Juno News - July 30, 2020


Conservative Leadership Fireside Chat

Topics
Guests
Mentioned
Trudeau's approval rating is still at 44% Independent Press Gallery Fireside Chat: Derek Sloan

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 19 minutes

Words per minute

183.8

Word count

14,582

Sentence count

545

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

12

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

The Independent Press Gallery hosts a Fireside Chat with Conservative Leadership Candidates Aaron O'Toole and Derek Sloan. Candice Malan and Andrew Lawton host the first of two fireside chats featuring each of the four remaining candidates.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hi, and welcome to the Independent Press Gallery's inaugural event.
00:00:27 what was supposed to be the final conservative leadership debate featuring all four candidates.
00:00:32 I'm your host, Candice Malcolm, columnist with the Toronto Sun and Sun Newspapers,
00:00:36 founder and editor-in-chief of True North, and the president of this,
00:00:40 the newly created Independent Press Gallery of Canada.
00:00:44 Now, unfortunately, due to some very last-minute complications,
00:00:47 tonight's debate is no longer a debate.
00:00:51 A few hours ago, Dr. Leslie Lewis and her campaign team
00:00:54 informed us that she had to withdraw from tonight's event because a doctor has ordered
00:00:59 her to stay at home and get some rest. We've been in touch with her campaign and we wish her 0.91
00:01:05 a speedy recovery. Now, upon hearing the news of Lewis dropping out, Peter McKay's campaign
00:01:12 informed us that he too would no longer be participating. He lives in Toronto. He's here
00:01:17 in Toronto right now, but he chose to abandon tonight's debate and instead at 3 p.m. on the
00:01:23 of the event, he urged us to postpone the entire thing. Look, anyone who's ever organized an event
00:01:30 like this knows that postponing something like this is just not possible. The hotel ballroom had
00:01:35 already been rented, the technical crew was here and had already set up, and journalists had already
00:01:40 flown in from all over the country to cover this event. We're not the CBC. We don't have billions
00:01:46 of dollars to waste just to do this all again next week. And besides, Conservative Party members
00:01:52 already have their ballots with them at home and the deadline to mail those in is fast approaching
00:01:58 realistically tonight is the last opportunity to host a leadership event and so the show must go
00:02:04 on instead of a debate tonight's moderator andrew lawton will instead be hosting back-to-back
00:02:10 fireside chats with the remaining two candidates first with aaron o'toole and then with derek
00:02:16 Sloan. Afterwards, there will still be a media scrum with the journalists who are here in
00:02:21 attendance. Leadership is about resiliency, courage, and trust. And voters can judge for
00:02:28 themselves what they think of Peter McKay's last-minute decision to renege on his commitment
00:02:33 and abandon this event. Regardless, tonight is a special night where we hope to showcase the value
00:02:39 of independent journalism in providing a platform to get to the real issues at the heart of the
00:02:45 conservative leadership race we've consulted with dozens of journalists and we've heard from
00:02:50 hundreds of grassroots party members from every region across the country every demographic to
00:02:56 craft the most interesting and important questions possible well of course we would have preferred
00:03:02 to have a debate and there's no doubt that we're disappointed with the way things have gone
00:03:06 we had to adapt and we're still putting forth the tough questions that are important to
00:03:11 conservative members and not the irrelevant issues obsessed upon by the mainstream media.
00:03:18 I'd like to say thank you so much to the two remaining candidates, Mr. Aaron O'Toole and
00:03:24 Mr. Derek Sloan. Thank you so much for participating in our event, and a special thanks to you,
00:03:30 the viewers at home, for supporting independent journalism in this country.
00:03:35 And so without further delay, I will now turn it over to my True North colleague,
00:03:39 Andrew Lawton to begin the formal program tonight thank you so much thank you very much Candice and
00:03:47 thank you to all of you who are tuning in if you caught the pre-show for this debate you are no
00:03:52 doubt aware that we had a medical issue that arose with a very valued member of our team Sam
00:03:57 Eskenazi I want to let you all know that he is fine he's alert and actually himself was very
00:04:02 encouraging to continue on with the show thanks to all of you who have sent in messages of support
00:04:08 As Candace mentioned we aren't doing the event that we thought we were even a few hours ago
00:04:13 but it's still a very critical opportunity to hear from the people vying not only to lead
00:04:17 the Conservative Party of Canada but also the country. We did a coin toss for order and I'm
00:04:22 very grateful to have with us the first of our two fireside chat Conservative leadership candidates
00:04:28 Derek Sloan. Please welcome Derek Sloan out.
00:04:30 Derek thank you very much for being here thank you to see you so obviously the event that you
00:04:42 had anticipated being here tonight is a bit different so we thank you very much for still
00:04:47 being here in spite of all the changes one of the reasons that the independent press gallery
00:04:53 was formed was to advocate for independent journalists to have a voice in this country
00:04:59 And I wanted to start off right there with you.
00:05:01 Where do you see the big challenges being for press freedom and for freedom of speech?
00:05:06 Well, hey, that's a really good question.
00:05:07 And I've been a very strong candidate on those issues.
00:05:11 And I think that the Conservative Party has to lead from the federal level on free speech.
00:05:16 And I've been very clear that bills like Bill C-16, which can compel you to use certain gender pronouns, for example, should be repealed.
00:05:25 We can't have bills like that from the federal level when we claim to believe in free speech.
00:05:30 So we need to be very clear on issues like that.
00:05:33 When it comes to the press freedom and the inherent bias that's in certain media groups,
00:05:39 I think it's great that we're seeing, you know, groups that have started recently or not so recently
00:05:44 that are holding their own against organizations like the CBC that get tons of funding.
00:05:51 And I'm glad to be here.
00:05:53 I think that I've set a trend that says do not ignore conservative media.
00:05:59 And that has been, you know, some people in the Conservative Party don't speak to certain groups.
00:06:04 And I've been very clear to speak to all kinds of groups, whether it's Rebel News or groups like yourself.
00:06:10 And I've set a standard for other candidates as well.
00:06:13 So I'm pleased to be here.
00:06:15 You know, on the topic of free speech, we have to do everything we can to defend it.
00:06:20 And, you know, I spoke about Bill C-16. There's also social media banning. And I've been the only candidate, to my knowledge, that's spoken about taking on the shadow banning and the banning and the censorship that we're seeing.
00:06:34 And whether that's during elections, we've seen examples of Facebook blocking statements critical of Jagmeet Singh or critical of open borders.
00:06:43 We need to take these guys head on. If they're going to claim to be a neutral platform, then they need to act like a neutral platform.
00:06:49 And this is where free speech is at right now.
00:06:53 We're talking about university campuses.
00:06:55 And I've been clear that universities need to be objectively in favor of free speech to receive federal funding.
00:07:02 And we need to be sure that we're pushing for federal funding on the cutting edge.
00:07:07 And that means social media.
00:07:08 That means it's something simple we can do is to criminalize doxing.
00:07:14 And I was speaking with a couple of young conservatives in Montreal just last week who I met with them at their apartment.
00:07:22 And I said, hey, you guys want to have a picture together?
00:07:24 And they said, well, we'd love to, but that might identify where we live.
00:07:27 And one of them had already been doxxed by Antifa, believe it or not, who, again, I've said should be declared a terrorist organization.
00:07:35 But they had been doxxed. And in this country, that's not a criminal offense.
00:07:38 You can sue people civilly, but it's challenging.
00:07:41 Other countries have made that a criminal offense.
00:07:43 And I believe if you are trying to release details of where someone lives or details about where their kids go to school or go to daycare for the intent of having other people cause you trouble, that should be a criminal offense.
00:07:56 So I think we need to hit this head on.
00:07:58 When you talk about on one hand, though, wanting to push for more free speech on social media platforms, there are those that would and let's take people's children out of the equation.
00:08:07 There are those that would say doxing is a logical extension of online free speech.
00:08:11 well i think when again when the intent of uh when the intent of sharing your uh your your address
00:08:19 and your location with a group of of people who the intent is to cause you problems the intent is
00:08:25 hey andrew if you have this opinion i'm going to tell my my followers here where you live where
00:08:30 your kids go to school this isn't about arguing political opinions this is with the intent of
00:08:35 people with bad intent showing up at your home basically it's the intent is to shut you up the
00:08:40 intent is to scare you into not sharing your opinion. But legislating intent, isn't that the
00:08:45 backbone? A lot of these other areas of law like human rights code, speech laws, other things that
00:08:51 conservatives are typically against when you start to get into the thought behind an act as
00:08:55 fundamentally changing the nature of the act itself. Well, I mean, criminal law is filled
00:09:00 with intent, right? You have mens rea and you have the most criminal laws have to do with intent,
00:09:05 not all of them um so i believe it's perfectly fine to target a behavior which has basically
00:09:11 malice as its intent so uh you know the typical attack on free speech is i don't like your opinion
00:09:17 your opinion is violent but if you are for instance free speech doesn't cover me threatening
00:09:23 you it doesn't cover me asking someone to assault you and doxing is basically in that category so
00:09:31 So if you're doxing someone, if you're putting out someone's intimate details of what they
00:09:35 do and where they go, this has nothing to do with furthering public discourse.
00:09:39 This has to do with targeting you and trying to silence you.
00:09:42 And so to me, I think that's a legitimate distinction.
