Juno News - March 05, 2024


Conservative byelection win is bad news for Justin Trudeau

Topics
Mentioned
Trudeau's "online harms" bill is an all-out assault on free speech The Canadian Armed Forces is facing a CRISIS | Ret. Lt.-Gen. Michel Maisonneuve

Episode Stats


Length

42 minutes

Words per minute

163.47

Word count

6,948

Sentence count

329

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

5

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of The Andrew Lawton Show, host Andrew Lawton talks about a by-election in his home riding of Durham, Ontario, and why he thinks it's a good idea to have a black man in office.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:19 north hello and welcome to you all canada's most irreverent talk show here the andrew lawton show
00:01:30 on true north i i don't feel sick but the second i started speaking right there i felt like my
00:01:38 throat is not functioning the way it is supposed to be so i don't know i was on a cruise last week
00:01:42 the idea that i got something on that cruise is i'd say about 117 so i could be sick and i hopefully
00:01:51 will be able to get through the show i mean i'm trying to wonder why i didn't realize before uh
00:01:56 one o'clock eastern time that i was sick and then i realized i have like gone the whole day without
00:02:00 really speaking i think my because my wife uh left she didn't leave that sounded dramatic
00:02:04 she she left our abode and i maybe had like you know five words with her then and i hadn't spoken
00:02:11 until now so now I realize I might not actually have much of a voice but we'll do what we can
00:02:15 great to have you tuned in we'll try to ratchet up the irreverence to make up for the volume but
00:02:21 all that aside it is good to talk to you thanks so much I announced yesterday on the show
00:02:25 the forthcoming book that I have penned I've penned it already that part's not forthcoming
00:02:31 but the publication is forthcoming it's called Pierre Polyev a political life the first I've
00:02:37 learned biography of the Conservative Party of Canada leader. It's a fair and journalistic
00:02:43 portrayal, not a piece of political propaganda, although I suspect that there's a bit of a
00:02:48 Rorschach inkblot effect on stuff like this, where many people will take out of it whatever
00:02:53 they went into it with. But thank you all of you who have sent along your kind words on that,
00:02:59 people who have said they've pre-ordered it. I hope you enjoy it, and I hope we'll be able
00:03:03 to get those shipped out to you as soon as it's released in May. The reason I lead off with that
00:03:09 shameless bit of self-promotion is because we had an election yesterday. Did you know that? It was
00:03:13 election day. Not the big grand general election, but there was a by-election in Durham. Now,
00:03:20 by-election does not mean it swings both ways. By-election means it is taking place in between
00:03:25 the regular election periods. And not that there's anything wrong with that, as Seinfeld would say,
00:03:32 But it was a bit interesting.
00:03:33 You had Jamil Javani, who's been on this show a number of times.
00:03:36 He was a very capable radio broadcaster with Bell, News Talk 1010 in Toronto,
00:03:42 before he was summarily fired for not being the token black guy, basically.
00:03:48 That was what he said when he sued Bell,
00:03:49 that they expected him to say all these things as their diversity hire
00:03:54 that he didn't want to say because he's an independent-minded guy.
00:03:57 So he sued Bell, and I believe that is still working its way through the process.
00:04:02 Then he went on to be the president of the Canada Strong and Free Network.
00:04:06 He was not there for too, too long before he ultimately jumped into politics, replacing
00:04:11 now we know Aaron O'Toole, the former leader of the Conservative Party of Canada, who had
00:04:16 been the member of parliament in Durham for a couple of, well, he wanted it a by-election
00:04:20 too, and now he will be replaced by Jameel Javani.
00:04:24 Now, let me first and foremost say, yes, Durham is a, well, yes, it's a greater Toronto area riding.
00:04:32 It's a riding that is in the GTA largely.
00:04:36 It encompasses Oshawa, Clarington, Cordes, all these communities.
00:04:40 Yes, it's in the GTA, but it's not Toronto.
00:04:44 Like no one in Durham would say that they identify as a Torontonian.
00:04:47 In fact, they would probably shoot you because Durham residents own firearms, which is wonderful.
00:04:52 One of the things I love about them.
00:04:53 They would not identify as Toronto. So when you say that it's a GTA seat, you have to put a big,
00:05:01 big asterisk beside that. Take it with a big giant grain of salt. It is a conservative riding. The
00:05:08 riding used to be called Clarington Scugog Uxbridge, I learned this morning. So it is a conservative
00:05:15 stronghold through and through. So I'm not going to do this grand thing where I say, oh, wow,
00:05:19 the Conservatives won the election. I mean, they've won at every election for the last 20
00:05:24 years, but it sends a message to Trudeau. That part was expected. We knew the Liberals were
00:05:29 going to win. But the margin of victory does send a message to Justin Trudeau. And I don't want to
00:05:36 bombard you with numbers, but I am going to give you some numbers here because this was the riding.
