Juno News - March 25, 2024


Election date change might make dozens more MPs eligible for pensions

Topics
Mentioned
Why Canada shouldn’t turn its back on Israel Liberals have spent $42 million on gun "buyback" without getting a single gun

Episode Stats


Length

48 minutes

Words per minute

173.87

Word count

8,396

Sentence count

305

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of The Andrew Lawton Show, Andrew takes a look at the growing protests against the federal government's carbon tax increase, and the people who are standing up against it. He also looks at a piece by Lawrence Martin, who is the Globe and Mail's Public Affairs columnist.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show
00:01:15 this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true north
00:01:19 hello and welcome to you all happy monday to you happy day after palm sunday for those who
00:01:30 observe welcome to another edition of canada's most irreverent talk show here on true north it
00:01:36 is monday march 25th just after one o'clock eastern and i won't go through the whole time
00:01:41 zone uh rigmarole but i hope you know where it is wherever you are if not you should probably
00:01:46 seek help, but do it after the show. Enjoy the next 45 minutes or so first. I want to talk a
00:01:52 little bit later on about not the great carbon tax revolt per se. We spent a lot of time last
00:01:57 week and the week before that on that subject, but I do want to speak a little bit about
00:02:02 how the federal government is still not exactly owning up to how long it's going to continue to
00:02:09 increase the carbon tax. We know it's going to keep going up until 2030. This weekend,
00:02:13 the Environment Minister Stephen Gilboa did an interview and he said, oh, the government hasn't
00:02:17 really decided beyond that. Now, I realize there's a lot of optimism in that on the part of the
00:02:22 Liberals that they think they'll be in power in 2030, when at this point, they don't even know
00:02:26 if they'll be in power in 2026. But this is a bit of an interesting dilemma in that on one hand,
00:02:33 we have a government that is so ideologically committed, so hellbent on the carbon tax,
00:02:39 It doesn't even quite know how long it wants to continue to ramp that up.
00:02:43 The most imminent increase is the one coming into effect on April 1st.
00:02:47 And I was seeing on Twitter, or X as they call it now, on social media this morning,
00:02:52 there are a lot of these rallies that are being planned across the country in places like Lloydminster, Alberta, Saskatchewan.
00:02:58 I don't know which side of the border it's on.
00:03:00 In Ottawa, in Cochrane, in a town in Ontario, Pickering.
00:03:05 I like Pickering. It's a nice place, but I've never known it to be the hotbed of any particular protest.
00:03:11 So all over the country, people are going to be demonstrating on April 1st.
00:03:14 Now, of course, by this time, it is too little too late.
00:03:17 The increase will be in effect.
00:03:19 The government has been unflinching and unrepentant so far, but it will show the growing dismay.
00:03:24 So we will talk about that later on in the program here.
00:03:30 But let me just first off talk about the elites saying the quiet part out loud.
00:03:35 Now, I've been talking on this show for, I don't know, probably years, but certainly for the last few weeks about Bill C-63.
00:03:41 This is the Liberal government's so-called online harms bill, a piece of legislation that the Liberals have just decided to believe is the panacea for online discourse.
00:03:57 Now, the problem is that they're trying to rein in and curb online discussion.
00:04:02 They're doing this under the guise of what we would call speech they don't like.
00:04:09 Speech they don't like is really what they're trying to avoid.
00:04:12 But they have to come up with all of these ways to deal with that, to make that justifiable.
00:04:17 And what they do is they say it is, oh, what do we call it?
00:04:21 It's hate speech.
00:04:22 Oh, it's a speech that is hateful.
00:04:24 Well, they are the ones who get to decide what hate is.
00:04:26 And I have lamented that in the past when this issue has arisen, you had this stable of people
00:04:34 that was a, I would say, an unflinching defender of free speech. People that weren't just
00:04:41 ideologically conservatives. You had principled liberals that, like Jerry Grafstein, the former
00:04:46 liberal senator, was an absolute firebrand when it came to defending free speech. People like
00:04:52 norm mcdonald at cbc no not norm mcdonald neil mcdonald norm mcdonald's brother i prefer norm
00:04:57 mcdonald to neil mcdonald for many many many reasons and i'm sad that norm mcdonald is no
00:05:02 longer with us but no neil mcdonald at cbc used to be quite critical of censorship but all of
00:05:08 these people at a certain point just shut up and they decided to go along with it they decided to
00:05:13 go along with the state's censorious impulses and what i want to share with you today is a piece
00:05:19 that I came across in the Globe and Mail,
00:05:22 a column by Lawrence Martin,
00:05:24 who is the Globe and Mail's public affairs columnist.
00:05:28 You can see the headline there,
00:05:29 excessive free speech is a breeding ground for more Trumps.
00:05:35 Now, sometimes, here's a little secret of journalism and media.
00:05:39 The writers generally do not write their own headlines.
00:05:42 Certainly at newspapers, the writers don't write their headlines.
00:05:45 So if you ever come across a sensationalist headline
00:05:47 that doesn't quite match what's in the story.
00:05:50 That's why.
00:05:50 It's a headline written by an editor
00:05:52 that didn't actually read the story.
00:05:53 But this one, the headline really does match
00:05:56 the substance of the column.
00:05:58 He talks about all of these cases
00:06:00 where there have been battles
00:06:02 between different state governments
00:06:03 and social media and all of that
00:06:05 before he gets to the real point.
