Juno News - May 23, 2023


David Johnston's report is a Trudeau whitewash

Topics
Mentioned
Should government spend billions on corporate handouts? What are the Liberals hiding?

Episode Stats


Length

38 minutes

Words per minute

172.64

Word count

6,712

Sentence count

337

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

9

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show, host Andrew Lawton talks about David Johnston, dandelions, and the fact that he almost ate a dandelion on air. Plus, he explains why he thinks it was a good idea to eat it.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:00:05 This is the Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:00:14 Hello everyone and welcome to you all.
00:00:17 Another edition of Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show here on True North.
00:00:21 Hope you caught our live election night, no debate night.
00:00:25 I keep calling it the election night.
00:00:27 The Alberta debate night confab that we had on Thursday, we'll be doing a supercharged version of that on election night on Monday.
00:00:37 So if you're in Alberta or are interested in Alberta politics, which I think all of you probably should be,
00:00:42 Monday night, tune in to True North.
00:00:44 We'll have yours truly, Rachel Emanuel, and a great other cast of characters coming to you live from UCP headquarters
00:00:50 in the election that will define in a lot of ways the future of Alberta.
00:00:56 and in a very corresponding way, I think the future of the country.
00:01:00 So we'll talk about that a little bit later on,
00:01:02 but wanted to just make sure you were aware of that to mark your calendars.
00:01:06 I have to start off.
00:01:08 I'm going to get into the whole David Johnston thing.
00:01:10 Like, so don't worry, I'm going to get into that.
00:01:12 I'm going to devote most of the show to it.
00:01:14 But I have to begin with a bit of a mea culpa here
00:01:17 because sometimes I just think something is just going to be
00:01:20 a light little non-serious topic.
00:01:23 and I mentioned something offhandedly that will get more emails than anything else I spoke about
00:01:28 on the big subjects and you may remember on Friday during Fake News Friday I talked about
00:01:33 this one article telling us we needed to decolonize our gardens and I mentioned just
00:01:38 offhandedly that I know nothing about gardening and if you left me to it I would look out on a
00:01:42 garden and see all those little yellow flowers and be like oh that must be nice those things
00:01:47 must be good let's not pull them out and then they'd be dandelions and then I mentioned that
00:01:51 dandelions are weeds and the premise of it was that if left to my own devices I wouldn't care
00:01:57 about them but I know other people take them out. I got more emails about dandelions over the
00:02:02 weekend than about any other subject and anything else I spoke about on the show including censorship
00:02:09 at a public library. That mattered less to people than what people understood as a shot across the
00:02:16 bow at Dandelions. I'll share a couple of these with you. People were very polite, generally.
00:02:22 Jacqueline writes, I'm the least woke person in the world. I'm very right-leaning.
00:02:27 However, Dandelions have been maligned unfairly for years due to their many, many food and
00:02:32 medicinal uses. The company that mostly attacks them is the producer of Roundup, and then she
00:02:38 goes on and says she's going to send me some other materials, which she did. Thank you, Jacqueline.
00:02:42 Nancy writes, FYI, love your show, Andrew,
00:02:45 but you have to catch up on the benefits of dandelions,
00:02:47 both for your lawn and your health.
00:02:50 All parts of the dandelion are edible right down to the root.
00:02:53 Juice from the stem can be used topically to treat bug bites,
00:02:56 supposedly anyway.
00:02:58 So I went outside this morning,
00:03:01 and unfortunately, most of the dandelions have now done that thing
00:03:04 where they turn to like the white, like, spore.
00:03:08 I know nothing about gardening.
00:03:09 But there were a couple of yellow dandelions remaining.
00:03:13 And I thought, what better way to show my contrition for maligning the dandelion
00:03:17 than to consume one on air for you?
00:03:20 Again, no one has ever emailed me and said, Andrew, I don't think you eat enough.
00:03:24 So someone said, here, this dandelion you probably have eaten.
00:03:26 Now, the problem is I picked this like three hours ago,
00:03:30 and it was a lovely, lovely, pretty dandelion then.
00:03:33 And now in the time it's been in my office, it's shriveled up into nothing.
00:03:38 So I don't know if this one still has the health benefits, but to prove there are no hard feelings, that was gross.
00:03:49 But you know what?
00:03:50 You got to give the people what they want.
00:03:51 I almost drank the water that I was keeping it in.
00:03:53 I'm going to go for the actual water.
00:03:56 If I die on air as we do this show, dandelions did not have the vaunted health benefits they were supposed to.
