Juno News - January 17, 2024


Davos Day 3 | Javier Milei warns WEF about dangers of socialism

Topics
Mentioned
John Kerry still doesn’t want to talk about China Davos Day 4 | Online censorship finds a home at WEF

Episode Stats


Length

34 minutes

Words per minute

168.74

Word count

5,873

Sentence count

347

Harmful content

Misogyny

6

sentences flagged

Toxicity

7

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Andrew Lawton is in Davos, Switzerland, at the World Economic Forum, and there's a lot to be said about the lack of people willing to speak to the media, and the silence that surrounds them. Today's guest is Javier Malay, an Argentine economist who has been a regular at Davos before, and who is now the president of Argentina.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:01:16 This is The Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:01:30 Hello, and we're most ready to hear the Martin Show on True North on this Wednesday, January 17th,
00:01:38 day three of the World Economic Forum's annual meeting in Davos, where I am, well, not quite.
00:01:45 I know I've told the story every day this week. Bear with me. I'll do it in like 15 seconds or less now.
00:01:50 We've had to stay in the neighboring country of Austria, specifically the little ski town of Donburn,
00:01:56 because the World Economic Forum snatches up like every hotel and Airbnb within a rather sizable
00:02:02 radius. So here we are, but we're still going live and we are still getting in many hours of every
00:02:12 day to Canadians. In fact, I say most things. Some of the questions we've been chatting about
00:02:23 with people, involve what they've said and done in Davos. In other cases, we meet someone who is
00:02:28 a bit of a subject matter expert. We want to ask them about that. I'm trying to kind of get a sense
00:02:34 and I can't recall every interview I did when I was in Davos last year, but people seem to be less
00:02:41 eager to speak this time around. And in fact, as you'll learn on the show today, we've got a bunch
00:02:48 of these clips that I've done where, you know, you look and you'll say, oh, wow, I spoke to so-and-so
00:02:52 and then you find that, oh, that interview was like, you know, four seconds because I asked a
00:02:57 question and they didn't give an answer. So that is effectively the problem that we're dealing with.
00:03:03 A lot of people do not want to speak. A lot of people are not willing to speak. And I think
00:03:07 yesterday was an interesting example of probably why that is. I spoke to J. Michael Evans, who was
00:03:13 the guy a couple of years back promoting the individual carbon footprint tracker.
00:03:17 and now he is left to just effectively pretending that he never said what he did last time he was
00:03:25 here. So that is I think why it's important to ask these questions and I'll say that silence
00:03:30 is deafening. A lot of the times these world leaders and business leaders giving me
00:03:35 non-answers and giving you non-answers because I'm here asking questions on your behalf
00:03:40 is far more revealing and I would say probably far more honest than anything they would have
00:03:46 said had they decided to open their mouths. So we got a few of those today, but the big story
00:03:51 is Javier Malay bringing what I would say rhetorical blame to this gathering of self-styled
00:04:00 elites in the Swiss Alps. Now, Javier Malay has been to the World Economic Forum before. He is
00:04:05 an economist. He's a bit of a renegade and a rebel. He's spoken at the WEF, and he has always
00:04:11 been a libertarian. And I know there were some people that were a little bit skeptical of this.
00:04:14 Was he just going to be some globalist shill now that he has become the Argentine president?
00:04:20 Now, when Javier Malay was added to the speakers list at the World Economic Forum this year,
00:04:25 I reported it and I had a number of people think, oh my goodness, this is not something
00:04:30 that we should be celebrating.
00:04:32 And then Javier Malay showed up.
00:04:35 And I'll say a couple of things about this.
00:04:37 One thing that was very important is that he did not change his tune at all from what
00:04:42 he talks about when he is campaigning and what he talks about in the media. This was
00:04:46 him making a rather significant and I would say cogent defense of capitalism.
00:04:52 If free enterprise capitalism and economic freedom have proven to be extraordinary instruments to