00:06:07 That there is a tsunami of free expression
00:06:11 that he links to the arrival of the internet
00:06:14 and social media platforms.
00:06:17 He says, despite the grumblings we still hear about the lack of free speech,
00:06:21 these platforms gave more of it to the masses than anything ever before.
00:06:25 He says, printing presses, radio, television, they were controlled by elites.
00:06:30 You had regulatory bodies like the CRTC in Canada.
00:06:33 But basically, people can say whatever they want online.
00:06:36 They can talk.
00:06:36 We have a tsunami of free speech.
00:06:39 And here's where he starts talking about the view he holds of the little people.
00:06:43 the masses were were finally weaponized not with arms but with a communications instrument that
00:06:52 empowered them against establishment forces like they had never been empowered before he says oh
00:06:57 what a wonderful democratic advance it was but well there's always a but with these folks but
00:07:03 it came with a rather massive irony free speech became as much a slayer of democracy as an enabler
00:07:10 He says unchecked free speech means there's raw sewage in the public square, misinformation, disinformation, propaganda, polarization, child pornography, threats, bigotry, conspiracy, claptrap.
00:07:21 That's effectively a direct quote.
00:07:23 And he says Trump's rise wouldn't have been possible without the Internet.
00:07:29 So ultimately, his argument here is that we can't have free speech because it yields a political outcome that he dislikes.
00:07:38 In fact, what he calls for very explicitly to reverse this trend is rigid regulation.
00:07:45 But he says, oh, the free speech lobby in the United States is as fierce as the gun lobby.
00:07:49 So Lawrence Martin believes that we need rigid regulation of speech.
00:07:53 And how terrible it is that you have a free speech lobby.
00:07:57 Again, someone committed to upholding the fundamental right to speak your mind
00:08:02 is just part of some evil, scary lobby group like the NRA.
00:08:06 That's the comparison he draws.
00:08:07 so because you might use your free speech in a way that he disagrees with free speech itself is
00:08:14 the problem now this is the ivory tower mentality that is being embraced and adopted increasingly
00:08:20 by the elites who are invested very heavily in your censorship because again just talk about
00:08:25 saying the quiet part out loud it's because we have twitter because i have this podcast because
00:08:30 you have the ability to engage with content as you so choose that people like lawrence martin are
00:08:35 increasingly irrelevant to people, that his voice in the Globe and Mail is no longer the forced,
00:08:43 it no longer has the forced relevance because it's just one of a small handful of voices that
00:08:48 people can access in the establishment media. So when people like that talk about being threatened
00:08:54 by free speech, you should very much pay attention to them because they're talking about this
00:08:58 because they do not want to have free speech for their own selfish reasons. They want to be
00:09:04 the gatekeepers on opinion. They want to be the arbiters of what you can and can't say,
00:09:09 what you can and can't think. And heaven forbid the plebs enjoy free speech. They might vote for 1.00
00:09:14 Donald Trump or, oh, maybe Pierre Paulyev or, oh, maybe they might oust Emmanuel Macron and
00:09:19 I mean, who cares? The point of free speech is that you have just as much a right to push back
00:09:25 against that. Free speech gave Joe Biden the ability to campaign against Donald Trump. Free
00:09:30 speech is what's giving Justin Trudeau the ability to defend his record. When people talk about free
00:09:35 speech as being the problem, what they're actually saying is that they don't believe their arguments
00:09:40 will win. They don't believe that when push comes to shove, their free speech will be as effective
00:09:45 as their opponent's free speech because on a certain level, they know they are wrong. So you
00:09:51 can take your censorship and you can shove it. And if you can find room wherever you shoved it,
00:09:55 you can put that copy of the Globe and Mail up there as well. My goodness. We are going to talk
00:10:01 about this, I'm sure, in more detail as the defenders of Bill C-63 come out of the woodwork.
00:10:07 But I do want to talk about MP pensions for a little bit here because this has been an incredible,
00:10:13 incredible display of brazenness. So we have in Canada, you may not realize it because we've had
00:10:18 a string of minority governments, but in Canada, we have a fixed election date and it's fixed in
00:10:24 statute. It's supposed to happen every four years. Now, obviously, the government can dissolve
00:10:30 Parliament at any point as it sees fit, and we can have an election. Opposition members of Parliament
00:10:35 could, of course, go to band together and take down the government with a motion of non-confidence.
00:10:40 The Conservatives tried to do that last week, but as predicted, it was defeated when the Bloc,
00:10:45 NDP, and Liberals all maintained their confidence in the government. But all things being equal,
00:10:50 if there's no non-confidence motion, there's no snap election by the Liberals, we have a fixed
00:10:55 election date, which means that we know it's coming, and our fixed election date right now
00:11:00 is on the books for October 2025. Now, I didn't give a specific date there because this is subject
00:11:08 to change. Currently, the law says the election will be October 20th, 2025, but the Liberals are
00:11:15 tabling an amendment to this that will push that date to October 27th. It will push it back seven
00:11:21 days. And you may think, okay, what's the big deal? I don't even know what I'm doing for dinner
00:11:25 tonight, let alone what I'm doing in October of 2025. Well, why it matters is you have to look
00:11:32 at the motivation. Why is the liberal government changing this? Well, the liberals say, and it's
00:11:37 not untrue, by the way, that October 20th is the date of Diwali. Now, Diwali is the Hindu festival
00:11:44 of lights. It's a very popular and very big celebration in the Hindu community, a large
00:11:49 enough group in Canada. Having this election on that holiday would be disruptive. We move elections
00:11:54 around for Jewish holidays and Christian holidays. So that in and of itself is not inherently
00:11:59 unbelievable, but they could move it a week earlier. They could move it two weeks earlier.