00:09:45 And on the regulation of social media companies, I guess there are two aspects of this.
00:09:49 Number one is the effectiveness when these companies are such a size that they have the
00:09:55 GDP of many countries.
00:09:56 And most of them are not domiciled or headquartered in Canada.
00:10:00 So how do you enforce a Canadian law on these companies without being like China, which is, you know, restricting access? 0.98
00:10:06 And the other part is the fundamental nature of is it not challenging their right as a private company to operate the way they want,
00:10:15 even if that means we don't think conservative speech is as valuable as liberal speech or something like that?
00:10:21 Yeah, well, I mean, that's a good question. And I'm not here to tell you the answer is easy.
00:10:25 There's obviously different parts of this that would play into provincial jurisdictions.
00:10:29 So the point is, is that we need to identify that that it's a problem.
00:10:32 And that's that's probably the most important thing.
00:10:35 But listen, I believe that I believe that organizations need to follow the law in Canada.
00:10:40 And there's all kinds of things that that businesses can and can't do.
00:10:43 And I believe that that social media companies, which, again, enjoy the benefits of, you know, they are not subject to to being sued for, for example, libel or things of that nature.
00:10:56 So at the same time, a publishing organization like a newspaper can be.
00:11:03 So if they're claiming the benefit of sort of a neutral platform for everybody to use for whatever the reason,
00:11:12 they can at the same time edit comments without any rationale.
00:11:16 They can't be removing certain comments unless it accords with a very open standard of conduct.
00:11:24 And we all know that the codes of conduct on these things are really, in many cases, unintelligible.
00:11:31 Really what you're describing there cuts to what we've seen a lot of us of late, which is cancel culture and this idea that conservatives have espress, which is that their voices are not valued by the elites.
00:11:43 And we see that in social media companies.
00:11:45 You see it in the mainstream media.
00:11:47 you've experienced yourself a fair bit of pushback from the mainstream media not just on
00:11:53 social conservative issues which I suspect we'll get to later on in this discussion but even your
00:11:58 approach to some issues that have been very pertinent throughout the coronavirus pandemic
00:12:02 such as wanting Teresa Tam the public health officer of Canada fired we know from the last
00:12:09 election from all of Stephen Harper's elections conservatives are not dealt a fair hand by the
00:12:14 mainstream media. And I think that on the cultural side, we can talk about media bias and all of
00:12:19 these things. But if you're within those parameters, you're operating as a figure in
00:12:24 Canadian politics, you know the treatments the media is going to give you is not going to be
00:12:28 good. How do you push back against that when you are, as you know, a conservative without apology,
00:12:33 a hardliner on a lot of social and economic issues? Well, I mean, the simple answer is you
00:12:38 don't jump through their hoops. And so there's been, I mean, we get a lot of requests from
00:12:43 mainstream media that we just ignore and it has it has nothing to do with you know it has nothing
00:12:48 to do with with with those organizations but it has to do with the the fight that we're in and
00:12:53 right now our fight is to win this leadership battle so I'm not there's some candidates who
00:12:58 who bask in the in the glory of you know sitting down with CBC and all this stuff if I don't think
00:13:03 that sitting down with a particular media outlet is going to help me reach conservative members
00:13:07 I don't even bother I don't even bother going on so part of it is just not jumping through the
00:13:13 hoops that the media has and in a general election obviously the strategy is is different but the
00:13:18 other thing too we have to remember is that we have access to social media and we can drive our
00:13:22 narrative uh through controversy or not using social media so I think that we you know my
00:13:29 experience anyways is that is that there's some conservatives who feel that they've done a good
00:13:33 day's work when the media isn't slamming them. And to me, I say, listen, you know, if the media
00:13:38 isn't slamming you, maybe you're not doing a good day's work. You know, if you're going to stand on
00:13:43 conservative principles in this day and age, you're going to get, you're going to get kicked
00:13:46 back. And sometimes we need to be able to stand there and take it and say, you know what, we've
00:13:50 said the right thing. We don't need to apologize. We don't need to rephrase what we're trying to say
00:13:54 and let the, let the media do what they want. I believe at the end of the day,
00:13:59 If we push our message, whether through controversy or not, the Canadian populace will see through it.
00:14:07 And I think that, especially with the use of social media, we can get our message through regardless of what the mainstream media says.
00:14:14 And I've seen that happen in my campaign.
00:14:16 I think the saying that there's a lot of truth to is that Twitter is not real life.
00:14:20 And when you go and knock on doors, most of the people that you encounter, regardless of where it is in Canada, aren't following hashtag CDN Polly on Twitter.
00:14:29 They don't know what the Laurentian elite types, the mainstream media are talking about.
00:14:33 A lot of people still know what is on the front page of the paper, what's on their six o'clock newscast.
00:14:38 And if you've got the mainstream media throwing every name of the book at you, how are you going to expand the base of the conservative movement and the base of the conservative voters if you're the leader?
00:14:49 Well, you know, the point you make about Twitter is correct, but it's not, but it's incorrect when it comes to Facebook. And we're seeing a massive use of Facebook. I forget the stats. It's 80, 90% of like everybody, even like grandmothers that are on Facebook. So I think that social media can be used to our advantage.
00:15:05 When it comes to Twitter,
00:15:06 you obviously don't look at your combination
00:15:08 of positives versus negatives
00:15:10 because it's only politically engaged people that are there.
00:15:13 But I believe that you stick to your narrative
00:15:17 and people will eventually come around.
00:15:19 And I saw that with some of the comments
00:15:21 I made about Dr. Tam.
00:15:23 Initially, some people thought it was the end of the world.
00:15:25 But even to this day,
00:15:26 I still get mail at my constituency office
00:15:28 from just random people who say,
00:15:30 you know what, thanks for speaking out on this issue.
00:15:32 you know you've proven yourself to be correct. So I think that we have to be okay with you know
00:15:37 maybe being a little bit early or stepping out on a limb and the truth will take care of itself
00:15:42 and I think that the media as biased as it is you know eventually the truth will come out and I
00:15:48 think that we have to count on it. You had MPs in your own caucus that after you had called for
00:15:55 Theresa Tam to be fired wanted you kicked out of caucus in the middle of a leadership race and you 0.99
00:16:00 can talk about people's motivations for that, whether they may have had an allegiance to
00:16:04 another leadership campaign. But still, there have been people that have spoken up that have said
00:16:08 they do not see themselves being able to serve under a Derek Sloan-led caucus. And you can say
00:16:14 they're wrong. You can say that they're perhaps having a narrow view of it. But even so, if you
00:16:19 are a leader, how do you unite that when you've got people that don't even want you to just not
00:16:24 win, but don't even want you in the caucus? How do you serve and unify a caucus like that?
00:16:30 some people think the party is about the caucus the party is about the members
00:16:34 we all serve at the leisure of the members if I am given the honor of
00:16:39 leading this party it will be because of the members and so the caucus it's up
00:16:42 to the caucus to recognize and respect the members who who put them there to
00:16:48 begin with and elected the leader that they want to lead the party so I believe
00:16:53 I firmly believe that the caucus will fall behind anyone who is elected but
00:16:57 at the end of the day there is this attitude that it's about the caucus and you know we're in
00:17:01 Ottawa and we're important. We're not important. It's the people that put us there and that's why
00:17:06 I'm here and I will never betray them. You can say that the members put the caucus there and if
00:17:12 you're successful the members will have put you there and that is accurate but even so leadership
00:17:17 is about unifying rather than dividing. So I'm not accusing you of dividing but you have divided
00:17:23 people against you, whether it's by your fault or not. So even if you say the caucus isn't the
00:17:28 be-all and end-all, what's your approach going to be as leader with these people? Because you still
00:17:33 will have to manage them. Caucus management is still a part of the role of leader of the
00:17:38 Conservative Party. Well, you know, it's interesting because I've been very clear that I believe that
00:17:43 votes should be free in caucus. So for people who don't agree with me on certain things, I'm not
00:17:48 sitting here saying, I want to twist their arm. Again, their mandate is to do what they feel
00:17:54 their constituents elected them to do. So I have no problem with a caucus member voting according
00:18:00 to their conscience, even if it's a different conscience than I have. But I do believe that
00:18:05 this leadership race is exposing certain fault lines in the party. And when you move from a place,
00:18:11 when you're moving from A to B or from a good place to a better place, it's never easy. I mean,
00:18:17 if it was easy then everybody would do it uh but improve but improving moving to a place where we
00:18:23 can become the dominant political force in this country uh takes certain risks it takes stepping
00:18:29 on certain toes and it's an inevitable outcome of being able to win and so um i'm not surprised that
00:18:35 this has happened but um i'm not i'm not concerned every everyone loves a winner and i'm i'm uh i've
00:18:42 experienced this before people say all kinds of things about you before you win and then when you
00:18:46 win they're your best friend so we'll uh we'll let that sort itself out conservative campaigns
00:18:51 have historically been about aversion to risk as you've seen and i think a focus on we heard the
00:18:57 term throughout the harper years of boutique tax credits and focus solely on pocketbook issues i
00:19:03 know that you've put forward a vision that deals with economic fiscal issues social issues foreign
00:19:09 policy do you fundamentally disagree with that idea that when you're asking canadians to vote
00:19:15 for you to vote for your party that the economics are where it's at well okay so let me put it so
00:19:23 yes i guess i disagree with all of it but in a more nuanced way than how you phrased it please
00:19:27 how do you phrase it well here so i definitely disagree with running on a platform of boutique
00:19:33 tax credits however you run it needs to be in big in a big bold vision and not you know hey
00:19:38 andrew if you put your kid in soccer i'll save you 200 bucks you know like in this last election
00:19:42 So we had people like literally like, okay, I'm going to save 25% of my cell phone.
