Juno News - April 12, 2023


Crime is making Canadians feel less safe

Topics
Mentioned
Trans activists want to ban Fox News in Canada It looks like GAME OVER for Justin Trudeau

Episode Stats


Length

34 minutes

Words per minute

173.62

Word count

5,917

Sentence count

243

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

7

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, Andrew Lawton takes a deep dive into the growing problem of crime in Canada, and why it's so bad. He's joined by the legend of a man himself, Lauren Gunter, to talk about the Trudeau government's attempt to ban a column about it from social media.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:00:05 This is the Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:00:15 Hello and welcome to you all, Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show here,
00:00:20 the Andrew Lawton Show on True North, 4.02 Eastern Time,
00:00:24 a point that is as meaningless as it comes if you're listening after the fact on podcast.
00:00:29 but know that that's what time it is right now if you want to get a big a big a little bit of
00:00:34 context in the show so if uh you know the whole world goes to hell in a handbasket at you know
00:00:38 i don't know 4 47 you'll know that i wasn't just not reporting the story it had not happened yet
00:00:44 by the time this show went to air but we are as we try to be more often than not live and we're
00:00:50 going to have lauren gunter the fantastic alberta institution the legend of a man the columnist
00:00:55 with us to talk about the column of his that the Trudeau government literally wanted censored
00:01:01 from social media. So that's something that will be coming up very shortly. And I also want to talk
00:01:07 a little bit later on about some other odds and ends, some bits and pieces, some potpourri, as
00:01:12 they say. But I have to start with a bit of a first world problem here, because I always like
00:01:17 to fancy myself a man of the people. And like all men of the people, I have an espresso machine in
00:01:22 my home, which I was cutting it very close and almost missed the beginning of the show
00:01:27 because I had an espresso extraction incident, which is to say the machine ran out of water
00:01:33 as I was trying to extract the espresso shot, which makes for a bit of a bitter, some might
00:01:39 even say, it's the proper word, astringent taste to the espresso, but I nonetheless am
00:01:46 plowing ahead and like most people in this country, I'm settling for crappy coffee right
00:01:50 now because that is what I ended up making for myself. But I think I have enough energy to get
00:01:56 through the next little while here. I want to talk about the crime wave that we're seeing in Canada.
00:02:02 And I want to just preface that by saying a lot of the times news coverage of crime does not
00:02:10 actually equate to bona fide crime statistics. So sometimes there are periods where we perceive that
00:02:17 crime is more rampant but it's actually that it's being covered more or we're noticing it more
00:02:21 the problem with a lot of official statistics is that they are very much lagging indicators by the
00:02:27 time we get the data to substantiate what we've seen it's years later so i i think in the meantime
00:02:33 we have to defer to people's experiences to some extent and we have to look around and see what it
00:02:40 is that's actually going on around us in the world here and i don't think few people well let me take
00:02:46 a step back. Most honest, real people, I'm not talking about dyed-in-the-wool partisans,
00:02:52 but real people are looking around and seeing crime, maybe not at record levels, but certainly
00:02:58 at significant levels and certainly higher than it's ever been in recent years. You talk to
00:03:02 in pretty much any city in this country, someone who owns a business in a downtown area or in an
00:03:10 area that is often replete with drug use or gang violence, and they're going to tell you exactly
00:03:16 what they're seeing. You've got businesses shuttering because they cannot deal with what's
00:03:22 happening there, either for public safety reasons or even just for insurance reasons.
00:03:27 And there was an interesting study that came out that, to be honest, the headline didn't really do
00:03:32 justice. The headline in a CTV story, polls suggest Canadians feel less safe than they did
00:03:39 before the COVID-19 pandemic hit. Now, when I first saw that headline, I assumed it was a column
00:03:45 about the COVID worry warts. I assumed that it was about people that just believe they need their
00:03:50 17 N95 masks to walk down an outdoor street. And I was about to do a segment about just the
00:03:56 brokenness of humanity right now. And then I read the story, I read the study it was talking about
00:04:02 and realized, okay, this isn't actually about COVID safety, it's about crime and just people
00:04:07 sort of comparing where they are now and where they feel their communities are now with where
00:04:12 they were three years ago, which is when, you know, for the last time people were actually