00:12:05 They chose to move it a week later. Now something happens between October 20th, 2025
00:12:12 and October 27th, 2025.
00:12:15 Something happens in that span of seven days.
00:12:19 And what you may ask, well, that's a fantastic question.
00:12:22 What happens is dozens more MPs become eligible
00:12:25 for their gold-plated taxpayer-funded pensions.
00:12:30 Ah, yes, now it starts to become clear.
00:12:33 Well, no offense to the Hindus in our audience,
00:12:35 no offense to observers of Diwali,
00:12:37 but I suspect your holiday has been less of an incentive
00:12:41 for MPs to delay the election by one week than this little detail about pensions has been.
00:12:49 And this is where we get into, I mean, what's the old Shakespearean line?
00:12:52 Aye, there's the rub.
00:12:53 Well, right here you have, and Canadian Taxpayers Federation and National Post both crunch the
00:12:58 numbers on this, you have to, to be eligible for your MP pension, have six years of pensionable
00:13:04 service.
00:13:06 Now, I was actually a little bit confused by this, and I spent much of my morning pouring
00:13:10 over legislation so uh you'll forgive me if i have a glazed over look in my eyes i haven't like ripped
00:13:16 the glaze off from reading legislation for it's not from donuts it's from reading legislation
00:13:20 but what happened is we saw that you needed six years of pensionable service now i didn't actually
00:13:27 know how they calculated that because mps are elected on election day but they're often not
00:13:32 sworn in for several weeks after that maybe even more than a month does pensionable service begin
00:13:38 when you are elected or when you are sworn in i would have assumed when you're sworn in because
00:13:44 that is when your work begins and similarly when parliament dissolves you cease to be a member of
00:13:50 parliament so do you stop amassing pensionable service time when parliament's dissolved or on
00:13:56 the election date if you lose now as it happens it goes from election to election so even though
00:14:04 you're not even serving as a member of parliament for a good chunk of either end of that you're
00:14:10 actually amassing pension credit in that time period which means that yes six years the amount
00:14:17 of time it takes to qualify your for your pension six years is actually a threshold that dozens of
00:14:22 mps will cross between october 20th 2025 and october 27th 2025. now the mps we're talking
00:14:30 about are the ones who were elected in the 2019 election now the elephant in the room here most
00:14:36 of those mps were conservatives because this was the election in which the liberals which had a
00:14:41 majority government from 2011 or from 2015 to 2019 were knocked down to a minority the conservatives
00:14:48 elected a couple of dozen more mps the liberals elected some new ones as well the bloc quebecois
00:14:54 the ndp there were lots of new faces conservatives have most of this but not all of it and why this
00:15:01 is relevant is because you have here i think in a lot of the cases mps that look the conservatives
00:15:06 aren't the ones changing the legislation the conservatives are the ones uh that are just
00:15:11 there the liberals are the ones steering this ship but you have liberals that are motivated
00:15:15 uh perhaps by realizing that they're not going to get much pushback from mps that are retiring
00:15:21 are going to lose i mean right now all the polling is showing the conservatives are on track to win a
00:15:27 super majority which means that liberals ndp and block mps all stand to lose a little bit in the
00:15:35 next election so the mps that were first elected in 2019 are getting very nervous right now they
00:15:40 don't want to lose their pensions and you better believe i think they care more about that than
00:15:44 they care about diwali chris sims is the alberta director for the canadian taxpayers federation and
00:15:50 joins me on the line now look chris cdf has always been sounding the alarm about mp pensions these
00:15:56 things are absolute sweetheart deals mps get a better pension than pretty much anyone in the
00:16:04 private sector in this country yes but the more insidious part is how you know that they make
00:16:10 decisions based on eligibility like i i know people make the criticism and no one can prove
00:16:16 what's in someone's mind but i'm convinced that jagmeet singh is motivated by his own pension
00:16:20 eligibility in terms of keeping the government alive yeah exactly uh we don't want to you know
00:16:26 dance around this uh we put out the news release uh franco terrazzano and his team there in ottawa
00:16:31 did an immense amount of work calculating these potential pensions and again this is the upper
00:16:36 limit right it's the parameter that if all of them lost their seats which is highly unlikely
00:16:42 this is how much the taxpayers would be on the hook for. So that's the mathematical part.
