Juno News - August 24, 2020


Conservative Leadership Results Show

Topics
Mentioned
Here's what we learned from the WE documents Diluting Conservatism vs. Selling Conservatism

Episode Stats


Length

8 hours and 43 minutes

Words per minute

166.93

Word count

87,420

Sentence count

3,242

Harmful content

Misogyny

47

sentences flagged

Toxicity

18

sentences flagged

Hate speech

12

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Candace and Andrew are joined by True North Fellow Andrew Lawton to discuss the results of the Conservative leadership vote, which will be announced at 6:40pm ET tonight. Candace is joined by her co-host, Andrew, to talk all things leadership and what we can expect from tonight's show.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Thank you.
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 Thank you.
00:01:30 Thank you.
00:02:00 Thank you.
00:02:30 Thank you.
00:03:00 Thank you.
00:03:30 Thank you.
00:04:00 Thank you.
00:04:30 Thank you.
00:05:00 Thank you.
00:05:30 Thank you.
00:06:00 Thank you.
00:06:30 Thank you.
00:07:00 Thank you.
00:07:30 Thank you.
00:08:00 Thank you.
00:08:30 Thank you.
00:09:00 Thank you.
00:09:30 Thank you.
00:10:00 Thank you.
00:10:30 Thank you.
00:11:00 Thank you.
00:11:30 Thank you.
00:12:00 Thank you.
00:12:30 Thank you.
00:13:00 Thank you.
00:13:30 Thank you.
00:14:00 Thank you.
00:14:30 Thank you.
00:15:00 Thank you.
00:15:30 Thank you.
00:16:00 Thank you.
00:16:30 Thank you.
00:17:00 Thank you.
00:17:30 Thank you.
00:18:00 Thank you.
00:18:30 Thank you.
00:19:00 Thank you.
00:19:30 Thank you.
00:20:00 Thank you.
00:20:30 Thank you.
00:21:00 Thank you.
00:21:30 Thank you.
00:22:00 Thank you.
00:22:30 Thank you.
00:23:00 Thank you.
00:23:30 Thank you.
00:24:00 Thank you.
00:24:30 Thank you.
00:25:00 Thank you.
00:25:30 Thank you.
00:26:00 Thank you.
00:26:30 One of the undeniable
00:27:00 Thank you.
00:27:30 Thank you.
00:28:00 Thank you.
00:28:30 Thank you.
00:29:00 Thank you.
00:29:30 Thank you.
00:30:00 Thank you.
00:30:30 Hi, we're live.
00:30:57 I'm Candace Malcolm. Welcome to a very special edition of True North Live.
00:31:01 I'm joined by my co-host, my friend, True North fellow, Andrew Lawton.
00:31:04 Andrew, thank you so much for being here.
00:31:06 Hey, it's an exciting night after months of the race. I'm glad we're doing this.
00:31:10 Yeah, I know. I woke up and I was like, you know, I know it's Sunday, but I feel like it's a work day.
00:31:15 Like, it's just a really exciting time. We've been following this campaign all summer.
00:31:19 And finally, I mean, you know, you see a total ruinous dumpster fire, to be quite frank,
00:31:24 over in Ottawa with the Prime Minister just going completely rogue with the Wee scandal,
00:31:29 firing his Vance Minister, proroguing Parliament.
00:31:32 This is a total gong show over there.
00:31:34 And, you know, it's about time that the opposition, which is really supposed to be the government
00:31:38 in waiting, has a leader, has a torchbearer to take them to that next stage.
00:31:43 So, Andrew, it's a big night tonight.
00:31:45 What can we expect from the Conservative show tonight?
00:31:49 So the Conservative Party of Canada's official show kicks off in just under half an hour.
00:31:54 And they're going to be having a number of speeches from some of the people in the party,
00:31:59 such as outgoing Conservative leader Andrew Scheer, the party's executive director,
00:32:04 the co-chairs of the leadership committee.
00:32:07 And then they're going to get to the real star of the evening, which is the results.
00:32:10 So after months of campaigning, millions of dollars raised and spent,
00:32:15 four candidates in the running, Peter McKay, Aaron O'Toole, Derek Sloan, and Leslyn Lewis.
00:32:20 And we don't know how many rounds of balloting there are going to be.
00:32:23 It is a ranked ballot, and I know that we'll have an explanation of the rules later on.
00:32:28 But ultimately, the party is hoping to have results start coming at around 6.40 Eastern time.
00:32:33 So that's just over an hour from now.
00:32:35 But we're going to have some analysis, some thoughts before then,
00:32:38 and talking to some of the candidates' campaign teams,
00:32:41 and ultimately really trying to contextualize what's going to be happening tonight.
00:32:45 Yeah, that's right.
00:32:46 So Andrew and I will be with you all night.
00:32:48 We'll go to the Conservative feed whenever, you know, they're announcing results
00:32:52 and whenever they have speeches and then in between if there's any downtime you'll get to
00:32:56 hear some you know analysis from andrew and myself trying to make sense of it all put the pieces
00:33:01 together and giving you really a conservative perspective on on what's going on you know
00:33:06 i've read so many stories andrew in the mainstream media on the cbc and other networks trying to
00:33:11 kind of understand and and and explain this leadership race and i feel like it's not very
00:33:17 authentic just because you know give me a break no one over at the cbc is is a conservative member
00:33:22 they're not voting they're not really insiders in the same way uh as as we as true north you know
00:33:27 most of us over here are conservatives i think some of us are even members i'm not personally but
00:33:32 i know that some some of the staff over at true north have definitely voted in this campaign and
00:33:38 have a lot a lot at stake are really excited so um i think you caught up with uh each of the
00:33:43 campaigns uh so we'll play some interviews as well and andrew let's let's start with your first
00:33:48 interview you got to sit down with uh lisa rate and chat a little bit about what's going on tonight 0.97
00:33:54 and joining me on the line now a woman who's done this before on both ends organizing the 0.99
00:33:59 race and actually running in the race as well looking back to the 2017 campaign lisa rate also
00:34:04 a former cabinet member lisa thanks very much for coming on tonight let me ask how is it for you
00:34:09 sitting on on the side of the table you're on now as a co-chair of leoc instead of a candidate this
00:34:14 time around i guess i'm a lot less nervous than i was the night of i don't have to give a speech
00:34:21 um but sadly what i'm missing is the big spectacle i'm missing the ballroom full of people remember
00:34:29 friends actually don't always follow each other in these leadership debates so we may have friends
00:34:34 that go to one campaign or another and but when he came together at the very end you're all a member
00:34:39 of the conservative team so i'm kind of missing that moment where we all kind of put down our
00:34:43 arms because it's over and then we we come into one room together to line up behind the new leader
00:34:49 there may not be a ballroom full of people this time around but we do have a huge conservative
00:34:53 family in this race more than any other conservative race past as far as number of
00:34:58 members what do you think that is really attributed to because i find it odd with fewer candidates
00:35:04 and a shorter campaign that there are just so many ballots cast this time around compared to
00:35:09 the last race well frankly with covet 19 there wasn't a lot else going on in entertainment wise
00:35:16 first of all so we we provide a good content if you're a conservative and you are unhappy with
00:35:21 what justin trudeau is doing in ottawa you are tuning in to see who is going to be the next
00:35:27 leader and you probably got a little bit engaged and here's the other thing that i find really
00:35:31 interesting that we should take lessons from coming out of COVID. Gone are the days when
00:35:36 candidates would have to fly around the country every single weekend and hit every small town
00:35:41 because if you didn't go to that small town, you were going to be penalized for not coming in and
00:35:46 seeing the constituents. Now it's just a Zoom call away. It's a Skype meeting. It's a Google
00:35:52 meetup kind of situation. So I believe the constituents of the Conservative Party actually
00:35:58 got better outreach from these candidates because we were all kind of stuck with doing it from the
00:36:03 comfort of our own living rooms. I think that accounts for more money raised because you didn't
00:36:08 have to go buy a ticket. You can just write the check yourself or send your email transfer. And
00:36:12 it also accounts for the number of memberships. I mean, you were part of the entire process.
00:36:18 Now, mainstream media didn't cover it, but that's okay. They were looking for those spectacles,
00:36:23 whereas we just got down to business.
00:36:25 The committee that you're co-chairing that's been really steering the race from the get-go,
00:36:30 Leoc, has had to make some tough calls as a result of the pandemic as far as timing is concerned.
00:36:36 This is a fair bit more delayed than the original plan was.
00:36:40 Do you think that there is going to be enough time for the next leader to really hunker down
00:36:43 and really get prepared and set up a team and get that machine in motion for when the fall comes around?
00:36:49 I do. I do. I think all four candidates have already expressed the fact that they do believe unity is important, that they've expressed their vision very clearly.
00:37:00 They've had great teams in all of their campaigns that have been ushering them along extremely well.
00:37:05 So I'm not really concerned about transition. I'm not concerned about people getting their feet underneath them.
00:37:10 And quite frankly, as you point out, Andrew, there's a very big conservative family out there who's willing to pitch in to help the new leader get off on the right foot and to continue to lead this party into being the next the next government.
00:37:23 I know you've had to maintain neutrality throughout the race, but what do you think the real stories have been that have stood out to you about this campaign?
00:37:31 it's a really good question i i do believe as i said that this was a very different campaign
00:37:37 for somebody like a derek sloan or a leslin lewis because you didn't need to have name
00:37:42 recognition in order to connect through zoom because people knew you were running
00:37:46 and then you could just dial in of your of your own volition on anything that you wanted to dial
00:37:51 in on and then make up your own mind without being in a room with all kinds of people and hearing
00:37:57 other people chatter in your ear i i think it was a really great opportunity for those who may not
00:38:03 have as big a name recognition in the party or in canada to equal the level playing field well i
00:38:09 know you've got to get to it that's starting just at 6 p.m eastern so coming up very quickly lisa
00:38:14 rate thank you so much for your time and for your work throughout the course of the race
00:38:18 my pleasure andrew thank you for covering it all so very well that's very kind
00:38:22 and so obviously a lot of work goes into these leadership races and you know andrew and i were
00:38:30 talking before we went live about you know what were really the big moments of this campaign what
00:38:35 were the defining moments what were the the times that changed people's minds and really defined
00:38:39 who a candidate was to the conservative members and just because of the nature of this campaign
00:38:44 run you know social distance through covet 19 it's just been a totally different kind of campaign
00:38:50 And like Lisa said, sort of an equalizer for some of the lesser known candidates, for the candidates that don't have the big budget, because everyone had access to the same venues, which were, you know, Zoom meetings and the ability to meet with people all over the country without having to pay for flights and hotels and all of that expensive stuff that goes into campaigning.
00:39:10 So it really has been an interesting campaign. Anything is possible. To me, the big moment,
00:39:17 the big story from this campaign has been the emergence of Leslyn Lewis. She was a very unknown 0.55
00:39:23 candidate, even among conservatives. Most people had never heard of her. But she had this really, 0.98
00:39:29 really charismatic star power. And she maintained, she had this ability to last throughout the 0.79
00:39:35 campaign, even with mainstream media that frankly ignored her, didn't pay much attention to her. 0.69
00:39:40 she really shined, lasted all the way to the end of the campaign. Andrew, you caught up with
00:39:45 someone from Leslyn Lewis's campaign, so let's hear that interview now.
00:39:51 One of the undeniable success stories of the campaign, regardless of the result, has been
00:39:56 Leslyn Lewis's rise from being a political unknown to a major player in this race. Her campaign
00:40:01 manager, Steve Outhouse, joins me on the line now. Steve, good to talk to you. Thanks for coming on
00:40:05 today. Hey, great to be here. Thanks, Andrew. You know, there were better known people with
00:40:10 in the party that couldn't even make it on the ballot as far as getting the money and signatures
00:40:14 in. What do you attribute Lesley Lewis's rise through this race to? Well, she had the courage
00:40:21 to get out there and she worked hard every step of the way. And I do believe she's just a special
00:40:27 candidate that a lot of people connected with and resonated with her message and they got excited
00:40:32 about it as she went. It was a faster pace of fundraising and support that I've ever seen on
00:40:37 any campaign i've been a part of i still don't have a perfect answer is what you're attributed
00:40:41 all to but i believe it starts with just the candidate and people connecting with her
00:40:45 i know a lot of people early on were looking at her as being a social conservative contender but
00:40:52 one of the more unique stories i've seen is how many people from across the spectrum even
00:40:56 people that might be peter mckay supporters are saying they're putting her second or
00:41:00 erin o'toole supporters that say they're putting her second and really a broad base of appeal that
00:41:05 doesn't seem to be ideologically pigeonholed. Was that an intentional part of strategy for you,
00:41:11 or is that just something that happened organically on the campaign?
00:41:14 Well, it's a bit of both, but it is definitely, it's who Luslin is. And for people like myself,
00:41:21 who often get branded as social conservatives, yes, we are, I guess, by that definition,
00:41:25 a social conservative, but we're more than that. We're conservatives, we're fiscal conservatives,
00:41:30 we're libertarians, we're people who want to see government generally having less involvement in
00:41:35 the day-to-day lives of individuals and letting freedom reign. And so Dr. Lewis is someone who
00:41:42 put herself forward as, yes, I am a social conservative. I'm going to be very open about
00:41:46 those views, but I have a broader agenda than that. And I think that that gave people a lot
00:41:50 of comfort and they were comfortable marking her second and in many cases marking her first,
00:41:55 even if they wouldn't have seen themselves as supporting a social conservative candidate when
00:42:00 this all began. I guess I would just put it she is a leadership candidate who is a social
00:42:05 conservative as opposed to a social conservative who is a leadership candidate. This week we had
00:42:11 that viral clip of an interview with Andrew Scheer on CBC in which the topic of the coverage and
00:42:17 attention that the Lewis campaign has received was called into question and basically the point
00:42:22 that Andrew Scheer has made is that you know CBC wasn't really following this story as much as it
00:42:26 was focusing on kamala harris in the u.s for example do you think that the story of what
00:42:32 leslund lewis's candidacy represents has been told uh i don't think fully no and and i'll say
00:42:38 like so i i was certainly at the beginning of this race covid took over the media coverage on on
00:42:43 everything and so i i know for dr lewis and myself and there were interview requests that came in for
00:42:49 sure and so she did i don't want to come down and kind of be completely like say something to the
00:42:54 effect, she's not had any coverage. She has had coverage. And we've had even interview requests
00:42:58 that we haven't been able to do. So it's not like there's been no coverage of her. But I do think
00:43:03 in the past, you know, whatever, it's been a week to 10 days since Kamala Harris has been named,
00:43:08 you know, vice president or the vice presidential candidate on the Biden ticket.
00:43:14 That has sort of put things into pretty sharp, you know, distinction, I guess, or we can see
00:43:21 there really wasn't that same amount of buzz it was one thing to say well there hasn't been a lot
00:43:26 of coverage on the cpc leadership race overall because of covid or there hasn't been a lot of
00:43:30 coverage on her because perhaps she's you know not seen as one of the purported front runners
00:43:35 but it was just very interesting to contrast that with what we've seen since kamala harris has come
00:43:39 on the ticket i don't know if you can answer this question but i'll put it to you anyway
00:43:43 if she's not successful is she around for the long haul in the party running again as a candidate
00:43:49 Yeah, that's certainly her plan.
00:43:50 I mean, she has said that she would be looking to run in the next election.
00:43:53 And there's been a lot of people asking questions about which rioting and so on.
00:43:57 And all those will start to be looked at after today's results come out.
00:44:02 But, yes, that is her plan.
00:44:04 She, I think, is going to be a very powerful voice in the Conservative movement in Canada for, I believe, years to come.
00:44:11 And on the note of the results, what do you think is going to happen tonight?
00:44:13 I'm not going to make any predictions.
00:44:15 I'm as interested as anybody to see what happens.
00:44:17 I mean, we've certainly worked hard as a team.
00:44:19 We've left no stone unturned, and, you know, we're working towards a win.
00:44:24 We still see that there is a path there, but obviously there's other campaigns working hard to help their candidate win as well.
00:44:31 So we've got some great candidates, and we'll all learn the results soon.
00:44:36 Steve Outhouse, campaign manager for Leslyn Lewis.
00:44:39 Thank you so much for coming on tonight.
00:44:40 Thanks for having me, Andrew.
00:44:41 it was a really interesting way of putting it that uh leslie lewis is a social conservative 0.98
00:44:49 but that didn't really define her throughout this race and you know it's true that she appealed to 0.99
00:44:54 a broader range of people even even people who just wanted to try something different uh have
00:44:58 something different not a queer politician per se uh leading the helm and i i think that there
00:45:04 was a lot of energy not not so much that the mainstream media paid attention to it andrew as
00:45:08 noted in that interview there was a super viral video uh from i think it was from yesterday the
00:45:14 day before of andrew sheer just sort of on the cbc telling it like it is saying you know the reason
00:45:19 that uh they're they're the media doesn't think that there's a lot of energy around less than
00:45:23 loses because they're not really paying attention to the campaign and for people who are i mean
00:45:28 less than lewis released her fundraising figures she raised two million dollars which is incredibly
00:45:33 impressive there obviously is a lot of energy and you know i'm glad that uh her campaign manager
00:45:39 there again just sort of said as it is you know inside the conservative world inside people who
00:45:44 who pay attention they are very excited about less than lewis despite what organizations like
00:45:49 the cbc who like to like to ignore what's happening in service circles especially when there's a good
00:45:54 news story like this true north had a report that came out last week that found that there was 500
00:45:59 percent more headlines about kamala harris who has literally nothing to do with canada other
00:46:04 the fact that she went to high school in montreal uh and yet you know they're covering her left
00:46:09 right and center and hardly giving any coverage to someone who could potentially become prime
00:46:12 minister of our country yeah and at the very least even if she doesn't win the candidacy itself
00:46:19 is the story i i think and i i think you're bang on there when you talk about just the the double
00:46:24 standard that's really dogged that campaign throughout the course of it as far as the
00:46:28 mainstream media is concerned. Well, I was happy to hear Steve say that she was in it for the long
00:46:34 haul. So even if she doesn't win tonight, she will continue to be involved with the party
00:46:39 and run as an MP in the next election. That was an array of good news that I heard from that
00:46:46 interview. What was your sort of takeaway? What was your biggest moments of this campaign, Andrew,
00:46:52 aside from the emergence of Lesley Lewis?
00:46:55 I really think it was seeing how the candidates navigated the media environment.
00:47:01 I mean, we saw a real contrast there.
00:47:03 Aaron O'Toole going to war with CBC in an interview.
00:47:06 Derek Sloan deliberately not doing a lot of mainstream media interviews, as one example.
00:47:12 Peter McKay focusing exclusively on mainstream media interviews.
00:47:17 Because I think if we are talking about the leadership race as a model for the next election,
00:47:21 seeing those different media strategies is, I think, very noteworthy.
00:47:26 That's a good point.
00:47:26 And, I mean, it is something true, again, to just go back to that interview you just did with Steve Outhouse,
00:47:32 where he said that she wasn't really defined as being a social conservative.
00:47:35 And that is a problem for conservatives in this country going forward,
00:47:39 not so much that it's something that Canadians care about, but it's something that the media really obsesses about.
00:47:44 And so one of the things I would sort of not worry about, but I would be a little hesitant about,
00:47:48 is if someone like Lesley Lewis was leader
00:47:51 and went into an election against Justin Trudeau,
00:47:53 they would just spend the entire time criticizing her
00:47:56 because of her position on abortion. 1.00
00:47:59 And the media and the liberals would try to define her that way.
00:48:03 And she did a good job explaining it and discussing it on the campaign trail.
00:48:07 But again, the media is just so awful and biased in this country
00:48:11 that you know they're going to try to set the agenda like that.
00:48:13 So it was interesting to see how Lesley Lewis described herself
00:48:18 and was able to talk about other things aside from that one issue,
00:48:22 which obviously, Andrew, is a very important issue,
00:48:24 but it's not the only issue.
00:48:26 And at a time like this, when the country is in record debt
00:48:30 and in a complete depth of an economic disaster
00:48:34 partially caused by our own government,
00:48:36 there's a lot more that you want to discuss and talk about
00:48:39 other than someone's position on something like that.
00:48:42 Well, you also caught up with someone from Derek Sloan's campaign
00:48:47 or someone who is a supporter of Derek Sloan
00:48:49 and someone who worked with Derek Sloan.
00:48:51 So let's go to that interview now.
00:48:53 Joining me now is Tanya Granik-Allen,
00:48:56 former Ontario PC leadership candidate
00:48:58 and someone who's actually been on the road
00:49:00 doing last minute get out the vote work
00:49:02 with Derek Sloan in the last few days
00:49:04 across Southern Ontario.
00:49:06 Tanya, thanks for coming on today.
00:49:08 Thanks for having me, Andrew.
00:49:09 Great to be on.
00:49:10 Derek's been unabashed about running
00:49:12 as a social conservative.
00:49:14 You've been, as I mentioned earlier,
00:49:16 You're on the road talking to a lot of Derek Sloan voters at stops around Ontario.
00:49:20 Do you think that his supporters are just social Conservatives,
00:49:23 or is there a broader base of support that you think he's tapped into in this race?
00:49:28 You know, I think a lot of people early on wanted to pigeonhole Derek
00:49:31 and the type of supporter he would attract.
00:49:34 However, based on touring 12 cities and 48 hours with him,
00:49:38 you had a broad spectrum of Conservatives coming out to meet Derek.
00:49:41 I think because Derek was so genuine and he's authentic in his word, people who are fiscal
00:49:47 conservatives, social conservatives, libertarians, people who just wanted the straight goods would
00:49:53 come out and listen to Derek and said, hey, you know what, I've got, I'm throwing my support behind
00:49:58 you. In fact, at one tour stop, there was a woman who wasn't even a member of the party and she came
00:50:03 out with her daughter, socially distanced, of course, and she said, you know, I just want to
00:50:06 say I support your policy on no mandatory masking. I don't even know if I support the rest of you.
00:50:12 I'm not even a member, but I just want to say thank you so much for standing up for me and my
00:50:15 family. You've done the leadership race before. You know, it's a fair bit grueling. What's your
00:50:22 read, not even as a member of Derek Sloan's team, of just how he's done and how he's risen to this
00:50:27 challenge in the last several months? Well, early on, you know, I was assessing all the candidates
00:50:31 and I was an early endorser of Derek, and now towards the end,
00:50:36 clearly I was the only candidate I ended up endorsing.
00:50:40 I thought he, you know, at first I was like, okay, he's very young,
00:50:43 he's a newly elected MP, but quickly he got his footing.
00:50:46 And again, it's a very unusual campaign with COVID,
00:50:49 with not being able to get out in front of people,
00:50:51 but clearly that's one of his strengths is when he connects with the voter,
00:50:55 speaks to them, looks them in the eye, they see that he's the real deal.
00:50:58 He's really authentic and something that attracted me to him early on.
00:51:02 And, you know, when you're speaking to Derek, he's not going to deviate.
00:51:05 What he says is really what he means and what he's going to do.
00:51:09 Yeah, that whole idea that we heard was conservative without apology.
00:51:14 That was the cornerstone, I think, message of Derek Sloan's campaign.
00:51:18 And that has been a very consistent one.
00:51:20 Do you think that message itself is one that at this point in time is really needed in the Conservative Party
00:51:25 or even more broadly, the conservative movement?
00:51:29 Absolutely.
00:51:30 I think many of us who consider ourselves small-c conservatives
00:51:35 or members of the Conservative Party are sick and tired
00:51:38 of seeing our leadership bow down to the politically correct,
00:51:42 to the political elite, to others.
00:51:45 You know, I'm a card-carrying member of the Conservative Party,
00:51:47 so to the liberal bullies, Big L, Little L,
00:51:51 I think we're sick and tired of the apologies.
00:51:53 If we believe we have the right message and the true message, why would we apologize?
00:51:57 And what is that message?
00:51:58 It's standing up for freedoms in Canada, standing up for our charters of rights and freedoms,
00:52:03 standing up for those God-given freedoms.
00:52:06 And I think that's something that one should never apologize for.
00:52:08 In fact, they should stand proudly.
00:52:11 And that's why I think Derek's slogan definitely came.
00:52:14 It's true, but you're right.
00:52:15 It was the right slogan at the right time in this movement.
00:52:18 So what do you think is going to happen tonight?
00:52:21 I guess time will tell.
00:52:22 think it's really going to be interesting to see who gets knocked off first and where that down
00:52:26 ballot support goes. I know recent polling has said it seems to be neck and neck with O'Toole
00:52:31 and McKay. And again, that's, you know, advanced polling. There's only one poll that matters. Of
00:52:36 course, that's today. You know, I think back to 2016 when it was Hillary Clinton running against
00:52:40 Donald Trump, polling had her out in the lead. I think there was a big shock on election night.
00:52:45 We'll see if that's going to be the case today. I think regardless of the outcome,
00:52:50 you know Derek should be very pleased with the campaign he ran and I think that we're going to
00:52:55 see a lot of emerging voices from this this campaign it'll be I think it'll be a challenge
00:52:58 for whomever emerges as leader to make sure that we unite everybody within the party.
00:53:03 Yeah very wise words. Tanya Granik-Allen thank you so much for your time. Thank you so much.
00:53:11 So this is one of the joys of doing a live podcast but while we were playing that interview
00:53:16 you. We just saw that David Aiken, who is a reporter over at Global News, he tweeted the
00:53:21 following. He said, well, we're off to a great start with the conservative leadership. And I
00:53:25 just got word that they're running 90 minutes late right now. So our plan, Andrew, is to do a
00:53:32 30-minute pre-show and then go to the conservative show at 6 p.m. Well, it doesn't look like that
00:53:38 conservative show is going to start now until 7.30. So we are just trying to figure out what
00:53:44 we're going to do on our end with the true north live podcast we're definitely going to continue
00:53:48 to bring you content we might have to take a short break at some point in between just to
00:53:53 make sure that we have everything lined up to to bring you all the information and bring you all
00:53:58 the news uh from the evening so that was just a quick programming note we were no longer going
00:54:04 yeah my dinner plans were predicated on throwing over to the party feed at six o'clock so i'm
00:54:07 I'm going to be, like, losing weight in real time on this show now.
00:54:12 Sneaking, sneaking a breakfast bar or something in between segments here.
00:54:17 Yeah, so, I mean, look, this happens, this is live.
00:54:20 And it's kind of interesting, Andrew, because, you know, you would sort of expect a delay.
00:54:24 I do remember at the convention when they announced the leadership, I guess it was 2000, I'm trying to think, 2016 when Andrew Scheer became leader.
00:54:33 Maybe it was 2017 in Toronto I was there.
00:54:35 And there always are delays in this kind of thing.
00:54:38 But given that the results, you know, the deadline for mail-in ballots was Friday and, you know, it's now Sunday.
00:54:46 They just announced, what, 10 minutes before they were supposed to go live that they were running late.
00:54:49 A little bit chaotic over there.
00:54:51 But, you know, we'll continue to try to do our best.
00:54:55 So, you know, that was a really interesting interview, Andrew, that you did with Tanya Granik-Allen.
00:55:00 And I know she has a lot of support in Ontario and a lot of people who look to her.
00:55:06 So was she working on that campaign or she was just sort of a supporter?
00:55:10 So Tanya is actually a very interesting example because she runs a parents' rights group in Ontario called Parents' First Educators
00:55:17 and is a very avowed social conservative.
00:55:20 And she actually did something very similar to what I did, which is really start vetting the candidates very rigorously,
00:55:26 doing some really in-depth, no-holds-barred interviews with them
00:55:30 to see who she would endorse.
00:55:31 And ultimately, she was not fond of some parts of Lesley Lewis's campaign.
00:55:36 Peter McKay, I think, gave her the same brush-off that he gave to us.
00:55:40 And Erin O'Toole, I don't think she was thrilled with.
00:55:42 So she ended up endorsing only one candidate.
00:55:46 And because of that, she was able to join and help with some of the get-out-the-vote,
00:55:50 So especially in Ontario, where Tanya Granik-Allen is very well regarded among social conservatives.
00:55:56 So that was something that was very interesting.
00:55:59 And I know that I touched on this with Tanya in the interview about who the type of people were that were coming out and saying, here's my ballot for Derek.
00:56:08 And it sounds from her perspective anyway that he wasn't pigeonholed as just a social conservative to his supporters, which is very similar to, I think, the observation you made and Steve Outhouse made about Leslyn Lewis.
00:56:20 Right. Well, the impression I got about Derek Sloan was that he was just willing to speak his
00:56:24 mind and he was willing to say what he believed. He didn't feel like a rehearsed politician.
00:56:30 You know, I'll give you an example. During the IPG, what was supposed to be the Independent
00:56:34 Press Gallery's debate that turned into that fireside chat that you hosted, you know,
00:56:38 when you guys were talking, it didn't really even at times feel like an interview. It just felt like,
00:56:43 you know, two friends talking about public policy or whatever. And then during the Q&A at the end,
00:56:47 he was asked, you know, would you recognize Taiwan as an independent country? He didn't even
00:56:51 hesitate for a second. He just answered. And it's so refreshing to hear that because, Andrew,
00:56:56 we live in a time where so many politicians are just so rehearsed, so robotic. They basically
00:57:03 base their platform on polling, on the latest data. And you don't really feel like you're
00:57:08 talking to an authentic person. You're just talking to a poll tested. And you see it in
00:57:15 in politics all over particularly in the u.s you know with those democrats but you see you see it
00:57:19 in canada too you saw it a little bit with andrew sheer it was just really refreshing to me to hear
00:57:24 derek sloan just sort of speak his mind and say things not politically correct at all you know
00:57:30 we know that the way that he was talking about the coronavirus and he wanted uh dr theresa tam to be
00:57:36 fired that that would turn into a big storm it turned off a lot of sort of more centrists i
00:57:41 I suppose. But from a conservative perspective, it was just sort of, again, refreshing to hear
00:57:46 someone who wasn't too worried about what the media was saying about them, wasn't too worried
00:57:51 about whether they were going to get slapped on the wrist or censured because of not being
00:57:57 politically correct enough. He was really just an authentic guy. And I could definitely see how
00:58:01 that would appeal beyond just the base of social conservatives there.
00:58:08 If you're just tuning in, this is the True North Conservative Leadership Results Show.
00:58:13 I'm Andrew Lawton, and hosting this is Candace Malcolm.
00:58:16 If you are just tuning in, we'll tell you that the official results have been delayed a fair bit.
00:58:21 Originally, the Conservative Party was to start its stream at 6 o'clock Eastern time,
00:58:26 which is in about a minute and a half.
00:58:27 And now they've done a little tiny, teeny, modest delay to 7.30 Eastern time,
00:58:33 which is, I think, a significant one that actually is even larger a delay than the English language
00:58:38 or rather the French language debate, which was delayed, I think, by close to half an hour as well.
00:58:44 So, I mean, these things do happen.
00:58:45 We're going to be with you for the long haul here.
00:58:47 We're already putting together a cast of characters to come
00:58:50 and shed out some light on different themes that have emerged through this campaign.
00:58:55 One story I will point out that's kind of interesting is I'm hearing from multiple sources
00:58:59 that the party is citing as its reason for the delay
00:59:03 the volume of ballots.
00:59:05 They had over 172,000 ballots cast.
00:59:08 The thing that I find interesting about this
00:59:10 is that the party has been promoting
00:59:12 the number of ballots for days now
00:59:15 since the deadline on Friday night.
00:59:17 So they've been aware of this.
00:59:19 And you'd think to some extent
00:59:20 they would know their capacity to count these.
00:59:24 And even earlier this afternoon,
00:59:25 you'd think they'd know,
00:59:26 hey, you know, it's 4 p.m.
00:59:28 we're supposed to be going live we're not done yet like that strikes me as
00:59:33 very disorganized to not know that they aren't going to have a number in time
00:59:37 for the show that they've been promoting but Andrew have you ever been to a
00:59:41 convention or a leadership event like this where they have been on time I feel
00:59:46 like this is just you know that this is exactly what happens every single time
00:59:50 well the jokes on us we're starting at 5 30 I guess yeah we should have seen this
00:59:54 one coming but that's okay you know we were kind of trying to squeeze a lot into a 30-minute
00:59:59 broadcast so i'm perfectly fine with stretching it out and hopefully we'll be able to bring in
01:00:04 some additional interviews but one of the interviews that you did was you got to catch
01:00:08 up with someone from the aaron o'toole campaign to talk about what they went through and what the
01:00:14 biggest moments were for them so let's go over to that interview i'm joined now by aaron o'toole's
01:00:21 campaign manager fred delori fred good to talk to you thanks for joining me tonight thanks for
01:00:25 having us on one of the big themes we've heard from aaron o'toole and your campaign throughout
01:00:31 the course of the race has been really that idea of being a true blue conservative was that really
01:00:37 what you think it was and is at stake in this race you know who is the most authentic broad
01:00:42 spectrum conservative in the running for the leadership well absolutely this is a this is a
01:00:46 race for the leadership of the Conservative Party. This is, you know, their membership are the ones
01:00:51 who are voting and it's important to communicate to them. And I can say, you know, it's been
01:00:56 working very well for us. It's a message that has been resonating. What would you say have really
01:01:02 been the big themes that have been central to the race? I know a lot of it was sidelined by
01:01:07 the pandemic, but in the last month in particular, it really seems like all of the campaigns really
01:01:13 leapt forward and did all the things that under normal circumstances they would have been doing
01:01:17 since january right well it's certainly been a strange campaign uh you know there's no in the
01:01:23 in the campaign manager manual there's no tab for how to manage during a pandemic
01:01:29 uh so things have obviously changed in the you know the messaging and everything that's
01:01:33 been going affected by that uh the main themes though of course it's not just about beating
01:01:38 trudeau it's about replacing him with a conservative version uh that we want not
01:01:42 a liberal light bird so that's been something that's very important to our campaign and to our
01:01:46 membership i know that obviously social media would have been a pivotal role in the campaign
01:01:53 regardless but i think we can all say more so when for the bulk of the campaign you couldn't travel
01:01:58 you couldn't have any in-person events how did you really adapt to that i know there were a lot
01:02:03 of videos that were being pushed out on a number of issues clips and stuff like that but but more
01:02:08 broadly speaking how was that for the campaign well it was interesting because at the beginning
01:02:13 of this campaign there was actually an internal debate about how much to have the candidate tour
01:02:17 around the country or do uh different facebook lives videos like that reach more directly to
01:02:22 all the members uh so the pandemic obviously forced us to do what we were thinking about
01:02:26 doing anyways uh so we were ready to to quickly go into that mode and instead you know aaron o'toole
01:02:32 was able to talk to someone in newfoundland in the morning and someone in bc at night
01:02:36 and go right across the country by doing zooms and whatnot so it's been it's been a great uh
01:02:40 a great way to do a campaign now i want to ask you about one of the key endorsements that aaron
01:02:45 o'toole had landed and really seemed to i think push and that was that of jason kenney and i had
01:02:51 made the observation when that happened that i think next to stephen harper that's probably one
01:02:56 of the the most significant endorsements you can get in canadian conservative politics right now
01:03:02 how much do you think that translates or endorsements in general translate to votes so
01:03:07 generally uh endorsements don't drive votes at all a lot of a lot of times it's a waste of time
01:03:13 uh they really don't pull a lot a lot of weight um when you go for an endorsement what you really
01:03:18 want is that person or a worker to go there and sign up memberships but generally endorsements
01:03:25 do have no impact having said that jason kenny though was a very special endorsement it's very
01:03:30 different word he's perceived as such a leader within the conservative movement uh across the
01:03:34 country uh in all parts of this country um certainly gave a huge boost to our campaign
01:03:43 there was a huge front runner in this race and we kept chipping at him and this is one of those
01:03:47 things that helped put us in a position where i think we're going to win this well on that note
01:03:53 i'll ask you the question i've been asking everyone what do you think is going to happen tonight
01:03:56 i think we're going to win on the third ballot okay so you're going specific third ballot win
01:04:02 is what you're predicting yep and i think less than lewis will be our phone all right fred
01:04:07 delori campaign manager for aaron o'toole joining me thank you so much for your time fred good luck
01:04:26 Thank you.
01:04:56 showing a black screen okay so that was really interesting interview that you did there
01:05:08 andrew and it's interesting to hear uh from fred delor delori just talking about you know how kind
01:05:16 of intense it was interesting how he was the only one who actually made up predictions he predicted
01:05:20 that his guy was going to win not surprising i'm sure they all think they're going to win
01:05:23 But he said that it was going to come down to the third ballot and that he thought that
01:05:28 it would be a competition between him and Lesley Lewis.
01:05:31 It would be really interesting because if you paid attention to the mainstream media
01:05:35 over the last few days, they all are kind of calling Peter McKay the front runner and
01:05:39 saying he's basically a shoo-in, it's going to be a landslide.
01:05:42 So I think we definitely still have an interesting evening on our hands. 1.00
01:05:47 That is, if we actually are delivered the results tonight, which at this point were
01:05:52 delayed by an hour and a half at least and who knows what will happen. Yeah and on that note just
01:05:58 a bit of breaking news coming in here. Susan Delacorte who was one of the debate moderators 0.99
01:06:03 in the general election debate last year and is a columnist with the Star predominantly has said
01:06:08 that the vote counting machines are apparently ripping the ballots. Now I didn't hear the original
01:06:14 quote but she cites Lisa Raid as saying that. So when the ballots are being spoiled by the machine
01:06:21 that's supposed to be counting them suffice it to say I don't think the speed at which they were
01:06:26 hoping to get through that stack of ballots is going to be on track so I mean if this this problem
01:06:31 I mean could create even bigger implications as far as the integrity of the results not just the
01:06:37 timing of the results well absolutely and I mean Andrew if they're if they're hand counting that
01:06:43 many ballots how many ballots did they say they got 180,000 I mean if that's the case that they
01:06:48 that they can't use the machine that they had designed to do this and they're going to be
01:06:51 counting those ballots by hand there is no way we're going to find out tonight um again interesting
01:06:57 that they will be waiting until the 11th hour i mean they're supposed to be live right now you'd
01:07:02 think that this is stuff that they would have been dealing with since friday afternoon when the
01:07:06 ballots officially closed so a little bit again a little bit of chaos over at the conservative hq
01:07:13 I guess. But we're going to do our best here to, you know, the show must go on. This is sort of
01:07:20 like the IPG debate all over again, Andrew, where we were supposed to have four candidates to do a
01:07:26 debate. And then at the last minute, two of them backed out. And so we ended up completely changing
01:07:31 our script and our schedule. So we're doing that again. But luckily, I think there's a lot of
01:07:36 content to talk about. I think that, you know, you raised really good points in that interview
01:07:40 that you did with Fred about Aaron O'Toole because, in my mind, I think he's sort of the
01:07:46 frontrunner of this campaign. You know, he was endorsed by Jason Kenney, as you said in your
01:07:51 interview there. He ran a very strong social media campaign. I follow all of the candidates on
01:07:56 Facebook and Twitter, and, you know, it was really Aaron O'Toole that I kept seeing over and over
01:08:02 again. His videos were going viral. He had really kind of funny, smart visual, you know, his tweets
01:08:09 that he was sending out and all that kind of stuff.
01:08:10 I just thought he ran a really good campaign.
01:08:12 So it's a little interesting to hear his campaign manager.
01:08:16 I think, I don't know what Fred's official role over there is,
01:08:18 but to hear Fred say that he thought that Peter McKay was the frontrunner.
01:08:22 I guess, you know, again, in the minds of people over at the CBC,
01:08:27 Peter McKay is the frontrunner.
01:08:28 But I think Aaron O'Toole is also very familiar.
01:08:30 You know, he ran in the last leadership debate.
01:08:33 He came in third, a very strong showing in that race.
01:08:37 that ultimately Andrew Scheer won
01:08:39 and Maxime Bernier was a close second.
01:08:41 So, you know, he's been a leader in the party
01:08:43 for a number of years now.
01:08:45 And I did think it was quite interesting
01:08:47 that his campaign team there referred to him
01:08:49 to some other guy, to Peter McKay as the front runner.
01:08:52 Yeah, and I think that one thing
01:08:54 that I found interesting on the social media game
01:08:56 from the O'Toole campaign
01:08:57 is that they really tried to tap
01:09:00 into some of the culture war issues.
01:09:02 I mean, his first video was about cancel culture,
01:09:05 which is an issue that you usually hear about from conservative commentators, not from conservative politicians,
01:09:11 really waging into the battle about statues being taken down.
01:09:14 And I mean, certainly something like that is very deliberate, same as when he went after CBC's bias in funding.
01:09:20 I mean, that is a political issue, but I think it's really a conservative cultural discussion.
01:09:25 And I think that that was certainly a calculation, but I think a very smart one,
01:09:29 because that's the way you get people energized and excited about your campaign.
01:09:32 If you're talking about the issues that people are actually talking about, which, let's face it, I mean, apart from a few policy wonks, and I count myself in that category, most conservative voters, I don't think, are spending all day, every day talking about this tax credit or that tax credit or even some of the other economic issues, which are important.
01:09:52 The ones that excite people are the cultural battles.
01:09:55 Absolutely.
01:09:56 And I think that that is why, you know, Aaron O'Toole, we saw his videos going viral.
01:10:01 we saw his tweets go viral. You know, he had a really funny tweet the other day that, again,
01:10:06 you know, he really went heavy on this Jason Kenney endorsement. But, you know, it had had a
01:10:10 sort of juxtaposition. Aaron O'Toole endorsed by Jason Kenney, who is, you know, one of the most
01:10:16 foremost conservatives, the premier of Alberta. And then inside next to it, it had Peter McKay
01:10:22 endorsed by the Toronto Star, which, you know, everyone's least favorite newspaper in the country.
01:10:26 So that was clever, and the sort of viral-ness of that, you know, goes a lot further than just his own reach.
01:10:34 But, you know, one of the things I just want to pick up on again that Lisa Raitt spoke about in that interview that we played that you did with her earlier
01:10:40 was about how usually a convention, usually a leadership race, ends in a convention, and you have the whole conservative family coming together.
01:10:49 And, you know, I've been to those events, and they're so fun.
01:10:52 there's so much energy you see so many familiar faces you know people who have
01:10:56 worked together you know different offices at different times and different
01:10:59 parts of the country everyone's just kind of coming together so regardless of
01:11:03 how you know not I won't say nasty but just how competitive these races are how
01:11:08 the different campaign teams work so hard and pour their hearts and souls into
01:11:12 these campaigns and you start to feel like other conservatives are like your
01:11:16 enemy but then you know you have the convention you all come together and
01:11:19 reunite and everyone unites around the candidate. But because we don't have that in-person event
01:11:25 this year because of COVID, Andrew, do you think that's something that's really missing? Do you
01:11:30 think that it could potentially lead to fractures in the Conservative Party just because you don't
01:11:34 have that kind of coming together? I know this was a really vicious campaign. There were times
01:11:38 where, you know, Aaron O'Toole and Peter McKay, I think there might have even been lawsuits filed
01:11:43 against each other over something about someone watching someone else's Zoom clips or something.
01:11:49 Anyway, it was a really hard-fought campaign.
01:11:53 Do you think any of those divisions are going to be long-lasting in the party,
01:11:56 or are they going to be something that we can get over quickly?
01:11:58 It's tough to say.
01:12:00 I mean, when we saw the 2017 leadership race,
01:12:03 there were 13, 14 candidates, depending on the particular point in the race.
01:12:07 And in that, there isn't as much direct one-on-one animosity,
01:12:11 although certainly there was between the Scheer and Bernier campaigns.
01:12:15 But I think there's a cautionary tale in that,
01:12:17 Because look at what happened with that dynamic between Andrew Scheer and Maxime Bernier after the race.
01:12:22 Now, I'm not suggesting that the loser or one of the losing candidates of this race will split off and form their own party.
01:12:29 But it's that the last time around, there wasn't that grand reuniting that everyone had become accustomed to and I think took for granted.
01:12:37 So in this time, I think, yeah, people that know politics and are in politics are used to this fight.
01:12:42 They know how it is to just be on opposing teams and then all come together because everyone wants the Conservative Party to win.
01:12:49 But I do think that there is going to be a difficulty for some, especially in the grassroots memberships, if they feel like they are not respected by whomever wins.
01:12:58 And that's, I think, the key here, because there was a lot of tension, not just about this is my guy, that's your guy, but tension over specifically whether certain factions of the party are going to be welcome.
01:13:11 And specifically social conservatives, with a lot of the dynamic being where you take Peter McKay and Erin O'Toole, both of them are the same on social issues.
01:13:20 They're pro-LGBT rights.
01:13:21 They're pro-choice.
01:13:22 But the difference was Erin O'Toole had said, yes, social conservatives have a place in my party.
01:13:27 And Peter McKay said the opposite at various points in the campaign.
01:13:31 And I do think that that's going to be where some of the issues will come and the fractures will come depending on the outcome tonight, if we get an outcome tonight.
01:13:40 Yeah, if we get an outcome. Well, it's interesting. I do remember the sort of media, I guess, talking points or narrative out of the last campaign was, you know, they were worried about the potential leader of the Conservative Party creating new division or falling back on old fault lines so that you would have the sort of former alliance base and the former PC base that, you know, Stephen Harper did such a good job of melding the two together and keeping the party united.
01:14:08 that under a new leader that those old fractions would become apparent and that didn't really
01:14:12 happen at all. Maybe if it had been you know a Jason Kenney versus Peter McKay scenario which
01:14:18 everyone kind of thought that that was what was going to happen back in 2015-2016 you know maybe
01:14:24 if that had been what had happened it would have fractured it. But Andrew what we saw was a little
01:14:29 bit of a different fraction with Andrew Scheer winning and then Maxime Bernier coming so close.
01:14:34 I mean, Maxi Bernier was winning on most of those ballots throughout that evening.
01:14:39 Everyone but the last one.
01:14:40 Everyone but the last one.
01:14:42 Yeah, he was the person who the most people put first on their list, put second on their list, and so on.
01:14:48 And yet, at the end of the day, there wasn't even room for him in the party.
01:14:52 I think he left the party just a couple of months after that.
01:14:55 And the fraction seemed to be sort of the difference between more establishment conservatives and more,
01:15:01 I don't want to say Trump-y conservatives, but people who were just sick and tired of political correctness and wanted more authentic politics.
01:15:09 And a lot of those people have left the party.
01:15:11 Some are still there, but they're not completely happy.
01:15:13 I know a lot of our True North audience, True North supporters, you know, they're not really excited about either Peter McKay or Erin O'Toole.
01:15:23 And so it will be a juggling act if either of those two candidates win.
01:15:27 I mean, same with Leslie Lewis or Derek Sloan. Whoever wins this thing tonight is going to have
01:15:31 a difficult job on their hands, just keeping the party together, keeping them energized and excited.
01:15:36 And, you know, you said that Peter McKay, you know, sort of brushed some people off and doesn't
01:15:43 really connect very well with social conservatives. I think you could say that about a lot of
01:15:46 conservatives. I have a hard time imagining him really exciting the base out in Western Canada
01:15:53 or getting Albertans really excited about being, you know, voting for the Conservatives.
01:15:58 A lot of Albertans, frankly, have had enough of the whole Canadian Confederation,
01:16:02 and they're looking in another direction entirely.
01:16:05 So I would worry about, again, party unity under any of these,
01:16:09 but very specifically under Peter McKay.
01:16:12 What do you think?
01:16:13 Yeah, I would agree.
01:16:14 And just on the note of Peter McKay, I want to make something clear for the record.
01:16:17 We had extended invitations to all four campaigns to send a representative,
01:16:22 someone from the campaign team to chat for a few minutes and as you heard in those interviews
01:16:27 they were all very light very friendly thinking of the past of the campaign thinking of the future
01:16:33 and Peter McKay was the only candidate to not accept that invitation similar to when we did
01:16:39 our initial leadership series interviews on my show back in March Peter McKay was the only
01:16:44 candidate to not accept the invitation and when we did the independent press gallery debate Lesley
01:16:49 Lewis had taken ill and was unable to attend, Peter McKay chose not to. And, you know, if this
01:16:55 sounds like a petty squabble, it really isn't. I think this is very significant when there has
01:17:01 been a trend going back to the very beginning of the race for Peter McKay to just not be available
01:17:06 and not even to have someone from his team available to chat for a few minutes on the night
01:17:10 the results are coming in. So the reason there wasn't a member of the Peter McKay team on this
01:17:15 show today is not for lack of trying it's not for lack of invitation it's because that is again the
01:17:20 latest example of the mckay campaign simply not being interested you know i i try to keep an open
01:17:26 mind with peter mckay i try not to sort of prejudge him from other uh experiences i had with him or
01:17:33 or views i had of him back when he was a minister in the harper government but you know there it
01:17:38 does feel like there's a reoccurring theme here andrew he he didn't want to sit down for an
01:17:42 interview with us why i mean what's so what's so scary about an interview with andrew lawton i mean
01:17:47 you know every other conservative candidate uh was more than happy to sit down with you you sat down
01:17:52 with i think most of them also back in 2015 i'm sure on your on your radio show and other uh
01:17:58 platforms you've interviewed just about you know every leader you i know you've interviewed
01:18:03 justin trudeau you've interviewed stephen harper you know you're not gonna come out and say
01:18:07 something radical that's going to get him in trouble it's just you know why why is he so
01:18:12 hesitant to talk to us to participate to engage with conservative media um again i think that's
01:18:17 going to be part of his problem again i try to keep an open mind and if he wins uh wish him all
01:18:23 the best and hope that he is able to defeat justin trudeau sooner rather than later um but i think
01:18:30 that he really does need to work on his uh outreach and his openness to to talk to uh conservatives
01:18:36 wherever they are which which frankly it's not through the toronto star it's not on the cbc
01:18:41 it's increasingly uh through independent media outlets and i know that that the folks over at
01:18:46 the rebel have had the same kind of issues you know they have to chase him through parking lots
01:18:50 and hotel lobbies just to try to get a comment from him and he runs away from them um for us he
01:18:56 just he says no or says yes and then changes his mind and doesn't show or no or no response at all
01:19:01 uh just for those of you tuning in the official results are delayed by about 90 minutes but our
01:19:07 team has been working uh around the clock for the last however long it's been since we learned that
01:19:11 to put a great show together and we've got a great rotating uh cast of people that are going to come
01:19:16 on and chat about these things from various perspectives so that is all coming up if you're
01:19:21 just tuning in now i wanted to give you a heads up about that yeah and i think that we are going to
01:19:27 have some great programming andrew we're going to try to get some guests on unfortunately we're
01:19:31 gonna have to cut this stream off because we're gonna have to change over to a different stream
01:19:35 so that we can accommodate bringing guests in but we're gonna try sorry just just to correct i'm
01:19:39 told that the the our stream is going to remain the same so if you hold tight okay and keep watching
01:19:44 the channel you're watching on now uh it will be the same for you but on the back end we've got to
01:19:48 take a little bit of a break uh to change things over okay thanks for that clarification andrew
01:19:53 yeah so we we're gonna we're gonna continue with you we're gonna stay on until 7 30. we're just
01:19:58 going to take a very brief break so that we can switch the platforms on the back end here
01:20:03 and then that way we're going to come back with some interviews andrew do we have any interviews
01:20:07 lined up so far yeah we've got a lot we're going to be speaking with elissa golab from right now
01:20:11 which has been very involved in driving support to lesl and lewis specifically but more broadly
01:20:17 and raising the uh the social conservative issues that have become so contentious we're also going
01:20:22 to be joined by our true north colleague anthony fury and some other folks as well and that's all
01:20:26 going to be in the next 45 minutes or so great well Andrew before we before we take a small
01:20:32 break here did you have any uh any predictions for the night any anything that you're hoping
01:20:37 to have happen other than hopefully you know we'll actually hear the results of this uh
01:20:41 I predict the party will announce another delay so all I can tell you is to stay tuned and we'll
01:20:46 have you looked after all right well there you have it okay folks we are going to take a very
01:20:50 quick break just stay stay put and we'll be back in a couple minutes and we'll have some interviews
01:20:54 for you.
01:21:24 Thank you.
01:21:54 Thank you.
01:22:24 Thank you.
01:22:54 Thank you.
01:23:24 Thank you.
01:23:54 Thank you.
01:24:24 Thank you.
01:24:54 Thank you.
01:25:24 Thank you.
01:25:54 Thank you.
01:26:24 Thank you.
01:26:54 Thank you.
01:27:24 Thank you.
01:27:54 Thank you.
01:28:24 Thank you.
01:28:54 Thank you.
01:29:24 Thank you.
01:29:54 Thank you.
01:30:24 Thank you.
01:30:54 Hi, welcome back to True North Live. I'm your host, Candice Malcolm, joined by my co-host,
01:31:05 Andrew Lawton. Thank you so much for bearing with us. Again, you know, this is not live television,
01:31:10 but it's live, you know, internet television or live podcasts. So we're trying to do the
01:31:15 best we can with the information as it's coming in. As you definitely know by now,
01:31:19 the conservative leadership uh uh race the results were coming in there it was supposed to start at
01:31:25 6 p.m then bump back to 7 30. so we're going to give you lots of content lots of interesting
01:31:30 interviews with with some folks that you're probably familiar with and we've got our first
01:31:35 interview lined up right now andrew i'll throw it over to you for the interview yeah one of
01:31:40 the big themes that emerged from the mainstream media in the last federal election was andrew
01:31:45 shares social conservatism. And that has really pushed itself into the discussion in the
01:31:50 conservative leadership race. And we mentioned earlier, the infamous albatross comment from
01:31:56 Peter McKay about social conservatives, which is really, I think, soured a lot of social
01:32:00 conservative voters on Peter McKay and a possible Peter McKay leadership. And I do have to point out
01:32:07 that this race has been in many respects, not defined by social conservatism, but defined by,
01:32:13 I think the willingness of the candidates to embrace the various factions of the party.
01:32:18 And Candace, you and I were talking about this earlier.
01:32:20 You have Derek Sloan and Leslyn Lewis that are running as social conservatives.
01:32:25 You have Aaron O'Toole who's saying, listen, I'm not a social conservative, but you all
01:32:29 have a place in my party right now, which is a group that has done a lot to advance
01:32:34 conservative or rather candidates who are pro-life through nominations and leaderships
01:32:39 has been very active in this race and specifically towards Leslyn Lewis. Now, I have to disclose when
01:32:46 I ran as a candidate in the Ontario election in 2018, Right Now was supporting me. I am very
01:32:51 grateful for that to this day. The co-founder of Right Now, Alyssa Globe, is joining us on the
01:32:57 line. Alyssa, thanks very much for coming on on short notice. Good to have you. Thanks for having
01:33:02 me. So let's talk about why Leslyn Lewis, because I know that one of the things that you look at 0.97
01:33:08 often when you're deciding who to endorse is who the most electable candidate is that's going to
01:33:13 be really in alignment on your issues and being pro-life. At the beginning of the race, Leslyn
01:33:19 Lewis was a virtual unknown. Well, I think she had a lot of winnability factors that made us 0.99
01:33:27 drawn to her right away. You know, we worked with her. We actually have helped support her
01:33:32 in the 2015 election when she came very last minute in the riding in Scarborough. So we
01:33:38 already had door knocked with her we knew her we knew what her capabilities were and then on paper 0.54
01:33:42 just in terms of her credentials all of these things um you know encapsulated her becoming the
01:33:49 number one candidate for us and it proved to be uh highly rewarding because she's done an amazing job
01:33:55 so far well she really has and it's been exciting for so many of us to to see a candidate like that
01:34:01 because you know the mainstream media likes to paint conservatives as being you know backwards
01:34:05 and sort of archaic and old white men and so it's so exciting to see uh you know someone who's who's
01:34:11 who's got a totally different background but can still communicate um the issues so so for someone
01:34:16 like you alissa who you know being pro-life is you know the most important uh aspect of of what she's
