Juno News - March 23, 2023


Combatting political discrimination (Live from CFSN)

Topics
Mentioned
Pierre Poilievre and Justin Trudeau face off over housing True North Update from the Canada Strong and Free Conference

Episode Stats


Length

49 minutes

Words per minute

182.05

Word count

9,096

Sentence count

366

Harmful content

Toxicity

11

sentences flagged

Hate speech

6

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

A live show from the Canada Strong and Free Networking Conference, hosted by Andrew Lawton, where he talks about the election of Jagmeet Singh to the House of Commons, and the challenges facing Canada's third party, the New Democratic Party.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Welcome to Canada's most irreverent talk show. This is the Andrew Lawton Show. Brought to you by True North.
00:00:17 The Andrew Lawton Show starts right now.
00:00:21 welcome everyone to a live edition of canada's most irreverent talk show which if you are not
00:00:34 careful on autocorrect is remarkably similar to irrelevant which describes canada's third party
00:00:41 led by jagmeet singh so we try not to get too much confusion going on there if you are watching
00:00:48 in the room here, you are very confused
00:00:50 to whom I'm speaking, we are broadcasting
00:00:52 live on True North
00:00:54 and we thank you so much for tuning in
00:00:56 whether you're in the room here at the Canada
00:00:58 Strong and Free Networking Conference
00:00:59 or if you are tuned in from anywhere else
00:01:02 in the country, we thank you
00:01:04 so much and I just want to say
00:01:06 on a bit of a housekeeping note
00:01:07 I want to begin by thanking, these things don't
00:01:10 happen without a lot of support
00:01:12 behind the scenes and I want to just say
00:01:14 a big thank you to our friends at the Chinese
00:01:16 Embassy
00:01:16 what sorry someone left their liberal nomination speech here my mistake did not mean to do that
00:01:27 totally disregard that happened it's live so we can't edit it out we'll just pretend it never
00:01:32 happened like the last seven years in Canadian politics so it was actually quite interesting
00:01:36 did anyone get a chance to see Stephen Harper and Preston Manning yesterday yeah they talked
00:01:46 a lot about some of the old glory days of conservative politics of reform politics and
00:01:51 the one that everyone really enjoyed was the fact that they had to go without support from the
00:01:56 government for their fledgling political party and they had to raise money by passing it was kfc
00:02:01 buckets they filled up with just little bits of donations and people thought that was actually a
00:02:07 story of a bygone era of canadian politics but you still do political fundraising by getting money
00:02:11 into kfc buckets it's just the chinese yuan now and it's the liberal party that tends to do it
00:02:17 actually i don't even know what the single plat the single use plastic bands if you can do the
00:02:20 kfc buckets anymore because they used to be paper like everything else they've just ruined it
00:02:25 entirely uh but it is my great pleasure to be here i've had the opportunity to be at a couple
00:02:31 of these canada strong and free networking conferences going back years going back before
00:02:35 they were called the canada strong and free networking conference and even if manning is
00:02:40 no longer in the name, we certainly are all grateful for his legacy in Canada as a grandfather
00:02:45 and a godfather of the Conservative movement in this country. The theme of this show is going to
00:02:53 be political discrimination, which is quite an important issue. We'll talk to a few fantastic
00:02:58 people about this that have their own different perspectives. But I do want to give a nod to the
00:03:03 theme of the conference, which is often, I think, overlooked in Canadian politics. We have a Prime
00:03:08 minister who does not particularly think of middle-class Canadians, but it is about the
00:03:13 middle class. And this is something that is so difficult. And, you know, when you talk about
00:03:18 the middle class, one of the big challenges is that everyone identifies with it, but no one
00:03:23 actually defines it. So we had a minister of middle-class prosperity who didn't actually
00:03:29 understand meaning of middle-class or of prosperity, which strikes me as at least one of the two you
00:03:35 should be able to get. So they abandoned that provision in the cabinet. But it is tough for
00:03:41 people in the economy right now. A lot of folks here have heard about the gig economy. Things are
00:03:46 so bad, even liberal MPs have to moonlight for China. It's terrible. You can't just survive on
00:03:52 an MP salary anymore. You got to get a little bit of help there. But we are going to, I shouldn't
00:03:56 make jokes about a serious topic. But if you aren't laughing, you're crying. And I think we
00:04:01 need to remain somewhat optimistic, because we all wouldn't be here if we didn't think that a lot
00:04:06 of the issues about which we care were fixable and were worth fixing. So speaking of jokes, let's
00:04:11 talk about Jagmeet Singh for a moment, because he actually encouraged me for a few moments last week,
00:04:19 just a few moments, which is all it takes usually. It looked like he found a spine. He was going to
00:04:25 vote in favor of the conservative motion to compel Katie Telford as a witness, which,
00:04:31 when the government eventually said, okay, fine, Katie Telford will appear as a witness to talk
00:04:35 about Chinese interference, Jagmeet Singh said, okay, she's testifying, we don't need to support
00:04:40 the conservative motion, and we will then, as he was saying in the same breath, we'll call the
00:04:45 conservative party a useless party, that was his word, and I believe that he is actually an authority
00:04:50 on uselessness, so we should take him at his word when he makes those assessments, but it was a
00:04:55 of a backhanded way i think of saying okay they were right but we don't want to admit they were
00:05:00 right and really the loyalty lies with the liberals but the joke's on everyone because
00:05:05 the punishment is that we actually have to hear katie telford speak so i don't know if it's
00:05:09 actually a win but we will see if the liberals are in keeping with their commitment to transparency
00:05:14 sorry couldn't get through that line all right let's talk a little bit about political
00:05:19 discrimination here this is a big issue and it's one that i think conservatives oftentimes
00:05:25 and I use that with a small c casing, have a very deep-seated appreciation for. Because
00:05:30 Conservatives, despite winning the popular vote in the last two elections, which doesn't amount
00:05:35 to much in the Canadian political system, it means that Conservatives oftentimes can look around and
00:05:41 see there are a lot of people like me, but I don't see them, and I don't know where they are. And I