00:04:58 end poverty in the world, and we are now at the best time in the history of humanity,
00:05:03 it is worth asking why I say that the West is in danger. And I say this precisely because
00:05:12 In those of our countries that should defend the values of the free market, private property and the other institutions of libertarianism, sectors of the political and economic establishment, some due to mistakes in their theoretical framework and others due to a greed for power are undermining the foundations of libertarianism, opening up the doors to socialism and potentially condemning us to poverty, misery and stagnation.
00:05:37 And it should never be forgotten that socialism is always and everywhere an impoverishing phenomenon that has failed in all countries where it's been tried out.
00:05:46 It's been a failure economically, socially, culturally, and it also murdered over 100 million human beings.
00:05:58 That was, you may think, okay, fine.
00:06:01 You know, he talks about capitalism.
00:06:02 Big whoop.
00:06:03 Most of the people in that room are capitalists, at least the business magnates to whom he's speaking.
00:06:07 But it was important nonetheless.
00:06:10 I mean, the World Economic Forum is, yes, nominally a capitalist free market organization.
00:06:15 But I say nominally because it doesn't really work out that way.
00:06:18 It's the same group that fets Antonio Guterres, the Secretary General of the United Nations,
00:06:22 and quite literally a socialist.
00:06:25 That's not just me saying, oh, he's a socialist.
00:06:27 He is actually a socialist.
00:06:28 He represents a socialist party.
00:06:30 You also have Klaus Schwab talking about his grand vision of remaking capitalism,
00:06:36 a capitalism that looks at government and industry and society as partners and co-owners
00:06:44 of companies instead of shareholders, which is, you know, the actual definition of capitalism.
00:06:50 And one thing that's interesting is that Javier Malay was kind of preempting the concerns that
00:06:55 people give when he talks about socialism. And why this is so important is because he was
00:07:00 really saying right from the outset, I'm not going to let you string me up on semantics
00:07:05 when I reject socialism.
00:07:07 He described perfectly what socialism is to him.
00:07:12 ...produced by collectivism is no fantasy,
00:07:16 nor is it an inescapable fate.
00:07:18 But it's a reality that we are...
00:07:20 Sorry, we're going to build up to that clip.
00:07:23 I think that's more of a dessert here.
00:07:25 This was on me.
00:07:26 This is the one I'm talking about
00:07:28 when he's talking about the West
00:07:28 being under threat from socialism.
00:07:31 Unfortunately, already started to go along this far.
00:07:34 I know to many it may sound ridiculous to suggest that the West has turned to socialism, but it's only ridiculous if you only limit yourself to the traditional economic definition of socialism, which says that it's an economic system where the state owns the means of production.
00:07:52 This definition, in my view, should be updated in the light of current circumstances.
00:08:00 Today, states don't need to directly control the means of production to control every aspect of the lives of individuals.
00:08:09 What he's done there is quite important, and it's a lead up to the point that he ended on,
00:08:16 which I think is important here and really speaks to what has kind of emerged as the theme of the day.
00:08:21 And it was kind of where I was going anyway, before Javier Malay took the stage.
00:08:26 Now, I'll say two things on this before I get there.
00:08:28 Number one, this is what world leaders should be doing when they come to Davos, if they come to Davos.
00:08:34 And I'm sympathetic to the argument that speaking here and being here is not itself an example of someone being a sellout.
00:08:43 It depends what you do here.
00:08:45 And most leaders, when they come here, do sell out.
00:08:47 They do decide to kiss Klaus Schwab's ring.
00:08:50 They go along with what I'll say is just basically the globalist songbook.
00:08:54 They all sing the same chorus and they don't really leave much room for individuality.
00:08:58 So what Javier Malay did here is incredibly important in that vein.
00:09:01 Now, he was a little bit flattering with some of the business leaders in attendance.
00:09:06 Now, I would say maybe too much, but I understand the point he's trying to make here because
00:09:11 these are people who are creating wealth by virtue of what they're doing.
