Juno News - December 13, 2022


Elon Musk needs to stand up to Trudeau's internet censorship

Topics
Mentioned
Canada is finally decoupling from China Poilievre and Trudeau spar over hunting rifles, crime, immigration and corruption

Episode Stats


Length

39 minutes

Words per minute

181.41

Word count

7,174

Sentence count

266

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

3

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show, host Andrew Lawton is joined by Dan Kelly of the Canadian Federation of Independent Business (CFIB) to talk about the Muskification of the social media platform, the by-election in Mississauga, Ontario, and much more.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:00:05 This is the Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:00:13 Hello and welcome to you all.
00:00:16 This is Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show here on True North.
00:00:19 Tuesday December 13th 2022 just after 4 p.m eastern standard time 5 30 in Newfoundland and
00:00:30 Labrador 1 o'clock in British Columbia and I'll let you sort out all of the times in between there
00:00:37 if time zone bingo is your bag it's great to have you aboard the program today as we near the holiday
00:00:44 season I mean I guess we're already in the holiday season but we near like the very thick of the
00:00:49 holiday season which I don't think is too insensitive to point out although it is less
00:00:54 than two weeks until Christmas so some of you may be listening in your ear pods or your car
00:01:00 as you go about your day with the Christmas shopping I hope it's going well and you are
00:01:04 surviving the mall chaos which I had to endure just the other day I went into a mall which I
00:01:10 don't think I had done since perhaps last year probably around this time last year yeah because
00:01:16 I don't even think I returned anything, and I certainly didn't do any Boxing Day shopping.
00:01:19 So it was probably like exactly a year ago that I did my last foray into the mall,
00:01:25 and I found it so unpleasant I didn't do it until just the other day.
00:01:28 But I survived.
00:01:29 I got through, and I made it through the line to see Santa Claus.
00:01:33 I sat on his lap, and unfortunately, he is in for a five-year wait for knee surgery
00:01:38 in the province of Ontario.
00:01:39 But you know what?
00:01:40 We got a good photo out of it.
00:01:41 So I don't know.
00:01:42 Why am I talking about Santa Claus's knee?
00:01:44 There are big things happening here. The muskification of Twitter continues. We'll talk about that in just a few moments. Also, a little bit about the Mississauga Lakeshore by-election last night. But before you hit the snooze button, I am assuring you that it is not, in fact, the case that the sky is falling, which is what the mainstream media would like you to believe as far as Pierre Polyev's leadership fortunes. 0.96
00:02:08 and also payroll taxes as a new year is upon us they're going to be getting a little bit worse
00:02:14 but the canadian federation of independent business is calling for a freeze on that which
00:02:19 they say would save canadians about 300 a year so we'll talk about that with dan kelly of the cfib
00:02:26 in just about i think 10 minutes or so dan will be on but let's start to start off by talking
00:02:31 about the muskification of twitter which is about the only verb i can think of to describe it here
00:02:37 And a thought that came across my mind as I was scrolling through my timeline, and I'm following Elon Musk, which all of you should if you're Twitter users, because you tend to get a sense of what's happening on the platform long before the mainstream media eventually writes a story based on what Elon Musk has tweeted.
00:02:53 so you can get it from the source directly and i'm kind of of the mind that donald trump
00:02:59 has now passed the torch at least in theory to elon musk as far as being the guy on twitter that
00:03:06 you have to follow because he's the one whose tweets everyone is talking about or soon will
00:03:12 but elon musk has done something tremendous here he has been a disruptor on a platform that very
00:03:19 much had succumbed to that big tech Silicon Valley groupthink that we see from Facebook and
00:03:25 that we see from Google or Alphabet as it's now called. And he has gotten in there and not only
00:03:31 has he taken over this platform and given it a very free speech focused mandate, but he has
00:03:38 decided that he is going to be unafraid of holding up a mirror and showcasing exactly what it was
00:03:45 that happened behind the scenes to make Twitter what it was up until the point at which he took
00:03:50 it over. And there have been some tremendous dumps of documents here that Elon Musk has orchestrated
00:03:57 through a number of independent-minded journalists such as Matt Taibbi and Barry Weiss and Michael
00:04:04 Schellenberger. And I don't know Michael Schellenberger I don't know if I'd call him a
00:04:07 journalist but certainly a prolific Twitter user and influencer as much as I hate that term. And
00:04:14 these documents show us a lot of what we've kind of known was happening but they give us more in
00:04:21 the sense of a concrete roadmap of what happened as far as the shadow banning of conservative
00:04:26 accounts the banning of donald trump's twitter account the suppression of conservative thought
00:04:32 online and all of these things which again people sort of suspected were happening but we didn't
00:04:38 have the receipts as they say but the twitter files have given us those receipts and the
00:04:44 suppression of the hunter biden laptop story by the way which again we've absolutely known was a
00:04:50 big part of what twitter was doing to try to help the democrats effectively but we now know exactly
00:04:57 what went on behind that and there were some small unnamed forces behind the scenes that were pushing
00:05:03 back against some of this, but by and large, people fell in line. And the banning of Donald
00:05:08 Trump, very same idea. Some people said, well, hang on, I'm not exactly convinced about that.
