Juno News - November 08, 2022


Chrystia Freeland checks her Disney privilege

Topics
Mentioned
Which provinces are opposed to the feds' gun grab scheme? Trudeau told Ford police didn't need more "tools" to deal with protests

Episode Stats


Length

40 minutes

Words per minute

172.58

Word count

6,943

Sentence count

352

Harmful content

Misogyny

8

sentences flagged

Toxicity

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

The Public Order Emergency Commission continues to focus on what happened in the cities of Windsor and Oshawa, but there's a lot of other stuff happening, too. Today, we hear from the Prime Minister's office about the impact of the strikes in both cities, and the government's response to them. We also hear from Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland, who says she wants to cut back on the number of Disney Plus subscriptions, and why that's a bad idea.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:00:09 north hello everyone and welcome to another edition of canada's most irreverent talk show
00:00:19 it is tuesday november 8 2022 you are tuned into another live edition of the program i'm back in
00:00:27 my home studio here as the Public Order Emergency Commission moves beyond Organizer Week to a week
00:00:35 where they're shining the spotlight on what happened in Windsor and Cootes. And we're still
00:00:40 going to cover it. I'm going to have an update later on in the program on some of the key takeaways
00:00:44 from yesterday's and today's testimony. But there's a lot of other stuff happening. And I want to be
00:00:50 very clear here. As we talk about what happened in Windsor, which was a very different animal from
00:00:56 what happened in ottawa one of the big things that the government really held to was the cost
00:01:02 of trade the value of trade that was moving across that border every day supposed to be moving across
00:01:08 the ambassador bridge which was brought to a standstill for that one weekend and i don't want
00:01:14 to diminish this because what happens across the border is incredibly significant i am from
00:01:20 southwestern ontario i've crossed the ambassador bridge many times in my life you always see trucks
00:01:25 They're bringing back auto parts, groceries, a number of other things, billions of dollars worth of trade, or actually, as the new unit of metric goes, millions of dollars worth of Disney Plus subscriptions.
00:01:37 Millions of Disney Plus subscriptions every day cross the border back and forth.
00:01:41 That is the new unit of measurement in the inflationary economy.
00:01:46 How much does it cost? $14? No, no, no. Give it to me in Disney Plus subscriptions.
00:01:50 This is, of course, courtesy of Chrystia Freeland, the deputy prime minister and prime minister who's been posting deficits worth many, many Disney Plus subscriptions, talking about what Canadians can do to withstand these inflationary pressures.
00:02:07 This was our finance minister and deputy prime minister's advice.
00:02:10 I personally, as a mother and wife, look carefully at my credit card bill once a month.
00:02:18 And last Sunday, I said to the kids, you're older now.
00:02:21 You don't want to watch Disney anymore.
00:02:23 Let's cut that Disney Plus subscription.
00:02:26 So we cut it.
00:02:27 It's only $13.99 a month that we're saving, but every little bit helps.
00:02:33 And I think every mother in Canada is doing.
00:02:36 now christia freeland makes somewhere in the range of memory serves of like 270 000 a year
00:02:46 so not an insignificant sum 270 000 a year uh divided by the 13 a month for a disney plus
00:02:54 subscription that is 20 769 disney plus subscriptions a year that christia freeland
00:03:01 makes. Now she was roundly mocked for this comment online and I'd say rightfully so and to be fair
00:03:08 the advice itself of auditing your household expenses and cutting what you don't need is not
00:03:13 bad advice. The problem is that Canadians are already doing that. Canadian mothers, Canadian 0.99
00:03:19 fathers are already faced with it. The problem is not that they don't know what they're spending
00:03:24 money on. The problem is they know exactly what they're spending money on because every time they
00:03:28 go to the grocery store, things that they used to be able to buy without even looking at the price
00:03:32 are now things where they have to question, is this really something I need? And with Christmas
00:03:37 coming up, the issue is not going to be solved by just cutting the Disney Plus subscription.
00:03:42 So as I said on Twitter, Disney Plus is the new avocado toast, where it's the thing that
00:03:48 someone from a place of economic privilege tells you is really this superfluous, extraneous thing
00:03:55 that you don't really need
00:03:56 that doesn't actually deal with
00:03:58 what the source of your problems are.
00:04:00 Now, to Minister Freeland's credit,
00:04:03 she seemed to understand this.
00:04:05 And when you're getting attacked
00:04:06 by the left and the right in this country,
00:04:08 generally speaking, I think it's safe to say
00:04:09 that you are not the bastion of unity.
00:04:11 You are just someone who has managed
00:04:13 to step in it profoundly.
00:04:14 But she did amend her comments yesterday
00:04:17 by talking about, in true woke language,
00:04:20 how she has to recognize her privilege.
