Juno News - September 10, 2025


Ending the temporary foreign worker scam

Topics
Mentioned
Ben Mulroney: “I’ve never seen this level of crime in Canada” Kirk’s influence on the next generation of activists

Episode Stats


Length

34 minutes

Words per minute

155.99

Word count

5,430

Sentence count

274

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

17

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

On this week's Not Sorry, host Alexander Brown is joined by Michelle Rempel-Garner and Dr. Michael Bonner to discuss the need to end the use of temporary foreign workers as a replacement for Canadian workers. And Jamil Javani is back in the news with some strongly worded comments for Ontario s premier and the Ford government.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hi, Juneau News. Alexander Brown, host of Not Sorry. Thanks for joining us here for another
00:00:09 week. The news of the week on my side of the fence is the continued work to fix immigration.
00:00:17 I've spoken about this extensively with Michelle Rumpel-Garner here on the show,
00:00:22 who was also on with Candace Malcolm last week. I've had trucking experts like Gord
00:00:28 McGill come in and tell us what the heck is going on with his industry and the connection
00:00:33 immigration fraud and exploitation has played in that regard. Cover the National Post this
00:00:41 weekend. It's a version of a too much too soon, a too much too fast. The conservatives are calling
00:00:48 to abolish this program. Myself and our guests today, Dr. Michael Bonner, are in the hub right
00:00:55 now, last week with a quick breakdown of why this call to abolish and sort of greatly ratify
00:01:03 the temporary foreign worker program. It does have its purposes in key sectors where it's actually
00:01:10 hard to find people and it's not just being used to exploit low-wage laborers. It's a good first step 0.94
00:01:16 and we have an even bigger feature coming in the hub this week that further expands on that.
00:01:21 This is, as you know, the moment to drive change where the charts are all going in one direction.
00:01:29 The feelings of the country are all going in the other. There's been terrific writing from Jamie
00:01:35 Sarkonic this weekend in the National Post. And this all ties back to just what we've seen the last
00:01:42 few years, what we're seeing in our job market, how concerned our young people are and our Canadian
00:01:48 workers that, for all that people like to now talk about by Canadian, we're not hiring Canadian.
00:01:54 Going into the summer, I put out a call to hire Canadian through the National Citizens Coalition, 0.83
00:02:02 where I'm the director, just saying that, you know, let's practice what we preach here. Now is the
00:02:07 moment to start foregoing this abuse of the temporary foreign worker program. And since then, I've been
00:02:13 really thrilled to see that take off because this is obviously a moment to return that to what its
00:02:19 original purpose was for, which was filling difficult, skilled roles for key industries,
00:02:25 not just as a low-wage replacement scam that it has now turned into. And that scam runs deep. You know,
00:02:32 they're dodgy characters, you know, all but running a slave labor market now for international young males 1.00
00:02:41 and young women who are being treated abhorrently. And that's got to stop. Michelle Rempel-Garner has 0.98
00:02:46 taken on a big leadership role with this. And there's more to come. There's more to come on that
00:02:53 front. Jamil Javani has taken on a large leadership role on that front as well. And Jamil, as you might
00:03:01 have seen, is back in the news with some strongly worded comments for Ontario's premier and the Ford
00:03:07 government and, and let's say sort of the consultants who, who run, um, who run that government. I want
00:03:15 you to take a look. I don't think Doug Ford or the people in his administration, um, believe they
00:03:23 have an ideology. I don't believe they have come to a rational conclusion that there's a better way to
00:03:31 be a conservative than what I or you would, would say. In fact, I'm not even sure they would be capable
00:03:38 of having a conversation about conservative ideas or principles. Um, it's weird when you talk to someone
00:03:49 as you might, if you've spent time with people in the current incarnation of Ford nation,
00:03:55 and you, and, and they think that because someone put a good poll out for them that you're supposed
00:04:02 to be happy. Like, Oh, you got a good poll. I guess that's good. And not to diminish the fact
00:04:12 that that's a reality of our business. Like we need to get public support, but if you're popular,
00:04:18 but you're not doing good things, why am I supposed to be happy about that?
