Juno News - January 30, 2020


Corporate Welfare, Internet Speech Crackdown, Forced Bilingualism

Topics
Mentioned
Is Canada doing enough about the coronavirus? CPC Leadership Candidates are following the liberal narrative of the day

Episode Stats


Length

52 minutes

Words per minute

167.23

Word count

8,860

Sentence count

355

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Toxicity

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

12

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Coming up, why corporate welfare needs to end, a dangerous proposal to regulate internet news, and why the litmus test on bilingual politicians needs to go away. The Andrew Lawton Show starts right now, and it never ends.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:00:06 This is the Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:00:12 Coming up, why corporate welfare needs to end,
00:00:16 a dangerous proposal to regulate internet news,
00:00:19 and why the litmus test on bilingual politicians needs to go away.
00:00:25 The Andrew Lawton Show starts right now.
00:00:30 Yes, indeed. Welcome back, my friends, to the show that never ends,
00:00:36 as that old Emerson, Lake, and Palmer song goes.
00:00:38 Good to have you aboard on Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show here on True North.
00:00:43 Thanks very much for tuning in.
00:00:45 The interesting thing about Canadian politics is that it tends to go sometimes glacially slow,
00:00:53 and other times at such pace as you can't keep up with it.
00:00:56 It's like feast or famine.
00:00:57 And we've actually been very fortunate, given that we're in an election year last year,
00:01:02 and that seems to have carried into 2020 so far,
00:01:06 that there's a lot going on and a lot to chew on.
00:01:09 Not that political news is necessarily good for the country, but it's good for talk radio.
00:01:13 So when the country's doing well, I'm happy as a Canadian.
00:01:17 When the country's in rough shape, I'm happy as a broadcaster.
00:01:20 So it's like that old saying that I've kind of coined,
00:01:23 which is there are no bad experiences.
00:01:24 There's good experience and there's material.
00:01:27 So we're in the material column right now in some respects.
00:01:31 We're going to talk later on in the show about this bilingualism litmus test
00:01:36 that the media seems to be injecting into Canadian politics,
00:01:39 and even into the Canadian Conservative Party's leadership race,
00:01:44 which normally has been relatively insulated from this whole Franco-supremacy thing that we see going on.
00:01:52 So we'll talk about that later on in the program.
00:01:54 I also want to give a little bit of a toast to Nigel Farage and the Brexiteers,
00:02:00 who are going to be successful.
00:02:02 Britain is leaving the European Union at long last,
00:02:06 and this will be the last episode of the show that is recorded while the UK is in the EU.
00:02:13 So we have to talk about that and acknowledge a great farewell speech that was done
00:02:17 and some other things that are going on in the show today that we'll get to as well.
00:02:21 I try not to, at the beginning of the show, tell you too much about what's happening
00:02:25 because sometimes I change my mind mid-middle of the show,
00:02:29 or I mean, sometimes I change my mind mid-sentence with where we're going.
00:02:32 So those little previews about what's coming up, little known fact,
00:02:36 I record those at the end once I know what I've talked about.
00:02:38 I shouldn't have told you that.
00:02:40 No, you never want to know how the sausage is made, so disregard that.
00:02:44 It's like a jury.
00:02:44 You have to just pretend you never heard that and move on with your life.
00:02:48 I do want to start off, though, if you are a credit card user,
00:02:51 you are not getting any benefit,
00:02:54 even though the company that you may well use for your credit card
00:02:57 got a huge $49 million check from the government.
00:03:01 This is absolutely insane.
00:03:04 MasterCard, one of the two biggest credit card companies in the world,
00:03:07 gets $49 million from Justin Trudeau's government to form this intelligence and cyber center,
00:03:16 which is going to be $510 million that it costs,
00:03:20 and of that, almost 10% coming from the federal government.
00:03:24 The center's goal, according to an article in the Vancouver Sun,
00:03:28 or a Canadian press article, actually,
00:03:30 to ensure that any internet-enabled device ranging from phones and tablets to computers and vehicles
00:03:38 can be used without fear that personal or financial information could be stolen.
00:03:44 The center will support about 380 jobs and 100 co-op positions.
00:03:49 Now, I don't know if they mean like high school co-op students or paid co-op students,
00:03:52 but 380 jobs, which works out to be, I think it's like $140,000 or $150,000 per job,
00:03:59 if you take the total sum of money that the government is putting into this.
00:04:03 But the thing that I find baffling is that on one hand,
00:04:05 we're saying this is for cybersecurity.
00:04:09 And on the other hand, when Justin Trudeau was asked about this by Andrew Scheer,
00:04:14 and also by Jagmeet Singh a lot in the House of Commons,
00:04:18 his answer was non-existent.
00:04:21 I mean, there was nothing that he said to indicate what actually was going on
00:04:27 and what this money was actually for.
00:04:29 And I want you to hear this clip
00:04:31 and let me know if you have any more of an idea than I do
00:04:35 about what it is that Trudeau was actually doing here.
00:04:39 MasterCard is a credit card company that makes money off of people
00:04:42 who can't afford to pay their full balances.
00:04:45 Why did the Prime Minister think that they needed a handout?
00:04:49 The Right Honourable Prime Minister.
00:04:53 Mr. Speaker, we continue to invest in things
00:04:56 that are going to create jobs for Canadians
00:04:58 and support hard-working families right across the country.
00:05:01 We recognize that investing in different sectors of the economy
00:05:06 allows us to move forward in a positive way for Canadians.
00:05:09 Everything this government does is focused on growing the middle class
00:05:14 and helping people, working hard to join it,
00:05:16 like the tax cut we're moving forward with
00:05:19 that is putting more money in the pockets of 20 million Canadians
00:05:22 and lifting close to a million people off of the federal tax rule.
00:05:26 These are the kinds of things that make a difference in people's lives.
00:05:29 To give this profitable company $50 million of public money
00:05:36 while they drag their feet to deliver the health care that Canadians need
00:05:41 so that they can afford the medication,
00:05:43 why does the Liberal government keep giving money to profitable companies
00:05:47 instead of investing in our health care?
00:05:48 The Right Honourable Prime Minister.
00:05:50 Mr. Speaker, once again, the NDP is choosing to share this erroneous perception
00:05:57 that we have not taken real action on moving forward
00:06:02 on reducing the cost of prescription drugs for Canadians.
00:06:06 We've moved forward in significant ways
00:06:08 that have lowered the costs for prescription drugs for Canadians.
00:06:13 We've continued to move forward on creating a national drug agency,
00:06:16 on moving forward on a strategy for high-cost, rare disease medications.
00:06:22 We know there is much more to do.
00:06:23 We will continue to work with them and everyone in this house
00:06:26 to deliver on affordable health care for all Canadians.
00:06:30 What?
00:06:31 I...
00:06:31 What?
00:06:33 So, somehow it ends up becoming about health care and pharma care,
00:06:39 and I realize part of that is how NDP leader Jagmeet Singh asked the question.
00:06:43 But the original question that Andrew Scheer put forward,
00:06:46 a very valuable one.
00:06:47 We're talking about a company that posted,
00:06:49 I think it was 60 billion or $16 billion in profits.
00:06:54 I want to verify that because I had it up on my screen here a moment ago.
00:06:57 I think it was $16 billion in revenue last year, not profits, revenue.
00:07:03 And we're still talking about a multi-billion dollar company