00:04:23 Look, I think I want to start by really recognizing that I am a very privileged person, for sure.
00:04:38 Like other elected federal leaders, I am paid a really significant salary, and I know that that puts me in a really, really privileged position.
00:05:03 And I really recognize that it is not people like me, people who have my really good fortune, who are struggling the most in Canada today.
00:05:24 The people who are struggling in Canada today with today's high prices aren't people like me.
00:05:33 They're not federally elected politicians.
00:05:35 They are people across the country who earn a low income,
00:05:43 who really do find that today's high prices mean they have to make difficult choices about what food to buy,
00:05:55 about whether to buy groceries or pull together the money to pay the rent.
00:06:00 So I 100% recognize that. And in fact, it is that recognition which shaped so much of the
00:06:12 fall economic statement. To be fair, I don't think there's anything wrong with what she said
00:06:20 right there. The fact that she has this condescending tone whenever she says anything
00:06:25 might just be an aspect of how she communicates and how she delivers remarks.
00:06:29 I think it was a much more tone-aware and self-aware comment than her comment about how,
00:06:36 oh yeah, we're all struggling.
00:06:38 You know, I could only afford 21,000 Disney Plus subscriptions,
00:06:41 so we decided to cancel our Disney Plus subscription last month.
00:06:45 And by the way, I mean, there's a difference between doing it because you think it's prudent budgeting
00:06:51 and doing it because you have to.
00:06:54 And that was why the remark was so tone deaf, because we're not talking about cases right now where people are looking at which discretionary items they want to live without to save a bit.
00:07:04 We're talking about people that don't even have the benefit of discretion, where they have already trimmed down their expenditures so much because they have to, not because they want to, not because they're choosing to, because they are being forced into this.
00:07:20 and I'm sorry but when people are going to the gas station and not able to afford to fill up
00:07:27 their tank because they just went grocery shopping or vice versa they you know can't afford to go
00:07:32 grocery shopping because they decided that they could get to the grocery store and that used up
00:07:36 all their gas especially in rural areas where people who want to load up on Costco runs or
00:07:41 whatever are driving an hour an hour and a half this is not an inexpensive thing and people are
00:07:46 forced to make very difficult choices and to be fair when christia freeland was asked what's your
00:07:54 advice to those people there isn't any because the problem is not the people's the problem has not
00:08:01 been brought on by these people the problem has been in part unleashed by global economic
00:08:06 circumstances but exacerbated by government a government that has increased the carbon tax this
00:08:12 year, a government that talks about tax relief and giving people their own money back, but a
00:08:17 government that isn't actually interested in not spending money, a government that is adding to
00:08:23 these pressures. So there is no answer. And that's why things are going to get, and I hate being the
00:08:28 bearer of bad news, so much worse before they get better, because we're not at the point where some
00:08:34 little nifty household budgeting tip is going to get you out of this financial hole. Government,
00:08:40 which has stopped you from working
00:08:42 if you've worked in certain sectors
00:08:43 for much of the last two years
00:08:45 government which is putting more regulatory charges
00:08:47 and more taxes on you
00:08:49 while claiming it's not
00:08:50 government which is still spending money
00:08:54 it does not have
00:08:55 and taking that money in the form of
00:08:58 just running off the cash printing machines
00:09:01 and also taking it from people
00:09:02 that are ostensibly in the government's eyes
00:09:06 able to withstand a little bit of an extra tax burden
00:09:08 but are still themselves struggling.
00:09:10 It's that government that has to own up to its role in this.
00:09:16 And it's so insulting that this minister, this finance minister,
00:09:23 thinks she can relate to what ordinary people are going through right now.
00:09:29 And she says, oh yes, it's her privilege and her understanding of how difficult it is
00:09:33 that has informed the fall economic statement.
00:09:36 Well, let's look at the fall economic statement
00:09:38 because Chrystia Freeland says,
00:09:39 oh yeah, we're on track to balancing the budget.
00:09:41 Don't worry about those hundreds of billions of dollars,
00:09:43 sorry, you know, tens of billions
00:09:46 of Disney Plus subscriptions of deficits
00:09:49 that the government has been racking up.
00:09:51 We're on track to balance it by 2027, 2028.
00:09:55 So she's convinced that in the next seven years
00:09:58 we'll be at balance.
00:10:01 Well, if you talk to the parliamentary budget officer,
00:10:03 which is ideally more responsible about its calculations
00:10:07 because it's not rooted in partisanship.
00:10:09 They're saying that the revenue in that budget
00:10:11 is going to be $11.1 billion lower
00:10:15 than what the government is projecting.
00:10:18 And interest charges are going to be $2.8 billion higher,