00:04:17 able to walk out and about and see their communities and allowed to leave their homes
00:04:21 and all that.
00:04:22 And if you look at these numbers here, it's very stark.
00:04:25 So 32% of those surveyed, and it's a poll, so take it with a grain of salt, say that
00:04:31 crime has gotten much worse in the last three years.
00:04:35 32% say it's a little worse. So combined, I'm no math expert, that's 64%, which is just shy of two
00:04:42 thirds, who would say crime and violence have gotten worse than the last three years would
00:04:48 suggest it was at the beginning of that time. And that is quite significant. When you've got
00:04:53 two thirds of people saying that they think the country is significantly less safe, then, I mean,
00:05:00 three years is not a long period of time. We're not talking about people saying, yeah, when I was
00:05:05 a kid it was better we're talking about people saying you know three years ago life felt safer
00:05:10 the world felt safer the country felt safer than it does today and again just for context a quarter
00:05:16 of the people said it didn't change eight percent said they don't know two percent said things are
00:05:21 better so the two percent are probably the ones that are out on bail that think things are all
00:05:25 hunky-dory right now and just to give you some stories from the last week alone here's one from
00:05:33 Calgary. Man may seek bail after being accused of drugging and raping Calgary sex workers. 0.83
00:05:40 Here's another story from just this morning. 17-year-old dead after stabbing on bus in Surrey,
00:05:46 British Columbia. Here's one from yesterday. Woman brought back to Canada from ISIS camps
00:05:52 released on bail. Now, I believe in balance. I believe in telling the other side of the story.
00:06:00 Not everyone is getting out on bail. Some people are languishing behind bars indefinitely, like, for example, Pastor Derek Reimer.
00:06:09 He had the grave, vile offense of protesting a drag show. He wasn't in an ISIS camp. He was not killing someone on a bus.
00:06:19 He was not drugging and raping sex workers. He did something much worse. 0.99
00:06:22 He actually said, you should stay away from our children if you're trying to sexualize them.
00:06:27 And he remains behind bars while the lawyers are trying to get around to scheduling a bail hearing.
00:06:33 So like I said, not everyone is getting out on bail.
00:06:36 If you are a pastor that doesn't like drag shows, you are still behind bars.
00:06:40 But if you are a former ISIS alum, well, I guess alums are all former.
00:06:46 If you're an ISIS alum, you get out on bail.
00:06:48 You have a case for bail if you are going after sex workers.
00:06:52 And if you stab someone on a bus, you probably won't get bail there.
00:06:55 But it's interesting if you look at a lot of the other stories of that ilk in recent months
00:07:01 and find how frequent it is to see the line in the police press release
00:07:04 that said this was an offender that was released out on bail.
00:07:08 If you really want to have some fun, you should actually go and subscribe
00:07:11 to all the news releases from various police departments in this country.
00:07:16 And you'll see when they release these offenders, they'll actually send an alert
00:07:19 that says we are releasing a high-risk offender into the community.
00:07:23 here's what they look like, here's their name, what they do, and you say, well, that seems like
00:07:27 the type of person we shouldn't release, but alas, that is not the way the system is oriented.
00:07:32 Now, believe me when I say I am actually not one of these people that is the complete tough-on
00:07:40 crime to the point of just destroying people's lives for minor offenses they've made. No, I
00:07:46 believe that carceral punishment, so putting people behind bars, should not be taken lightly
00:07:53 at all. But we're talking about violent offenders here. We're not talking about drug offenders.
00:07:58 We're not even talking about people that have cheated on their taxes or whatever, which again,
00:08:02 probably get to a worse treatment than a lot of formerly capital offenses do in this day and age.
00:08:08 We're talking about people here who have done very heinous things, who will continue to do
00:08:14 heinous things, and who are part of this system, not because they are victims of the system,
00:08:19 but because people that interact with them in the real world become victims of them.
00:08:25 So I'm not all that surprised that Canadians are finding things just a little wee bit less safe.
00:08:30 And they're looking at governments, federal and provincial, and saying,
00:08:33 you guys are the problem. You guys solved this.
00:08:36 There was one, just a side of a story here to bring up,
00:08:40 that the surge in suicidal and threatening calls to CRA call centers during the pandemic was observed.