00:07:06 and a profitable company,
00:07:07 and one that in many cases is recession-proof in some respects.
00:07:12 Now, in other areas, you look at consumer behavior.
00:07:15 If you don't have much money, you don't have much cash flow,
00:07:18 you're more reliant on credit card.
00:07:20 So Visa and MasterCard have solid business models.
00:07:22 They tend to do very well over time,
00:07:24 and they're getting a bailout, essentially, of $49 million
00:07:28 to do something that it sounds like would be a selling point for their business.
00:07:34 If MasterCard's saying, hey, we've got this state-of-the-art center
00:07:38 that is going to protect your information,
00:07:40 protect you, protect all that you're doing,
00:07:42 that seems like a really good feature that is going to pay off over time.
00:07:48 If it is just about protecting consumer interests
00:07:51 and protecting consumer data,
00:07:53 then all companies would have these things.
00:07:56 The government would be giving money to Visa to do it,
00:07:58 to Amex, to all of the banks.
00:08:00 No, it's to MasterCard only.
00:08:03 And when asked about it, Trudeau doesn't mention cybersecurity.
00:08:06 Trudeau doesn't mention all about the Internet of Things
00:08:09 and the immersive economy and data and all this stuff.
00:08:11 He says, oh, well, we're always going to invest in things
00:08:14 that are going to create jobs. 0.93
00:08:16 I mean, the problem with corporate welfare
00:08:18 is that it never actually creates jobs.
00:08:22 It's like that age-old expression.
00:08:24 If you teach a man to fish, he eats for a lifetime.
00:08:27 If you give him a fish, he just eats for that one day.
00:08:30 And I know I reversed it there, but the sentiment is still true.
00:08:33 If you give a bailout or a check
00:08:36 or a corporate welfare payment of some kind for jobs,
00:08:41 those jobs are only going to exist
00:08:43 as long as that government check is there
00:08:45 because it is not a sustainable job
00:08:48 unless the business model of the company says it's sustainable.
00:08:52 And you look at Bombardier as a fantastic example of this,
00:08:55 a company that can't stand on its own two feet
00:08:59 unless someone is holding it up from behind,
00:09:01 pulling it from above, and holding it at the sides
00:09:03 just to make sure.
00:09:04 This is a company that only exists
00:09:07 to be a receptacle of corporate welfare.
00:09:10 And the problem with this is that when you're in a recession,
00:09:13 government says, well, the economy is bad.
00:09:15 We've got to protect and promote and preserve.
00:09:18 So we've got to put all of this money towards companies.
00:09:20 And when we're in a relatively good economy,
00:09:23 and a lot of that is because of the United States,
00:09:26 but we're in a relatively good economy,
00:09:28 then the government says, well, things are going well.
00:09:30 We can afford it.
00:09:31 We can afford to invest.
00:09:33 So I'm sitting here as a taxpayer going,
00:09:35 wait, well, if the time to invest is when things are bad
00:09:39 and the time to invest is when things are good
00:09:42 and when things are in between you invest
00:09:44 because you don't want them to get bad,
00:09:45 when is the time to not spend money on this?
00:09:48 When is the point that, okay,
00:09:49 well, I guess we don't need corporate welfare anymore.
00:09:52 And it's not just MasterCard.
00:09:54 It's not just Bombardier.
00:09:56 Loblaw, a great example,
00:09:57 which just a few weeks ago announced job losses
00:09:59 despite getting millions from the federal government,
00:10:02 I think last year.
00:10:04 It might've been two years ago,
00:10:05 but I'm pretty sure it was last year.
00:10:08 I mean, so when Maxime Bernier comes out
00:10:10 and says we're going to end corporate welfare,
00:10:12 everyone said, oh, well, that's terrible.
00:10:13 That's, you can't do that.
00:10:14 Why?
00:10:15 What on earth does Canada get out of corporate welfare?
00:10:18 Corporate welfare is what leads to companies
00:10:21 like S&C Lavalin staying on board and online
00:10:25 and getting government contracts.
00:10:27 Corporate welfare is the mentality
00:10:28 that keeps Bombardier on life support.
00:10:31 And corporate welfare is even rewarding profitable,
00:10:34 I'd say successful companies for what purpose?
00:10:39 For what purpose?
00:10:40 How are Canadians benefiting
00:10:42 from this money going to MasterCard?
00:10:45 And interestingly enough,
00:10:46 I was reading in one article a comment that said,
00:10:49 this is actually going to be about cybersecurity
00:10:51 for the entire world.
00:10:54 So this little center in Vancouver
00:10:55 is going to be part of MasterCard's global operation.
00:10:59 And I know Canada is going to get the employment out of it, 0.80
00:11:01 but then I'm like, well, wait,
00:11:02 why is customer satisfaction
00:11:05 for MasterCard customers in Britain or India
00:11:09 or Japan or the United States?
00:11:12 Why is that now the responsibility of Canada?
00:11:16 And this whole thing is absolutely senseless,
00:11:20 but this is where we're going.
00:11:22 And now Justin Trudeau's got a friend for life
00:11:24 from MasterCard.
00:11:25 He's got a friend for life
00:11:26 from the people that are going to be working
00:11:28 at this center in Vancouver.
00:11:29 And the whole point is,
00:11:31 if the economy is doing well,
00:11:33 these companies clearly can afford
00:11:35 to staff their own centers
00:11:37 and they can afford to do their own projects
00:11:40 because the other side of corporate welfare
00:11:43 is that government is picking and choosing winners.
00:11:46 Why not Visa?
00:11:47 Why not Amex?
00:11:48 Why not TD?
00:11:49 Why not Scotia?
00:11:50 And the reason is once you start doing that,
00:11:53 you can't afford it.
00:11:53 You can't afford to pay everyone off.
00:11:55 So you just pick and choose which ones do.
00:11:58 And then these companies have a competitive advantage
00:12:01 over all of the other ones.
00:12:03 You let the market work this stuff out.
00:12:05 And that's why I absolutely love Rick Peterson's idea,
00:12:10 which is the conservative leadership candidate
00:12:12 who is rehashing the tax plan that he had in 2017
00:12:17 in the leadership race,
00:12:18 which is to say a 15% personal flat tax
00:12:21 for personal income tax and an abolition,
00:12:24 a complete abolishment of the corporate income tax rate.
00:12:29 And doing this is going to let individuals
00:12:32 better manage their finances
00:12:33 and also take a lot of the burdens off of companies,
00:12:37 particularly small and medium-sized companies,
00:12:39 so that they can better be equipped
00:12:42 to deal with the market
00:12:43 and deal with the market realities.
00:12:46 And the way you support companies,
00:12:48 real corporate welfare,
00:12:50 is by allowing a climate that can let them invest.
00:12:55 Because the problem is that there is inevitably
00:12:58 going to be a race to the bottom.
00:13:00 You see this with production, with film productions.
00:13:04 There are more and more,
00:13:04 if you watch the credits of movies,
00:13:06 which I do because I have no life,
00:13:08 the more and more films you see at the end
00:13:12 are produced in partnership with the state of Georgia,
00:13:16 produced in partnership with the state of Oklahoma,
00:13:19 even produced in partnership with these.
00:13:20 And ones that are filmed in Canada,
00:13:22 the list goes on of, oh, the Telefilm Grant
00:13:24 and ACTRA and the, you know, Quebec Film Board
00:13:28 and the Canadian Film Board and the National,
00:13:30 like, you see this and the list goes on and on
00:13:33 of all of these organizations
00:13:34 that contributed in some way
00:13:36 to buying that production going there.
00:13:38 And remember, when Amazon was looking around
00:13:41 for its HQ2 that everyone was asking about, 0.97
00:13:46 this was like pathetic, 0.94
00:13:48 the way that cities, provinces 0.99
00:13:49 were bending over backwards to say,
00:13:52 how much can we give Amazon?
00:13:53 We're just going to make it rain
00:13:54 to buy them to come here.
00:13:56 And I don't fault the companies for this
