that are on these drugs going
00:15:05 getting them and basically wanting to do with that like one red paper clip guy did years ago of like
00:15:10 trading them up for something else or is it people that are for whatever reason not drug users that
00:15:15 that are being co-opted or paid to go into these programs and pose as drug users? Or is it a bit
00:15:21 of both? It's a combination of both. So the vast majority of it are people who are actually addicted
00:15:27 to fentanyl. And we give out something called hydromorphone, which is the strongest heroin.
00:15:31 But fentanyl is 10 to 50 times stronger than heroin and hydromorphone. So if you're a fentanyl
00:15:35 user, the hydromorphone is not going to do anything for you. So you're going to go and
00:15:39 sell your hydromorphone to get money to buy fentanyl. So those people are actually addicts.
00:15:43 then there's a smaller population of people who may have drug issues but it's not as severe and
00:15:48 for them they are often coerced by these are vulnerable women who are coerced by abusive 1.00
00:15:54 partners or spouses who push them to get as much safer supplies possible to sell for money
00:16:00 so it's a combination and i mean when you look at organized crime which is what the police
00:16:05 allegations here are being involved in it it wouldn't be difficult to imagine uh criminal
00:16:10 organizations that are running these vast networks. I mean, in many cases, this is in BC,
00:16:15 but these could be spanning the entire country. And it seems to be really unbelievable for the
00:16:20 province to come out and say, well, we've not really seen any evidence of this when police
00:16:24 have literally made that claim days earlier. Well, here's the thing. I've been hearing about
00:16:29 organized crimes involvement in this market for about a year now. I heard it when I was doing my
00:16:33 initial report based on interviews with 14 addiction physicians, and that report came out
00:16:37 in May. Then I interviewed another addiction physician who prescribed Safer Supply in
00:16:41 Victoria. And she said, yeah, we're aware of the fact that organized crime is involved here too.
00:16:45 Then last July, I interviewed former drug users in London, Ontario. And one of them said, yeah,
00:16:49 he just got out of jail. He knows that organized crime is involved because his associates are in
00:16:53 organized crime and they traffic Safer Supply. And then last October, I went and basically did
00:17:00 investigation on safer supply uh trafficking on reddit and found dozens of example of thousands
00:17:08 of pills being sold online originating from safer supply validated with safer supply prescriptions
00:17:15 and it's obvious that if you're trafficking to that degree that there's an element of
00:17:19 organization there and then on top of that i even interviewed uh one drug dealer who i was able to
00:17:25 locate through this investigation who confirmed like how this all works he mentioned that you
00:17:30 would have criminals put together teams of let's say five or six safer supply clients and then
00:17:34 that criminal would go and buy up all of their supply get like a thousand pills in a week and
00:17:39 then ship it all over canada so we know this is happening and then in january or rather early
00:17:44 february the bc government came out with a report based on extensive interviews with clinicians and
00:17:51 drug users across the province and they concluded diversion was a common occurrence and then last
00:17:58 week the rcmp at the lower level did two big drug busts where they found thousands of safer supply
00:18:05 pills that have been sold and you know these these frontline police officers are saying
00:18:09 that organized crime is involved but now now that there's political pressure here all of a sudden
00:18:15 the top level of the rcmp is spreading this new narrative which is completely at odds with all
00:18:21 the other information that we have out there which to me would raise concerns about the
00:18:27 the politicization of the leadership of the RCMP. Yeah, and I've been obviously, I think,
00:18:34 giving a fair bit of deserved criticism to the B.C. government here, but the federal government
00:18:38 is not immune from this at all. And I know you've written about this, where activists in,
00:18:43 or experts rather, in this space have brought their concerns directly to the federal government,
00:18:47 and basically they've fallen on deaf ears. Well, yeah, I mean, look, right now the Minister of
00:18:52 Mental Health Addictions is Yara Sachs. She is not competent to be in her position. She just comes 1.00
00:18:56 from a background where she was a yoga teacher and then she was the head of some mental health
00:19:00 nonprofit. I mean, you know, we got a yoga teacher in charge and we've got a former drama teacher in
00:19:05 charge. Maybe not the best team to be handling a high stakes initiative like this. And a team of
00:19:12 17 addiction physicians, many of you who are highly respected in their field, tried to write
00:19:17 a public letter to Yara and said, you know, we have concerns. We are seeing mass diversion in
00:19:22 our practices. We are seeing people relapse because of safer supply in our practices.