00:19:47 If I vote liberal, I'm going to get a hundred bucks.
00:19:48 If I put in green lights or your, you know, environmentally efficient lights.
00:19:54 So it can't be about that.
00:19:55 It has to be about values.
00:19:57 And I've said, listen, we need to, we need to run on a freedom platform in the BC debate.
00:20:02 We saw a poll that was done online from people all over BC.
00:20:06 And I feel that they reflect conservatives across Canada.
00:20:10 And they were asked, what's the most important issue to you?
00:20:12 And the economy was asked, debt was asked.
00:20:15 These are things that they are important.
00:20:16 I mean, we see a third of a trillion dollars in debt
00:20:20 and yet 60 some odd percent of people said free speech.
00:20:23 The economy was like 8%, 9%.
00:20:26 So does that mean that conservatives don't care
00:20:28 about the economy?
00:20:29 It does not.
00:20:30 But the point is, is that our metanary,
00:20:32 I mean, Justin Trudeau does not campaign on the economy.
00:20:37 He campaigns on his version of Canadian values,
00:20:41 of his version of bringing the country together.
00:20:43 He campaigns from the heart, or at least he tries to,
00:20:46 and we have to do the same because that's what Canadians,
00:20:49 at the end of the day,
00:20:50 Canadians are gonna follow someone
00:20:51 who campaigns from the heart.
00:20:53 And so when we campaign on freedom,
00:20:57 all of that impacts the free market,
00:20:58 it impacts the economy, it impacts all these things,
00:21:01 but we need to have a meta narrative
00:21:03 that drives our vision and freedom is what that needs to be.
00:21:07 On the economics,
00:21:08 because we can't get through a conservative leadership fireside chat without talking about
00:21:13 those. Anyone who inherits the premiership of Canada, if they win an election after winning
00:21:18 leadership, is going to have a very challenging economic situation to deal with, a deficit nearing
00:21:24 $350 billion debt that continues to go up. How do you deliver that conservative vision that you
00:21:30 want, which is tax cuts, lower regulations, less government spending, when that's the mess you'll
00:21:36 have? What's the budget that you'll put forward or the economic platform that you'll be putting
00:21:40 forward? Well, we have to do all that and we have to drive the narrative. So, you know, the idea
00:21:45 that I'm not asking about the narrative, though, I'm asking about the numbers. Well, so we have to
00:21:51 put forward a budget that cuts federal spending, like period, right? But when it comes to the
00:21:56 economy as well, we have to look at growth as much as we have to look at cutting. So getting our
00:22:02 energy sector back on track is is a major way of doing that i mean you know every job in the oil
00:22:07 field impacts many other jobs in ontario and elsewhere whether it be manufacturing or banking
00:22:11 or even legal work so the energy sector is a big thing we have to look at at real tax cuts we have
00:22:18 to look at promoting made in canada small business here in canada and i have some good ideas of how
00:22:24 to deal with that as well but you know to to do all these things we have to put canada sovereignty
00:22:29 first and I don't believe that we can get a recovery in the energy sector without getting
00:22:34 out of the Paris agreement and I think it's very clear that we recognize as conservatives we
00:22:38 shouldn't be in these agreements that don't do us any good and hurt our own industries. So we do
00:22:43 have to do that but there's also regulations that need to be cut. We need to do what we would we
00:22:47 would have liked to do anyways but now we have a real reason to do it with this with this debt
00:22:51 that we have and we need to be very focused and brave in how we do that. On regulations your
00:22:58 Your platform calls for a significant reduction in regulations.
00:23:02 You talk about not just looking at federal ones, but even using federal authority to
00:23:06 reduce provincial and municipal regulations.
00:23:09 Now I'm all for getting rid of regulations, but how on earth do you justify being a conservative
00:23:14 that respects other levels of government if you're wanting to start cutting their own
00:23:19 regulations of those other levels of government?
00:23:21 Well, again, I don't think we would literally be doing it for them.
00:23:26 But this is we need to get into a culture in Canada where we encourage.
00:23:29 Sorry to interrupt. Your platform says you would use federal authority to reduce regulations at all three levels of government.
00:23:34 What does that mean?
00:23:35 Well, again, what we have to do when we're discussing regulations is we need to make sure.
00:23:43 And I think that we're in a good place right now with the premiers of the provinces to offer them certain things from the federal government in exchange for compliance with reducing regulatory oversight.
00:23:56 And I think that if we I think if the federal government champions a move like this, I think that we can get buy in.
00:24:02 And I don't like to, you know, I'm a carrot type of guy as opposed to a stick type of guy.
00:24:08 And I think that we can, I think it's in our best interest to have the best economy we can have.
00:24:13 And I think that we can work with provinces and municipalities.
00:24:16 I mean, you know, as someone who has 19 municipalities in his riding, along with a reserve as well, there is all kinds of infrastructure funding that comes from the feds.
00:24:27 So, again, there's all kinds of ways that we can work with our municipalities, work with our provincial partners to encourage this type of streamlining.
00:24:37 And you've pushed, I believe, for two in and one out on regulations, right?
00:24:41 That's correct.
00:24:41 For every one that comes in, you're going to get rid of two.
00:24:45 What are the specific regulations that you see as being disruptive to business, the specific ones that if you're in there as prime minister, theoretically, after winning the leadership, have to go?
00:24:54 Well, listen, I'll give you a couple of examples, and maybe we'll just use those as examples.
00:25:00 So I think we can, when it comes to paperwork for small businesses, we can put all of that into one portal.
00:25:06 So, and hopefully we could even combine federal and provincial paperwork as well into one portal.
00:25:10 So that would be one example of something we can do.
00:25:13 I've also said, and this again would be to work in conjunction with provinces, we need to look at ways to be more innovative in our funding.
00:25:20 So when it comes to entrepreneurship, which again is something that's very important and innovation to growing our economy, we need to look at more sophisticated ways of allowing small startups to get money.
00:25:33 And often the securities regulations that we have butt up against things like crowdfunding and things like that.
00:25:40 So we need to work with our provincial partners to make it easier to get funding to small business ideas.
00:25:47 because uh you know the business the business development bank of canada these things they're
00:25:51 not geared for the the the small the startup funding that we need and we lose a lot of these
00:25:56 ideas to the states where the capital markets are more developed so we need to be a little more
00:26:00 creative on these types of things and when you talk about funding you're not talking about
00:26:03 government funding you're talking about even accessing private sector so crowdfunding by
00:26:07 people who so crowdfunding is a great way to to um you know get quote-unquote investment for your
00:26:14 business but the way it's set up right now there's no way to really offer an equity stake in your
00:26:19 business unless you go through the rigmarole of securities laws which requires more money and
00:26:26 expertise than a lot of small people would want to do but it is a great way in a small town or
00:26:34 with the environment we have with the internet right now to find people online who like what
00:26:39 you're doing you know maybe you're starting some sort of a craft company they could they could
00:26:43 invest in your business and again this is something that would need to be done in conjunction with
00:26:47 the provinces but i'm saying there are ways to make for example crowdfunding more accessible
00:26:52 to canadians to allow them to get businesses off the ground you mentioned earlier about made in
00:26:58 canada which is a part of your platform as well pushing for labeling and identification of products
00:27:03 that are made here certainly throughout the pandemic i think we've seen the risks of having
00:27:08 such a reliance on other countries for supply and recent cases on personal protective equipment.
00:27:14 But even so, we are a country that is based on free trade. The Conservative government in
00:27:19 particular inked numerous trade agreements with countries all around the world. We had recently
00:27:24 the renegotiation of NAFTA, which is now the USMCA, I think, or the CMUSA. They changed the
00:27:30 letters around. But when you come out and say, we need to make a push for Made in Canada,
00:27:35 are you talking about protectionism or are you just talking about promoting that culture of
00:27:40 homegrown goods yeah so i think it's about promoting the culture and i mean there's there's
00:27:45 all kinds of ways in which free trade doesn't even happen within canada between the provinces
00:27:49 so so i mean there's a great place to start but i do believe that and a key to this of course is
00:27:55 is reasonable energy prices and we saw with the green energy act with kathleen win our electricity 0.97
00:28:00 prices increased by about 70 percent driving all kinds of manufacturing business out of the province
00:28:05 And they're trying to do that again, by the way.
00:28:07 Jerry Butts is in a new organization that's suggesting $50 billion for resilient recovery.
00:28:13 Well, God help us if that's the type of recovery that we have.
00:28:16 But in any event, with affordable energy, which is fossil fuels and not subsidizing green energy, which is what we had done before, we can get to the place where we can reduce costs for manufacturing.
00:28:31 Reducing regulatory overload, again, is another thing.
