Juno News - April 23, 2024


Even Canada Post wants nothing to do with the Liberal gun grab

Topics
Mentioned
Former finance minister slams Liberals’ fiscal record ‘This is not justice’ — member of Coutts 3 responds

Episode Stats


Length

58 minutes

Words per minute

186.93

Word count

11,002

Sentence count

535

Harmful content

Misogyny

8

sentences flagged

Toxicity

15

sentences flagged

Hate speech

19

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

On this episode of Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show, Andrew Lawton takes a look back at the Liberal government's attempt to get rid of all guns across the country through a massive confiscation program, and points out that it's not quite as simple as it sounds.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:01:16 This is the Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:01:24 Hello and welcome to you all.
00:01:26 Another edition of Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show here.
00:01:29 the Andrew Lawton Show on True North on this Tuesday, April 23rd, 2024. I always give the
00:01:37 ear just in case you've been in a prolonged coma. You went into it in 2015, perhaps. And I have to
00:01:43 tell you, Justin Trudeau is still the prime minister. No, no, no, don't go back into the
00:01:47 coma. I think it's going to get better as well. If you look at the polling numbers anyway,
00:01:52 Canadians are eager for a change. Now, obviously, when push comes to shove, the Liberals thought
00:01:58 that their big giant big spending capital gains increasing budget was going to move the needle on
00:02:04 their polls but new numbers that came out I don't know if it was yesterday or this morning
00:02:08 showed that even with all that spending and all of that tax the rich stuff yeah 40 percent of
00:02:15 those who reacted said two thumbs down 43 percent didn't give a hoot and only 17 percent were keen
00:02:21 on what the liberal government was doing so that is not exactly the turning around of the numbers
00:02:27 that the Liberal government thought it would be getting.
00:02:30 So very good news if you're Pierre Polyev,
00:02:33 less so if you're Jagmeet Singh
00:02:34 because you're still keeping that Liberal government afloat.
00:02:37 And I think voters may, in fact,
00:02:39 not take too kindly to that in the next election.
00:02:42 But I don't want to talk about polling and horse racing.
00:02:44 We've still got, how long do we have now?
00:02:46 We're in April.
00:02:47 Next election's probably going to be September, October.
00:02:49 We've still got a year and a half left.
00:02:52 And so I don't want to just spend every day like,
00:02:54 you know, oh, this pop two points
00:02:56 and down one point and all of that.
00:02:57 But every now and then you have to pop in and look at the bigger picture trends there.
00:03:01 I do want to talk about some things that never change.
00:03:04 And one of those is government incompetence, which if you've heard this show in the past
00:03:08 and you've heard me talk about the Liberal government's attempted gun buyback,
00:03:13 you'll know that this is one of the rare situations in which I am delighted that the Liberal government is as incompetent as it is.
00:03:20 So let's go back in time here.
00:03:22 it was May 1st, 2020. So almost four years to the day ago that the Liberal government announced
00:03:30 this order in council, the sweeping prohibition on about 1,500 types of firearms. It was written
00:03:36 on the back of a napkin in the wake of the horrific spree killing in, well, it was around
00:03:42 different parts, but the epicenter of it was Portapique, Nova Scotia. And the Liberal government
00:03:48 knew that at that moment in time, Canadians were just so horrified by what had happened
00:03:53 that they would swallow any gun control measure the Liberals put forward.
00:03:57 It didn't matter if it had nothing to do with the criminal acts themselves.
00:04:01 The Liberals knew that they could just point to this guy, point to this incident,
00:04:04 then point to a gun ban, and it would be very difficult for Canadians to defend firearms in that moment.
00:04:10 And indeed, Aaron O'Toole was the leader, so it was difficult for Conservatives to, well, defend anything.
00:04:15 but what had happened there which was quite interesting is that the liberals which had
00:04:20 been promising this they had been promising this for quite some time just shoved this out the door
00:04:25 and gave no thought to implementation or rollout. Originally when they announced this order in
00:04:31 council they thought it was going to be wrapped up and done by May 1st 2022. Well I shudder to tell
00:04:38 you that it is not 2022. It is not 2023. It is almost May 1st, 2024. Not a single firearm has
00:04:46 been bought back. Now, obviously you need to take into consideration here that the buyback is in
00:04:52 and of itself a branding exercise. This is a massive nationwide firearms confiscation. But
00:04:57 nevertheless, the firearms buyback confiscation, whatever you want to call it, has racked up tens
00:05:03 of millions of dollars in costs, well over 40 million without acquiring a single firearm. And
00:05:08 shockingly, the government doesn't even have a way of getting these guns. Now, look, call it
00:05:14 schadenfreude, I find this to be absolutely hilarious. So let's start with Alberta and
