Juno News - August 22, 2026


David Eby is giving away hundreds of thousands of acres to First Nations communities


Episode Stats


Length

15 minutes

Words per minute

133.64

Word count

2,023

Sentence count

65

Harmful content

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00.000 The British Columbia government led by David Eby is now just handing away public land,
00:00:12.400 crown land, to First Nations. We're not talking about remote land that you were
00:00:16.720 never going to step foot on anyway. We're talking about prime Victoria real estate,
00:00:21.860 waterfront real estate, national parks, Royal Roads University and Hatley Castle,
00:00:27.560 just to name a few. This is like the inevitable outcome from all those land acknowledgements.
00:00:34.220 We went from proclaiming that the land belongs to First Nations communities to now just giving 0.93
00:00:39.800 it to them outright. What's going on in British Columbia is genuinely insane and it should concern
00:00:46.000 everyone. The Canadian government and big tech find new ways every day to shut down and silence
00:00:50.860 conservative voices online. There's no longer this big moment when you get cancelled. It's done so
00:00:55.960 quietly behind your back by tweaking algorithms the only way we can make sure that you receive
00:01:00.600 every episode of ratioed is to make a free account at junonews.com that way we can send
00:01:06.120 it straight to your inbox if you want early access to each episode of ratioed as well as exclusive
00:01:11.880 juno news reporting you can use my code junonews.com harrison return to get a discount on a juno news
00:01:19.400 subscription as always before we get into it be sure to like this video subscribe to the juno news
00:01:24.600 youtube channel and the common question for the episode is this what will happen to the public
00:01:31.000 crown land once it is in the hands of first nations let me know your answer in the comments below
00:01:36.680 and let's get into it all right joining me now is british columbia mla and the conservative
00:01:41.640 attorney general critic steve cooner mr cooner thank you so much for joining me thanks for having
00:01:47.080 me so when canadians are reading this story about the victoria land transfer what is actually going
00:01:55.160 on what what does this mean for british colombians the bc government has given away approximately
00:02:03.000 334 000 acres of public land and that's what's going on and the public has had virtually no say
00:02:15.000 in all of this the provincial government had said that they've had some consultation meetings but
00:02:21.400 if you look at the extent of those consultations the essentially it was next to nothing in terms
00:02:28.200 of consultation so why is this happening i mean this doesn't seem like it's uh is this necessary
00:02:36.680 is something going on behind the scenes that requires this negotiation
00:02:40.120 well this is a uh pattern of uh a pattern or a theme with this current provincial government
00:02:50.440 um they have this ideological land back agenda and this is a priority for them and so uh public
00:03:00.120 land is uh up for grabs we're seeing and uh and and we're seeing in a amongst the public here in
00:03:08.440 in British Columbia, they're very concerned and upset about this. Some of the reporting that I've
00:03:15.120 read shows that when it comes to prime real estate like Hatley Castle, Royal Roads University,
00:03:21.400 that stretch of Victoria, that area, the first nation that is set to receive the land is
00:03:26.940 preparing to sell it back to the university. This seems unbelievable. It's like theft.
00:03:33.480 Is that correct?
00:03:36.540 Well, that seems to be what was reported in the news.
00:03:42.220 And, you know, it's some suggestion that right now the university is leasing the land from the federal government for a minimal amount.
00:03:50.640 And it seems that once the land gets transferred to Aboriginal title, it seems that there's a suggestion that the university may be able to buy back.
00:04:05.960 And that's very concerning because using the university is a form of public use.
00:04:14.640 And that's where the concern lies, that the public has had access to all this government land, whether it be federal land, whether it be provincial land.
00:04:23.100 But now the public is going to be losing their right to use this land.
00:04:29.680 And so this is of a huge concern.
00:04:34.120 So what are the long-term implications of this?
00:04:37.680 Obviously, this is yet another example of a land case gripping your province.
00:04:43.420 We know about the Kowitian tribes decision.
00:04:47.460 What is the sort of long-term implications of this?
00:04:50.720 Is this the idea that First Nations will be responsible for the land, for conserving the land?
00:04:57.720 How is there any guarantee that the land will actually be conserved, for example?
00:05:02.120 What are your concerns regarding this long-term?
00:05:05.580 Well, I think you just hinted at one of the concerns there.
00:05:08.920 What are the long-term consequences and how will this land be used?
00:05:13.420 And we have heard from discussion papers that local bylaws will not apply to the newly acquired Aboriginal private land.
00:05:25.440 And this is a specific concern amongst the vicinity of Victoria that we're currently talking about.
00:05:33.780 And the concern there is there is some waterfront property right in the downtown core of Victoria and the inner harbor.
00:05:41.860 And right now you have like heritage character protection bylaws, but what does that mean?
00:05:50.060 Like when the land turns to private land under Aboriginal title, those bylaws to protect the heritage character will no longer apply.
00:06:00.900 So that will open the doors to new development, could open the doors to high density development.
00:06:07.780 And that is a huge concern for the public.
00:06:11.860 Absolutely. What would happen if the British Columbia government simply decided to stop negotiating with these First Nations and refuse to recognize any of these claims to land, which they don't already operate in?
00:06:29.280 What would be the consequence if the B.C. government just said, no, we're not participating in whatever this really is?
00:06:35.940 First of all, the provincial government should be listening to the public, right?
00:06:42.960 And our official opposition caucus is calling on the premier to halt these land transfers
00:06:51.540 because they are of utmost concern right now, and that needs to be done.
00:06:58.480 And the other thing is that what needs to be done, this provincial government,