00:08:47 So people who work at the Canada Revenue Agency, again, not a department that I have much use for, but the people there are saying they've had more threatening calls in the pandemic, they've had more suicidal calls, and I don't know, maybe people think if they just threaten suicide, they'll get a break on their taxes or whatever, but the thing there that I take from this is that government has presided over a breaking of society in the last few years.
00:09:15 Government has pushed people to the brink, and I'm not saying it's Justin Trudeau's fault that someone wants to stab someone on a bus.
00:09:21 I'm not saying it's Justin Trudeau's fault that someone wants to kill themselves or tell a CRA worker they're wanting to kill themselves.
00:09:28 But I do think government policies in aggregate, on the whole, have made things worse for so many people in this country.
00:09:36 And government is not there to come up with the solutions to those problems.
00:09:40 Government's not there to say, okay, let's now help you through it.
00:09:43 So they have created a public health crisis far worse than the pandemic and are nowhere to be found when it comes to trying to solve it, which is probably just as well because I think this government has shown that it is incapable of providing solutions that don't exacerbate the problem and then create new ones.
00:10:01 And such is, here's for a subtle segue here, the case of the government's internet regulation, where again, they are creating solutions in search of a problem that doesn't exist.
00:10:12 And if you want to get a little bit of a glimpse of what the government-regulated internet space is going to look like, you needn't look further than what happened to a good friend of True North's and of basically anyone who's picked up a newspaper in Alberta over the last many years.
00:10:28 Lauren Gunter. This is a columnist who I actually have not had on this show. I had him on my old
00:10:34 radio show a couple of times. But Lauren Gunter dared to criticize the Canadian government's 1.00
00:10:41 approach to refugees and immigration more broadly. And this was something that I guess
00:10:46 the government didn't like. So what the government did is tried to get this thing pulled from social
00:10:54 media. There's a record of government trying to get this whole column taken off of Facebook and
00:11:00 Twitter. And we didn't learn in the initial stories what article they were talking about,
00:11:05 but thankfully, Lorne Gunter agreed to out himself here and he joins us now. Lorne, what have you
00:11:10 done? Well, you know, I've added some specifics to a non-specific item that the government
00:11:20 admitted to in a parliamentary question.
00:11:25 There was a Conservative MP asked the Liberals
00:11:28 to give some examples of efforts they'd made
00:11:32 to have Internet content controlled prior to their Bill C-11,
00:11:39 which still has not yet been proclaimed but will become law very soon.
00:11:44 And so there was a whole list came back, 180 pages,
00:11:47 some with one or two items on them.
00:11:49 And when it says an unspecified newspaper column about the Immigration and Refugee Board, Director of Communications asked Facebook and Twitter to remove links to this item from their platforms.
00:12:04 And so I knew who it was when I was shown it by editors. And it was a piece that I'd written in September of 2021. I'd come into possession of a confidential internal document that the IRB had, that the chairman had drafted and was circulating among staff and professionals that said, you know,
00:12:27 we are now going to try and make it much easier for refugees to stay in canada prior to
00:12:35 this policy that had not yet been introduced at that time was just being debated but but prior to
00:12:42 that you had to show that you were under threat of torture or death if you were sent back to your
00:12:46 home country you had to show that you were you know you're in in grave personal danger or you
00:12:52 had to prove that you met met the united nations criteria for what a legal refugee was and this
00:13:00 policy would have said anybody who was suffering from any two discriminations
00:13:08 and that would be poverty age sexual orientation race ideology religion any of those if you had
00:13:15 two of those then there was nothing that the irb could do or very little that the irb could do
00:13:21 unless you're a security threat uh to keep you out as long as you got here if you could say
00:13:27 you know i'm gay and poor i'm indigenous and i have views that my government doesn't like 0.72
00:13:33 you know i i'm old and and i'm whatever whatever the other criteria might be if you had any two of
00:13:42 these intersectionality uh criteria uh then there was very little that the adjudicators could do
00:13:49 to keep you out of Canada. Government didn't like that I had that. And so they then went
00:13:56 to my editors and said, you need to retract this, or you need to correct all of the following
00:14:02 factual errors. My editor said there are no factual errors that we can tell, and we're not
00:14:08 going to retract it. So then the director of communications at the time of the IRB,
00:14:12 and we're not entirely sure who that was, went to Facebook and Twitter in particular,