00:10:21 which means the year of balance budget in 2027-2028
00:10:26 that Christopher Freeland is promising
00:10:27 is going to be a year with a little tiny, teeny,
00:10:30 itsy-bitsy $10 billion deficit.
00:10:34 A $10 billion deficit.
00:10:35 Or to keep with the trend here,
00:10:37 That is a $83.3 million Disney Plus subscription deficit.
00:10:43 My mask's a little rusty there.
00:10:44 You'll have to bear with me.
00:10:46 Franco Terrazzano joins me on the line now,
00:10:49 the federal director for the Canadian Taxpayers Federation.
00:10:52 Franco, good to talk to you.
00:10:54 How bad was this update in your view?
00:10:57 Oh, it was really bad.
00:10:58 You know, I was expecting it to be bad,
00:11:00 but I wasn't expecting it to be this bad.
00:11:02 And before we really get into the nitty gritties,
00:11:04 I have to address the opening segment off the top with the finance minister's gaffe because there's also four points that all taxpayers need to remember when we hear this statement from Freeland.
00:11:18 Number one, Freeland as a minister, her annual salary is just under $280,000 to your earlier point, Andrew.
00:11:27 Number two, Freeland, like all other members of parliament, gave themselves three pay raises during the pandemic.
00:11:36 So are we really all in this together? I don't think so.
00:11:39 Point number three, Freeland's talking about the increasing cost of living. 0.64
00:11:43 Well, Freeland is making life more expensive in Canada with her tax hikes, carbon tax up, payroll taxes up, alcohol taxes up, and her crazy out of control deficit spending.
00:11:55 point number four and this ties into the fiscal update we're hearing freeland talk about finding 1.00
00:12:02 uh household savings in her household budget right disney plus well why can't you do that 0.99
00:12:07 in the federal government budget what tax yeah i want her to cancel the government of canada's
00:12:12 disney plus subscription i don't care what she does in her own household budget and i'm not sure 0.59
00:12:16 she's doing that i mean the obvious comparison is cbc which is 1.4 billion dollars a year depending
00:12:24 I'm at 1.2 to 1.4. So I, as a Canadian taxpayer, would happily cut my portion of the CBC subsidy
00:12:30 before I cut my Disney Plus or my Netflix or whatever else I'm subscribed to. Crave, maybe?
00:12:36 Yeah, well, absolutely. And here's the thing, right? Leading up to this fiscal update,
00:12:41 we heard Freeland talk about the government's fiscal restraint, how they're going to be spending
00:12:45 with prudence. We didn't see any of that in the fiscal update. Here's what we saw.
00:12:49 somehow freeland is going to spend 20 billion dollars over budget let me just read you the
00:12:56 numbers let me break down the numbers here in the april budget freeland said the government would
00:13:01 spend 452 billion dollars now in the fiscal update seven months later freeland says the government
00:13:07 will spend 472 billion dollars so the math is simple here freeland is spending 20 billion dollars
00:13:15 over her budget. Now, this was a budget that she penned seven months ago. And it's not like that
00:13:21 budget in April was this extreme austerity budget. No, no, no, no. The government was going to spend
00:13:28 $90 billion more compared to pre-pandemic and all-time highs, right? So she's overspending 1.00
00:13:35 her own budget just seven months ago by $20 billion, Andrew. Yeah. And I think that it's
00:13:43 very important to note that we haven't seen many radical or at least unpredictable changes
00:13:48 in the financial situation in that time. We've known where interest rates were trending. We've
00:13:53 known where inflation was trending. So this was, I think, entirely foreseeable.
00:13:59 Well, and here's another thing too. You've mentioned this, but I don't think taxpayers
00:14:04 should buy the spin that the government is going to balance the budget in 2027.
00:14:09 I mean, we'd love to see a balanced budget. But if you just look at the numbers, I don't think that is credible at all. Because as you mentioned, the parliamentary budget officer released its budget projections only a few weeks ago. And it shows that in 2027, well, Freeland's fiscal update is overestimating revenues by 11 billion, underestimating the interest charges on the government debt by just under $3 billion.
00:14:33 dollars. So in 2027, if you use the parliamentary budget officer's revenue and interest charge
00:14:39 figures, instead of balancing the budget, the government would have a 9.4 billion dollar
00:14:45 deficit. And of course, Andrew, the Trudeau government has not seen a budget that it couldn't
00:14:51 blow, right? Remember back in 2014, Trudeau said the budget will balance itself. Well,
00:14:56 what time is it right now? What, 4.17 p.m. November the 8th, 2022? The budget still hasn't
00:15:02 balanced itself. Remember when Trudeau was first running for prime minister, he said he'd run a few
00:15:07 modest deficits and then balance the budget in 2019. Well, he missed that by $20 billion,
00:15:13 even before the pandemic. Yeah, and I think that's an important caveat. And you and I have
00:15:19 spoken about this in the past, that the government has used the pandemic as cover for its spending
00:15:24 without acknowledging openly that the spending was already pretty out of control beforehand. And I
