Juno News - November 22, 2022


Emergencies Act Inquiry – Bill Blair testifies

Topics
Mentioned
CBC says crosswords are racist Liberal ministers joked about sending in tanks to break up Convoy

Episode Stats


Length

5 hours and 12 minutes

Words per minute

138.74

Word count

43,389

Sentence count

893

Harmful content

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, we hear from Bill Blair, Minister of Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness, and Minister of Emergency preparedness and Public Safety, Mario Mendocino. We also hear from the Prime Minister and Deputy Prime Minister.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 .
00:00:30 .
00:01:00 .
00:01:30 .
00:02:00 .
00:02:30 .
00:03:00 .
00:03:30 .
00:04:00 .
00:04:30 .
00:05:00 .
00:05:30 .
00:06:00 .
00:06:30 .
00:07:00 .
00:07:30 okay
00:07:56 okay
00:07:58 Now, just before we start, if I could just, I just want to make a brief statement that from now on for the balance of the week, we will be hearing from a number of senior government ministers, including the prime minister and the deputy prime minister.
00:08:21 um the commission recognizes that this is exceptional and even more so as the house
00:08:28 as i understand it is sitting so the latter fact the fact the house is sitting is such that
00:08:36 uh it may require some accommodation for these witnesses in the event of votes the house of
00:08:43 commons or events requiring that they respond to pressing needs so i just wanted to put that
00:08:50 on the record so for parties it's also important that in the course of these examinations we not
00:08:58 lose sight of the reason that they are here to testify that is the subject matter of this inquiry
00:09:06 the examinations therefore must remain focused on this particularly in light of the limited time we
00:09:15 have finally as I have insisted throughout I will continue to insist that the conduct of
00:09:24 the public and indeed to the parties be respect respectful at all times which I'm sure everyone
00:09:32 understands so i just wanted to to say that because it's it uh we're sort of entering another
00:09:39 phase for the balance okay so with that introduction uh commission council
00:09:55 thank you commissioner uh gordon cameron for commission council and the first uh witness in
00:10:02 in this category of ministers is Minister Bill Blair.
00:10:10 If you could take the stand and he will be sworn.
00:10:26 Minister Blair, will you swear on a religious document
00:10:29 or do you wish to affirm?
00:10:31 on a Bible, please.
00:10:49 For the record, please state your full name
00:10:50 and spell it out.
00:10:52 My name is William Blair, B-L-A-I-R.
00:10:56 Do you swear that the evidence to be given by you
00:10:58 to this commission shall be the truth,
00:11:00 whole truth and nothing but the truth so help you god thank you
00:11:21 good afternoon minister blair uh i'll begin just with some housekeeping some formalities
00:11:28 uh and in particular what i'm going to ask you to do is recall that you had an interview uh with
00:11:36 me and some of my colleagues on september 6th and uh for the record i'll note for parties that
00:11:43 the summary of that interview is wts seven zeros uh 48 um now minister blair if you had a chance
00:11:52 to review this witness summary that was prepared following your interview yes sir i have can you
00:11:57 confirm that it's accurate and that you adopted as part of your evidence before this proceeding
00:12:01 i can confirm that yes thank you now if we can just go through a little bit of background for
00:12:07 those who aren't already familiar with your uh role in the federal government recently and before
00:12:13 that um you were uh the minister of public safety from november 2019 to november to october 2021 is
00:12:23 that correct yes sir and in october of 2021 you were appointed and this is a long title
00:12:31 and it requires a bit of updating uh you were you were appointed as president of the queen's
00:12:36 privy council now uh you will be the president of the king's privy council i take it and also
00:12:42 uh as the minister of emergency preparedness is that right yes sir
00:12:47 um now in the prime minister's mandate letters that is the letters that the prime minister writes
00:12:54 for each of his ministers to describe what he expects from them during their tenure
00:13:01 uh the prime minister assigned leadership responsibilities uh regarding public safety
00:13:09 and emergency preparedness both to you uh minister blair uh and uh to minister mendocino
00:13:17 and so the question is can you help us understand how that division works under the umbrella of
00:13:27 the ministry of emergency preparedness and public safety yes sir as you noted earlier um i previously
00:13:35 held the position of minister of public safety and emergency preparedness quite frankly the
00:13:41 government recognized in in in the most recent past a significant increase in both the severity
00:13:46 complexity and frequency of national emergencies taking place in this country and so a decision
00:13:52 was made to bifurcate my my previous ministry um into the public safety which is a portfolio held
00:14:00 by my colleague and friend, Minister Mendicino, and Minister of Emergency Preparedness, which
00:14:05 is the portfolio that I am responsible for. Under that, I think there's a very clear delineation
00:14:10 of responsibilities, but there's a very close alignment between the work that I do and that
00:14:15 Minister Mendicino does. Mr. Mendicino is, for example, responsible under the Act for
00:14:20 five different, you know, significant agencies in the federal government, including the RCMP,
00:14:27 CVSA, CSIS, Corrections Canada, and the Parole Board.
00:14:31 And he also has a number of other significant responsibilities within his own mandate.
00:14:34 For myself, my responsibilities particularly pertain to ensuring that the government of Canada is prepared to respond effectively to all hazards and emergencies in this country,
00:14:47 to improve the way in which the government prepares and also creates greater resiliency in the country about these events.
00:14:54 Among the administrative processes I am also responsible for is I oversee requests for assistance that are received from the provinces and territories for assistance in the event of an emergency.
00:15:06 If I could just, if you could try and be a little slower for the interpreters because they have to translate everything you say and you have a tendency to have a high output.
00:15:17 Yes, sir. I'll certainly do my very best.
00:15:21 and and i would appreciate the occasional reminder that i think mr cameron's quite
00:15:25 prepared to provide um yeah the the scribes at the interview uh got lost after a few minutes
00:15:36 of the interview um now if if that that's a helpful description minister blair of the division
00:15:44 between uh the two uh parts of public safety and emergency preparedness here's a something that's
00:15:52 more challenging for all of us is if you can describe for us your role as president of the
00:15:58 king's privy council and how that uh what what role you play there i i'll remind you just as a
00:16:07 place to start that among other things you chair the sse committee the safety security and
00:16:13 emergencies committee but writ large can you describe that office and what responsibilities
00:16:18 come with it there are within federal legislation certain um federal agencies such as the transportation
00:16:24 safety board that is answers directly to the president of now the king's privy council but it
00:16:31 also is important to recognize the very the close collaboration that exists between my responsibilities
00:16:38 as the president of king's privy council and the work of of of of the of the privy council office
00:16:44 in within the federal government um it it requires in addition to my responsibilities in in sharing
00:16:51 for example the ssc committee the safety security and emergency committee a very close collaboration
00:16:57 with the privy council office i i have for example within pco a deputy secretary ms bogdan i believe
00:17:05 you've heard from who i work very closely with on on matters of emergency preparedness and with
00:17:10 respect to other um cabinet related issues i work very closely with the deputy clerk mr ann as well
00:17:18 right and something we'll come back to uh in a little bit of detail and a little later in this
00:17:26 examination one of the functions of of your office includes handling requests for assistance what
00:17:34 we've now learned to call rfas uh where somebody from a level of government lower than the federal
00:17:42 government asks for the assistance of the federal government in some particular sphere can you tell
00:17:46 us just broadly speaking how that works as we'll come to the one specific to the convoy in a minute
00:17:52 but just broadly how that process works yes sir um there is a provision within our government
00:17:58 for provinces and territories to make requests of our government for assistance for certain types
00:18:05 of emergencies the the criteria is reasonably well established um in the past two years i've
00:18:11 been responsible for um well since the beginning of the pandemic i've actually managed about 200
00:18:17 requests for assistance that the government has received from our provincial and territorial
00:18:21 partners these can take a number of different forms um it there were quite a number of them
00:18:25 related to um the pandemic in particular but also in the in the advent of floods and fires
00:18:33 the hurricanes that recently took place in atlantic canada all can result when when events
00:18:39 exceed the capacity of the provinces and territories to manage it the rfa process allows
00:18:45 them to reach out for assistance um and and and whatever we're able to provide it is my
00:18:52 responsibility to arrange that much of that work is done with other federal departments public
00:18:56 safety the department of national defense and others but to ensure that whatever federal
00:19:02 supports can be provided to the provinces and territories we do that as expeditiously as
00:19:06 possible and can you describe to me the level of of formality that that process follows
00:19:13 and it's probably not the same in every case but sometimes it's a phone call perhaps followed up
00:19:18 later by writing sometimes writing followed up later by a phone call but can you describe for
00:19:23 the commissioner just how the process tends to take place in the example of a typical flood or
00:19:30 hurricane in my experience sir and as i said we've done now a couple of hundred of these
00:19:34 senior officials usually begin talking very quickly even in anticipation of an emergency
00:19:40 for example if we know a hurricane is coming um or at the beginning of the wildfire season
00:19:45 communications begin to take place between senior officials in both either the province or territory
00:19:51 and our federal departments whichever is implicated most of that is managed through
00:19:55 the ministry of public safety um and and for example in my experience most of that work has
00:19:59 been done by deputy uh stewart who i think you've also heard from there's usually discussions that
00:20:05 take place between senior officials there is also a table of senior officials sometimes referred to
00:20:11 who is the senior officials responsible
00:20:13 for emergency management, Sorum,
00:20:15 who also engages in these types of discussions.
00:20:19 That's usually followed up very quickly
00:20:20 by a formal letter of request from the province
00:20:23 or territory that is directed
00:20:26 to the Ministry of Public Safety
00:20:27 and then on to me for determination.
00:20:31 But we tried to work as quickly as possible
00:20:33 in order to see whatever helps we can provide
00:20:37 in response to those requests.
00:20:39 then and then through again deputy steward our response to that request is prepared to which
00:20:45 i'm able to to then hopefully quickly respond so so if the hurricane's coming up the coast you
00:20:50 don't wait till the letter arrives before you start mobilizing of response to a request no and
00:20:56 in fact in our most recent experience with hurricane fiona's it was as it was moving to
00:21:01 atlantic canada we were receiving very good um forecasting from environment canada which gave
00:21:09 us a pretty good idea of where that hurricane was going to land and so there were conversations that
00:21:13 began days in advance so that we could be better prepared and mobilize and even stage resources in
00:21:19 order to respond to what we knew was going to be a significant impact on the on those regions of
00:21:25 the country and that we would be able to work closely together as quickly as possible there
00:21:30 are a number of other programs as well and for example i'm also responsible for what we refer
00:21:35 to as the humanitarian workforce where we work very closely with with ngos such as the canadian
00:21:40 red cross and and stage those resources and begin to register people well in in advance of the
00:21:46 hurricane in that case so that we can respond as quickly as possible in real time to help people
00:21:51 be safe and and i assume that if you do uh act immediately before the paperwork arrives
00:21:59 there will nonetheless be the requirement for the orderly administration and documentation
00:22:04 of the rfa that the paperwork eventually come through and then the request be properly documented
00:22:10 yes sir those those requests are are properly documented but we don't necessarily wait for the
00:22:15 paperwork sometimes in in there have been very limited circumstances where the paperwork arrive
00:22:20 first and then we start responding to that immediately but in the vast majority of cases
00:22:24 there's outreach from the province and territory who identify a situation that exceeds their
00:22:29 capacity where they where they seek our help and then we undertake immediately to see if we could
00:22:33 find that help within the federal government thank you now if you can describe uh
00:22:42 perhaps well certainly atypically relative to most other government departments
00:22:48 you are lodged so to speak in the privy council office and supported by by people uh
00:22:55 and also in the Privy Council Office.
00:22:58 And one of the people also there is the National Security Intelligence Advisor, Jody Thomas.
00:23:04 If you could describe for us how you, as Minister of Emergency Preparedness,
00:23:09 work with or relate with, interact with the National Security Intelligence Advisor.
00:23:15 Yes, the National Security Intelligence Advisor is actually a very important source of guidance, advice, and information
00:23:21 our preparation in order to respond appropriately to emergencies um i in a number of different
00:23:28 capacities including like that i chair the safety security emergency committee but even in our daily
00:23:34 and weekly interactions the national security intelligence advisor is a person who gathers
00:23:40 information from the national security intelligence establishment from law enforcement and from other
00:23:46 resources and provides it to government including to me to assist us in making sure that we're able
00:23:52 to do our duties in a timely way and be well informed of what government needs to know in
00:23:57 order to to keep people safe thank you now we've we've uh had as you probably know already
00:24:04 testifying among the senior government officials who who uh testified last week uh jack and
00:24:12 bogdan and jeff hutchinson uh maybe you could just remind us now that you're here uh where they fit
00:24:19 in the scheme of of your department of emergency preparedness yes sir when the government decided
00:24:26 when the prime minister decided that to place a special emphasis and create a unique ministry
00:24:31 dealing with emergency preparedness we recognized that in order to make that work we also had to
00:24:36 fundamentally change the way in which the public service through the privy council office organizes
00:24:41 itself in response to preparation for emergency and and so there there was decisions made within
00:24:48 pco by the clerk in order to create some additional positions within the privy council office
00:24:53 to to essentially create an office to to more formalize and i think to make more effective
00:25:01 the government's response to emergencies and and in our preparation in in a wide variety of a very
00:25:07 significant spectrum of activities including increased resilience investment in critical
00:25:11 infrastructure um and and in all hazards approach and it was also i think very important to make
00:25:17 connections one of the things i have found in my my responsibility sir and working with pco that
00:25:23 that emergencies are not uniquely located within any one ministry or department that is they're
00:25:29 very often implicate like a whole of government we learned that certainly in the floods for example
00:25:34 in british columbia where you know initially when i when i went to british columbia with
00:25:38 the prime minister to meet with the provincial government you know we looked at it as a an
00:25:42 emergency response to a flood but very quickly learned that agriculture transportation fisheries
00:25:47 and oceans natural resources environment canada of all of these different departments of government
00:25:53 were deeply implicated in that emergency and so one of my responsibilities working with pco and
00:25:58 and Ms. Bogdan, is in a convening role to bring all of the departments together
00:26:02 and bring senior officials to make sure that all of government
00:26:05 is responding appropriately as necessary to every emergency.
00:26:11 And so a decision was made.
00:26:12 Ms. Bogdan was brought in as the Deputy Secretary responsible for emergency management,
00:26:17 and she also has responsibility for the COVID response of the government.
00:26:22 She's also overseeing that.
00:26:24 And Mr. Hutchison was also brought in and serves in a number of different roles,
00:26:31 including he is secretary to the cabinet committee that I chair, the Safety, Security, and Emergencies Committee.
00:26:38 He's also acted as secretary in other duties that I've been assigned by the prime minister.
00:26:43 And, for example, I co-chaired with British Columbia, a committee with the British Columbia government
00:26:49 involving all the ministers and it's very significant representation from first nations
00:26:54 leadership in in coordinating all of government's response to to the to the floods and jeff acted as
00:27:00 the secretary for that committee as well okay and and a a third uh name that we're going to encounter
00:27:07 uh uh in some of the documents and that those who have been following will have will have seen
00:27:14 already zita astravis uh can you describe what her role is in your department yes zita is the chief
00:27:21 of staff for my ministry office i have within my ministry office people who are responsible
00:27:26 for policy development as it pertains to emergencies with with communications and media
00:27:31 relations and finally with operations because we engage with every region of the country
00:27:36 and and all the people that work in that office are overseen by my chief of staff zita astravis
00:27:43 she is a very serious and experienced political staffer within the ministry office and she
00:27:50 previously served as my chief of staff when i was the minister of public safety now um
00:28:00 again people who've been uh who've been following this proceeding or following the original events
00:28:06 we'll know that uh there's another part of your background that ended up assuming special
00:28:12 significance as these events unfolded in january and february and that was your first career as a
00:28:19 police officer and ultimately the chief of police of the toronto police service uh first of all can
00:28:24 you describe in broad strokes what that experience was and then i'll bring you back to the to the
00:28:30 particular public order experience that that you had in those roles yes mr cameron i joined the
00:28:37 toronto police service in 1976 i served as a toronto police officer for 39 years and from
00:28:43 for the last 10 years of that my 39 year career um from 2005 until until 2015 i was the chief of
00:28:51 police of the city of toronto um and in that capacity i served in a number of roles and that
00:28:58 were somewhat related to um the events that transpired right now as i understand it as you
00:29:07 were coming up the ranks uh you in fact served a term as an inspector of a public order unit itself
00:29:16 that is the actual unit that goes out and deals with public order uh incidents yes yes sir i was
00:29:23 public order trained and i served as a public order incident commander um for very very many
00:29:29 public order incidents in the city of toronto over a number of years okay now the one that that
00:29:35 often gets uh remembered because it was it was so newsworthy was the g20 uh event in toronto which
00:29:45 ended up being a public order event as well as its political event on its own.
00:29:53 And you played a role in that, but it would probably be helpful if you described what role
00:29:58 you played, what role you didn't play, and roughly how that, what you learned from that experience.
00:30:05 Yes, sir. The G20, it occurred in June of 2010 in the city of Toronto. It was a planned event.
00:30:15 I was, throughout that entire period of time, the chief of police, and therefore responsible for policing in my city.
00:30:21 But the event itself was actually headed up by an integrated command structure with a gold, silver, bronze command structure that was put in place,
00:30:31 the leadership of which was with the RCMP, but also it had representatives from my service, but also from some of the regional services around it and the OPP.
00:30:41 and they were actually responsible for the operational response to the g20 but throughout
00:30:48 that period i was the chief of police and therefore ultimately responsible for every
00:30:52 policing related matter taking place in my city right and as you mentioned uh probably in a
00:31:01 30-odd year career and especially ten as chief of police there were more than just the g20 event and
00:31:07 And the one other perhaps event or series of events that was memorable during that period when you were chief of police were the Tamil protests in Toronto.
00:31:19 And I mention them because you might find some similarities with some of the events that happened around Ottawa.
00:31:27 And if you could just tell us about those events and how they were resolved, at least as best as you can recollect it.
00:31:33 Yes, sir.
00:31:34 that took place in may of 2009 um it was a period in which there was a great deal of concern within
00:31:40 the tamil community and there's a very substantial tamil community in the greater toronto area
00:31:44 about events that were taking place in sri lanka at that particular time i mean as a consequence
00:31:50 a number of people came out onto the streets to begin to protest there were two frankly significant
00:31:55 and somewhat distinct um matters that i had to deal with as the chief of police during that event
00:32:00 On Mother's Day of 2009, about 5,000 people from the Tamil community were demonstrating and marching
00:32:08 and unfortunately went up on a ramp of the Gardner Expressway and ended up on the elevated highway that runs through downtown Toronto.
00:32:17 I was called because, of course, they had blocked the highway.
00:32:20 It wasn't a particularly serious traffic issue because it was Mother's Day, a Sunday evening and not too concerning.
00:32:27 But I heard from my operational commanders that evening that there were no safe ways to remove those people from the bridge.
00:32:35 There was a real concern because the guardrail really is for vehicles, not for pedestrians.
00:32:41 There were children and elderly people up on that elevated highway.
00:32:45 And there was a very sincere concern among my officers that any action that we might take to remove them from the bridge or even bring them down the ramp could result in a stampede,
00:32:54 crushing of people and would just be simply too dangerous and so i directed that we would slow
00:33:01 down that we would engage with the people that were on the bridge we would find people that we
00:33:07 could talk to on the bridge and that took a couple of hours and then eventually i engaged them in
00:33:12 some conversation i had a pretty good relationship with that community and found a way to have them
00:33:17 safely come down off that bridge. And it was, in my opinion, an entirely appropriate and safe
00:33:24 resolution of what could have potentially been a very dangerous situation. The other element to
00:33:29 this is tens of thousands of people initially converged on University Avenue in the area of
00:33:35 University of Armory, which is right near the 361, our superior courts in Toronto, but also right
00:33:41 opposite the u.s consulate and initially when they went there it was it was considered quite
00:33:47 disruptive it was noisy and it was interfering with traffic but very quickly we were able to
00:33:52 work with that crowd to allow the ttc for example to operate on both queen and dundas so that the
00:33:58 transit would continue to move those are pretty important transit routes in the city we also were
00:34:03 concerned about accessing egress for our hospitals on hospital row on university avenue we worked out
00:34:09 with them a way in which we could do that and and although that protest went on for several days
00:34:15 and there were concerns actually being expressed by the time i remember hearing from spirit court
00:34:20 judges about the noise outside the courtrooms um but but at the same time you know there was very
00:34:25 little residential in in that area um i would also want to acknowledge the people that were protesting
00:34:31 did so in a very respectful way they cleaned up after themselves you know they were on the street
00:34:35 they were very seriously concerned but but i think that was a situation that in toronto
00:34:40 we were able to resolve appropriately and safely um and and and eventually i i think it actually
00:34:46 strengthened our relationship very much with that community and and if i if i recollect accounts of
00:34:51 those events one of the things you were able to accomplish with that demonstration was was to move
00:34:57 it from uh an arguably illegal demonstration in the sense that it was blocking university avenue
00:35:04 to a location nearby where the demonstration could continue but not be obstructing traffic
00:35:10 and potentially breaking the law.
00:35:13 Yes, sir.
00:35:13 And actually, that was based on some experience that we'd had in that particular area as well.
00:35:17 I also remember in the late 90s, there were very significant demonstrations among two
00:35:21 other communities serving in Croatian at that same location, and we worked very closely
00:35:25 with those protesters to allow them to engage in their lawful peaceful protests, but do
00:35:31 in a way that minimized the disruption to traffic to the movement of people and to the functioning of
00:35:36 basically the city's daily life all around them and as an incident commander a public order
00:35:46 senior police officer how do you factor in that particular attempted transition that is you you
00:35:54 encounter a public order incident ideally you're able to keep it legal from beginning to end
00:36:00 But when it starts to transition into illegality, either because it's obstructing traffic or violating some other law, where in your ranking of objectives do you put turning what has become an unlawful protest into a lawful protest?
00:36:20 I think it's important.
00:36:23 Frankly, I actually very sincerely believe in the right to lawful peaceful protest.
00:36:27 It's a protected charter right in this country.
00:36:29 sometimes it can be a challenge it can be very difficult to manage these events but but i think
00:36:36 when we if if the protesters are willing to work with the police and if the police work with them
00:36:41 there are always some individuals who will push the limit and sometimes will break the law and
00:36:47 and there are ways to deal with those individuals but but in my experience it is
00:36:52 always preferable if you're able to to minimize the impact and to facilitate lawful peaceful
00:37:00 protest um while not allowing unlawful protest or a risk of public safety and we you might not have
00:37:08 monitored this part of the evidence but we had a similar discussion with deputy commissioners
00:37:12 oblocki of the rcmp about this attempt that the rcmp took in in in and near coots alberta to
00:37:20 find a legal way for the protest to continue and and let me ask you if you find if you found in
00:37:28 those days when you were doing this the same tension because the protesters want to be visible
00:37:34 they want in effect cause at least enough of a nuisance that they're noticed and that they're
00:37:38 able to make their point and be heard and yet you want them to be as little a nuisance as possible
00:37:46 And is that a tension that your forces and the people you have as your liaison team are trained to try and sort out?
00:37:55 Well, if I may, just let me cite as an example.
00:37:58 During the G20, we designated certain places where we wanted to facilitate lawful, peaceful protests.
00:38:04 And, for example, over at Queen's Park, we said, you know, if you gather there, you'll be able to protest.
00:38:10 And some people were quite willing to do that, but unfortunately not everybody is.
00:38:14 And then some people, you know, prefer to be, you know, to disrupt traffic or in the case of the G20, unfortunately, it also resulted in a set of circumstances where there was significant property damage, fires were set and windows were smashed.
00:38:29 But I think it's important to distinguish there are always people who seek only to engage in lawful, peaceful protests.
00:38:39 And I think it's our responsibility, and I say our, forgive me, it's the police responsibility to facilitate that to every extent possible.
00:38:48 And, unfortunately, there are also, in some circumstances, people who choose to engage in unlawful behavior and don't engage in lawful but rather unlawful protest, and then there has to be whatever action is required in order to curtail that.
00:39:06 Right. Now, coming to the events in question, as the matters were developing, there was a series of what ended up getting called briefings on truckers' convoy among ministers and senior officials in the government.
00:39:29 And it looks from our account of the documentation that you attended, probably all of them or almost all of them.
00:39:39 Is that your recollection?
00:39:41 I believe almost all of them, yes.
00:39:42 Yes.
00:39:45 There was one on January 28th, and I'm going to ask the clerk to call up SSM NSC CAN 50251.
00:39:59 and uh if you can mr kirger if you can just scroll down there's a there's a point where
00:40:13 we have a number 18 and uh blair there we go and these are the this is the uh
00:40:22 the notes of of that uh the readout as it's called of that meeting and uh do i understand
00:40:31 the way this is laid out correctly that uh beside the number 18 in your name are a series of of
00:40:36 points that you were making at the meeting yes sir the one i'm uh going to ask you to talk about is
00:40:43 see uh we need to keep the language down and uh probably the people in the room knew what you
00:40:53 were talking about and you probably used more words than just that so if you could flesh that
00:40:57 out for us what what you were what message you were trying to get across uh during that briefing
00:41:04 when you said we need to keep the language down i believe we all have a responsibility to do what
00:41:10 is necessary to keep the peace and and i was concerned that inflammatory language could
00:41:16 say incite a more violent response potentially um or or in in incite others to continue to
00:41:25 to come to the protest and and so i think one one needs to maintain and i've had some experience in
00:41:33 this um in in your language around an event to to speak of it in such a way as to not aggravate it
00:41:42 so um minimize name calling and uh that kind of thing is i just don't normally engage in name
00:41:50 calling sir right uh but is that what you mean by keep the language down keep keep the rhetoric
00:41:56 moderate on the on the government side on the protester side i i believe in in my experience
00:42:03 sometimes people live down to your expectations and so one one should be careful in in right in
00:42:08 in how you speak of these events i also quite frankly i'm always concerned about fear i think
00:42:14 fear is one of the greatest enemies of public safety and and i think if our if our language
00:42:18 is intemperate we can make people quite fearful and and if people are fearful then they don't
00:42:24 use public space they don't engage with their neighbors it can actually create a more dangerous
00:42:28 situation and and so my advice to colleagues was that we would remain tempered in our language
00:42:38 um i'd like to move now to another topic area that uh
00:42:47 it's apparent that you you took a role in and i i and and that has to do with the arrangement of
00:42:52 what were called perhaps it was ended up being a misnomer but what and what were originally called
00:43:00 the tripartite meetings uh can you describe first of all what those were meant to be
00:43:06 to situate them in in time if it assists you they were february 7th 8th and 10th the ones that
00:43:12 started it off but if you can just tell us what you had hoped to accomplish uh with those meetings
00:43:17 yes sir it was my intention to convene all three orders of government to bring them to a table
00:43:25 because i i believe that all three orders of government had a role and responsibility here
00:43:31 i believe that good communication between all three orders of government could have been
00:43:35 facilitated by convening you know a meeting among initially it was attempted to to do so with at
00:43:43 at the political level.