00:04:03 In any event, the big stuff that's happening today,
00:04:06 still, even today, I'm going to get more emails about the dandelion bit
00:04:09 than about David Johnston's complete whitewash
00:04:12 of the federal government's actions or inactions on the China file.
00:04:19 And I want to just put this in a little bit of context for people here.
00:04:23 David Johnston, we all know, is the lifelong family friend of the Trudeaus. 0.73
00:04:28 He's the skiing buddy of the Trudeaus. 0.69
00:04:30 He's the guy who was a neighbor of the Trudeaus. 1.00
00:04:34 Yet somehow, somehow, of all the people in the country,
00:04:38 all the people in the world, in fact,
00:04:40 David Johnston was the guy tapped by Justin Trudeau
00:04:43 to be the so-called special rapporteur
00:04:46 into foreign interference in Canada's elections.
00:04:50 Again, anyone in the country.
00:04:51 I would have been available.
00:04:52 Candace Malcolm was available.
00:04:54 Ezra Levant was available.
00:04:55 You've got former cabinet ministers, judges, Paul Rouleau.
00:04:58 Not a perfect pick, but Paul Rouleau might have been available.
00:05:02 But of all the people there, Justin Trudeau said,
00:05:04 we need a so-called eminent Canadian,
00:05:06 and it was David Johnston and a couple of former Supreme Court justices
00:05:10 that were all in the room, and David Johnston was next in the rotation
00:05:13 as far as eminent Canadians are concerned.
00:05:16 So David Johnston appointed to look into his longtime chum, Justin Trudeau,
00:05:22 and shocker, no surprise whatsoever, he comes out today and says,
00:05:26 well, you know, Justin Trudeau didn't really do anything wrong.
00:05:29 He has advised against an inquiry into foreign interference in Canada's elections,
00:05:34 but he says the story is not over yet.
00:05:36 We've got to do a little bit more digging.
00:05:38 And who better to do that than me?
00:05:40 David Johnson, the eminent Canadian.
00:05:42 So David Johnson has decided that David Johnson should continue to look into this.
00:05:48 And David Johnson also says if you criticize his appointment,
00:05:52 if you accuse him of being impartial, you are undermining confidence in democracy or undermining confidence in Canadian elections.
00:06:02 So this is actually a pretty sweet gig for David Johnson because he's the guy, you can't criticize him,
00:06:07 and he's making sure to reward Justin Trudeau by saying they did nothing.
00:06:11 So he's made this report available. There are five key recommendations in it.
00:06:17 Five key recommendations. The most important is that we don't apparently need an inquiry.
00:06:21 That is the reason. His argument was kind of bizarre. It was that, well, you know, I had the full context on this. All these media outlets like Global News and the Globe and Mail, they didn't have all the information I did, but I, David Johnston, did. And, well, it's classified, though. The rest of you can't see it.
00:06:40 So this was legitimately the point that he was trying to make.
00:06:44 And I think we actually have a clip to this effect where he says that media reports lack proper context.
00:06:51 Take a look.
00:06:52 Much of what has been reported has been based on limited and partial intelligence.
00:06:57 That reporting has been made without the benefit of the full context provided by all relevant materials.
00:07:05 Experienced intelligent professionals understand that individual pieces of intelligence must be viewed with considerable skepticism.
00:07:14 It is extremely rare to draw conclusions, much less take action from a single intelligence report.
00:07:23 Each piece of intelligence is a brushstroke to paint a broader picture.
00:07:28 Only upon seeing the full picture, with the benefit of all relevant intelligence,
00:07:34 Can one conclude that much of the reported intelligence has been misconstrued in media reports, presumably because of this lack of context in these instances?
00:07:48 Oh, yeah, what a great approach there.
00:07:50 So all of you can't see what I can see.
00:07:54 And then the obvious question is, OK, well, why don't we all see this?
00:07:57 Why don't we declassify these documents?
00:08:00 He says, no, no, no, no, no.
00:08:00 The general public can't see classified documents.
00:08:03 So his recommendation is that there should be no public inquiry because to have a public inquiry, you would need to provide people with documents that they can't see. So the only way we get to have accountability is by he continuing to look at this stuff and David Johnston continuing to be the one who gets to decide what's relevant and what's not.
00:08:24 And he said, oh, but, you know, maybe this committee like NSACOP can look into it.
00:08:28 And if they disagree with my findings, they can tell the government.
00:08:31 But he still becomes the gatekeeper on information.
00:08:35 So for a guy whose whole thesis in his report is that the media got it wrong and the media
00:08:40 didn't get the so-called full context, he then turns around and say, well, nobody else
00:08:44 can see this full context.