00:15:30 I think that there is a general tendency for the government here to not accept its own role.
00:15:36 And I think that point of Chrystia Freelands is an important one for us to acknowledge
00:15:39 because she's talking about combating inflation as though it's the kind of thing you do on an individual level by making choices.
00:15:45 But that is not dealing with the causes of the problem that are within the government's control on a macro level,
00:15:52 like, for example, the carbon tax, which is a purely discretionary tax.
00:15:57 This is money that the government is putting forward, not for revenue collection, according to its own definition, but because they're trying to change behavior, which means the government could live without that money because they're claiming that it's not even a tax.
00:16:11 Did I hear you correctly, Andrew?
00:16:13 Did I hear you say that spending before the pandemic was pretty out of control?
00:16:18 That might be the biggest understatement I've ever heard.
00:16:22 Before the pandemic, the Trudeau government was spending all time highs, even after including inflation and population differences.
00:16:30 So that means that the Trudeau government in 2018 spent more money than the feds did during any single year during World War Two.
00:16:38 Inflation and population adjusted before a pandemic, before any countrywide recession.
00:16:44 Prime Minister Justin Trudeau spent more money than the feds did during any single year while we were fighting the Nazis.
00:16:51 OK, so we were spending all time highs before the pandemic and then a pandemic comes around.
00:16:56 Well, I think most Canadians understand that, look, if you have a legitimate problem, if you have a leaky roof, let's say you fix the leak, the leaky roof.
00:17:05 But you don't go pull out the credit card and blow money that you don't have on a new flat screen, a couple of ATVs and brand new BMW.
00:17:13 Right. You prioritize. But we didn't see the federal government make any tough decisions.
00:17:18 Even the parliamentary budget officer says that of all the new spending that has been announced since COVID-19 started, $200 billion had nothing to do with COVID-19.
00:17:29 Now, I'm glad you brought up the carbon tax, because you know what?
00:17:33 I think the Trudeau government, every time they pass a gas station, they pat themselves on the back because they see the high pump prices.
00:17:40 Because a carbon tax, its objective is to raise the price of gasoline.
00:17:44 And while Ottawa has continued to raise taxes on Canadians, we identified 51 other national governments that actually did the right thing and cut taxes during the pandemic or to combat inflation.
00:17:58 Yeah, I think that's very, very important.
00:18:01 And it's funny, when you talk about these issues, the government gets very sensitive about them.
00:18:06 I want to play a clip from your testimony before a parliamentary committee the other day.
00:18:12 And I'll let you explain and contextualize it afterwards here,
00:18:15 because sometimes people just need to see the brazenness with their own eyes first.
00:18:20 The increases in premiums for EI and CPP are needed to make sure that when people lose their jobs,
00:18:26 in the case of EI, or when people retire, when our seniors retire,
00:18:29 that the funds are there to ensure that they can collect their pension,
00:18:32 or in the case of EI, that they can collect EI.
00:18:35 So the effect of not increasing those premiums with the demand for EI and CPP would mean that when people retire or when people lose their jobs, they would not have the funds needed to collect EI.
00:18:49 The funds wouldn't be there, certainly to keep up with demand, their needs, but also with inflation, and that would apply to CPP as well.
00:18:56 Are you concerned about that?
00:18:58 What I'm so concerned about are so many Canadians who, in the private sector, just took it on the chin for two plus years, while the people who are supposed to be their representative gave themselves pay raise after pay raise after pay raise.
00:19:14 And not just that, raise the carbon tax, raise payroll taxes, raise alcohol taxes, and then play word games with Canadians using magic math when the government's own independent budget watchdog shows that the cost of these tax hikes, like the carbon tax, is costing the average household hundreds of dollars this year, even after the rebates.
00:19:34 I'm concerned with the tax hikes. I'm concerned that all of this burden is falling on those hard-working Canadians who lost their job during the pandemic while members of Parliament gave themselves pay raises, while 300,000 bureaucrats received pay raises, while failing Crown corporations gave out bonuses and pay raises during the pandemic.
00:19:53 So I'm very concerned about the tax hikes.
00:19:54 Thank you very much. I've heard you.
00:19:55 So I hear that you're not concerned about the pensioners and the PEI recipients who wouldn't receive their funds.
00:20:00 That's what I've heard you just say.
00:20:01 It sounds to me like the Canadian Taxpayers Federation is actually not supporting the very
00:20:05 taxpayers who would struggle the most in an inflationary environment, in a circumstance
00:20:11 where they do retire and where they do lose their jobs.
00:20:14 And I think that's really, really disappointing.
00:20:16 Well, I'm glad you brought it up.
00:20:17 That wasn't a question.
00:20:20 Ooh, stone cold.