00:05:45 feel alone when I'm in my office. I feel alone when I'm in my classroom. I feel alone when I'm
00:05:50 in all of these other places. And one of the big reasons for that is the profound divide between
00:05:57 ordinary people and institutions. John O'Sullivan, a brilliant, brilliant thinker who formerly
00:06:03 worked for Baroness Thatcher when she was the Prime Minister in the UK, coined the term O'Sullivan's
00:06:08 first law. And I brought this up with him in an interview years ago, and he reminded me it was
00:06:13 also his only law, but it's called O'Sullivan's first law. And it's that any organization or
00:06:18 institution that is not explicitly right-wing will over time become left-wing. And political
00:06:25 parties are not immune to that. Media organizations are not immune to that. Academic institutions are
00:06:31 not immune to that. And if you look at the 20-odd, 25 years since he coined that law,
00:06:38 it's become more and more apparent that conservatives are always going to be swimming
00:06:42 upstream. Conservatives are always going to be, in a weirdly roundabout and counterintuitive way,
00:06:50 the countercultural force of our era. And we often think of counterculture as being the domain of the
00:06:56 pot-smoking, free-love hippies, but they're now the culture. They're now the majority.
00:07:01 It's people that want to stand up for individualism, and people who want to stand up for liberty,
00:07:05 and people who want to stand up for family, that are increasingly the ones that have to be carving
00:07:11 out a space in an environment that is so hostile to them. It used to be that conservatives were
00:07:16 accused of being in bed with corporations. Conservatives longed for the days when corporations
00:07:22 could be reliably conservative, I'm sure, because right now, wokeness is permeating through
00:07:26 institutions as well. And when I was speaking at the Canada Strong and Free regional conference
00:07:32 in Red Deer, we spoke a little bit about this idea of institutional wokeness. And we were talking
00:07:38 about some of the bigger picture aspects then. And I want to follow up with it in the discussion
00:07:43 we're going to have in this show today that talks about some very real and very concrete ways in
00:07:48 which political discrimination is not just pervasive throughout institutions, but also how
00:07:54 it is targeting people who are on the right. And it's oftentimes called cancel culture. And I think
00:08:00 the two are very similar, but very distinct phenomena. Cancel culture is the overarching
00:08:07 culture political discrimination is the the tactical manifestation of cancel
00:08:12 culture and it's interesting because no one I shouldn't say no one few people
00:08:16 will openly defend cancel culture people will say well I'm I'm against it but 0.97
00:08:20 they support institutions that are increasingly closed off to people of
00:08:26 viewpoints and when we talked about the drift word or the leftward drift that
00:08:33 exists the one important aspect that people need to realize here is that it
00:08:37 means neutrality is increasingly liberal. So the idea of being agnostic in politics is to be
00:08:45 liberal. And I was reminded a few years ago, CBC does these vote compass things in elections where
00:08:51 you answer all these questions and it tells you how to vote. And CBC telling you how to vote should
00:08:57 be terrifying in and of itself. But CBC, after a 10-question quiz, I don't think is any better
00:09:02 suited to tell you how to vote. And years ago, I believe it might have been on Sun News Network,
00:09:07 Ezra Levant did the quiz on air, and he answered don't know to every question. And at the end of
00:09:14 it, it said liberal, which was in a strange way, probably honest, because if you don't know anything
00:09:20 about anything, you probably are a suitable liberal voter. But the implication, oh, don't
00:09:24 give me that. Oh, it's seven years. It's not too soon. And what was fascinating, though, is that
00:09:31 the implicit bias in this system that they had designed, this quiz they had designed,
00:09:36 is that neutrality is liberal, that the center is liberal. And the liberals have oftentimes
00:09:44 relished this idea that they are a centrist party or a moderate party, just because they have
00:09:49 the NDP to the left, the conservatives to the right, therefore they're the voice of reason in
00:09:53 the middle. But it doesn't work that way. Just because they may exist, you know, slightly three
00:09:58 shades to the right of the ostentatious socialist does not mean they get a pass for their own
00:10:04 socialism. And this is something that conservatives need to be very aware of. And we can talk about
00:10:10 politics and we can talk about campaigns, and those are very important things. My friend Mark
00:10:14 Stein has often said that when liberals win, they're in power, and when conservatives win,
00:10:19 they're in office. And there's a lot of wisdom in that, because if you win an election, but every
00:10:24 other institution is against you, whether it's the bureaucracy, the academic institutions, the media,
00:10:30 you're going to be very limited in what you can do. And if you look at 10 years of Stephen Harper,
00:10:34 what you do can be unraveled very quickly when you have a liberal government that comes in,
00:10:39 and more importantly, a liberal government that has the backing of all of these other facets of
00:10:44 society. So we're going to break it down for you on an individual level and talk about what the
00:10:49 stakes are. And we'll do this with a great group of guests. And I want to start with two of the
00:10:53 young faces you'll have seen coming around here through the Canada Strong and Free Network's
00:10:58 Conservative Values Tomorrow program. And please give a warm welcome to Noah Jarvis and Liam Dunn.
00:11:12 Welcome.
00:11:13 him. So I used to, when I was on stage doing events, wear a cowboy hat myself. And then I
00:11:24 started guest hosting in Calgary, living in Ontario. And I thought, well, they're going to
00:11:28 think I'm making fun of them. So I had to retire the cowboy hat. But I'm glad it's been channeled
00:11:32 in your attire today, Liam. And Noah, it's good to have you here as well. I actually work with
00:11:36 Noah at True North. So we can work in his performance review at the end of this if he
00:11:41 does particularly well. Young people in particular bear the brunt of a lot of this because you don't
00:11:48 have a lot of power when you're sitting in the classroom and you're being told what to think
00:11:52 and you're being told all of these crazy things that we see in the news from time to time.
00:11:56 Both of you are in university, one in Ontario, one in Alberta. Let's start off with this question.
00:12:02 Is it as bad as everyone thinks? I think it's just as bad if not worse than everyone thinks.
00:12:08 You know, the thing is, in Canada, we value free speech, you know, and this is a principle that we've held for decades through, you know, the Canadian Bill of Rights from John Diefenbaker or the 1982 Charter.
