Juno News - January 10, 2024


Chrystia Freeland silent on journalist's arrest despite past support for press freedom

Topics
Mentioned
Reporter speaks out after being arrested while questioning Chrystia Freeland CBC justifies church arsons in latest “investigation”

Episode Stats


Length

45 minutes

Words per minute

181.74

Word count

8,213

Sentence count

401

Harmful content

Misogyny

6

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

23

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of The Andrew Lawton Show, Andrew Lawton talks about the dismal state of the Canadian Armed Forces, his trip to Kosovo, and Groucho Marx's "I don't want to be in a club that would accept me as a member."

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:20 north hello and welcome to you all canada's most irreverent talk show here midway through the
00:01:30 week on this wednesday january 10th 2024 had phenomenal feedback to my interview yesterday
00:01:38 well both interviews actually both with david the menzoid menzies of rebel news but also my
00:01:43 interview with Drew McGilvery and Tom Marazzo on the rather dismal state of affairs in the
00:01:50 Canadian Armed Forces. You may have seen at True North yesterday, my colleague Cosman Georgia had
00:01:56 a rather chilling report about this war on whiteness and patriarchy in the Canadian Armed
00:02:03 Forces official journal. The, what is it? The Canadian, I forget the name of it now. It's like
00:02:07 the Canadian Military Journal or Canadian Armed Forces Journal or one of those just benign
00:02:12 academic names uh sean said that's it but i mentioned like four so i don't know which one
00:02:16 the canadian military journal there we go so that was i think a really important interview and i heard
00:02:22 from a number of veterans including by the way my father who i mentioned yesterday on the show
00:02:26 is a veteran and i heard from a number saying that they would not enlist today if they were to you
00:02:33 know be their young selves when they enlisted the first time around they would not enlist today
00:02:37 seeing the military how it is and that is uh tremendously shameful and i mean it's easy to
00:02:41 sort of crack our jokes and say, oh, well, what's the Canadian military doing anyway? But the Canadian
00:02:46 military has a role to play. Canada has a role to play. And I think if we move beyond the Trudeau
00:02:51 era, as many of you hope we do sooner rather than later, we may find there is a role for Canada to
00:02:57 play that is even greater than. And it's really disgraceful that what the military has done in
00:03:03 the last several years has started to make the very best people want to self-select out of that
00:03:10 process. So we lower the bar so much that we think it's going to make all of the recruitment
00:03:15 problems go away. And all it does is mean you balloon it with basically people that don't
00:03:19 belong there. And the ones that you really want there, the ones that are really going to make the
00:03:24 military great are saying, I don't want anything to do with this. They're kind of doing the old
00:03:29 Groucho Marx thing to adapt that line. I think it's actually him. It might be apocryphal, but
00:03:33 the line as it's often attributed to him is that, you know, I don't want to be a member of a club
00:03:39 that would accept me as a member.
00:03:41 Now, that's pretty much my approach to life.
00:03:43 Speaking of by, well, speaking of nothing,
00:03:45 it's nothing to do with Groucho Marx.
00:03:46 It has to do with me.
00:03:48 I was nervous that if I were to say for sure
00:03:50 it was a Groucho Marx quote,
00:03:52 someone would email me and say,
00:03:53 well, actually it's not.
00:03:55 Because someone did email me
00:03:56 and fact-checked me the other day.
00:03:58 And I meant to bring it up yesterday
00:04:00 when I was talking on,
00:04:01 I think it was Monday's show about going to Davos.
00:04:04 I talked about last year and I said that
00:04:06 there was the time in which I was
00:04:08 just hanging out in the Davos Congress Center and there was the Serbian president who I spoke to
00:04:13 and then I went and spoke to the president of Kosovo and I made a joke about how they were
00:04:17 standing at opposite ends of the room because Balkan humor is absolutely my bread and butter 0.99
00:04:23 here. And of course I got the email pointing out that the president of Kosovo was not in fact in
00:04:30 Davos in 2023, to which I said, mea culpa. I meant to say the prime minister of Kosovo. It was not
00:04:38 the president of Kosovo. It was the prime minister of Kosovo and the president of Serbia. But I am
00:04:43 unflinching on the king of the Belgians because he was at the urinal next to me in the bathroom.
00:04:47 Not the king of Belgium. They don't call him that. They call him the king of the Belgians for
00:04:51 reasons unclear. Nevertheless, we got that out of the way. We'll put the correction notice
00:04:56 down at the bottom, way, way, way, way, way down that I meant to say the prime minister of Kosovo
00:05:01 instead of the president of Kosovo. And to be honest, I should have known better. I've been
00:05:05 to Kosovo. It's a lovely little country, except for the one thing that greets you when you go
00:05:10 into the capital of Pristina, which is this giant statue of Bill Clinton. And there is not a statue
00:05:17 of Monica Lewinsky in front of it, which would have been my, maybe I can get a Kosovo arts grant
00:05:21 to put a Monica Lewinsky statue there. 1.00
00:05:23 But anyway, Kosovo, Kosovo as a side,
00:05:27 we are going to talk just for a few moments.
00:05:29 I want to update you on the lead story we had yesterday,
00:05:32 which was the arrest and subsequent release of David Menzies,
00:05:37 who's a reporter with Rebel News,
00:05:39 arrested, well, questioning Chrystia Freeland.
00:05:43 Take a look.
00:05:45 Chrystia Freeland, how come the IRDC is not a terrorist group?
00:05:49 why is your government supporting islamo naturally 1.00
00:05:53 what are you doing
00:05:56 you're under arrest for assault
00:05:58 you're under arrest for assault
00:06:01 you're under arrest for assault
00:06:04 police you're under arrest
00:06:07 you bumped into me
00:06:09 you pushed into me