00:08:47 So China's interference in Canada's elections, which he admits is a thing, which no one disputes 1.00
00:08:51 is a thing, basically goes where democracy dies.
00:08:55 It goes into some hollowed out empty chamber where the public will never understand the
00:09:00 extent of it.
00:09:01 And more importantly, will never understand what Justin Trudeau knew when he knew it and
00:09:07 what he refused to do with it.
00:09:09 And if you look at a couple of the clips that came out from David Johnston's remarks here,
00:09:15 one I'm going to share, which I think is fascinating because we know that he was a
00:09:19 longtime friend of Justin Trudeau's, but he has said that no one can question his impartiality.
00:09:24 No one whatsoever can question the old great oracle, David Johnson's impartiality. And then
00:09:31 he was asked about this friendship with Justin Trudeau. And he like spoke for basically two
00:09:36 minutes about how, oh, well, yes, you know, we used to be neighbors and his family would park
00:09:42 at my house because it was in Mont-Tremblant near the mountains when they went skiing. And
00:09:45 one time I gave him a ride home, but oh no, I've never, never seen, really saw him until he was
00:09:51 prime minister and I was governor general. And that, that was only when we started to be real
00:09:55 chums. And I'm like, well, okay. So yes, you've had this longstanding relationship with him. You
00:10:01 spoke for two minutes about why I'm not going to play the whole two minutes because I've summarized
00:10:05 it well. But you know, you've spoken about it and then you say, well, it's no biggie. And that
00:10:09 anyone who dares ask about it is the problem. So what we have from this is, I think, a pretty
00:10:16 sensible example of why he's not the guy who can deliver accountability on this. And it was funny,
00:10:24 he was asked by David Akin, to his credit of Global News, about whether there was a conflict
00:10:29 of interest because he's, again, a longtime Trudeau family friend. He's a former Trudeau
00:10:34 Foundation advisor. And I kid you not, his response was that he had himself cleared
00:10:41 of a conflict by former Supreme Court Justice Frank Iacobucci. Frank Iacobucci,
00:10:50 where do I know that name from? Oh, put up that graphic there, Sean.
00:10:56 Oh, what do you know? Frank Iacobucci is a Trudeau Foundation mentor. So heaven forbid,
00:11:02 the Trudeau Foundation guys turn on each other. So David Johnson cleared of a conflict of interest
00:11:08 for his role as a Trudeau Foundation mentor and member by Frank Iacobucci, who's a Trudeau
00:11:14 Foundation mentor, which means that oddly enough, David Johnson's report does not even acknowledge
00:11:21 the Trudeau Foundation. You look at the document here and you do a control F or a command F if
00:11:30 you're a mac user like i am for the word foundation and oh what do you see foundation of our democracy
00:11:35 foundation of information uh foundation weird the word trudeau foundation does not appear in his
00:11:42 report at all yet we know that to the tune of six figures the trudeau foundation was being used by
00:11:47 china as what china at least thought would be a laundering outfit where they get to give a big 0.95
00:11:53 check to the trudeau foundation which then gets filtered into putting these meetings in all the
00:11:58 right places, friends in high places. And this was not something that was investigated by the
00:12:04 special rapporteur. So all of this is coming at a time when how dare David Johnston put himself
00:12:13 in a situation where criticizing his impartiality, perceived or otherwise, is undermining democracy,
00:12:19 when I'd say his appointment as special rapporteur undermines democracy. And Stephen
00:12:25 Chase from the Globe and Mail had said something on his Twitter that I retweeted maybe about an
00:12:31 hour, an hour and a half ago, that his report inexplicably addresses only three Globe stories
00:12:37 on Chinese foreign interference in recent months that relied on CSIS documents and national
00:12:42 security sources. He's silent on 10 other Globe stories on the same topic that rely on secret
00:12:49 sources and documents. So David Johnson has been very selective about which stories he focuses on,
00:12:57 which stories warrant his condemnation of the media. He's been selective on which stories he
00:13:02 thinks are worth including, worth analyzing, worth investigating. And he has the gall to tell us that
00:13:08 we don't have the full context. We don't have all the facts. We don't actually know or get to know
00:13:15 or get to hear or get to understand why everything happened the way it was reported.
00:13:19 Because, well, you know, we're just these lowly plebs without security clearance. 0.91
00:13:24 We can't possibly.
00:13:25 And there was a thing here that jumped, that came out where Aaron O'Toole,
00:13:28 who we invited to come on the show today.
00:13:30 And as I understand, it didn't respond to us for one reason or another.
00:13:34 But Aaron O'Toole was interviewed by David Johnson.