00:20:22 That wasn't a question.
00:20:23 So just that little grenade that they throw and don't even let you respond.
00:20:26 When was that, by the way?
00:20:28 Oh, this was just, I think this was what, October the 26th, I think is when I was presenting in front of the finance committee on the CTF's budget recommendations.
00:20:38 And why was it that you think that's such a sore spot when you point out what the government's payroll taxes are doing to people that they're claiming to protect?
00:20:48 Oh, well, I know exactly why.
00:20:50 I was essentially there telling them they're doing a bad job, saying, hey, you're wasting way too much money and you're raising taxes at the worst possible time.
00:20:56 And you remember at these type of like build the budget type meetings, they hear these members of parliament here from what hundreds of individuals and groups asking for more money.
00:21:07 Well, I was there on behalf of the Canadian Taxpayers Federation telling them to spend less money, telling them to stop wasting money.
00:21:14 So I told them, hey, stop spending eighty eight hundred bucks on a sex toy show in Germany.
00:21:20 Yeah, that happened. Stop spending nearly $100,000 on fancy airplane food during a week long trip, right? Don't spend $6,000 a night on a hotel room. Stop giving former governors general a $200,000 expense account for life. You know, stop taking pay raise after pay raise after pay raise while the people that you're supposed to represent struggle through a pandemic.
00:21:44 And, you know, stop giving buckets of cash to big corporations like no more announcing two hundred ninety five million dollars for the Ford Motor Company or more than three hundred dollar or more than three hundred million dollars.
00:21:57 Sorry, for Bombardier. So I was essentially there saying, hey, you guys are doing a bad job.
00:22:01 You're wasting money like crazy and you're raising taxes, making life much more difficult for so many Canadians.
00:22:07 So that's why they're getting a little or trying to get a little feisty with me.
00:22:11 I just have to point this out.
00:22:12 I just got a push notification on my phone
00:22:15 because the markets closed, of course, half an hour ago.
00:22:18 And for the Wall Street Journal,
00:22:20 costs tied to Disney streaming service weighed on earnings,
00:22:23 even as theme parks brought in record revenue.
00:22:25 Shares fell 6% after hours. 0.98
00:22:27 Look at what she's tanking the Disney share price 0.99
00:22:30 by telling Canadians to get rid of their Disney Plus subscriptions.
00:22:34 Frank Ote-Terrazano,
00:22:35 Federal Director of the Canadian Taxpayers Federation.
00:22:38 Always a pleasure.
00:22:39 hope they invite you back to Parliament soon. Hey, so do I. Thanks for having me on, Andrew.
00:22:44 All right. Thank you. That's actually hilarious. I'm not saying that she was responsible for it,
00:22:50 but I am going to say that it makes a fun tweet to blame her for it anyway. It's the epitome of
00:22:54 fake news, but I'm going to say satire. Elon Musk, don't take me off Twitter. I'm just joking.
00:22:59 This is quite fascinating to me. And when you talk about the gap between the people that are
00:23:06 the governed and the people who are the governors. It seems to be growing ever wider. And you know
00:23:11 me, I'm not fond of conspiracy theories, but to say that Chrystia Freeland is on the Board of
00:23:15 Governors for the World Economic Forum is a statement of fact. And I think to raise questions
00:23:20 about what it means that she is a minister of the crown, supposedly beholden to Canadian taxpayers
00:23:26 and to King Charles's government in Canada. And she's also on the board of this global organization
00:23:33 that has a very aggressive policy agenda that I think is at odds with people in Canada's needs.
00:23:40 And when you ask that question, you are lumped in with the conspiracy theorists.
00:23:45 And I should say, I'm heading back to the World Economic Forum in January,
00:23:50 continuing our coverage that we did in May, asking the questions there,
00:23:53 calling out these policies that are very aggressively anti-oil and gas, anti-business, pro-carbon tax,
00:24:00 and all of these things which are genuinely fueling this cost of living crisis that governments
00:24:06 claim. I mean, before they used to say transitory. Now they don't say that. Now they just say you can
00:24:10 get through it by canceling your Disney Plus subscription and what have you. I want to shift
00:24:15 gears a little bit. I am going to get in a couple of moments to the Public Order Emergency Commission
00:24:19 and what's been happening today. But I have to start before we go there on something of an
00:24:25 indulgent note. Now, I should say I don't fancy myself an elitist, but I was in Ottawa last week
00:24:32 covering the Public Order Emergency Commission hearings in person, and I flew to Ottawa and
00:24:38 flew back. And the interesting thing about this decision is that when COVID came along and
00:24:44 travel things were disrupted, there used to be a direct flight from London, Ontario to Ottawa
00:24:50 that they canceled.
00:24:52 It was an Air Canada flight
00:24:53 and you could go from London to Ottawa.
00:24:55 You'd be there in an hour and a half or so.
00:24:57 And that no longer exists.
00:24:58 So if you want to fly anywhere,
00:24:59 you have to fly from London to Toronto,