00:14:19 and said we want you to take these down because they contain dangerous misinformation and not
00:14:26 surprisingly that is the terminology that the liberals are using in their new bill to try and
00:14:33 justify handing over the power to the canadian radio television and telecommunications commission
00:14:39 the crtc or to an internet safety board to take down dangerous misinformation even if it's legal
00:14:47 under their new law so i i think what what we've seen with with their attempts to to take my piece
00:14:54 off the internet is a glimpse of of canada's future well i fear you're right and i just want
00:15:00 to drill into the the who for a moment do you know if this was someone that came from the minister's
00:15:06 office being someone who's a a partisan liberal staffer or from the departmental side which is
00:15:12 supposed to be uh staffed by non-partisan bureaucrats such as they are yeah i mean as
00:15:18 near as we can tell because there's very little information about who actually made the request
00:15:22 of the social media platform but as near as we can tell is a staffer from the immigration and
00:15:28 refugee board uh who who sought to have this done but you know so not someone who's supposed to be a
00:15:33 partisan no no so it was supposed to it was a person who was supposed to be uh an objective
00:15:40 bureaucrat who was supposed to be doing you know objective work not not a political operative who
00:15:47 was trying to shine the government's apple uh but you know from 2015 on the liberals had been
00:15:56 going out of their way to appoint people who are ideologically friendly to their view of increasing
00:16:02 immigration uh to places on the irb so uh the people the the permanent staffers at the irb
00:16:10 and the political appointees would have known on one side their bread was buttered uh but they
00:16:16 probably also would have ideologically agreed largely with with the liberals efforts to increase
00:16:21 at this point it seems funny now to to to consider this but you know i i said this is this is kind of
00:16:28 outrageous because the liberals are trying to in one fell swoop increase immigration to canada
00:16:34 newcomers to canada from 300 000 a year to 400 000 a year well now they've blown well past 400 000
00:16:42 a year but at the time they were trying to increase immigration by a third yeah by using these
00:16:49 tactics that were never going to be debated in parliament by by increasing the uh criteria by by
00:16:56 greatly expanding the ways you could claim refugee status in canada and i they didn't like that but
00:17:03 you know it's funny because they said well this this article is full of of uh mistakes and
00:17:09 misinformation but i quoted enough of this internal document that they must have known
00:17:16 i had the original and yeah and this was i mean i i remember the column it was it was reporting it
00:17:22 it wasn't just you sort of going on about some opinion or some theoretical thing you had the
00:17:26 document they would have known that document existed yeah they would have and it was you
00:17:31 know it was put out by the chairman of the board at the time richard wex and and so they were just
00:17:39 they were embarrassed that it had been found out before it could become policy and make a political
00:17:46 problem for the government. And that's, to me, that's the really troubling part, is that
00:17:51 because it was embarrassing to them, not because it was factually incorrect, not because I was
00:17:56 inciting riots, not because I had done something illegal, but because it was embarrassing to the
00:18:03 government. They got caught trying to sneak through a major change to immigration and refugee
00:18:10 policy they wanted it pulled out and they used the cover of dangerous misinformation to try and
00:18:17 make that happen now imagine so they they go to Facebook they go to Twitter both of whom said no
00:18:24 there's nothing wrong about this isn't misinformation necessarily it's it's fair comment but now imagine
00:18:32 if under Bill C-11 the government hands the power to take those things down to the CRTC which is
00:18:39 full of government appointees or even worse to a board of internet safety which is all government
00:18:46 appointees and they say you know it doesn't have to be illegal for you to take it down if you think
00:18:52 that this is dangerous misinformation you the safety board or the crtc have the power under
00:18:59 this new law to start deciding what can and cannot be posted on the internet and that just
00:19:05 that really frightens me. Well, it should. And I would point out to people here that in this case,
00:19:11 the social media companies didn't take what I would say is a particularly principled free speech
00:19:16 view. They didn't defend your reporting. They just said, listen, your fight's not with us.
00:19:20 It's with the Calgary Sun. It's not our original content was the line, which, you know, as far as
00:19:24 social media platforms go, I think that's a win. They just said to the government, you know, we're