00:04:23 And that's a valuable point for, for him to focus on, which is that, you know,
00:04:28 popularity only goes so far when we've seen, you know, the records here, when we've seen
00:04:33 where that gets you. Ontario now has a great example to take a leadership role on, you know,
00:04:41 ratifying greatly, you know, this, this temporary foreign worker program and, and the use and abuse
00:04:46 of it and, and continuing to step in on the diploma mills and fraudulent colleges to,
00:04:51 to, to, to show some conservative principles here that have been unfortunately sorely lacking.
00:04:57 David Eby, the, the premier of British Columbia has, has come out and, and finally tested the waters
00:05:03 uh, out in the Pacific and, and, and realize, you know, it's warm enough for him to be able to say
00:05:10 he, you know, you're right. This program does need to be largely abolished and what has become of it.
00:05:15 And so this is a real opportunity to, to push these, these politicians. It's a real opportunity
00:05:21 to get behind this effort to fix immigration, to restore the Canadian dream for our present and
00:05:28 future, uh, working generations. And there's going to be a lot more to come from the Michelle 0.95
00:05:34 Rempel garners of the world from, from Jamil. And there's going to be a lot more to come from guys 1.00
00:05:38 like me and, and all those committed to, to getting, you know, this fixed. And so keep an eye out,
00:05:44 for all the work to come here on Juno news. Do take advantage of our promo code at junonews.com
00:05:50 slash not sorry for 20% off and enjoy this chat with Dr. Michael Bonner. Dr. Michael Bonner joins us
00:05:57 now here on Juno news. He is a former immigration policy advisor who once held the temporary foreign
00:06:03 worker, uh, in international mobility files in Ottawa, and is a former director of policy within
00:06:09 the government of Ontario. Thank you for joining us, doctor. Pleasure. Thanks for having me.
00:06:13 Now I was lucky enough to get to, to collaborate with you last week. We are in the hub right now,
00:06:19 and there is a larger piece coming, uh, later this week where, uh, your ex esteemed expertise along with
00:06:27 my, whatever the heck I do, uh, spoke about how Polyev's call, uh, to scrap the temporary foreign
00:06:33 worker program is a good first step. Why would you say it is a good first step? Um, uh, in relation to,
00:06:41 you know, your work you, you did on that file in the past and, and, and what more would you like to see?
00:06:46 Well, look, let's, we, we need to be, uh, totally clear about what we're talking about. We're talking
00:06:51 about low wage, low skill, mass immigration, such as we've never seen. We're not talking about say 1.00
00:06:58 a steel company having to fly in like an expert, like an absolute expert of which there's only like
00:07:05 three in the world to fix a boiler. The temporary foreign worker program is used for that. Like it was 1.00
00:07:11 originally designed for that kind of thing, but that's not the kind of problem we're talking about.
00:07:15 We're talking about a business model whereby Canadians, especially those trying to get into 0.97
00:07:23 entry-level jobs, getting their, getting, uh, their first, you know, career starting jobs,
00:07:29 that they are priced out of the market. They can't compete with cheap foreign labor that is largely, 0.97
00:07:35 uh, mistreated, discouraged from any kind of, uh, collective bargaining or actively prevented through
00:07:42 threats and so forth. The whole system is, you know, I hesitate to use the word. This whole system
00:07:48 is, is evil and it has economic consequences that, uh, have, that are very obvious. If you look at our
00:07:57 unemployment statistics, especially among, among youth. So getting rid of that absolutely a step in
00:08:04 the right direction. Yeah. I don't hesitate to use the word evil and, and I can appreciate the reticence
00:08:10 there. It might sound sort of bombastic to the audience. I wrote a piece during the waning days
00:08:16 of the campaign just called do good campaign against evil, because if programs like the temporary
00:08:21 foreign worker program, uh, abuse of the international mobility program are to continue, that means,
00:08:29 you know, 15 people to a basement. That means, you know, young people without hope. That means indentured
00:08:35 servitude servitude. That means, you know, more UN reports equating our program with slave labor.
00:08:41 I thought those were, you know, issues that we, we cared about in Canada. We've, we've decided to
00:08:46 lower the standard. It's not particularly liberal. It's certainly not conservative. And, and I believe