00:06:10 I was just scrubbing
00:06:12 I got my credentials here and you just bumped into me
00:06:14 so excuse me
00:06:16 what is your name in your bag
00:06:18 Now, had he arrested David for a fashion crime for wearing that hat, maybe it would be a bit
00:06:45 more justifiable. But no, he was arrested for assaulting a police officer, which, as we did
00:06:51 the slow-mo version of the video yesterday, simply did not happen. It's the officer himself who you
00:06:57 see outstretch an arm to try to block David's path. This is perhaps why police later decided to
00:07:04 drop. They've already managed to do what they wanted to do there, which was put a barrier
00:07:13 between a journalist asking questions and Chrystia Freeland. 0.99
00:07:17 It was never about a good faith belief on that officer's part
00:07:20 that David had committed an assault.
00:07:22 It was that we needed to find a pretext
00:07:24 to get him away from Chrystia Freeland,
00:07:27 even though there was no risk there.
00:07:29 This was the RCMP making up a charge, basically,
00:07:32 to run interference for a cabinet minister.
00:07:35 But it's peculiar that that cabinet minister
00:07:38 has had nothing to say about this.
00:07:40 This would be a great opportunity
00:07:41 for a magnanimous minister to speak up and say, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, this is not how journalists
00:07:47 should be treated. Oh, wait, hang on. I'm told she actually did put out a statement about
00:07:53 journalists being essential to liberal democracy. Oh, okay. I stand corrected. Let's watch that.
00:08:01 And there is no part of our liberal democratic garden, which is more threatened by the jungle's
00:08:08 resurgence than the free press. The danger is often specific and physical.
00:08:15 Many of you have probably already, in fact, realized that this – have seen the number
00:08:29 of journalists that have lost their lives over the last few years. So let's just remember
00:08:35 them for a minute and let us also salute their courage because the troubling reality, as
00:08:43 was explained in detail during meetings today and yesterday, and that the journalists and
00:08:50 workers in the media are more and more targeted and more and more abused and attacked. And
00:08:58 This must stop. We have to work together in order to ensure that journalists can carry out their
00:09:06 work in all safety and without any kind of worry for reprisals. Wow, that was a bold statement. Oh,
00:09:16 wait. No, hang on. It looks like that was from 2019. Okay, she had nothing to say in the last
00:09:26 48 hours or so. My, my, my, I wonder why that is. Could it be that her bold, big proclamation for
00:09:33 press freedom was merely lip service? Well, that clip that I just shared was from the Global
00:09:39 Conference for Media Freedom, which took place in London in the United Kingdom in 2019. I had the
00:09:45 great privilege of going there. I was accredited by the UK government to be a journalist at the
00:09:50 Global Conference for Media Freedom. But you may find it to be a little bit weird as to the why
00:09:58 she was there. This was this big thing that she wanted to do, this big giant thing that she wanted
00:10:03 to do with the UK. And what we found, which was quite fascinating here, is that it was Chrystia
00:10:11 Freeland who blocked Sheila Gunn-Reed from Rebel News and me from attending a press conference she 0.98
00:10:17 was holding at the Global Conference for Media Freedom. And it was only a rare bit of unity from
00:10:23 our legacy media colleagues who said, we're not covering your press conference unless you let
00:10:28 them all in. We have not seen that unanimity or any support, in fact, for David Menzies. So in
00:10:34 fact, the only people that are offering any are qualifying it by saying, well, I don't like rebel,
00:10:40 but maybe the police officer went a little bit too far with this. So Christian Freeland, perhaps
00:10:47 not actually a supporter of press freedom. The reason I wanted to revisit this, Ezra Levan has
00:10:53 announced that they are suing not just Freeland, but also the RCMP and York Regional Police for
00:10:59 this. I know they're still working out the details on exactly why, but Ezra joins me now. Ezra, I mean,
00:11:05 this is something that you've basically had to just contend with, with David Menzies. And I know
00:11:10 that there are a lot of people, when the Conservatives have spoken up in support of David,
00:11:15 as they did yesterday, that have said, oh, well, hang on, they were the ones who not that long ago
00:11:19 were kicking them out and calling the police. But I don't think that's, you know, an accusation of
00:11:24 hypocrisy. I think if anything, it's to say that they realize that that is not what politicians
00:11:29 should be doing. And I was critical when that happened, as I know you were. So that being said,
00:11:35 the media is not offering any support right now. Yeah. And I'm not surprised by that. I mean,
00:11:40 And I remember when I was growing up, I would study legal cases where the media, all the different rivals, all the different competitors, would each chip in a couple of thousand dollars to hire a lawyer together to fight every free speech freedom of the press case in Canada.
00:11:59 So CTV, Global, CBC, Toronto Star, Global Mail, they would each chip in a few grand and they would hire an excellent lawyer who would go to court on any free speech matter.
00:12:09 and say, Your Honor, I'm here on behalf of basically every journalist in the country.
00:12:15 You see that with publication bans right now still to some extent.
00:12:18 That's right. So that's the one place you see it. But I have not seen it for general free speech
00:12:23 cases in 10, 20 years. So what happened to David Menzies yesterday, and we've all seen the video,
00:12:30 14 million people have seen the video in about 36 hours, by the way. We see that David had clean
00:12:36 hands. He didn't push anyone. He didn't threaten anyone. He didn't swear at anyone. He didn't
00:12:41 assault anyone. And we all saw the worst. That was astonishing that he was arrested. But we all saw
00:12:47 how the cop pushed him, sticking out his arm, getting in his way and say, you're under arrest.