01:34:23 running for you know what specifically about her her policy um was it that that really uh got you
01:34:29 you guys excited? Well, for me, I think it's her personal story. Just the fact that she was
01:34:35 coerced to have an abortion while articling on Bay Street as a lawyer, as a young female lawyer,
01:34:41 was a big thing that her friends and family were coercing her, and she withstood that pressure
01:34:46 and had her baby, and now she has two children. And so she's actually experienced and walked in
01:34:52 the footsteps of women who experience unplanned pregnancy and feel that pressure to abort. And
01:34:58 so it's very difficult to have you know the mainstream media the evan solomons say you know
01:35:03 you're trying to roll back women's rights when she actually went through that process and her 0.64
01:35:08 policies are there to support women one of her main policies is to find pregnancy care centers
01:35:14 very difficult to argue against that and it's all things that the pro-life movement ardently
01:35:17 endorses so these are the things that really draw me personally to her campaign and her candidacy
01:35:23 One thing I found interesting is that Lesley Lewis has gotten a lot of support from people
01:35:28 that aren't from the social conservative or pro-life wing of the party necessarily. In fact,
01:35:33 I've seen a lot of people even who are on the Peter McKay campaign who have put Lesley Lewis
01:35:37 as their second choice. And even in the media, when they have gotten around to covering her,
01:35:42 they've done it in a favorable way that they didn't really extend to any other candidates
01:35:47 in history who have socially conservative views. So why is it that you think she's been able to
01:35:52 bypass a lot of the treatment that pro-life candidates typically have
01:35:56 gotten? Because I think her her pro-life policies are grassroots policies that 0.99
01:36:02 are already a part of the Conservative Party of Canada handbook so she's not
01:36:06 really saying anything that we haven't already decided at convention not only
01:36:10 that but she has these credentials that make her very different like her a
01:36:13 master's degree in environmental science I know people automatically view that as 0.96
01:36:18 bad thing but she has um you know she puts canadians first she has a very in-depth policies
01:36:24 on um the environment that a lot of social conservatives i think kind of veer more towards
01:36:30 the right and don't take that into consideration as much when there are a lot of people who are
01:36:35 socially conservative but maybe a little bit more progressive in terms of environmental or economic
01:36:40 issues so i think less would encapsulate all all those things so she has a broad background
01:36:45 i can really unite the party in all aspects well absolutely and i i don't think that those are
01:36:50 necessarily bad things because it's so good to understand the other side so the fact that she
01:36:54 has a master's degree in environmental science she understands the environmental arguments she
01:36:59 understands you know what the opponents are trying to say i know i personally took a few classes of
01:37:04 international environmental law when i was in grad school and i find them painful because i
01:37:08 disagreed so much but it was ultimately helpful because you know you understand what the other
01:37:13 side um is going through well Alyssa maybe just quickly tell us what what does a right now
01:37:19 endorsement uh provide or what you know what is it that you are doing uh at this point for
01:37:23 Leslyn Lewis uh well we did encourage people to rank their ballots fully so even though Leslyn
01:37:29 was one we still wanted people to vote for um all the candidates one to four um and so what that
01:37:35 means is basically we'll call our our membership lists uh we'll encourage people to buy memberships
01:37:40 will help with get out the vote will uh doorknock to pick up ballots um basically work as a little
01:37:46 party within a party and do as much as we can to help the candidates and tilt the skill in their
01:37:52 favor so they come out on top i know that one of the dynamics of the conservative leadership race
01:37:58 that oftentimes can be make or break is the ranking and you just indicated that let me ask
01:38:03 you about aaron o'toole because i i know that some pro-life voters i've heard from say they
01:38:08 They cannot vote for Aaron O'Toole in good conscience because he's pro-choice, whereas
01:38:12 you've actually looked somewhat favorably on him and you've asked people to rank him
01:38:16 after Lesley Lewis and Derek Sloan.
01:38:19 Is someone who is not on side with you, but is willing to allow people who are on side
01:38:26 with you to have a voice in the party, is that enough in this day and age?
01:38:29 Yeah, I mean, personally, I was very disappointed to see pro-life MPs endorse Peter McKay when
01:38:35 he very vehemently says that if they are in cabinet they won't have that freedom to vote
01:38:40 according to their conscience and that their views are that stinking albatross that has felt
01:38:44 that has become his stinking albatross in this leadership race um so i'm very disappointed in
01:38:49 mps who have endorsed him because even though you say you're pro-life what are you actually going to
01:38:53 do about it and conversely even though aaron says he's pro-choice he has dif he has different pro-life
01:38:59 policies that were outlined in our interview and he has a fairly good voting record so he has the
01:39:05 actions to back it up um so these things are really important it's one thing to say something
01:39:10 it's another thing to do it and so that's why i think it was important for us to rank our ballot
01:39:14 fully and not be dropped out of the conversation if you know it doesn't go our way with the first
01:39:18 two rounds alissa just one final question this is something that always really bothers me it seems
01:39:25 like there's a really big disconnect between canadians and public opinion and what the
01:39:30 mainstream media says is allowable opinion i'll give you an example when it comes to specific
01:39:35 aspects of abortion obviously late-term abortions we've all kind of read and seen really gruesome
01:39:41 imagery and pictures of sometimes how that goes uh sex selective abortion is a big issue now
01:39:46 because people are coming from other parts of the world where they just don't want baby girls and
01:39:50 And those are the kind of policies that most Canadians would just rightly instinctively say, like, no, no, no, that's not okay.
01:39:57 You know, there are instances, you know, pro-choice people might say there are instances where an abortion might be something that they would want to do.
01:40:05 But when it comes to the media, it's like you can't even have the very introduction of a conversation.
01:40:09 You can't even have the beginning of a conversation.
01:40:11 So, you know, I know this is a very deep and loaded question, but maybe you could just
01:40:17 provide your kind of brief explanation as to why there is this huge disconnect between what the
01:40:22 media says we can talk about and what most Canadians believe to be true.
01:40:27 I mean, I think that the media has their narrative, but them, much like party establishments,
01:40:33 are very much stuck in their own bubble and they're disconnected to what the opinions of
01:40:37 Canadians actually are and I'm currently 35 weeks pregnant and just a few years ago thank you
01:40:44 just a few years ago there was a Montreal woman who had an abortion at 35 weeks and even though
01:40:50 the doctors didn't know what was wrong with the baby and it wasn't her life wasn't in danger and
01:40:56 neither was the baby's life in danger so there was a big outcry about that yet when you say that the
01:41:02 abortion debate is closed or we won't reopen the abortion debate you are supporting these late-term
01:41:07 abortions that are actually happening and allowing them to continue and there were two polls recently
01:41:14 an angus reed poll and i can't remember the other one but both said that the majority of canadians
01:41:19 want restrictions on abortion in every single province they broke it down even in quebec
01:41:24 and one-third of people in the liberal and ndp parties also want restrictions so this crosses
01:41:30 party lines this crosses all different types of canadians it's a winning policy um and i think
01:41:36 that it also follows the directives of the supreme court which actually told parliament
01:41:40 to regulate abortion equally across the country so i'm not sure why parties let the media dictate
01:41:47 what policies are going to put forward but if they actually looked at the numbers which is what our
01:41:51 organization is ruled by they'll see that these types of policies will help them win in the gta
01:41:57 and differentiate themselves from other parties
01:41:59 who are trying to say the same thing.
01:42:01 Alyssa Gallobe, co-founder of Right Now,
01:42:05 and as you've heard, unabashedly supporting Leslyn Lewis,
01:42:08 but for a different reason than a lot of other people,
01:42:11 a very singular focus on an issue that matters a great deal.
01:42:14 Alyssa, thank you so much for coming on tonight.
01:42:16 Good to talk to you.
01:42:16 Thanks so much, Andrew and Candice.
01:42:18 Thanks, Alyssa.
01:42:19 And this is the live Conservative Leadership Results
01:42:23 show on True North.
01:42:24 Candice Malcolm and yours truly, Andrew Lawton hosting. And if you're just tuning in and you
01:42:30 are no doubt aware that we're rolling with the punches here, I hope, because we had a delay of
01:42:35 about 90 minutes so far. And like I said earlier, I mean, we have to be prepared for the inevitable.
01:42:40 The one report that came out was that the ballot counting machines are ripping the ballots. And
01:42:46 there are other reports that are still coming in about some of the turnouts so far. I've seen
01:42:51 little glimpses here and there of people saying that so-and-so is in the lead and you have to
01:42:56 take these with a bunch of grains of salt. But we are with you for the long haul. We've got a whole
01:43:01 roster of people that are going to be coming on to break this down. But Candice, what did you
01:43:06 think about what Alyssa was bringing up there? Yeah, I mean, it's a really interesting organization.
01:43:10 I know you know them really well. You've worked with them. I'm not as familiar with them, but
01:43:14 you know, it definitely seemed like, you know, everyone knows that social conservatives or
01:43:20 pro-life conservatives are the most sort of organized, energetic, involved people that
01:43:26 they volunteer, they get involved. They really are passionate and care about politics. And so
01:43:32 it's not surprising that they would be so well organized. And I think it was probably a good
01:43:37 choice picking Leslie Lewis, just given her personal story and what she went through. And
01:43:41 I think that's why the media will have a tough time pigeonholing her and trying to paint her
01:43:47 in a specific way when she's had her own experience that she's lived through.
01:43:51 So I thought it was a really interesting interview and a great organization.
01:43:55 And there is something, I think, very important in the clarity that Leslyn Lewis has had with
01:44:01 her position on abortion, because I actually talked about this with her back in March when
01:44:05 I sat down with her at the very beginning of the race as part of my conservative leadership
01:44:09 series, which had invitations extended to everyone.
01:44:12 And her platform had specifically called it a no hidden agenda platform where she listed 0.99
01:44:17 point by point, I think it was three or maybe four things that she wanted to do on the abortion 0.87
01:44:22 issue. And if you contrast that with Andrew Scheer, who I really think suffered in the last
01:44:28 election, because his position was always equivocal and waffly. I mean, he was pro-life,
01:44:34 everyone knew he was pro-life, but he still just wouldn't say that as clearly and unabashedly as
01:44:40 he felt it. And I think that was what really dogged him in a lot of cases, where if he just
01:44:44 said, yeah, this is what I think. So what? And there, there really isn't a criticism to be
01:44:49 leveled that is as relevant and pertinent and ongoing as the one that he got. Whereas Lesley
01:44:54 Lewis and also Derek Sloan, I think have been able to really sidestep that by just being so clear
01:44:59 and so open about what they feel. Yeah, that's a really good point. Cause one of the issues with
01:45:03 Andrew Scheer is, you know, he's Catholic. And like you said, everyone knows that he's pro
01:45:07 life and people who are pro life, it's not just, uh, you know, like what's your favorite color
01:45:12 something like that it's a very deeply held belief and and and to to to say i want to be
01:45:17 prime minister of this country but i don't want to change any of the laws you're kind of like
01:45:23 well okay you're either not very sincere in your personal beliefs because if you truly believe
01:45:29 um that you know that that abortion allows for murder of babies how can you just say i'm going
01:45:35 to be prime minister and not do anything about it but then to try to say to the media like oh don't
01:45:39 worry you know i'm not going to legislate on it then they're going to think okay well he probably
01:45:43 is and down the road we're going to end up uh with policies that we're not being told about right now
01:45:48 so i don't think andrew sheer handled that question very well at all and like you said
01:45:52 just being transparent and open about it uh with these candidates is a different approach and i
01:45:57 guess we'll we'll have to see how it goes depending on whether one of those pro-life candidates
01:46:01 actually wins tonight uh how the media handles that and and how they react to someone you know
01:46:07 if they are completely upfront and transparent in the way that Les Lewis has been.
01:46:11 Yeah, very much so. And continuing along with our live show, we have one of our True North
01:46:15 colleagues, a columnist, a commentator, does all sorts of things in front of and behind the scenes,
01:46:21 Devin Drover, joining us on the line. Devin, thanks for coming on.
01:46:24 Happy to be here. It's exciting.
01:46:27 Your perspective, I think, is a really interesting one in this race, coming from Atlantic Canada,
01:46:31 where I think the prevailing narrative has been that Peter McKay has a lock on the Atlantic
01:46:36 provinces. And I wanted to ask you, how strong is that grip that he has on Atlantic Canada as far
01:46:42 as name recognition, organization, and really just the broader support? Well, I think Peter
01:46:50 McKay has benefited a lot from having represented in Atlantic riding for a very long time,
01:46:56 from also being the regional minister for Newfoundland and Labrador when we didn't have an
01:47:00 MP here. So he definitely benefits from that. But it also comes with any scandals that were
01:47:05 involved. So the helicopter incident is very, very well known in Newfoundland, for example. So
01:47:12 it comes with both good and bad reputations. I think one of the areas that he benefits from is
01:47:16 he did have a lot of support from the provincial parties who normally in this region are less or
01:47:22 more hesitant to support federal conservatives. So for example, Chess Crosby, the leader of the
01:47:27 provincial PC party here in Newfoundland and Labrador endorsed him. The leader of the Nova
01:47:32 scotia pcs tim houston endorsed him he had a number of endorsements from m8 from mlas in both
01:47:38 pi and new brunswick so he does benefit from that and he also has the endorsement of caucus
01:47:42 even though it's a small caucus a lot of the caucus members endorse him for the region as well
01:47:47 he has that kind of former or former colleagues that have come out and helped him a lot in the
01:47:54 right in the region as well so devon does that translate into actual seats in atlantic canada
01:48:00 because I know that the Conservatives were basically completely shut out, I believe, in 2015.
01:48:05 I believe they did a little better. Maybe you can remind us of what the seat count looks out there.
01:48:09 But do you think if Peter McKay were the leader of the Conservative Party going into a general election against Justin Trudeau,
01:48:14 that he would actually be able to win a number of seats? How many seats? And maybe you can break that down for us a little.
01:48:21 Well, I mean, if we look at just historically, Stephen Harper was not the most popular guy in Atlantic Canada when he was prime minister,
01:48:27 but we still managed to win between 2004 the the 2004 election and the 2015 election we've won
01:48:35 up to 19 of the 32 seats in the region never at the same time but of those 32 seats conservatives
01:48:40 have been competitive then um i think we would have done a lot better last election if we were
01:48:45 focused on different writings we the conservative party tended to support writings that were not
01:48:50 um that were historically conservative leaning but no longer in 2015 or
01:48:55 or uh 2019 were conservative writing so for example they put a lot of effort
01:48:59 here in st john's in a seat that we came third in
01:49:02 and then there was a seat that we had no campaign manager and no candidate until 0.99
01:49:06 after the uh after the the campaign begun and she
01:49:10 only lost by a few hundred votes so it just shows that the the conservatives
01:49:13 aren't um organized on the ground here and
01:49:15 they're not there seems to be a disconnect between the
01:49:18 ottawa war room and actually what goes on in atlantic provinces but i do suspect with peter
01:49:23 if peter is elected leader tonight he'll have room to grow uh here though i think that um
01:49:29 those gaining 19 seats only matters if he can hold on to everything the conservative party
01:49:34 actually has and i think that's probably where he he may struggle with is maintaining grassroots
01:49:39 support when kind of expanding to what may be considered more moderate parts of the country
01:49:44 including Atlantic Canada and parts of Ontario. And from a leadership perspective, I'll tell
01:49:49 people a little bit more in depth about the rules and regulations of the race if that interests you
01:49:54 later on, but I will note that each riding has an equal weighting in the overall results. Each
01:50:00 riding is worth 100 points, whether it's a riding that has 7,000 Conservative members like Calgary
01:50:06 West or Calgary Heritage, or if it has just a few dozen members like some of the Quebec ridings do.
01:50:11 So in areas where the Conservatives are not as strong or don't have a huge or robust membership list, in a leadership race, it actually can be quite beneficial because you have to work a lot less hard to win the points that that riding has.
01:50:25 And when you talk about some of these Atlantic Canada ridings that don't have a huge conservative presences, if they have like a membership list that has just 100 people or a couple of hundred people, if he could get a lot of those, that would be a very easy path to a really significant scoring in this leadership.
01:50:42 Yeah, exactly.
01:50:43 And I mean, we've talked or you both have talked tonight about the impact of the Jason or the Jason Kenney endorsement of Aaron O'Toole.
01:50:50 When that's really important, at the end of the day, you don't need Alberta to, despite a lot of the membership being located in Alberta, you don't need to win Alberta to win the leadership, which even Maxime Bernier demonstrated last time.
01:51:00 He won Alberta and still managed to lose the race.
01:51:03 So I think that regional breakdown does make a huge difference.
01:51:06 whether or not, you know, Peter McKay has enough support between Atlantic Canada and Quebec to
01:51:13 kind of counter any support he's losing in the West, that remains to be seen. I guess the other
01:51:17 strength Peter McKay does have is despite the endorsement of Jason Kenney and a lot of the UCP
01:51:22 backing McKay, you did see a lot of conservative MPs from Alberta support Peter McKay. So there
01:51:29 is a bit of a divide there. And that's, that'll be interesting to see if the MP endorsements
01:51:34 actually translate. In the last election, we saw that Scheer had a number of the caucus endorsements
01:51:40 and then did end up pulling it off. So maybe those endorsements do matter, maybe they don't
01:51:46 matter. I guess it'll be interesting to see how that works out tonight. It'll be one of the things
01:51:50 I'm looking for. Well, Devin, enough about Peter McKay. Aside from him, I mean, you've been following
01:51:56 this race really closely. You've been writing op-eds for True North and commentary. What do you think
01:52:02 the big sort of moments are, what has the takeaway been? And are you confident in the sort of strength
01:52:08 of the Conservative Party at this point to be a real contender to beat Justin Trudeau in the next
01:52:13 election? Yeah, I think the biggest takeaway for me is just how disappointed I think the
01:52:21 grassroots are in kind of the old candidates. And I'm going to say, I'm going to lump Aaron O'Toole
01:52:26 and Peter McKay in that category together. And I think one of the big things I saw is how much
01:52:30 momentum lesden lewis has been able to gain and she went from literally a universal unknown to
01:52:35 raising millions of dollars and that's no easy feat when you looked at last during the last
01:52:40 leadership race you had candidates who everyone thought or who mainstream media loved to talk
01:52:44 about like uh um like um lisa wright for example who couldn't even hold her own seat in the last
01:52:50 election but everyone was hyping lisa wright up as if she was going to be the next leader of the
01:52:53 party or would have an important role and she couldn't even manage to win her seat
01:52:56 because she just, at the end of the day, was not exciting for the grassroots of the party.
01:53:00 We have someone like Lesley Lewis who is able to speak passionately about both social and fiscal
01:53:05 conservative policies, and she's managed to do a great job. So I think that's kind of the big
01:53:10 takeaway. I do think unity is a big problem for the Conservative Party after this leadership.
01:53:16 If the party fails to unite behind the leader, whether or not it's any of those candidates I've
01:53:21 mentioned or Derek Sloan, if they fail to do that, I think they're going to have a hard time
01:53:25 uh, leading into the next election. And I do think we need, we need to ensure that both,
01:53:29 that all, all four candidates have a significant role in the party moving forward. Um, I think
01:53:34 that that was a fault of Maxime. I think he's, uh, he's went from somebody who had a lot of
01:53:39 relevance to now he's kind of seen on the fringe and would have had a lot more influence if he was
01:53:44 given a key role in, uh, Andrew Scheer's shadow cabinet. Um, we didn't see that. I I'd like to
01:53:49 see that, um, no matter who wins tonight, all four leadership candidates have front bench roles or
01:53:54 in the case of Leslin or Peter, are willing to seek nominations or at least be involved
01:53:59 in a fundraising capacity and a local event capacity.
01:54:06 You touch on an important point there.
01:54:08 And I know it's very difficult to do the what if and the what about game because, you know,
01:54:12 in a parallel universe in which Maxime Bernier stayed in the Conservative Party of Canada,
01:54:16 I think there's a very high likelihood that he's the leader tonight.
01:54:20 And I think that that shows the importance of, I think, hanging around, and if you are a conservative, of working to build a policy, of working to build a party, of building a base, of building all of these things, rather than just moving out and trying to start your own thing.
01:54:37 Because quite frankly, Maxime Bernier was so close, and a lot of the criticisms he had put towards Andrew Scheer tended to come to pass.
01:54:45 So I think we were looking at a very different race if Bernier were still in the conservative party.
01:54:50 I mean, certainly he'd still be a member of Parliament right now.
01:54:53 Yeah, absolutely.
01:54:54 I mean, he would have held his seat pretty easily, I think.
01:54:57 And I think he could have been an important voice for kind of that libertarian populist
01:55:01 wing, however you categorize Maxine Bernier these days.
01:55:03 But I think I think he definitely made a mistake in doing that.
01:55:06 I think he he was an important voice in the last election.
01:55:09 I think he was able to bring in a kind of or unite both libertarians and social conservatives,
01:55:14 which is actually a huge it's not an easy task all the time, but it's really important
01:55:19 to keep the base together. And even if you look at some of the polling that was done,
01:55:23 that was asking questions like, what is the most important thing you're looking for in a candidate?
01:55:29 Some of those people just wanted to vote for a candidate that they could defeat Justin Trudeau.
01:55:33 That doesn't mean that they, you know, necessarily want to elect somebody as leader that can't keep
01:55:40 the party together, because that is at the end of the day, the only way to beat Justin Trudeau.
01:55:43 So I do think Maxine Bernays shot himself in the foot there. And I think unity has to be the main,
01:55:49 the main takeaway from tonight if we do get the results so i don't i don't disagree i think that
01:55:54 maxine bernie if he had stayed in the party would be much more relevant today but i can't blame
01:55:58 it entirely on him devon i mean like you said he didn't even have a role in andrew shear's shadow
01:56:04 cabinet he was sort of pushed to the side we saw him coming out really strong with messaging on
01:56:09 immigration speaking out against illegal immigration it seemed to make the conservative
01:56:14 sort of establishment uncomfortable uh to the point where he was sort of pushed out from my
01:56:18 perspective so i think that that was on andrew sheer for failing to really keep the party uh
01:56:24 united and andrew lawton and i talked about it earlier how everyone thought that the divides
01:56:29 in the party were the sort of old alliance uh pc parties i i i think those lines still exist and
01:56:34 if peter mckay wins tonight uh we will see them um but but but i think that that sort of again
01:56:40 almost like populist establishment uh divide you you gotta say that's just as much on the
01:56:45 establishment side uh as it is on the populist side uh so so uh just speaking of the sort of
01:56:52 again regional divides between the the sort of peace alliance what do you make of alberta what
01:56:58 do you think uh would happen say if if peter mckay uh did win i think you said that he got a couple
01:57:04 of endorsements from mps in alberta which is really surprising uh do you think that that folks
01:57:09 in Alberta who are very conservative or very libertarian, very populist, would stick with
01:57:15 the Conservative Party with a Peter McKay leader? Yeah, and not to sound patronizing to my many
01:57:21 friends in Alberta, but I don't think they have another real place to go right now. I don't think
01:57:25 the PPC is a maintainable party in most seats in Alberta, and unless the Wexit party takes off,
01:57:30 I don't think they have a real, they don't have anywhere else to go right now. I don't think that
01:57:36 means, though, that Peter McKay can take advantage of them, which is, I think, to your point, that's
01:57:41 what Andrew Scheer was doing with Maxine Bernier's wing of the party, right? He was not letting him
01:57:45 speak out on issues, but was trying to make sure that he still had all of their support. I think
01:57:51 it's important that if I was Peter McKay and I won the race tonight, the first person I would
01:57:57 call tomorrow morning, one of the first people I would call tomorrow morning would be Jason Kenney
01:58:00 to make sure to really get that support back.
01:58:04 I wonder if it may have been a mistake by Jason Kenney
01:58:08 to endorse so early in the race,
01:58:10 because I think Lesley Lewis is going to do very well
01:58:13 in Alberta tonight as well.
01:58:14 And I think it would be embarrassing to him
01:58:15 if Jason Kenney doesn't come out heavily on top in,
01:58:19 or sorry, if Aaron Atul doesn't come out a lot on top in Alberta,
01:58:22 I think it'll look bad on Jason Kenney's behalf.
01:58:24 But I do think that Peter needs to, if he does win tonight,
01:58:28 needs to work with jason kenny a lot and work with the ucp a lot to maintain support in alberta
01:58:34 and he also needs to um and and him and aaron atool will have this problem that they'll need to be
01:58:40 open to keeping the social conservatives in the tent i don't like either of their answers i know
01:58:44 alissa just mentioned uh both of their positions um you know uh jason or um where peter mckay
01:58:52 won't let those bills be discussed aaron atool says he will but that was you know we're all we've
01:58:57 all become aware of how a leader can say one thing and then, you know, in cabinet meetings
01:59:02 do a completely other thing. So I really don't like either of those answers. I think they need
01:59:06 to be more welcoming to social conservatives if elected leader tonight. I think the Alberta
01:59:12 dimension is an important one. And there's no better trio to talk about the intricacies of
01:59:17 Alberta representation than two Ontarians and a Nova Scotian. But bear with us if you're listening,
01:59:21 because you're going to find probably the three most Alberta-friendly Ontarians and Nova Scotians
01:59:27 in this group right now, because I spent a lot of time in the last several months covering Western
01:59:32 alienation. I don't necessarily think of myself as an Ontarian yet. You know, I've definitely
01:59:36 lived here for a few years, but in my heart, I'm still a Western Canadian.
01:59:41 Fair enough. And that's why I go with Western sympathetic. But, you know, I've spent a lot of
01:59:45 time covering the Western alienation, talking to a lot of the people that are really leaning
01:59:50 towards greater independence and in some cases separation. And I do think that regardless of
01:59:55 the result there's a big loss in that not a single western Canadian was in the race at all I mean
02:00:01 the closest you could say would be Rick Peterson who was not able to get on the ballot I mean he's
02:00:07 running for a nomination in Edmonton Strathcona but but I really don't think he's a model Albertan
02:00:12 in the sense of what we're talking about when it comes to really being a an unabashed Alberta
02:00:17 defender and and you know even if someone wasn't going to win it would have been really great to
02:00:21 see someone who represented the West in and and there were people that opted not to I mean you
02:00:26 had Western MPs like Candace Bergen and Michelle Rempel that didn't want I didn't want to run
02:00:30 Ronna Ambrose who's from Alberta didn't want to run so so it's not like there weren't options but
02:00:35 the fact that no one stepped up I think is a big loss for the party because a lot of people in the
02:00:41 West are looking at the race and saying my interests are not represented in any of the
02:00:45 candidates. Yeah, I think that's completely true. And I mean, also, you have somebody like Pierre 0.55
02:00:53 Polyev, who is an Ontario MP, but is a Franco Albertan originally. So, you know, there were a
02:00:58 lot of candidates in the race that could have taken advantage of that Western or not taken
02:01:02 advantage, but would have benefited from being the Western candidate. I'm shocked that no one
02:01:06 entered the race just to be the Western candidate because it seems like a clear, you know, they
02:01:09 would have had a clear path to, you know, getting at least, you know, first or second ballot support
02:01:15 by a lot of, a lot of the membership. So I do think that is disappointing. I think there's also
02:01:20 a lot of diversity amongst the Western caucus, or diversity of belief amongst the Western caucus.
02:01:25 So you could have had, you know, a more libertarian leaning member of the Western
02:01:28 caucus run or more populist or social conservative candidates. So there would have been a lot of
02:01:32 good candidates to choose from, from the West. And hopefully, no matter who wins tonight,
02:01:39 they can tap into a lot of the talent we have in the Western bench to keep those people
02:01:42 involved. Western alienation is a real thing, and we need to be very careful with it, which
02:01:48 I think the last time we, or not the last time, but under Mulroney and Campbell, we realize what
02:01:55 happens if we ignore them. Well, the last time that there was a PC, a progressive conservative,
02:02:00 really running the country, which, you know, again, if Peter McKay wins, the party's called
02:02:04 the Conservative Party now, but he very much, you know, his ideology and his worldview and
02:02:09 where he comes from, his political history is very much
02:02:12 on that side, the progressive conservative side.
02:02:16 Well, Devin, thank you so much for your insight.
02:02:18 It's great to have someone on the team
02:02:20 from Eastern Canada, from Atlantic Canada,
02:02:22 and we appreciate you coming on
02:02:24 on very short notice here tonight.
02:02:25 So enjoy watching the rest of the show
02:02:28 and thank you so much to Devin Drover.
02:02:31 Thank you for having me.
02:02:32 Have a good night, bye-bye.
02:02:34 All right, see you later.
02:02:36 So we are live.
02:02:38 We're doing our supposed to be the pre-show before the conservative leadership race winner
02:02:43 is announced.
02:02:44 Although at this point, Andrew, do we have any word, anything from the party about where
02:02:49 we're at in terms of a timeline?
02:02:51 No, I don't know how many ballots are stuck in the shredder yet.
02:02:54 So we don't have anything in the way of numbers.
02:02:57 And again, this is something to take with a grain of salt, because I know that oftentimes
02:03:01 the rooms themselves where the ballots are being counted and where the scrutineers are
02:03:05 very uh closed off however cory tonight who is fairly well connected he's not affiliated formally
02:03:12 with any campaign said on cbc that it looks like mckay is not doing all that well in the early
02:03:17 results and that leslin lewis is doing quite well now i don't know how to quantify not very well and
02:03:22 quite well and i i don't know if again this is just a bit of bluster but this is uh again if we
02:03:27 are reporting what we get this is what we've got right now in the absence of numbers the uh the
02:03:32 official timeline that's been proposed by the party is that we're going to have their stream
02:03:36 starting at 7 30 eastern which is in about 27 minutes again this was already delayed 90 minutes
02:03:42 with not much notice so we have to be prepared that it could be bumped back again but that's
02:03:47 where we are right now but as we've said we're in it for the long haul we're bringing you
02:03:50 commentary analysis interviews with people from true north and from outside the true north family
02:03:55 that have their finger to the pulse of what's happening in canadian conservative politics
02:04:00 Yeah, and that was interesting to have Devin Drover on one of our researchers and a contributor
02:04:07 here at True North because, well, he's from Atlantic Canada, but I don't think he's always
02:04:11 the biggest supporter of Peter McKay, so definitely an interesting perspective there. And we've got
02:04:17 another True North fellow that is going to be joining us here. We've got Anthony Fury. I guess
02:04:23 you're in Toronto or maybe somewhere up in cottage country, Anthony, but thank you so much for taking
02:04:29 the last minute invitation to joining us on this show hey guys great to be here no i i'm not up uh
02:04:36 i'm not in toronto i'm at an undisclosed bunker somewhere in rural ontario so uh hanging out up
02:04:42 here in uh in great parts of the woods great well thank you so much uh for for coming on anthony so
02:04:49 you know you're you're really a national security sort of expert and someone who pays a lot of
02:04:54 of attention to security and those kinds of issues.
02:04:57 Doesn't really seem like that kind of stuff
02:04:59 has come up very much on this campaign.
02:05:02 But I wanted to get your take on it
02:05:04 because both Erin O'Toole and Peter McKay
02:05:07 have sort of military backgrounds
02:05:10 and they're big supporters of Canadian Armed Forces.
02:05:14 So I wanna hear your take specifically
02:05:17 from a national security perspective on these candidates
02:05:20 and how this campaign has gone so far.
02:05:24 Well, and I think these are some of the issues that really matter right now, Candace, because, yes, we're obviously in the pandemic, we've got the worst debt and deficit we've ever had, so those issues really matter, and we're going to have to learn to pivot, really, on a whole number of fronts with how we approach politics.
02:05:39 But even prior to the pandemic, foreign affairs is really the big issue.
02:05:44 We've got a world very much changing.
02:05:47 We've got China competing with the United States to be the rising global superpower.
02:05:51 These are things that have to be confronted. 0.96
02:05:54 We have to deal with them.
02:05:56 And Canada has to be positioned in a way to take best advantage of the future in all of this.
02:06:01 Pick and choose the right allies, distance ourselves from different organizations and countries
02:06:06 and these sort of multinational institutions
02:06:09 that perhaps don't best serve our interests.
02:06:11 So I do think, and I wrote a column
02:06:13 when this whole leadership first began,
02:06:15 talking about the fact that, well, odds are Peter McKay
02:06:17 or Aaron O'Toole will be one of the two who win.
02:06:20 This is, you know, we're thinking months ago
02:06:22 and still is right now.
02:06:23 And at least we're pretty well served from that
02:06:25 because they're both foreign policy-minded individuals.
02:06:28 I don't know how much they're willing to deviate
02:06:30 from the status quo, which is what we need right now,
02:06:32 but I'm glad that their eye is on that issue.
02:06:35 they do both have a background. Yeah, I think that's an important aspect of this. And both of
02:06:41 them have really been pushing those credentials as being a part of their experience and their
02:06:46 vision. Aaron O'Toole, I think, is in that RCAF jacket and pretty much every photo of him that's
02:06:51 taken at all, like anywhere in the campaign. Peter McKay often talks about his time serving
02:06:56 in Afghanistan, which I find is a bit disingenuous because I think there's a difference between
02:07:01 wearing a uniform and being a defense minister, but both of them have really tried to bolster that
02:07:06 foreign policy side of their experience. And I guess that lends itself to a question of,
02:07:12 do you think there really has been that much of a substantive focus on policy,
02:07:16 foreign or otherwise, throughout the race? No, there hasn't at all. It's been really
02:07:21 disappointing. And I also think one thing that, obviously, the pandemic has been a bit to the
02:07:26 detriment of the leadership, because, I mean, hey, guys, if I knew that all you needed to do
02:07:31 to become the next conservative leader was make a bunch of phone calls and put up some YouTube
02:07:35 videos and you were actually banned from doing campaigning. Gee, I would have run and a whole
02:07:39 bunch of people would because, you know, that's pretty much stuff that we all do now. Anyway,
02:07:43 so they've obviously been hamstringed in terms of doing what is a traditional
02:07:47 leadership campaign, going around meetings, reading people, working the room
02:07:51 and so forth, and that's been unfortunate. But what we're also seeing
02:07:55 right now, and I've been predicting, and you guys have been talking about this a lot now,
02:07:58 I think post-pandemic, I mean, a lot of the functions are going to be challenged.
02:08:03 A lot of individuals, you know, Justin Trudeau, among many, are just not aware of the fact
02:08:08 a lot of stuff is going to change.
02:08:10 And I think people are rethinking their relationship to so many things, obviously to travel, but
02:08:16 also to public health, to government.
02:08:18 They're going to be rethinking trade.
02:08:20 They're going to be rethinking economic nationalism, regular folks, not just those engaged in the
02:08:25 political process already.
02:08:26 And I think one of my big criticisms I would make
02:08:29 of this current leadership race
02:08:31 is that they haven't seemed to acknowledge this.
02:08:33 It just seems like a regular conservative leadership race.
02:08:35 Guys, the very definition of what is conservative,
02:08:38 what is liberal, what is social democrat,
02:08:40 what is republican, that's all going out the window
02:08:42 in the next few years is a really radically change.
02:08:46 And I wish you'd kind of flush that out a bit.
02:08:48 That's a really good point, Anthony,
02:08:50 because I do feel like the world is sort of orienting
02:08:52 more towards you have the sort of elites
02:08:55 the people who are in charge who tell us what to do and what to think and then you you sort of have
02:08:59 the rest of the people we we played some interviews earlier that uh andrew did with some different
02:09:03 campaign uh people for the different campaigns and they were all kind of talking the same thing that
02:09:09 you know their their campaigns appealed more broadly uh to people than just the specific
02:09:13 say type of conservative they are like like derek sloan appealed to a lot of people aside from just
02:09:18 you know people who are social conservatives a lot of it was because he he came out pretty
02:09:22 strongly saying that i uh disagree with uh the mandatory wearing of masks well uh you know you've
02:09:29 been covering well i mean with your job with the toronto sun you know you cover the news day in
02:09:34 and day out and this has been a really really turbulent say six months in the world it's also
02:09:39 been a really interesting past two three weeks just seeing how the trudeau government is sort of
02:09:44 self-destructing and and crumbling you basically see a dumpster fire over the prime minister's
02:09:49 office you've been covering that uh really really closely so what what do you think is is in store
02:09:55 for whoever wins tonight what what's what's it going to be like the next you know couple of
02:09:59 weeks couple of months uh trying to hold this trudeau government to account yeah and a couple
02:10:05 of weeks is really i think the important way to put it because of course there's a phone speech
02:10:09 coming up towards the end of september and as i read my column in today's gun papers i mean i
02:10:14 And I think this speech is more going to represent a platform, and it's going to represent a
02:10:19 completely new platform, Trudeau going in a different direction, or at least ratcheting
02:10:24 up what he does.
02:10:25 This is like, you know, Trudeau on steroids or what have you, it's pulled in, there was
02:10:28 media reports from inside liberal sources that there's going to be ambitious climate
02:10:33 goals.
02:10:34 Well, I'm sorry that I thought the previous goals were ambitious, but what on earth does
02:10:37 that mean?
02:10:38 Radical reform and social reform and so forth.
02:10:40 So I really think what we're looking at here is a platform, and quite frankly, one,
02:10:44 so far to the left that it may be judging single like it, Tom will care when you do not campaign
02:10:49 on the platform that Justin Trudeau is putting together. And if you want to put forward a
02:10:53 platform, well, there's a place and a time for that. It's called an election. A throne feed
02:10:57 is really just a little reset. You realize, okay, I had my legislative priorities to accomplish my
02:11:03 agenda, but they weren't right. They're going to bring in some different legislation, but the
02:11:07 agenda still has to be the same within that umbrella. That's not what we're looking at right
02:11:12 now I think we're being told a whole new agenda I think what Justin Trudeau is doing is going
02:11:15 all right you don't let a you don't let a crisis go to waste here's my opportunity and I'm going
02:11:20 to throw off the cloak of you know pretending to be some sort of centrist of the you know Paul
02:11:25 Martin mold not that any of us ever believe that and I'm now saying here I am full progressive
02:11:30 SJW you know let's get this party going I say okay fine if that's who you want to be all right
02:11:35 and you know I'd expect democracy but put it to the people so I really think there needs to be
02:11:40 election pretty soon i don't like the idea of spending all that money just 12 months after the
02:11:43 last one i i guess that there are technical challenges to doing it during a pandemic but
02:11:47 you know he's the guy who i think is bringing us to this juncture where we have something
02:11:51 totally different than what he campaigned on only 12 months ago yeah very well said anthony fury
02:11:58 toronto sun columnist and true north fellow thanks very much for coming on on such short notice
02:12:03 thanks guys have a good one thank you sorry i'm told we had some audio issues with anthony there
02:12:10 sorry about those we'll try to get those fixed up in the post-production version but that is the
02:12:14 the challenge with live television or live candace and i haven't figured out what to call this yet
02:12:19 but live something so in any case casting on the internet there we go yeah live streaming as the
02:12:25 kids say these days but in any case this is the true north live conservative leadership results
02:12:32 show. We are going to continue to follow this. I've seen some reports that the leadership results
02:12:37 might be delayed even further to 8pm potentially. There are apparently thousands of ballots or at
02:12:43 least a thousand that need to be looked at manually because the machine has been ripping
02:12:47 them up. So a process that was supposed to be somewhat automated is now looking at something
02:12:53 that is a lot more manual. And this takes a fair bit of time. We were talking with Anthony about
02:12:58 some of the policy centric discussions that we would have loved to have seen and one of the big
02:13:03 ones and certainly one of the issues that has been very dramatically represented in discussions we've
02:13:08 had and what our supporters have asked us is the carbon tax and people on the right certainly say
02:13:14 they're against Justin Trudeau's carbon tax but there was some confusion about whether in fact
02:13:19 all four candidates were unequivocally against it and you had Derek Sloan promoting himself as being
02:13:26 the only one that wanted to get out of the Paris Accord. You had Leslyn Lewis that said she wanted
02:13:31 a sensible, common sense approach to it. And because she had an environmental sciences
02:13:36 background, I think people were a little bit unclear on which side of the global warming
02:13:41 alarmism discussion she was on. And then you had Aaron O'Toole's platform, which I challenged him
02:13:47 on in my fireside chat with him at the Independent Press Gallery event a few weeks ago. And I'll roll
02:13:52 that clip now one of the things that most conservatives i think can agree on is that the
02:13:58 carbon tax is a job killer i think this is something that everyone on the right tends to
02:14:02 get even many people not on the right you say in your platform that the carbon tax is gone
02:14:07 you also say you want a national regulatory and pricing scheme on industrial emitters and your
02:14:14 rationale for this has been that you don't want to target individual canadian families but rather
02:14:19 target the companies themselves. We all know that any cost that a company has to bear gets filtered
02:14:26 down. So any tax that's put on a manufacturer or distributor is something that Canadians are paying.
02:14:31 So how can you say you're against the carbon tax when your plan seems to just move the tax to
02:14:35 another payer? No, there is no tax. There's no federal carbon tax. I will eliminate the carbon
02:14:41 tax completely, Andrew. What I've said in terms of the national framework, we have to respect what
02:14:48 the provinces are doing now. In BC, there's been their provincial carbon tax started by Gordon
02:14:54 Campbell. I've talked to him about some of the challenges and problems that were caused,
02:14:59 but he explained to me his rationale there. Quebec has a version of a cap-and-trade system.
02:15:04 Alberta, Ontario, my own province has a large emitter strategy just working with emissions
02:15:09 of the larger emitters. We need to follow the provinces here because guess what? They have
02:15:15 shared jurisdiction on the economy I've been saying this for years the Court of
02:15:19 Appeal in Alberta in February just supported my view when they said
02:15:22 Trudeau's carbon tax is unconstitutional we actually have to say on the federal
02:15:27 government how can we make sure we respect the different approach within a
02:15:33 national framework and say this is how we're going to reduce emissions not with
02:15:37 a tax but with partnering with the provinces to get their emissions down
02:15:41 but does your platform or does it not say pricing because the provinces are pricing but you say
02:15:48 national pricing so is there going can you say that there is not going to be any federal price
02:15:53 on carbon at a federal level for anyone whether it's a family or an industrial emitter the
02:15:58 provinces will be in the driver's seat so I will respect what they do well Andrew you handled those
02:16:08 those fireside chats so well,
02:16:10 and you got so much new information.
02:16:11 I remember afterwards it was like,
02:16:13 we learned things about both those candidates
02:16:14 that we didn't really know.
02:16:16 And that answer that you got
02:16:18 on the sort of climate change policy,
02:16:20 to me, it just seemed like doublespeak,
02:16:22 the sort of, you know,
02:16:24 exactly the typical political speak that you expect
02:16:28 where, you know, he was saying one thing,
02:16:29 but he could have been saying something else.
02:16:31 Were you satisfied with that answer?
02:16:34 And what do you think the climate policy would be
02:16:37 under Aaron O'Toole? You know, I was satisfied with the answer he gave, but it was still confusing
02:16:43 about why it had to get to that point because the Peter McKay campaign had actually been
02:16:48 pressuring Andrew, pressuring Aaron O'Toole rather on that section of his platform for quite a while
02:16:53 and there was never a response or a clarification. So, I mean, the reason I asked about it was because
02:16:58 I was still unclear on what he supported and his answer didn't seem to align with the wording that
02:17:03 I had took or the interpretation that I had took from the platform I was happy with the answer I
02:17:08 was just a bit confused about why I had to press him on it so hard in that interview yeah and I
02:17:15 mean that's kind of the whole point of the leadership race is to get to know the candidates
02:17:20 get to know their policies so that in a general election there isn't the kind of confusion you can
02:17:25 you can expect that you know what they said during the leadership race that you know that's going to
02:17:30 be their policy and you can kind of have a clear idea it still isn't really clear in my mind what
02:17:35 what his policy um would be but i mean again that's sort of also the nature of these campaigns
02:17:41 is that you have one campaign saying one thing you know the candidate themselves saying something
02:17:46 different but i wanted to uh ask you andrew quickly before we bring on our next guest um
02:17:52 so something about what anthony fury brought up which was that he didn't really think that
02:17:57 Justin Trudeau had a mandate anymore,
02:17:59 and he thinks that it's time to go to a general
02:18:03 and have an election.
02:18:04 I know that that was Justin Trudeau's sort of own
02:18:06 justification for the prorogation of parliament.
02:18:10 He said that, you know, he was gonna introduce
02:18:12 something that was so ambitious,
02:18:13 it was only fair to restart parliament
02:18:15 and have a new session.
02:18:17 Well, just judging Trudeau from his own rhetoric,
02:18:19 then wouldn't that lead to also needing to get
02:18:21 a new mandate from Canadians?
02:18:23 What do you think?
02:18:24 Do you think that there's going to be an election
02:18:25 coming up soon? Or do you think it's still, you know, a ways away? I think if you were to take
02:18:31 the pandemic out of the equation, and questions about safety and logistics and health of having
02:18:37 an election, I think there's a hugely strong case to have a fall election, even though that would
02:18:42 just be one year past the previous election. So I do think there are going to be issues about
02:18:47 whether it looks to be a bit more opportunistic if there's an election now or whatever the case
02:18:52 may be. But I think if you're to take coronavirus out of the equation, there is a tremendous
02:18:57 justification for an election. So I guess the question is, do you then find a way to do it
02:19:02 because it's what makes sense for the country and you work around it? I think a lot will depend on
02:19:06 how the United States tries to navigate this terrain. I just want to deviate for a moment
02:19:11 from the direction we're going here because there have apparently been some interviews on TV
02:19:15 with representatives from the McKay campaign and the O'Toole campaign.
02:19:20 And the tone of this is that Fred DeLore, who we heard from earlier, tremendously confident.
02:19:26 And Peter McKay's campaign is actually downplaying expectations.
02:19:30 So whether this is a bit of flexing on the part of either, I don't know, or strategy,
02:19:35 but that's just the tone as it's coming in.
02:19:36 The campaigns are showing a very different interpretation of what they've seen so far
02:19:42 with O'Toole's campaign very confident
02:19:43 and McKay's campaign a fair bit more reserved.
02:19:47 Well, interesting.
02:19:47 And we did talk about that a little earlier
02:19:49 that if you were only watching the mainstream media,
02:19:51 you're only watching the CBC,
02:19:53 you would think that Peter McKay had this thing in the bag
02:19:55 and that he was going to run away with it.
02:19:57 But, you know, from the conversations I've had
02:19:59 with conservatives and some of the polling I've seen,
02:20:02 you know, of course, polling's like always going to be off
02:20:05 and traditionally is not very accurate.
02:20:07 But it seems to me like Aaron O'Toole is doing pretty well
02:20:11 so is Les and Lewis. Well, Andrew, let's bring in our friend Aaron Gunn. Aaron Gunn is a political
02:20:17 commentator. I had him as a guest on my show for the True North Speaker Series a couple of weeks
02:20:22 ago. And Aaron Gunn, you're out in Vancouver Island, is that right? Yeah, out here in Victoria.
02:20:30 Victoria. So first of all, thank you for coming on our podcast on our live stream,
02:20:35 sort of late, late notice and last minute, we appreciate it. Why don't you give us a little
02:20:40 bit of an update about what uh what the campaigns have done out in british columbia and uh what you
02:20:45 know from people that you're hearing people that you're speaking with uh you know what do you make
02:20:50 of this race so far well i think like uh some of your previous guests noted earlier uh all the
02:20:57 candidates are from out east or at least from our perspective uh what is out east and with the
02:21:03 COVID travel restrictions, I think you have that added almost obstacle of them actually
02:21:10 interacting with British Columbians. So most of the interactions have been online. I think the
02:21:16 kind of traditional different camps of the Conservative Party are all there and being
02:21:22 represented. So the Social Conservatives obviously strongly promoting Leslyn Lewis. I would note that
02:21:29 A couple of high-profile BCMPs have endorsed Peter McKay, which had upset a lot of their
02:21:37 socially conservative members. So I've heard that story, especially in the riding of Abbotsford,
02:21:44 over and over again as well. You raise an interesting point there, and I know a lot of
02:21:49 Albertans might not want to be lumped in with British Columbia, but there are a lot of British
02:21:54 Columbia ridings, I mean, if you get outside of the Vancouver area and the lower mainland,
02:21:58 that are very much aligned with some of the Western issues.
02:22:01 They're experiencing the issues with the federal government's energy policy right now.
02:22:05 They're experiencing the problems with pipeline uncertainty, a lot of the economic challenges.
02:22:10 So, I mean, there are parts of BC, especially in the North, that are very much in the West.
02:22:15 Would you say that any of those issues have really been discussed outside of, I mean,
02:22:19 there was that one Zoom debate that was hosted by a number of the British Columbia,
02:22:23 or I think all of the British Columbia Conservative Riding Associations.
02:22:27 But has anyone been speaking about these issues?
02:22:30 Well, I've been disappointed in it.
02:22:34 There's been some attempt to have a deeper conversation on these important issues that are for British Columbians, Western Canadians, and then just the kind of the cultural and big economic issues for Canada.
02:22:45 They feel at times haven't been discussed as forthrightly as they could have been, as, for example, Candace does on her show.
02:22:55 So I would really like to see that level of discussion actually moved also in the into the Conservative Party
02:23:00 But they seem to still be scared of the mainstream media of saying the wrong thing
02:23:06 And not having an open and frank discussion with Canadians
02:23:10 So that did concern me a little bit, but of course on the energy side there were some conversations
02:23:15 But not as much that I would have liked to see for sure
02:23:18 Well, Aaron, I know on your social media channels. You're really big critic of cancel culture
02:23:24 you've come to the defense of people like Don Cherry when they've been unfairly sort of maligned
02:23:29 by the mainstream media. Have you been impressed at all by any of the candidates, any of the
02:23:35 campaigns? I know you just said that you feel like they're all, you know, too afraid, too timid of the
02:23:39 mainstream media and what they might say, but have you seen any sort of glimmer of hope in terms of
02:23:45 any of the policy about cancer culture? And then just a sort of follow-up question, you know, how
02:23:50 come there wasn't any candidates from Western Canada? How come there weren't any MPs or anyone
02:23:54 from British Columbia that threw their head? I know Andrew Saxton ran in 2015 and he was sort of,
02:24:00 you know, the torchbearer for British Columbia for their issues. We didn't see anything like
02:24:04 that this time around, so maybe you could quickly comment on why we didn't see anyone from BC or
02:24:10 from Western Canada running. Well, that's a really good question, Candice, and I wish I had an answer
02:24:16 for you. To me, Justin Trudeau is an incredibly vulnerable Prime Minister. I think for someone
02:24:22 who is running for re-election, his first time for re-election, he got the lowest percentage of
02:24:28 the popular vote. I think that's a correct statistic. So I think he's someone that's
02:24:31 incredibly vulnerable. There's scandal after scandal. I would have hoped that there'd be
02:24:35 people lining up to take over the Conservative Party to get that chance. But I think your two
02:24:43 questions that were kind of related I think the ascent of cancel culture kind of the toxic
02:24:50 environment of working in the eye of the media now and trying to placate all these different
02:24:55 groups and the identity politics has really turned a lot of people off from politics in general
02:25:00 so I think that's one of the reasons as far as people speaking on the cancel culture topic I
02:25:07 I think there were, again, no one really excited me, but I would say Peter McKay disappointed
02:25:15 me the most, for sure, in a couple different points that he made.
02:25:21 So I think, you know, I think we'll see what happens and how, I'm sure this won't be decided
02:25:26 on the first ballot.
02:25:27 We'll see how everyone's second choices kind of pan out.
02:25:32 We are just five minutes away from when the Conservative Party of Canada is supposed to
02:25:37 be starting its show. And we're going to keep going as well, right up until the moment that
02:25:42 the results are available and start coming in again. We're still waiting on exactly what's
02:25:48 going to happen and when that is. I want to bring into this discussion with Aaron Gunn,
02:25:53 Sam Eskenazi, who is a fellow with True North. And he is ultimately someone that we have seen a lot
02:26:00 from and heard a lot from and really can break down some of these complex issues. Sam, do we
02:26:06 have you um i hope so hopefully no okay good yeah well i heard you say you hope so so we're glad to
02:26:11 have you here uh sam we just heard from aaron a lot of the problems about i think some of the
02:26:16 uh the alienation between uh the west and western issues and bc and also the candidates who by and
02:26:25 large are from you know downtown toronto i mean that's the dynamic with the exception of derek
02:26:29 sloan all of them are lawyers too so that's something you have to keep in mind what would
02:26:34 you say sam has been the biggest issue that you think needed to be covered and wasn't by any
02:26:40 candidates throughout the race well i think for me the biggest thing was a lot of people were
02:26:45 talking about modernizing the conservative party but there was very little substance as to what
02:26:49 that actually means and so is it going to be we're suddenly going to adopt identity politics and
02:26:54 become like the liberal party in many platform issues is it going to be that we're going to
02:26:59 simply say you know this issue and that issue are put to bed we're never going to discuss them ever
02:27:02 again? Is it going to be we're suddenly going to talk about conservative ideals or some kind of
02:27:06 value in a different way? Because I think there's a lot of messaging that could definitely be
02:27:10 improved. And that's the type of modernization that I would support. But very, very little kind
02:27:14 of substance that I saw, at least in that respect. That's a really good point. Whenever we hear that
02:27:19 word modernize, you kind of think, OK, they just want the party to become more liberal. They just
02:27:23 want us to become more politically correct and more in line with what they say. And I kind of
02:27:29 that same feeling with the talk of a moderate conservative i don't really know what that word
02:27:35 really means in terms of conservative i know aaron you were just saying that you were pretty
02:27:39 disappointed uh with peter mckay but i think i think the word moderate means the same thing in
02:27:43 this context modern moderate it basically just means a more liberal version of of the conservative
02:27:50 aaron what what do you think that the party is missing or what do you think that they need in
02:27:55 in order to get back into power in Ottawa?
02:28:01 Well, I think that's the question, Candice.
02:28:03 And to me, what the party is missing and what it needs
02:28:06 and whoever the new leader is needs to take up
02:28:08 is a bold vision for Canada that's complete.
02:28:14 So if you go back through kind of the,
02:28:16 some of the leaders in Canadian history,
02:28:18 I think on the conservative side,
02:28:19 you really need somebody to articulate something
02:28:22 like John A. Macdonald did back in the 1800s,
02:28:25 where he had a complete bold vision for Canada,
02:28:28 and Canadians rewarded him with six majority governments.
02:28:32 And I think if you look at and you read your history
02:28:34 about some of the incredible undertakings that he took on,
02:28:37 we're not even in the same league right now.
02:28:40 And I think we're missing that.
02:28:42 I think people are hungry for that.
02:28:44 I think, by the way, it's not just Liberal voters
02:28:47 that could come over to the Conservative Party
02:28:49 and present with a vision like that.
02:28:50 It could be new voters.
02:28:51 It can be people that haven't voted before. It can be rural NDP voters as well. So I think there's a hunger in this country for for a bold vision that nobody's talking about to do away with the political correctness. And we're just waiting for somebody to take up that mantle. And while I'm not exactly optimistic, I am hopeful that whoever wins this leadership race will come into their own and really embrace that opportunity.