00:05:19 Saskatchewan. These are two provinces that have put up serious roadblocks between the federal
00:05:24 government and its gun-grabbing desires. The government has decided that it's going to,
00:05:30 the Alberta government has decided it's going to license anyone who wants to function in the
00:05:36 province of Alberta in a capacity of collecting firearms. And that means that if a federal police
00:05:42 officer wants to come in and start collecting guns, they will need to have a provincial
00:05:46 license. And you know, what if the provincial government is very, very stingy with those
00:05:54 licenses? What if they just don't want to give out any of those licenses? That is what former
00:05:58 Justice Minister Tyler Shandro indicated would be the government's approach. Saskatchewan has
00:06:04 done something very similar. We had a couple of weeks back the new chief firearms officer of
00:06:09 Saskatchewan and the new, what's his name, I forget his name, a firearms commissioner. Bob
00:06:13 Freeberg was his name, who was the previous chief firearms officer and Saskatchewan not interested
00:06:19 in participating in this federal gun grab. So here you have two provinces, which I think per capita
00:06:24 have more gun owners in them than anywhere else in the country that are saying they're not going
00:06:29 to go along with this. Alberta has also, by the way, said it will not allow police resources in
00:06:35 the province to be used for this gun confiscation. Manitoba has been a little iffy on this. Not under
00:06:42 the NDP government. They're probably going to roll, but the previous PC government was fairly
00:06:47 critical in the territories. They've been fairly critical. But then we have this reporting that
00:06:52 came out of Radio Canada CBC, where the federal government thought that Canada Post could be a
00:06:58 partner on this. They thought because Canada Post has experience shipping guns. When I ordered a
00:07:03 handgun from one vendor, it was Canada Post that brought it to my door. And Canada Post, they
00:07:08 thought, okay, let's just send everyone a self-addressed stamped envelope. They can put
00:07:13 their gun in it and hand it to the mailman and the mailman will bring it back to Ottawa.
00:07:18 I mean, not exactly. You know what I mean? That's what the government thought. Well,
00:07:23 well, well, Canada Post isn't having any of it. They're saying, well, hang on. Why is this our
00:07:27 employees problem. They've sent a letter to the federal government saying, I love this, saying,
00:07:31 no, we don't want to do this. We don't want to send our postal carriers to your angry gun owners 1.00
00:07:37 houses, the gun owners that you've teed off with this gun grab and demand that they hand over their
00:07:44 guns to your friendly neighborhood mailman. I have a lovely mailman. I wouldn't yell at him,
00:07:49 but I have no interest in giving him my legally owned, legally purchased firearms to send back to
00:07:53 Justin Trudeau. So you have here now Canada Post, which was the government's fallback plan saying,
00:07:59 we don't want any part of this. So who is left? I mean, I have to wonder of the tens of millions
00:08:04 of dollars that the liberals have spent on this, where has it gone if they don't even have anyone
00:08:09 that's willing to assist in this so-called gun buyback? Remember, they partnered up with the
00:08:15 Canadian Sporting Arms and Ammo Association. We had the president of the CSAAA, Wes Winkle,
00:08:21 on the show a couple of weeks back, a very similar thing. They were trying to help the government with
00:08:26 just getting inventory out of businesses. They hadn't even gotten to the consumer stuff. And even
00:08:31 on the business side of things, they're not optimistic that there's a roadmap in place. And
00:08:36 one of the points that Wes Winkle raised on the show here is that the federal government just
00:08:41 doesn't even know anything about the space that it's decided to enter. They don't know about the
00:08:46 types of guns. They don't know the difference between a shotgun and a pistol. They don't know
00:08:50 any of this stuff. And they're now trying to come in and pretend to be the experts to oversee this
00:08:55 massive, massive program, the costs of which are likely to balloon up to a billion dollars
00:09:00 if this goes ahead. So all of this is to say, I am not telling the government to get its act
00:09:06 together. I actually am completely fine with the government spinning its tires and being so utterly
00:09:11 inept and incompetent that it can't actually do what it's setting out to do. But my goodness, 0.97
00:09:16 this is an absolutely hilarious development where, you know, the governments first expected
00:09:22 the provinces to do their job. And then the provinces said, well, this isn't our job. We
00:09:26 aren't interested in doing this. And then the federal government said, okay, Canada Post is
00:09:30 going to, yeah, Canada Post will do it. And now Canada Post is saying that it's not going to do
00:09:36 this as well. So again, at a certain point, I don't even know what they have left because you
00:09:40 may recall, I believe it was David Lamedi, the former justice minister, who, when the provinces
00:09:46 were initially saying what Alberta and Saskatchewan were saying, which was that we're not going to let
00:09:50 police resources be used, we're going to license them, the federal government really didn't have