00:19:27 We have some very moderate recommendations on how you can reform this program so you can keep it in
00:19:33 some aspect, but make it much more responsible and much less harmful to surrounding communities.
00:19:39 And she ignored them. And after she ignored them, they found more signatories. So there was now
00:19:44 another open letter with 35 signatories. It came out, I believe, in late October, early November.
00:19:50 and she ignored that too so then they sent a third letter and then she finally responded
00:19:56 she gave them 30 minutes of her time in january which is nothing and she changed the timing right
00:20:03 beforehand which suggests that they either you know that they weren't really valuable
00:20:07 and they gave her a presentation that was very firmly based in evidence you know these highly
00:20:12 experienced addiction physicians and i i've reviewed the slides that they showed to the
00:20:16 minister you know it was all solid material it was all thoughtful none of it was alarmist all
00:20:21 of it was based on evidence and strong reasoning and she never responded and then a few weeks later
00:20:27 told the canadian press that criticism of safer supplies unfounded and based in fear and stigma
00:20:35 and so she's essentially arguing that these addiction physicians who went into this field
00:20:41 to help people who are struggling with addiction now have some giant fear and stigma directed
00:20:47 towards their clients, which doesn't make any sense at all. One of the things that I wanted
00:20:53 to raise on this is that obviously, if you do have organized crime co-opting this system,
00:20:59 as you've certainly laid out the case for, we're going to see more people using this
00:21:03 than would otherwise be eligible or drawn to it. And the problem is, is that the people that
00:21:07 are all in on this see increases in usage as being a positive because they say oh well great
00:21:13 more people are using this program that's what we want so there isn't really there isn't really an
00:21:18 incentive for them to face the fact that it's not working and face the fact that even if you believe
00:21:24 in the core essence of what safe supply is supposed to be which is dubious the diversion problem
00:21:29 isn't really being caught by them well for them many of these people think the diversion is
00:21:34 totally fine because they want to flood the market with quote unquote safe because organized crime is
00:21:40 selling the uh the safe government approved drugs is that the yeah well because they say look if
00:21:45 people buy these these diverted pharmaceutical drugs at least it's not something that made in
00:21:50 someone's bathtub and therefore it's safer for them to use um the fact that when you add more
00:21:56 supply to the market that cheapens prices and that leads to more overall usage and you can't just
00:22:02 expect to replace the entire illicit supply with pharmaceutical opioids that's not going to work
00:22:08 that's not what we're seeing in practice today you know uh what happens is that the people who
00:22:13 are using the street fentanyl car fentanyl they just continue using that they don't want the
00:22:17 pharmaceutical goods that we're giving to them so this idea that we're keeping people safe is really
00:22:22 naive um and then on top of that the entire reason that we have an opioid crisis to begin with in
00:22:28 in North America, is because we're doing exactly what these harm reduction activists want. We did
00:22:33 that, sorry, 20 years ago. So you had this, you know, the OxyContin scandal, where you had this
00:22:39 predatory pharmaceutical company called Purdue Pharma, that essentially lied to people about
00:22:43 how dangerous pharmaceutical opioids are, said it was safe, said it was fine, and then flooded
00:22:48 communities with safe pharmaceutical opioids. And that got everyone addicted, and then created
00:22:52 the crisis that we see today. So now, for some reason, even though 20 years ago to 10 years ago,
00:22:57 like like this isn't 100 years ago this is very recent we saw how damaging it is some people are
00:23:03 saying ridiculously that flooding communities with pharmaceutical opioids is somehow a good thing
00:23:08 wow well very very well put and good work on this adam zeevo from the national post and i should
00:23:14 also plug you are the founder and director of the center for responsible drug policy what's that
00:23:19 about uh it's a new organization that i started launched about a month ago uh that is focused as
00:23:25 the name suggests, on pushing Canada towards more responsible drug policies that rein back some of
00:23:31 the excesses that we've seen in recent years. But at the same time, we are cognizant of the fact
00:23:37 that the war on drugs rhetoric that we saw in the 80s and 90s doesn't work either. So we're
00:23:42 basically trying to chart a middle path that doesn't just rely on incarcerating drug users,
00:23:47 that is actually empathetic to their needs and focuses on addressing why people do drugs
00:23:51 and investing into mental health and housing,
00:23:54 but at the same time saying that maybe it's not a good idea
00:23:57 to give everyone free drugs to destroy themselves,
00:23:59 and maybe it's not a good idea to decriminalize drugs
00:24:02 without investing into treatment and recovery.