00:12:54 He's a plainclothes cop who didn't identify himself, by the way. And so we all saw how the
00:13:00 police immediately lied about it and tried to gaslight David saying, oh, you were aggressive.
00:13:04 you were pushing people around, pack a lies. I get the feeling that these bodyguards for
00:13:10 Trudeau and Freeland do this all the time. This is just the first time it was caught on tape.
00:13:16 So normally, I mean, if this were a CBC reporter that Doug Ford did this to, or Danielle Smith did
00:13:23 this to, or back in the day, Stephen Harper did this to, you might well see that consortium
00:13:28 of media companies hiring a lawyer together and you would see a national condemnation of this
00:13:34 but no it's david menzies of rebel news and actually by the way he's the only person in
00:13:39 our company with a journalism degree um and i mean i so we're all citizen journalists here but he's
00:13:46 actually the most credentialed of us and he was doing real journalism and it's astonishing to me
00:13:52 to watch the CBC denigrate him.
00:13:55 They won't, the CBC won't even call him a journalist.
00:13:58 They won't even call him a reporter.
00:13:59 Their website calls him a media personality.
00:14:04 I'm not too sad about that
00:14:06 because the CBC won't call Hamas terrorists
00:14:09 and the CBC doesn't know the answer to what is a woman. 0.99
00:14:13 Well, and their people also lack personality, 1.00
00:14:15 so it might actually be a compliment.
00:14:17 Yeah, but anyway, my point is,
00:14:18 So yesterday, I checked the Twitter feeds of all the so-called free speech groups, Canadian Association of Journalists, Canadian Journalists for Free Expression, Amnesty International, Penn Canada, Canadian Civil Liberties Association, Canadian, sorry, the Council for the Protection of Journalists, about six different groups, not one of them had anything to say.
00:14:42 And I think it's because Trudeau has successfully colonized the media.
00:14:48 And most of those groups I just referred to are too busy applying for grants from Trudeau and Freeland to upset them.
00:14:56 Anyways, we're going to take things into where that's a very long way of saying we can't rely on anyone to help us.
00:15:02 No one's coming to help us.
00:15:04 So we have to help ourselves.
00:15:06 So I have spoken to Sarah Miller, who I know has been a guest on your show before.
00:15:10 That's the excellent young lawyer who managed to get Pastor Arthur Pawlowski his successful appeal at the Court of Appeal in Alberta.
00:15:20 She has agreed to take on this case.
00:15:22 Now, we're still formalizing the lawsuit, but I would imagine it would encompass false arrest, false imprisonment, malicious prosecution, negligent investigation, assault,
00:15:36 and charter violations violating David's freedom of the press.
00:15:41 And by the way, I'm not the only person who's worried about this.
00:15:44 I see the RCMP has claimed that they are reviewing the incident.
00:15:48 Now the CBC will, I can tell you in advance, they're going to whitewash it.
00:15:51 But I'm not going to let them go so easily.
00:15:55 They abused, lied, arrested, detained, assaulted David Menzies and said,
00:16:01 whoopsie, my bad, you can go now.
00:16:03 All right, we can go now, but they can't go now.
00:16:06 Now we're going to take this before court.
00:16:07 And one of the things I'm going to ask Sarah as we prepare the lawsuit is,
00:16:11 do we want a jury trial?
00:16:13 I don't know the answer to that right now, but I want the world.
00:16:16 Listen, 14 million people saw that video and were disgusted by it.
00:16:19 I want a judge to see that, maybe a jury to see that.
00:16:23 And I want David Menzies to get a win.
00:16:27 And I want to set a precedent.
00:16:29 I want to send a warning because this is not the first time Trudeau's thugs have beat up David.
00:16:33 and it's not the first time christia freelance thugs have assaulted our people too one of her 1.00
00:16:38 staffers assaulted our videographer lincoln jay so if we don't stand up to these bullies it's
00:16:43 going to keep happening and sometimes people say as are you too litigious my first answer to that
00:16:48 is they violated our rights it's my right to go to court second of all sometimes we win like when
00:16:54 we fought to get access to the election debates and i know you were part of that fight in 2019
00:16:58 and sometimes you just need a small precedent for a win when Stephen Gilboa blocked us on Twitter
00:17:04 oh that's a trivial matter well no not really because it's a government department blocking
00:17:08 us from getting government information we sued in federal court and we won these are all little
00:17:14 wins and I wish more people were doing it I give I tip my hat to the Justice Center for
00:17:18 Constitutional Freedoms and the Canadian Constitution Foundation but we need more
00:17:21 civil liberties litigation no absolutely and one of the big things that we see in this and I
00:17:26 mentioned our little mini solidarity that we saw at the Global Conference for Media Freedom a couple
00:17:32 of years ago. But, you know, that event was very interesting because you were there as well for a
00:17:37 part of it. But I don't know how far away was it, maybe 20 kilometers away from that conference.
00:17:42 Tommy Robinson was appearing in court at the Old Bailey. And I can't remember which appearance it
00:17:47 was at that point, but I believe it was a decision about whether he was going to jail or a decision
00:17:52 about whether he was at risk of going to jail,
00:17:55 whatever it was at the day.
00:17:56 And I recall talking to one of the journalism advocates
00:18:00 at this group.
00:18:01 I think she was with Reporters Without Borders.
00:18:04 And she said, oh, yes, press freedom,
00:18:06 journalists are being targeted.
00:18:07 And you mentioned Tommy Robinson.
00:18:08 And just instantly, the color drains from the face
00:18:10 of, well, he's not a journalist.
00:18:11 And they had the same approach to Julian Assange.
00:18:14 And look, I'm all for debating the tactics,
00:18:18 the ethics, the merits of a Tommy Robinson,
00:18:21 and a David Menzies, a you, a me, a Julian Assange, a Rosie Barton, a David Carr. Let's debate and