00:13:37 And Aaron O'Toole wrote about this on his substack this morning.
00:13:41 In it, he basically said, listen, when he sat down with Johnson,
00:13:45 And he was convinced it was a waste of time and was also told, and Johnson confirmed this,
00:13:51 that parts of the final report that we saw today were already being sent off for translation.
00:13:58 So the report was already effectively done when he was sitting down being supposedly
00:14:04 interviewed by David Johnson.
00:14:07 And when the report is already being translated, it basically says that the idea of just talking
00:14:15 to a conservative was just an afterthought. And I think Pierre Polyev was right to just say he
00:14:20 wanted nothing to do with this process. Polyev did a statement today in which he basically said
00:14:26 this proved everything that he warned about with this inquiry. Take a look. We need a full public
00:14:33 inquiry to get to the bottom of Beijing's interference in our democracy. And that's what 0.85
00:14:39 i will deliver when i am prime minister there will be a full public inquiry into this mess
00:14:44 and in the meantime we will continue to push for a real foreign influence registry that exposes
00:14:50 anyone who does paid work on behalf of foreign dictatorship to manipulate our politics it's just
00:14:57 common sense yeah it should be common sense but i i wrote about this in a column a few months ago
00:15:07 The problem with this eminent Canadian category, of which David Johnston is a member, Frankie
00:15:13 Iacobucci is a member, Beverly McLaughlin's a member, is that they actually don't have
00:15:18 much sense, common or otherwise, between them.
00:15:22 Because it's all about just trying to keep the regime alive.
00:15:25 That's the goal.
00:15:26 It's all about just making sure that we don't undermine democracy.
00:15:30 But they get to define what democracy is.
00:15:33 They get to define what democratic institutions are.
00:15:35 And democratic institutions only exist if they're the ones representing, if they're the ones who are the faces of them. 0.62
00:15:44 So here we have David Johnston coming out and saying, yes, China is interfering in our elections.
00:15:49 And by the way, in his remarks, it took, I think, like 20 minutes before he even uttered the word China.
00:15:55 So he was just trying to deal with this only in the abstract, which is noteworthy and concerning.
00:16:01 But the report does talk about China. It talks about Chinese interference.
00:16:05 He says, oh, yeah, there were some shortcomings.
00:16:07 But you look at the shortcomings, and oddly, none of them involved Justin Trudeau.
00:16:12 It was the system needs to do better.
00:16:16 So he is either intentionally or otherwise, I don't know, parroting Justin Trudeau's approach to everything,
00:16:21 where when he is caught to have broken rules or broken the law in some cases,
00:16:26 it somehow becomes society's fault.
00:16:29 It's society's problem.
00:16:30 It's never Justin Trudeau's problem.
00:16:32 There's never a learning opportunity for him, but there's a growth opportunity for all of us.
00:16:37 And Johnson is essentially doing the same thing here, where he's saying,
00:16:41 well, you know what, we all need to do a little bit better.
00:16:44 But no, let's focus on the people that were being told that Michael Chong's family
00:16:51 was being spied on and intimidated.
00:16:54 The people who were told that a Liberal member of Parliament, or at the time,
00:16:59 and earlier a liberal candidate was being helped along in his career by officials with the Chinese
00:17:05 consulate. The Handong stuff is particularly interesting here. So Handong, the liberal MP
00:17:12 who was getting some help from Chinese officials, who later on was as a liberal MP, a backbench
00:17:19 liberal MP, having a conversation with a Chinese consular official about the two Michaels, which in
00:17:25 of itself is concerning. And a CSIS report said that he had advised against the release
00:17:30 of the two Michaels. And Handong said, oh, he's out of caucus now. But I mean, Handong
00:17:36 had basically said that, well, it was a mistranslation. He never actually said that.
00:17:42 Well, David Johnson gives like three paragraphs of attention to the Handong issue. And in the
00:17:48 three paragraphs, he says, there is well-grounded suspicion that the irregularities tied to the
00:17:55 PRT were tied to the PRT consulate in Toronto with whom Mr. Dong maintains relationships so
00:18:00 they say that absolutely he's friends with people that have been meddling in Canada's elections but
00:18:04 then they say well he probably wasn't aware of the irregularities but on the two Michaels he says
00:18:11 and this is I think quite fascinating here that and I'm just pulling up the exact quote because
00:18:18 I don't want to be accused of getting it wrong, that he never, in David Johnson's words,
00:18:27 he never talked about the, he never advocated for keeping them detained. So that's a complete
00:18:35 contradiction of the global news report. Johnston concludes the allegation is false. But then he
00:18:41 says, Mr. Dong discussed the two Michaels with a PRC official, but did not request to the official
00:18:49 that the PRC extend their detention. Well, okay, let's talk about why they were having a discussion.