00:05:41 The Conservatives have had it since 2004 when Bev Oda won it. She won it again 2006, 2008,
00:05:47 2011, Aaron O'Toole won it in a by-election in 2012, 2015, 2019. So it has been a conservative
00:05:54 stronghold going right back to when the Kretzian-Martin dynasty ended in 2004. Now, when you look at
00:06:02 the numbers though, Jamil Javani won with a larger margin of victory than any conservative had in
00:06:10 those elections. Then Bev, $16 orange juice Oda, and then Aaron, too bland to come up with a
00:06:17 nickname O'Toole, and Jameel Javani. So he won with 57.44% of the vote. That is a pretty
00:06:26 significant margin in an Ontario riding, 57.44%. Aaron O'Toole, he had 46% when he won it in 2021.
00:06:35 That was when he was the leader of the Conservatives. In 2019, he had 42% of the vote.
00:06:41 Aaron O'Toole in his by-election, 45% of the vote.
00:06:45 Bev Oda, she was the last one who did particularly well there. 0.76
00:06:49 She, or sorry, no, when Aaron O'Toole first won in the by-election, he got 50% of the vote.
00:06:54 Bev Oda, she had gotten 54.55%. 0.76
00:06:59 So certainly getting up there into the Giovanni territory, but not really that close.
00:07:04 54% in 2008 47% in 2006 and 40% in 2004 so all of those numbers say that Jamil Javani did very
00:07:16 very well and the big thing though is not just his margin of victory but it's where that came from
00:07:23 so he got 57% the liberals got 22% what did the liberals get last time 29.9% the NDP got 10%
00:07:33 What did they get last time? 17.5%. The PPC, Patricia Conlon, she got 4.43%. What did the
00:07:41 PPC get last time? 5.5%. So every single party went down except for the conservatives.
00:07:52 The conservatives, that means, were drawing support from everywhere else imaginable. They
00:07:58 were drawing support. Now, one caveat you have to put in with by-elections is that they have
00:08:04 notoriously low voter turnout. This by-election was no exception. So you have to, I mean, you
00:08:09 don't want the percentages to be deceptive there because, you know, yes, Jamil Javani won 57 point
00:08:14 some odd percent, but turnout was a lot lower. He had 32,000 votes cast and that was 27% turnout,
00:08:25 whereas in 2021 turnout was 61 percent. In 2019 turnout was 68 percent. So by election turnout
00:08:34 is a lot lower but at the same time elections are won by those who show up. So at the end of the day
00:08:39 it still means that the conservatives were getting their voters out to the polls. They were getting
00:08:43 their voters to the ballot box and they were getting ballots that were drawing support from
00:08:48 the liberals. So even though there is low turnout which a lot of the true anons, the shamrock brigade 0.83
00:08:54 on Twitter that are just completely loyal to Justin Trudeau until the end of time, until
00:08:59 their dying breath, they're all saying, oh, well, you know, low turnout, it's not really,
00:09:03 they're trying to say a win is not really a win.
00:09:06 But what they're missing in all of that is that if Liberal voters don't want to go to
00:09:10 the polls, that is not at all a line of support for Justin Trudeau.
00:09:16 If the only candidate that can get people motivated to vote for them is the Conservative,
00:09:21 that's something that the Liberals need to be worried about.
00:09:24 So where is the NDP? Where are the Liberals? Where are the Greens? Where are the People's Party of Canada voters? Maxime Bernier practically moved to Durham. He practically moved to the riding. He was there more times than anyone could count. They had a candidate who I've spoken to before. I've met her. She's a very nice woman, Patricia Conlon, a very, very passionate woman. She was a second time candidate.
00:09:48 So she had profile in that riding from having run in 2021, and Patricia Conlon was not even
00:09:54 able to match the percentage that she and the PPC got in 2021 when they ran in the by-election.
00:10:02 So all of this means that right now the Liberals should be very nervous, not because they lost
00:10:07 a seat that they were never going to win in the first place, but because none of their
00:10:11 voters care.
00:10:12 None of their past voters care to show up and vote Liberal right now, which is going
00:10:17 to spell disaster in 2025 now there as it happened was a poll that came out from nanos that i wanted
00:10:24 to share with you now obviously i don't do polling coverage on this show i was like getting the i was
00:10:30 getting the the baton there uh sean was about to kick me off the show he just put up the closing
00:10:34 graphic no no we're gonna do the poll so i don't normally do polling and horse race stuff but
00:10:39 every now and then one is pretty illuminating so we can put it up now and hopefully not the
00:10:43 closing graphics. There we go. So this was from March 1st, sample size of 1,000, phone poll,
00:10:49 margin of error, plus or minus 3.1%. Conservatives at 43%. That is super majority territory.