00:43:46 And as you said, it wasn't entirely successful,
00:43:49 but I believe what we were able to achieve
00:43:51 is convening officials to come to that table
00:43:55 because I believe that the events
00:43:57 that were transpiring in Ottawa
00:43:59 really did require good communication,
00:44:01 clear expectations and communications
00:44:06 and how we could assist each other.
00:44:08 All of us had a responsibility,
00:44:10 all of us had a role to play.
00:44:11 And I was attempting to convene that.
00:44:14 And by the way, not inconsistent with the role that I also play, as I mentioned earlier,
00:44:18 in convening other orders of ministries within my own government,
00:44:23 I've learned the value of bringing people together from many different disciplines
00:44:26 and authorities to be at the table to share perspectives and to help each other.
00:44:33 There's two topics I'd like to see if we can talk about,
00:44:37 and I'll see if we can do it without pulling out too many documents,
00:44:42 but just going by your memories of these meetings.
00:44:49 And I'll just describe the topics and then we'll try to treat them one at a time,
00:44:54 though they might end up getting blended together.
00:44:56 One is the fact that you didn't succeed in getting Ontario at the political level
00:45:02 to the table, as I think had been your ambition.
00:45:05 but the other topic is is why there seemed you know in at least the records of these meetings so
00:45:11 much uh confusion or misunderstanding uh between the city of ottawa and the federal government and
00:45:19 to the extent they were there officials of the ontario government about which resources would
00:45:25 be committed by whom when who was actually there etc the documents just seem to be the equivalent
00:45:32 of a whole bunch of ships passing in the night and nobody understanding what the other person's
00:45:37 saying and perhaps even a lot of mistrust so let's take the first of those issues the the the effort
00:45:43 you made to include the province of ontario and how much success you had there well first of all
00:45:49 i i reached out to minister jones who was the solicitor general in the province of ontario
00:45:53 at that time um i've had i've enjoyed a very long-standing and very positive professional
00:45:58 working relationship with minister jones i i reached out to to extend an invitation for her
00:46:04 to join that table um mr joint jones indicated to me during the one call i had with her uh that
00:46:10 that you know she would consider the invitation but she did express some concern and i understood
00:46:15 that concern and i acknowledged that to her she expressed some concern that she did not want to
00:46:19 be seen to be directing the police and and actually we had a very brief exchange um because i'm also
00:46:26 very familiar as she was with the linden commission report on the upper wash event and and i and i
00:46:31 think there is an actual sensitivity and concern among ontario officials about um any appearance
00:46:39 of being seen to direct the police um i i would also acknowledge uh minister mendicino who has
00:46:46 a direct working reporting relationship he is the he is essentially minister jones counterpart he
00:46:52 also had a number of conversations with her and with the premier at the time i in my but in my
00:46:56 one conversation um with the with the sister general i i sought to offer to make the invitation
00:47:04 and to provide her with assurances about what my intent was in convening that that table um
00:47:10 um mr clerk perhaps you could call up uh ssm nsc can four zeros 2676
00:47:25 and just start at the top so we can orient ourselves with what this document is
00:47:32 that's got a nice helpful heading there tripart meeting readout
00:47:37 and uh uh this is a february 10th meeting and so mr clerk if you could scroll down to uh about page
00:47:50 three thank you um and uh
00:47:59 is just a little further please mr clerk so we get mr players their minister bears comments there
00:48:09 and under bb which is doubtless you uh there's this uh notation thanks if we can speak frankly
00:48:19 for a moment it has come to the media's discussion that they are not in this meeting for the third
00:48:25 day uh and are we understanding this correctly that they is ontario yes sir and so this is the
00:48:34 third of your three attempts to table a tripart meeting and the third uh time that ontario is
00:48:42 missing in action and uh you refer to a statement from ontario that that your meetings will
00:48:51 accomplish nothing is that what you're saying there is that what you've heard from ontario
00:48:56 i i believe that's what i'm referencing too i don't have a memory of that statement at this
00:49:00 moment but i i think clearly my statement my comment here is that there was a statement
00:49:06 suggesting the table would accomplish nothing right and then there's there's a
00:49:12 uh a discussion between you and and uh i take it that's you and the mayor uh yes sir myself the
00:49:23 mayor i believe as well i believe the city manager and minister mendicino of course we're on that
00:49:28 right um and and there's you say good point and then sorry the mayor says good point and you say
00:49:36 You refine a point he's trying to make, and then the mayor says in the third line,
00:49:46 I can say that I'm disappointed that the province has not come to the table.
00:49:51 Premier is telling me, and then he's quoting, it appears, what the premier is telling him,
00:49:57 anything you want, but then there is silence.
00:50:02 now we've already heard from the mayor and he's given his side of this but but from your perspective
00:50:10 was were you uh disappointed that ontario hadn't participated in these meetings so far was it your
00:50:17 sense that the mayor was also disappointed that that ontario at least at the level you
00:50:21 would hope to have participation hadn't shown up at the meetings frankly i i had hoped that that
00:50:29 we would be able to convene the the tripartite table as i had originally uh planned it but but
00:50:36 i was you know this this was on the 10th by that date i was receiving assurances that you know for
00:50:43 example deputy minister was in regular deputy minister stewart was in regular contact with his
00:50:47 counterpart in ontario deputy minister um di tomaso and and that there was ongoing discussions
00:50:53 between my government operations center between the deputy minister of public safety and and between
00:50:58 as as frankly the deputy minister of public safety mr stewart was acting as as as an
00:51:03 interlocutor between both municipality and the province in these circumstances and and and so
00:51:28 .
00:51:58 .
00:52:28 .
00:52:58 .
00:53:28 .
00:53:58 Thank you.
00:54:28 But what we were seeking was assurances from those who did have operational responsibilities
00:54:34 that they were satisfied with an integrated operational plan, an action plan that they
00:54:40 were prepared to action.
00:54:42 That, I think, was a consideration.
00:54:45 Because it's also useful to remember, I think, Mr. Cameron, there were a number of things
00:54:50 happening right across the country at the time.
00:54:53 You know, the OPP in particular were dealing with a difficult situation in Windsor.
00:54:56 They had also had to respond to other events across southern Ontario.
00:55:03 Their resources were being quite significantly challenged because they had to continue to respond to a very dynamic and mobile threat across the country.
00:55:12 And so my understanding was that, you know, they needed the clarity of an integrated command action plan
00:55:23 that they'd all agreed to in order to facilitate the movement of people to go and deal with the situation in Arwa.
00:55:29 And in that context, did you have a view as to whether there was any logical order of operations,
00:55:40 if i can call it that way in terms of uh where ottawa should look to first uh we we have heard
00:55:48 from commissioner lucky that she wasn't standing on protocol here she was prepared to devote
00:55:54 resources uh as quickly as she could while while ottawa sought uh sought help from the province as
00:56:02 well but putting aside those urgent first steps that were taken did you have a sense of what the
00:56:11 proper protocol was for Ottawa to follow in this context putting in mind both the hatch we're wearing
00:56:17 as Minister of Emergency Preparedness and your history of having encountered similar situations
00:56:22 Douglas over many years in Toronto. Yes sir to be very clear there's a number of different ways in
00:56:27 which this has been uh particularly if there's a planned event a planned event as i've already
00:56:32 mentioned the g20 in 2010 there was another plan that i was involved in involving
00:56:52 structure put in place at the time i actually brought about 400
00:56:56 Toronto Police Service officers up here to Ottawa to work under that integrated command structure
00:57:00 and to assist in public order for that event. I'm also aware, because I've been around a long time,
00:57:09 that there was always a very close working relationship between all of the police
00:57:14 services working in the National Capital Region. They convened a table that they refer to as
00:57:18 Intersect. I've had no dealings with it in the recent period, but I was familiar with it
00:57:24 when i was a police chief where the rcmp worked very closely with the ontario or the ottawa police
00:57:29 service i believe the opp were at the table and the gatineau police and and so there's always been
00:57:35 good cooperation among the police services in the national capital region i'm also very familiar
00:57:41 that i've i've been involved in very many instances when i was a police officer where we
00:57:46 would in the toronto police service we had frankly a lot of people we had a lot of people trained in
00:57:50 public order and we would bring our public order resources to assist in in in kingston for example
00:57:56 for their homecoming event i mean
00:58:20 to make a request to the commissioner of the opp and the commissioners is required under that act
00:58:36 to respond you may also make a request to a municipal another municipal police service
00:58:40 and and that municipal police service has the ability to decline but there is a provision
00:58:46 whereby a police service dealing with an emergency exceeding their capacity to manage
00:58:51 can also within the act um make an appeal and a request to the to the opp
00:59:16 .
00:59:46 .
01:00:16 organization team put together that doesn't work if the event manifests itself over the course of
01:00:29 a weekend and so one thing that the commissioner might be interested in in your views on is whether
01:00:36 it would assist matters to have a protocol in place so that there isn't quite as much confusion
01:00:44 and disagreement about whose responsibility it is to who goes where and who provides what
01:00:51 to have a protocol in place and perhaps even stand by memorandum memoranda of understanding
01:00:58 or something so that it within days rather than weeks everybody knows who goes where whose
01:01:05 responsibilities are what and the matter hopefully gets sorted out more quickly yes sir i believe
01:01:10 good communications, and to the extent that it is possible to plan for an unplanned event,
01:01:17 those types of arrangements can be very useful. I've actually had the experience as a police
01:01:22 chief making arrangements with other police services in the event of emergency, how many
01:01:27 people I would send them and how quickly I'd be able to get them there. Because we all know that
01:01:32 certain types of events can exceed any of our capacity to respond to an emergency. Planned
01:01:38 events is actually pretty straightforward and I believe that we've got a long history and a lot
01:01:42 of success in in dealing with I say I'll stop saying we sir it's in my previous capacity um the
01:01:49 police services have a long history of working very collaboratively together for planned events
01:01:53 and and a number of different things are worked out well in advance including the integrated
01:01:59 command structure who's going to who's going to be in charge a a what they call what they're often
01:02:05 referred to as a gold silver command structure that is put in place who's paying for what and
01:02:10 etc what resources and obligations each of them will undertake to to provide is usually worked
01:02:17 out well in advance it is quite frankly more challenging in the event of an emergency and
01:02:23 made even more challenging when that emergency might be taking place in multiple jurisdictions
01:02:26 The speed with which you're able to deliver information, Minister Blair, is helpful, if
01:02:46 not to the translators, to me in getting through my questions in record time.
01:02:53 so I'm flipping through some pages here.
01:02:58 I wanna ask you some questions about a related issue.
01:03:03 You talked about IPRWASH.
01:03:05 You had the probably not entirely pleasant experience
01:03:09 of having a commission of inquiry look into the events
01:03:13 of the G20.
01:03:18 Not an entirely pleasant experience
01:03:20 having your conduct examined in a commission of inquiry.
01:03:26 And one of the issues that came up
01:03:28 in the Morden inquiry into the G20 event
01:03:32 and in IPRWASH as well,
01:03:35 had to do with the extent of administrative oversight
01:03:39 and political input to the activities of the police.
01:03:43 And so, again, with your long policing experience
01:03:48 and your role now as a Minister of the Crown,
01:03:54 can you start by giving us an overview of how you see either Police Board
01:04:02 or other levels of government officialdom oversight of police,
01:04:08 where you see that fits in and how you view what has been called in this hearing so far
01:04:15 sometimes the line between church and state or the conundrum of how much uh police forces should
01:04:22 resist political interference and that whole topic thank you sir if i may first of all just
01:04:28 a point of clarification justice morden's report although a very important report was not a public
01:04:33 inquiry it was a report commissioned by the toronto police services board um in the in the
01:04:38 aftermath of that report there was also another public report done by the office of the independent
01:04:42 police review director mr jerry mcnealy also on that report but also not a public inquiry thank
01:04:48 you one of the things i i can share with you sir i was a police chief for 10 years i was appointed
01:04:55 by the police services board the police services board is constituted under the police services
01:04:59 act it's defined on on its duties and responsibilities and how and how it's comprised
01:05:05 i very firmly believe very sincerely believe that good policing requires good governance
01:05:12 And governance is not to suggest, sir, that a police services board or the governance authority will direct the police in their investigations, in their operations, will even direct them in the administration of their police service.
01:05:26 That's not the function of good governance.
01:05:28 The function of good governance, in my experience, is oversight and accountability.
01:05:34 And I think it's fairly well articulated in a number of provincial statutes across the country, including the Ontario Police Services Act.
01:05:41 In my own personal experience, I used to meet with my board every month for several hours over the course of a day.
01:05:49 It was done in public. Some of it was in camera, much of it was in public.
01:05:54 They would ask me questions about use of force. They would ask me about training.
01:05:58 They would ask me about HR issues, the discipline and maintaining of conduct within my organization.
01:06:05 I reported to them in a very public way about our engagement with diverse communities, about a number of efforts that we were making to prevent crime, all those things that were the responsibility of the police service to deliver adequate and effective police service.
01:06:19 And that's actually directed at the board and then designated to delegated to me by the board.
01:06:25 The police have extraordinary authorities in our society, but those are not unfettered authorities.
01:06:31 I think there's an expectation that we will be held to account for the way we use those authorities
01:06:38 and that there will be independent civilian oversight of policing activities.
01:06:44 And I believe that's absolutely key.
01:06:46 There is no good policing without good governance.
01:06:48 Sorry, slow down and say that again, please.
01:06:50 There is no good policing without good governance.
01:06:54 And when you use governance in this context, you're not talking about the police and his or her deputies.
01:06:59 you're talking about some level sir i'm talking i'm talking about independent civilian oversight
01:07:04 of policing the police chief answers to someone i answered to my board i worked for my board and
01:07:11 and and i was accountable to my board and and i understood that was my responsibility to be
01:07:18 accountable to answer their questions they were always very careful by the way and i can't
01:07:22 remember recall you at one incident in 10 years where they ever directed me in an investigation
01:07:28 in an operation, but they asked me a lot of questions about what we were doing and why we
01:07:32 were doing it. I believe it was my responsibility to provide them with that information so that they
01:07:38 could fulfill their function of providing oversight to me and to hold me accountable
01:07:42 for the job that I was doing. And so I know there's been, because I've watched, there's been
01:07:47 a lot of discussion about, you know, having a civilian or a politician directing the police,
01:07:54 And that's never acceptable. But at the same time, the police must be accountable to an independent civilian authority.
01:08:01 And that can be achieved through a government minister who's assigned responsibility can be done through a police services board.
01:08:08 But but in my experience, public policing is all predicated on public trust and the consent of the people who are policed.
01:08:14 That trust is really warranted by that oversight and accountability and transparency and the way those extraordinary authorities given to the police are exercised.
01:08:28 Right. And in the time that you were chief of police and having this governance relationship with the police services board,
01:08:39 would you have considered it interference or what is sometimes called directing the police
01:08:46 for that board to have outlined to you either long-term or immediate priorities
01:08:51 or rankings of objectives to accomplish with your available resources there are a number of
01:08:59 different models of governance that are often employed by police service boards one of them
01:09:03 is through policies and priorities i think i believe it's called the carver model um i actually
01:09:07 slow down for the reporter and the what model the carver model i've actually spent a lot a lot of
01:09:11 time i i also felt it was my responsibility to help my board be a good board because they would
01:09:17 help me be a good chief and so we spent a lot of time talking about how they could do their job
01:09:22 and it would help me do my job um as as a board and and i think it it was a very effective
01:09:28 relationship um they did set priorities for the service they also set my budget um i would
01:09:35 collaborate with them and work very closely with them and they would consult with the public on
01:09:39 what those priorities should be because there is a bridge that a governance body can serve
01:09:45 for a police service to be that connection on behalf of community and and so they they would
01:09:51 bring there's lots of community deputations made at our board meetings where people would would
01:09:56 outline their expectations and their concerns and and and the board would set priorities but my board
01:10:01 was also very careful not to cross a line into operational matters to suggest where we should
01:10:08 deploy people or or you know what investigations or what laws would be enforced they never went
01:10:13 there and and neither would frankly i have allowed them i had to push back on that but they often
01:10:19 talked about you know placing a greater emphasis on community policing on community outreach on
01:10:24 building greater diversity within the police service and and you know how we interact with
01:10:31 you know the incredible diverse population of our city and and issues of crime prevention and and
01:10:36 how communities were to be be policed and frankly i never considered those infringements on police
01:10:43 operations i just thought it was we were working together to do good policing and and what about
01:10:48 when that uh effort at direction uh from the police services board was aimed at a more immediate
01:10:58 situation and i don't mean a particular investigation or anything of that type but for
01:11:03 example if the tamil protest had shut down university avenue for four days would you
01:11:09 have considered it out of line for the police services board to to ask you what you intended
01:11:14 to do about it and express to you their view that they considered this a serious problem for the
01:11:20 city? I would have considered it entirely appropriate. And frankly, I recall getting
01:11:25 these questions from the board. What are you doing? Why are you doing it? There was a fair
01:11:29 bit of criticism, as you can imagine. As a matter of fact, some of the national papers were accusing
01:11:34 me of being overly tolerant. My board was very supportive of what we were doing, but they did
01:11:38 asked questions about what and why, which I considered entirely appropriate, but at no time
01:11:44 did they tell me how to police that community. And I think that's, for me, there's a bright line
01:11:49 there. And they didn't cross that line, but they held me to account to the decisions I was making
01:11:56 on how I was going to deliver policing services in those circumstances. And I didn't consider
01:12:01 their questions infringements on any aspect of my authority and responsibility. It was my job
01:12:07 answer their questions and and to to allow them to perform that oversight role and to hold me
01:12:14 accountable for the decisions i made now that's very helpful now i'm going to ask you to see if
01:12:21 you can direct those thoughts to the uh i don't know if unique is the right word but at least the
01:12:29 different situation of the rcmp which doesn't have a police services board structure to which it is
01:12:37 accountable uh the commissioner reports to the minister and uh has a relatively thin statutory
01:12:45 framework uh that that that delineates that relationship have you had some thoughts about
01:12:55 what what you're calling governance of the rcmp could and should look like if it's different
01:13:01 than it currently is now yes sir and in fact it actually appeared in in my mandate letter
01:13:07 when I was the Minister of Public Safety, that we were looking at the issue of governance.
01:13:13 It's also, I also had some responsibility, I have a keen interest in the delivery of
01:13:18 First Nations policing program across the city, and we're working towards the development
01:13:22 of a new legislative framework for First Nations policing in Canada.
01:13:27 In order to make sure that that's as effective as it can be, I believe we have to resolve
01:13:32 the issue of governance in those communities, give people a say in how they're going to
01:13:36 be policed. That doesn't mean they get to direct the police operations, but they can make decisions
01:13:42 about how the police will function within their communities. And I would also make the observation
01:13:48 in a number of jurisdictions across the country, you know, we sometimes see the tension that exists
01:13:54 for the contract policing across this country, but very often it's an issue of governance.
01:14:00 And I'll just cite, if I may, I also recall vividly, in Ontario,
01:14:06 there were a number of communities that had their own little small police services
01:14:10 who made a decision to go and contract with the Ontario Provincial Police
01:14:15 to deliver policing services in their community.
01:14:18 And I witnessed the OPP make a very strong effort
01:14:22 to give those communities governance authority over their detachment
01:14:27 and to meet regularly with the local officials
01:14:30 and to actually give them a say in how they're going to be policed.
01:14:34 I thought it was very thoughtful, and I also believe that model,
01:14:38 which I'm familiar with Ontario, could assist us
01:14:41 in improving the quality of policing right across the country,
01:14:45 particularly in contract areas and, in particular, in First Nations.
01:14:51 And do you have any specific recommendations,
01:14:53 or I shouldn't say specific in the sense of drafting legislative terms,
01:14:58 but what a more complete governance structure would look like for the RCMP?
01:15:07 I think there's a number of models to be considered.
01:15:10 I also want to be respectful.
01:15:11 This is the responsibility now of my friend and colleague, Minister Mendicino.
01:15:14 He is the minister.
01:15:15 If you want to stop there, then we're going to hear from him shortly.
01:15:18 But at the same time, I have obviously some thoughts on the matter,
01:15:22 and I'm more than happy to share that with Minister Minogino.
01:15:24 I think ultimately it's going to lead to better policing,
01:15:27 which is our collective goal.
01:15:33 Now, there were a couple of times,
01:15:36 and you might remember them,
01:15:40 I'm going to bring you to one in particular,
01:15:42 where you made comments to the effect of
01:15:45 the police just need to do their job.
01:15:48 In other words, you made comments that gave the public
01:15:52 the impression that you didn't think the police were doing as much as they could to deal with the
01:15:57 situations in both ottawa and and elsewhere in the in the country um and uh all the ottawa ones
01:16:08 i think you're familiar with and we've heard a lot from the ops and about their reaction to to your
01:16:14 to your comments so let me just begin there did you have the impression uh uh that uh the ottawa
01:16:23 police were not doing as much as they could or should have or perhaps as early as they should
01:16:28 have to deal with the situation that they encountered when the convoy arrived in ottawa
01:16:34 i i think initially the their response was incorrect was was incorrect i i think and and
01:16:41 And based on the intelligence that they had, I think allowing those trucks into the downtown
01:16:45 core to establish themselves and become essentially very large barricades in hindsight, and I
01:16:53 appreciate this is the clarity of my hindsight, but I believe that was a mistake.
01:16:57 And I think they would acknowledge that it would be better had that not happened.
01:17:01 But once that actually happened, they were dealing with what in my experience would be
01:17:05 a unique set of circumstances a uniquely challenging set of circumstances which which was
01:17:11 was it was extremely challenging and and in fairness to them um my concern and and and the
01:17:18 statements i made frankly it was not my intention to criticize the police it was in it was to
01:17:23 encourage them to utilize the tools that were available to them because again i've spent most
01:17:29 of my life telling police officers to do their job and and and i have every confidence in them
01:17:34 I'm very proud of my profession, and I'm very proud of the men and women who do that work,
01:17:37 and I was just trying to encourage them.
01:17:39 We, as a society, needed the police because they're the only ones empowered to deal with
01:17:45 these public order events, and we needed them to do what was required to bring it to a peaceful
01:17:52 resolution, and I was simply commenting that we needed them to do that job.
01:17:57 okay and i'll ask you i'll ask the clerk uh if i can read this uh to call up ssm nsc can
01:18:06 four zeros 3129 uh minister blair this will be a a text uh exchange between you and and zita
01:18:17 astrovis your chief of staff and of and of course you can see the uh words that caught our attention
01:18:26 when when uh your office uh sent the commission this document among among all the others and uh
01:18:34 that is uh your your comment the police are finally doing their job in windsor
01:18:42 uh and we'll go on to the next paragraph in a second but had it been your impression
01:18:47 that the situation in windsor uh was taking longer than it should have to resolve because
01:18:53 the police were not doing their job and again not something i would have ever said to the police
01:18:57 because it's not i don't believe that would have been appropriate but personally i i believe that
01:19:02 the impact of the blockades at the ambassador bridge were being hugely impactful not just
01:19:10 economically but you know auto plants were being shut down right across the province
01:19:14 there was a huge impact that was taking place people people were being laid off they were being
01:19:18 sent home factory floors were being idled and and i i believe there was a sense of urgency to resolve
01:19:25 that um i i respect you know the operational commanders i wasn't second guessing them
01:19:31 certainly to them but i was frankly relieved that they were in my opinion finally finally resolving
01:19:38 that i also had every expectation as i indicate in that note that they would do everything to
01:19:43 to avoid violence, that they would be measured and proportional and professional, because
01:19:48 I know those guys, and I have every confidence in their work, but I was very much seized
01:19:54 with a strong sense of urgency about the blockades at that particular location, because I believed
01:20:00 that they had been so impactful.
01:20:02 And do you recollect any view you had about the liaison efforts?
01:20:06 and we're looking now at the second paragraph where you say it appears they presumably the
01:20:14 police windsor police force and the opp who are and rcmp who are acting here it appears they didn't
01:20:21 actually need to offer terms and concessions to the protesters can you explain what you were
01:20:27 thinking there if you remember i i don't really recall except again i was feeling a sense of
01:20:33 relief that they were now clearing that bridge because it did strike me as a matter of urgency
01:20:39 and previous tactics had not been effective in clearing.
01:20:51 I'm going to move to a different topic.
01:20:57 So before I leave, is there anything more you'd like to say about those topics that
01:21:02 we've just been covering about police governance,
01:21:07 about the effectiveness of the police operations
01:21:12 in Ottawa, I'm not expecting any more from you,
01:21:18 but I'm just about to change topics,
01:21:20 and so I'd offer you that.
01:21:21 Let us change topics, sir, I'm fine.
01:21:23 Okay, although you might not like to change the topic,
01:21:27 it's to the Alberta RFA,
01:21:29 You'll recollect that, I think, and can you just, to those who haven't followed the proceedings
01:21:40 quite as closely maybe as the rest of us, can you just outline what that was about and
01:21:45 how it came across your desk?
01:21:47 Yes, sir, and I don't recall precisely whether the letter arrived first or I heard from Deputy
01:21:53 Minister Stewart, but I became aware that there was a request from the province of Alberta,
01:22:00 and I believe it was from Minister Rick MacGyver, stating a number of things about what was
01:22:06 transpiring in Alberta with respect to the Coutts blockade. The Coutts blockade had been going on
01:22:12 for some time, and among the things that Minister MacGyver was asking for, he made a number of
01:22:18 comments, but his primary ask was for access, and he was very specific, to Canadian Armed Forces
01:22:23 tow trucks, I believe, in order to assist in the movement of trucks that were blockading the
01:22:31 highway in southern Alberta at Coutts. And so immediately, because he was asking for Canadian
01:22:38 Armed Forces resources and personnel in order to respond to this, that request I forwarded to the
01:22:45 Department of National Defence and to minister an end, because it didn't fall under any of our
01:22:49 existing agreements. So it would have been something that, first of all, we'd have to hear
01:22:53 from the Canadian Armed Forces, whether or not they had equipment fit for purpose, and would also
01:22:57 require the approval of the Minister of National Defence. And so that information went on over to
01:23:05 them. I also recall a number of days later being advised by Deputy Minister Stewart that the
01:23:12 Canadian Armed Forces advised that they did not have equipment fit for purpose and didn't believe
01:23:17 that they would be able to respond to that request. The advice I received from the Deputy
01:23:23 Minister at that time is that we should simply advise Alberta that we weren't able to respond
01:23:28 positively to their request for assistance. We always endeavor to try to do our best, but there
01:23:33 have been a few occasions when we've had to say, no, we just don't have that equipment.
