Juno News - January 15, 2024


Davos Day 1: Klaus Schwab says "selfish" people are to blame for trust crisis

Topics
Mentioned
Why Canada needs to have a ‘grown-up’ discussion about immigration John Kerry still doesn’t want to talk about China

Episode Stats


Length

41 minutes

Words per minute

172.77

Word count

7,230

Sentence count

387

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

7

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

This week, Andrew Lawton is in Davos, attending the World Economic Forum, where the theme this year is "Reinventing Trust" and the focus is on building trust in the institutions that they re a part of.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:24 oh i'm back on now okay sorry i thought we like just completely cut the show so
00:01:28 this is what happens. I want to blame Klaus Schwab. I don't know if I can on that. That
00:01:32 might have just been like me sitting on my mic back. Apologies for that. You wouldn't believe
00:01:37 we are professionals, really. But anyway, one of the things that I wanted to share with you here
00:01:44 is that we are in the country of Austria right now. We are actually in Donburn, Switzerland,
00:01:51 where we were forced to basically look outside the area that we wanted to stay in just because
00:01:58 the World Economic Forum was so hell-bent on keeping people out. So all of that is to say
00:02:03 we are still here. We are driving lots. We're seeing the beautiful Swiss Alps and the Austrian
00:02:09 Alps, I should say. So maybe you'll get a little bit of a reprieve from me if I just get like
00:02:16 run off the road or something by some errant mountain goat. But nevertheless, we are really
00:02:21 fully committing to covering this conference where the theme is rebuilding trust. And we'll
00:02:28 talk about that a little bit, but I wanted to give you a bit of a scene setter for what you 0.87
00:02:32 can expect this week. I'm joined in Davos by my producer and videographer, Sean, who you can't
00:02:38 see, but I understand you heard a few moments ago. He made a rare audio cameo on the program
00:02:43 and also by True North journalist and editor, Cosman Georgia, who is with me. I was going to
00:02:49 say in studio. He's joining me in my hotel room, which is not nearly as salacious as it sounds,
00:02:53 I promise you. Cosman, good to have you joining us in Davos here. Let me just ask you, because
00:02:59 you're a first-timer at this, you've not seen this conference in action before. What have your
00:03:04 early impressions been here? I think the most extraordinary impression I've had is the fact
00:03:11 that life goes on in Davos. I mean, driving through the city, you see schoolchildren returning
00:03:19 home you see people walking around biking etc while at the same time all of these global elites
00:03:27 descend on this place to set the global agenda so it's a really interesting juxtaposition that
00:03:34 happens where you see ordinary people going about their everyday lives yet there are
00:03:41 consequential decisions being made at this conference yeah and i think that it's interesting
00:03:48 because you're right in some ways like there are still locals here but it's also weird and i've
00:03:53 talked about this in the past that like all of these stores that exist every other week of the
00:03:58 year are just completely gone and when you walk down the main drag it's like you know the india
00:04:03 pavilion and the second india pavilion and the third india pavilion and so it's like i remember
00:04:07 the first time i i came i was looking on google maps ahead of time and saying oh that might be a
00:04:11 good restaurant to check out and then you get there it's like oh the restaurants just picked
00:04:14 up and left town because the World Economic Forum is here. So the theme this year is rebuilding
00:04:20 trust. They've got, you know, some heavy hitters on the lineup. There's the premier of China,
00:04:24 Lee Chang. There's Javier Malay, who's the president of Argentina, who interestingly has
00:04:29 been here before as an economist. Emmanuel Macron. No one officially from Canada, as far as the
00:04:36 Canadian government, is on the speakers list. Now, whether they'll make appearances, I don't know.
00:04:40 But what is it you're looking out for this week?
00:04:43 I think the issue of trust kind of like underwrites everything that's happening here.
00:04:49 And True North has reported on their global risk report, which the World Economic Forum releases every single year.
00:04:58 And the number one issue that they chose in the short term for 2024 was misinformation and disinformation.
00:05:07 and i'm interested to see what some of the speakers will say are the solutions to these
00:05:16 proposed problems how do we deal with what they call misinformation or disinformation and
00:05:22 the consequences which i think they think is the declining trust in the institutions that
00:05:29 they're a part of so solutions might what they might look like uh i i expect some bizarre and
00:05:38 heavy-handed uh propositions being made the other major thing is uh ai seems to be everywhere at
00:05:46 this conference this year there are a bunch of different pavilions and we are having uh we are
00:05:55 going to see the CEO of OpenAI, Samuel Altman, showing up and discussing, giving a panel.
00:06:05 And so I'd like to see what he has to say. Yeah. And I actually have a clip that I'll share a
00:06:11 little bit later on in the show of Klaus Schwab like six years ago or seven years ago talking