00:13:58 because the companies are doing what any company is.
00:14:01 If someone were to come to me and said,
00:14:03 Andrew, I'm going to give you this,
00:14:06 for this thing you're already going to do anyway,
00:14:08 I'm going to pay for 20% of it.
00:14:09 I'd be, all right, just sign me up,
00:14:12 hand over the check.
00:14:12 Where is it?
00:14:13 The responsibility is for government to say no
00:14:17 and to say, listen, I mean,
00:14:19 we can promise you we'll stay out of your way.
00:14:20 We won't regulate you out of existence.
00:14:22 We won't tax you out of existence,
00:14:24 but we're not going to get into this race
00:14:27 to the bottom of buying you to come here
00:14:30 because that's what these companies are doing now.
00:14:32 They're leveraging their own existence
00:14:34 and it's forcing corporate welfare to be ramped up,
00:14:39 which is why you have to stop it all.
00:14:40 You can't just pick and choose.
00:14:42 You have to say, no,
00:14:43 this is not something that we are going to rely on
00:14:46 as being a tool to somehow grow the economy
00:14:50 because it just isn't going to work that way.
00:14:53 And that, by the way,
00:14:54 when Trudeau says in that little response there,
00:14:57 what was supposedly to pass for a response
00:15:00 about the importance of, you know,
00:15:02 growing the middle class and those seeking to join it,
00:15:04 we still don't have a definition for it.
00:15:07 So this minister for middle-class prosperity,
00:15:11 Mona Fortier, has been on the job now for how long? 0.66
00:15:15 Three months, pushing three months,
00:15:16 and still cannot identify it.
00:15:20 And this was, I think, absolutely laughable
00:15:23 because the middle class is this malleable term,
00:15:28 but Trudeau speaks of it like it's gospel.
00:15:30 He says, oh, you know,
00:15:31 the middle class and those seeking to join it.
00:15:33 Okay, seeking to join it.
00:15:35 What's that target?
00:15:36 What's that benchmark?
00:15:37 How do I know when I've made it there?
00:15:39 How do I know when I've joined the middle class?
00:15:41 And the answer to that, according to Trudeau
00:15:44 and according to Minister Fortier,
00:15:48 quote,
00:15:48 The income required to attain a middle-class lifestyle
00:15:51 can vary greatly based on Canadians' specific situation.
00:15:56 Canada has no statistical measure,
00:15:59 no official statistical measure,
00:16:01 of what constitutes the middle class.
00:16:04 The trick in this is that everyone thinks they're middle class
00:16:07 because no one views themselves as being particularly wealthy.
00:16:12 I mean, you've got the super rich, obviously,
00:16:13 but most people, even those who are very affluent,
00:16:17 are going to say, yeah, you know, I'm middle class.
00:16:19 And we subcategorize under there,
00:16:21 upper middle class, middle middle class,
00:16:23 lower middle class.
00:16:25 But the government is basically mandating this group
00:16:29 that it has no interest in defining,
00:16:31 which is great because this is what they do
00:16:33 with assault weapons and all of these other things.
00:16:35 They just pick a word and expect that everyone knows
00:16:38 what it means when it's actually nothing to do
00:16:42 with what the government is saying it's to do with.
00:16:46 But it's laughable to me that so many people
00:16:49 are prepared to go along with this.
00:16:51 You as might as well have the Ministry of Feel Goods,
00:16:54 the Ministry of Platitudes,
00:16:56 the Ministry of whatever.
00:16:57 Silly Walks was the old Monty Python one
00:16:59 because this is what we're dealing with here.
00:17:02 It's a ministry that is completely non-existent
00:17:04 for a portion of the population that is not defined.
00:17:08 Imagine, for example, there was a Minister of Poverty
00:17:10 and they were asked, okay, well, what's poverty?
00:17:13 What's poverty?
00:17:14 And they said, well, you know,
00:17:15 you've got to be open to different things.
00:17:19 And, you know, poverty looks different in Toronto
00:17:22 than it does in Hamilton,
00:17:23 than it does in Owens Sound,
00:17:25 than it does in Burnaby.
00:17:26 And, you know, poverty, you know,
00:17:28 you know if you're impoverished.
00:17:29 She's like, well, okay, maybe you do,
00:17:32 but if you're talking about a national strategy
00:17:34 to address it,
00:17:35 you'd think or hope that maybe there is a number in mind
00:17:39 or a metric in mind.
00:17:41 And it's not just that they haven't figured it out yet.
00:17:44 It's that this minister doesn't seem
00:17:46 to think it's relevant to even have one.
00:17:49 Because she's now had several months,
00:17:51 but MP Pat Kelly asks her in the House of Commons,
00:17:53 okay, what is it?
00:17:54 And she's like, yeah, there's no measure.
00:17:55 Then what's the point?
00:17:58 How do we know if we've succeeded
00:18:00 in achieving that Trudopian dream
00:18:02 of joining the middle class
00:18:03 if we don't have a measure to know we've got there?
00:18:07 More of The Andrew Lawton Show in just a moment.
00:18:10 Stay tuned.
00:18:14 Hey, welcome back.
00:18:17 So I don't really trust government to do all that much.
00:18:22 And I don't think I'm alone in this.
00:18:24 So color me a little bit skeptical
00:18:27 of these proposals that appear in a report
00:18:30 that was just tabled before government the other day.
00:18:32 In fact, a report chaired by Janet Yale,
00:18:36 who was the head of the Broadcasting
00:18:37 and Telecommunications Legislative Review Panel.
00:18:41 She pushed her report to government.
00:18:44 And this report deals with a number of issues
00:18:48 from whether to tax Netflix
00:18:50 to how to make streaming services
00:18:52 provide Canadian content,
00:18:53 whether CBC is permitted
00:18:56 or should be permitted to have advertising
00:18:57 or should be entirely reliant on subsidies.
00:19:01 And the final report called
00:19:03 Canada's Communications Future, Time to Act
00:19:06 lists a number of recommendations
00:19:08 that among other things
00:19:12 would just completely disrupt
00:19:14 the way telecommunications
00:19:16 and traditional media operate now in some ways.
00:19:20 And in other ways, I think,
00:19:21 are just absolute tax grabs.
00:19:23 But there are a couple of very concerning ones in here.
00:19:26 As I look through the list,
00:19:28 and I mean, how many recommendations are there?
00:19:29 I think there are 97.
00:19:32 97 recommendations.
00:19:34 But I want to read two in particular
00:19:36 that have stood out.
00:19:37 And I might do more in the future
00:19:39 as I work my way through this.
00:19:41 But the two in particular,
00:19:43 number 73 and 74,
00:19:45 we recommend that to promote
00:19:47 the discoverability of Canadian news content,
00:19:50 the CRTC impose the following requirements
00:19:53 as appropriate on media aggregation
00:19:55 and media sharing undertakings.
00:19:57 Links to the websites of Canadian sources
00:20:00 of accurate, trusted, and reliable sources of news
00:20:04 with a view to ensuring a diversity of voices
00:20:07 and prominence rules to ensure visibility
00:20:11 and access to such sources of news.
00:20:14 And number 74,
00:20:15 we recommend that the Broadcasting Act
00:20:17 be amended to ensure that the CRTC can,
00:20:20 by regulation, condition of license,
00:20:22 or condition of registration,
00:20:24 impose codes of conduct,
00:20:27 including provisions with respect
00:20:28 to resolution mechanisms,
00:20:30 transparency, privacy, and accessibility
00:20:33 regarding all media content undertakings.
00:20:37 Now, the reason this is so important
00:20:39 is because we're talking about
00:20:41 the imposition of codes of conduct
00:20:43 and also a government definition
00:20:45 of what a reliable and fair news organization is.
00:20:49 And the only way it can do this
00:20:51 is by a centralized registry of online media.
00:20:55 And this is something I've been sounding the alarm
00:20:57 about for quite some time
00:20:59 because it was only a matter of time
00:21:01 before it got to this point.
00:21:03 As the government takes its crusade
00:21:05 against fake news
00:21:06 and all of these other things
00:21:07 they use as terms of convenience.