01:23:37 But I did ask the Deputy Minister and some of my own staff to explore, again, from a whole government standpoint, did we have any other resources that we can draw upon?
01:23:49 I was quite reluctant to say just say no.
01:23:52 And so we looked at other departments and agencies, Parks Canada, Transport Canada, even had people checking to see if we could access trucks in the United States that could have been brought across the border to assist.
01:24:03 and ultimately I was advised no and that they weren't able to do that I then asked because
01:24:10 Mr. MacGyver had called me and wanted an answer to the question and and I said to my people we
01:24:17 have to have a formal response to Mr. MacGyver a letter was produced I approved it I was concerned
01:24:23 that again we were saying no but I approved it also making an offer because he had indicated
01:24:29 that they were going to purchase some of their own vehicles at that point in time that we the
01:24:33 federal government would assist in paying for those vehicles um and and eventually a letter
01:24:38 was approved um and and and i signed off on it thereafter um it goes back to officials to to be
01:24:46 sent i understand in my subsequent uh messaging with with minister macgyver that he never received
01:24:51 that letter i have no explanation for that and we we've we've heard an explanation from your staff
01:24:57 So I won't ask you to expand on that.
01:25:02 But if we could, it might give some more insight on that process if we looked at another document.
01:25:12 So, Mr. Clerk, could you call up SSM CAN NSC 402689?
01:25:18 and if the system is working this will be the unredacted version of a document that has been
01:25:33 redacted to the parties until just about right now and you can see it there's a
01:25:43 um we're we're at february 11th here at this exchange of emails and uh
01:25:54 the email we're looking at right now is from ms astrovis uh and uh
01:26:02 she's recording that the pmo is approved and this we're going to find out when we go down here
01:26:09 is followed by an email from from you and uh i'll suggest to you you might recognize it
01:26:16 but you're commenting here on the response to alberta uh and if if i've got that right what
01:26:22 you're saying is it's a weak response that is the response you or the federal government is giving
01:26:28 to alberta it's a weak response but all we have i approve please advise alberta and if if i've
01:26:36 correctly characterized that as your your message in relation to the response to the rfa
01:26:43 and why were you describing it as a weak response because i wanted to help alberta and we had
01:26:50 examined all of our options and we weren't able to provide them with the equipment that they sought
01:26:56 and and and and so a letter was was prepared i believe it indicated our willingness to provide
01:27:01 them with financial assistance for what they're requiring but at this point in time we weren't
01:27:07 able to provide them with the trucks that they sought i had hoped we would be able to and so
01:27:12 i thought a weak response but i also thought it was equally important that we respond and that
01:27:16 we advise alberta of the position that we were in and that in particular the caf had advised excuse
01:27:24 excuse me the canadian armed forces right had advised that their equipment wasn't appropriate
01:27:29 and it requires their approval, and they didn't give that approval.
01:27:34 Okay, so one reading of it's a weak response would be,
01:27:40 we the federal government don't have a good rationale for denying this RFA.
01:27:45 That is, it's a weak response to Alberta,
01:27:48 but that's not how you intended those words to read.
01:27:53 Not at all, sir.
01:27:54 Frankly, we didn't have the equipment.
01:27:58 the rationale was pretty straightforward
01:28:01 we don't have the equipment
01:28:03 that you've asked us for
01:28:04 Canadian Armed Forces said it's not fit for purpose
01:28:07 and they're unable to provide it
01:28:09 and that is
01:28:11 exactly what it is sir
01:28:12 so you would say it was
01:28:15 a complete
01:28:16 and logical response but it was unfortunate
01:28:19 in that you weren't able
01:28:21 to deliver anything
01:28:22 my strong preference would have been to help Alberta
01:28:24 now
01:28:26 Now, moving chronologically through events to the consideration of the Emergencies Act, as it came up, you participated in the SSE meetings and then the IRG meetings when the forum transitioned to the IRG.
01:28:44 Were you present at or represented at all of those meetings?
01:28:47 I was present at all of them, sir.
01:28:48 Thank you. And if you can describe in general, what was Cabinet, or at least those members of Cabinet who were gathered in those meetings, looking to you for, and what were you able to contribute to the meetings?
01:29:05 first of all in in the safety security and emergency uh committee that i chair um it's a
01:29:14 it's a smaller group of cabinet ministers that that regularly convene although each of these
01:29:18 meetings was what i referred to as ad hoc it was beyond our regular schedule of meetings but we
01:29:23 we i brought them together in order to receive uh briefings from depending on the officials deputy
01:29:30 minister stewart commissioner lucky the nsia advisor to provide information to my cabinet
01:29:37 colleagues um also to to discuss the appropriate government response um i also took the opportunity
01:29:45 during these meetings and i think what i was able to contribute was was to provide them with an
01:29:49 understanding because of my policing background with the the policing environment that that
01:29:55 governed um this event and and as the event unfolded over the course of a number of days
01:30:01 about you know what again the policing environment not just in ottawa but in in in various locales
01:30:08 in provincial in alberta british columbia in manitoba and a number of points of entry in ontario
01:30:15 right now uh i i have a particular question that comes out of something we discussed in the
01:30:22 interview uh uh and and uh that i believe you have a view on you you were participating in these
01:30:31 meetings as events were coming to a head uh we had uh irg meetings coming up towards the uh
01:30:41 irg meeting immediately before invocation on the 13th uh and i'm gonna get in your interview
01:30:49 summary which the parties have already seen you outline the reasons that you thought
01:30:54 were certainly bearing on your thoughts as you were contemplating the the propriety of invocation
01:31:01 but there was a there was a particular sub point that i wanted to ask you about which was was
01:31:07 whether uh you were aware of i think you've probably heard about now uh at the time you
01:31:16 were contemplating this and ultimately giving your input to the prime minister uh on the 13th
01:31:21 whether you were aware of commissioner lucky's uh views that she thought that there were still
01:31:27 law enforcement tools uh available to the rcmp to deal with the situation in ottawa and elsewhere
01:31:34 in canada i don't believe i was aware of that on the 13th right or before or before yes i've
01:31:42 obviously subsequently become aware of it and we've talked about you've asked me about it but
01:31:46 but i don't i don't recall being aware of it right i'm prior to that and and and as i'll just
01:31:52 to be clear despite having been at all of the ssc and irg and ultimately cabinet meetings that we're
01:31:57 considering invocation is that correct yes sir okay now can we come to your for for you don't
01:32:04 have to do them off by heart although you might remember them i can i can help guide you through
01:32:09 them but but as i recollected from our interview with you you you had categorized the reasons that
01:32:14 you thought uh invocation of the act was important and as i i don't want you to characterize these
01:32:22 necessarily as the advice you gave cabinet because that would be a confidence of cabinet so if you
01:32:29 can just describe them to us as how you were viewing the matter as the con as you were
01:32:33 contemplating invocation yes sir if if i may um the situation in ottawa had been enormously
01:32:41 challenging for the people of ottawa um and and i i think people were living in a state of of
01:32:47 fearfulness and and intimidation um and and frankly i think it was a very difficult set
01:32:53 of circumstances for them there um and and i was aware of that and you know obviously anxious to
01:33:01 to to resolve that but i remained hopeful throughout and and and i i'd like to also
01:33:08 sort of be clear to characterize i believe very much the emergency act was a measure of last resort
01:33:14 and that it was incumbent upon us to first of all either exhaust all existing authorities or
01:33:21 acknowledge that they would not be successful and could not be used for a number of different
01:33:25 reasons and we were hearing that type of feedback from law enforcement about the enormous challenges
01:33:30 they were facing we were also hearing about how stretched their resources were being were being
01:33:35 pulled because of events that were taking place in different parts of the country that required
01:33:40 them to respond to one place but then be required in other places and that was a challenge that we
01:33:44 were hearing quite frequently as well but i will also tell you i became very concerned because one
01:33:50 of my responsibilities as the minister for emergency preparedness is the resiliency and
01:33:55 safety and security of critical infrastructure and we define critical infrastructure as 10
01:34:00 different sectors sectors of critical infrastructure and in particular as it relates to
01:34:04 this event it includes such things as manufacturing our transportation routes the essential supply
01:34:11 lines the movement of essential workers and and what i was witnessing at the ambassador bridge
01:34:17 at Coutts, at Emerson, and then in a number of different venues where we would see similar
01:34:27 activity being threatened to be done at Point Edwards, at the Peace Bridge, at the Pacific
01:34:32 Highway in British Columbia. That escalation I viewed as a significant escalation because it did
01:34:41 result in significant disruption of critical supply lines. The cutting off of essential
01:34:47 goods and services, the impact that it was having, not just economically, but on people,
01:34:53 on families, and, you know, people who laid off their jobs, and factories were being idled. I was
01:34:59 also concerned because I'm aware, being a person from Ontario, that the integrated manufacturing
01:35:05 processes in Ontario, particularly in the auto sector, but in many other manufacturing sectors
01:35:10 as well, you know, prior to being public safety minister, I was also the minister of border
01:35:14 security. And so it really did give me an understanding and appreciation of how important
01:35:19 the integrity and functioning of that border is to our prosperity, to our economy, and to the
01:35:26 well-being and health and safety of Canadians. And so when those borders were essentially closed
01:35:33 and that, you know, the movement of goods and services, particularly some of the parts that
01:35:38 go into our factories was being essentially stopped, it was hugely impactful. And I believe
01:35:44 that it had risen to the level of a national emergency. We were also seeing, frankly,
01:35:52 the information that we received from the RCMP on or around February 10th, that they believed that
01:35:57 there were firearms present at Coutts. And then subsequently, I believe on the 13th and 14th,
01:36:03 when they completed their criminal investigation and arrested people and seized a number of
01:36:06 firearms it also for me elevated concern about public safety and and and the risk that not
01:36:13 everyone involved in these process represented but embedded within these protests the possibility
01:36:18 is certainly in Alberta of of of violence and even serious violence um taking place and and so
01:36:26 for for me the that the impact that that it was having not just in the city of Ottawa but I don't
01:36:33 want to minimize what was going on in Ottawa by any stretch of the imagination, but right across
01:36:37 the country, particularly as it pertains to critical infrastructure, for me, elevated the
01:36:42 situation to a national emergency. I would also observe as well, I believed that there was strong
01:36:50 evidence that the fact that this protest was so well entrenched in blockades in Ottawa really
01:36:59 anchored what was taking place even right across the country that there was in my mind a clear
01:37:03 correlation between the activities of border blockades and what was taking place in ottawa
01:37:10 and and and it it also for me highlighted the need we had to resolve the whole situation and
01:37:15 failure to do so would it failure to resolve in ottawa would have resulted just continue to like
01:37:21 like whack-a-mole chasing border blockades from one point of entry to another there are 119 border
01:37:29 points of entry, land border points of entry in this country, plus our airports, and all of them
01:37:34 are vulnerable to this type of unlawful action. And in my opinion, that represented a serious threat
01:37:41 to our national security and became a national emergency. And when you describe
01:37:47 your observation that the impact on the critical infrastructure elevated the situation,
01:37:54 that the blockades the convoy the protests etc elevated that to a national emergency
01:37:59 when you say that the impact on the critical infrastructure when i think of infrastructure
01:38:06 i think of physical built bridges and roads and trains and things like that but i i i don't think
01:38:13 there was any actual harm to those so i take it you're talking about the the impact on trade and
01:38:18 the economy and people in the vicinity, their lives, things like that, not the infrastructure
01:38:25 itself? When an artery, a point of entry into the country, in Manitoba, in Alberta, in Ontario,
01:38:34 is essentially rendered dysfunctional, when it's closed and nothing is moving through there,
01:38:41 the movement of those goods and services, in my opinion, is part of our critical infrastructure.
01:38:45 It supports manufacturing. It's part of the transportation, you know, but and you don't you don't have to blow everything up.
01:38:53 To render it unusable. Right. And, you know, that can be done through cyber attack, for example.
01:38:58 But but but rendering unusable is an attack on critical infrastructure, in my opinion.
01:39:02 And that that's excuse me, that's precisely what happened in these in these circumstances.
01:39:07 and it was for me we'd seen bridges and highways and rail lines go down in the in the floods and
01:39:15 storms in British Columbia it we knew we had to work hard to get those reopened but the situation
01:39:22 in across this country it it was exacerbated by the the very significant challenges the police
01:39:29 we're obviously having to clear these in a timely way all right um and if i can remind you uh
01:39:39 you had a fourth believe it or not you just did go through three of your factors that they sort
01:39:46 of got lumped together but your fourth had to do with your your your view on whether or not
01:39:51 the existing legal authorities were adequate uh whether they had been exhausted etc uh what was
01:39:59 your view there yes sir i want one of the things that i can go through a bit of a list one of the
01:40:05 things we'd heard in alberta in manitoba in british columbia and certainly in ottawa and at
01:40:10 the ambassador bridge was the very significant challenges that the police were having in gaining
01:40:16 access to vehicles that they could tow the the large trucks that were being used basically to
01:40:23 blockade you know they think these almost ceased to be trucks they they were uh fortresses and and
01:40:29 very very difficult to move um there there were a number of reasons why that i think have been
01:40:34 articulated for this commission as to why they couldn't gain access to those but it was a reality
01:40:38 that they could not um i i looked very carefully by the way on on the friday when ontario brought
01:40:44 in their measures they did attempt to address making those those tow trucks available at least
01:40:50 in ontario but you know it only authorized the use of the truck it did not compel it
01:40:55 and and so i was concerned that given the circumstances and what i believe to be the
01:40:59 reasons why those trucks weren't available to to the police to clear the blockades either
01:41:04 at ambassador bridge or in ottawa that we needed to do something else i'm also aware in in previous
01:41:11 part of my police career i was very much involved in organized crime and money laundering
01:41:15 investigations. And so I am familiar with the authorities and the activities of FinTrack.
01:41:21 And one of the questions that we had as a government was, where is this money coming from
01:41:25 and how is it being used? I became aware that FinTrack did not have existing authorities
01:41:31 to provide us with that information. And so that was, in my opinion, a deficiency in existing
01:41:37 authorities and something that we needed to consider how we might be able to address it.
01:41:41 there were there were also a number of areas like one of the things when ambassador bridge as an
01:41:47 example was was blockaded one of the first things i did is i dug out the international bridges and
01:41:52 tunnels act to see what authorities we had but the authorities within that act were limited only to
01:41:57 the bridge and as you recall the blockades in windsor didn't set up on the bridge or even in
01:42:03 their their their primary points of access it was further down the road it was very effective in
01:42:07 closing down that bridge but it would happen to be on a municipal roadway which which is governed by
01:42:13 municipal bylaw and the ontario highway traffic act but not up really effectively by any federal
01:42:18 statute and so the ability to designate certain spaces that also became relevant um in in the
01:42:23 city of ottawa i think um for wellington street and the sir john a parkway um in order to this
01:42:31 it became necessary to designate certain spaces where those activities would not be prohibited
01:42:37 and so there were a number of circumstances where the normal tools that the police would rely on
01:42:43 either in municipal statute in provincial statute or municipal bylaw provincial statute or in
01:42:49 federal statute were not being able they could not use them effectively to to resolve this in a
01:42:55 peaceful way and and you know we we listened very carefully to the challenges that we were facing
01:43:01 And I came to believe that we needed to find a remedy to provide them with the tools that they required
01:43:08 in order to affect the purpose of bringing these protests to an end.
01:43:12 Okay, and coming to the end of our time and to the end of the part of the story that the commission hopes to have you talk about,
01:43:24 You observed, not as a police participant, but as an experienced public order commander,
01:43:32 the enforcement action that eventually came to pass in Ottawa when the plan,
01:43:38 the Joint Forces Plan, was implemented.
01:43:42 Did you have observations about the propriety effectiveness, timeliness, etc.,
01:43:48 of the police action once the plan was in place?
01:43:51 Yes, sir, I did.
01:43:52 and and i can tell you it restored my pride in my profession you know i i have great respect and
01:43:59 admiration for the men and women who do that very difficult job of policing and what i witnessed
01:44:03 certainly in the city of ottawa but in other jurisdictions as well but particularly in the
01:44:07 city of ottawa an entirely professional proportional measured response they they move
01:44:15 slowly methodically respectfully um you know it was very clear that they were well trained very
01:44:21 clear they were well led um i i believe that their their their um exercise of the authorities that
01:44:31 they had both in existing law and in the new regulations was done in a very uh measured and
01:44:36 careful way and i i've i've seen some video of how they've done it it was textbook like i've
01:44:43 been trained as a public order commander and i've seen it done well and i've never seen it done
01:44:46 better than what i witnessed here in the city of ottawa as they i think to the extent possible as
01:44:53 peacefully as possible brought this to a resolution they they allowed people for example points of
01:44:58 egress it's always important to let people have a space to go they did that work they know they
01:45:03 moved slowly i actually found myself trying to explain to some of my friends that why they're
01:45:08 going slowly because that's the right way to do it and and in my opinion they did it the right way
01:45:14 okay thank you uh minister blair and thank you commissioner those are the questions of
01:45:19 commission council i think pretty close to on time i think you have 10 minutes left oh there you go
01:45:26 you can think up new questions i'm sure we're happy to share them um so this may be a good time
01:45:34 for the afternoon break then and we can come back in 15 minutes to go into the cross examinations
01:45:46 the commission is in recess for 15 minutes
01:46:04 .
01:46:34 .
01:47:04 .
01:47:34 .
01:48:04 .
01:48:34 .
01:49:04 .
01:49:34 .
01:50:04 .
01:50:34 .
01:51:04 .
01:51:34 .
01:52:04 .
01:52:34 .
01:53:04 .
01:53:34 .
01:54:04 .
01:54:34 .
01:55:04 .
01:55:34 .
01:56:04 .
01:56:34 .
01:57:04 .
01:57:34 .
01:58:04 .
01:58:34 .
01:59:04 .
01:59:34 .
02:00:04 .
02:00:34 Thank you.
02:01:04 Thank you.
02:01:34 .
02:02:04 Thank you.
02:02:34 .
02:03:04 Thank you.
02:03:34 Order alert.
02:04:04 The Commission has reconvened that Commissioner Le Proulx.
02:04:27 Minister, good morning or good afternoon.
02:04:29 Good afternoon.
02:04:30 Long week.
02:04:31 my name is brennan miller and i'm counsel to freedom corp which is the entity that represents
02:04:35 the protesters that were in ottawa january and february of 2022. if we could please bring up
02:04:41 uh document ssm dot can dot zero zero zero zero six three five eight underscore rel dot zero zero zero
02:04:50 1 Council is that 16 5 8 6 3 5 8 6 3 5 8 6358.
02:05:20 we can scroll to the last page please have you seen this email before sir um the last page please
02:05:31 no sir i don't recall okay so this email is from january 27 2022 at 4 21 pm you can agree with me
02:05:38 that the protesters in ottawa didn't arrive here until uh the 28th is that fair that's my
02:05:42 understanding yes sir all right so they're already preparing the narrative that they're going to
02:05:47 label the protesters with can you scroll down please
02:05:52 and there i put this to the last witness as well our government recognizes and
02:05:55 respects that everyone in canada has the right to safe and peace of protest
02:05:59 threatening acts of violence and inciting hatred
02:06:01 as we have seen from a select few in recent days
02:06:04 is unacceptable and does not reflect the views of the majority of canadians
02:06:08 we condemn all such hateful and violent rhetoric in strongest terms
02:06:12 so can you agree with me that that labeling of the protesters had already
02:06:16 been set out on january 27th sir i don't know the context of this email or or or frankly where
02:06:24 it comes from okay if we can scroll up okay and scroll up to the top please
02:06:33 so this is with your chief of staff and they're agreeing about how they're going to
02:06:38 set the narrative for the protest and if you scroll down again they confirm with one another
02:06:45 that this is what they're going to do so can you agree with me again that by january 27th 2022
02:06:54 you're essentially all your colleagues and yourselves had agreed that there'd be a joint
02:07:01 government response and this was how you're going to deal with it you were going to label the
02:07:05 protesters uh violent to incite hate hateful violent rhetoric that was the intention on january
02:07:14 27th correct no sir i disagree okay there is no agreement here it's it's recommendation from
02:07:20 someone on staff right if we could bring up document ssm.can.00007719 underscore rel.0001
02:07:34 so sir i can tell you these are the notes of miss sarah jackson i take it you know
02:07:47 sarah jackson is the office manager to the chief of staff of the prime minister is that correct
02:07:51 i know of her i don't believe we've met face to face right and you know uh who katie telford is
02:07:58 yes sir and she's the chief of staff to the prime minister yes sir all right can we scroll down to
02:08:04 page three please all right so you'll see that this note it's the notes from miss jackson it
02:08:13 says february 4th kt call so i'm sure you can agree with me that kt that's katie talford is
02:08:18 that correct i have no idea sir okay so let's scroll down to page four please
02:08:22 and there at the note on february 4th 2022 it says blair strategy emergency act you see that
02:08:33 yes sir i see it yeah because it was your strategy on february 4th 2022 to get the
02:08:38 emergencies act invoked was it not no sir that's incorrect so why would in a conversation to your
02:08:44 knowledge why would miss jackson record that in a meeting with miss telford why would she do that
02:08:51 to your knowledge? I have no idea, sir. I can tell you I recall the meeting in which I talked
02:08:57 about the need for the police of jurisdiction to exhaust their existing authorities and that
02:09:04 we needed to support them. I also made it very clear to colleagues that the Emergency Act was
02:09:09 a measure of last resort and not appropriate at this time. But that was the conversation I had
02:09:16 in fourth. And can you agree with me, though, that if there was a strategy to invoke the
02:09:19 Emergencies Act that if the purported emergency resolves itself on its own, of course, there's
02:09:25 no reason to invoke it, correct? Again, sir, there was no strategy to invoke the Act. There was a
02:09:33 discussion among colleagues about the various options that were available, and I was very
02:09:38 explicit to my colleagues that the Emergency Act was not under consideration at this time.
02:09:43 you you had said on uh global news on the 13th at eight o'clock on the 13th you had told them
02:09:54 and i can i have the transcript if you'd like me to repeat it you said that the emergencies act
02:09:59 was under consideration from the outset do you want me to read the transcript to you
02:10:03 to be to be really clear i believe what i said is and you can read whatever you like by the way
02:10:08 but what i believe i said is everything was on the table and we were considering every option
02:10:12 throughout that that is the responsibility of of those of us sir what you actually said was that
02:10:18 it was under consideration in the first from the first day that's what you said would you like me
02:10:23 to show you the transcript that might be useful okay if we could bring up the support documents
02:10:29 um it i believe is in there
02:10:43 you're you're referring to hrf 40 1622 right council yes sir do we have the actual reference
02:10:51 maybe your your associate can tell us what the reference is in the uh in the database
02:11:02 well i don't want to slow this down so i'll move on and come back to that so sir um we'll come back
02:11:07 to what you said but by february 4th of 2022 you agree that the prime minister and minister mendocino
02:11:19 had already labeled the protesters in ottawa as extremists is that correct
02:11:25 i have no knowledge of that i don't agree with that but you can agree that on january 31st 2022
02:11:30 the prime minister addressed the nation on tv and on the internet by video do you remember that no
02:11:35 sir you don't remember that no sir when the prime minister went on television to the whole nation
02:11:44 and talked about the ottawa protest on the following monday you don't remember that i
02:11:50 i know the premier spoke i have no recollection of what he said i was busy doing things i'm going
02:11:55 to read you what he said you can tell me if you remember it and he stated i know you are wondering
02:12:00 about what you saw in our capital city this weekend.
02:12:03 As my friend Erwin Kotter said on Saturdays,
02:12:05 freedom of expression, assembly and association
02:12:08 of the cornerstones of democracy,
02:12:09 but Nazi symbolism, racist imagery,
02:12:12 and desecration of war memorials are not.
02:12:14 It is an insult to memory and truth.
02:12:17 Hate can never be the answer.
02:12:19 Over the past few days, Canadians were shocked
02:12:21 and frankly disgusted by the behavior displayed
02:12:24 by some people protesting in the nation's capital.
02:12:26 I want to be very clear.
02:12:28 We are not intimidated by those who hurl insults and abuse at small business works and steal food from the homeless.
02:12:36 We won't give in to those who fly racist flags.
02:12:39 We won't cave to those who engage in vandalism and dishonor the memory of our veterans.
02:12:44 There is no place in our country for threats, violence, and hatred.
02:12:47 So to those responsible for this behavior, it needs to stop.
02:12:50 To anyone who joined the convoy but is rightly uncomfortable with the symbols of hatred and division on display,
02:12:55 Join with your fellow Canadians.
02:12:57 Be courageous and speak out.
02:12:58 Do not stand for or with intolerance or hate.
02:13:01 Do you remember hearing that now?
02:13:03 Actually, now that you've read it to me, sir, I not only remember it, but I agree with it.
02:13:07 Okay.
02:13:08 And so you can agree there that the Prime Minister has stated that being part of the protest is essentially standing with intolerance and hate.
02:13:15 Can you agree with that?
02:13:16 I don't believe that was the distinction the Prime Minister made.
02:13:19 He was actually telling people who don't agree with those measures not to stand with those who do.
02:13:24 Right. And I take it, you know, that when the protesters arrived on January 28th up to February 1st, that the evidence to date is that they were largely and completely peaceful and that there was little to no violence. Do you agree with that?