00:12:20 But it seems as if campuses, it seems as if universities don't have the same respect for free speech as the everyday Canadian does.
00:12:31 Instead, they feel as if it is incumbent on them to shake the minds of young people in the way in which they see fit.
00:12:39 This is done through the classrooms, and this is done through clubs.
00:12:43 This is done through the campus programs.
00:12:46 Every single institution within the university is working against conservatives and is working to push a progressive message.
00:12:55 An example of this would be the York Federation of Students.
00:12:59 I don't want to go into too much specifics, but the gist of it is that the York Federation of Students is responsible for ratifying campus clubs.
00:13:10 and it takes about three to four weeks
00:13:13 for your normal campus club to get ratified
00:13:15 but I can tell you that the campus conservative club
00:13:19 that I'm a part of, it took about three to four months
00:13:22 for them to get ratified and that's not because
00:13:24 they were understaffed or anything like that
00:13:26 other clubs were getting ratified
00:13:29 just as
00:13:32 they were getting ratified quickly
00:13:36 but only the campus conservative club took months on months
00:13:39 on end to get ratified and that's because you know the yfs does inherently have an anti-conservative
00:13:45 bias this is not just the federation of students it is also the university administration from
00:13:50 professors teacher administrators and tas you know when you go into a tutorial or a lecture
00:13:58 it is the ta who is generally orchestrating the conversation and they have a lot of power in
00:14:06 in highlighting or suppressing certain views.
00:14:10 For example, if a leftist student wanted to talk about 0.95
00:14:14 how terrible Canada is, just a racist, vile country, 0.91
00:14:19 they'll get applauded and they'll be praised 0.98
00:14:22 and they'd be encouraged to expand on their point.
00:14:25 Whereas maybe someone like me would come from the perspective
00:14:27 that Canada is a great country that has afforded me
00:14:30 and many other people and every single Canadian
00:14:32 the opportunity to succeed.
00:14:34 And that sort of message is not really accepted.
00:14:38 It's not really tolerated.
00:14:40 There's a lot of pushback.
00:14:42 They encouraged me to sort of think about the historical injustices that has happened.
00:14:47 And while there is definitely a good reason to address historical injustices,
00:14:54 you know, they try to, it's very manipulative because they appeal to the historical injustices
00:15:03 in order to push their own agenda, their left-wing progressive agenda, instead of recognizing
00:15:09 the injustices of the past and, you know, moving forward in a positive direction, they
00:15:16 instead want to recognize the injustices of the past and linger on them and sort of, you
00:15:21 know say that the injustices of the past is reflective on the character of Canada today
00:15:29 that's just that's just one example but it just systematically the university does everything
00:15:35 they can to elevate progressive viewpoints and you know suppress conservative ones yeah I remember
00:15:42 years ago there was a bit of a contrast I was involved in in 2010 in a speaking tour to bring
00:15:47 Ann Coulter, which was at the time before the university cancel culture had gotten as bad as
00:15:51 it's gotten since then. And we had a relatively good showing in the University of Western Ontario
00:15:57 in London, which was where I went. We went to the University of Ottawa and had the angry mob
00:16:01 shut the event down. And the University of Calgary, which was the third and final stop,
00:16:06 said, hey, do you guys need a bigger room? I don't think that would have happened today.
00:16:11 But let me ask you, Liam, you're at the University of Calgary. Is your experience similar to Noah's
00:16:16 or is it a little bit better in the conservative heartland?
00:16:19 It all depends on which professor you have, I guess.
00:16:22 But one word I want to lead off on is unaccountability.
00:16:25 We have so many people in positions of power,
00:16:28 and the university turns a blind eye to them.
00:16:30 It's, you know, these professors, they're older,
00:16:33 they don't want to mark papers,
00:16:34 so they get their TAs or master's students
00:16:37 to mark their papers for them.
00:16:38 And a lot of the times, these are the progressive ilk
00:16:40 that don't want to go into the workforce
00:16:42 and like to stay in a room writing a thesis.
00:16:46 So they have a lot of control.
00:16:47 I know a friend of mine, Emil, back in Calgary, he submitted a paper, and in his review, in the comments, why he got the mark he did, the professor wrote down,
00:17:00 your conservative viewpoints are untrue, based on an opinion.
00:17:06 I myself have been marked harder because I used what I thought was a pretty good news source, the post-millennial.
00:17:12 apparently they don't view that as scholarly or an accurate news source which was news to me when
00:17:18 i received that big c minus on the page don't cite rebel or you get expelled i think you put that in
00:17:24 a paper but well is there a temptation i mean because i remember i was always a little bit of
00:17:29 i won't use the word but a disturber of fecal matter and i never minded it too much and i was
00:17:36 okay pushing back against but but is there an incentive for you to just go along with it to 0.99
00:17:41 write the paper that Canada is evil and Canadians are terrible 1.00
00:17:45 and the Canadian flag is a hate crime and the Freedom Convoy are terrorists 0.99
00:17:48 because you know it's going to give you a 95.
00:17:50 Is that a legitimate temptation that you have?
00:17:53 Of course it is.
00:17:55 Nobody wants to go into university and fail.
00:17:58 Everyone wants to go into university and have some success
00:18:02 and achieve something.
00:18:04 And the TAs who just hate conservatism, who are anti-conservative,
00:18:10 They're, you know, suppressing, you know, these views and are giving, you know, conservatives worse grades because of, you know, they're expressing their opinions.
00:18:19 You know, you go to university in order to develop your opinion, in order to, you know, become more informed and to challenge yourself.
00:18:27 And, you know, if you know that your TA is going to mark you poorly for expressing, you know, a certain kind of perspective, it really inhibits your ability to challenge yourself.
00:18:37 And, you know, it really diminishes the value of what you get from a university.
00:18:41 And also, not only that, but when you graduate from university, you sort of develop, you have already developed these habits of suppressing your views.
00:18:49 So when you leave and you enter the workforce or whatnot, you know, you're sort of used to that.
00:18:55 You're used to, you know, suppressing yourself and holding your tongue.
