Juno News - March 03, 2020


Coronavirus Panic, Big Tech Censorship and Marginalizing So-Cons (feat. Richard Décarie)

Mentioned
The term “settler,” explained Remember when the Left politicized the coronavirus? We do!

Episode Stats


Length

45 minutes

Words per minute

167.01

Word count

7,585

Sentence count

152

Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged

Toxicity

5

sentences flagged

Hate speech

14

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Coming up, should we be panicking about coronavirus, Big Tech censorship, and Richard Dacre rejoins to talk about his disqualification from the Conservative leadership race. The Andrew Lawton Show starts right now on the True North Network.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:00:06 This is the Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:00:12 Coming up, should we be panicking about coronavirus, big tech censorship,
00:00:17 and Richard Dacre rejoins to talk about his disqualification from the Conservative leadership race.
00:00:24 The Andrew Lawton Show starts right now.
00:00:30 Hey, welcome to another edition of Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:00:35 You're tuned in to the Andrew Lawton Show here on True North.
00:00:39 Coronavirus free so far, so thank you very much.
00:00:42 We'll see how it is by the end of the show, but I don't have any in-studio guests,
00:00:45 so I think I can probably make it.
00:00:47 We'll be talking about the coronavirus scare later on in the show
00:00:53 and why I'm kind of alienating myself from, not in quarantine,
00:00:57 but I mean ideologically from both sides of this,
00:01:00 people that think it's nothing to worry about
00:01:02 and people that think we all need to be stocking up and prepping for doomsday.
00:01:06 I'm somewhere in between those two.
00:01:08 So we'll be talking about that later on in the show,
00:01:10 as well as big tech censorship and where the answer to that,
00:01:15 if there even is one, lies.
00:01:17 That's all coming up later on.
00:01:18 But I want to talk first off about where the Conservative Party of Canada
00:01:23 has gone, in my view, horrendously wrong in disqualifying Richard Descaires.
00:01:29 So the Conservative Party had its leadership filing period, which has now ended.
00:01:34 It was on the 27th or 28th of February, last weekend.
00:01:39 And in order to be on the ballot as a leadership candidate,
00:01:42 you had to submit by that point, 1159 p.m.,
00:01:46 your 1,000 signatures of members that are active
00:01:48 in a number of provinces and ridings across Canada
00:01:52 and also a check for $25,000, which could have been your own money.
00:01:56 You could loan it to the campaign.
00:01:58 And the money is not as difficult as the signatures are.
00:02:03 It's actually hard to find 1,000 people who are paid up members.
00:02:07 But regardless, a number of candidates did that.
00:02:10 Candidates were successful.
00:02:11 There were, to be exact, nine of them that submitted their papers in time.
00:02:17 Eight of them are authorized as candidates right now,
00:02:22 or approved applicants, as the party calls them.
00:02:25 One of them, Richard Descaires, was disqualified.
00:02:28 Now, the party has not said why he was disqualified specifically.
00:02:33 A spokesperson did tell me, quote,
00:02:35 reasons for not allowing a candidacy are not disclosed
00:02:38 per our standard nomination practices,
00:02:40 but it's not a decision the committee ever takes lightly.
00:02:45 Now, the only thing we can really do is read between the lines
00:02:49 and look at what it is that Richard Descaires has done
00:02:52 that the party might not like.
00:02:54 And it's something that we actually talked about on the show
00:02:57 when it happened a few weeks ago.
00:02:59 He was doing an interview on CTV with Evan Solomon
00:03:02 in which he avowed that he views homosexuality as a choice
00:03:05 and said that he opposes same-sex marriage.
00:03:09 Now, Dick Harry is a devout Catholic.
00:03:11 He adheres to the traditional Catholic Church teaching
00:03:15 on homosexuality and same-sex marriage.
00:03:18 He is avowed as a social conservative,
00:03:21 but they didn't bar other social conservatives from running.
00:03:24 They didn't bar Leslyn Lewis,
00:03:26 who identifies as a social conservative,
00:03:28 or Derek Sloan.
00:03:29 Jim Carajalios, very devoutly pro-life.
00:03:32 He was approved as a candidate as well.
00:03:34 The only one that was denied is Descaires.
00:03:38 Now, in many respects,
00:03:40 this sounds like an example of the party feeling,
00:03:44 okay, we've got to make an example of this guy
00:03:47 to fend off the attacks we're going to get from the media
00:03:50 if we allow him to be a candidate.
00:03:52 The problem with that is that you cannot,
00:03:55 as a party establishment,
00:03:57 as a group of, for the most part,
00:03:59 unelected people in a conservative party boardroom
00:04:02 or on a conference call,
00:04:03 say, we are going to decide
00:04:05 who has the right to stand as a candidate
00:04:08 rather than letting the voters decide
00:04:11 who they think is going to be the best suited
00:04:14 to lead the party.
00:04:15 And this is where I am now,
00:04:17 because you may remember a few weeks ago,
00:04:19 I said very unequivocally on this show
00:04:21 that I thought Descaires' comments
00:04:23 were not in alignment with the party.
00:04:25 They were not in alignment
00:04:27 with where the party needs to be
00:04:29 as far as the messaging
00:04:30 and the form of communication goes.
00:04:33 And I say this as someone
00:04:34 who is more of a social conservative
00:04:36 that I don't think we need to be dwelling
00:04:39 on certain issues
00:04:41 that seem to be in the SOCON Rolodex sometimes.
00:04:44 And one of those is gay marriage. 0.80
00:04:45 I don't think it's an issue
00:04:46 that social conservatives should be campaigning on
00:04:49 or the Conservative Party of Canada.
00:04:52 But, you know, that's really beside the point,
00:04:54 because I think that even though Descaires' 0.70
00:04:57 may have said something and done something
00:04:59 that makes him unsuitable
00:05:01 to cast a ballot for in many people's eyes,
00:05:04 that is the responsibility
00:05:06 and the prerogative of the members to decide,
00:05:09 not the leadership committee.
00:05:12 And this is the issue,
00:05:13 is that I don't think he would have won.
00:05:15 He's not a well-known person.
00:05:18 He's not someone that was a frontrunner
00:05:21 in the race necessarily.
00:05:23 He had support.
00:05:24 I mean, clearly he was able to get 1,000 members
00:05:26 and he was able to get the money together
00:05:28 to file that application.
00:05:31 But it says a lot that the party was so scared
00:05:34 of having him on the ballot.
00:05:36 It says a lot that the party didn't want him
00:05:38 to even have a shot.
00:05:40 And that's interesting
00:05:41 because if you look back in 2017,
00:05:43 it was the social conservative vote
00:05:46 that gave Andrew Scheer the victory.
00:05:48 It was the social conservative votes
00:05:50 that were cast for Pierre Lemieux
00:05:52 and more specifically Brad Trost
00:05:54 that ultimately filtered into Andrew Scheer's support
00:05:57 because of the ranked ballot
00:05:58 and gave Andrew Scheer the victory.
00:06:02 So by taking out a social conservative
00:06:04 that was unlikely to win,
00:06:06 what the conservatives are actually doing
00:06:08 is taking out a support base