02:13:36 and and and again i i think i i think there might have been isolated incidents and and frankly
02:13:47 i also believe um the the carrying of hateful symbols like a nazi flag is is in many ways
02:13:55 causing fear and it is a form of violence and intimidation against people who who who would be
02:14:01 caused caused to be very fearful about such symbols in their community and so the bearer of
02:14:07 the nazi flag that that is a person who is hateful and it is someone that the government
02:14:13 of canada is concerned about is that fair um again i don't know the person who was who was
02:14:17 bearing the flag and i i wouldn't comment on that but i i know how hurtful that a nazi flag can be
02:14:25 to very many canadians who in in their life experience that's a symbol of of anti-semitism
02:14:31 hatred i understand and so i understand that you're also though you're familiar with the company
02:14:35 enterprise canada it does work for the liberal party of canada i do i'm not sir are you familiar
02:14:41 with uh supra davini does that sound i'm not sir are you familiar with mr brian fox no sir have
02:14:49 you heard anything about the individual carrying the nazi flag actually not being a protester
02:14:56 but somebody sent there so that photos were taken you have you heard anything about that
02:15:03 only from you sir okay and we'll just come back to uh the issue with the labeling then
02:15:11 i take it though that you consulted your comms people on the narrative that you wanted the
02:15:17 media to accept before the protesters even got here according to that email no sir that's not
02:15:22 not correct that email states that they were buying the narrative that's what it states with
02:15:29 with respect sir i believe what the email says is is that some of our communications people were
02:15:34 were examining and being prepared for the event coming but no decision had been made none of that
02:15:40 was presented to me and it did not form any of of my messaging can you agree that from the
02:15:45 protesters arrival at least after february 4th you intended and wanted the protesters removed by force
02:15:50 didn't you absolutely not sir i i wanted the protest to end and then to be removed but i've
02:15:57 always been committed to doing that as peaceably and proportionally as possible but you couldn't
02:16:02 talk to them after they had been labeled these extremists because your colleagues and yourself
02:16:08 of course you know extremism nazis terrorists you can't talk to that sort of group can you it would
02:16:14 look bad wouldn't it um i would actually disagree with your characterization in various points of
02:16:19 life sir i've engaged with with people who are engaged in protest and and and so i frankly i
02:16:26 disagree with your characterization so on february 7 2022 when the mayor of ottawa asked the federal
02:16:32 government and yourself to bring in a mediator to meet with the protesters do you remember what you
02:16:37 said to your chief of staff in response to that no sir perhaps you could share it with me we can
02:16:42 bring up document ssm.nsc.can.00003070 underscore rel.0001
02:17:01 so this is your response to finding out about the request for a mediator and you respond as follows
02:17:09 i don't know who is advising mayor watson but this is a bad mistake he has conceded without
02:17:13 ever using the many tools available to the city his language is also problematic this is not a
02:17:18 labor dispute between interest it's an unlawful occupation as long as the city and its police
02:17:23 refuse to do anything no progress will be possible so i take it at the time when you
02:17:28 wrote that to your chief of staff that was how you felt correct yes sir all right that's that's
02:17:34 an email from myself to my chief of staff correct and so it's fair to say that you did not want to
02:17:39 bring in a mediator i i was concerned about the intention of the mediation and and what was being
02:17:46 negotiated um in in my experience the the intent of engaging with protesters is to bring a peaceful
02:17:53 resolution to the protest yes but also then on february 11th of 2022 you were given a copy of
02:17:59 of the engagement proposal that inspector bedoin of the opp and deputy minister steward
02:18:05 had drafted right you were emailed a copy you'll have to share it with me sir to help me recall
02:18:10 if we can bring up document ssm.can.00006131 underscore rel.0001
02:18:19 if we can scroll down to the bottom
02:18:31 and so this is attached as the draft for your review and comments i have validated the proposed
02:18:36 approach with the opp expert and since shared the draft but no word back yet and that is from deputy
02:18:41 minister rob stewart and it is on february 11 2022 at 12 p.m if we can go up
02:18:49 and we can keep going it is then forwarded to you by your chief of staff astra zita
02:18:57 astravas zita and then it appears if we can scroll up you have a response but it's redacted
02:19:04 under section 39 the canada evidence act now can can you agree with me that your chief of staff
02:19:11 should not remember cabinet that's correct right so what was your response here i don't recall
02:19:18 you don't recall would it be helpful to the commission if we had your response
02:19:22 i don't know because i don't know i don't recall the response you don't recall the response
02:19:26 but given that it's an engagement proposal and in the meeting when you actually had it before you
02:19:32 there's notes to the effect that this isn't action we want action is it fair to say that
02:19:40 both yourselves including the prime minister and minister mendocino you were never on any terms
02:19:51 going to carry out any such proposal that would essentially require you to go and talk to the
02:19:58 protesters were you no sir i don't agree with anything you've just said so you had you had
02:20:05 always been open to meeting with the protesters we were and deputy stewart had advised that he
02:20:13 was involved in a process of engagement with with the protest protesters um but but i'm i'm frankly
02:20:20 i was not in in favor of having senior ministers of government and go out and engage with the
02:20:25 protesters um in in my experience that that's done at at an officials level and not involving
02:20:31 cabinet ministers are certainly not the prime minister but right now as i understand it and
02:20:36 there has been testimony that it's not uncommon for law enforcement to request of the political
02:20:42 branch to assist in negotiation like that it's actually relatively common they testified to that
02:20:48 so what was the problem was it because you couldn't be seen to meet with nazis and extremists
02:20:54 is that what was the issue first of all i i disagree with the characterization you've just
02:21:00 provided, but I don't have any experience in the many years I've dealt with public order events
02:21:07 of engaging with political figures to engage with protesters. Okay, can we please bring up
02:21:11 one last document? SSM.can.00008763 underscore rel.0001. And you're over your time, so I hope
02:21:25 This is a copy of the proposal with respect to engaging the protesters.
02:21:36 Okay.
02:21:37 Minister, what's the problem with it?
02:21:43 Could I see the whole thing?
02:21:44 Absolutely.
02:21:45 Great.
02:21:55 And again, I did not express a problem with this. The Deputy Minister was engaging with city and provincial officials in this and then came with his proposal to serve this proposal was before you in the IRG on the 13th.
02:22:13 actually i appreciate you you bringing that up sir i also recall that in in the discussion
02:22:20 almost immediately after deputy minister uh stewart advised us of the discussions that had
02:22:25 been taking place um there was very public disagreement among a number of people in the
02:22:30 protest who disavowed that disavowed this process and and and so quite frankly i think that i
02:22:36 understand i understand that but that's not really what the evidence that's come out there's been
02:22:40 evidence and we'll leave it at that but at the end of the day when you saw this you agree that
02:22:46 it was recommended by the opp it had been brought to you and drafted by the deputy minister of
02:22:51 public safety and they were on board in fact i found an email can you agree that the privy
02:22:58 counselor the privy counselor clerk she gave it the green light again it was it was cabinet
02:23:07 was it not well there was no recommendation mr commissioner i think that misstates the
02:23:12 evidence of the clerk with respect to the green light just one friend has made i'd like to ask
02:23:17 that my friend have a good faith basis for the questions put in the characterizations of the
02:23:21 evidence that are placed before the witness as some of the characterizations suggest that there
02:23:26 is a purpose to the questions less of seeking the witness's evidence but a purpose of stating the
02:23:32 stating facts as though they were evidence when that evidence is not properly before you.
02:23:36 I have one last question and then I'm done.
02:23:38 So you agree with me that after the invocation, on numerous occasions,
02:23:44 your government told the public that law enforcement had told you
02:23:51 that the threshold to invoke the Emergencies Act was met.
02:23:56 Do you remember all those statements that your colleagues and maybe even yourself made?
02:24:00 Do you remember those?
02:24:00 To be very clear, sir, I do not agree with you.
02:24:02 okay so you don't agree that those statements were made i don't agree with what you said
02:24:06 okay so you don't agree that ministers in your government have said that law enforcement advised
02:24:14 cabinet at the threshold to invoke the emergencies act was met and again sir the question you put to
02:24:22 me i do not agree with okay but then you do agree of course is that law enforcement never advised
02:24:26 you at the threshold to invoke the emergencies act was met did they
02:24:34 frankly it was never a question i put to law enforcement i don't think that would
02:24:38 have been appropriate okay thank you okay next is the honorable police service
02:24:56 Good afternoon, Minister Blair. My name is David Michikowski, and I'm counsel for the Ottawa Police Service.
02:25:04 One of the things I gather you know from your long experience as a Chief of Police is how important an operational plan is. Is that right?
02:25:14 Yes, sir.
02:25:14 And in order to have an operational plan to end the type of event that occurred in Ottawa, you'd agree with me it'd be necessary for the police to draw upon subject matter experts?
02:25:28 Very often the case, yes, sir.
02:25:30 And you wouldn't be critical, I take it, if the police needed to draw upon resources outside their own service, whether that be other Ontario services, the OPP, the RCMP, etc.
02:25:47 Not at all, sir. That's a very common practice.
02:25:49 And that might take a bit of time to assemble such a team. Fair enough.
02:25:53 Yes, sir.
02:25:53 um you participated in a meeting with um and you may have had more than one i believe with mayor
02:26:01 watson and minister mendicino i believe mr kanalakis um deputy minister stewart and at the time uh ops
02:26:10 in the city had made a request for more police resources do you recall that yes sir and um you
02:26:19 indicated at that meeting that it may be necessary to look at the matter of information sharing
02:26:29 around the allocation of resources. Because fair enough, you'd want to know what are you going to
02:26:34 do with those resources, correct? Yes, sir. And one of the things Deputy Chief Bell said at the time
02:26:42 was that the OPP were asking for the same thing, and then Minister Mendicino said,
02:26:48 we need to know from the chief what the plan is with the appropriate boundaries on operational
02:26:55 independence. How is the convoy being broken up and disengaged? And then he added, we need to know
02:27:03 the plan. And I take it you would agree with that. Respectfully, sir, I don't believe I needed to
02:27:09 know all of the operational details of the plan. I needed simply to be satisfied that the police
02:27:14 services that would be contributing to its execution would be involved in the plan and
02:27:19 be satisfied with its sufficiency. But I did not ask for details of the operational plan.
02:27:25 Right. So what you needed was the RCMP and the OPP to say they were satisfied with the
02:27:31 operational plans. When we were asking them to bring significant resources to bear, my understanding
02:27:37 from from them is that they also wanted to be satisfied to the sufficiency of the plan
02:27:44 and the subject of the ottawa police service not having a fully developed operational plan
02:27:51 came up several times during the period prior to the emergencies act invocation is that right and
02:27:58 yes sir i think i think that's fair we had heard it from a number of police officials
02:28:02 there was some general discussion about the plan right one of the comments I see that was made and
02:28:10 this may sound familiar was when they showed up there was no or or let me let me turn to the
02:28:21 document. Mr. Clerk, if you could please turn up ssm.can.ns402674. And if you could turn to the
02:28:35 first page of that, please. And so this is from Ms. S. Travis. And in it, that's your chief of
02:28:51 staff, correct? That's correct. And so she indicates there's an operational update as to what the
02:28:57 RCMP were reporting. RCMP integrated planning cell was set up to assess OPS operational plan.
02:29:06 I do have concern. Strategic tactical planners, OPP, OPS, RCMP were identified to be part of that
02:29:14 planning cell to review, challenge, and provide plan. When they showed up, there was no plan to
02:29:21 review slowly later verbally shared plan was not taking feedback or challenge no open discussion
02:29:30 on way forward um and i take it uh minister if those statements are true those actions by the
02:29:40 chief would be problematic is that fair and again i i'm i'm reluctant to comment on on
02:29:48 on Chief Slowley's involvement in this thing,
02:29:51 this is the information we were receiving back from the RCMP
02:29:54 and to me through my chief of staff about concerns that they had.
02:29:59 But again, not being part of this discussion,
02:30:02 I'm reluctant to characterize anybody's particular behavior on this.
02:30:06 But it's very clear that the RCMP had concerns.
02:30:10 And in fact, in text message with your chief of staff,
02:30:16 one of the things we see that you're saying is we still need to fairly clarify what is he going to
02:30:23 do with these resources if it's just more inaction the opp and other ontario police services will sit
02:30:31 this one out do you recall that exchange yeah yeah i do i i in my conversations with um a number of
02:30:39 police officials outside of the city, there was concern. They wanted to see an integrated
02:30:47 operational plan that involves an action to end the blockade, or end the protest.
02:30:55 And in another email exchange with your chief of staff, you also indicated, and that was the one
02:31:02 I think that Mr. Miller just took you to, as long as the city and the police refuse to do anything,
02:31:07 no progress will be possible, correct? There was a concern we were hearing from both the RCMP and
02:31:14 the OPP that they wanted to see an action plan for the resolution of the protests.
02:31:20 You talked about the importance of communication with the protesters and the style of communication.
02:31:26 I take it you wouldn't disagree with me that equally a chief of police needs to have the
02:31:32 ability to communicate effectively with those in his or her organization yes sir and as chief of
02:31:40 police it would be important to respect those uh below the chief in the chain of command yes sir
02:31:47 and you would not condone a chief of police telling his command that if they didn't support
02:31:52 his plan he will crush them i don't think that language is appropriate and you um you wouldn't
02:32:02 take, you understand that the RCMP and the OPP were asking for information on operational plans
02:32:11 and you indicated that that would make sense that they want that information if they're sending a
02:32:16 thousand or more officers, correct? I would expect that they would have an expectation to be aware of
02:32:23 how their people would be used. And you wouldn't take that as evidence that the RCMP wanted to see
02:32:29 the ops fail or that they were serving their political masters that wouldn't be the message
02:32:34 you'd want for a chief to deliver to his or her command team what it well again i have no direct
02:32:39 knowledge of of that communication but my expectation is is that every everyone was
02:32:46 had a strong interest in resolving this quickly and peaceably um you indicated that you attended
02:32:52 the irg uh meeting i believe all of them correct yes sir and one of the things i note at the um
02:32:59 February 12th IRG meeting was the commissioner of the RCMP advised that there continued to be
02:33:08 challenges working with the integrated planning team in Ottawa around communication and decisive
02:33:15 it says decisively I assume it's a typo communication and decisiveness of the OPS
02:33:23 chief you heard her make that comment correct yes sir and that did not come as a complete surprise
02:33:28 to you did it i was hopeful that they would be able to resolve it um you understood that
02:33:35 ultimately the integrated planning team um did come up with a plan that was very successfully
02:33:41 uh executed yes sir as i commented in my earlier testimony and that team only came together about
02:33:50 on or about february 9th and the plan was then actually signed off on february 13th and and sir
02:33:56 I don't have a line of sight into the internal meetings and discussions that were taking place.
02:34:03 That was not shared with me.
02:34:05 I was aware that all three organizations were working together,
02:34:09 but the timing and the steps that were taken, I don't have a set.
02:34:14 And you also attended the February 13th cabinet meeting.
02:34:18 Yes, sir.
02:34:18 And at that meeting, it was reported that there was potential for a breakthrough in Ottawa, correct?
02:34:23 i can pull up the document if you need to see it it might be useful to see the document i don't
02:34:29 have a precise recollection of that comment okay um the document is um ssm nsc dot can
02:34:39 uh five zeros two one six and it's on page eight
02:34:44 and I believe it's six lines up from the bottom
02:35:05 with respect to recent actions the national security and intelligence advisor indicated
02:35:11 that law enforcement gains have been important and that there was potential for a breakthrough
02:35:15 in ottawa ontario do you see that yes sir and you understand that the breakthrough was that there
02:35:21 was now an integrated uh operational plan correct and and again i i i recall this now knowing that
02:35:29 there was a breakthrough in ottawa we were also made aware that enforcement significant enforcement
02:35:33 action was now taking place in coots alberta um and and that the cabinet was informed about that
02:35:38 I don't have a recollection of the exact nature of the potential breakthrough
02:35:42 to which the NSA refers. And finally, if I may just have two minutes left, Commissioner,
02:35:48 I was hoping not to have to go to the document so that used a bit of time, but I will be very quick.
02:35:55 Go ahead. You had certain frustrations with Chief Slowly, and there's a text message
02:36:07 exchange with your chief of staff where you refer to your frustrations with chief slowly which is
02:36:13 an internal issue we need to be met that needs to be managed do you know that uh text message
02:36:19 exchange no sir i don't recall okay um it's ssm.nsc.can.03 uh sorry uh four zeros 3014
02:36:37 so it says individuals have relayed your frustrations with ops slowly which is an
02:36:51 internal issue we need to manage i assure them that mendocino has been working with the rcmp
02:36:57 i've relayed this conversation to nsia pmo and mendocino chief of staff i think what was what was
02:37:05 being spoken of here um was that unfortunately some people were talking making assumptions and
02:37:12 and speaking about um some of the concerns that i was expressing about the the police response
02:37:17 to the ottawa thing and and i was concerned that frankly some people had been uh speaking in in my
02:37:24 stead i'm perfectly capable of speaking for myself and was was concerned that others were doing that
02:37:31 and ultimately just to finish off uh you had an email a text message exchange with senator verne
02:37:37 white yes sir senator white was the former chief of police of ottawa yes sir and he expressed the
02:37:44 view that chief slowly had not done his job and you didn't disagree with that in that exchange
02:37:51 did you i i didn't take a position one way or the other and and if if i may sir um i think i've known
02:37:58 chief slowly for a very long time we worked together for 25 years and he used to be my field
02:38:02 deputy when i was the chief in the in the toronto police service he was facing a very difficult
02:38:06 situation and and and in a very challenging environment um i have respect for the man and
02:38:14 for the very difficult job he had to do and when you stated that the police response was inexplicable
02:38:19 that was after the actions on phase and you indicated at that point that the police then
02:38:28 had redeemed themselves. And to be very clear when I said that I was asked specifically about
02:38:35 the police response and I said it was somewhat inexplicable and to be really clear what that
02:38:40 means is I could neither explain nor account for the police response it really isn't my place to
02:38:46 explain or account for it and so i characterize it as inexplicable and ultimately they redeemed
02:38:52 themselves well and and the work and as i've already characterized in my earlier testimony
02:38:56 i think that they did an excellent job in in in utilizing the tools that were available to them
02:39:01 in clearing the convoy um in the week following the invocation of the act thank you very much
02:39:06 thank you sir okay for the opp please
02:39:10 commissioner i will endeavor not to go over time
02:39:20 be nice good evening minister chris diana council to the opp we've heard pretty extensive evidence
02:39:33 from both ottawa police service and winter police service witnesses that the opp provided
02:39:38 significant support to both ottawa and windsor i don't know if you've heard any of that evidence
02:39:43 yes sir i have and and i would agree with it all right and former chief slowly in particular was
02:39:48 very complimentary of the assistance provided by commissioner karik and the resources provided that
02:39:54 helped bring it into the protest correct yes sir and as you said you would agree with that assessment
02:40:00 yes sir i would all right and that assistance started with a hand in reports went to frontline
02:40:06 officers pou support integrated planning team leadership and that's just in the ottawa context
02:40:12 correct and and if i may sir i'm not familiar with any report it wasn't intelligence that i
02:40:16 had access to um or the internal activities within the police service but my general overall
02:40:22 impression is that the opp were very helpful all right can we go to document ssm.nsc.can402983
02:40:36 so what i'm bringing you to appears to be a text exchange between you and your chief of stress
02:40:44 the chief of staff mrs stravis now unfortunately there doesn't appear to be a date on this if you
02:40:49 can scroll down and allow the witness to see it it's fairly short down at the end
02:40:58 now at the bottom you'll see that you suggested that chief slowly does not have a strong support
02:41:04 network within provincial police leadership now again i don't have a date on this but certainly
02:41:10 at the time you wrote this you would not have been privy to the many text messages and phone calls
02:41:15 between chief slowly and commissioner kareek correct and and and to be clear i wasn't referring
02:41:20 to commissioner kareek or the ontario provincial police in that message i was i was referring to
02:41:25 his relationship with some of the other police services in ontario oh i see so when it says
02:41:29 within provincial police leadership you weren't referring to the opp you were referring perhaps
02:41:32 to other police leaders yes sir but not the opp no sir
02:41:42 all right and was this your own observation or was that observation made by others that you
02:41:45 were forwarding on it it was in part my own observation but also in feedback i was receiving
02:41:52 from former colleagues was that the view of cabinet no sir
02:41:56 all right i'd like to move to another issue which is consultation on the emergencies act
02:42:05 if you can bring up a clerk mr clerk document id pb.nsc.can403256
02:42:17 and while that's loading we've heard evidence from commissioner lucky that the rcmp did not
02:42:24 request the Emergencies Act, but she was asked to provide a list of tools that may be useful
02:42:30 in terms of the Emergencies Act legislation. I'm sure you're familiar with that.
02:42:34 Sure.
02:42:35 All right. So what we have here is an email exchange between Mike Jones, who I understand
02:42:40 is what the Chief of Staff of Minister Mendicino.
02:42:44 Yes, sir.
02:42:44 And of course, Commissioner Lucky. If you can just kind of scroll down a little bit,
02:42:49 This appears to be the commissioner's kind of list of tools that could be potentially useful.
02:42:57 Did you see a copy of this list?
02:42:59 No, sir.
02:43:01 Now, by this point, if you scroll to the top, just so we can get the date, this was February.
02:43:06 If we subtract five hours, this was the evening of February 13th.
02:43:10 And by this point, on February 13th, the OPP was heavily involved in policing protests all across Ontario.
02:43:16 you spoke about this in your evidence both leading the enforcement in windsor integrated planning
02:43:23 team in ottawa 402 there were other areas in ontario correct so the opp you would agree was
02:43:30 heavily engaged throughout the province yes sir right what i asked both deputy minister deputy
02:43:38 minister stewart and commissioner lucky about consultation and both agreed that in light of
02:43:44 that context where opp was heavily involved and would be using these tools the opp could have
02:43:49 provided valuable input into the request as to what would be useful or necessary policing tools
02:43:57 would you agree with that i'm not sure what the opp might have provided there was also um an issue
02:44:04 of the decision had not yet been made at the at the time of this email it was it was under
02:44:08 consideration but but the decision had not um been made and and it it was you know a matter
02:44:17 there was still a very important uh consultation that the prime minister had to undertake
02:44:22 uh with the first ministers from across the country and and so the decision to invoke and
02:44:27 had not yet been made uh there was some consultation internally about useful tools
02:44:32 but but it wasn't completely it wasn't fulsomely uh pursued because of the need to maintain
02:44:40 um the process that is required under the legislation no fair enough but it would have
02:44:45 been relatively easy for commissioner lucky to reach out to commissioner to creek to say
02:44:49 just in case at some point we get to an emergency that can vacation are there any tools you might
02:44:54 find useful that could have happened right well i i have no knowledge direct knowledge of that
02:44:59 But we were also, over the course of the entire event, witnessing some of the challenges, the very real challenges that law enforcement, the OPP, the RCMP, and many others were experiencing in this event.
02:45:11 And it very much informed our deliberations and consideration of various tools that might be useful to the police response.
02:45:19 Sure, but you're not in the command room anymore, right?
02:45:20 I mean, you're observing from afar, but Commissioner Karik would certainly have the better perspective on it.
02:45:26 No, and I agree, but it's also I think one has to be circumspect about it's not the police that determine what tools would be provided under the Emergencies Act.
02:45:39 We consult with them on some of the challenges that they were facing, but it is a responsibility of government to determine what measures would be appropriate under the Act.
02:45:47 Sure, the decision is made by politicians, but ultimately, in terms of proportionality and using only the tools that are useful and necessary, it's a good idea to reach out to law enforcement, isn't it?
02:45:58 And again, to understand the challenges that they were facing, but not specifically to ask them what additional tools.
02:46:04 I don't believe that would have been appropriate.
02:46:06 I've never been in a circumstances where, you know, that was a question put to a police leader.
02:46:11 What additional legislative tools do you require?
02:46:13 so we heard from from mr the deputy minister mendicino sorry deputy minister
02:46:19 di tamaso that that's what happened before the ontario emergency legislation that he consulted
02:46:23 that way and of course commissioner lucky was consulted for tools but you think it's somehow
02:46:28 inappropriate to ask police for input on this i i i think there is a an appropriate process
02:46:35 um i'm mindful that of deputy excuse me commissioner karek's reporting responsibility
02:46:41 to Deputy Minister Di Tommaso.
02:46:43 I'm also well aware of Commissioner Luckey's reporting relationship to Minister Minichino.
02:46:49 I'm not part of either of those.
02:46:51 All right, okay.
02:46:51 So just so I'm clear, would you disagree then with Commissioner Luckey and Deputy Minister
02:46:55 Stewart that there ought to have been consultation in that regard?
02:46:59 I think consultation on the challenges that the police were facing.
02:47:03 I would not personally have asked what additional legislative authorities they might require,
02:47:09 But it's very helpful to understand the difficulties that they were having with existing authorities.
02:47:14 Right. Now, of course, you're not like most of their cabinet ministers because you're looking at this as a 30 plus year police leader yourself, correct?
02:47:22 Close to 40, I'm afraid.
02:47:23 Right. As a police leader.
02:47:25 But in fairness, I don't have that role anymore.
02:47:28 And I'm mindful of the responsibilities of my current position and that I no longer hold that position.
02:47:33 All right. Fair enough. I'll move on. I've only got a couple of minutes left here.
02:47:36 in your capacity as a politician as a cabinet minister of course you're no longer in the room
02:47:42 the police room so that you're no longer having a direct look at the intelligence reports you have
02:47:49 to rely on your federal law enforcement advisors various agencies to advise you what the situation
02:47:56 is correct yes sir i i i have been regularly briefed by for example the national security
02:48:00 intelligence advisor the rcmp commissioner and the director of cesus but i don't have any line
02:48:06 of sight in into the raw intelligence or many of the reports and you rely on those agencies and
02:48:13 the national security advisor to give you credible and reliable information so that you can make
02:48:18 informed decisions as a cabinet minister yes sir now you mentioned you had never heard of project
02:48:22 tendon and nor would you have any had any reason to correct i i was not familiar with that
02:48:28 subsequently after you know other information came out particularly through testimony i've
02:48:32 heard the phrase but at the time i was not familiar with that portfolio of intelligence
02:48:38 all right now we know from the hendon reports and we've looked at this in some detail that
02:48:41 as early as january the 20th which is a week before the protest started to arrive
02:48:46 that the opp had warned in its reports that this may not be a short protest you've probably heard
02:48:51 some of that evidence yes sir that there was no exit strategy and that some at least some
02:48:55 protesters intended to stay until the demands were met correct i've heard that subsequently right
02:49:01 there was there was conflicting uh information and intelligence that was being made available
02:49:05 uh to me prior to the arrival of the block uh the protests um in in ottawa but you know quite frankly
02:49:12 there was also open source reporting that the that some intended to remain right as a decision
02:49:18 maker it's important to know as much as you can about potential risks of any situation always our
02:49:24 hope and of course intelligence that you get in the hendon reports would be more valuable than
02:49:29 simply uh opening the twitter machine right of course all right i see in exactly my 10 minutes
02:49:34 i need about 45 to 60 seconds can i have it commissioner go ahead i i was hopeful but
02:49:43 all right so not only is important that you would know this information but you want to be told
02:49:46 in a timely way so that you can make appropriate preparations and again there's a decision as to
02:49:51 what information is appropriate to share with cabinet but but of course we want that information
02:49:56 to be as clear as possible not only so that so that we can assess um it's it's it's on its
02:50:02 merits but also its credibility and and so that information could be very important to us and the
02:50:06 reason i ask i go back to a phrase used by my friend for the commission earlier when he talked
02:50:10 about if there's a hurricane moving up the coast you know you want to know well in advance and i'm
02:50:15 not analogizing necessarily between the convoy and hurricane but the earlier you would know the
02:50:19 better correct yes sir just went through hurricane fiona and we were tracking really carefully where
02:50:25 it was going to make landfall right and so your first briefing according to your witness summary
02:50:28 was actually january 27th that's that's in your witness summary yeah i believe that's correct and
02:50:32 that's a full week after the opp reported ahead and about the fact it could be a long protest
02:50:39 i again again sir i didn't have a i didn't have any information about that i'll take your word
02:50:43 for it of course but but i did receive my first briefing i believe on january 27th all right thank
02:50:49 you thank you for the intelligence commissioner much appreciated okay next is uh council for
02:50:55 former chief slowly thank you minister i'm tom curry for your former your former colleague
02:51:11 chief slowly um can i start by asking you a couple of questions about your relationship with
02:51:22 the former chief he was your deputy chief for the period 2009 to 2015 i guess sir
02:51:30 and prior to that i think you told the commissioner that you had worked with him
02:51:34 in the aggregate for 25 years close to it sir i think we first became like he was actually
02:51:40 He was subordinate to me in the division I ran beginning around 1997 or 1998.