00:21:10 And Blacklock's reporter,
00:21:11 which has just been doing
00:21:12 some phenomenal work as of late,
00:21:14 had picked up on this as well.
00:21:16 And they noted that the report calls
00:21:19 for internet news media
00:21:20 to register with the government
00:21:22 and ultimately do this
00:21:25 so that they would be subject
00:21:26 to federal codes of conduct.
00:21:28 Now, the chair of the panel says,
00:21:31 we are not proposing to regulate the internet
00:21:33 and we are not proposing
00:21:35 to regulate news online.
00:21:37 Nevertheless, the panel's report
00:21:39 calls what we have right now in Canada
00:21:42 a crisis in news.
00:21:44 They say it's about helping production of content
00:21:46 and all of these other things.
00:21:49 Here's the problem.
00:21:50 The CRTC does not have jurisdiction
00:21:54 over the content of online news.
00:21:57 The CRTC has content restrictions
00:21:59 on what goes on conventional broadcast.
00:22:02 The CBSA has some other controls
00:22:05 and I know that's technically industry-led
00:22:08 but still it has essentially
00:22:10 the force of law behind it.
00:22:12 So when you start broadening
00:22:14 who's included in this to online media,
00:22:17 how can there not be an issue
00:22:20 of what we're seeing now,
00:22:22 which is the liberals wanting to pick
00:22:24 and choose who can access their events,
00:22:25 who can cover things,
00:22:27 extending to government.
00:22:28 And this is so dangerous for Canada,
00:22:32 so dangerous that we even have
00:22:34 the inch of support
00:22:37 or ounce of support, I guess is more accurate,
00:22:40 for a registry of government-approved news.
00:22:44 Because this is what was happening
00:22:45 when the bailout list was put together.
00:22:48 All of a sudden, there's a right answer
00:22:50 and a wrong answer to
00:22:51 what are you doing as an organization.
00:22:54 And the government has used this now
00:22:56 as the basis to say,
00:22:57 all right, well, you're government-approved media.
00:22:59 And you may remember back in the federal election,
00:23:02 I was jumping around trying to cover the campaign
00:23:04 and the liberals were saying,
00:23:05 oh, you're not accredited media.
00:23:07 You don't have accreditation.
00:23:09 And as you've heard me say in the past,
00:23:11 there is no centralized accreditation database in Canada,
00:23:15 nor should there be.
00:23:17 Countries like the UK have press cards,
00:23:19 other countries have press licenses,
00:23:21 but in Canada, that does not exist.
00:23:23 And it shouldn't exist
00:23:24 because in a freedom-loving country,
00:23:26 a country with free press,
00:23:27 there's no gatekeeper to who can be a journalist.
00:23:31 You are a journalist or you're not.
00:23:32 It's a craft.
00:23:33 It's not a licensed profession.
00:23:36 And when you start talking about state registries
00:23:39 and the idea that there has to be a list
00:23:42 of government-approved media,
00:23:44 it's impossible to not have that go down the road
00:23:47 of government picking and choosing
00:23:48 who's legitimate based on subjective measures.
00:23:53 And they will be subjective.
00:23:54 There's no way they won't be
00:23:55 because in a lot of cases,
00:23:57 this idea of fake news is in this column
00:24:00 of I know it when I see it.
00:24:03 And what the government likes to call fake news
00:24:05 is opinion it disagrees with.
00:24:08 And if you say, all right,
00:24:09 well, there's the line right there.
00:24:10 No opinion is allowed.
00:24:12 Well, CBC has opinion.
00:24:13 Toronto Star has opinion.
00:24:14 National Post has opinion.
00:24:16 Legitimate media incorporates opinion.
00:24:19 So all of these platforms,
00:24:21 of which True North is one, by the way,
00:24:24 risk the government saying,
00:24:26 no, no, no, you're not officially.
00:24:28 You're not officially media on the list.
00:24:30 And once you're off that list,
00:24:33 it's not just about whether you get the tax credit
00:24:35 or the bailout money,
00:24:36 which True North doesn't get and isn't interested in,
00:24:39 but it goes beyond that.
00:24:41 You lose access
00:24:42 because now the government has a tool
00:24:44 to deny you access to government events.
00:24:48 They say, oh, well, the CRTC has reviewed
00:24:50 and you don't fall into this list.
00:24:53 So it basically is trying to silence new media
00:24:56 and protect the stronghold
00:24:59 that traditional media used to have,
00:25:01 and I think in some ways thinks they have,
00:25:04 on the media sector and on the media industry.
00:25:07 So Ms. Yale can say, all right,
00:25:09 well, we're not trying to regulate online news.
00:25:11 Well, what is this code of conduct?
00:25:13 What is the code of conduct?
00:25:15 What is the code of conduct going to be
00:25:17 that by this report's own definition
00:25:20 will be imposed on those who register
00:25:23 with the CRTC on these online content providers
00:25:27 that are going to be trying to play ball with this
00:25:30 because they feel they have to,
00:25:32 because that's the only way
00:25:33 they'll be able to survive as organizations.
00:25:35 And when you read the report,
00:25:38 it doesn't actually give you all that much clarity
00:25:41 as far as what that means
00:25:44 and what that would look like.
00:25:45 Now, the good news is this isn't a law.
00:25:47 This isn't a bill.
00:25:48 The government has to pick this up
00:25:49 and decide if it's worth legislating
00:25:52 anything further on it.
00:25:54 I'm going through some of the other recommendations right now.
00:25:57 And like I said at the beginning of this,
00:25:59 there is going to be a fair bit of material there
00:26:01 that I can work through at other points
00:26:03 in the show in the future.
00:26:05 And certainly I'll take a look
00:26:07 and see if things are being addressed or ignored.
00:26:10 And if I have something to add, I will.
00:26:13 But I do want to read one additional paragraph here
00:26:17 that I think is important.
00:26:18 If I can pull it up here,
00:26:19 it's that to further promote regulatory efficiency
00:26:23 and flexibility,
00:26:25 the CRTC should have the power
00:26:27 to provide partial or additional relief
00:26:29 to issue conditional and interim decisions
00:26:32 and to issue ex parte decisions
00:26:34 where it considers that the circumstances
00:26:36 of the case justifies it.
00:26:38 Now, the problem with this
00:26:40 is that you're dealing with a regulatory framework
00:26:43 that would allow CRTC to start clapping
00:26:46 or clamping down on these new media operations
00:26:50 that are supposed to be included
00:26:52 in the now broadened list of content providers.
00:26:59 So these codes of conduct,
00:27:01 I mean, some of them that they talk about
00:27:03 are how advertising to children works.
00:27:05 But others are, and I want to read this section,
00:27:10 could apply to different undertakings
00:27:13 depending on the level of editorial control they exercise.
00:27:17 So codes of conduct could extend
00:27:21 to editorial content on new media.
00:27:25 And that is absolutely the death knell
00:27:29 for free speech in Canada
00:27:32 if the government is now regulating the internet speech,
00:27:35 not just by saying who's official and who's not,
00:27:37 but even by having the mandatory capability
00:27:40 of enforcing adherence to an editorial code of conduct.
00:27:45 And I'm sorry, but there is no way in hell
00:27:50 I would ever agree to play by their rules.
00:27:54 There isn't.
00:27:55 This is not an organization that has jurisdiction.
00:27:59 And if government gives it jurisdiction,
00:28:01 everyone better stand up and say no.
00:28:05 And this is, by the way,
00:28:06 just to segue into a clip I wanted to play for you,
00:28:09 what the UK has done with Brexit.
00:28:12 I said at the top of the show,
00:28:13 the last day, the last show that is recorded
00:28:16 while the UK is in the EU.
00:28:18 And because of this,
00:28:19 I have to share a little bit of this speech
00:28:21 that Nigel Farage gave in the European Parliament,
00:28:24 signaling his own exit,
00:28:25 the last speech he'll give in the European Parliament.
00:28:28 And it ended in such a glorious way
00:28:31 as the chair of the parliament