00:06:15 about AI. And it is interesting to see. I mean, it's one of those things where we don't quite
00:06:22 have an answer in society to how we deal with this. And so I'm very, I'll say nervous about
00:06:28 how politicians who don't really know much about the issue are going to come away from this
00:06:33 conference, where they are talking about it a lot, thinking like it's just, you know, some
00:06:37 know nothing politician who's here. Like I ran into earlier, Chris Coons, who's a senator in
00:06:42 Delaware, I presume this guy who's like, you know, 70 has nothing to do with AI doesn't know anything
00:06:46 about it. But he's the type of guy who could like be in some panel, and they all say this is
00:06:50 something's a good idea. And he brings it back to Washington and says, you know what we ought to do.
00:06:54 So I'm nervous about that. And so in the case of Sam Altman, you know, maybe he can, you know,
00:06:58 bring something relatively sensible to the discussion. There also has just been this
00:07:04 massive, massive number of sessions I saw on the agenda devoted to climate change and like every
00:07:10 possible angle imaginable. There's like, you know, how to transition away from fossil fuels,
00:07:15 how to transition to renewables, how to accelerate the transition, net zero, net zero,
00:07:20 net like they're doing it's like the same discussion like 20 different times and we even
00:07:24 saw a little bit of that walking around today on the streets like there was the one we were going
00:07:27 to go into the climate hub but the climate hub hadn't opened uh until tomorrow so we'll we'll
00:07:31 give you a full report on the climate hub on tomorrow's show but that seems to be a really
00:07:36 pervasive theme here as well yeah no climate seems to be top of mind still but it's not the theme of
00:07:44 the conference that seems to have changed uh to an entirely different issue and while i think you
00:07:52 know we we came here on the day where protests were happening and all of these left-wing protesters
00:07:59 were pressuring the global elites to take more action uh calling them hypocrites etc and if
00:08:08 you're here in davos one of the things that you see is like the helicopters flying by
00:08:14 uh we we know that there are private jet terminals you know when i arrived here at the airport there
00:08:22 were designated world economic forum areas waiting for these global people to come so they're all
00:08:29 flying in and the hypocrisy is mounting and i do think that uh they're aware of it to some degree
00:08:37 right? And it'll be interesting to see how long that continues, how long they will keep pushing
00:08:44 this climate issue when it's apparent to everybody that they are not really part of the solution.
00:08:52 Yeah. And just, I mean, as an illustration of this, we were trying to find, there's like all
00:08:57 of the, you know, they take the private jets in and then when they get to the private jet terminal,
00:09:01 they transfer from a private jet to a helicopter and then they take the helicopter to Davos and
00:09:06 then they get from the helicopter to a limo and the limo takes them to their hotel it's a it's a
00:09:10 really sustainable way of doing these but we were trying to find the heliport and the reason we
00:09:15 couldn't find it on on a map when we were looking is because it does it's not actually a heliport
00:09:19 the rest of the year it's a farmer's field so it's like what better illustration of the world
00:09:23 economic forum's approach which is to just like cover up the farmer's field with helicopters
00:09:27 for all of the uh the jet-setting elites all right well we are looking forward to seeing what you do
00:09:32 the rest of the week, Cosman. It is great to talk to you and great to have you here at all as well
00:09:37 on True North. We are here on the Andrew Lawton Show. And I just want to give you a little bit
00:09:42 of a teaser here. Cosman had mentioned a story, or Cosman had done a story today. And I had alluded
00:09:48 to it earlier when Klaus Schwab appeared on Chinese state media. And he was like talking up
00:09:54 how China is so critical in helping rebuild trust. Take a look. I think it's very, very important
00:10:02 the participation of Premier Li Chang could exactly be placed into this framework of rebuilding
00:10:12 trust because, as you know, there are many doubts at the moment whether China really
00:10:23 could master all those challenges or is at the beginning of a fast slowing down phase
00:10:33 of its economic growth.
00:10:36 So to hear Premier Li Chang speaking about the prospects of Chinese economy and the role
00:10:48 China will play inside the global economy, I think, can restore and rebuild to a large extent, 0.88
00:10:57 not only grows into China, but grows into our global system. 0.71
00:11:05 So right there, he, I mean, he's sucking up, basically is what he's doing. He's talking to 0.94
00:11:11 Chinese state media about the premier of China, one of the most senior officials in the Chinese
00:11:16 communist party and he's saying oh yes china's great it's china's moment it's china's world 0.72
00:11:20 which look i guess is a rare bit of honesty on this issue but it shows what this organization
00:11:26 is all about they want to suck up to big power they want the big corporate giants and the big
00:11:32 political giants to all be under one roof and klaus schwab is the guy that wants to sit at the