00:09:16 Now, largely, the business leaders in Davos are creating wealth for themselves.
00:09:20 But if you are a capitalist, you believe that large corporations, large businesses that bring in money are making opportunities for people.
00:09:29 They're stimulating the economy.
00:09:30 Now, we can haggle over inequality and equality.
00:09:33 We can haggle over trickle down economics and all of that.
00:09:36 But I think he was making a very clever point here in how he ended his remarks, even if it did sound a bit deferential on the surface.
00:09:45 Take a look.
00:09:45 The impoverishment produced by collectivism is no fantasy, nor is it an inescapable fate.
00:09:52 But it's a reality that we Argentines know very well. 0.87
00:09:55 Do not be intimidated either by the political castes or by parasites who live off the state. 0.94
00:10:01 Do not surrender to a political class that only wants to stay in power and retain its privileges. 0.70
00:10:06 You are social benefactors. You're heroes. You're the creators of the most extraordinary period of prosperity we've ever seen. Let no one tell you that your ambition is immoral. If you make money, it's because you offer a better product at a better price, thereby contributing to general well-being.
00:10:27 do not surrender to the advance of the state. The state is not the solution. The state is the
00:10:33 problem itself. You are the true protagonists of this story. And rest assured that as from today,
00:10:40 Argentina is your staunch, unconditional ally. Thank you very much and long live freedom. Damn it.
00:10:49 Long live freedom. Damn it. Now, this is like a Javier Malay catchphrase, 1.00
00:10:55 which I don't believe the interpreter did justice to.
00:10:58 I think that you had to hear it in Javier Millet's original tone and cadence to appreciate it.
00:11:04 But nevertheless, that was what he said.
00:11:06 That was how he ended.
00:11:07 And it was probably not something that had ever been said before. 0.98
00:11:09 I'm not talking about the dammit. 0.95
00:11:10 I'm talking about the freedom part. 0.94
00:11:12 That was not something that world leaders at Davos have ever heard other world leaders at Davos say, I suspect.
00:11:19 Now, Javier Millet did what a lot of his supporters thought and hoped he would do when he got there.
00:11:24 He took a flamethrower to the sacred cows and said, I'm going to stand up for liberty.
00:11:28 I'm going to stand up for markets.
00:11:29 And yeah, we are not going to say that making money is immoral.
00:11:33 Good on him for doing that.
00:11:35 Now, just as a bit of an aside here, Javier Malay did the opposite of what many of those
00:11:40 attending Davos did by taking their private jets to then get on the private helicopter
00:11:45 and then get in the limo.
00:11:46 He flew commercial, which heads of government will oftentimes claim they are not able to
00:11:51 do or aren't allowed to do for security reasons.
00:11:53 But, you know, the UK prime minister, the Australian prime minister, they've all flown commercial.
00:11:57 The Canadian prime minister does not.
00:11:59 And that's true.
00:12:00 Conservative, liberal, doesn't matter.
00:12:02 Javier Malay flew Lufthansa from Buenos Aires to Frankfurt.
00:12:06 And then he got on a connecting flight in Frankfurt to get to Zurich, where, you know, it's a couple hours from Davos.
00:12:13 But it was interesting to see how much support he had on that plane.
00:12:18 And this was just a little snippet of one of the videos, many, many videos and photos
00:12:22 that were uploaded of his commercial flight.
00:12:25 imagine just like looking up and seeing in you know three seats ahead of you a weird hairdo and
00:12:49 a leather coat and you're like oh that's kind of odd that guy looks like a an aging 80s rocker or
00:12:53 the president of Argentina. And you say, oh, it must be the 80s rocker. And then you realize, oh,
00:12:57 no, that is the president of Argentina right there. Flying commercial. Now, my colleague is
00:13:02 flying back home Lufthansa. So he's like wondering now, Cosman Georgia is wondering if he's going to
00:13:08 be on the same plane as Javier Malay. So if so, we'll probably have that interview that a lot of
00:13:13 you have been asking for. But that was what he did. Now, someone asked in the comments here,
00:13:18 angry Canadian, perhaps not her legal name, why did WEF let him speak? That's weird. I have two