00:16:47 But we have to notice the forest along with the trees here. And of course,
00:16:51 this would play into somebody's decision whether or not they want to, say, continue to support the
00:16:56 Trudeau government. If they're going to be lined up for a big pension in just a few more days,
00:17:01 why not just hang in there? There are very few members of parliament who've been able to withstand
00:17:08 that temptation credit where it's due uh the former prime minister stephen harper took a big
00:17:13 hit on his personal pension i can't remember how much money it was but it was big time like seven
00:17:19 figures something like that over his lifetime for his pension so there are some members of parliament
00:17:25 who do walk the talk and they are in it for pension reform but they're pretty few and far
00:17:31 between yeah and i'll give those numbers you just alluded to that franco crunched here is there are
00:17:36 80 members of parliament who will become eligible in that week who will become eligible on October
00:17:43 21st 2025 80 of them now of those I think it's about 30 or 33 that were conservative so
00:17:49 most of them very few conservatives are saying they're not running again a handful are so most
00:17:55 of them given these polling numbers are probably going to be staying around but even if you look
00:18:00 at the 50 of liberals that aren't running again or will lose NDPers who aren't running again or
00:18:05 will lose, Bloc Québécois. These are all folks that will amass collectively tens of millions of
00:18:11 dollars just by moving that election one week. Yeah, exactly. And imagine that temptation. And
00:18:17 so again, folks need to remember that quite a member of parliament will start getting a pension
00:18:23 once they reach a certain age. And then you just do the basic calculation from there. You decide,
00:18:28 you know, how long are they going to live past then? Sorry to be grim, but that's what we have
00:18:32 to do with mathematics and calculations. It's not personal. You know, are they going to live
00:18:35 to 80, 85, 90? And then you go through all the different numbers of MPs and that's how you do
00:18:41 this math. And so I think that's why it's really important that Franco put out this piece this
00:18:44 morning. So yes, we understand the politics and the chess match that is happening right now,
00:18:49 but we also understand the math and the cost to taxpayers behind it. I think I just saw before
00:18:55 we jumped on here, did the opposition leader, Pierre Polyev, call this bluff and say that,
00:19:01 no, let's move it up even earlier. So we don't run in to the religious ceremony and festival,
00:19:07 but you're still not hitting the pension date. I think I saw that.
00:19:12 Yeah, I guess I'm just a little bit, well, take a step back. How do you think that plays out?
00:19:19 Have to see, right? So this is it. So, okay. Taking off my CTF hat a little bit here.
00:19:25 I was on Parliament Hill working there through a couple of different political blowups,
00:19:30 you'd call it. So I remember when suddenly the Canadian Alliance, a lot of people within the
00:19:36 Canadian Alliance lost faith in their leader Stockwell Day. And a lot of party stalwarts
00:19:41 got up and left. And they went and sat by themselves. I remember when Belinda Stronach,
00:19:47 who actually ran for party leader, it's not like she was just some random no-name backbencher,
00:19:51 when she dramatically crossed the floor. We all got to see Peter McKay with his dog in his
00:19:56 potato field. Like politics sometimes isn't boring. My point of all of this is, is before that
00:20:02 happened, everything seemed fine. So on the surface, the duck is cool and calm and collected,
00:20:08 but underneath the surface, they're just going like this. And so everything's fine until it
00:20:14 suddenly isn't. And so the same way that we saw the carbon tax vote, getting all of those members
00:20:19 of parliament on the record, yay or nay, are you for or against the carbon tax increase?
00:20:24 that was pressure. And I think if I can just put on my hat a little bit here, I think that's what
00:20:30 they're doing with this. He's calling a bluff. It's kind of a gangster move. And he's going to
00:20:35 try to get everybody on the record whether or not they want to move the vote day. And so again,
00:20:40 that's more pressure that's increasing on this hull. And so I think that's why they're doing
00:20:45 that. Yeah. And again, I gave my little civics one. Candace Malcolm always calls me the in-house
00:20:51 political scientists because i just have a tendency to take all of these like salacious
00:20:54 political topics and just frame them in the most boring technical terms possible but i've said at
00:20:59 any time there could be an election so we're not bound by this but that supply and confidence
00:21:04 agreement with the ndp and the liberals has been pretty ironclad so far i mean justin trudeau i'm
00:21:10 convinced and you and i have spoken about this before that he's a burn it all down on the way
00:21:14 out kind of prime minister i actually don't think he cares about his mp's pensions i think that he
00:21:19 wants to just pick the moment that's going to be best for him. And if it costs a few dozen liberal
00:21:25 MPs their pensions, so be it. I don't think he cares. But I do think it says a lot about the
00:21:30 entitlement mentality you see in the House of Commons and you see among MPs. And look, I'm not
00:21:36 going to say conservatives are immune. I mean, there were a lot of these fire-breathing reformers 0.90
00:21:41 that were elected in the 90s and then alliance candidates in 2001 that were big crusaders against
00:21:48 this sort of stuff, but then benefited from it the second they were in the door.
00:21:51 They sure did. And a lot of them were part of a majority government. And we didn't see a lot
00:21:57 of dramatic reform. Again, credit where it's due, we did see some. Some folks are pretty sticklers
00:22:03 to their principles. And so we did see some, but no, this has got nothing to do with the color of
00:22:07 the jersey. This has got everything to do with power and money. And in this case, those who are
00:22:14 currently holding on to power are in line for an awful lot of money for the rest of their lives,
00:22:21 if only they move this little election date up just a little bit further. And so we'd be naive,
00:22:27 we'd be silly to think that this does not play a role here. You mentioned Prime Minister Trudeau
00:22:33 in this sense, and this is where I wanted to bring it back to political activism and peaceful
00:22:39 grassroots activism. I was describing all the pressure these MPs are under, and we're seeing
00:22:43 that with polls right we're seeing that with these votes another element for real is the pressure
00:22:49 they're getting from constituents and it's not just coming from taxpayers federation writers
00:22:53 but a lot of it is if they keep getting this pressure from their constituents right so their
00:22:58 their middle bencher and backbencher mp if they're getting a call from mary and joseph and sahil from
00:23:05 their from their constituencies saying hey man i can barely afford this i can't pay my hydro bill
00:23:12 I can't fill up my minivan and take my kids to school.