00:11:37 head of the table for reasons that you know may make sense to him but if you look at it from the
00:11:42 the perspective of a citizen of this world, of a country in this world, I should say, you're like,
00:11:47 well, hang on. He's not an elected head of state. He's not an elected head of government. This is
00:11:52 not an intergovernmental organization. This is not the United Nations, which whatever you may
00:11:57 think of it, at least has official standing. This is just a group. I mean, the Andrew Lawton show
00:12:01 could have a forum and we could invite all these people, but we don't. And more importantly, if we
00:12:07 did, all of these leaders would not want to sit there and kiss my ring like they do Klaus Schwab.
00:12:13 Now, admittedly, I can't entertain them in a 24 million franc Swiss villa. Maybe if we do a few
00:12:19 more successful election coverage experiences in Canada, we'll get up to the level where we can
00:12:27 have a nice villa in Oshawa, but certainly we're not doing a Swiss villa. So that's exactly what's
00:12:33 happening in the case of Klaus Schwab. He's enriching himself. He's empowering himself
00:12:37 all the while sitting back and telling his people that as you heard in the clip last year is a future
00:12:43 is built by the people we are going to be seeing on the streets of Davos. Now on the theme of
00:12:50 rebuilding trust, I had to share this clip with you because I think this is going to set the stage
00:12:54 for what we see a lot of in the week ahead. This is how Klaus Schwab in that same interview
00:13:00 to Chinese state media, CGTN, described the conference theme.
00:13:06 Now, why did we choose the theme or the motto, Rebuilding Trust?
00:13:15 If we compare the world today with the world before we had the COVID pandemics,
00:13:24 we find a completely different mood.
00:13:27 First, the world has become very fearful, very fragmented, of course, and in such a
00:13:42 situation, trust has vanished.
00:13:46 We have lost trust to a certain extent in each another because we all have become, under
00:13:52 the pressure of the crisis, of the multiple crisis, we have become more egoistic. So,
00:13:59 and if you are more egoistic, you think first of yourself, and this distorts an atmosphere
00:14:07 of trust. So, if you want to recreate, and that's the objective of the annual meetings
00:14:14 this year, we want to recreate a new spirit, a much more constructive spirit. Again, looking
00:14:21 forward and having confidence in our future and that's the reason why we have chosen this theme
00:14:31 rebuilding trust
00:14:34 so interesting that when he talks about the failure of society to trust institutions
00:14:44 which is valid i mean if you look at polling and surveys you can see this time and time again trust
00:14:49 is in decline. No one trusts the media. No one trusts government. I dare say no one trusts
00:14:53 the World Economic Forum. And who is to blame for this? Well, he says people are to blame. People
00:15:00 are being egotistical. People are being selfish. They're thinking only of themselves. This is
00:15:06 the Klaus Schwab ideal here, that the institutions are not the problem. The rest of us plebs are
00:15:12 problems for thinking only of ourselves and not valuing these people. How dare we not look to the
00:15:18 dear leaders of the World Economic Forum and realize all the good they're doing for us,
00:15:22 they're there to help us. Yeah, I don't quite see it that way, because some of the ideas that are
00:15:28 discussed here are things that may, in a very esoteric way, be entirely normal discussions to
00:15:34 have. But to real people, these are not normal. And one example of this is a discussion from 2019
00:15:41 between Klaus Schwab and Sergey Brin,
00:15:45 who is one of the founders, I believe, of Google.
00:15:47 And the discussion was about AI.
00:15:50 Now, this was 2017.
00:15:51 You think of where AI is now.
00:15:53 And I mean, ChatGPT is going to reprimand you
00:15:56 if you misgender someone.
00:15:58 But in 2017, it was still all uphill
00:16:01 and all upside to a lot of people.
00:16:03 They realized that it was a blank slate.
00:16:05 Who knew what was gonna come of it?
00:16:07 And this is what Klaus Schwab and Sergey Brin
00:16:10 decided to talk about as just one of the use case scenarios they saw as potentially coming about
00:16:16 from AI. So technology now is and digital technologies mainly have an analytical power.
00:16:25 Now we go into a predictive power and we have seen the first examples and your company very much
00:16:32 involved into it. But since the next step could be to go into a prescriptive mode which means
00:16:40 you you do not even have to have elections anymore because you can already
00:16:46 predict what predict and afterwards you can say why do we need elections
00:16:53 because we know what the result will be
00:16:56 why do we need elections because ai has told us the result you know elections are big business
00:17:06 There's a lot of money that goes into elections, to running them, administering them, to running campaigns.
00:17:11 What if we just say, hey, JATGPT, who should the next president be? 0.90
00:17:15 And it will spit out an answer, and that's that.
00:17:17 Now, I looked up this clip because this was circulating today, and I knew it wasn't today,
00:17:22 because the conference, as I'll talk about in a moment, hasn't officially, I mean, it started,
00:17:27 but the main sort of meat of the sessions have not begun and won't until tomorrow.