02:29:18 I'm sorry to tell you, you mentioned John A. MacDonald, so you are effectively cancelled. Sorry, we have to cut you off there. We can't have any of that trash talking of anyone in this day and age.
02:29:30 Let's talk about the media side of things here, because the one thing that all conservatives, I think, secretly crave for, or in some cases not so secretly crave for, is politicians really kind of challenging the mainstream media the way that it deserves to be challenged.
02:29:45 And this is why I think there's a little id-like fascination that a lot of people who aren't even Trump supporters have with Donald Trump because he challenges, you know, the mainstream media.
02:29:55 We saw Andrew Scheer do this the other day on CBC.
02:29:58 We saw Aaron O'Toole do this a bit through the leadership.
02:30:01 Do you think that this could be something that we get from whomever the leader is that they're going to stop doing that thing of really trying to kiss the mainstream media's ring instead of saying,
02:30:12 listen, you aren't the best vessel for me to put my message forward.
02:30:15 We'll start with you, Sam.
02:30:16 I don't know if I would have said ring.
02:30:18 I think, you know, that's a good way to put it,
02:30:20 but definitely kissing something.
02:30:22 You know, look, I would hope so.
02:30:24 All we need is someone who's going to speak plainly to Canadians
02:30:27 to explain what they're going to do and not be sucked into some trap.
02:30:31 I mean, there's that clip that you shared in,
02:30:32 a number of people shared it, of Andrew Scheer, you know,
02:30:35 pushing back on Natasha Fada on the CBC about why, you know,
02:30:38 coverage of Les and Lewis.
02:30:39 that's was a very calm you know not an angry conservative not nothing crazy just listen you
02:30:45 ask yourself that question why did you guys not cover leslin that's the kind of pushback that we
02:30:49 need because so many conservatives tend to get trapped into this box they put you into a little
02:30:54 frame and now you're supposed to argue your way out of this little box that you're in when the
02:30:58 premise of the question might be just totally farcical and so pushing back is definitely
02:31:02 something that needs to be done it doesn't need to be done in a mean mean-spirited way you don't
02:31:05 need to be Donald Trump to be firm and say, listen, you know, I'm sorry, but I reject the premise of
02:31:10 the question. What actually happened is A, B and C. So definitely, I hope so. You know, we'll see
02:31:14 who wins, but I hope they're going to do such a thing. Yeah. And I think you raised something
02:31:19 that was kind of, you know, the idea of watching Andrew share pushback against Natasha. I don't
02:31:24 have a problem with Natasha. I think she's one of the better, if not the best journalist over at
02:31:28 the CBC. And at least she asked that question. I don't know that any of the other hosts over the
02:31:34 CBC would even ask that. But when you see Andrew Scheer kind of push back against her, you're like,
02:31:39 yes, this is exactly what a conservative needs to do. And you kind of wonder, like, where was this
02:31:44 Andrew Scheer over the last year? Why wasn't he this punchy and this willing to push back against
02:31:49 the media when he was leader? And I really hope that whoever wins tonight is able to sort of have
02:31:55 that courage and that ability to push back against the media. I think we have a clip of
02:32:02 Derek Sloan doing exactly that. So let's play that clip now.
02:32:09 You've experienced yourself a fair bit of pushback from the mainstream media, not just on
02:32:15 social conservative issues, which I suspect we'll get to later on in this discussion, but even your
02:32:20 approach to some issues that have been very pertinent throughout the coronavirus pandemic,
02:32:25 such as wanting Theresa Tam, the public health officer of Canada, fired. We know from the last
02:32:31 election, from all of Stephen Harper's elections, conservatives are not dealt
02:32:35 a fair hand by the mainstream media. And I think that on the cultural side
02:32:39 we can talk about media bias and all of these things. But if you're within
02:32:43 those parameters, you're operating as a figure in Canadian politics,
02:32:47 you know the treatments the media is going to give you is not going to be good. How do you
02:32:51 push back against that when you are, as you know, a conservative without apology,
02:32:55 a hardliner on a lot of social and economic issues?
02:32:59 Well, I mean, the simple answer is you don't jump through their hoops.
02:33:02 And so there's been, I mean, we get a lot of requests from mainstream media that we just ignore.
02:33:07 And it has nothing to do with, you know, it has nothing to do with those organizations,
02:33:12 but it has to do with the fight that we're in.
02:33:15 And right now, our fight is to win this leadership battle.
02:33:18 So I'm not, there's some candidates who bask in the glory of, you know,
02:33:22 sitting down with CBC and all this stuff.
02:33:24 If I don't think that sitting down with a particular media outlet is going to help me reach conservative members,
02:33:30 I don't even bother going on.
02:33:33 So part of it is just not jumping through the hoops that the media has.
02:33:36 And in a general election, obviously, the strategy is different.
02:33:40 But the other thing, too, we have to remember is that we have access to social media.
02:33:44 And we can drive our narrative through controversy or not using social media.
02:33:48 So I think that we, you know, my experience anyways is that there's some conservatives
02:33:54 who feel that they've done a good day's work when the media isn't slamming them.
02:33:58 And to me, I say, listen, you know, if the media isn't slamming you, maybe you're not
02:34:02 doing a good day's work.
02:34:03 You know, if you're going to stand on conservative principles in this day and age, you're going
02:34:07 to get kicked back.
02:34:09 And sometimes we need to be able to stand there and take it and say, you know what,
02:34:12 we've said the right thing.
02:34:13 We don't need to apologize.
02:34:15 We don't need to rephrase what we're trying to say.
02:34:18 Well, I think conservatives just feel good when they see, whenever you see someone pushing
02:34:28 back against the media, we know the media in this country are so unfair to conservatives
02:34:32 and don't give them a fair punch. I think that one of the keys to a conservative winning
02:34:37 election is bypassing the media. I mean, you see so many new organizations like True North,
02:34:42 like The Rebel, there's so many people out there where you have the ability to just bypass
02:34:47 the media entirely so why would you go through their filters and we saw that uh down in the
02:34:51 u.s with trump you know he's been doing this for years uh completely bypassing media regardless
02:34:56 of what you think of trump himself you have to admire his his message and his ability uh to just
02:35:01 kind of bypass the uh the the media sam i want to get your your thoughts on this uh what what are
02:35:09 you thinking what do you think is going to happen tonight uh what are your thoughts on the the
02:35:13 campaign and how how it's been run is there any specific candidate that you're talking about that
02:35:18 you're looking at that uh has really excited you or done anything that's really impressed you
02:35:23 so you know it's it's hard to say i mean i i don't want to pick favor we're so close to
02:35:27 we're so close to the announcement i feel i don't want to necessarily jump in with a last minute
02:35:31 prediction um you know i think i think it's been an interesting campaign i mean peter mckay has
02:35:36 been around since the beginning of this you know iteration of the conservative party so it would
02:35:41 definitely be interesting i think a lot of criticism that he took was that he sort of felt
02:35:44 that he was the heir apparent right that it was just you know peter mckay's that it's his turn
02:35:48 now and that's his turn um aaron i think he's done a lot of good work this is not his first
02:35:52 time running for leader so he's done a lot of good work trying to really boost up his image um he does
02:35:57 have a point about being ready to fight day one now again carlo is prorogued so that whole thing
02:36:01 might be out the window but he's made a solid point there um it'd be very interesting to see 0.97
02:36:06 less than lewis and the media try and say that the conservatives are all a bunch of racist white old 0.75
02:36:10 men uh when leslie lewis is the leader that that again you know just from that point alone it would
02:36:15 be spectacular to have her win um aside from the fact that she's super qualified and then derek is
02:36:20 he's taken a lot of positions i think that a lot of the others haven't so i've been um and he's
02:36:25 been firm about them he's been very tough on china a couple other things um i've been excited to see
02:36:29 that overall you know the only thing i was telling my wife just before the only thing that i never 1.00
02:36:33 like about these uh races is the delays because if you're someone who wants to you know make a bit of
02:36:39 a theory about what might have happened what's causing these delays if you get one two three
02:36:43 four delays and the race is really tight it doesn't necessarily look so good for the party
02:36:48 and again for people who want to spin stories it makes it that much easier so you know i'm sure
02:36:52 we'll be pleasantly surprised i hope uh we have some uh some spicy memes ready to go for whoever
02:36:57 wins and i'm just looking forward to the show well you are the meme maker in chief so if i mean if
02:37:02 you're not out of the meme factory i don't know what you expect from us sam you know that idea
02:37:07 of bypassing the mainstream media, Aaron, I know you do a lot of work that has to involve getting
02:37:13 your message out, and I know you do a lot of it yourself on your platforms, and I know you've
02:37:17 also been interviewed by the mainstream media. Do you find that conservatives can do what Candice
02:37:22 suggested, which is just, you know, avoid it altogether, or do you think that there still
02:37:27 has to be a playing within that system, so to speak, to some extent? I think you have to play
02:37:33 in that system but you don't have to play by their rules that's how i is how i would put it you can
02:37:39 uh if you have if they're misrepresenting the facts if they're i think it was pointed out
02:37:45 earlier if they're if they're skewing the premise of the question i think that has to be called out
02:37:50 now i think uh in fairness with all these cameras pointed at you and the mainstream media and the
02:37:56 24 hour news cycle it's going to take somebody with a lot of guts to stand up to them on over
02:38:02 and over and over again on a consistent basis so we will see if the leader the new leader of the
02:38:08 Conservative Party will find out uh tonight uh has that kind of guts to do that over the the medium
02:38:14 and long term and I think that's that's to be seen I mean I'm I I hope that they do but um
02:38:20 talk is cheap in politics as in life that's interesting I'm just seeing some interesting
02:38:26 numbers here this is the final number of endorsements uh for each Conservative Party
02:38:31 leadership candidate before the vote. So Peter McKay had 176 endorsements, Erin O'Toole had 97,
02:38:39 Leslie Lewis had 28, and Derek Sloan had six. And so what you're really seeing from the sort
02:38:45 of establishment of the Conservative Party is a rallying around Peter McKay. You know,
02:38:51 something that we've talked about on this program since beginning is that, you know,
02:38:55 he's sort of seen as a front runner. I think, Erin, you sort of said that he was assumed to be
02:39:00 the heir apparent or sorry maybe sam said that one of you guys just said that um but but but
02:39:06 but from what uh andrew just reported you know it seems like uh they're now doing damage control and
02:39:12 that erin o'tool is looking like he might be the winner again this is just from speculation but
02:39:17 less than lewis is doing much better than anticipated uh question i want to hear from
02:39:22 both aaron and sam on this but what do you think that that would do for party unity if if someone
02:39:28 other than Peter McKay wins given that he had the overwhelming majority of support from the caucus.
02:39:34 So if the you know conservative members don't actually get the person that they they wanted
02:39:40 and the membership chooses someone different could that potentially be another divide again
02:39:44 between the sort of establishment part of the party and the more populous base? Sam why don't
02:39:48 you answer that first? So I think in that respect a lot of the battleground has been between Peter
02:39:53 McKay's campaign and the Erin O'Toole campaign so there's been a lot of sort of maybe friction
02:39:58 between those two. Honestly, I think if it's Leslie Lewis, she's totally new to the party.
02:40:02 I think that as much as they might dislike or, you know, have some beef with what Aaron did or
02:40:08 said during the campaign or vice versa from the McKay side, you know, Leslie Lewis is totally
02:40:12 new, totally blank slate. So I think they would have to just fall in line. And ultimately, you
02:40:16 know, same thing with Derek Sloan to a certain degree, even though he's a sitting MP. But
02:40:20 ultimately, again, they're going to have to come together. If you want to defeat Justin Trudeau
02:40:24 in what will probably be a sooner election than later,
02:40:27 you're going to have to come together.
02:40:28 And I'm sorry, but that's going to all have to go out the window.
02:40:31 Very nice that that's in the past.
02:40:32 And, you know, sorry, start the page again.
02:40:35 I want to actually jump in here because when I spoke with Derek Sloan
02:40:39 at the Independent Press Gallery Fireside Chat a couple of weeks ago,
02:40:42 this was one of the questions that I put to him.
02:40:45 I had some of those numbers that Candace just mentioned.
02:40:47 I don't think I said the numbers, but about the caucus
02:40:49 and where they were endorsing.
02:40:51 And one of the things that was most notable is that Derek Sloan, despite being a sitting
02:40:56 member of parliament, had virtually no support for caucus.
02:40:59 And quite frankly, a lot of the caucus was trying to kick him out at a certain point.
02:41:03 And he had put an interesting thought forward that I want to play in and get all of your
02:41:08 thoughts on here, which was basically that the caucus isn't really the driving force
02:41:12 and shouldn't be for the party.
02:41:14 Let's roll that.
02:41:16 You had MPs in your own caucus that, after you had called for Theresa Tam to be fired,
02:41:22 wanted you kicked out of caucus in the middle of a leadership race.
02:41:25 And you can talk about people's motivations for that,
02:41:28 whether they may have had an allegiance to another leadership campaign.
02:41:31 But still, there have been people that have spoken up that have said
02:41:33 they do not see themselves being able to serve under a Derek Sloan-led caucus.
02:41:39 And you can say they're wrong.
02:41:40 You can say that they're perhaps having a narrow view of it.
02:41:43 But even so, if you are a leader, how do you unite that
02:41:46 when you've got people that don't even want you to just not win
02:41:50 but don't even want you in the caucus?
02:41:52 How do you serve and unify a caucus like that?
02:41:56 Some people think the party is about the caucus.
02:41:58 The party is about the members.
02:42:00 We all serve at the leisure of the members.
02:42:03 If I am given the honor of leading this party,
02:42:05 it will be because of the members.
02:42:07 And so it's up to the caucus to recognize and respect
02:42:10 the members who who put them there to begin with and elected the leader that
02:42:15 they want to lead the party. So I believe, I firmly believe that the caucus will
02:42:20 fall behind anyone who is elected but at the end of the day there is this
02:42:23 attitude that it's about the caucus and you know we're in Ottawa and we're
02:42:27 important. We're not important. It's the people that put us there and that's why
02:42:32 I'm here and I will never betray them.
02:42:40 MPs, that included all endorsements, which would also include provincial MLAs and premiers
02:42:47 and other people.
02:42:48 But I think it's still, the point still stands, which is that the establishment is firmly
02:42:53 behind Peter McKay, also not at all behind Derek Sloan, which was the question that Andrew
02:43:00 raised in that interview.
02:43:01 So Erin, let's put the question to you.
02:43:03 Do you think that there is potentially a divide in this party between the establishment and
02:43:09 the base?
02:43:11 Look, I think there's always a divide of sorts, and it's the job of a leader to bridge that divide and bring people together.
02:43:18 So I think that whoever wins will be given that opportunity, and then it's up to them to bring the different wings of the party, the social conservatives, the people that are more on the populist side, the fiscal conservatives, the foreign policy defense hawks, and bring kind of that traditional conservative coalition together.
02:43:38 um and and for sure there could be pitfalls along that along that way because there are significant
02:43:45 divides uh in the movement um but uh i think that the one the one thing that they have going for
02:43:52 them is that justin trudeau is such a heavily disliked uh liberal prime minister right now
02:43:59 that uh i imagine conservative and there's a large portion of canadians that would take
02:44:04 pretty much anybody other than him. Let's talk about where a lot of those endorsements really
02:44:12 came from, because I was quite, I'll say surprised to see early on in the leadership race, a lot of
02:44:17 people that I consider really hardline blue Tories endorsing Peter McKay, including a number of
02:44:24 people who had endorsed Aaron O'Toole in 2017 that actually flipped. And I had asked Aaron O'Toole
02:44:29 about this and his theory was that a lot of people were basically just parking. They wanted to be
02:44:34 on the winning team. And at the beginning, it looked like it was going to be a Peter McKay
02:44:37 coronation. Do you guys think, though, that there is a sense of people perhaps wanting to be on the
02:44:45 winning team? And that's why they endorsed McKay when everyone thought that was going to be the
02:44:48 direction it was going. Or alternatively, do you think that a lot of people who may not even agree
02:44:53 with McKay ideologically just think it's his turn? I mean, he's been involved. He's been waiting for
02:44:58 this for a while. He's wanted this for a while. And do you think there's a lot of kind of honor?
02:45:02 okay harper had his turn now it's the the turn of of peter mckay or something else entirely we'll
02:45:06 start with you sam so there's a couple ways to look at it and i think it depends on how
02:45:12 you're deciding to vote and it's are you looking at it what's the best candidate that will give us
02:45:17 a chance to victory what is the candidate that aligns with my principles what is the candidate
02:45:22 that i think will put up the best fight or there's any number of metrics which you can look at it and
02:45:27 so there's probably a lot of truth to that i think a lot of people did think that peter mckay had
02:45:31 the name recognition he probably still does have the best name recognition across the country
02:45:35 but if you're simply going on that alone you're saying well who's got the best name recognition
02:45:38 a lot of people go into the polling station and say okay well i don't really know who to vote for
02:45:42 but i know this guy's name or i don't like this guy who's the only other guy that kind of sounds
02:45:46 familiar or girl um and so they might vote for that person and so name recognition does have a
02:45:50 lot of value and so people might have might have indeed parked their vote um it'd be interesting
02:45:54 it would be really interesting to go back to some of those people now i mean you know probably
02:45:58 probably a lot of people will not want to switch uh so close but it would be very interesting to
02:46:02 see what a lot of those people say because again it does make a big difference and people do want
02:46:06 to be on the winning uh on the winning team on the bandwagon i mean you know look at any sporting
02:46:10 event that has nothing to do with canada or nothing to do with a local team who's jumping
02:46:13 all these national teams etc etc you just want to be on the either the underdog or the winner
02:46:21 oh sorry go ahead let's go to aaron on that question
02:46:23 No, I think I agree. I don't think it should surprise anybody that you might have some
02:46:29 politicians that are on the opportunist side of things. And I think that's what was going on here
02:46:35 to an extent. People want to back the winning horse to get to spots in cabinet or whatnot.
02:46:41 And I do think there is a legitimate argument that at least at the start of this race, Peter
02:46:47 McKay certainly looked to be the most electable. So if that's the lens that you were viewing the
02:46:52 race through, then that's probably a reason why you ended up parking your endorsement for McKay.
02:47:00 I just find that line of thinking incorrect, though. I mean, the fact that he's supposedly
02:47:04 the most electable, but yet, you know, we didn't see him anywhere. We didn't do anything. He didn't
02:47:09 bother showing up to several of the debates, including the one that the IPG put on. You know,
02:47:14 I really didn't get a very clear message from his campaign. He doesn't seem like he has a lot of
02:47:19 energy, doesn't seem like he's very excited, he doesn't have an excitement around him. So,
02:47:23 you know, even if his name is the most famous out of all of them, I don't think that that necessarily
02:47:27 translates into, you know, being electable. Andrew, I wanted to ask you a question,
02:47:33 because I've heard from party sources over here, that a lot of gun owners have voted,
02:47:41 particularly in Quebec, a place that doesn't traditionally have a large conservative support.
02:47:46 we were talking earlier about how the the voting system works how every single riding gets equal
02:47:52 weight so even if it's in the riding quebec that never votes conservative at all and never
02:47:56 elects a conservative mp um you know they potentially have the same weight as a riding
02:48:02 in calgary that gets 80 of the vote but i'm hearing that there were a lot of gun owners who have been
02:48:06 very motivated by justin trudeau's gun grab policies and that they showed up in droves uh
02:48:12 mostly to support Erin O'Toole. I know you're a gun owner and you're probably the most knowledgeable
02:48:18 person I know in Canada about gun issues. Have you heard anything like that? And are you surprised
02:48:24 by this? No, not at all surprised. And, you know, gun ownership is really a low-hanging fruit for
02:48:30 conservatives because pretty much every conservative MP is a supporter of gun rights.
02:48:37 But right now, it's more than just the, yes, I support gun rights that you need to say, because there is an attack on gun ownership from the Liberals. There has been continuously since Justin Trudeau was elected, most recently with the so-called assault weapons ban.
02:48:52 But what's interesting that I found is that a lot of single issue firearms voters are equally happy with Aaron O'Toole and Peter McKay, because Peter McKay has always been very solid on firearms. He was, remember, Canada's attorney general at a time when there was a conservative government in power that, again, was very supportive of gun rights.
02:49:12 So a lot of the gun owners that I know are happy with McKay and O'Toole and Derek Sloan.
02:49:18 And Leslyn Lewis is not, I mean, she's a downtown Toronto lawyer.
02:49:21 So she's not someone who's been around firearms by her own admission, but she's expressed a
02:49:27 willingness to learn about the issue and has said the right things.
02:49:30 So in that respect, if you're a gun owner, I don't think there's a candidate that is
02:49:35 a bad bet.
02:49:37 I think it just goes with familiarity and confidence.
02:49:40 And people are, in some cases, putting, you know, O'Toole 1 and McKay 2, and in other cases, it's reversed. But you are very right, Candace, that in a lot of the areas of the country that conservatives do well, they're rural areas that have conservative elected MPs. Quebec is kind of the exception in that you've got a lot of rural Quebecers that are affected by guns, but those are not typically conservative strongholds.
02:50:05 That's interesting because, yeah, I remember when we were putting together questions for
02:50:09 the debate, you didn't even want to ask a question about gun rights because you thought
02:50:12 that basically all the candidates had the same kinds of answers.
02:50:16 Yeah, there wouldn't be much of a debate there.
02:50:19 Yeah, so it wouldn't be that interesting.
02:50:20 But maybe you can kind of fill in the gap a little more.
02:50:24 What is it about Aaron O'Toole and his policy that would make him, it would push him over
02:50:28 the edge for so many gun owners if this is the case?
02:50:31 Well, they're both promising to roll back what the Liberals have done to gun ownership, which have been really in two different categories. One was the bill, I think it was C-72, I may be wrong about the exact number, early on, which really tried to roll back some of what Stephen Harper did to open up gun usage.
02:50:50 And then the most recent one, which was the Bill Blair with the stroke of a pen banning
02:50:55 1,500 variants of firearms, all because of an act in Nova Scotia that involved illegally
02:51:02 acquired, illegally obtained guns.
02:51:04 So rolling back what the Liberals have done, and actually perhaps even further than that,
02:51:10 potentially, because when Stephen Harper was in, they did a lot of things that were
02:51:14 very good for firearms.
02:51:15 they had uh of course the end of the long gun registry but they didn't get at a lot of the
02:51:22 regulations that really don't make sense because it's very difficult to explain something that most
02:51:28 people in canada don't know uh which is how guns do work and that they are legal and how many gun
02:51:33 owners there are more than two million so that i think is where the gun lobby is going right now
02:51:39 education which then makes it easier for politicians to take pro-gun positions without
02:51:44 being pilloried in the media. And just to put in perspective, in a couple of weeks in Ottawa,
02:51:49 there is going to be a very large gun march on September 12th. And, you know, I would love to
02:51:54 see the next conservative leader, whoever it is, at that march, marching in it, standing up for
02:51:58 gun owners. Well, you know, this is a joke that happened down in the U.S. There was a pro-gun
02:52:04 rally, anti-COVID rally, and the media painted them like they were absolute, you know,
02:52:10 fear like put the most fear-mongering out and treated them like they were some kind of an armed
02:52:15 um militia and then you know a week later when we had the black lives matter
02:52:19 uh protest it was like all totally fine and they were cheering on the uh protesters so hopefully
02:52:24 that's not what's going to happen ottawa but good good to see you know we've seen a couple
02:52:28 different special interest uh groups coming together to put forth their policy of choice
02:52:34 We talked to Alyssa Golub earlier with Right Now and talking about the gun rights issue
02:52:40 right now.
02:52:41 Well, folks, thanks so much for tuning in.
02:52:43 I'm hearing now, this is what Susan Delacorte, a writer with the Toronto Star, just wrote.
02:52:48 She just posted on Twitter.
02:52:49 She said, uh-oh, now it could be a 9 p.m. start.
02:52:52 That's start to announce the conservative leadership results.
02:52:56 Andrew, what are you hearing?
02:52:57 Are we still set to go?
02:52:58 Because I thought that they said that they were starting at 7.30.
02:53:01 it's now 7 50 here on the east coast in in in the eastern time zone so what what's going on
02:53:08 what's the schedule do we do we have any idea yeah at a certain point i think we're gonna have
02:53:12 to hand things over to uh aaron gun on the west coast because it'll be like you know four in the
02:53:16 morning on eastern time so stand by aaron you're the you're you're the uh the furthest away as far
02:53:20 as time zone uh listen i've been watching the uh page that the youtube channel for the conservative
02:53:27 Party of Canada is set to go live with the results. And it has a little ticker on it that
02:53:32 says live in X number of minutes. And I was watching it because it was supposed to be live
02:53:36 at 730. And I kept refreshing and refreshing. And then I noticed that quietly ticked to 9pm.
02:53:42 And I thought, you know, maybe it's a typo, or maybe they switched over to Pacific time. And
02:53:46 then I saw a couple of tweets from people that are on the ground in Ottawa that are saying very
02:53:50 similarly that this is now looking to be even later. And again, that 9 p.m. time is for the
02:53:57 start of the results. It's not to say that that's when the winner is going to be announced. So all
02:54:02 of a sudden, we're talking about moving out of prime time here. And again, the fact that this
02:54:07 has now been bumped back, what, three times suggests that even then you can't necessarily
02:54:11 take it for granted. And I'm already seeing a lot of talk about people that before they even hear
02:54:17 the result are convinced that it's not going to be worth its salt because of these ripped
02:54:22 ballots. They now have said the party, thousands of ballots were ripped by the machines. Supposedly
02:54:27 they're trying to count those manually. But what do you guys think it says about, you know,
02:54:32 this process? I mean, is this into this category of, listen, things happen, live events are
02:54:38 difficult? Or do you think there is a disorganization or dare I say, incompetence that
02:54:42 needs to be called into question here? I'll start with you, Candice, and then we'll go to our guests.
02:54:47 Yeah, I mean, this is not good for the Conservatives. I just kind of quickly breezing through Twitter
02:54:53 here and there's a lot of mockery and a lot of comments saying, you know, you want to
02:54:57 run the government. You can't even run your own little leadership race. I don't think
02:55:02 it's good. Obviously, it's not a very fair criticism, but I mean, come on. Like I said,
02:55:07 the ballots were all due on Friday. They had two full days to put this together. They let
02:55:11 us know what 10 minutes before the broadcast was supposed to begin that they were delaying
02:55:17 it i think it's pretty unprofessional and again it's the same kind of thing reminds me of this
02:55:23 little spat that happened between uh peter mckay and erin o'toole earlier on where they were accusing
02:55:30 one one was accusing the other of stealing files through an intern through zoom and and it's like
02:55:35 you know we're looking at the liberals and all their ethics scandals and all their issues
02:55:38 and the conservatives are supposed to be the people who are you know transparent and open
02:55:44 and committed to you know getting the books in order and running the government more like a
02:55:49 business just being more responsible and it's like how are we supposed to believe that when you have
02:55:54 this weird little petty infighting uh scandals so i i don't think it looks good for the party
02:56:00 um at all at the same time obviously you know this stuff does happen and and you got to be
02:56:05 be patient with it but you know the whole country is watching right now and they're not really
02:56:09 performing very well uh sam what what do you think uh you know this is what i said before deloitte is
02:56:16 who's doing the uh the counting deloitte is one of the big four accounting companies so they're one
02:56:21 of the largest accounting companies in the world it's a little disappointing to see that this is
02:56:26 happening because again if it's a close race between erin o'toole and peter mckay especially
02:56:31 if it's a close race and suddenly they had to throw out a bunch of ballots and those ballots
02:56:35 can't be counted by the machine doesn't mean you can't eventually count them maybe some of them
02:56:39 return maybe you can still piece them back together oh maybe the little pieces that we you
02:56:43 know it's kind of like the george bush dimpled chads and all this nonsense maybe that would
02:56:46 make a totally different result it just it's not good for building confidence that this party and
02:56:52 this this group of people can lead this country look again i think it's an unfair criticism as
02:56:57 you said but that's unfortunately what's going to happen and it's not going to help with party
02:57:02 unity especially if it's going to be for example a peter mckay and erin o'toole where you know one
02:57:06 is up by by a very small handful of votes and it turns out that a thousand of them were ripped
02:57:10 and that might have made the difference absolutely what do you think aaron yeah i mean i think it's
02:57:18 not uh it's it's not that surprising in the sense that one of the reasons that uh conservatives are
02:57:25 those that are right of center are big proponents of small government as we find uh these bureaucratic
02:57:30 organizations can't do anything competently. So I think that fits the trend. I will say that
02:57:36 the delay, if it's just delayed a little bit, not a big deal, especially if you're out on the West
02:57:41 Coast like me. But the ripping of the ballots and the, you know, anything that causes people
02:57:48 to lose trust in the electoral process is very concerning because trust in elections, in
02:57:54 democracy really leaves on horseback and returns on foot. So I think it's really important that
02:57:59 we don't have any controversy. If it's just delayed a little bit, I'm sure we'll all forget
02:58:03 about it in a couple of days from now. But if there's any of this ripped ballot where
02:58:06 it causes people or some of the campaigns or camps to question the results, then that is
02:58:11 very concerning. I think the real winner is whichever company is making the machines that are
02:58:17 on their own destroying the ballots, because I think we is placing a bulk order for a bunch
02:58:22 of those machines. You know, I'm just looking at some of the news that's coming in here. And again,
02:58:31 I mean, a lot of mayhem, people start to read between the lines, people start to raise questions
02:58:35 about all of the things that are going on, and basically just the uncertainty now. So we still
02:58:42 have the O'Toole campaign being very confident that they're winning. We still have the Peter
02:58:46 McKay campaign being kind of reserved and tight-lipped. There's one report that I wanted
02:58:52 to share here, and I'm just trying to find it on. This is the problem with live. Things get lost in
02:58:56 the hustle. Mackenzie Gray from CTV has said that he has talked to an insider who has seen internal
02:59:03 polls from all four candidates. Two of them show O'Toole winning on the third ballot. Now, this is
02:59:09 a little bit of hearsay because Mackenzie Gray is citing an unnamed insider who has seen other
02:59:15 polls. So he's not reporting that he's seen them. But there does seem to be a trend right now that's
02:59:21 going on of people thinking that this is an O'Toole win. But I mean, my whole point on this is that
02:59:26 even if O'Toole is leading, if the whole question mark is about ballots that are being destroyed and
02:59:32 delays, in the last two leadership races where we've seen significant delays and uncertainty,
02:59:38 the Ontario PC leadership race of 2018, and the Conservative Party of Canada leadership race of
02:59:43 2017. Those were too close to call. So anyone to be claiming victory would have been very
02:59:50 premature. And I fear it's probably the same thing here. So I guess my question on this,
03:00:09 And I want to hear from some of our panelists as we talk about this, is what are the real
03:00:16 stakes moving forward?
03:00:17 So I would like all of us to have a big discussion about where we want to see the conservative
03:00:24 leader go forward.
03:00:25 And I know it seems like it is a little bit of a challenge for a lot of people to figure
03:00:31 out if we're even going to have a conservative leader tonight, and if so, at what time and
03:00:36 all of that sort of stuff.
03:00:37 But what does the conservative leader need to do, not just to unite the party, which is what we've been talking about, but also to actually have that narrative moving forward that is going to put the conservative party on the right footing.
03:00:56 And we've talked about media bias.
03:00:58 I want to play a clip, actually, from my fireside chat interview with Aaron O'Toole.
03:01:04 This was from a couple of weeks ago.
03:01:06 And Aaron O'Toole was actually speaking about media bias and specifically the way that the
03:01:12 conservatives can break through that and should break through that.
03:01:15 And I know it's been a theme of our discussion tonight.
03:01:17 So let me roll that clip now.
03:01:20 You've said very clearly that you are pro-choice, you're pro-gay rights.
03:01:25 yet you are not going so far as to say that everyone in your party has to be pro-choice,
03:01:30 that everyone in your caucus has to be.
03:01:32 To a lot of people who criticize social conservatives,
03:01:36 that is an indistinguishable position from being a social conservative yourself.
03:01:40 And we saw this with Andrew Scheer, for example.
03:01:42 He was personally pro-life but had fundamentally the same position as you
03:01:46 on the sense that he wasn't going to introduce any legislation,
03:01:50 he wasn't going to make any changes to Canadian law on abortion.
03:01:54 So how do you fight back against really going down the exact same road that the Conservatives have been down?
03:02:00 Because I've been clear in my political life since I was elected.
03:02:03 I often say I'm not a career politician, so I don't have to go back to the 1990s or 15 years ago to put speeches or votes I gave into context.
03:02:12 When I left the military, became a lawyer, and then ran for Parliament, I said I'm running to Parliament to defend Canadians' rights.
03:02:18 I'm not here to take away any rights granted by the court under the Charter or rights that go back to the Magna Carta
03:02:24 That's why I'm a strong proponent of free speech rights
03:02:28 Conscience protections and I don't like the increasing view on the left that some rights are okay and other rights can be dismissed in a
03:02:35 democracy like us you have to
03:02:38 Respect all points of view and be willing to defend all rights
03:02:41 You know that's what our soldiers have done throughout our history. That's what our Parliament is meant to do
03:02:46 that's what Diefenbaker did with the Bill of Rights we have to defend those
03:02:50 rights whether it's property rights of Canadians that have seen that right
03:02:54 removed with an order of counsel no debate in the middle of a pandemic for
03:02:58 firearms owners or whether it's a conservative who wants to express a
03:03:02 point of view based on their faith when did religious freedom become a right
03:03:06 we're not willing to stand up for in this country I have concerns about what
03:03:10 Justin Trudeau is doing to democratic debates political party organization and
03:03:15 really Parliament in general, and it fuels me.
03:03:18 And what's great, Andrew,
03:03:20 Conservatives are a great, passionate,
03:03:22 intelligent bunch from coast to coast.
03:03:24 We don't have to have the same view on all issues.
03:03:27 We have to have respect for one another.
03:03:31 And, you know, like, it's so good that finally
03:03:34 we hear Conservatives talking about the media bias
03:03:36 because it's such an elephant in the room every time.
03:03:38 I mean, this has been an ongoing complaint of mine,
03:03:41 as viewers of True North know very well,
03:03:44 goes all the way back to 2015, when Justin Trudeau was running in the midst of the campaign,
03:03:48 he pledged an additional $150 million to the CBC. How can you say that doesn't affect coverage when
03:03:55 they're literally one of the parties is offering to massively, massively expand your business and
03:04:01 that grant did end up going through the CBC grew by $150 million, created a whole online news
03:04:08 division in English language. And then because of that, the newspapers couldn't compete. And so
03:04:12 Trudeau gave them a bailout of 600 million dollars so you have this weird situation where
03:04:17 you're the government and taxpayers are funding competing media entities and you know the more
03:04:23 success one has the more you have to bail out the other how can you say that journalists don't have
03:04:28 a conflict of interest you know they all they all have a conflict of interest Sam you're talking
03:04:32 about how David Akin tweeted that he doesn't have any skin in the game well maybe global technically
03:04:37 hasn't gotten any of the bailout money yet, but surely it's to come. And I think that that is one
03:04:42 of the major problems that conservatives, small-state conservatives, which includes us at
03:04:47 True North, face in this country. Well, we have an exciting guest that is joining us. You know,
03:04:53 again, we have a live show that we're putting together. We thought that we were going to be
03:04:56 going to the conservative convention at 6 p.m. It's now 8 p.m. We're here. It might not go till
03:05:01 So we've got lots of friends joining us online. And here we have our friend MP, Michelle Rempel-Garner. Michelle, thank you so much for taking the time out to join us.
03:05:12 You know what, thank you for doing this live feed tonight, Candice. You know, I just, it's so exciting to be commenting on what I think is the future of media. I'm just really excited you guys are doing this. I just gave you guys a big shout out on Twitter. And I think it's awesome. And congratulations for taking the initiative on it. It's great.
03:05:31 Well, thank you so much. And, you know, we're doing what we can with our limited ability, you know, doing a live show and trying to put things together at the last minute.
03:05:39 So hopefully, you know, the audience is bearing with us. But, Michelle, I'm going to put a question to you that we've been talking about throughout this program.
03:05:45 You know, there seems to be a bit of a growing divide. All four of the leadership candidates in this race are from Ontario or live in Ontario.
03:05:52 We didn't really see anyone jump in the race from Western Canada.
03:05:55 in Western Canada, some worry that the issues that matter to Albertans
03:05:59 haven't really been addressed in this campaign.
03:06:02 You know, you're an Albertan, you're a representative of Calgary in Parliament.
03:06:07 Do you feel like Alberta's been adequately represented,
03:06:10 and are you happy with this batch of potential candidates here?
03:06:14 No, I don't. I don't think that the issues Alberta were facing
03:06:18 were adequately addressed in the leadership race.
03:06:21 I'll be very blunt.
03:06:23 And I talked about this phenomenon in the Buffalo Declaration where our system of governance, both from a general election perspective, but also within the primary system of our major political parties, I really don't think allow or incent people who are seeking the leadership of parties to advocate for Western Canadian issues.
03:06:44 So, you know, this isn't necessarily a slight on the leadership candidates. I think it's just an acknowledgement of reality
03:06:51 The reality is is that my constituents are facing
03:06:56 Incredible economic turmoil
03:06:58 They're facing a downturn in the economy that has been precipitated by detrimental policies put in place by the current liberal government
03:07:06 But this is a cyclical problem. This isn't the first time this has happened
03:07:09 It's happened many times in in the history of our country
03:07:13 and without structural change to enable Western Canada to be an equal
03:07:19 participant in Confederation it will continue to happen again so for me it's
03:07:23 not enough to say that you know we're gonna repeal some bills or defeat the
03:07:28 current Liberal leader we need to be talking about how we're addressing
03:07:34 structural change so that Albertans don't have to look at what political
03:07:39 party is in power to ensure that their livelihoods are successful that that's not sustainable and I
03:07:45 know that I might be you know frankly pissing people off within my own party by saying this
03:07:50 but it needs to be said and that's why I was really proud to be behind the Buffalo Declaration
03:07:54 because that was something that was designed to spur conversation about how we do this and this
03:07:59 is frankly what I'm going to be working on no matter who wins tonight. What would your recommendation
03:08:05 be michelle to the the next conservative leader on a way to uh loop in not just the alberta and
03:08:12 broader western caucus but also a lot of the the western base that are feeling growing alienation
03:08:19 in some cases uh a desire for separation or headed towards that how can the next leader
03:08:24 really tell those people that yes you're heard yes you're part of the canadian uh conservative
03:08:30 family and and yes i i'm here to represent you even if i'm not from the west well i think step
03:08:35 one, Andrew, is acknowledging that there's a problem, right? I think that the next leader has
03:08:41 to say, look, this is something this like history is repeating itself, right? So we need to have
03:08:46 some sort of plan and be advocating for a plan that will not just fix the current situation,
03:08:52 but ensure that it won't happen again. That's step number one is acknowledging that there's
03:08:56 a problem. Step number two is acknowledging that advocating for one region of the country or
03:09:03 another is normative in canadian politics right it's completely political politically acceptable
03:09:08 for the leader of a party to say look here's a policy that's not working for atlantic canada
03:09:12 we need to work for atlantic canada or you know what here's some issues with quebec language
03:09:17 laws that we need to be advocating for or whatnot why is it all of a sudden not normative for
03:09:22 western canadians to be standing up and saying we've got a big problem here and canadian leaders
03:09:28 need to address that and i think that there's a propensity in any political party to be like oh
03:09:32 well, you know, we don't want to piss off Ontario, we don't want to piss off Quebec,
03:09:36 so, you know, we'll just, like, not talk about the Western Canadian stuff.
03:09:39 I've experienced that, and that's not going to cut it anymore.
03:09:42 And I think that, you know, so, again, just underscoring step number two,
03:09:46 it's just acknowledging the Conservative Party of Canada was given a big mandate
03:09:51 by Western Canada to be bold on these issues, right?
03:09:54 And the next leader has to figure out how to do that
03:09:58 while maintaining a national voter coalition.
03:10:00 And anybody who is running for the leadership of the party needs to understand that that's what the job description is.
03:10:06 And there are going to be caucus colleagues like myself and others who understand this and will be pushing them on the same.
03:10:13 And I'm not afraid of that. And I know that others aren't either because it's why we were elected and it's why people pay our salary.
03:10:19 Well, and conservatives do so well in Alberta because they trust the conservative party to speak up for them and to stand up for them.
03:10:26 Michelle, I want to get your thoughts on just the very turbulent few weeks that you've had in Ottawa with the Trudeau government.
03:10:35 I mean, it's just been one thing after the other.
03:10:37 The We Scandal, you know, your MPs in the Finance Committee have done an excellent job just exposing how much the Liberals have misled Canadians about the timeline.
03:10:47 Then all of a sudden you had Bill Morneau sort of bizarrely resigning, pretending it had nothing to do with this whole scandal.
03:10:52 And Chrystia Freeland jump in.
03:10:54 And, you know, she's from Alberta technically, 0.98
03:10:56 although I don't think she's lived in Canada much
03:10:58 since she was a teenager.
03:10:59 And she said something about, you know,
03:11:02 the economic restart to COVID has to be based
03:11:04 on decarbonization, whatever the heck that means.
03:11:07 You know, what is your take on this current
03:11:10 corrupt liberal government?
03:11:11 And do you think that they even have a mandate
03:11:13 at this point?
03:11:14 Do you think that it's time to go to another election?
03:11:17 What are your thoughts on all that?
03:11:19 Sure, I do think Justin Trudeau has lost
03:11:22 the moral authority to govern.
03:11:23 somebody voted liberal in the last election they should be asking why he is still the leader of
03:11:27 the party but i digress i i think that um we're gonna even start on this here's my bold prediction
03:11:35 here's my punditry um you know when you think about trudeau's father pierre elliot uh he needed
03:11:41 a national unity crisis to change the channel on a lot of his failures and what i predict is that
03:11:48 that Justin Trudeau will impose a very punitive budget
03:11:52 that's punitive towards Western Canada.
03:11:55 I think it's just gonna go for broke
03:11:56 on the energy sector, shutting it down.
03:11:59 And what he is going to try and do with that
03:12:01 is deflect from the corruption of the wee scandal.
03:12:03 And you know that there's gonna be more, Candace.
03:12:06 Like, I mean, there's how many hundreds of billions
03:12:09 of dollars that happened without parliamentary oversight?
03:12:11 There's going to be more.
03:12:12 He's gonna try and deflect from that
03:12:14 by getting conservatives to fight internally
03:12:17 over the question of Western Canada
03:12:19 and just hope that we separate and let them get a pass.
03:12:23 And so the needle that the new leader
03:12:26 is going to have to thread is to say,
03:12:28 look, the issue of Western alienation is real.
03:12:32 It has to be addressed in a real way,
03:12:33 but we're not gonna let Canadians give Trudeau
03:12:36 a free pass on these other issues, right?
03:12:39 So, to me, you can see that this is where they're going.
03:12:43 So we need to be smarter than that.
03:12:44 We need to be ahead of them.
03:12:45 And I'm confident of the ability of our party to do this.
03:12:48 So, yeah, I just think it's something that we all need to be aware of.
03:12:54 Your name, Michelle, was one of the early ones that was put forward by a lot of people as a potential candidate in this race.
03:13:00 And you obviously opted not to step forward.
03:13:03 But I'm curious what your rationale was when you saw that there weren't candidates in the race that were really putting forward positions on the issues that, you know, we were all talking about earlier, specifically Western issues.
03:13:14 why did you not feel or perhaps you did feel that you know it wasn't your time to step forward even
03:13:20 if those issues weren't having a voice in the race um i guess i'll just be very blunt with you
03:13:28 my first concern is to my constituents at this point in time like the the economic crisis that
03:13:33 we're going through right now the number of people that are out of work is is something like that has
03:13:37 to be my first and primary concern as an elected representative it's it's situation critical here
03:13:43 and um i feel like yes i do have a voice yes i do have reach and um i felt in my heart that
03:13:52 it was more important for me to use that reach to be an unapologetic advocate for western canadians
03:13:59 and the reality is is that the way that the conservative party's primary system is set up
03:14:03 is that i could not do both i could not run through the leadership of the party and do
03:14:07 things like the buffalo declaration do things like saying i don't care who wins tonight i'm going to
03:14:12 ensure that western canadian interests are put forward and you know that does make me sad um
03:14:18 but there are moments in our history where you have to realize what your your role and your
03:14:24 calling is and i can't look at the 70 mandate that i got from the people of my writing from people
03:14:29 that even that typically don't vote conservative and they're like you have to vote for you have
03:14:33 to fight for us and sometimes you have to put self and ego aside and and and do what you've been
03:14:40 given a mandate to do so
03:14:42 You know again, I I'm at the point in my political career and in my life is I you know
03:14:49 I just turned 40 where I'm only doing this
03:14:52 At this point in time to make sure that my constituents and the people that I represent get a fair shake
03:14:57 And if that means putting pressure on my own party so be it, but it certainly means
03:15:02 Pushing back against the agenda that we're seeing from the Liberal government as well
03:15:05 I am optimistic that our party is going to get it right
03:15:08 but they might need a shot in the right direction and that's what my job is going to be.
03:15:13 Well that's a great initiative. Michelle, maybe for viewers that aren't too familiar with the
03:15:18 Buffalo Declaration and what exactly it entails, you could sort of walk through, you know, you don't
03:15:23 have to give a comprehensive presentation or anything, but maybe you can just point out some
03:15:27 of the highlights and what what the goals and objectives of the Declaration are. Sure, so in
03:15:32 In February, myself and three other colleagues released a comprehensive, very thorough document
03:15:40 that outlined the systemic problems that Western Canada, specifically Alberta and Saskatchewan,
03:15:45 have faced from confederation, that we've never been an equal participant, that we've
03:15:50 always been a colony towards other parts of Canada, and that the problems that we're
03:15:56 facing are cyclical in nature, that they're not, you know, this isn't the first time this
03:16:00 is happening and we proposed a series of recommendations that could be used as a
03:16:09 starting point to talk about how we fix these things how we fix confederation
03:16:13 you know it was a very controversial document I knew it would be anytime that
03:16:18 you talk about these things it's gonna piss everybody off I know it piss
03:16:23 people off within my own party but I'm at the point where I just don't care
03:16:26 because you have to we have to say things we have to if you're not if you
03:16:30 can't fix a problem if you don't acknowledge that it exists so yeah you
03:16:34 know I encourage people to read it buffalodeclaration.ca I stand by it and
03:16:39 you know what I hope that it did I actually hope that it would inform some
03:16:43 of the leadership conversations that it would allow some of our leadership
03:16:47 candidates to talk about the things that were in there and say I agree with this
03:16:50 I don't agree with this I acknowledge that here's some issues with Western
03:16:53 Canada here's how I would fix it and frankly we didn't see I'm not saying
03:16:57 that you know they have to talk about the buffalo declaration per se i don't have that type of an
03:17:01 ego but i don't think that we address those issues and um what i'm hoping is that whoever wins tonight
03:17:07 will um will start addressing that i do have to jump off candace i'm getting the uh the signal
03:17:13 from the back here but um i just again i want i want to thank i want to thank you and andrew for
03:17:18 for doing this and and if for those who are watching i do think that what you guys are doing
03:17:23 here tonight will be considered the future of media and it's nice to see pundits and other
03:17:31 media gaining prominence and different voices in our country so congratulations to you.
03:17:36 Well Michelle thank you so much for taking the time and it was super last minute but
03:17:40 one of the things we talked about was that there wasn't enough policy in this last
03:17:44 leadership debate so hopefully you'll be at the forefront in leading policy discussions
03:17:48 for the party and in the conservative movement for a long time to come.
03:17:51 thank you have a good evening you too thanks very much Michelle you know one of the things I was
03:17:57 actually hoping to chat with Michelle about we ran out of time was immigration which is an issue
03:18:02 she's been doing a lot on and we actually haven't talked about immigration all that much tonight so
03:18:08 let's start now because I would say that there wasn't a huge amount of immigration talk during
03:18:14 the leadership there was some certainly everyone seemed to be united on wanting to close Roxham
03:18:19 Road. We had a news story this week that True North actually broke. It was an exclusive story
03:18:24 that the government has put out a call for a vendor to transport asylum seekers near the Quebec
03:18:31 border up to 150 a day. So clearly the government's not making good on its whole closing Roxham Road
03:18:37 promise as of late. So you've got Derek Sloan who wants to decrease immigration. You've got
03:18:43 Aaron O'Toole that wants to do the steady increase, that very Harper and Kenny approach to immigration.
03:18:49 But by and large, it wasn't, I would say, a central issue on the campaign. I'll go to our panelists as well. But first, Candace, would you say that's a fair assessment that, yeah, it was mentioned, but it wasn't really made a central part of anyone's plans?
03:19:02 Yeah, I think that's right. And I think it's interesting. You know, talk about immigration around immigration does sort of ebb and flow whenever there's sort of a big something event in the media. You know, you end up talking about it a lot.
03:19:16 So in 2015, with the refugee crisis flooding Europe and, you know, civil war in Syria and all of a sudden, Justin Trudeau pledging to bring in, you know, 50,000 Syrian refugees on an incredibly rushed timeline without any security checks and all that kind of stuff, it became a really big, urgent issue and a lot of people had a lot of things to say about it.
03:19:35 Same thing with Rocks and Road when all of a sudden, you know, we went from having a couple of dozen people cross illegally from the United States per year to we were having five, six hundred a day for a while.
03:19:45 It became a big pressing issue.
03:19:48 Whereas right now, Andrew, I mean, we're sort of in an unprecedented situation in that we've almost had a full lockdown of our border for the past four months.
03:19:57 I don't think that's happened at all in recent history.
03:20:00 now of course we know that the numbers aren't exactly true that even though the trudeau
03:20:04 government says the border is closed we've still had a million odd people come and and more people
03:20:09 who've entered canada have not been citizens so we are still accepting immigrants uh some of the
03:20:14 big uh covet outbreaks have happened with temporary foreign workers coming from uh mexico and other
03:20:20 countries and so you know despite the fact that that they say the borders closed it is still open
03:20:25 and it is causing some issues in terms of COVID and public safety. I would have liked to hear a
03:20:31 little bit more about immigration from each of the candidates, but I think we're in an interesting
03:20:36 time in Canada in our history right now. I've written about this in the past, and I'll just
03:20:41 really quickly say it again. If you look at Canada's historic immigration figures dating back
03:20:45 150 years, there have always been peaks and valleys in admittance. So we've always had
03:20:51 time periods where we've just let in lots and lots of people pretty much open the floodgates
03:20:55 and then a couple of years later we close them and allow a break of one to five to ten years
03:21:00 where you essentially just like let everyone settle let the people who are here integrate
03:21:05 and become Canadian and then you say okay let's open up again and have another wave
03:21:10 we haven't had that you know we've had sustained high numbers of immigration getting higher and
03:21:15 higher and higher every year for the past 25 years I don't think it's necessarily been good 1.00
03:21:20 the country actually it's been bad for the country there's parts of vancouver where i grew up where
03:21:24 you don't see any english speakers there's no english signs people have no incentive to learn
03:21:28 english because no one around them speaks english um and and you're also seeing lots of tensions in
03:21:33 and around toronto with so many new people coming and not being able to settle so i think it's good
03:21:38 for the country to just take a pause on immigration altogether and the fact that's sort of what's
03:21:42 happening because of the situation i i we don't know what the immigration levels will be for 2020
03:21:47 the government hasn't announced them and i've been trying to dig into them and find them but i think
03:21:52 once we do learn they'll be significantly lower than where they were i think the conservatives
03:21:56 would be wise to just maintain that for a few years until covid gets under control until the
03:22:01 economy recovers and then we can open up again but i i hope that all the conservative leadership
03:22:06 candidates take this as as an opportunity um to really push that pause button on immigration and
03:22:11 have some kind of a moratorium. Aaron, I know you and I have talked about the immigration issue
03:22:17 before and you're not in Vancouver but you're on the west coast where there is a large population 1.00
03:22:23 of people that come but don't necessarily bother to learn English and don't really integrate.
03:22:28 I'm curious to hear your thoughts on this issue. Well I think the big point to be made with COVID
03:22:35 and the unemployment as high as it is right now is the economic rationale for opening the flood
03:22:41 gates on immigration simply isn't there anymore um i think in addition to all the the points that
03:22:46 you made i think we also need to uh pump the brakes on immigration a bit to to allow more
03:22:53 housing spots to open up in cities like vancouver victoria and toronto where there's a lot of stress
03:22:58 on the market so i think that's another point to be made but my big thing with immigration 1.00
03:23:02 that bugs me is with justin trudeau right now you have this arbitrarily high number of immigrants
03:23:09 and refugees. And if you want one less than that, you're basically a racist. And I think 0.96
03:23:14 all I want is a common sense, open debate about immigration and the economic effects and the
03:23:20 cultural effects. And to be honest, I think a lot of Canadians have those conversations around the
03:23:25 water coolers and the barbecues during summer. But it'd be nice to actually have those conversations
03:23:29 at the forefront in forums like this. And one of the downsides is we didn't see that
03:23:36 in the leadership race, which would have been nice.
03:23:41 Yeah, I totally agree.
03:23:43 Again, it's one of the disconnects that this is how, you know,
03:23:45 everyday Canadians talk about these issues,
03:23:47 but politicians are so afraid of being called the dreaded R-word racist
03:23:52 that they don't want to talk about immigration.
03:23:54 Sam, what's your perspective on this?
03:23:56 Well, I actually want to take it in a bit of a different direction,
03:23:58 and that is to bring the economy into it,
03:24:02 because immigration and the economy are very closely tied together.
03:24:05 You bring people into this country or to any country because by growing your population
03:24:09 base, you grow the size of your market, you grow your labor force, and obviously that's
03:24:12 one of the main drivers of the economy.
03:24:14 But with the Trudeau government going to bring in, and I firmly believe that they're going
03:24:18 to try and bring in some sort of universal basic income, and remember that Eric Hoskins,
03:24:23 who was the Ontario health minister for a number of years, that he's gone to Ottawa
03:24:26 to help them with the national pharma care strategy.
03:24:29 So you have a potential on the horizon of pharma care strategy and a universal basic
03:24:32 income. How is that going to affect the need and demand for labor? What are the changes in the
03:24:38 economy with people that are coming in? Is everyone going to suddenly qualify for this
03:24:42 universal basic income? So people who just arrived yesterday, what's going to be the
03:24:45 criterion? Are you going to be allowed to work, make more money? There's going to be a lot of