00:18:57 Why was Handong even talking to China about the two Michaels? He had no consular authority. He
00:19:03 was not a member of global affairs. He wasn't a minister. It doesn't sound like he was doing it
00:19:07 on the government's behalf.
00:19:08 So you'd think a special rapporteur
00:19:11 would be interested in getting to the bottom of that.
00:19:13 But instead he does this.
00:19:15 This is what Johnson says.
00:19:17 The allegation that he did make that suggestion
00:19:20 has had a very adverse effect on Mr. Dong.
00:19:25 Hmm.
00:19:26 So David Johnson is more interested
00:19:29 in talking about the hurt feelings that Handong had
00:19:33 than the substance of the allegation.
00:19:35 And even the uncontested substance, which is that he was having a conversation with Chinese officials
00:19:40 while China was keeping two Canadians locked up for years without due process.
00:19:46 And we're supposed to be concerned about all the adverse effect that Global News' reporting had on Mr. Dong.
00:19:54 So I think that if it's false, great, let's see the transcript.
00:19:58 Why are we being told to just trust David Johnston when David Johnston was reviewing a transcript of a call
00:20:04 that he's saying no Canadians should be allowed to see.
00:20:07 And this is exactly why there needs to be an inquiry,
00:20:10 an inquiry that makes public documents that right now are not being public
00:20:14 because right now the government has shown itself to not be trustworthy on this.
00:20:19 Not Justin Trudeau, not the brass at CSIS, and certainly not David Johnson.
00:20:25 We're going to revisit this a little bit before the show ends,
00:20:28 but I want to shift gears to another topic which is important.
00:20:31 We had actually planned to talk about this today as of last week, and that is the move towards climate-friendly banking, which sounds like a bit of an absurd thing, but there are some MPs that are actually trying to force this on financial institutions, on pension funds, that they rejig their investment rules to only back projects or initiatives or corporations that have climate-aligned goals.
00:20:59 We spoke a while ago about this in the context of what Gina Papano of InvestNow is doing,
00:21:05 and we have Gina back with us today.
00:21:07 Gina, it's good to talk to you again.
00:21:08 Thanks for coming on the show.
00:21:12 So let's first off talk about this idea that it is not a new one.
00:21:15 I mean, we've seen institutions push this, and you've been on the front line of that,
00:21:20 but now we have MPs that are actually trying to codify this in regulation.
00:21:24 What would that actually mean?
00:21:25 well it would mean that they're putting an arbitrary um rule on investments in what it
00:21:34 really means the elimination of the oil and gas sector as an investment potential
00:21:37 and in canada this is very disconcerting because everything that we do runs on oil and gas and we
00:21:44 have an abundance of oil and gas and we need to invest in this sector to ensure that the supply
00:21:51 that the world needs is met by Canada and Canadian companies. So putting this into law
00:21:57 is giving it the climate alignment as a superseding duty over fiduciary duty to
00:22:06 invest in things that will provide the best returns for their beneficiaries.
00:22:12 You know, I have a big problem with the ethical aspect of this for reasons that we'll get into
00:22:18 with the effect on the oil and gas sector.
00:22:19 But if I'm someone who is trying to get my retirement savings
00:22:24 done through a pension plan,
00:22:25 I mean, I'd be mortified that I was being denied
00:22:28 what should be the primary goal of a pension fund,
00:22:30 which is return on investment,
00:22:32 because they've decided, oh, you know what?
00:22:34 We only need to invest in climate aligned companies
00:22:37 or you could take that to any number of other issues.
00:22:40 We only want companies that have a feminist focus. 1.00
00:22:43 We only want companies that fly the pride flag or whatever.
00:22:46 If you're an investor in this, is this even something you care about?
00:22:51 Well, if you're an investor, you should only be concerned, it's public money.
00:22:56 So the investors, the public pension funds, the banks, they should be concerned with providing the best returns to their shareholders, to their beneficiaries.
00:23:07 And imposing this rule eliminates an entire sector from the investment potential.
00:23:13 and that is not that's not even ESG investing because if you if you take a if you take away
00:23:20 the oil and gas sector for example you can't invest in any Canadian oil and gas sectors
00:23:24 any oil and gas companies the demand is still there so the supply will come from somewhere
00:23:31 it just won't be Canada and emissions will go up and everything that they're trying to do
00:23:36 will not be attained achieved but what will happen is the elimination of the oil and gas sector in
00:23:42 Canada, jobs, our way of life. There's just so many industry will shut down. So many industries
00:23:52 rely on oil and gas. The mining industry, you can't have industries without oil and gas
00:23:56 because they fuel every industry on the stock exchange.