00:28:34 basically proved the point
00:28:36 of what the UK is leaving for.
00:28:39 Take a watch.
00:28:40 I want Brexit to start a debate
00:28:42 across the rest of Europe.
00:28:43 What do we want from Europe?
00:28:45 If we want trade, friendship,
00:28:47 cooperation, reciprocity,
00:28:49 we don't need a European Commission.
00:28:52 We don't need a European Court.
00:28:54 We don't need these institutions
00:28:56 and all of this power.
00:28:58 And I can promise you,
00:29:00 both in UKIP and indeed in the Brexit Party,
00:29:03 we love Europe.
00:29:05 We just hate the European Union.
00:29:08 It's as simple as that.
00:29:10 So I'm hoping this begins the end of this project.
00:29:15 It's a bad project.
00:29:16 It isn't just undemocratic.
00:29:19 It's anti-democratic.
00:29:20 And it puts in that front row.
00:29:22 It gives people power without accountability.
00:29:26 People who cannot be held to account by the electorate.
00:29:30 And that is an unacceptable structure.
00:29:33 Indeed, there's an historic battle going on now
00:29:36 across the West,
00:29:37 in Europe,
00:29:38 America,
00:29:38 and elsewhere.
00:29:40 It is globalism against populism.
00:29:44 And you may loathe populism,
00:29:46 but I tell you a funny thing,
00:29:48 it's becoming very popular.
00:29:51 And it has great benefits.
00:29:53 No more financial contributions.
00:29:56 No more European Court of Justice.
00:29:58 No more common fisheries policy.
00:30:01 No more being talked down to.
00:30:02 No more being bullied.
00:30:05 No more Guy Verhofstadt.
00:30:07 I mean,
00:30:07 what's not to like?
00:30:10 I know you're going to miss us.
00:30:12 I know you want to ban our national flags.
00:30:15 But we're going to wave you goodbye.
00:30:17 And we'll look forward in the future
00:30:19 to working with you as sovereign.
00:30:24 If you disobey the rules,
00:30:26 you get cut off.
00:30:28 Could we please remove the flags?
00:30:33 Mr Farage.
00:30:34 Could we remove the flags, please?
00:30:38 That's it.
00:30:39 It's all over.
00:30:40 Finished.
00:30:42 We've gone.
00:30:44 Could I please ask for quiet?
00:30:45 Thank you.
00:30:46 Thank you.
00:30:47 Thank you.
00:30:48 Thank you.
00:30:48 Thank you.
00:30:48 Thank you.
00:30:48 Thank you.
00:30:49 Thank you.
00:30:49 Thank you.
00:30:49 Thank you.
00:30:50 Thank you.
00:30:51 Thank you.
00:30:51 Thank you.
00:30:51 Thank you.
00:30:52 Thank you.
00:30:55 I'm really...
00:30:56 Please sit down.
00:30:57 Resume your seats.
00:30:58 Put your flags away.
00:30:59 You're leaving.
00:31:00 And take them with you.
00:31:01 If you are leaving now.
00:31:02 Goodbye.
00:31:08 Isn't that just great?
00:31:09 Leave and take your flags with you.
00:31:11 I mean, the EU's entire existence
00:31:13 is trying to deny countries
00:31:15 their individuality.
00:31:16 So it's unsurprising
00:31:17 that they have a ban
00:31:18 on national flags
00:31:20 by the same stretch.
00:31:21 But Nigel Farage
00:31:22 and his caucus
00:31:23 happily obliged.
00:31:24 They left
00:31:25 and they took their flags with them
00:31:26 and they won't be coming back.
00:31:28 So good for the UK
00:31:29 for finally getting it.
00:31:30 I know there are still some issues
00:31:31 to be worked out.
00:31:32 But again,
00:31:33 this idea of
00:31:34 figure it out later
00:31:35 actually makes more sense
00:31:37 than delay indefinitely
00:31:38 while you try to come up
00:31:39 with a deal
00:31:40 when that lets the EU
00:31:41 drag its heels.
00:31:42 So thanks very much
00:31:43 for indulging
00:31:44 as I play that clip.
00:31:45 I'm a big Nigel Farage fan.
00:31:46 Back in a moment
00:31:47 with the perils
00:31:48 of official bilingualism
00:31:49 here on
00:31:50 The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:31:51 You're tuned in
00:31:54 to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:32:00 Welcome back.
00:32:01 Bienvenue tout le monde.
00:32:02 The bilingualism litmus test
00:32:05 is something that we have
00:32:06 to talk about here
00:32:07 because it's not
00:32:08 a requirement
00:32:09 to be the Conservative leader.
00:32:10 It's not a requirement
00:32:11 to be the Prime Minister
00:32:12 of Canada.
00:32:13 But the media thinks
00:32:14 it's not only necessary
00:32:15 but also is the most
00:32:17 important trait required
00:32:19 if you want to lead
00:32:20 the country
00:32:21 or lead a party.
00:32:22 And I'm here to say
00:32:23 I don't think
00:32:24 that's the case.
00:32:24 Now there are a couple
00:32:26 of things at stake here.
00:32:27 Peter McKay
00:32:28 when he announced
00:32:28 his campaign
00:32:29 made a little bit
00:32:30 of a flub
00:32:31 in the words
00:32:32 that he chose to use
00:32:34 when he was announcing.
00:32:35 Now admittedly
00:32:36 it's kind of a boneheaded move
00:32:38 to when you're announcing
00:32:39 and presumably
00:32:39 you're reading from a script
00:32:40 not using
00:32:42 the proper French terms.
00:32:44 I think he used
00:32:45 a three word line
00:32:46 and of the three words
00:32:47 he got exactly
00:32:48 three words wrong
00:32:49 which again
00:32:51 doesn't bode well
00:32:52 but it makes you mocked
00:32:53 but it doesn't take away
00:32:55 from the point here.
00:32:56 And the words
00:32:57 that he used
00:32:59 je serai candidat
00:33:01 instead of
00:33:02 je serai candidat.
00:33:04 And well
00:33:04 that may sound similar
00:33:05 if you don't speak French
00:33:06 it's
00:33:07 if you were to say it
00:33:08 in English
00:33:08 it would be like
00:33:09 imbcandidate
00:33:10 or imbcandida
00:33:12 or something
00:33:12 was what Stephen Marr
00:33:13 of Maclean's
00:33:14 tried to compare it to.
00:33:16 And it's not as amusing
00:33:17 as JFK's
00:33:19 infamous
00:33:19 ode to the jelly donut
00:33:21 the Ich bin ein
00:33:22 Berliner
00:33:22 error in German
00:33:24 but it is certainly
00:33:26 something that got
00:33:27 McKay mocked.
00:33:28 He was on the front page
00:33:29 of Le Journal de Québec
00:33:30 Le Journal de Montréal
00:33:31 and they were
00:33:32 saying in English
00:33:33 on Le Journal de Québec
00:33:35 good luck mister
00:33:36 as if to say
00:33:37 he has no hope
00:33:38 in heck of winning
00:33:39 because he didn't speak
00:33:40 those three words
00:33:41 of French properly.
00:33:42 And I do think
00:33:44 it's interesting
00:33:45 why Peter McKay
00:33:46 doesn't speak French
00:33:48 better.
00:33:48 I mean he's had
00:33:49 prime ministerial ambitions
00:33:50 for quite some time
00:33:52 he's obviously
00:33:53 been in politics
00:33:55 he as a cabinet minister
00:33:56 had access to
00:33:57 private French lessons
00:33:58 since then
00:33:59 he could have learned
00:34:00 so if he hasn't
00:34:01 I wonder why
00:34:03 but at the same time
00:34:04 I also think
00:34:05 that
00:34:05 we put way too much
00:34:07 stock in this
00:34:08 and
00:34:08 I don't even want to say
00:34:10 we
00:34:10 because I don't think
00:34:11 Canadians do
00:34:12 the media puts way
00:34:13 too much stock in this
00:34:14 and
00:34:16 Aaron O'Toole even
00:34:18 the conservative
00:34:18 leadership candidate
00:34:19 decided to spike
00:34:20 the football
00:34:21 on McKay
00:34:22 and Aaron O'Toole
00:34:23 had tweeted out
00:34:24 a link to this
00:34:25 McLean's article
00:34:26 called
00:34:26 Why Doesn't Peter McKay
00:34:27 Speak French
00:34:28 and he had said
00:34:29 in it
00:34:31 where was the
00:34:31 exact thing
00:34:32 how can you represent
00:34:33 Quebecers 0.66
00:34:34 when you can't speak
00:34:35 their language
00:34:36 and this was like
00:34:37 the first attack
00:34:38 of the conservative
00:34:39 leadership race
00:34:40 I think
00:34:40 and I've thought
00:34:42 about this a lot
00:34:43 and I think
00:34:43 there is a benefit
00:34:44 to speaking French
00:34:45 I think if you're
00:34:46 running a national campaign
00:34:47 and you know
00:34:48 that you're going
00:34:48 to be approached
00:34:49 by French language media
00:34:50 and you're going
00:34:51 to want to talk
00:34:51 to French voters
00:34:52 and be in a French debate
00:34:53 there is an advantage
00:34:55 to speaking French
00:34:56 but I don't think
00:34:58 it's a requirement
00:34:59 and I don't think
00:35:00 it's a given