00:06:12 that would have gone to another candidate.
00:06:16 And the theory that's been advanced
00:06:17 by Richard Desqueries' campaign
00:06:19 is that the party establishment
00:06:21 is trying to help Peter McKay.
00:06:23 Now, Peter McKay has taken
00:06:24 a very anti-social conservative stance
00:06:26 to date in his campaign.
00:06:28 Aaron O'Toole,
00:06:29 who's the other frontrunner,
00:06:31 I guess you could say,
00:06:32 not a social conservative,
00:06:34 but has said unequivocally
00:06:35 that he supports conscience rights
00:06:37 and he realizes that the conservative party
00:06:39 has a place for social conservatives.
00:06:42 So it's likely that a lot
00:06:44 of the social conservative votes
00:06:46 would have eventually trickled
00:06:48 to Aaron O'Toole
00:06:50 if the party dynamics
00:06:52 and the leadership dynamics
00:06:53 stay the way they are right now.
00:06:54 And that's a big if.
00:06:55 We're still talking about months away.
00:06:58 So it's actually quite important
00:06:59 because the party has not just handicapped
00:07:02 Richard Desqueries.
00:07:03 They're handicapping anyone 1.00
00:07:05 who would have benefited
00:07:07 from votes that Desqueries brought
00:07:10 into the race.
00:07:11 And that's why there is an element
00:07:13 of 3D chess that's going on here
00:07:15 in whomever made the decision
00:07:17 to disqualify him
00:07:18 because there are other votes
00:07:20 that are at stake
00:07:21 and other candidates
00:07:21 that are at stake here.
00:07:23 I want to speak to Richard Desqueries himself
00:07:26 about what the party has told him
00:07:29 because so far the party
00:07:30 has not said anything
00:07:32 other than that statement
00:07:33 that I gave you basically
00:07:34 that well we don't make
00:07:35 these decisions lightly
00:07:36 but we aren't going to talk
00:07:37 about what's happening
00:07:39 and what went wrong
00:07:39 and why.
00:07:40 Richard Desqueries joins me
00:07:42 on the line now.
00:07:43 Richard good to talk to you.
00:07:44 Thanks very much
00:07:44 for coming on today.
00:07:46 Thank you for having me.
00:07:47 So let's get through
00:07:48 the nuts and bolts of this.
00:07:50 You submitted all of the documents
00:07:52 that the party required.
00:07:54 The form, the questionnaire,
00:07:55 1,000 signatures,
00:07:57 the $25,000.
00:07:58 You did all of that correct?
00:08:00 Yes.
00:08:00 Yes absolutely.
00:08:01 And what happened
00:08:03 when you did that?
00:08:04 Because I understand
00:08:05 there's supposed to be an interview.
00:08:06 Did the party interview you?
00:08:08 Yes, the interview
00:08:09 occurred last Thursday
00:08:11 and it went very well,
00:08:13 about 45 minutes,
00:08:14 asking questions
00:08:15 mainly about the things
00:08:16 that were already public
00:08:18 and there were no sub-questions
00:08:20 or other questions.
00:08:21 So I think it went very well.
00:08:24 And since it was only in English,
00:08:26 I think they saw
00:08:29 that I could
00:08:30 speak English very easily.
00:08:33 And so at the end of that,
00:08:35 you didn't think
00:08:36 that you were being disqualified.
00:08:38 They never told you
00:08:39 they had these grave concerns
00:08:41 about your candidacy.
00:08:42 No, and apparently
00:08:43 from an anonymous source
00:08:46 that said that
00:08:47 it wasn't based on
00:08:48 what I said publicly,
00:08:51 it's very mysterious
00:08:52 because they're not supposed
00:08:54 to comment at all.
00:08:56 So somebody has commented,
00:08:57 first of all.
00:08:58 And if they had had
00:08:59 something else
00:09:00 other than what I said publicly
00:09:02 in the past months or years,
00:09:05 they should have asked me
00:09:06 about it during the interview.
00:09:08 I think the interview
00:09:08 is based on the fact
00:09:10 that they must ask
00:09:11 that could be confidential
00:09:14 and nothing occurred
00:09:17 towards that way.
00:09:18 So I think,
00:09:19 and that's the rumor internally,
00:09:22 that the decision
00:09:23 of the committee
00:09:24 was positive
00:09:25 after the interview
00:09:27 and 48 hours later,
00:09:29 it was the opposite.
00:09:31 So in the absence
00:09:32 of any real substantive
00:09:34 information from the party,
00:09:36 I read the statement
00:09:37 they gave earlier
00:09:38 on the show
00:09:39 that reasons are not disclosed
00:09:41 and it's, quote,
00:09:42 not a decision
00:09:42 the committee ever
00:09:43 takes lightly, unquote.
00:09:45 The only assumption
00:09:46 that anyone's been able
00:09:47 to make is that
00:09:48 it goes back
00:09:49 to that interview
00:09:50 you did with Evan Solomon
00:09:51 where you talked
00:09:53 about your belief
00:09:53 that homosexuality 1.00
00:09:54 is a choice
00:09:55 and I don't want
00:09:56 to re-litigate that,
00:09:57 but you're saying
00:09:58 that you've heard
00:09:59 that wasn't the case,
00:10:00 that they had something
00:10:01 of else mysteriously
00:10:02 that they're using
00:10:03 to justify your disqualification?
00:10:05 Something mysteriously
00:10:07 according to that
00:10:08 anonymous source
00:10:09 and saying also
00:10:12 that it wasn't
00:10:13 something I said publicly,
00:10:15 so it disqualifies
00:10:16 the fact that I said
00:10:17 what I said
00:10:18 at the CTV interview.
00:10:20 And what I said
00:10:21 at the CTV interview
00:10:21 was based on
00:10:23 scientific
00:10:23 studies
00:10:27 that were
00:10:27 public since
00:10:29 2019,
00:10:30 August 2019,
00:10:31 in a magazine
00:10:32 Science
00:10:33 that revealed
00:10:35 that 470,000
00:10:36 people were polled
00:10:38 and more than
00:10:40 90% of the chances
00:10:41 were that
00:10:42 homosexuality 0.87
00:10:44 was a choice.
00:10:45 That's mainly
00:10:45 what I base
00:10:46 my mind on.
00:10:50 You know,
00:10:51 even most
00:10:52 social conservatives
00:10:53 that I know,
00:10:54 however,
00:10:54 are less interested
00:10:56 in gay marriage
00:10:57 and homosexuality 0.59
00:10:58 than they are
00:10:58 in things like abortion
00:10:59 or gender identity.
00:11:01 So I guess
00:11:02 the question
00:11:02 is legitimate.
00:11:03 Why did you feel
00:11:04 it was so important
00:11:05 to focus
00:11:05 on that issue
00:11:06 early on
00:11:07 in the campaign?
00:11:09 Because
00:11:09 one of the main
00:11:11 things that brought
00:11:12 Brad Truss
00:11:12 to run
00:11:15 at the last
00:11:15 leadership race
00:11:16 in 2017
00:11:17 was the fact
00:11:18 that the party
00:11:18 changed the definition
00:11:20 of marriage
00:11:20 in 2016.
00:11:24 Unilaterally,
00:11:25 it was done
00:11:26 against
00:11:27 Aldo Salkan base
00:11:28 who was amazed
00:11:30 to see that change.
00:11:31 Well,
00:11:32 in fairness,
00:11:32 Richard,
00:11:33 it wasn't unilaterally.
00:11:34 The members voted on it
00:11:35 as they vote
00:11:35 on other policy.
00:11:37 I've been in the back
00:11:38 office of
00:11:39 a party organization.
00:11:41 I can tell you
00:11:41 the way it works.
00:11:42 So we won't
00:11:43 extend on that.
00:11:44 I agree with you
00:11:45 that we need
00:11:46 to do the same process
00:11:47 and that's why
00:11:48 I was bringing that
00:11:50 into this race,
00:11:53 saying that we need
00:11:54 to reverse
00:11:55 the process
00:11:56 and we will do it
00:11:57 democratically.
00:11:58 And I think
00:11:58 the party
00:11:59 was fearing
00:12:00 that I could
00:12:01 succeed doing that.
00:12:03 And I was just
00:12:04 asking to change
00:12:05 the name
00:12:06 and destitution
00:12:06 of marriage