00:09:55 any tool in its arsenal to respond to that except for finger wagging. They basically said, oh,
00:10:00 you're getting in the way of what we're doing. And I think it was, you know, Daniel Smith that said,
00:10:04 well, yeah, that's kind of the point, minister. We don't want you to be doing what you're doing,
00:10:09 and we don't want you to be doing it in our province.
00:10:11 I would love a whole country of people doing that.
00:10:14 I would love to see Premier Doug Ford in Ontario.
00:10:17 I can't remember if Blaine Higgs went down that road as well in New Brunswick.
00:10:22 I seem to recall there was at least some resistance
00:10:24 to what the federal government was trying to do.
00:10:26 But I can't recall if they had gone as far as Alberta and Saskatchewan had.
00:10:30 But I wanted to read a quote from this letter
00:10:33 that the Canada Post folks sent to the federal government here.
00:10:37 they said that i just got to find it here oh here it is that employee safety is the concern that
00:10:46 they actually don't believe that it's safe for their employees uh now the federal government
00:10:51 has said that it would be the most efficient and least costly way of doing it so they think that
00:10:56 canada because now they care about cost savings and efficiency in ottawa inexplicably but they
00:11:01 think canada post is going to be that uh the canada post folks are saying yeah we're actually
00:11:07 refusing to do this. Now, here's the one quote I wanted to share with you from the article.
00:11:11 Federal officials told Razio Canada, oh sorry, no, that's the, I just read that line. My screen
00:11:16 is bouncing all over the place here. They're saying it's going to delay. It's a challenge,
00:11:21 but we don't think this jeopardizes our timetable or the government's desire to move forward.
00:11:25 We want the discussions to continue. So the government's latest timeline on this is October
00:11:33 of 2025, conveniently when the next election is scheduled for. So we're now talking about a year
00:11:40 and a half from now, and the government is still in the discussion phase. So the idea that they
00:11:46 are going to discuss, reach a conclusion, find a plan, implement that plan, and finish it,
00:11:55 collect the millions of guns across the country that fall under this prohibition. And they're
00:12:02 going to do this all in a year and a half. If you believe that, I have some oceanfront property in
00:12:09 Saskatchewan for you. This is not going to work at all. Now, I suspect what the Liberals want
00:12:15 is they want to just delay, delay, delay, delay, delay until like right at the election time.
00:12:20 And then all of a sudden, the big, scary, meanie conservative Pierre Paulyev is going to have to
00:12:25 get out there in front of journalists and Canadians and defend the right of Canadians
00:12:29 to keep their AR-15s, a gun that is vastly misunderstood by people, which is why it became
00:12:35 the subject of the Liberal government's ire in the first place. But they want to make this an
00:12:39 election issue in the same way they did in 2021, and I believe 2019, but more so in 2021 with Aaron
00:12:46 O'Toole. But the reason it was so effective on Aaron O'Toole is because he completely rolled on
00:12:51 his platform. He had his pledge literally printed and laminated and bound in his platform, and then
00:12:58 he got a couple of questions from reporters he didn't like, and all of a sudden he just reversed
00:13:02 it, and they released an updated version with some asterisk where they effectively said they
00:13:06 weren't going to change what the Liberals had done. And when your commitment in an election
00:13:11 is that you're going to let what the other guys did stand, you're telling Canadians that you are
00:13:16 not providing any contrast. You're telling Canadians that you're not actually a different
00:13:21 option. You're not actually an alternative. So that's why it is so important to not try
00:13:25 to compete on the other side's turf if you are in fact running on a different platform. Own that
00:13:30 platform, defend it. And let's be real, Canadians don't understand guns if they haven't been around 0.95
00:13:36 them. A lot of Canadians just do not get it. The way you counter that is through education. It's
00:13:42 one of the reasons I made Assaulted, which was a firearms documentary I am incredibly proud of.
00:13:47 It's one of the reasons that I also have continued to talk about this issue on my show. I know there
00:13:52 are a lot of people that listen that are gun owners, that love it, that whenever we do a
00:13:56 segment on guns, it's always shared on the gun groups on Facebook. And I love hearing from those
00:14:00 people. There are also folks that are like, yeah, I'm a conservative on every other issue, but you
00:14:05 know, I don't get on this one. But even a lot of those people are starting to understand the
00:14:09 importance of firearms policy, just from a property rights perspective. Like, do you want
00:14:16 the government coming and saying that this thing that you bought legally, that you played by the
00:14:19 rules on is now the government's property. And someone raised, I was chatting with someone who's
00:14:25 a gun owner in Toronto. So, you know, heaven help him. But he was telling me when we were chatting