00:19:28 not interested in playing this game. But you look at now, as you've alluded to, Lorne, the policies
00:19:33 that are coming down the pipeline, which would threaten social media companies with very steep
00:19:39 fines if they don't take down content that's identified as being wrong in one of the several
00:19:45 categories. And interestingly enough, I was just at a seminar about this. And if you look at the
00:19:50 categories, they include misinformation in the same bundle as hate speech and child pornography.
00:19:58 So they're using online harm laws that are intended for child pornography to go after, quote unquote, misinformation.
00:20:05 Well, and they have a very wide, very broad definition of what constitute hate speech.
00:20:11 When I first started covering hate speech, which would be back in the late 90s, you had to convince a court that under a very narrow definition that was set out by the Supreme Court, the speech that was published or broadcast had been hateful, according to some very narrow definitions.
00:20:34 Now, really, hate is in the ear of the hearer.
00:20:37 It's not in the mouth of the speaker.
00:20:40 So if you say something that the most sensitive activist in a ideological cause thinks is hateful, then it's hateful. And that's what I worry about, too, is that, you know, child pornography, fine.
00:20:59 We should keep children safe from pornographers.
00:21:05 But if the person in an activist organization who hears my microaggression feels that they're hated upon as a result of it, they can go to the upcoming Internet Safety Board and say, this is really bad.
00:21:22 You should take it down.
00:21:23 There's a good example of that, too. 0.67
00:21:25 The CRTC has been petitioned by EGAL, which is an LGBTQ rights group, to bar Fox News from being rebroadcast in Canada, from the cable stations or the satellite services, from carrying Fox News. 0.94
00:21:41 because Fox News has lots of people on it who don't believe that trans people have a right to all the same protections that non-trans people do,
00:21:56 or that LGBTQ communities, I'm actually not phrasing that properly.
00:22:02 No, but I get what you're saying, and as I was saying on the show yesterday,
00:22:05 imagine if that power were extended to Fox News clips on YouTube,
00:22:09 So it's not enough that you take Fox off the air, but Canadians shouldn't be able to access Tucker Carlson on YouTube or Rumble or anything.
00:22:17 Yeah, exactly. And, you know, I have my own problems with Tucker Carlson.
00:22:22 I remember when he was a bow tie wearing nerd about 25 years ago who wouldn't say butter if his mouth was full of it.
00:22:32 And now he's the fire breathing dragon of the alt right.
00:22:39 And so I have trouble with him.
00:22:40 But do I want to ban him?
00:22:42 No, but I have the same problem with all sorts of commentators on the left.
00:22:46 Do I want them banned because every time I listen to them, my blood pressure rises and my cardiologist tells me that I have to turn that off?
00:22:54 No, I don't.
00:22:56 That's what free speech is about.
00:22:58 I like often to use the example of newspapers in London.
00:23:02 There are eight daily newspapers in London, and none of them, except perhaps the Times of London, makes any claims to being balanced.
00:23:11 What they say is that among the eight of us, there is balance.
00:23:16 If you don't like what one of us is writing, you can read another one and you can find the opinions or the slant that you want.
00:23:23 And, you know, that's how you get to balance and freedom of expression.
00:23:28 But you don't do it through government regulators.
00:23:31 No. And to go back to your column, I mean, if the government felt so strongly that it had been misrepresented in your piece, why don't they do, you know, Katie Telford's favorite pastime of just planting some op-ed to rebut you in another paper? I mean, go down the street to the Calgary Herald and say, we'd like to denounce what Lauren Gunter said. And again, I think, you know, the reality of it here is they knew that the facts were on your side. But if you don't like a particular bit of expression, respond to it with better expression.
00:23:59 this is not a difficult concept and my editors did offer wex the the chairman of the uh of the
00:24:07 immigration refugee board did offer him equal space to explain what it was that i had gone
00:24:14 which is incredibly generous by the way of course of course it is but that's yeah i'm all for that
00:24:19 if you don't like what i've written and you you will take the time to to pen your own 600 words
00:24:25 have added that and now especially it's it's a little bit trickier when you have a printed
00:24:31 newspaper but now that we all have websites with sort of unlimited space that's exactly how it
00:24:37 should be handled but not going to the social media giants and saying this is dangerous misinformation
00:24:46 you should take it down that that is nothing but censorship lauren gunter calgary sun columnist
00:24:53 Glad you were not censored, and I'm glad to always continue to read your work.
00:24:57 Thanks so much for coming on today, Lorne.