00:08:52 that in the case of the province of Ontario, there is an opportunity for, for better advocacy and,
00:08:57 and better leadership, uh, on these temporary streams. There's a lot being said right now online,
00:09:07 not just about the temporary foreign worker program, but it's now sort of reaching this sort of modern
00:09:13 lexicon is this, uh, international mobility program, the IMP. Until now, we've largely talked about,
00:09:20 at least within this sort of Canadian fixed immigration sphere, about the diploma mills, these sort of,
00:09:25 these, these schools that are dodgy beyond belief, uh, and, and the temporary foreign workers stream. 1.00
00:09:32 What could you tell us about the IMP, the, the sudden focus on it and what kind of reform would
00:09:38 be needed there as well? So the IMP is arguably more sinister than the TFWP, uh, for a couple of reasons.
00:09:48 The first reason is that temporary foreign workers are supposed to be, uh, allowed because you have
00:09:56 proven that you need them. You've shown evidence that you've advertised, uh, at or above the, uh,
00:10:04 prevailing wage in your region that you've gone out of your way to try to recruit people, um, and you
00:10:10 haven't found anyone. So that is the evidence you need to get what they call a labor market impact
00:10:18 assessment, LMIA. And that, uh, normally entitles you to, to bring in the worker that you hire from,
00:10:27 uh, abroad. Now, um, the IMP doesn't require even a token nod at, uh, prevailing labor market conditions.
00:10:39 It was designed to allow, um, students, international students who are already studying, you know,
00:10:47 they're studying at a respectable college or a university, uh, ostensibly, it would allow them
00:10:54 to work after hours, you know, a couple of hours here or there. That was the purpose. Okay. Um, and,
00:11:02 you know, we can ask questions about that or, or, or, or quarrel with the, the, the theory,
00:11:07 but it was meant to be just, you know, a tiny bit of work here and there in case anybody wanted
00:11:13 to do that. Like you finish your day of studying, um, engineering, and then you work at your local
00:11:21 cafe or something. You work, you know, 16 hours a week or something like that. Yeah. Very like tiny
00:11:27 amounts. Right. These fly by night, fake colleges though, uh, that have sprung up like weeds everywhere.
00:11:37 They recruit students for these sort of bogus programs, uh, in English as a second language or
00:11:44 some other thing. And there there's maybe some token studying and then a kind of, uh, phony degree at the
00:11:54 end of it. All the while these fake students are working often, uh, hours that shouldn't really be
00:12:04 allowed, uh, very low pay, just like the temporary foreign worker program. Um, that in and of itself,
00:12:11 I think is bad enough because it's kind of like a, you know, low level, like human trafficking,
00:12:19 like contract labor scheme. But in, in many cases there, there are actual human trafficking schemes
00:12:28 that these things are implicated in, uh, that was not just implicated. They're at the center of them,
00:12:33 that people are recruited from, uh, abroad. There's a kind of elaborate money system involving a bond
00:12:43 because you have to play post a bond to, to come in the country in many cases under these schemes. And then
00:12:52 you're brought in, you pretend to study there. And all the while the, the authorities that run your fake
00:12:59 college are confecting a scheme to bring you across the border into the United States where you then go
00:13:05 underground. Tens of thousands of, of, uh, there, there are tens of thousands of such cases which are
00:13:12 now being investigated, uh, by the RCMP as well as, uh, Indian law enforcement, uh, overseas. There was a
00:13:20 whole pipeline that hopefully has now been broken up from various institutions in India to the fake 0.79
00:13:27 colleges here and people across the border. There's probably also truck drivers involved there
00:13:31 somewhere. Uh, someone must be driving them. Um, you know, that's absolutely unacceptable. I mean,
00:13:38 you can talk about labor market distortions there too, but that's, that's human smuggling.
00:13:43 Yeah. There's no, there's no other word for it. So shut it all down, you know, shut it all down.
00:13:49 And that's, we expand on that in the hub and in particular in the, the larger version of this,
00:13:54 of this feature later this week, which is that it's not just an economic imperative, right?
00:14:00 It's a moral imperative. Yes. This, you know, the former governor of the bank of Canada, David Dodge
00:14:06 had pointed out that, you know, when we abuse this system, we're just propping up then unhealthy
00:14:11 economy, you know, unhealthy and unhealthy economy through sort of cheap, low calorie companies who