00:25:02 which is a 22 minute flight.
00:25:04 And then from Toronto to wherever you want to go.
00:25:06 And when you do this,
00:25:08 you don't actually have to pay any extra usually.
00:25:11 It's a loss leader for Air Canada
00:25:13 because they know that it's a convenient thing.
00:25:16 It lets people,
00:25:17 I think the line that the airport uses is like your gateway to the world or something schmaltzy like that.
00:25:24 But basically, the whole point is it's a 22-minute flight that's basically free, doesn't cost you any extra than had you just flown out of Toronto, but saves you the two-hour drive and parking at Toronto Airport and all of that.
00:25:35 All of this is a lengthy preamble to this story here, where when I was coming back home on Friday night, I got on the plane in Ottawa, landed in Toronto, everything fine.
00:25:45 and then my flight from Toronto to London gets cancelled and the reason it was cancelled was
00:25:51 crew restraints which is just one of these terms they use for whatever reason but then all of a
00:25:55 sudden I'm in Toronto I don't have a car there it's late at night it was like around uh I think
00:26:00 eight uh no it was uh eight or nine o'clock whatever time it was and I am not able to get
00:26:06 home to London as planned that night so I get the notification from Air Canada though that we've
00:26:12 rebooked you on a flight that leaves at 6 p.m. Well, this was Friday at like 9 p.m.
00:26:21 And they're rebooking me on a flight that leaves at 6 p.m. I should say 6 p.m. on Monday. So three
00:26:28 days later for a flight that is 22 minutes in length. And just because I was feeling a little
00:26:33 bit creative, I decided to look it up and I determined, as you can see here, and I pointed
00:26:38 it out on Twitter, I could have walked from the Toronto airport to the London airport in just over
00:26:44 33 hours, which is less than half of how long it would take me if I were to wait to take this flight
00:26:52 from Air Canada. So what ended up happening is I took a taxi and Air Canada agreed to pay for the
00:26:58 taxi ride. So that's all sorted out. But I shared this just because I feel it was kind of an amusing
00:27:03 thing. I wasn't trying to make a point. I was trying to make, I guess, a little bit of a point
00:27:07 about Air Canada's customer service,
00:27:09 but there was really like nothing to this story,
00:27:11 except this is an amusing thing that happened,
00:27:14 having to wait three days for a 22-minute flight.
00:27:18 And oh my goodness, did people online
00:27:20 absolutely lose their minds over this. 0.71
00:27:24 A couple of people said, oh yeah, that sucks, I understand. 0.84
00:27:27 Some people went absolutely bonkers about this,
00:27:30 and I want to read a couple of these.
00:27:33 This one is from Adam L., who says,
00:27:36 Andrew, down with those elites. Also, Andrew, can you believe they dared to cancel my 22 minute
00:27:43 flight? Well, I don't see how that's like an elitist thing. It's like I've paid for a service.
00:27:49 I've paid for this thing. And that's that. H.U. Canna writes, next time, think about carbon
00:27:55 footprint and take a train. Well, I got in at nine o'clock. The train does not leave from Pearson
00:28:01 Airport. The train leaves from downtown. And the last train also left like a couple of hours
00:28:05 earlier. So then I would have had to stay overnight and I might have had to emit more emissions to
00:28:10 go to the hotel room there. Now, one person, Crampy Grifter, I don't think that is Crampy
00:28:17 Grifter's legal name. Crampy Grifter says, Andrew, it's like a two and a half hour drive. I can come
00:28:22 pick you up if you buy me a coffee. That was a very kind offer, but I didn't need to take Mr.
00:28:27 Grifter up or Ms. Grifter up on it because I'd already made my way there. And my personal
00:28:34 favorite, a YOW anti-fascist writes, you're a climate criminal and you're just posting openly 0.97
00:28:42 about it as a customer service complaint. And I was thinking a climate criminal. I've been called 0.95
00:28:47 many things before. I don't know if that one is one I've been called recently. I should say, no,
00:28:53 this one is my favorite. This is from Chuka Ajecum, who is a writer with Rabble, I believe, which is
00:28:59 a very, I think it's actually an onomatopoeia because it's what it sounds like when you read it.
00:29:04 But Chuka Ajekum writes,
00:29:06 a flight like this makes you a willful participant
00:29:08 in the crime against humanity
00:29:10 that is global climate inequity.
00:29:13 One of the worst people on the planet.
00:29:16 So next time I take the London to Toronto flight
00:29:19 or the Toronto to London flight,
00:29:20 I am going to look around and see all these like,
00:29:23 you know, grandparents that are going to meet their loved ones
00:29:26 or families that are going off on a vacation,
00:29:28 kids that are going with their parents to Disneyland.
00:29:31 I'm going to just look around them and say,
00:29:32 You are all willful participants in the crime against humanity that is global climate inequity.
00:29:39 In fact, they should actually put that on the back of the seat in front of you.
00:29:42 So for the entirety of the 20 minutes, you know just how terrible a person you are.
00:29:47 And it's funny because if I'm self-aware, I could probably come up with like an argument