00:14:30 about this, and I thought it was an interesting point. If the government hasn't even thought of
00:14:34 the transport aspect, if the government hasn't even thought of how they're going to transport
00:14:39 all these firearms, have they thought about how they're going to store them? Because remember,
00:14:44 all of these guns that get turned in are going to get melted down. It's going to be a very depressing
00:14:48 day if you love guns, when these, you know, antique guns, these collectible guns, these
00:14:52 fascinating guns, these things that are used for sport shooting that have never hurt anyone
00:14:56 are just, you know, smelted down and put into this big heap of metal in Ottawa. But what are
00:15:02 they going to do when they're storing it? What's the repository going to look like? Like we just
00:15:07 passed the anniversary of, I forget how much it was, but it was like millions of dollars of gold
00:15:12 that was stolen from a secure warehouse at Pearson airport. Now, if we can't protect millions of
00:15:18 in gold from being stolen by, you know, based on the charges, not, you know, just a random group
00:15:23 of guys. How are we going to protect thousands of thousands, tens of thousands, hundreds of
00:15:29 thousands of firearms that are all sitting in a warehouse just waiting to be smelted? Keeping in
00:15:34 mind, we know how inefficient and ineffective government is on this. So I absolutely, absolutely
00:15:41 do not believe that this is going to happen. I think there is probably going to be a significant
00:15:46 an about face when there is an election coming around. And look, every time I talk about Pierre
00:15:52 Paulieva as being the most likely elected in the next election, you get people saying,
00:15:58 oh, what about Maxime Bernier? What about Yves-Francois Blanchet? No one's actually said
00:16:01 about what about Blanchet, but I'm going with what the poll numbers are now. And the poll numbers are
00:16:05 showing that Canadians are ripe for change. If they perhaps change from there and you see someone 1.00
00:16:10 else poised for victory, I'll amend my commentary. But for all intents and purposes, we are looking
00:16:15 towards a conservative government in 2025 and that is one that has at this point been pretty
00:16:22 unequivocal about wanting to roll back all of these liberal government proclamations edicts
00:16:28 the order and council the firearms laws all of that so that is exactly where we are on this now
00:16:33 and I think it's an important one because if government is going after your property on
00:16:37 something like firearms it's only a matter of time before they go after your property for some
00:16:42 other reason that they think is necessary that they think is a public safety requirement and you
00:16:47 don't and that is I think so crucial here so it isn't just a gun issue it is a property rights
00:16:54 issue and that I think is an important angle on this now I wanted to revisit a discussion we had
00:16:59 on the show yesterday about plastics you may have seen there's this big giant plastic confab that
00:17:05 the United Nations is hosting in Ottawa right now so the Canadian government is the host nation as
00:17:11 the world delegates decide they want to create a plastics treaty. Now, even the Secretary General
00:17:19 or Director General of the World Health Organization, Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, he was
00:17:23 tweeting today about the need for a plastics treaty as a public health issue. He says we need
00:17:29 a plastic treaty to protect the health of people and the planet, to which I replied somewhat
00:17:35 glibly on Twitter, two weeks to flatten the Tupperware. That is my response to that. When
00:17:40 When the guys who brought you the global COVID response are leading the plastic response, it will not be good in the least.
00:17:47 That was from Dr. Tedros there.
00:17:50 We also had Greenpeace roll out the red carpet and welcome delegates there.
00:17:54 This was them, I believe that's the Shaw Centre in Ottawa.
00:17:59 Welcome delegates, don't trash the treaty.
00:18:02 Welcome to Ottawa for Inc. 4 unless you are with big oil and plastic.
00:18:06 So if you're with big oil and big plastic, they are not welcoming you.
00:18:10 But if you're not from one of those industries, they welcome you to Ottawa.
00:18:16 By the way, Greenpeace, I assume, has to travel to these conferences, and I presume they don't swim and walk.
00:18:26 So take from that what you will, but I think there's a little tiny bit of hypocrisy.
00:18:32 Oh, Sean's done the research on this.
00:18:34 Her bio says she's from North Carolina.
00:18:36 So, okay, she didn't need to swim.
00:18:38 She could have walked.
00:18:39 I don't think she walked from North Carolina.
00:18:42 I don't even, Greyhound doesn't even like
00:18:44 running Canada anymore, I don't think.
00:18:46 So she had to get to Ottawa somehow
00:18:47 and she might have burned some fossil fuels 1.00
00:18:52 to get to Ottawa.
00:18:54 He says he has a script.
00:18:54 What do you have?
00:18:55 I don't know what you're,
00:18:55 what do you have a screen grab of?
00:18:57 Oh, there we go.
00:18:58 Sean was just telling me you had a screen grab.
00:19:00 Yeah, I really hate plastic
00:19:01 and get to do fun things with Greenpeace.
00:19:04 That, imagine that being your epitaph.
00:19:07 I really hate plastic.
00:19:09 Like the one line of real estate that you get to define yourself to the world is I really