00:17:32 But I was wondering the context of this, and I looked it up,
00:17:35 The first thing I found when I looked it up was not the clip, but it was an Associated Press
00:17:40 fact check of the clip saying, I'll read it directly for you because I think this is kind
00:17:46 of funny. You heard the clip yourself. The headline, the World Economic Forum's chairman
00:17:51 didn't call for AI to replace elections. The claim, a video shows Klaus Schwab, the founder
00:17:58 and chairman of the World Economic Forum, calling for artificial intelligence to replace elections.
00:18:02 AP's assessment, false. So their argument here is that, no, no, no, he didn't call for it. He just
00:18:10 mused about it. Like this is their answer. Like, oh, he just, he wasn't endorsing and he was just
00:18:15 saying it's a possibility. Yeah. But the fact is those ideas, those possibilities are entirely
00:18:20 normal to the people gathering here in Davos, but they are not normal to real people in society
00:18:27 facing very real challenges, who understandably might have a declining level of trust and faith
00:18:33 in institutions, including, by the way, in democratic institutions. So that is where we
00:18:39 are as a society now. And Cosman and I were talking a few moments ago about some of the
00:18:45 things that are being discussed here. Misinformation, disinformation are key. There are panels,
00:18:51 sessions that are being done about freedom of expression. And I'm going to say from past
00:18:55 experience. There are unlikely to be panel discussions about the importance of protecting
00:18:59 freedom of expression. It was something that actually came up earlier when I was speaking
00:19:05 with Jonathan Greenblatt. Now, Jonathan Greenblatt, I have a number of disagreements with. He is the
00:19:10 executive director of the Anti-Defamation League, which is an organization that has done a lot over
00:19:16 the years to call out what they say is hate, mainly anti-Semitism, but hate in general.
00:19:22 And I was chatting about this with Avi Yamini of Rebel News earlier because he had a much
00:19:27 less friendly interaction with Jonathan Greenblatt shortly after mine, which was by all accounts
00:19:33 quite convivial and civil.
00:19:34 And Avi, who is Jewish, had a bit of a different perspective on this because he said the ADL
00:19:39 has been crying wolf for years.
00:19:41 So now when you have real virulent anti-Semitism around the world, no one is really caring
00:19:48 about it.
00:19:48 And that was Avi's perspective, which I'm sympathetic to.
00:19:50 My approach was very different. I went to my discussion with Jonathan Greenblatt as a Canadian, where we have a government, a government who has promised to regulate what it says is the scourge of online hate, a government that has promised legislation, regulations of social media, human rights laws that will prohibit the dissemination of what they say is online hate.
00:20:14 And I wanted to talk to someone who has made a living combating what he sees as hate,
00:20:19 what he thinks of these sorts of pushes.
00:20:21 And I must say, I was actually quite impressed with his response.
00:20:25 Take a look.
00:20:26 I'm here with Jonathan Greenblatt from the Anti-Defamation League.
00:20:30 In Canada and countries around the world, we hear about how online hate is one of the
00:20:34 big menaces to society here.
00:20:36 But obviously, especially in an American context, First Amendment protections, constitutional
00:20:40 freedoms.
00:20:40 So how should governments approach this in your view?
00:20:44 I think government should approach social media like all traditional media.
00:20:48 So if in your mainstream media you have laws about libel,
00:20:51 or you have regulations about slander or misinformation,
00:20:54 they should be applied equally and enforced regularly with respect to social media.
00:20:58 So it actually shouldn't be considered very differently.
00:21:00 If a government is going to regulate hate speech, how should they define what that is?
00:21:05 I don't know that you can regulate hate speech,
00:21:06 but you should make the companies liable for publishing libel.
00:21:10 It doesn't matter whether it's Facebook or the CBC.
00:21:14 So if the CBC is responsible for making sure that lies and whatnot isn't published or isn't broadcast,
00:21:22 the same thing should apply to Facebook in Canada.
00:21:24 The same thing should apply to every other social medium in Canada.
00:21:27 You've obviously had a bit of a spat recently with Elon Musk and Twitter.
00:21:31 Is your view that this is just a market-based solution that needs to happen here?
00:21:35 Individuals can boycott them and that's that?
00:21:37 Well, I think individuals need to make their own decisions about what media they choose
00:21:41 to use.
00:21:42 Brands need to make their own decisions about media where they choose to advertise, but
00:21:46 ultimately governments need to make the decision about how they think the media supports the
00:21:53 open society that they want.
00:21:54 Again, just so we're clear, I don't believe that you can censor hate speech.
00:21:58 I think hate speech is the price of free speech.
00:22:00 The trick is that the private companies have a responsibility as actors in the marketplace
00:22:06 to behave responsibly and that often doesn't happen. Hate speech is the price of free speech.
00:22:15 That is a remarkably lucid and accurate comment. Now, admittedly, Jonathan is speaking about this