00:29:52 that has like 10 points of support for why I'm just an absolutely terrible person.
00:29:57 And one of those would not be that I have flown from the London, Ontario airport to the Toronto
00:30:03 airport. That like, as far as my sins go, that's not the one I put at the top of the list of my
00:30:08 transgressions. But apparently in the climate wars, if I fly from London to Toronto, that makes
00:30:13 me a climate criminal. But if I were to fly all the way across the ocean to Egypt for the Sharm
00:30:19 El Sheikh COP27 conference, I would be a climate hero. So I don't know if the emissions stack up
00:30:25 there, but I think everyone thought that I was just flying from like point A to point B, which
00:30:30 wouldn't be really, wouldn't make any sense. No, it's a connecting flight people. And you also have
00:30:35 no sense of humor. So all of that out of the way, I was like trying, I was getting so annoyed
00:30:39 because I'm like, I wanted to respond on Twitter, which doesn't work. And I'm like, I'm going to
00:30:43 take five minutes and just explain this all on my show. And hopefully the people will come on my
00:30:48 side. But if not, apparently I'm an Alisa's climate criminal, so it doesn't matter anyway.
00:30:53 let's talk about the public order emergency commission which this week is continuing
00:30:59 with a little bit of a focus outside of ottawa which has been where most of the attention's been
00:31:05 in the few weeks up to this point and windsor which was the most disruptive part of this i
00:31:11 think because of the volume of trade that goes across the windsor detroit border every single
00:31:16 day this was an area that i think changed the game a little bit it made it so that the
00:31:21 Conservatives were less willing to openly support the convoy. It also showed how this was really a
00:31:27 movement that was turning into whack-a-mole. It wasn't just Ottawa. Things were happening at
00:31:31 different points across the country. But even so, the Emergencies Act has not been subject to a
00:31:39 compelling claim for why it was necessary, because Windsor was cleared without the use of the
00:31:46 Emergencies Act, and we already knew this, but now we're hearing from people under oath,
00:31:51 just reiterating exactly how true that was. Here's a clip of Windsor Mayor Dilkens testifying
00:31:58 that emergency powers were, well, just listen to his words.
00:32:04 And just to be clear, the blockade was cleared and the bridge reopened before the Emergencies
00:32:10 Act was invoked. Is that right?
00:32:16 On the 14th. So the 13th around midnight into the 14th, I think the bridge opened
00:32:23 around midnight on the 14th. So the Emergencies Act was invoked sometime on the 14th. So yes,
00:32:29 the answer to your question is yes. Okay, great. So none of the measures
00:32:32 in the Emergencies Act were used to clear the blockade since it came after, correct?
00:32:37 Correct. Okay, thank you. Those are my questions for you.
00:32:41 Ooh, interesting. And that was from the commission's lawyer. That wasn't one of those
00:32:45 scary convoy lawyers trapping into a corner that was just a friendly cordial direct examination
00:32:50 in which he says yeah no we cleared it without that and it was reiterated by a representative
00:32:55 of the opp who was involved in that and that is uh i forget the rank of the officer but officer
00:33:02 crowley i'm just moving on to february 14th uh the day the there was a declaration of emergencies
00:33:10 by the federal government um i'm wondering if it if you had any because of the injunction was
00:33:18 enforced the amcpa was in was in place you had a traffic management plan um is there anything that
00:33:25 the emergencies act added um to to to to to the situation or helped you in any ways in preventing
00:33:34 further blockades i i can't say operationally that we didn't use the emergencies act after that
00:33:39 But I can't imagine it didn't dissuade people from coming back.
00:33:44 But that's just a speculation.
00:33:46 We did not use the Emergencies Act at all.
00:33:50 So you would say it may have had a dissuasive effect, but it was not used on the ground.
00:33:58 That's correct.
00:34:00 That was Windsor Police Service Interim Deputy Chief Jason Crowley.
00:34:05 So again, confirming on the record what was already known, because you can see the timeline, that the Emergencies Act was not used in Windsor.
00:34:12 Now, Mayor Dilkens explained this a little bit in another moment where he talked about how, well, it sent a signal.
00:34:21 It sent a signal that we had declared an emergency in Windsor.
00:34:24 The Ontario government declared an emergency provincially.
00:34:26 The federal government declared an emergency.
00:34:28 So it sent a message to people that might want to come back to the bridge.
00:34:32 Well, if you read the Emergencies Act, and I would encourage you actually do it because I don't think most people in the media or in the liberal government have read the Emergencies Act, it becomes very clear that using it as a deterrent is not one of the rationale that you could use.
00:34:50 Using it to send a signal is not one of the criteria for the Emergencies Act.
00:34:55 Using it as a strongly worded letter or a big giant finger wag is not, believe it or
00:35:01 not, part of this extremely, extremely powerful piece of legislation.
00:35:06 You can't use it just to send a message.