00:12:07 to be applied
00:12:10 only to a couple
00:12:11 that is made
00:12:12 out of men
00:12:13 and women. 0.98
00:12:14 And all the other
00:12:15 unions would be 0.63
00:12:17 celebrated
00:12:17 as civil unions
00:12:18 like it was
00:12:19 already the case.
00:12:20 So it wouldn't
00:12:20 change much,
00:12:22 but the impact
00:12:23 on a social
00:12:24 conservative base
00:12:25 was very important.
00:12:26 and I have been
00:12:28 praised by
00:12:31 this declaration
00:12:33 everywhere I went
00:12:34 in Ontario
00:12:35 and Quebec.
00:12:36 People were amazed
00:12:37 that I have
00:12:38 the guts to say
00:12:39 that on national
00:12:40 television.
00:12:41 If your disqualification
00:12:44 by the party
00:12:45 was about
00:12:46 your social
00:12:47 conservatism,
00:12:48 how would you
00:12:48 explain the fact
00:12:49 that other social
00:12:50 conservatives
00:12:51 were approved?
00:12:52 Derek Sloan,
00:12:53 Leslyn Lewis,
00:12:54 Jim Carajalios,
00:12:55 I know he's pro-life,
00:12:56 I don't know
00:12:56 about other issues,
00:12:57 but at least two
00:12:58 social conservatives
00:12:59 that were approved
00:13:01 when you weren't.
00:13:01 How do you
00:13:02 explain or think
00:13:03 about that disparity?
00:13:05 First of all,
00:13:06 none of them
00:13:07 are bilingual,
00:13:07 so I'm the only
00:13:09 bilingual social
00:13:10 conservative in
00:13:11 that race.
00:13:12 So I was
00:13:13 a threat
00:13:13 to Peter McKay
00:13:15 who is not
00:13:15 bilingual,
00:13:16 by the way.
00:13:17 So to keep
00:13:18 those candidates
00:13:20 who were less
00:13:21 local
00:13:24 than I was,
00:13:25 and I said
00:13:25 three words
00:13:26 during this interview,
00:13:27 you know,
00:13:27 three words
00:13:28 that killed
00:13:28 my campaign
00:13:29 and killed 0.97
00:13:29 all the 0.81
00:13:31 SOCON base
00:13:32 of this party,
00:13:33 it's pretty amazing.
00:13:34 So at the same
00:13:37 time,
00:13:37 you think
00:13:38 that it was
00:13:38 because you
00:13:39 had a better
00:13:39 shot
00:13:40 or were
00:13:41 a more
00:13:42 electable
00:13:43 candidate
00:13:44 in the leadership
00:13:44 than the other
00:13:45 ones that were
00:13:46 approved?
00:13:47 I think so,
00:13:48 because I was
00:13:48 bilingual,
00:13:49 that would help
00:13:50 for sure.
00:13:51 I have extensive
00:13:51 experience
00:13:52 in politics,
00:13:54 like I said,
00:13:55 in back office
00:13:56 work,
00:13:56 so I know
00:13:57 about all the
00:13:58 tricks,
00:13:59 and I was ready
00:14:00 to fight the
00:14:00 good fight,
00:14:01 so I think
00:14:02 they were scared
00:14:02 about that.
00:14:03 But at the same
00:14:04 time,
00:14:04 you've not
00:14:05 held elected
00:14:06 office,
00:14:06 you're not
00:14:06 one of the
00:14:07 people that
00:14:07 was one of
00:14:08 the perceived
00:14:08 frontrunners
00:14:09 of the race,
00:14:10 why do you
00:14:11 think you
00:14:11 would have
00:14:11 been seen
00:14:12 as a threat
00:14:13 in those
00:14:13 terms,
00:14:13 just because
00:14:14 you're
00:14:14 bilingual?
00:14:16 Not just
00:14:17 because I'm
00:14:17 bilingual.
00:14:18 Since I am,
00:14:19 and Peter McKay
00:14:20 is not,
00:14:20 and Erin O'Toole 0.89
00:14:21 has difficulties
00:14:22 to speak
00:14:22 French,
00:14:23 it would have
00:14:24 been a disaster
00:14:25 at the French
00:14:26 debate,
00:14:26 you can't
00:14:27 imagine that.
00:14:28 But also,
00:14:29 all the
00:14:29 frankness
00:14:30 of my
00:14:31 directness
00:14:38 of what
00:14:39 I was
00:14:40 saying,
00:14:40 I think
00:14:41 was a
00:14:42 threat to
00:14:43 the party
00:14:43 establishment
00:14:44 and to
00:14:45 those other
00:14:45 candidates.
00:14:47 And when you
00:14:47 say I'm not
00:14:47 in the
00:14:48 frontrunners,
00:14:49 I think
00:14:50 that's the
00:14:51 way liberals
00:14:52 work in
00:14:53 and out
00:14:54 of the
00:14:54 party,
00:14:54 I would
00:14:55 say,
00:14:55 by controlling
00:14:56 the messaging
00:14:57 and having
00:14:58 a lot of
00:14:59 money so
00:15:00 they can
00:15:00 spin the
00:15:01 news and
00:15:02 all that.
00:15:03 So I'm
00:15:03 used to
00:15:03 that and
00:15:04 I was
00:15:04 ready to
00:15:05 fight it
00:15:05 with my
00:15:06 very small
00:15:08 partition,
00:15:09 I would
00:15:10 say,
00:15:10 in this
00:15:10 race.
00:15:12 And I
00:15:13 think the
00:15:13 fact that
00:15:13 I was a
00:15:14 threat
00:15:14 shows that
00:15:15 the content
00:15:17 that I was
00:15:18 presenting
00:15:19 was stronger
00:15:20 than all
00:15:21 the marketing
00:15:24 that those
00:15:25 parties are
00:15:25 used to
00:15:26 build on.
00:15:27 I think
00:15:27 that's fair
00:15:28 and I
00:15:28 think in
00:15:29 my defense
00:15:29 I said
00:15:29 perceived
00:15:30 frontrunner
00:15:31 because I
00:15:31 was trying
00:15:32 to establish
00:15:33 that this
00:15:33 is the
00:15:34 narrative.
00:15:34 And I
00:15:35 mean,
00:15:35 ultimately,
00:15:35 until people
00:15:36 cast ballots,
00:15:37 you don't
00:15:37 technically know
00:15:38 who the
00:15:38 frontrunner
00:15:39 is.
00:15:39 And I've
00:15:40 maintained,
00:15:41 and I said
00:15:41 this to my
00:15:42 listeners and
00:15:42 I'll say it
00:15:43 to you as
00:15:43 well,
00:15:43 that you
00:15:44 have a
00:15:45 democratic
00:15:45 process or
00:15:46 what's
00:15:46 supposed to
00:15:47 be a
00:15:47 democratic
00:15:48 process,
00:15:49 which means
00:15:49 the voters
00:15:50 have the
00:15:50 opportunity to
00:15:51 say if they
00:15:51 don't think
00:15:52 you're a
00:15:52 suitable
00:15:52 candidate.
00:15:53 And that
00:15:53 should have
00:15:54 been where
00:15:54 the decision
00:15:55 was made,
00:15:56 not in a
00:15:56 back room.
00:15:57 And that's
00:15:58 why I was
00:15:59 surprised and
00:15:59 my team was
00:16:00 very surprised
00:16:01 that I was
00:16:01 disqualified
00:16:02 because they
00:16:03 should have
00:16:03 let me run
00:16:04 for the
00:16:04 next month
00:16:05 at least
00:16:05 to show
00:16:06 if we can
00:16:07 gather
00:16:07 $300,000.
00:16:08 It's a
00:16:09 bit exaggerated
00:16:11 because the
00:16:12 first rule
00:16:12 that they
00:16:13 should have
00:16:13 put,
00:16:14 their first
00:16:15 requirement
00:16:15 to be a
00:16:16 candidate
00:16:16 should have
00:16:17 been to
00:16:18 be bilingual
00:16:18 enough to
00:16:19 debate at
00:16:20 a French
00:16:20 debate.
00:16:21 Since
00:16:22 they didn't
00:16:23 do that,
00:16:24 we ended
00:16:25 up with
00:16:26 over 10
00:16:28 candidates
00:16:28 potential.
00:16:30 We would
00:16:30 have been
00:16:30 maximum
00:16:31 three people
00:16:32 in this
00:16:32 race.
00:16:33 So what's
00:16:34 the need
00:16:34 to have
00:16:34 a $300
00:16:35 barrier
00:16:38 when you
00:16:39 have simple
00:16:40 things like
00:16:41 bilingualism?
00:16:43 I guess
00:16:43 the question
00:16:44 that I
00:16:45 would ask
00:16:45 you or
00:16:46 any other
00:16:47 candidate
00:16:47 here is
00:16:48 do you
00:16:48 think that
00:16:49 the party
00:16:49 has an
00:16:51 issue with
00:16:51 social
00:16:52 conservatives
00:16:52 who make
00:16:53 up a
00:16:53 sizable
00:16:54 chunk of 0.97
00:16:54 the base?
00:16:55 I mean,
00:16:55 Andrew Scheer
00:16:56 was elected
00:16:57 as leader
00:16:58 as a
00:16:58 social
00:16:59 conservative
00:16:59 and I
00:17:00 think there
00:17:00 are some
00:17:00 disputes
00:17:01 about whether
00:17:02 he maintained
00:17:03 his leadership
00:17:04 as one,
00:17:04 but he was
00:17:05 chosen as a
00:17:06 leader as a