00:23:14 I'm voting against you unless you smarten up.
00:23:18 That really rings bells with these MPs.
00:23:21 And what I'm hearing, some scuttlebutt from Parliament Hill, is that apparently, I don't know if this is true, apparently the Prime Minister is tuning out of his caucus more than he has before.
00:23:35 And this has been a pretty late development.
00:23:37 and regardless of political party once a leader starts doing that and tuning out the people who
00:23:44 are part of his team if that's happening things start getting bumpy and so this is again why i
00:23:51 would encourage people and i would say the same thing if it was another party that was screwing
00:23:54 you over on your taxes and trying to take your money um this is why it's important to keep up
00:23:59 the pressure right now right now continue yeah and we we had heard something to that effect when
00:24:06 And the Liberals had their caucus retreat in London, which I only know of through other reporting, because as we perhaps recall, I was banned from covering it, even though it was, you know, like five minutes from my house or whatever.
00:24:16 Were you kicked out of the city? Or were you allowed to stay in?
00:24:19 No, I was allowed to maintain my residency in London. They didn't go full like G20 on me and like shit me out. 0.87
00:24:25 They didn't give me the old David Menzies and drive me out to the outskirts and dump me in a parking lot or anything. 0.97
00:24:30 But they did say, you know, you're not welcome here and that's fine. 1.00
00:24:33 Well, it's not fine, but I'm just moving on to what I wanted to say here, which was that we heard that Liberal MPs were quite frustrated with the status quo in their party.
00:24:44 And again, how they have been so silent.
00:24:47 I mean, hurting Conservatives is very, very, very difficult.
00:24:51 I mean, Stephen Harper was probably the best at it, and even he had a lot of trouble with caucus members that were just a little bit rambunctious.
00:24:58 Hurting Liberal, they are a conformist people.
00:25:01 They fall in line.
00:25:02 He has kept that caucus tight. There has only really been one criticism of him that is by someone who's still in that caucus, and that was a no-name Quebec MP. Others, like the second there's a bit of dissent, they're out the door. Jody, Jane Philpott, Jody Wilson-Raybould, Selena Cesar Chavans, and as a result, everyone else just shuts up.
00:25:22 Yes. Until recently. And until the carbon tax, which is again why I think this pressure is so important. And I keep coming back to it. I know we're geeking out here politically speaking. But the fact that the Atlantic caucus of the Liberal Party said, hey, Trudeau, we're not going to be paying this carbon tax here, boy.
00:25:43 like all of our constituents are really mad at us who we've been hearing at it hearing about it over
00:25:48 the summer and again i have family there i lived there okay i know the culture all of those little
00:25:53 gatherings over the summer they they still call them box socials i'm not kidding and the picnics
00:25:59 and all that stuff they would have been hearing from a lot of their hardcore liberal party
00:26:04 supporters in atlantic canada and they got an earful and they turned around and gave prime
00:26:09 Minister Trudeau an earful. And magic, he carves out a carbon tax exemption for their primary home
00:26:17 heating fuel, which of course is oil. So for him to blink on that showed that there is a division
00:26:23 within that caucus, that he will cave to pressure, and he had to admit that the carbon tax is a
00:26:30 financial burden to people. So that was a major move. And the fact that the environment minister,
00:26:35 Stephen Guilbeau was not at that meeting, I think that's the crack in the armor. So I would
00:26:41 encourage everybody just go at that and put pressure on that fissure. We have a super chat
00:26:47 from Marco here. He says, why is everybody against the liberals? They made my house the best asset I
00:26:52 have. Yes. You're one of those wealthy homeowners just because of inflation and all of that stuff.
00:26:59 You mentioned Stephen Guilbeau, Chris. Let me play this clip of, well, let's just let the clip
00:27:04 speak for itself here. The plan rather that your government laid out post-2019, the 2019 election
00:27:11 got us to 2030 and the targets that you've set out to 2030 and that is when the price on carbon
00:27:16 will reach $170 a ton. Do you intend for that price to continue to go up since you do see this
00:27:23 as such an integral part of your climate policy beyond 2030 to help Canada reach its 2050 target?
00:27:28 So we haven't made a decision on that. We've started consultation to prepare the next phase of emission reduction, so post-2030 in Canada, in fact, going to 2035. Those consultations are ongoing.
00:27:43 Canada will need to make a determination by next year, as per our United Nations commitment, to set those new targets for 2035. We will need to do that by next year, by 2025.