00:13:25 answers for that. Number one, because they think that he's going to go along with it. Maybe they
00:13:32 think that like everyone else, he's going to go there and he's going to be absorbed in to the
00:13:36 international community and start saying exactly what everyone wants him to say. The other
00:13:41 alternative, which I'm leaning towards, is that they've become very nervous about a lot of the
00:13:49 criticism that they've been facing. And they wanted to be able to say, no, we don't all sound
00:13:54 the same and talk the same. Look, we had to have your Malay here, the same reason they had Donald 0.99
00:13:57 Trump here a few years back. And they love to be able to hold that up as an example of saying,
00:14:02 no, no, no, we let people in that we don't necessarily disagree with. So I think it's
00:14:06 because they're so secure in what they are and who they are that they do not feel threatened by
00:14:12 someone like him coming in. But I also would think there's a little bit of option A bleeding into it
00:14:17 and that they don't think he's going to behave the way he did. They don't think he's going to
00:14:21 embarrass them as much as I think he did. And really, as I was watching and listening to that,
00:14:26 it reminded me of Ricky Gervais, the actor and comedian hosting the Golden Globes a few years
00:14:34 back. Like literally, I realized the implications of them are a bit different, but this is the clip
00:14:39 that it reminded me of. Spoiler alert. Season two is on the way. So in the end, he obviously
00:14:45 didn't kill himself. Just like Jeffrey Epstein. Shut up. I know he's your friend, but I don't care.
00:14:56 You had to make your own way here in your own plane, didn't you? Right. Well, you say you won't,
00:15:00 But the companies you work for, I mean, unbelievable.
00:15:03 Apple, Amazon, Disney.
00:15:05 If ISIS started a streaming service, you'd call your agent, wouldn't you?
00:15:09 So if you do win an award tonight, don't use it as a platform to make a political speech, right?
00:15:15 You're in no position to lecture the public about anything.
00:15:18 You know nothing about the real world.
00:15:20 Most of you spent less time in school than Greta Thunberg.
00:15:23 So if you win, right, come up, accept your little award, thank your agent and your God.
00:15:30 Javier Malay at World Economic Forum, Ricky Gervais at the Oscars.
00:15:40 Maybe we put a poll up in the comments on who you think wore that level of snark and disdain for the status quo better.
00:15:47 But that was the big takeaway for today.
00:15:50 Now, when I said that a theme had emerged, I think that what I mentioned earlier is important here,
00:15:55 is that world leaders, oftentimes, whether they are liberal, conservative, green, socialist,
00:16:00 right-wing, left-wing in their home countries, when they get onto the international stage,
00:16:04 they all kind of converge and coalesce into this amorphous blob. I mean, Mark Ruta, who is the
00:16:10 nominally conservative prime minister of the Netherlands, I would say a lot of people would
00:16:14 dispute that, when he's at Davos, sounds the same as a Justin Trudeau does. Boris Johnson,
00:16:20 when he was the, again, supposedly conservative prime minister of the UK, when he's chairing the
00:16:25 COP climate summit in Glasgow, he sounds exactly like, you know, maybe not exactly like Al Gore,
00:16:31 but he sounds exactly like all of these other pro net zero anti oil and gas people.
00:16:37 So you need someone that's going to at least be consistent. And one of the big models of
00:16:41 inconsistency, and I've mentioned him on the show in the past, is a gentleman by the name of
00:16:45 Hardeep Singh Puri. Now he is the minister of natural gas and petroleum in India. Now,
00:16:51 this is a guy whose cabinet position is not shying away from the fact that India is a country that
00:16:58 relies on fossil fuels. It has the largest population in the world. I didn't realize it
00:17:02 had surpassed China, but that was what Hardeep Singh Puri said today. Not only do you have that,
00:17:09 but it's a country that needs energy and the energy is coming from oil and gas. Now, Hardeep
00:17:15 Singh Puri knows full well that you cannot just flip a switch and transition away from
00:17:22 oil and gas to renewables, to solar and wind and all of that.
00:17:26 And even if you could, it would be incredibly expensive.
00:17:28 But you cannot sustain a population of a billion people by doing that.
00:17:32 Yet.
00:17:38 It was him in 2022.