00:17:06 social
00:17:07 conservative.
00:17:07 A lot of
00:17:08 the support
00:17:08 that Brad
00:17:09 Trost had in
00:17:10 that leadership
00:17:10 race was what
00:17:11 pushed Andrew
00:17:12 Scheer over
00:17:12 the edge.
00:17:13 So do you
00:17:13 think that the
00:17:14 party is against
00:17:15 social conservatives
00:17:16 or do you
00:17:16 think the party
00:17:16 is just for
00:17:17 whatever reason
00:17:18 against you?
00:17:19 When we
00:17:19 say the party,
00:17:20 I think we
00:17:20 say the
00:17:21 establishment
00:17:21 that is
00:17:22 behind the
00:17:23 party and I
00:17:25 think the
00:17:25 establishment of
00:17:26 the progressive
00:17:27 conservative who
00:17:28 tried to fight
00:17:28 Harper's
00:17:29 beginning when I
00:17:33 helped him in
00:17:33 2003-04 to
00:17:35 get elected as
00:17:36 a leader.
00:17:37 Those people
00:17:38 are still
00:17:39 fighting and
00:17:39 they tried to
00:17:40 come in with
00:17:41 Peter McKay
00:17:44 and Aaron
00:17:45 O'Toole.
00:17:45 So I think
00:17:47 this is not
00:17:48 a surprise
00:17:48 that those
00:17:49 people and
00:17:50 Peter McKay
00:17:50 was very
00:17:51 clear about
00:17:52 that with 1.00
00:17:53 his stinking 0.99
00:17:54 albatross
00:17:55 image about
00:17:58 the fact that
00:17:58 social
00:17:59 conservatism
00:17:59 for them
00:18:00 is from
00:18:02 the past
00:18:03 and we
00:18:03 should get
00:18:04 rid of 0.99
00:18:04 those people.
00:18:05 So that's
00:18:06 what brought
00:18:06 Brad Trost
00:18:07 into the
00:18:08 race.
00:18:09 Unfortunately,
00:18:10 Mr. Scheer,
00:18:12 who is a
00:18:12 social conservative
00:18:13 personally,
00:18:14 couldn't defend
00:18:15 his own
00:18:16 position,
00:18:16 his own
00:18:17 values at
00:18:18 the last
00:18:18 election campaign
00:18:19 and that's
00:18:19 why he lost.
00:18:20 I agree with
00:18:21 Peter McKay
00:18:22 and all those
00:18:22 people about
00:18:23 that.
00:18:24 But the
00:18:25 fact that
00:18:25 social
00:18:26 conservatism
00:18:27 is,
00:18:28 we have to
00:18:29 get rid of
00:18:30 that segment
00:18:31 of conservatism,
00:18:33 I think it's
00:18:34 the opposite.
00:18:35 This is the
00:18:36 foundation of
00:18:36 this party
00:18:37 and if
00:18:38 Andrew Scheer
00:18:40 had defended
00:18:41 those values
00:18:42 at the
00:18:42 last election
00:18:43 campaign,
00:18:44 I think he
00:18:44 was winning
00:18:46 in the first
00:18:47 week of the
00:18:47 campaign and
00:18:48 the last
00:18:49 two weeks
00:18:49 when he
00:18:49 stopped
00:18:50 defending
00:18:50 those values,
00:18:51 that's where
00:18:52 he lost.
00:18:52 So I think
00:18:53 and that's
00:18:54 the reason
00:18:54 I came
00:18:55 into this
00:18:55 race is
00:18:56 to ensure
00:18:57 that we
00:18:58 would bring
00:18:59 those values
00:18:59 upward and
00:19:01 ensure that
00:19:01 the party
00:19:02 changes few
00:19:04 things in
00:19:04 its policies
00:19:05 and like
00:19:09 you said,
00:19:09 the members
00:19:10 should have
00:19:10 been decided.
00:19:11 They should
00:19:12 have let me
00:19:12 run and
00:19:13 see if I
00:19:14 had the
00:19:15 support base
00:19:16 and I think
00:19:17 they were
00:19:17 afraid that
00:19:17 I had it
00:19:18 and that's
00:19:19 why they
00:19:19 just did
00:19:20 what they
00:19:20 did.
00:19:21 Would you
00:19:22 support,
00:19:22 Richard,
00:19:23 the party
00:19:23 making
00:19:24 public
00:19:25 its decision
00:19:26 to disqualify
00:19:27 you?
00:19:28 I don't
00:19:28 think they
00:19:29 will because
00:19:29 we have
00:19:31 an agreement
00:19:31 signed that
00:19:33 nothing has
00:19:34 commented
00:19:37 or said
00:19:37 and like
00:19:38 I said
00:19:38 I didn't
00:19:39 say anything
00:19:40 about the
00:19:41 interviews
00:19:41 or all the
00:19:42 answers I
00:19:43 gave and
00:19:43 everything
00:19:44 so I
00:19:44 think it's
00:19:45 going to
00:19:46 stay
00:19:46 confidential
00:19:46 and that's
00:19:47 okay
00:19:47 but the
00:19:48 proof is
00:19:49 in the
00:19:49 pudding
00:19:49 in the
00:19:49 sense
00:19:50 that
00:19:50 if the
00:19:51 anonymous
00:19:51 source
00:19:52 is
00:19:53 true
00:19:54 is
00:19:55 right
00:19:57 about the
00:19:57 fact that
00:19:58 it wasn't
00:19:58 based on
00:19:59 what I
00:19:59 said
00:20:00 publicly
00:20:00 so if
00:20:01 it's
00:20:02 something
00:20:02 else
00:20:03 that is
00:20:03 not
00:20:03 public
00:20:04 we will
00:20:05 never
00:20:05 know
00:20:05 and then
00:20:06 I think
00:20:07 I'm not
00:20:09 the type
00:20:10 to go
00:20:11 fight for
00:20:12 the recognition
00:20:13 and all
00:20:13 that
00:20:14 you know
00:20:14 to go
00:20:14 a lot
00:20:15 of people
00:20:15 are asking
00:20:16 me if
00:20:16 I want
00:20:16 to fight
00:20:17 in the
00:20:17 this one
00:20:19 through the
00:20:19 tribunals
00:20:20 and all
00:20:20 that
00:20:20 it's not
00:20:21 my type
00:20:22 I think
00:20:22 it's a
00:20:22 political
00:20:23 party
00:20:23 we need
00:20:24 to fight
00:20:24 it
00:20:24 politically
00:20:25 and that's
00:20:26 why I
00:20:26 will continue
00:20:27 with
00:20:27 richarddecarry.ca
00:20:29 my website
00:20:31 and we
00:20:31 will gather
00:20:33 all the
00:20:33 social
00:20:34 conservative
00:20:34 and others
00:20:35 real
00:20:35 conservatives
00:20:36 from the
00:20:37 CPC
00:20:38 from the
00:20:38 PPC
00:20:39 because a
00:20:39 lot of
00:20:40 those
00:20:40 members
00:20:41 were
00:20:42 following
00:20:42 me
00:20:43 or
00:20:43 supporting
00:20:43 me
00:20:44 in my
00:20:44 campaign
00:20:44 and also
00:20:45 those who
00:20:46 are not
00:20:46 affiliated
00:20:46 to any
00:20:47 parties
00:20:47 I
00:20:48 welcome
00:20:49 them
00:20:49 to
00:20:49 my
00:20:50 new
00:20:50 movement
00:20:51 I would
00:20:51 say
00:20:52 and we
00:20:53 will
00:20:53 get
00:20:53 organized
00:20:54 in the
00:20:54 next
00:20:54 weeks
00:20:54 and we'll
00:20:55 follow
00:20:55 this
00:20:56 leadership
00:20:56 campaign
00:20:57 closely
00:20:57 and I
00:20:58 even
00:20:58 told
00:20:59 journalists
00:21:00 that I
00:21:00 will be
00:21:01 very
00:21:01 available
00:21:02 to
00:21:02 comment
00:21:03 whatever
00:21:04 will
00:21:04 happen
00:21:04 and we'll
00:21:05 ensure
00:21:06 that the
00:21:06 social
00:21:06 conservative
00:21:07 members
00:21:07 who are
00:21:08 still in
00:21:08 the
00:21:08 CPC
00:21:09 party
00:21:09 will have
00:21:10 a voice
00:21:11 I'm
00:21:11 the voice
00:21:12 of those
00:21:12 who don't
00:21:12 have a
00:21:13 voice
00:21:13 unfortunately
00:21:14 so we'll
00:21:15 be there
00:21:15 until the
00:21:16 next
00:21:16 general
00:21:17 election
00:21:17 and I
00:21:19 am
00:21:19 pretty sure
00:21:20 that if
00:21:21 it's
00:21:21 Mr.
00:21:21 McKay
00:21:21 that is
00:21:22 leading
00:21:22 this
00:21:22 party
00:21:22 we'll
00:21:23 have
00:21:23 a big
00:21:24 problem
00:21:24 big trouble
00:21:26 to be
00:21:26 elected
00:21:27 at
00:21:27 the next
00:21:27 general
00:21:28 election
00:21:28 so on
00:21:29 that note
00:21:29 are you
00:21:30 going to
00:21:30 support
00:21:31 the other
00:21:31 social
00:21:32 conservatives
00:21:32 in the
00:21:32 race
00:21:33 or have
00:21:33 you kind
00:21:33 of washed
00:21:34 your hands
00:21:34 of the
00:21:35 conservative
00:21:35 party at
00:21:36 this point
00:21:36 I already
00:21:37 told Derek
00:21:39 Sloan who's a 0.98
00:21:40 very nice man
00:21:41 an MP from
00:21:42 Ontario
00:21:42 we were very
00:21:43 close to his
00:21:44 positions
00:21:44 socially
00:21:45 unfortunately