00:10:58 That's a nine point gain over what they had in the last election, the federal election.
00:11:03 23% for the Liberals, that's a drop of 10%. NDP is almost surpassing the Liberals. So the NDP
00:11:11 right now is at 21%. If you take that margin of error into account, the NDP could be over
00:11:17 the Liberals. They could be at 24 and the Liberals could actually be at 20 conceivably.
00:11:22 And the Bloc Québécois, not that they're all that relevant, they're at 6%. The Greens at 4%.
00:11:27 Now, this one I find really interesting. The PPC at 1% in this poll. Now, I suspect that is a
00:11:35 statistical outlier. I suspect the PPC probably is actually hovering at around four or five percent.
00:11:41 This is, again, one of the dangers of statistics. So within the margin of error, the PPC could be
00:11:47 at four percent still. But nevertheless, it looks bad for them on that. But 43 percent for the
00:11:53 conservatives, even with the margin of error taken into account, that could be 40 percent.
00:11:57 We are not just majority territory. We are super majority territory. Like we're talking
00:12:02 Brian Mulroney numbers, John Diefenbaker numbers. And this is why all of the Liberals' attacks on
00:12:09 Pierre Polyev are simply not landing. Now, Justin Trudeau did the gracious thing. He
00:12:15 congratulated Jamil Giovanni on his by-election win. You can see this tweet that Trudeau put out
00:12:21 yesterday. Congratulations, Jamil Giovanni, on winning yesterday's by-election. Let's work
00:12:27 together. Oh, this was this morning. Oh no, sorry. Yeah. Thank you, Sean. This was at 1159 AM.
00:12:33 He was in denial last night, so he didn't do the congratulation until today. Let's work together
00:12:39 on issues that matter. Thank you to everyone who ran, including our own Robert Rock, who was the
00:12:44 liberal. He tried to be the conservative candidate, lost the conservative nomination, then ran for the
00:12:48 liberals. And then it goes on from there. And let me then talk, let's throw up Jamil's tweet because
00:12:55 Jamil was a bit spicier and sassier on Twitter with Justin Trudeau. He said, he posted last
00:13:01 night, Durham sent you a message today. Did you receive it? Best, Jamil Javani. I am not entirely
00:13:09 convinced that Justin Trudeau did receive the message, but nevertheless, Jamil Javani took his
00:13:14 win as being a sign. And we've asked him, by the way, to come on the show. He wasn't available
00:13:19 today. We're hoping to get him tomorrow or Thursday. So if you know Jamil and want to give
00:13:23 him a nudge to get him to come on, please do. But he said that his win was a rebuke of the
00:13:28 liberal elites. Now, that may sound like some low-hanging fruit. Who is he talking about? Well,
00:13:34 it's a broader category than you might think. Talk about what's happening in the country right now.
00:13:41 I do think it is the liberal elites betraying the working people of this country, betraying the
00:13:47 middle class, betraying the working class. And when I say liberal elites, I am talking 1.00
00:13:53 about Justin Trudeau and the Liberal Party, but not just them. I'm also talking about
00:13:57 the liberal elites who run big banks and big telecommunications companies, driving up the
00:14:02 cost of everything. I am also talking about the liberal elites who run the Ontario Ministry
00:14:08 of Education in this province. I'm also talking about the liberal elites who are activists
00:14:13 and academics, and trying to consistently undermine law enforcement and public safety,
00:14:19 leaving the most vulnerable Canadians with fewer protections from our justice system.
00:14:30 When you want to spot them, it's pretty easy, and it's bigger than partisan politics.
00:14:36 They're the people pushing DEI and ESG initiatives while hiking up the cost of living for hard-working people.
00:14:43 They are the people who virtue signal and engage in performance theater while your life gets harder.
00:14:50 And they are the people who serve the interests of a privileged few
00:14:54 and make you feel like a bad person for expecting our country to work for you.
00:15:00 And they are wrong.
00:15:02 The liberal elites in this country are wrong.
00:15:04 Absolutely.