00:22:22 with a bit more authority because he lives in a country that has far more ironclad protections
00:22:27 for free speech. The First Amendment in the United States is much stronger than Section 2B
00:22:32 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
00:22:35 But nevertheless, the point that he's making there
00:22:37 is a valid one, that we cannot regulate
00:22:39 and should not regulate hate speech,
00:22:42 but we need to enforce laws that exist offline
00:22:45 onto online scenarios.
00:22:49 And that's actually very key.
00:22:50 And Bruce Party and I have had this discussion in the past,
00:22:53 the Queen's University law professor,
00:22:55 that we already have criminal code provisions
00:22:57 on hate speech.
00:22:58 We already have defamation laws.
00:22:59 We already have a number of laws that apply anywhere.
00:23:03 They apply in a classroom, they apply in a workplace,
00:23:06 they apply on the street, they apply in a theater.
00:23:09 And if they apply in any place in Canada,
00:23:11 they also apply to the internet.
00:23:14 So that was one.
00:23:15 And again, I don't believe he's on
00:23:16 the freedom of expression panel I mentioned earlier,
00:23:19 but if there is at least someone
00:23:20 making that comment on that panel,
00:23:23 it will be very much needed, I think,
00:23:25 for world leaders to hear.
00:23:26 I have a message I wanted to share with you from Sheldon, who writes on YouTube in all caps so as to indicate that he's whispering it in a very calm and even-keeled way.
00:23:39 He says, focus on Canada, Andrew.
00:23:43 So this is a fair comment.
00:23:45 I am not in Canada right now.
00:23:46 I am several countries away.
00:23:48 I'm at the World Economic Forum.
00:23:50 I was in Davos.
00:23:51 I was not an invited guest of the World Economic Forum, but we are here doing the reporting anyway.
00:23:56 Now, this is not to me a distinct thing from what we do on this show generally.
00:24:03 The reason that we are at the World Economic Forum is not because we are covering things that matter to the world.
00:24:09 They are, and we are, but we are covering things that matter to Canadians.
00:24:14 And there are a few direct reasons for this.
00:24:16 Number one, we have a country with very deep ties between the government of Canada and the World Economic Forum.
00:24:23 Chrystia Freeland, who is the Deputy Prime Minister of Canada, is a member of the Board of Governors of the World Economic Forum and has never answered a reporter's question, to my knowledge, about why she thinks she can do that without it being a conflict of interest.
00:24:38 And I'm going to, if I see her, I don't know if she's coming this year.
00:24:41 If I see her, I'm going to ask her and I might get the full Menzies treatment and be tackled, although I don't believe the RCMP have jurisdiction in Davos. 1.00
00:24:48 So let's hope the Swiss Polizzi treat me better than the RCMP treated David Menzies last week. 1.00
00:24:55 So that's one of the ties.
00:24:56 We also have a situation in which the World Economic Forum has, by its founder and chairman's admission, Klaus Schwab,
00:25:03 penetrated the cabinet in Canada.
00:25:06 Now you may think, oh, well, it's a mistranslation, it's bravado.
00:25:09 But he is making a claim to have profound influence over the Canadian government specifically.
00:25:18 Now, I do not believe, as I've said on this show in the past, that Klaus Schwab is pulling the strings on what happens in Canada.
00:25:24 I think we have Justin Trudeau and Chrystia Freeland who have their own ideological agenda,
00:25:28 which happens to align with a lot of what's discussed at the World Economic Forum.
00:25:34 But the WEF positions itself as being a hub and a basis for ideas.
00:25:40 They talk about being ahead of the curve, talking about the future.
00:25:43 So when politicians and business leaders are all sitting around the table discussing, these ideas are really germinating and becoming policy eventually.
00:25:54 In some cases, it's very quickly when you have these government leaders that meet behind closed doors in the multilateral rooms at Davos.
00:26:01 And then they come out and say, we've reached this agreement or this pact or this accord.
00:26:05 But in other cases, it may be the seeds are planted that will shape over time to become policy.
00:26:11 So anyone who thinks that what happens here is not directly relevant to Canada is not thinking big enough.
00:26:20 There are people in this climate that we're in right now, I'm not talking about the chilly mountain weather,
00:26:25 I'm talking about the political climate, that are all too willing to put global needs above national needs,
00:26:31 to put communal needs above individual needs, and by extension, individual freedoms.
00:26:37 And that's why we're here, that's why we're covering this.
00:26:39 And I'm sorry, Sheldon, but this is focusing on Canada.
00:26:43 Just because we're not in Canada doesn't mean it is not a focus on our country.
00:26:48 And Mark Carney, I'll give you a little bonus one here.
00:26:50 Mark Carney, who is the former Bank of Canada governor, he's here and he is speaking.
00:26:56 And Mark Carney is a guy who has his eyes on replacing Justin Trudeau.
00:27:00 So at the very least, we have a direct Canadian political story as well.
00:27:04 Now, Mark Carney in the past has always been very friendly when we've seen him.
00:27:07 I mean, if you have my question that I should ask Mark Carney this year, let me know in the comments, because he owns the streets of Davos, basically.