00:19:14 hate plastic.
00:19:15 I actually, William Shatner, I saw, wrote an op-ed in the Globe and Mail the other day
00:19:20 calling for a global plastics treaty.
00:19:23 And look, I like William Shatner, but I think if we restrict plastics too, too much, his
00:19:28 face might not look the way it looks to this day.
00:19:30 So, oh, was that a low blow?
00:19:33 No, he, no.
00:19:34 William Shatner actually picked a fight with me on Twitter once.
00:19:37 So I think I'm allowed.
00:19:37 Okay. What happened was I had requested an interview with him because I had his email
00:19:43 address and I had emailed him for something unrelated. And I had emailed him for an interview
00:19:48 because I thought this is, you know, I like William Shatner. He's a Canadian legend. I had
00:19:52 interviewed him once on my radio show years ago. And instead of responding to the email,
00:19:56 he looked me up on Twitter and issued like a public rejection of my request and then told me
00:20:03 I had to go through proper channels next time.
00:20:05 I, you know, wanted to speak to him.
00:20:07 So that was the last I spoke to William Shatter.
00:20:10 Anyway, I just had my comeuppance, I suppose.
00:20:12 So this is what is happening there.
00:20:15 We've got the WHO pushing this.
00:20:17 We've got Greenpeace pushing this.
00:20:19 And you've got Stephen Gilbeau pushing it.
00:20:21 I shared the clip yesterday of him talking about
00:20:23 the need to have a global plastics treaty.
00:20:27 And we're going to be revisiting this
00:20:29 over the course of the week here
00:20:30 because you have to be very concerned
00:20:31 at what happens at these sessions
00:20:33 because it always tends to trickle down to domestic policy.
00:20:38 And this is the part that people fail to realize
00:20:40 is that they'll all say,
00:20:42 oh, this treaty is non-binding, it's symbolic,
00:20:44 we're just doing this,
00:20:45 we're trying to all get on the same page.
00:20:46 But at a certain point,
00:20:48 it all trickles down to what we do here.
00:20:52 And remember, this is a federal government in Canada
00:20:54 that tried to and succeeded in banning single-use plastics.
00:20:57 They did it by declaring plastics a toxin,
00:21:01 believe it or not.
00:21:02 and then it was only when it went to court that the judge ruled like yeah you can't call plastics
00:21:07 a toxin you actually can't put plastic in this category so the federal government has tried to
00:21:12 redefine this to push a very I mean they couch it as an environmental agenda but really it is an
00:21:20 anti-energy agenda it is an anti-energy agenda and it's one that ultimately makes consumers suffer
00:21:27 in this country. It makes manufacturers suffer. And it's not even like this old like big oil
00:21:31 versus the environment thing. Like plastics really are the backbone of industry. They've made
00:21:37 infrastructure incredibly affordable. They have made just COVID. Just look at COVID alone.
00:21:44 Whatever you think of pandemic response, it was plastics that really saved the day in COVID
00:21:48 because you had this ability to manufacture single-use products, which was needed in a
00:21:54 situation like this. So, you know, basically I wanted to just set the stage that we are on top
00:22:00 of this. We are following along with this and we're going to continue to have coverage over
00:22:05 the course of the week because I want to make clear here that as much as they claim science
00:22:09 is on their side and environmental policy is on their side, these things could not be further
00:22:15 from the truth. And they really are waging what looks genuinely like an anti-industrial agenda.
00:22:21 And we had yesterday on the show from the Vinyl Association, the president of that organization, Anya Curran, and she was saying, listen, we're working with them.
00:22:30 We're working. We're trying to be stakeholders here.
00:22:32 So anyway, we will follow that along over the course of the week.
00:22:36 I wanted to kick back in time to something else in Ottawa.
00:22:39 A couple of weeks back, I was there for the Canada Strong and Free Network Conference and sat down with my friend Jen Gerson,
00:22:45 who has quickly become one of the most successful figures in independent media in this country as
00:22:51 co-founder of The Line. Now, she's not, you know, one of these like disrespectful, you know, horrendous 0.99
00:22:56 evil Haiti right-wingers like me, but she was invited and she was on a panel. It was rather
00:23:01 spirited with Michael Geist and David Freyheit, who goes by Viva Fry or Viva Free, Frey. To be
00:23:08 honest, I don't know how he pronounces it now that I think of it, but he goes by Viva on Rumble
00:23:12 and on social media, and they had a spirited discussion about the future of media.
00:23:17 Now, Jen is very critical of the government's heavy-handed approach here,
00:23:21 but at the same time, she also doesn't go as far into the libertarian realm as David did,
00:23:26 and as perhaps many of you do.
00:23:27 So I wanted to sit down and get her perspective on this.
00:23:30 This is from the CSFN conference in Ottawa.
00:23:35 Non-subsidized media, independent media.
00:23:38 It is a relatively small community in Canada.
00:23:40 One of the best in this space, though, is The Line, founded by Jen Gerson and my old talk radio colleague, Matt Gurney.