00:15:04 you you are not a bad person for believing that Canada should work for those who do the work
00:15:15 that was the MP elect for Durham Jamil Javani taking aim at liberal elites but what I found
00:15:24 so interesting there was he referred to the liberal elites who run the Ontario Ministry
00:15:30 of education. Now, I don't think he's just talking about bureaucrats. I think he's talking about
00:15:37 Stephen Lecce, the Ontario education minister, nominally a progressive conservative. He's
00:15:42 previously called him incompetent because Jamil used to actually have a position with the Ontario
00:15:47 government. He was a, I forget the name of it. It was like a community opportunities advocate or
00:15:52 something. And then he ended up having to, well, not having to, he ended up choosing to resign
00:15:58 from that position when he just said, listen, I can't get on board with this government's
00:16:04 incompetent handling of the COVID file. So very principled guy in that sense. He was principled
00:16:09 when he took aim at Bell Media, when again, it's very subtle, but when he talks about the big
00:16:13 telecommunications platforms, I'm pretty sure that's where he is directing his ire. And I just
00:16:20 have to say something. I know that not everyone who listens to this show is, well, certainly not
00:16:24 everyone's conservative. And I welcome all of you. Not everyone is partisan conservative with a
00:16:29 capital C. And I am, to be fair, I'm sympathetic to a lot of what Pierre Polyev is talking about.
00:16:36 And I know that people accused me of being some, you know, partisan sellout shill or whatever,
00:16:40 to which I say, I have not yet received the checks that everyone on Twitter thinks I'm
00:16:44 collecting. So maybe we'll talk, well, I mean, I do have checks over here on my desk, but they're
00:16:48 it's like a $3 book royalty check. So it's not a conservative party of Canada check.
00:16:52 But the one thing I'll point out about this is that Pierre Polyev has done something which his predecessors have not done, which has surrounded himself with people who are so-called controversial candidates.
00:17:06 You look at people like Aaron Gunn, a YouTuber and filmmaker, has talked about very hot-button issues.
00:17:12 Jamil Javani, a broadcaster.
00:17:14 Dr. Matt Strauss, the anti-lockdown doctor in Kitchener.
00:17:18 Roman Babber, the anti-lockdown advocate who was kicked out of the Ontario PC Caucus for this.
00:17:24 Sean points out they're all the Andrew Lawton Show regulars.
00:17:26 Yeah, anytime you let an Andrew Lawton Show guest appear on your slate as a candidate, you're throwing caution to the wind.
00:17:33 Sabrina Maddow, she's been on the show as well.
00:17:35 she's vying to be a conservative candidate. So this is actually quite relevant. This is quite
00:17:41 relevant because it means that Pierre Polyev is unafraid to be around people who have done and
00:17:47 said things that the media are going to pounce for. And that in and of itself suggests there's
00:17:53 going to be a different type of campaign in 2025. Now, Jamil Javani, he's got a bit of a runway
00:17:58 ahead of him. Now, I realized when I just mentioned that like all of my guests end up running as
00:18:03 conservative candidates that's like an awfully big uh an awfully big setup to my next guest
00:18:07 franco terrazzano who is the federal director for the canadian taxpayers federation franco
00:18:12 any announcements from you today uh absolutely not other than the fact that canadians are furious
00:18:19 with the government raising carbon taxes that's the only announcement today andrew well and that's
00:18:24 a big one and i will say uh pierre pauliev yesterday in his endorsement of jamil and his
00:18:30 congratulations today said, I think it was the first thing he mentioned that Jamil is going to
00:18:34 help him ax the tax. So you don't want to extrapolate too much from by-elections, but when
00:18:40 you look at how much the Liberals have been doubling down and tripling down on the carbon
00:18:43 tax and you look at where they are in their polls, it's clear that Canadians are not happy with this.
00:18:49 Yeah, Canadians are sick and tired of the federal government in Ottawa making our lives more
00:18:54 expensive. And that's exactly what the carbon tax does. Not only does it make our lives more
00:18:59 expensive, it makes the necessities of life more expensive. It makes it more expensive for you to
00:19:04 fuel up your car, to get to work, to go to see the in-laws. It makes it more expensive for you to
00:19:09 heat your home during the cold winter months. And it makes it more expensive for you to put food
00:19:13 on your family's table because the carbon tax taxes, the farmer taxes, the trucker,
00:19:19 and therefore you pay higher bills. And look at these poll numbers that the CTF just released
00:19:23 about seven in 10 Canadians are against the Trudeau government's upcoming carbon tax hike.
00:19:30 And no matter how you slice the numbers, every single demographic, age, gender, income level,
00:19:35 education level, they're all vast majority of Canadians against the carbon tax hike.
00:19:40 And no matter which province they're in, again, the vast majority of Canadians are against the
00:19:44 carbon tax hike. So Canadians are united in the fact that we're furious about the government
00:19:49 making our lives more expensive. The only question now is, are Trudeau and his Liberal
00:19:54 MPs going to listen to Canadians, or are they going to keep cranking up their carbon tax?