00:14:16 actually should be allowed to fail and should be allowed to struggle. But the, the moral one is,
00:14:21 is the big one for me. It's the one that I noticed when I leave, you know, my front door in the
00:14:26 morning, you see people being mistreated. You talk to young people who don't have any help.
00:14:31 You see scenes of, of squalor and incongruity and, and this, this, this whole mix no longer
00:14:37 sort of clearly, uh, is, is what it once was. And this program is not the success that it once was.
00:14:43 And you worked under Stephen Harper and Jason Kenney, you were, you were, you were able to, to, to,
00:14:52 you know, shepherd this file in a, in a much more, uh, comprehensive manner that seemed to serve the
00:15:00 country. What differentiated the leadership of the right honorable and Jason Kenney from what we've
00:15:06 witnessed from the liberals since 2015. Uh, Kenny, first of all, did not hesitate to throw the book,
00:15:14 um, at nefarious companies. First of all, he created a blacklist, uh, which, um, ought probably to be
00:15:28 revived. Yeah. Naming and shaming, um, delinquent companies. And, you know, we all know who they are.
00:15:35 We don't need to pretend that we don't, uh, you know, like Tim Hortons has, has the TFWP as a business
00:15:43 model. Yeah. Everywhere, everywhere. Um, and they'll, you know, you often hear people say things,
00:15:50 well, you know, uh, uh, a cup of coffee or a donut or what have you, you know, it shouldn't cost, uh,
00:15:59 exorbitant amounts in, in, you know, Northern Ontario or in, you know, none of it or whatever.
00:16:04 But if that's the case, why are you doing this in downtown Toronto? You know, why are there,
00:16:10 why is downtown Toronto where it's like, whatever, 16% youth unemployment? Why do you have,
00:16:16 why are you hiring from, you know, Manila and, and New Delhi there, you know, just doesn't,
00:16:23 it doesn't seem to really add up. The reasoning is, is, is, is flawed at best. Um, and, you know,
00:16:30 there are other companies that, that don't, uh, hospitality companies that don't use this as a,
00:16:37 don't use the TFWP as, as a business model and their prices are higher, but they at least employ,
00:16:44 uh, local people and, you know, they haven't gone out of business. So like the idea,
00:16:49 the idea that there's some, there's going to be some sort of economic catastrophe if you just,
00:16:54 if you hire Canadians, I just find that, I find that preposterous. And that was fundamentally, 1.00
00:16:59 that was fundamentally Kenny's attitude that it was time to just sort of put an end to this. It
00:17:03 had gone far enough. The, the boom times of the, of the, uh, um, great recession, because it was,
00:17:10 it was a great recession everywhere else. It was sort of a resource boom here. Those were coming to an
00:17:15 end and the bill was going to come due. Uh, it was time to sort of ratchet down the program, not,
00:17:23 not, you know, suddenly overnight, but a sort of gradually diminishing cap, uh, of a certain
00:17:29 percentage of your workforce that would diminish, um, over, over time. And, you know, that was,
00:17:36 some people didn't like that. Um, some people complained, obviously some people tried to, uh, get
00:17:43 around it or to, uh, uh, break the rules in various ways. And they were, they were punished and denounced
00:17:50 and so forth. But ultimately there was a consensus that this needed to be done. And that, you know,
00:17:55 the, the, the difficulty for these companies of sort of phasing it out was worth it. Um, and this
00:18:02 was eventually the solution also that the Trudeau government came round to finally at the end, they
00:18:08 just basically lifted our policy and brought it back. But in those intervening years, the program
00:18:17 was out of control as, as, as, as, as never before. And there, there sort of putting the brakes on it
00:18:23 was much more sudden and, and, um, uh, precipitous than, than what we had to do. So, um, the pain certainly
00:18:34 would be felt, um, just as acutely, I would imagine if not more so, hence Carney's remark that
00:18:41 he's constantly being asked about it, especially in Quebec, apparently, which I thought was a kind 0.77
00:18:45 of ridiculous thing to say. Um, but look at the end of the day, what is required is just the strength
00:18:54 of a government to reign this thing in, especially, especially from a conservative or sort of classically,
00:19:02 classical liberal perspective, allowing this subsidy, allowing this cheap, uh, labor and sort of contract,
00:19:10 you know, indentured servitude, again, is, is tantamount to a subsidy, to a kind of welfare