00:28:35 still at the end of the day we won't be competing directly on a cost basis but I believe we can
00:28:40 compete on it on a quality basis and we've seen that happen with success in places like Germany
00:28:45 and I believe a lot of Canadians just want to know I mean I hear all the time you know hey I
00:28:50 wanted to buy something made in Canada I couldn't even find it you know but I think if we do
00:28:53 in different provinces Alberta has their own their own system I don't care if it's a provincial or a
00:28:59 federal one but we need to let people know where products come from I think Canadians are primed
00:29:03 to buy made in canada just by virtue of wanting to and we need to give them the option to do that
00:29:08 so under your ideal scenario would there be a rollback of some of the agreements that have
00:29:14 made it possible to freely trade in goods from everywhere and imaginable around the world well
00:29:19 we need to we need to evaluate all the the agreements that we have i i'm certainly not
00:29:24 against free trade when we're trading with countries like china i don't call that free 0.98
00:29:28 trade i mean we we have we have a we have a country there that's devaluing their currency
00:29:32 they're using predatory pricing tactics they're often trying to steal intellectual property so
00:29:37 we have to be very careful that we're not opening ourselves up to theft so so i believe in trading
00:29:42 with countries that want to trade with us and want to play fair and i don't care where they are they
00:29:46 could be in any part of the world but we also have to be safe when we're dealing with countries that
00:29:51 are acting in a predatory danger let's talk about national unity here which is a big problem not
00:29:57 just from quebec which has always had its troubles with the canadian confederation experience also
00:30:04 alberta saskatchewan parts of british columbia people who feel that the west is not a part of
00:30:11 confederation anymore people who completely want to separate or at the very least people who feel
00:30:16 like they're getting a raw deal i know you have said you are a federalist you don't want to
00:30:21 entertain alberta separation but you will still as a conservative leader and if your
00:30:27 plan works according to how you want it to as prime minister the growing discontent and discord
00:30:32 with the west and with quebec as well so what's your vision to keep canada together well you and
00:30:38 i were at an event where a lot of people in the room this was in calgary uh are on the separatist
00:30:43 track and um you know i spoke to them and they seemed to like what i had to say i don't know if
00:30:48 everyone is is not a separatist now probably not but uh you know it starts with recognizing that
00:30:54 repealing Bill C-69 and C-48 is not enough to quell Western separatist sentiment. It's much
00:31:03 more than that. These are feelings and issues that go back decades, if not generations. And
00:31:09 I think recognizing that is a very important part. I hope Alberta, like other provinces,
00:31:17 bargains hard. I hope that the leadership of any province puts their own
00:31:24 province first, obviously with a mind to confederation. But I hope that Alberta stands for
00:31:29 their rights and I've encouraged them to do that. But I also think that we need to do more than
00:31:35 simply repeal a few bills that Justin Trudeau has bought in. We need to look seriously at the way
00:31:41 that equalization works. And I'm not here to tell you the exact way that that should be done, but we
00:31:45 have to make sure that we have something in place that Alberta feels is fair. We have to, on the very
00:31:51 base of it we have to make sure that uh the the representation in the house of commons is adjusted
00:31:57 quickly enough to accord to the changing population levels in bc and alberta and we know that bc and
00:32:03 alberta are underrepresented uh in relation to even ontario and certainly quebec when it comes
00:32:08 to numbers of representatives in the house of commons alberta should should have right now
00:32:13 probably about 39 or 40 if it was on the same ratio as ontario which is about four or five more
00:32:18 than they do now so these are things that we we must look at we have to put every option on the
00:32:23 table you i mean andrew i think you and i know that separatist sentiment is so serious right now
00:32:27 i don't think people in the rest of the country get it i get it i've i've been in rooms with
00:32:33 hundreds of people who are so serious about this and um and and people like me out there i mean i've
00:32:40 i've i've had uh there's many people who who say listen derrick if you don't win this i'm out of
00:32:45 here. And I think that the number one priority for a conservative leader, for a prime minister,
00:32:51 is making sure that every part of the country feels like an equal partner in confederation.
00:32:55 And I don't care what it takes, so I'll make sure that happens with Alberta.
00:32:58 One of the big issues that we heard in the 2017 conservative leadership race, which
00:33:04 was odd to become so central, was supply management. And this is an issue where I
00:33:09 think conservatives have often philosophically been at odds with some of the political realities.
00:33:15 and i know you have farmers in your riding i know a lot of farmers including dairy farmers
00:33:19 specifically make up the conservative base what's your stance well i think that uh i think that when
00:33:25 you look at uh so first i'll say i don't have any intentions to make any major changes to supply
00:33:31 management uh although we can always look at ways to to modify the system the when it comes to dairy
00:33:37 uh every country has heavy subsidies for their their dairy industry so and we have farmers right
00:33:44 now that have millions of dollars of property built up into the system so i don't think that
00:33:49 there's any easy way to to solve the system i think that when it comes to food security when
00:33:54 it comes to our farmers we need to make sure that they're getting the help that they need i mean
00:33:58 these are these are industries where um you know when when you have a bad season you may be wiped
00:34:04 out and it it's not it doesn't necessarily fit the the immediate constructs that you would see
00:34:10 and in an economics textbook that farmer is done now maybe i mean you know maybe someone else can
00:34:16 buy his stuff or whatever but we need to keep our farmers from from getting going there in the first
00:34:21 place so when it comes to food and when it comes to things like this i'm okay uh as conservatives
00:34:27 making sure that that doesn't happen so obviously we believe in free trade we believe in all this
00:34:31 type of stuff but you know when countries like china are are attacking our canola farmers and 1.00
00:34:36 things like that we have to step in and defend them and when it comes to supply management
00:34:41 listen it's not a perfect system but again we live in it we live in a marketplace where other
00:34:46 countries are basically subsidizing their industries to the same or greater degree at
00:34:51 least in this case and again it's not a perfect scenario the subsidy is not undertaken by the
00:34:58 government it's basically on the consumer so whoever is purchasing these things is the one
00:35:02 that's bearing the cost of it which again not perfect but it is better than a generic subsidy
00:35:08 that we all pay for how do we as a country then make ourselves competitive when we're
00:35:13 in many cases engaged in a race to the bottom with other countries that don't have the moral qualms
00:35:18 with subsidizing relentlessly flooding the market in many cases flooding the market with product
00:35:23 that is inadequate how do you make yourselves competitive in a global marketplace in those
00:35:28 circumstances well again i think you you just can't be afraid to say listen if that's what
00:35:33 you're going to do you're not having free access to our to our market so again i don't think like
00:35:39 i certainly have no qualms in saying listen we will trade with countries that play by the rules
00:35:45 and we're not going to be uh giving free access to our market to countries that are actively
00:35:49 undermining our own economy so again i i think it's fair and i'm i'm not afraid to say we can
00:35:54 make that distinction what would you say has been the most eye-opening experience of this campaign
00:36:01 and i ask that because it's been a very different campaign than everyone thought when they got into
00:36:06 the race more zoom calls and all of those sorts of things than actual debates when you came in
00:36:11 did you have a different vision for what you thought you were going to be hearing from people
00:36:16 than what you actually did well there's so much centered around covid which obviously no nobody
00:36:21 expected and that's and that's very interesting obviously i've seen firsthand the fault lines that
00:36:26 have been exposed in the party um you know really i i've been surprised you know it's so interesting
00:36:32 if we would focus on a few different issues i think we we could easily win in an election
00:36:36 and there's an there's a there's a big concern right now in canada with with certain values issues
00:36:41 and canadian sovereignty issues and civil liberties issues i don't know if i'm just a
00:36:46 unique candidate but one of the biggest questions i get right now or i used to get everyone knows
00:36:51 what i think now is are you in favor of like mandatory covid vaccines what do you think of
00:36:56 you know like mandatory mass and things like this you know i i would have assumed some people would
00:37:01 have been concerned about that but literally the most uh frequent question i get it's not about
00:37:06 abortion it's not about anything like that it's about mandatory vaccinations so i think this kind
00:37:11 of civil liberties issues uh canadian sovereignty issues when it comes to you know un agreements
00:37:16 that we've signed on to and even values issues these are these are such important issues and i
00:37:21 don't see many of the other candidates really focusing on that very much do you think there is
00:37:27 an opportunity in canada to push for a bit more of a political approach to appointing judges this
00:37:33 is something that we often hear about in the united states in canada we've seen conservatives be on
00:37:38 on the losing end of Supreme Court cases
00:37:39 on key issues of conscience.
00:37:41 Is that something as a lawyer,
00:37:43 as a leadership candidate that you've taken an eye to?
00:37:46 Well, we have to do everything we can
00:37:48 when we're in power to appoint good conservative judges.
00:37:51 And when I say conservative,
00:37:52 I don't mean that they vote conservative.
00:37:56 I mean that they use conservative principles
00:37:58 when they're interpreting the constitution,
00:38:00 when they're interpreting the law.
00:38:02 And what we see is judges that take an activist,
00:38:06 I want to impose my version of utopia or whatever it is.
00:38:10 They don't say this,
00:38:12 but they're very activist in terms of their approach.
00:38:14 Whereas the small C conservative approach 0.51
00:38:17 to judicial application is, well, what does the law say?
00:38:21 What has the court said before?
00:38:22 Whether I like it or not, how do we apply it?
00:38:25 And everyone here, even the average Canadian
00:38:27 thinks that that's how it's done anyways.
00:38:28 And you and I know that that's not how it works.