00:21:46 Derek doesn't
00:21:47 speak French
00:21:47 so I told
00:21:48 him that I
00:21:49 would support
00:21:49 him
00:21:50 because he
00:21:52 will be
00:21:52 Peter McKay
00:21:54 who doesn't
00:21:54 speak French
00:21:55 anyway
00:21:55 so it's
00:21:56 not a
00:21:56 big
00:21:57 problem
00:21:57 that will
00:21:59 probably bring
00:22:00 us a leader
00:22:01 that doesn't
00:22:02 speak French
00:22:03 enough to
00:22:03 be fighting
00:22:04 as a
00:22:05 prime minister
00:22:05 so we
00:22:07 will be
00:22:07 supporting
00:22:07 Derek
00:22:08 Sloan
00:22:09 well I
00:22:09 appreciate you
00:22:10 letting me
00:22:11 know that
00:22:11 and also
00:22:11 taking the
00:22:12 time to
00:22:12 chat
00:22:13 and interestingly
00:22:13 only a couple
00:22:15 of candidates
00:22:15 have really
00:22:16 defended you
00:22:17 against the
00:22:18 process
00:22:18 and Derek
00:22:19 Sloan was
00:22:19 one of them
00:22:20 Jim Carajalios
00:22:21 was one of
00:22:22 them
00:22:22 but I think
00:22:23 that's a
00:22:23 very interesting
00:22:24 dynamic as
00:22:25 well that
00:22:26 there's a lot
00:22:27 of silence
00:22:27 from some
00:22:28 of the
00:22:28 others
00:22:28 yeah I
00:22:30 think the
00:22:30 silence
00:22:30 is talking
00:22:31 by itself
00:22:32 Richard
00:22:33 Descarry
00:22:34 thank you
00:22:34 very much
00:22:34 for your
00:22:35 time sir
00:22:35 thank you
00:22:36 have a good
00:22:36 day
00:22:37 you know this
00:22:37 sort of thing
00:22:38 I find
00:22:39 just so
00:22:40 very frustrating
00:22:41 because this
00:22:43 is what happens
00:22:44 that gets
00:22:44 parties really
00:22:46 in a lack
00:22:47 of alignment
00:22:48 with their
00:22:49 members and
00:22:49 with their
00:22:50 base and
00:22:50 and look I
00:22:51 say this I
00:22:52 want to make
00:22:52 perfectly clear
00:22:53 that I am
00:22:54 totally pro
00:22:55 social conservative
00:22:56 and I'm pro
00:22:58 having social
00:22:58 conservatives in
00:22:59 the party
00:22:59 I'm pro
00:23:00 life and I
00:23:01 take a
00:23:01 libertarian
00:23:02 stance as far
00:23:03 as the role
00:23:04 of government
00:23:04 on issues
00:23:05 like gay 1.00
00:23:05 marriage etc
00:23:06 but again I
00:23:07 am not
00:23:08 someone who
00:23:09 is resistant
00:23:10 to having
00:23:10 social
00:23:11 conservatives
00:23:11 in the
00:23:12 party
00:23:12 I do
00:23:13 realize that
00:23:14 there are
00:23:14 messaging
00:23:14 challenges
00:23:15 I think
00:23:15 that you
00:23:16 need to
00:23:16 be able
00:23:16 to sell
00:23:17 your
00:23:17 policies
00:23:18 and sell
00:23:19 your ideas
00:23:19 well and
00:23:20 I say this
00:23:20 again as
00:23:21 someone who
00:23:22 writes for
00:23:23 the interim
00:23:23 a social
00:23:24 conservative
00:23:24 magazine
00:23:25 one of the
00:23:25 columns I
00:23:26 wrote recently
00:23:27 was talking
00:23:27 about how
00:23:28 social
00:23:29 conservatives
00:23:29 need to
00:23:30 better package
00:23:32 their message
00:23:32 and not all
00:23:33 of them
00:23:34 I'm saying
00:23:34 in some
00:23:35 particular
00:23:35 cases
00:23:36 so when
00:23:37 that initial
00:23:38 CTV interview
00:23:39 came up
00:23:40 this was an
00:23:40 example where
00:23:41 I'm like you
00:23:41 know what I
00:23:41 think this is
00:23:42 probably not the
00:23:42 best way to
00:23:43 put this forward
00:23:44 now Richard
00:23:45 Descartes and
00:23:46 his defense he's
00:23:46 saying yeah this
00:23:47 is what I think
00:23:48 this is what I
00:23:48 feel this is the
00:23:49 basis for it and
00:23:50 I'm going to be
00:23:51 honest and
00:23:51 transparent about
00:23:52 where I stand
00:23:53 and I have a lot
00:23:54 of respect for
00:23:55 politicians that
00:23:56 are not leaving
00:23:56 you wondering
00:23:57 what it is that
00:23:58 they believe
00:23:59 and this was the
00:24:00 frustration that a
00:24:01 lot of social
00:24:02 conservatives had
00:24:03 with Andrew Scheer
00:24:04 is that they knew
00:24:05 he was one of
00:24:05 them but he
00:24:06 wasn't speaking
00:24:07 like that during
00:24:08 the general
00:24:09 election campaign
00:24:10 and he was still
00:24:11 getting criticized
00:24:12 just as much
00:24:13 for being a
00:24:14 social conservative
00:24:15 so it's not even
00:24:16 like it really
00:24:16 won him all
00:24:18 that much in
00:24:18 the way of
00:24:19 support from
00:24:20 these people
00:24:20 but to go
00:24:22 back to the
00:24:23 disqualification
00:24:24 the party cannot
00:24:25 disqualify people
00:24:26 because it does
00:24:27 not want them
00:24:29 to have an
00:24:29 opportunity to
00:24:30 put their message
00:24:31 to the voters
00:24:31 unless they
00:24:33 have some
00:24:33 major disqualifying
00:24:35 reason as this
00:24:36 anonymous source
00:24:37 supposedly said
00:24:38 that is against
00:24:39 the rules or
00:24:40 eligibility
00:24:41 in which case
00:24:42 disclose it at
00:24:43 the very least
00:24:44 to the candidate
00:24:45 you don't need to
00:24:45 make it publicly
00:24:46 but disclose it
00:24:47 to the candidate
00:24:48 which it sounds
00:24:48 like did not
00:24:49 happen here
00:24:50 so I'm
00:24:51 wanting to see
00:24:52 a lot more
00:24:53 transparency from
00:24:54 the party
00:24:54 because again
00:24:55 the conservative
00:24:56 party of Canada
00:24:57 did not do
00:24:58 itself any
00:24:59 favors by
00:25:01 really muddling
00:25:03 this process
00:25:04 at first they
00:25:05 weren't saying
00:25:06 anything
00:25:06 they were just
00:25:07 saying nope
00:25:08 we have eight
00:25:08 approved candidates
00:25:09 and everyone's
00:25:10 like well hang
00:25:11 on there was
00:25:11 this other guy
00:25:12 that applied
00:25:12 we have eight
00:25:13 approved candidates
00:25:14 and then they
00:25:15 started to say
00:25:16 we don't discuss
00:25:17 and we don't
00:25:18 take these
00:25:18 decisions likely
00:25:19 they're not even
00:25:20 mentioning his
00:25:21 name
00:25:21 they're not even
00:25:22 saying the guy's
00:25:23 name
00:25:24 so by doing
00:25:25 this they let
00:25:26 people fill in
00:25:26 the blanks
00:25:27 themselves
00:25:27 they force
00:25:28 people to fill
00:25:29 in the blanks
00:25:29 themselves
00:25:30 and everyone
00:25:31 assumes the
00:25:31 worst that this
00:25:32 is an assault
00:25:33 on the social
00:25:33 conservative wing
00:25:34 of the party
00:25:35 by the party
00:25:36 establishment
00:25:37 that's the way
00:25:38 this is perceived
00:25:38 and yes you
00:25:40 have social
00:25:40 conservatives
00:25:41 that were
00:25:41 approved
00:25:42 like Leslyn
00:25:43 Lewis and
00:25:44 Derek Sloan
00:25:46 and I think
00:25:46 that there is
00:25:48 some disparity
00:25:51 there of okay
00:25:51 well if they're
00:25:52 against social
00:25:52 conservatives how
00:25:53 come these ones
00:25:54 were allowed in
00:25:54 and a lot of
00:25:55 people are trying
00:25:56 to say right now
00:25:57 that oh well
00:25:57 there's a right
00:25:58 way and a wrong
00:25:59 way to be a
00:25:59 SOCON and
00:26:00 they're doing it
00:26:00 the right way
00:26:01 and Richard was
00:26:02 doing it the
00:26:03 wrong way
00:26:03 and again
00:26:04 whatever you
00:26:05 think it is
00:26:05 the responsibility
00:26:06 of the voting
00:26:08 members of the
00:26:09 voting members
00:26:10 to make that
00:26:11 determination
00:26:12 not the party
00:26:14 elites which is
00:26:15 by definition
00:26:16 what the
00:26:16 leadership committee
00:26:17 and I have
00:26:17 friends on that
00:26:18 committee I
00:26:19 none of them