00:27:55 there's no decision that has been that has been made yet other than we will continue
00:27:59 increasing the price on pollution oh we don't yet know again a lot of things here that are
00:28:06 important to caveat such as are the liberals going to be in power in 2030 i don't know i mean
00:28:11 theoretically even if they lose in 2025 they could be back in in 2030 crazy things happen
00:28:15 i do love the profound uh irony here of him giving a lecture on global warming well he's like
00:28:22 puffed up like the blueberry girl in Willy Wonka. Like he's like, basically he's on the verge of
00:28:27 just taking off off the ground. He's so puffy while talking about how we need to tax more
00:28:31 because it's so warm outside. Yeah. It's late March and you're a basically jiggly puff there
00:28:36 with your big giant parka. But, uh, nevertheless, what do you make of that? I mean, literally this
00:28:42 is an infinite carbon tax and an infinitely increasing carbon tax to Steven. Yeah. I was
00:28:46 noticing his downfilled, likely downfilled parka there too. It looks pretty chilly. I would bring
00:28:52 us back to the former environment minister. So Catherine McKenna famously before an election
00:28:58 said they had no plans to increase their carbon tax past $30 a ton. Remember that? Feels like it
00:29:05 should be like with old timey music and like sepia tone, right? And then magic, as soon as
00:29:11 election was over up it went and they announced it to a hundred and seventy dollars a ton so folks
00:29:17 regardless of political party again i hate to break this to people but i think i need to because
00:29:23 we're getting some feedback of oh well look at the rebates look at the rebates you're richer for it
00:29:27 politicians sometimes don't tell the truth they do this so often that we have a mascot for them
00:29:34 that looks a lot like that italian fable of the wooden boy who couldn't tell the truth and his
00:29:39 nose kept growing so they do this and so for him to say oh well we'll have to wait and see
00:29:45 yeah wait and see so i think in this case you just need to look back at his previous work history
00:29:52 and his current behavior as environment minister and will they continue to increase the price the
00:29:57 carbon tax or the price on carbon or whatever they want to call it you know is water wet of course
00:30:04 they will. Of course they will. The only thing that would stop them, I think, is a strong rebuke
00:30:10 from their own constituents. Again, we would have to crack through that fissure of influence, I
00:30:16 think, and get through to those members of parliament and get those members of parliament
00:30:20 to convince their prime minister to change his ways on this. To say, hey, people are broke. They
00:30:26 can't afford anything anymore. We have to, you know, call a spade a spade and do a full retreat
00:30:31 on this. I'm always an optimist. I actually think that that risk is not zero. I do think
00:30:38 that politicians do change their mind when they realize their own job is on the line.
00:30:42 This could happen because the NDP in British Columbia used to rail against the carbon tax
00:30:47 and now they love it that they're in government. The NDP here in Alberta imposed a carbon tax
00:30:53 in Albertans without warning and now most of their political candidates. Oh yeah, they're all
00:30:58 scrambling to see who can oppose it the most yeah right so just you know if you don't like the
00:31:02 politics wait five minutes right so i do still think that there's a chance of that but we need
00:31:07 to keep that clip because we need to remember what gibo said there in the future all right and
00:31:13 if you are missing any feathers from your duvet uh check stephen gilbo's jacket uh all right
00:31:19 chris simms alberta director for the canadian taxpayers federation always a pleasure we well
00:31:24 we won't see you next monday because it's easter monday but we'll we'll make it up somehow
00:31:27 Thanks so much.
00:31:28 Have a happy Easter.
00:31:29 Bye-bye.
00:31:29 All right.
00:31:30 And to yourself as well.
00:31:32 This, yeah, I'm not making fun.
00:31:35 Well, I guess I'm sort of making fun.
00:31:36 Yeah, no, I'm making fun of the coat.
00:31:37 Okay, never mind.
00:31:38 He looks very warm.
00:31:39 That's all I'm saying.
00:31:40 And I don't think it's climate change
00:31:41 that is letting him feel that warm.
00:31:43 I think it's the jacket because he's standing out
00:31:46 in the Alberta cold in late March
00:31:48 or the Quebec cold in late March.
00:31:50 I actually don't know where he is.
00:31:51 I don't care anymore either.
00:31:52 But all right, we will shift gears here.
00:31:54 there was a bit of a development on the Freedom Convoy legal front last week. Now, I've been
00:32:00 speaking on this show periodically about the seemingly never-ending trial of Tamara Leach
00:32:06 and Chris Barber. They went on trial supposedly for 13 days in September, but it is now the end
00:32:12 of March and their trial is still underway, although it's not every day. It's on and off.
00:32:18 They'll do a couple days at a time and whatnot. But it is easy to forget that there are other
00:32:23 cases that have a lot less publicity around them, but are still stemming from those same three
00:32:30 weeks in Ottawa. Now, one of those came to a bit of an end, at least to some extent last week. It
00:32:35 was the trial of Jason Vanderweer, Jay Vanderweer as he goes by. He was one of the participants in
00:32:42 the Freedom Convoy protest. Now, one of his contributions, and I only learned this after
00:32:47 the fact but let's put up the cover of my book on the convoy uh so this is the freedom convoy the
00:32:54 inside story of three weeks that shook the world pardon the shameless plug but the you can see
00:32:58 there's a shed on the back of that one truck there that shed was actually a rather a pivotal role
00:33:05 uh in the convoy it was a multimedia studio it was live streaming it was doing all of that
00:33:11 and uh there there's a connection between that shed and the man i wanted to speak about in this
00:33:15 particular segment now uh david anbert joins me he is a criminal lawyer very prominent uh commentator
00:33:21 on twitter as well and he was the legal representative of mr vander weir uh david
00:33:28 it's good to talk to you thanks for coming on today thanks for having me andrew uh now now i
00:33:33 should just say i actually testified in this trial just by way of disclosure and my testimony was
00:33:39 effectively my own experiences and things that i saw as a journalist covering this but but let me
00:33:45 ask you what happened last week what was the judge's finding here so after the trial you
00:33:51 testified you were i think on day two of what was ultimately a four-day trial um there were
00:33:57 different sort of pieces to the puzzle that came together uh different uh testimony about the
00:34:03 beginning the middle the end of the convoy and ultimately uh we made arguments that a mischief
00:34:10 had not been made out uh certainly jason's participation in a mischief had not been made out
00:34:17 and even if it had been made out in the alternative we argued that there were two sections of the
00:34:22 criminal code uh that permitted either one to act with color of right or one to act in the course
00:34:31 of delivering a message and i i argued that the evidence certainly established that that's what
00:34:38 what the convoyers were engaged in doing.