00:24:05 Very, very well put on that point as well.
00:24:07 Adam, thanks very much.
00:24:09 Thanks for having me.
00:24:10 Thank you.
00:24:10 And I should say, I wholeheartedly agree.
00:24:13 The criminalization approach doesn't work.
00:24:15 Now, this is where my inner libertarian comes out,
00:24:18 because if you were to talk about what you actually believe
00:24:21 as far as whether drug use should be a choice that people can make.
00:24:26 I think most pure libertarians will say, absolutely, yes, you should.
00:24:29 But when you cannot separate drug use from criminality,
00:24:35 and I don't mean by criminalizing drug use,
00:24:37 I mean by all the crimes that are related to people
00:24:39 that are often suffering from addiction,
00:24:41 property crime, which is a massive vandalism
00:24:44 and then trespassing and all of these things,
00:24:47 and trafficking, of course,
00:24:48 then you get into a much more dicey territory. And yeah, locking up drug users is not stopping
00:24:56 the problem. Otherwise, it would have been dealt with in the 80s. As Adam said, locking up drug
00:25:00 dealers hasn't even really worked, because that's been the attitude that they've taken in a number
00:25:05 of jurisdictions. So then you look at, okay, what is the way forward? And to be honest, I think the
00:25:09 most sensible approach that I've seen, and it will take some time to see whether it bears out,
00:25:15 is what Alberta is doing, which is saying that, you know, we'll give you this option, which is
00:25:19 treatment and it can be forced, forced treatment. But if forced treatment is an alternative to being
00:25:25 prosecuted, then look, you're still going to get some absolute, like you're going to get some
00:25:31 pushback. We're seeing this, but the problem is the pushback is not coming from people that are
00:25:35 making a libertarian argument that, you know, my body, my choice. The pushback is coming from
00:25:40 people that are effectively normalizing drug use. They want to normalize that and they don't
00:25:44 actually think that the state has an interest in trying to push people out of that lifestyle. So
00:25:49 it's a fascinating discussion, one that I've only started immersing myself in within the last year
00:25:54 or so, but we'll certainly see more instances of it as it puts itself on the political agenda.
00:26:00 And I guess I should say we have a couple of clips. I will just play either one of them. If I,
00:26:04 Sean, you know which one's better than the other one from a conservative leader, Pierre Polyev on
00:26:09 this. Just yesterday, the RCMP confirmed that thousands of these pills have made their way
00:26:15 into the hands of organized crime. So your tax dollars are paying for organized criminals to
00:26:21 get their hands on the same pharmaceutical drugs that caused the crisis in the first place. This
00:26:26 is insanity. I will put an end to it. We will stop funding drugs and start funding treatment and
00:26:32 recovery to bring our loved ones home drug-free. I've got an eye roll emoji from someone displeased
00:26:40 with my commentary on this. Like I said, my radical libertarianism sometimes rubs people
00:26:45 the wrong way. Although in this case, it might not, it might be the other way, the other direction
00:26:48 of the complaint. But nevertheless, I mean, Polyev, so I do know, and I've been told that 0.65
00:26:54 Polyev has quite a good relationship with Danielle Smith's chief of staff, Marshall Smith, who himself
00:27:00 is a former, well, he's, I mean, you're always an addict, I believe, but a recovered addict,
00:27:06 and he was a drug user, and he's actually been quite an instrumental force in pushing the Alberta
00:27:12 approach. And I understand Marshall Smith and Pierre Polyev have spoken quite a bit about this.