00:35:01 and by the way
00:35:02 this litmus test
00:35:03 is not
00:35:04 a long-standing one
00:35:06 it's relatively new
00:35:07 in 1993
00:35:08 Preston Manning
00:35:09 did the French
00:35:10 language debate
00:35:11 and he got up
00:35:12 on stage
00:35:12 read a prepared
00:35:13 statement
00:35:14 I believe in English
00:35:15 I can't remember
00:35:16 I think it was
00:35:17 in English
00:35:17 that he read it
00:35:17 but it was
00:35:18 a prepared statement
00:35:19 didn't participate
00:35:20 in the debating
00:35:21 part of the French
00:35:21 debate
00:35:22 because he couldn't
00:35:22 understand what
00:35:23 was being said
00:35:24 and couldn't respond
00:35:25 and then he read
00:35:25 a prepared
00:35:26 closing statement
00:35:27 and that was that
00:35:28 and yeah people
00:35:29 in Quebec were upset
00:35:30 and then people said
00:35:31 oh well can he
00:35:31 can he actually
00:35:32 participate
00:35:32 but who cares
00:35:35 he's a party leader
00:35:36 he doesn't speak French
00:35:37 don't force it
00:35:38 there are other things
00:35:39 you can bring
00:35:39 to the table
00:35:40 and that's what
00:35:42 I think is missing
00:35:42 when everyone says
00:35:44 that speaking French
00:35:45 is the be-all
00:35:46 and end-all
00:35:46 if you're from
00:35:47 rural Alberta
00:35:49 or BC
00:35:49 or Saskatchewan
00:35:51 or most of Manitoba
00:35:52 and most of Ontario
00:35:53 and most of Atlantic Canada
00:35:55 the only reason
00:35:57 you have as a politician
00:35:58 to speak French
00:35:59 is to run for leader
00:36:02 of your party
00:36:03 basically
00:36:03 I mean there's a reason
00:36:04 that in Ottawa
00:36:05 hey so-and-so's
00:36:07 learning French
00:36:07 is kind of code
00:36:08 for hey I think
00:36:09 so-and-so is running
00:36:10 for leader of their party
00:36:11 because why else
00:36:13 would you need
00:36:14 that skill
00:36:15 if you are representing
00:36:16 a part of a country
00:36:17 that doesn't have
00:36:18 a French population
00:36:19 which is most
00:36:20 of the country
00:36:21 outside of Quebec
00:36:23 and outside of New Brunswick
00:36:24 the only two provinces
00:36:25 that have officially
00:36:27 enshrined French 0.99
00:36:28 the French population
00:36:29 is minuscule
00:36:30 and even Ontario
00:36:31 which has a Franco-Ontarian
00:36:33 population
00:36:34 and Manitoba
00:36:35 the tiny tiny percentages
00:36:37 of the overall population
00:36:40 of these provinces
00:36:41 we are a country
00:36:42 that has French
00:36:43 we are not a French country
00:36:44 and I think a lot of this
00:36:46 comes back
00:36:47 to official bilingualism
00:36:49 and I want to talk about that
00:36:50 in a moment
00:36:50 with a representative
00:36:51 of Canadians
00:36:52 for Language Fairness
00:36:53 Gordon Miller
00:36:54 but I also think
00:36:55 it's important
00:36:56 that we understand
00:36:57 that this is very much
00:36:59 a media driven
00:37:00 narrative
00:37:02 and not one
00:37:03 that the Conservative Party
00:37:04 of Canada
00:37:04 needs to take
00:37:05 too seriously
00:37:06 but there are people
00:37:07 in the CPC
00:37:08 that do take it seriously
00:37:09 I think a lot of that
00:37:11 is because they just
00:37:12 are backing a candidate
00:37:13 who speaks French
00:37:14 so if they can say
00:37:15 oh no they gotta speak French
00:37:16 you can't have someone
00:37:17 who doesn't speak French
00:37:18 it's just because
00:37:19 they're trying to
00:37:20 draw people to
00:37:21 whoever their candidate is
00:37:23 kind of like
00:37:24 Aaron O'Toole
00:37:24 was doing in that tweet
00:37:25 but I also think
00:37:27 you need to look
00:37:28 at the numbers
00:37:28 when Stephen Harper
00:37:29 won a majority government
00:37:31 in 2011
00:37:31 he had only five seats
00:37:33 in Quebec
00:37:34 so a Conservative majority
00:37:36 even does not rely
00:37:38 on Quebec votes
00:37:40 and Francophones
00:37:41 outside of Quebec
00:37:42 I don't think
00:37:42 are as obsessed
00:37:43 with this need
00:37:44 to speak French
00:37:45 like Quebecers are 1.00
00:37:47 and obviously
00:37:47 it's their language
00:37:48 I get it
00:37:49 but I wonder why
00:37:50 we can't just have
00:37:51 politicians
00:37:52 that appoint
00:37:53 lieutenants
00:37:54 lieutenants rather
00:37:55 to deal with
00:37:56 French issues
00:37:57 why can you not
00:37:58 just have a
00:37:58 Francophone lieutenant
00:37:59 in the same way
00:38:01 that politicians
00:38:01 will appoint someone
00:38:02 to deal with the West
00:38:04 someone to deal
00:38:04 with Quebec politics
00:38:06 someone to deal
00:38:06 with any of these areas
00:38:08 that require
00:38:09 special attention
00:38:10 you know the Prime Minister
00:38:12 represents all Canadians
00:38:14 yes
00:38:14 but they don't have
00:38:16 to be themselves
00:38:17 the embodiment
00:38:18 of all Canadians
00:38:19 you know a Prime Minister
00:38:20 has to represent
00:38:21 Liberals
00:38:22 Conservatives
00:38:23 Andy Pears
00:38:23 that doesn't mean
00:38:24 they need to be
00:38:24 all of those things
00:38:25 they can't be
00:38:26 you can represent
00:38:27 Francophones
00:38:28 without yourself
00:38:29 speaking French
00:38:31 just by surrounding
00:38:32 yourself with a team
00:38:33 of people that's going
00:38:34 to help you do it
00:38:35 the same way you would
00:38:36 to represent all of
00:38:37 these other Canadians
00:38:38 like those from the
00:38:39 North
00:38:39 like those who are
00:38:40 Indigenous
00:38:41 you don't have to be
00:38:42 those things
00:38:43 to represent those
00:38:44 things
00:38:44 and yes
00:38:46 is it an asset
00:38:47 to speak French
00:38:48 for sure
00:38:48 but if the time
00:38:50 that someone could
00:38:50 have put into
00:38:51 speaking French
00:38:51 they put into
00:38:52 volunteering
00:38:53 or learning
00:38:55 about history
00:38:56 or bettering
00:38:57 themselves
00:38:57 in some other way
00:38:58 why is that
00:38:59 less virtuous
00:39:00 than learning French
00:39:01 that's the question
00:39:02 that no one's been
00:39:03 prepared to answer
00:39:04 want to talk to
00:39:06 now from
00:39:07 the Board of Directors
00:39:08 of Canadians
00:39:08 for Language
00:39:09 Fairness
00:39:09 a group that
00:39:10 fights against
00:39:11 official bilingualism
00:39:12 Gordon Miller
00:39:13 who joins me
00:39:14 on the line now
00:39:15 Gordon thanks very much
00:39:16 for coming on sir
00:39:16 it's good to talk
00:39:17 to you
00:39:17 thank you
00:39:19 very good to talk
00:39:19 to you Andrew
00:39:20 so let's start
00:39:22 with the first
00:39:22 question here
00:39:23 of whether you
00:39:25 think
00:39:25 and your organization
00:39:26 thinks that someone
00:39:27 needs to speak
00:39:28 English and French
00:39:29 to represent
00:39:30 all Canadians
00:39:31 well
00:39:33 I guess really
00:39:35 our position
00:39:36 isn't whether
00:39:36 they need to
00:39:37 it's that
00:39:39 our concern
00:39:40 is that language
00:39:42 always seems
00:39:43 to trump
00:39:43 merit
00:39:44 and merit
00:39:45 is the principle
00:39:46 consideration
00:39:48 for any
00:39:50 major position
00:39:51 in Canada
00:39:52 and
00:39:53 as far as
00:39:54 I'm concerned
00:39:55 I don't care
00:39:56 whether the
00:39:56 Prime Minister
00:39:57 is unilingual
00:39:57 English
00:39:58 or unilingual
00:39:59 French
00:39:59 as long as
00:40:00 that person
00:40:00 stands for
00:40:01 principles
00:40:02 and
00:40:03 if we're
00:40:04 talking about
00:40:05 the current
00:40:05 Conservative Party
00:40:07 and their
00:40:07 consideration
00:40:08 that the
00:40:09 leader has
00:40:09 to be
00:40:09 bilingual
00:40:10 we just
00:40:12 don't agree
00:40:12 with that
00:40:13 well you
00:40:14 raise an
00:40:15 important
00:40:15 it's
00:40:16 desirable
00:40:16 sure
00:40:17 all other
00:40:20 things equal
00:40:20 bilingualism
00:40:21 is an
00:40:22 asset
00:40:22 well but
00:40:24 that's the
00:40:24 point there
00:40:25 is that
00:40:25 it is
00:40:26 something
00:40:26 that you
00:40:26 can look
00:40:27 at I
00:40:27 think
00:40:27 or should
00:40:28 be able
00:40:28 to look
00:40:29 at as
00:40:29 one of
00:40:30 many
00:40:30 qualities
00:40:31 that someone
00:40:32 could have
00:40:32 and it's
00:40:33 like you're