00:19:59 You know, to force you into a bit of a pundit role for a moment here, Franco, one of the things
00:20:04 that I find the Liberals did that was incredibly short-sighted was offer that exemption on home
00:20:09 heating oil that carve out to Atlantic Canada. Now, I think it's the right thing to give Canadians
00:20:14 relief on the carbon tax. And I think they should have done it to every single region,
00:20:17 every type of home heating, not just home heating oil. But when they did that, it was a strategic
00:20:23 blunder because all of a sudden every government in the country, including the NDP in Manitoba,
00:20:29 conservatives elsewhere, were like, whoa, whoa, whoa, hold up here. Like on one hand, you're
00:20:33 positioning this as being this panacea for the climate woes. And then on the other hand, you're
00:20:37 saying, okay, yeah, we can give a little exemption here and there. Well, it was a strategic blunder,
00:20:43 right not just for the reason that you bring up but for the reason that it proves that the carbon
00:20:48 tax does make life more expensive right otherwise why would trudeau take the carbon tax off of
00:20:54 furnace oil for three years right so there the trudeau government their talking point is oh
00:21:00 don't worry the rebates make you better off don't worry folks somehow the government will magically
00:21:05 put more money in your pocket than it takes now canadians never bought that idea right and the
00:21:11 reason Canadians saw through that talking point is because it's impossible to bring in a carbon tax,
00:21:17 charge the sales tax on top of the carbon tax, skim hundreds of millions of dollars off the top
00:21:22 to pay for bureaucrats to administer the carbon tax, and then somehow make everyone better off
00:21:28 with rebates. That's impossible. Canadians, all Canadians outside of the Ottawa bubble 1.00
00:21:32 understand that. But the strategic blunder on that is that Trudeau essentially made it obvious
00:21:41 himself when he announced that they're providing relief by taking the carbon tax off of one form
00:21:46 of heating energy, right? Because if the carbon tax didn't make that heating energy more expensive,
00:21:51 then why would Trudeau provide that relief in the first place? Now, to your point earlier,
00:21:57 it's good that some Canadians are getting relief, but he's leaving 97% of Canadians out in the cold.
00:22:02 So the only fair thing to do would have been to just provide that relief to every Canadian.
00:22:07 And of course, we'd like to see him go a step further and just completely scrap the carbon tax altogether.
00:22:13 Yeah, and that's the one thing I've always pointed out on this is that the Supreme Court, I think, made the wrong decision on this when it adjudicated a few years back whether the federal government had the jurisdiction to do this.
00:22:24 But even with that, there's always the political option, which is a government coming in and saying we are going to get rid of the carbon tax.
00:22:31 And this has become a flagship issue for the conservatives.
00:22:35 I mean, even some new Democrats, I think, are getting a little bit stronger on this
00:22:39 issue, certainly provincially in Alberta and Manitoba, and I believe Saskatchewan.
00:22:44 I might be wrong on that.
00:22:47 But at a certain point, do you think that's going to be a mobilizing issue for voters
00:22:51 when we are dealing with a cost of living crisis?
00:22:54 Yes, of course.
00:22:55 I mean, dude, it's like the price of a jug of milk of hamburger meat has gone.
00:23:00 i'm in ontario we do bags bag of milk right i saw that the bag of milk era is coming to an end maybe
00:23:06 i maybe i misread that but i saw that come across my twitter feed but you know the point right i mean
00:23:11 just the basic necessities of living in canada are getting more expensive and one of the reasons for
00:23:16 that is the carbon tax and i and and another thing too is when people are seeing their grocery bills
00:23:21 rise their gas bills rise uh their heating bills rise it's pretty easy to just look south of the
00:23:27 border where even a new Democrat run White House doesn't have a national carbon tax, right? Pretty
00:23:34 easy to look south of the border. Also, the vast majority of countries don't have a national carbon
00:23:39 tax. Canada now has two national carbon taxes, right? So Canadians, not only are they seeing
00:23:45 the cost of living going up, but they're saying, hey, hold on a second. How does making it more
00:23:49 expensive for me to fuel up my sedan or to heat my home or to buy groceries, how does that reduce
00:23:55 submissions in places like china india russia or the united states i mean it obviously doesn't so
00:24:00 you know not that i'm a political pundit but i think it's pretty clear that the key economic
00:24:05 issue facing canadians right now is the cost of living and the carbon tax makes all of the
00:24:09 necessities of living more expensive here in canada did you follow this morality accusation
00:24:16 in saskatchewan so saskatchewan has been like you know alberta protesting the carbon tax uh they've
00:24:22 said they're just not going to submit the carbon tax money which is like a great trump card because
00:24:26 the federal government really can't do anything with it if the money's not being submitted but
00:24:31 then you had steven gilbeau say that it's immoral to do this well what about making people's lives
00:24:38 more expensive when they're already lining up at food banks you know how about that or or just
00:24:43 canadians who are stressing out about getting their natural gas bill right or what about the
00:24:49 farmers who work so hard to feed us and the carbon taxes on natural gas and propane is going to cost
00:24:55 them a billion dollars by 2030. Well, what about that? You know, I think that's wrong. But on the
00:25:01 point about Saskatchewan, look, Scott Moe's heart is in the right place, right? It's good to see a
00:25:05 premier come off the bench and actually stick up for his constituents. Now, I'm not going to talk
00:25:10 about the legal issue here. I'll leave that for the legal beagles, the people who are smarter than
00:25:13 I am. But what I do know is that it's good to see premiers pushing back against this federal tax.