02:51:45 Right.
02:51:47 And during the time that you worked with him, he had succeeded under your command in achieving promotions and taking on increasing responsibilities.
02:51:58 Yes, sir.
02:51:59 And you knew him then and now to be an experienced and effective police leader.
02:52:05 Is that true?
02:52:05 Yes, sir. I have great respect for Chief Sloley, Mr. Peter Sloley.
02:52:11 And that included, as I understand it, in matters that concerned public demonstrations.
02:52:19 You mentioned the Tamil demonstrations.
02:52:21 I understand that Chief Sloley, or at that time, not Chief Sloley, but at that time as a member of the Toronto Police Service,
02:52:27 that he was a major incident commander in that respect.
02:52:30 There were a number of my commanders, but Peter also held that role in the service at that time.
02:52:35 And you have seen firsthand his ability to manage successfully large-scale public demonstrations.
02:52:43 And again, I did not have direct observation of Peter dealing with large public order events.
02:52:49 Of course, his actual involvement in the G20, as I recall, was somewhat more limited.
02:52:55 But certainly I recall quite vividly the Tamil protests.
02:52:59 frankly i think we took a very careful measured approach to that and and frankly i've always
02:53:06 been proud of my my services keeping everybody safe in those circumstances including the role
02:53:11 that he played including all of the men and women who were involved in that that effort it was very
02:53:15 much a team effort thank you now the and in that during the time that you were chief of the toronto
02:53:23 police service and and uh deputy chief slowly or chief superintendent he held a number of different
02:53:29 ranks during your tenure he had your confidence and respect yes sir just to be clear if i may
02:53:38 he i i deployed him as my field commander which put him in charge of close to 4 000 of my officers
02:53:44 responsible all of our divisional response which was one of the largest and most significant jobs
02:53:48 in the police service and and during that time you were asked a number of questions by my
02:53:53 my friend for the Ottawa Police Service about the role of a chief and various other aspects of things.
02:54:03 During the time that you worked with Chief Slowley, you just confirmed he had your confidence and respect,
02:54:11 and you saw him in command, and he was a good commander. True?
02:54:14 Yes, sir.
02:54:16 Now, when he came here to the city of Ottawa to become the chief,
02:54:20 you understood also that it was to implement a change mandate on behalf of the police services
02:54:24 board yes sir including in respect of the board's effort to try to improve the relationship between
02:54:33 the ottawa police service and racialized communities marginalized communities yes sir
02:54:39 and those strategies are uh are challenging strategies as an agent of change is that true
02:54:47 I have had considerable experience, Toronto being a very diverse city in bringing about a stronger relationship between the police and the minority communities we serve.
02:54:57 I was going to say that you yourself made improving community policing one of your objectives as Chief of the Toronto Police Service.
02:55:04 Very much so.
02:55:05 And, of course, Deputy Chief, slowly at that time, was an important member of your command team on that score.
02:55:12 Yes, sir.
02:55:12 now when he when he came to ottawa you learned am i right that he faced some opposition from
02:55:22 within the rank and file actually peter reached out to me upon his appointment and we met and
02:55:28 at his he requested we went and we had breakfast and we talked about the challenges of taking in
02:55:33 over a new organization and the change agenda he was hoping to implement got it now the turning
02:55:39 for just one second to the to the events of the convoy protests uh you've already said in your
02:55:45 statement and to to my friends that these were unprecedented events in your nearly 40 years of
02:55:51 police and you've never seen anything like this there were certain aspects of it that were unique
02:55:55 and uniquely challenging and in terms of the questions that you were just asked by my friend
02:56:00 on behalf of the opp about what could have been known or foreseen i won't take you to the documents
02:56:06 because there are a number of them, and I won't take the time.
02:56:11 But were you aware that representatives of the RCMP, the OPP,
02:56:16 the Surete de Québec Parliamentary Protective Service
02:56:20 all reviewed the Ottawa Police Service plan for the convoy?
02:56:27 I'm not aware of that activity, sir. I had no hindsight to it.
02:56:31 Or that you wouldn't be aware that the OPP,
02:56:34 one member of the OPP, described the OPS plan for managing the convoy in advance as a robust plan.
02:56:42 Again, I've not seen any documents with respect to that. I have no knowledge of it.
02:56:46 Fair enough. And it's as I understand it, you haven't you yourself haven't you aren't second
02:56:54 guessing the Ottawa Police Services plan or the plan that was reviewed by those other police
02:56:59 services in advance of the convoy. No, sir. And quite frankly, I have no insight into the
02:57:03 plan. I don't inquire about the plan. I only needed some assurance that one was in place.
02:57:08 And then once it was here and it became a very different protest leading eventually to an
02:57:16 occupation, you understood that the Ottawa Police Service on its own lacked the resources to manage
02:57:21 it successfully. That had been made clear to me, yes. And you accepted that? Yes, sir. Now,
02:57:27 Now, let me just take you to one document that one of my friends had projected for a second, just while I have it.
02:57:35 SSM, please, Mr. Registrar, SSM, NSC, C-A-N, 2983.
02:57:43 Minister, this was shown to you a moment ago.
02:57:45 I'm just going to ask you to look at a different line than the one that was shown.
02:57:52 Thank you.
02:57:53 Just scroll down if you don't mind.
02:57:54 please keep keep going and keep going a little bit there thank you stop I doubt you wrote this
02:58:03 I doubt Peter is getting a lot of support in his own organization they are likely sitting back
02:58:09 and waiting for him to flounder and then the line that was read to you earlier about
02:58:14 lack of a strong support network within other police leadership just focusing on the first
02:58:21 part of that sentence, it was your concern that members of his own police service, the Ottawa
02:58:27 Police Service, were not supporting this chief. And if I may, just to be very fair here, I have
02:58:35 no information. I have no insight into, you know, what was going on within the Ottawa Police
02:58:40 headquarters. I don't know. I don't know the men and women under his command or anything that may
02:58:44 have, you know, we've heard some evidence since, but I had no sense of that. But I was concerned
02:58:50 because in a conversation Peter Knight had upon his appointment
02:58:55 that he was coming in with a strong change mandate,
02:58:58 and I know how challenging that can be.
02:59:01 And the expression to hear in this text or message
02:59:06 was a very real concern for you.
02:59:10 Is that fair?
02:59:11 That you were concerned that his own command team
02:59:15 or at least members of his own organization
02:59:17 would sit back and wait for him to flounder not support him in the expectation that perhaps he
02:59:23 would fail and pay a price not unlike the one that you were invited to comment about by his
02:59:29 own police service in their questions to you well and and again to be fair i i was speculating here
02:59:35 and and i don't wanted to characterize this as based on any factual information that was available
02:59:41 to me but i i was concerned um that that that in in a very challenging set of circumstances
02:59:50 it's really cohesion within the command structure is really really important and i was concerned
02:59:55 that that cohesion may not have been as strong as it needed to be understood and of course one
03:00:00 cannot lead an organization that does not wish to to be led very easily right i know a little bit
03:00:10 about the challenge of leading a large police organization and i think leadership is very
03:00:15 important but i would also say leadership doesn't exist just in the chief's office there's leadership
03:00:19 throughout the entire organization and it and that leadership has to be mobilized to get the job done
03:00:24 understood now a couple of things if i may please um the the um i want to ask you if i could about
03:00:34 rfa requests for assistance can i just ask you please to confirm that the solicitor general
03:00:39 ontario asked for the use of the cartier drill hall you recall this yes sir and am i right that
03:00:46 the solicitor general ontario asked for that for that use of the cartier drill hall parking lot
03:00:52 for two days being the weekend of the protest yes sir and i i also recall being able to give a
03:00:58 positive answer to that request right and you've exactly you made that available just for the record
03:01:02 commissioner ss i don't want to see it but ssm can four five uh six four um minister you you spoke
03:01:12 about uh just in terms of the role of the chief could you help the com this commissioner please
03:01:17 with this question during the operations in respect of that tamil protest in your witness
03:01:22 statement i won't take you to it but you described how or i think today you described how you directed
03:01:27 operations when when you needed to as the chief in terms of keeping the the protesters safe on the
03:01:34 off ramps and and just to be very clear i was taking advice and guidance from my operational
03:01:39 commanders on the ground who told me that this situation couldn't be resolved utilizing our
03:01:44 normal public order tactics without putting people at significant risk and and and therefore
03:01:50 it was on their advice that i made the decision that that we would engage with these people and
03:01:55 find um another way to resolve understood and in the same way i think in your witness statement i
03:02:01 don't want to turn it up see if this recall if you recall this it's paragraph five for the record
03:02:06 you you reviewed and approved plans as the chief concerning the g20 protests yes sir and and in
03:02:13 fact as the chief of police there were literally dozens of protests taking place in toronto every
03:02:19 single week and and i for the larger events would have those operational plans presented to me
03:02:25 for my awareness the the the command structure for those events was not the chief doesn't
03:02:32 command those events we actually maintained a very robust um command structure for for those
03:02:38 types of events and i think the language that you used in your statement was uh that you would
03:02:43 review those approve them and and then present them to the board yes sir thank you now um
03:02:49 Commissioner, I'm going to go a little over time with your consent, only because my friends
03:02:56 for the commission introduced a few new things through the minister about police services.
03:02:59 Yeah, no, you're already over time, so don't get me wrong, you're already there.
03:03:04 So I'm going to see what I can do as quickly as I can do it, but thank you for that.
03:03:10 The resources.
03:03:14 You mentioned to the commissioner that you received a request for resources
03:03:18 from Windsor for the Ambassador Bridge blockade. Can you confirm that you received those
03:03:28 via a letter directly from the chief of police to you, and one similarly went to Minister Jones?
03:03:35 Yes, sir. We did, in fact, receive that letter. It wasn't something that I, frankly,
03:03:40 I'm not authorized to deal with, a request for assistance coming from a municipal police chief,
03:03:44 but it was referred back to other officials to deal with.
03:03:48 Right, understood.
03:03:48 But in that respect, regarding Windsor,
03:03:51 the request for resources came to you as the minister,
03:03:54 to Minister Jones, for her counterpart.
03:03:58 There was an urgent need for resources
03:04:00 and you did what you could to send them urgently.
03:04:03 Fair?
03:04:04 I think in fairness, it was the OPP
03:04:06 that responded to the Windsor situation.
03:04:09 And again, I stand to be corrected,
03:04:12 but I understood that the Windsor Police Chief utilized the authorities under the existing Police Services Act
03:04:19 in order to seek out the assistance in support of the OPP.
03:04:22 So I think, I won't take you to it, but just for the record, Commissioner,
03:04:25 WIN 1648 and 1649 are letters not directed under the Police Services Act,
03:04:31 rather directly to you and to the Minister.
03:04:33 Yes, sir.
03:04:34 You passed them on and the resources came from the RCMP and the OPP,
03:04:38 but nobody followed the Police Services Act protocol in Windsor.
03:04:41 I'm not sure, sir. My understanding is with the OPP involvement there, they essentially led that response. That was my understanding.
03:04:50 And the Police Services Act protocol to which you referred isn't mandatory in respect of a sequencing.
03:04:58 It is there, but police services, including at the time that you were the chief in Toronto, gain resources through memorandum of agreement and other requests through police services, right?
03:05:08 Generally for planned events, yes.
03:05:11 When I made reference in my early remarks to the Police Services Act and the provision within the act for a chief of police to deal with an emergency that exceeds their capacity, there is that provision in the act.
03:05:23 But I am in agreement, sir, that quite routinely for a lot of these events, they reach out to neighboring police services and people come to help each other as best they can.
03:05:30 And what you observed from Chief Slowly was that he was trying his best to get the support he needed for the community to keep the protest safe and his own service safe, correct?
03:05:43 He was certainly advocating for what he believed to be the necessary resources.
03:05:47 And your observation was that he acted in good faith in the performance of his duties?
03:05:51 I did not detect any element of bad faith.
03:05:54 and that he did you were you made aware i assume that you weren't you did not know of the plans
03:06:00 that the ops had their evolution and the approvals that chief slowly chief slowly's team gave to those
03:06:06 plans no sir as i've previously testified i i made no inquiry and received no information of
03:06:11 the operational plans that were either being developed or in place the information that you
03:06:16 received as a minister and in cabinet came in respect of police services and resources through
03:06:22 Commissioner Luckey, is that fair? Primarily through Commissioner Luckey, yes. And are you aware
03:06:26 that certain of the information that you received turned out not to be accurate in terms of the
03:06:32 resources? I'll give you a couple of examples that you were aware of what has been described,
03:06:37 I think, by Deputy Commissioner Duhame to the Commissioner as a mix-up about the 250 RCMP
03:06:44 officers. I'm not familiar with Deputy Duhame's testimony. I wasn't following it. What about
03:06:51 minister jones 1500 opp officers on the ground in in ottawa were you aware she made that statement
03:06:58 i'm not okay or that therefore that it was inaccurate you wouldn't have known that
03:07:03 no sir a couple of last things and if i may you you uh i think in your evidence in your
03:07:12 statement have described that you had requested or spoken with chief slowly about the possibility
03:07:17 of tagging vehicles and towing vehicles he explained to you why that was not possible
03:07:22 as a matter of safe enforcement and you accepted his his conclusion and did you did you know that
03:07:29 rcmp and opp officials were urging ops through chief slowly and others to not take enforcement
03:07:36 steps because in ottawa they lacked resources to do so safely i'm not aware of that if they did you
03:07:43 would again defer to them as them and the ops as to the people with the best line of sight into that
03:07:50 of course chief slowly gave me an explanation and i accepted that he was the chief of police
03:07:56 and that was his belief last thing then please if if i could because of course you know minister
03:08:03 from the nature of the questions that you've been asked that there's a great deal of of scrutiny
03:08:09 about what Chief Peter Slowley did here in Ottawa.
03:08:12 Can you agree that in hindsight that more could have been done
03:08:16 and sooner to assist Chief Slowley and the OPS
03:08:20 to secure the assistance of resources?
03:08:22 I believe with the clarity of hindsight, sir,
03:08:25 that there were a number of steps that upon reflection,
03:08:28 I think everyone involved would have liked to have seen a quicker outcome.
03:08:33 I'm very mindful of the enormous impact this was having
03:08:36 on the people of Ottawa in particular.
03:08:37 and and because of some of the other then related protest activities across the country was huge
03:08:43 hugely impactful upon all Canadians and so the the timeliness of of resolving that I think was
03:08:50 it was important to all of us and in hindsight I think that's it's also our responsibility
03:08:54 to learn from that experience and make sure that we can do it better next time. And in hindsight
03:09:01 nothing more chiefs really could have done individually to make a difference. Well again
03:09:05 you did that that's a judgment but i don't have enough information to make respectfully um but
03:09:10 but at the same time time i think we we all need to reflect on how we could have resolved this
03:09:14 quicker and more peace more effectively thank you commissioner thank you minister okay next is uh
03:09:22 and now we're into the shorter more challenging uh timelines uh city of ottawa
03:09:35 Thank you, Commissioner. I'll do my best. Minister, my name is Alyssa Tompkins. I'm
03:09:44 one of the lawyers representing the City of Ottawa. So I will try to be quick. I do want
03:09:50 to take you to a couple documents, though. So first document, Mr. Clerk, ssm.nsc.can
03:09:59 uh four zeros two nine nine three
03:10:11 so this is one of the texts between you and your chief of staff and it's just this comment so if
03:10:19 we see there uh a date below uh thursday february 10th but i'm actually looking at one of the
03:10:26 comments above and i believe if we scroll up um because i believe these are uh produced by your
03:10:34 chief of staff so your texts are the ones on the left and there's in white yes sir and there's a
03:10:40 comment that says uh and it's not really going to help in ottawa unless the opp take over here
03:10:46 i just want to know what you meant by the opp taking over i i i again i'm not entirely clear
03:10:53 on the context of this because there's clearly conversation that was taking place before
03:10:58 but i i i believe that um it was going to be necessary for the opp to to have a much greater
03:11:05 operational role in in this in in the resolution of this event for for public order okay and if
03:11:13 the next document we can go to ssm.nsc.can403140 um more text messages between you and your chiefs
03:11:38 of staff now here it's just forwarding tweets but there's a tweet being forwarded from robert fife
03:11:44 that says this is what ontario government sources have said was coming she slowly pushed aside to
03:11:50 allow opp rcmp to take charge of 16 days of chaos in downtown i think you then forward a text from
03:11:58 glenn mcgregor maybe the opp will help i'm just wondering particularly with respect to the text
03:12:03 from mr fife um the he's hearing from ontario government sources that uh opp and rcmp are
03:12:11 coming i was just wondering sir whether you ever heard anything to that effect from the
03:12:16 province no no ma'am my only knowledge of of this information was what mr fife was tweeting
03:12:21 and that's why i shared it with my chief of staff okay no those are those are my questions uh thank
03:12:26 you very much sir well under your time okay next is the ottawa coalition
03:12:43 thank you commissioner i'll try to be as efficient as my friend miss domkins
03:12:47 uh minister my name is paul champ i'm one of the lawyers for the ottawa coalition of residents and
03:12:51 businesses um as the toronto police chief for 10 years uh minister i gather you to become very
03:12:58 familiar with the police services act yes sir in ontario and you know that at the police services
03:13:03 act uh the mayor of a city is by default a member of the police services board unless he or she
03:13:09 delegates it i'm aware that that it is it is a position that that they get ex-officio but they
03:13:17 they can delegate it to others. And I'm also aware of many municipalities where the mayor
03:13:21 chooses not to sit on the board. And in your last, I think the last mayor you had when you were chief
03:13:27 is Mayor Tory, he sat on the board? Not while I was the chief, sir. I don't, well, perhaps maybe
03:13:33 for a few months, but only a few months. You were near the end. I was kind of on my way out the door.
03:13:37 One foot out the door. And prior to that, it was chief, actually Mayor Miller had served on the
03:13:43 board for a period of time not his entire term right mayor ford didn't choose to we won't go
03:13:48 into that uh no sir um now you convened tripartite meetings on february 7th 8th and 10th with uh
03:13:55 intended to be the municipal provincial and federal levels of government is that right
03:13:58 that had been my hope yes and uh you had uh from ottawa uh city manager steve cantalucos
03:14:05 and mayor jim watson is that right yes and when you dealt with mayor watson uh you would have
03:14:10 assumed he was chair of the police services board is that right i don't think i was making that
03:14:14 assumption i i'm not aware of that did you know if he was the chief or if the if he was on the
03:14:19 board or not no and i apologize but i'm not that familiar with ottawa council or its board right
03:14:25 but given your um familiarity with the police services act uh would you not have wanted to
03:14:30 deal with uh someone from the police services board who actually has some operational uh guidance and
03:14:36 responsibility over the ottawa police if i may i don't think that's an appropriate um discussion
03:14:43 for a minister of the federal government to engage with the chair of a municipal police services
03:14:47 board my intention in establishing the tripartite table was to bring the three orders of government
03:14:52 right and and i and i use that word advisedly by the way because i don't believe in levels
03:14:55 there are orders of government the federal provincial and the municipal um governments
03:15:00 all had a responsibility to to work together to collaborate and it was my intention to convene
03:15:06 that discussion but i gather then though if you were sharing information with uh the mayor and
03:15:13 the city manager uh that was relevant uh for the police services board you would have assumed the
03:15:18 mayor and the city manager would have shared that information the police services i again i make no
03:15:22 assumptions about those discussions my intention was to bring the federal provincial and municipal
03:15:27 governments to the table but to do what sir it's about managing the police services no sir it's
03:15:33 It's about managing the protest that was taking place in Ottawa.
03:15:36 It was hugely impactful.
03:15:37 There is a police, obviously a police responsibility there, but respectfully, I don't believe it is my place.
03:15:44 And I've always been meticulously careful not to in any way interfere with police operations.
03:15:49 I believe, you know, the city clearly has a role with that with their police services board, but not directly from me.
03:15:55 Now, we know from your testimony or for your witness statement as well that it appears that there was indeed a lack, a delay in resources, RCMP resources being provided to the City of Ottawa, in part because there wasn't a firm plan in place for the deployment of those resources, correct?
03:16:12 There are a number of reasons I've come to learn as to some of the challenges of deploying those resources.
03:16:18 Some of them were also deployed in a number of functions, as I understood it, that were dispersed from the downtown core.
03:16:23 but you you and on your witness statement anyway sir uh which i understand you've adopted you said
03:16:29 one of the first one of the main reasons was that there was not a firm operational plan in place and
03:16:34 and and that's true mr champ there was a concern that we were hearing from not just the rcmp but
03:16:40 other police services that they wanted confidence that an operational action plan was was in place
03:16:48 before they were able to deploy their resources and you would have agreed with me sir that would
03:16:51 been important for that information to be shared by someone in some way with the Ottawa Police
03:16:56 Services Board? I'm going to object. This is, again, Alyssa Tompkins. Chair Deans, in her witness
03:17:05 statement, stated that she knew that there was not, that there was a concern that there wasn't
03:17:12 a plan. And my friend keeps putting that to witnesses to try to get them to agree. When her
03:17:17 witness summary which she adopted on cross and confirmed uh states expressly that she was aware
03:17:24 that well i'm ready for my friend this time if i may commissioner uh the testimony of uh
03:17:29 ms deans was that that was her speculation but she was never told that by anyone no one shared
03:17:34 that information she was concerned that she wasn't getting detail in the plan she was wondering why
03:17:38 there was a delay but no one shared that information that's what's in her statement
03:17:42 that's what her testimony was when she testified in fact her statements suggest that she's the
03:17:45 one that suggests okay well let's try and keep this can you just uh i i just want to be careful
03:17:53 because it's an important point and my friend keeps putting it to witnesses i'll be sending
03:17:58 a letter to my friend after this but i just want to close with this miss uh minister um you would
03:18:05 agree with me that it would be inappropriate for a federal government official to be
03:18:10 uh trying to influence the police services board on the selection of a
03:18:14 chief of police or to delay a decision of appointing of chief of police for municipal service
03:18:21 i can i can speak for myself sir i would not engage in in in that behavior if if my advice
03:18:28 was asked on on a matter i might provide the advice but but but as you characterize it i'm
03:18:33 trying to influence or interfere with that decision i don't believe that would be appropriate okay
03:18:36 thank you very much of course okay next is uh the windsor police service
03:18:46 hi good evening heather patterson here for the windsor police service uh good evening
03:18:51 minister blair can you hear me okay yes ma'am thank you in your testimony today you praise
03:18:58 the ottawa enforcement operation uh because and i'm going to paraphrase what you said you said
03:19:03 because it moved slowly it took care and it allowed for the least amount of force possible
03:19:10 i think you described it as a textbook operation yes then would sorry would you agree that it's a
03:19:16 hallmark of good police enforcement that that type of slow careful um least amount of force
03:19:23 possible type operation i i yes i would i would certainly characterize that police operation as
03:19:30 proportional measured charter compliance and appropriate great and you praise the ottawa
03:19:37 enforcement action even though you had to explain to colleagues the need for police to move slowly
03:19:42 and carefully in an enforcement operation i i i don't that's probably inappropriate to
03:19:48 characterize that i needed to explain to co to colleagues but i have some familiarity with
03:19:54 those operations and what i was witnessing here in ottawa or textbook and entirely appropriate
03:20:02 and i certainly shared that with colleagues okay so then let me put it to you this way would you
03:20:07 agree it's important to move slowly with an enforcement operation even when others feel
03:20:11 there's a sense of urgency and and and again i think the the response is it depends on on the
03:20:18 urgent nature if if someone was being injured for some for example i think under those circumstances
03:20:24 one might want to go a little quicker, and it'd be necessary.
03:20:27 But I think a methodical, measured, and proportional response,
03:20:32 every public order response is in part determined by the actions of the other side, the protesters.
03:20:39 And if their behavior is less aggressive, then that type of approach is entirely appropriate.
03:20:48 Okay. And would you agree that that equally applies to the situation in Windsor and the Ambassador Bridge?
03:20:54 oh yes um and would you agree that citizen and after officer safety is the forefront in any
03:21:01 public order operation i i believe certainly in in public safety and that includes officer safety
03:21:06 as a priority in every operation and you would agree with that despite the fact that you felt
03:21:12 there was a need for urgency of action in windsor i i was very concerned about about the blockade
03:21:17 of that of that roadway and and that there wasn't a need for urgency but but at the same time you
03:21:23 the operational decisions made by the police commanders on the ground,
03:21:26 knowing the challenges they face, the resources available to them
03:21:30 and their legal authorities, I respect the decisions that they make.
03:21:34 Okay, great.
03:21:36 Mr. Sololi's counsel briefly referred to the letter you received
03:21:41 from Chief Mizuno on February 9th requesting assistance from Windsor.
03:21:45 Yes.
03:21:46 Just for the record, I don't need to see it.
03:21:48 It's WPS 60788.
03:21:51 and you advised that you passed that along to others but didn't respond to it directly is that
03:21:57 correct to the best of my recollection it is not part of the process that i'm responsible for the
03:22:03 request for assistance to receive requests directly from a municipal police chief those
03:22:09 requests come through provincial and territorial ministers and it was referred to the best of my
03:22:15 knowledge to the appropriate minister in the ontario government did you know who that minister
03:22:20 was i believe it would be the solicitor general sylvia jones okay and if i but if i may be clear
03:22:27 that that was likely done through officials um i i don't want to suggest that it was done directly
03:22:32 to minister jones but it would have been done in likely in all likelihood from federal officials
03:22:37 to provincial officials to make sure that that information was properly shared okay great and
03:22:42 And Mr. Clerk, could you please pull up SSM CAN NSC 402671?