00:23:47 Great to have Jen Gerson with us in person here.
00:23:49 Jen, welcome. 0.97
00:23:50 Thank you for having me.
00:23:52 You were speaking on a panel that actually got, it was one of the more engaging panels because there was a fair bit of contrast about the internet regulations.
00:23:59 And there are a great many of them from C11 to C18 and now C63. 0.99
00:24:04 At its core, you had said something that I found quite interesting, which was that, you know, yes, you're against a lot of what the government's doing.
00:24:09 but you're also concerned about a media ecosystem in which there's only a particular type of media
00:24:15 left i mean frankly one in which true north fills that void and i was wondering if you could just
00:24:19 expand on that a bit yeah i mean this this goes back to my argument and i it's a very unpopular
00:24:25 argument in this room and it will definitely be an unpopular argument with your audience
00:24:28 is that i do think there's a an important role for an organization like the cbc to play especially
00:24:34 when we're talking about a population we don't have the same population density in the u.s we
00:24:39 We don't have the same economies of scale that the U.S. has, and therefore it's a really,
00:24:43 really hard place for private media organizations to cover extensively, particularly when we're
00:24:48 talking about local news, right?
00:24:51 Not talking about Calgary or Toronto, those places are well served.
00:24:53 What about Medicine Hat?
00:24:54 What about Lethbridge?
00:24:55 What about Moose Jaw?
00:24:56 Places like that.
00:24:57 These places have become news deserts, and I think it becomes really difficult not only
00:25:01 to govern countries that don't have access to good quality journalistic media, but also
00:25:07 how do we maintain a sense of national identity and a sense of national cohesion in a media
00:25:13 environment where private media has essentially vacated this field? This is where I think that
00:25:17 there could be a role for a radically reformed or radically rethought out CBC or something like it
00:25:24 to be able to, by statute or by mandate, provide good quality, basic, objective journalism in,
00:25:32 say, every town over 100,000 people in this country. I think the counterpoint to that is
00:25:36 that that was supposed to be what CBC was doing,
00:25:39 and they've had a fair bit of mission creep
00:25:41 in the sense that they haven't wanted to do that.
00:25:43 I mean, when CBC launched its online opinion section,
00:25:45 it's like, can anyone say that opinions on the Internet
00:25:47 are in short supply, that we need a government?
00:25:49 Oh, dude, I'll go further.
00:25:50 Why do we have a CBC gem?
00:25:52 Why do we have a CBC streaming service?
00:25:54 Did you know that CBC actually is trying to duplicate Duolingo
00:25:57 with an app to teach people French and English?
00:25:59 I mean, these are things that are radically beyond
00:26:01 what most of us would understand the CBC mandate to be.
00:26:04 However, the answer to that question isn't necessarily to defund the CBC, the answer
00:26:08 is a radical mandate review.
00:26:10 And the other thing that I would do is I would take the CBC out of the Broadcasting
00:26:13 Act, where it currently nestles and has a very unclear and fairly vague mandate which
00:26:17 permits that kind of remission creep, and I would create a CBC Act.
00:26:21 I would essentially put the CBC in statute and I would enshrine things like their journalistic
00:26:25 standards of practice, I would enshrine a standard of journalism that I think most taxpayers
00:26:29 could get behind, and I would enshrine things like every, let's say for example, every town
00:26:33 over 100,000 people needs a CBC reporter, for example.
00:26:37 The other thing that I would do with the CBC,
00:26:39 I mean, if I were in charge in God,
00:26:40 then you know that's going to happen.
00:26:41 Well, if we probably have wins,
00:26:42 we can put your resume to the top of the pile
00:26:44 for taking over.
00:26:45 I would also say everything that the CBC produces
00:26:48 should be open source.
00:26:49 So every news organization, left, right, center, whatever,
00:26:52 should be able to take the CBC's written and visual content
00:26:54 and audiovisual content and use it.
00:26:55 Canadian press might not like that,
00:26:57 but let it be a public good.
00:26:59 But it's a public good.
00:26:59 If we're going to fund it like a public good,
00:27:01 we should treat the resources of that thing
00:27:03 like a public good.
00:27:03 I would have the CBC imagine itself more as a library,
00:27:06 like a library of journalistic knowledge and resources.
00:27:08 The other thing that I think people are not remembering as well
00:27:10 is that the CBC is a huge store of archival information,
00:27:13 digital and physical archives.
00:27:15 This is the repertoire or the reservoir
00:27:18 of a huge amount of Canadian culture and history,
00:27:20 and I think that we need to treat it as such
00:27:22 and put some serious investment
00:27:24 in maintaining those archives and those archive services
00:27:28 for the purpose of maintaining a Canadian culture thing.
00:27:31 The other thing I would do, and I would just say this,
00:27:32 I would also have the CBC see itself as a training apparatus or a training role.
00:27:38 So perhaps you go to the CBC if you want to start a podcast in Lethbridge.