00:35:09 You have to use it when there is a national emergency caused by violence, caused by espionage,
00:35:15 caused by sabotage, caused by foreign intervention.
00:35:18 None of that was present.
00:35:20 and no one before this commission and we're on the back half of this we're on the back nine to
00:35:25 use a sports metaphor which I hope I'm using correctly because I don't understand sports
00:35:29 metaphors so I just have to like find one that I've heard in a vaguely similar circumstance from
00:35:33 someone else but we're on the back nine and we are still not hearing anyone explain where those
00:35:42 criteria were met and to the contrary we're hearing police and government officials at various
00:35:47 level saying that, yeah, the Emergencies Act simply was not necessary to do all the things
00:35:52 that we did. And the thing that I find fascinating about all of this, by the way, I'm being like
00:35:59 fact-checked in my production chat here. I know back nine is a sports analogy. I said it. That's
00:36:06 what I said. I did use it. See, my team gets so impressed when I use a sports analogy because
00:36:11 usually I just like stare blankly. This is not helping me. Andrew Lawton is not an elitist
00:36:16 argument. So never mind. I am a man of the people with my hockey and golf and football. I'm a fan
00:36:22 of all of the teams, all of the sports. In any case, the Windsor situation is going to continue
00:36:29 to show the story. The Coutts situation is going to be very similar. Now, the timeline on Coutts
00:36:34 is a little bit different. But remember, Coutts was under the control of the Alberta government,
00:36:40 which rejected and is rejecting the Emergencies Act and its use and is challenging the federal
00:36:47 government in court. And the Emergencies Act actually does require provincial buy-in if it's
00:36:51 being used in a situation that is solely within one province. So the but coots happened after is
00:36:58 not the slam dunk that the Emergencies Act offenders, who are I think fewer in number
00:37:03 than they were a few weeks ago, think it is. So all of this is to say that the narrative that
00:37:09 the government has put forward here has absolutely crumbled. And if you watched the testimony last
00:37:15 week of Tamara Leach, you would see a woman who even the anti-convoy lawyer Paul Champ
00:37:22 conceded is not a national emergency, not a national security threat, didn't run away with
00:37:29 the money. This has been one of the most obnoxious rumors that people have peddled online that
00:37:33 Tamara Leach was like cashing out in millions of dollars of convoy donations, when the whole point 0.73
00:37:39 is that the convoy never really had access to a substantial sum of the donations.
00:37:44 They actually didn't access any of the Give, Send, Go donations.
00:37:48 They didn't access more than like, actually, they didn't access any of the GoFundMe donations.
00:37:53 They had a few thousand in e-transfers.
00:37:56 And then later on, they had some crypto donations,
00:37:59 which the commission acknowledged went directly to truckers.
00:38:03 $800,000 worth went to truckers in envelopes.
00:38:06 The rest was seized by the court.
00:38:08 so the convoy was not a money maker for anyone other than the government that managed to seize
00:38:13 all of these assets and put them in an escrow account where they're still sitting pending the
00:38:18 result of this like 300 million dollar lawsuit that's being filed against convoy organizers
00:38:23 and and this is significant and by the way if you donated five dollars to the convoy
00:38:30 the lawyer representing the residents of ottawa paul champ is trying to include you as a defendant
00:38:37 He actually wants to expand his lawsuit beyond the organizers, the Tamara Leach's, the Benjamin
00:38:44 Dictor's, the Chris Barber's, and he wants to sue anyone who donated to this thing.
00:38:48 So if you spent $5 because you said, well, you know, those truckers seem like they are
00:38:53 in need of a sandwich or maybe a little bit of fuel, not that $5 of fuel gets you much
00:38:58 now, then you are culpable in that lawsuit's eyes.
00:39:02 And the court has to, as I understand, still accept that amendment.
00:39:06 but this is purely punitive purely punitive and do not forget it that this is not about
00:39:11 just making sure the streets were clear this is about making sure that these people who
00:39:16 embarrass the government pay for doing it and that's the only thing they want we've got to end
00:39:23 things there my thanks to all of you for tuning into the show today we'll be back tomorrow with
00:39:27 more of canada's most irreverent talk show if you haven't heard it yet we have a brand new show at
00:39:33 true north anchored by our very own anthony fury called the daily brief it is a daily podcast and
00:39:40 i'll be making an appearance from time to time so i do hope that doesn't discourage you from
00:39:45 subscribing but do subscribe you can get all the details at tnc.news where you can also if you're
00:39:50 so inclined donate to cover our journalism our reporting on the public order emergency commission
00:39:56 and much else that is at donate.tnc.news thanks very much to all of you we will talk to you
00:40:02 tomorrow. Have a good one. God bless and good day to you all. Thanks for listening to the Andrew
00:40:07 Martin Show. Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.