00:05:13 One person in the documents published by Barry Weiss was saying, yeah, you know what, I come from
00:05:18 China, so censorship is not exactly something that I would enter into lightly. And the Twitter
00:05:24 safety team, or whatever it's called, did an assessment of Donald Trump's tweets and found
00:05:28 there was actually no violation, or vios as they call them, of their safety policies.
00:05:35 But Twitter decided after employees were pushing for it because they were triggered
00:05:40 and Donald Trump violated their safe space that they should ban Donald Trump in general.
00:05:45 And this was something that Twitter did in spite of an internal finding
00:05:49 that Donald Trump hadn't broken the Twitter rules.
00:05:54 And dictators from other countries, Ayatollah Khomeini,
00:05:57 their Twitter accounts all stayed. Donald Trump was the one that got permanently suspended on
00:06:02 Twitter. And it was only after Elon Musk took over the company that Donald Trump was unsuspended or
00:06:08 unbanned, although he has not tweeted since that happened. He's preferring to communicate on
00:06:13 Truth Social, which is the platform that he himself has started. Now, I would like to see
00:06:18 him come back to Twitter just for the entertainment value alone. And to kind of just push like the
00:06:22 last vestiges of the annoying triggered set off of Twitter because they won't really be able
00:06:27 to tolerate him being there all that well but I want to talk about this in a Canadian context here
00:06:33 because we have not seen any Canadian analog to the Twitter files just yet and to be fair we haven't
00:06:40 seen any big picture bans or suspensions apart from some of the ones that we've already gotten
00:06:45 some information about like the feminist writer Megan Murphy who has now been unbanned from Twitter
00:06:51 as part of the muskification thereof but a lot of Canadian conservative accounts I suspect were
00:06:57 also victims of this very same dynamic that was going after American accounts and Twitter
00:07:03 infamously said that shadow banning does not exist it was I think two years ago maybe three
00:07:09 years ago they said a lot of people are talking about shadow banning we do not do it well we saw
00:07:15 twitter evidence of the opposite we saw accounts that were tagged and we saw the screenshots of
00:07:21 this with do not amplify or exclude from searches or all of these other terms that show twitter was
00:07:28 making very deliberate decisions to limit the exposure of some accounts and curiously these
00:07:36 all tended to be conservative accounts dan bongino was one charlie kirk was another and so on so it
00:07:43 It wouldn't surprise me to know that I might have been on that list or Candace Malcolm might have been on that list, True North, Ezra Levant, a number of these people.
00:07:51 And as long as I know that it's not happening, I don't really care about what happened in the past.
00:07:56 And I think this is where people need to get very nervous about which levers of power, about our online identities we have given to people in a room in California that have an agenda that I think has been made abundantly clear right now.
00:08:14 And this was always the issue because I know some of you have been very annoyed by this, but I've always taken a very deliberately libertarian view on big tech.
00:08:22 I don't think it's the role of government to ensure that we have the constitutional right to free speech on Twitter or Facebook.
00:08:29 I think these are private companies.
00:08:31 I think people decide to use them.
00:08:33 And I think the companies have an obligation to, I think the companies have a moral obligation to be platforms for free speech, but not a legal obligation.
00:08:43 But at the very least, I think it's important that they be honest about what it is that they're doing.
00:08:48 and these companies are making billions of dollars off of user-generated content but they're
00:08:55 the ones deciding which content they think should be seen and which content shouldn't be seen and
00:09:00 the implications of this are vast especially when you're talking about democracy they can decide
00:09:05 which post by politicians get amplified which politician doesn't have a right to use the
00:09:10 platform and even if you think this is as i do legally sound you can think it is morally despicable
00:09:18 And I think that we all need to start talking about the moral value of free speech because
00:09:22 a society filled with people that don't fundamentally respect free speech is far worse in my view
00:09:27 or in a different sense bad than a society in which the government doesn't recognize
00:09:34 free speech.
00:09:34 Because if you have people that are yearning to be free and yearning to speak freely, there's
00:09:39 at least a force that will go up against the government.