03:22:52 And while that's coming up, you're
03:22:53 going to see that after receiving the WPS request,
03:22:58 this seems to be a draft between Carolyn Williams and Rady Barak.
03:23:04 These are members of your staff, correct?
03:23:08 Yes.
03:23:11 and did you direct them to prepare a draft response to chief mizuno's letter
03:23:16 we we tried to respond to every bit of correspondence and just
03:23:19 and not leave it simply unanswered okay and if we go down towards the end of
03:23:24 page one
03:23:28 um we see that this is a draft but i've never been able to find
03:23:33 whether it was actually sent or not do you do you know no i'm afraid i don't
03:23:38 okay and if you look um in the last paragraph on that page it says local communities are the
03:23:46 ones ultimately paying the price for the actions of these demonstrators uh do you agree with that
03:23:51 sentiment i i think certainly the the local communities are we're in fact being significantly
03:23:57 impacted by these actions and by these blockades and demonstrations that were taking place
03:24:02 okay and would you agree it's vital that government ensure that police have resources
03:24:07 required to maintain public safety to bring and bring about a peaceful resolution to a public
03:24:13 order of it i believe people keeping people safe is the first responsibility of every order of
03:24:18 government and and to provide whatever resources are available to assist law enforcement in their
03:24:24 in affecting their purpose great thank you commissioner i just have three more questions
03:24:29 if i could have a brief indulgence as long as they're short yes they will be um and are you
03:24:35 aware the ambassador bridge is privately owned yes and you're aware that it's the windsor police
03:24:41 that will respond to incidents on the bridge such as a traffic accident i would have anticipated yes
03:24:48 okay and we looked uh earlier this afternoon at a february 12
03:24:52 uh text exchange that you had for the record ssm nsc can 3129 i don't need to see it unless
03:25:00 you do minister but this is where you said police are finally doing their job in windsor
03:25:06 yes um are you aware that the enforcement action took place over february 12th and 13th
03:25:13 yes and that the bridge was opened in the early hour mornings of february 14th yes i watched it
03:25:18 very carefully i was very concerned about the blockades at the at the ambassador bridge and so
03:25:22 you would agree that any difficulties the opp or the wps were having in windsor were resolved before
03:25:28 the emergency act was invoked i i was aware that they had been able to move that that protest i
03:25:35 was also aware of of concerns that they were expressing to us that that that those blockades
03:25:41 could either go to some other place or or could return to windsor and what we had heard very
03:25:46 clearly from the police is although they had been effective in clearing it there was real concern
03:25:51 as to whether they could hold it open okay thank you and lastly would you agree with me that the
03:25:56 windsor enforcement operation was a success yes there was no loss of life or serious injury to
03:26:01 either the public protesters or police yes ma'am thank you very much those are my questions
03:26:07 okay thank you next uh call on the city of windsor
03:26:16 Good evening, Minister. My name is Jennifer King. I am legal counsel to the City of Windsor.
03:26:24 Minister Blair, I would like to start by confirming your views about the unlawfulness of the blockade
03:26:29 in Windsor. Mr. Clerk, if you could please pull up PB NSC CAN 402437. While this is coming up,
03:26:38 can you confirm, Minister Blair, is it your opinion that the blockade in Windsor was
03:26:42 unlawful from the outset that is when the protesters blockaded the bridge access to the
03:26:49 bridge on february the 7th yeah yes i believe that that was unlawful i i believe there are
03:26:55 relevant statutes municipal although i don't have a deep knowledge of your municipal bylaws but
03:27:00 certainly within the ontario highway traffic act and even criminal code offenses that uh were
03:27:05 relevant to the situation okay so what we're i'm showing you is a transcript of a media availability
03:27:11 that you held on February the 9th at 1 p.m. with Ministers Mendicino and Alhambra.
03:27:18 Do you recall that media availability?
03:27:20 I did several of them that week and the next,
03:27:23 but I don't have a specific recollection of this unless you bring me to a specific point.
03:27:26 Okay, so this was one on February the 9th.
03:27:29 It's the first media availability that I've been able to find
03:27:32 or statements that you made about the blockade at the Ambassador Bridge.
03:27:36 My friends will let me know if there was an earlier one.
03:27:39 Have you seen this transcript that's on the screen?
03:27:42 If you could just scroll down a little bit, Mr. Clerk.
03:27:52 I've actually not seen this transcript, but if you could scroll down.
03:27:55 And by the way, I think I likely used the word thuggery, not thuddery.
03:27:59 Okay.
03:28:00 Well, Mr. Clerk, if you could please scroll to the bottom of page three.
03:28:03 and you'll see here I think at page three of the
03:28:09 PDF I apologize I might not have the right spot
03:28:18 you could scroll up please
03:28:24 all right so I don't seem to have the right spot but instead of wasting time and scrolling through
03:28:33 the transcript i'm just going to read to you some of the parts of your transcript so in the
03:28:37 transcript you state these blockades are unlawful um and i would urge all of those who are engaging
03:28:44 in this unlawful activity think about the people you are truly hurting and stop let me be very
03:28:49 clear the ambassador bridge is a vital artery to our country and it's a vital artery to our supply
03:28:54 chain it's central to the functioning of our economy and to serving all canadians do you recall
03:28:59 making those comments yes and later in your remarks you referred to the protesters unlawful
03:29:04 actions blocking ports of entry as essentially putting their foot on the throat of all canadians
03:29:10 do you recall that yes and in your remarks you also state that the rule of law has to be upheld
03:29:15 and canada will ensure police have the resources they need to uphold the law and keep the peace
03:29:20 right yes your opinions reflected in these remarks have not changed since february have they no sir
03:29:26 no ma'am i take it you made these statements to national media to make it clear to the public
03:29:30 and to the protesters that protested protesting by blockading ports of entry is unlawful
03:29:35 correct yes and that the protesters should stop yes are you aware that the same day as this media
03:29:41 availability that it was widely reported by american and canadian media that you and your
03:29:46 fellow ministers labeled the bridge blockade as illegal i didn't have the opportunity to read
03:29:51 the american press but i'm not surprised okay but the protesters did not stop did they
03:29:57 no okay um i have a few questions uh minister blair about um
03:30:06 planning around critical infrastructure so um will you agree with me that systems of support
03:30:13 should be in place to support the communities and local authorities who are most often the
03:30:17 first responders to emergencies i i would agree that local communities are often the very first
03:30:25 impacted i i would try to make the point though the blockaded ambassador bridge went well beyond
03:30:31 that intersection in windsor was affecting auto plants for example right across the province and
03:30:37 in in michigan that you know a lot of people were being deeply impacted but certainly i would
03:30:41 acknowledge how difficult that was in ottawa and in windsor minister blair are you aware that shortly
03:30:49 after the successful police operation windsor representatives including mayor dilkins started
03:30:54 asking all three levels of government to sit down and develop a long-term sustainable framework to
03:30:59 protect the critical border infrastructure i did not have a direct conversation with with mayor
03:31:04 dilkins but i believe my colleague did well minister uh are you aware that minister mayor
03:31:09 dilkins wrote to you directly on march the 17th if you share it with me i'll refresh my memory i
03:31:14 have no direct recollection of that letter from mayor dillkins although we've communicated quite
03:31:19 extensively over the course of the pandemic and other related matters okay well i i will ask the
03:31:24 clerk to bring this up this is win four zeros two two four zero so he sent you a letter on march the
03:31:30 17th and just to summarize it for you and you can see it but i don't have very much time minister
03:31:36 um he does ask for you and minister mendicino and former solicitor general jones to sit down
03:31:43 to debrief and work together to protect windsor's important international border crossings you don't
03:31:48 recall receiving this letter i have no direct recollection of it but but it it strikes me as
03:31:53 a reasonable request from the mayor okay and mr blair are you taking any steps as minister of
03:31:59 emergency management to ensure the inter-jurisdictional collaboration that's requested
03:32:04 by mayor delkins here and the planning occurs to protect border infrastructures and the communities
03:32:10 around them there's a great deal of work ongoing about creating a more resilient critical
03:32:14 infrastructure for this country from all hazards um including what we have seen um over the course
03:32:20 of last year and if i may i'm over my time um are you taking any steps as a minister of emergency
03:32:28 management to ensure that municipalities and border municipalities are included in these
03:32:32 conversations i can tell you in every community that i go to i try to go and visit the mayor i
03:32:37 believe very much in all three orders of government have a role here and and and i and i as i said
03:32:43 i've engaged with mayor tilkins numerous occasions and and many of the mayors particularly the border
03:32:48 mayors throughout the pandemic i'm on a very regular basis with all of the mayors of ontario
03:32:53 border communities they had some important things to say and and they needed to be heard thank you
03:32:58 very much okay thank you i'd like to now call on the province of alberta
03:33:07 good evening minister blair my name is stephanie bose i'm council for the province of alberta
03:33:14 i'd like to start with a document ssm.can 406055
03:33:28 And if Mr. Clerk, if you could scroll down to the last email on this page, or sorry,
03:33:38 in this document, it'll be on the next page.
03:33:42 And this is an email dated February 9th from Mr. Stratfest to you, subject line ABRFA.
03:33:51 And if you scroll down to the text, please, Mr. Clerk, you'll see the text on the letter
03:33:56 itself john broadhead and i spoke and i think we revised the response about exhausting provincial
03:34:01 resources and enforcing contracts and laws and we look forward to learning more on that front
03:34:07 so it's not a no just more context now i understand mr broadhead is the director of policy
03:34:14 in the pmo is that correct yes do you know what the reference to it's not a no is about
03:34:22 i i believe i do i was very concerned when i heard back from the deputy minister and the
03:34:28 canadian armed forces that they did not have the equipment that minister macgyver had requested in
03:34:33 his request for assistance and so i asked my my staff and public safety to explore other areas
03:34:39 of government to see if there was any way that we could provide assistance uh to um to alberta and
03:34:46 we looked for example in other in other federal departments we look outside the country in in
03:34:50 montana um we were looking for any way that we if the calf equipment was not appropriate or available
03:34:57 we were looking to see if there was any alternative that we could help out there with all right thank
03:35:01 you um at ssm.can.nsc 402689 this was a record that commission council put to you earlier today
03:35:18 um and i'll ask the clerk to please pull that up the version that you saw today was
03:35:23 redacted and i understand that that was only recently supplied and when we review this um
03:35:30 this is an email from again your chief of staff on february 11th if we scroll down
03:35:40 we see an email from rady barrack to you on february 11th
03:35:44 within the the next page we see a response further i understand that alberta has the
03:35:52 required legal authorities necessary to enforce compliance as a highway is considered essential
03:35:58 infrastructure and it goes on there are a number of contraventions or other applicable legislation
03:36:04 that may also be enforced by alberta and its police forces so at that point in time the reason
03:36:11 for rejecting alberta's rfa was in fact that the position of government of canada was that alberta
03:36:17 had the required legal authorities is that correct yeah if you could read down through
03:36:22 the entire letter because i i want to see how that this is dealt with
03:36:31 and and and i think it's also it's relevant that in the last paragraph where the letter
03:36:37 also refers to the lack of commercial resources the canadian armed forces being the only federal
03:36:41 asset and discussions that make clear that calf have neither the type of assets required nor the
03:36:46 expertise to do this without significant possible risk so it was an answer to minister macgyver's
03:36:52 specific request for tow trucks belonging to calf and and it was i think it was important context for
03:36:57 this letter as well but certainly also the position of canada was that alberta still had authorities
03:37:03 that it could exercise to deal with the blockade at coots correct there is some reference to to
03:37:07 that in this in this letter yes okay thank you if we scroll down to the last paragraph in the letter
03:37:19 there's reference there to the use of federal resources may be reconsidered at a future date
03:37:26 once all other provincial options and capabilities have been exhausted what was meant by that
03:37:33 Well, again, we were also examining across all of government.
03:37:38 We were also talking about the possibility of providing funding to assist them in acquiring through private and commercial means the vehicles that they required.
03:37:47 But, of course, contingent on all other provincial options and capabilities having been exhausted, correct?
03:37:52 Well, and again, not just exhausted or unlikely to succeed.
03:37:58 I think that's a reasonable consideration as well.
03:38:01 I think we were trying to communicate.
03:38:03 My concern, quite frankly, is I felt a necessity to reply to Minister MacGyver,
03:38:08 who had made a request to give him the information.
03:38:11 He very specifically asked for something, and we were saying no.
03:38:15 And I think as you saw in the email above this, I was concerned that we weren't able to say yes,
03:38:22 but I was also concerned that we needed to reply to his letter.
03:38:27 and that reference of course is to the at the very top when you approve this response is the
03:38:32 response to go to alberta yep and then i'll ask you mr clerk to please go up to the top
03:38:37 there's a reference to has the pmo approved and i take the pmo to be the prime minister's office
03:38:43 is that correct that's the usual uh that acronym represents the prime minister's office for sure
03:38:49 and was it a requirement that the prime minister's office approve a response to an rfa i'm i no not
03:38:56 not normally um but clearly there was communication between uh the offices about because there's also
03:39:02 an issue of inter-government affairs between ourselves and the provinces um i think there
03:39:07 was a complexity to this request because it involved a number of different ministries
03:39:11 and it was on it was an unusual outcome because we always try to find a way to say yes
03:39:17 do you know if the prime minister's office ever did approve a response to alberta's rfa i have
03:39:21 have no knowledge of that i'm not involved in those those communications all right there is
03:39:27 reference um in the the records um to your chief of staff um arranging a february 9th meeting with
03:39:35 the prime minister to discuss the rfa were you aware of those discussions no okay thank you um
03:39:43 i am over my time i would ask the indulgence of the commissioner for a couple more minutes
03:39:47 just to touch on two more things please okay go ahead but try and make it fast everyone's been over
03:39:54 with one exception as i recall all right um mr clerk could you please pull up document
03:40:00 ssm.nsc.can403164 and this is an email dated february 17th from you to your chief of staff
03:40:13 minister blair yes i'll have you scroll down a little bit to that to that second email it says
03:40:21 zeta this letter from alberta is incredibly helpful they are asking for federal assistance
03:40:26 they say have they've exhausted all existing authorities and resources they are practically
03:40:31 begging for us to help we should think about publishing this i'll take it this is reference
03:40:35 to the february 5th rfa that your office received from minister mckiver is that correct yes
03:40:43 All right. You wanted this letter to be published as support for Government of Canada's invocation of the Emergencies Act, correct?
03:40:50 My intention was that it would be published because we were putting documentary evidence before Parliament.
03:40:55 There was an ongoing parliamentary debate and there was a vote scheduled for the following week.
03:40:59 And my recommendation, because specifically Minister MacGyver had talked about the RCMP exhausting,
03:41:07 the language isn't in front of me, but I believe his letter said, all of their resources and options.
03:41:13 And I thought that was particularly relevant to the discussion around the invocation of the act.
03:41:19 But you were also aware prior to the invocation of the act of Alberta's success in purchasing tow equipment, correct?
03:41:26 I was aware that they purchased tow equipment.
03:41:28 And I also was aware that it had become somewhat moot
03:41:33 because after the investigation by the RCMP,
03:41:37 the seizure of weapons and the arrest
03:41:38 of a number of individuals,
03:41:40 the blockade that existed at Coutts,
03:41:45 most of those people skedaddled. 0.64
03:41:47 All right, thank you.
03:41:48 One last record to put before you,
03:41:50 that's pb.can401132.
03:41:55 And this is an appearance that you, a transcript of an appearance you had on Global News on
03:42:02 February 13th at 11 a.m. Eastern Time.
03:42:17 And if you scroll down, please, Mr. Clerk, to page two.
03:42:24 a question from mercedes stevenson you can see it now just at the bottom of your screen are you
03:42:29 prepared to invoke the emergencies act it's not on the bottom of my screen but sorry can you can
03:42:34 you scroll down there please mr clerk there it is there and your response is certainly i will tell
03:42:42 you the emergencies act has been under a very fulsome consideration right from the first day
03:42:47 as to what needs to be done when you refer to right from the first day what day are you talking about
03:42:52 actually my responsibility as the minister of emergency preparedness is to examine every
03:42:59 federal authority and and resource of that that can be brought to bear i i as i've earlier
03:43:06 testified um i we had i'd actually examined the use of this particular act during the pandemic
03:43:12 and determined that the threshold was not met um and throughout this this event i was aware of
03:43:18 this and many other legislative options available to us.
03:43:23 And so it was something that we were prepared to examine.
03:43:27 But as you can see in my answer, a more fulsome answer below that,
03:43:32 I was very clear that our work with the provinces was important.
03:43:39 And I talked about the Ontario steps that they had taken with their own emergency act.
03:43:45 And as I believe, we said, we will see if their effectiveness is sufficient
03:43:47 to bring the situation in Ontario under control.
03:43:52 And as I've said, I don't believe that we had at the time of this discussion
03:43:59 on the Sunday morning reached that decision.
03:44:02 And I was indicating that we were prepared to look at every option.
03:44:07 But you'll agree your answer was that it was under very fulsome consideration.
03:44:11 So it's not just a background option.
03:44:13 It's something that you're seriously considering, correct?
03:44:15 What I was attempting to convey is that every option was on the table
03:44:20 and we were prepared to examine every option
03:44:23 and then to do what was required to bring about a peaceful resolution of these blockades.
03:44:30 I understand that you did a...
03:44:31 Okay, I'm going to have to say it to you now more than double your time,
03:44:36 so one last question is all I'll allow.
03:44:40 All right, you will agree with me that by speaking on news programs
03:44:44 on february 13th you made the public aware that the federal government was considering the
03:44:48 emergencies act correct i i anticipated that the public was expecting their government to consider
03:44:55 every option to bring about a peaceful resolution to these protests because it was hugely impactful
03:45:01 not just to the people of ottawa and the communities impacted but to the entire country
03:45:05 all right thank you very much for answering my questions today minister blair thank you
03:45:08 very much okay the province of saskatchewan please good evening minister my name is mike
03:45:15 morris and i'm counsel for the government of saskatchewan sir will you agree with me that
03:45:22 after the cabinet meeting on february 13th the prime minister was left with full discretion as
03:45:29 to whether the emergencies act would be invoked the next day following his consultation with first
03:45:35 ministers just just to be clear sir because if i'm going to agree with you i want to be precise
03:45:42 um yes the the the matter had been discussed at cabinet it was led left what we call ad referendum
03:45:47 to the prime minister but it was very clear to everybody that the the prime minister's decision
03:45:54 wasn't was contingent upon the consultation that he would undertake the following day with first
03:45:59 ministers understood um my understanding is that cabinet did not meet again then though
03:46:07 you know until after the emergencies act was invoked is that fair yes sir okay so the prime
03:46:15 minister did not then take the consultations back to cabinet before invoking the act you'll agree
03:46:21 with me and and i believe sir that we we've had the cabinet meeting as you as you've indicated
03:46:26 the night before there was a cabinet discussion but the final decision was left to add referendum
03:46:32 to the prime minister following his consultations with the first ministers i understand your answer
03:46:39 minister blair i understand you are the president of the privy council correct yes i am on friday
03:46:47 we heard evidence from the deputy clerk of the privy council and i'd like to pull up the transcript
03:46:53 for some of the evidence given by the deputy clerk ms durain so registrar if we could pull
03:46:59 up the transcript it's trn six zeros two six
03:47:10 and spoiler alert we're going to be looking at page 300 of the transcript
03:47:14 where ms durain is giving evidence
03:47:17 uh it'll be 300 right not on the pdf but on the document itself
03:47:28 so can you go down just a little bit further remember is where i want to start
03:47:35 okay up just a bit okay this is ms duane's evidence from last week and she says remember
03:47:44 that we also discussed today that the moment we talk about the emergency act that can trigger
03:47:49 some reactions and that was the CSIS assessment on the risk of triggering or invoking the emergency
03:47:55 act so we were quite aware that the moment that we talk publicly about the emergency act
03:48:01 the timeline to take a decision is very short it can be a go or no go but you cannot wait
03:48:08 i'm just going to ask you to scroll down a little bit further now please
03:48:11 scroll down a little bit further thank you no no up okay next paragraph you cannot put that
03:48:20 in the domain without taking a decision and what we were afraid happened very rapidly the moment
03:48:27 we hang off the call on the fmm it was already out there that we were thinking about the emergency act
03:48:33 so this is why you know we were very concerned and concerned that talking about the emergency
03:48:39 act will request a very rapid decision a no or a yes but a rapid decision now you can probably
03:48:46 anticipate my next question uh minister but is it it is did you share ms drawing's concern
03:48:52 about publicly talking about the emergencies act i think if i read this correctly uh the deputy
03:49:01 clerk's concern is that after a very important step in any process of invocation involves
03:49:08 consultation with the First Ministers, and Deputy Joanne's concern appears to be that after that
03:49:16 call, some of that information was being made public, which I think, and I do understand the
03:49:22 concern, because it does, although it's not the final decision, it does, many might take an
03:49:29 inference that this was likely to happen. That, in my opinion, is different than suggesting we
03:49:35 were considering all options which was a conversation that we had i'd had a number of
03:49:39 times prior to that but if if the the deputy's uh concern quite frankly i have great respect
03:49:46 for the deputy and and if this was a concern she had um i i and and it it aligns somewhat
03:49:52 with ceases advice that the invocation of the act could result in a violent reaction from some
03:49:59 okay my friend for council for the government of alberta referred to your interview with mercedes
03:50:06 stevenson i understand you also gave an interview with rosemary barton on sunday morning february
03:50:12 13th is that correct minister yes sir and that was on rosemary barton live
03:50:19 i understand at that time you advised ms barton that the irg had been having daily discussions
03:50:25 about the potential invocation of the emergencies act is that fair i i'd actually have to see that
03:50:32 to to to understand the precise language i was trying to be and and it was always my
03:50:36 intent to be very precise that that we were considering all of our options including
03:50:42 the emergencies act but but but that no decision had yet been made you recall telling miss barton
03:50:48 that the police now have new authorities and very effective tools we just need the police to do their
03:50:54 job yes i do and i was referring to the new authorities as those that had come from the
03:51:00 province of ontario with the invocation of their emergencies measures and and as well the
03:51:06 regulations that they had brought in on the saturday and did you all you also recall stating
03:51:12 that it was somewhat inexplicable why enforcement was not happening i was asked if i could explain
03:51:19 uh the law enforcement's response and and i said it was somewhat inexplicable in my my meaning there
03:51:26 i hope was clear that i could neither explain nor account for law enforcement's response frankly
03:51:32 that's up to them okay did you think that uh your statements might suggest that a decision needed to
03:51:42 be made fairly promptly about invoking the emergencies act or not i don't believe that
03:51:47 that would have influenced either the prime minister or the first ministers in their deliberations
03:51:53 okay i understand that you were not present at the first minister's meeting held on february
03:51:59 14th is that correct yes sir that's correct now in your view would it have been appropriate
03:52:07 to advise what that meeting was going to be about before the start of the meeting you're asking me
03:52:12 to speculate on something frankly i have no knowledge of and i was not part of that meeting
03:52:17 if you were a premier would you would would you have preferred being advised in advance about
03:52:24 what a first minister's meeting is going to be about that's quite a hypothetical sir and and i've
03:52:28 never thought about being a premier you're uh well over time so with that answer you're going to have
03:52:34 to wrap up please last question thank you commissioner minister from your perspective
03:52:42 would there have been any risk to advising the premiers about what the first minister's meeting
03:52:48 was going to be about respectfully sir i don't believe i'm in a position to assess that risk
03:52:54 okay that's my last question so thank you for answering them
03:52:58 thank you next is the canadian constitution foundation
03:53:11 Mr. Blair, good evening. My name is Sujit Choudhury. I am counsel for the Canadian Constitution Foundation.
03:53:19 I have some questions for you about some remarks you made or evidence you provided in your witness statement regarding the sequencing of requests by the OPS to the OPP and the RCMP.
03:53:35 and so just for the sake of time I'd prefer not to call it up although I will if you'd like to
03:53:40 refresh your memory but do you recall you said that the city of Ottawa and the OPS were not
03:53:47 following the proper procedure for requesting resources because requests for police resources
03:53:53 in Ontario are formally governed by section 9 of the police services act and I believe that I
03:53:59 expanded upon that evidence in my examination in chief earlier today sir that I am familiar of
03:54:04 course with the number of circumstances where various police services may seek and obtain
03:54:09 assistance from others. I was also just simply pointing out to council that there is a provision
03:54:15 within the Police Services Act that allows for a police chief dealing with an emergency that
03:54:21 exceeds the capacity of his police service to manage. There is a section in the act that allows
03:54:25 him to request assistance from the OBG. And Minister Blair, would you agree that that provision,
03:54:32 although it authorizes a municipal police force or a chief of police to seek assistance from the
03:54:39 OPP, it doesn't require that they go first to the OPP before going to the RCN. No, and in fact,
03:54:45 they, well, again, depending on the circumstances, they often go to neighboring police services.
03:54:52 I can tell you from experience in the Toronto Police Service, we very frequently assisted
03:54:56 other municipalities because we had a fairly robust um and and well established public order
03:55:02 unit that we would we would assist those those other police officers and so you'll you'll recall
03:55:06 the tripartite calls that chief slowly participated on on february 7th and 8th yes sir and you had a
03:55:13 brief interaction with him and this was after the request for policing resources was sent
03:55:19 simultaneously by mayor watson and chair deans both to ontario and to the federal government
03:55:24 And this type of concern about sequencing, it wasn't ever relayed to him, was it?
03:55:30 I did not discuss the Ontario Police Services Act with the mayor.
03:55:35 My primary interaction was with the mayor. 0.66
03:55:38 And on the first apartheid meeting, she slowly joined that call right at the end, and we did not discuss.
03:55:44 And you'd agree there's nothing in the RCMP Act that says that the RCMP can't respond to a request from a municipal police service?
03:55:53 No, and in fact, they do. But there is actually the Ontario Police Services Act is silent to the RCMP. And the RCMP has some capacity to respond. But under normal circumstances, it's somewhat limited.
03:56:07 Sure. And this wasn't a normal circumstance, though, was it?
03:56:12 No, I think, as I said, it was uniquely challenging for the city of Ottawa and then in the multiple other jurisdictions that were being impacted by the blockades.
03:56:19 And so if I could conclude her, so you'd agree that even though in the normal course it might be appropriate and it might be standard practice for a municipal police service in this province to first go to the OPP or to other municipal police forces before going to the RCMP, perhaps in the case of the convoy and in the national capital region, it might have been entirely appropriate to set aside that normal practice and go directly to the RCMP in parallel.