00:24:00 So prior to the environmental dimension that we talked about previously and that we're talking
00:24:06 about now, has there ever been a moral test to these investment funds or is that in and of itself
00:24:11 a new phenomenon well there was apartheid uh so people weren't investing in south african companies
00:24:18 um and tobacco companies in the past but um there's what they found was um those pension
00:24:28 funds lost out especially tobacco companies they lost out on returns and i think if someone wants
00:24:36 to do what whatever they they if they want to invest in something of their own money but this
00:24:42 is taking the public pension plan and using it weaponizing it basically to invest in what is
00:24:51 termed climate friendly but we we really have no way of proving that because i mean there therein
00:24:57 lies i think the other problem which is even if you agree fundamentally with what they're trying
00:25:02 to do uh it's not even clear that it will do that and i think all the evidence probably points in
00:25:07 the other direction i mean uh you talk about the environmental impact of the mining industry and
00:25:13 it is there but it's the mining industry that benefits the most when we decide that everything
00:25:17 needs to be electric like i remember once seeing uh at davos there was this mining executive that
00:25:22 was talking about oh we need battery powered everything and everyone's like oh he's so he's
00:25:26 such a climate champion and it's like well yeah who stands to benefit from you know the world
00:25:30 ratcheting up its demand for lithium. It's these mining executives. So it's not even like it will
00:25:35 achieve that environmental objective. No, it's really an exercise in magical thinking because
00:25:41 to think that we can eliminate our oil and gas sector, especially in Canada, where we're blessed
00:25:45 with the natural resources, we should be getting our Canadian oil and gas out there. We should be
00:25:50 investing in it because the divestment activists may believe that they're helping Canada and
00:25:58 reducing co2 emissions but the facts point to quite the opposite just today 84 percent
00:26:05 of primary energy needs are coming from oil natural gas and coal and global demand is
00:26:11 increasing not decreasing so we want canada and canadian companies to meet this demand
00:26:18 otherwise we're hobbling ourselves and giving it to you know the supply will be met from someone
00:26:25 and we want it to be from Canada. When we look at these regulations, do they make a distinction
00:26:32 between, you know, Canadian companies that, as you've noted, are doing a lot of work to really
00:26:37 comply with government environmental regulations and to innovate themselves and reduce their
00:26:42 emissions and, you know, foreign oil companies that might not be as diligent with this? Or does
00:26:47 it basically just paint any traditional energy source with the same brush and any company in
00:26:51 that space. That's right. It's all oil and gas and coal painted with the same brush. There's no
00:26:57 distinction for Canada. It's obvious that they want to dismantle this sector in Canada. And we
00:27:04 hear the government using these, you know, nice little words like just transition as though this
00:27:09 is all just part of some natural evolution. And, you know, they don't often conceal the
00:27:13 fundamental goal of envisioning a future without oil and gas. No, but the problem is, is that even
00:27:20 possible you know there's so much so much more to oil and gas than just electricity there are so
00:27:26 many products that rely on oil and gas and uh you can't make steel without coal there's so many um
00:27:32 products that we rely on to live our lives to uh to drive to work to you know um to to heat our
00:27:41 homes to air condition our homes and so we we we can't i don't even think you can fathom a world
00:27:48 without oil and gas right now but people think we can just flip a switch in 20 years and be done
00:27:54 with it i i know there's been a big push and it's actually been unfortunately getting some success
00:27:59 at universities to have universities divest from from oil and gas and i was wondering if you could
00:28:05 just provide an update on on kind of how that is because i think there were uh some calls and i'm
00:28:10 in london ontario there are some calls at western university which hasn't yet done it yet but some
00:28:13 pretty big universities have that's right u of t has um so the divestment movement's been around
00:28:20 for 10 years uh the universities were a prime target to get the endowment funds to divest from
00:28:26 oil and gas but if you if you look at the movement um pension funds have divested now they're attack
00:28:33 you know they're going after the banks to divest so you see an escalation in their targets but what
00:28:39 you don't see is any reduction in emissions. In 10 years, demand has gone up, emissions have gone
00:28:46 up. So even though all of these endowment funds and public pension plans have divested,
00:28:56 there has been no discernible impact on emissions. Now, I know that the Canadian 0.97
00:29:02 pension or the Canada pension plan has rejected this call, but are you optimistic that position
00:29:07 will hold if the current trajectory keeps up? Well, we've been tracking all of the movements
00:29:14 and I guess the targets of the divestment activists. And we're just trying to state
00:29:20 our case of why the Canada pension plan should not be divesting from oil and gas. They should
00:29:25 be investing in oil and gas. It's good for innovation. It's good for emissions reductions.