00:09:42 A society in which people don't actually care about that freedom, government doesn't need
00:09:46 to censor because we all just censor ourselves and censor each other before the government needs
00:09:51 to get its hands dirty. And this brings me to the challenges that we have right now in Canada. And
00:09:59 Elon Musk is someone that perhaps doesn't care about Canadian public policy. I know he used to
00:10:05 be engaged to a Canadian singer, Grimes. He has a child that is therefore Canadian. I think he spent
00:10:11 like five minutes at Queen's University but he's not a Canadian so he may not actually care about
00:10:17 Canada. Canada represents a very small subset of Twitter's market because it is a country that is
00:10:23 very small in the world although his mother is Canadian I should point out. I don't know if he
00:10:28 has Canadian citizenship though I don't think he does but he may just as a matter of interest care
00:10:32 about Canada and I think he should because Canada is a country that is at least sharing the continent
00:10:38 with him and is integrated with the United States and can decide to make itself an enemy of social
00:10:45 media and social media free speech, which I think is going to be the case. And one of the reasons
00:10:50 this is so important is because the Trudeau government has been putting forward over the
00:10:55 last couple of years a package, a whole suite of bills that take aim at online free speech.
00:11:01 The one that everyone talks about is Bill C-11, which is the infamous internet regulation bill
00:11:07 that takes the CRTC approach to regulating TV and radio
00:11:11 and vastly expands it to the purview of online content.
00:11:16 And this bill is bad, and I've been tooth and nail fighting against it.
00:11:20 A lot of people have, but there are other bills as well
00:11:23 that the Liberals are putting forward that have gone under the radar.
00:11:26 One of them is, I think it's C-18,
00:11:29 which is the bill that the government will use
00:11:31 to force social media companies to pay news companies.
00:11:37 for the privilege of letting those news companies publish their content on social media.
00:11:42 It's a very convoluted bill.
00:11:44 So the Toronto Star voluntarily gets a Facebook page and a YouTube page
00:11:48 and posts links to their stuff on there.
00:11:50 And the government thinks that Facebook should have to pay the Toronto Star
00:11:54 for letting them use it to promote themselves.
00:11:57 And the rationale of this is that Facebook is making money off of Canadian news
00:12:01 that they should have to pay it back. 1.00
00:12:02 And it's a stupid bill. 0.98
00:12:04 It's what Australia tried to do, and Facebook had to acknowledge the fact that, listen, news content is a very insignificant part of what we do. 0.99
00:12:13 All of our users care more about cat gifs and memes than they do about your Heather Malick column, and I would rather see a million cat memes and gifs than a Heather Malick column.
00:12:23 In fact, if I never see a Heather Malick column until the day I die, it will be too soon. 0.71
00:12:27 but the thing is they're trying to basically integrate government regulation and big tech
00:12:35 and this is going to be an unholy alliance when you look at other things the government has tried
00:12:40 to do along this same vein one of the big ones is trying to make social media companies enforce
00:12:48 government's definition of hate speech and harmful speech now no one is going to get up and say well
00:12:55 well, actually, I like hate speech and, you know, by George, I think we need to defend hate speech.
00:12:59 But the problem always comes when you look at what the government's definition of it is.
00:13:04 And if the government censors you in some way, you have recourse, you have court, you have a way to fight that.
00:13:11 What if that censorship is happening because government has threatened social media companies with a penalty
00:13:17 if those social media companies don't censor your own content?
00:13:23 Well, then all of a sudden, Facebook or Twitter is making this decision about what you post.
00:13:28 They're doing it because of the government, but your issue is not with the government,
00:13:32 it's with them.
00:13:33 And you have this very murky territory here in which big tech companies have become the
00:13:38 government's enforcers based on a very itself murky definition of what you're allowed to say
00:13:46 online.