00:19:18 for unproductive businesses that cannot, uh, you know, that, that cannot market or sell their product,
00:19:25 uh, at its proper cost or, or it's like right value in, in such a way that people will actually
00:19:32 buy it. You know, it, it stifles innovation and it keeps wages, keeps wages artificially low
00:19:40 and, uh, perpetuates a kind of structural unemployment.
00:19:47 It does. And I, I do think of how the modern business lobbies now, and I'll, I'll just say
00:19:53 the name that the CFIB, um, uh, Dan Kelly has been out in media, uh, the last few weeks, um, talking
00:20:01 about how, you know, well, we can't, uh, Carney's parroted this line exactly, which is just, we,
00:20:07 you know, businesses are asking for this, so we can't get rid of it. And you're going,
00:20:11 well, how did businesses survive before 2020? Because we saw this as a response in some parts
00:20:17 to the COVID years, which is, oh, gee, we really messed up our GDP. What if we just throw, uh,
00:20:25 every young man we can find from, from, from the globe at this number. So this goes up, uh, and then
00:20:33 we can kind of maybe push off this recession that is, if not here, not so quietly is, is very much coming.
00:20:40 We used to let these businesses fail. We used to, uh, understand that free enterprise
00:20:47 uh, requires failure and that to, to succeed is you, you don't put this, this, this governor on,
00:20:55 on these endless subsidies and bailouts and, and what, what problems that creates beyond just
00:21:02 these sort of moral imperatives that we're, we're seeing increasingly. So, and so, I mean, you're,
00:21:07 you're, uh, uh, an author, a man of letters, an Oxford grad, a historian, uh, the, a political
00:21:13 consultant. I think some of those are fancier titles than political consultant, but
00:21:17 you know, you, you, you can look back at history and see some of the lessons of, of maybe what we're,
00:21:23 what we're, we're doing wrong right now. Like, is there a, is there some era or some, or some,
00:21:29 you know, ancient regime that, that did something similar that you could pinpoint and go, uh, oh,
00:21:33 here's a lesson from history for you. Yeah. I mean, the, the, the United Nations report that you,
00:21:39 you referenced, uh, a moment ago that, that included, this is in 2024, this included the
00:21:48 temporary foreign worker program as an example of modern day slavery. Okay. If that's an exaggeration,
00:21:54 it's a, it's a very small one. Um, people are not literally owning one another or they're not like
00:22:00 buying and selling people, but it's not, it doesn't fall that short of, of that you're recruiting people
00:22:07 from abroad, uh, basically attaching them to only one employer. They, so they, they can't move around 0.77
00:22:16 and, um, they're generally kept at a very low wage. In fact, when it works out, it works out to less
00:22:25 than minimum wage because they're working such horrible hours. They don't, they don't have, uh,
00:22:30 benefits most of the time they're discouraged or forbidden on pain of deportation and other
00:22:37 punishments from, from unionizing. And they have, you know, this is arguably the worst part of it.
00:22:44 They have just absolutely no stake in the society that they serve. Okay. So they're like slaves or
00:22:52 serfs, you know, uh, the word surf comes from the word, the old Latin word for slave. Um, they're
00:22:59 like indentured servants or the, like a participants in the coolie system, uh, like convicts shipped over
00:23:08 from, uh, from, uh, from, from Britain to work in the tobacco fields of Virginia. I mean, you, you name
00:23:15 it, it's just, it is the same kind of, of thing. And, um, I think that that's on its own, that's
00:23:25 intolerable. I mean, why, like there was a time probably when we had, uh, millions of, of, uh, of
00:23:34 temporary work permits on the go, uh, at a, at a, at a particularly, uh, probably about this time
00:23:41 last year, there, there may be only slightly fewer now, it creates a gigantic underclass. And I don't
00:23:49 think that that's the society that, that we want to live in. I don't think, and I'm not sure our
00:23:54 elites have reflected on this at all. I mean, this is, this is genuinely not the kind of society I want to
00:23:59 live in. And I think that if you spoke to them, these sort of left, left liberal types, uh, very
00:24:06 few would, if any would probably acknowledge that this is the nature of the society that we've created
00:24:11 here, or that it's in any way similar to past examples of immorality or, or appalling abuse of,
00:24:19 of people. Uh, but if you proved it to them, I think they would probably be unhappy about that.
00:24:25 I'm unhappy about it. I'm not, you know, I don't live in the annex. I'm not one of these left wing