00:25:19 and you know Trudeau he's in the wrong here like what did what did Trudeau think was going to
00:25:24 happen when he did that political ploy clearly political ploy when he had a press conference
00:25:29 with his Atlantic caucus announcing that he would take the carbon tax off of furnace oil
00:25:34 while leaving 97 percent of Canadians out in the cold like what did you think was going to happen
00:25:38 of course this was going to happen but let me just illustrate the point that outside of Ottawa
00:25:44 fuel tax relief is a nonpartisan issue, right?
00:25:47 Everyone knows Alberta, Ontario,
00:25:49 the conservative governments there provided fuel tax relief,
00:25:51 but also the NDP government in Manitoba
00:25:55 completely suspended its fuel tax.
00:25:58 The liberal government in Newfoundland and Labrador
00:26:00 has also provided significant income tax
00:26:02 or significant fuel tax relief, sorry.
00:26:05 So while Ottawa has been cranking up our gas taxes,
00:26:08 you have a bunch of governments across Canada,
00:26:11 regardless of party stripes,
00:26:13 doing the right thing and providing fuel tax relief so one question i'll ask you in closing
00:26:20 here on on this franco is where you see this going because i know that i think you and i it
00:26:24 might have been chris and i or all i mean not that you i i don't i don't view you and chris
00:26:27 sims interchangeably but uh you're both so witty and intelligent i i sometimes get your insights
00:26:32 crossed so i can't remember who it was i was talking about this with but the rebrand the
00:26:37 lipstick on a pig of the carbon tax here do you take from all of this that that isn't sinking in
00:26:42 with Canadians that they're not falling for it? Well, you know, Trudeau's big problem with his
00:26:48 rebrand is that Canadians aren't dumb. Canadians know generally how much they spend for the 0.96
00:26:54 necessities and they know generally how much money is in their bank account, right? This whole
00:27:00 rebrand, this whole lipstick on the carbon tax pig is really just an insult to our intelligence,
00:27:06 right? The Trudeau government appears to seem like, oh, the problem with Canadians is that
00:27:11 us Canadians just don't understand their infinite wisdom in the federal government. But the problem
00:27:18 for them is that we do understand that the carbon tax makes our lives more expensive. We do understand
00:27:23 that the carbon tax is not an environmental solution. We do understand that the vast majority
00:27:29 of countries do not have a national carbon tax. We do understand that Canada's economy
00:27:35 is heavily reliant on natural resources and that these energy taxes are particularly damaging
00:27:41 in a big, cold, vast country that depends on these natural resources.
00:27:46 So, look, Trudeau seems to think, or at least this is the narrative in the media,
00:27:51 that Trudeau has a communications problem.
00:27:54 Look, the PMO's communications, it's been sloppy.
00:27:57 But Trudeau's real problem isn't a communications problem.
00:28:00 Trudeau has a carbon tax is making people's lives more expensive problem.
00:28:06 Franco Terrazano, Federal Director for the Canadian Taxpayers Federation.
00:28:10 Always a pleasure, good sir. Thanks for coming on.
00:28:13 Hey, thanks for having me on today, Andrew.
00:28:15 All right, thank you.
00:28:16 Well, one thing we are going to be doing this week
00:28:19 and in the weeks and months that follow, I suspect,
00:28:21 is continuing our coverage of Bill C-63.
00:28:24 Now, make no mistake, I did a deep dive into the Online Harms Act yesterday.
00:28:30 This is, without a doubt, and I do not say this with hyperbole,
00:28:34 one of the most, if not the most dangerous pieces of legislation,
00:28:38 in my view, the Liberals have presented.
00:28:40 It is, I believe, flawed in its premise and certainly flawed in its application, and it's
00:28:46 going to have an absolutely terrible effect on free speech, not just as an incidental
00:28:52 effect, but by the very design of the bill.
00:28:54 But I want to talk about this from a number of angles, because it's one thing to say free
00:29:00 speech, good, censorship, bad, which, by the way, I agree with, and sadly probably summarizes
00:29:05 my show more than I'd like, but it also is important to look at how it is bad.