00:24:59 You bet.
00:25:00 All right, thank you.
00:25:01 And let me just say, I mean, obviously what the government was trying to do to Lorne and his piece
00:25:07 was what Twitter did to the New York Post when they published their reporting about Hunter Biden's laptop.
00:25:13 And this was a big, big story that had waves and had momentum.
00:25:17 People knew about it.
00:25:18 People could go and read it for themselves.
00:25:21 Twitter ended up apologizing for it, but funnily enough, the damage had already been done by that
00:25:25 point. But people who did not know about the story, who weren't plugged into the ins and outs
00:25:30 of online regulation, actually never saw this thing. There was a mainstream media blackout,
00:25:35 there was a social media blackout, and as a result, no one is actually seeing this story
00:25:41 except for those who already knew about it. And I imagine if that were to happen, and this is not a
00:25:46 slight at Lorne or the Calgary Sun, but they're smaller than the New York Post.
00:25:50 Imagine if this were happening to smaller outlets that do not have the ability to as easily blast
00:25:57 out to people, hey, this article is being censored. Well, that would mean that all of a sudden
00:26:02 government bureaucrats are controlling the narrative. What if they're doing this in an
00:26:07 election? What if during an election campaign, you have the same government officials that are
00:26:13 going to Twitter and Facebook and saying, you have to take down this column. Actually, you know,
00:26:17 we think that's misinformation. Even though it's quoting a document of ours, we think it's
00:26:22 misinformation and has to go. So you can say in this case, yes, it all ended up as it was supposed
00:26:28 to. The article wasn't censored and the bureaucrat can just go back to, you know, just claiming
00:26:32 overtime and, you know, extended trips. And at the same time, we don't know how many cases they are
00:26:39 doing this with success. If they had a contact, again, if I wanted something taken down from
00:26:46 Twitter and Facebook, I could, you know, go and there's a little report button in there. You can
00:26:50 report. And when you report something, it asks you, is this because, you know, you're being
00:26:55 misgendered or is it because they're threatening self-harm? And you can say, no, it's because it's
00:27:00 misinformation. For all we know, they had existing relationships with Twitter and Facebook, or they
00:27:05 say, oh, if you want to get a column taken down, why don't you just call up Sarah? She works in
00:27:10 the account takedowns department. And the whole point is that we wouldn't even know. So when you
00:27:16 have this process taking place before the internet regulation bill is even there, imagine how bad
00:27:24 it's going to be when government cements this power and actually starts threatening social
00:27:28 media companies with fines if they do not comply. That is absolutely what's going to happen with
00:27:34 this, whether it's the Lauren Cunter case, whether it's the Agal Canada and Tucker Carlson case,
00:27:40 or many others that come up that are eerily similar to this. There are people in the government right
00:27:46 now and in civil society, activists, media types, politicians that fundamentally do not believe in
00:27:52 free speech. They do not agree with the premise of free speech. They do not agree with open debate
00:27:57 and they actually want dissent to be silenced. And they probably wouldn't even hide that as much
00:28:03 as you'd think. And these people, legitimately, I'm going to do probably next week, maybe in a
00:28:09 couple of weeks, a bigger deep dive into C11, because I know that a lot of people still do
00:28:14 not understand the ins and outs of it. They don't understand why it's so dangerous. And you have to
00:28:19 look at it in the context of all of these other internet regulations. But I mentioned to Lauren,
00:28:26 there are different categories of harm that are being dealt with under the auspices of what they
00:28:32 colloquially call an online harms bill or an online safety bill. And I can't remember the
00:28:37 whole list, but I do know that on that list is misinformation, disinformation. On that list is
00:28:44 hate speech. And on that list is child sexual exploitation. CSEM, they call it. Child sexual 0.65
00:28:52 exploitation materials, I believe. And the fact that they're taking the same tool and applying it
00:28:59 to all of this stuff simultaneously as though child porn is on the same moral and logistical
00:29:07 and legal plane as a column about immigration from Lorne Gunter is absolutely insane.
00:29:14 And the reason they're doing it is so that when people eventually criticize this, when people
00:29:19 like me stand up and say, whoa, whoa, whoa, I do not support the government controlling free
00:29:23 speech like this, it's so that the government can turn around and say, are you saying you
00:29:28 support child pornography online, mark my words, that is going to be what happens. They're throwing