00:38:31 But we need to get people in there, originalists, 0.99
00:38:36 as it were, to borrow language that's used down south a lot,
00:38:39 that interpret the laws that we have as they're written
00:38:43 and stop trying to rewrite things
00:38:45 for the benefit of their own political agenda.
00:38:48 So really conservative judges apply the law
00:38:51 whether they like it or not.
00:38:52 And I think that that's really unpolitical,
00:38:54 but unfortunately not what we see typically.
00:38:57 Now, of course, we invited you to participate in a debate,
00:39:00 which we didn't get to give you,
00:39:01 but we will give you a closing statement if you'd like,
00:39:03 we wind things down and give people that final pitch for why they should vote for you as the
00:39:08 ballot deadline nears. Sure. Well, I'm the only candidate that has been so clear on some of those
00:39:13 three points that I mentioned earlier. I'm dead set against mandatory vaccinations for COVID or
00:39:19 anything. I'm against mandatory masks. I'm against the Paris Agreement. I'm the only candidate who's
00:39:24 been talking about this. I'm against these other UN agreements that we've signed on to. I've been
00:39:30 only candidate that says we need to defund the world health organization i've been the only
00:39:34 candidate that says we need to defund these radical green uh energy organizations i've been dead set
00:39:40 on being against green energy subsidies and i will always put canada first everybody knows
00:39:45 that i'm up front and what you see is what you get and i will never compromise on our conservative
00:39:50 values thank you god bless and god bless canada well thank you very much derek sloan for coming
00:39:56 i know that uh 50 of the field didn't so we appreciate that you did and we thank you to
00:40:01 your team as well for making this happen we have got to take a quick break here we'll be back with
00:40:06 a little message about the independent press gallery after a short video break and also
00:40:11 with our fireside chat with aaron o'toole that's coming up i'm andrew lutton
00:40:24 much
00:40:26 .
00:40:56 .
00:41:26 Welcome back.
00:41:39 So if you were following the federal election campaign in 2019,
00:41:44 my view of that was the back of the liberal campaign bus.
00:41:48 It was quite an ordeal, as many of you who have followed my work with True North may have seen.
00:41:52 We were denied access to Justin Trudeau's liberal campaign events,
00:41:56 and then eventually denied access to covering the Leaders Debates Commission's official
00:42:01 government-sanctioned, government-hosted English and French-language debates with all of the leaders
00:42:06 of the major political parties. True North and Rebel News were denied access and had to file
00:42:13 an emergency court injunction to have permission to be journalists, permission to cover a government
00:42:19 event. Now, if you're familiar enough with the story, you know that we emerged victorious from
00:42:23 We were granted a court order that required the Leaders Debates Commission to credit us.
00:42:28 But even then, the battle has not ended.
00:42:31 The Leaders Debates Commission and the federal government have continued to block our attempts
00:42:35 for more transparency as the case continues.
00:42:38 They continue to say that there was no press freedom case that was at stake.
00:42:42 They continue to say that our case is moot because the debate's over, even though there
00:42:46 are broader press freedom issues that I think matter, constitutional freedoms.
00:42:51 That was in part the spirit that led to the creation of the Independent Press Gallery,
00:42:55 a gallery that is not closed off like the Parliamentary Press Gallery, is not limited
00:43:00 to people who live in Ottawa and work for mainstream media outlets, but is actually
00:43:04 a voice, a vessel, and a vehicle for independent journalists that aren't beholden to the government
00:43:10 to do their work.
00:43:11 And we were astonished at how controversial this idea seemed when we were going through
00:43:16 our ordeal throughout the election, but very grateful as the Independent Press Gallery
00:43:20 has launched to see all of the support from established journalists, freelance journalists,
00:43:24 from all varieties of publications around the country that have stepped forward, and many of
00:43:29 whom have actually come from around the country to be in attendance here at this media event,
00:43:35 which, as you know, will be followed by scrums with the candidates after. So you can find more
00:43:39 information about the organization at independentpressgallery.ca. I hope many of you are on
00:43:44 there watching the events we're doing right now, and I thank you very much for that. Now, as I
00:43:49 mentioned earlier, we've had to change things up a little bit. Instead of the debate that we had
00:43:54 initially planned, we're doing sit-down fireside chats with the two leadership candidates that
00:43:58 are here. And it's my great pleasure to welcome Conservative leadership candidate Aaron O'Toole
00:44:03 for a fireside chat here brought to you by the Independent Press Gallery.
00:44:09 Aaron, thank you very much. Thank you very much. Good to see you. Yes, we'll do the elbow bump from
00:44:14 afar there. Thank you very much for being here. It's truly appreciated. Well, thanks for doing
00:44:18 This is a great setup and looking forward to a great chat.
00:44:21 I thought you had a good chat with Derek, so ready to go.
00:44:24 When we launched the Independent Press Gallery, one of the things that we saw was a platform item from your campaign
00:44:31 that had pushed for not just recognition of the Independent Press Gallery in relation to the Parliamentary Press Gallery,
00:44:38 but broadly speaking, increased access to independent journalists at government events.
00:44:44 this isn't something that in 2020 you'd think would have to be in a leadership candidates
00:44:49 platform but it is so why was it important for you to include that and why do you think
00:44:53 we got to the place where something like that was needed well for a few years I've been talking
00:44:59 about the decline of free speech rights in Canada and cancel culture and taking down a statues and
00:45:06 a range of things and it's sad to see in a democracy that we would have to have the leadership
00:45:11 you guys have shown with the independent press gallery because parliament itself means to speak
00:45:16 parlement it hansard was published in the original parliament so that the constituents across canada
00:45:23 could see what was being debated in parliament so why would there be sort of a club-like mentality
00:45:30 for the press gallery if you actually look at their sort of guidelines and rules they don't
00:45:34 even seem to anticipate bloggers podcasters obviously not many canadians read hansard
00:45:40 anymore but a lot of them listen to podcasts read online blogs some of the great insightful
00:45:45 investigative reporting is now done by people who are primarily online and writing for alternative
00:45:52 outlets so we should in a democracy welcome as much coverage of the debates of the nation as
00:45:58 possible which is why in my platform I'm going to give full recognition to the independent press
00:46:03 gallery and really it's time to shake up a sort of out-of-date club in Ottawa and that's that's
00:46:10 what I'm going to do as prime minister. You've taken aim throughout your campaign at cancel
00:46:15 culture. You've spoken up about free speech. You've been criticized for only really recently
00:46:20 adopting this. See, people have said that you're just doing it because that's your niche in the
00:46:25 conservative leadership race. When was it that you first started to actually speak out and pay
00:46:30 attention to these issues? I had watched the decline of debates on university campuses for
00:46:36 some time and even when i would appear on a university campus um you know there would be
00:46:41 criticism from activist groups and almost wanting to suppress other opinions other than their own
00:46:47 cancel culture when i became very active andrew was when justin trudeau took the name of a father
00:46:53 of confederation off a building as a big symbolic act without any debate in parliament without any
00:47:00 discussion of who hector langevin was one of only two french canadian fathers of confederation who
00:47:06 attended all the conferences that led to Canada. He was removed, primarily because he was conservative,
00:47:11 by the way, with Sir George Etienne Cartier. And I challenged Trudeau on that. I didn't just
00:47:16 complain about it. I also said, you know what? Who opened more residential schools than Mr.
00:47:21 Langevin? Your father, Justin. A hundred years later, when the program was known to be problematic
00:47:27 and to really be destructive. So when I challenge cancel culture and this limitation of free speech,
00:47:35 I make sure I go in to win the debates.
00:47:37 I make sure I stand up for the things I believe in.
00:47:40 And I think Canadians are looking to this.
00:47:43 When I had cancel culture and the removal of statues in my launch video in January,
00:47:48 many members of the media and some conservatives in other camps mocked me for it.
00:47:54 A couple of weeks ago, Andrew, J.K. Rowling, Malcolm Gladwell, 150 authors from around the world,
00:48:00 said the same thing.
00:48:01 this online cancel culture driven by the left is impacting free speech, impacting the principles
00:48:09 that basically underscore our democracy. And it's time to stand up for them. I've been doing that
00:48:13 and as leader and prime minister, I will make that a key centerpiece of my leadership.
00:48:18 How do you defend against that when a lot of the things that you might speak out about are the very
00:48:23 things that get people canceled as the term goes? How do you then face the media in an election
00:48:29 campaign. How do you avoid getting sucked into that vortex that so many people on the right do
00:48:34 and actually get your message out if those are, by your own admission, the stakes of discourse in
00:48:39 2020? Well, you make sure you know what you're talking about and you make sure you plan. I don't
00:48:45 go into debates to lose them. I go in to win. In fact, I joke that my staff didn't want me. I went
00:48:52 on to campus two and a half years ago to debate Sir John A. MacDonald statues, an Indigenous
00:48:58 studies class, and my staff said, we may never see you alive again. But I went. And you know what?
00:49:05 I didn't win everyone over, but people heard the other side. You know, that principle of
00:49:10 Audi alder and partum I learned in law school, hear the other side. What's happening to that
00:49:14 in our society? Universities is where that used to be encouraged. Now it's being discouraged. And
00:49:20 there were people yelling at me for being there on unceded land and things like this.