00:27:14 So he's just like walking back and forth all day, every day.
00:27:16 So we'll get to the Mark Carney stuff later in the week, I am sure.
00:27:20 Just before we get to Chris Sims, who is joining us, I just wanted to give you a little bit of a rundown of what's going to happen this week.
00:27:28 So this is technically the first day of the World Economic Forum annual meeting.
00:27:32 but the official opening remarks, the main sessions, they all start tomorrow and run until
00:27:39 the end of the week. They run until Friday. We'll be doing the Andrew Lawton Show live every day
00:27:44 this week as we normally do, but at a different time. And I promise you, we will iron out the
00:27:49 tech glitches we had at the beginning. I just, again, I'll blame Klaus Schwab because it's easy
00:27:54 when we're covering the World Economic Forum. But no, I think it was just like me sitting on my
00:27:58 Mike Pack. So nevertheless, we will sort all that out. But just before we get to the next topic,
00:28:05 I wanted to share something which I think is incredibly important here. In years past,
00:28:10 the World Economic Forum has published ahead of time, in some cases, weeks ahead of time,
00:28:15 the list of people participating. So they have from around the world, 3,000 in the past,
00:28:22 two to 3,000 people, depending on the year that are business leaders, government leaders,
00:28:26 media leaders, academics, they're all invite only. They have their coveted white badges with blue
00:28:32 lines on them, which means they're really important people. And they publish a list because the WEF is
00:28:37 a big business. It's worth about, they have half a million, or sorry, half a billion US dollars in
00:28:42 revenue every year. So this is a company that I read one report today, if it were a private
00:28:48 corporation would be valued at like a billion dollars. So this is a big business. And in order
00:28:52 to be relevant and keep the money flowing in, they need to prove that people believe this is
00:28:58 the it place to be. So that's why they published the list. This year, they didn't do that. They
00:29:03 didn't publish the list of participants. They also didn't publish the list of public figures.
00:29:08 They gave like a one paragraph write-up listing some of the leaders of government and heads of
00:29:14 state that are going to be here, but they didn't publish the full list. So actually I'm here and
00:29:18 I have no idea who from Canada is here, except for those who were on the speaking program. And
00:29:23 the only Canadian I saw was Mark Carney. So maybe a Christian, maybe Christian Freeland's here. 0.55
00:29:28 Maybe not. Maybe Francois Philippe Champagne is here. Maybe Pierre Polyev is here. Who knows?
00:29:33 Maybe Maxine Bertie. I don't know. I don't think they're here. But the whole point is that we do
00:29:37 not know because the organization that says it wants to rebuild trust won't even publish the
00:29:43 guest list of its fancy Alpine conference. So this is just a bit of a palate cleanser. We will have
00:29:50 more coverage from Davos via Austria in the days to follow here on the Andrew Lawton Show. But
00:29:56 I do not, I want to, to Sheldon's point from earlier, neglect or ignore what's happening in
00:30:02 Canada. I know for people in Alberta, it was a very, very rough weekend. We had temperatures,
00:30:08 my friends in Alberta, of which I have a great many, were sharing screenshots of their temperature
00:30:14 readings and of thermometers. And it just looked absolutely miserable. I think at some places it
00:30:18 went down below minus 40. And because of this, you had the Alberta government telling people to not
00:30:24 use electricity, to rein in their electricity usage. Now, many people in Canada have reigned
00:30:30 in energy usage because they can't afford the carbon tax or the power bills. But it was a bit
00:30:35 of a different situation in Alberta.
00:30:37 Saskatchewan to the rescue, by the way.
00:30:39 Scott Moe announced that Saskatchewan was giving a bit of surplus power to the people
00:30:44 in Alberta.
00:30:45 But what does this all mean?
00:30:47 Chris Sims is the Alberta director with the Canadian Taxpayers Federation and joins me
00:30:52 as always on Monday.
00:30:53 I'm not going to let the Atlantic Ocean get in the way of this.
00:30:56 Chris, always good to talk to you.
00:30:57 Thanks for coming on.
00:30:58 How are you keeping, by the way?
00:31:00 We're okay.
00:31:01 It was actually pretty scary there on Saturday night.
00:31:04 A lot of people might be familiar, you know, any 80s kid that remembers the Cold War.
00:31:10 This is an emergency broadcast system.
00:31:12 It was like that.
00:31:14 Instead of being worried about the Ruskies, we were worried about the lights suddenly going out.
00:31:18 And when it's minus 42 outside without the wind chill, that's pretty scary because then you're getting into like pipe bursting cold.
00:31:28 So if all of a sudden your power goes out and you're in the middle of a January in Alberta with this kind of wind and this kind of cold, that was pretty alarming.
00:31:36 And then we saw, to your point, Premier Daniel Smith taking to social media and saying things I never thought I'd hear or say, saying things like, hey, folks, only use your microwave.
00:31:46 Don't use your oven. You know, cover your windows with your curtains. Turn off all your lights. Please, everybody.
00:31:51 Like we have to make sure we don't have rolling blackouts. And this is largely apparently because