00:29:09 and why it's bad and why this bill will have, in many cases, adverse effects even on the people
00:29:15 it purports to be serving. And there was a fantastic op-ed in the Western Standard that
00:29:21 was written by the, well, courtesy of the Fraser Institute and University of Saskatchewan law
00:29:27 professor Dwight Newman that talks about this. It's that Ottawa's online harms bill actually
00:29:32 threatens marginalized communities. I wanted to have Professor Newman on the show to unpack this 1.00
00:29:38 bit further and i'm very pleased that he took us up on the offer uh dwight good to talk to you
00:29:42 thanks for coming on today well thanks i'm glad to to be with you here so let's first and foremost
00:29:48 talk about why it is that it does i mean what's your premise here on how marginalized communities
00:29:53 may actually be harmed by this bill which the government is claiming is there to serve them and
00:29:58 protect them well my focus uh in my comment is on particular parts of the bill and one of the
00:30:05 challenges in talking about the bill is there are so many different things going on at the same time
00:30:10 because there is the piece about online harms and that warrants its own analysis those parts of the
00:30:16 bill but there are parts of the bill that aren't about anything online at all and they're either
00:30:23 sneaking through provisions on hate related matters generally or those matters are there
00:30:30 to distract from the online part. I don't know what the story is, but they somehow don't fit
00:30:37 together. But the piece on hate is what I focused on, that isn't necessarily in the online context,
00:30:44 and there the creation of a freestanding offence that goes along with any other criminal code
00:30:51 offence where there's a motivation by hate and that creates an offence subject to life imprisonment
00:31:00 is actually a very dangerous offense to create in this bill and one that puts at risk even people
00:31:07 from marginalized communities. Now there's another step to get there but that's quite simply that if
00:31:12 you create offenses in the criminal code where there's vast discretion on what the sentence is
00:31:20 going to be, people are going to get caught up in that that don't have representation or as much
00:31:27 representation by lawyers and be at more risk from those uh sentences or the threat of those
00:31:33 sentences in the context of plea bargain negotiations and those will be marginalized
00:31:38 people that are the very people that uh the government claims to be protecting i i wanted
00:31:43 to go back to the the bill itself here for a moment and just explain this because i mean in
00:31:48 the criminal code again i'm not a lawyer but in the criminal code uh you know all of the offenses
00:31:53 that are criminal in Canada have an associated sentence with them. And these sentences are
00:31:57 created based on the severity of the act itself, which is why, you know, a mischief charge will
00:32:04 have a different potential sentence from a murder charge. So I'm correct in my understanding that
00:32:10 what this bill would do is add a separate, basically an add-on component where if you've
00:32:17 done anything else that has its own sentencing guideline, and it is motivated by hate, that
00:32:22 could be a life sentence. So am I construing that correctly? That's right. And so the example you
00:32:29 gave is graffiti. So someone who commits vandalism, which would never have a life sentence if it was
00:32:35 motivated by hate, could conceivably have a life sentence for the motivation. That's right. So we
00:32:41 normally draw a line between what are called summary offenses and indictable offenses. That's
00:32:47 just one line we could draw. The summary offenses tend to have very much lighter punishment
00:32:53 associated with them. Well, this new section of the criminal code will say if you commit any other
00:32:59 offense in the criminal code or under another federal statute, I believe, that you've committed
00:33:05 also a separate indictable offense if your motivation was one of hatred. And I mean, I don't
00:33:12 encourage, I mean, hatred is a terrible thing that we should all be fighting against,
00:33:20 but creating a separate offence here that attaches on to even very relatively minor offences but now
00:33:27 adds the prospect of a life sentence with an attached offence creates a lot of risks and a
00:33:34 lot of problems. And the example I gave is sort of some young person that's old enough to be an
00:33:39 adult for criminal law purposes, but still not really mature. They go and write graffiti,
00:33:47 they're caught up in some bad ideas as a youth, and they're accused of being motivated by hatred.
00:33:54 Well, they're now subject to a life sentence potentially that has no relationship to the
00:33:59 severity of writing or painting graffiti somewhere. There's a total mismatch that's created there.
00:34:07 it's awful and again i i don't want to whitewash what are our very serious acts i mean we've seen
00:34:16 in in the last uh you know few months alone we've seen some horrific uh acts of vandalism that have
00:34:21 taken place against churches uh there was the church that's been burned in in your province
00:34:25 we have also instances of targeting mosques and jewish community centers and i think those should 1.00
00:34:31 be prosecuted. Well, they should be prosecuted. But at the same time, I also have a very
00:34:38 significant issue fundamentally with adjudicating motivation in this way. And this idea that
00:34:45 the motivation fundamentally changes the crime in that disproportionate way you just described
00:34:51 here. Is this really the only area of the law where we have this with the motivation having
00:34:57 such a significant distinction in how an offense is viewed?