00:49:24 but there were a group of people that listened
00:49:27 and I actually got positive feedback
00:49:29 from the professor who facilitated
00:49:30 the debate who I can tell you from his
00:49:32 Twitter feed is not a conservative
00:49:34 but he respected me
00:49:36 we need to bring respect
00:49:38 freedom of speech and the ability
00:49:41 for a conservative principle
00:49:42 to be articulated without fear
00:49:44 of cancel culture, without feel of
00:49:46 ridicule because that
00:49:48 makes our democracy better. Justin Trudeau
00:49:51 you have to have the same view
00:49:53 as him on all issues to be a part of his caucus. That's undemocratic. I think our diverse and
00:49:59 vibrant conservative movement with free votes, with freedom of speech, that makes our party
00:50:04 better because we're truly representative of many views across our country. And that's what a
00:50:10 parliamentary democracy should be. You've said very clearly that you are pro-choice, you're pro-gay 1.00
00:50:16 rights, yet you are not going so far as to say that everyone in your party has to be pro-choice,
00:50:21 that everyone in your caucus has to be.
00:50:23 To a lot of people who criticize social conservatives,
00:50:27 that is an indistinguishable position
00:50:29 from being a social conservative yourself.
00:50:32 And we saw this with Andrew Scheer, for example.
00:50:34 He was personally pro-life,
00:50:36 but had fundamentally the same position as you
00:50:38 on the sense that he wasn't going
00:50:39 to introduce any legislation.
00:50:41 He wasn't going to make any changes
00:50:43 to Canadian law on abortion.
00:50:46 So how do you fight back against really going down
00:50:49 the exact same road that the Conservatives have been down? Because I've been clear in my political
00:50:54 life since I was elected. I often say I'm not a career politician, so I don't have to go back to
00:50:58 the 1990s or 15 years ago to put speeches or votes I gave into context. When I left the military,
00:51:05 became a lawyer, and then ran for Parliament, I said I'm running to Parliament to defend Canadians'
00:51:09 rights. I'm not here to take away any rights granted by the court under the Charter or rights
00:51:14 that go back to the Magna Carta.
00:51:16 That's why I'm a strong proponent of free speech rights,
00:51:19 conscience protections,
00:51:21 and I don't like the increasing view on the left
00:51:23 that some rights are okay and other rights can be dismissed.
00:51:27 In a democracy like us, you have to respect all points of view
00:51:31 and be willing to defend all rights.
00:51:33 You know, that's what our soldiers have done throughout our history.
00:51:36 That's what our parliament is meant to do.
00:51:38 That's what Diefenbaker did with the Bill of Rights.
00:51:41 We have to defend those rights,
00:51:42 whether it's property rights of Canadians that have seen that right removed with an order of
00:51:48 council, no debate in the middle of a pandemic for firearms owners, or whether it's a conservative
00:51:53 who wants to express a point of view based on their faith. When did religious freedom become
00:51:57 a right we're not willing to stand up for in this country? I have concerns about what Justin Trudeau
00:52:03 is doing to democratic debates, political party organization, and really parliament in general,
00:52:08 and it fuels me. And what's great, Andrew, conservatives are a great, passionate, intelligent
00:52:14 bunch from coast to coast. We don't have to have the same view on all issues. We have to have
00:52:19 respect for one another. And that's why in my launch video, I said unity of the party is key
00:52:24 to me. It's why I launched in Alberta to speak to people that are giving up on our country
00:52:30 because they're so frustrated with Justin Trudeau. I said, let's make sure that Justin Trudeau does
00:52:35 not define canada our democracy defines canada let's defeat him and get our country back on track
00:52:42 but i'm not sure you really answered the fundamental crux of that question which is
00:52:46 that if your vision of the conservative party allows for people who do want to advance on
00:52:51 these issues or other issues that come up how will you as leader deflect against the campaign being
00:52:57 sidelined by that which to a lot of critics was what sidelined the conservative campaign in 2019
00:53:03 they say. And it may be that you dispute that premise, but you're going to be faced with those
00:53:07 same questions. So how will you deal with them? Well, look, Andrew Scheer is my good friend.
00:53:11 I think he realized he had some challenges in the last campaign, squaring off his personal
00:53:16 position and his personal views with how he would act as prime minister and leader of the party. I
00:53:21 do not. People know that I, you know, I'm a person of faith. I'm Catholic. My family, you know, we
00:53:28 believe in faith, and it's an important part of who we are. And as a parliamentarian, I've had
00:53:35 to square off the fact that my position on rights and my position as a conservative doesn't always
00:53:40 square with my faith tradition. I have voted consistently in favor of rights, even when I'm
00:53:47 just one of 18 conservatives that voted on an LGBT bill, for example. What was great? Stephen
00:53:53 Harper allowed a free vote on that. That's a principle of our party. And I wasn't hurt for
00:53:58 being in the minority position. I was promoted twice. Here's the kicker, Andrew. Justin Trudeau
00:54:04 skipped that vote to go to a Cash for Access fundraiser with his friends Dalton McGinty and
00:54:09 Kathleen Wynne. So they're not going to be able to trot out the age-old hidden agenda campaign with
00:54:14 me because I've been clear. And you know what? I'm going to defend free votes, defend free speech
00:54:21 as a principle of our party at a time that I think Canadians want to see that.
00:54:25 They don't want a cookie-cutter politician who has been a member of the We Board and the Liberal Party.
00:54:31 They want real debate. They want accountability. They want ethics. They want leadership.
00:54:36 And that's what they will have with Erin O'Toole as Prime Minister.
00:54:39 Throughout the Conservative leadership race, there have been two candidates disqualified.
00:54:43 One of them, Richard Desquerie. Another one, Jim Carahalios.
00:54:46 And the reason I bring those up is because your campaign had actually complained about Jim Carahalios' campaign in the race.
00:54:54 A lot of members have reached out to us wondering how you square on one hand being against cancel culture and being for free votes.
00:55:02 But on the other hand, seemingly supporting a position that denied the members the ultimate right to determine who their leader should be or who their candidates should be.
00:55:10 Well, we have a leadership election committee, the LEOC committee that decides.
00:55:14 We complained because Mr. Karajalios was lying, lying to thousands of Canadians about me and on issues that I'm very passionate about.
00:55:24 You know, when he's sending letters to people in our party suggesting I'm bringing Sharia law to Canada, Andrew, that's a lie.
00:55:31 And it's divisive. And more than that, I served in the military.
00:55:36 I know people that have died fighting the Taliban.
00:55:38 I will do whatever it takes to make sure that law or those cultural practices never come to Canada.
00:55:46 They're 180 degrees removed from what we are as a society.
00:55:52 So if you want to come and debate tax issues, economic issues, foreign policy, I love that.
00:56:00 When you just start sending out stuff that's completely fabricated, I think you have to be held to account.
00:56:06 so we have within the rules the ability to file that complaint it was the party that made the
00:56:11 decision and it's disappointing because i do think he probably has some perspective to contribute
00:56:18 but now we've seen this with the ontario pc party we've now seen with this with the federal party
00:56:23 uh let's have a good debate um i win debates i don't lose them but you can't lie you can't divide
00:56:29 canadians you can't mislead particularly on something like that um and so we had to connect
00:56:35 correct the record because once people get lists of thousands of peoples they they can send out
00:56:40 whatever they want reminds me of the old churchill quote a lie gets around the world before truth
00:56:46 gets its pants on so i had to make sure for the record my values as a strong conservative
00:56:53 particularly on law and order issues is fundamentally opposed to the the elements of
00:56:59 sharia law and people deserve to know that when you mentioned in that response canadian values
00:57:05 This has become a pivotal part of the discussion about immigration.
00:57:08 We know Stephen Harper had a great deal of backlash from the media, to go back to how
00:57:13 we started on media bias, for really suggesting that values should be a consideration in immigration.
00:57:19 We've seen under Justin Trudeau the problem of illegal immigration balloon.
00:57:24 How do you put forward your vision?
00:57:26 What is your vision if you're the conservative leader, if you're the prime minister on immigration?
00:57:31 Well, we have to fix the system.
00:57:33 Justin Trudeau allowed the system to become broken.
00:57:36 And even worse than that, Andrew,
00:57:38 now Canadians' confidence in our system has been undermined.
00:57:43 If I go into a Tim Hortons in my riding now,
00:57:45 I have people that have serious concerns about our system,
00:57:48 about our levels, all these sorts of things that didn't exist
00:57:51 seven years ago when I was elected and Jason Kenney was our minister.
00:57:54 We need a fair, compassionate, rules-based system.
00:57:59 So when people see 60,000 people walk across the road at Roxham Road, breaking the law, doing that, claiming asylum in an improper way, and nothing being done, and that surge starting after Trudeau's welcome to Canada tweet, within days, some of our consulates around the world sent notes back to Ottawa saying, look, the Prime Minister's got to clarify this ridiculous example of virtue signaling.
00:58:26 that's what he was doing he's done it many times because they were saying people feel this is a
00:58:33 change in our rules in canada and so in my riding i represent a riding in the greater toronto area
00:58:39 the most frustrated people from the whole rocks and road situation andrew were families waiting
00:58:45 longer and longer to sponsor a family member according to the rules they feel and i had
00:58:53 someone say this to me should i tell my relative to just go to new york state and walk across the
00:58:57 border what do i say to them no of course not that's not the way it's supposed to work but
00:59:02 justin trudeau's incompetence on this file now has some canadians questioning immigration we
00:59:08 need immigration in this country in fact we have a less than replacement birth rate so if people 1.00
00:59:13 like cpp and all of our our programs we need to have immigration it's good for canada but it's
00:59:19 good when it's fair, compassionate, rules-based. Same with refugees. The private sponsorship route 1.00
00:59:25 have better outcomes for families on housing, on jobs, on opportunity a year after they're here.