00:40:33 hiring for
00:40:34 a job
00:40:34 you say
00:40:35 alright
00:40:35 well you
00:40:35 know
00:40:35 they have
00:40:36 a master's
00:40:36 degree
00:40:36 but they
00:40:37 don't
00:40:37 speak
00:40:37 French
00:40:38 but they
00:40:38 have
00:40:38 10 years
00:40:39 of experience
00:40:39 and you
00:40:40 decide
00:40:40 at the
00:40:40 end
00:40:41 of it
00:40:41 on
00:40:41 balance
00:40:42 which
00:40:42 assets
00:40:43 matter
00:40:44 the most
00:40:44 and which
00:40:45 bundle of
00:40:46 assets and
00:40:47 traits you
00:40:48 might think
00:40:48 is better
00:40:49 than someone
00:40:49 else's
00:40:49 the idea
00:40:50 that we
00:40:51 see the
00:40:52 media putting
00:40:52 forward now
00:40:53 seems to be
00:40:53 as though
00:40:54 it's a deal
00:40:55 breaker
00:40:55 and that
00:40:56 idea of
00:40:56 making it
00:40:57 non-negotiable
00:40:58 I think
00:40:58 opens us up
00:40:59 to and I'm
00:41:00 glad you brought
00:41:00 up merit
00:41:01 a lot more
00:41:02 issues down
00:41:02 the line
00:41:03 if you're
00:41:03 prepared to
00:41:04 ignore all
00:41:05 of those
00:41:06 other traits
00:41:06 as long as
00:41:07 this one
00:41:08 is met
00:41:08 right on
00:41:10 Andrew
00:41:11 in fact
00:41:12 if this
00:41:13 country
00:41:14 operated in
00:41:15 the way
00:41:15 that you
00:41:15 just described
00:41:16 it would
00:41:17 be a
00:41:17 different
00:41:17 country
00:41:18 and a
00:41:18 vastly
00:41:19 more
00:41:20 I would
00:41:22 say
00:41:22 prosperous
00:41:23 and
00:41:24 harmonious
00:41:25 country
00:41:26 I know
00:41:27 you're up
00:41:28 there in
00:41:28 Ottawa
00:41:29 and I
00:41:29 used to
00:41:29 live in
00:41:30 Ottawa
00:41:30 years ago
00:41:31 and I
00:41:31 was working
00:41:32 for government
00:41:32 so I
00:41:33 didn't really
00:41:33 leave the
00:41:33 downtown
00:41:34 that much
00:41:35 and I
00:41:35 had this
00:41:36 vision
00:41:36 from just
00:41:37 walking
00:41:37 around
00:41:38 those
00:41:38 couple
00:41:39 of square
00:41:39 kilometers
00:41:40 that it
00:41:40 was a
00:41:41 I mean
00:41:41 at least
00:41:42 half English
00:41:43 half French
00:41:43 city
00:41:44 but certainly
00:41:45 one that
00:41:46 felt as
00:41:46 though the
00:41:47 French
00:41:47 population
00:41:48 was a lot
00:41:49 larger than
00:41:49 it actually
00:41:50 is if you
00:41:50 look at
00:41:51 the broader
00:41:52 city
00:41:52 and I do
00:41:53 think that
00:41:53 it's important
00:41:54 to note
00:41:54 here that
00:41:54 official
00:41:55 bilingualism
00:41:56 has it
00:41:57 sounds like
00:41:58 created this
00:41:59 idea and
00:42:01 this perception
00:42:02 that there
00:42:03 is a lot
00:42:03 more of a
00:42:05 presence of
00:42:06 Franco
00:42:06 Canadians
00:42:07 than there
00:42:08 actually is
00:42:09 outside of
00:42:09 Quebec
00:42:09 anyway
00:42:10 well you
00:42:12 get that
00:42:12 impression
00:42:13 and that
00:42:14 that's
00:42:14 actually a
00:42:15 legitimate
00:42:15 impression
00:42:16 because
00:42:16 Ottawa I
00:42:18 think it's
00:42:19 somewhere around
00:42:19 13 or 14
00:42:21 percent we
00:42:21 have
00:42:22 francophones
00:42:22 but you do
00:42:24 get the
00:42:24 impression that
00:42:25 it's much
00:42:25 more when
00:42:26 you're downtown
00:42:27 but a lot
00:42:27 of that's
00:42:28 because the
00:42:29 federal government
00:42:29 is in Ottawa
00:42:31 is about 70
00:42:32 percent francophones
00:42:33 it used to
00:42:34 be 30
00:42:35 and now
00:42:37 it's 70
00:42:37 how things
00:42:38 have turned
00:42:39 around but
00:42:40 you know all
00:42:40 of those
00:42:41 francophones
00:42:41 are from
00:42:42 Quebec and
00:42:42 they're downtown
00:42:43 in Ottawa
00:42:43 so you get
00:42:44 the impression
00:42:45 that the
00:42:45 city is much
00:42:46 more French
00:42:47 than it
00:42:47 really is
00:42:48 now is this
00:42:50 something that
00:42:51 we can link
00:42:51 back to a
00:42:53 real market
00:42:54 pivot point or
00:42:55 has this been a
00:42:56 gradual rise
00:42:57 because I think
00:42:58 that the issues
00:42:59 that we were
00:42:59 talking about at
00:43:00 the beginning
00:43:00 with the
00:43:01 conservative
00:43:02 leadership
00:43:02 litmus test
00:43:03 that we see
00:43:04 presented and
00:43:05 that stat you
00:43:06 just mentioned
00:43:06 about francophones
00:43:07 in the public
00:43:08 service I think
00:43:09 those two have
00:43:09 to be related
00:43:10 well actually
00:43:14 I'm kind of
00:43:15 missing your
00:43:16 point a wee bit
00:43:16 but it's all
00:43:19 very related
00:43:20 it all goes
00:43:21 back to the
00:43:21 official languages
00:43:22 act and the
00:43:23 growth of the
00:43:24 francophones in
00:43:25 the public
00:43:26 service is
00:43:27 strictly based on
00:43:28 French and it's 0.99
00:43:28 gotten to the
00:43:29 point now
00:43:30 unilingual
00:43:32 or sort of
00:43:33 marginally
00:43:34 bilingual
00:43:35 anglophones
00:43:36 in the
00:43:37 federal government
00:43:38 they're all
00:43:38 they're afraid
00:43:39 to even speak
00:43:40 about it
00:43:40 but there's
00:43:42 a definite
00:43:42 discrimination
00:43:43 going on
00:43:44 there
00:43:44 it can't
00:43:46 be denied
00:43:46 and that's
00:43:48 that's
00:43:49 Ottawa
00:43:50 yeah but I
00:43:52 guess the
00:43:52 question that I
00:43:53 was putting
00:43:53 there is has
00:43:54 this been
00:43:54 more gradual
00:43:55 or was it
00:43:56 just when
00:43:57 that official
00:43:57 languages act
00:43:58 was put into
00:43:59 effect it was
00:43:59 as though a
00:44:00 switch was
00:44:01 flipped and
00:44:01 we've never
00:44:01 gone back
00:44:02 well yes a
00:44:05 flip
00:44:05 switch was
00:44:09 flipped
00:44:09 but yes I
00:44:12 mean it
00:44:12 wasn't instantly
00:44:13 going from
00:44:14 30% francophones
00:44:16 to 70%
00:44:17 francophones and
00:44:18 quite honestly I
00:44:19 can't tell you
00:44:20 what exactly the
00:44:22 gradient was over
00:44:23 the years but
00:44:24 here's where we
00:44:26 are today and
00:44:27 the federal
00:44:28 public service
00:44:29 is a francophone
00:44:30 organization now
00:44:32 and you know
00:44:33 when you get
00:44:34 right down to
00:44:35 it the whole
00:44:37 concept of
00:44:38 bilingualism is
00:44:39 fine and
00:44:40 official bilingualism
00:44:41 well actually we
00:44:42 really don't agree
00:44:43 that there should
00:44:44 be language laws
00:44:45 but we certainly
00:44:46 do agree that
00:44:47 the federal
00:44:48 government where
00:44:49 it meets the
00:44:50 public should
00:44:51 definitely be able
00:44:52 to address the
00:44:54 public in both
00:44:55 languages and I
00:44:56 think you know if
00:44:56 you look at the
00:44:57 city of Ottawa
00:44:57 they do an
00:44:58 excellent job in
00:44:59 that regard in
00:45:00 terms of being
00:45:01 able to address
00:45:02 both languages in
00:45:03 fact I think we
00:45:04 actually think that
00:45:05 they go way over
00:45:06 the top but fine
00:45:08 at the public
00:45:10 interface that's
00:45:12 where bilingualism
00:45:13 should be and in
00:45:14 this country when
00:45:16 I really when you
00:45:16 think about it you
00:45:18 know anglophones
00:45:18 who grow up in
00:45:19 Quebec have an
00:45:20 opportunity to be
00:45:21 bilingual francophones
00:45:22 who grow up in the
00:45:23 rest of Canada have
00:45:24 an opportunity to
00:45:25 be bilingual there's
00:45:26 amazing opportunities
00:45:28 for bilingual people
00:45:29 where we need to
00:45:31 have bilingualism but
00:45:32 the problem with
00:45:32 official bilingualism
00:45:33 it's just over the
00:45:35 top and it really
00:45:37 what it amounts to
00:45:38 now is that you
00:45:39 really have to be
00:45:40 competent you know
00:45:41 highly competent in
00:45:43 French 85% of the
00:45:44 Canadian population
00:45:45 can't qualify for any
00:45:48 type of a supervisory or
00:45:49 management job in
00:45:50 government because
00:45:51 they're just not
00:45:51 sufficiently bilingual not
00:45:54 only that if you go
00:45:55 all the way back to
00:45:56 the official languages
00:45:57 act and look at the
00:45:59 percentage of the
00:46:00 Canadian population
00:46:01 it was somewhere
00:46:02 around 13 14% or so
00:46:04 was capable of being