00:26:19 have given me
00:26:20 any inside
00:26:20 scoops I
00:26:21 assure you and
00:26:22 I don't know
00:26:22 if it was a
00:26:23 split decision
00:26:24 I want to
00:26:24 believe and I
00:26:25 certainly hope
00:26:25 there was some
00:26:26 pushback on
00:26:27 that committee
00:26:28 to say this
00:26:29 is not what
00:26:30 we should be
00:26:30 doing when we
00:26:31 come back more
00:26:32 of the Andrew
00:26:32 Lawton show
00:26:33 stay with me
00:26:34 you're tuned in
00:26:36 to the Andrew
00:26:37 Lawton show
00:26:37 welcome back to
00:26:41 the show still
00:26:42 no coronavirus
00:26:42 still none I
00:26:44 mean I did
00:26:44 cough a couple
00:26:45 of minutes before
00:26:45 I started this
00:26:46 segment but no
00:26:47 coronavirus just
00:26:48 yet so we're
00:26:49 still managing to
00:26:50 sit pretty as we
00:26:51 coast through this
00:26:52 I don't want to
00:26:52 make light of
00:26:53 something well I
00:26:54 do actually because
00:26:54 I try to make
00:26:55 light of things
00:26:56 it's the only way
00:26:56 to survive the
00:26:57 world sometimes
00:26:57 but we have the
00:26:59 number of
00:26:59 coronavirus cases
00:27:00 worldwide passing
00:27:02 90,000 and I'm
00:27:04 following this very
00:27:05 closely because I'm
00:27:06 supposed to be going
00:27:07 to Taiwan in less
00:27:08 than two months so
00:27:10 obviously if there's
00:27:11 a massive pandemic
00:27:12 outbreak in Taiwan I
00:27:14 might have to
00:27:15 reevaluate this but
00:27:16 I'm planning on going
00:27:17 at this point I
00:27:18 received a very kind
00:27:19 invitation to a media
00:27:21 opportunity there but
00:27:23 I do think that
00:27:24 where we are at
00:27:26 now and I said
00:27:27 this at the top of
00:27:27 the show is that
00:27:28 you've got people
00:27:29 that are on full
00:27:30 blown panic clearing
00:27:31 grocery store shelves
00:27:32 of hand sanitizer
00:27:34 disinfectant wipes
00:27:35 canned foods all of
00:27:36 that and then you've
00:27:37 got people that are
00:27:38 just completely
00:27:38 uninterested that
00:27:39 think that it's
00:27:41 basically just a
00:27:42 bunch of hooey and 0.99
00:27:43 not really a thing at
00:27:44 all that it's no
00:27:44 different than the
00:27:45 flu and even better
00:27:46 than the flu and
00:27:48 I'm actually somewhat
00:27:49 in between these two
00:27:50 camps because I think
00:27:51 it has the potential to
00:27:52 be something very
00:27:53 serious it is very
00:27:55 serious in several
00:27:56 parts of the world
00:27:56 and for several
00:27:57 people Iran most 0.78
00:27:59 notably where it
00:28:00 seems I think it was
00:28:01 like eight percent of
00:28:02 eight percent of
00:28:03 lawmakers had
00:28:04 coronavirus I saw
00:28:05 something I haven't
00:28:06 looked into the report
00:28:07 but that was what I
00:28:08 read and then you've
00:28:09 got of course China
00:28:11 and the big variable
00:28:12 here is whether China
00:28:14 has been deliberately
00:28:15 downplaying the impact
00:28:17 of this and I think
00:28:18 that's where the real
00:28:20 issue is going to be
00:28:22 because when everyone
00:28:22 talks about the
00:28:23 mortality rate and
00:28:25 says that oh it's
00:28:26 actually lower than the
00:28:27 common flu they're
00:28:28 missing that China may
00:28:29 be grossly deflating
00:28:31 its deaths from this
00:28:34 and I think that is
00:28:35 where we are looking
00:28:37 at this now there's
00:28:38 been a number of
00:28:39 reports that have been
00:28:39 talking about mass
00:28:41 cremations in China
00:28:43 mass cremations in
00:28:45 China and when you
00:28:46 look at some of these
00:28:48 and this is not just
00:28:49 some conspiracy BBC
00:28:50 was writing about
00:28:52 this and there was
00:28:54 basically a swift
00:28:56 cremation that was
00:28:58 taking place an order
00:28:59 by China's top health
00:29:00 authority to not even
00:29:01 do funerals to just do
00:29:03 direct cremation you
00:29:04 had crematoriums that
00:29:06 were working around
00:29:07 the clock and in one
00:29:09 particular case that I
00:29:10 read you had Wuhan
00:29:12 crematoriums burning
00:29:14 bodies 24-7 to cope
00:29:16 with extra workload
00:29:17 during coronavirus and
00:29:19 that doesn't align with
00:29:20 what China says its
00:29:22 death toll has been
00:29:23 officially and this is
00:29:25 getting a lot of people
00:29:26 to wonder okay have
00:29:27 there been a lot more
00:29:28 fatalities that China 1.00
00:29:29 was not talking about
00:29:31 and let's face it it was
00:29:31 China it was China you 0.99
00:29:33 can't believe what they
00:29:35 say when they have so
00:29:36 much invested in their
00:29:38 image around the world
00:29:39 so the Epoch Times had
00:29:41 an interview with a
00:29:42 crematorium worker who
00:29:43 said 90% of their
00:29:45 employees working 25%
00:29:46 24-7 since January
00:29:49 28th and if you do
00:29:51 the math that is a
00:29:53 lot more than the
00:29:55 490 I think it was
00:29:58 that China officially
00:29:59 said Wednesday was its
00:30:00 death toll around the
00:30:02 clock for a month and a
00:30:04 week around the clock
00:30:05 for six seven weeks
00:30:06 basically so a lot of
00:30:08 question marks there so
00:30:08 this is why I realize
00:30:10 there is probably a
00:30:11 legitimate reason to be
00:30:13 concerned and I think
00:30:14 general precautions like
00:30:16 washing your hand and
00:30:17 not just doing open
00:30:18 mouth kissing with
00:30:18 strangers which I mean
00:30:20 we do all the rest of
00:30:21 the year I guess not
00:30:22 doing that I think is
00:30:23 probably pretty reasonable
00:30:24 I did find it
00:30:25 interesting I was I'm a
00:30:27 former Anglican I'm now
00:30:28 I go to a Pentecostal
00:30:30 church so we don't do 1.00
00:30:31 the communion wine thing
00:30:32 but I do realize that
00:30:35 the communion tradition is
00:30:36 very important around
00:30:37 this time of year because
00:30:38 of coronavirus and in
00:30:40 the Anglican church I
00:30:41 don't know if they still
00:30:42 do it in most Catholic
00:30:43 churches but in the
00:30:44 Anglican church a lot of
00:30:45 the time you will all
00:30:46 sip from the common
00:30:47 communion chalices and
00:30:50 the bishop of the
00:30:51 diocese of Toronto for
00:30:52 the Anglican Church of
00:30:53 Canada has suspended
00:30:55 communion wine so no
00:30:57 communion wine in
00:30:58 Toronto Anglican
00:30:59 churches for the next
00:31:00 little while amid the
00:31:01 coronavirus scare we the
00:31:04 statement that was
00:31:05 released says presiding
00:31:06 celebrants are to
00:31:07 consecrate both the bread
00:31:08 and the wine and to
00:31:09 consume in both kinds but
00:31:11 to administer only the
00:31:12 bread to the rest of the
00:31:14 congregation and they
00:31:15 say that the church's
00:31:16 ancient teaching is that
00:31:18 the whole Christ is
00:31:19 received whether one
00:31:20 receives only consecrated
00:31:22 bread or both bread and
00:31:23 wine the protocol is
00:31:25 effective today and to be
00:31:27 continued until further
00:31:28 notice so we've gone from
00:31:30 this is my body this is my
00:31:31 blood to this is my body
00:31:34 and we'll save the blood
00:31:35 for once the flu season
00:31:36 and the coronavirus season
00:31:38 ends that's where things
00:31:39 are now and I like this
00:31:41 part better we are
00:31:42 advising people to share
00:31:43 words and smiles only not