00:34:42 The judge rejected all four of our arguments
00:34:44 and ultimately found the Crown had proven
00:34:46 beyond a reasonable doubt that there was a mischief,
00:34:49 that Jason was involved in it to the requisite level
00:34:55 of attracting criminal guilt,
00:34:56 and he did not find that there was color of right
00:34:59 or that the other section applied.
00:35:02 So he found Jason guilty.
00:35:04 And now the case, I mean, it's, you said brought to a conclusion.
00:35:09 It still has one more step is because he has now been found guilty, regardless of what you think about that, the court has found him guilty.
00:35:16 And as a result, there will be a sentence that's going to be imposed.
00:35:20 He will, of course, have the chance to appeal.
00:35:23 And that's something that he is looking into doing.
00:35:26 What is this?
00:35:27 I mean, mischief was something that a lot of people who are not criminal lawyers had really first heard in the context of the convoy.
00:35:34 i know it's not a new charge but what actually is mischief in a criminal sense and how does that
00:35:39 apply to the freedom con where we've heard it come up both in uh jason's case and also the cases of
00:35:44 tamara leach and chris barber and others right um okay so mischief we most commonly see it in
00:35:50 criminal law involving the destruction of property you know if you get an argument with someone um
00:35:56 and let's say they i don't know they film they want to record you on their phone and you don't
00:35:59 like that's you grab the phone from their hand and smash it into the ground that could be mischief or
00:36:04 punching a hole in the wall could be considered mischief but if you go in and read the section
00:36:09 there are other ways in which a mischief can be committed and one of the well-established ones is
00:36:15 by interfering with the lawful enjoyment of property and i think that was the angle that
00:36:22 the crown came at this from uh that they actually had two counts that basically slightly different
00:36:28 with slightly different wordings said the same thing one said that it basically interfered with
00:36:33 the lawful enjoyment of the property wellington parliament hill uh the downtown area and that
00:36:40 also interfered with the citizens of ottawa's lawful enjoyment of the property and so i mean
00:36:47 he was found guilty of both but because they're so closely related he can only be sentenced on
00:36:53 one of them effectively the conduct that leads to one inextricably leads to the other and so
00:36:59 he's only going to get sentenced on one of those counts on which he was found guilty and so what
00:37:04 what is meant by interfering with the lawful enjoyment is that it was the crown's theory
00:37:10 that people could not enjoy the public property uh downtown ottawa that roads could not be
00:37:18 traveled that good night sleeps could not be had because of the constant honking um that
00:37:27 there was the inability to uh to access certain roads uh and what's interesting about this trial
00:37:35 compared to maybe some of the more high profile trials like you talked about the tamara leach
00:37:40 trial is the crown actually led very little evidence in this particular case in fact it
00:37:46 led so little evidence a judge even said that it wasn't for the evidence both of the defense but i
00:37:53 mean we would we wouldn't have called that evidence if they also didn't have some in their case and
00:37:58 the judge also pointed the fact that mr van weir had posted videos on social media himself if it
00:38:04 wasn't for that evidence there would have been there would have been really no evidence of what
00:38:09 the actual mischief was um i mean again like the defense had to call the evidence because the crown
00:38:16 would have and did call the evidence of that jason had posted and so without any response the
00:38:23 conviction would have almost been been certain at least on this judge's analysis of of the law
00:38:28 and so we argued that they didn't really prove they didn't really prove uh the mischief and in
00:38:37 fact one thing that was actually interesting was you may recall there was a video montage that i
00:38:43 I put to you about some misinformation that went on during the convoy to such an extent that
00:38:53 numerous members of parliament and the NDP and the Liberal Party kept talking about this arson
00:38:58 case, arson, kept repeating this lie that the convoys had been involved in arson. I put that
00:39:05 to you, and there was actually a point where the judge intervened, and we had to address this in
00:39:11 your absence where the judge was suggesting to me that I was essentially you know putting up a
00:39:17 straw man that no one was suggesting that anyone was engaged in arson but my response to the judge
00:39:23 was that one of the reasons we're trying to put this forward is that the crown in other cases has
00:39:29 asked the court to take judicial notice to accept without hearing evidence certain facts such as
00:39:36 the fact that Ottawa was occupied or Ottawa was the subject of this large-scale mischief where
00:39:43 people couldn't get to their homes or couldn't sleep at night without even hearing evidence of
00:39:47 people saying those things. And I explained to the judge that whenever, if the Crown were to approach
00:39:53 him, approach the court and ask the court to take judicial notice, or even if the Crown wanted to
00:39:59 ask the court just to draw inferences about the convoy, that the court should be very guarded to
00:40:04 do so because of the prevalence of misinformation that's what that evidence sought to establish
00:40:10 and i thought that that was clear to the judge um one comment he made which is going to be
00:40:15 interesting to look at if this matter goes to appeal is that in response in response to one
00:40:20 of my arguments the judge made the comment that said you'd have to be living under a rock
00:40:26 to not be aware of the intrusion that this caused and that's exactly what judicial notice is
00:40:34 that we don't necessarily have to hear evidence of it that everybody knows that this is what
00:40:38 happens and that that's the type of of finding that the court shouldn't have been able to make
00:40:44 and so certainly that's something we're going to look at when deciding whether or not to appeal
00:40:50 just to jump in on that point david because one of the problems here is that you do have in a lot of
00:40:55 these cases that i i've seen come up a case where crown is putting the convoy itself on trial right
00:41:02 and applying that to the person who happens to be the defendant and and it it really happens
00:41:07 irrespective of the individual defendant's conduct and it sounds like that was really
00:41:10 what was happening here as well well to a certain degree that is a an effective and an appropriate
00:41:16 strategy of the crown and to a certain degree that was our strategy to combat it i mean the
00:41:22 crown would need if the crown wants to go that route they have to establish that the convoy
00:41:26 itself constituted a mischief and also that the person on trial participated in some way that they
00:41:35 just weren't simply observing it happen in front of them, but they were in some way acting either
00:41:40 as a principal actor in that convoy or as a participant or as a aider or a better of the
00:41:47 convoy as a party to that. And so we actually liked framing it like that because if we could
00:41:55 establish either of those two had failed to be done, that would have resulted in an acquittal.