00:27:17 Now, mostly provincial, that's the issue is mostly provincial, but it would be interesting to see,
00:27:23 especially in light of what Polyev said there, what the federal government's approach on this
00:27:28 would be with a conservative government in place there. So the reality is, we'll play that other
00:27:35 clip now, safe supply policies are simply not working. We were told that decriminalizing crack,
00:27:43 heroin, cocaine, and other hard drugs was proven by all the experts to work. And then we added to
00:27:50 that taxpayer-subsidized opioids, which they called, ironically, a safe supply, that somehow
00:27:58 this was going to protect addicts from overdoses.
00:28:02 What has happened?
00:28:04 The data's in.
00:28:05 The debate is over.
00:28:06 We've had 40,000 overdose deaths in the last eight years, a 200 percent increase.
00:28:13 And where these policies have been tried most enthusiastically, the results have been the
00:28:20 most horrifying and that is the the point i've stressed on the show in the past no one can look
00:28:26 at british columbia which has been look whatever people think about british columbia's approach to
00:28:31 this it's actually been very useful because bc has turned itself into a provincial laboratory
00:28:37 it's turned itself into a testing center where we can look at this approach and see if it's working
00:28:43 and i'm sorry but there is not a single metric a single argument you can give for british columbia
00:28:49 faring better on these issues because of its approach. If anything, it's worse. Now, some
00:28:54 people would say, okay, well, that's just because British Columbia has a bigger drug problem in
00:28:58 general. But certainly you cannot say that this permissive approach, the safe supply approach,
00:29:04 even, I mean, I remember when supervised injection sites were controversial and the activists used
00:29:09 to say, well, it's not like we're giving them the drugs, they're bringing their own drugs. And now
00:29:12 that wasn't enough. Now we are in fact giving them the drugs and it simply is not working.
00:29:17 And that's why British Columbia is seeing this time and time again.
00:29:22 Now, we're going to move on from this for now, but I do want to talk some more about Bill C-63.
00:29:28 Now, this is the Liberal Government's Online Harms Act.
00:29:31 It's the bill that, among other things, reintroduces Section 13 to the Canadian Human Rights Act,
00:29:37 which prohibits online hate, hate being subject to a definition provided by the federal government
00:29:44 and one that will inevitably and invariably censor what you can say
00:29:49 and by extension, what you can read online.
00:29:52 Now, Margaret Atwood, who I disagree with on a fair bit of stuff politically,
00:29:56 but Margaret Atwood decided to weigh in on this. 0.50
00:29:59 The author, I'm actually watching with my wife now, The Handmaid's Tale,
00:30:03 which I had avoided assuming it would be excessively preachy,
00:30:07 but the first few episodes have not actually been all that preachy
00:30:09 and I'm enjoying it so far.
00:30:11 But Sean says he likes The Handmaid's Tale too.
00:30:13 all right, well, Sean, we'll have to do a viewing party.
00:30:16 I mean, we work in different cities,
00:30:17 so it might be difficult.
00:30:17 But anyway, it was a nice gesture on my part.
00:30:20 So the Handmaid's Tale.
00:30:22 No, we're not talking about the Handmaid's Tale.
00:30:23 Margaret Atwood.
00:30:24 There we go.
00:30:25 Thanks for bringing me back on track.
00:30:27 Margaret Atwood says,
00:30:28 if this account of the bill is true,
00:30:30 it's lettre de cachet all over again.
00:30:33 The possibilities for revenge,
00:30:36 false accusations, and thought crime stuff
00:30:39 are so inviting.