00:13:47 And the fact that more people aren't aware that this is happening and aware that the
00:13:51 government is pushing this the fact that more people aren't up in arms about that is i think
00:13:57 a tremendous shame there's been so much emphasis on bill c11 which don't get me wrong is a very
00:14:02 important bill and i think one that needs to be opposed but they're not talking about all these
00:14:07 other areas where government is trying to and i think largely succeeding at ingratiating itself
00:14:14 in just what happens on the internet and what these big tech companies do and you have to look
00:14:18 at all of these things in aggregate the government lowering the threshold for what hate speech is
00:14:23 the government doing all of this to then give itself the power to deputize social media companies
00:14:30 to enforce that definition and threatening them with fines if they don't and i think it's so
00:14:35 paramount to go back to the elon musk point that elon musk takes a stand against this i mean canada
00:14:42 may be a very insignificant player in the grand scheme of things and twitter i think shut down
00:14:47 its whole Canadian operation, which I think only had a handful of people. But the point is that
00:14:53 Canada is not a key market for Twitter. So this may not be on his radar. Canada Proud a few weeks
00:15:00 ago had actually tweeted Elon Musk and asked him if he was going to oppose Bill C-11, I think it
00:15:06 was. And he had said it was the first time he had heard of it. So I hope in that interceding time,
00:15:11 he has been informed of it by people on his team, or maybe Canada Proud has sent him the whole memo,
00:15:15 or maybe he's even been reading true north reports who knows but i think it's so important
00:15:20 that elon musk realizes if this commitment to free speech that he's espousing is something
00:15:25 he believes authentically and i believe it is i hope he looks at what the canadian government is
00:15:30 doing and what other governments around the world are also going to be doing the uk is doing its
00:15:36 own version of this and takes a stand against it and realizes that the only thing worse than
00:15:41 government censorship or big tech censorship is this weird hybrid where it's government empowered
00:15:47 but big tech enforced censorship and we'll obviously talk more about that but it's a
00:15:52 tremendous opportunity for Elon Musk and it doesn't take away from the fight we have as Canadians on
00:15:57 our hands but I think it is important for these companies to say no we are not devoting our
00:16:02 resources to complying with this Canadian law and if the Canadian government wants to go up against
00:16:07 Twitter I think Twitter's GDP is probably greater than that of Canada not exactly but certainly
00:16:12 greater than that of some smaller countries we'll talk about this a little bit more in the future I
00:16:17 want to turn to some cost of living issues which are very much affecting Canadians we spoke about
00:16:22 inflation a fair bit last week and I know we'll have a bit of a more in-depth look at this in a
00:16:28 couple of weeks with Franco Terrazano of the Canadian Taxpayers Federation but I think one of
00:16:34 the big things that it's important to identify here is that for most Canadians who are grappling
00:16:40 with inflation, there isn't just one instant snap of the finger solution. There are a number of
00:16:47 inputs here. There's general inflation, supply chain issues. There are the increases to the
00:16:52 carbon tax. And one that doesn't often get discussed, but I think it's important here,
00:16:57 is the increases to payroll taxes, which if you're talking about thousands of dollars a year that
00:17:02 Canadians are spending more on groceries and taxes. A few hundred a year in payroll taxes is
00:17:08 quite significant. The Canadian Federation of Independent Business is calling on the federal
00:17:13 government to pause the planned increase of EI and CPP premiums, which will take about $305
00:17:22 away from the average Canadian worker next year. Dan Kelly, president of the CFIB, joins me now.
00:17:29 Dan, good to talk to you.
00:17:30 Thanks for coming on today.
00:17:32 Good to be here.
00:17:35 Do we have you there, Dan?
00:17:37 I can hear you.
00:17:38 Hope you can hear me.
00:17:39 Okay, perfect.
00:17:39 Sorry, we had a little bit of a technical issue there.
00:17:42 Let's talk about what this is first off.
00:17:45 These premiums go up every year, but we're also talking about a year that isn't exactly
00:17:50 business as usual economically for Canadian families.
00:17:54 No.
00:17:54 I mean, typically there is an increase in the maximum amount that we can pay CPP and EI on,
00:18:02 but the rate generally has not risen.
00:18:05 In fact, for two years, the federal government froze the employment insurance rates
00:18:09 because they recognized the economy was in rough shape.
00:18:11 Canadians were struggling through the pandemic, and so they kept those rates frozen.
00:18:15 Now they've removed that cap on EI,
00:18:18 and they're in the process of raising CPP rates significantly over a seven-year period.
00:18:23 Those two things combined are going to raise employees' payroll taxes by over 6% this year.
00:18:32 As you said, about a $305 increase, up to a $305 increase for the employee, $325 increase for the employer.
00:18:42 So your payroll on January 1 for most working Canadians will drop.
00:18:46 That's in the face of an environment where we're all dealing with the inflationary pressures on everything that we buy.
00:18:52 We're seeing EICPP premiums rise.
00:18:55 And then, as you noted, later in the spring, in most provinces, an increase in the carbon tax as well as an increase in liquor taxes.
00:19:04 Do you recall in the last couple of years when the government put this freeze in, when that decision was made?
00:19:11 What I mean by that, basically, is are we past that point where the government could easily do something about this?
00:19:16 look the government could could even now announce a freeze or retroactively take out the increase
00:19:24 there are ways to do that in fact in 2015 and 2016 the liberals just as they took power put
00:19:30 a two-year freeze on a two-year reduction plan for small businesses on their share of the ei bill
00:19:36 that could happen as soon as budget 2023 so it's not too late but you know we're a couple of weeks
00:19:43 away from January 1, and rates are expected to rise. They did increase them, the Liberals,
00:19:49 did increase EI, sorry, did increase Canada Pension Plan premiums in both COVID years,
00:19:55 in 2021 and 2022. They're doing it again this year, despite the fact we're all dealing with
00:20:01 wicked inflation levels. You know, when you take 300 bucks out of somebody's take-home income,
00:20:06 that's, you know, that's a round or two of groceries for many Canadian families at a time
00:20:12 when Canadians are really struggling.