00:59:33 The government route has less successful outcomes, so it's unfair to the people that are coming. 1.00
00:59:40 So let's fix it. I've talked to Jason Kenney, who you know is supporting me quite a bit on these
00:59:45 issues i think we can show canadians we're going to get back on track and you know what defending
00:59:50 your border and actually having people respect the border is a fundamental element of our
00:59:55 sovereignty and it's okay to criticize trudeau's inaction we had a federal court decision just
01:00:02 recently that really called into question that safe third country agreement which has been used
01:00:07 to basically justify accepting or denying refugees or people that claim asylum at official ports of
01:00:14 entry and thus creating the rocks and road problem. With a federal court saying that this
01:00:20 agreement is no longer valid, that it violates the charter, how do you secure the border? How do you
01:00:25 protect people from gaming the system, taking advantage of the compassionate part and ignoring
01:00:31 the rules-based part? Because I agree when you say fix it, but I haven't heard what that fix is.
01:00:35 Well, first, I've read the decision. It's actually easy to fix what the judge called out. I don't
01:00:40 think it was a great decision to be honest with you but her concern was actually the incarceration
01:00:45 of the people once they went back to the United States. So Andrew I think I can actually fix that
01:00:50 as we renegotiate closing off the loophole in the safe third country agreement. So until we do that
01:00:57 she delayed the decision by six months anyway so it's not in effect. We may even be in government
01:01:02 within six months. We need to turn Roxham Road into a border stop and even temporarily
01:01:10 Once that's done, the loophole in the Safe Third Country Agreement is addressed.
01:01:15 You can then say, did you claim asylum in the first country you were in?
01:01:19 Yes.
01:01:20 You then cannot claim, you can't forum shop in claiming asylum.
01:01:25 So the temporary creation of a border stop there would fix this entirely.
01:01:31 I've been advocating for this for three years, Andrew.
01:01:34 And I do think we could, as part of our negotiations with the United States, to say, look, when we're returning people that cross illegally, we do not want them to go into this incarceration element for the offence because our court has questioned the safe third country agreement.
01:01:51 I think the U.S. want that treaty to be in place.
01:01:55 So if we can have a new approach for them to be returned under, that would fit within the spirit of the decision.
01:02:02 Right now, we're facing a major employment crisis in Canada. We have, in many cases, CBSA no longer doing removals, deportations. We know the list of people waiting for a hearing for their asylum claim is ballooning. Do you think we need a wholesale re-evaluation, whether it's a pause or a reduction or even just a back to basics, back to square one redrafting of our approach to immigration right now?
01:02:28 Well, I think as we're fixing the failures of the Trudeau government on this and addressing the Rocks and Road issue, which I've been talking about for several years, I think we can do a refresh to the system post-COVID, right?
01:02:41 Because some of the skills, the express entry program, the great approach that Jason Kenney had to fill productivity gaps in our economy, that's going to be slowed because of unemployment.
01:02:51 But here's a catch.
01:02:53 We know that one thing that was hurting families during COVID with the closure of daycares
01:02:57 and schools was childcare.
01:02:59 So can for a while we pivot to more family reunification, particularly if it helps solve
01:03:04 the care needs of a family or sometimes elderly care in the home, can we pivot while the economic
01:03:11 situation is sorting itself out in terms of employment levels, those sorts of things,
01:03:17 to make sure that the system adapts to the needs of the country?
01:03:21 That's what we should be doing.
01:03:22 We should not do things the way they were done 50 years ago just for the sake of doing it the same way.
01:03:29 We need to make sure that our system addresses the needs of Canada today, particularly post-COVID.
01:03:35 So I think there's actually a pivot we can do to more family reunification to help families get to work if there's prolonged school closures or something like that.
01:03:45 And then as we see the private sector recover, we should almost on an annual basis say, where are the gaps in our productivity in skilled trades in Ontario or, you know, when the resource sector comes back after we win, are there some gaps in Western Canada?
01:04:01 We should make sure the system is nimble enough to pivot to address those.
01:04:05 One of the things that most conservatives, I think, can agree on is that the carbon tax is a job killer.
01:04:10 I think this is something that everyone on the right tends to get, even many people not on the right.
01:04:15 you say in your platform that the carbon tax is gone you also say you want a national regulatory
01:04:21 and pricing scheme on industrial emitters and your rationale for this has been that you don't
01:04:26 want to target individual canadian families but rather target the companies themselves we all know
01:04:33 that any cost that a company has to bear gets filtered down so any tax that's put on a
01:04:38 manufacturer or distributor is something that canadians are paying so how can you say you're
01:04:42 against the carbon tax when your plan seems to just move the tax to another payer no there is
01:04:48 no tax there's no federal carbon tax i will eliminate the carbon tax completely andrew
01:04:54 what i've said in terms of the national framework we have to respect what the provinces are doing
01:05:00 now in bc there's been the their provincial carbon tax started by gordon campbell i've talked to him
01:05:07 about some of the challenges and problems that were caused but he explained to me his rationale
01:05:12 there quebec has a version of a cap and trade system alberta ontario my own province has a
01:05:17 large emitter strategy just working with emissions of the larger emitters we need to follow the
01:05:23 provinces here because guess what they have shared jurisdiction on the economy i've been saying this
01:05:28 for years the court of appeal in alberta in february just supported my view when they said
01:05:33 trudeau's carbon tax is unconstitutional we actually have to say on the federal government
01:05:39 How can we make sure we respect the different approach within a national framework
01:05:44 and say this is how we're going to reduce emissions?
01:05:47 Not with a tax, but with partnering with the provinces to get their emissions down.
01:05:52 But does your platform or does it not say pricing?
01:05:56 Because the provinces are pricing.
01:05:58 But you say national pricing.
01:05:59 So can you say that there is not going to be any federal price on carbon at a federal level for anyone,
01:06:06 whether it's a family or an industrial emitter the provinces will be in the driver's seat
01:06:11 so i will respect what they do look two great conservatives my friends jason kenny and doug
01:06:17 ford have large emitter approaches where they're stepping down through a price on carbon for
01:06:23 emitters what the provinces decide to do often with the cooperation of industry i will respect
01:06:31 and the national framework is because we are reporting a canadian response and we have to
01:06:38 recognize we have a confederation we have a national unity crisis because justin trudeau
01:06:43 doesn't understand that that's why the wexit movement is gaining steam because he has attacked
01:06:49 the ability for certain provinces to live to their economic potential i will respect that in
01:06:55 In fact, I will empower it.
01:06:57 My first 100 days is all natural resources.
01:06:59 But if they want to work on reducing emissions
01:07:03 and target working with and partnering with large emitters,
01:07:07 why should Ottawa get involved, Andrew?
01:07:09 We should say we are going to incorporate Alberta's approach
01:07:13 alongside Quebec's approach.
01:07:14 And we're not going to say this approach is bad
01:07:17 and this one is good.
01:07:18 We're going to say Canada's diverse economy.
01:07:20 We've got an offshore in Newfoundland and Labrador as well
01:07:23 that's in trouble now because of Trudeau.
01:07:25 We are going to try and make sure
01:07:27 that we have a national respected approach
01:07:29 that allows the provinces to lead.
01:07:32 But what if a province says
01:07:33 they don't want any part of it?
01:07:34 A provincial government in some provinces
01:07:36 we don't believe that we need to deal with emissions,
01:07:39 we don't believe in a carbon tax.
01:07:40 Does inaction fit into that national framework
01:07:43 if that's what a province chooses?
01:07:44 If that's what the province chooses, yes.
01:07:47 Look, we have to have a real climate change policy,
01:07:51 a real environmental policy in the next election.
01:07:53 If we don't, we lose. So the other candidates in the race aren't ready to run in an election this
01:07:59 fall anyway, but I don't think they realize I've knocked on doors in southern Ontario for two
01:08:04 elections now where this was an issue. We were seen as not having real policy. I'm going to make
01:08:10 sure we have real conservative approach so that when I say I'm killing the carbon tax, I'm going
01:08:16 to say here's what we're going to do. A lot of it will be partnering with the provinces, but can we
01:08:21 invest in carbon capture and sequestration as part of our solution particularly with some of
01:08:25 the provinces that still use coal for generating electricity uh nuclear energy i'm a big advocate of
01:08:32 greenhouse gas emission free you know the left they hate it because it's actually technology
01:08:37 that will allow us to have a productive economy the activists on the left they want to shut down
01:08:42 our economy i want to grow our economy particularly the resource economy that has given us this rich
01:08:48 wealthy and respected nation we're actually the best producer of all the goods we produce because
01:08:54 of our human rights record our rule of law our indigenous engagement we don't need anyone 1.00
01:08:59 including the un telling us what to do we are the world leader in environmental social governance
01:09:06 i will i will empower that and at the same time i will show canadians i am very pro development
01:09:13 and resource oil and gas you know forestry agriculture and we're going to have substantive
01:09:20 policies that will reduce emissions without disrupting the economy it's difficult 0.90
01:09:27 but attacks is what the liberals do because it's easy and dumb we are going to do smart policy
01:09:33 and canadians that care about the environment will know the conservatives will have a plan that
01:09:37 that will reduce emissions without them losing their job.