00:18:58 So not only does universities create leftists, but it also creates weak conservatives.
00:19:04 Unwilling Stockholm Syndrome.
00:19:06 Yeah, well, that's brilliant. And well put. Yeah, please. Because censorship is egregious. And I think everyone in this room can agree. It depends on who's at the journalist table, I guess. But censorship is egregious. But self-censorship is far more insidious. 0.68
00:19:22 because when people self-censor, you don't even have the people pushing back to give you the sense
00:19:29 that this is something that other people believe. And that's, I think, the tremendously difficult
00:19:35 part. And I'm assuming in classroom discussions, it's very similar, is that everyone's looking
00:19:39 around and there may be half a dozen more people like you that are waiting for someone else to
00:19:44 break the ice and someone else to go in and say something really controversial like Canada's a
00:19:49 nice place yeah and and you know it's not it's not everyone who's you know outgoing and expressive
00:19:54 and is you know willing to express their opinion and you know there's uh there's people who might
00:19:58 be just only be moderately conservative or not really into politics and they don't they don't
00:20:02 think it's worth it you know turning most of the classroom at plus your ta you know against you
00:20:08 just to you know say an opinion that you know nobody's gonna remember like after you leave
00:20:12 class right um and and that's what what i'm saying that it creates weak conservatives because
00:20:18 These people who feel like they have to bite their tongue, they go into their business or they work for a bank or something, and their manager tells them that they have to take a CRT training class or they have to believe X or Y or expressing certain conservative political views on your off time is unacceptable, they capitulate.
00:20:45 You know, they don't, you know, they don't do what they should do, which is, you know, racist think about it, which is quite unfortunate.
00:20:53 And I think we as conservatives have to be there for the people that, you know, are getting cancelled or having their viewpoint suppressed.
00:21:02 Because if we don't provide that support network, then you're just going to have more, you're going to just create more weak conservatives and more leftists.
00:21:10 Yeah, it's not just, you know, the suppression of ideas.
00:21:14 I'd say it's more just outright intimidation.
00:21:17 I do a lot of stuff with Students for Liberty,
00:21:20 and I hear from my colleagues down in the United States,
00:21:23 they'll just do a simple tabling.
00:21:24 They'll set up a banner, have some free books and stickers on the table,
00:21:27 and they'll want to bring people into their movement.
00:21:30 And these leftists organize, and they pound at their tables
00:21:33 and make a scene and protest them. 0.90
00:21:36 And when the campus police come around, they punish the tablers. 0.99
00:21:41 You know, the people that spent their time setting up and being there and filled out 0.99
00:21:45 all the paperwork, and they're coming and intimidating people from expressing different
00:21:50 viewpoints.
00:21:51 I did a postering campaign recently at the University of Calgary.
00:21:54 We put up a bunch of Les Marks, more Mises posters, and the next day, all throughout
00:22:00 the University of Calgary on our posters, pinned up a picture of Karl Marx with the 0.65
00:22:05 sign, Mises is unserious on it, with some commie garble underneath.
00:22:09 But I just thought it's suppression of our ideas.
00:22:11 That's like a doctoral dissertation you've just taken aim at there.
00:22:16 All right.
00:22:16 Well, let's just in 15 seconds or less here,
00:22:19 what's the best survival tip you can give other people in your age range?
00:22:23 Find some people like you.
00:22:25 If there's a campus conservative on campus, join it.
00:22:29 Try and don't suppress yourself.
00:22:34 You know, if TA is asking you something and you want to, you know, express, you know, a centre-right, you know, a viewpoint, just do it.
00:22:41 You know, maybe you'll find other people like you, and you'll actually have that support network.
00:22:46 And just to add on that, if you get the comment that your friend did, send that paper in to True North.
00:22:52 We will provide some support from outside your classroom for it.
00:22:55 But what would your survival tip be?
00:22:57 Be authentic.
00:22:59 That is the one thing.
00:23:00 You will find that more people believe and agree with you than you may think.
00:23:04 I ran every single right-wing organization at the University of Campus at one point,
00:23:09 and there are a lot of people that agree with you that just don't stick up.
00:23:12 So be authentic.
00:23:13 So I ran every single right-wing organization at my campus, too.
00:23:16 Unfortunately, it was just one.
00:23:17 So it wasn't as impressive as it was in Liam's case.
00:23:20 Well, Liam Dunn, Noah Jarvis, you're doing tremendous work.
00:23:23 Thank you so much, Ford, and thanks for coming on.
00:23:24 Thank you for having me.
00:23:25 Give him a hand, everyone.
00:23:29 I should say, by the way, I don't think I'm all that big a deal, but I've been very grateful that
00:23:37 people I've met here in Ottawa have come up and said, I listened to your show. I got a little
00:23:40 nervous, though, because I had one woman text me and said, did you know Noah Jarvis was here?
00:23:45 And I said, yeah, but come on, he's outpacing me. So Noah's going to be doing this show soon enough.
00:23:50 Let's turn our attention to some of the policy implications of this. I want to welcome to the
00:23:55 stage two people that have different perspectives on this but i think very important ones one is
00:24:00 probably one of the most prolific employment and labor lawyers in canada now katherine marshall
00:24:05 and the other is conservative member of parliament garnett jenis
00:24:08 thank you very much thank you normally i do the show in my basement so this is a real uh
00:24:23 exciting development for me, but which was flooding the other day. So this is particularly
00:24:27 good to not have like water pouring down on the show. But let's talk about the legal context here
00:24:33 because we know there are people that are in some cases probably directly targeted and other cases
00:24:38 less directly because of their political beliefs. I know in Ontario there's in labor law or in human
00:24:45 rights law there's protection for creed, but that really doesn't extend to political beliefs. So
00:24:50 do you have any protection? Well, I mean, aside from calling me, no.
00:24:58 You know, this is one of the really interesting things is that pretty much everything under the
00:25:03 sun these days is covered under human rights legislation, but not political protection. And
00:25:11 what the woke mobs have figured out, and it's pretty smart, and they do it over and over again