00:31:57 a few years back, a previous government had shut down some power plants, but they didn't replace
00:32:04 the generation. So just apparently the story goes, we've lost a lot of power generation
00:32:10 here in Alberta, and we've added a lot of people coming to Alberta, myself included.
00:32:15 So they've really wanted a larger population of people coming here, lots of people moving here
00:32:19 to do business as well. So the grid just couldn't take it apparently. And the Alberta government
00:32:25 says that they're really being hindered by federal government regulations when it comes to expanding
00:32:31 their power base. And so here we had this strange situation of a province of Alberta, which if you
00:32:38 close your eyes and picture it, you imagine natural resources, right? You picture them as like an
00:32:43 energy patch but here we were facing rolling blackouts luckily that didn't come on saturday
00:32:50 night and so i wanted to remind people that this was how scary and critical it was this is how
00:32:56 essential it is to be heating your home and prime minister trudeau is nuking us with the carbon tax
00:33:03 on home heating as well so it just really added insult to injury well he heard the warning about
00:33:08 having to use your microwave that's why he's nuking uh that's a terrible pun i'm sorry
00:33:13 That was good. It was twins.
00:33:15 Yeah, fair enough. But let me ask you about the electric vehicle aspect, because this was like buried in the list of things you weren't supposed to do in Alberta.
00:33:23 They're like, you know, oh, and delay charging your electric vehicle, which is good.
00:33:27 Here's the alert that went out.
00:33:28 Basically, it's just like, you know, three city blocks in Edmonton are all the electric vehicles in Alberta, I think, in downtown Edmonton.
00:33:35 But then you had this ridiculous CBC story I wanted to share with people.
00:33:40 I know you've read it, but basically what CBC has said here is that the winter is the perfect time to have an electric car.
00:33:50 Their headline here, electric cars, the best vehicle in frigid temperatures, they're saying.
00:33:56 Meanwhile, the government is like, no, no, no, stop charging these things.
00:33:59 We can't sustain it on the grid.
00:34:01 Yeah, exactly.
00:34:02 This is literally part of what they said.
00:34:04 turn off all unnecessary lights and electrical appliances minimize the use of space heaters
00:34:09 delay use of major power appliances delay charging electric vehicles okay and so okay i'm not an
00:34:16 electrical engineer but i was a journalist for an awful long time so i've spoken to you know a
00:34:21 quadrillion people about all sorts of things including things like electric vehicles the
00:34:26 story goes is if you have your own electric vehicle quite often you have to have an upgrade
00:34:33 to your panel at home in order to be able to pull enough juice off the grid to plug your own car in
00:34:40 okay therefore it uses a little bit more power than a laptop to charge the thing the point here
00:34:47 being electric vehicles use a lot of energy in order to recharge their batteries the idea that
00:34:54 while we're all being told to avoid using hair dryers and blenders to have the cvc come out and 0.77
00:35:00 and say, hey, you know what's awesome in minus 50 windchill, which it was here in Lethbridge,
00:35:04 by the way, an electric vehicle. While the alert itself is saying, folks, don't do this.
00:35:10 This is where good intentions or fanciful notions or good planning, you know, I would love it if we
00:35:17 all ran off dilithium crystal generators. I'm a Star Trek kid. That would be fine. The only problem
00:35:22 is they don't exist. So that's a bit of a big problem when you've got minus 40 degrees outside
00:35:28 and you don't want your house and your kids freezing.
00:35:31 So to have this CBC article come out at this time
00:35:33 was just bizarre.
00:35:35 Yeah, and when you mentioned the,
00:35:38 I happened to get that lithium crystal reference
00:35:41 only because Ezra used it in his book,
00:35:43 Ethical Oil, back in the day.
00:35:45 So I learned it there, not from Star Trek. 0.51
00:35:47 I'm a bit of a weird, a dork
00:35:49 for a different reason like that. 0.99
00:35:51 I was gonna say, we have to convert you, what the heck?
00:35:53 Yeah, fair enough.
00:35:54 But I don't do sci, I don't do aliens, I don't do sci-fi.
00:35:56 So it's not just Star Trek specifically before all the Trekkies jump on me here.
00:36:00 But the thing that I would point out here is that everyone who talks about the transition
00:36:05 misses what is the most painfully obvious point, which is that we don't yet have the
00:36:10 magic thing that we can transition to that will do all of the things we're getting rid
00:36:15 of can.
00:36:16 And to put this back to the World Economic Forum context for a moment, we have people
00:36:20 here that are on these panels talking about, oh, the acceleration of the transition, net
00:36:25 zero, all of this.
00:36:25 And none of them have an answer for how you're going to get the people in Alberta through a cold that is minus 40, of how you're going to power the developing world, which right now only has fossil fuels available to them.
00:36:40 None of them have or really care about that.
00:36:44 And it's very fanciful, maybe.
00:36:46 I would say quite callous, to be honest.
00:36:49 It is callous because at the end of the day, these are real people involved.