00:20:14 The benefits for CPP, the future benefits,
00:20:17 that increase is going to be phased in over the next 40 years.
00:20:23 So putting a one-year pause in place, we don't think, is too tall in order.
00:20:27 Unfortunately, the government has ignored these calls and is moving ahead.
00:20:32 Now, if you're self-employed, you're getting hit on both ends of this, aren't you?
00:20:35 The employer and the employee side?
00:20:37 You're quite right.
00:20:38 You don't have to face EI premiums, but on Canada Pension Plan,
00:20:41 you pay the both the share as the employee and you pay the share as the employer on self-employment
00:20:47 income so you could have hundreds and hundreds of dollars of of increased canada pension plan
00:20:52 premiums and the self-employed really were huge losers out of covet for the business of course
00:20:58 this is adding additional pressure i mean you we talk about the inflationary pressures on average
00:21:03 canadians for business owners they're seeing that pressure on every line of their budget
00:21:08 And of course, with rising taxes, these payroll taxes, that obviously saps their ability to
00:21:15 provide raises for their employees to deal with the inflationary pressure that they're facing.
00:21:19 So it's a pretty vicious circle right now. I know that there's this vision that I don't even know
00:21:24 if it's an intentional one, but this approach of the business owner as being the miserly one that
00:21:29 doesn't want to give their employees benefits. And you know, any small business owner I've
00:21:33 ever spoken to would love to pay their employees a lot more, but sometimes they look at their
00:21:37 balance sheet and that money just isn't there. So when you're talking about, you know, a few
00:21:42 hundred dollars per employee, if you've got 10 employees, that $3,000 is not insignificant on
00:21:47 some small businesses, is it? It's not at all. And look, I mean, we have to also put the context
00:21:53 of what's happening right now. Sure, the COVID restrictions are behind us, but if you can
00:21:59 believe it, only half of small businesses say that they are back to 2019 levels of sales.
00:22:04 For many, they're not seeing customers return in the volume that they did pre-pandemic.
00:22:10 On top of that, just to get through the restrictions of the last two years,
00:22:13 the average small firm has taken on $110,000 in debt.
00:22:18 That's how much they now owe, exposed to higher interest rates that they're having to make good on.
00:22:25 And they're seeing these cost pressures.
00:22:27 So lower sales, more debt at higher interest rates, and huge cost increases.
00:22:32 This is not the boom times that people were predicting coming out of COVID that many of the articles were breathlessly talking about.
00:22:44 Sadly, for many small businesses, these remain pretty bleak times.
00:22:48 Small business optimism, if you can believe it, is actually fairly close to the low levels it was at the beginning of the pandemic.
00:22:56 That's how bad it is for small businesses.
00:22:58 And yet the federal government feels like this is a great time to jack up taxes.
00:23:01 is. Yeah, I mean, there's always been that divide that people have seen between the financial
00:23:07 economy and the real economy, between the picture of the economy that you might see looking at the
00:23:12 stock market, although not always, and what you see when you look on the ground. And again, a lot
00:23:17 of these, a lot of people have made billions in the pandemic, but for a lot of small business
00:23:22 owners, they haven't seen that. They haven't seen that, you know, incredible financial success story
00:23:26 that amazon has no well look restrictions really hit independent businesses particularly hard
00:23:33 especially in retail hospitality the service sector arts and entertainment travel and tourism
00:23:38 these were the sectors that were most directly affected by covet restrictions they took it on
00:23:42 the chin uh to try to get through yes there were government support programs in place but
00:23:48 our data shows that only about one-third of the cost to business was covered by covet subsidies
00:23:54 two-thirds was borne by the business itself. This is deeply unfair at this stage and business owners
00:24:00 are saying, look, give us a bit of a breather here before you start to return to raising taxes.
00:24:06 You add to that the carbon tax increase that we're expecting in April and for small businesses
00:24:12 that's especially deadly. Small firms don't qualify for any of the rebates that supposedly
00:24:17 are there for consumers. They basically are just payers of the carbon tax itself.