00:18:27 let's challenge and let's criticize and be skeptical. But where you draw that line on what
00:18:32 a journalist is, is crucially important because the government's trying to make it where audiences
00:18:38 aren't the ones that make that determination, where police do. And I want to just play a clip
00:18:43 if I may, Ezra, here, because at the Global Conference for Media Freedom ended up becoming
00:18:47 a big dud like christian freeland and jeremy hunt in the uk had such big hopes and then the next year
00:18:52 it ended up being like this virtual conference that botswana was hosting and then it just disappeared
00:18:57 but i asked at that next one francois philippe champagne who was the canadian delegate
00:19:03 what a journalist is and if it's government what what definition government uses and this is the
00:19:08 answer he gave okay well that's a very good question and thank you for it i don't think it
00:19:13 is for any government to define who is a journalist actually i would leave it to journalists to define
00:19:19 that themselves i think our role is to make sure that as we said today we have seen a number there's
00:19:25 a number of trend uh against media freedom around the world we heard from our colleagues in belarus
00:19:32 today who have been harassed who have been facing violence and i've been seeing more and more
00:19:37 restrictions on media freedom one other aspect which is of concern to me and i mentioned that
00:19:43 before it's the kind of emerging technologies which are spreading misinformation and disinformation
00:19:51 so i would think that we need more than ever journalists around the world to speak up to stand
00:19:59 up and to report information accurately so that citizens around the world can be properly informed
00:20:04 And that's the bedrock of our democracy.
00:20:07 And you notice the pivot to Belarus.
00:20:09 Christopher Freeland loves to do this.
00:20:11 You talk about it.
00:20:12 Well, let's talk about journalists in Congo.
00:20:14 Let's talk about journalists in Iran.
00:20:15 Let's talk about journalists in Belarus.
00:20:17 I say, let's talk about journalists in Richmond Hill.
00:20:20 So right there, you have Minister Champagne saying, no, no, no, it's not government that
00:20:24 decides, but his government is the one that has effectively a podcast registry that has
00:20:30 state subsidized media a government that has all of these designations of qualified canadian
00:20:36 journalism organizations where they decide you can be a journalist and you can't be and and now you
00:20:40 look at the liberal response to what happened to david and it's all well he's he's not a real 0.62
00:20:46 journalist as though that excuses the conduct first and foremost yeah well that's why i want
00:20:51 to get this in the court i i mean i i spoke to a very senior lawyer this morning um very senior
00:20:57 criminal lawyer, famous name, and he said that, he watched the tape very carefully. He said,
00:21:03 absolutely, they violated his rights. Absolutely, there's significant damages here.
00:21:09 So all these know-nothings at the CBC and elsewhere poo-pooing what happened to David,
00:21:15 I know a court will find it differently. And by the way, you got to keep hope alive because we
00:21:20 have had victories in the courts, which tells me there are still some people in Canada who believe
00:21:25 in freedom for reporters. By the way, you didn't include in your list of censorship there that the
00:21:31 CRTC is now requiring news companies like yours and mine to come up with codes of conduct that
00:21:39 the government will approve or not. Could you imagine the chutzpah in this? The government
00:21:43 will hold journalists to account rather than journalists being allowed to hold the government
00:21:47 to account. I saw a CBC panel yesterday that said that David Menzies was harassing Chrystia
00:21:53 Phelan by asking her questions by virtue of him being male. And there was a gender aspect. And so
00:22:00 the arrest may have been reasonable because he was a man and she was a woman. That's the new 1.00
00:22:06 ideological woke thinking at the CBC. They would never say that, by the way, if the woman in 0.94
00:22:12 question were Danielle Smith or another conservative like that. Andrew, it falls to
00:22:19 people like you and us and David Menzies to keep real journalism alive, that doesn't make excuses
00:22:25 and say, oh, that's harassing, and doesn't excuse police brutality. Because the regime media,
00:22:33 the media party, they no longer believe in speaking truth to power. They no longer believe
00:22:39 in scrumming powerful people, if it's people on the left who are being scrummed. So I'm looking
00:22:45 forward to going to court and as soon as our lawsuit is finalized we'll publish it and i'm
00:22:49 happy to share it with you and happy to talk to you about it or invite our lawyer sarah miller
00:22:53 to go on your show to answer technical questions um it's an expensive thing to sue because we get
00:23:00 no government money we're like you in that regard so we do crowdfund it and sometimes people say oh
00:23:04 ezra you're always crowdfunding yeah because i feel like i'm fighting the whole world at the
00:23:08 same time we have seven different lawsuits against justin trudeau right now and this will be number
00:23:13 eight if people want to help out they can go to standwithdavid.com i don't know how much it's
00:23:18 going to cost to sue the government i don't think there's any chance it'll be less than 100 grand
00:23:23 and i can tell you right now the government is going to have five or ten lawyers on the other
00:23:26 side they always do i can tell you right now they're going to spend a million dollars of public 0.89
00:23:30 money fighting against us but i i'm pretty sure we're going to win and damn it we have to try
00:23:35 all right ezra levant thank you very much for coming on thanks my friend bye-bye all right
00:23:40 Right. Thank you. And I just want to show, I mean, there's the legal aspect of this, which I think
00:23:44 is incredibly important, but I also want to focus on the political response because the conservatives
00:23:51 saw an opportunity here. And again, the conservatives have not always been great on this