00:30:41 Trudeau's Orwellian online harms bill. Now, by the way, the lettre de cachet she's talking about,
00:30:50 that's a reference to arbitrary whims by the roi de France, by the king of France,
00:30:56 that basically were judgments that could not be appealed. So she's talking about
00:31:00 the edicts that will invariably come down from the higher authority that is the Canadian Human
00:31:05 Rights Tribunal, the federal government, the list of things you can and can't say
00:31:10 that will become foisted upon Canadians.
00:31:13 Now, Margaret Atwood, I'm glad she did that.
00:31:17 I'm glad she wrote about that.
00:31:18 Now, she then got a response from the Justice Minister,
00:31:23 Arif Farhani, who didn't like that Margaret Atwood
00:31:25 had tweeted out criticism of his bill.
00:31:28 And I forget, we don't have the graphic of his response
00:31:31 because I actually didn't see,
00:31:32 I don't follow Arif Farhani on Twitter, I guess.
00:31:34 Well, I didn't follow Margaret Atwood either,
00:31:36 but that one broke into my bubble.
00:31:38 but he says it does not include content that's awful but lawful it includes expressions of
00:31:45 detestation and vilification it does not include insults offensive comments or jokes that are not
00:31:50 very polite he says that but there's no way he can actually make that make that statement because
00:31:58 we don't genuinely know what will be captured by this bill and what won't be a lot will be
00:32:05 subject to regulations. It will be subject to decisions made by adjudicators on the Canadian
00:32:10 Human Rights Tribunal, which, yes, you can say, all right, well, we can appeal this to the Supreme
00:32:14 Court and get judicial review and all of that, but he cannot actually make the claim that it won't
00:32:20 cover content that you'll hear, that awful but lawful. Well, yes, I mean, technically,
00:32:26 the bill will only cover things that aren't lawful, but that's because it will be under
00:32:29 the bill's authority, that adjudicators determine for themselves what is lawful and what is not.
00:32:36 So there's a bit of a circular logic taking place in what Verani has said. And he's, of course,
00:32:41 very graciously invited Margaret Atwood to be re-educated by him. He said he'll have a chat
00:32:47 with Margaret Atwood about the bill. Now, Margaret Atwood, whatever you think of her politics,
00:32:51 good on her for standing up because she is part of that vintage that does take free speech 0.95
00:32:55 seriously because she's part of that generation of novelists like, for example, Salman Rushdie
00:33:00 that know full well what censorship is. Salman Rushdie nearly lost his life because of radical
00:33:08 Islamist resistance to his book. But the problem was not just the radical Islamist that didn't
00:33:13 like his book, it was censors that didn't like his book. And I have no doubt that Salman Rushdie
00:33:19 would be subject to the star chambers that will be established under Bill C-63
00:33:24 if his book is published in a venue in which the Canadian Human Rights Commission wants to claim
00:33:30 jurisdiction. I have no doubt that anyone who misgenders someone on social media
00:33:34 will be subject to it. You want to talk about all of these instances in history when we saw,
00:33:40 whether it was the Western Standard publishing the Danish Muhammad cartoons, whether it was
00:33:44 Mark Stein's book, America Alone, all of these things that were targeted by Human Rights
00:33:49 commissions in the 2000s and before will be targeted once again, but I think we will even
00:33:55 from there expand what people are trying to capture. And we are just supposed to be so hopeful
00:34:00 that the Human Rights Commission will exercise this authority judiciously and responsibly.
00:34:06 And that's basically the government's argument here, just trust us. And one of the most insidious
00:34:11 aspects of this bill has been that the government is pushing all of this very controversial,
00:34:17 very contentious stuff and they're doing this while also claiming that this bill is really
00:34:25 about protecting children they're they're doing some tremendous gaslighting here they're saying
00:34:29 that this is all just to protect children from online exploitation yes there are sections of
00:34:34 the bill that does that those would be uncontroversial if they were passed on their own
00:34:38 I believe this is a point that was raised by Peter Menzies in the Epoch Times he is well he's been on
00:34:43 the show before. You know who he is. He's a legend, but he is also a former vice chair
00:34:47 with the CRTC. Peter, it's good to talk to you. Thank you so much for coming back on today.
00:34:53 Oh, thanks for having me. It's always a pleasure.