03:24:49 effects and immigration is now a piece of that discussion. And I think that's an interesting
03:24:53 one going forward for whoever the new conservative leader is going to be, because it's not just
03:24:57 about universal basic income or about immigration or about any of these things, because they're all
03:25:02 tied together and I'm curious what you guys think as well actually. Yeah it's a really good point
03:25:05 because one of the things you often hear almost as a cliche is that you can't have open borders
03:25:09 and you know social socialist programs or a socialist welfare state. Canada seems to be
03:25:16 the exception to that because we do have these socialist programs like we already this is one 0.97
03:25:21 of the arguments you hear conservatives making in the U.S. like well these Democrats are so crazy
03:25:25 they want open borders but they also want Medicare for all. It's like well yeah it's basically what
03:25:30 our policy is in canada already and it hasn't bankrupted the system yet but surely it could
03:25:35 potentially be a problem and you know for me i've someone who's worked inside the immigration
03:25:38 department i see i saw that there were a number of scams and a number of people who aren't coming
03:25:44 with good intentions to canada they're not coming because they want to join the canadian family or
03:25:48 because they love canada believe in the canadian ideal no they're coming because they want to take
03:25:52 advantage of our generous our generosity uh essentially and i think that the more that you
03:25:57 expand that welfare state sam it's a really excellent point the more that you're going to
03:26:01 attract the wrong kind of people which is so unfair uh to the canadian fabric to the canadian family
03:26:07 but also to the canadian taxpayer and and people who you know potentially could be displaced in a
03:26:12 hospital uh in an emergency room setting in an intensive care setting um because someone else
03:26:19 who has no connection to canada that didn't live here five minutes ago uh showed up and and got
03:26:24 ahead of them and that's just the nature of uh you know rationed health care but it could
03:26:29 apply to any number of other programs that justin trudeau and his liberals uh pull out uh you know
03:26:35 as we're expecting in this next uh throne speech this is the true north conservative leadership
03:26:42 results show candace malcolm and andrew lawton hosting we also have joining us right now aaron
03:26:48 gunn and true north fellow sam eskenazi uh just before we go back to the panel i want to report
03:26:53 on some of the details that are coming in.
03:26:56 If you're just tuning in right now
03:26:57 because you thought you'd skip to the end
03:26:59 and get the results,
03:27:00 well, do we have some bad news for you?
03:27:01 The results are nowhere near
03:27:03 where they're supposed to be right now.
03:27:05 This was originally promised to start at 6 p.m.
03:27:08 with results coming in at 6.30.
03:27:10 It's now 8.30.
03:27:11 The latest is that 97% of the ballots,
03:27:14 according to the Conservative Party of Canada,
03:27:16 have been counted.
03:27:18 3% of them, which is several thousand,
03:27:20 were ripped by machines.
03:27:21 Now, just to put this in context,
03:27:23 there were about 172,000 ballots, which means that if 3% of them were ripped, that is about
03:27:30 5,000 ballots that we're talking about here. So a significant number that have been ripped and
03:27:38 they're being counted manually. That's been the main cause of the delay. The Conservative Party
03:27:44 says it's going to start its program at 8.30, which is coming up any moment now. And there's
03:27:50 going to be a break at 9 p.m. And then the results will start coming in the first ballot at 10 p.m.
03:27:57 Now, this is all Eastern time. So it's important to keep that in mind. But we're looking now at
03:28:02 potentially the Conservative Party of Canada starting its show at 830. Now, I've actually
03:28:06 just got some breaking. I don't know if it's breaking news, but no one else has this yet.
03:28:11 Andrew Scheer is going to be speaking in about 15 minutes. So the Conservative Party, it seems
03:28:17 like is committed to starting its show in some form soon. And we'll obviously throw to them
03:28:21 live to hear the latest. So just with apologies to our panelists, if we have to cut you off too
03:28:27 quickly, that's why, because we want to go to the main event, but it sounds like we'll be back for
03:28:32 at least an hour at 9pm when the party breaks to finish its counting. So again, I mean, this is
03:28:39 as far as what you can have, if you're trying to present that you can capably and competently
03:28:45 hit the ground running and go after Justin Trudeau in the next election, this isn't exactly the
03:28:49 message that you want to be sharing. But let me go to you on this, Sam. I mean, what do you think
03:28:56 needs to be the Conservative Party leader's top priority, assuming there is a leader tonight,
03:29:00 when they start their first full day in that job tomorrow? I mean, what does the election
03:29:05 readiness plan look like or what should it look like for the Conservatives?
03:29:15 oh sorry um top priority honestly make sure you've got party unity all set um make sure
03:29:22 you guys with me still uh make sure you've got party unity all set that's going to be super
03:29:26 critical yeah keep going sam all right so yeah so party unity is going to be super critical but
03:29:33 that's going to be just like a day one kind of thing maybe the first week just make sure you
03:29:37 know you make all the phone calls you need to make mend all the fences that you need to mend
03:29:40 and then make sure you've got the machinery ready to go because justin trudeau is basically sitting
03:29:44 on the trigger yes it's a minority government but big question that i've posed before is the
03:29:49 ndp do they have enough money are they ready to fight this election and that's really i think for
03:29:53 them that's what's going to be keeping this government propped up so you've got to be ready
03:29:57 at a moment's notice to fight an election you've got to make sure you've got the machinery in place
03:30:01 and then you worry about the messaging that that can take you know again depends on what the ballot
03:30:05 question or what the what track the liberals are going to take you can obviously come back from
03:30:09 that but uh first step again mend your fences second step make sure the machinery is ready
03:30:14 third step work on your messaging and keep it simple.
03:30:18 That's a really good point. I think just quickly to pick up on one thing you said
03:30:22 with Jagmeet Singh and the NDP. I mean to me it seems really obvious
03:30:26 that we need to have an election aside from whatever the health
03:30:28 concerns may be with COVID and the concerns around that.
03:30:32 But one of the kind of sticking issues is the NDP and how much
03:30:36 debt they have and how poorly they perform under Jagmeet Singh.
03:30:40 So you have this awkward situation where you could have a political party
03:30:43 that's, you know, propping up another party, not because of any principle or any shared belief,
03:30:48 but simply because of their own sort of opportunistic situation. Aaron, I'll bring
03:30:55 you in on this. You know, British Columbia is sort of the NDP heartland and Jagmeet Singh's
03:31:00 from out there. What do you make of that party right now? And do you think that they would be
03:31:06 willing to prop up the Trudeau government, even if it meant like, you know, further demise of our
03:31:11 country? I think so. I think that, I mean, maybe in fairness to the NDP,
03:31:18 Justin Trudeau's Liberals have moved so far to the left now that it probably
03:31:23 makes a degree of ideological sense to prop them up. It's all the, a lot of the
03:31:29 crazy policies that we might have affiliated with the NDP party of massive
03:31:35 deficits, completely out of control spending, mindless and rudderless foreign
03:31:41 policy, all these things, political correctness, identity politics. Trudeau has adopted all those
03:31:46 as his own. So I do think there is a, at least in the inner city NDP, I think that does make
03:31:55 a lot of sense. But what I'm curious is there seems to me two kinds of NDP voters, especially
03:31:59 here in British Columbia. You still have kind of the common sense, a lot of times union worker,
03:32:06 NDP voter, a lot of rural areas here in Vancouver Island, a lot of forestry workers.
03:32:11 And I don't think the NDP party federally under Jagmeet Singh is a,
03:32:15 is a party they can identify with. And I think though, hang on,
03:32:19 I'm sorry to interrupt there,
03:32:20 but we have the live event at the conservative party broadcast headquarters in
03:32:26 Ottawa starting up. Are we good to throw to that now? All right,
03:32:31 we'll, we'll go to that live.
03:32:41 ready to cut you off there all good all good i think you made your point
03:32:50 yeah it was good stuff oh my gosh he's not all right i think we can probably let you guys loose
03:32:58 because this is going to be about half an hour we might uh stand by your phones though we might
03:33:04 bring you back on later yeah let me know i'll be rocking the baby all right thanks a lot for
03:33:09 everything, guys. Yeah, thanks so much, guys. Hey, uh, Cordy-
03:33:39 de l'énergie et le talent de nos bénévoles leadership races are a time of renewal thousands
03:33:46 of volunteers have given their time to support a candidate adding to the energy and excitement of
03:33:50 this extraordinary leadership race we wouldn't be here tonight for this announcement without
03:33:55 our volunteers who began arriving before 5 a.m this morning to open count and record tens of
03:34:02 thousands of ballots that we received over the past several weeks i'd also like to say a very
03:34:08 special thank you to the Conservative Party of Canada staff who have pulled together and worked
03:34:13 tirelessly long hours often through adversity to ensure that we could elect our next leader
03:34:19 in spite of a global pandemic. Your resourcefulness and dedication to the Conservative Party and its
03:34:24 goals have carried us through the challenges of the past months and we thank you.
03:34:38 Here's a little peek of how all of this came together.
03:35:02 To the volunteers who made the 2020 Conservative Leadership election possible, thank you.
03:35:08 With a record participation across the country, the logistics of the health course to help
03:35:14 to get a little bit difficult.
03:35:17 Thanks to our amazing volunteers, we were able to make this race a massive success,
03:35:22 even during a pandemic.
03:35:24 Thanks to everyone who gave their time. We would not have been able to get there without you.
03:35:29 Here are just a few of the milestones we were able to accomplish thanks to the dedication of our volunteers.
03:35:38 And thank you to all of the campaigns and their volunteers for helping us.
03:36:08 to help build conservative momentum right across the country.
03:36:20 Thank you.
03:36:21 And now I'd like to introduce our president of the party,
03:36:25 not president de l'executive national du Parti conservateur du Canada, Scott Lamb.
03:36:31 Without Jamie, and I want to say without Jamie Girard stepping forward last December
03:36:39 to take the role as our Executive Director, the success of this leadership race in setting
03:36:45 a record for ballots and votes cast could not have occurred.
03:36:49 You've done so much for our party and we are in a debt of gratitude to you and your
03:36:54 team.
03:36:55 It is my honour to say thank you on behalf of the Conservative Party of Canada to our
03:37:00 our leader, Andrew Scheer, for his years of service to our party and our country.
03:37:21 As many of you know, Andrew's remarkable career commenced in 2004 when at the political novice
03:37:28 age of 24, he contested the riding of Regina Capel for our party against Lorne Nystrom
03:37:34 of the NDP, a political legend who was a 25-year veteran of the House of Commons. Not only
03:37:41 did Andrew beat Lorne Nystrom in 2004, he went on with that seat to win it a further
03:37:47 five consecutive times. Andrew served as the youngest ever Speaker of the House of Commons
03:37:53 in the Harper government, securing his place as a great parliamentarian.
03:37:59 When Stephen Harper stepped down as our leader in 2015, I often caution people we are a relatively
03:38:06 young party formed out of two predecessor parties.
03:38:10 It was a little bit like a start-up company with a very successful founding leader who
03:38:14 suddenly exits the company.
03:38:16 Often start-up companies fail at this stage.
03:38:20 Our party had only known one leader for 12 years and we have been in government for over
03:38:24 nine of those years.
03:38:26 Like any startup company transitioning to a new leader, this was a daunting task to
03:38:31 take on as the role of our new leader of our party.
03:38:35 It required focus on party unity and moving our party back into contention to form government
03:38:41 once again.
03:38:43 On his election as leader, Andrew Scheer did just that.
03:38:48 Shearer focused on fighting for all Canadians and not just the favored few by the Liberals.
03:38:53 You saw this in Andrew Shearer's campaign against Trudeau's massive tax hike on small business,
03:39:00 forcing the Liberal government to back down from many of their changes. Andrew Shearer kept
03:39:05 the party unified. He has listened to and understood all points of view in our big
03:39:12 conservative tent. He built momentum to put our party into contention to win
03:39:17 government again. Winning key by-elections that we had not won in a generation,
03:39:22 building our party's lead in fundraising, and welcoming Liberals to join our party
03:39:27 like Member of Parliament Leona Asalev who crossed the floor of the House of
03:39:31 Commons from the Liberals to join our party. In the 2019 election, Andrew Scheer
03:39:37 took on Justin Trudeau's Liberals, who the media said after 2015 would hold majority
03:39:43 governments not just for four years, but as much as 12 years. In that election, Andrew
03:39:49 Scheer led our party to reducing the Trudeau Liberals to a minority government. Our party
03:39:55 won the popular vote and formed the strongest official opposition in Canadian history with
03:40:01 121 Conservatives elected. Throughout his leadership and years as a
03:40:07 Parliamentarian, Andrew Scheer has always demonstrated fairness, decency and
03:40:12 intelligence. He's a dedicated family man and a friend to all. Andrew, you kept us
03:40:20 united and focused on fighting for all Canadians. With you, we took a large step
03:40:26 once again to forming a Conservative government.
03:40:30 We thank you.
03:40:32 We wish you and your family all the best.
03:40:34 And we look for many years in the future of your service
03:40:37 as a Member of Parliament for our party.
03:40:40 Thank you.
03:40:42 Honourable Leader of the Opposition. 0.98
03:40:44 It's so gross and disgusting that this Prime Minister 0.98
03:40:47 keeps using the pandemic as an excuse for his corruption. 0.97
03:40:51 They will stop and take the time to reward their friends.
03:40:55 That is the essence of this Liberal Party. 0.99
03:40:57 It's just disgusting. 0.91
03:40:59 Justin Trudeau only pretends to stand up for Canada. 1.00
03:41:02 Mr. Trudeau, you are a phony and you are a fraud 1.00
03:41:04 and you do not deserve to govern this country. 1.00
03:41:07 That was the weakest response to a national crisis in Canada.
03:41:12 Now, I listened to the Prime Minister's word salad.
03:41:15 The actions of these radical activists are illegal.
03:41:19 Put an end to the illegal blockades and get our economy back on track.
03:41:23 But I don't blame the Prime Minister for not getting up off the mat.
03:41:27 And we know that he'd rather be sitting there signing autographs.
03:41:31 If he likes to sign his name so much, maybe he can take out his checkbook
03:41:35 and sign a check paying back taxpayers for the money.
03:41:38 He told Donald Trump that if he didn't get rid of tariffs, there'd be no photo op.
03:41:42 Well, that Donald called his bluff.
03:41:44 He knew that the Prime Minister couldn't resist another photo being taken.
03:41:47 And there he was signing along with the rest of the leaders.
03:41:49 Now, for taking his picture with Donald Trump,
03:41:51 Did he get an end to a steel and aluminum journey?
03:41:54 Even the Australians can't understand why we're buying their old planes.
03:41:57 If the Prime Minister is so keen on buying fixer uppers, will he come over?
03:42:01 Because I've got an old minivan I'd love to show up.
03:42:03 Meanwhile, families across the country are suffering because of their lack of action and their incompetence.
03:42:10 When will the Prime Minister take responsibility for his decision and stop trying to blame other people?
03:42:15 It is fashionable today to look down on the past.
03:42:18 that is a luxury that we enjoy from heights built by those who preceded us in this chamber.
03:42:25 If you look back at our rich history and study the leading figures in its telling and see only
03:42:31 the blemishes, then you are missing out on the beautiful story of a country constantly bettering
03:42:36 itself and consistently offering refuge to so many people. This country has bestowed such fortune
03:42:47 and opportunity on my family that i stand before you running to be the next prime minister one
03:42:55 generation removed from having nine kids in a two-bedroom bungalow along a dirt road
03:43:00 that right there is canada ladies and gentlemen and it's worth fighting to protect canada must be
03:43:07 a place where no ambition is too big where no dream is out of reach and where no government
03:43:13 will stand in the way of people working hard to get ahead.
03:43:17 Conservatives have put Justin Trudeau on notice.
03:43:19 When your government falls,
03:43:21 Conservatives will be ready and we will win.
03:43:24 Tonight we have accomplished
03:43:25 what only two parties have ever done before,
03:43:27 by holding a first-term majority government to a minority.
03:43:31 This is how it starts.
03:43:32 This is the first step.
03:43:34 And now we are heading back to Ottawa
03:43:36 with a much bigger team,
03:43:37 with more support from coast to coast,
03:43:40 and with an endorsement from the Canadian people
03:43:42 that we are the government-in-waiting.
03:43:55 Folks, the Honourable Andrew Scheer.
03:44:06 Well, thank you very much, Scott.
03:44:08 Thanks, Lisa.
03:44:09 Thanks, Dan.
03:44:10 Good evening, everyone. What an incredible three years.
03:44:15 I have been so honoured to serve as leader of the Conservative Party of Canada
03:44:20 and as leader of the official opposition in the House of Commons, leading our amazing team.
03:44:36 Looking back on where we started in 2017,
03:44:39 In 2017 and all that we have accomplished together, I am struck by the determination, strength and resilience of our party.
03:44:47 In 2017, no one thought we could win the next election.
03:44:52 The media establishment was predicting that Justin Trudeau would easily win two or maybe even three majority governments.
03:44:59 He would be Prime Minister for as long as he wanted.
03:45:02 But we rolled up our sleeves and reminded voters that Conservatives are the only party fighting for hard-working Canadians.
03:45:12 The fact that anyone even considered the 2019 election winnable is because of the incredible success of our entire team.
03:45:20 And while we didn't get the result we all would have liked, we did reduce the Trudeau government to a minority and formed the strongest opposition in Canadian history.
03:45:32 There are so many people I would like to thank.
03:45:36 First off, my House leadership, shadow cabinet and caucus teams.
03:45:40 Merci pour vos conseils et votre soutien pendant mon mandat.
03:45:48 One of the most frustrating parts of not forming government is stopping to think about what
03:45:53 a great group of ministers we would have had if we had won.
03:45:57 I know that Canadians would have been far better served during this pandemic had there
03:46:01 been a conservative government in power and I look forward to the many great things that
03:46:07 our next conservative team will accomplish.
03:46:09 I would also like to thank Joan Bayless, Hamish Marshall, Kenzie Potter, Marc-André Leclerc
03:46:19 and all the teams who encouraged me to present myself as a chef and who stayed on my side.
03:46:26 This has sometimes been difficult, but I can't imagine a better group of people to do it.
03:46:35 To the Office of the Leader of the Opposition and Party Headquarter Teams,
03:46:39 thank you for all your hard work over the past three years and throughout this leadership race.
03:46:44 I know that the new leader will be in good hands with all of you.
03:46:48 I'd also like to thank our entire Conservative Caucus,
03:46:52 National Council, Party President Scott Lamb,
03:46:55 and all of our thousands and thousands
03:46:57 of party members and volunteers.
03:46:59 Each of you contribute so much to our movement
03:47:03 and are vital to our success.
03:47:07 But most of all, I would like to thank my incredible wife,
03:47:10 Jill, for her love and support,
03:47:13 without which none of this would have been possible.
03:47:16 Jill, I love you so much.
03:47:18 thank you for all the sacrifices that you and the kids made over the past few years.
03:47:26 I can honestly say that I have never been prouder to be a conservative
03:47:29 or to be a Canadian.
03:47:31 La pandémie nous a mis au défi, mais elle a aussi montré le meilleur côté des Canadiens
03:47:38 partout au pays. Les voisins cédant les unes et les autres, les entreprises trouvant des façons
03:47:45 We have improved the government's response to the pandemic and have never backed down in our fight to keep our parliament open during this crisis.
03:48:15 As we look forward to the recovery, Canadians will be faced with a fundamental choice.
03:48:21 You see, the left is offering the same failed policies that they always do.
03:48:26 Bigger government, more government intervention and less individual freedom.
03:48:31 The lie of the left is that the very people they claim they want to help are hurt the
03:48:46 most by their policies.
03:48:48 They pretend to be motivated by compassion, but there is nothing compassionate about big
03:48:54 government intervention.
03:48:56 Over-increasing intervention in the marketplace rewards big corporations who can afford expensive
03:49:02 government relations experts.
03:49:04 New rules and laws make labour costs so expensive that low-income workers and new entrants into
03:49:09 the workforce lose their jobs first.
03:49:13 And little by little, fundamental rights and freedoms are eroded.
03:49:17 In the 1980s, the Soviet bloc and Eastern European countries all had the same rhetoric.
03:49:23 Their policies were supposed to help the poor and promote equality.
03:49:27 The exact same rhetoric that the left is using today.
03:49:30 But all it caused was misery.
03:49:32 The challenge for conservatives today is that many people do not understand the free market economy,
03:49:41 individual freedom, a limited government, and more individual choice.
03:49:48 voters didn't grow up. Many of today's voters didn't grow up watching the wall
03:49:52 come down or looking at the bread lines in East Berlin. So we as a party need to
03:49:58 constantly be looking for new ways to make the case for the core conservative
03:50:02 principles we all believe in. Freedom, limited government, and unlimited
03:50:07 potential. Our values and ideals have stood the test of time. For generations
03:50:13 they have guided Canadians through adversity and they will once again. You see, the Liberals are
03:50:20 all candy before supper. They make superficial promises and hope you don't blame them for the
03:50:26 consequences. Then, all you're left with is a stomach ache and a serious case of buyer's remorse.
03:50:33 Conservatives, on the other hand, we believe in a balanced meal. We
03:50:37 look at the whole picture and we seem we see the harm
03:50:50 we are your voice but the biggest risk to freedom and liberty is when people empower government to
03:50:57 do more and more for them it may be tempting to use the government to address the challenges
03:51:04 society often faces. But once invited inside, the government is a terrible houseguest. It
03:51:10 may feel good to vote in a party that is going to overstep the limits of government in order
03:51:15 to do something you agree with. However, that invitation is quickly used to justify all
03:51:21 sorts of actions you might never have considered. It is far better to keep government within
03:51:26 strictly defined limits and leave the rest of society to fulfill its proper role. That
03:51:33 is why Conservatives put their faith in people.
03:51:37 We know that there is more to society than just government, and that free people, within
03:51:42 a free market, working hard and enjoying the fruits of their labour, free to express themselves
03:51:47 and live their lives the way they want, that is the recipe for success every single place
03:51:55 it's been tried.
03:51:57 When given a choice between societies where governments control more and more of their
03:52:01 citizens lives and those where freedom and opportunity are protected people
03:52:05 always choose freedom after all no one ever got shot trying to jump the wall
03:52:11 to get into East Berlin or paddle the raft to get to Cuba we don't even have
03:52:16 to go back into the past to see these examples we just need to look at the
03:52:20 mess happening right now in Venezuela and all the tragedy that it is causing
03:52:26 You know, it's to the Conservatives to transmit this message.
03:52:32 For us, a guaranteed election does not exist.
03:52:38 At a time when the establishment elites are doing everything they can to defeat us,
03:52:43 at a time when dozens of groups like Lead Now and Unifor pay millions of dollars
03:52:48 to run ads against us and bash our policies,
03:52:51 policies, at a time when the mainstream media bias in this country has never been more clear.
03:53:00 In times like this, it is up to the Conservative Party to unite Canadians instead of allowing
03:53:07 the left to divide Canadians.
03:53:12 At a time when our kids, when young people, have never been taught the value of those
03:53:17 free market principles, where they've actually been taught that there's something wrong
03:53:22 with free markets and individual liberty.
03:53:27 In times like these, it is even more important for every single Conservative to stay united
03:53:34 and do everything you can to work together to spread our message of hope.
03:53:40 So it doesn't matter what kind of Conservative you are, our party needs all of you, and we
03:53:45 We need you to go out and find more people who share our beliefs.
03:53:49 Please stay involved.
03:53:50 Be bold.
03:53:51 Think.
03:53:52 Challenge the mainstream media.
03:53:54 Don't take their narrative as fact.
03:53:56 Check out smart, independent, objective organizations that are growing all the time, like the Post
03:54:02 Millennial or True North.
03:54:04 There are other places to get information.
03:54:06 Let's stop being the silent majority.
03:54:09 Don't be afraid to challenge leftist professors or public figures.
03:54:13 Millions of Canadians share our Conservative values, they just don't all know it yet.
03:54:20 Now, I know that we can win the next election.
03:54:26 Quand je suis devenu chef du parti en 2017, nous avions quatre-vingt-dix-neuf sièges.
03:54:34 Today, I am leaving the next leader with 121 amazing MPs from coast to coast.
03:54:43 In 2015, we won around 31% of the vote.
03:54:46 In 2019, we won 34.4%, won the popular vote, and formed the strongest opposition in Canadian
03:54:54 history.
03:54:55 I'm also proud to say tonight that the Conservative Party of Canada is officially debt-free.
03:55:05 We are in an excellent position, but we cannot be complacent.
03:55:09 Our party's unity has been tested in the past and media love nothing more than writing
03:55:13 about disgruntled Conservatives.
03:55:15 So we cannot give them that opportunity.
03:55:18 For the last few months, the different candidates and their supporters have been highlighting
03:55:22 the differences between them.
03:55:25 After tonight, let's all come together and focus on the things that unite us.
03:55:32 We must stay squarely concentrated on working together and focusing on the many things we
03:55:38 that we share in common.
03:55:58 Where they will use the pandemic as an excuse to reward their friends,
03:56:01 Conservatives will clean up their corruption.
03:56:04 Where they will play the politics of envy,
03:56:06 will spread a message of hope and opportunity. Where they will attack our energy sector, we will
03:56:13 champion it and celebrate the prosperity it creates for all Canadians. Where they will demonize people
03:56:18 for having different views on issues facing Canadians, we will not attack people for their
03:56:23 deeply held positions, but instead look to find the common ground.
03:56:27 And when they let Canadians down, as they always do, we will be ready to offer them
03:56:45 a conservative government that puts people first.
03:56:49 And after tonight, let's all rally behind the new leader and do everything we can to
03:56:55 make sure that the next leader of the Conservative Party becomes the next
03:56:59 Prime Minister of this great country. Serving in this role has been the
03:57:04 greatest honour of my professional life. I want to thank all the members, all the
03:57:09 volunteers, the member of our fantastic team so much. This has been such an honour.
03:57:13 Thank you very much. Thank you so much for all the support that you've given to
03:57:19 me and my family and we will get them in the next election. Thank you very much.
03:57:24 Thank you leader. Okay, so I know that you are all anxious to hear the ballot results
03:57:47 and we are almost there. I am now pleased to turn things over to our co-chairs for this evening,
03:57:53 the Honourable Lisa Raitt and Dan Nolan for the news that I know everyone is waiting for.
03:58:00 Thank you, Jamie. We'll start with a short explanation of the process that brought us here today.
03:58:04 At the limit of the election of May 15, our conservative party counted a record number of 269,469 members.
03:58:14 Voting was by preferential ballot and members could rank one, two, three or all four candidates in order.
03:58:30 Members were required to return their ballots along with a signed declaration form and a copy of their identification to the offices of Deloitte here in Ottawa prior to 5 p.m. on Friday, August 21st.
03:58:43 starting back on july 20th we began processing ballots as they were received and over the last
03:58:48 month we succeeded in processing a record number of ballots for a canadian leadership race
03:58:52 174 849 ballots were verified once the validity of the memberships and the identification was
03:59:01 confirmed the ballots which remained in their secrecy envelopes were set aside in sealed bins
03:59:07 this morning these bins were opened and we counted the ballots using tabulators certified and
03:59:13 supplied by dominion voting services from the tabulators dominion voting services will produce
03:59:20 the first ballot results which are then verified by deloitte and then approved by the chief
03:59:25 returning officer if subsequent balance are required the same process will be followed
03:59:30 Each of the 338 electoral districts or ridings are worth 100 points, and these points are allocated to candidates based on the percentage of valid votes in that writing.
03:59:42 To win, a leadership candidate must receive 16,901 points, which is 50% plus one of the 33,800 points available.
03:59:56 At every step of the process, we have assured a total transparency to the candidates and to their team.
04:00:04 The prosecutors have been present during the manipulation of voting documents,
04:00:09 and everything is done under the attentive regard and with the useful advice of Deloitte.
04:00:15 Speaking of watchful eyes, many members also turned into our live 24-hour webcams
04:00:21 cams that monitored the ballots and processing centers from the moment it opened until this
04:00:26 morning. This was all done to ensure a process that was accurate, transparent, efficient and
04:00:31 fair for our leadership candidates and for the members of our party. We'd like to recognize
04:00:37 the members of Leadership Election Organizing Committee and thank them for their service.
04:00:42 Valérie Asoulin from Quebec, Scheer Barsley from Ontario, Jay Batty from Ontario, Lois Brown,
04:00:49 former MP from Ontario, David Connolly from the North, Tanya Corbett from British Columbia,
04:00:55 Stephen Dolansky from Alberta, the Honourable Diane Finlay who Lisa will be talking about
04:01:00 further from Ontario, Macaulieu Fortin from Quebec, the Honourable Linda Frum from Ontario, Marie-Josée
04:01:07 Garrett from Quebec, Scott Lamb the President from British Columbia, Sam Magnus from Saskatchewan,
04:01:13 Judy Manning from Newfoundland, the Honourable Don Plett from Manitoba, and Kevin Price from
04:01:18 beautiful New Brunswick. Lisa. Dan I don't think the people at home know that you did not have the
04:01:24 provinces next to the names that you just listed out so I'm very impressed with the fact that you
04:01:29 know where everybody is from and I know that everybody likes to know representation across
04:01:33 the country. Now before we walk you through how this night is going to unfold in terms of the
04:01:38 election results I want to take a minute to pay tribute to a dear friend and a colleague of mine
04:01:45 who has just announced she will not be running as a Conservative candidate in the next election.
04:01:51 The Honourable Diane Finley from Haldeman Norfolk, who, as you just heard, is also on the Leadership
04:01:57 Election Committee, has been our rock in the Conservative caucus since 2004. She's been a
04:02:05 loyal friend to many, a strong mentor to caucus and staff alike, and she's always equipped with
04:02:11 the dry, witty joke to brighten the mood. When Stephen Harper formed government in 2006,
04:02:17 he entrusted Diane to run several senior portfolios where she developed the universal childcare
04:02:23 benefit, retired and replaced the aging Sea King helicopters, and secured citizenship
04:02:30 for thousands of lost Canadians who came here after World War II. I can tell you from experience
04:02:37 that Diane was always well-briefed and prepared at the Cabinet table, and her staff and officials
04:02:43 and some of my Cabinet colleagues can tell you that briefing notes and memos always came
04:02:48 back filled with commentary, further questions, and the occasional grammatical edit. 0.89
04:02:54 Diane was also the first person to send a care package to every new female MP that was 0.75
04:03:01 elected to our caucus, containing little practical items to help make the job easier.
04:03:08 Now, I'd be remiss if I didn't thank Diane for sharing her late husband as well, Senator Doug
04:03:13 Finley, with our party for so many years. Diane was Doug's rock, and he tirelessly planned and
04:03:21 implemented victorious conservative campaigns in 2006, 2008, and 2011. Diane applied some of
04:03:30 the lessons that she learned from Doug over the last five years as she conducted election reviews
04:03:36 across the country, served as our party caucus liaison, and was a vital member of the last two
04:03:42 leadership election organization committees. Diane, thank you for your service to our country,
04:03:50 to our party, and to Haldim and Norfolk. We're really going to miss you in Parliament.
04:03:55 Yes, thank you, Diane, from our part as well. Okay, so we've lined up an impressive
04:04:00 group of high-profile Canadiens conservatives from across the country to help us make tonight's
04:04:05 announcements. They'll be coming to us from their home provinces and will read out the
04:04:09 unofficial ballot results by province for each candidate in ballot order.
04:04:30 but no, the candidates have received the vote vote.
04:04:33 Now obviously, Dan, they're not going to be giving us the results right away
04:04:37 because we're still going to be waiting for the last of the processing to happen for us in the votes.
04:04:42 But when they are ready to give us the votes, they're going to be getting a call from the auditors at Deloitte
04:04:49 and those results will then be read out to the rest of us.
04:04:53 Yes, it's true. They will receive a Deloitte call, which is in the meeting room, where the results are displayed.
04:05:12 The candidates and you all will hear the results for the first time. Thank you.
04:05:19 Lisa?
04:05:20 Yes.
04:05:23 As I said, these folks are going to receive a phone call from our Deloitte auditors in
04:05:28 the results room where the ballot results will be pulled later.
04:05:32 The candidates and you will be hearing these results for the first time right here together.
04:05:40 We'll be checking in with the candidates when Dan and I announce the official national
04:05:43 results at the end of the provincial results.
04:05:46 If we go to multiple ballots, we may do this three times.
04:05:51 And we will announce the total points for each candidate only, official writing by writing
04:05:56 votes.
04:05:57 Votes and percentage will be posted immediately on the party website once they are announced
04:06:01 to comply with our constitutional requirements.
04:06:04 We will only announce the points obtained by each candidate, but the points, votes and
04:06:10 the percentage for each circumcision will be published on the website of the party
04:06:15 dès leur annonce.
04:06:45 Let's take a look and see who we have gathered from across the country.
04:06:49 And Dan, let's start with BC.
04:06:52 James Moore is a senior business advisor at the multinational law firm Dentons
04:06:57 and a public policy advisor at the global firm Edelman.
04:07:00 He served as Member of Parliament for Port Moody, Coquitlam, Port Coquitlam for 15 years
04:07:05 and served as a member of Stephen Harper's Cabinet.
04:07:09 James Moore is a chief chief chief of affairs in Denton's legal legal cabinet and a chief chief of public policy for the international firm Edelman.
04:07:19 He was a deputy of Port Moody Coquitlam and Port Coquitlam at the Chambre des Communes for 15 years and a member of Stephen Harper's cabinet.
04:07:27 Joining James today is Cathy McLeod. Cathy McLeod has served as the member of Parliament for the riding of Kamloops Thompson Caribou since 2008.
04:07:36 She is the current Shadow Minister for Natural Resources, Forestry and Mining.
04:07:40 Cathy McLeod is Deputy of Kamloops Thompson Caribou at the Chambre des Communes since 2008.
04:07:46 She currently occupies the Minister of the Phantom Cabinet for Natural Resources.
04:07:52 So let's check in with you there. James and Cathy, how are you?
04:07:56 So Lisa, Dan, it's certainly a delight to join you here tonight.
04:08:00 And of course, we're in beautiful BC where we still are also enjoying some sunshine.
04:08:05 advantage to have pacific standard time today and typically in an election night for british
04:08:11 colombians we turn on the tv when our ballots have closed and the results are already over
04:08:18 i am so pleased tonight that british columbia is going to get to go first and so it won't be
04:08:22 a fait accompli by the time we're announcing the results so again very pleased to join you tonight
04:08:28 and looking forward to a great evening it's great to be with you kathy as well and dan
04:08:34 And Lisa, thank you for your leadership on this, like everybody else, looking forward to the results.
04:08:38 We are ready for the results of the first vote for our leadership course of the Conservative Party,
04:08:45 because we are sure that the next leader will certainly be the Prime Minister of Canada.
04:08:49 So we are going, we are waiting for the results, and I am very happy with our meeting today and tonight.
04:08:57 Thank you very much, Dan. Thank you very much, James. Sorry, I was going to talk to Dan X.
04:09:00 Now, it's good to mention to everybody that out there in British Columbia, we hold 17 out of 42 of those seats.
04:09:07 In fact, we're the largest federal party in British Columbia.
04:09:10 And we're about to go to Newfoundland, which is nine hours in the air away in four and a half time zones.
04:09:16 And interestingly, flat Australia is only 15 hours, so it's a remarkably big country.
04:09:21 Over in Newfoundland, we have Judy Manning.
04:09:24 Judy Manning practices law in historic downtown St. John's, a founding partner of the Manning-Bradbury firm.
04:09:29 She is a former Minister of Justice and Public Safety and the Attorney General for the province
04:09:34 of Newfoundland and Labrador.
04:09:36 Judy Manning is the founder of Manning-Bradbury and practices the rights of the historical
04:09:41 city of St. John's.
04:09:42 She has been the Minister of Justice and the Public Security and the General of the province
04:09:47 of Tarn-Neuve and Labrador.
04:09:50 Sharon Voelke has served as the Executive Director of the Newfoundland and Labrador PC
04:09:54 Party.
04:09:55 currently President of the Bonavista-Burin-Trinity Federal Riding, where she is also the current
04:10:00 Conservative candidate of record.
04:10:02 Sharon Vokey has been the General Director of the Conservative Party of Terre-Neuve-Labrador.
04:10:07 She is the President of the Bonavista-Burin-Trinity Circonscription and is also the President of the Conservative Party of the Conservative Party.
04:10:17 Welcome, Conservative friends, from Canada's youngest province, Newfoundland and Labrador,
04:10:22 specifically St. John's, the far east of the western world. Judy Manning here and I am delighted
04:10:29 to join you as we usher in our new conservative leader to right this ship that is our great nation.
04:10:36 It's been a privilege to serve on the leadership election organizing committee. Now I'm very eager
04:10:43 to shed this neutrality and get back into campaign mode with our new leader at the helm.
04:10:48 I am joined tonight by another ardent campaigner, my friend Sharon Vokey, from the village of Trinity on Newfoundland's northeast coast.
04:10:59 During our last federal campaign, Sharon hopped aboard her RV, combing every corner of the riding of Bonavista-Burin-Trinity,
04:11:08 in excess of 16,800 square kilometers, rallying enough votes to double our share of the vote.
04:11:17 How's that RV fueled up and ready to go, Sharon?
04:11:22 Thank you, Judy.
04:11:24 And yes, I'm just waiting for the call.
04:11:27 And I'm so pleased to have this opportunity to work with you again.
04:11:31 And like you, I am absolutely thrilled to be a part of the 2020 Conservative Leadership Race.
04:11:40 You know, from coast to coast to coast, all across our beautiful country, our conservative
04:11:49 family are all excited and united.
04:11:53 There's a lot of work to be done, but we know, given the caliber of our four outstanding
04:11:58 candidates, that the country is going to be in good hands.
04:12:02 And I'm just very pleased to be a part of all of this this evening.
04:12:08 Thank you very much.
04:12:09 Appreciate that.
04:12:10 Sharon thanks Judy so just as a reminder to folks when we're getting into the results as we are
04:12:15 putting up the provincial results we're not going to actually be providing the tally that's for you
04:12:20 and I to disclose at the very end of hearing what's happening across in the provinces yep so
04:12:25 everybody's going to get their pens and paper and calculators out just to keep track of what's going
04:12:29 on but we will have the results hopefully soon that's right we're going to move now to Alberta
04:12:35 much like Newfoundland does go to Alberta an awful lot that's exactly what we're going to follow in
04:12:39 this one we're so delighted to have minister sonja savage sonja savage was elected as the mla for
04:12:45 calgary northwest in 2019 for the united conservative party she has lived in alberta
04:12:51 all her life and been involved in the conservative movement for over 30 years and as i
04:13:01 to those who have been watching from the get-go and earlier on in the show
04:13:04 to true north live this is the conservative leadership results show i'm andrew lawton
04:13:08 joined by my friend and colleague candace malcolm as we uh count down to the conservative party of
04:13:14 canada leadership results that were supposed to be in about uh three hours ago but are still uh
04:13:20 promised to us soon as we just heard from lisa rate and dan nolan the co-chairs of leoc which
04:13:27 is the leadership election organizing committee for the party which has been responsible for the
04:13:31 rules and procedure of this race uh right now what's happening is they're introducing some of
04:13:36 the the dignitaries that are going to be involved in reading the provincial results from coast to
04:13:41 coast to coast and and just because it gets a bit repetitive and we're going to be hearing from these
04:13:45 people later uh we're going to go away from that and and cut back in when they have results or
04:13:50 something else but if you see in your screen uh you'll still see what's happening there and we're
04:13:54 monitoring it our team is on it so if something starts happening we'll switch back to that
04:13:58 immediately so do uh stay tuned but i want to talk i don't know about you candace but i want
04:14:02 to talk about that speech from andrew sheer a lot of good stuff in there that i think we need to pay
04:14:08 attention to but one in particular that we'd be remiss to not pay attention and this race is
04:14:12 which was a line that i'm going to read directly verbatim challenge the mainstream don't take their
04:14:20 narrative as fact check out smart independent objective organizations that are growing all the
04:14:25 time like the post-millennial or true north these there are other places to get information quite
04:14:31 an endorsement and something that obviously we're grateful for in the national spotlight honestly
04:14:37 i that was surprising to me and i was very pleased to hear andrew you know i was watching the speech
04:14:42 and i was thinking yeah this is pretty good thinking of coming back and being a little
04:14:46 bit critical though and hitting him back on uh you know things that he was saying now that he
04:14:51 wasn't saying in the campaign or anything well then you know as soon as he said something nice
04:14:54 about true north i just uh that's what it takes to buy your support in this particular case
04:15:01 exactly i'm kidding of course because of course all of the uh mean girls as ezra likes to call
04:15:06 them in the mainstream media were very quick to tweet out uh you know their their dismay at the
04:15:12 idea that the conservative uh outgoing leader would give props to organizations like true north
04:15:18 and post-millennial we are i guess the sworn enemy of the mainstream media at this point so you can
04:15:22 see them all sort of you know tweeting angrily coming across as being a little bit jealous but
04:15:29 no of course we'll still be critical of politicians even if they say nice things to us. I think that
04:15:35 Andrew Scheer did a good job though all in all. You know whenever I hear him give these speeches
04:15:40 he sounds very ideological and very very conservative and I wish we had seen more of
04:15:44 that on the campaign trail. Andrew what was your takeaway aside from you know his nice remarks about
04:15:49 true north what did you think about that well to be honest the one thing that really jumped out
04:15:53 before the the true north shout out was the comment he made about people always choosing
04:15:57 freedom and he had said in very vivid imagery that no one was shot climbing the berlin wall into
04:16:03 east germany that no one dies paddling a raft made of javex bottles towards cuba that people
04:16:09 are fleeing these regimes so why should any country any society any civilization want to emulate the
04:16:15 the failed policies of the unfree world. And I thought that was quite a beautiful analogy and 0.99
04:16:22 something that, again, really cuts at what we needed to see from Andrew Scheer up until this
04:16:27 point, which is really driving why conservatism doesn't need to be diluted to be sold, why
04:16:32 conservatism is the answer to the problems that face societies and the problems that face
04:16:37 governments. And that was so important. And it's an ideological position. It's somewhat
04:16:42 philosophical. But that idea of standing up for freedom was not something we heard from him during
04:16:47 the election. And it was really, I'd say, refreshing, albeit, yes, you could say a bit
04:16:52 belated to hear him talk about why unequivocal conservatism is what the Conservative Party and
04:16:58 what the Conservative movement needs to be striving towards. Oh, I absolutely agree. And we talked
04:17:03 about a little bit earlier with our panel with Aaron and Sam about how the Conservatives need
04:17:07 to just put forth something fresh, something new,
04:17:11 a positive image of what conservatism can be.
04:17:15 I think Aaron Gunn mentioned something about how,
04:17:19 we need a bold vision for a conservative leader,
04:17:21 something like John A. MacDonald and National Plan,
04:17:23 something that can unite all Canadians.
04:17:25 And again, it is a little unfortunate
04:17:28 because when you look back to the 2019 campaign,
04:17:31 I don't even really know
04:17:32 what Andrew Scheer's platform was based on.
04:17:35 It was sort of a, hey, look,
04:17:36 not the liberals they're corrupt uh look at the snc lavallon scandal and you know more or less the
04:17:42 same kind of stuff that we had in canada under the harper conservatives where i think that a lot of
04:17:47 conservatives would have wanted something new something fresh and you know again andrew sure
04:17:52 did bring up some some great points um you know where he said it's not compassionate to be a
04:17:57 leftist the left thinks it's compassionate to always have bigger government i mean government
04:18:02 doesn't necessarily help people i i completely agree that that the more compassionate worldview
04:18:06 is conservatism because it seeks to unlock the uh the powers of of individuals and their freedom to
04:18:13 to do things and have more opportunities you know and even if it is helping out our fellow
04:18:18 man it's through private charity and churches as opposed to these big bureaucracies and government
04:18:23 programs i don't think there's anything you know uh great about what uh big government does because
04:18:30 it's not very generous and as we see in real life oftentimes it turns into things like the
04:18:34 we scandal where even though it's supposed to be a charity and it's supposed to be about getting
04:18:38 young people to volunteer it's really more about uh organizations driving their own self-interest
04:18:44 so i wish that uh andrew sheer had been more of that sort of genuine conservative point uh creating
04:18:51 a big picture idea i i also want to say one other thing andrew which is that i think i think it's
04:18:57 unfortunate that the Conservatives really did a really good job in the last election. They won
04:19:02 the popular vote, Andrew Scheer gained seats in every region of the country, you know he had a
04:19:07 very good showing and I think it's sort of bad precedent for the party that if you lose one
04:19:12 election you're gone and it would have been great for continuity, you know Canadians are now more
04:19:17 familiar with Andrew Scheer, we could have gotten to know him more, we could have encouraged him to
04:19:20 come out of his shell more, talk more about his Conservative beliefs, his philosophy, maybe he'd
04:19:25 be more comfortable maybe doing it a second time he would have done a lot better and he was to say
04:19:29 if we really are going into a fall election as some people are speculating again we'll have a
04:19:34 new candidate that doesn't have the same kind of name recognition to canadian so i'll just put that
04:19:39 out there there's nothing you can do about it now but it is a bit of an unfortunate precedent
04:19:43 uh that if you lose one election you know you're kicked to the curb and the next guy comes in well
04:19:48 you know what if that happens again then at some point you're just constantly rebuilding internally
04:19:54 and you're not really gaining grounds in the country yeah and when i sat down with andrew
04:19:59 sheer for an exit interview of sorts a couple of weeks ago there was a very candid moment where he
04:20:04 had said and i don't know if conceded is the right word but he had said that you know he really felt
04:20:09 in retrospect that his personality didn't shine through in the last election and and i think that
04:20:15 in this particular speech he was being authentic and one of the explanations he gave for that in
04:20:20 in our interview was that, you know, at a certain point, you have nothing to lose. And he thinks
04:20:24 perhaps there's a bit of a lesson in that, that you should be a lot more authentic when you're
04:20:28 running. And it's interesting to your point, Candice, about would he have reached that
04:20:32 conclusion had he not stepped down? And that's the whole thing. Is he only this version of himself
04:20:37 because he has nothing to lose? Or would he have kind of come to terms with the fact that the best
04:20:41 path forward was to be himself if he had stuck around as leader and was gearing up for an
04:20:46 election. And we'll never know. It's academic in many respects. But I will say on the note of his
04:20:51 shout out to us and beyond just the fact that we were mentioned and we like it, I think his point
04:20:58 about the mainstream media is proven by the mainstream media's response to that. So David
04:21:03 Akin has gotten upset with it. Justin Ling has gotten upset with it. Dale Smith, who's in the
04:21:09 parliamentary press gallery, has gotten upset with it. All of these mainstream media reporters
04:21:12 are tweeting out very snarky things about that, which proves the point that they aren't there for
04:21:17 conservatives. And let me just say, I found out from Paul Vieira, who I believe is with the Wall
04:21:22 Street Journal, that CBC is cutting away from its coverage of the leadership results to go to a
04:21:28 hockey game. And I realize hockey is important to Canadians, but I would say that for the most part,
04:21:34 conservative Canadians don't feel that the mainstream media is really interested in covering
04:21:39 their stories, which is why alternative media is important. And I think it's why Andrew Scheer
04:21:43 realizes that conservative media or alternative media is the only path to conservatives really
04:21:50 getting a fair shake in the future. And I have been very critical of Andrew Scheer, as have you.
04:21:55 So this is not about being sycophants. He knows that we've been critical of him. It's that we've
04:21:59 also given him a fair shake, which is something that the mainstream media doesn't do always.
04:22:05 Absolutely. And I mean, to the point about going to hockey, I mean, look, there's private TV
04:22:11 stations that cover these hockey games. You can go watch hockey on any channel. The whole idea,
04:22:16 we have a state broadcaster, is to tell Canadian stories and is to provide Canadians a voice and
04:22:22 a mirror of what's happening in society. The fact that they can't even be bothered to show
04:22:27 the Conservative leadership race, a person who very well likely will be the next Prime Minister,
04:22:32 is exactly what is wrong with that institution and as far as all those snarky journalists i'll
04:22:38 just point out that they're all in the parliamentary press gallery all of those people
04:22:42 that you just named and here they are not only you know being snarky about the fact that andrew
04:22:48 andrew sheer mentioned us uh but calling us names uh belittling us mocking us i mean that's not
04:22:54 really what you expect so-called objective reporters to be doing you know they're they're
04:23:00 there to report the facts find tweet out that he that andrew sure said you know go watch true north
04:23:05 uh but but you don't have to be snarky and bitter about it and again i think that that's just
04:23:10 they they see the writing on the wall they know that they are not seen as legitimate by so many
04:23:16 canadians particularly by conservative leading canadians who who struggle to understand how
04:23:21 these journalists have the uh authority when they're actually paid for essentially by the
04:23:28 Trudeau Liberals by the government in their various bailouts and various payments and forms.
04:23:34 So I think that this is not a good night for those mainstream media journalists, especially
04:23:39 the ones who work for CBC that can't even be bothered to play the leadership election results.
04:23:45 It's a pretty telling sign and pretty embarrassing for those networks.
04:23:50 Yeah, it really is. And I mean, this is a point that I've raised and it's a point that came up
04:23:54 in the independent press gallery fireside chats that the next conservative leader
04:23:59 is someone who needs to embrace independent media and i've been by and large very happy
04:24:05 that three of the four candidates have my hope is that the fourth will uh if he's successful in it
04:24:10 but but my goodness i mean i look at this and and say that there is a story and i look at our
04:24:16 coverage right now i mean we've been getting more views by my count than a lot of other mainstream
04:24:20 media, and it's not just about view count, obviously, but I do think there has to be a
04:24:24 recognition that conservatives have, in a lot of cases, tried to filter their experience through
04:24:31 the mainstream media lens. I mean, how many times have we seen stories where a conservative insider
04:24:35 has leaked some story to the Toronto Star, to CBC? I'm saying, if you want to leak a story,
04:24:40 why are you not leaking to the media that are not going to embrace it because of the salaciousness,
04:24:45 but rather because they want to advance a certain policy or advance a discussion
04:24:49 about a policy. And I think that's the problem with some of the more establishment people in
04:24:54 the Conservative Party is that, you know, the people who run some of these campaigns are
04:24:58 populated by lobbyists who live in downtown Toronto. And they just happen to have friends
04:25:03 who work at the Toronto Star and the CBC because they run in the same social circles. And so they
04:25:08 pass the stories on to their friends over at those networks. I've been very critical of this practice.
04:25:13 actually spoken to a couple of mps and conservative leadership hopefuls about this and you know they
04:25:19 all kind of agree that it's a problem that that conservative voters don't go to the toronto star
04:25:24 or the cbc for their news so there's no real point in giving news stories to them to those outlets
04:25:30 when they're going to kind of torque whatever it is and put a spin an anti-conservative spin
04:25:34 much better off coming to journalists that at least have the same philosophical basing um and
04:25:40 and beliefs and they're not gonna twerk your words
04:25:44 and try to paint you as being something that you're not.
04:25:47 So I think that organizations like True North
04:25:50 are gaining a lot of ground.
04:25:51 And I guess we'll stop tweeting our own horn here,
04:25:57 but it was nice to hear a shout out from Andrew Scheer.
04:26:01 So Andrew, what do we expect here?
04:26:04 So we're still going through and hearing
04:26:06 from all of the various people across the country
04:26:09 who are going to be announcing the results.
04:26:12 I believe Lisa Raitt said
04:26:14 that they are not going to give us the tallies as they go.
04:26:17 We're gonna have to wait to the end.
04:26:18 Do we have any kind of a timeline
04:26:20 for when we're expecting to hear the news
04:26:23 of who won at this point?
04:26:25 I think one thing this evening has told us
04:26:27 is that we can't expect a timeline for anything.
04:26:29 All I'm grateful for is that we don't have a country
04:26:31 with 50 states.
04:26:32 So the time it takes to go through 10 provinces
04:26:35 is easier than the time it would take
04:26:37 to go through it in an American system.
04:26:39 Right now, I believe that's Randy Hoback, I see, which means they're on Saskatchewan,
04:26:43 although that doesn't help me because I don't know where they are in the overall order.
04:26:47 And that's Kelly Block right now, who is there.
04:26:50 I don't know if she's a sitting MP, certainly a former MP.
04:26:54 She may be still there.
04:26:56 My encyclopedic knowledge of who's in the caucus has not been updated in a few years.
04:27:02 So you'll have to forgive me there.
04:27:03 But the one thing I will say is that it seems like the party is on track to announce a leader
04:27:09 tonight. So it's not, I think the nightmare scenario, which is where they would have to
04:27:13 just completely hold things off and delay. Right now, I'm trying to kind of keep tabs on a number
04:27:19 of sources and it sounds like the party is hoping to have results in at 10. The process, as Lisa
04:27:25 Raid has said, is that they're going to announce each province's overall score in order and then
04:27:29 go back to Lisa and Dan, who are the co-chairs of LEOC for a national result. And I know we have
04:27:38 a couple of guests lined up. We'll work on getting some of them into the mix here. But in the meantime,
04:27:42 I want to throw to one particular clip that had jumped out at us when we were going through our
04:27:49 archives and talking about the issues and themes that have really emerged here. And I just want to
04:27:56 preface this by saying, I know we're playing a lot of the independent press gallery clips and
04:28:01 other things like that. This one's from the official party debate where they talked a bit
04:28:07 about immigration and Derek Sloan had brought up his plan to lower immigration levels, which is
04:28:13 unique because he's the only leadership candidate that has done that, that made that pledge. And we
04:28:18 have a clip of Derek Sloan addressing why he wants to lower immigration levels. And I want to play
04:28:23 this and talk about it after because it sets him apart from his party. And I want to discuss whether
04:28:28 that is because, as Candace mentioned earlier, there's a bit of a fear there or if it's just
04:28:33 because the party thinks immigration is a bit of a different animal than how Derek Sloan is
04:28:39 describing it. But let's let's roll that. Follow up. On immigration, you've pushed for an overall
04:28:45 reduction. The Stephen Harper government had a manageable and steady increase in immigration
04:28:50 numbers and i don't think you've said or i certainly haven't heard you say that that was
04:28:54 something that overtaxed canada so i guess the question would be if you can do smart immigration
04:28:59 prioritize economic immigration uh vet people as you've talked about why does the number have to
04:29:05 go down if you're vetting as you mentioned a few moments ago individual immigrants well i so
04:29:13 i don't believe there's any reason to be very rigid on numbers i mean we can we can i believe
04:29:18 right now that lowering the level to what i said would be best for the country but obviously you
04:29:22 monitor it and you change things if things need to be changed but i do believe that that the
04:29:27 immigration levels that we have and the numbers of people that are settling for example in toronto
04:29:31 year after year are just many more than the the new housing units that we have and i looked at
04:29:37 these stats earlier today and we had roughly last year about 150 000 people settling in the uh the
04:29:44 census area for for the GTA and we had 27,000 new housing units come online so
04:29:50 obviously more than one person can fit into a house but you can see that the
04:29:54 the supply or the demand rather is greater than than the supply and that's
04:29:59 that's part of the issue but I just believe our rise in housing prices over
04:30:04 the last decade or so is has been a natural and it's it's not allowing our
04:30:09 families that live in the GTA in other areas to afford to buy houses and I
04:30:12 think that's a problem
04:30:14 and andrew i mentioned this a little earlier when we were doing our panel but one of the things i
04:30:20 thought was so refreshing about derek so even though he's a sitting mp and two of the other
04:30:24 leadership candidates are not he comes across not as a polished politician i say that in a very
04:30:31 good way uh he's very authentic he sort of just says what he believes and doesn't worry too much
04:30:36 about you know whether or not that's politically correct or whether or not that's been poll tested
04:30:40 one of the things that that really irks me is how polished so many of these politicians are it's like
04:30:46 when they answer a question it's not necessarily what they believe it's not based on their