00:23:54 issue. They've had a very, I mean, in the past they've banned rebel from their events. It seems
00:23:59 like that embargo or that ban has ended and the conservatives are fine. I saw a screenshot. I
00:24:05 haven't verified it, but that the Conservatives might even be advertising on Rebel News. I don't
00:24:10 know if that's the case, and it doesn't matter. I mean, a party should be targeting where it thinks
00:24:16 voters are. I mean, we are at True North, we don't take ads. So for us, it's not really an issue. But
00:24:21 I know the Conservatives have advertised with Key and Bexy's countersignal. I believe the Western
00:24:26 Standard as well, if I recall. But ultimately, what we're seeing here is a real change in that
00:24:33 party. So when in the past, they had an incident with Melissa Lansman, who's a conservative member
00:24:39 of parliament who's been on this show. I don't think she is a particular fan of David Menzies.
00:24:44 And that case, though, there was one big difference because while I was critical and
00:24:48 condemned that, I don't regret doing so, I've had a number of people say, oh, well, why didn't you
00:24:52 criticize the conservatives? Well, I did. There is a difference, though, in one way, which is that
00:24:58 political parties do not have a legal obligation to accommodate journalists. I think they have a
00:25:04 moral duty and a political duty, but legally a political party is a private entity. When it has
00:25:09 an event, they have the legal right to have police remove people from that event in the same way that
00:25:16 if I hold an event and you're there and I don't want you there, I can have police review because
00:25:19 at that point you're trespassing on private property. Now that's what's happened to me.
00:25:25 The liberals have done that. It's what's happened to me. It's what happened to Menzies with 1.00
00:25:30 conservative events. It's what's happened to Karima Saad, who's an independent journalist
00:25:34 and lawyer as well. And in that case, there isn't a legal ground on which you can go after these
00:25:41 parties. You have to just criticize them and condemn them and shame them, which I think you
00:25:45 should. I mean, the liberals had police in Thunder Bay remove me from an event during the 2019
00:25:50 election. They eventually apologized, but didn't really release their ban on me covering their
00:25:56 events as a journalist. So in this case, we're talking about a police officer who either
00:26:02 unilaterally or with direction from the cabinet on a public space, this was not a trespassing issue,
00:26:09 decided to arrest this journalist, accuse him of assaulting a police officer. Then as David said
00:26:15 yesterday, just like drop him off on the outskirts of town with, I don't know, they gave him like a
00:26:19 bag on a stick or something and just like the hobo had to march around. But what we see happening
00:26:25 here is the normalization of this decision by the liberals. And when the liberals banned me from
00:26:34 covering their caucus retreat, which was in my own city, there was nary a peep from a lot of legacy
00:26:39 media outlets, which I think was absolutely disgraceful. Not because my fragile little
00:26:45 legal wanted the support, but because we need to take the principled stand on these issues and you
00:26:51 need to apply it to everyone. So that is, I think my little Ted talk on this, although I will show
00:26:56 you a video of the liberals just did not choose their timing all that well. So they're being
00:27:02 dragged even by people that are generally fans of them for having this reporter arrested or the
00:27:07 perception that they had this reporter arrested. This was the tweet they issued and the video they
00:27:12 put out yesterday.
00:27:42 how one-sided it is, how biased it is.
00:27:44 Well, first of all, your question was typical of CBC, biased again.
00:27:50 So they're doing the, oh, he's mean to the media on the same day,
00:27:56 or I guess the day after they literally had a reporter arrested
00:28:00 for questioning their deputy leader.
00:28:03 All I'm thinking is like, dudes, just sit this one.
00:28:05 Like, you're losing this one.
00:28:07 Absolutely just sit this one out because this is not reflecting well for you.
00:28:11 And of course, I should actually check the numbers.
00:28:13 This might be a good nominee for Ratio of the Week for my colleague, Harrison Faulkner.
00:28:19 Let's just, while we're on this topic, to wind it down, let's show one more clip of
00:28:23 Chrystia Freeland pontificating about the virtue of media freedom.
00:28:28 Journalists are not the enemies of the people.
00:28:32 Journalists serve the people.
00:28:34 Speaking from my own experience in government, I cannot say that every single question that
00:28:40 I am asked by a journalist is welcome or easy to answer. But I am absolutely convinced that the
00:28:51 fact that journalists are present to bear witness, the fact that journalists are present to hold
00:28:59 governments to account, makes governments better. So freedom of the press is an essential human
00:29:09 right and it is an essential element in making democracy strong essential the questions are
00:29:18 sometimes unpleasant you don't always like them uh then okay arrest that man all right well glad
00:29:24 we're consistent at least uh we are going to move on from this for now but i suspect this story will
00:29:29 have a few more developments in the days and weeks to come uh we've spent a fair bit of time on the
00:29:35 show in recent weeks talking about immigration. Now, this was something that came up when I sat
00:29:39 down with Conservative leader Pierre Polyev for a year-end interview, which was, well, I guess,
00:29:45 as the name would suggest, near the end of the year last year. And I was asking about immigration,
00:29:50 and I said, listen, we have a housing crisis. You've talked about this. Here are the immigration 1.00
00:29:54 numbers. Are those inflaming the housing crisis? And he basically said, well, yeah, you have to do
00:29:59 the numbers. There are only so many houses being built. There are this many people coming into the
00:30:03 country, but he would not commit to what his number would be. Although he said that when he