00:35:02 Well, I mean, other than the willful promotion of hatred offense itself, but that isn't really
00:35:10 even about the motivation still. That ends up being about what it is that's been done.
00:35:17 And I mean, normally we're looking at intention and the type of intention. And so first degree
00:35:22 murder is more serious than second-degree murder because of the intention, the pre-planning,
00:35:29 the premeditation. It's not exactly the same thing as motivation. This is an example where
00:35:35 motivation, which is a vague thing to get at, is going to have a huge effect. And I think that's
00:35:42 quite different than what happens anywhere else I can think of in the criminal law offhand.
00:35:47 But it is something that's challenging to judge. What is somebody's motivation? And it's transforming the nature of these. And I gave the graffiti example, because it's actually one that's a genuinely lighter offence. I mean, it's still something that should be prosecuted. I don't want to make light of it.
00:36:07 The church burnings, arson, is a serious offence, and this government has sort of laughed that off in some ways.
00:36:17 And it's really disappointing to a lot of Canadians of faith that their religious places of worship can't be protected.
00:36:26 But when you are going to protect them, which I think should be done, the prosecution should be arson if it's arson.
00:36:35 That's a serious offense because it puts lives at risk, but it still shouldn't necessarily be something that has a life sentence because of the motivation.
00:36:44 And that's a very realistic scenario.
00:36:47 Some of the church burnings, probably there's a motivation there of a form of hatred for the religious institution involved, or at least the argument could be made.
00:36:57 That's where we get into the complexities of how do you judge and describe motivation and say whether it's actually hateful.
00:37:05 So that's a real example where this could come into play.
00:37:10 And even there, with a more serious offence, I don't think one should be adding on this additional offence with a life sentence.
00:37:18 And again, even if it's not something that someone would be convicted over, it puts immense pressure on them then to plead guilty to another offense and give up their defense rights if they don't have the means to fight this looming offense of life imprisonment successfully.
00:37:38 Well, and that is the crucial point I wanted to circle back to here, which is, I mean, the Supreme Court did, I think, a lot to really dismantle reforms on sentencing that the previous conservative government tried to put in, especially when it comes to mandatory minimums.
00:37:54 But now you have the opposite problem where you have this just insane range that you could find yourself having applied to you.
00:38:04 And that leaves so much to just how good your lawyer is and how good your judge is. 0.83
00:38:11 And if you have a judge that wants to make an example of you because of these hate motivations or you don't have, as you've said, access to particularly good counsel, you're kind of screwed. 0.89
00:38:21 Yeah. Well, the legal system will try to provide guidance on that through the case law that builds
00:38:27 up, but it comes down to if you don't have access to enough legal counsel, you may not know that as
00:38:34 someone who gets caught up in things. And I mean, I do worry on sort of the, as I say, the wayward
00:38:40 youth that is involved in the graffiti offense. I mean, if someone's a long-term criminal and
00:38:47 I'm less concerned that they might be under pressure to plead out, but someone who really shouldn't be caught up in things could get caught up in things in problematic ways because of this offense.
00:39:01 And it just all of these things also with the whole bill, the chill effects on people in various ways permutate out and restrict freedom more than things first appear.
00:39:18 And that's something that needs to be thought about in every part of the bill that one's looking at is it's not just what's on the paper, but it's how people are affected in their behavior in their day-to-day lives by what's on the paper.
00:39:33 And it probably chills a lot of things that are actually legal and legitimate that people worry that they're going to be caught up in because a lot of people are law abiding Canadians and don't want to be caught up in a criminal prosecution.
00:39:49 Well, they're going to have their liberty restricted in a lot of different ways.
00:39:53 Yeah, well, you can't really blame them in that context.
00:39:56 It's a great piece over at the Western Standard, also available at the Fraser Institute website by Dwight Newman.
00:40:03 professor of law at the university of saskatchewan dwight thank you so much for your
00:40:08 insights really good to talk to you well thank you good to talk with you thank you all right we'll
00:40:12 have more on bill c63 in the days and weeks to come like i said it cannot be understated
00:40:19 how dangerous this bill is i will sound like a broken record or for the uh gen zers in our
00:40:25 audience a broken mp3 player which i'm not sure has the same uh metaphoric ring but hopefully
00:40:30 you'll get my drift there. But that does it for us. We'll be back tomorrow in due course with more
00:40:35 of The Andrew Lawton Show here on True North. Thank you, God bless, and good day to you all.
00:40:40 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:40:42 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.
00:41:00 We'll be right back.
00:41:30 Thank you.
00:42:00 We'll be right back.