00:29:34 that in there just because it's the sacred cow that no one can criticize. Whereas I would fight
00:29:38 back to them and say, no, actually I care so much about child pornography. I want you to pluck that
00:29:43 out and pass it as its own law right now. Put huge penalties on platforms that do not take down child
00:29:50 pornography. Throw the book because it's already illegal. The material is already illegal. They
00:29:55 just need to talk about ways that they can better manage taking it down. Misinformation, disinformation,
00:30:01 that is a far more contentious category. You know, I don't like dishonesty. I don't like
00:30:07 dishonest reporting, but we already know that this government has a particular tendency to
00:30:12 label as misinformation news coverage that it does not like. Look at Jerry Butts right now.
00:30:19 I don't encourage following Jerry Butts on Twitter, and it's actually difficult to do because he's
00:30:23 blocked. I think like half of the people who listen to this show, but not me, oddly. Jerry
00:30:28 Butts, though, he's been like on this crusade at the Globe and Mail ever since the Globe and Mail
00:30:32 broke the SNC-Lavalin story. And he's upset that they took down We Charity. He's upset that now
00:30:38 they're taking down the Trudeau Foundation. The entire board of directors for the Trudeau
00:30:43 Foundation resigned this week. And Jerry Butts is basically saying it's the media's fault,
00:30:49 not the fault of those who decided they wanted to take a big fact check from the Chinese
00:30:53 Politburo via a prominent connected businessman of sorts.
00:30:58 But nevertheless, I want to thank you all for tuning in to the show today.
00:31:02 Just very briefly here, I'm not one of these huge AI junkies.
00:31:07 I've talked about it in the past on the show.
00:31:09 It was a bit of a novelty when it came out and you could actually type in and have these
00:31:13 like conversations with the AI chatbot.
00:31:17 And the reason I will have a conversation with the AI chatbot is because the AI chatbot
00:31:22 actually is interested in listening to me speak, which not everyone is for some reason. But the
00:31:27 thing about this is that it's actually not as crazy as some people think. When you're reading
00:31:33 it, for example, I told it to tell me a joke and I picked three very random things. I think I said,
00:31:40 tell me a joke about a Lynx, a MacBook, and a slipper or something stupid like that. 1.00
00:31:47 And the joke it gave me was so stupid, you'd think the prime minister said it at a press 1.00
00:31:52 conference. 1.00
00:31:52 It was just completely nonsensical and it wasn't particularly funny in any meaningful
00:31:57 way.
00:31:57 And I said, you know, if I were a comedian, I would be incredibly happy right now with
00:32:01 the fact that AI is not sufficiently funny to displace me from being able to perform.
00:32:07 Now, I should say a lot of modern comedians aren't particularly funny either.
00:32:11 So maybe AI is just going based off of what's already out there.
00:32:15 But the AI thing is not as ascendant as people would like to believe.
00:32:21 So I was actually very surprised to see that in the University of Toronto at St. Michael's
00:32:26 College, starting in the fall, there's going to be a class about AI, but the class is going
00:32:32 to be conducted by AI.
00:32:35 So it has like a professor who's designed it, but they're using research prompts and
00:32:40 assignments and materials that have been curated by artificial intelligence.
00:32:45 So again, I don't know if this is going to work out or not.
00:32:48 I mean, if the professor succeeds, then I guess he can just get fired because he'll
00:32:53 have proven that the AI could do his job better than he did.
00:32:56 So it's just like a very meta Inception-like thing.
00:32:59 The St. Mike's to offer an experimental course taught by AI.
00:33:04 So even your university degrees now are being taught by this computer that is supposed to
00:33:10 be smarter than you and will eventually take over from us.
00:33:13 but we're okay letting it happen.
00:33:15 So I think it's a bit of a novelty.
00:33:17 I'm not one of these people that like thinks,
00:33:19 oh, the cell phone, that's never going to catch on.
00:33:20 No, I like technology.
00:33:22 I like innovation.
00:33:23 I like development.
00:33:24 And I know this thing will continue to get better,
00:33:26 but I don't buy that the AI revolution is here just yet.
00:33:31 So there will always be people around
00:33:33 to screw everything up.
00:33:34 You don't need machines to help with that.
00:33:36 That's it for today.
00:33:38 We'll be back on Friday
00:33:39 with another edition of the Andrew Lawton Show
00:33:41 talking about the decline of civilization,
00:33:43 a big cheery topic to head into the weekend,
00:33:46 but we'll liven things up with Fake News Friday.
00:33:48 That's all coming up in two days here on True North.
00:33:52 Stay tuned.
00:33:52 Thank you.
00:33:53 God bless and good day to you all.
00:33:56 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:33:58 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.