04:30:49 convictions it's not based on their worldview instead it's just based on you know whatever
04:30:54 the latest poll is told them or whatever a campaign aid is whispering into their ear and
04:31:00 it just doesn't feel authentic whereas derek sloan was not that way at all and and and i really
04:31:05 appreciate him you know with with any other criticisms i might have about him just his
04:31:09 frankness and his openness in discussing the issues. And immigration was certainly an example
04:31:14 of that. I think he was really the only one who mentioned something different about immigration,
04:31:19 who said he would do something different, even at a time like this, where it's so obvious that a lot
04:31:23 of the economic justifications surrounding immigration, you know, the idea that we needed
04:31:28 to boost our economy at a time when unemployment rate is at a record high as it is, it doesn't
04:31:33 really make sense to be importing people from other parts of the world. So anyway, it was just
04:31:38 a bit refreshing to hear that. And I was grateful to have Derek Sloan as one of the candidates in
04:31:43 this race, because he was one of the ones that was really pushing for a more honest and robust
04:31:48 debate on the issues. Yeah, for sure. And just to give you a heads up, everyone, on where we are
04:31:54 right now, we are still watching the Conservative leadership stream right now. They're still going
04:31:58 through the dignitaries and notable figures from the various provinces. So the second we have
04:32:03 results or something else in the program, we will go back to it. But in the meantime,
04:32:06 we're continuing our analysis commentary breaking everything down and we have another guest joining
04:32:12 us candace why don't you uh introduce our next player in this great discussion yeah sure so as
04:32:17 everyone watching knows we've just sort of thrown this show together we're now in our third hour of
04:32:21 trim earth live and we're only expecting to do about 25 minutes sorry this is our fourth hour
04:32:26 we started at 5 30 oh yeah you're right i can't even keep back the time now but uh yeah we were
04:32:33 initially expecting to do a little bit of a show and now we've got a solid four hours of content
04:32:38 and so we brought on another one of our friends, Vitor Marciano, who is out in Alberta. He's a
04:32:44 longtime conservative activist and worked on many, many campaigns in many different
04:32:50 roles. So, Vitor, thank you so much for joining us here tonight.
04:32:54 It's my pleasure to be part of, I guess, the chaos that this evening has become.
04:32:59 Right. Well, and we sort of found ourselves sort of the center of the chaos, not just because we're
04:33:05 putting together this live broadcast, but because Andrew Scheer gave us a little bit of a shout out
04:33:09 during his speech and that made all the mainstream media journalists on Twitter very angry. So that's
04:33:14 been fun too. There were heads exploding all over Canada. They now have another reason to hate Andrew
04:33:23 Right and to hate True North if they didn't already. Well Vitor you've worked on a lot of
04:33:29 campaigns and you've really been an insider and so I'm hoping you can give us some perspective
04:33:34 on a campaign strategy. I know you know this has been a very different kind of campaign just because
04:33:40 of COVID and the inability to travel and do live events so you know coming from that perspective
04:33:45 of running a campaign you know what kind of insights can you give us about how this this
04:33:50 campaign is my apologies i have a very yappy little dog that's having an issue we'll solve
04:33:57 that they're upset the results aren't in yet too yeah totally totally he's uh he's whining a little
04:34:01 bit about it too i have no idea what he's barking at i'll close the doors all right uh in the
04:34:08 meantime we'll uh we'll just let you all know uh again that we are continuing uh we're joined by
04:34:12 vitor marciano oh there we go he's back already all right i know it just took a second um these
04:34:18 campaigns are really interesting because it ends up being 300 and some campaigns um you essentially
04:34:24 have to organize provincially but then organize almost riding by riding and frankly because of
04:34:33 the way the system is built the weaker writings become really really important um in in a writing
04:34:41 that's only got 60 or 70 members you know impressing 20 people really matters and you can
04:34:49 so this becomes an exercise in building really strong teams and working really hard to
04:34:58 be good everywhere in the country so you know as an albertan sometimes i get frustrated with
04:35:04 the fact that it's not one member one vote but for everybody who always made the argument that
04:35:09 all writings being equal puts a premium on the winner having a good strong national organization
04:35:17 well it's true um you everybody ends up chasing you know northern quebec writings with 23 members
04:35:25 and uh writings in the north and it becomes important and you end up doing different types
04:35:30 of campaigns so in you know rural ontario or rural alberta where you have thousands of members
04:35:36 per riding it becomes a finding a way to do a mass conversation with the actual members but in
04:35:44 yukon and nunavut and nunavik and you know uh mount royal in in montreal it becomes an exercise
04:35:54 in finding those 65 people who are the the the members and really connecting with them at a
04:36:01 personal lever so that you can maximize your points out of that writing. We spoke earlier in
04:36:06 the show to Lisa Raid, and one of the points that she had made in this campaign is that because
04:36:11 everything was moved for most of the campaign online, a lot of Zoom events, virtual campaigning,
04:36:18 phone banking, not coffee houses, not travel, it almost served as a bit of an equalizer,
04:36:23 whereas candidates that are lesser known that don't have the fundraising capacity as Aaron O'Toole
04:36:27 and Peter McKay do, and in Leslie Lewis and Derek Sloan, they were almost able to run the same type
04:36:33 of campaign, which was from a, you know, a hunkered down location. And I'm curious for you as a campaign
04:36:38 guy, how would you feel if you had a lesser known candidate or a candidate that didn't have as much
04:36:44 of a leg up on fundraising, and the pandemic hand was the one you were dealt? Well, I have to tell
04:36:50 you that you know if if the candidate's attractive if the candidate has an ability to connect with
04:36:57 the members it's an incredible opportunity and i think what that's what you've seen with leslin
04:37:02 lewis she's got an interesting message she is a non-traditional delivery device for that message
04:37:11 so she gets everybody's attention it's like you know a black immigrant woman from toronto okay
04:37:17 I wanted members all across the country wanted to hear what you have to say. And then she impressed them. So COVID, by equalizing the dynamic and by removing the advantage of early money in a big way, allowed Lesley to get going and then allowed her to raise an awful lot of money.
04:37:40 I mean, she's raised more money than the Democrats have nationally. That says something. And the fact that we are all talking about it, the fact that the mainstream media isn't doing five Lesley Lewis stories for every one Kamala Harris story tells you how disgraceful our media is in Canada.
04:38:00 but um i you know this is one of the really neat things about uh about politics in canada and then
04:38:08 this time one of the really neat things about running a campaign in the middle of a pandemic
04:38:12 that equalized a whole bunch of things it's a really great point and i'm glad you raised it i
04:38:19 was going to ask you who you were sort of most impressed by and who you thought ran the best
04:38:23 campaign and you kind of alluded that less than lewis did did such a great job so i'll ask you
04:38:28 that question you can answer Vitor but on top of that I also want to ask you
04:38:31 you know you're you're as connected as it gets to the grassroots of the party
04:38:35 and you know a lot of people in sort of what's the conservative heartland in
04:38:38 Alberta but also around the country traveled a lot and campaigned a lot you
04:38:42 know if conservative Canadians can't trust the mainstream media and
04:38:46 increasingly they can't where are they getting their their news where are they
04:38:49 getting their information is it straight from the candidates is it through
04:38:53 mediums like like true north or where do you think Canadians are really going
04:38:58 when grassroots conservative Canadians are going to get their news?
04:39:02 Let me start with the second question first.
04:39:05 More and more, they're getting their information from alternative media, the new media, True
04:39:10 North, other sources like that.
04:39:13 Still not enough.
04:39:17 You know, Candace, I think this is really sad, but I'm willing to bet that less than
04:39:23 one third of Conservative Party of Canada members know that True North exists.
04:39:27 and we need to change that over time, frankly, less than one-third of Conservative Party of
04:39:32 Canada members probably could name any member of the alternative or the new media.
04:39:39 So oftentimes they're not really getting information, but they've trained themselves
04:39:46 to be very, very skeptical of the mainstream sources. So they oftentimes look at what CBC
04:39:52 says or post media or global or ctv and they go okay if they say it i better take it with a grain
04:40:01 of of salt and so you get a very convoluted situation um but the other thing that's happening
04:40:08 is that i think as a whole the membership across the country the the grassroots members as opposed
04:40:18 to say the hardcore activist um they probably found this race to be very frustrating um it was
04:40:28 it was hard to stay on top of the race unless you were actively working at it every single day
04:40:35 because kovid made it a telephone telephone town hall email race as opposed to a
04:40:43 both of the frontrunners or all four of the candidates are going to come to my town
04:40:49 and I'm going to get to go to a breakfast or a lunch and see them speak.
04:40:52 So the fact that we couldn't do these communal things made things very complicated.
04:40:58 And the truth is for the average grassroots member,
04:41:02 these face-to-face events are really important because they end up being able to sort of figure
04:41:10 out who's on which team and who's backing which horse and oftentimes the opinions of activists
04:41:18 and key opinion leaders are are like a shorthand that different members of the grassroots say well
04:41:25 if so-and-so likes that candidate i can feel good about being with that candidate this was much
04:41:30 harder to do and so transitioning over to your first question you actually get something very
04:41:37 odd. I think Leslie Lewis was incredibly successful. She massively exceeded expectations
04:41:45 in raising money. I don't think her campaign was all that great. I think she could have done with
04:41:53 a little bit more prep time and a little bit more writing talent in her group. And you were just
04:42:00 having this conversation a moment ago about the authenticity of scripted versus unscripted
04:42:05 candidates. It's always important that a candidate be authentic, but it's even better when they're
04:42:13 authentic and well-scripted in the context of they've sat down with the people who help them
04:42:19 write and get speeches ready for things. They've poured out their heart to a small group of people
04:42:24 who do a bunch of the preparatory writing, and then they can appear in places and they can
04:42:30 you know, flip to their notes and their notes reflect who they are, but they're also a wonderful
04:42:35 aid memoir so that they can put themselves out there at their best. And there were moments where
04:42:41 Leslie Lewis came across as not quite ready for prime time. But there were also moments where she
04:42:47 came across as honest and authentic, serious, committed conservative, completely what a lot
04:42:55 of conservatives weren't expecting. And the party as a whole, the grassroots especially, are
04:43:00 incredibly generous. And I think they found her a very interesting candidate. So I think she's
04:43:05 going to exceed expectations. I still don't think she's going to win, but I think she's going to be
04:43:10 one of the big stories out of this. And I think, you know, three, four years from now, the story
04:43:16 will be the person that won and how this was Leslie Lewis's coming out party. Let me ask you
04:43:23 about a topic we covered earlier on in the show, Vitor,
04:43:26 but I know you're very involved in not just politics in Canada,
04:43:29 but specifically the Alberta discussions that are going on.
04:43:32 In fact, I ran into you last in Calgary a few weeks ago
04:43:35 at the event where Alberta alienation
04:43:38 and independence was being discussed.
04:43:39 And we've had some discussions on this show
04:43:42 and throughout the campaign of the fact
04:43:44 that not a single leadership candidate hails from Alberta.
04:43:47 You've got some that are still, I think,
04:43:49 more aligned with the Alberta sensibility than others are.
04:43:52 But do you think that someone like an Aaron O'Toole or a Peter McKay or a Lesley Lewis or a Derek Sloan can get a lot of those Alberta conservatives that are on that fence on separation back on board and feeling that, yeah, we might have a future in Confederation?
04:44:11 I'm really nervous about that.
04:44:15 I think. 0.61
04:44:18 I think Alberta is on a knife edge.
04:44:22 um lots of albertans are feeling like the rest of canada wants to push us out of confederation
04:44:31 and it's going to be a tough exercise for mckay or o'tool to capture
04:44:40 the interest of those people and demonstrate that they get what's going on um
04:44:45 Um, right now, you know, Alberta is the economic driver of Canada and has been for, for quite
04:44:52 a while.
04:44:53 Um, and you know, our, we, we drive Canada's biggest export industry, which has been energy.
04:45:01 Um, we have Canada's biggest taxpaying industry, which is energy.
04:45:06 We have Canada's biggest industry in terms of being able to percolate out across the
04:45:12 rest of the country, which is energy.
04:45:13 So much of what happens in the Alberta energy market comes from other provinces, either with workers or with manufacturing that sustains the Canadian energy.
04:45:22 And then we have a government that has signaled that they don't care about energy anymore and that they actually want to signal to the world that they're getting out of energy.
04:45:35 Well, that's a really big problem.
04:45:38 Over and above that, Albertans feel like they're landlocked inside Canada.
04:45:46 And so just this week, you had, you know, UCP MLA, Drew Barnes from Medicine Hat, writing a column that said, you know, Alberta would be less landlocked as an independent country than it is landlocked as a province.
04:46:01 Because as a province, we can't do anything about the rest of Canada treating us badly.
04:46:05 but as an independent country, we could be really nasty to the rest of Canada and put ourselves in
04:46:11 a better negotiating position. That attitude is becoming very, very common in Alberta. I'm not
04:46:19 saying that it's the majority attitude right now, but it's a very important attitude. I will say
04:46:25 that you can poll Albertans on the question of, is Canada broken? And 80% of conservatives will
04:46:33 tell you that Canada is broken in Alberta. But the part that blows my mind is 40 to 50% of new
04:46:40 Democrats, Alberta new Democrats will tell you that Canada is broken. So when you get this
04:46:45 perception that the country's in trouble, and it percolates at different levels of intensity
04:46:51 across the political spectrum, that's a big deal. And, you know,
04:46:56 i'm not sure it would make for great politics for peter mckay or erin o'till to talk about
04:47:04 that on the national stage but should they script themselves and come up with a message
04:47:11 that works for canada and form government that becomes probably the unspoken thing from the
04:47:18 campaign that becomes the instant top priority of a new government.
04:47:22 Because if we get a conservative national government and it doesn't do anything to
04:47:29 waylay this sense of alienation in Alberta, that's going to be a huge problem.
04:47:35 So there's, there are, this is not the immediate problem facing whoever wins
04:47:41 tonight, but this is probably the biggest potential problem.
04:47:47 and the one that will be attached to their name
04:47:50 25 years from now when the history of the 2020s is written.
04:47:55 You raised so many good points, Vitor,
04:47:57 and unfortunately, these are the conversations
04:47:58 that haven't really happened in the mainstream media,
04:48:01 in the discussion around this conservative leadership race.
04:48:05 One of the things I worry about when people say,
04:48:07 you know, we've got Peter McKay, he's electable,
04:48:10 he's moderate, whatever that means,
04:48:12 and maybe he'll pick up some seats in Atlantic Canada,
04:48:15 maybe some more in and around Toronto,
04:48:18 but at what expense?
04:48:19 And will that come as a result of further alienation
04:48:23 among Canadians in Western Canada,
04:48:26 specifically Albertans, of course Canada is broken. 0.97
04:48:28 I mean, how can you say it isn't?
04:48:30 We spent the first month of the year
04:48:32 without a ability to get rail,
04:48:36 anything moved by rail.
04:48:37 We don't have any pipelines going,
04:48:39 so we're moving oil by rail.
04:48:42 And then all of a sudden, the country shuts down.
04:48:45 Keep in mind that in the 2019 election, we had a huge resurgence of the bloc in Quebec and also the rise of Wexit, which, you know, there's nothing electorally to show for it, but you certainly hear a lot about it in, you know, on social media, online.
04:49:02 Just looking at our live chat on our YouTube here, you know, you keep seeing Wexit every few posts.
04:49:08 So certainly a lot of people are talking about it.
04:49:10 And there certainly is that sense of fear around, you know, what will happen if we get an East Coast guy running the country and he doesn't really care about what's happening in Western Canada.
04:49:22 It's right now, the liberals are the only truly national party.
04:49:28 And by that, I mean that a B.C. liberal really has very few differences from a Saskatchewan liberal or a Manitoba liberal or an Ontario liberal or a maritime liberal.
04:49:45 There is actually quite intense uniformity of opinion and worldview inside the liberal party as you cross the country.
04:49:54 But the truth of the matter is, and this is going to be a big problem for whoever wins tonight, that there are multiple actual conservative parties in this country.
04:50:07 And there are very intense, distinct worldviews amongst those parties.
04:50:14 And whoever wins is going to have a really tough time dealing with the fact that the conservative voter base in the Maritimes is dramatically different than the available conservative voter universe in Quebec, and there is one.
04:50:29 Or the conservative voter base in Ontario, which we already do well in rural Ontario, and we only have to turn it up a couple of notches to start moving back into the suburbs and doing okay, which is different than Manitoba, which is dramatically different than Alberta and Saskatchewan, which is different than BC.
04:50:46 In some ways, the fact that we're all one big party and the leader has to say things, the same thing, to Alberta and to Quebec and to Ontario and to the Maritimes is actually a disadvantage for assembling a broad coalition of conservative voters to win federal elections.
04:51:13 Now, I think that's a very key point. And I guess the one thing I'd ask you, Vitor, is,
04:51:19 you know, is it possible to take on that national unity role and to win over the support of
04:51:27 disenfranchised Albertans and Westerners without alienating people in other parts of the country?
04:51:33 I believe so, but it's going to require incredible courage. I think the way you do it
04:51:41 is to head back into the late 1980s early 1990s and reopen the constitution and i think it involves
04:51:51 discussions about you know supply management which is going to offend a whole bunch of conservatives
04:51:58 but that is a trade-off uh relative to protecting seasonal workers which offends a whole bunch of
04:52:05 conservatives but drives political decisions in the maritimes relative to not landlocking alberta
04:52:14 and saskatchewan which offends a whole bunch of conservatives in british columbia um there are some
04:52:22 difficult complicated issues facing this and i think ultimately to hold the country together
04:52:29 We either need to accidentally stumble into a global boom and then everybody
04:52:34 is rich and maybe they stop complaining about things, but that's very,
04:52:38 very unlikely post COVID or we need to reformulate the country,
04:52:45 probably a little bit closer back to the model in the terms of union.
04:52:49 Like you almost have to go back to pre-confederation, the, the, you know,
04:52:53 the, the meetings in Charlottetown, the terms of union, the,
04:52:56 Union, the agreement that got Upper Canada and Lower Canada together, that then got them
04:53:01 together with the Maritimes in BC, which was the suggestion that Canada was a business
04:53:08 arrangement. We were all going to go into business together and we all agreed that by
04:53:13 being together, we'd be stronger than if we were apart and we weren't going to do anything
04:53:18 together that damaged each of the parts singularly. Part of the terms of Union was, you know,
04:53:26 By uniting, we weren't going to screw over any of the sub parts of Canada and
04:53:30 close off their access to their markets.
04:53:33 And right now what we have in Canada is that, you know, the federal government
04:53:39 won't allow Western Canadian energy to go east.
04:53:43 BC won't allow Western Canadian energy to get to, um, tidewater on the Pacific
04:53:50 coast, which means we can't sell to Korea or Japan or China or India or
04:53:55 Indonesia or Vietnam, all people who want to buy our heavy oil,
04:53:59 which is incredibly useful in the world.
04:54:01 Heavy oil is what everybody wants. We have it,
04:54:05 but we can only sell it to the Americans.
04:54:07 They're the only people who are allowed to buy our heavy oil. We,
04:54:10 we sell our heavy oil to the Americans and we sell a little bit to Eastern
04:54:16 Canada by shipping it through the United States.
04:54:19 We are one crazy court decision in Michigan away from
04:54:26 Ontario and Quebec having oil shortages because they can't get Alberta oil
04:54:33 because a democratic politician or a crazy judge made a weird decision in
04:54:38 Michigan and cut off line three or line six or line five.
04:54:43 That's nuts.
04:54:44 But that's what we're talking about.
04:54:46 or line five that's nuts but that's the country we live in that is not so maybe that would serve
04:54:53 as a something like a wake-up call vitor to folks in ontario who just don't hear about these issues
04:54:58 i don't know about them i know we at true north we produced a documentary a couple of months ago
04:55:02 we released called calgary in crisis i flew out to calgary and did a whole bunch of interviews
04:55:07 not just with sort of politicians and leaders but just with everyday people who were telling
04:55:13 these stories about how they lost their jobs I felt like it was eye-opening for me and look I
04:55:17 used to live in Alberta I went to university there I have a lot of friends and a lot of
04:55:21 connections to Alberta but I didn't know the extent to which the problem was and I think so
04:55:25 many other Canadians don't so maybe it would take a crisis like that Vitor not saying that that's
04:55:31 what we want and it really does show the deep problems it's great that you've thought them
04:55:36 through and that you have you have ideas but I'll just have to say that I think a lot of Canadians
04:55:41 are just not even tuned into these issues at all.
04:55:44 And that's definitely a major problem.
04:55:46 And it is.
04:55:47 And kudos to True North.
04:55:50 Kudos to the new media and the alternative media
04:55:53 for starting these discussions.
04:55:55 Because nobody at CTV, nobody at CBC,
04:55:58 nobody at global television is actually talking about that.
04:56:02 You know, where Ontario does not realize
04:56:06 that it gets its Canadian oil,
04:56:07 but that Sarnia is fed through the United States.
04:56:11 and these were political decisions made in the 1950s you know we had the pipeline debates in
04:56:18 the 1950s where we rushed through a natural gas pipeline uh north of the great lakes so that
04:56:24 alberta natural gas could power and and heat the rest of canada and then because that pipe
04:56:32 line debate was so painful the liberal government at the time said
04:56:36 yeah we're not doing that again we'll just ship stuff through the states well
04:56:41 It's nuts. We're a country that actually isn't attached to each other. And then because we're not attached to each other, we're not actually thinking about that we're all in this together. And the risk about that is, and this is going to be a huge issue for whoever wins tonight, is that if we're not holding together, we might come apart.
04:57:03 well absolutely that's been a theme throughout our show tonight uh just wondering about what post uh
04:57:10 you know post new leader will look like what the unity question will look like uh vitor we thank
04:57:15 you so much for your time and your insight really it's great to talk to someone from alberta just
04:57:19 just one final question do you have any uh any predictions for tonight
04:57:23 i think it's going to be ridiculously close um i expect peter mckay to get between 43 and 45
04:57:36 on the first ballot i think he has a maximum of eight percent growth so 43 45 eight percent growth
04:57:46 he wins um if he's at 41 8 growth he doesn't win um i think if peter mckay doesn't win
04:57:56 then it's erin o'toole's for sure to win unless something odd happens and that is that
04:58:02 you know sloan outperforms and his people all go to leslin lewis and leslin lewis somehow manages
04:58:08 to bump o'toole and then at that point that opens the door to possibly peter mckay doing something
04:58:16 odd. Because I think that unlike the O'Toole activists, the O'Toole voters, probably an awful
04:58:24 lot of them have Peter McKay as their second choice. I mean, realistically, for the non-activist
04:58:28 members of the party, there's not too much difference between the two of them. So I think,
04:58:35 you know, I think McKay is the odds-on leader to win tonight. But there's three or four models
04:58:42 that could see him losing well interesting i have to say vitor we've asked like everyone else tonight
04:58:49 about predictions and they all go oh i don't know it's going to be a good night you don't just give
04:58:53 a prediction you give percentages which means you are the most precise tonight you might be the most
04:58:57 wrong you might be the most right but i appreciate that you took a swing at it in a true political
04:59:01 campaigner way so thank you i was neutral in this race so i could actually run the numbers and put
04:59:07 out what i want thank you so much for having me on it's been a real pleasure keep up the great work
04:59:12 Thanks very much. And I will just say we have a standing by or not standing by, but we're
04:59:18 awaiting to dial in a couple of people that we've spoken to earlier in the show, but obviously things
04:59:23 have changed a fair bit in the last five hours. We'll be speaking with someone from Leslie Lewis's
04:59:28 campaign very shortly and also Aaron O'Toole's campaign. I think we are also going to have
04:59:33 someone from Derek Sloan's campaign on as well. So we'll try to get as many of these voices on
04:59:40 as we can uh just to give you a little bit of context here the official conservative party
04:59:47 is uh not well the the party stream is still standing by and waiting for results apparently
04:59:54 there are still a thousand or several thousands left to be counted so this is the the infamous
04:59:59 ripped ballot problem that the party is dealing with here and just to give you a little bit of
05:00:05 context and background in this, the party is still saying that we're going to have a result
05:00:10 tonight. So with all the changes and delays, they're still saying we're going to have a result
05:00:14 tonight. I'm looking at some of the latest details. They're now up to 98% of ballots counted
05:00:20 and they're still going to go through the same announcing by province. So they're not deviating
05:00:25 from that plan to do just one dump. And I should also tell people that the party is going to have
05:00:31 a press conference after the leader is announced. They're going to be announced. They're going to
05:00:36 give a speech. And then there's an optional press conference. And this is something that the
05:00:40 Conservative Party of Canada, a communications person had said to me, is not a guarantee. They
05:00:45 don't have to do it. They might not do it. So I don't know if that was just being cautious or if
05:00:50 that was because one or more candidates said, we don't want to do a post-event presser. But now
05:00:54 that we're already at 10 p.m. Eastern time, the idea that we could even have a leader, let alone
05:00:59 an acceptance speech and a resulting press conference seems a little bit unlikely.
05:01:05 Candace, I mean, just as this goes on more, do you think that there's anything to read
05:01:11 into this about the closeness of it?
05:01:13 Or do you think it is just about ensuring that every ballot is counted?
05:01:17 Well, I think that they want to be extra careful at this point.
05:01:20 They don't want anyone contesting that the results aren't completely accurate.
05:01:24 And, you know, it's really going to come down to the wire, especially in terms of the,
05:01:28 you know, if we get into second and third ballots there. So I think they're just trying to be as
05:01:35 careful as possible. But I can't imagine them wanting to drag it on much, much longer. I mean,
05:01:41 it's already 10 p.m. here in Toronto later over on the East Coast. And, you know, again, this is
05:01:48 their evening. They're in the spotlight, the Conservative Party, everyone's watching. You've
05:01:53 got all the mainstream media people there making comments and paying attention. And I think that
05:01:58 the longer that this thing goes on,
05:01:59 just the more embarrassing it gets.
05:02:01 I mean, come on, we want to find out
05:02:02 who's the leader of the party.
05:02:03 We want to, tomorrow's Monday morning,
05:02:05 we want to get going, you know,
05:02:07 be able to start fresh with a new week.
05:02:10 And obviously whoever the leader is,
05:02:12 it's going to want to hit the ground running.
05:02:13 So, you know, I think that they're in a tough position
05:02:16 because everyone wants to know
05:02:17 people are going to start tuning off soon
05:02:19 and going to bed or going to do something else.
05:02:22 And I think if they don't come up with something soon,
05:02:25 it's not going to be good for the party.
05:02:27 what do you think, Andrew? Yeah, I mean, I'm kind of getting flashbacks to the 2016 US election when
05:02:33 John Podesta comes out at like 3.30 in the morning and says, you know, we're still, you know, going
05:02:39 to wait and see, come back tomorrow and we'll have a position. I mean, in that case, it was a campaign
05:02:43 that didn't want to accept that it had lost, even though there was a result. I'm looking at now the
05:02:48 fact that it seems like leadership races are just never going to be as smooth and clear cut as
05:02:54 they're supposed to be, because this race is not all that distinct from the Ontario leadership
05:03:00 race in 2018 or the Conservative Party federal leadership race in 2017. Although I will add
05:03:06 that the 2018 Ontario PC leadership race was a lot better because they were planning on announcing
05:03:12 a lot earlier in the day. So when they eventually announced later, at least it wasn't, you know,
05:03:16 to the point that we're at now. So I'm just looking at a couple of the, you know, the things
05:03:22 that are coming across on Twitter. And a lot of people just again, just want to get down and deal
05:03:28 with it. I think there are some people that obviously want the result. But I do think to
05:03:32 your point, Candace, that everyone understands that there is a reason that they aren't announcing.
05:03:36 So I don't think people want them to jump the gun and just end it early. Because again, if you have
05:03:42 all of a sudden, a party making a determination that a couple of 1000 ballots aren't needed,
05:03:46 you create other problems. So whether it was avoidable or not, I don't know. I do think that
05:03:52 there is a timing issue here, in part because the Conservative Party is bound, and I'm going to get
05:03:57 a bit geeky here, so I apologize, bound by its constitution to have mail-in votes. So other
05:04:04 parties have done things that are a lot more streamlined and a lot easier, but the Conservative
05:04:08 Party of Canada has to have a mail-in ballot. So the idea of doing online voting just wasn't
05:04:14 available to them. But I do think when we talk about that term earlier, Candice, modernizing
05:04:20 the party, perhaps a constitutional amendment that opens up different types of voting might be
05:04:24 permissible. Yeah, I mean, it's interesting, just given, you know, the different dynamics of the
05:04:31 campaign, the fact that, you know, we had COVID, you couldn't really go and do these kind of live
05:04:36 events. And now with voting, you know, trying to just figure out exactly how to make sure that
05:04:42 everyone's vote is counted. It's really kind of interesting. And Andrew, I wanted to get your
05:04:48 your quick take on you know we just had that interesting conversation with Vitor you know he
05:04:53 was much more uh open about the issue of how divided Canada is and we talked about it a little
05:04:59 bit throughout the show about how you know there aren't anyone any candidates from Western Canada
05:05:05 the issues that are really important to Alberta are so different than the issues that are important
05:05:09 uh to the media and and to folks in Toronto and across Ontario uh you know do you think that he
05:05:17 he was on to something when he talked about how divided Canada is and how we really need to have
05:05:21 a complete restructuring? Or do you think that that's sort of an overstatement?
05:05:25 I think it's a bit of both. I do think that we are at a pivotal point where
05:05:30 when a lot of the West is saying they want out of Canada, that also means they want out
05:05:35 of the Conservative Party of Canada. So if the Conservative Party of Canada is still
05:05:39 fixated on this vision that we need to stand up for the whole country, which is a valid one,
05:05:45 and that is at odds with what a lot of alberta conservatives want there's going to be a big
05:05:49 problem so i think there needs to be a unity challenge not just within the party you know
05:05:54 whether you were on the mckay campaign or the o'toole campaign or the sloan campaign or the
05:05:57 lewis campaign but the different regions of the party i mean aaron o'toole is one example had
05:06:02 a quebec specific platform he didn't have an alberta specific platform so i mean these are
05:06:07 some of the challenges absolutely absolutely well i think we've got another guest i'm very pleased
05:06:13 to welcome our friend Steve Outhouse. Steve Outhouse has been involved in working on the
05:06:19 Leslyn Lewis campaign. So, Steve, welcome and thanks for joining us. Hey, thanks for having me,
05:06:23 Candice. So, can we just get your quick take on the sort of chaos of the evening? I mean,
05:06:29 it's now 10 p.m. Andrew and I started our live broadcast at 5.30, thinking that we were going
05:06:34 to be on for, you know, 15 minutes or so, and we're now in hour four, hour five. Stay hydrated.
05:06:40 yeah we're trying so so what's going on from your perspective and uh you know how come this
05:06:46 is happening like this yeah well none of us none of our plans have worked out the way that we
05:06:50 thought they were going to this evening we uh we were also expecting a bit more of a brief evening
05:06:55 and now i'm here and holding a phone up in my hotel room to speak to you uh because i can't
05:07:00 even get my my computer to work it's been that type of night here for me so uh yeah we're just
05:07:05 you know look we're being as patient as we can be you know we would obviously love to have the
05:07:11 results come out as soon as possible but I do think I mean you and I know you know people who
05:07:18 have been around this a while it's more important that it get done properly than it be rushed
05:07:23 because people need to have confidence in the in the results and know that it was done well so
05:07:28 we just we're just waiting we don't have a lot of updates for what's what's going on but
05:07:34 we hope to start to hear results we've heard it could be as early well i was gonna say as early
05:07:39 as 10 p.m but it's 10 07 so and be a specific time perhaps no andrew i i will ask you steve
05:07:49 because we've been hearing for the last several hours rumors about oh this candidate's doing well
05:07:54 that candidate's not doing well is there any way that these rumors have a source in the ballot room
05:08:00 or are they just that baseless rumors i i would see them as baseless rumors frankly i mean there's
05:08:05 no way that anyone so the only time there was an exit of of scrutineers uh would have been around
05:08:11 noon or so when i mean the the exercise was literally removing the ballots from the the
05:08:17 envelopes and putting them in piles so the machines could count them if someone thinks that they're
05:08:22 going to be able to kind of stand at one sorting table and get a picture of what's going on in 338
05:08:27 ridings across the country i more power to them but i don't think that that's really realistic so
05:08:33 of course you know at the beginning you know it was a pretty clear explanation from the party that
05:08:39 you know it was due to these slice ballots and then sure enough sort of as hour by hour went by
05:08:44 and time needed to be filled and people had time to speculate about every conspiracy theory we're
05:08:50 now hearing every rumor imaginable that someone's won someone's lost there's legal challenges there's
05:08:56 There's not legal challenges.
05:08:57 And so, you know, we have no way to communicate with our scrutineers in there.
05:09:01 So for anyone to claim that they have, you know, credible information, I mean, if they
05:09:06 did, that would be a clear violation of the rules.
05:09:08 And that starts at a minimum fine of $100,000 from their security deposit or their compliance
05:09:14 deposit.
05:09:15 So if you have information, turn that in.
05:09:18 Interesting.
05:09:19 That's a good point.
05:09:20 Now, this is a little bit of an insider baseball question here, Steve.
05:09:23 but you know the the deadline for ballots was friday evening you know it's now sunday night
05:09:29 the broadcast was supposed to start at 6 p.m we didn't hear word of the delay until what 5 45 or
05:09:35 something like that wouldn't they have known in advance uh i just don't really understand why
05:09:40 they didn't let us know this you know on friday evening or saturday or even earlier in the day
05:09:44 on sunday why did it come down to the wire like that yeah so i mean that's a great question and
05:09:49 and maybe I can clarify that a little bit.
05:09:50 So it was interesting because from what we've been told,
05:09:54 it's not actually an issue that there's too many ballots
05:09:56 or anything like that.
05:09:57 It was what happened was on Friday,
05:09:59 they stayed until a late Friday evening
05:10:01 and they were actually done opening all the ballots.
05:10:04 There was nothing.
05:10:05 Originally, they had told all the scrutineers,
05:10:07 so we had all our people on standby to be in
05:10:10 for the normal processing.
05:10:12 So the first way,
05:10:13 if we're going to go inside baseball,
05:10:15 let's go ahead and we'll get into all the details
05:10:16 so people know.
05:10:17 I mean, the way it works is that
05:10:19 You know, every day, our scrutineers will go into the room where the counting was happening. And what they do is they open up the first envelope and they see, okay, you know, Bob Smith from 123 Main Street in Calgary Centre. And then they match him up with the database and they see the ID is good. It has a name, a photo, you know, the attestation has been signed. Okay, that's all good.
05:10:43 so now bob's and bob's ballot who we don't know who bob voted for because it's still in the secrecy
05:10:49 envelope goes into this pile here uh and any any ballots that they couldn't tell like sometimes
05:10:55 people would stuff all of their id and everything into the secrecy ballot so they would have to then
05:11:00 escalate those open them up with scrutineers watching to see if um in fact the id was in
05:11:06 there and the attestation was signed and if they're if they were then it would go in for
05:11:11 counting if it wasn't then it would have to be shredded and their ballot would be would be spoiled
05:11:16 so as a friday night all of the ballots the 174 000 plus or whatever the number was uh were
05:11:24 opened like from the the outside envelope the id was checked and all of the ballots that were to
05:11:30 be counted on sunday were all put in the vault and ready to go and so then what the issue happened
05:11:37 today was the first process when you go to count these ballots is you have to physically remove
05:11:42 them from the secrecy envelope so they're slicing there's a machine that's there to slice the the
05:11:46 envelope open and for whatever reason and we've heard things from like oh the paper was too thin
05:11:52 or they're trying to make it a little bit lighter so it'd meet all the canada posts you know
05:11:56 guidelines and it wouldn't have to pay extra postage um when they were slicing them it sliced
05:12:02 it appears to be and i've only heard this number in the media i haven't heard it directly from the
05:12:05 party of three to four thousand ballots and so that only would have happened today which is why
05:12:11 they would only have had that information today so maybe that answers a little bit about that
05:12:16 question no thank you i appreciate the insight just because we haven't had anyone uh explain
05:12:20 that thoroughly to us so uh we appreciate it although it was a little technical but that does
05:12:25 help kind of clarify what why it is that we're going so late so one of the things that we've
05:12:30 talked about one of the stories a big stories of this campaign has really been the ascent
05:12:34 of Leslyn Lewis. She was relatively unknown or completely unknown to most Canadians just a few
05:12:39 months ago. And now she's got this huge star power, lots of momentum. You know, even if she doesn't
05:12:44 win tonight, she's still one of the big, big stories of the campaign and could potentially 0.97
05:12:48 finish a lot higher than people expect. So I just want to ask you, what initially connected you to
05:12:53 her? What did you see about her campaign that excited you and got you involved in the first
05:12:58 place? Yeah, so I had originally, my wife and I had talked it over and we've had enough, you know,
05:13:03 we've been involved with a lot of campaigns and she'd said you know maybe we could sit this one
05:13:07 out and i i agreed to do that for uh well i agreed to do it uh agreed to sit it out and then i had a
05:13:14 good friend it was a few months later and i was still on the sidelines as a political person you
05:13:19 get a little bit twitchy you kind of want to want to be engaged and uh i had a friend of mine say
05:13:24 that uh you know it was um sorry the uh you know you should really talk to talk to dr lewis like
05:13:31 she's the real deal and i think you would you would connect with her well and i had some
05:13:36 conversations with her and i have to say it was it was she was very impressive for myself i am a
05:13:42 pro-life individual i guess i fall into the social conservative camp and i i have a real drive to
05:13:51 help social conservatives put forward positions in particular on the pro-life issue that are
05:13:57 respectful and and reasonable and you know I believe that it's important that we continue
05:14:03 to have this debate in our country and whether whether people agree with me or not I think it's
05:14:08 an important debate to have and so that was primarily kind of the first thing that that
05:14:14 drew me to to her was just that this is something that's important to her but it wasn't something
05:14:19 that she was looking to kind of you know drive a hidden agenda or force people to believe what she
05:14:24 believed and I really resonated with her approach and so when she kind of put out the no hidden
05:14:28 agenda approach of here's the four things I would do you know I really was glad to have the chance
05:14:34 to work with her on that so that was kind of at the core what drew me to her but overall I mean
05:14:39 just her I found her to be a very very strong candidate who I thought could do a good job
05:14:46 leading both the party and the country and that I wanted to help out. You and I spoke earlier in
05:14:52 day, Steve, when we were both so young and full of hope that we'd all be in bed right now.
05:14:56 But the one thing I have to ask you about, because you and I spoke a little while back,
05:15:03 of course, with the independent press gallery debate in which Lesley Lewis was ill and couldn't
05:15:09 make it. And you were very gracious and trying to make it work. And you were there. And we heard
05:15:13 tonight from Andrew Shearer, a real support for independent media. We've heard talk from
05:15:18 a number of the candidates about the importance of independent media and i guess no matter what
05:15:23 happens to you do you think there's a hope that the conservatives can really turn a page and and
05:15:27 start pushing back a bit against the mainstream media after tonight i i hope so i mean i hope
05:15:33 like i i think and i i've shared this i think with both of you you know just in personal
05:15:37 conversations like i think there's a whole new media landscape forming in canada and i think
05:15:41 it's a good thing i think more competition and more ideas uh and people being able to kind of
05:15:46 have access to different platforms that want to you know provide conservative ideals and also I
05:15:53 think on the left like you know with press progress and others I think there's room for all of this
05:15:58 out there and that we shouldn't be boxed in to sort of kind of what's been the more traditional
05:16:02 media and so I think you know I'm working with Dr. Lewis I mean I know she's very much into
05:16:07 both you know free speech and debate and I do think that we need to be more comfortable just
05:16:13 when people sort of, you know, try to put us on our heels on these things and say, no, like
05:16:17 conservative principles are solid. They're, they're sensible and they make sense. And yeah,
05:16:22 let's have this discussion about it instead of just seeing someone being able to just, uh, you
05:16:26 know, point at you and call you a name and everyone kind of back away in fear that you're going to get
05:16:33 called another mean name. It's like, so yeah, I hope that that's sort of where we're getting to
05:16:37 this place. I think, I think some of that movement in particular on the left, um, it's starting to
05:16:43 go too far. And even people who might even naturally sympathize towards, you know, kind of
05:16:48 leftist views, even, you know, some of my friends who are on the far more left side of the spectrum
05:16:54 are starting to really kind of question it and say, whoa, you know, where does this make sense?
05:17:00 So I think that they're probably kind of overshooting and it's starting to kind of create
05:17:04 a, I think there's a bit more of an appetiting candidate to just respectfully push back on some
05:17:09 these things well there certainly is a credibility issue uh you know i have critiques of the cbc that
05:17:15 go at so many different levels it's not just about their editorial position being left-wing i mean
05:17:19 one of the stories that we broke at true north last week was the fact that kamala harris who's
05:17:24 running to be the second place you know the deputy the vice president uh for a party in another
05:17:29 country got 500 more headlines than leslie lewis did who's running to essentially be prime minister
05:17:36 in canada and so it's such a disconnect that you see it so much where the cbc is supposed to be
05:17:40 covering canadian news and telling canadian stories but instead you know they're they're
05:17:45 obsessing over what's happening in the united states or tonight we're told that they're playing
05:17:50 uh hockey games instead of covering the conservative convention here so it's it's like
05:17:55 you know they're not even doing what their mandate is is to do steve we really appreciate your time
05:18:01 and thank you for joining us i don't know if andrew asked you this uh before in your interview
05:18:05 i can't remember but i'll just ask you quickly do you have any predictions for the rest of the
05:18:08 night or how do you think this is all going to play out no i have zero predictions i i uh anything
05:18:14 i felt i knew at the beginning of the day as we've gone on and played this waiting game i
05:18:18 i have no confidence in anything no i just think he hasn't changed his non-prediction from earlier
05:18:26 fair enough fair enough well thank you so much steven hopefully uh hopefully eventually this uh
05:18:30 we learned some news and we can all get to bed at something like a reasonable
05:18:34 hour. So thanks so much for joining us. Great.
05:18:36 Thanks to you both for the job you're doing. Take care.
05:18:39 Thank you. That was Steve Outhouse, campaign manager for Leslyn Lewis.
05:18:42 And since we're revisiting the highlights from earlier in the show, some,
05:18:46 I don't know, seven hours ago or so,
05:18:48 very pleased to welcome back Tanya Granik-Allen,
05:18:51 who's moved indoors now because that beautiful natural light you had earlier
05:18:54 is no longer there. We are past 10 PM now,
05:18:58 still awaiting results from the Conservative leadership race.
05:19:02 Tanya Granik-Allen, not officially on Derek Sloan's team,
05:19:05 but as I mentioned earlier, did her due diligence,
05:19:07 interviewed, vetted the candidates, and ended up endorsing Derek
05:19:10 and was doing some get-out-the-vote stuff with him in the past week.
05:19:14 Tanya, thanks for coming back on.
05:19:17 I'm sorry I have to be back on.
05:19:18 We should be in bed by now.
05:19:20 Oh, we're having some trouble with your audio there, Tanya,
05:19:23 so we'll try to get that resolved.
05:19:25 Hopefully we could hear you only very faintly.
05:19:28 So I don't know if the issue is that you're muted
05:19:30 or the microphone isn't fully connected,
05:19:32 but we'll try to get you back on there.
05:19:36 I hear it clicking, so that could be a good sign.
05:19:39 No, unfortunately not.
05:19:42 We'll try to get that resolved there.
05:19:43 The reason I think it's important to talk
05:19:46 to the Derek Sloan campaign
05:19:49 and Tonya Granik-Allen from that campaign specifically here
05:19:52 is because one of the dominating themes
05:19:55 of certainly my coverage
05:19:57 and a lot of the coverage
05:19:58 when you look at the system of voting
05:20:00 is the down ballot support.
05:20:02 So if Aaron O'Toole is running
05:20:04 as being the most sympathetic
05:20:06 to social conservatives,
05:20:08 then that means that when you have two people
05:20:10 that are running on a socially conservative platform
05:20:12 in Leslyn Lewis and Derek Sloan,
05:20:14 if they do really well,
05:20:16 they bring in a lot of new members.
05:20:17 That support is more likely to go to Aaron O'Toole
05:20:20 than Peter McKay.
05:20:22 And this is how we get that scenario that a lot of people have theorized about, that
05:20:26 Peter McKay could be in first place on round one and even round two.
05:20:31 But, you know, if a lot of that support from other candidates goes towards Aaron O'Toole,
05:20:36 Aaron O'Toole is the winner.
05:20:37 Or if it works in other ways as well, I don't want to predestine the final outcome here.
05:20:43 But I guess I'll ask you, Candace, while we're waiting and troubleshooting with Tanya there,
05:20:47 do you think that the social conservative vote will be the determining factor in that race or
05:20:54 do you think it's too simplistic in some respects? Well I don't know if it will be the determining
05:20:59 factor Andrew but it certainly does have a big impact and we saw that back when Andrew Scheer
05:21:04 was elected I think we mentioned it on the show a little earlier that Maxime Bernier had the you
05:21:10 know number one slot throughout the whole every ballot he was he was number one he was number one
05:21:14 number one and i think that ultimately a lot of the votes went to andrew sheer mostly you know
05:21:19 partially because he's a nice guy and he's not objectionable he doesn't like you know he's kind
05:21:23 of a middle of the road kind of person um but but of course you know he he did come across and many
05:21:28 many people did perceive him as being um pro-life and and more of a social conservative so that
05:21:34 certainly helped him and i think that that could have an impact but you know thinking back to what
05:21:39 Vitor Marciano said earlier he's the only one who really gave us a very detailed prediction of what
05:21:45 he thought and you know his idea was basically that Peter McKay is going to come in first on the
05:21:50 first ballot but that he won't get any of the lower ballots so he won't get any support from
05:21:57 Derek Sloan and Lesley Lewis which is a presumption on that they will come in fourth and
05:22:01 third and therefore that would all go towards Erin O'Toole and give him enough momentum to
05:22:07 bump forward and i think that that would definitely be based on peter mckay's positions
05:22:11 not just on social issues but a number of the stuff that we've been talking about throughout
05:22:15 the whole program andrew his his lack of ability to connect with the base his sort of fear of of
05:22:21 coming and doing interviews with conservative media outlets um his lack of appeal and lack of
05:22:27 energy especially in western canada and this perception that he is sort of part of the um
05:22:33 laurentian elite establishment and that he's not really among the the grassroots conservatives so
05:22:39 i think all those uh things would would go against him again that's just based on on vitor's
05:22:44 prediction and vitor could be completely wrong um but i do think that there is something to that
05:22:49 theory and that kind of does seem like the way that we are the direction we're headed right now
05:22:53 yeah and there's a tweet from elias here he says social conservative feels like a bad word in
05:22:58 Canada. It could be why we once had the PC party at the federal level. I do think a lot of that
05:23:03 perception comes down to when there are candidates who have socially conservative views, they tend to
05:23:09 equivocate about them and not own up to them. So they get hammered on the media for being socially
05:23:14 conservative and they get hammered by social conservatives for not being socially conservative.
05:23:19 And this was one of the prevailing criticisms against Andrew Scheer is that people who were
05:23:23 pro-life were saying, hey, you're selling us out. And people who weren't, didn't like him that
05:23:27 because he was pro-life. So this is the, I think, I think in many respects, the, if you feel that
05:23:33 way, own up to it and hope that your authenticity will carry you. I think we have Tanya Granik-Allen
05:23:40 back on. Let's see if we can fix that. Tanya, can you hear us? I can hear you. Can you hear me? 1.00
05:23:45 We can hear you as well. Thank you very much for coming in. You're a little bit quiet. So if you
05:23:50 could speak up, it would be very much appreciated. I mentioned earlier that you did a pretty
05:23:55 extensive vetting of the candidates and i i want to note for people this isn't you as a campaign
05:24:01 manager this is you as an advocate as an activist why did you do this and and what was your vetting
05:24:07 process like well i suppose because i ran in the 2018 ontario conservative leadership that
05:24:14 you know i guess i established myself as a voice of conservatives in canada and i feel i guess an
05:24:20 obligation or a responsibility to that effect and you know different candidates call me at all times
05:24:25 asking for my support or endorsement and you know three out of the four leadership candidates reached
05:24:30 out to me and i thought it's important to ask them you know what i like to call the tough questions
05:24:34 on issues that i think are important for canadians yes fiscal issues yes energy issues but also
05:24:41 things that affect the family that sometimes gets swept under the rug or as some people will relegate
05:24:45 as social issues and they're not as important but in fact they really are important to canadian
05:24:49 families.
05:24:50 Tonya, one of the things that always sort of bugs me is that, you know, the word social
05:24:56 conservative, like Andrew just said, kind of gets considered to be a bad word.
05:24:59 But, you know, really what we're talking about is just policies that put the family at the
05:25:04 center of public life.
05:25:05 You know, I spent a bunch of time in the U.S., and it seems like the issues that define Canadian
05:25:10 conservatives as being social conservatives, they're just kind of like mainstream conservative
05:25:14 values in the U.S.
05:25:16 So why do you think that these ideas have become considered like so toxic in Canada
05:25:22 when really they're not and so many Canadians agree with the issues, but why do you think
05:25:27 that the concept around them has become so negative?
05:25:31 Well, I don't think that they should be considered toxic and I don't think actually, although
05:25:36 I don't necessarily like that moniker, social conservatives, I don't think it should be
05:25:40 received with toxicity.
05:25:42 I sometimes think that we do that to ourselves and when I say we I mean conservatives that we
05:25:48 relegate social conservatives or that phrase social issues to the side and say oh those are
05:25:52 not as important they are second tier issues let's not talk about them but when we start a
05:25:58 censoring and applying our own filter on issues that grassroots conservatives feel are important
05:26:03 then I think we're doing a disservice to the movement I think rather we should embrace all
05:26:08 these issues and say, hey, you know what? Clearly this is impacting Canadian lives. These are issues
05:26:14 which matter. If you look at the past several leaderships, the 2017 federal conservative
05:26:19 leadership, look at the 2018 provincial Ontario leadership, even look at the Jason Kenney leadership,
05:26:24 it's very clear that time and time again, it is these, again, quote unquote, social conservative
05:26:29 voters who determine the leader and the outcome of these leaderships. So I don't think it's
05:26:36 appropriate to relegate a big chunk of the base and some people suggest it's
05:26:40 up to 40% of the Conservative Party federally their base to the sidelines
05:26:44 and rather we should embrace these issues say hey clearly these matter to
05:26:47 the grassroots they must matter to Canadians
05:26:53 oh Andrew I think you're muted here but I think thank you I went the whole night
05:26:57 without doing this and then I ended up doing the thing that we expected we'd
05:27:01 have to tell the guests to not do sorry about that you know I think it's an
05:27:04 important point when you talk about the grassroots because oftentimes there is
05:27:07 this huge divide Tanya between what the grassroots members and grassroots
05:27:12 Canadians feel and also what the members are told are acceptable positions by the
05:27:21 media by the party elite other other stuff like that so so I do think this is
05:27:26 an important aspect I guess the question is how do we break through that how do
05:27:30 do we as grassroots or how do we I mean how do we as you know free-thinking people break through
05:27:36 that divide when you have a portion of the party of the country of the movement that's being told
05:27:42 their views don't deserve to be entertained well anytime someone has told me that my view doesn't
05:27:47 deserve to be entertained I usually double down so what I would encourage grassroots members of
05:27:52 the party to do is if there's an issue that's important to you be it pipelines in Alberta or
05:27:56 social issues double down and get out and raise those issues at policy conventions and in nominations
05:28:03 I think it's important again that we elect candidates or leaders that respect the
05:28:08 grassroots and reflect the positions that we elect them to have which is through our policy process
05:28:15 and it's important that our leaders of our party respect the policy process and adopt those
05:28:21 policies as their own because that's what party leadership is about it's about respecting the
05:28:25 grassroots and listening to their will and advocating for them and i think the sooner that
05:28:30 we stop apologizing for being conservative for uh you know stop this this weakness and just embrace
05:28:37 our values and embrace the conservative freedoms then we will be miles ahead of the opposition
05:28:44 that's a good point we've been talking about this a little bit on the show too this sort of
05:28:48 what seems like a gaping divide an increasing divide in all of our society but it's also
05:28:53 evident within the Conservative Party between the sort of elites or the experts or the establishment
05:28:59 and then on the other side you kind of have everyone else and you know you see the rise of
05:29:02 populism but also just sort of grassroots surge. So I'm curious just in the context of this specific
05:29:10 leadership race, Sonia, have you felt like grassroots voices were included? Were you happy
05:29:17 with the way that the candidates discussed issues? I know you know you ended up supporting and
05:29:22 endorsing uh derek sloan do you think he was given a fair shake and what's your take on this sort of
05:29:27 divide between the sort of establishment elites and and everyone else well i'm perhaps i'm a huge
05:29:34 softy at heart but i believe maybe in a utopian idea of of what a leadership should be but i
05:29:40 believe truly that every candidate should have had the opportunity to run and you know richard
05:29:45 de cutty was was denied running obviously jim carahalios had that happen it was twice uh
05:29:50 prevented from running and and and some encountered financial barriers to entering into the leadership
05:29:56 race like rudy husney and marilyn gladu i think the more the merrier that's what a big tent is about
05:30:02 so i do think that the addition of all of those voices would have uh improved the race i i think
05:30:09 it was a fine field the way it is obviously there's a candidate that i felt strongly enough
05:30:13 to endorse that i felt his positions were excellent i did not like it when there were
05:30:18 the rumblings that perhaps caucus was considering derek sloan's uh participation within their
05:30:24 caucus again we're conservatives we we love our grassroots democracy we want our members to
05:30:30 to make those so i think there's always room for improvement was this process perfect no
05:30:36 was the room for improvement absolutely and i hope that there will always be lessons learned but
05:30:41 again you know i think we're gonna have to wait to see what the outcome is of this of this leadership
05:30:46 and see who the leader is and how well they're going to be able to unite all people within the
05:30:51 party including those who were not able to have their preferred candidate even put on appearing
05:30:56 on the ballot very well said tanya granick allen former ontario pc leadership candidate the
05:31:04 president of parents as first educators and supporter of derek sloan in this race tanya
05:31:09 thanks so much for coming back on really appreciate it thank you and hopefully we'll be over soon
05:31:14 enough yes we can only hope and and on that note i should share with those of you who are tuning
05:31:19 into the live conservative results show here on true north at the party is now saying first round
05:31:26 results will come in at 10 30 p.m eastern time which is particularly significant because it's