00:30:09 forms government, if he forms government, his immigration target, which for the liberals is
00:30:14 500,000 a year, but is truthfully higher than that when you take into account foreign students,
00:30:19 temporary foreign workers, and so on, that the number would be tied to economic metrics. It
00:30:25 would be tied to housing, it would be tied to labor force availability, and so on. Now, I think
00:30:30 there is a bit of an issue when we only look at immigration on the narrow economic grounds. While
00:30:36 these are important, it is not the totality of the immigration issue. There are issues to do with
00:30:41 culture and integration. These were very controversially discussed in the 2015 election,
00:30:47 but as a result, it's become this big no-go topic that no one is allowed to bring up.
00:30:53 Well, if there are issues here, and we're going to take an honest high-level view of immigration,
00:30:58 can we have a grown-up conversation? Aaron Woodrick, who is the Domestic Policy Program
00:31:04 Director for the Macdonald-Laurier Institute, had a fantastic piece over at The Hub about this. Let's
00:31:10 see if we can kick off this grown-up conversation. Aaron, always good to talk to you. Thanks for
00:31:15 coming on today. Always a pleasure, Andrew. So let me just first ask you why this gets so
00:31:21 narrowly pigeonholed into being an economic issue when obviously immigration is going to be more
00:31:28 complex than that? I think it's because it's safe turf for people, right? If we're talking about
00:31:33 economics, if we're talking about the obvious thing, which is that we have a housing problem
00:31:37 and immigration as arithmetic, that I think is safe turf. I think it starts to get a little 0.99
00:31:43 more uncomfortable for people when they're starting to imply that they're uncomfortable
00:31:47 with large numbers of people who are not like them coming here. And look, I understand why 0.99
00:31:53 this is a minefield. Some people can interpret this as just being hostile to people who aren't
00:31:57 like you or racist. I mean, there are people who are like that, but a lot of it also is just human
00:32:02 nature, right? Like we are more comfortable around people like us who speak our language,
00:32:07 who practice our religion, who have the same cultural tastes as we do. That's just human
00:32:12 nature all around the world. And so I think it is fair to have a conversation, especially in a
00:32:16 country like Canada, which is, as I make the argument in the piece, largely been built by
00:32:21 immigration and fairly successfully at that. You know, what is the rate of immigration that we're
00:32:27 all comfortable with that's optimal for canada that gives canadians who are already here the
00:32:32 most benefits the newcomers most benefits and that you know ensures that we can all continue
00:32:35 to get along um you know this is a problem that a lot of countries are struggling with and canada
00:32:39 is no exception but we need to have this conversation out in the open because pretending
00:32:44 that it doesn't matter and pretending that um it is it's not creating any tension uh does not do us
00:32:49 any favors i i think there there have been waves of this discussion and i wouldn't say they've
00:32:53 always been constructive or productive i think post 9 11 certainly a lot of people were talking
00:32:57 about uh the integration aspect of immigration i think we're seeing another wave now and in canada
00:33:03 you you see this on a number of fronts i mean you have uh ethnic tensions on the calistan seek
00:33:09 separatism issue especially out in some parts of british columbia you've got uh now the wave of
00:33:14 anti-semitism and and again i'm not going to broadly uh in in broad strokes here malign any
00:33:20 individual group but you have a lot of people that are immigrants from arab or muslim countries that
00:33:24 have views on israel that don't align with i think where a lot of canadians are and we see this in
00:33:28 some of these protests you have uh then on the other side the gender uh the gender ideology
00:33:34 fights that were taking place in the fall where you had some of those same people muslims saying 0.66
00:33:38 well hang on my values don't align with these things so no one can say there isn't a conversation
00:33:44 there. But as we see, the longer you don't talk about it, the more hot it gets.
00:33:50 Yeah, you know, and that's a problem. You know, we have to recognize that, you know,
00:33:55 when we talk, for example, about integration, right? About the idea that when you come to a
00:33:59 country, you're kind of joining a national project, right? And nobody expects you to,
00:34:03 you know, you move to Canada and the next day, suddenly you're pouring maple syrup on your
00:34:08 cereal and you've got the toque on. I mean, but what they do expect is that over time,
00:34:13 You know, you kind of, if not assimilate, which is a dirty word in a lot of quarters, integrate, sort of at least merge your past with our future together.
00:34:21 I think most people think that's a reasonable compromise.
00:34:23 And there's all kinds of things that impact how that happens.
00:34:26 It's how many people from your home country are here when you get here.
00:34:30 Are you able to live in Canada, essentially amongst the community from your home country entirely?
00:34:34 What does that impact, does that have on your integration?
00:34:38 You know, government, whether the government is signaling to you that there's an expectation that you're supposed to start to adopt or integrate Canadian ways, you know, respect Canadian laws, Canadian values, or whether it's sort of, you know what, you come here and you can just do your own thing and you don't need to pay any attention to the national project.
00:34:53 So there's a bunch of different factors at play here. But I think most Canadians, you know, look, again, I think there are some who are just genuinely, if someone has a different skin color, they don't like them.
00:35:03 I don't think that's most Canadians, though. I think most Canadians, what's more important to them is that people come here and they want to be Canadian. They want to feel Canadian. They want to live together with other Canadians rather than side by side. And I think that is the sort of general consensus that's really there. We just have to figure out, you know, what's the right level of immigration that allows us to get there?