00:25:19 now because it's very effective is that a great way to silence someone and get them to go away
00:25:26 is by attacking their livelihood. You know, when you mess with someone's ability to put food on
00:25:32 the table, they are going to censor themselves, unless they're Jordan Peterson or Jamil Giovanni.
00:25:38 But, you know. But those ones are fewer and further between than other people. And let me
00:25:45 ask you about this, Garner, because I know you have a private member's bill that aims to
00:25:49 specifically protect political discrimination by amending the Human Rights Act, and this is where
00:25:55 you have protections for, as Catherine mentioned, everything else. I mean, it is actually a bit
00:26:00 amusing, and I'll quote Caitlyn Jenner, who said she had a harder time coming out as a Republican
00:26:03 than coming out as transgender, because right now you could identify as a woman but not as a
00:26:08 conservative if you want the protection of the Canadian Human Rights Act. So why do you think
00:26:12 that's the vehicle to address this. Yeah, and first of all, it's great to be on your show. It's
00:26:17 great to be here with all of you, and I think it's very important that as conservatives we be
00:26:21 people of hope, right? We don't buy into these kind of declinist narratives where everything's
00:26:25 getting worse, and it's just going to keep getting worse until the end of time, right?
00:26:30 No, there are reasons for us to be involved in politics and to be hopeful that we can make
00:26:34 concrete policy changes that are going to make our lives and our country better, and one of those
00:26:40 ways is to very simply support my private member's bill. It's C-257. There's a parallel
00:26:45 bill, S-257, from Senator Salma Atulajan, a conservative senator. And these bills would add
00:26:52 political views and activity as prohibited grounds of discrimination in the Canadian Human Rights
00:26:58 Act. So right now, if you're an airline employee, a bank employee, these are our workplace in the
00:27:05 federal jurisdiction, and your employer says, I don't like your religion, I don't like your
00:27:10 marital status, whatever it is, you're fired because of it, then you could take them to a
00:27:16 human rights tribunal, because we would all accept that firing someone, discriminating against
00:27:20 someone because of their ethnic identity, sexual orientation, religion, marital status, etc.,
00:27:27 there's a long list, but that's unacceptable. But if your boss says, hey, I'm going to fire you
00:27:32 because you were advocating for lower taxes
00:27:36 or a pro-life position or something,
00:27:39 I'm going to fire you because of that political view or activity,
00:27:43 then you have no recourse.
00:27:45 And the great thing is we have this existing framework
00:27:48 designed to protect people from discrimination.
00:27:50 It just doesn't include political views.
00:27:52 So it's a very, I think, simple, reasonable fix.
00:27:55 There are certain parameters around human rights legislation.
00:27:59 It's legitimately balanced against other things,
00:28:01 and we can talk about some of those limitations and exceptions,
00:28:05 but it essentially fits this protection against political discrimination
00:28:08 within the wider jurisprudence that exists.
00:28:11 And I will say it's not so radical.
00:28:14 This protection doesn't currently exist at the federal level.
00:28:17 It doesn't exist in a number of the larger provinces,
00:28:20 such as Ontario or Alberta,
00:28:21 but actually a majority of Canadian provinces
00:28:23 have some kind of protection against political discrimination
00:28:26 in their human rights statute,
00:28:30 so not at the federal level,
00:28:31 not in a couple of our larger provinces, but in a majority of provinces, it's already protected.
00:28:35 Now, I should just say on a housekeeping note, the Canadian Human Rights Act governs federal government and federally regulated sectors.
00:28:42 So radio is one.
00:28:44 So let me ask you, Catherine, in the case of Jamil Javani, if the law that Garnet wants to see law were there on the books,
00:28:52 do you think that would change the Jamil case going up against a big media telecom company?
00:28:57 Yeah, so, you know, firstly, you know, what Jamil's doing is something that most people would never do.
00:29:04 Like, the idea of taking on, like, a massive corporation when you've been mistreated is something that most people, that makes them want to hide in a hole.
00:29:13 So it takes a lot of bravery to do that.
00:29:16 I, you know, I see a lot of mistreatment.
00:29:20 I see a lot of political discrimination.
00:29:22 People come to me all the time.
00:29:24 But most people who are willing to go forward, like I would say 1% of the people who I see.
00:29:29 It would make a difference.
00:29:30 You know, Bell is a federally, they're part of a federally regulated industry.
00:29:37 You know, why is there not a legislative protection for people who work there to be protected from political discrimination?
00:29:47 And hopefully this case will change that.
00:29:50 I mean, we're hoping to set a precedent.
00:29:52 and um you know something that's really disturbing uh that i see happen is people will get terminated
00:29:59 or they'll get hauled into hr meetings about maybe something they they posted on social media or
00:30:05 comment they made at the water cooler or you know hate comes out from you know a privacy breach that
00:30:11 they donated to a certain cause and they get disciplined or they get fired and that is a
00:30:17 traumatic experience to begin with but then the idea of like having to then launch a lawsuit and
00:30:23 fight your employer and have them call you a racist or call you a bad person or call you
00:30:29 a misogynist or whatever other horrible label they're going to give you and then be publicly
00:30:34 shamed but just most people don't go down that path and that's why we're not seeing enough change
00:30:41 in the system these companies are getting away with it the mobs are learning it's a very effective
00:30:46 tactic. And then they've learned that because they get the success from doing it, they do it
00:30:52 more and more. So I'm fighting it. I hope other lawyers will join me. And it's great to have
00:30:59 clients who are willing to go out there and kick some butt as well. If I can just quickly add to 0.73
00:31:05 that point, because I think that's really critical, that what motivates me in this is there are the
00:31:09 high-profile cases that folks will be aware of, the Jordan Petersons, Jamil Giovannis. These are
00:31:13 people who are already involved in public speaking, have a public profile, and have a
00:31:22 sense of how to fight and how to challenge these things. What I'm most concerned about,
00:31:27 what motivates me, are the everyday normal people who didn't sign up for politics or
00:31:34 controversy, who just want to be able to live their lives, do their jobs, and provide for