03:56:48 I can tell you from a long experience that the RCMP are actually a very important and valued partner
03:56:54 in providing public safety services here in the National Capital Region,
03:56:58 and because they have a presence here, probably stronger than anywhere else in Ontario.
03:57:04 Thank you, sir.
03:57:04 Of course, sir.
03:57:09 Thank you.
03:57:09 Next is the DDF, JCCF, Democracy Fund.
03:57:19 Mr. Blair, I'm Rob Kittredge, counsel for the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms.
03:57:25 And we share standing at these hearings with the Democracy Fund and Citizens for Freedom.
03:57:32 You understand that in order to declare a public order emergency pursuant to the Emergencies Act,
03:57:37 there must be a threat to the security of Canada, as that term is defined in Section 2 of the CSIS Act, right?
03:57:43 Yes.
03:57:45 And I guess let's put that definition up on the screen, please, just for reference.
03:57:49 COM 935, Section 2.
03:57:53 Are you familiar with the Section 2 CSIS Act definition of a threat to the security of Canada?
03:57:58 Yes.
03:58:00 CSIS themselves advised Cabinet that the protests didn't pose a Section 2 CSIS Act threat.
03:58:05 you were aware of their assessment weren't you but but i think context is really important sir
03:58:10 the advice that i understood from cesis is that it did not meet the cesis threshold for them to
03:58:17 enable them to to initiate an investigation um and and and they were very clear about that but
03:58:23 but for the purposes of the emergencies act that that definition i believe has a broader application
03:58:31 that is contained within that definition.
03:58:35 And it really, the violence and the threat of violence,
03:58:38 I believe very clearly the threat of violence.
03:58:41 I also believe that, excuse me, the threat of violence existed.
03:58:45 And I also believe that the thresholds for, in that definition,
03:58:51 is different for the Emergencies Act than it was in the very narrow application
03:58:58 of that definition to enable the CISIS to undertake an investigation.
03:59:04 I was previously the minister responsible for CISIS.
03:59:08 I'm not unfamiliar with the extensive jurisprudence
03:59:11 and very high standards that exist for CISIS to take that action.
03:59:15 In the interest of just trying to, I'm hoping to understand your thinking a little bit better,
03:59:20 and in the interest of trying to do that in five minutes,
03:59:23 If you can help us get through this in, you know, shorter answers wherever possible, that would be really appreciated.
03:59:32 Looking at this definition here, you haven't raised any concerns about espionage, sabotage, foreign interference,
03:59:39 or a credible threat to overthrow the Government of Canada associated with the protests, have you?
03:59:45 And again, there was some concern, not the activities of a foreign state actor,
03:59:50 but that there was some concern about foreign-influenced activities detrimental to the
03:59:56 interests of Canada. And as well, just to be very clear, I believe there was more than ample
04:00:02 evidence in support that the threat or the use of acts of serious violence, and that or is rather
04:00:08 important. I think very many people felt threatened. Okay, fair enough. You outlined
04:00:13 several concerns to Commission Council earlier. Disruptions to supply chains, impacts on the flow
04:00:19 of goods and services disruptions to transportation disruptions at the border etc these things may be
04:00:25 undesirable and they may have an impact on canadians but they aren't in and of themselves
04:00:30 serious violence are they no but i think i think there is an underlying threat of serious violence
04:00:34 just if i if i may very quickly give you an example in our conversations with with the police
04:00:40 both the rcmp in alberta and the ottawa police service here in ottawa they were very concerned
04:00:46 and CISA's actually reaffirmed this concern that any enforcement on their part could result in a
04:00:54 violent and provoke a very violent response I think as well in all the people that we dealt
04:00:58 with in Windsor and in Ottawa certainly the disruption of critical infrastructure was a
04:01:04 very serious issue of national it's a very serious issue but it's not serious violence in and of
04:01:10 itself I mean you spent a lot of time earlier on today speaking to commission council about your
04:01:15 concerns about the protests and you outline concerns like the impact of uh the disruption
04:01:21 to supply chains on canadians and and you spent quite a bit of time on that if i'm you didn't
04:01:26 spend much time identifying any and i'm pleased to have the opportunity to do so now sir did you
04:01:32 i believe that many canadians um experience threats of violence intimidation and fear as a
04:01:38 result of the activities taking place intimidation and fear aren't in and of themselves let him
04:01:43 finish the answer, then you can. I mean, in the interest of getting me through this in five
04:01:47 minutes and giving me a chance to answer. Yeah, but if you don't let him answer, then there's no
04:01:51 point asking the question. It's true. Intimidation and fear in and of themselves, though, aren't
04:01:58 serious violence. I mean, the experience of intimidation and fear, serious violence means
04:02:03 something, doesn't it? Well, threats of violence, I think very many people felt very threatened
04:02:09 by what was taking place.
04:02:11 Quite frankly, intimidation and a very real apprehension of risk and danger
04:02:20 as a result of these activities.
04:02:22 I think we heard from very many Canadians who were very sincerely fearful
04:02:26 about these things, and we heard from the police who told us that
04:02:30 just in the normal, even writing municipal bylaw tickets
04:02:34 could precipitate a violent response.
04:02:36 And so the police were very fearful of a violent reaction.
04:02:40 But writing municipal bylaw tickets didn't incite a violent response, did it?
04:02:46 Well, again, we were talking about a threat of violence, not just merely the act.
04:02:50 You know, I think it's...
04:02:51 Right. So, can I just...
04:02:52 If something blows up, that's crystal clear.
04:02:55 But acts of threats, intimidation, obstruction, all of those things can also be quite violent.
04:03:02 So...
04:03:02 Is there experience by Canadians?
04:03:03 There's there's been a lot said here in the last couple of minutes, and I'm probably I'm very close to with not over my time here.
04:03:09 But I guess I'd like to ask you, you're making a lot of noise about intimidation and threats of violence.
04:03:18 But can you point me to any particular specific threat of violence or event that was violent?
04:03:24 Well, sir, you've characterized my response as noise, but I was trying to answer your question.
04:03:28 Well, I appreciate that. But I'm just trying to cut through this and get an answer out of you.
04:03:31 I can tell you we heard from very many Canadians who were very fearful about the activities of these blockades and protests.
04:03:40 You know, they were afraid to walk down their street.
04:03:41 They were intimidated and fearful of all those reactions.
04:03:46 Some of the, you know, the symbols and other things that were on display were very threatening to very many Canadians.
04:03:53 And frankly, the threat of violence is every bit as impactful on a community and on individuals.
04:04:01 and therefore it became it was a very serious matter from my perspective all right um the
04:04:05 definition of in section two of the cesus act of a threat to the security of canada doesn't capture
04:04:11 everything that you and your capacity as a minister of emergency preparedness would consider
04:04:16 to be a threat to the security of canada does it i'm not sure what you mean i i think i think this
04:04:23 definition is is fairly comprehensive and includes the type of behaviors that i've referred to but
04:04:28 But you would say that in your occupation as Minister of Emergency Preparedness, this sets the limit of what you would consider to be a threat to the security of Canada, Section 2 of the CSIS Act?
04:04:41 I think this defines what, in my opinion, would be a public order threat to the security of Canada.
04:04:48 There can be other types of threats that were not necessarily evident here.
04:04:55 A cyber attack, for example, that's targeted at critical infrastructure that shuts off a pipeline or a power grid or a water treatment plant, those can also manifest themselves as threats.
04:05:06 There is a significant threat there that doesn't necessarily involve physical violence in the first instance.
04:05:14 Okay. And just a final question. It's your belief that this definition here in Section 2 of the CSIS Act applies differently to CSIS than it does in the context of the Emergencies Act, right?
04:05:25 I'm aware of the way in which this definition applies to CSIS's authority, as determined by the courts, to initiate an investigation.
04:05:35 But I also believe that in its reference in the Emergencies Act, that this needs to be looked at in a broader context than simply whether or not CSIS could go get a wiretap, for example.
04:05:47 And there is, I think, very useful guidance here.
04:05:51 So the Emergencies Act uses a different definition of a threat to the security of Canada.
04:05:56 No, I think this definition, as provided within the Act, in my opinion, is appropriate and does, in fact, identify the events and circumstances that we have described as a concern within the Act as, in fact, a threat to the security of Canada.
04:06:16 All right. Well, thank you very much. Those are my questions.
04:06:18 Thank you.
04:06:18 Okay, next is the CCLA, please.
04:06:38 Good evening, Minister Blair.
04:06:40 My name is Cara Zwiebel.
04:06:41 I am counsel for the Canadian Civil Liberties Association.
04:06:44 I just have a few minutes with you,
04:06:46 And I just want to ask you about those few days, I guess, between February 10th and the 14th.
04:06:53 So I think this is when we switch from the SSE meetings to the IRG meetings.
04:07:01 Is that right?
04:07:01 Okay.
04:07:02 And is it fair to say, I mean, I think probably starting at the end of January, but certainly
04:07:08 by this time that the federal government was feeling significant pressure from many quarters
04:07:14 to do something about what was happening across the country?
04:07:18 Respectfully, I would characterize that the government was feeling significant concern.
04:07:22 We were concerned about the impact these protests were having
04:07:24 on the people of Ottawa and the other communities impacted
04:07:27 on critical infrastructure and in very many aspects of the country.
04:07:31 Okay. And, I mean, this was a crisis not just at the borders,
04:07:35 but also at the seat of Parliament.
04:07:39 We had people in the nation's capital.
04:07:42 If I may, Parliament continued to function throughout this, notwithstanding it was a challenge and noisy.
04:07:47 I think the impacts, from my perspective, were far more significant on the people living in Ottawa, trying to do business in Ottawa, and as well in Windsor.
04:07:56 And, you know, I'm also very mindful of the impact that these events were having on people's ability to make a living, to go about their business.
04:08:04 It was very impactful on a lot of people in a lot of different places.
04:08:07 um and and around this time the so that the 10th um i believe it's the 11th when ontario uh uses its
04:08:17 it's invokes its uh emergency under the emergency management and civil protection act um now
04:08:26 so that's the 11th and i think we we learned that the 12th is when the the orders under that
04:08:31 act were actually published so the the actual sort of operative provisions that gave police
04:08:36 the authorities under that act uh came into existence on the 12th that's my recollection yes
04:08:41 okay um now then we have the the 13th where there's an irg meeting was there any um consideration
04:08:51 i guess by by you i'm not asking you to to disclose the deliberations of cabinet but any
04:08:56 consideration around giving uh the ontario orders some time to work i i can tell you i had asked my
04:09:05 my staff for for a full list of the ontario measures that were enacted the day before
04:09:10 um i also looked at their utility and whether they would address the concerns that had been
04:09:15 raised to us um about and and i'll just give you some quick examples if i may um one of the things
04:09:21 that we had heard from a number of jurisdictions is the difficulty in compelling uh tow trucks to
04:09:26 come to provide assistance i looked at the ontario regulations and although it allowed for those tow
04:09:32 trucks it didn't compel and and and we were a little bit concerned about its limitations there
04:09:36 was also nothing in there as i recall that dealt with some of the real challenges we had in in
04:09:41 in tracing the financial uh elements of this in the in the crowdfunding who was who was donating
04:09:47 that money where it was going and and so we believe that there was a need to address that
04:09:54 how we eventually got there there was still considerable deliberations going on but but again
04:09:59 the limitations of of the federal statute and they also did not have the ability to designate
04:10:04 certain spaces um where and which was a concern as well because you know we were concerned they
04:10:10 were concentrating for example on wellington um i was very concerned about their ability to go
04:10:14 back to a municipal intersection just off the ambassador bridge um and and so we looked at
04:10:19 whether or not the ontario regulations provided us with adequate assurance that those matters
04:10:26 could be dealt with and although they were very welcome i want to be very clear that i i was very
04:10:31 appreciative of the work that ontario had done and the and the measures that they brought forward
04:10:36 in my opinion after an examination of them they didn't address all of the deficiencies
04:10:41 and the lack of tools that we had identified okay um now would you say that at this point um
04:10:49 you and perhaps some of your colleagues in the federal government are feeling
04:10:55 embarrassed about what's happening in Canada, feeling that there's international attention
04:11:01 and it looks like Canada's struggling to deal with this situation.
04:11:05 Respectfully, I've never indulged myself in feelings of embarrassment. I've got a job to do.
04:11:10 We have a responsibility to protect Canadians, to protect critical infrastructure in this country
04:11:15 and to respond appropriately to unlawful activity.
04:11:19 I personally, and I believe all of my colleagues,
04:11:21 were deeply motivated by our responsibility to Canadians
04:11:24 to do what was required to restore the rule of law and peace.
04:11:30 Can we turn up ssm.nsc.can402999?
04:11:39 And this is another text message between you and your chief of staff.
04:11:45 um now i don't think we have dates on most of these
04:11:53 yes i recall this okay and i think this is you on the uh on this side of the screen i'm wondering
04:12:00 if anyone else is embarrassed that the protest on wellington is expanding dozens of new porta
04:12:05 potties and a new stage i'm embarrassed for my former profession and worried for my government
04:12:10 which is being made to look very weak and ineffective.
04:12:14 I can't believe that I'm hoping that Doug Ford will save us.
04:12:16 And again, my remarks obviously are intemperate, and I regret that,
04:12:21 but let me be very clear.
04:12:23 I was very concerned by a number of things.
04:12:25 First of all, there was an expansion in some of the protest activity
04:12:28 that was taking place in Ottawa.
04:12:30 I was hearing very clearly how concerned the people of Ottawa were
04:12:33 about not just the activity that was taking place,
04:12:37 but that it appeared to become even more entrenched.
04:12:39 there was also a lot of public discourse and and particularly in ottawa but in other places as well
04:12:46 about people losing confidence in the police and trusting confidence in the police is absolutely
04:12:51 essential for them to do their job and so i was very concerned about the impact that the apparent
04:12:56 ineffectiveness of the police to deal with this was causing in the public's confidence in their
04:13:01 competence and their ability to to resolve this and and finally one of the things that we were
04:13:06 also hearing a lot of people were very confused about who is responsible for policing in the city
04:13:11 of Ottawa and and you know for most people they don't differentiate between the responsibilities
04:13:16 of different orders of government and what I was also hearing is that many people assumed that the
04:13:22 federal government was responsible for this and and my comment is was was that I knew it was
04:13:27 primarily the provincial responsibility the province's responsibility under their police
04:13:31 services act to to take certain steps and and i was hoping that they would take those steps and
04:13:37 by the way subsequently on i believe december 11th they did in fact pass their own emergencies act
04:13:43 and and introduce regulations on the 12th okay and i i know i'm out of time can i just have one
04:13:48 more moment to wrap up thank you commissioner um so the the irg on the 13th um and then there's a
04:13:55 cabinet meeting the night of the 13th as well and then the following morning is when there's the
04:14:01 first minister's meeting and then the act is invoked. But we know that the morning of or
04:14:09 overnight leading into the 14th, the blockade at Coutts was dealt with and arrests were made
04:14:16 and the Ambassador Bridge, I believe, had also been cleared. Is there anything that could have
04:14:24 happened between the 13th and the 14th that, in your view, would have caused the government or
04:14:30 should have caused the government to pause and say perhaps we don't need to take this nuclear
04:14:36 option that we're about to take well thank you for the question i want to be very clear
04:14:40 we approach and certainly my approach to this but i believe an approach shared by my colleagues and
04:14:45 the prime minister we approached the invocation of the emergency act with with great caution
04:14:50 with with with real reluctance we we saw it as a last resort and and we were prepared to do what
04:14:57 was required, but only if required, and only for as long as was required. And so throughout all of
04:15:04 our deliberations, there was that concern. You asked what circumstances might have enabled us
04:15:10 to say we're done, if we'd been able to receive some assurances. The blockade at Coutts had gone
04:15:16 on for almost, I think, 13 days. Its resolution was not as a result of the towing away of those
04:15:26 trucks with people deciding to leave. It was a direct result of an RCMP investigation in which
04:15:31 several people were arrested, charged with very serious criminal offenses and the seizure of
04:15:35 quite a number of weapons. And then they moved very quickly. We still had significant blockades
04:15:40 at Emerson. We were seeing them in the Pacific Highway. Although the Ambassador Bridge had been
04:15:47 reopened, there was lots of intelligence suggesting that they would return. The police were telling us
04:15:53 they had the ability to clear it, but not the ability to hold it.
04:15:57 And we were hearing of an intention to go to the Point Edwards Bridge at Sarnia,
04:16:03 to go to the Priest Bridge, to go to other bridges,
04:16:05 all of which would have had a similar effect of significantly impacting Canadians and Canadian interests.
04:16:13 And so we were still dealing with a set of circumstances where,
04:16:17 although, yes, some very positive things had happened at Goetz and at Windsor,
04:16:21 the threat that existed had not yet abated and and and and we were still
04:16:26 dealing with with that thank you very much those are my questions okay next
04:16:32 the Criminal Lawyers Association
04:16:40 Minister my name is Greg Del Piccio I'm one of the lawyers representing the
04:16:45 Criminal Lawyers Association and the Canadian Council of Criminal Defense
04:16:48 lawyers you have testified that in your view reliance upon the emergencies act was a matter
04:16:56 of last resort and i'm going to pick up on that theme okay when commission council asked you
04:17:03 questions what now probably feels like some time ago he asked you questions about why there was
04:17:12 about mistrust between as i understood it police agencies he used the phrase ships passing in the
04:17:19 night he in a question suggests there was confusion and disagreement about what who goes where and
04:17:27 does what your answer to that was in reference to governance but my question is as you look back
04:17:37 today to what extent do you believe that better communications more effective communications
04:17:47 between police agencies and within police agencies
04:17:52 might have avoided the need for resort upon the emergencies act
04:18:00 and and first of all let me agree vigorously that good communications within police services and
04:18:06 between police services is very important in them doing the important job that we tasked them with
04:18:11 in our society to keep the public safe um what we were also dealing with however in government
04:18:17 was the reality that that communication perhaps had not been as effective and as a result of
04:18:23 you know and and again it's not my job here to assess um responsibility but the reality was
04:18:30 this had persisted for a very long time in in many respects it had gotten more difficult and
04:18:35 dangerous and we were concerned that it had to be resolved and and so you know i i i'm in
04:18:41 complete agreement that good communications within police services and between police services and
04:18:46 i would also add between those governance bodies responsible for policing and the public i think
04:18:52 those those communication is really critically important and on all aspects of this but in the
04:18:58 event that that had not been as effective as perhaps we would have preferred or wanted it to
04:19:04 be. We were dealing with a situation that was uniquely challenging and required, unfortunately,
04:19:10 in my opinion, an extraordinary response. You looked at the Emergencies Act because
04:19:16 circumstances pushed it onto your plate and you had to deal with it. Well, my responsibility is
04:19:25 to look at all federal authorities in existing legislation. And because of, frankly, my background,
04:19:31 I also look at municipal bylaws in their application and Ontario statutes such as the Highway Traffic Act, which can also be applicable and useful in these circumstances.
04:19:43 And so one of my responsibilities is to look at every legal authority.
04:19:47 I've already mentioned, for example, at Windsor, we looked at the International Bridges and Tunnels Act to see if there was any application that that would assist us with.
04:19:55 and what we found in the unique and challenging circumstances that police and communities were confronted with
04:20:02 as a result of these blockades, there were, I think, a need for additional tools
04:20:09 and authorities to enable them to affect the important lawful purpose of restoring the peace.
04:20:14 And finally, Minister, when you testify about your belief that the Emergencies Act is a matter of last resort,
04:20:22 that's not just a personal preference you're expressing that's your belief with respect to
04:20:26 what the law requires right yes i believe that is a requirement that and and and as well the law
04:20:32 also requires that it be charter compliant that it be time limited um and and and that and you
04:20:38 know it also provides a number of parliamentary processes and an inquiry um all of those are very
04:20:43 high standards that the law puts in place and and in my opinion appropriately high standards
04:20:48 thank you those are my questions thank you uh call on the government of canada please
04:20:59 uh commissioner yes before he begins uh my colleagues at the government of canada
04:21:06 have moments ago provided some unredacted records finally based on our motions
04:21:11 one of those records is relevant and material to this witness extraordinarily and if my friend
04:21:21 I'd be asking to deviate on that basis because they were just provided moments ago to be able
04:21:28 to ask this witness for five more minutes so I may question them about this new document
04:21:34 I can advise it's February 12th minutes readout from a ministerial meeting about this very issue, and it's very enlightening.
04:21:45 Does it involve this witness?
04:21:49 It does.
04:21:51 What's your position on that?
04:21:53 I'm trying to sort that out right now, as I'm not aware of what my friend is speaking up in terms of the specific document.
04:21:59 um i see that there's been a uh a response sent from the government of canada with respect to
04:22:08 one of my friend's motions with an attachment to it and um frankly um commissioner i don't
04:22:14 think i'm informed enough nor are those at the council table at the moment to respond to what
04:22:18 my friend has if we took two minutes we may be able to get there yeah maybe we'll take uh five
04:22:22 minutes uh a five minute break and probably the witness can appreciate it uh it's been a long
04:22:29 afternoon or evening so we'll take five minutes and then uh maybe you can start it out and
04:22:36 we can come back because obviously it's better to have uh the questioning before your uh finals
04:22:43 question and you can also deal with commission council i don't know if they can help but
04:22:48 i'm sure they're willing to help if possible okay thank you we'll take five minutes and you can
04:22:55 commission council come and get me if it's the commission is in recess for five minutes
04:23:25 .
04:23:55 .
04:24:25 .
04:24:55 .
04:25:25 .
04:25:55 .
04:26:25 .
04:26:55 .
04:27:25 .
04:27:55 .
04:28:25 .
04:28:55 .
04:29:25 Order a lot. The Commission has reconvened, the Commissar Apprent.
04:29:32 Okay, has it been sorted out?
04:29:39 Commissioner, I've had a chance to speak to my friend with respect to the lifting of a redaction in document nssm.can.nsc00002872,
04:29:49 and I've undertaken to my friend that I'm happy to ask the witness, I'm not sure if it's technically feasible to put it on the screen,
04:29:54 but to ask the witness the question whether he was advised of the
04:29:58 information that has now been unreducted in a document that's previously been
04:30:02 seen as a ministerial update readout. Okay and is that acceptable? No I advise my
04:30:10 friend it wasn't. I would like to ask five minutes worth of questions that's
04:30:14 it sir that's all I would ask. Okay well I think I'm going to exercise my
04:30:22 discretion and and let the convoy ask a few questions um and and the reason is uh it this
04:30:33 has been a very difficult uh inquiry given the time constraints the government has had
04:30:40 uh a lot of pressure to produce documents and we're very appreciative of their continuing efforts
04:30:47 and similarly with redactions redactions have been done quickly and in some cases we appreciate the
04:30:57 government reviews those redactions and can then provide more clarity when after they review them
04:31:06 and all of this is I think to the government's credit having said that it it does in some cases
04:31:14 result in the parties having missed opportunities and i would feel much better allowing the convoy
04:31:23 to do the five minutes if they hadn't well exceeded their time but in the circumstances
04:31:29 i'm still prepared to to give them some time and and it's no no negative reflection on the
04:31:35 government and ron your ability to question i'm not questioning that you would do it fairly
04:31:41 uh it's simply uh in recognition of the circumstances we're operating under and
04:31:48 i think an accommodation is appropriate so i accept that you're okay so we'll give them
04:31:54 but but it is please uh be respectful of what the ruling is
04:32:03 so hopefully this is already in relativity uh it is document uh ssm.can.nsc.0000287220
04:32:25 i think is that you have it great thank you so minister this is the 1pm ministerial update
04:32:34 readout and you can scroll up and see it's a readout of what happened at your ministerial
04:32:40 meeting on february 12 2022 all right and if we can scroll down to the second page please
04:32:49 where it says ottawa thank you so i just need to know if you were made aware of this
04:32:56 essentially right there it says plan it's this is for the third from the bottom
04:33:01 plan presented yesterday was slowly for approval opp rcmp have approved will further present to
04:33:11 minister meeting with sally at two you're aware of that you're aware that was what was advised
04:33:18 on uh february 12th i i was president at that meeting and and although i don't have a specific
04:33:25 memory of every point that's listed here i i believe this was part of the discussion right
04:33:30 and you can agree with me that the plan presented uh was the one uh from the deputy minister of
04:33:36 public safety mr stewart and and i don't have any information on on on like whether the deputy
04:33:43 minister was i have no recollection of what you've just said okay and so i'm unable to agree with
04:33:48 you right and are you aware and is already in evidence um that on february 12th at 5 p.m
04:33:54 deputy di tomaso deputy minister di tomaso uh texted with chief slully and he too approved
04:34:03 the plan i have no knowledge of that well if that's the case and all of the police in the
04:34:09 jurisdiction of ottawa approved the plan why'd you invoke the emergencies act the the um the
04:34:18 invocation of the emergencies act was not contingent upon an approved plan it was it was
04:34:23 contingent upon what was necessary to bring about a peaceful resolution but isn't the rcmp the opp
04:34:30 and the ops approving a plan that isn't the emergencies act
04:34:35 isn't that what law enforcement advised you to do and again i wasn't getting advice from law
04:34:43 enforcement we were getting information from law enforcement i don't have any insight at all into
04:34:49 whatever plan may have been devised by them i had every expectation that they were working together
04:34:54 and would develop a plan but i don't know its particulars and and and frankly our decision
04:34:59 was based on the threat assessment,
04:35:03 the determination of the circumstances
04:35:04 that existed across the country.
04:35:07 And yes, I think it's a positive development
04:35:10 that the police are working together in a plan,
04:35:12 but the execution of that plan had not yet been realized
04:35:15 and the threat had not yet been.
04:35:17 Last question.