00:36:53 So these are real people, real families.
00:36:55 These are people who are depending, in some cases, imagine if you were depending on an oxygen tank or something, God forbid, you know, you need electricity, you need power.
00:37:04 I'll give you an example.
00:37:05 There's a gentleman out in British Columbia.
00:37:07 He is a scientist.
00:37:08 OK, he does these calculations all the time.
00:37:11 We happen to disagree even on the carbon tax.
00:37:13 So he's not completely on my side here, but he understands energy calculation.
00:37:18 A few years back, Andrew, you might have remembered when he did this.
00:37:22 He calculated that, say, Santa Claus brought everybody in British Columbia an electric vehicle.
00:37:29 Boom, you now own it. It's in your driveway.
00:37:32 And British Columbia residentially started relying on electric heat pumps for bare minimum.
00:37:38 So we're not talking industrial, forget commercial, just households.
00:37:42 They would need nine new Site C dams. Nine of them.
00:37:48 So for folks who are unfamiliar with Site C, imagine those big honking gorge dams that you've seen on TV and in movies that James Bond runs across.
00:37:59 They're building something like that right now in British Columbia.
00:38:02 It has taken them like 30 years from first blueprints to final approval to get this thing going.
00:38:08 That's the kind of mega wattage we're talking about.
00:38:11 they would need nine of them tomorrow if they all switch to electric vehicles and bare bones
00:38:18 heat pump electricity yeah and i we don't have it we go back to all of these different scenarios
00:38:25 that we've talked about in the past on the show and and you know and and to bring it back to real
00:38:29 people because i think real people need to be at the core of an energy transition if there's going
00:38:33 to be one and uh real people's needs real appeals people's capabilities and we see that callousness
00:38:39 on display with the carbon tax and i don't want to sound like a broken record here because i know
00:38:43 this has been coming up in our discussions and other days on my i show pretty much every week
00:38:48 now but it's important and the federal government has made a choice here they like to say that oh
00:38:52 well it's the climate emergency we have no choice but they do have a choice and they have chosen
00:38:57 to make energy which is not a luxury item it is a necessity especially in canada but anywhere
00:39:03 they've chosen to make that more expensive. Yes, they have. And here's the nub. So the
00:39:10 Liberal government, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and his government have a mandatory minimum carbon
00:39:14 tax. It's $65 a ton right now. It costs 12 cents per cubic meter of natural gas, 10 cents per liter
00:39:22 of propane. But most people in Canada use natural gas. On average, Andrew, that will cost Canadian
00:39:28 families more than $300 extra just this winter, just in the carbon tax. But here's the weird catch.
00:39:35 So back in October, for some reason, the Atlantic Caucus of the Liberal Members of Parliament got
00:39:40 a hold of Justin Trudeau and said, hey, we need a car vote. He admitted, one, that this makes life
00:39:47 too expensive. And he admitted, two, that they could afford then to give them a car vote on
00:39:53 furnace oil. Only 4% of Canadians use furnace oil. Almost all of them happen to be in Atlantic
00:40:00 Canada in vote-rich seats for the Liberals. So he gave an exception on home heating for three years
00:40:07 to those folks. But all the rest of us who are using natural gas and propane,
00:40:12 praying to God the power stays on, we're still getting hit by this carbon tax. And just one
00:40:17 more thing, Andrew, you're going to be hearing a lot about, oh, rebate checks landed in bank
00:40:21 accounts today because there's a huge propaganda push coming out of the Trudeau government today
00:40:25 saying, you know, thank me, thank me, peasant, for giving you a rebate. No, no, no. The parliamentary
00:40:32 budget officer himself has shown that people pay more than they get back. So on average,
00:40:38 the average Alberta family will be out more than $900 this year. That's net. That's with the rebates
00:40:45 factored in. So yeah, you're right. This is a huge carbon tax punishment on an essential like
00:40:51 home heating. Yeah, no, that's important context here. And again, my sympathies to anyone in
00:40:56 Alberta who had a terrible weekend. I mean, you're in for a number of horrors with the cold
00:41:02 weather in general on a given year, but I know this was particularly straining and trying for
00:41:07 people. The good news is Stephen Gilbeau is actually fine with having to reduce electricity
00:41:13 because he is already a dim bulb. So it was good. He was already energy efficient in that respect.
00:41:17 Have you seen him yet? Did he fly his electric hoverboard over there yet?
00:41:21 I haven't seen him just yet. He might have been in the Greta Thunberg sailboat.
00:41:26 He left last week, so he should be making it to Davos anytime in 2026, I believe.
00:41:31 Well after the next election, though. So good for a contestant in his riding, perhaps.
00:41:36 Chris Sims, always good to talk to you. We'll see you back on the other side of the Atlantic next week.
00:41:40 Thank you.
00:41:41 Have fun, Andrew.
00:41:42 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:41:44 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.