00:27:42 Well, maybe you can go to the CBC and get a workshop about how to do podcast editing.
00:27:45 Maybe you can go to the CBC and rent out a room.
00:27:47 Maybe you can go to the CBC and rent out your equipment, that kind of thing.
00:27:50 So I could see them as being a real hub for being a support for creating an innovative media model in a country like Canada
00:27:58 where we have some unique sort of market-based challenges
00:28:00 by virtue of our size and lack of population density.
00:28:04 To go back to the local aspect for a moment,
00:28:06 one of the challenges with a true north is that,
00:28:08 and the line in particular, we're lean operations.
00:28:10 We can also find a coalition to support what we're doing nationally.
00:28:15 It would be incredibly difficult, if not possible,
00:28:17 to do that at a local level.
00:28:18 It's a hard, the numbers are really hard.
00:28:21 Because how many people do you need to make a living?
00:28:24 Well, you really need about a base of about 1,000 people
00:28:27 who will pay for you.
00:28:27 I mean, it's not huge.
00:28:28 It's not unattainable.
00:28:29 It's the old 1,000 true fans argument.
00:28:30 It's the 1,000 true fans, right?
00:28:32 So, okay, that's easy when you have, well, it's not easy,
00:28:35 but even in a country of, what, 40 million people, what are our fan bases?
00:28:39 Our fan bases are maybe large enough to support our income and a small team around us.
00:28:44 They're not large enough to support the 20, 30-person newsrooms of yore.
00:28:48 And I think that's just a reality that mainstream media has got to get used to.
00:28:51 But if we're talking about, well, how do we ensure that people in Sparwood
00:28:56 have good access to local information are there gonna be a thousand paying
00:29:00 people in Sparwood well maybe for some people they're really good but you know
00:29:04 what you're producing is the local football team the local basketball team
00:29:08 your local City Council your local court cases those sorts of things it's really
00:29:14 hard to make the economy of scale work there and that might be a reason or an
00:29:18 argument for some kind of help in the form of maybe it's just the CBC is in
00:29:23 that is in that space and supporting any kind of local startups but also serving that community in
00:29:28 that space. I think we need to get the CBC also does need to get back into the mindset of like
00:29:32 its job isn't to be a top-down creator of culture and meaning for people it's there to serve the
00:29:38 people it's a service that the people need to buy into to understand its value. If you lost the
00:29:43 audience in your CBC plan I think you can get them back on this one because you had also made a
00:29:47 comment in your remarks on stage that was I think probably the most controversial thing you'd say
00:29:51 to some people, which was that we need to get comfortable
00:29:54 with the idea of things going out of business.
00:29:57 And we need to get comfortable with this idea of collapse
00:29:59 because there is never going to be that reinvention
00:30:01 without that death.
00:30:03 And what we have now is this weird, you know,
00:30:05 indefinite life support model where we're keeping industries
00:30:08 that don't want to reform a board for what?
00:30:12 Well, that's the question.
00:30:13 And also, I mean, the line has made a particular point
00:30:15 of not accepting government subsidy in any form.
00:30:18 Not only do we not accept government subsidy in any form, 0.85
00:30:20 www.read the line please subscribe uh gotta get that bitch in like and like and subscribe um 1.00
00:30:26 but we think that's a bad business model not only does it compromise your independence and 0.91
00:30:31 your integrity and the credibility that you have with an audience but it's terrible it's a terrible
00:30:36 way to build a sustainable business model because it means that the next time a government comes in
00:30:40 and out of power your money can get turned off like that that's not that's not a way to run a
00:30:44 business now i understand that to some degree there's always going to be some aspects of
00:30:48 of subsidy in a country like Canada, you know, okay, fine, I'm fine with the local journalism
00:30:52 initiative that supports local reporters. You know, I don't really have an issue so much with
00:30:56 that. I do also understand that there's going to be some subsidies for organizations that are
00:31:01 purely cultural, so maybe there's going to be some arts magazine subsidies, those sorts of things.
00:31:06 Fine, you know, I'm not too fussed about that. I think that's the table stakes of a country like
00:31:11 Canada. There's nothing to be done about it. It's nothing I'm going to get too worked up over.
00:31:15 But no, what we've done is we've moved into a model
00:31:18 where basically every single private media outlet,
00:31:21 with the exception of maybe you and me, are government-subsidized.
00:31:25 That's not sustainable. That's insane.
00:31:28 That's completely insane.
00:31:29 And the taps are, I think, when Pierre Polyev becomes prime minister,
00:31:33 and I think at this point it's very likely to happen,
00:31:34 the taps are just going to get turned off on you.
00:31:36 And then what are you going to do?
00:31:37 You haven't reformed. You haven't sustained.
00:31:39 You haven't built something viable for yourself.