00:35:23 Yeah, and I would also say even if someone views immigration purely as an economic calculation, if there's enough space and there are enough jobs and enough resources, I don't really care about anything else.
00:35:33 Let's just accept that premise for a moment.
00:35:35 There is a threshold that will exist for Canadians as how many is too many. 0.99
00:35:40 And it's not to say that they're right or wrong, but it's that people are going to have their own threshold.
00:35:44 And once you push above that, whatever it is, you start to have Canadians turn on immigration and turn on immigrants themselves, which I don't think anyone wants.
00:35:54 And I mean, it's an unpleasant conversation because we can say, well, Canadians shouldn't have an issue with it if there's enough space and there are enough jobs.
00:36:01 But if they do, any government that overextends that is naturally going to, as you talk about in your piece, erode that consensus around it.
00:36:10 Yeah, and I think it's a sliding scale.
00:36:12 And I think what's important is that, you know, it's OK for some people to be uncomfortable with people that aren't like them.
00:36:18 That doesn't necessarily make them racist.
00:36:20 And I really, really like to reserve that term for people who sort of are very explicit in saying they think lesser of people who, you know, have a different skin color.
00:36:28 Being, you know, just being more comfortable with people who speak your language or practice your religion or things like that.
00:36:33 That's normal. I don't I don't begrudge people that.
00:36:36 And I think, you know, I think we need to allow for that roommate.
00:36:40 To me, the analogy to me, Andrew, is kind of like some people, they like to try different
00:36:44 kinds of food all the time.
00:36:45 That's just their personality.
00:36:47 They find it interesting.
00:36:48 They like the adventure.
00:36:49 Other people know what they like to eat, right?
00:36:51 And they want to stick with what they know.
00:36:52 And it's just that maybe it's a handful of things.
00:36:54 And there's nothing wrong with either of those.
00:36:56 Those are just different personality types.
00:36:57 And I think we need to be careful with Canadians when they express that preference that we're 0.99
00:37:02 not really make.
00:37:03 And I think that's the reason we don't have this conversation a lot of the time is people
00:37:06 are afraid that if they even say something remotely, like, you know what, I, you know,
00:37:10 in my own town, sometimes I feel like there's no one like me, even though I was, I was born in
00:37:15 Canada. You know, people are wary of being called racist for saying that. And I don't think that's
00:37:20 fair to treat people that way. And even on the economic side alone, you have, you know, basically
00:37:26 what's an inherent contradiction here. You have, you know, some jobs that just, you know, we don't
00:37:30 have enough people to fill in Canada. So we say, okay, well, we need to bring in all of these 0.97
00:37:34 immigrants to fill those jobs and then oh well we don't have enough houses to uh house the immigrants 1.00
00:37:38 uh so we need to build more houses oh we need to build more house okay let's bring in more
00:37:42 immigrants to build like and it's this cycle that no one has really found an answer to yet 1.00
00:37:47 yeah and you know this is a problem that exists in a lot of countries where you kind of have this
00:37:52 almost imported labor for underclass you know i've lived in different places uh you know places like
00:37:56 the middle east in dubai where you have basically a whole imported uh class of slave labor i call 0.97
00:38:03 nothing short of labor, indentured labor almost. And in a lot of other countries, it's the same
00:38:08 thing. Canada, we've had a bit of that, right? We're seeing a lot more of it now. I think that's
00:38:12 why it's attracting more attention. And a lot of cases, you know, employers will say, well, we
00:38:16 can't find Canadians to do the work. In some cases, they could by raising wages. That, of 0.98
00:38:22 course, would lead to higher prices. And I think Canadians might not love that part. But part of
00:38:27 it also is we don't talk about our entitlement system, right? Especially with seasonal workers 0.96
00:38:31 In Atlantic Canada, some employers, for example, have had a hard time trying to find people to work.
00:38:36 That's why they import foreign labor. 1.00
00:38:39 But that would, you know, if we reformed our entitlement system, remove that disincentive to work.
00:38:43 So part of this is systemic, too.
00:38:45 And I think a lot of governments are just taking a shortcut.
00:38:47 The easy thing to do is just say, oh, yeah, we'll just kind of let people in through this channel.
00:38:50 And that solves the problem.
00:38:51 It goes away.
00:38:52 But as we can see now, it creates a whole different set of problems when it comes to discussing immigration.
00:38:57 Just on another note here, one of these issues that it's kind of like supply management in that
00:39:02 you have like nine people in Canada that really care about it from a policy perspective, but those
00:39:07 nine people really care about it, which is telecom regulation. And I would say more people should
00:39:11 care about it because, you know, it affects everyone, you know, price of dairy, price of
00:39:14 your phone plan. I'm a Rogers customer. I am on a contract right now. So I think I'm a little bit
00:39:21 safe, but anyone who's not on a contract is going to find an increase, which I know will affect me
00:39:25 when it comes up for renewal um here we have an issue in which the conservatives previously
00:39:31 tried to do a little bit with it they tried to basically allow verizon and you'd think it was
00:39:36 though like we were being invaded by germany it was just like how dare we let a foreign telecom 0.99
00:39:42 company in the liberals say the right things they say well yeah you know competition we need but
00:39:46 they aren't doing anything as you pointed out to allow competition what's going on here yeah look