00:31:38 their family, people that we've never heard of, but who hold common sense opinions. Maybe who don't
00:31:44 hold common sense opinions, by the way, because protecting people against political discrimination
00:31:47 applies to everybody, and it should, right? But if somebody is simply expressing their points of
00:31:55 view in social media posts, around the water cooler, it's all of those cases we don't hear
00:32:01 about of people that are intimidated into silence, who don't have recourse, that if a bill like mine
00:32:06 passes, they'll have some tools available to them.
00:32:09 And using the Human Rights Act, it's often a much more accessible remedy.
00:32:12 There are some cases, crown corporations, federal government, where someone could litigate
00:32:17 under the charter, but that would be likely much more complicated and expensive, and they
00:32:21 have an easier remedy available to them if we use the remedies that exist in the Human
00:32:26 Rights Act.
00:32:26 But let me challenge the premise that human rights law is the vehicle for this, because
00:32:31 we were talking earlier in the show about the institutional challenges, and human rights
00:32:35 tribunals have not been kind to conservatives in the past, I'd say. I mean, it was the Canadian
00:32:40 Human Rights Tribunal that was going after conservative bloggers when Section 13 was there.
00:32:44 It was the Alberta Human Rights Tribunal that was going after Ezra Levant for publishing the
00:32:49 Danish Mohammed cartoon. So if you put political discrimination in, does that not actually expand
00:32:56 the power of these organizations that could be weaponized against conservative business owners,
00:33:00 say. Do you know what it does? Adding it to human rights legislation is at least a
00:33:08 significant message that this is wrong. And employers do pay attention to that.
00:33:17 I think that having it codified, at least it's going to have, you know, that baseline, okay,
00:33:23 this is wrong, you can't do this. And if you do it, if you breach this right, people are going
00:33:28 have some legal remedies but I hear all your concerns about the human rights tribunal systems
00:33:33 as someone who litigates a lot of them I've got my own frustrations but I wanted to touch on
00:33:39 something that you brought up earlier we were talking about you know high profile people
00:33:46 getting targeted of course the Jordan Peterson case is another example of something that I find
00:33:52 very disturbing which is these groups of people are using professional regulators and the complaint
00:33:59 systems to launch these bad faith complaints against people they want to silence and um i've
00:34:05 had a lot of conversations with like doctors and lawyers and people who'll come up you know quietly
00:34:10 to me and they'll say catherine i i deleted my twitter account um you know i i'm not writing
00:34:15 anymore i'm so terrified that if i say something that someone doesn't like i'm gonna get a complaint
00:34:22 i'll lose my license i'll be suspended and then i'll have no ability to put food on my table
00:34:26 and i that really that's very disturbing people people who have interesting things to say who are
00:34:33 who should be thought leaders in their professions are removing themselves from the arena and it's
00:34:40 becoming this thing where it's like okay are the are the only people who are going to share their
00:34:44 views are people who have nothing to lose um or maybe in their basements unemployed that's not a
00:34:51 good thing for society or democracy. No, and let me get your take on that. And I'm also curious
00:34:57 about the concerns with the tribunal system as well. Yeah, yeah. To your question about the
00:35:01 appropriateness of the vehicle, I mean, I think there's a level of pragmatism that we have to have
00:35:06 about the kinds of structures and institutions that exist. But I think it's also important to
00:35:11 say that this shifts the balance of the calculations that those bodies are going to make.
00:35:16 So now if you have a complaint made against somebody on the basis of discrimination on one category, they can also talk about political discrimination.
00:35:28 And that doesn't mean that one would necessarily trump the other, but it means that freedom of speech in the expression of a political point of view becomes explicitly part of the calculation that these bodies have to take into consideration.
00:35:45 And finally, look, I'll say it's true of everything we do, right?
00:35:50 Personnel is policy.
00:35:52 These tribunals are only as good as the appointments of the people that are on them.
00:35:57 That's inevitable.
00:35:58 And that's maybe another conversation, which is, you know, how do we ensure that people
00:36:03 who are going to apply certain principles in a way that is reasonable are given the
00:36:09 power to apply those principles?
00:36:12 But I don't think we should give up on our ability to appoint strong, reasonable people
00:36:16 to these kinds of bodies.
00:36:17 The question is just, is the framework that they're being given reasonable and balanced?
00:36:23 I think it's just common sense that if we are going to have these bodies that are adjudicating
00:36:30 complaints about religious discrimination and other forms of discrimination, then why
00:36:34 not include political discrimination as part of the calculation?
00:36:38 For all you people that want to run for office, everyone wants to be finance minister, apply
00:36:42 to be one of these people on the tribunals, because oftentimes when conservative governments
00:36:48 come in office, they have however many thousands of roles to fill, and there aren't that many
00:36:53 thousands of conservatives that want to sit on some government tribunal. So you end up even with
00:36:57 Stephen Harper in power, but all of these woke liberals on the Canadian Human Rights Commission.
00:37:02 So that's a place to get involved as well. Let me turn back to you on this, Catherine,
00:37:07 because one of the big challenges is that you may have a case where you've got some, you know,
00:37:12 really woke lefty employer that is discriminating against an employee. But one of the things with
00:37:17 cancel culture that happens is you get people that very viciously target an individual and
00:37:23 they want to destroy their life. And they look up their LinkedIn and say, oh, this person is a,
00:37:27 you know, a junior sales secretary and, you know, the department of whatever. And they go after a
00:37:33 company that may actually have no interest in getting into politics, but the company goes
00:37:37 into crisis mode and they capitulate and we've seen this happen time and time again so i do think
00:37:43 that putting it on the radar to say to companies this is not consequence free and you may capitulate
00:37:49 to get the twitter mob on side but you're going to have another fight if you do yeah that's a
00:37:55 really good point and i i often advise my employer clients and my corporate clients that like look