01:09:41 Fiscal management is going to be a huge problem in Canada
01:09:44 as we look at what the next government is going to have inherited.
01:09:49 We have deficits that are rising even beyond what they were before.
01:09:53 The Justin Trudeau approach was that when the economy is great,
01:09:55 it's time to spend, and when the economy is bad, it's time to spend.
01:09:58 How do you balance the budget?
01:10:00 How do you get the books in check without having to raise taxes
01:10:05 or without having to cut spending or how do you accomplish all of those things that
01:10:09 conservatives want to do financially well you're right world did change i thought we were dealing
01:10:14 with a 25 billion dollar deficit when we launched uh our campaign in alberta in january which was
01:10:20 terrible enough because we had good economic times strong employment numbers trudeau was raising
01:10:25 taxes and still running huge deficits so is this the guy that's going to dig us out of this hole
01:10:31 he got us in the hole so our approach has to learn the lessons from jim flaherty and and
01:10:36 stephen harper have a plan to get the balance keeping taxes low over a timeline and be disciplined
01:10:44 and stick to it now do you mean personal corporate or both both in fact andrew small businesses
01:10:50 we're probably going to have to provide more tax relief i want to bring back the elements
01:10:55 for small businesses that justin trudeau took away with his war on small business 70 roughly
01:11:01 of canadians work for small and medium-sized enterprise 70 why do we have high unemployment
01:11:07 and we'll likely have it coming out of covet trudeau didn't save many jobs he put everyone
01:11:12 on the serve so i'm actually going to work with small businesses and over the next few years
01:11:18 we actually may have to provide some tax relief to small businesses and maybe seniors on pension
01:11:24 income because of tight circumstances for many of them but we can do that stephen harper did it he
01:11:30 took a five-year program to to do it after the 2009 recession ours will likely be longer but i
01:11:36 think if canadians know that we are doing it for the long-term prosperity of the country they will
01:11:41 be with us but the key part of my plan andrew is taxes low a plan to balance over a period of time
01:11:49 but a private sector renaissance we need to eliminate the anti-development programs of
01:11:54 justin trudeau we need to renegotiate uh trade arrangements with the united states we need a
01:12:00 softwood lumber agreement we need fair trade amongst free countries free trade with democracies
01:12:06 and start taxing or tariffing the bad actors like the chinas of the world and canada needs to help 0.98
01:12:12 lead that process. We're not even at the table with Trudeau. Every country he's interacted with
01:12:19 as Prime Minister, our relationship with that country is worse. Every single one. As foreign 1.00
01:12:25 affairs critic for the Conservatives, I meet with them. They would often say to me behind closed
01:12:30 doors, Andrew, what has happened to Canada? Right now, after five years of Trudeau, we are poorer
01:12:37 and weaker at home and less respected around the world.
01:12:40 That is why I'm ready to go in September to hold them to account
01:12:44 and win an election that could come in the next few months.
01:12:47 We need to get our country back on track.
01:12:49 We need to take it back from an ideological, out-of-touch government
01:12:54 that has our future prosperity at risk.
01:12:57 You've been a big proponent of CANZUK,
01:13:00 which is an agreement for those that can't decipher it from the letters
01:13:03 that would really put Canada in a special partnership with Australia, New Zealand, the United Kingdom.
01:13:08 Is that really where you think the future of trade needs to be,
01:13:11 which is to trade with the countries most like you,
01:13:15 which really seems to be putting a values assessment onto trade agreements?
01:13:20 Or do you think that's a unique relationship outside of broader free trade policies
01:13:24 with countries around the world, like we saw from the Harper government in which you were a minister?
01:13:29 The answer is a bit of both.
01:13:30 Kanzuk is very special.
01:13:33 Look, you know, my sister married an Australian fighter pilot.
01:13:36 She met when I was in the military, and he was on exchange with Canada.
01:13:39 We have fought and died together with these countries.
01:13:42 We're in the Five Eyes security partnership with them already,
01:13:45 our closest relationship.
01:13:47 So we should be doing more.
01:13:49 In fact, Prime Minister Johnson is talking to Australia and New Zealand now
01:13:52 about more trade, more capital sharing,
01:13:55 more exchange of people and ideas between some of the closest countries.
01:13:59 Where's Canada?
01:14:00 Of course, Trudeau and Morneau, I think, was in Kenya on a we trip.
01:14:05 He wasn't actually at the meetings with some of our closest partners.
01:14:09 So we have to be there.
01:14:11 Beyond that, I do think when you say free and fair trade amongst free countries, it's not just Commonwealth or our traditional close allies.
01:14:20 Japan, our relationship with Japan, an important trade partner, is in the doldrums after Trudeau.
01:14:25 He skipped a leaders' meeting for the Trans-Pacific Partnership meetings to meet with Facebook rather than to meet with other world leaders.
01:14:34 All of our relationships have deteriorated.
01:14:37 India, the world's largest democracy, a commonwealth partner, many of the same systems in terms of parliament and rule of law.
01:14:44 There's more we can be doing there.
01:14:46 We literally doubled trade with India under Harper.
01:14:49 We all remember the state visit Justin Trudeau paid there.
01:14:52 You know, could flash a few photos on the screen to remind people of his trip.
01:14:56 They slapped tariffs on Canadian lentils right after that.
01:15:00 We've had Italy tariff Durham wheat after ridiculous comments Trudeau made about Italian and Greek immigrants to Canada.
01:15:08 So we have to repair a lot of these relationships.
01:15:11 And while Kanzuk will be a very unique one, I see doing more with Japan, India especially, a growing and important partner.
01:15:19 France, a lot of our partners in Europe.
01:15:21 I think we need the democratic world to stop allowing the bad actors of the world, the China, the Russia, the Venezuela, Saudi Arabia, to game the UN, to game the WTO.
01:15:35 We see the results.
01:15:37 The countries that play by the rules lose.
01:15:39 So the democracies have to start standing up.
01:15:42 I've been talking about this for several years.
01:15:43 I ran on UN reform and holding back our dues when I ran in the 2017 leadership.
01:15:49 leadership. Now, I think we're ready to win and implement these as prime minister.
01:15:56 Just as we wind down here, do you feel that you have pivoted in some way from your 2017 run? Or
01:16:02 do you think that you're talking about a lot of the same issues? And if it is the latter,
01:16:06 what makes you think that they're going to resonate this time?
01:16:09 I have not pivoted. You know, the media loves to say, you know, O'Toole's very different. Almost
01:16:14 all my policy is the same. What has changed? Justin Trudeau has divided this country to the
01:16:20 point that people are giving up on it. My first rally in Nisku, Alberta, back when we could have
01:16:25 rallies, the first question, I always take Q&A from my audience, was a veteran who stood up and
01:16:32 said, thank you for your service, Aaron. I served almost 30 years from my country, and I want to
01:16:36 leave it now after what Trudeau's done to my province. Wow. I agree with what Derek said.
01:16:42 most canadians don't know how tenuous our national unity is a reporter in the press gallery when i
01:16:49 said my main priority will be unity he kind of said well some of the issues they have out west
01:16:54 aren't valid that's part of the problem we've got a laurentian elite ottawa bubble and they don't
01:17:02 realize that our country is at risk after an ideological trudeau government that fuels me
01:17:08 am i more passionate and and frustrated this time than in 2017 absolutely because of what
01:17:14 justin trudeau done to a country that i believe in that i'm proud of i'm a patriot some campuses
01:17:21 that would be a bad word these days i think a lot of canadians want someone that's going to put
01:17:26 our interest at the front of the agenda make it make people proud of our history and our country
01:17:33 um i'm hearing that everywhere i go years ago when i was talking about sir johnny mcdonald's
01:17:38 statues i would get notes from people saying thank goodness someone is standing up to this
01:17:44 cancel culture type approach that's what i will do as leader and i can't stress it enough if we
01:17:50 allow the we scandal the out of control situation with our economy all of this if we don't have a
01:17:56 leader in the house this fall we miss the opportunity to replace a corrupt and incompetent
01:18:02 government. I'm ready to go and I'm ready to unite the party and win. We promised you a debate and we
01:18:08 told you and your team that there would be an opportunity for a closing statement in that and
01:18:12 with all the changes I think we can keep the closing statement. So if you want to give us
01:18:16 people are putting their ballots forward in the next couple of weeks that final pitch please.
01:18:21 Well thanks. I love a good debate so I regret that but I respect my colleagues in this race.
01:18:26 I want their help as we rebuild and take back Canada from a government with Justin Trudeau that has their own personal interests ahead of the national interests.
01:18:37 I'm ready to win.
01:18:38 And Conservatives across the country need to know that there's a true blue Conservative that has won three times in the GTA where we need to win seats here in southern Ontario.
01:18:49 If we win just most of what Doug Ford won two years ago in Ontario, we will form a strong, stable, majority Conservative government.
01:18:57 I'm asking for the trust of members of our party to make sure we keep our movement united, grow it where we need to, and win the next election by standing up for the things we believe in.
01:19:10 I'm a leader that's ready, in the House now, and I bring experience from outside of Ottawa at a time we need it.
01:19:16 12 years in the Canadian Armed Forces.
01:19:19 I lived across the country.