00:31:45 handshakes or hugs you
00:31:47 know there are a lot of
00:31:48 people that would love to
00:31:49 have the no handshake no
00:31:51 hugs no greeting your
00:31:52 stranger rule at church
00:31:53 year-round so this may
00:31:54 actually be like boosting
00:31:56 church attendance because
00:31:57 people that don't like
00:31:58 for social interaction are
00:32:00 like all right I guess I
00:32:01 can go to church now
00:32:01 without being put on the
00:32:03 spot to do the exchange of
00:32:05 peace so I am curious do
00:32:07 send me an email let me
00:32:08 know what you think
00:32:08 andrew at andrew lawton
00:32:10 dot ca are you panicking
00:32:12 are you worried I do a
00:32:15 lot of travel for some of
00:32:16 the work things that I do
00:32:17 not just covering various
00:32:19 things but I also do media
00:32:20 and PR consulting and I
00:32:22 have clients that I travel
00:32:23 for and I've done a fair
00:32:25 bit of air travel in the
00:32:26 last couple of weeks
00:32:27 relative to the general
00:32:29 population and haven't felt
00:32:30 concerned really I do think
00:32:33 that in the next few weeks
00:32:34 things are ratcheting up a
00:32:36 little bit I don't have
00:32:37 anywhere that I'm going
00:32:39 for at least I think three
00:32:41 weeks or two weeks or
00:32:43 whatever two and a half
00:32:44 weeks so again I'm cautious
00:32:46 but I I'm not panicked
00:32:48 about it and I may entirely
00:32:50 be the one in the wrong
00:32:51 here but I also think that
00:32:53 we can't downplay the
00:32:55 possibility that China has
00:32:56 been at the at the anchor
00:32:58 the epicenter of something
00:33:00 that is much bigger than
00:33:02 China has acknowledged and I
00:33:03 think that's the big
00:33:04 variable here and it's not
00:33:05 racial or racist to say
00:33:07 that it's about
00:33:08 understanding that China as
00:33:09 a country does not have
00:33:11 the best track record when
00:33:12 it comes to honesty we'll
00:33:14 be talking about big tech
00:33:15 censorship when we come
00:33:16 back here on the Andrew
00:33:17 Lawton show you're tuned in
00:33:21 to the Andrew Lawton show
00:33:22 I gotta mention this story
00:33:26 very briefly here this comes
00:33:28 from CTV news an eight-year-old
00:33:31 won $200 worth of cannabis
00:33:33 products at a youth hockey
00:33:35 tournament in BC now a I bet
00:33:38 the prizes have increased in
00:33:40 value and an interest since
00:33:41 you were a kid right a BC
00:33:42 grandfather is angry after a
00:33:45 novice hockey playing grandson
00:33:47 of his was the winner of this
00:33:50 $200 stash which you look at it
00:33:52 it just looks like cannabis there
00:33:54 is a lighter USB which I didn't
00:33:57 know you could have a USB lighter
00:34:00 but you've got all of these
00:34:02 cannabis products you've got
00:34:03 edibles you've got this box of
00:34:06 this container of pills it looks
00:34:08 like you've got a camo pipe for
00:34:10 smoking the pot that you get like
00:34:12 you have all that you need to
00:34:14 embrace the cannabis life which is
00:34:16 in British Columbia as
00:34:17 quintessential as drinking water
00:34:19 anywhere else in Canada and this
00:34:22 this prize was it was a raffle
00:34:25 prize each team apparently at this
00:34:28 tournament was responsible for
00:34:29 putting a gift basket together with
00:34:31 a minimum value of $5 and they
00:34:34 have the paper bags you've been to
00:34:36 these raffles the paper bag in front
00:34:37 of each one you buy your tickets and
00:34:38 you go and you stick them in the bag
00:34:40 of whatever prize you want to be in
00:34:42 the draw for and this eight-year-old
00:34:44 spent $10 on raffle tickets and ended
00:34:47 up winning this he says he thought he
00:34:49 was getting chocolate because when he
00:34:52 was looking at the list the basket
00:34:53 wasn't actually on display but when
00:34:56 he was looking at the list of items
00:34:58 he was seeing vanilla chai chocolate
00:35:01 edibles and other things and the
00:35:03 words just jumped out to his eight
00:35:05 year-old sensibility he didn't realize
00:35:06 that they were all laced with THC and
00:35:09 stuff like that so the I when I read
00:35:11 into this I was actually on the hockey
00:35:13 association side because the Dawson
00:35:16 Creek Minor Hockey Association said
00:35:18 look listen we clearly marked this for
00:35:20 adults it was a fun prize it was a
00:35:22 it was never out in the open and we
00:35:23 didn't give it to the kid it was
00:35:25 collected by his father or grandfather
00:35:28 one of the two who proved they were
00:35:30 overage so that the kid was not
00:35:32 actually given this which I think is a
00:35:35 very important distinction on this
00:35:37 although I still think it's hilarious
00:35:38 that like I would never supply because
00:35:40 this is a minor league hockey
00:35:43 thing I would never bring in like the
00:35:45 $200 bag or basket of weed for a kid's
00:35:49 school fundraiser or like PTA fundraiser or
00:35:52 something so maybe hockey parents are a
00:35:54 little bit different maybe they're a
00:35:55 lot more freewheeling or maybe it's just
00:35:57 the British Columbia thing but there's a
00:35:59 boldness in bringing this to a family
00:36:01 event one way or another but this is
00:36:03 Trudeau's Canada eight-year-olds winning
00:36:05 $200 cannabis baskets that a lot of
00:36:08 people are probably very jealous of so in
00:36:11 any case I wanted to talk about this
00:36:13 story out of the US a bit because it
00:36:15 impacts all of us if you're watching
00:36:18 this on YouTube listening to it on Apple
00:36:19 podcast and if you aren't subscribed to
00:36:22 the podcast do subscribe please go to
00:36:24 andrewlottonshow.com and whatever
00:36:26 podcast platform you like we have all the
00:36:28 subscription links there but anyone that
00:36:31 is partaking in digital media is going to
00:36:34 be at some point faced with the world of
00:36:37 shadow banning of censorship of big tech
00:36:40 clamping down on your right to free
00:36:42 speech and the challenge here is that big
00:36:46 tech evil as they are in many cases are
00:36:49 examples of private companies despite
00:36:51 their ubiquity they are private companies
00:36:53 with their own rules and their own
00:36:55 policies and PragerU which is Dennis
00:36:58 Prager's fantastic platform has been
00:37:02 shadow banned by YouTube they've been
00:37:04 unable to get the views that they used to
00:37:07 get because YouTube is not pushing them
00:37:09 into people's feeds and related videos and
00:37:12 stuff because YouTube does not like
00:37:13 conservatives we know this
00:37:15 PragerU sued YouTube or Alphabet which is
00:37:19 the parent company of Google which owns
00:37:21 YouTube saying that Google is infringing
00:37:25 upon their First Amendment rights and
00:37:29 they say that Google's censorship quote
00:37:32 unlawfully censored PragerU's educational
00:37:35 videos and discriminated against its right
00:37:37 to free speech PragerU said that YouTube
00:37:41 was using arbitrary and capricious use of
00:37:45 restricted mode and demonetization viewer
00:37:47 restriction filters targeting them because
00:37:50 of their political identity and they said
00:37:53 that this is a First Amendment issue because it is a
00:37:59 state actor essentially that a regulation of
00:38:03 speech by a private party in a designated public
00:38:06 forum is quintessentially sufficient to make that