05:31:32 now 10 31 eastern time and uh so far the uh the conservative party of canada's official feed is
05:31:39 still the starting soon so we'll uh continue along with our coverage and analysis bringing
05:31:43 in some of the people from the conservative movement and also the Conservative Party of
05:31:48 Canada Leadership race. And I can bring in, I believe, Fred DeLore. I don't know if we have
05:31:53 Fred on the line. I see a headshot. I don't know if we can get him on video there. But Fred DeLore,
05:31:58 we spoke to earlier in the show. He is the campaign manager for Aaron O'Toole. And we
05:32:03 chatted with him this afternoon when we thought we were doing just a little 30-minute pre-show.
05:32:07 and now here we are several hours into this five hours since we started Fred good to have you thanks
05:32:14 very much oh we've got a black screen for Fred all right we'll we'll get to Fred once oh there
05:32:21 we go Fred thanks very much for coming back on I know it's been a long day turned into a long night
05:32:27 so it's good to have you with us right now well I'm used to these long nights remember 2018 I
05:32:33 campaign manager when we were very delayed in that process as well. So becoming used to this.
05:32:40 We spoke about this earlier in the evening with Steve Outhouse from the Leslyn Lewis campaign.
05:32:44 Obviously, we've had different rumors that have been circulating about which candidates are up
05:32:50 and which candidates down. And the question I'll put to you, are these just rumors or is there
05:32:55 actually information that's coming out of the ballot room from scrutineers or from other sources?
05:33:03 Oh, we've lost Fred there. So we'll get Fred back on the line. And if you are still standing with
05:33:10 us, we managed to make it through the first four and a half hours without any tech glitches. So
05:33:14 I hope you'll indulge these in the last few moments here. A lot of moving parts to the
05:33:20 coverage tonight. I will ask you, Candice, I mean, do you find that because in politics,
05:33:24 there seems to be the two major currencies, money and rumours. So do you find that just people in
05:33:30 politics need to believe in a rumor just to be doing something because that's the fear here when
05:33:35 you start talking about all these different scenarios and they may or may not be rooted
05:33:39 in reality but we have to to fill our headspace in the absence of official numbers with something
05:33:44 yeah there might be a little bit of like confirmation bias as well because if you if
05:33:49 you are someone who you know wants less than lewis to do really well and wants to see a strong showing
05:33:54 for her, then you're definitely more likely to believe the rumors that, you know, she's doing
05:34:00 much better than expected. But I think to Steve Outhouse's point, you know, no one's left the room
05:34:05 since noon today. So anything that we are hearing can't necessarily be true, although who knows,
05:34:11 because there are always are leaks, as we know from our profession in the media. But certainly,
05:34:17 you know, this kind of program where you have pundits and journalists filling up hours and
05:34:22 hours of air time on election night it's just pure speculation you know the
05:34:27 morning comes and you wish that you could take back all the things that you
05:34:30 predicted because they never they never come true I've certainly made predictions
05:34:33 I thought that Stephen Harper was gonna win in the 2015 election I didn't think
05:34:37 Justin Trudeau stood a chance and then boy was I wrong I remember watching the
05:34:41 2016 results come in it down in the US I was actually in San Francisco at the
05:34:47 time and you know i definitely no one was expecting donald trump to win uh so we we've been wrong
05:34:54 many many many times and uh that's why i'm avoiding making any any predictions tonight but certainly
05:35:00 rumors are are part of uh you know what what keeps what keeps pundits and journalists uh busy on
05:35:07 nights like this is just talking about things that they hear and speculating into that andrew
05:35:11 so it looks like we had or have fred back on if the video is not working well i will talk to you
05:35:18 by audio fred because i am curious to hear if you're okay no apparently we're having a bit of
05:35:23 an internet issue there so we'll uh uh we'll deal with that uh and get fred back on when we can so
05:35:28 we we thank you very much for for sticking with us it is live this is what live media is all about
05:35:34 and this is what independent media is all about and i i do think it would be uh incumbent upon
05:35:39 us right now, and I'll actually hand over to Candice for this, to tell people how they
05:35:44 can support us because I've seen a few messages come in of people that are fans of True North
05:35:49 that like what we're doing and also people that came because they heard from Andrew Scheer
05:35:53 about True North. Well, gee, that's really nice. And to anyone who's watching, for the
05:35:58 first time, welcome. Just to tell you a little bit about True North. I started the organization
05:36:03 back in 2016. I write for the Toronto Sun. I'm a columnist over there and I've been doing that
05:36:09 for a while. And initially when I started True North, the idea was that we're going to do
05:36:14 research and look into the immigration issue, national security, immigration, terrorism,
05:36:19 an issue that's really, really under explored and discussed in Canada, but increasingly
05:36:24 important. One of the things that we found, you know, we're entirely grassroots driven,
05:36:29 and meaning that our income comes entirely
05:36:32 just from supporters like you Canadians
05:36:35 who watch our programming, enjoy what we do,
05:36:38 appreciate what we contribute to the media landscape.
05:36:42 You know, they encourage us to do more and more
05:36:44 of the journalism side, more investigative journalism,
05:36:46 more reporting, more digging.
05:36:48 We brought on Andrew Lawton,
05:36:49 who's a very well-known conservative commentator
05:36:52 and longtime radio host from London, Ontario.
05:36:56 And since then we've sort of pivoted more and more
05:36:58 towards journalism more and more towards original reporting.
05:37:01 I think that's where the demand is.
05:37:03 And so here we are now as a full-fledged media company.
05:37:08 We employ journalists across the country.
05:37:10 We give you scoops, breaking news.
05:37:12 We have podcasts and videos that come out every day.
05:37:15 Andrew and I do a live show every Friday afternoon.
05:37:19 Andrew also does his own podcast radio show
05:37:22 on Mondays and Wednesdays.
05:37:24 We produce a lot of contents.
05:37:25 We produce documentaries.
05:37:27 we're really busy and we do a lot of great stuff.
05:37:30 And so again, we're funded entirely through donations.
05:37:35 And I think that's really the new business model for media.
05:37:38 Traditionally, media always relied on advertising
05:37:42 that made the media landscape kind of more neutral
05:37:45 and more boring.
05:37:47 Canadian media is very traditional, it's very boring.
05:37:49 Everyone has the same opinions.
05:37:51 And the idea when you're backed by advertisers
05:37:54 is you can't upset anyone.
05:37:56 So you have to remain kind of in the middle
05:37:58 and you can't really have too many people outside.
05:38:02 I think that model is gone.
05:38:03 And what you're seeing now is more of a niche media
05:38:07 driven towards people who want to see stories
05:38:10 that sort of reflect their experience,
05:38:12 want to hear from voices that reflect
05:38:14 what their worldview is.
05:38:15 And so we try to offer something
05:38:17 that's just totally different from the mainstream media.
05:38:19 We're much more connected
05:38:21 to the small C conservative base in Canada.
05:38:25 That's sort of the worldview that many of us present.
05:38:27 We're non-partisan.
05:38:28 We're not at all affiliated with the Conservative Party.
05:38:31 In fact, we do interviews all the time
05:38:34 with other politicians.
05:38:35 I sat down with Maxime Bernier a couple of weeks ago.
05:38:38 Andrew, you had Salim Mansour, you've spoken with him
05:38:42 and did a profile of him during the last election.
05:38:45 We reach out to politicians of all stripes.
05:38:47 Andrew tried and failed many times to get interviews
05:38:51 with Liberal campaigns and MPs during the last campaign.
05:38:56 All that's just to say,
05:38:58 you know, we try to provide something different
05:39:00 and where our finances come from
05:39:04 and how we fund our entire operation
05:39:06 is just from the support of Canadians
05:39:08 who appreciate what we do.
05:39:09 So, you know, if you're new, welcome.
05:39:11 We invite you to check out our programming.
05:39:14 TNC.news is our website.
05:39:15 We have lots of new content all the time.
05:39:18 And if you're so inclined
05:39:18 and you appreciate what we're doing,
05:39:20 really do encourage you to chip in even if you're just donating something really small five ten
05:39:26 dollars that's really what drives our organization and helps us to you know hire young reporters
05:39:32 hire journalists create all this content you know we have producers we have videographers
05:39:38 um you know we try to keep our budget down obviously we're not the cbc we're not spending
05:39:42 money uh left right and center we're really a startup mentality and we and we we keep things
05:39:48 tight um but you know the the fact that we have donors from all over the country we have hundreds
05:39:54 or i think thousands of canadians that give us money every month uh it really shows that you know
05:40:00 what we're doing is good we listen to the feedback from our audience we listen to uh what people say
05:40:05 we read every email that comes in we try to respond we don't always respond to every email
05:40:10 and every message but we read them all and we sort of provide the content that canadians want
05:40:15 So I think we're much more connected with our audience and with our base
05:40:19 than the mainstream media is why they're so out of touch.
05:40:22 So, you know, it was great to have that shout out from Andrew Scheer.
05:40:26 We did an interview earlier with Vitor Marciano and he he sort of said, you know,
05:40:30 I think that probably a lot of conservative activists know about True North and know who you guys are.
05:40:36 But of the party membership and of the people who are members of the Conservative Party,
05:40:40 which is hundreds of thousands of Canadians, he said probably only about a third
05:40:43 actually knew about true north and knew who we were so you know we've got our work cut out for
05:40:48 us still andrew we've got a lot to a room to grow and a lot more work to do to try to reach our
05:40:53 audience our audience isn't just conservative members as well we i get emails every day from
05:40:58 people who who say you know i disagree with you about politics candace but i appreciate the
05:41:03 reporting that you do or i appreciate you know the way that you stand up for yourself and the way
05:41:07 that you stand up for the organization or the way that you expose the mainstream media so again we're
05:41:13 just limited to people who share our exact same worldview and we don't even all share the same
05:41:18 worldview we disagree on issues uh amongst you know the fellows all the time but um that's just
05:41:23 you know part of the media landscape so all that's just to say you know we're really excited about
05:41:27 the work that we're doing at true north we invite you uh to to take part to to watch to donate if
05:41:32 you can to join our insider club which gives you all kinds of different content um and ability to
05:41:38 to connect with us uh you know we we do uh what kind of content do we offer andrew for insiders
05:41:44 we've got we've got some sort of we we used to try to do live events but can't really do that
05:41:49 anymore well we plan to do live events at some point in the future i i know we've also talked
05:41:55 about really revamping the clubs and trying to build a community there and have opportunities to
05:42:00 you know kick back with with you and i and and talk on on zoom and that's stuff we've uh we've
05:42:05 wanted to put into effect. And I think after the conservative leadership race, we'll be rolling
05:42:10 potentially into an election mode. So there will be a lot of opportunities for, you know, bonus
05:42:14 content, I think, along the way. But, you know, the one thing that I would really say that is
05:42:19 important is that the people that support the work that we're doing, it's they're doing it because
05:42:24 we don't paywall our content, which I think is really great for people. They're doing it not
05:42:29 because they want to buy access to this story or that story, but simply because they like it and
05:42:33 want to keep it open and accessible and I really like that that's a big part of our vision I mean
05:42:37 I know of outlets that and I don't begrudge anyone for coming up with their own business model but
05:42:41 I've been outlets that have all this great content and it's it's not accessible to people unless they
05:42:46 pay whereas I love that you know my show's out there and your show's out there and all our
05:42:50 stories are out there I think that's so important because we're not trying to to speak just to an
05:42:55 echo chamber we're trying to speak to Canadians speak to Canadians but also I think again just
05:43:01 try to provide something different i think that the issue with the mainstream media we're talking
05:43:06 about this a little bit earlier when we're interviewing steve outhouse with leslie lewis
05:43:09 campaign you know it's not just a problem that the mainstream media is too left-wing there's
05:43:15 just there's so many there's so many issues about them the way that they're funded um the way that
05:43:19 they that they produce the news the way they're not transparent about their own biases like
05:43:25 we're supposed to believe that they're just completely neutral uh you know people whereas
05:43:30 you know, we know they don't vote conservative. We know that they probably don't have any
05:43:33 conservative friends. And if they do, you know, they're resentful because they came from a
05:43:36 conservative family and don't like them. We know all these things about journalists and they're
05:43:41 not open about it themselves. They pretend to stand up there and be neutral and pretend that
05:43:45 they didn't all vote for Justin Trudeau or Jagmeet Singh. Well, we know that's not the case. And
05:43:51 again, with the CBC, part of the main problem with them is that they are supposed to be there
05:43:56 to cover canadian stories and to reflect the canadian experience uh but we know we turn on
05:44:01 the national and half the time the top two three stories are all about donald trump and joe biden
05:44:06 and and us stories it's like well why are we paying our taxpayer dollars to hear more and
05:44:12 more fawning over kamala harris when they're completely ignoring the phenomenon that is
05:44:17 leslie lewis is happening in their own backyard um and so part of what true north tries to do is
05:44:23 just be different than that we we stand up to the cancel culture mindset uh we stand up to the the
05:44:28 idea that you know every story has to come back towards like oh look at how evil Donald Trump is
05:44:34 it's like no there's a whole bunch of Canadians out there that have a different perspective
05:44:38 we're unapologetic about the fact that we do have a small c conservative outlook at least I do um and
05:44:44 Andrew I think you do too and so we try to provide the news from that perspective more honest about
05:44:51 it i don't try to lie and pretend that i'm completely neutral and apolitical say you
05:44:56 know i don't have a membership in the conservative party um but i am a small c conservative and i
05:45:01 brought the support what the conservatives are doing and at least we're transparent about that
05:45:06 yeah i think that that's very important and we'll pick back this uh conversation up on the other
05:45:10 end of this i believe we do have uh once and for all fred delori joining us uh by phone we don't
05:45:15 get to see his his uh smiling face after hours and hours in a ballroom but we will talk to fred
05:45:21 about uh where things stand now fred thanks for your patience on this maybe i spoke too soon
05:45:32 oh there we go yeah sorry can you hear me now yes we have you at long last right
05:45:38 thanks very much for sticking with us here so let me ask you uh without having any information
05:45:44 coming out of the room here, has the confidence that you expressed earlier changed one way or
05:45:49 another? Because you said unequivocally, you're thinking a third ballot victory for Aaron O'Toole.
05:45:54 Is that still the direction that you're headed? Yeah, nothing's changed. So we were exit polling
05:46:00 throughout this campaign. We did a tremendous amount of polling and research, something that's
05:46:04 never really been done before in a leadership race from my experience or my knowledge. We really put
05:46:09 a lot of effort on that in this campaign, and we could really sense where the membership was going
05:46:12 and who they were supporting uh and uh you know i'm very confident in our numbers that we're going
05:46:19 to be first place in the first ballot and we'll lead all the way through and aaron will become
05:46:23 leader of our party tonight well that that's a bold prediction and so one of the things we heard
05:46:32 from one of the other can uh campaigns fred is that uh you know it's not really possible to know
05:46:38 at this point who's winning because everyone's been uh stuck and locked away so so you know are
05:46:43 the leaks that we're hearing and the rumors online is is there anything to that or is that sort of
05:46:47 just speculation no what's going on inside it's it's pure speculation what what we're basing our
05:46:53 our predictions on or my my bold prediction as you say is our exit polling right so every day
05:46:58 the conservative party would give us a list who has voted yesterday so we can knock it off
05:47:02 our lists for get out to vote purposes so what we've done is we pulled that list every day for
05:47:07 for the last 20 plus days.
05:47:09 And that's where our numbers come from.
05:47:11 We don't have a real insight of what we were hearing
05:47:14 dribs and drabs, you get a bit of information
05:47:16 what's going on inside the room,
05:47:17 but nothing's been counted yet or it's about,
05:47:20 or it's being counted as we speak right now,
05:47:22 it's being put through the machines.
05:47:25 So we don't know the actual result,
05:47:26 but we're, again, our exit polling,
05:47:29 we have over 51,000 members of the Conservative Party
05:47:32 tell us who they voted for.
05:47:34 um so we we have a we have a good sense from that when you say 51 000 that is uh you know
05:47:41 basically out of i think 172 000 ballots cast you've got a little over a third of the entire
05:47:49 uh sample then that's right that's right so usually when you pull a riding if you're trying
05:47:53 to get a sense you want one to three percent we are around 30 percent uh so it's a massive massive
05:47:59 sample and that's where a lot of our confidence is based in um and uh so you know we we feel very
05:48:04 good uh of course you never know we're we're sitting here we're waiting like everyone else
05:48:10 uh we'll see what the results are but we we do feel we're in a good spot
05:48:15 well that's great so what do you think it was fred uh that that if if if you're polling is
05:48:20 accurate and you think you're confident that your candidates can win tonight what what was it uh
05:48:25 tell us a little bit about the campaign that you ran and what you felt like your candidates
05:48:28 real strengths were well look aaron's a tremendous communicator he was able to talk to our membership
05:48:35 it was interesting one thing we noticed um when the the main party debates that we had the english
05:48:41 and french one uh which feels like a lifetime ago uh when those debates happened all the media and
05:48:46 all the pundits said peter mckay won and i watched those and i felt okay shoot everyone's saying he
05:48:52 He won. That wasn't good for us. But then we saw a spike in our polling, because we've been pulling
05:48:56 not just exit polling. We've been pulling our membership list every week, constantly, aggressively.
05:49:00 So we saw a spike in our polling. So I actually went back and watched the French debate in
05:49:04 particular. And I noticed Aaron was the only one actually speaking to our members. Peter was
05:49:10 speaking to media. He was speaking to pundits. He wasn't speaking to Conservative Party members
05:49:16 in his tone and his direction Aaron was and I think though you know people said Peter won the
05:49:23 debates I think we'll see it was actually Aaron who won those debates that I think is an interesting
05:49:32 dynamic because I know that oftentimes you get candidates in campaigns that think there's a lot
05:49:37 of emphasis on the debates and the advertising and stuff like that and you have other campaigns
05:49:43 that are in the school of thought of it's just, you know, simply a membership drive and a voter
05:49:47 drive. With the high numbers in this race for how many ballots cast, as I said earlier, over 170,000,
05:49:54 do you think that the high turnout is an overall reflection of engagement? Or do you think that's
05:49:59 really coming down to specific campaigns that brought in members for that campaign rather than
05:50:05 people that just joined up on the party and said, you know, I think this is a good race to get
05:50:09 involved in i'm going to join and listen and then cast a ballot for someone eventually
05:50:13 so based on our tracking and based what we can uh you know gather from the other campaigns and
05:50:18 our conversations with them the biggest when the membership sale period was going on the number one
05:50:23 you know there's four campaigns selling memberships it was the conservative party of canada who crushed
05:50:29 us all in membership sales just people generally getting involved in the party and buying a
05:50:33 membership and taking an interest i know other campaigns about spinning that they sold an insane
05:50:38 amount. It wasn't them. It was the party who sold on its own organically a tremendous amount.
05:50:45 I got to say, we crushed records this summer, fundraising records, donor records,
05:50:50 membership sales, and voters. No political party in the history of this country has had more people
05:50:56 vote in a leadership race than what we have seen this conservative party race. We're doing it in
05:51:02 the middle of a pandemic in the middle of summer. I think it's very real. I think our party is
05:51:07 incredibly strong and i do believe uh the next the leader of our party is going to be prime minister
05:51:13 and will be prime minister soon well i think that's definitely fred a reflection of the times
05:51:18 that we're living in i mean just look at what's going on in ottawa over the last few weeks just a
05:51:22 total storm of calamity for the trudeau liberals and just learning the extent to which not only
05:51:30 the ethical scandals with regards to we but just how much money they're handing out left right and
05:51:34 center you know their own bureaucrats are saying they use loosey-goosey logic and meh it's just
05:51:39 money no problem winky face like just seeing the extent of of chaos in in ottawa uh i'm sure
05:51:46 motivated a lot of people uh who might be on the conservative spectrum to to join and get a
05:51:51 membership to to get a new uh leader i just i want to hear your thoughts on what you think about the
05:51:58 idea of a general election do you think that's something that is coming down soon uh do you care
05:52:03 to speculate on what might happen after the throne speech in september look i i believe uh trudeau is
05:52:10 going to um take every opportunity he can to seize more power he's going to look at this
05:52:17 and he's going to come in with some kind of speech on the throne and budget with
05:52:22 measures that he think will get him re-elected i i think trudeau is going to try to orchestrate his
05:52:27 own defeat or call an election himself i think that's very real that's very possible so we as
05:52:32 conservatives need to prepare for that regardless of who wins this leadership race we all need to
05:52:36 get behind that person and start preparing for that for for that potential scenario i know one
05:52:43 of the the big i'll say talking points and i don't mean it in a negative or judgmental way but it was
05:52:47 in fact deployed by the campaign and by erin o'toole is that erin o'toole was ready to hit the ground
05:52:53 running with a seat in parliament if he's successful what does the role of official
05:52:58 opposition leader look like for Aaron O'Toole if he is successful tonight, given that Parliament
05:53:03 has been prorogued? What's the priority for him if he's successful starting tomorrow over the next
05:53:08 month? Well, we need to build our campaign team. We need to build the party. We need to build the
05:53:13 leader's office. There's so much work that needs to be done. And if Aaron wins, and I do believe
05:53:17 he will, we go to work tomorrow morning. There's no day off. There's no time. There's no vacation.
05:53:22 We go to work tomorrow. I've been working eight days, or sorry, eight months straight on this,
05:53:27 seven days a week i took yesterday off because the polls closed friday night uh and uh we've been uh
05:53:33 you know this was our break and we go right back to work uh we you know taking a leadership of a
05:53:38 political party is a responsibility uh to our country and we have a lot of work to do and we
05:53:43 we need to take it serious and we're going to go right at it well one of the questions that i had
05:53:48 for fred was uh we heard earlier lisa wright talk about how usually you know campaigns are hard
05:53:54 fought usually you're fighting them against ideological opponents when it comes to leadership
05:53:58 race you're fighting against fellow conservatives and usually a convention is a time where everyone
05:54:02 can come together and feel united and and and reminded of of how we're all sort of you know
05:54:08 in it for the same thing and and that ultimately you're all on the same team but because this year
05:54:14 it's all done digitally that that might not happen and that bridging those divides might be tough
05:54:20 I know it has been a pretty vicious campaign at times, particularly between your campaign and
05:54:26 Peter McKay. So I wonder if you could speak a little bit about how that divide has happened
05:54:32 and what you think the path forward for unity of this party is. Well, look, I mean, political
05:54:39 campaigns or leadership campaigns are the political equivalent of a civil war. It's friend versus
05:54:43 friend, brother versus sister. I have very close friends on the McKay campaign that I have not
05:54:50 spoken to in many many months um you know we are you know we're fighting for what we believe in we
05:54:55 go full tilt at the end of the day after tonight four leadership campaigns become one we unite we
05:55:01 we join together and uh it you know it takes time we'll have to sit down over the next few weeks
05:55:08 but look when we win this campaign uh this leadership race we we will absolutely reach
05:55:13 out to the other camps we want the best and the brightest we owe that to canada that's our
05:55:16 our responsibility we're not just it's not just about it's our team takes over it's we unite and
05:55:21 make a new team of all of us together to take on uh the true to liberals and that's how we're going
05:55:26 to win the next election we we can't be we can't divide ourselves we can't act like it's you know
05:55:31 it's just us who won it's uh we all have to come together one question i want to put with you put
05:55:38 to you just before we uh we let you go here uh fred uh this is from a tweet from steve pakin he
05:55:43 He says that an Aaron O'Toole campaign official is saying that the Peter McKay campaign is challenging virtually every single outstanding ballot, which is significantly adding to the delay.
05:55:55 He followed up with a tweet that says the Peter McKay campaign says they're not protesting.
05:55:59 What's going on in there?
05:56:01 Look, I don't have insight.
05:56:02 This is the first I've heard of this.
05:56:04 I know the McKay campaign has very good scrutineers who are doing their job.
05:56:09 So I don't call and question what they're doing.
05:56:11 they're uh at this point without any information but if they're uh you know if they're concerned
05:56:16 about a ballot they're gonna they're gonna fight it and but uh the end of the day um you know we
05:56:22 have all the campaigns of scrutineers there's party officials that are well practiced in this
05:56:27 uh i think you know we're going to get a result soon and it'll be a clear result
05:56:35 well excellent fred thank you so much for taking the time to join our show i know you joined it
05:56:40 earlier and now you're joining in again hopefully we will be uh learning the results very soon but
05:56:45 we we thank you again for your time no look anytime love you guys and what you guys are
05:56:50 doing i think this is incredibly important issues that you guys have put together and you're
05:56:54 you know you speak to a very uh important part of our country that doesn't get the
05:56:59 the uh the coverage that is usually needed so thank you for everything you guys do and thanks
05:57:03 Thanks for having me.
05:57:06 Thank you very much.
05:57:07 That is Fred DeLore, campaign manager for Aaron O'Toole,
05:57:11 joining us as we go through the highlights of people
05:57:14 that we spoke to earlier, just with all that's changed here.
05:57:17 And as far as updates in the actual official dynamic of things,
05:57:23 not much has changed since we gave you another update,
05:57:25 but if you are just tuning in,
05:57:27 this is the True North Conservative Leadership Results Show,
05:57:30 co-hosted by me and candace malcolm my colleague and friend here and and just again i mean this
05:57:37 has been a very long evening we started about five and a half hours ago and it's not to say that we
05:57:42 are deserving of a medal or anything i think you watching it for five and a half hours if anyone
05:57:46 certainly is deserving of a medal i will point out that the party is still committed at this point
05:57:53 to a province by province announcement of the ballots and just to put this into perspective
05:57:58 if we do not have a winner on the first ballot, that's going to add probably another 20, 30 minutes
05:58:04 to each round. So once they start with the results, there still could be a significant delay.
05:58:10 At this point, Candace, do you think they should just kind of dispense with the ceremony and just
05:58:14 give a straight reading of the results? Yeah, you know, we were talking earlier about how in 2016,
05:58:21 when they were announcing the winner of the US election, it took until three o'clock in the
05:58:24 warning. But, you know, there was just so much at stake. That was the leader of the free world.
05:58:29 That was the president of the United States. You know, you need to count every ballot. It's not up
05:58:34 to anyone at the central HQ. This is a little different. This is, you know, the leader of a
05:58:40 party. It's all internal. They have the information. They don't need to do the ceremony and the pomp
05:58:45 at this point. I think that, you know, it's 11 o'clock in Toronto on the east, you know, in the
05:58:50 eastern time zone it's even later out on the actual east coast then most people just don't
05:58:56 really want to stay up all night uh to to hear from each and every every uh province in their
05:59:02 delegate to find out who won so i think that it obviously would be a lot better if they would just
05:59:07 announce the winner we want to know and i'm hearing from conservative sources that it's going to
05:59:12 happen soon party sources say it's going to happen soon i i feel like we've heard that one before
05:59:17 Andrew. But yeah, I think that at this point, they should just announce the winner and let us get on
05:59:24 with it. What do you think? Yeah, especially since there is still going to be a speech from the
05:59:28 winner after. And again, we mentioned earlier, potential for a press conference, even after
05:59:34 that. So that would be depending on how long the speeches go. And then they are politicians,
05:59:38 you never know, could be an extra, you know, 20, 30 minutes. So that is, I think, a very
05:59:43 interesting decision by the Conservative Party of Canada. Again, when they come back, they could
05:59:48 change it. There was a CTV News report that said they are down to the last 800 votes. And I won't
05:59:55 even pretend to do math on the spot about how long it took from when they were at the last 6,000
06:00:02 votes to now. But depending on how long it takes them to go through that 800 vote gap that they
06:00:09 may have, which again, is from a report that I haven't seen. We could be dealing with a little
06:00:15 bit of time left, especially if this is going manually. I thought it may be good while we are
06:00:19 waiting to revisit some of the highlights from earlier in the evening. And one of them, I think,
06:00:26 was a section of Andrew Scheer's speech where he certainly singled us out by name in a favorable
06:00:31 way at True North. But I would say, generally speaking, singled out press freedom in relation
06:00:38 to independent press and this was a great moment let's roll the clip of Andrew Scheer's
06:00:43 outgoing speech as conservative leader earlier this evening. In times like these
06:00:49 it is even more important for every single conservative to stay united and do everything
06:00:56 you can to work together to spread our message of hope. So it doesn't matter what kind of
06:01:02 conservative you are our party needs all of you and we need you to go out and find more people
06:01:08 who share our beliefs. Please stay involved. Be bold. Think. Challenge the mainstream media. Don't
06:01:15 take their narrative as fact. Check out smart, independent, objective organizations that are
06:01:21 growing all the time, like the Post-Millennial or True North. There are other places to get
06:01:26 information. Let's stop being the silent majority. Don't be afraid to challenge leftist professors
06:01:32 or public figures. Millions of Canadians share our conservative values. They just don't all know it
06:01:40 yet. I know Candace mentioned earlier, I think, the importance of supporting True North and
06:01:47 supporting independent media and the work that we're doing. And I will say it's incredibly
06:01:51 important that politicians recognize it. And it's not out of vanity. It's not just because,
06:01:56 oh, they said our name. It's because of, I think, the space that we're filling in the Canadian
06:02:02 media landscape, that recognition and equal access are important. And again, I mean, I know
06:02:08 we talk about that independent press gallery event that was supposed to be a debate. But one of the
06:02:13 points that I brought up with Erin O'Toole there is that the Erin O'Toole campaign had actually
06:02:18 made as part of its platform, granting equal access to the independent press gallery, what
06:02:25 the parliamentary press gallery has now and actually bolstering access for independent
06:02:30 journalists to government events. And remember the Conservative Party of Canada during the last
06:02:36 election had banned David Menzies from Rebel at one point of covering it. I believe Rebel was
06:02:41 barred from covering the convention in Halifax a year or two years ago. So the Conservatives
06:02:46 record is not exactly unblemished in this area. So the fact that candidates are actually making
06:02:53 a point of raising this issue now, or at least responding to it, I do think is encouraging.
06:03:01 Yeah absolutely and I think that you know this is it's just a changing landscape and it is so
06:03:07 important that we continue to talk about these issues and raise these issues and look Andrew
06:03:14 you know we we've been going live here for what four or five hours now and we really couldn't
06:03:20 couldn't continue to do this we've got a whole team behind us so you know it's you and I that
06:03:24 that are on air, that are at times struggling
06:03:28 through this long await with filling in
06:03:32 with interviews and stuff.
06:03:33 But we have a whole team behind the scenes
06:03:35 that we would be remiss if we didn't think.
06:03:37 So I just wanna quickly say thank you to Oliver McKenzie,
06:03:42 who is our producer, Phil Trin,
06:03:44 who is really running around behind the scenes
06:03:46 to help us line up interviews.
06:03:48 You know, we had Devin Drover on earlier.
06:03:50 He's our sort of correspondent out on the East Coast.
06:03:53 We have Kozma Zerja, who's a reporter for us
06:03:56 on the West Coast, who's doing a lot of our social media.
06:03:59 We really do have a whole team of people here.
06:04:01 We had Sam Eskenazi join us to do some punditry.
06:04:05 Earlier, we had Anthony Fury as well.
06:04:07 So we've got a great team with True North
06:04:10 and it's great to have that again,
06:04:12 great that there are so many Canadians out there
06:04:14 supporting us and for all the people supporting us,
06:04:17 Andrew, there's a whole bunch of naysayers.
06:04:19 I just, I've been focusing on a broadcast,
06:04:22 barely been on social media but i went on to my twitter feed uh or not even my twitter feed i
06:04:27 just went on to twitter and saw that andrew shearer was trending so i clicked on it and i realized
06:04:31 that the tweet one of the top tweets that's making him uh trend right now is a mclean journalist uh
06:04:38 who's making fun of me saying that that most journalists i knew would be ashen faced if a
06:04:43 partisan leader bashed most media and then singled out their organization and then he said but most
06:04:49 journalists didn't come up through a party's comm shot um so i guess he's saying that i shouldn't
06:04:53 have shared that clip of andrew sheer um because i should have been embarrassed well i i do recall
06:04:58 during the last federal election justin trudeau going out of his way to single out the cbc saying
06:05:03 that the liberal party always supports the cbc and then gave a journalist a plate of poutine um
06:05:10 and you know i don't remember all the mainstream media journalists getting up in arms over that i
06:05:15 know a lot of conservatives were and independent people were but apparently the fact that Andrew
06:05:20 Scheer you know gave us props and gave props to post-millennial is is so horrific to these
06:05:26 mainstream media journalists and just to fact check this McLean's journalist I've never worked
06:05:31 for the conservative party I've never never ever worked for them I was a conservative political
06:05:37 staffer about a decade ago working for Jason Kenney but I never worked for the party and I didn't
06:05:44 work in their comm shops. So fake news over there at McLean's. Maybe you should fact check your
06:05:49 tweets before sending out nonsense like that. But we definitely did hit a nerve with the mainstream
06:05:56 media, Andrew. And I think that they probably feel threatened by the fact that a lot of people are
06:06:01 tuning out of the mainstream media and tuning into more independent voices. Very much so. And I mean,
06:06:07 this is coming at a really point at a really important point when people saw firsthand the
06:06:13 contrast between conservatives and the mainstream media journalists in an interview and a clip of
06:06:20 that interview that went viral between Natasha Fatah of CBC and Andrew Scheer. And you, I think,
06:06:26 Natasha, I know her as well. And I'm not friends, but professionally, I've always had a good rapport
06:06:32 with her. And I think she is fair and very reasonable. And the questions that she was
06:06:36 putting to Andrew Scheer in this interview, I don't think were necessarily offside because she
06:06:40 was giving him the opportunity to respond to them and boy did he so while we wait for the results to
06:06:46 come in and we're talking about media bias and mainstream media and its role in covering
06:06:51 conservatives we have to play this clip by a popular request of Andrew Scheer on CBC this week
06:06:56 I totally hear that sir but allow me to push back a bit on that with with the fact that you've
06:07:03 brought up Lesley Lewis being a black woman running for leadership of the party if she were to win the
06:07:08 leadership, she could very well become the prime minister of this country. So if you compare the
06:07:13 amount of energy and momentum around her story, which arguably was very little, versus someone
06:07:19 like Kamala Harris in the United States, there was so much energy around her identity and gaining
06:07:25 momentum for the Democrats by putting her in a high profile role. What's the disconnect here? 0.98
06:07:31 Why was Kamala Harris lauded and celebrated? And one could argue Leslie Lewis was somewhat
06:07:36 forgotten in in the conversation you know that would be a great question for me to ask you and
06:07:41 ask your network why you spend so much time talking about american politics and highlighting
06:07:46 american candidates here we have a canadian candidate here we have a black woman who's
06:07:51 running for the leadership of the party and as for the conversation around the energy around it
06:07:55 you can't look to the cbc to find an accurate reporting of what's going on in the conservative
06:08:00 party of canada there's a tremendous amount of excitement i think you're going to see less than
06:08:04 Louis, placed very, very strong in many, many regions. I'm not going to predict the outcome
06:08:08 of the race, but she's generated a tremendous amount of excitement. When you look at what she's,
06:08:13 how she's tackled some of these issues based on conservative principles, there is, you know,
06:08:19 I don't, I'm not surprised that the mainstream media in Canada is downplaying her candidacy
06:08:23 while focusing so much time and attention on American politics. It's always been frustrating
06:08:27 for me as a Canadian taxpayer that the state broadcaster in this country, CBC,
06:08:32 spend so much time and energy covering American politics,
06:08:36 using taxpayers' money to cover politics in another country
06:08:39 when they ignore and downplay many of the things happening here in Canada,
06:08:44 especially within the Conservative movement.
06:08:45 So I'd love to hear an answer to that question from your own network.
06:08:49 All right.
06:08:50 So we'll put that question to the public broadcaster for you.
06:08:54 I mentioned earlier at some point this evening
06:08:57 that Conservatives have this id-like quality in them
06:09:00 that wants conservative politicians
06:09:02 to push back against the mainstream media.
06:09:04 And you know that the politicians all want to,
06:09:06 but I do genuinely believe
06:09:08 they've been suckered into this mentality
06:09:10 that you have to play nice with the media.
06:09:11 You have to be respectful of the media
06:09:14 and of the role of the media
06:09:15 and understand that their role is to criticize,
06:09:18 but that doesn't mean you have to accept
06:09:20 the media's premises.
06:09:22 And that's, I think, the key part of this.
06:09:24 The media is not used to being called
06:09:26 when they show their bias.
06:09:28 They're not used to being called on that. So I think that's why that was such a masterclass
06:09:33 in political interview. Yeah. And I'll just say it again. I said it earlier on the show,
06:09:39 but we might have different people watching. Natasha Fittah is a class act and she's probably 1.00
06:09:43 the best journalist over at the CBC. So I definitely don't fault her for asking this.
06:09:48 And maybe she didn't even notice. I mean, I think a lot of conservatives pay attention to these
06:09:52 things. A lot of conservatives really roll their eyes when they see so much attention and so much
06:09:57 fanfare and so much energy from the canadian media first focused on u.s
06:10:01 stories uh but also the sort of devotion obsession
06:10:06 that the media has with democrats um painting them as if they're these like
06:10:09 godlike figures there to save us from the evil
06:10:12 donald trump you know kamal harris is not running for
06:10:15 president she's running as vp and maybe she'll end up being president if joe
06:10:19 biden wins and can't fulfill his duty as president but
06:10:23 but really you know the the media is obsessed with kamala harris and at the same time you know
06:10:28 there's another woman who's very impressive very fresh very new very energized to the conservative
06:10:34 base who the media just ignoring true north had a report that that showed that 500 more headlines 0.99
06:10:41 were written about kamala harris just in the past what two weeks um then about leslie lewis and 0.94
06:10:45 leslie lewis is running to essentially be prime minister in the country she could very well
06:10:50 be the next leader of this party in the morning and yet the mainstream media is not really paying
06:10:54 attention to her so certainly cbc deserves to be called out on that and i applaud andrew sheer for
06:11:00 finally doing that i wish we'd seen a lot more of that from him but um as we talked about a little
06:11:06 bit after his uh speech andrew you know now the pressure's off now he doesn't have to perform
06:11:12 he can kind of relax and maybe be himself a bit more uh you know we heard during that speech that
06:11:18 that he gave earlier tonight,
06:11:19 a lot more about sort of principled philosophical
06:11:22 conservatism, really painting the argument
06:11:24 that conservatism is the more compassionate worldview
06:11:27 and how conservative policies and values and ideas
06:11:32 have really helped to create the freedom and prosperity
06:11:35 and that there's a really a moral argument
06:11:38 towards that worldview.
06:11:40 It would have been great to hear more of him
06:11:41 talk about that during the campaign,
06:11:43 but hey, I'm happy that he's sort of hitting his stride now
06:11:46 and saying things that are true
06:11:47 that need to be said and deserve to be said.
06:11:50 Yes, and one very interesting thing about Andrew Scheer
06:11:53 that is easy to forget,
06:11:54 because we tend to view politicians
06:11:56 not really in terms of who they are as individuals,
06:11:59 but he's very young.
06:12:00 He's younger than Justin Trudeau.
06:12:02 He's, I think, 40 or 41.
06:12:04 He's not an old man at all.
06:12:06 And that means that he's still got
06:12:09 a huge amount of life left in him
06:12:11 and potentially political life as well.
06:12:13 And a lot of the times when you think about
06:12:15 politicians that have stepped down. They're at a point where they can kind of transition into being
06:12:21 more ex-officio members of the Canadian political class. Whereas Andrew Scheer, I mean, could easily
06:12:27 do a lot of other things. And I don't know what those things will be. I did when I was speaking
06:12:32 with him a couple of weeks ago on earth that he plans to stick around as a member of parliament.
06:12:36 He wants to run again in 2021 or 2020 or whenever the next election is. So he wants to continue
06:12:43 serving. So he could be a cabinet minister conceivably. But I also wouldn't be surprised
06:12:49 to see him go as, you know, Premier of Saskatchewan in the future to take on another role somewhere
06:12:55 else. And again, I mean, it's purely theoretical at this point. We don't know what the future is
06:12:59 going to hold for the Conservatives or for Andrew Scheer. But it is important to note that this is
06:13:04 not necessarily the goodbye that it is for some other politicians who are a lot older.
06:13:10 Well, I'm sure that many in the media are wishing it's a good buy. And, you know, it's actually kind of funny because Andrew Scheer is just kind of trolling the media right now on social media, which to me is just so enjoyable. Usually it's me that's making fun of all these idiotic, self-important journalists. But right now it's Andrew Scheer.
06:13:31 So just a few examples of the tweet that I mentioned from the McLean's reporter, a guy named Jason Markusoff, who was saying that I was that I came up through the party's comm shop, which is false, fake news, not true.
06:13:48 Andrew Scheer replied to that saying yes, and they and they are ashen faces when their organizations cash in checks they receive from a liberal bailout fund.
06:13:57 know the one that this guy with this guy on the board so then you post an article from mcclain's
06:14:02 of jerry diaz kind of embracing justin schrudo so andrew shear is there replying to these uh
06:14:09 these journalists who are making fun of him and true north same thing paul vieira from the wall
06:14:14 street journal said uh shear suggests tories uh should read post-millennial and true north instead
06:14:20 of the mainstream media andrew she replied not just tories all canadian so uh good to see andrew
06:14:27 sheer punching back in real time trolling uh all the mainstream media who are mocking them and
06:14:33 mocking true north it's kind of funny andrew because obviously we weren't expecting uh andrew
06:14:40 sheer to give us a shout out like that and it just seemed really seemed to hit a nerve with
06:14:44 the media you know there he gave a long speech it was very detailed it was full of interesting
06:14:48 things he made one comment about how you know you shouldn't just take the fact of the of the
06:14:53 mainstream media you should do research you should look into other areas you should look to new
06:14:58 independent outlets like uh post-millennial and true north for your news and all of a sudden you
06:15:02 have all these mainstream media journalists like you know the the media party or the mean girls in
06:15:07 the media as our friend ezra levant likes to call them um and these journalists all start freaking
06:15:12 out and so here again you have uh andrew shared trolling these journalists this is someone from
06:15:18 the toronto star um saying partisan endorsements clearly okay with the post-millennial and they
06:15:25 post the same image of of sheer making that comment and then andrew sheer replied back
06:15:32 with a toronto star article saying liberals are the best choice for canada so you know
06:15:36 and his captions so weird eh so weird okay so good to see andrew uh sheer having a good time
06:15:43 with these journalists who probably are not used to a politician pushing back and again i guess
06:15:49 this brings me to an earlier point i made andrew which is that you know it's too bad that that
06:15:55 that industry got pushed out after one election because he did have a good showing you know it
06:15:59 was a tough it was an uphill battle he didn't do as well communicating some of the social
06:16:03 conservative issues as we wish he had he he stumbled a little bit in his explanations and
06:16:08 pushing back to the media he was a little bit too polite and too cute and you know tried to be funny
06:16:12 at times when he should have been firmer in some ways i just wish that maybe he would have had a
06:16:18 second opportunity because he's becoming more known he's becoming more comfortable you know
06:16:22 in some ways he would be a great leader now although that's that's not what's happening but
06:16:28 you know the idea that you lose one election and you have to go i think that that's that's tough
06:16:32 precedent going forward yeah so we have a couple of updates from ottawa apparently they have 100
06:16:38 ballots left and the party has given campaigns a 20-minute warning. Now we are with you for the
06:16:45 long haul. The Andrew Scheer resignation speech or farewell speech is just under 14 minutes so
06:16:50 we're going to share that speech with you again because it was very popular. The media is not
06:16:55 happy with it although as Candace just mentioned Andrew Scheer is not backtracking at all from
06:17:01 that so we're going to play that. We are still with you. We are not you know throwing in the
06:17:05 towel on this. If the party starts its broadcast before the speech ends, we'll cut away and we'll
06:17:11 come back. But the results may be happening within 20 minutes. But let's go to Andrew Scheer's
06:17:16 farewell speech delivered earlier this evening. Folks, the Honourable Andrew Scheer.
06:17:22 Well, thank you very much Scott, thanks Lisa, thanks Dan, bonsoir tout le monde.
06:17:38 What an incredible three years.
06:17:40 I have been so honoured to serve as leader of the Conservative Party of Canada and as
06:17:46 leader of the official opposition in the House of Commons, leading our amazing team.
06:17:51 I am very honored to have been the Chief of the party and the Office of the House of Communities
06:17:58 and led our excellent team.
06:18:01 Looking back on where we started in 2017 and all that we have accomplished together,
06:18:06 I am struck by the determination, strength and resilience of our party.
06:18:12 In 2017, no one thought we could win the next election.
06:18:17 The media establishment was predicting that Justin Trudeau would easily win two or maybe even three majority governments.
06:18:23 He would be Prime Minister for as long as he wanted.
06:18:27 But we rolled up our sleeves and reminded voters that Conservatives are the only party fighting for hard-working Canadians.
06:18:36 The fact that anyone even considered the 2019 election winnable is because of the incredible success of our entire team.
06:18:45 And while we didn't get the result we all would have liked, we did reduce the Trudeau
06:18:50 government to a minority and formed the strongest opposition in Canadian history.
06:18:58 There are so many people I would like to thank.
06:19:00 First off, my House leadership, Shadow Cabinet and Caucus teams.
06:19:05 Merci pour vos conseils et votre soutien pendant mon mandat.
06:19:12 One of the most frustrating parts of not forming government is stopping to think about what
06:19:17 a great group of ministers we would have had if we had won.
06:19:22 I know that Canadians would have been far better served during this pandemic had there
06:19:26 been a Conservative government in power, and I look forward to the many great things that
06:19:31 our next Conservative team will accomplish.
06:19:34 J'aimerais aussi remercier Joan Bayless, Hamish Marshall, Kenzie Potter, Marc-André Leclerc et toute l'équipe qui m'ont encouragé à me présenter comme chef et qui sont restés à mes côtés.
06:19:50 Ça a parfois été difficile, mais je ne peux pas imaginer un meilleur groupe de personnes pour le faire.
06:19:58 To the Office of the Leader of the Opposition and party headquarter teams, thank you for
06:20:04 all your hard work over the past three years and throughout this leadership race.
06:20:09 I know that the new leader will be in good hands with all of you.
06:20:12 I'd also like to thank our entire Conservative Caucus, National Council, Party President
06:20:18 Scott Lamb, and all of our thousands and thousands of party members and volunteers.
06:20:24 Each of you contribute so much to our movement
06:20:27 and are vital to our success.
06:20:31 But most of all, I would like to thank my incredible wife,
06:20:35 Jill, for her love and support,
06:20:37 without which none of this would have been possible.
06:20:41 Jill, I love you so much.
06:20:43 Thank you for all the sacrifice that you and the kids made
06:20:46 over the past few years.
06:20:50 I can honestly say that I have never been prouder
06:20:53 to be a conservative or to be a Canadian.
06:20:56 La pandémie nous a mis au défi,
06:20:59 mais elle a aussi montré le meilleur côté des Canadiens
06:21:02 partout au pays.
06:21:05 Les voisins cédant les unes et les autres,
06:21:07 les entreprises trouvant des façons innovatrices
06:21:10 de servir leurs clients,
06:21:13 et les proches se réunissant pour célébrer
06:21:16 des moments importants, même de façon virtuelle.
06:21:20 Pendant cette épreuve,
06:21:22 Notre équipe conservatrice s'est concentrée sur l'aide aux Canadiens.
06:21:28 We have improved the government's response to the pandemic
06:21:32 and have never backed down in our fight to keep our parliament open during this crisis.
06:21:39 As we look forward to the recovery, Canadians will be faced with a fundamental choice.
06:21:46 You see, the left is offering the same failed policies that they always do.
06:21:51 Bigger government, more government intervention, and less individual freedom.
06:21:58 Mais un gouvernement plus gros et plus omniprésent nuit aux gens.
06:22:05 The lie of the left is that the very people they claim they want to help are hurt the most by their policies.
06:22:13 They pretend to be motivated by compassion, but there's nothing compassionate about big government intervention.
06:22:21 Ever-increasing intervention in the marketplace rewards big corporations who can afford expensive
06:22:27 government relations experts. New rules and laws make labour costs so expensive that
06:22:32 low-income workers and new entrants into the workforce lose their jobs first.
06:22:37 And little by little, fundamental rights and freedoms are eroded.
06:22:42 In the 1980s, the Soviet bloc and Eastern European countries all had the same rhetoric.
06:22:47 their policies were supposed to help the poor and promote equality, the exact same rhetoric
06:22:53 that the left is using today. But all it caused was misery.
06:23:12 Today's voters didn't grow up. Many of today's voters didn't grow up watching the wall come down,
06:23:17 or looking at the breadlines in East Berlin.
06:23:20 So we, as a party, need to constantly be looking
06:23:24 for new ways to make the case
06:23:25 for the core conservative principles we all believe in.
06:23:28 Freedom, limited government, and unlimited potential.
06:23:33 Our values and ideals have stood the test of time.
06:23:37 For generations, they have guided Canadians
06:23:39 through adversity, and they will once again.
06:23:44 See, the Liberals are all candy before supper.
06:23:47 They make superficial promises and hope you don't blame them for the consequences.
06:23:52 Then, all you're left with is a stomachache and a serious case of buyer's remorse.
06:23:58 Conservatives, on the other hand, we believe in a balanced meal.
06:24:01 We look at the whole picture, and we see the harm and the misery that the policies of the left cause.
06:24:09 The Liberals put all their faith in government.
06:24:11 They believe that bigger government and more state intervention will somehow solve all of the world's problems.
06:24:17 Conservatives fight for those who don't have powerful lobbyists getting insider deals.
06:24:23 We fight for the men and women who don't have well-connected friends in Ottawa, who
06:24:26 are too busy raising their families and working hard to attend the cocktail circuit.
06:24:33 We are your voice.
06:24:36 But the biggest risk to freedom and liberty is when people empower government to do more
06:24:40 and more for them.
06:24:43 It may be tempting to use the government to address the challenges society often faces.
06:24:48 But once invited inside, the government is a terrible house guest.
06:24:52 It may feel good to vote in a party that is going to overstep the limits of government
06:24:57 in order to do something you agree with.
06:24:59 However, that invitation is quickly used to justify all sorts of actions you might never
06:25:05 have considered.
06:25:06 It is far better to keep government within strictly defined limits and leave the rest
06:25:11 of society to fulfill its proper role. That is why Conservatives put their faith in people.
06:25:20 We know that there is more to society than just government, and that free people, within
06:25:24 a free market, working hard and enjoying the fruits of their labour, free to express themselves
06:25:29 and live their lives the way they want, that is the recipe for success every single place
06:25:37 It's been tried.
06:25:39 When given a choice between societies
06:25:40 where governments control more and more of their citizens' lives
06:25:44 and those where freedom and opportunity are protected,
06:25:47 people will always choose freedom.
06:25:50 After all, no one ever got shot trying to jump the wall
06:25:53 to get into East Berlin or paddle the raft to get to Cuba.
06:25:58 We don't even have to go back into the past
06:26:00 to see these examples.
06:26:01 We just need to look at the mess happening right now
06:26:04 in Venezuela and all the tragedy that it is causing.
06:26:07 At a time when the establishment elites are doing everything they can to defeat us, at
06:26:25 a time when dozens of groups like Lead Now and Unifor pay millions of dollars to run
06:26:30 ads against us and bash our policies at a time when the mainstream media bias in this
06:26:37 country has never been more clear.
06:26:42 In times like this, it is up to the Conservative Party to unite Canadians instead of allowing
06:26:49 the left to divide Canadians.
06:26:54 At a time when our kids, when young people, have never been taught the value of those
06:27:00 free market principles, where they've actually been taught that there's something wrong
06:27:04 with free markets and individual liberty.
06:27:09 In times like these, it is even more important for every single Conservative to stay united
06:27:16 and do everything you can to work together to spread our message of hope.
06:27:22 So it doesn't matter what kind of Conservative you are, our party needs all of you, and we
06:27:27 We need you to go out and find more people who share our beliefs.
06:27:31 Please stay involved.
06:27:33 Be bold.
06:27:34 Think.
06:27:35 Challenge the mainstream media.
06:27:36 Don't take their narrative as fact.
06:27:38 Check out smart, independent, objective organizations that are growing all the time, like the Post
06:27:44 Millennial or True North.
06:27:46 There are other places to get information.
06:27:48 Let's stop being the silent majority.
06:27:51 Don't be afraid to challenge leftist professors or public figures.
06:27:55 of Canadians share our Conservative values. They just don't all know it yet.
06:28:04 Now, I know that we can win the next election.
06:28:16 Today, I am leaving the next leader with 121 amazing MPs from coast to coast.
06:28:25 In 2015, we won around 31% of the vote. In 2019, we won 34.4%, won the popular vote,
06:28:33 and formed the strongest opposition in Canadian history.
06:28:38 I'm also proud to say tonight that the Conservative Party of Canada is officially debt-free.
06:28:47 We are in an excellent position, but we cannot be complacent.
06:28:51 Our party's unity has been tested in the past, and media love nothing more than writing
06:28:55 about disgruntled Conservatives, so we cannot give them that opportunity.
06:29:00 For the last few months, the different candidates and their supporters have been highlighting
06:29:04 the differences between them. After tonight, let's all come together
06:29:10 and focus on the things that unite us. We must stay squarely concentrated on working together
06:29:18 and focusing on the many things we share in common.
06:29:40 Where they will use the pandemic as an excuse to reward their friends, 0.66
06:29:43 conservatives will clean up their corruption. Where they will play the politics of envy,
06:29:48 we will spread a message of hope and opportunity where they will attack our energy sector we will
06:29:55 champion it and celebrate the prosperity it creates for all canadians where they will demonize people
06:30:01 for having different views on issues facing canadians we will not attack people for their
06:30:05 deeply held positions but instead look to find the common ground alors qu'ils vont diriger
06:30:12 a fédération centrée sur Ottawa, nous allons respecter les compétences provinciales et la
06:30:18 nation québécoise. And when they let Canadians down, as they always do, we will be ready to
06:30:27 offer them a Conservative government that puts people first. And after tonight, let's all rally
06:30:33 behind the new leader and do everything we can to make sure that the next leader of the Conservative
06:30:39 party becomes the next prime minister of this great country. Serving in this role has been the
06:30:47 greatest honor of my professional life. I want to thank all the members, all the volunteers,
06:30:52 the member of our fantastic team so much. This has been such an honor. Thank you very much.
06:30:58 Thank you so much for all the support that you've given to me and my family,
06:31:02 and we will get them in the next election. Thank you very much. Merci beaucoup.
06:31:09 well here we are it is now well we're in our seventh hour because we started we've done six
06:31:19 hours which means we're in our seventh hour of the true north live conservative leadership results
06:31:24 show i'm andrew lawton joined by candace malcolm and again we've had a lot to get through a lot