00:17:41 You were on a panel about oil and gas and energy this morning.
00:17:44 Do you think phasing out of fossil fuels is actually a realistic goal?
00:17:48 Look, I said what I had to, but you know, if you were to do that survey in different parts
00:17:55 of the world, if you were to do it for instance in South Asia or Africa or in Latin America,
00:18:01 you'd get results that might be a little different from the kind of results you're getting here.
00:18:07 So that was when I ran into him on the streets of Davos after he had said this.
00:18:14 Mr. Moderator, if the global crises that we are facing has taught us anything, we need to accelerate on the transition.
00:18:24 And we are doing it in a large number of ways.
00:18:27 But let me also share with you the perspective that we are a country where 60 million people go to the petrol bank every morning to fill up.
00:18:35 60 million. One of the things that we need to ensure is to make sure that there is no
00:18:43 energy shortage in any form in a large country which has a population of 1.34 billion. See
00:18:50 what's happening to countries around India. I don't want to be, I'm not, I'm nearly stating
00:18:55 a fact. Four or five countries around India are in severe, dire straits. It's happening
00:19:03 in countries all over the world. So we need to be able to navigate our way out of this
00:19:08 current energy crisis and into an accelerated transition to green energy.
00:19:14 So on stage, when he's talking to his Davos chums, he's saying we need to accelerate the
00:19:20 transition. We need to get away from fossil fuels faster. And then you run into him on the streets
00:19:24 and he's saying, oh, well, yes, in the developing world, no one buys into any of that. Well,
00:19:28 I thought when I saw him today that a follow-up on that was in order.
00:19:33 Take a look.
00:19:35 Minister Andrew Lawton, True North, I'm wondering how countries like yours are supposed to power themselves after this so-called energy transition.
00:19:44 Doesn't want to answer a question.
00:19:45 He's advocating for the energy transition on stage, but won't explain the very fundamental question of how India is supposed to power itself if that transition happens.
00:19:54 you can tell my frustration with these people is growing and my tolerance is waning when like
00:20:01 after the questions I just start to do like a little bit of a monologue when they walk away
00:20:05 from me but this is I think an example of what the problem is here and it's why it's so important
00:20:10 when someone is going to go and tell them no so that's kind of where I am on this whole thing
00:20:17 right now is that if you want someone to push back against this I do think there is some
00:20:22 significance to the idea that maybe you have to have a little bit of disruption from within the
00:20:28 institution. I think boycotting it is ultimately going to be more important because when you boycott
00:20:32 it, it loses its influence. None of the big money guys are going to spend money just to hang around
00:20:37 with each other. They need access to politicians for this to be worthwhile. Now, earlier in the
00:20:42 day, that was actually a bit of a theme that I was trying to get out of some of the conversations I
00:20:46 had with people. I wanted to really get them to acknowledge what it is that they see in all of
00:20:52 this. And just to give you some of the raw numbers here, well, Microsoft, Accenture, Salesforce,
00:20:58 all of these strategic partners of the World Economic Forum, they pay hundreds of thousands
00:21:03 of US dollars a year to be members of the World Economic Forum. They get then the opportunity
00:21:11 to spend tens of thousands of dollars a year to buy tickets for the World Economic Forum Annual
00:21:17 Meeting. It's invitation only, but the invitation is an invitation to pony up, I don't know,
00:21:22 like $20,000 to buy a ticket here. We get here for free, but we don't get to go inside and enjoy
00:21:27 their fancy bug sandwiches and whatnot. So that's effectively the racket here. And why are these
00:21:34 businesses ponying up the cash? My theory on this is that they're getting access to politicians
00:21:38 behind the prying eyes of the media.
00:21:40 Well, the president of Microsoft, Brad Smith,
00:21:42 happened to be walking by, and I thought maybe,
00:21:45 just maybe, he would be able to shed some light
00:21:47 on why Microsoft sees this as such a worthwhile investment.