00:24:31 types, but it doesn't make me feel good. And I don't know why they defend it or appear to, or, or
00:24:36 appear to be complacent, uh, uh, about it. And if you, you know, when, when we think back to the days
00:24:44 of the Harper government, we didn't defend it. It was, you know, this was a, a situation that
00:24:49 unfortunately got out of hand. I was annoyed that businesses that use the program didn't make
00:24:56 any effort to defend it at all. Um, they expected us to do so, which is again, another example of
00:25:02 sort of lack of skin in the game or like a failure to, you know, put your money where your mouth is.
00:25:10 Uh, so, you know, I'm not surprised that business leaders think, well, how are we going to get on,
00:25:16 but what they're, you know, what they're missing or forgetting is that they're in this mess because
00:25:23 of the temporary foreign worker program. Like that is, that is what it is the cause of its own. 1.00
00:25:31 It's like Homer Simpson saying that alcohol is the cause and the solution to all of life's problems.
00:25:37 Yeah. It's, it's a delayed, it's a problem delayed, right? Like you can indulge on the temporary foreign 1.00
00:25:42 worker program, but you were just then creating a dependency and pushing off the fact that you still
00:25:48 now have this inefficient business model and, uh, increasingly sick economy. When you worked on this
00:25:55 file over a decade ago, is what has happened now, what has come to pass? Is that sort of the worst
00:26:02 case scenario for, for what you saw from the program? I mean, I've, you know, I had the chance to get to
00:26:07 know you recently to work with you and, and you've been a major advocate on the, the fixing all this
00:26:12 file, a terrific work, uh, for the Aristotle, uh, foundation as well for, for public policy, which
00:26:18 really kind of lit the way for many organizations on, on specific policy points. Was this always the
00:26:24 fear for you when you were, when you were working on this program that, you know, in the wrong hands
00:26:28 or for the wrong reason, this would just turn into a kind of exploitation network.
00:26:34 Uh, yeah. Um, I mean, I think that the worst, the worst case scenario is, I mean, what we're seeing
00:26:43 now is worse than probably anything we've ever seen before with the possible exception of contract
00:26:48 labor schemes in, you know, the late 19th century or early, early 20th before, before, um, immigration to
00:26:59 Canada was basically shut down, um, for 30 years or so between the wars. So, um,
00:27:09 excluding something like that within, within, you know, recent living memory, this is the worst it's
00:27:17 been the sense of, uh, uh, shortage and, and, and, and scarcity and competition for, uh, housing or, uh, crowded,
00:27:29 um, waiting, uh, healthcare waiting rooms, crowded emergency rooms, uh, the sense that the economy has
00:27:39 got bigger, but the portion that everybody has is smaller because there's more people, you know, the,
00:27:47 this, this is inextricably bound up with, with what has happened to the, the temporary foreign
00:27:55 worker program. Now there's the damage we've talked about to the economy. There's damage to our sort of
00:28:00 moral, uh, sense, but there's also, um, the, uh, the collapse of the pro-immigration consensus. Like
00:28:11 the idea that there's nobody left, as far as I can tell, who, who will tell you without qualification,
00:28:18 without some, without some kind of apology or equivocation that, um, immigration is on balance.
00:28:25 Good. Those days are over. We're not, maybe, maybe the globe opinion section, but it's, it's,
00:28:30 Andrew Coyne will tell you. Yeah. Yes. Few and far between. Well, Andrew wants, you know,
00:28:34 his Uber Eats for even cheaper, you know, delivered by a guy who lives in a trucking yard,
00:28:39 who sleeps 17 to a crate, evidently. Yes. Keep, keep the fires of Taroni.
00:28:46 Yeah. The, the, the keep Yorkville, uh, bustling, but no, it's true. That's the, that's the concern,
00:28:51 right? Like I've, I've written about it recently as well, which is, we can all see where young men are
00:28:56 going with this, where alienated young people are going with this, you know, history has given us
00:29:02 constant lessons as you well know of, you know, idle hands and, and the disenfranchised. It's not,
00:29:09 that's not a productive mix. And so we can, we can choose to really act on this now to really fix this
00:29:16 now. Uh, or this gets a whole lot worse and, and you couldn't, if you were trying to, to radicalize
00:29:22 people to, to rob them of hope, to, to destroy this immigration consensus, you couldn't do a better 0.98
00:29:28 job than, than seemingly following the playbook of the last few years. Yeah. Well that, I mean,