00:38:01 if you don't have the back of your people the people that you chose to hire that you put into
00:38:06 the roles that might have, you know, they might have great performance, but yeah, maybe they 0.96
00:38:10 did an off-color tweet or they did something stupid on social media or whatever, then you're 0.97
00:38:16 signaling to the world that you don't have a backbone and they can come after any of your 0.99
00:38:21 people. And it sets a terrible precedent. And I mean, obviously it exposes the company to a
00:38:27 wrongful dismissal suit, but more to the point, like what kind of a message are you sending your
00:38:31 own employees when you're not going to have their back because a few you know um you know
00:38:36 wokesters kind of you know dox your your employee and i think part of the problem is a lot of
00:38:42 companies they panic you know the idea of like trending and you know they they freak out they
00:38:48 don't know how to deal with this the first thing they do is the worst idea which is just fire the
00:38:53 person and they're trying to manage their own crisis and of course anyone in crisis management
00:38:58 can tell you, like, don't manage your own crisis. It's a really bad idea. But they've got to have
00:39:03 more backbone. And, you know, I'm seeing a lot of this type of political discrimination and
00:39:11 mistreatment happen in corporate environments that are not traditionally, like, woke. Like,
00:39:17 it's sort of everywhere. It's really any company where you have, you know, people who are just very
00:39:24 cautious they're very risk adverse and like they're firing people for saying or doing something
00:39:30 that has nothing to do with their service or their product and i think um it's something that
00:39:36 employers really have to take more of a responsibility and because this is not going to
00:39:40 change unless companies also change their policies yeah i remember back in i think it was well actually
00:39:46 i know for a fact it was 2018 there was this uh pipeline demonstration that was taking place and
00:39:52 someone went to Domino's and picked up some pizzas and brought them there.
00:39:56 And then it ended up becoming this controversy where Domino's was forced to comment for the
00:40:02 crime of selling pizza to someone.
00:40:04 And I wrote a column at the time about it, combating against sort of corporations that
00:40:08 were wading into politics.
00:40:10 And then I got fired three days later, but it was unrelated.
00:40:13 That was one of the other big radio companies.
00:40:15 But there is this...
00:40:16 You should have called me.
00:40:17 I should have, yeah.
00:40:18 Is this sort of the domino effect we're seeing?
00:40:20 Yeah.
00:40:20 Oh, that's good.
00:40:22 That's good, because that means I didn't make the worst joke of the show.
00:40:25 So thank you for that, Garnet.
00:40:26 But I won't discriminate against you for your humor or lack thereof.
00:40:31 I don't know.
00:40:31 No.
00:40:32 We're not proposing to add that.
00:40:33 You can still fire someone for telling bad jokes.
00:40:36 So let's be a bit more forward-looking here,
00:40:38 because I think that obviously legal mechanisms are very important,
00:40:42 but I think you were touching on this as well, Catherine,
00:40:44 that culture needs to change as well.
00:40:46 And the one thing I've often said about cancel culture in general,
00:40:49 not in a business context, is that people who resist what's happening need to speak up and
00:40:55 defend the victims because the mob is very, very loud. The mob is very loud. And when someone is
00:41:03 being targeted, as someone who's been through the cancel culture mill, the thing that you get a lot
00:41:08 of are people that say, I'm with you, but shh, don't tell anyone. And we need people that are
00:41:12 going to stand up. And I'd say for companies as well, they need to know that there are people
00:41:17 that are going to back them for doing the right thing as well. That's a really good point. I've
00:41:22 acted for a lot of clients who've been cancelled, and it is a horrifying experience. And you do feel
00:41:30 like you want to die. I have clients who've felt suicidal. I mean, there's really not that shame
00:41:35 of being cancelled and told that you're not worthy of being in society anymore. It's one of the most
00:41:43 terrible human emotions. And I get so upset when I see people being cancelled or targeted. And I
00:41:50 totally agree with you, Andrew. Like, we have to stand up. If we see it, as conservatives especially,
00:41:56 we have to go out there and defend that person and support that person. And that means the world
00:42:02 to that individual. But it's also a way of fighting back against that cancel culture and showing the
00:42:09 mob that there's going to be people who will who will defend that person and that person is not
00:42:15 alone um and i think that's so critically important um so yeah i mean i i mean ironically
00:42:22 um one of my other cases and this is also in the media is um i'm acting for a former chair of the
00:42:29 alberta human rights commission who was canceled i mean ironically like he you know so yeah i mean
00:42:35 going back to the earlier point, it would definitely make a difference, at least in our laws in this
00:42:41 country. I would, by the way, love for you to take the Human Rights Commission to the Human Rights
00:42:44 Commission. I've been waiting for that for years. Stay tuned. Yeah. I mean, on the culture, the
00:42:51 question I would ask people is, look, why do you want to personally punish someone for sincerely
00:42:59 holding a different point of view than you do? I just have a hard time understanding this mentality,
00:43:04 If I meet somebody who is a socialist or whatever, I'm going to disagree with them.
00:43:10 I'm going to maybe, if time allows, talk to them about why I disagree with them.
00:43:13 Hide your wallet.
00:43:14 But the idea that I would wish them harm, that I would want them to lose their job, not be able to provide for their family, is just absurd and so foreign to me.
00:43:26 I don't think conservative employers should be able to discriminate against their left-wing workers either.
00:43:31 I think it goes both ways.
00:43:32 I just don't think that's happening.
00:43:33 I think generally it's the other way around.
00:43:36 But I can't fathom this mentality of wishing someone ill for having sincerely considered a political issue and come to a different conclusion than me.
00:43:44 And I think we just have to ask people, aside from the merits of this person's point of view,
00:43:48 why can't you have a conversation with them about the particulars of the issue rather than condemning them morally and trying to harm them because of the political conclusions they've come to?
00:43:59 But this is what sets the right apart from the left, and why in this day and age, despite how the liberals have been in the past, the right is the only vehicle for championing free speech.