00:34:56 Do you think the government is trying to just do this all in one fell swoop because they think
00:35:02 that these things belong together? Or do you think that the child exploitation stuff is really
00:35:07 the political cover for the online censorship provisions i have no insight into their thinking
00:35:14 um i wish i did and i could answer that that way it appears that they have bundled a whole bunch
00:35:21 of things into something because they couldn't do them the way they originally wanted to do them
00:35:27 which was all going to be through the digital safety commissioner the digital czar if they
00:35:34 wanted to call it that, the digital version of the CRTC for oversight. That got so much pushback
00:35:40 from the public and various platforms that described it at various times as similar to
00:35:47 what is used in Iran or North Korea or China. And those statements, I don't think were hyperbolic
00:35:54 because they actually were. So I think what they did was they tried to divide it up into certain,
00:36:00 into these different portions these sort of three areas and then of course as you were just
00:36:06 discussing get the human rights commission to do what they figured out that they couldn't legally
00:36:15 do through the creation of the office of a digital safety commissioner and and explain that part to
00:36:23 people because i i haven't covered that as extensively on the show what that digital
00:36:27 safety commissioner is supposed to be as the government envisions it with c63 well it's
00:36:33 i mean the simplest way to put it is that it's an oversight body that that
00:36:36 looks over the how the platforms conduct their business now having you know co-authored a paper
00:36:44 that called for something not dissimilar from that and it imposed what it does is it imposes
00:36:50 a duty of care it in fact imposes three duties of care but we don't need to get into those
00:36:54 those specifically on the platforms to make sure that they perform responsibly essentially that
00:37:03 everything each of the harms that it points to are already things that are illegal for the most part
00:37:10 and they're designed to protect children from being exploited from people being embarrassed from
00:37:15 people being victims of extortion through other things like recruitment for terrorism child
00:37:23 pornography, child sexual exploitation, a number of things that are already illegal. And that for
00:37:29 the most part, in fact, entirely, as far as I know, the platforms have been working for years
00:37:35 to make sure don't get posted on their websites at all. So it's kind of double coverage. I don't
00:37:42 mind the duty of care thing at all. Because, I mean, after all, these are very powerful,
00:37:47 almost monopolistic platforms. And somebody's got to have some oversight somewhere making sure that
00:37:53 they aren't being run by bond villains, you know, that Mark Zuckerberg is, and this is where I was
00:37:58 disappointed. I thought there should have been a duty of care to ensure free speech in an unbiased
00:38:03 fashion, right? Some people suspect Mark Zuckerberg of being a closet leftist who's suppressing
00:38:09 right-wing views. Currently, the same view was held, or previously the same view was held over
00:38:16 twitter now the left seems to think that elon musk is let uh you know extremists of all kinds
00:38:23 run amok on x twitter um there needs to be somebody overlooking that to make sure like i said
00:38:30 essentially bond villains is the best description of it that people are behaving responsibly and
00:38:35 using and not abusing their power but well and and i know the areas are a real problem yeah and
00:38:42 And it gets away from C63 somewhat, but I don't think hugely.
00:38:45 We've already seen through C18, which was the Online News Act, how Facebook chooses
00:38:51 to respond to what it believes as excessive regulation from the government.
00:38:55 In this case, the government was saying that they would have to compensate news companies
00:38:59 in Canada, and Facebook decides, all right, we'll just ban news in Canada.
00:39:03 Now, I don't know if Meta, the parent company of Facebook, would, in response to C63, say
00:39:09 this isn't worth it and just pull the plug and say Canadians can't use Facebook at all.