00:24:23 liquor tax increases affect hospitality and some in the retail sector. We need to make sure that
00:24:30 Canadians have dollars to spend in businesses. We're not doing a lot to help them. I know that
00:24:37 you have obviously called first and foremost for a freeze on these increases. Another idea is
00:24:43 putting forward a refundable tax credit, and you mentioned 2015-2016 on that. The freeze would be,
00:24:49 your view the ideal response correct yeah absolutely look if our first choice is to put
00:24:55 the brakes on the increase that is expected for january 1. uh i'm not optimistic that that's going
00:25:01 to happen only two weeks away from uh from the new year uh but but you know that would be the
00:25:06 the best course of action for the federal government to take but there are ways even after
00:25:11 that to to try to offset these costs even if they're not going to offset them for average
00:25:16 canadians trying to to remove some of the payroll burden on canadian employers would be helpful
00:25:21 and there are ways through through a mix of credits tax reductions in other ways that the
00:25:25 federal government can come to the aid of of small and medium-sized firms uh you know we've got we've
00:25:31 got all sorts of pressures right now and and we need to get a few of them taken off our our list
00:25:37 have you found that christia freeland the finance minister actually hears you out when
00:25:40 you've brought these concerns historically or do you find that the government is just
00:25:44 completely detached from the reality of what small business owners are facing well look i've been
00:25:50 doing this a long time uh and uh when the liberals took office uh there was no secret that uh that
00:25:56 the finance minister bill borneau did not listen one bit to the concerns of small business owners
00:26:02 and that's when the cpp increase plan was was first hatched uh it was negotiated and i will say
00:26:08 criticism of the federal government alone does not set cpp rates many provincial governments
00:26:14 including conservative provincial governments supported the increase in the canada pension
00:26:18 plan we're trying to convince some of those same governments to put pause of to press pause
00:26:23 when when when the deputy prime minister when christy friedland took the reins in finance she
00:26:28 did listen to many of our requests over the course of the pandemic some of the work that we did to
00:26:34 try to make sure that there were effective subsidy programs in place for small business
00:26:38 But that remains incomplete, and right now what businesses need is a little bit of relief.
00:26:43 There was in the fall economic statement a plan to reduce credit card processing fees.
00:26:48 That's good news.
00:26:50 I'm hoping to be speaking to her before the holidays in the next couple of days,
00:26:53 and we'll be putting this request to her once again to see if small firms can get at least some relief
00:27:00 from the massive pressures that Otto is imposing right now.
00:27:04 I wasn't going to go there, but since you mentioned credit card processing fees,
00:27:07 I don't know if a lot of consumers realize how disruptive those are to businesses.
00:27:13 Oh, gosh.
00:27:14 You know, the average consumer, of course, thinks that the credit card industry is funded through the annual fee that they might pay to get a premium card,
00:27:22 or is funded by the interest that they might pay if they carry a balance on their credit card.
00:27:27 What they don't know, for the most part, is that every time that card is swiped or chipped,
00:27:32 the merchant pays a fee somewhere in the range of one and a half to two and a half percent of the
00:27:37 sale for the courtesy of making that transaction happen. That's somewhere in the range of five to
00:27:42 ten billion dollars a year that Canadians pay that is embedded in the prices of everything
00:27:47 that we buy. So and those fees sadly in Canada are among the highest in the world. So it is good that
00:27:55 the government has talked about finding ways to lower the pressure of these fees on average
00:27:59 Canadians. We're working to make sure that that actually happens, putting some ideas forward
00:28:05 to government, to Visa, to MasterCard. But the pressures are there. The rewards that,
00:28:13 you know, your free trip to Florida that you may never get, that's funded by consumers that are
00:28:18 paying with cash, paying with debit. So it's actually in many ways a wealth transfer from
00:28:22 low-income Canadians that pay with cash and debit to wealthier Canadians that have one of
00:28:27 these premium credit cards. That's something that I think very few understand. Yeah, and I'm guilty
00:28:33 of it as well, because don't get me wrong, I've got credit cards that, you know, give me Aeroplan
00:28:36 points, and I use those things, but it's not coming out, like, you know it's not being conjured
00:28:42 out of thin air. Someone is paying for that. You got it. It's the merchant, ultimately, and then
00:28:48 that gets passed back to the consumer. So we think that a fair system would be to keep these fees low,
00:28:55 as is the case in many other countries in the world.
00:28:57 The reward schemes are still there,
00:28:59 but it's unfair that the merchant has to pay for the reward schemes,
00:29:04 the customer loyalty schemes that really do reward the banks
00:29:08 and the customers of the banks in the end.
00:29:11 That's not the way that this is supposed to work.
00:29:14 All right.
00:29:15 So here's, I guess, where we get down to the action item here.
00:29:17 We're looking at this increase going in January 1st,
00:29:21 and I think you mentioned earlier that technically there are options
00:29:24 after january 1st but this is really the crunch time if there's going to be a freeze most likely
00:29:29 on these increases in premiums correct you got it and we have a petition on our website right now
00:29:35 directed at the federal government and provinces uh to press pause on the ei and cpp premium
00:29:41 increases that are expected on that are planned for january 1st again i think you know one of my
00:29:46 observations about canadians is we actually don't mind paying higher taxes we actually don't mind
00:29:51 fees. We just don't want to know about it. And that's the problem with CPP and EI. Because it
00:29:57 comes off our paychecks, most people, it flies right under their radar. And then they realize
00:30:02 in January, hey, I'm a little bit poorer, not drawing the connection, sadly, between the policies
00:30:07 that the government's putting in place and their bottom line. All right. And yeah, certainly, I know
00:30:13 a lot of, I get a lot of emails from people who are self-employed. You'll certainly see both ends
00:30:17 of that as well. Dan Kelly, President of the Canadian Federation of Independent Business.