00:46:08 bilingual today I
00:46:10 think it's 16 or 17%
00:46:12 it's hardly changed and
00:46:13 that's with all of this
00:46:14 money that's been
00:46:15 thrown into all of
00:46:16 these you know French
00:46:18 immersion schools across
00:46:20 Canada it's just over
00:46:23 the top and you know
00:46:25 when we start talking
00:46:26 about expense I mean we
00:46:27 don't even know how
00:46:28 much it's cost for all
00:46:30 of the training for
00:46:31 bilingualism in the
00:46:32 federal government and
00:46:35 what's more is that
00:46:37 training doesn't work an
00:46:39 awful lot of the time
00:46:40 because they go on
00:46:41 French training but
00:46:42 then they're still not
00:46:43 sufficiently qualified to
00:46:46 take those senior
00:46:46 positions because you
00:46:49 just can't learn a
00:46:50 language because you
00:46:52 go and take courses and
00:46:53 that sort of thing you
00:46:54 need to be immersed in
00:46:55 you have to live in it
00:46:57 and that's never going
00:46:58 to happen in across
00:47:00 this country well and
00:47:02 that right there is one
00:47:03 of the big problems we
00:47:04 see with conservative
00:47:06 leadership candidates in
00:47:07 the current context but
00:47:08 politicians more broadly
00:47:10 is that they're
00:47:11 criticized for not
00:47:11 speaking French and
00:47:13 even the ones that do
00:47:14 go through the process
00:47:15 of learning enough to
00:47:16 get by are then
00:47:17 criticized for not
00:47:19 being good enough at
00:47:20 French and at a
00:47:20 certain point it
00:47:22 seems like all they
00:47:23 want is for them to be
00:47:24 born as francophones
00:47:25 it seems like they
00:47:29 just are never going to
00:47:30 be happy unless it's a
00:47:31 francophone that's in
00:47:32 that position a native
00:47:33 born francophone and
00:47:34 that isn't realistic it's
00:47:36 not practical and it's
00:47:36 not where the country is
00:47:38 if you want to limit the
00:47:39 pool of talent to a group
00:47:42 that is still a minority
00:47:43 in Canada well not only
00:47:46 limit the pool to a
00:47:48 minority it happens to be
00:47:50 a minority that comes out 0.95
00:47:51 of Quebec and if you
00:47:52 look at what's happening
00:47:53 in Ontario they were
00:47:54 trying to put through
00:47:55 new a couple of new
00:47:57 acts that would make
00:47:58 Ontario essentially
00:48:00 officially bilingualism
00:48:01 across the province and
00:48:03 how do you fill all of
00:48:05 the necessary jobs when
00:48:07 everything has to be
00:48:08 bilingual well they're
00:48:09 going to have to come to
00:48:10 from Quebec so I mean it's
00:48:11 almost like they're asking
00:48:12 for an invasion yeah it
00:48:16 really it's funny though
00:48:17 because I was in Montreal
00:48:19 for a project I was working
00:48:21 on for one of the other
00:48:23 hats that I wear and I had
00:48:25 to navigate the bureaucracy
00:48:26 and I have a passable
00:48:27 knowledge of French I don't
00:48:29 consider myself fluent or
00:48:30 bilingual and I was dealing
00:48:32 with the city of Montreal and
00:48:33 at one point could not find
00:48:35 someone who spoke English now
00:48:37 I don't have an expectation
00:48:39 of that I'm in Quebec it's a
00:48:41 French province I get that
00:48:42 but it is interesting how
00:48:44 there is a double standard
00:48:46 there that what Quebec is
00:48:48 able to do as far as not
00:48:49 having anglophones in
00:48:51 positions of service would
00:48:53 never be able to fly on the
00:48:55 reverse in the federal
00:48:56 government anyway well
00:48:58 absolutely actually in
00:49:02 Canadians for language 0.95
00:49:03 fairness we actually believe
00:49:05 that Quebec as a province
00:49:06 has it right they are a
00:49:09 French culture with a 0.92
00:49:11 French language and they
00:49:12 want to preserve it that's
00:49:13 great we don't agree with
00:49:15 language laws but the point
00:49:18 of the matter is Quebec's
00:49:19 French it it always has been 0.99
00:49:22 and it probably always will be
00:49:24 unfortunately the rest of
00:49:26 Canada's English always has 0.99
00:49:29 been but will it be with the
00:49:32 amount of money that's spent by
00:49:33 the federal government and all
00:49:35 of these linguistic activist
00:49:37 groups that are trying to make the
00:49:40 rest of the country officially
00:49:42 bilingual province by province
00:49:44 well fortunately it'll never
00:49:45 happen at west but Ontario is in
00:49:47 dangerous position and if you look
00:49:49 recently the federal government
00:49:52 well let's put it this way
00:49:55 education is a provincial
00:49:58 responsibility under the British
00:50:00 North America Act in Ontario
00:50:03 uh Doug Ford uh said we're not
00:50:06 going to go ahead with this
00:50:08 ridiculous expense in this French 1.00
00:50:09 university in Toronto and then all 0.56
00:50:12 of a sudden the federal government
00:50:13 comes in with money and buys them
00:50:15 off well you know that that's a huge
00:50:17 problem because first of all the
00:50:19 federal government shouldn't be
00:50:20 involved in education and and and
00:50:22 second of all uh Doug Ford
00:50:25 essentially capitulated and said
00:50:28 okay well you know he'll go ahead with
00:50:29 you know go ahead with it now uh not
00:50:32 to mention with bills 135 and 137 to
00:50:35 make Ontario you know totally uh
00:50:38 francophone bilingual etc uh he was
00:50:42 basically silent on those things now
00:50:44 yes they didn't pass the you know this
00:50:46 the second read for the second
00:50:48 reading but nevertheless uh he he was
00:50:52 he was invisible and we really need to
00:50:55 start speaking up because as far as I'm
00:50:58 concerned I I have complete respect for
00:51:00 any francophone living in Ontario
00:51:02 uh I I think they should be able to be
00:51:05 addressed in their language at the
00:51:07 interface of the federal government
00:51:09 uh I would say though the Ontario
00:51:12 government uh in communities where
00:51:15 numbers warrant by all means but
00:51:17 there's no way we should be bilingual 1.00
00:51:19 across the province in that regard
00:51:21 because we just shouldn't be spending
00:51:22 money on that we're broke to begin with
00:51:25 yeah very well said and we're talking
00:51:28 about a bit about the budget early on so
00:51:30 you know you can have all these things
00:51:31 on the wish list but it doesn't mean
00:51:33 you have the ability to pay for them
00:51:35 Gordon Miller from Canadians for
00:51:36 Language Fairness joins me on the line
00:51:38 now thanks very much for your time
00:51:39 Gord
00:51:40 well thank you Andrew and thank you for
00:51:42 discussing the issues
00:51:44 you know that story in Montreal it was
00:51:46 very true I was trying to get a parking
00:51:48 permit and there was only one person in
00:51:51 the city of Montreal Bureau d'Access they
00:51:53 call it that could help she was on
00:51:55 lunch when she got back from lunch she
00:51:57 didn't speak English and I try I really
00:51:59 tried my best but at a certain point
00:52:01 you're dealing with technical
00:52:02 terminology where I don't have it in
00:52:05 French she had very little English she
00:52:07 had less English than I had French and
00:52:09 the greatest part where if I were to
00:52:12 script it in a movie you wouldn't
00:52:14 believe it happened was when a
00:52:16 Vietnamese guy was the savior for whom
00:52:19 English and French were his second and
00:52:22 third languages in some order and he
00:52:24 comes out and greets us with hola in
00:52:27 Spanish so we just what we needed
00:52:28 another language into the mix here but
00:52:30 eventually I got the parking permit so
00:52:32 all was good in paradise or Montreal
00:52:34 anyway that does it for us today my
00:52:37 thanks to all of you for tuning into
00:52:39 the show and supporting the program
00:52:40 we'll be back next week with more of
00:52:42 Canada's most irreverent talk show the
00:52:45 Andrew Lawton show on true north thank
00:52:47 you God bless and good day Canada
00:52:48 thanks for listening to the Andrew
00:52:50 Lawton show support the program by
00:52:52 donating to true north at www.tnc.news
00:52:56 you