00:07:02.080 this in the fall session, they should be adopting MLA Scott McInnes' private member bill,
00:07:08.420 which is the Aboriginal Title Transparency Act, which shows any stage of negotiation regarding
00:07:15.200 land transfers in this province. So the public will get notice of what's at stake. The public
00:07:21.220 needs to be involved. And so there needs to be a halting of these land transfers by the Premier.
00:07:28.040 the aboriginal title transparency act needs to be passed and the the provincial government
00:07:35.080 needs to call back the legislature so we can repeal drip out right away
00:07:38.540 are you hearing from first nations people in your province about their thoughts regarding
00:07:47.480 these transfers i'm guessing i'm guessing there isn't complete unanimous support among first
00:07:54.620 nations for this i don't see how this personally leads to more reconciliation for example what are
00:08:01.640 you hearing from first nations people regarding these land transfers well there's a there's few
00:08:08.860 examples there's one recent example where one indigenous group is now suing or applying for
00:08:15.600 injunction to stop a land transfer because they feel that they're entitled to that land and so
00:08:23.080 there is disagreements amongst different indigenous bands in this province. And that really highlights
00:08:34.360 the concern and the level of concern with this provincial government. Provincial government
00:08:38.760 doesn't seem to be listening to anyone, is on a straight path of doing what they want,
00:08:44.920 because they think they can do what they want with land.
00:08:47.400 this seems to me to be the inevitable outcome of these endless land acknowledgements it was only
00:08:57.060 it was only a matter of time right until when until we went from saying the land belongs to
00:09:03.760 such and such first nation until we actually gave it back and now it seems it's actually happening
00:09:09.000 what is to prevent a first nation 10 years in the future from reopening whatever land
00:09:16.940 they're receiving now to go ask and demand more of it it seems like this could just keep going
00:09:22.180 and going until it's fully stopped right with uh these treaties um they call them uh many
00:09:30.180 refer to them as living agreements that means that once there's a treaty signed that doesn't
00:09:35.780 mean that that's it uh the treaty can be reopened into the future in terms of uh other potential
00:09:42.300 land as well. So has this had a major impact on property values in your province yet?
00:09:52.780 Well, you touched upon the Cowichan case, which is a little bit different from a treaty
00:09:58.540 negotiation. It involves a court decision. And I represent the constituency of Richmond,
00:10:04.780 Queensborough, which has all of that Cowichan decision land in it. And I can tell you those
00:10:10.860 people that live within the affected land they are very concerned and uh from there there has been
00:10:18.380 limited uh activity in terms of uh real estate in terms of the realtors that i've spoken to
00:10:25.500 and tell me about that area and uh so and there has been significant issues there's a industrial
00:10:33.740 company in inside my constituency that has had problems getting a land loan and improving their
00:10:41.900 business so this does cause issues significant issues and because it's causing significant
00:10:49.980 issues this provincial government really the premier needs to put a halt halt to these land
00:10:56.060 transfers right away that are causing significant issues so is this purely ideological or is it
00:11:05.020 political as well does the ndp seem to think that this is going to help them politically
00:11:11.340 obviously they have some ideological drive to just hand away public land but clearly there must be
00:11:19.100 something political in this is is it is this going to help them in any way
00:11:23.660 Well, from what I see, when I'm viewing their ideological lens, I view that as a political lens. I see that as their political agenda, their ideological agenda, because if you look at the opinion polls in terms of the opposition to these land transfers, it's huge.
00:11:47.000 It's not just a small minority. There was a recent poll and the polling showed about 61% of the people in British Columbia were against these types of land transfers.
00:12:01.920 Well, before we wrap it up, I just want to hand over the floor to you again, just to clear up what you think might be the biggest misconception regarding these land transfer cases, these treaty negotiations, and your party's position on it.
00:12:20.220 I'm sure you're receiving some pushback from from activists who claim you don't care about reconciliation or whatever they might be saying.
00:12:29.020 But what do you think people are getting wrong about this that they really need to be made aware of?
00:12:35.260 Well, when we're talking about these examples of some of these land transfers coming up, these are only a small example of what's to come.
00:12:48.920 There are 150 other Indigenous bands across British Columbia that also have claims.
00:12:59.420 And so, and one example is that we've seen revealed in the media about Northwestern BC, there's been a revealing of a land claim from the Tall Tan Nation.
00:13:12.960 And they are claiming essentially about 10% of British Columbia's landmass, 23.7 million acres.
00:13:24.380 And that also concerns $1.28 trillion of mineral wealth.
00:13:33.280 And so these examples that we're seeing in Victoria are just a small example of what the future holds.
00:13:42.960 and what types of issues the future holds.
00:13:45.160 So the magnitude of the issues are huge for the future.
00:13:50.260 So when you're looking at one example,
00:13:52.900 you have, if there's issues around examples
00:13:56.280 and it's gonna be a bigger issue even into the future
00:13:59.020 by magnitude, you have to create a halt.
00:14:02.800 The premier needs to put a halt on the current examples
00:14:06.640 that we are seeing before us.
00:14:08.280 just the tip of the iceberg we'll be watching very closely steve cooner thank you so much for
00:14:14.340 joining me thank you a reminder that you can use my code juno news.com slash harrison return
00:14:20.040 to get a discount on a juno news subscription a further reminder to answer the comment question
00:14:25.080 of the video what will happen to public crown land once it is in the possession
00:14:30.160 of first nations communities my name is harrison faulkner and this is ratio
00:14:38.280 Thank you.