06:31:31 of back and forth on where things are in the result process and the counting process if you
06:31:36 folks the honor but we are supposedly down to double digit numbers of the number of ballots
06:31:44 that are remaining so the latest was about a hundred and that was i think 15 minutes ago or so
06:31:49 results are supposedly going to be coming within the next 10 to 15 minutes again i mean you have
06:31:55 to take with a few grains of salt anyone who has claimed to have knowledge of the specific time
06:32:00 because this was supposed to start at 6 p.m. Eastern
06:32:03 and it's now just after 11.30 Eastern time.
06:32:06 If you are in Atlantic Canada,
06:32:08 if you're in Newfoundland, it's right now 1 a.m.
06:32:10 So you've probably tapped out.
06:32:12 If you're in BC, it's 8.30.
06:32:13 So you're just getting started.
06:32:14 If you're in any other part of the world,
06:32:16 I don't know what time it is.
06:32:17 But regardless, thank you to all of you
06:32:19 who have been watching.
06:32:20 This has been something that was actually,
06:32:22 I should say, Candice, a bit of a,
06:32:24 not necessarily an experiment for us.
06:32:26 We've done live shows with our weekly True North update,
06:32:29 but this sort of a anchored live show around an event was a bit of a new one for us. So I don't
06:32:34 know if, I mean, obviously we want them to be a bit shorter next time, but I am so far actually
06:32:38 happy all things considered about how it's gone. Well, we've learned a lot together, haven't we,
06:32:43 Andrew? Uh, you know, initially we were going to have a 30 minute broadcast prior to the results
06:32:48 coming in. About half of that was interviews that Andrew had done. So, so, you know, we've been live
06:32:53 here for seven hours. We did a pre-show for an hour before Andrew was doing interviews all day.
06:32:58 so we've really been non-stop and you know unlike our friends at the mainstream media we don't have
06:33:02 a huge budget we don't have a huge production team it's basically just us with uh oliver our
06:33:07 producer and phil our producer executive producer behind the scenes putting this all together and so
06:33:13 you know huge uh thank you to you guys uh behind the scenes uh for that you know if we're over at
06:33:18 the cbc we would have people interns bringing us coffee and and people bringing us different uh
06:33:24 interesting tidbits to talk about and we'd have all kinds of clips that we could throw to and
06:33:30 you know life would be a lot easier but you know the life of an independent journalist isn't quite
06:33:35 as glamorous as the life of a cbc journalist i guess andrew but i all things considered i'm
06:33:40 you know pretty happy with our broadcast i think we still have a couple thousand people watching
06:33:44 across the mediums between facebook and and youtube which which is great for a very small
06:33:50 outlet like us and i think the numbers have been higher at other points in the night so we're very
06:33:54 happy with it and we thank you you know to each and every one of you who's who's stuck with us
06:33:58 and and watched all of our interviews and this entire show really really appreciate it you know
06:34:03 we are still growing and and and learning and trying to get our message out there and trying
06:34:08 to provide the kind of coverage that canadians are looking for i'll just say it again you know
06:34:13 we replay this uh the the speech from andrew sheer it was great to hear uh to have him you know push
06:34:18 back against the mainstream media in his speech tell canadians specifically to you know question
06:34:23 the the the facts that are coming from mainstream media because they're not always true and to look
06:34:28 to alternative sources of news and media and he he said specifically post-millennial and true north
06:34:33 which obviously is a huge compliment for us i'm not going to pretend uh that it isn't but apparently
06:34:39 to some of the journalists watching and and commenting on twitter um it was very unbecoming
06:34:46 of us to share that clip andrew because we we should have been uh embarrassed and humiliated
06:34:51 by the fact that a partisan politician mentioned us instead of actually, you know, sharing that
06:34:56 message and supporting it. So I guess that's part of the reason why they just don't consider us
06:35:01 real journalists over here at True North. Yeah, and one of them was from a member of the
06:35:06 Parliamentary Press Gallery, who many of our viewers and supporters know we've had a bit of a
06:35:11 battle of sorts with because it was the Parliamentary Press Gallery that was instrumental
06:35:15 in barring True North from covering the election debate. So when people in this exclusive club that
06:35:21 has, by government mandate, a greater access to practice journalism than other people is
06:35:27 kind of snarking at the recognition of independent media, there's a big problem. And that's why it's
06:35:32 important to fight for it. So this is, I guess, proving that no timeline can be taken for granted
06:35:38 or taken at face value. About 15 minutes ago, we were given the 20 minute warning. And as per our
06:35:44 friend Brian Lilly, he just tweeted a moment ago that the 15 minute warning didn't apparently start
06:35:50 right away. The 15 minute warning had a delayed start time. So there was actually a 15 minute
06:35:56 warning for the 15 minute warning. So according to Brian Lilly, the 15 minute warning went into
06:36:01 effect at 1130 Eastern, which means at 1135 Eastern, which is what the time is now, we are
06:36:07 supposedly 10 minutes away. So at this point, I don't even know why we're bothering with the times,
06:36:11 but we are giving you the information as we get it. That's the fun of a live show. And we are,
06:36:17 as I said, at this point, we're committed to it. We've had a lot of support from people on
06:36:22 social media. And while we are waiting, I guess let's actually put an invitation. I mean,
06:36:28 I'm watching Twitter right now more than anything else. So if you want to tweet me
06:36:30 at Andrew Lawton, your thoughts on the race predictions, questions, we can turn this into
06:36:35 a bit more of a, not necessarily casual, but a bit more of an informal conversation now just as
06:36:41 we wait for the results to start. So if you have any questions, you can tweet me at Andrew Lawton
06:36:46 And we'll we'll get to a few of those. But I do think as far as the takeaways from the race and from the evening are concerned, the one thing that I would very much say everyone seems to be on board with, regardless of what side of the Conservative Party they're from, is that Leslie Lewis has become a real star of the race.
06:37:05 And to go, even if you're not a fan of hers or if you didn't vote for her, to go from being a political unknown who has no elected experience and not much political experience in general, to being the potential, I mean, under some scenarios, winner of the race or at the very least the kingmaker of the race, that is a real achievement.
06:37:23 And Candace mentioned those fundraising numbers earlier, to raise $2 million when a few months ago people were thinking you wouldn't be able to raise even the $300,000 entry fee is quite substantive. And it still is a bit odd in a way, and not at all as a knock against Lesley Lewis, but oftentimes politics is very closed off to newcomers.
06:37:46 And there are a few exceptions to this.
06:37:48 Obviously, we had Kevin O'Leary last time, but he came in with some celebrity.
06:37:53 So that helped him do well.
06:37:54 And ultimately, he didn't think he was going to win.
06:37:56 And that's why he bowed out of the race.
06:37:58 So I don't know if what Leslie Lewis did was something that could be replicated or if it
06:38:03 was just the right candidate, the right team, the right strategy at the right point in time
06:38:07 when there wasn't a lot of other options stepping forward.
06:38:11 Well, it's interesting because the rules sort of changed last time around.
06:38:14 it seemed like there's sort of course correction on behalf of the conservative party and the people
06:38:19 who run these kind of things because you know in the race to replace stephen harper after the 2015
06:38:24 election uh that i guess it was in 2015 2016 um we had so many candidates you know we had i think
06:38:32 there there was 18 candidates or something like that and they didn't have any kind of a cutoff
06:38:37 so i was always kind of expecting you know half the the the ballots to drop off and then have a
06:38:43 smaller race near the end the way that the republicans sort of do it down in the us where
06:38:47 the the group gets smaller and smaller um i i guess at that point they wanted more people more
06:38:53 ideas in some ways that leadership race andrew was was much more about ideas you had different
06:38:58 kinds of conservatives putting forth different ideas you recall you had maxine bernier who
06:39:03 really was a libertarian and kind of morphed into this new populist uh leader in canada but we also
06:39:09 had people like Kelly Leach who were proposing just something a little different with regards to
06:39:14 immigration uh integration talking about having some kind of a values test for people coming into
06:39:20 Canada which of course the media blew that out completely out of proportion um but but all that's
06:39:25 just to say that there was a lot more people involved a lot more regions represented and
06:39:29 different kinds of conservatives uh this time I think they wanted to avoid that large large field
06:39:34 of just so many candidates and sort of lack of focus and you know I think it ended up taking
06:39:39 14 ballots or something to determine that Andrew Scheer was you know became the leader and so this
06:39:45 time around they made it more restrictive there was a higher barrier in terms of the amount of
06:39:49 money raised and it's no easy fee I mean Lesley Lewis said it herself that she didn't think
06:39:54 initially that she would have enough support to be able to raise that three hundred thousand
06:39:59 dollar threshold well she ended up raising two million dollars which is a huge amount of money
06:40:04 for you know a new candidate in Canada it's a relatively small country we don't have as much
06:40:08 money in our politics as they do in the US it's all just sort of small money grassroots
06:40:13 campaign donations and contributions so you know regardless of what the results are I think
06:40:18 Lesley Lewis really really did accomplish something spectacular and I think that the
06:40:23 Conservatives should really continue with that momentum make sure that Lesley Lewis is in a key
06:40:28 position that she runs for in a riding it's relatively safe that she can win she can have a
06:40:33 seat uh in parliament and and be a strong voice going forward conservatives because i think she's
06:40:38 got a great tone a great message she appeals to a lot of people you know one of the criticisms 0.99
06:40:43 about her is that she didn't have a very well scripted campaign or that she wasn't necessarily 0.99
06:40:50 ready for prime time or as smooth as she should be well look you know she's brand new to the game 0.97
06:40:54 she's got a lot of time to grow and i hope that she does have a future uh in in the party and
06:40:58 also in the broader conservative movement in canada we uh asked for your questions on twitter
06:41:04 we'll read a couple that have come in and by the way a lot of tweets that have come in from people
06:41:08 that aren't even questions just uh congratulations i i mean i'm honored and quite humbled by this
06:41:13 we're we're having a good time doing this so thank you very much for your support uh kelly creek
06:41:17 dairy says thoughts on the next leader of the conservatives not running against trudeau but
06:41:21 but another leader of the Liberals like Freeland.
06:41:24 And there was another tweet along a similar vein.
06:41:26 What's the deal with the mainstream media 0.94
06:41:27 hailing Chrystia Freeland as some kind of new savior?
06:41:30 This is, I think, interesting.
06:41:32 And I thought that when Justin Trudeau won the last election,
06:41:35 that he was kind of phoning it in
06:41:37 in the first couple of months of his premiership.
06:41:39 And I think was probably ready to hand over the reins
06:41:42 to someone else because he had downloaded
06:41:44 so many of his responsibilities to Freeland.
06:41:47 And then the pandemic hit and all of a sudden
06:41:48 we need to have the prime minister.
06:41:50 We need to have someone stepping forward.
06:41:52 So I think that has renewed his relevance to his party and his relevance to his government
06:41:57 when he was trying to backtrack.
06:41:59 He said the other day at a press conference that, yes, he's going to be on the ballot
06:42:03 next time.
06:42:04 But what are your thoughts, Candace?
06:42:05 I mean, do you think the Conservatives need to be abandoning the strategy that seems to
06:42:09 have been there since 2015 of just running against Justin Trudeau?
06:42:14 Well, I think that was certainly part of the problem for Andrew Scheer.
06:42:17 you know, during this last campaign, the SNC-Lavalin scandal was so devastating. And for
06:42:22 folks that were really tuned in and paying attention to sort of, you know, political
06:42:26 insiders like you and I, Andrew, it seemed like it was, you know, that was going to be the end of
06:42:31 the liberal government, the end of Justin Trudeau. I remember there was a really devastating
06:42:37 cover on Maclean's magazine, calling him the imposter, and just seemed like, okay,
06:42:42 the mask has fallen off, you know, the emperor has no clothes. Once the mainstream media turns on you,
06:42:46 there's not really anything there there with Justin Trudeau there's a substance and so if he
06:42:51 doesn't have the loving admiration of his friends in the mainstream media what does he have but
06:42:56 clearly that wasn't enough you know Canadians weren't as tuned into the SNC level scandal
06:43:01 maybe it was more complex obviously Trudeau got downgraded to a minority government he didn't win
06:43:07 the popular vote Andrew Schur got more individual votes cast for him and so I thought the conservatives
06:43:12 actually did a pretty good job last time around but they didn't get the coveted uh government you
06:43:17 know obviously Andrew Scheer wanted to become prime minister so I think that there is a lesson
06:43:21 learned there which is that you have to offer something different you can't just say you know
06:43:26 we're not them um Canadians want to have a strong alternative they want to understand what it is
06:43:31 that that is going to be the next government what what the platform is what the values are
06:43:36 and instead of just running about what we're not you know you have to really put forth uh something
06:43:41 and I think we've talked about it a little bit throughout the podcast, Andrew, which is that,
06:43:46 you know, there is a really tremendous story to be told. The conservative worldview needs to be
06:43:52 emphasized and it's such an easy story to tell that you need someone who's really unabashed,
06:43:57 unafraid, willing to tell that story and just culturally at this moment in time, you know,
06:44:03 we're living through some really strange times, not just with COVID and not just with all these
06:44:07 scandals in government but just more broadly speaking where we we see this the rise of cancel
06:44:13 culture these woke social justice warriors who are trying to say that you know if you don't believe
06:44:18 exactly the same things that they believe in and you don't agree with their extreme ideology on
06:44:22 every point uh you shouldn't have a platform you shouldn't exist that you know they go out of their
06:44:26 way to try to uh cancel and remove platforms from any conservative in canada that has a platform
06:44:32 they've done it to rex murphy they did it to barbara k to conrad black uh you know we saw
06:44:37 stock all day get kicked off the show uh at uh cbc just for saying something really mild um that
06:44:44 wasn't ill-intended at all and so i think more and more canadians are looking at this trend
06:44:49 with with concern and they want someone who's going to push back and provide sort of a common
06:44:53 sense appeal and that's really where conservatives can can step in and be the counter voice to to
06:44:59 this sort of woke out of control left leftist madness um that has really captured the imagination
06:45:05 not just of the liberal party but also the mainstream media and so many other mainstream
06:45:10 institutions in canada it's time that someone pushed back against it i think conservatives are
06:45:14 well positioned to do that so i think that all this is just to say the conservatives have a lot
06:45:18 going for them they should really try to communicate that more to canadians what they do stand for
06:45:23 what they believe in and not just uh hey look you know true liberals are corrupt yeah we all know
06:45:28 that but we've got to do something more i think in order to replace the government so i'm hearing
06:45:34 from a source in one of the campaigns right now just so you all know that 35 000 ballots were
06:45:42 sliced by the machine and had to be fixed so earlier we were told that it was somewhere in
06:45:46 the range of four or five thousand now we're being told 35 000 ballots now again this is coming from
06:45:53 a campaign so so take that with a grain of salt although this doesn't seem to be anything that is
06:45:57 is particularly biased or partisan. This is just a statement of fact. So again, it puts things into
06:46:03 perspective. And what was interesting, I mean, a lot of people, yes, of course, were complaining
06:46:07 about the delays. And, you know, I count myself in that category, not as complaining necessarily,
06:46:13 but certainly pointing it out. But ultimately, even the people on the campaigns that I were
06:46:17 speaking to were saying, we've got to get it right. I mean, a rushed result would be worse
06:46:21 than a delayed result when it comes into questioning the integrity of some of the
06:46:26 information. So that is one of the details and all the more impressive that they seem to be down to
06:46:32 at least the final few ballots, if not completely done right now. The latest estimated start time
06:46:39 for results was 11.45pm Eastern. It is now 11.46pm Eastern. So perhaps it's going to be bumped back
06:46:46 again, or perhaps we'll actually be looking at a result that's coming in the mere moment. So we
06:46:52 are monitoring that and we'll throw to it the second that we have that available. I mentioned
06:46:57 earlier in the show that I think one of the challenges here is the Conservative Party's
06:47:01 required usage of mail-in ballots. And I think I'd suggest it offhandedly, online ballots. I
06:47:08 actually got a lot of pushback from that. People saying that online voting only makes the integrity
06:47:13 question more of an issue rather than less of one. I would love to find a secure way to do
06:47:21 a vote that's a little bit more modernized. I don't know what that would look like without
06:47:25 compromising security, though. Do you have any ideas, Candace? Well, I remember looking into this
06:47:30 some time ago, back when I was a political science student, and, you know, reading what the sort of
06:47:36 leading people in the field at the time were saying was that basically, there was just no way
06:47:40 to do these kind of elections, you know, either digitally or through mail-in ballots. There's all
06:47:46 kinds of security and fraud issues. I mean, you know, it's already difficult as it is just given
06:47:52 that you, well, Andrew, you've broken stories in the past of people showing up to vote without any
06:47:57 ID, people who may or may not even be Canadian citizens trying to vote in general elections,
06:48:03 people who are, you know, in Canada as permanent residents or refugees even that haven't even had
06:48:09 their paperwork process that are being invited to vote. There are all kinds of issues with
06:48:14 integrity and so when you move it away from in person and you put it online and into mailing
06:48:20 ballots even uh there's just so many security concerns so i i at this point i wouldn't be too
06:48:25 confident i haven't read the the recent literature maybe they've found ways to make it more secure
06:48:30 but i would i would certainly be be skeptical of that i think that the best way to vote is still
06:48:35 good old-fashioned in-person voting uh obviously you know given the the situation with covid and
06:48:41 everything that wasn't possible and you know this is the reality with with something like
06:48:46 a mail-in ballot i'm a little disappointed with the conservatives for not being more forthright
06:48:49 i mean how many times have we heard a new time tonight it just hasn't come true it's like hey
06:48:55 guys you know politicians already have a reputation of not being trustworthy and you know when they
06:49:00 say things that they're not really telling the truth uh you know this is exactly an example of
06:49:05 that here where we're you know we're told it's going to be six o'clock then we're told it's
06:49:09 to be eight o'clock now we're told 11 30 actually we're told very precisely 11 42 um and then that
06:49:15 was clearly not the case so the the campaigns are being told that they are given 15 minute notice
06:49:21 before the results are supposed to come in we've been given that 15 minute notice a couple of times
06:49:26 now and uh we still don't have the results and the fact that they're now saying that it was 35 000 or
06:49:31 we're now hearing that it was 30 000 ripped ballots and not the 2 000 that we were initially
06:49:36 told us like, what's the story here? Just tell us it straight. Tell us the truth. Don't give us
06:49:43 these half answers that turn out to be not true. That's exactly why people don't really trust
06:49:48 politicians and political parties in the first place. Yeah, at this point, I think it's gone on
06:49:53 long enough. Stacey Abrams thinks she's the winner of the conservative leadership race, which 1.00
06:49:57 is eventually what happens with any delayed election. So we have to be very mindful of that.
06:50:01 she might show up for question period when parliament resumes. I do think that, you know,
06:50:06 it's so interesting because obviously candidates and campaigns have to be optimistic and they have
06:50:12 to be confident. But I go back to the point that I raised earlier, which is the level of confidence
06:50:17 from the O'Toole campaign. I mean, I don't know if it's bravado or ignorance or genuine reliance
06:50:24 on their data. I mean, we heard the numbers from Aaron O'Toole campaign manager, Fred DeLaurie
06:50:29 earlier, saying that they did exit polls of 51,000 people, of 51,000 voters out of 172,000.
06:50:37 If those polling results are accurate, and this is not predictive polling, but exit polling,
06:50:43 as in how did you vote? If that's accurate, yeah, I'd be inclined to trust the O'Toole campaign,
06:50:49 but we all know campaigns seem to have a blind spot for their own data and for their own results.
06:50:54 Absolutely. I mean, every campaign that I've spoken to says that they think their candidate
06:50:58 is going to win uh obviously you know when we had uh steve outhouse from less than lewis campaign he
06:51:04 didn't want to make any predictions but definitely you know when you when you speak to them off the
06:51:09 record and on background and stuff they all think their their people are going to win so i don't
06:51:13 know if it's just uh optimism of a campaign or or selective uh information that they choose to
06:51:19 consume but yeah at this point you kind of wonder like what's what's the benefit in saying that your
06:51:24 campaign is going to win. You're going to turn around if that's not actually the case.
06:51:29 Because you look really bad if you're wrong and you look really good if you were humble and,
06:51:33 well, I don't know, we hope to win. So it's a high stakes game when you act this confident
06:51:38 even after the votes are in. Yeah, exactly. And again, there's nothing really to gain other than
06:51:44 just to say that you believe that your campaign did a good job or whatever. But yeah, no, I think
06:51:50 that there probably is something to their polling and i wouldn't be surprised if that is how the
06:51:54 results come out even some of the things that we're sort of hearing about how the mckay team
06:51:59 is challenging each and every ballot well that would sort of indicate that they're behind they're
06:52:03 trailing and they're trying to catch up and make up for votes you know which is why again we're
06:52:09 told that perhaps you know the speculation that that's why we're so delayed is because
06:52:13 the sorry the mccade uh campaign is questioning a lot of the results and and and you know wanting
06:52:20 to double check everything and again that would that would indicate that they were behind but
06:52:25 again you don't you don't want to speculate based on half half uh true information or based on
06:52:32 things that you're hearing and that kind of thing so it doesn't really benefit you uh in the end
06:52:37 well andrew i know this wasn't really the the night that we expected at all um you know we still have
06:52:43 our staff meeting scheduled for tomorrow morning yeah we do uh we do a true north scrum every
06:52:48 monday morning bright and early and so andrew and i might be a little burnt out for that call
06:52:53 uh just to any uh true north staff uh paying attention right now you know you might have to
06:52:58 carry the call tomorrow but um yeah we did we did a a pool inside of true north where we predicted
06:53:05 the outcome uh just a little friendly internal poll among true north uh staff and i i was pretty
06:53:13 surprised i think that most people who work for true north predicted that erin o'toole would win
06:53:19 uh most people predicted that that uh that peter mckay would come in second uh given that you know
06:53:24 mckay is supposedly the front runner he's the one that had the most name recognition he he's got the
06:53:29 you know the thickest resume and he was one of the founders essentially of this party
06:53:34 Andrew, why do you think that so many people on our team were leaning more towards thinking that
06:53:40 Erin O'Toole was going to win? It's tough to say. I think a lot of the discussions that I had with
06:53:45 some of our friends and colleagues were really coming down to the ranking. I think people seeing
06:53:49 a lot of support for Sloan and Lewis and just not seeing Peter McKay as having that 50% threshold
06:53:55 that he would need to win without down ballot support. And I think that's what it came down to.
06:54:00 And by the way, predictions are not endorsements. I mean, a lot of people on our team were somewhat agnostic or certainly aren't members or voting members.
06:54:09 And they still were just kind of looking at where they thought things were going with it.
06:54:13 And a lot of us had the same results, but very different paths to get there.
06:54:19 Yeah, that's right. And different people who they thought would, you know, come in second or come in third, different percentages and all that.
06:54:26 And certainly not endorsing any candidate or anything, just predicting it.
06:54:31 It's kind of always fun to see these office pools.
06:54:35 I think only one person on our entire team had Peter McKay winning.
06:54:39 So if McKay does pull it off, that one person will walk away with a lot of bragging rights
06:54:45 and a little bit of cash too.
06:54:48 So it should be interesting.
06:54:50 Keep the night interesting, I guess.
06:54:51 Yes, it is 1154 p.m. Eastern Time. And I will point out not to gloat, but the Conservative Party of Canada did say earlier that it would have a leader tonight. Now, if I'm getting technical here, I don't know if they said tonight, Eastern Time or just tonight. I mean, it's still going to be for a little while. I think in the in Guam, I think it's still going to be tonight for, you know, a good, you know, 10 hours or so.
06:55:18 But ultimately speaking, this is, you know, five minutes away from it no longer being tonight. And we don't have a result just yet. Although I'm seeing a couple of things here. Steve Pakin has tweeted that the lawyers for Peter McKay have left the counting room where they've been locked up for 18 hours.
06:55:37 We have another tweet here saying that this is from someone else, Western Standard, saying
06:55:44 that Aaron O'Toole has been told that he has won.
06:55:47 Now, the reason I share that with you is because we were told by the party that when the results
06:55:52 are broadcast live, the candidates will be hearing them for the first time.
06:55:56 So if he has been, as they say, told he has won, it might not mean by any official source,
06:56:01 but rather by scrutineers in the room that are just saying, yeah, we think you've won.
06:56:05 So I take that with a grain of salt if you see it circulating, but I share that just to give the
06:56:10 context that the party has said unequivocally that candidates will not be given advanced knowledge
06:56:16 of a win. Interesting. And yet we were told that they were going to go to a press conference. So
06:56:23 I guess the winner would just find out spontaneously, which I guess is pretty much what happens
06:56:29 when these results are delivered live at a convention. But again, I don't even really
06:56:34 know at this point, Andrew, if they're going to just announce the first ballot and then we're
06:56:38 going to have to wait for the second ballot, are they still going province by province? Have they
06:56:42 just scrapped that? Do we know anything about what the ceremony is going to look like once they
06:56:45 finally do come back? The last I heard was that they're still going to province by province. Now,
06:56:51 I mean, we heard how long it took to do the introductions of the people from the various
06:56:55 provinces that were going to be doing their announcements. So I don't know if they have
06:57:02 those people on retainer and they have to stick with the province by province analysis. But I do
06:57:07 think that at this point, that has not changed officially, though once the parties come back,
06:57:12 we may see a little bit of a change. So just if you're tuning in, again, I'm getting a bunch of
06:57:17 people asking about this tweet that said Erin O'Toole has been told he won. The party has said
06:57:21 that candidates are not being told in advance. So if a candidate has been told that they are
06:57:27 victorious, it would have to have been from a scrutineer. And I don't actually know if
06:57:32 scrutineers have the full numbers. I like they could be keeping their own ballot counts, of
06:57:37 course. But as I understand it, they'd be just looking at individual ballots. I don't think
06:57:42 they're getting a final tally that they're leaving the room with. So so take this all with with a
06:57:47 grain of salt. I know I've used that expression a few times tonight. But I think we need that much
06:57:50 salt with a lot of the information that's coming out because the longer it goes, the higher the
06:57:55 stakes are. And I think the easier it is for for things that are in some cases, rumors, maybe it's
06:57:59 a half truth or just something that's entirely untrue to be able to get around. So that's my
06:58:06 TED talk on this, if you will. Well, it is good to know. And again, yeah,
06:58:10 there's lots of circulation. And with anything, social media, you know, you hear rumors and you
06:58:15 don't know how true they are, where they're coming from. Andrew, I'll ask you a bit of a more,
06:58:19 not a personal question, but a professional question about this race. You've gotten to sit
06:58:23 down and interview all of the candidates except for Peter McKay, who for some reason didn't want
06:58:28 to. You interviewed them at the start of the race. And then again, near the end, when we did the
06:58:32 fireside chats, was there anything that sort of surprised you from what the candidates had to say
06:58:38 in your interviews? What was the sort of biggest thing that you learned from sitting down with
06:58:42 them? It's actually an interesting question. I would say that nothing surprised me really about
06:58:51 the interviews that I did. I think in some cases I was really in, what's a good way of putting it?
06:58:57 I was very pleased with how the candidates carried themselves in the face of criticism.
06:59:04 And to look at the most recent interviews, the Independent Press Gallery fireside chats,
06:59:09 both Aaron O'Toole and Derek Sloan were in the hot seat.
06:59:12 And it was a bit of a distinct experience for us because we were planning on doing a
06:59:17 debate.
06:59:17 But ultimately, what we were looking to do was showcase the candidates and showcase the
06:59:24 campaigns.
06:59:24 And we did that in a different format.
06:59:26 And in a one-on-one interview, there's nowhere to hide. Your talking points won't save you.
06:59:31 Soundbites won't save you. If you don't answer the question, I was pressing them on it. And both of
06:59:35 them said things that I might not like or whatnot, but they both, I'd say, composed themselves very
06:59:41 well. And when they were pushed, when they did have pushback from me, I thought they did very
06:59:46 well. Now, I don't think it's fair to compare interviews later on in the race with at the
06:59:51 beginning of the race because candidates, especially newer candidates, grow. Lesley Lewis,
06:59:56 I sat down with once very early on, and I didn't think she was exceptional. I thought she was good,
07:00:01 but I've also seen her improve throughout the race. I mean, even from some of the earlier 0.83
07:00:07 interviews she did to the English language debate to some of the later interviews,
07:00:11 she really rose to it. And Derek Sloan as well. I saw him do a couple of speeches actually
07:00:16 a few weeks from one another. And even between the first and the second, he had improved a fair
07:00:22 bit. So for Peter McKay and Erin O'Toole, I mean, they've been in politics for a while. What you see
07:00:26 is what you get. But I was really interested to see how Leslyn Lewis and Derek Sloan really
07:00:33 continued to improve throughout the race, even though it was a challenging race. And for Leslyn
07:00:37 Lewis, especially, who's not a member of parliament, a relatively new experience.
07:00:42 Absolutely. And so unfortunately, you did not get the opportunity to sit down with Peter McKay. He's
07:00:47 the only one who declined to take up our invitation to come and do a one-on-one interview. And
07:00:53 unfortunately, again, he didn't show up to the Independent Press Gallery's debate that we held.
07:00:59 But Andrew, you did get a chance to ask him a question, which was after, I believe it was the
07:01:04 English leader debate that was held through the official Conservative Party. So we have that clip
07:01:11 of you asking a question to peter mckay on his position on hate speech let's go to that clip now
07:01:17 good evening mr mckay in the previous parliament the justice committee had done studies on on
07:01:23 potentially reviving a new version of the old section 13 which was the part of the canadian
07:01:29 human rights act that went after online speech and the new version that ended up being recommended
07:01:34 was something that would look at putting liability on social social media companies that have what
07:01:40 What the government determines is hate speech and also bringing back some of those mechanisms that allow the government to use human rights legislation to go after online hate speech.
07:01:49 Do you support something like this?
07:01:51 What I support, Andrew, frankly, is greater emphasis on protecting children from online abuse, from luring.
07:01:58 And we tried to do that when I was in government.
07:02:00 When I was Justice Minister, one of the bills that we brought forward that is now part of the Canadian Criminal Code that I'm very proud of was designed to protect children from online bullying.
07:02:10 and the non-consensual distribution of intimate images that type of legislation when it's used
07:02:17 to protect rather than to be pernicious or to limit free speech I do support that type of
07:02:23 legislation this bill that you're talking about I have not seen the details of it but in in general
07:02:28 terms I'm not for punishing people's thoughts or expressions or putting limitations on their speech
07:02:34 I am in very much in in favor of protecting children in particular from some of the online
07:02:39 activities that are going out that I find to be very pernicious very evil
07:02:43 quite frankly and and they go after vulnerable people children who are
07:02:47 highly impressionable I also do believe on the same subject that we should be
07:02:52 doing more to ensure that those big internet service providers have
07:02:58 requirements to operate in Canada to provide Canadian jobs and to not be
07:03:02 exempt from the the taxation quite frankly that they are exempt from
07:03:07 currently under the rules
07:03:10 Well you know one of the unfortunate things about uh unfortunately the fact that Peter McKay
07:03:14 wouldn't sit down with a true north journalist that we couldn't interview him is that we didn't
07:03:17 really get the chance to get to know him I felt like the interviews that you did Andrew were so
07:03:22 illuminating about the candidates I really learned a lot from watching them particularly the fired
07:03:26 side chats there were some elements even that late in the campaign uh that we just really didn't know
07:03:31 I think that you really helped us clarify what uh Erin O'Toole's position was about carbon taxes
07:03:37 and climate change we learned that derek sloan supported supply management of dairy i had no
07:03:42 idea that was the case i just kind of assumed because he was this like authentic true conservative
07:03:46 that he would be take the conservative position on every issue and then obviously on that one
07:03:51 you know he was he was on the side of of the supply management of dairy um but but but
07:03:56 unfortunately because peter mckay didn't allow you to have that access to sit down and talk with him
07:04:02 We didn't really learn that much about him.
07:04:04 And even now, I sort of struggle sometimes to think of, you know, what does Peter McKay really want different for the country?
07:04:11 What is his vision for Canada?
07:04:13 What does he believe in?
07:04:14 What would Canada's role be on the world stage?
07:04:16 What would our fiscal situation look like?
07:04:18 You know, we hear a lot that he's a red Tory.
07:04:21 What does that even really mean in the context of today's politics?
07:04:24 Because Justin Trudeau is so far to the left.
07:04:27 His government is basically a socialist government.
07:04:29 we've seen spending never before seen before i think that the current deficit is seven times
07:04:34 larger than any other deficit in canadian history well typically a red tory would be someone who's
07:04:40 more social more more fiscally liberal more more open to big government programs uh but without
07:04:46 that means smaller government compared to justin trudeau so then wouldn't he sort of become more of
07:04:50 a fiscal conservative in today's environment there's so much that we didn't get to hear from
07:04:55 peter mckay that we didn't learn about him and i think that that's ultimately to his detriment that
07:05:00 he's the one that loses out because you know conservatives want to get to know someone before
07:05:04 they consider putting their name on the ballot whether it's in the first place second or third
07:05:09 and it is really too bad that peter mckay failed to do that you know you did get that opportunity
07:05:14 to put the question to him after that leadership debate but do you feel like there's something
07:05:19 missing uh from peter mckay that you would have liked to learn more about him uh any specific
07:05:23 policies or anything like that, Andrew? To be honest, I think national unity was the key thing
07:05:28 I wanted from him. How do you reconcile your identity as an Atlantic Canadian, as a Torontonian
07:05:34 with the Westerners and a lot of those old reform alliance types that are very uneasy about a PC
07:05:40 leader? I would have asked about how you bring social conservatives and other conservatives that
07:05:45 feel they're alienated from his vision of the party in. And I have to say, I've had some criticism,
07:05:50 especially in the last few days from Peter McKay loyalists and supporters that think I have a
07:05:55 vendetta against Peter McKay because I've been critical of him. And I would defend that by saying
07:06:00 two things. Number one, I've had to be critical in the absence of any opportunity to ask a question
07:06:05 beyond that one question at a press conference after the debate. And the fact that we've offered
07:06:11 numerous opportunities to interview, to debate, to do more interviews, we couldn't even get a
07:06:16 campaign official from McKay on the show today, which would have been a very light, easygoing,
07:06:22 friendly interview just about the campaign. So I've had to be very critical because of the
07:06:26 disdain that McKay has had towards us and other independent journalists that are trying
07:06:31 to cover the race. And I mean, the dirty little secret I'll let you all in on is that I've had
07:06:36 nothing against McKay. In fact, I had a lot of respect for him when he was in cabinet and I've
07:06:42 had pleasant interactions with him in the past years ago. And when the race started, I, despite
07:06:47 thinking, you know, maybe I'm not a fan of the red Tory thing. There are lots of red Tories that I
07:06:52 sat down with and had great chats with like Rudy Husney, like Marilyn Gladue. And I would have
07:06:56 happily done the same thing with Peter McKay. And as we've said, given everyone and every candidate
07:07:01 a fair shake. So my frustrations with McKay have had more to do with how he's treated media during
07:07:08 the campaign than any of his policies. And as I believe you mentioned earlier, when I was prepping
07:07:14 for the debate and when we were prepping for the debate and the fireside chats and looking at the
07:07:18 platform, there wasn't anything really objectionable in Peter McKay's platform. It really just comes
07:07:24 down to his conduct. And I think there is a cautionary tale there for McKay and for other
07:07:29 candidates that it isn't just about your values, your beliefs, your platform, but the way that you
07:07:34 engage with people and the way that you don't engage with people. And that remains to this day
07:07:40 my only issue with the McKay campaign and with McKay. Those are really good points. I've said
07:07:45 it several times. I try to keep an open mind with Peter McKay. And if he does win tonight, I think
07:07:49 that I'll have to take another opportunity to try to get to know him and to keep an open mind
07:07:54 about what he could stand for. But what you talk about is his sort of reluctancy to go into rooms
07:08:01 where he's unfamiliar and to go in and engage with different kinds of conservatives, that
07:08:06 does seem like a big red flag, especially given in light of some of the conversations
07:08:11 that we've had tonight with guests and just among ourselves about this issue of not just
07:08:16 unity within the party, but national unity.
07:08:19 And there are some really, really big questions and problems on the horizon that the leader
07:08:24 will have to really, really, you know, invest themselves into addressing and understanding
07:08:30 and trying to solve and what we've seen from mckay is sort of a reluctancy to engage with the
07:08:35 grassroots of the conservative party be it independent media like us or you know going
07:08:40 into other rooms where people might not be as receptive to him and trying to win people over
07:08:45 and it doesn't really seem like that's something that peter mckay has been all that willing or
07:08:49 interesting to do now maybe if he wins tonight becomes leader of the party he'll be forced to
07:08:54 do that and to to branch out and to broaden his appeal not just you know to the more
07:09:00 establishmenty kind of mainstream uh laurentian elites in ontario and quebec but also really you
07:09:08 know doing things that resonate uh with with the grassroots trying to connect with people
07:09:14 in other parts of the country and and really trying to understand a little bit more you know
07:09:18 what's what's going on in western canada what's going on in alberta how can we uh create policies
07:09:23 that bring this whole country together and, you know, not just conservative voters, but all
07:09:28 Canadians. Very much so. And I would point out as well that with Peter McKay and Aaron O'Toole and
07:09:34 all of the candidates in the race, I said something on my show that I think bears repeating
07:09:39 to this audience as well. A candidate is never going to be more conservative than when they are
07:09:44 seeking the conservative leadership. They're never going to be more accessible to conservative
07:09:49 media than when they're seeking the conservative leadership. They might maintain, they might get a
07:09:53 little bit less so, but they're never going to be more so. And I think that's hugely important for
07:09:58 a few reasons. Number one, if someone isn't going to do an interview with conservative media
07:10:02 when they are only seeking conservative votes, it's very difficult to imagine circumstances
07:10:09 under which in a general election, they would take the time to speak to conservative media. So
07:10:13 that's a big issue with Peter McKay. And by the way, I mean, if he is the winner tonight,
07:10:17 We're going to send an invitation to his campaign for a sit-down interview at 9 a.m. tomorrow.
07:10:23 And that invitation will be genuine and it will be a frank, candid, open discussion.
07:10:28 But I'm just not optimistic that they would accept given that they haven't up until this point.
07:10:34 And I think there is something in that to learn when it comes to policies.
07:10:38 When leadership campaigns are giving you red meat policies, you're probably not going to get everything in a general election platform, but you're going to get some things.
07:10:47 If a campaign is not giving you any of those things, they're never going to get more conservative and more bold. So you have to understand that. And the idea of the safe, cautious route, if they're doing that this early, it's not going to get any better after the leadership is over.
07:11:03 Oh, absolutely.
07:11:04 And, you know, one of the things that was sort of a knock Gates, Peter McKay, was that
07:11:08 the fact that he was endorsed by, you know, the fringe far left or the sort of most hated
07:11:14 figures among conservative, including, you know, the Toronto Star gave him an endorsement.
07:11:19 Charles Adler, longtime radio host, who used to be a strong, you know, reliable conservative
07:11:25 voice, but who's recently really gone off the rails in a sort of strange direction where
07:11:31 he really believes that conservatives deep down are these truly awful people he seems to have a
07:11:36 really big problem with jason kenny premier of alberta and you know really doesn't have a lot
07:11:42 of good things to say about any conservative idea or value uh well he's out there endorsing
07:11:49 peter mckay and so i think that's that's part of the reason why a lot of conservatives don't like
07:11:54 him is just because of the people who do like him are not the kind of people that we typically align
07:11:59 ourselves with i say i try to keep an open mind about peter bouquet because maybe it's time that
07:12:05 there's a conservative uh leader that's just really likable to the mainstream media that's
07:12:09 really palatable uh that sort of can break through in a way that other conservatives haven't
07:12:15 but then of course the the counter the flip side of that coin is that you know if you're resonating
07:12:21 so easily with the mainstream media who hates conservatives you're not really resonating with
07:12:26 your own side of the team and how are you going to keep the party together how are you going to keep
07:12:30 conservatives energized and excited to go out and vote for you because you know the people who
07:12:35 ultimately are going to help a conservative leader win is having mass support and excitement around
07:12:41 a candidate throughout the country in particular in western canada you can't start jeopardizing
07:12:46 some of those seats in alberta just because you think you know it's a shoe and we're seeing
07:12:51 other parties make a lot of inroads in alberta albert is not the solid blue block that it used
07:12:56 to be and so i think any conservative leader should be mindful of that i would agree and
07:13:02 when you talk about people like charles adler lining up to support peter mckay and a lot of
07:13:07 people i know who are on the left liberal or ndp that are supporting peter mckay there's an
07:13:12 important dynamic here that i i have to talk about for just a moment because this is what leads into
07:13:18 that idea of the electability myth, which is, I think, what it is. If you see in a leadership
07:13:24 people that aren't conservatives that are saying they support them, that proves that, oh, well,
07:13:28 in a general election, it means they're going to be bringing in all this other support.
07:13:31 And there are two issues with that. Number one, if you pick up support from the left at the expense
07:13:36 of support from the right, there has to be a question asked as to, are you actually a conservative?
07:13:42 And if a conservative wins by shedding their conservatism, I don't think it's a real win
07:13:47 overall. But the bigger question that I would raise is that, is that even going to hold up?
07:13:54 Because I find that the left generally loves certain conservatives up until the point that
07:13:59 they're actually the leader. And you get this all the time, whereas people will say,
07:14:03 oh, well, if so-and-so was the leader, I would vote conservative. And when they are,
07:14:08 they become the new Hitler. They become the new worst person in the world and this far-right bigot 0.69
07:14:12 and all that sort of stuff. And if Peter McKay, who right now is a darling of the media and of a lot
07:14:17 of centrists and center-left people were the leader. I have no doubt that he's just going to
07:14:21 be this far-right former Harper sycophant and that love that he had from the center is going to be
07:14:26 gone. I completely agree. It's interesting because sometimes we even see it the reverse.
07:14:33 And this is what happened. I think this is part of the way that the reason that paved the road
07:14:37 for Donald Trump to become president of the United States is that when you had sort of a
07:14:42 more mainstream, moderate conservative running
07:14:45 for the position of president in Mitt Romney, 0.70
07:14:48 he was painted as this awful misogynist.
07:14:51 Everything that he said was sort of taken out of context. 0.98
07:14:54 He was really painted as this like mean, horrible person.
07:14:57 You know, I remember there was one clip
07:15:00 that was taken from a debate where he was talking
07:15:03 about how he wanted to populate his cabinet with women.
07:15:06 And he wanted to point women 1.00
07:15:08 into all these different positions, which is, 1.00
07:15:10 you know, that's what the left wing loves.
07:15:11 what Justin Trudeau said and did but Mitt Romney kind of said in an awkward way he said you know
07:15:15 I've got binders full of women uh that I want to fill and the mainstream media took that to mean
07:15:22 something like totally different than what Mitt Romney was saying to try to say like oh look at
07:15:27 this sexist guy he thinks that women live in binders or whatever it became this whole meme
07:15:30 of the campaign it's like no obviously that's not what he was talking about that wasn't his intention
07:15:36 that's not what he meant but that was sort of the way that they took it so you know when you
07:15:40 do have these moderate conservatives to your point they're painting them as these horrible awful far
07:15:45 right figures and then after the fact now you know now that Mitt Romney is sort of an anti-Trump or
07:15:51 an ever-Trump or and comes out frequently to criticize Trump the mainstream media love him
07:15:57 and elevate him and pretend that he's this like noble voice that speaks for all conservatives
07:16:01 it's like well first of all why didn't you treat him this way when he was running for president
07:16:06 back in 2012 uh and how are we supposed to trust your judgment like you know you just can't be a
07:16:12 conservative seeking strange new respect from the media because no matter what the media is just
07:16:17 going to you know use what you say against you or they're going to paint you in positive light in 0.97
07:16:21 some circumstances and then stab you in the back later it's it's really a fool's errand uh andrew
07:16:26 to try to go after the love and admiration of the mainstream media because they're not your friends 0.99
07:16:30 especially if you're conservative they're they're just going to you know do something um to stab you
07:16:36 in the back so i think that peter mckay uh yeah should proceed with caution if that's his strategy
07:16:43 and that's his approach well yeah i mean did you ever think you'd see the day when uh people in the
07:16:48 media and on the left were saying why can't all republicans be like george w bush like i remember
07:16:52 when he was a war criminal and then in the era of trump it's oh you know i miss bush he was great
07:16:56 why can't they all be like bush and again i i look forward to the fact that in 15 20 years
07:17:01 some liberal columnist is going to be the first person to say if only republicans could be like
07:17:06 donald trump and because the cycle keeps going and going i mean michael chong who in the the 2017
07:17:13 leadership race was pretty much the the furthest to the left of the field he was the only one of
07:17:17 the 14 or so that was in support of a carbon tax if he had somehow won he would be subjected to
07:17:24 that same sort of song and dance that we're talking about now. And I think it really speaks
07:17:29 to Derek Sloan's point throughout the campaign, and to some extent, Erin O'Toole's and Leslyn
07:17:34 Lewis is that you have to just be yourself. And at the very least, then if you go down,
07:17:39 it will be on honest terms. Yeah, absolutely. Well, I will say I haven't yet seen the mainstream
07:17:46 media come around for Stephen Harper. I haven't heard them say, you know, we only wish that we
07:17:52 had a guy like Stephen Harper. So I think we're still a couple years away from that. But surely
07:17:57 it'll be interesting if the media ever does look back positively at a Trump administration
07:18:03 in any regard. Andrew, I think we have another clip that we're going to play. This one is
07:18:08 about Derek Sloan talking about how Conservatives need to campaign on their values. Let's play that
07:18:16 clip. Conservative campaigns have historically been about aversion to risk as you've seen and
07:18:23 I think a focus on, we heard the term throughout the Harper years of boutique tax credits and
07:18:28 focus solely on pocketbook issues. I know that you've put forward a vision that deals with
07:18:33 economic, fiscal issues, social issues, foreign policy. Do you fundamentally disagree with that
07:18:40 idea that when you're asking Canadians to vote for you, to vote for your party, that the economic
07:18:46 economics are where it's at. Well, okay, so let me put it, so yes, I guess I disagree with all of it,
07:18:53 but in a more nuanced way than how you phrased it. Please, how do you phrase it? Well, here, so I
07:18:58 definitely disagree with running on a platform of boutique tax credits. However you run, it needs
07:19:03 to be in a big, bold vision and not, you know, hey, Andrew, if you put your kid in soccer, I'll save
07:19:07 you 200 bucks. You know, like in this last election, we had people like, literally like, okay, I'm
07:19:12 going to save 25% of my cell phone if I vote liberal. I'm going to get 100 bucks if I put in
07:19:17 green lights or you know environmentally efficient lights. So it can't be about that. It has to be
07:19:23 about values. And I've said listen we need to we need to run on a freedom platform. In the BC
07:19:29 debate we saw a poll that was done online from people. We are back and now we go live to Ottawa
07:19:37 for the Conservative Party of Canada's results.
07:20:07 the exact representation of what our members want to see.
07:20:12 Excellent. So now the moment we've been waiting for, Dan.
07:20:15 Remember, ladies and gentlemen at home, the number is 16,901.
07:20:21 All right. So…
07:20:23 And the first place we're going to go to… Do you want to repeat it in French for me?
07:20:26 In French, the results are 16,901.
07:20:32 Excellent. And the first place we're going to go to is British Columbia.
07:20:36 How are you doing out there, Cathy and James?
07:20:40 We're doing well, thank you.
07:20:43 Finalement, hold on.
07:20:46 You're up.
07:20:47 Finalement, on a des chiffres.
07:20:48 Merci beaucoup.
07:20:49 Thank you, Dan.
07:20:50 Thank you, Lisa.
07:20:51 You can hear me all right?
07:20:52 Yes, thank you, James.
07:20:53 Very good.
07:20:54 La province de la Colombie-Britannique dispose un total de 4200 points.
07:20:59 Par ordre alphabétique, chaque candidat a obtenu le nombre de points suivant.
07:21:06 Leslyn Lewis a obtenu 1,047 points.
07:21:13 Peter McKay a reçu 1,281 points.
07:21:21 Erin O'Toole a reçu 1,255 points.
07:21:27 Derek Sloan a reçu 617 points.
07:21:32 so there are 4200 points available in the province of british columbia leslin lewis has earned 1047
07:21:45 points peter mckay has earned 1281 points aaron o'toole has earned 1255 points derek sloan has
07:21:59 earned 617 points and that's from british columbia thank you kathy thank you james okay merci and
07:22:07 now we will go on valley a la province la belle province the town of labrador judy and sharon are
07:22:12 you there and for those of you looking at home you can see that the british columbia results
07:22:21 have been posted on your screen judy and sharon are you there to give us the results from newfoundland
07:22:27 we're here excellent great there are 700 points available in the province of newfoundland and
07:22:34 labrador in alphabetical order each candidate has earned the following leslin lewis has earned 118
07:22:44 points peter mckay has earned 282 points
07:22:50 Aaron O'Toole, you got me. Aaron O'Toole has earned 240 points. Derek Sloan has earned 61 points.
07:23:09 Thank you. The results of TARDE-NEUV are the following.
07:23:14 Leslyn Lewis received 118 points.
07:23:18 Peter McKay received 282 points.
07:23:21 Erin O'Toole received 240 points.
07:23:24 Derek Sloan received 61 points.
07:23:29 Excellent. Thank you very much, Dan.
07:23:32 We are now going to go to Alberta.
07:23:34 So, Sonia and Dustin, tell us the results.
07:23:38 well thanks lisa and dan um and in alberta we have a total of 3 400 points and in alphabetical
07:23:47 order leslin lewis has earned 957 points peter mckay earned 826 points aaron o'toole earned 1084
07:23:59 points and derek sloan earned 532 points for a total of 3 400. over to you dustin
07:24:08 Lesley Lewis obtenu 957 points, Peter McKay obtenu 826 points,
07:24:16 Erin O'Toole obtenu 1,084 points, and Derek Sloan obtenu 532 points.
07:24:23 Thank you very much.
07:24:25 Thank you very much, Dustin. Thank you very much, Sonia.
07:24:28 And there you have the results for Alberta put up in front of you again.
07:24:32 Our next place that we're going to be going to is the province of Nova Scotia
07:24:36 and we're looking for Tara and Chris there there are 1100 points available in
07:24:46 the province of Nova Scotia in alphabetical order each candidate has
07:24:51 earned the following
07:25:04 Leslyn Lewis has earned 160 points.
07:25:10 Leslyn Lewis a obtenu 160 points.
07:25:15 Peter McKay has earned 710 points.
07:25:21 Peter McKay a obtenu 710 points.
07:25:26 Erin O'Toole has earned 142 points.
07:25:30 Aaron O'Toole a obtenu 142 points.
07:25:35 And Derek Sloan has earned 88 points.
07:25:40 Derek Sloan a obtenu 88 points.
07:25:45 Thank you very much.
07:25:49 And now we're going to Northern Canada to David Connolly.
07:25:53 And now we're going to Northern Canada to David Connolly.
07:25:57 David, are you there?
07:25:59 David's going to be announcing, of course, for Nunavut, for the Northwest Territories,
07:26:05 and for Yukon.
07:26:06 Of course.
07:26:07 So the three will be included in one announcement with David.
07:26:10 Okay.
07:26:11 David, are you there?
07:26:12 Yes, I am.
07:26:13 All right.
07:26:14 Go ahead.
07:26:15 Good evening from the North, and thank everyone for their patience and hanging in there this
07:26:19 evening.
07:26:20 There are a total of 300 points available from the combined three Northern Territories
07:26:26 of Nunavut, the Northwest Territories, and the Yukon.
07:26:31 Leslyn Lewis has earned 90 points.
07:26:35 Peter McKay has earned 111 points.
07:26:40 Erin O'Toole has earned 65 points.
07:26:44 And Derek Sloan has earned 35 points.
07:26:50 34 points, I correct, 34 points.
07:26:54 For the three territories of the North, the Norwood, the North-West, and the Yukon,
07:27:01 they have 300 points.
07:27:05 Leslie Lewis has obtained 90 points.
07:27:10 Peter McKay has obtained 511 points.
07:27:16 Aaron O'Toole has obtained 65 points.
07:27:21 and Derek's loan has obtained 34 times.
07:27:27 Thank you very much and good evening.
07:27:29 Thank you very much, David. We appreciate it.
07:27:32 And now, the next province we're going to,
07:27:33 it's the beautiful province of Prince Edward.
07:27:36 Next, we are going to the beautiful province of Prince Edward Island,
07:27:39 and we're going to Pat Binns and Gayle Shea.
07:27:41 Are you there?
07:27:43 We are, and there are 400 points available
07:27:46 in the province of Prince Edward Island,
07:27:49 in alphabetical order each candidate has earned the following leslin lewis has earned 96 points
07:27:59 peter mckay has earned 206 points erin o'toole has earned 55 points and derek sloan has earned 43 points
07:28:11 Thank you very much and in French, Leslyn Lewis had 96 points, Peter McKay had 206 points, Erin O'Toole had 55 points and Derek Sloan had 43 points. Thank you very much.
07:28:26 Thank you very much. Our next province is we're going to the province of Saskatchewan where we're going to be hearing from Kelly Block and Randy Hoback. So Kelly and Randy, do we have you on the line yet?
07:28:37 Thank you Lisa. In Saskatchewan we have 1400 points in play and the results in alphabetical
07:28:45 order are Leslie Lewis 554 points, Peter McKay 224 points, Erin O'Toole 369 points,
07:28:56 and Derek Sloan 252 points. Over to you Kelly.
07:29:06 de 1400 points. Leslie Lewis a obtenu 554 points. Peter McKay a obtenu 124 points. Erin
07:29:25 The keynote tour has obtained 369 points.
07:29:33 Derek Sloan has obtained 252 points.
07:29:42 Thank you very much.
07:29:45 And now we'll go to beautiful New Brunswick.
07:29:48 Monica and Mel, are you there?
07:29:53 We're just, we are just getting them.
07:30:02 As we're waiting, we have Saskatchewan.
07:30:05 We can take a look again at the results that we have there for Saskatchewan.
07:30:08 Les and Lewis, 554.
07:30:10 Aaron O'Toole, 369.
07:30:12 Derek Sloan, 252.
07:30:14 And Peter McKay, 224.
07:30:17 Okay.
07:30:19 And we have Mel Norton from New Brunswick.
07:30:22 Nell are you there? I am Dan and thank you everyone for hanging in with us. In New Brunswick
07:30:27 there are 1,000 points available from our province. In alphabetical order each candidate has earned
07:30:34 the following. Leslyn Lewis has earned 204 points. Peter McKay has earned 533 points.
07:30:44 Aaron O'Toole has earned 153 points, and Derek Sloan has earned 110 points.
07:30:54 All right, thank you very much, Mel.
07:30:56 And in French, Leslie Lewis has earned 204 points, Peter McKay has earned 533 points,
07:31:04 Aaron O'Toole has earned 153 points, and Derek Sloan has earned 110 points.
07:31:10 Great. And our next province, as we take a look at those New Brunswick results one more time,
07:31:17 our next province is we're going to Manitoba. And there we have Candace Bergen and Heather
07:31:23 Stephenson. Thanks very much, Lisa and Dan. There are 1,400 points available in the province of
07:31:31 Manitoba. In alphabetical order, each candidate has earned the following. Leslyn Lewis has earned
07:31:38 360 points. Peter McKay has earned 414 points. Erin O'Toole has earned 373 points. And Derek
07:31:51 Sloan has earned 253 points.
07:31:55 Okay, merci beaucoup. Et en français, Leslyn Lewis a reçu 360 points. Peter McKay a reçu
07:32:01 414 points. Aaron O'Toole a reçu 373 points. Et Derek Sloan a reçu 253 points.
07:32:10 Et là, nous allons au Québec. Alain et Marie-Josée, êtes-vous là?