00:39:52 And it's not just telecoms or supply management, it's banks, it's airlines.
00:39:55 There's a raft of sectors in this country where the reason there's no,
00:39:59 was we don't allow it.
00:40:00 We have rules around foreign investment and foreign ownership.
00:40:03 And that is the reason for the lack of competition.
00:40:05 So I say to people, you have to pick a lane.
00:40:07 You can have on one side,
00:40:08 if you absolutely insist that all these companies be headquartered in Canada,
00:40:13 be owned by Canadians, by controlled by Canadians, 0.91
00:40:15 you're not going to have enough competition.
00:40:17 You're going to pay high prices for things like telecoms.
00:40:19 The other alternative is you let in foreign competitors. 0.71
00:40:22 you'll see more competition, you'll see price wars, you'll probably get better customer service
00:40:26 to boot. The trade-off will be some of our companies will not survive. Some of our corporate
00:40:30 giants are titans. They are coddled. They are protected. They don't want competition, Andrew.
00:40:35 They're afraid of it. And, you know, I made this remark elsewhere. When it comes to trade and
00:40:39 business, anytime there's talk of a new trade deal or loosening restrictions, you see Canadian
00:40:43 business divides into two camps. One camp is excited. They're ambitious. They say, you know
00:40:48 what i can go out there i can take over the world you know i can dominate and then you know the other
00:40:52 half which are terrified they do not want competition they're afraid of global competition
00:40:56 why i want to know why our governments always side with the terrified group and never double
00:41:01 down on the ambitious entrepreneurial group that see you know competition as an opportunity and a
00:41:06 challenge not as an existential threat yeah and i think the re i mean i remember i you you and i
00:41:13 first met i don't even know if you remember this but it was a fraser institute student seminar
00:41:17 however many years ago, back when they used to do those and they'd bring in a bunch of
00:41:21 rambunctious young students to talk about policy. I don't know if they still do them, but
00:41:25 they were great fun. And you know, at the time I was a bit of a rabble rouser. And I remember at
00:41:29 university, I sat in through this one session that you all had to do if you were part of a club on
00:41:35 campus. And the head of the club's program, as always, who's like a raging lefty, gave this big
00:41:41 long lecture about how we're not allowed to sell food as clubs because there are vendors on campus
00:41:45 that sell food and she used the line and everyone knows competition makes prices go up and i was
00:41:52 like i i i don't know if i could agree on that but but everyone like it's the opposite i mean
00:41:59 even like raging marxists i think concede that competition will except for this one will will
00:42:03 lower prices they may say it's not good to do so but no one can argue that competition wouldn't be
00:42:08 better for consumers here no but the problem the problem that the government has from a stakeholder
00:42:13 standpoint is it's not good for the incumbents, right? It's not good for Rogers and Bell.
00:42:17 And Rogers and Ellis, I mean, we see this over and over in other sectors. What they do is they
00:42:22 start trying to spook the public with job losses, right? They say, oh, well, if we get a competitor
00:42:27 in here, we're going to have to lay off all these people. And then governments don't want the bad
00:42:30 headlines. So they back off. And of course, they never want to tell you the other half of that is
00:42:34 that, you know, someone else is going to be doing that job. I mean, when, you know, when Walmart
00:42:37 moved into Canada, that wasn't good for certain Canadian retailers that were the competitors. But
00:42:42 A lot of people work at Walmart in Canada now.
00:42:44 So they created jobs on the other side of the ledger.
00:42:46 So, you know, I think it's disingenuous.
00:42:48 It's self-serving.
00:42:49 Obviously, any business that's doing well wants to keep doing well.
00:42:52 And they're going to pull all the levers they can, including trying to press your governments into not allowing more competitors.
00:42:58 I think as consumers, as voters, we need to be very, very aware about that.
00:43:01 They're not looking out for our interest.
00:43:03 They're looking out for their own self-interest.
00:43:05 And really, if we're really interested in competition and lower prices, it shouldn't matter, you know, which company is delivering that.
00:43:11 What should matter is that consumers are getting lower prices and better service.
00:43:15 Yeah, and telecom is probably a great example because everyone's had a terrible customer service experience with every one of the companies.
00:43:22 And everyone's had at a certain point a call drop on every one of them.
00:43:25 But they all claim to have like the fastest network, the largest network.
00:43:28 So they're all the same.
00:43:29 It's purely a matter of which one has your business at a particular point in time.
00:43:33 And I think, you know, anything that would change that, I would be all for.
00:43:36 So an opportunity for the conservatives, possibly.
00:43:39 Aaron Woodrick, thank you so much as always, sir.
00:43:42 Thanks a lot, Andrew.
00:43:43 All right.
00:43:43 And you can read his phenomenal piece
00:43:45 on immigration over at The Hub.
00:43:47 I would encourage you to do so.
00:43:48 And hopefully we started off
00:43:50 that grown-up conversation on immigration
00:43:52 right here on the Andrew Lawton Show.
00:43:54 So I don't want to be presumptuous.
00:43:55 He may have had like a conversation before this one,
00:43:57 but I'm claiming it because I didn't know about it.
00:44:00 All right, that does it for us for today.
00:44:02 We will be back tomorrow
00:44:03 with more of Canada's most irreverent talk show
00:44:05 here on True North.
00:44:07 Same time, same place.
00:44:08 Thank you.
00:44:08 God bless and good day to you all.
00:44:11 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:44:13 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.
00:44:41 We'll be right back.