04:35:18 The plan, all right, the engagement plan or proposal,
04:35:23 in all of the cabinet minute meetings
04:35:27 where it was discussed,
04:35:28 it's attached to the minutes as a document that was discussed so i take it can you agree
04:35:35 that the engagement proposal you had that document right i don't know that's what they're referring
04:35:42 to in in the in the document you put in front of me today right okay thank you
04:35:50 okay now i'm calling on the government of canada again
04:35:58 thank you um uh it's brendan vinnie and heist uh for the government of canada
04:36:11 um just on the last point looking at that word plan and the bullet point my friend was taking
04:36:18 you to are you certain sitting here today which plan that referred to no sir i i make an assumption
04:36:25 that it was the police operational plan but i've never been given the details of their planning
04:36:30 i've never asked for it and and did not require it okay so is it looking at what's noted there is it
04:36:36 equally possible sitting here today as far as you know that that's the engagement plan as
04:36:40 opposed to enforcement plan and and i i don't know and wouldn't i don't think it's probably
04:36:45 to try to venture a guess i i you know it's clear that there was discussion that they were
04:36:50 had come to an agreement with respect to a plan but i don't know its particulars
04:36:55 all right i'd like to um come back now to the broader issues here and ask you some questions
04:37:01 about the environment that you were assessing in as one of a number of members of cabinet
04:37:08 this morning commission council asked or this afternoon commission council had asked you a
04:37:12 number of questions about your perspective on the policing of public protest
04:37:18 which included um a couple of well-known protest events that occurred when you were the chief of
04:37:22 police at the toronto police service do you recall that i'm taking you through the 2009 tamil protest
04:37:29 for example yes sir and um another well-known uh uh protest event in toronto when you were the chief
04:37:38 was the g20 held in june of 2010 right yes sir i think um you and i are both quite familiar with
04:37:45 that event as well as the later process of accountability for some of the orders that
04:37:49 were given by the bronze level incident commander on this Sunday June 27th? Yes sir. And as I recall
04:37:58 the evidence in that example you ultimately intervened and ordered that an end be brought
04:38:04 to certain of those operations when they came to your attention? That's correct sir. I would
04:38:09 like you to ask you to focus for a moment on the events in Toronto on Saturday June the 26th and
04:38:14 thinking about the scenario before us here in this inquiry do you recall what happened on june
04:38:22 the 26th of 2010 in toronto on the saturday sir yes sir yes sir there was a a very difficult
04:38:29 situation what had been a relatively peaceful protest although involving a very significant
04:38:35 number of protesters and there had been some incidents leading up to that but on saturday
04:38:40 unfortunately um the a very significant portion of the protest began to to riot um tumultuously
04:38:50 is i think the appropriate term um there was they were marching down towards the summit site they
04:38:55 turned and began um running rapidly north um up young street smashing windows as they went there
04:39:03 was a number of of police cars that were set on fire and a number of my officers were injured as
04:39:07 Yes, and one of your officers was quite seriously injured as a result of the police car being attacked by protesters, is that right?
04:39:16 He was injured and rescued from the vehicle, which was subsequently set on fire.
04:39:19 Now, leading up to that event, sir, were you aware that there was a not insignificant amount of advanced information and intelligence available with respect to certain actors, most famously associated with the black bloc actors that were shared with the Toronto Police Service?
04:39:41 Yes, sir. I recall that vividly.
04:39:42 And those individuals and groups were assessed as intending to cause violence to property and potentially persons during the course of the G20 protests, yes?
04:39:53 Yes, sir. That was the intelligence we'd received.
04:39:56 And in fact, am I correct that some of these identifiable groups or individuals warranted or were found to warrant the issuance and execution of search warrants in advance of the protests?
04:40:08 Yes, sir. That's correct.
04:40:08 but the events you described on saturday june the 26th they involved individuals who were
04:40:18 not on your radar specifically didn't they that's correct sir um the groups that smashed
04:40:25 stores and laid waste to a long section of young street in downtown toronto do you know whether
04:40:31 all of them were a part of the target group assessed um uh or as subjects of interest ahead
04:40:37 of the summit i i believe many of them were not previously identified as subject of of interest
04:40:42 i also we also i also believe sir that a number of people frankly get caught up in the moment
04:40:48 and it's part of the mob mentality sometimes when people begin to riot that others who may not have
04:40:55 come with that intention join in and it becomes very challenging for for the police to restore
04:41:00 with the same do you have the same perspective with respect to what occurred on queen street
04:41:05 west where at least two of the burning police cars i understand uh occurred yes sir i i i recall
04:41:12 watching that actually on on video from police headquarters and and and again there was an element
04:41:18 of of of that that protest on queen west um which was directly related to a number of identified
04:41:28 um anarchist groups including the black bloc but there were also very many other people that had
04:41:33 not previously been identifying who joined in looking um putting yourself in the back to the
04:41:41 situation in the streets of toronto on june the 26th you know sitting there in the middle of that
04:41:46 afternoon um would you have had any reason to think that um obtaining more uh surveillance
04:41:54 or monitoring authorities wiretap authorities would have been useful as a response to what was
04:42:01 going on in the streets amongst that mass of people that it's very difficult to say if i may
04:42:08 um i would also remind you sir that at that time i was the chief of police in toronto but there was
04:42:13 an integrated command um team that was put in place the the leadership of of that response
04:42:19 planned well in advance and agreed to by all parties was was led by the rcmp there was also
04:42:25 integrated intelligence gathering units related to that certainly you know we had a fair bit of
04:42:32 intelligence available to us but it was clearly not entirely complete I think in hindsight we
04:42:38 could always have hopefully have done more. Would that have been a useful public order response
04:42:44 on June the 26th of 2010 when those events were occurring in plain sight on broadcast and social
04:42:53 media in real time yes and unfortunately law enforcement did not have the capacity to monitor
04:42:59 all social media and neither do we now by the way or neither do they now um have that that capacity
04:43:05 but again the extent to which more information is available you know better intelligence um can
04:43:13 enable a more effective response now coming back to february the 14th or 13th the the the period
04:43:21 in question leading up to the infocation of the Emergencies Act. Did you have a view about whether
04:43:27 there was an atmosphere of lawlessness in the city of Ottawa? Yes, sir. And not, I think, to be very
04:43:33 clear, not just simply characterized by, you know, some of the activities which were bouncy castles
04:43:41 and hot tubs, but there was a number of activities that were, which were concerning, as I viewed them
04:43:50 And, for example, there was a very real concern being expressed by citizens about people bringing jerrycans full of gasoline into the demonstration site.
04:43:59 It is rather unusual.
04:44:01 I will tell you for, you know, flammable liquids, potentially explosive liquids being brought into a demonstration site, it can create a manifestly dangerous situation.
04:44:13 And so the police had said that we're not going to allow it.
04:44:15 But what we then witnessed is all sorts of people were coming into the site, carrying jerry cans, some of which had water, some of which may have had fluid, but it had the effect of thwarting the ability of the police to affect the purpose that they had stated that was their intention to keep those gas cans out of the area.
04:44:32 and and we saw you know there was a clear anticipation of of police tactics there was
04:44:37 i think a very thoughtful effort to thwart those tactics and and render them ineffective um which
04:44:43 to me is also characterized you know a commitment to continue and persist with the unlawful activity
04:44:49 um so when you you draw on that example when you assess the environment of of of lawlessness or
04:44:57 relative lawlessness in that scenario. Is your assessment based only on information received
04:45:03 from public officials, intelligence agencies, and police channels, or does it include what you can
04:45:09 see with your own eyes? Yeah, I was obviously being briefed by our officials, but I was in
04:45:15 the City of Ottawa at the time. I reside in the downtown area. I was in that area and saw some
04:45:23 of this behavior firsthand. Where an environment of lawlessness persists for a protracted period,
04:45:32 does that, in your view, affect the likelihood that there will be acts of serious violence
04:45:36 against persons or property in a given city? I think it can. We also recognize that in areas
04:45:43 where there is significant disorder, and that can manifest itself in many ways, but certainly during
04:45:48 this process protest i think we could characterize a lot of the behavior as as significant disorder
04:45:53 in the downtown core it it has the effect first of all it has the effect on everyone else in the
04:46:00 neighborhood law-abiding citizens they stop using public space they stop shopping on their main
04:46:05 streets you know they stay in their houses lock their doors put bars in the windows and and they're
04:46:10 fearful of going outside and engaging with each other and where that lawlessness becomes really
04:46:17 entrenched in my experience that can actually create a very unsafe situation and and even
04:46:23 behaviors that people might otherwise not be inclined to engage in in in more serious criminal
04:46:29 behaviors i think when you create a situation of significant disorder they're more likely to occur
04:46:35 we heard from commissioner karik in this proceeding about his fears that his officers were being
04:46:40 stretched between the extreme ends of this province that is to say windsor and ottawa
04:46:45 so that it would become impossible or extremely difficult at any rate
04:46:49 to have an effective public order response occur in both places at once.
04:46:54 And my question for you, sir, is did you, looking from the federal perspective,
04:46:59 did you have a similar concern about the stretching,
04:47:02 potential stretching of resources amongst the RCMP?
04:47:04 I was witnessing very clearly the challenges that the OPP was having,
04:47:08 not just for their activities in Windsor and Ottawa,
04:47:10 but also having to cover off the Peace Bridge,
04:47:14 assisting the Niagara Regional Police,
04:47:15 the Sarnia Police over at Point Edwards.
04:47:18 There was also other activities on other highways,
04:47:21 402, for example,
04:47:22 all of which had the effect of really pulling and stretching
04:47:25 the capacity to respond of the OPP
04:47:28 and their policing partners in Ontario.
04:47:31 We also saw, for example, as a result of the Coots blockade,
04:47:34 there was an Article 9 request from the province of Alberta
04:47:38 to move additional RCMP officers into Alberta
04:47:41 to assist with managing that particular event.
04:47:45 They were drawn primarily from British Columbia.
04:47:47 But then we saw almost immediately
04:47:49 there was protest and blockade activity
04:47:51 taking place at the Pacific Highway.
04:47:53 So the place from which those resources had been drawn
04:47:55 was then being challenged.
04:47:57 And it appeared to be an effort
04:47:59 to stretch even thinner limited police resources.
04:48:02 And I think one of the things we heard very clearly
04:48:05 from the commissioner
04:48:06 is that he had to make some very difficult choices about what he could do first
04:48:11 and what he would then have to do subsequently
04:48:12 because he just didn't have unlimited resources to bring to bear.
04:48:17 If there are inadequate numbers of police officers available
04:48:21 to maintain law and order in a given location,
04:48:26 do you consider that that might affect the likelihood
04:48:29 that there will be acts of serious violence that occur in that location
04:48:33 against persons of property?
04:48:34 I think it's very important to have enough resources to affect the lawful purpose.
04:48:39 And again, I leave that decision to the operational commanders on the ground.
04:48:44 But in my experience, having insufficient people to deal with a substantial protest,
04:48:49 and I've been involved in protests where we were in our dozens up against thousands,
04:48:54 and it becomes extremely difficult to bring that situation to a peaceful conclusion.
04:48:58 I'd like to ask you about the risk of counter-protest.
04:49:01 Do you see that as a relevant risk in a protest situation where a risk of counter-protest develops in terms of...
04:49:10 It can be. And I want to be very clear that I know that there was a high level of frustration in Windsor and in Ottawa and in other places with the blockades that were taking place.
04:49:19 And I did not see evidence of a violent response.
04:49:23 But when there has been counter demonstrations, the police are also very challenged to sort of stand between the two protesting groups to maintain the peace between them.
04:49:32 And that can be a very challenging environment.
04:49:34 And it's because people who become quite upset and emotional and feel that they're being treated unfairly may.
04:49:42 And I say may very carefully because we did not see evidence of this in Ottawa, certainly.
04:49:46 But they can become quite agitated and upset.
04:49:49 And that could lead to confrontation.
04:49:53 Did it affect your sense whether there was a risk of serious violence against persons or property when you learned about the seizure of a large quantity of guns, ammunition and body armor from Coutts on February 14?
04:50:05 Yeah, actually, I had been advised earlier in the week, I believe around the 10th by the RCMP commissioner speaking at an IRG that I had convened, that there was concern about the presence of firearms at Coutts.
04:50:21 that immediately alerted, like for me, was a very significant potential escalation of violence and
04:50:27 risk at that site. You know, it's where the police advised that they had that information
04:50:35 and that they were dealing with it. And when the investigation was complete, I believe on the
04:50:39 morning of, or on the 13th going over into the 14th, and they began making arrests, the weapons
04:50:46 that were seized, the charges that were laid were deeply concerning. And I won't, and I can't
04:50:51 comment on any aspect of that matter now before the courts but i can tell you it was deeply
04:50:55 concerning that and that's not to suggest i want to be very clear that's not to suggest
04:51:00 that i came to believe that everyone involved in these protests was potentially armed but it was
04:51:06 deeply concerning that embedded within that protest in alberta was a number of people who
04:51:12 did appear to be armed and that there clearly was some evidence that they intended to cause harm
04:51:16 Did it have any effect on your view of the likelihood or the risk level that there would be acts of serious violence against persons or property in Ontario when you learned on February 13th of the theft of a trailer of 2,000 guns near Peterborough, Ontario?
04:51:35 Yeah, that was concerning. And we were getting information from the police. I'm aware as well that subsequently it was determined that that was not related to the protest activities. But in the moment of their theft and not knowing where they were, it was concerning that there was that many guns out there in unknown hands.
04:51:55 thank you I'd like to ask you about a subject some of the lawyers in this
04:52:00 inquiry have repeatedly asked witnesses about and that is whether or not you
04:52:05 believe in the rule of law I spent my whole life upholding the rule of law
04:52:10 sir so yes I do does the rule of law include the sense that citizens will
04:52:15 generally acknowledge and abide by the law of their own volition I think
04:52:22 overwhelmingly in in our country um the vast majority of canadians embrace the rule of law
04:52:28 it's frankly part of our social contract that that we all agree that these are the laws and
04:52:33 that we will all obey them what happens to the capacity of police to do their jobs if the vast
04:52:41 majority of people do not voluntarily abide by the law i i can advise it it can be very difficult
04:52:49 If a large number of people choose not to obey the law, the capacity of the police, and frankly I don't think it's necessary or appropriate for the police to charge everybody, it would overwhelm our criminal justice system. You couldn't bring all those people before the court. I think the law works best when it's done with the consent of the people, and we all agree to abide by those rules in how we treat each other and how we live together.
04:53:15 Do you see that if large numbers of Canadians repeatedly and for extended periods refuse or fail to abide by laws, by court orders, and so forth, do you think this has any effect on the willingness of other Canadians to follow the law themselves?
04:53:33 I remain optimistic, and I would hope that the vast majority of Canadians would understand the importance of the rule of law.
04:53:43 And it's foundational to our society.
04:53:47 And, you know, we live in a, we talk about peace, order, good government, and Canada is one of the safest large cities, or excuse me, large countries in the world.
04:53:57 And so I think that one of the reasons that it is such a livable country is because we all agree that the rule of law is important and should prevail.
04:54:08 But let's say that they didn't. Let's say that large numbers of Canadians for a long period of time declined to obey the law, to abide by court orders, and so forth.
04:54:18 Do you think that there would be a greater likelihood that others would take the law into their own hands, so to speak?
04:54:24 I think when people lose confidence in the rule of law, when they lose confidence in their police services to uphold and maintain the rule of law, when they lose confidence in the criminal justice system to provide justice for everyone, like when that confidence is lost, then I think it's far more likely that people will ignore the law and would engage in criminal behavior.
04:54:44 and in that situation do you see that it has any effect on the likelihood that there will be
04:54:50 serious acts of violence committed by someone or other against persons or property i think as we
04:54:57 saw the persistence of clearly unlawful and disorderly behaviors around these these convoys
04:55:03 i think i think the situation in my opinion was escalating towards a greater likelihood
04:55:10 of the violent outcome all right um i want to ask but one more area which is with respect to
04:55:18 and mr cameron had asked about some uh this to some extent earlier i think you'd referenced it
04:55:23 as well in your in later testimony but it's with respect to the implementation or execution of the
04:55:30 ultimate public order operation that occurred in ottawa specifically after the invocation of the
04:55:36 Emergencies Act. I wonder if we could call up pb.can.401805 underscore rel01 and it will be at
04:55:46 one minute thirty five seconds. And while this is coming up Minister, in this inquiry there have
04:55:55 been some evidence or suggestion that the enforcement operation in the City of Ottawa on February 18th
04:56:04 following was excessively was conducted in an excessively brutal fashion one witness i believe
04:56:10 suggested that they couldn't believe that something like this was happening in canada
04:56:16 did you observe the public order operation at any time yes sir i did if we could when we get to the
04:56:23 135 mark i'm going to show you what appears to be drone footage taken by the rcmp to record the
04:56:31 execution of the public order operation on the 19th and i'll just let you observe that for a
04:56:36 moment and then ask your comment on the execution and whether it is up to snuff
04:56:49 and i'll note as we go that it appears that um in a certain point the footage
04:56:53 will be sped up and that'll be indicated on the screen
04:57:01 Thank you.
04:57:31 is this what that appears to be sir is a film of the um that public order operation yes sir
04:57:40 if you can stop the video there um would you um tell us your views on whether that represents a
04:57:51 well executed public order operation i've been involved in many sir and that that again i described
04:57:56 this or that type of behavior is textbook. I believe that the officers were responding in a
04:58:03 very proportional and measured way. One of the things that happens in any public order event,
04:58:08 if you line the police officers up, there will be some people that will come and push against them.
04:58:13 And, you know, clearly the police were, had adequate resources and a clear plan and were
04:58:18 moving people out. I was particularly impressed as I watched that, that the protesters were given
04:58:24 paths of egress so that they could leave. And that's really important when you're trying to
04:58:30 clear a street, that you give people a reasonable point of exit from that street. The other thing
04:58:36 that I would observe is the presence of those vehicles. I think even as I watched this, the
04:58:42 police were dealing with a unique challenge because those vehicles, in many cases, still
04:58:46 present in that event. But I thought the way in which they managed the movement of those people
04:58:52 was entirely proportionate and I looked very carefully I personally did not see anything that
04:58:59 I would characterize as excessive force there is a minimal amount of force that is necessary to
04:59:04 affect that purpose and that's what I believe I witnessed are you aware of whether the public
04:59:09 order operation that occurred in Ottawa resulted in any deaths or serious bodily injuries to
04:59:15 members of the public or to members of the police I'm not aware of that I've seen absolutely no
04:59:20 evidence or indication of that thank you so those are my questions okay any re-examination
04:59:30 thank you commissioner with your leave i have just one area that i'd like to explore
04:59:36 the witness go ahead shouldn't take more than a few minutes um minister blair at a
04:59:43 point earlier in in the evening when you were being asked some questions by council for alberta
04:59:48 you discussed the possibility you discussed the fact that you were facing a vote in the house and
04:59:55 you thought a letter from Alberta might be useful in some support in that cause and I'd like to
05:00:03 ask you about in general the efforts that you made to to gain support for either that vote or just
05:00:10 generally public opinion in terms of the invocation of the act and so if I could ask the clerk to call
05:00:16 up this document, OPP 40s 4583. And when you get it to go to page 54,
05:00:29 I think that's it, PDF 54 should have.
05:00:54 Yes there we are, thank you.
05:00:56 is this isn't an exchange that you're involved in Minister Blair but you're
05:01:02 mentioned in it Commissioner Creek is in green on the right of the screen and
05:01:13 Commissioner Lockie is is in blue on the left of the screen and she says this the
05:01:22 text text begins with something that appears just a continuation of an
05:01:28 earlier conversation and then she says has Minister Blair hit you up for a
05:01:32 letter to support the EA question mark and I guess the first question is did
05:01:40 you hit up Commissioner Karik for a letter to support the EA and we're using
05:01:45 that colloquially and and we wouldn't be suggesting there was necessarily
05:01:51 anything wrong in you having contacted can i say sir i personally believe that would have been
05:01:56 wrong i've known i know tom creek we're friends um i would not have called commissioner creek or
05:02:02 any other uh police chief to seek their support for essentially a political um move as i did have
05:02:11 conversations there are a number of organizations police uh chief organizations who are advocacy
05:02:17 organizations the canadian association of chiefs of police uh justice and and the ontario association
05:02:22 of chiefs of police i'm quite familiar with those organizations i was previously the president of
05:02:26 both those organizations are are advocates for policing and public safety and and and yes there
05:02:35 there was we did receive support from the oacp and the cacp but i did not i'm not i have no idea what
05:02:43 what Commissioner Luckey was referring to there,
05:02:47 but I would have considered it entirely inappropriate
05:02:49 to call Commissioner Karik.
05:02:51 I didn't call the chief of my old service.
05:02:54 I did reach out to the associations
05:02:57 through the executive directors, not chiefs of police,
05:03:00 to allow those associations to comment,
05:03:04 and they said whatever they said.
05:03:06 I also had communication with the president
05:03:09 of the Canadian Police Association,
05:03:12 which represents all the unions, police unions in Canada,
05:03:16 and all three organizations, the CPA, the OACP, and the CACP,
05:03:21 all sent very strong letters of support for the Emergencies Act
05:03:25 and the measures that were provided.
05:03:28 Well, as in some other instances, you've followed right to the end of my line of questions,
05:03:33 and so thank you, Commissioner.
05:03:35 That completes the questions on that topic.
05:03:38 Okay, thank you.
05:03:39 If I can just ask a few short questions, and some of them it's for a little clarification.
05:03:48 And I know it's been a long afternoon, evening.
05:03:53 I just want to confirm the point you made about the Police Services Act and requesting the OPP assist.
05:04:03 the difference there is as i understood it and i just want to be sure i have the right note is the
05:04:09 opp is required to assist as opposed to other police services including the rcmp would likely
05:04:19 support or help but but the difference is requirement am i right about that my understanding
05:04:25 of the act sir is that the opp is if if a chief believes an emergency exceeds their capacity and
05:04:30 ask the opp for help that the opp commissioner is required they can they can also ask another
05:04:36 municipal police service or first nations police service who do have in the legislation as i
05:04:41 understand it um and this legislation has been amended a few times so i stand to be corrected
05:04:45 but i believe this is still correct those municipal police services could decline
05:04:50 and interestingly enough the ontario police services act is completely silent to the rcmp
05:04:54 and and that i mean is that because policing is a provincial responsibility yes sir i believe
05:05:03 that's true and and and certainly the police of jurisdiction in seven of our provinces for
05:05:07 example are the rcmp serving under contract to the provincial authority but in in ontario the
05:05:13 rcmp have a very important policing role in ontario and in quebec they they provide federal
05:05:18 policing services they do tier one investigations they do money laundering they they head up the
05:05:24 integrated national security and enforcement teams.
05:05:27 Those are very important RCMP responsibilities,
05:05:30 but they also quite routinely will come
05:05:33 and help other police services
05:05:34 with the deployment of their uniformed officers.
05:05:37 Another question, and this is about the relationship
05:05:42 between the Solicitor General and the OPP
05:05:48 or you, not you, but in your former role
05:05:53 over the RCMP or even police services boards and I guess to use a concrete example is it
05:06:05 appropriate in your view or could it be that the board or the Solicitor General give
05:06:14 indicate its priority and to use a specific would it be improper for the Solicitor General
05:06:19 of ontario to have said there are big problems in ottawa and in windsor our view is windsor is more
05:06:28 important it's of course up to you but uh as far as the province is concerned our priority is
05:06:36 windsor but it's your decision and sir i believe that is an operational decision the decision you
05:06:42 just described in the deployment of their people i believe that's the responsibility of the
05:06:46 commissioner in this case um and and and would be inappropriate to receive direction direction and
05:06:52 and i if i may i'll just give you a quick example when i was the public safety minister
05:06:56 um i only issued it one direction to the commissioner of the rcmp and it was a ministerial
05:07:00 directive in writing which i made public and it was to require that they respond to a tip
05:07:07 requests in a timely way and that was it and and and i was very careful not to sort of wade into
05:07:13 this issue of operations so just just to pursue that so in this case even though it was just uh
05:07:21 what the province would like but it's up to him that you think would be would still constitute
05:07:27 interference i i think ultimately in my opinion the decision as to where he can safely deploy his
05:07:35 people and do his job is an operational decision that i would i personally would have deferred to
05:07:41 the commissioner okay uh and then there was a question you answered about whether you were
05:07:49 aware that commissioner lucky had had said that there were still police tools available that had
05:07:56 not been fully uh utilized i was not made aware i've subsequently heard to this inquiry um that
05:08:05 that information was available but i was not aware of it on at that cabinet meeting now leaving
05:08:11 Taking aside Commissioner Luckey's comments, were you aware that the police had tools available to it that they had not utilized?
05:08:21 I believe that, I always believe, quite frankly, that the police have to utilize all of the tools that are available to them.
05:08:29 And where they have an existing authority, then that authority is the one that should stand.
05:08:33 But I had also come to believe, sir, that there were a number of circumstances and challenges that the police were facing.
05:08:41 where they did not have the appropriate tools to deal with it they had not asked specifically and
05:08:46 had not certainly asked me specifically for those tools but they had indicated you know the
05:08:51 insufficiency of their existing authorities and and and and tools and and had indicated that
05:08:59 that i believe was necessary for us to to remedy and address okay the uh
05:09:05 you you made a mention and i'm not sure i've got the correct note when you were talking about the
05:09:17 the deficiencies or the tools that were added by the emergencies act you talked about
05:09:23 the financial and the fin track and you you mentioned the tow trucks i'm just trying to
05:09:29 You did mention designated spaces, and I'm just trying to understand, because we've had a fair amount of evidence here, let's just say I'm not quite clear for sake of argument, on whether the common law powers to create exclusive zones, exclusion zones, was adequate to deal with the Ottawa situation,
05:09:54 situation or whether it required the uh the the act the uh in uh emergencies act yes sir and and
05:10:04 and i i've actually given some consideration to that i was a little bit concerned with the
05:10:09 agreement that the city had attempted to enter into it it frankly kind of quickly fell apart
05:10:14 because they had suggested that you know the trucks would park on wellington and so john a
05:10:19 and in and not out of the residential area i understand their motivation but i was concerned
05:10:24 it had the effect of potentially giving permission for those trucks to remain on wellington and sir
05:10:28 john a which i think could have been problematic i i was also very mindful of the challenge that
05:10:34 windsor had experienced because this had taken place in a municipal intersection and and our
05:10:40 ability to designate that space because of its i think significant impact and vulnerability for
05:10:47 for critical infrastructure,
05:10:48 that we needed to go beyond simply the tools
05:10:52 of a municipal bylaw
05:10:53 and potentially take a more proactive stance
05:10:56 with respect to that.
05:10:58 I am, of course, familiar with the common law authorities.
05:11:02 One of the challenges of common law authorities
05:11:04 is they're not always clearly understood or articulated
05:11:07 and they're always subject to challenge.
05:11:11 And I think some particularity
05:11:12 with respect to defining those spaces
05:11:15 could prove useful to the police to affect their purpose.
05:11:19 And when you did the G20,
05:11:21 were there problems with the creation of exclusion zones?
05:11:25 There was indeed, sir.
05:11:26 And it needs to be very carefully defined
05:11:31 and very carefully communicated.
05:11:33 Okay, well, thank you very much for,
05:11:37 if nothing else, for your endurance.
05:11:40 And thank you for coming.
05:11:41 And that ends the examination and your testimony.
05:11:47 So thank you and have a good evening.
05:11:49 We're going to adjourn until tomorrow morning at 9.30.
05:11:54 And we'll have, I think, two new witnesses tomorrow.
05:12:02 The commission is adjourned.
05:12:11 .
05:12:41 You