00:21:52 What is it Microsoft gets out of its association
00:21:54 with the World Economic Forum?
00:21:57 It must be something.
00:21:58 You're spending enough money on it.
00:21:59 What do you get out of it?
00:22:01 Well, that's a softball, too, that one. 0.97
00:22:04 I'm getting body checked by your security for an easy one.
00:22:08 it was the it was the shorter woman that uh bought i don't know if it was on camera when
00:22:15 it happened but sean says iffy yeah she kind of body checked me out of the way but then when i
00:22:19 commented on the body check the other security guy and brad both chuckled so uh that was that
00:22:23 i mean i i'm a big boy i could hey i didn't get like the full david menzies takedown which maybe
00:22:28 i'll get if i if i run into christopher freeland later uh but he didn't want to answer what it is
00:22:32 that he gets out of being at the world economic forum neither did the prime minister of bulgaria
00:22:38 to whom I asked the same question.
00:22:44 Prime Minister, what's the value in world leaders being here?
00:22:47 I have to go.
00:22:50 Oh, I'm sorry. That's the only clip.
00:22:52 That's it. That's all we have. I have to go.
00:22:55 It's funny that the time it takes them to say whatever they say to ignore you
00:22:59 is no different than the time it's going to take them to answer the question.
00:23:02 Now, I did get a little bit of an answer from the Prime Minister of Belgium,
00:23:07 alexander decrew although as you'll see in a moment on the follow-up question man that limo
00:23:12 door shuts quickly minister i'm from canada i'm just wondering what the value is of world leaders
00:23:17 like you being here well people need to talk to each other and people need to listen this event
00:23:22 is much more about listening than about talking but aren't you being sold access by having business
00:23:27 leaders paying to be in your presence sir i guess not yeah there's the again the little sass at the
00:23:36 my apologies. I lower the veil of professionalism ever so slightly. But there you go. You have
00:23:42 really not an eagerness for any of these people to explain what it is that's so important that
00:23:49 they get here that they could not get in any other way. Now, Chrystia Freeland, I mentioned
00:23:56 a moment ago obliquely, I should probably make this a little bit more clear. She is in Davos
00:24:01 right now. Now, I suspected she would turn up, but there was never any public announcement of it.
00:24:07 And the World Economic Forum had not released its list of attendees. And I will say up until
00:24:13 this morning, again, the third of five days for this conference, Chrystia Freeland did not appear
00:24:19 on the speaking agenda. So she was added in at the last minute to this morning for a speech
00:24:27 she's giving or a panel she's doing tomorrow. Now, maybe she just had to clear her schedule to find 0.99
00:24:34 a way to make it work. Maybe they were trying to, you know, hide the fact that she was coming. I
00:24:39 don't know what it was. I don't really care. But the point is, Chrystia Freeland, who is the Deputy
00:24:43 Prime Minister of Canada, while also serving as a member of the Board of Governors for Board of
00:24:48 Trustees for the WAF, is in the city. She had, according to her itinerary, a bunch of private
00:24:53 meetings today and tomorrow she's going to be speaking on a panel. So this is I think fascinating
00:24:59 to me that we have politicians and she's an example not of a Javier Malay that's going to 1.00
00:25:03 come here and represent Canadian interest but she's an example of the one that wants to come 1.00
00:25:08 and kiss Klaus Schwab's ring and talk about how Canada and the World Economic Forum have so much
00:25:14 in common and that I think is why it's so important as I've said time and time again this week for
00:25:20 journalists to be here and ask these questions because even if they don't get answered, there's
00:25:25 still a value in putting questions to these people and exposing their unwillingness to answer,
00:25:31 their unwillingness to tackle what are very real concerns for people around the world. I think the
00:25:36 big get of the day was definitely the World Health Organization Director General, Dr. Tedra, well
00:25:42 doctor, I mean he's a PhD, I don't want to dismiss it, but he's not a medical doctor, Tedros Adhanom
00:25:48 Ghebreyes. Now, this is a man who has had extraordinary power over the last few years