00:29:31 It's good for our economy. And so the Canada pension plan should not be entertaining divestment.
00:29:37 but we're just hoping to be able to um get our messages out there our narrative well yeah and i
00:29:43 think as you should be and i know you've talked about the demand issue but you know they talk
00:29:47 about a divide between the real economy and the financial economy here because if you know if you
00:29:52 if you could divest you know all your stocks and holdings in an oil and gas company but it does
00:29:56 nothing to eliminate the demand for oil and gas which is still there and and the need for hydrocarbon
00:30:02 But it really does try to just kill this industry by a thousand blows.
00:30:08 It's just affecting their access to capital.
00:30:10 And it gives other companies in less democratic regions an opportunity to fulfill the supply.
00:30:21 Yeah, and that's always been the reality here, is that anything that we do in the West to hurt our oil and gas sector benefits Venezuela
00:30:30 and benefits the Middle East and to indirectly Iran and all these other places that tend to do
00:30:38 very well. So when you get Justin Trudeau saying there's no business case for exporting LNG to
00:30:44 Germany, well, Germany is looking around, desperately looking for it. It's another 0.90
00:30:48 country that fills that void. Yes. And also at the same time, China's building a coal plant every
00:30:53 week right now, or getting approvals to build a coal plant every week. So there's not a global
00:30:59 alignment on this stuff and to just hobble ourselves makes no sense. So I guess the big
00:31:07 question here, and I don't know if you can answer it simply, but are you an optimist or a pessimist
00:31:11 on this? I'm an optimist. I think the way things are looking in Europe is like a marker for us to
00:31:22 watch. And even like countries like Qatar are saying that due to the lack of investment,
00:31:29 there's going to be a severe oil supply shortage, which means prices are going to go up.
00:31:35 So I think people might start connecting the dots that, hey, maybe investment is not such a bad
00:31:41 thing. We need to invest in our supply. We need to invest in our Canadian companies. We have the
00:31:46 highest environmental standards in the world. So I think we just have to keep getting our messages
00:31:50 out and we might be heard. I'm optimistic that we'll be heard. All right. Well, we certainly
00:31:58 hear you here as well. And I think there is obviously a little bit of a deck stacked against
00:32:03 the little guy feeling that a lot of individual investors have. But I think you need to call up
00:32:08 your banks. I think you need to call up the people managing your funds because we know that the
00:32:12 activists are doing that. And if they're not getting anyone on the other end saying it's
00:32:16 important that you keep my money going towards this, if there's a business case there, then it's
00:32:21 completely going without being contested. That's right. We need to stand up and fight for the
00:32:27 industry. All right. Well, you're certainly doing that. And I think everyone needs to join you in
00:32:31 that fight. Gina Papano, Executive Director of InvestNow. Thanks so much. And do keep us posted
00:32:37 on this. Thank you, Andrew. All right. Thank you, Gina. I said before the show was up, I'd get back
00:32:42 to the China files here. And I will in just a moment. But speaking of being heard, let me just
00:32:49 briefly offer an update to a story we've talked about at True North, which is the ban on Canada
00:32:55 day fireworks by the city of calgary so uh the city of calgary decides uh when mayor jody gonda
00:33:01 gets in that it's a climate emergency so all of a sudden the climate crisis means you can't light
00:33:07 fireworks uh it has nothing to do with their hatred of canada day it's their hatred of anything
00:33:12 that emits into the atmosphere or something like that so uh now they've decided to replace it with
00:33:17 a sound and light show now i'm not against sound and light shows i went and saw an abba hologram
00:33:23 concert that was a sound and light show and I loved it, but I didn't do it because they were
00:33:27 fighting against the climate crisis. I did it because it looked like it was good on its own
00:33:32 merits. And now in Calgary, thousands have signed a petition to bring back Canada Day fireworks. So
00:33:38 I don't know if Jody Gondak is going to listen. I think some, I think anyone who wants to should
00:33:44 chip in and have their own private firework show that's going to rival the cities. Just rent some
00:33:49 giant acreage and do the fireworks show that the city is not allowing and make sure you admit
00:33:54 twice as much as the city would have just to prove the point. But all that being said, let's talk
00:33:59 about the China stuff here. If you're just tuning in, David Johnston has decided to give a clean
00:34:06 bill of health to Justin Trudeau's handling of the China file. He said, oh no, he didn't know
00:34:11 anything. He didn't avoid anything. He didn't ignore anything. The real problem is those pesky