00:44:10 And it's funny, because if you were to put all of the victims of cancel culture in a conference room, I think, actually, maybe we did, I don't know.
00:44:17 But in general, if you were to put them in a conference room, you're going to find people that are on the left there.
00:44:21 There's a professor from Alberta named Frances Widdowson, who is a literal Marxist, but she has a lot more conservative friends than liberal friends because they support free speech.
00:44:29 and they support her position on speaking out on indigenous issues the way she does.
00:44:35 My colleague at True North, Lindsay Shepard, was never a conservative,
00:44:38 but she's found a home among conservative people
00:44:42 because they're the ones that were kind of like Garnet was saying,
00:44:45 come as you are, we don't care, just have your position here.
00:44:48 And it is cyclical, and I think that would be the one bit of advice I'd give to people on the left,
00:44:52 is you may think you're immune from this, but you're not.
00:44:55 And one of the more amusing examples, there was this guy who a few years ago
00:44:59 had gotten some little viral moment with Bush, the beer company, and some reporter from the
00:45:06 Des Moines Register found some tweet of his from, I don't know, like 1873 that was mildly off-color
00:45:13 when he was a teenager and then canceled him, and then someone dug into the reporter and found a
00:45:17 tweet of his that was off-color and then canceled the reporter, and it's like, who wins at the end
00:45:22 of this? So it is like a race to the bottom. Yeah, I mean, I've been listening to a lot of
00:45:27 Renee Brown recently, so I apologize in advance, but something that she says that I love is that
00:45:33 if you live in the arena, you're going to get burned. You know, you are going to fall on your
00:45:38 face. And if you take risks with your life and you actually go out and do something and say
00:45:42 something and hold opinions, yeah, you're going to have people who criticize you. And I think
00:45:47 this sort of scary notion that's emerged with cancel culture of, okay, I'm just going to be
00:45:52 super safe. I'm not going to ever say anything. I'm never going to hold any opinion. And I'm just
00:45:57 gonna hope that i just make it through life that's that sucks yeah that's like that's boring that's
00:46:04 terrible we don't want that yeah it was like the old joke was what's a liberal's favorite wine 0.71
00:46:09 you can't say that uh and i think that there is something to that it's like i don't want to live
00:46:13 the life that you know has to be so scripted and choreographed like that so we're we're winding
00:46:19 down our time here but let me just end with the same question to you both and we'll start with
00:46:23 you, Garnett. Are you an optimist or a pessimist on this? Well, I'm fundamentally optimistic about
00:46:29 what we can do specifically through legislation, again, through my private member's bill, C257.
00:46:36 I mean, I've been told you need to repeat, repeat, repeat these things. C257 could use all of your
00:46:43 support. If it passes, then we will have legislation at the federal level in federal
00:46:48 jurisdiction that will provide recourse to people who face political discrimination. And I think
00:46:53 we have some provincial elected officials in the room and others that are involved in that level,
00:46:58 so seeing these kind of parallel legislation at the provincial level as well. I think we do need
00:47:02 broader cultural change, and that's going to take time, just kind of pushing our friends and
00:47:07 neighbors saying, hey, let's have respectful disagreements but not try to punish each other
00:47:11 for being wrong, but I think we can legitimately use the tools that already exist for human rights
00:47:16 protections, and I don't think it's that likely that this legislation will make it all the way
00:47:23 through the process in this parliament, given the timelines and so forth. But it has the strong
00:47:29 support of our caucus, and I'm hopeful that we'll be able to see bills stopping political
00:47:33 discrimination be implemented and become law, if not in this parliament, then under Prime Minister
00:47:38 Polliver. Optimist or pessimist? I'm definitely optimistic, especially because of the work that
00:47:45 Garnett's doing, and when I've got clients like Jamil Giovanni and people who are willing to go
00:47:49 there and be the pointy end of the spear and and fight the system i think that there is a cultural
00:47:55 change that's happening we just need more people to you know speak up and stand up and not be
00:48:00 afraid to to beat down the system and challenge the system and look i've got a lot of frustrations
00:48:06 with the system as someone who litigates i mean there's a lot about the court system
00:48:10 the human rights system that i don't like and i have issues with um but it's the only system
00:48:15 that we have and i always say to my clients we just you know these are the cards we've got and
00:48:18 and we got to play them and there's lots of creative things that we can do to get people
00:48:22 thinking outside of the box but the biggest thing I think we can all do in this room and it's
00:48:26 something that I personally really um tried to do um and it does put me in the line of fire
00:48:31 sometimes and I've also gotten like crazy weird complaints like from crazy people as well which
00:48:37 is you know if I see someone getting cancelled or doxxed or abused on social media because they
00:48:44 did something or they tweeted something or they donated somewhere i'll go out there like and
00:48:49 publicly stand up for them and i don't really care if someone comes at me and calls me terrible names
00:48:54 because i know what it does to those people and i the idea that someone's going to feel so
00:49:00 emotionally like ruined because of this makes me really upset so you know we've got to do that and
00:49:05 it takes some courage but it's something that conservatives i think are really good at i don't
00:49:10 stand up for them because it usually makes their problems worse when i'm in their corner so it's
00:49:14 like, see, look, they're like Andrew Lawton. But in any case, I've always said, especially in the
00:49:19 last year, I think the most terrifying thing you could ever see in a courtroom is Kathleen Marshall
00:49:22 on the other side of it. You've been doing amazing work, and I thank you for that and for being here
00:49:27 today. And Garnet Janis, Conservative MP, thank you as well, sir. That does it for us. We are going
00:49:34 to wrap things up here. There's going to be, for those of you in the room with us now, there's going
00:49:38 to be a brief break, and then Conservative leader Pierre Polyev will be joining us next. But for
00:49:43 this episode of the Andrew Lawton Show. We're signing off. Thank you. God bless and good day
00:49:47 to you all. Thanks for listening to the Andrew Lawton Show. Support the program by donating
00:49:53 to True North at www.tnc.news.