07:32:15 Oui. Oui, allĂ´?
07:32:19 Bonjour.
07:32:20 Donc, pour la province de Québec, dispose au total de 7800 points.
07:32:25 There are 7,800 points available in the province of Québec.
07:32:31 Alors, pour Leslie Lewis, 781 points, 781 points.
07:32:40 Pour Peter McKay, 2,685 points, 2,685 points.
07:32:49 For Erin O'Toole, 3,532 points, 3,532 points, Derek Sloan, 802 points, 802 points.
07:33:05 Excellent. Thank you very much, Marie-Josée. Sorry about that. So, for Quebec, we have the
07:33:11 numbers up there for Erin O'Toole, Peter McKay, Derek Sloan, and Leslyn Lewis. And going to our
07:33:18 We're heading back here to Ontario where it's going to be Minister Caroline Mulroney and Gary Clement.
07:33:25 Thank you very much, Lisa and Dan.
07:33:29 The province of Ontario has a total of 12,100 points.
07:33:34 In alphabetical order, each candidate has obtained the number of points.
07:33:39 There are 12,100 points available in the province of Ontario.
07:33:49 In alphabetical order, each candidate earned the following.
07:33:54 Leslyn Lewis earned 2,557 points.
07:33:58 Leslyn Lewis a obtenu 2,557 points.
07:34:04 Peter McKay earned 4,056 points.
07:34:08 Peter McKay a obtenu 4,056 points.
07:34:13 Aaron O'Toole earned 3,414 points.
07:34:18 Aaron O'Toole a obtenu 3,414 points.
07:34:23 Derek Sloan earned 2,073 points.
07:34:27 Derek Sloan a obtenu 2,073 points.
07:34:33 Thank you very much.
07:34:34 Appreciate that.
07:34:34 So in Ontario, Peter McKay, 4,056.
07:34:38 Erin O'Toole, 3414, Leslie Lewis, 2557, and Derek Sloan, 2073, and we are going to be able to see a live shot from the candidates' suites, and we're going to pull that up for you as we announce the results for the national vote.
07:35:00 So, Dan, over to you.
07:35:02 Okay, the results for the first vote.
07:35:04 Peter McKay, 11,328 points.
07:35:08 Erin O'Toole, 10,681 points.
07:35:12 Leslyn Lewis, 6,925 points.
07:35:16 Derek Sloan, 4,864 points.
07:35:19 That means that Mr. Sloan is eliminated and we will have a second vote.
07:35:23 So, on this national ballot in English, Mr. McKay, 11,328 votes.
07:35:29 votes. Mr. O'Toole, 10,681 votes. Ms. Lewis, 6,925 votes. Mr. Sloan, 4,864 votes. Mr. Sloan
07:35:40 drops off the ballot and we move to a second ballot.
07:35:59 We are going to reset, so we can go back for our second ballot, so we'll be rejoining
07:36:05 you in a moment.
07:36:06 But I'm sure, Dan, there's lots to talk about.
07:36:08 These numbers, I'm sure there's got a lot of people talking across the country.
07:36:11 It was fantastic to see what the results were like from coast to coast to coast.
07:36:16 Absolutely.
07:36:17 And thank you again to our regional announcers.
07:36:19 Merci beaucoup à nos annonceurs régional et à avoir resté avec nous autres.
07:36:23 Et on va prendre une courte pause pour avoir le deuxième scrutin.
07:36:28 Merci beaucoup.
07:36:29 We'll be back.
07:36:29 Thank you.
07:36:44 Well, that was the first round of voting,
07:36:47 the first round of counting, rather,
07:36:49 releasing those results from the Conservative Party of Canada viewing party.
07:36:53 There is a lot in this,
07:36:55 and I can say that there is a lot of speculation that these results from
07:36:59 round one are suggesting an Aaron O'Toole win. We're going to go over the numbers with you again.
07:37:04 Peter McKay is leading in the first round of national results. He has 11,328 points. Aaron
07:37:11 O'Toole trails behind by less than a thousand with 10,681. And Leslie Lewis has just under 7,000,
07:37:21 6,925 votes with Derek Sloan at 4,864 points, rather. Sorry, I said votes points. So just to
07:37:31 round it, McKay at 11,000, O'Toole at 10,700, Lewis at 7,000 roughly, and Derek Sloan in fourth
07:37:40 place at 4,800. Sloan has been eliminated. So when the second round of votes are counted,
07:37:47 it will be with all of the people who had Sloan as their number one,
07:37:50 it will be the reallocation based on the second choice of those.
07:37:54 Now, you don't need to rank your ballot.
07:37:56 If some people put only Sloan, then those numbers will just dissipate.
07:38:01 They'll fall off.
07:38:02 But anyone who put Sloan one and someone else number two,
07:38:05 those number two votes will be retabulated and we start again.
07:38:09 I mean, these are hugely impressive numbers for Leslie Lewis.
07:38:13 In a couple of provinces, she actually was beating O'Toole and McCain.
07:38:17 namely Alberta and Saskatchewan.
07:38:19 O'Toole had huge support in Quebec,
07:38:22 which I found a bit surprising,
07:38:24 although we mentioned earlier
07:38:25 that he had a specific Quebec platform.
07:38:28 So that may have been a role played there.
07:38:30 Peter McKay, no surprise,
07:38:32 won in Atlantic Canada by a huge margin.
07:38:35 Lesley Lewis, though,
07:38:36 she did very well in BC, Alberta, Saskatchewan,
07:38:40 but fell short, relatively speaking, in Ontario,
07:38:43 which is where she ended up falling back.
07:38:46 Candice, any big surprises from the first round?
07:38:49 Well, I'll just say I don't think that Peter McKay did what he needed to do here.
07:38:53 I think that, yeah, sure, he won in Atlantic Canada,
07:38:56 but he wasn't posting huge, big numbers.
07:38:59 I think that it's very, very close at this point.
07:39:02 It's really going to come down to the views that social conservatives have.
07:39:07 You know, if Derek Sloan votes go toward who they're going to go towards.
07:39:11 I think Leslie Lewis really, really outperformed pretty much what anyone was expecting.
07:39:15 It's really exciting to see her come in first place in Saskatchewan and second place in Alberta.
07:39:21 You know, for all we hear about the fact that Conservatives are these closed-minded people who
07:39:27 hate immigrants and hate people who look differently. You know, the base and the
07:39:31 grassroots of the party really have delivered a huge victory for Leslie Lewis. And there were times,
07:39:38 i mean before the ontario and quebec results came in she was neck and neck they were all within one
07:39:42 percent according to my tabulations which are a little off because you know i was just jotting
07:39:47 them down as we went but i i think that it's it's incredibly close it's going to come down to the
07:39:53 wire and uh i mean i i wish they would just announce results already because this is really
07:40:00 starting to drag on but we're getting into the exciting moments here and uh looks like we are
07:40:06 are back onto the live stream, Andrew.
07:40:15 Open the stream, but I don't see anything happen yet.
07:40:17 So I'll point out while we're waiting
07:40:19 a couple of analytics facts here.
07:40:22 So McKay at 11.3, Aaron O'Toole at 10.6,
07:40:26 Lewis at 6.9 and Sloan out.
07:40:29 Now there are 4,864 points from Derek Sloan
07:40:33 that are theoretically up for grabs now.
07:40:35 So we don't know what percentage of people just put Sloan and no one else and what percentage
07:40:41 of people ranked a second choice.
07:40:43 But I want to just put these numbers here because at 4,800 votes, if 4,000 of those
07:40:50 went to Lesley Lewis, she would eclipse O'Toole and she would only be a few hundred points
07:40:57 behind McKay.
07:40:58 Now, that would be a significant margin, but we do know that the social conservative groups
07:41:02 we're pushing either Lewis Sloan or Sloan Lewis as being the top two choices so this is where you
07:41:09 have to start looking at again that down ballot support you have to look at the Sloan plus Lewis
07:41:14 numbers combined which again not taking into account drop-off would actually put us at over
07:41:21 11,000 if everyone from Sloan broke for Lewis which would actually put her in the lead now
07:41:26 that would be based on again everyone doing a certain thing which is always a bad assumption
07:41:31 in politics. But we're looking at numbers here that suggest, I mean, we had said that Peter
07:41:37 McCain needed to have a really strong showing on the first ballot, either a win or not far behind
07:41:42 50%. And he is nowhere close to that right now. So this is, again, it's possible that things could
07:41:49 break a little bit differently here. Lesley Lewis has a base of support that is not just
07:41:55 social conservatives. But doing this and looking at the numbers this way, it's easy to see a path
07:42:02 to victory for Aaron O'Toole, easier to see that than a path to victory for Peter McKay based on
07:42:07 these numbers. I just got to say, I need to say it's really exciting in general, you know, even
07:42:13 the fact that Derek Sloan did as well as he did, nearly 15% of the vote, it's nothing to shake your
07:42:18 head at. That is a really tremendous standing. And the fact that now his voters, so the people
07:42:24 who support him and got behind him, they're now in the kingmaker position because really anything
07:42:30 could happen at this point. To your point that you just made, Andrew, you know, 4,800 votes
07:42:36 going towards any of those campaigns, we could potentially see Peter McKay get knocked off the
07:42:41 list, go from first to last in this ballot, depending on how Derek Sloan's voters chose
07:42:47 to rank their second person. You know, if it is really an alliance of pro-life social conservatives
07:42:53 and they all go towards Leslyn Lewis, potentially we could see Leslyn Lewis winning this whole thing
07:42:59 just based on the support of those Derek Sloan voters. So really, you know, we can't make any
07:43:05 predictions at this point because we still have so much information that needs to get filled in,
07:43:10 but it's really close. It shows sort of a little bit of the divide that's happening in the country,
07:43:16 how different the results were in eastern Canada than they were in western Canada. I was a little
07:43:20 surprised that Peter McKay won in Ontario. I would have assumed that that would sort of be
07:43:25 the place where Aaron O'Toole would shine and do his best, given that's where he's from
07:43:31 and that's where he lives. But I guess, you know, when we talk about the supposed moderate
07:43:36 conservative vote, I suppose that's coming from Ontario. And so those people were the ones that
07:43:41 got behind Peter McKay. But what do you think is going to happen next, Andrew?
07:43:46 Well, again, it's going to look at, I think drop off is going to be the real question here. How
07:43:51 many people continue and rank their full ballot versus just drop off because they only liked one
07:43:56 candidate or two candidates? I mean, it would be possible. And again, I'm not saying probable,
07:44:01 but possible for Lesley and Lewis to get to first place if the Sloan to Lewis pipeline of the
07:44:08 ranking is really, really strong. That would have to be really strong, but it's possible. But
07:44:13 certainly I would agree with you wholeheartedly that I was surprised that neither candidate had
07:44:18 a stronger showing in Ontario. I thought that with how much of an emphasis was being put there,
07:44:24 that would be the key battleground. I thought we'd see something a bit more decisive there,
07:44:27 but we didn't. No, we didn't. And again, I just don't think that Peter McKay got the votes to
07:44:33 your point. I think that he really needed to have a strong showing on that first ballot,
07:44:37 just because, you know, the other candidates seem more aligned with each other and more likely
07:44:43 that Derek Sloan's votes will go towards Lesley Lewis or Erin O'Toole. At least they're more
07:44:48 open-minded and open towards all the social conservative issues. Obviously, Lesley Lewis
07:44:52 herself is a social conservative as well, but I think that Peter McKay is going to be in trouble
07:44:58 when these ballots come in. Andrew, do we have any idea how long this pauses and when we're going to
07:45:03 hear the next round of votes? No, and this is a little bit of an annoyance, if I do say so myself,
07:45:09 because I, we, we are right now looking at something that I think is more readily available
07:45:14 to be described as theater than any substantive delay. This is at this point, they know the
07:45:19 results they're in the computer system. I mean, maybe it's lining up all the different provincial
07:45:23 representatives on zoom, or maybe it's putting the graphics together with the numbers. But at
07:45:28 this point, it seems unnecessary to take a break when the whole point of the first round of
07:45:32 balloting is that we have the numbers available. Yeah. I, you know, you can forgive the delays.
07:45:39 all along because of all the problems they had with their voting machines but it's a good point
07:45:43 at this point you know they know I was even wondering why they bothered with the whole
07:45:47 pageantry of going province by province but I'm sure you know everyone wants to have their their
07:45:52 moment to get to announce their you know votes and they want to have their moment where they get
07:45:58 a little bit of recognition but again you know it's it's now one o'clock in the morning nearly
07:46:03 in Toronto later out on the east coast and I think that we're all just sort of ready to
07:46:09 to learn the results and sort of move on with our lives. So hopefully we get the next ballot
07:46:15 pretty soon. But I guess the next ballot could be the end of the night, in which case, you know,
07:46:21 then they are trying to drag it out for some reason. Yeah, that would actually be fairly
07:46:26 difficult, I think. But to be honest, I actually think, no, I think that would be impossible. We
07:46:30 need to go to three ballots at this point. The magic number is, if I'm not mistaken,
07:46:36 in 16,000, but I might be off on that now. So no, correct me if I'm wrong. I'm mixing up two
07:46:44 numbers here. So when we look at this, I am suspecting it will go to the third ballot,
07:46:49 but I would also point out as well, and we've spent a fair bit of the show talking about social
07:46:54 conservative support and how much that was doing for Lewis and Sloan. And we had Steve Outhouse
07:46:59 from the Lesley Lewis campaign on twice tonight. And he was saying that he thinks that she's
07:47:04 tapped into something that's bigger than that. And these numbers would really suggest that's true
07:47:09 because yes, there is a huge social conservative support base, but at the same time, there also
07:47:15 has to be more than that. I mean, that's enough to give you a solid block. It's not enough to
07:47:19 give you a win. And if she's focused to being, if she's targeting right now, a figure that could
07:47:25 be in first or second place, that's more than just SOCONs. Absolutely. That's a really good
07:47:30 point and if you just uh you know just quickly looking at the numbers here if you add leslie
07:47:35 lewis's support with derek slone's support you've got 35 30 36 almost which is more than either
07:47:42 mckay or o'toole so it is a good reminder that a very solid large percent of the conservative party
07:47:50 continues to be pro-life conservatives and i think that every time that there is a leadership race or
07:47:56 or anytime there's a vote like this, people are surprised,
07:47:59 particularly our friends over in Legacy Media
07:48:02 and over at the CBC,
07:48:03 always surprised by how well pro-life candidates do.
07:48:07 Well, the reality is that a large portion of Canadians,
07:48:11 a large portion of people
07:48:12 who are part of the Conservative Party,
07:48:14 that's one of their firmly held beliefs.
07:48:16 So I'm not necessarily surprised with how well
07:48:20 the pro-life candidates did in this campaign so far,
07:48:24 just very different than I think
07:48:25 what the predictions were coming from our friends over in the mainstream media and again the ability
07:48:30 to be kingmaker I think that you're right that I'm looking at how many points each candidate
07:48:35 needs to win it looks like Peter McKay would need another 5,800 points and Aaron O'Toole would need
07:48:42 another 6,200 and so Derek Sloan's 4,800 won't be enough to push either of them over the edge so
07:48:49 you know we could have a different first place candidate at the end of the next ballot but it
07:48:54 looks like we will have to go to three ballots on this night. I want to focus for just a moment
07:49:01 on Quebec numbers. So Quebec has 7,800 points available. And I was, to be honest, I wasn't sure
07:49:08 how Quebec would ultimately shake out. Now it's important to note we're talking about conservative
07:49:12 members in Quebec, not a huge population compared to the province at large. It's not like general
07:49:18 election results. And some of these ridings, as we talked about earlier, only have a small handful
07:49:23 of members. So if you can win those over, which comes down to strategy, you can do very well in
07:49:28 the points because it is the second most riding rich and thus point rich province in Canada.
07:49:34 But I would point out that it was really surprising to see O'Toole come out very strong there. In
07:49:40 fact, I think it was his biggest margin just by virtue of the province size and not winning
07:49:44 Ontario. In Quebec, Leslyn Lewis had 781. Peter McKay had 2685. Aaron O'Toole had 3532. And Derek
07:49:54 Sloan had 802. And this is where you have to wonder how much the language effect played into
07:50:00 things here. Because there was a lot of mocking Peter McKay earlier on for mixing up a French word
07:50:06 when he announced his campaign. Aaron O'Toole tried to say that he was bilingual, but people
07:50:10 raised some issues with his French. Lesley Lewis gave a really, really bad performance in that
07:50:16 French debate because she's not a French speaker. She was reading and I don't think she looked up
07:50:20 for the entire time. Derek Sloan was rocky, but he was a bit more engaged. He was looking up,
07:50:25 like he was looking back and forth. Whereas for Lesley Lewis, she was reading it because she
07:50:29 didn't know the language. And both Lewis and Sloan have said they've continued to work on their
07:50:35 French. But I have to wonder, and again, it's subtle, we're talking about a difference of 21
07:50:40 points overall. But I have to wonder if that French debate performance was really a determining factor
07:50:46 in where those Quebec votes landed. Yeah, that's an interesting perspective. And again, for all the
07:50:52 hey that media make over an ability to speak French for the candidates. I mean, I don't really
07:50:59 know that it does move that many votes in Quebec. I think that the point that we raised earlier,
07:51:04 I think we were probably one of the only media outlets to report on this and to raise this,
07:51:09 was the fact that Aaron O'Toole was able to reach a whole bunch of rural voters in Quebec
07:51:17 with his gun policies and that gun owners and people who were really alarmed by Justin Trudeau's
07:51:24 gun grab were showing up in droves to support Aaron O'Toole. It's a lot easier to win points
07:51:30 in Quebec just because there aren't that many conservative voters and conservative members
07:51:35 in some ridings and so you don't need that many people to come out and change but you know if you
07:51:39 have a targeted campaign issue like that like gun rights which I think Erin O'Toole did kind of
07:51:46 come out above and beyond the other candidates even though we did talk about how all candidates
07:51:50 were supportive of gun owners and all opposed Justin Trudeau's gun grabs. Erin O'Toole really
07:51:55 made that effort. I think that was a real part of the reason why he was able to win so many points
07:52:00 in Quebec. Yeah, someone pointed out on Twitter, unfortunately, the tweet kind of went off my
07:52:06 timeline when I refreshed, so I don't know who to give credit for it. But that all candidates have
07:52:11 had lots of time today alone to learn French in the course of reading the results. So it's very
07:52:16 likely that anyone who didn't speak French before will be able to now. So we are just minutes away,
07:52:22 it sounds like from the round two results coming. And again, we've crunched the numbers and it
07:52:27 doesn't sound like it's possible for there to be a winner on the second ballot. So we are in this
07:52:33 for the long haul. And we don't have like CNN does, John King in the corner with the big smart
07:52:38 board doing all of the calculations and permutations. In fact, I think our math guy
07:52:43 went to bed. So you're stuck with Candace and I right now. But I do think that when we look at
07:52:49 this, it completely vindicates all of the people that have been talking about Lesley
07:52:54 Lewis's rise.
07:52:55 I mean, it's not theoretical at this point.
07:52:57 The fact that she has these numbers and was beating the supposed front runners in some
07:53:02 provinces and pretty key provinces to the conservative movement, I think, is a huge
07:53:08 endorsement for her and for her campaign team.
07:53:10 And props to Steve Outhouse, who we talked to tonight for doing that.
07:53:13 I would also point out when we spoke earlier about how some of these really high density 0.90
07:53:20 ridings have thousands of members, that means that for her to do well in those ridings took
07:53:26 a lot more effort than some of the winners of the ridings that don't have a strong conservative 0.88
07:53:32 base.
07:53:32 And this is not to say that there's anything unfair about it because you have to play to
07:53:36 the rules and you play to the system.
07:53:38 But if she's winning huge support in ridings that have thousands and thousands and thousands
07:53:43 of conservative members. That's showing a real mass appeal that can't be ignored. 0.90
07:53:49 Absolutely. I agree. I'm just going through the numbers a little more closely. It looks like
07:53:53 Lesley Lewis won in British Columbia. In Alberta, she beat out Peter McKay, got more than 100 more
07:54:00 points than McKay did. In Nova Scotia, she beat Erin O'Toole. What else do we have? In Northern
07:54:07 Canada, so the three territories, she beat Erin O'Toole. I mean, it's just really remarkable how
07:54:13 well she did in in beating uh you know some of these establishment politicians who probably you
07:54:19 know much more experienced in much bigger campaign teams in prince of rhode island uh she beat out
07:54:24 erin o'toole uh in new brunswick she beat out erin o'toole in ontario she came in third in quebec
07:54:32 she came in fourth in saskatchewan she won and in manitoba she was very close to uh to to erin
07:54:41 O'Toole and Peter McKay won over there so really across the country she definitely you know appealed
07:54:48 to to conservative voters and I think that's great again for the party hopefully she can bring a lot
07:54:54 of that energy into the general election if there is one and and help maintain more outreach and
07:55:02 reaching a broader range of Canadians aside from just you know the people who the mainstream media
07:55:07 believe are conservative voters, which isn't really an accurate portrayal of the country at
07:55:12 this point. And I do think that even if Aaron O'Toole, or for that matter, Peter McKay wins
07:55:17 tonight, if there is a real, I don't want to say a loss, but somewhat of an embarrassment,
07:55:23 and this is not to discount Lesley Lewis's campaign, but when you come in with the fundraising,
07:55:28 with the name recognition, and you still have to work for it to someone who has just showed up out
07:55:34 of the blue, basically. What does that say about you? And there's always that question of,
07:55:39 is it a reflection of Lesley Lewis doing really well? Or is it a reflection of Erin O'Toole and
07:55:44 Peter McKay not exciting people? Well, I think it's probably a combination of both. And that's
07:55:53 not to say that McKay and O'Toole didn't run good campaigns. I'm sure they did. And they had good
07:55:59 policy. I think particularly Erin O'Toole had some really interesting and new policy ideas. But
07:56:05 I just think that there is a caricature of what a conservative is in this country and what they
07:56:11 look like and how they sound. And Leslie Lewis just sort of defies that. And that's what makes
07:56:16 her interesting. She has a different background. You know, I'm not one to obsess over identity
07:56:21 politics. I don't think that that's all that matters is someone's identity. But just given
07:56:26 the fact that so many of the critiques and the stereotypes and the negative things that get said
07:56:31 about conservatives in canada and a lot of it is driven by the mainstream media are about one very
07:56:37 specific stereotype of a conservative being sort of you know uh angry old white male probably from
07:56:44 western canada probably not very well educated and all that kind of stuff uh it's obviously not true
07:56:49 it is not accurate representation of the conservative party or the conservative movement
07:56:54 but that's what the stereotype is and so when you have people that just clearly defy that and you
07:56:59 can't you know put them into a box and write them off in the same way as you can other candidates
07:57:05 it's just exciting in general and so obviously you know the whole old white male uh image is
07:57:11 something that either erin o'toole or peter mckay will have to shake and and try to get past whereas
07:57:17 leslie lewis has an inherent advantage in that she just isn't that and so because of that she's
07:57:22 she's able to, I think, break out of that box and appeal to different types of Canadians.
07:57:27 It is just coming up on 1 a.m. on August 24th on the East Coast, Eastern Standard, not the East
07:57:34 Coast, Eastern Standard Time or Eastern Daylight Time, not the East Coast. I don't want to get
07:57:38 jumped on by Devin Drover and our Atlantic Canadian friends who I don't know if they're
07:57:42 still up or not. We have been rolling for my math is no longer working. I've been devoting it to
07:57:47 points. I think seven and a half hours now we have been on and we've gotten our second or third win
07:57:52 because things have started to pick up with results. This is the True North Live Conservative
07:57:58 Leadership Results Show. We are still waiting for the Conservative Party of Canada's release
07:58:04 of the second round of votes. Just to recap, in the first round, Derek Sloan was eliminated. He had
07:58:11 4,864 points. Leslyn Lewis is now in third place with 6,925 points. In second place is Aaron O'Toole
07:58:23 with 10,681 points. And in the lead, Peter McKay has 11,328 points. So as you can see from those
07:58:34 numbers, if you're looking at them on your screen somewhere, we're looking at less than 700
07:58:39 separating O'Toole and McKay. You're looking at a little over three, three and a half thousand
07:58:46 separating Lewis from O'Toole and 4,864 points conceivably being reallocated. If everyone on
07:58:55 Derek Sloan's support list has ranked a second choice, then we have 4,864 points up for grabs.
07:59:02 So again, we still have some, some different ways that this could go. Possible that Leslie and
07:59:08 Lewis could eke out a victory. Difficult, but there's a way to do it. And it would depend on
07:59:13 if she and Sloan had a really strong one-two punch, basically, where everyone who had Lewis
07:59:20 first was putting Sloan second or vice versa. And again, I won't say it can't happen. I think
07:59:24 the fact that Lewis has these numbers already is showing us that the unforeseeable or the unlikely
07:59:30 is, in fact, possible. Right. And now it's confirmed that, you know, it wasn't just rumors
07:59:36 is saying that Lesley Lewis overperformed or outperformed expectations, we have the hard
07:59:41 data for it. And interesting tidbit, Andrew, I saw during close to the end of the campaign,
07:59:47 there was a flyer that was mailed out to many conservative members from Lesley Lewis. I don't
07:59:53 know if it was across the whole country or just in some writings, where she basically just said,
07:59:58 you know, thank you for being a conservative member. I know I'm not your first pick,
08:00:03 but I humbly ask you to put me as number two. And I thought that was an interesting ask because
08:00:09 usually as a politician, you know, you're not asking to be someone second choice. You're asking
08:00:13 to be their number one choice. You want to win. You want to have the most votes. And so for her
08:00:19 to send out a dedicated flyer asking conservative members to consider putting her number two,
08:00:25 I mean, it was just, it was a nice thoughtful card. And I think a lot of people who didn't
08:00:29 really maybe give her a chance might have at that point considered hey okay I'll put her number two
08:00:34 this seems like a good person that we want as part of our party and part of the leadership of our
08:00:39 party you know I wonder maybe maybe something like that as a tactic at a moment like this
08:00:44 is going to pay off for her because if if conservative members did listen to that flyer 0.99
08:00:50 take it to heart decide to put her number two it could be enough in this moment for her to 0.99
08:00:54 really be a spoiler right now and eliminate Peter McKay, leading to a Lewis-O'Toole showdown in the
08:01:02 end, which, you know, is not what we expect. I think at this moment, the expectation is that
08:01:07 Les and Lewis will get eliminated next, and then we'll have the O'Toole-McKay show-off, which is
08:01:13 dual, which is what we really kind of expected from the outset. So if Les and Lewis is able to
08:01:19 pull out those number two rankings, I think it would be a huge, huge upset. And that would,
08:01:25 regardless of who becomes the leader, that would be the big story of the night.
08:01:30 Yeah. And I would also add to that, that when we see this happen and when we see these results,
08:01:37 it makes it, I think, more important for the eventual conservative leader to know that you
08:01:44 cannot take social conservatives for granted expect their support and then turn around and
08:01:52 not give them anything back for it they're here to stay and that's a reality so I think that this
08:01:58 is important to send a message and a lot of people even if they thought Derek Sloan wouldn't win I
08:02:02 think voted for him because they wanted the party to know that yeah we're here absolutely and again
08:02:08 not just pro-life conservatives or social conservatives uh but we've talked about it a
08:02:12 it throughout this program, Andrew, about how Derek Sloan didn't really just fit into a box.
08:02:17 You know, part of the reason that so many people who maybe didn't know about him before
08:02:21 ended up putting their sport behind him, or even, I think, people who might have left the
08:02:26 Conservative Party to go with Maxine Bernier came back to give Derek Sloan a chance. It's because
08:02:32 he just said what he thought. He didn't seem overly scripted. He called things out. He was
08:02:37 really one of the only ones being fiercely critical of the response of the Trudeau government working
08:02:44 with the World Health Organization pointing out some of the major flaws in that organization and
08:02:48 how it was handling coronavirus the really really just awful advice we're getting from Canada's
08:02:55 chief medical officer Theresa Tam calling for her to be fired even if it was sort of a clunky
08:03:00 address that the media made a lot of hay out of you know that's the sentiment that a lot of Canadians
08:03:05 are behind and feel that way.
08:03:07 And he was one of the only ones calling him out.
08:03:09 So I wouldn't just say that Derek Sloan's supporters
08:03:12 were just pro-life people.
08:03:14 I think that there was a broad range of people
08:03:15 that supported them.
08:03:17 But again, it's a good reminder
08:03:20 that a good portion of this party is pro-life.
08:03:24 It shouldn't be taken for granted.
08:03:25 We are going now, someone from Deloitte is speaking
08:03:29 at the Conservative Party event.
08:03:31 We go to that live.
08:03:32 20, Conservative Party of Canada, leadership election.
08:03:35 Today we have performed specified procedures over the calculation of the total points
08:03:39 received by each leadership candidate in connection with the election result.
08:03:44 As a result of applying the procedures, we found no exceptions.
08:03:48 However, these procedures do not constitute an audit of the election result
08:03:51 and accordingly we do not express an opinion on such information.
08:03:55 Thank you. And with that, Dan and Lisa, I'm going to give you the results for round two and three.
08:04:00 Okay, thank you.
08:04:03 Thank you, Doreen.
08:04:05 It's very helpful.
08:04:06 So, we will…
08:04:07 So, the first thing to do,
08:04:09 the first thing we're going to mention,
08:04:10 is that we're going to give the results
08:04:13 of the national report.
08:04:16 We're not going to do the regions
08:04:18 for the next results.
08:04:20 So, we're going to do that for the second report.
08:04:25 Are we ready with the results?
08:04:29 Are we ready with the second round results?
08:04:32 Okay.
08:04:33 We are ready to go.
08:04:34 Okay.
08:04:35 On ordre alphabétique.
08:04:39 Leslyn Lewis, 10,140 points.
08:04:44 Peter McKay, 11,756 points.
08:04:50 And Erno Toole, 11,903 points.
08:04:54 Ms. Lewis, we thank you and thank you for participating with a Grand Macar campaign.
08:05:24 Okay.
08:05:27 And with that, are we ready with the results of the third scrutin?
08:05:35 This is it. Yeah.
08:05:38 Okay.
08:05:41 And the results of the third scrutin. 1.00
08:05:44 Ms. Lewis falls off this ballot. We proceed to the third.
08:05:47 And I want to thank you very much for her participation in this leadership.
08:05:52 points. Le gagnant est le prochain chef du Parti conservateur, Erin O'Toole, avec 19,261 points.
08:06:00 Est-ce qu'on est prêt avec les résultats du troisième scrutin?
08:06:02 OK.
08:06:06 Et les résultats du troisième scrutin.
08:06:12 Ms. Lewis calls off this ballot we proceed to the third part of the Conservative Party of January.
08:06:17 Congratulations, Mr. O'Toole.
08:06:20 And thank you to the next chief and party conservator,
08:06:24 Erin O'Toole, with 19,260 points.
08:06:33 Now, if you're wondering what's coming next…
08:06:42 Can we go?
08:06:48 Are we done?
08:06:49 Oh, thank you.
08:07:12 Well, as you can see, there are a lot of celebration from the Erin O'Toole Watch Party.
08:07:37 if you've just missed it. Aaron O'Toole has been elected Conservative Party of Canada leader. It was
08:07:44 on the third ballot as predicted. The final score had Aaron O'Toole at 19,271 points and Peter
08:07:52 McKay at 14,528 points. Although it was interesting how close that number was in round two with
08:07:59 Leslie Lewis, Peter McKay, and Aaron O'Toole all in many respects. I mean, neck and neck.
08:08:04 Leslyn Lewis had 10,140 points. McKay had 11,756. Aaron O'Toole had 11,903. And when Leslyn Lewis 0.61
08:08:16 dropped off, Aaron O'Toole picked up 8,000 votes almost. And McKay just picked up about 3,000.
08:08:23 And that are about 7,000 to 3,000. And that was what we predicted when we saw that first ballot.
08:08:29 but Erin O'Toole wins.
08:08:30 Candice, immediate reactions to this 0.85
08:08:32 while we wait for the acceptance speech from Erin O'Toole.
08:08:35 Any moment now.
08:08:37 Well, first I just wanna say congratulations
08:08:39 to all the candidates.
08:08:40 I think that we've talked a lot throughout this show.
08:08:43 We've had to fill what, eight hours of time here
08:08:47 unexpectedly, Andrew.
08:08:48 So we've said everything we've ever thought
08:08:50 about any of the candidates on air,
08:08:52 but I think it's an exciting moment
08:08:54 for the Conservative Party,
08:08:56 the Conservative movement more broadly. 0.96
08:08:58 great to see someone like Erin O'Toole pulling it off. It wasn't really even that close in the end.
08:09:03 He won by, I think, 6,000 points over Peter McKay based on that last ballot. Great to see
08:09:09 Les and Lewis do such a strong showing. Again, you know, it wasn't her and O'Toole at the end,
08:09:17 like I thought maybe it would be, but still a really great showing. And I hope she does fall
08:09:20 through and run as an MP for the Conservatives and becomes a strong voice for that party
08:09:26 in ottawa but i i think really this was a big surprise upset for peter mckay he he didn't he
08:09:32 didn't get it done he didn't do what he needed to do considering that he was the front runner
08:09:37 and that so many people thought that it was a coronation and that he was the heir apparent of
08:09:42 the party well i think the party had uh another idea about things and again i think that the
08:09:48 difference probably did come down to how those pro-life voters voted the second ballot third
08:09:54 ballot, giving more and more votes to Aaron O'Toole. So I think, you know, to anyone considering
08:10:01 running for conservative politics in the future, you know, ignore and neglect the conservative base
08:10:08 at your own Perel, because really, that was the difference tonight.
08:10:13 Yeah, I think that's a really spot on analysis. And I'm glad you gave it, Candace, because this
08:10:17 was a grassroots victory. And also, I think we can say that Aaron O'Toole, obviously, he worked
08:10:22 hard. His team worked hard. But I think it's fair to say that Leslie Lewis delivered that victory
08:10:27 for him. And that's something that needs to be acknowledged. She said she's going to be running.
08:10:33 I think that she is probably going to be a cabinet minister. And I hope she has a very strong role
08:10:37 in the Aaron O'Toole party and in the Aaron O'Toole potentially government if Aaron O'Toole
08:10:43 is successful in an election. And I know he was saying since the start that as an MP who's sitting
08:10:48 right now he's going to be hitting the ground running there's going to be a big test ahead
08:10:52 remember we've got parliament coming back in september we've got throne speech budget
08:10:57 potentially an election uh it's not going to be a long runway that the conservative leader now the
08:11:04 erin o'toole team has to get ready that's that's very true and it is a really good position that
08:11:11 he's in the fact that he is a sitting mp considering that the two other candidates
08:11:14 that were in the top three there neither of them were mps so we would have had to wait to a by
08:11:18 election and they would have had a disadvantage just not being in the house we saw that with
08:11:22 ndp leader jagmeet singh who wasn't an mp when he was named leader of that party and he was sort of
08:11:27 just irrelevant for a while you didn't really hear anything about him and it took him a long time
08:11:32 to gain national relevancy he still hasn't really found his stride as leader of that party so it is
08:11:39 great that aaron is in that position aaron o'tool is in that position where he can you know quickly
08:11:44 jump in to hold this liberal government to account. I wonder, you know, we heard earlier
08:11:49 from Steve Outhouse, who was running Les Lewis's campaign, about how she was committed, regardless
08:11:54 of the outcome, to run as an MP and to be involved in the next government. Have we heard
08:11:59 any of the same assurances, Andrew, from Peter McKay? Do we know for sure that he's going
08:12:05 to run as a Conservative in the next election? No, we don't. And you raise an important question
08:12:11 there because Peter McKay had bowed out from politics. He had gotten out of the game and it
08:12:15 was only just in this leadership race that he jumped back in. So I don't know if he's interested
08:12:21 in actually becoming a part of someone else's team or if it was just leader or bust. I don't know if
08:12:28 we'll get an answer to that for the next little while. One thing that I would say is interesting
08:12:33 is that Christine Elliott in Ontario came out of political retirement to run for the leadership and
08:12:38 When she lost, she actually got back in, ran again, and now she's Ontario's health minister.
08:12:43 So there is precedent that Peter McKay could still run and be a part of Erin O'Toole's team.
08:12:49 We talked earlier with Fred Delory from the O'Toole campaign about some of that animosity between the O'Toole campaign and McKay campaign.
08:12:56 And you've seen the sniping between staffers on those two campaigns on Twitter a lot.
08:13:01 I don't know if it's going to be as easy to bury the hatchet, so to speak, and move on at that level.
08:13:07 So that'll be one thing to watch, I think.
08:13:10 And it's interesting.
08:13:11 We had Devin Drover, our own True North correspondent who lives out in Newfoundland.
08:13:16 He was talking about how Peter McKay is very electable and has a lot of appeal in Atlantic
08:13:21 Canada.
08:13:21 So having him be a strong voice and sort of a partner within an Air No Tool Conservative
08:13:28 Party would be good in that regard if he can carry some of his appeal and his connections 0.98
08:13:34 to Atlantic Canada to help at least devise some kind of a strategy to make folks Canadians out
08:13:41 in Eastern Canada reconsider the Conservatives because we know there wasn't really a lot of
08:13:46 love lost between folks in Atlantic Canada and the Harper government. I think that the Conservatives
08:13:54 ended up being completely locked out if I recall correctly back in 2015. So certainly it would be
08:14:00 great to have more voices from Eastern and Atlantic Canada and, you know,
08:14:05 helping again with conservatives to understand what, what it,
08:14:08 what it takes to appeal to conservatives in that area and get them out to vote
08:14:13 in the election.
08:14:14 So if you are just tuning in, we are coming up on eight hours.
08:14:19 What has ended up being a marathon conservative leadership results show.
08:14:22 We have the leadership results right now.
08:14:24 We are waiting on the acceptance speech, the victory speech from Aaron O'Toole.
08:14:29 Now, for context, what's happening here is all of the candidates were having their own viewing parties at a hotel in Ottawa.
08:14:37 I think they're all at the Westin.
08:14:38 And the way it happened, normally you'd have a big ballroom.
08:14:41 Everyone's in one room.
08:14:42 You'd have big screens.
08:14:43 In the coronavirus era, the COVID-19 era, this wasn't possible.
08:14:48 So every candidate had their own viewing party.
08:14:50 The footage that we saw after the results were announced was actually a live feed of the O'Toole viewing party where he had his family and team there.
08:14:58 So what happens now, according to Conservative Party of Canada spokesperson, Corey Hahn, is all of the people that are in the O'Toole campaign now make their way to the Conservative studio, which I believe is at the next door Shaw Centre, if memory serves.
08:15:14 And that part, I don't know for sure. And then Aaron O'Toole will speak from where the party is set up.
08:15:20 So it's not a long walk, but it is a bit of a walk.
08:15:23 And if everyone's wanting to celebrate him and pop champagne corks and shake his hands,
08:15:27 this migration might take a bit of time.
08:15:30 I think we are, you know, some 10 to 12 minutes after announcing the results.
08:15:34 And that's where we are now.
08:15:36 So we're waiting.
08:15:37 The party has said to stay tuned for the new leader.
08:15:40 So that's what we are watching.
08:15:42 And we'll cut to that speech the second it starts.
08:15:45 I would say that there was a question about whether the leader would do a press conference
08:15:50 after their speech, and given the late hour of this,
08:15:53 I don't necessarily think that that would be a good idea.
08:15:57 Aaron O'Toole may do a press conference tomorrow from Ottawa.
08:16:00 That's something to keep in mind,
08:16:02 and I don't know if I'll end up having to be on the first flight out to Ottawa
08:16:06 or if we can just phone it in, and I don't mean that in a lazy way.
08:16:09 I mean, literally dial into the press conference,
08:16:11 but that's going to be something to watch here.
08:16:14 But we are going to have the victory speech.
08:16:16 That is happening tonight.
08:16:17 We don't know exactly what time.
08:16:19 what do you think the key message of this speech will be Candace do you think it is just going to
08:16:23 be about unity or do you think it's going to be more of the the sort of red meat anti-cancel
08:16:28 culture uh the policy issues that got O'Toole to this point well I guess this is like the moment
08:16:34 of truth we're talking about it a little earlier on about how you know for conservative running in
08:16:39 a conservative uh election this is like the most that this is the most red meat that we're going
08:16:45 this is the most that a candidate is going to try to appeal to the conservative base. So
08:16:50 we're going to find out, I think tonight by this speech, Andrew, whether or not Aaron O'Toole was
08:16:56 really, you know, putting it on and playing, putting on a show and pretending to be a true
08:17:01 blue conservative. But now that he's the leader, he's going to morph back into sort of a red Tory
08:17:05 and try to be more genteel and appeal to the mainstream media a bit more, or whether he is
08:17:11 going to continue on his path of saying it like it is and standing up to the radical left and being
08:17:17 the sort of you know champion of conservative issues that so many hoped and so many conservatives
08:17:23 voted for in this campaign so i i hope that he maintains his uh authenticity as as being that
08:17:31 sort of true blue voice we heard it from him so many times that he said i'm the true blue guy i'm
08:17:35 the true blue conservative you know he talked a lot about his endorsement from jason kenney
08:17:39 uh it was almost became sort of a running joke i think during the uh fireside chat that you did
08:17:45 with him how many times he mentioned jason kenny it was almost like it could have turned into a
08:17:50 drinking game like take a drink every time erin o'toole touts uh his endorsement from jason kenny
08:17:55 but uh you know obviously unity is important unity of the party uh it's great to keep everyone
08:18:02 united it is a big blue tent and if you're gonna try to beat justin true to win a general election
08:18:06 you have to have as many votes as possible so obviously you have to reach across the aisle but
08:18:11 i hope you know some of his core policies that really did appeal to conservatives talking about
08:18:16 defunding the cbc uh you know his his support for groups like the independent press gallery
08:18:21 and true north his strong position on guns i hope i hope he maintains all of that and and continues
08:18:28 on in that direction running uh you know in in more of a general election and i hope that
08:18:34 like andrew shear has done as of late i hope that he's more willing to push back against the media
08:18:39 i think he did a great interview at one point with the cbc where he was talking about how his
08:18:45 position was actually to cut their funding and to defund them and uh really pushed back against
08:18:51 the host was really firm really strong and then the cbc ended up cutting that portion of the
08:18:55 interview out so they didn't even show it to their own viewers which is incredibly uh
08:19:00 disingenuous of the CBC exactly what we've come to expect from them but I hope that we see more
08:19:05 of that from Erin O'Toole more of the sort of pushing back that Conservatives love to see.
08:19:10 I hear applause coming from the Conservative studio but we don't have a visual of the stage yet so
08:19:16 I think from the sound it's moments away but we don't have a visual yet but do stay tuned.
08:19:21 Candace mentioned the Jason Kenney endorsement let's just take advantage of this and look at
08:19:26 at the numbers here since we have a few moments. The Alberta results in round one had Aaron O'Toole
08:19:32 as the winner at 1,084, but Leslyn Lewis not far behind at 9.57 and McKay behind that at 8.26
08:19:40 and then Sloan at 5.32. So yes, O'Toole won Alberta and ultimately we know that Sloan's
08:19:46 and Lewis's numbers eventually went to O'Toole, but it wasn't a blowout in Alberta. And I don't
08:19:51 know if there's anything to read into that except for the fact that Leslyn Lewis did very well and
08:19:56 was very popular. But I would say that there is very much, I think, an intrigue there in that,
08:20:04 you know, the Jason Kenney endorsement, did it actually deliver votes? Because we know that
08:20:08 endorsements in general simply are sometimes overstated. Alex Boutillier, who's a reporter
08:20:14 with the Toronto Star, has just tweeted that he got a text from Hamish Marshall, Andrew Scheer's
08:20:20 former campaign manager, saying Peter McKay losing his leadership is like missing a shot on an empty
08:20:25 net. And that is exactly what Peter McKay said snarkily in the wake of Andrew Scheer's election
08:20:30 loss. And it sounds like Hamish Marshall is returning the favor. A little bit of sour grapes
08:20:35 there, but that's okay. Yeah, I think that, you know, again, Peter McKay just didn't really get
08:20:41 it done. And, you know, the fact that Jason Kenney did endorse Aaron O'Toole, you know, I know we've
08:20:47 said over and over that endorsements don't really mean much, but it is a signal to sort of the base
08:20:52 of the Conservative Party that someone like Jason Kenney who is so does such a great job articulating
08:20:58 so many of the issues he stick handles his way through issues so well he pushes back against
08:21:03 the mainstream media he's you know doing a lot of things that conservatives like over there in
08:21:08 Alberta as he did when he was a federal cabinet minister it does mean something and I think the
08:21:13 fact that Aaron O'Toole ultimately won in Alberta you know he didn't do that well last time around
08:21:20 in Alberta. It was Max St. Bernier that cleaned up out there. So, so I think that the endorsement
08:21:25 obviously did go, you know, a little bit of a ways. It didn't, didn't really, you know,
08:21:29 it wasn't a big, huge blowout there or anything like that, but still, you know, endorsement did
08:21:34 help. Well, Andrew, because we're going to be cut off at any moment by Aaron O'Toole's
08:21:39 concession, or not concession, I can't even dig straight, his victory speech.
08:21:45 We're nine minutes away from the eight hour mark. I think it can be forgiven.
08:21:48 Let's go now to Erin O'Toole in Ottawa.
08:21:54 What an honour. Thank you so much. Conservative members across this country have been patient
08:22:03 throughout this leadership race as Canadians have been through COVID-19
08:22:08 and Conservatives were patient again tonight. So thank you for being patient throughout this
08:22:13 leadership race. But I want to start by thanking my friends, Leslyn Lewis, Derek Sloan, and of course
08:22:20 the Honourable Peter McKay. Thank you for stepping up for our country. Congratulations for the
08:22:27 campaigns you have run, for the ideas you have put forward, and for the Canadians you have recruited
08:22:33 to our cause. Thank you for putting your name on the ballot, for leaving your family for weeks to
08:22:39 travel all over this great country whether on the ground or in a room of
08:22:44 your house for hours of zoom calls thank you for talking to Canadians about our
08:22:50 country our party and ideas for a stronger future thank you for valuing
08:22:57 the grassroots members of our movement I want to thank my incredible campaign
08:23:03 team from coast to coast to coast we have built a passionate team of
08:23:08 patriotic Canadians. And your hard work led to this victory.
08:23:14 My friends, this course shows that the Conservative Party is a part of ideas and principles.
08:23:21 The positive debates with Leslin, Derek and Peter prove that our movement is healthy.
08:23:29 Thank you to you three. We will continue the work together.
08:23:35 During this course, I was proud to travel across the beautiful province.
08:23:40 I met hundreds of Quebecers in Montreal, Trois-Rivières, Quebec and in Saguenay.
08:23:47 Thank you for being here to talk about economy, health and agriculture.
08:23:55 When journalists will talk about this course, they will talk about our great success in Quebec.
08:24:02 I also want to thank the volunteers for Peter, Leslin and Derek.
08:24:19 You worked incredibly hard and I look forward to all of us working together to build a stronger
08:24:25 country with more opportunity for our children and our grandchildren.
08:24:31 I would also like to thank Andrew and Jill Scheer and your family for your service and
08:24:40 dedication to the country and to our party.
08:24:44 We will continue to work together for Canadians.
08:24:48 And of course, I want to thank my wife Rebecca, our children Molly and Jack and all of my
08:24:58 family and friends here tonight, or still up watching at home, thank you for your love,
08:25:04 advice and patience these nine months.
08:25:07 Cette victoire revient évidemment à mon épouse Rebecca, nos enfants Molly et Jacques, ainsi
08:25:14 que toute ma famille et nos amis. Merci pour votre amour, votre patience et vos conseils.
08:25:24 of all, thank you to the tens of thousands of Canadians from coast to coast to coast
08:25:28 who voted for me. You put your faith in me to lead this historic party, and I'm honoured
08:25:36 and humbled. I promise you, I will not let you down. Today, you have given me a clear
08:25:42 mission to unite our party, to champion our Conservative principles, to show Canadians
08:25:50 what we know so well, that Justin Trudeau and his team are failing our great country.
08:25:57 We must continue to point out liberal failings and corruption, but we must also show Canadians
08:26:04 our vision for a stronger, prosperous and more united Canada. Canada can and must do better,
08:26:14 and Conservatives will work hard to earn the trust and confidence of Canadians in the next election.
08:26:20 Today, you give me a clear mission – to unite our party, to hold me up for our values
08:26:29 and to demonstrate, again, that Justin Trudeau defends Canada.
08:26:34 But I will not just criticize the liberals.
08:26:39 We are going to propose a vision of a stronger, stronger and prosperous Canada – a conservative
08:26:47 positive conservatrice friends now the real work begins we could be into an election campaign as
08:26:55 soon as this fall but as more than 260 000 passionate conservatives have already shown
08:27:03 in this record-breaking leadership amidst a pandemic the conservative party will be ready
08:27:10 for the next election and we will win the next election to the millions of canadians
08:27:23 that are still up that i'm meeting tonight for the first time good morning i'm erin o'toole
08:27:32 you're going to be seeing and hearing a lot from me in the coming
08:27:35 weeks and months. But I want you to know from the start that I'm here to fight for you and your family.
08:28:05 Like many millions of Canadians, Rebecca and I have been juggling a lot of jobs lately.
08:28:23 With our kids at home, COVID has made us appreciate teachers more than ever before.
08:28:29 my mother who passed away when I was nine was a teacher and throughout my life I
08:28:35 wish she was here to give me advice right now I wish you were here to see
08:28:41 her child succeed but I know she is here tonight because I can see her in my
08:28:47 daughter who shares her name thankfully I've also had my stepmother also a
08:28:53 teacher to guide me to this very day. I'm thankful that she and my dad are here
08:29:00 with me tonight. My father John inspired me into public service. But like many
08:29:06 teenagers, especially those who lost a parent, I gave my dad a hard time
08:29:11 growing up. He worked at General Motors for over 30 years which brought us from
08:29:16 St. Therese, Quebec to Bowmanville, Ontario to my home in the Toronto area.
08:29:22 After high school, I joined the military to gain discipline and to serve the country.
08:29:27 It deepened my love for Canada and defines who I am today. I served as a navigator on
08:29:35 Sea King helicopters and sailed with our Navy out of Halifax. It was in Halifax where I met Rebecca,
08:29:42 the love of my life. Today, Rebecca and I are both navigating, raising our amazing children,
08:29:49 Molly and Jack, and five days ago, Rebecca and I celebrated 20 years of marriage.
08:30:00 I have spent my entire adult life trying to serve Canada and its people. Soon, I will be asking
08:30:06 Canadians for the chance to serve as Prime Minister so that we can get this country back on track.
08:30:13 I love this country and I'm very worried about the course we are on.
08:30:18 When I launched my campaign in Calgary in January, I said that the stakes were high.
08:30:24 They are even higher today. Our country is currently facing its most serious economic
08:30:31 challenges since the Great Depression. Capital and jobs have been leaving Canada and large
08:30:36 deficits were being run before the COVID crisis led to record debt and deficits.
08:30:47 of the failure. We see the tariffs on the aluminum increase and no agreement for the
08:30:57 Canadian labor. Warren Buffett has banned his investment of several billion dollars in
08:31:03 the Saguenay because of the illegal blocus. With the Liberals, Canada is a risky country
08:31:12 to invest. We need to give confidence to employers, to the PME and to the innovators.
08:31:20 We need to remind them that it is possible for Canada to be one of the best places in the world to do things. 0.99
08:31:30 But I'm going to fight for all the forgotten people.
08:31:35 These people who wake up early to feed their families,
08:31:39 Les hommes et les femmes qui travaillent fort et qui sont fiers de travailler, ils peuvent compter sur moi.
08:31:48 Our country is more divided than it ever has been in my lifetime.
08:31:52 People are losing faith in Canada because of the ideological and out-of-touch policies from the Liberals.
08:31:59 We just emerged from the first wave of the largest health crisis in our history.
08:32:04 Premiers across our country have shown real leadership amid the COVID-19 crisis.
08:32:10 They were looking out for you. Justin Trudeau, Bill Morneau and the Liberals showed once again
08:32:15 that even amid a national crisis, they were still interested in looking after their friends.
08:32:23 We can rebuild our great country while protecting Canadians from the ongoing threat of COVID-19.
08:32:30 We can get Canadians back to work, be proud of the things we grow, build and produce in Canada again.
08:32:37 We must have a government that will keep us safe and ensure that we are never ill-prepared again.
08:32:44 To do that, we need a leader with real-world experience and someone who is not afraid
08:32:49 to make the tough decisions. A leader who cares more about keeping Canadians safe and united
08:32:55 than about his personal image and the interests of insiders.
08:33:00 We need a leader who puts Canadians first and will stand up for Canada and our interests
08:33:05 in a challenging world where we've lost the respect of our friends and allies.
08:33:11 The world still needs more Canada, it just needs less Justin Trudeau.
08:33:18 Why should I be that leader? Because I believe that whether you are black, 0.83
08:33:22 white, brown, or from any race or creed. Whether you are LGBT or straight, whether you are an
08:33:29 Indigenous Canadian or have joined the Canadian family three weeks ago or three generations ago,
08:33:36 whether you are doing well or barely getting by, whether you worship on Fridays, Saturdays,
08:33:42 Sundays, or not at all, you are an important part of Canada and you have a home in the Conservative
08:33:50 party of Canada. Maybe you have voted for a different party your whole life or have never
08:33:56 voted at all. Maybe you feel that as a union member you should not vote for our party. Maybe
08:34:03 you feel let down repeatedly by politicians. Maybe your family came to Canada for better
08:34:09 but you are still waiting for fair treatment. Maybe you run a small business and work all day
08:34:15 only to be called a tax cheat by your own government. It is time for many
08:34:22 Liberal and NDP voters to socially distance themselves from those out of
08:34:27 touch parties. It is time for more Canadians to look at the Conservative
08:34:32 Party again. If you want the opportunity to work hard to provide for your family
08:34:38 you should be voting Conservative. If you want to stop insiders from getting ahead
08:34:44 head while you are falling back you should be voting conservative if you are
08:34:50 proud of what we produce in this country whether it's the resources in the ground
08:34:55 or the ideas in our heads you should be voting conservative and if you believe
08:35:01 deeply like I do that you need an ethical government and that we need to
08:35:07 give the ethics commissioner a break you should be voting conservative Justin
08:35:13 Trudeau and Jagmeet Singh claim to stand up for working families, but they failed them
08:35:18 time and time again.
08:35:20 Et le Bloc Québécois? On va se dire la vérité. Le Bloc est passé date.
08:35:27 Il est né quand Justin Trudeau méprise les Québécois. Ça va être très différent
08:35:34 avec moi. C'est le temps pour le Québec d'avoir une chaise à la table des décisions.
08:35:40 Et je le dis à vous tous, les Québécois nationalistes ont une place importante dans le Parti conservateur.
08:35:49 Canada needs serious leadership for these challenging times,
08:35:52 to keep Canadians safe and prepared for the future,
08:35:55 to rebuild our country,
08:35:57 to navigate our way out of record liberal deficits
08:36:00 before they put our social programs at risk,
08:36:03 to ensure that we rebuild stronger and more self-reliant,
08:36:07 more resilient so that we are better prepared for future waves of COVID-19 and all threats.
08:36:15 To restore Canada's place in a tough world, earning back the respect that Justin Trudeau
08:36:20 has lost on the world stage. That is what Conservatives stand for. Doing what is right
08:36:28 even when it is not what is easy. That is what Canadians stand for. It's the same sense of duty
08:36:36 that kept our health care workers and PSWs helping our sick in the early weeks of the pandemic
08:36:42 when they were worried about risks to themselves and their families.
08:36:45 We were all proud of our soldiers who came to help in the CHSLD.
08:36:52 The situation was very difficult, but Canadians have worked together.
08:36:58 In our families, we cooked potatoes. We took care of our parents.
08:37:04 That same feeling when a family helps newcomers to Canada by opening up their own home and
08:37:18 letting them get their start with the help from family or friends in the community, even
08:37:22 when it makes things challenging. That same feeling our soldiers must have felt at the
08:37:29 bottom of Vimy Ridge more than a century ago. It's a belief in what Canada can be.
08:37:36 It's a belief in the hope and opportunity that Canada represents.
08:37:42 My fellow Canadians, my name is Erin O'Toole.
08:37:46 I believe in this country and I'm running to serve you as Prime Minister. Thank you and good night.
08:37:53 do we have to put this back on
08:38:23 And maybe put me in a small.
08:38:53 Well, as you can see there, a triumphant moment from the new Conservative Party of Canada leader
08:39:17 Aaron O'Toole raising his hand up with his predecessor Andrew Scheer and joining Aaron O'Toole
08:39:24 on stage right now you can see are his family to his right and to the left you have his competitors
08:39:31 in the leadership race I see Leslyn Lewis and Peter McKay and it looks like Peter McKay's wife
08:39:38 and son Derek Sloan is there as well I'm not sure who the the person is between Peter McKay and
08:39:44 less than lewis i believe he's on less than lewis's campaign so that is the that is it and that look
08:39:51 that here's the camaraderie in the moment all of the fellow competitors who were not successful
08:39:56 congratulating shaking hands with erin o'toole the new leader of the conservative party of canada
08:40:02 and we cleared the eight hour mark eight hours and nine minutes later i am ready to call it a wrap
08:40:10 on the True North Live
08:40:12 Conservative Leadership Results Show.
08:40:15 I want to thank all of you truly for tuning in.
08:40:18 This was not the show we anticipated,
08:40:20 but it was, I think, a very important one
08:40:22 for True North, for Canada,
08:40:23 for the conservative movement.
08:40:25 And I thank you on behalf of Candace Malcolm
08:40:27 and the entire team for being a part of it.
08:40:30 If you want to support the work that we do,
08:40:32 please go to www.tnc.news.
08:40:36 And a big thank you
08:40:37 to the entire True North team behind the scenes.
08:40:40 I am not going to list everyone by name because there are too many,
08:40:42 but all of the people that have worked from the videography side to the
08:40:45 research, to the social media, to the production,
08:40:48 everyone was a simple class act today and we are so grateful.
08:40:52 So thank you very much to you all.
08:40:55 We will talk to you soon and Andrew Lawton show tomorrow,
08:40:57 breaking down the results. Thank you. God bless. And good night, Canada.
08:41:09 Thank you.
08:41:39 Thank you.
08:42:09 Thank you.
08:42:39 Thank you.
08:43:09 Thank you.
08:43:39 You