Juno News - November 05, 2018


Do oaths matter to Jagmeet Singh?

Hosted by
Mentioned
HIGHLIGHTS: Trudeau's Immigration Minister on CBC bullying MacLeod Five Brits arrested for making "vile" social media video

Episode Stats


Length

2 minutes

Words per minute

145.02

Word count

392

Sentence count

18


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Jagmeet Singh says he doesn't think Canada should continue to have a relationship with the monarchy. Andrew Lutton explains why this is a stunning statement in Canadian politics, and why it runs counter to the oath of allegiance to Queen Elizabeth II.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 NDP leader Jagmeet Singh has made what is actually a stunning declaration in Canadian politics
00:00:06 that he does not believe the monarchy is relevant.
00:00:10 He says he's a Republican and while it isn't at the top of his priority list,
00:00:14 he doesn't think Canada should continue to have a relationship with the monarchy.
00:00:19 Now his belief that Her Majesty is irrelevant is actually quite ironic
00:00:24 because I think that Mr. Singh himself is fairly irrelevant in the Canadian political discussion.
00:00:30 But the challenge that I have with this is that his belief in the monarchy not having a place in Canada
00:00:36 didn't seem to stand in the way of him taking an oath of allegiance to the monarchy
00:00:40 when he became an MPP in Ontario, a member of the provincial parliament.
00:00:46 And should he be successful in seeking a federal seat in the House of Commons,
00:00:49 he will once again have to pledge allegiance to Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth II, the Queen of Canada.
00:00:56 Now this is not to say that having a belief that the system itself in Canada should change
00:01:01 runs contrary to that oath of allegiance.
00:01:03 Although arguably trying to change the system might actually run contrary to that
00:01:09 because you're proving that you're actually not having an allegiance to Her Majesty the Queen
00:01:13 and the system that she represents.
00:01:15 But I find it interesting that he seems to be like so many people willing to make an oath
00:01:21 just because it's what you do and not actually because of a genuine sense of belief for it.
00:01:28 And that's a challenge in Canadian politics.
00:01:30 It's a challenge in politics in general.
00:01:32 Politicians who say something despite believing something completely different.
00:01:37 But in the case here we're talking about the tradition on which Canada exists in the first place
00:01:42 which is us a constitutional monarchy.
00:01:45 And the fact remains that that tradition in Canada is immensely important.
00:01:49 And it's one that has all the checks and balances necessary
00:01:52 and also allows our tradition to maintain.
00:01:55 And for someone to lead a political party
00:01:57 but have such a fundamental disrespect for the traditions that really make Canada what it is
00:02:03 I would say to them that they are the irrelevant one, not the Queen.
00:02:08 For the True North Initiative, I'm Andrew Lutton.
00:02:12 For the True North Initiative, I'm Andrew Lutton.