00:25:54 because of the role the World Health Organization took in leading Canada and the world through the
00:25:59 pandemic, supposedly. This is the guy who's now pushing countries to adopt a pandemic treaty in
00:26:05 March, and he was actually touting that in one of his panels on stage today. But he cannot answer
00:26:11 or will not answer fundamentally simple questions about the public health interventions that have
00:26:17 proven catastrophic for the world.
00:26:21 Dr. Adnan, do you believe that lockdown should always be rejected as a public health measure?
00:26:26 Can we talk later?
00:26:27 What time? I'm happy to arrange a meeting with you, sir.
00:26:30 Do you believe lockdown should be rejected as a public health measure?
00:26:33 Sir, it's a simple question.
00:26:34 Do you condemn public health interventions like lockdowns and vaccine mandates?
00:26:38 The slogan for the WEF agenda this year is rebuilding trust.
00:26:43 Do you believe China should be held accountable for its role in COVID? 0.87
00:26:52 Sir, our lockdown's bad.
00:26:54 Our lockdown's a bad thing.
00:27:02 I mean, you can't say I didn't try.
00:27:04 That was an example.
00:27:06 You saw Avi Yamini from Rebel News, Callum Smiles,
00:27:09 who is an independent journalist from the United Kingdom.
00:27:11 We're all trying to get it there.
00:27:13 And again, the simple question, will you condemn lockdowns?
00:27:17 No answer.
00:27:18 Will you condemn vaccine mandates?
00:27:19 No answer.
00:27:20 Now, maybe he didn't hear me.
00:27:21 I was pretty close to him, though.
00:27:22 Silence, again, is deafening, I will say.
00:27:25 And here's a man that, I reiterate, wants to get countries on board with this pandemic
00:27:31 treaty by May.
00:27:33 Now, this is where we go back from the streets into the Davos Congress Center for a moment,
00:27:38 because I want you to hear what he articulates as being one of the chief impediments
00:27:42 to his ideal vision for how the world should respond to health crises.
00:27:49 The key in order to have better prepared and to address the disease X is the pandemic agreement.
00:27:55 The pandemic agreement can bring all the experience,
00:27:59 all the challenges that we have faced, and all the solutions into one.
00:28:03 and that agreement can help us to prepare for the future in in a better way because
00:28:11 this is about a common enemy and without a shared response starting from the preparedness
00:28:18 you know we will face the same problem as as as covid and deadline for the pandemic agreement
00:28:26 is may 2024 and member states are negotiating this is between countries and i hope they will
00:28:34 deliver this pandemic agreement by that time by on the deadline because if this generation cannot
00:28:42 do it we're the lived community we have the first-hand experience i don't think incoming
00:28:49 generation the next generation will do it so for our children and grandchildren's sake i think we
00:28:55 have to convert all the lessons we have learned into this pandemic and prepare the world for
00:29:01 for for the future because this is a common global interest and national interest very
00:29:07 narrow national interest should not come into into the way of course national interest is natural
00:29:13 but it's the narrow national interest that could be difficult and affecting the negotiations even
00:29:20 as we speak.
00:29:25 Ooh, Tedros is a lot more chatty
00:29:28 when he's among friends, isn't he?
00:29:30 I would have taken even just, you know,
00:29:32 seven or eight of those words
00:29:33 that he had for his Davos chums
00:29:35 when I was chatting with him on the streets.
00:29:37 Again, I was asking yes or no questions.
00:29:39 You can't argue that it's because
00:29:40 you have to get to a meeting
00:29:41 when I'm walking alongside you.
00:29:43 I like how, by the way,
00:29:44 he was like, let's do this later.
00:29:45 Okay, name a time, sir.
00:29:47 Name a time and a place
00:29:48 and I will be there.
00:29:50 That happened to me last year, actually, where I wanted to ask the president of Serbia a question.
00:29:54 And he said, can we do this tomorrow?
00:29:56 As though I can just be guaranteed to run into the president of Serbia tomorrow.
00:29:59 So one day I told him it was a sports question.
00:30:01 He was all fine with it.
00:30:04 One Elisa Angel just has a lovely comment here, which I may use tomorrow.
00:30:08 She says, ask them if their silence is acquiescence to the premise of the question.
00:30:13 If they don't respond, we'll simply assume it is.