00:30:22 Thanks very much. And that petition is on the CFIB website. So have a good one, Dan. Merry
00:30:27 Christmas to you. To you too. Thanks so much. Thank you very much. I said earlier in the show,
00:30:32 I want to talk a little bit about Mississauga Lakeshore. And I assure you, if you do not live
00:30:38 in Mississauga Lakeshore, you're like, why on earth do we have to talk about a by-election in
00:30:41 a riding in which I do not live? And there is a good reason for it because by-elections tend to
00:30:46 be presented as though they have a national character to them and there's some reason why
00:30:52 this is probably accurate to some extent you saw in the course of the by-election MPs from all over
00:30:58 the country from as far away as BC and Alberta were knocking on doors in this riding in the
00:31:04 greater Toronto area for the Liberal or for the Conservative or for the NDP and the thing that
00:31:10 was happening here is that the media was trying to present this narrative as though this was going
00:31:16 to be the real test of Pierre Polyev's leadership. If the Conservatives failed to win in Mississauga
00:31:21 Lakeshore then Pierre Polyev was a failure as a leader and it's done and he's going to lose the
00:31:25 next election and I was never quite convinced of that and it was certainly his first electoral
00:31:31 test. I mean it's by definition the first election that has taken place since Pierre Polyev became
00:31:38 the Conservative leader but it's also a riding that has elected a Conservative member of Parliament
00:31:44 in recent history once and that was Stella Ambler in 2011 when the Conservatives had a national
00:31:52 majority and did very well in writings that they have only done well in in that same election that
00:31:59 very election in recent memory so I think expectations were low and the Conservatives
00:32:05 knew it and the Conservatives acted that way I think the Conservatives saw the writing was on
00:32:10 the wall. They knew they weren't going to win. They were up against a star liberal. Now, how on
00:32:15 earth the finance minister for Kathleen Wynne in Ontario is not in and of itself something that
00:32:22 makes you a pariah, I don't know. But he was a star candidate. And the Conservatives ran a guy
00:32:27 who, by all accounts, is a nice enough guy, a police officer named Ron Chinzer. But the fact
00:32:33 that I had to look down on my screen before I said Ron Chinzer, I think, is probably an example
00:32:37 of the fact that he didn't have the star power that Charles Sousa did, such as it is. And all of
00:32:44 that was, I think, why the Conservatives were like, we're just going to run and we're going to send
00:32:49 some MPs there to knock on doors. But Pierre Polyev was not knocking on doors. He wasn't
00:32:54 thumping his chest saying, this is our guy, we're going to win. He was getting attacked yesterday
00:32:58 for not having tweeted about the by-election. And then eventually in the afternoon, like got
00:33:03 around to tweeting that there was a by-election going on. He sent out a blast email to conservative
00:33:08 members or donors, I don't know which one it was, yesterday, fundraising for Peter McKay's
00:33:14 leadership debt. So I think it's safe to say that when Peter McKay's leadership debt is more of a
00:33:20 priority than the by-election that the conservatives don't actually care. Maybe Peter McKay should have
00:33:25 run for the by-election in Mississauga-Lakeshore and he could have lost the election and paid off
00:33:29 his leadership debt all in one fell swoop but the conservatives were not expecting to win now
00:33:35 i still think that there is a bit of a problem here if you look at the numbers this was a low
00:33:41 turnout election as by elections often are but charles souza won with 51 of the vote 51 of the
00:33:50 vote the conservatives should at least be in the wheelhouse but only got 37 of the vote the ndp
00:33:57 just completely collapsed. They were under 5%. The Green Party was an afterthought. The PPC got
00:34:03 1.2%, which is not at all anything to be proud about. So the only people that really showed up
00:34:09 were people that were saying, yeah, I guess I'm okay just voting for the Liberals. So the makeup
00:34:13 in the House of Commons stays the same as it was before Sven Spengerman resigned the seat to go
00:34:19 work at the UN, which is, I think, like the number one off-ramp for a Liberal member of Parliament
00:34:24 in Trudeau's government.
00:34:25 So does it mean anything?
00:34:27 I think it means something in the sense
00:34:30 of what the Conservatives need to do.
00:34:32 Because as Stephen Harper showed in 2011,
00:34:36 it is possible to win a majority without Quebec,
00:34:39 but you need to then have
00:34:41 the so-called Greater Toronto Area in your corner.