00:39:13 That does seem extreme, but it's possible that they may just say, like, we just don't want to
00:39:17 even deal with this. Yeah, they could, but I really don't think they will because basically,
00:39:23 I think they're probably pretty happy. There've been no statements from them yet that I'm aware
00:39:27 of, but I think the platforms are probably reasonably happy. They've been kind of looking
00:39:33 for some kind of consistent global regulation to to help them get their affairs in order so they
00:39:40 know exactly what the rules are and like i said they're they're all just about everything they're
00:39:44 being asked to do they're already doing um so i don't i mean they're on the child stuff or on the
00:39:50 the hate speech stuff because i i wouldn't say they're doing it on the hate stuff because their
00:39:54 threshold is much different than i think the government's is going to well that's where we
00:39:58 we're going to get into you know when you get into the meat of the matter and the regulation so i
00:40:02 I mean, I think it'll be very important to have a look at what these regulations are once that part of the bill gets passed.
00:40:10 I mean, hopefully the government will step away from the Human Rights Commission one,
00:40:14 which is the one that's going to be used to basically harass people online and cost some money and suppress free speech.
00:40:25 I mean, you're right in the sense that one of the factors that could come into play is that the platforms will, rather than stay close to the line, step way back from the line and start self-censoring in a more enthusiastic fashion, I guess you'd call it.
00:40:44 But as far as Facebook is concerned, for the most part, they're quite happy without news, near as everything I've heard indicates that, because there's less fighting.
00:40:54 People, they get fewer complaints from people, there's less bullying.
00:41:01 It's a happier space, people sharing pictures of grandchildren and children and weddings and funerals, et cetera, moments of their life, which I think they're more comfortable with.
00:41:14 You mentioned regulations. And I think that's always the danger of bills that establish a
00:41:21 framework is that you kind of pass it and don't entirely know how it's going to be used. And I
00:41:25 just wanted to ask with your experience with the CRGC, like the CRGC obviously has the authority
00:41:30 to, you know, govern, you know, for example, what you can play before and after the watershed hour
00:41:34 and things like that. So there is a kind of a moral, not moral standards, but there's a,
00:41:40 there's an obscenity standard that has been set by these regulations. How good are they
00:41:45 at doing that? And how kind of much latitude do they have to determine these things?
00:41:51 Well, the watershed hour, that one always lights me up because it only actually applies on Eastern
00:41:57 time zones. Oh, really? Yeah. Something that's inappropriate to put on the air at 9 p.m. Eastern
00:42:04 is just fine at 6 p.m pacific right i didn't know that that's actually an interesting bit
00:42:10 of trivia they don't apply these bc kids have just been subject to just horrendous horrendous
00:42:15 things exactly they just ignore it but they keep it in place and the kids in bc seem to be growing
00:42:21 up okay anyway with their parents controlling what they watch um but that's been the case that's been
00:42:26 the case for years um one of the things that concerns me greatly about the digital safety
00:42:31 commissioner like i said i don't have any problem with the duties of harm but the power is given to
00:42:35 the new digital safety commission and there's there is also going to be a digital safe digital
00:42:41 ombudsman to deal with appeals etc and that's a whole other story but that seems relatively
00:42:49 harmless at the moment but with the digital safety commissioner the powers are extensive
00:42:54 and the opportunity for the digital safety commissioner's office to expand its turf going
00:43:00 forward is, appears endless. And that's really, really worrying because all of these organs, I
00:43:08 mean, it's human nature in almost any business for people to seek to expand their turf and their
00:43:15 power and their influence and their importance and their, the number of cool conferences they
00:43:21 get invited to and speeches they get invited to make. It's just human nature. So giving them that
00:43:26 much power that worries me because there should be there should be a firm fence around how much
00:43:31 power how much power they have um and like i said with the you know the the watershed hour how good
00:43:37 are they at it well not that good all right well fair enough uh peter menzies former vice chair of
00:43:43 the crtc and uh also fantastic uh contributor uh to a number of places the mcdonald lorry institute
00:43:49 you have a great piece in the epic times on this as well so uh thank you very much peter always
00:43:53 good to talk to you. Thanks a lot, Andrew. Good to talk to you. All right. That does it for us
00:43:57 for today. We'll be back in just 23 hours and 15 minutes with more of Canada's Most
00:44:02 Irreverent Talk Show, The Andrew Lawton Show here on True North. Thank you, God bless, and good day
00:44:07 to you all.
00:44:23 We'll be right back.
00:44:53 We'll be right back.