00:34:16 civil servants, that we need to figure out what a good way is for them to be able to communicate
00:34:21 stuff to government and communicate stuff to Justin Trudeau. So they're the ones we need to
00:34:27 look at here, not Justin Trudeau. And oh, the media, you guys, no, no, no, the media just got
00:34:31 it wrong. We didn't have access to all of the wisdom and documents that David Johnson had. So
00:34:37 the recap on this, and if you're having trouble following along, you're not alone, because I think
00:34:42 anyone with two IQs, two IQ points to rub together is even having trouble with this. And the whole
00:34:49 point here is that David Johnston is effectively saying that everyone but Justin Trudeau is the
00:34:57 problem. And if you criticize Justin Trudeau, you're part of this media misinformation. If you
00:35:02 criticize David Johnson, you're undermining faith in democracy. It's actually quite brilliant because
00:35:06 it means that no one is able to say anything but David Johnston because, well, you didn't have all
00:35:11 the facts you didn't have all the full context so uh it's a pretty smart way of doing things but is
00:35:17 it in canada's best interest absolutely not and i i pointed out on twitter earlier you can tell why
00:35:23 johnson and trudeau are friends because both of them whenever they're busted on something just
00:35:29 talk about broad abstract shortcomings well not talking about their own responsibility and saying
00:35:35 it's the system to blame and then pointing to the media more than anything else. But what happens
00:35:42 here, and I'm just going to go through some of the greatest hits of this, the five conclusions
00:35:45 that Johnson had. One, yes, foreign interference is happening in Canada's elections. Two, materials
00:35:51 were misconstrued in some media reporting. Three, there are serious shortcomings in how intelligence
00:35:59 is communicated and processed. Again, the general, the abstract, nothing to do with Trudeau.
00:36:04 number four, I'll get back to in a moment. Number five is that Trudeau should invite
00:36:10 these independent oversight committees like NSACOP to review his conclusion and have access
00:36:17 to classified information and say if they disagree with his conclusion. Number four, though, was that
00:36:23 a further public process is required, but that should not be a formal inquiry because to do so
00:36:30 would mean that documents that have been classified
00:36:34 would have to be made public, and we can't have any of that.
00:36:36 So instead, Johnson is going to embark on a second phase
00:36:40 and keep this going himself.
00:36:42 And in that second phase, he's going to have public hearings,
00:36:45 but the documents, well, those aren't going to be public.
00:36:48 So this is what he's saying, and we're supposed to just trust him.
00:36:52 And if you read through the report,
00:36:54 it's odd how he tends to just want to give Justin Trudeau outs on things.
00:37:01 Like I mentioned the Handong stuff.
00:37:03 There's one point of Handong that talks about when he was a nomination candidate,
00:37:08 which was the subject of one of the CSIS reports.
00:37:11 And the reason it was important is because there were things brought up to the Liberals at the time
00:37:16 that looked like he was trying to get a little bit of help from China and from the Chinese Politburo.
00:37:22 And Justin Trudeau was briefed about the irregularities.
00:37:27 And Johnson acknowledges this in his report.
00:37:29 He said he was briefed.
00:37:30 No specific recommendation was provided.
00:37:32 He concluded there was no basis to displace Mr. Dong as the candidate for Don Valley North.
00:37:39 Now, had he ended there, it would have been just a statement of fact.
00:37:44 But Johnson goes one line further.
00:37:46 He says,
00:37:47 this was not an unreasonable conclusion based on the intelligence available to the Prime Minister
00:37:53 at the time. So he's actually in his report trying to make Justin Trudeau's case for him.
00:37:59 He is preemptively doing Justin Trudeau's spin so that Justin Trudeau doesn't have to even do
00:38:05 his own spin. He can just look at the report, take it at face value and say, see, David Johnson
00:38:09 exonerated us. That's probably why you appointed him because you knew this was going to be the way
00:38:14 things are going. We're going to talk about this more after I've had a time to go through the
00:38:18 report in a bit more depth tomorrow, but you can read it for yourself and I would encourage you to
00:38:23 because that way when Trudeau gets up there and misrepresents it, you are armed with the facts
00:38:28 and not just the spin. Although I warn you, the spin is baked into the report itself. That does
00:38:34 it for us. We will be back tomorrow with more of Canada's most irreverent talk show. This is the
00:38:38 Andrew Lawton Show on True North. Thank you, God bless, and a good day to you all.
00:38:42 thanks for listening to the andrew lawton show support the program by donating to true north
00:38:49 at www.tnc.news