00:34:45 If you don't have the Greater Toronto Area,
00:34:46 you've got to get Quebec.
00:34:47 But this is just a basic numbers game.
00:34:50 You cannot win a majority government
00:34:51 without getting one or the other.
00:34:55 So what's your plan, Pierre Polyev?
00:34:57 If you want to be the guy that's going to command a conservative majority,
00:35:01 which is the only real way to have a conservative government at this point,
00:35:06 you've got to be able to show that you're at least in the ballpark.
00:35:09 And I do think the conservatives need to answer for why they didn't contest it.
00:35:13 Was it just to save face?
00:35:15 Did they not campaign aggressively because they didn't want it to be able to blow up?
00:35:19 And if he lost when Pierre Polyev had been really invested, that would have looked worse than losing when Pierre Polyev just forgot there was a by-election.
00:35:27 I don't know. I don't know what the strategy was.
00:35:29 Maybe it was just that they're all getting their ducks in a row and he's still just finding out where the furniture is going to go in his office on Parliament Hill.
00:35:37 But it's not exactly a ringing vote of confidence for conservatives that know that's the area where they need to do well.
00:35:47 So I'm not going to say that it is a failure in the sense of what Andrew Coyne and Robert
00:35:53 Benzie and all of these other mainstream media types are saying, but I am going to say that
00:35:58 it raises some questions, some questions that the Conservatives need to have answers for
00:36:02 because it is just a numbers game.
00:36:04 And you can talk about how Aaron O'Toole just completely hinged all of his ambitions
00:36:09 on the idea of winning Quebec and the GTA and didn't.
00:36:12 but he ultimately did better in this riding in 2021 than Pierre Polyev did in the by-election
00:36:18 and sure recognize the by-elections are different low voter turnout fine but if there was not enough
00:36:25 of an incentive for people to come out and vote for someone other than Trudeau's candidate
00:36:30 why was that what is it the conservatives need to do better to do well there and I mean the
00:36:36 liberals just think this is like a complete win across the board just take a look at this clip
00:36:41 from today in question period now i haven't actually seen the clip i've only seen a little
00:36:46 bit of a preview of it that was circulating in the transcript so we get to enjoy this together
00:36:52 but this is justin trudeau using the by-election win as like the trump card on criticism for his
00:36:59 minister violating ethics rules and confidence to bad ethics we have another liberal minister
00:37:07 found guilty of violating the Ethics Act, this time for giving a $23,000 contract
00:37:13 to one of her best friends at a company called Pomp and Circumstances.
00:37:19 It reminds us of the Prime Minister giving a half billion dollars to an organization
00:37:24 called the We Charity that gave his family a half million dollars.
00:37:28 So, Mr. Speaker, will this minister be held accountable,
00:37:30 and will she be required to pay back the $23,000 in improper contracting that she gave out?
00:37:37 Mr. Speaker, in this House there's a lot of debate and back and forth,
00:37:43 but every now and then there's an opportunity for Canadians to weigh in directly
00:37:47 on what's going on in federal politics.
00:37:49 And yesterday, the residents of Mississauga Lakeshore had a choice.
00:37:54 They could choose between the Conservative Party's politics of division
00:37:58 and reckless proposals that included recommending you opt out of inflation
00:38:02 by investing in crypto or our government's approach
00:38:06 of being there for Canadians every step of the way
00:38:08 and putting more money back in their pockets.
00:38:11 Well, Mr. Speaker, the people of Mississauga-Lakeshore
00:38:13 have spoken and elected a Liberal Member of Parliament.
00:38:17 Take on God of it.
00:38:25 Okay.
00:38:27 I just want to try to recapture or recap this for you.
00:38:32 Mr. Speaker, a liberal minister was paying her friend tens of thousands of dollars.
00:38:39 The Conflict of Interest and Ethics Commissioner has found this to be wrong.
00:38:43 How do you answer for this?
00:38:45 Well, how about those Mississauga Lakeshore results?
00:38:49 And that gets applause.
00:38:52 Okay, this is what we're doing.
00:38:55 So you win a by-election in Mississauga Lakeshore, and it actually doesn't matter if you break
00:38:59 federal ethics laws, which is good.
00:39:01 That must be the secret. 0.99
00:39:02 Justin Trudeau can have all the vacations with the Agacon he wants
00:39:06 as long as he keeps winning in Mississauga Lakeshore. 0.98
00:39:09 We've got to end things there.
00:39:11 My thanks to all of you for tuning in.
00:39:13 We will be back tomorrow with more of Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:39:17 Thank you, God bless, and good day to you all.
00:39:20 Thanks for listening to the Andrew Lawton Show.
00:39:22 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.
00:39:31 Amen.