00:42:02 So our primary line of focus is to argue, look, the Crown is not established beyond a reasonable
00:42:07 doubt, certainly not in the evidence in this trial, that there was a mischief. And to whatever
00:42:13 extent that there was, the convoy was there to deliver a message. And so under subsection seven
00:42:22 of the mischief provision. You can't find someone guilty of that. And then even if that was
00:42:27 established, they had to establish that Jason participated. And I think the judge was able to
00:42:32 make that leap in the sense that they found him to be a fairly involved participant in the convoy.
00:42:39 So let me just ask you moving forward here, not just in this case, but in general,
00:42:44 now that a judge has found that someone who was involved in the convoy had committed mischief,
00:42:50 that's the finding as it stands right now can that seep into other cases when crown is making
00:42:57 similar arguments for example the tamara leach and chris barber trial which is already underway
00:43:02 can they use this ruling to kind of help make that case against them that oh a judge has already
00:43:06 found the convoy was a mischief in theory it shouldn't i mean and the main reason why is that
00:43:12 um every criminal trial is a trial on its own evidence other than when a court takes judicial
00:43:18 notice like just to just to reiterate that point you know a court can take judicial notice that
00:43:23 water freezes at at zero degrees without having to call a scientist into court to testify in every
00:43:29 case where that's where that's a situation there is a place for that process you're saying pardon
00:43:35 me there's a place for that process of taking judicial notice right i'm saying there are ways
00:43:40 in which judicial notice can be taken i mean judicial notice can be taken of the fact that
00:43:44 that Wellington is located north of the Queensway and that Metcalfe Street runs north-south. I mean,
00:43:52 these are things where everybody does in fact know this. There's no controversy. Any resources
00:43:59 like maps or anything like that would confirm that. And so where there's no dispute, courts can
00:44:04 find that. But to answer your question, on the extent of whether or not something is a mischief,
00:44:11 the court needs to adjudicate it on the record that's before it on the evidence that's before it
00:44:16 and and so i think that it would be inappropriate for a court to um to find that because one court
00:44:25 found it to be a mischief another court could do that as well all right well uh sorry about the
00:44:30 loss but i know you're looking at your options and let's hope that uh we have some sanity prevailing
00:44:35 here david anberg criminal lawyer in ottawa and not a simpsons character as for quite a while his
00:44:40 uh twitter uh profile photo made it seem david good to talk to you thanks thanks thanks for
00:44:44 having me and also thanks again for your testimony in the in the trial it was it was quite well
00:44:49 received well always happy to talk about things i i saw and observed there so appreciate that very
00:44:54 much david and we will uh end things in a moment but just since we're talking about the post covet
00:45:00 era here i'd be remiss to not talk about this i've never seen the show yellowstone i see the ads for
00:45:05 it i think it's on amazon prime or something and i think kevin cost and i was gonna say kevin space
00:45:09 he's not in anything now kevin costner i think is in it uh but there's another guy who's in it who
00:45:14 is uh let's see uh my my show notes here i don't even have the name of the guy um how do how do we
00:45:20 have this story on oh there we go forrey j smith and apparently his name forrey j smith he uh well
00:45:26 let's just hear what he has to say for himself like i just got kicked off a plane in uh where
00:45:33 the hell am i at houston texas because i asked told them that i didn't feel comfortable sitting
00:45:44 next to somebody with a mask on yeah i've been drinking i've been sitting in the airport for
00:45:51 three hours yeah i'm drinking i ain't drunk but they throw me off the plane because i'm drunk
00:45:57 because you people won't stand up and tell everybody what this is i just told them i
00:46:07 didn't feel comfortable about sitting next to somebody that had to wear a mask and i'm off the
00:46:14 plane uh i never heard of the guy but i don't even so i don't even know if he's any good on
00:46:22 Yellowstone, but I like him for that alone. His best performance is his post-plane ejection
00:46:27 confessional about not feeling comfortable sitting beside someone wearing a mask. All right,
00:46:32 a little bit of lighter fare for you as we end the day here. We will be back tomorrow in just
00:46:37 23 hours and 15 minutes here on Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show. Thank you, God bless,
00:46:43 and good day to you all. Thanks for listening to The Andrew Vaughn Show.
00:46:47 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.
00:47:17 We'll be right back.
00:47:47 We'll be right back.