00:30:16 I'll actually do you one better than that, Elisa.
00:30:18 So I think what I might do tomorrow is say, if you don't answer, I'm going to report it as a yes
00:30:23 or something like that. Or if you don't answer, I'll report it as a no, depending on the idea.
00:30:28 We'll play around with ideas. But yeah, I should tell them that by being silent, they are saying
00:30:33 X, they're saying something, whatever the context of the discussion is. And in his case,
00:30:39 his refusal to condemn lockdown, because again, if I were to say to him, take the exact same
00:30:43 circumstances, the guy walking down the street doesn't want to be questioned, but he's getting
00:30:46 question. If I were to say, do you think the world should know that vaccines are good? He's going to
00:30:52 break stride and say absolutely, because he wants to say it. He wants to brag about that. He wants
00:30:56 to promote that. If I said, hey, do you think the pandemic treaty is good? He's going to say yes.
00:31:01 But it's only when you ask questions that they, for whatever reason, do not wish to answer,
00:31:06 that they clam up and get silent, as was the case with John Kerry yesterday talking about China
00:31:11 and private jet travel. Although the private jet one oddly seemed to like get him riled. I should
00:31:16 led with private jet, because he actually seemed to want to answer that one, because he believes
00:31:20 the technicality of, I don't personally own a private jet, is exonerating enough for him.
00:31:25 But nevertheless, that is what happened today on the streets of Davos. Now, it wasn't all heavy.
00:31:32 It wasn't all heavy. I will point out that there's a bit of an oddity in Davos, and that it's just
00:31:37 like a big major conference in a lot of ways. You just see people walking around. Today, it was a
00:31:42 weird one because we saw the Queen of the Belgians. I believe, is it Marguerite? Margret? I forget her
00:31:48 name. I apologize to the Belgians. Belgians probably don't tune in, but we saw the Queen of 1.00
00:31:52 the Belgians and I was like, oh wow, that's the Queen of the Belgians. I didn't have any questions
00:31:55 for her. I'd already spoken to the Prime Minister. And then like five minutes later, I wish that I
00:32:00 had thought of a question because the King of the Belgians came. So I guess they were traveling in
00:32:04 separate motorcades. So we had two monarchs, two princesses also. We got Princess Beatrice
00:32:09 and Princess Eugenie of York, who were passing by today.
00:32:14 I have no grievances with either of their royal highnesses.
00:32:19 I'm not particularly fond of their father, Prince Andrew,
00:32:22 but I don't believe that daughters should pay for the sins of the father.
00:32:25 So I thought I'd have like a softball for her royal highness, Princess Beatrice,
00:32:29 when she walked by, but she seemed to have to work way too hard 0.75
00:32:32 to come up with an answer to this one.
00:32:36 Minus, any message to Canadians?
00:32:37 uh oh gosh so many wonderful things good
00:32:42 oh at least she was lovely she had a she had a lovely accent and by the way if you saw uh sean
00:32:51 thompson my producer on the show a couple of weeks back uh you'll know that his hair uh is
00:32:56 like identical in color to princess beatrice's hair uh but his is a lot smoother but she has
00:33:01 a nicer accent so it's a tough one if her royal highness needs a new gig we uh we might be able
00:33:06 to just like do a ginger swap every couple of days.
00:33:08 It's like a work study program or something,
00:33:10 but the Royals, you know, they're real people just like us.
00:33:13 All right, well, in any case, that does it for today here.
00:33:16 I will bid you adieu, but we will be back tomorrow
00:33:19 and hopefully have some more hard-hitting questions,
00:33:22 maybe some non-answers, maybe some answers
00:33:24 from those assembled in Davos
00:33:27 for the World Economic Forum annual meeting.
00:33:29 But again, a big thank you to all of your support
00:33:30 and encouragement as we brave the cold
00:33:33 and try to at least have some truth to power here.
00:33:36 It is important work and I'm honored to be doing it.
00:33:39 We'll talk to you tomorrow.
00:33:40 Thank you, God bless, and good day to you all.
00:33:43 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:33:45 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.
00:34:03 We'll be right back.
00:34:33 We'll be right back.