00:38:11 private party a state actor and this there is case
00:38:14 law for this it's not as absurd a premise as it
00:38:17 sounds however I do not view any of these platforms as
00:38:21 public spaces even if the companies choose to allow the
00:38:26 public generally to use them that's the issue so suppose
00:38:30 that I own a private park in the middle of the city and
00:38:34 I let everyone use that park and then one day I decide
00:38:37 to say you know what I don't think this park is public
00:38:40 anymore I'm gonna shut it down and say I'm only the people
00:38:42 that I like can come in I don't think that I am owing to
00:38:46 anyone just because of how that park has been traditionally
00:38:50 used and the thing here is that you do not have to use
00:38:55 YouTube you can upload a video to Vimeo you can upload it
00:38:59 on your own server you can upload it to Facebook until
00:39:02 Facebook goes after you you do not need to use YouTube if
00:39:06 you choose to you have to therefore be at the mercy of
00:39:10 YouTube's algorithm you have to be at the mercy of what it
00:39:14 is that YouTube says its rules are and how YouTube chooses to
00:39:20 enforce those rules and this is a point that a lot of
00:39:24 conservatives seem to have a very difficult time understanding
00:39:27 they talk about wanting to treat these things as publishers
00:39:31 rather than platforms because they're imposing an editorial
00:39:35 bias and I agree I mean Facebook does have an editorial
00:39:38 bias if it's shifting views away from certain pages and to
00:39:42 others YouTube has an editorial bias if they're clamping down on
00:39:47 conservatives and not on people that are doing the same things on
00:39:50 the left but I don't think them having a bias changes that they do
00:39:55 not owe anyone the right to use their platform and this is what the judges ruled
00:40:00 against PragerU's lawsuit despite YouTube's ubiquity and its role as a public
00:40:07 facing platform it remains a private forum not a public forum subject to
00:40:14 judicial scrutiny under the first amendment they further said that YouTube's
00:40:20 censorship faces a formidable threshold hurdle YouTube is a private entity the
00:40:26 free speech clause of the first amendment prohibits the government not a private
00:40:31 party from abridging speech and this is so key because you have the right to
00:40:35 freely associate with people and views as you so desire if I own a stage I have the
00:40:42 right to decide who's allowed to perform on that stage and I cannot demand that
00:40:48 some theater let the Mirvish theater in Toronto if we're talking about this in a
00:40:52 Canadian context entertains me as a performer and I don't think that
00:40:58 conservatives are embracing an intellectually consistent position on this
00:41:03 because the same conservatives that I see in my life are saying you know the gay
00:41:08 baker or the Christian baker doesn't have to bake a cake for the gay wedding are the 0.84
00:41:14 same people saying YouTube censorship is illegal we need to break up these
00:41:18 YouTubes we need to regulate them we need to really start trust busting and look you
00:41:24 can dislike all of these platforms and I use them because they they make the most
00:41:29 sense for what I'm doing but I'm very aware that one day YouTube could say no and I'm
00:41:34 very aware that Twitter could one day say yeah you know I don't think you you you
00:41:37 want to use this their obligation is to their terms of service which is the
00:41:42 contract that they have with the people using them and I'm sorry but if you're
00:41:46 not paying for a platform and you choose to make it the center point of your
00:41:53 business model then you are unfortunately at the mercy of these things now I
00:41:58 think their decisions can and should be criticized when Twitter and Facebook get
00:42:03 together and they start suspending accounts and they do this whether it's
00:42:07 info wars or someone else whether you like them or not I think these should be
00:42:12 criticized I think they should do this with good faith I think they should do
00:42:15 this with fairness I think they should have appeal mechanisms but they don't owe
00:42:19 anyone the right to use their platform for free it's that simple and
00:42:24 conservatives should be very wary of what happens when these outlets start
00:42:29 being subjected to state oversight because then you get into what's
00:42:33 happening in Canada right now where Justin Trudeau's liberals actually want to
00:42:38 regulate social media companies to curb what they call hate speech and they
00:42:43 don't define what hate speech is they're gonna let for a social media
00:42:47 companies remove it within 24 hours or be punished by the government and the idea
00:42:52 of letting these companies do what they want is a heck of a lot better than
00:42:58 making them actual state actors and making government oversight government
00:43:03 regulation and government control the cornerstone of determining what content
00:43:08 is allowed and what what content isn't because if you do that then what's
00:43:13 happened is these companies have become essentially deputies of the state
00:43:18 deputies of the government and that is going to be a lot worse for everyone
00:43:22 involved in these platforms than letting them run wild in the more libertarian idea
00:43:28 which is what the judges against the PragerU case basically upheld which is
00:43:32 look they're private companies they can do what they want they do not owe you the
00:43:36 right to First Amendment protections because constitutional freedom is not meant
00:43:41 to protect people as much as it's meant to limit government that's what that
00:43:46 constitutional right to free speech is in Canada and in the US by the way it's
00:43:51 about limiting government it's not about protecting you from other private actors
00:43:56 now the one thing that I think is interesting in this case and that the
00:44:01 area that I thought was a more compelling argument is false advertising if a
00:44:06 company is pretending or presenting itself as being a bastion of free speech
00:44:10 and an open platform as YouTube is do they owe you procedural fairness and in that
00:44:15 case I'd say yes and I don't know enough about what YouTube is promising in the
00:44:20 terms of service but in that particular case I'd say there's a lot more of a
00:44:25 substantive argument you could make about where things are going in any case I am a
00:44:30 firm believer in the fact that big tech needs to be understood for what it is that
00:44:35 these oligopolies need to be reined in and they need to be criticized and they
00:44:40 need to be held to account but this needs to happen by their consumer base not by the
00:44:45 government forcing them to allow other people on because that means you're
00:44:50 surrendering your rights down the road when the government says oh well you
00:44:54 forced YouTube to have your show so now I'm gonna force you to have someone on
00:44:59 your show I mean it's absurd but not really if we get into that area of
00:45:04 government being able to regulate content on two platforms my thanks to
00:45:10 Richard day career and all those who tuned into today's show we'll be back in a
00:45:14 couple of days with more of the Andrew Lawton show here on true north thanks for
00:45:18 listening to the Andrew Lawton show support the program by donating to true
00:45:21 north at www.tnc.news