00:29:34 and, and I think, I think this was widely understood within, uh, policy circles. I mean, one of the things
00:29:43 that, I mean, again, Jason Kenney was the master of this file that preserving the consensus, preserving
00:29:53 the, uh, uh, confidence of the public within, uh, the confidence of the public had for a system that
00:30:02 was not well understood and an immigration system is not well understood, which is kind of complicated.
00:30:08 And there are all these groups and subgroups and branches of this, that, and there's like an entire
00:30:14 program that's only for living caregivers and, you know, like, uh, intricate stuff, preserving, uh,
00:30:22 people's confidence that it was working in the public interest that, that was priority number one,
00:30:27 not making sure that, uh, a big Mac costs the same amount in, you know, every corner of the country.
00:30:35 Yeah. That's, that was not the, the, the, the, the priority. So yeah. Um, I think that it's certainly
00:30:44 radicalizing and I don't know how you would go about sort of building up that trust. Again, the last
00:30:53 time this happened, again, this was like the late, late 19th century, the time leading up to the
00:31:00 first world war, uh, it took until the mid 20th century for anybody to feel good about immigration
00:31:08 again in this part of the world. Uh, and that's, that's, uh, and the intervening years there were
00:31:15 not always very happy. So, you know, we're, we hopefully we can avoid something like that.
00:31:22 But what I do know is I know the result that I want to see. I want to see these companies forced
00:31:28 to invest in the workforce, to invest in, in training, uh, in, in hiring and training Canadians.
00:31:36 Of course, Canadians will cost more than, than foreigners. We live here. We have a stake already 1.00
00:31:42 in the country. We have had for a long time, people who have parents and grandparents here or children
00:31:48 where, you know, it's very different from those who, who, who don't and who are willing to work for
00:31:55 less and who will tolerate, um, what I would call exploitation. Of course, people who live here are
00:32:02 going to cost more. That's the way life is. And if you, you know, if somehow that's like too much for
00:32:10 you, maybe being in business is wrong, is like the wrong thing for you to be doing. If you can't be
00:32:16 profitable without this army of slaves or, or whatever, you know, like you've made a mistake, you've, you've
00:32:22 got it wrong. And one of the obvious roles for government, I would say would be to put a stop to this
00:32:29 and force them either to give up and try something different or, uh, spend some of the money that
00:32:38 they have been accumulating. Many Canadian companies are sitting on piles of cash still, uh, spend that
00:32:46 and hire and train people. It's, you know, in some ways it's very simple. Well said, Dr. Michael Bonner.
00:32:53 Thank you for joining us here on Not Sorry on Juno news. Pleasure. Thank you. Juno news.
00:32:58 We've got an essay contest for our viewers and readers to check out. The Manning Foundation,
00:33:03 along with C2C Journal, the Institute for Liberal Studies, Juno News, Generation Screwed,
00:33:10 and the Aristotle Foundation for Public Policy are pleased to sponsor the third annual
00:33:15 Patricia Trottier and Gwen Morgan student essay contest. We're inviting undergraduate Canadian
00:33:21 students to submit an essay between 1500 and 2500 words to address a current political,
00:33:26 cultural, or economic topic broadly consistent with the tenets of classical liberalism and
00:33:32 Western civilization, which include the principles of free markets, democratic governance, individual
00:33:38 liberty, reason, personal responsibility, and freedom of conscience and expression.
00:33:44 This is a good one, folks. There's a $6,000 in prize money will be split among five students with the top
00:33:50 essay receiving $2,500. These five students will also receive books provided by the sponsors,
00:33:57 opportunities to work with, you know, a professional editor, have their essays published in the C2C Journal.
00:34:03 You know, they could get an invitation and a profile on Juno News, automatic enrollment in Freedom Week,
00:34:10 hosted by the Institute for Liberal Studies. You know, they could have their registration fee and travel
00:34:16 voucher to Canada Strong and Free Networking Conference in 2026. So the deadline for online
00:34:22 submission is midnight November 2nd at 2025. We'll include some contest deals below, and applicants are
00:34:30 encouraged to read the winning essays from the 2023 contest and the 2024 contest. Take advantage of
00:34:38 that great opportunity, kids.