00:31:41 You're still bloated. You're still debt-ridden.
00:31:43 and you've still lost your advertising monopoly.
00:31:45 Now what?
00:31:46 There's no there there.
00:31:49 There's no future in that.
00:31:50 Well, and it cements that path dependency
00:31:52 because now you can't take it away
00:31:53 because we've built our entire businesses around that.
00:31:56 And also you've destroyed your brand models in the process
00:31:58 because now you've taken money from the government
00:32:00 so nobody trusts you, right?
00:32:02 Yeah, very well said.
00:32:03 And if you believe that money doesn't sway coverage
00:32:08 and how things are covered,
00:32:09 look at the way that the media who are the recipients
00:32:12 of, for example, C63's, Google's money,
00:32:16 go look in the past and look at how they covered C63.
00:32:19 It was almost-
00:32:19 C18.
00:32:21 C18, you're right.
00:32:21 I'm sorry.
00:32:22 Yeah, C63 is the online harm's one, yes.
00:32:23 I'm talking about the online news app.
00:32:24 All the numbers blur together.
00:32:25 It's a problem, I'm sorry.
00:32:26 But go look at how they covered themselves in that.
00:32:28 There was very, very little coverage
00:32:30 outside of the independent media,
00:32:32 organizations like mine, organizations like yours,
00:32:34 and academics like Michael Geist.
00:32:36 There was very little critical coverage of that.
00:32:39 So you can see in real time how money affects
00:32:41 the way people approach problems and coverage and by the way I don't think
00:32:45 that that's even unique to government money or advertising money you know the
00:32:49 people who could cut the check kind of get to set the rules and you and I we're
00:32:52 right now the line is 100% reader funded everybody who supports us supports us
00:32:56 because they find value in our product the risk of that kind of a model is
00:33:00 audience capture right like how do you make sure that you're providing stuff
00:33:03 that's true to yourself and demonstrates integrity for your own
00:33:06 beliefs and not just pander to your audience because you know that's what
00:33:09 they're going to pay for, right? That's a risk. When you have an advertising-based model,
00:33:14 you run the risk of being swayed by your advertisers. That's a risk you have to deal
00:33:19 with. And when you're predominantly subsidized by government, yeah, the government in power is
00:33:25 going to affect your ability to pay your rent. Of course, that's going to sway the way that you
00:33:29 view news and the way that you're shifting your mindset. That is unavoidable, but the way to
00:33:35 avoid that is to try and create as many different revenue streams as possible so that you can avoid
00:33:39 too much dependence on one kind of revenue stream and the other thing is to do is to just try and
00:33:44 maintain your integrity as much as possible with with a high diversity of revenue streams but also
00:33:48 you know not making yourself solely dependent on one revenue stream like the government right i
00:33:53 mean that's which is also true of you because even though you run the line you're publishing
00:33:56 everywhere i see you see you all the time but there's no purity here right and there can't be
00:34:00 because in a in an environment where everybody takes government money money if i want to do any
00:34:05 freelancing on the side yeah i mean i guess i have to i'm going to the cbc i'm going to take
00:34:09 a fee for going to the cbc but i'm also going to take a fee if i if i go to to write something for
00:34:14 the star or the globe so you're respectable you get invited all these places i don't yeah well
00:34:17 that's i i mean i'm i'm working on it i mean one of the funny things of the panel today is that i
00:34:21 suddenly realized that i'm not the bomb thrower in the room anymore and that was a real shift for
00:34:25 me yeah viva fry took that role yeah he took that role and i became the adult in the room and i'm
00:34:28 like i got a new suit but my god like i didn't think that this had happened like i'm i'm an old
00:34:33 I'm the old respectable lady now.
00:34:35 Like, how did that...
00:34:36 He's more of a burn-it-down person than you are on this, yeah.
00:34:39 Yeah, I mean, it was...
00:34:40 And then Michael Geist was, like, the government defender for a moment.
00:34:42 Which is hilarious, because Michael Geist is not a government defender in everything.
00:34:47 I think David and I sort of just agreed on a couple of points,
00:34:50 and that was one of them being there are aspects, for example,
00:34:53 of the Online Harms Act that are probably good and worth preserving.
00:34:56 There's a lot of problems with the Online Harms Act,
00:34:58 and, I mean, both Michael and I have written in depth and at length
00:35:01 about what we think those problems are.
00:35:03 I kind of disagreed with David.
00:35:05 I think he's got a misapprehension of why mainstream media is in trouble.
00:35:09 It's not for the reason that people like to think it is.
00:35:11 Most people, especially conservatives, like to think that mainstream media is in trouble
00:35:14 because mainstream media doesn't align with their viewpoints,
00:35:18 and therefore they've lost audience.
00:35:19 I think that's contributing, though.
00:35:21 I don't think you can separate the trust deficits from the business issues.
00:35:27 Yes, there's a trust deficit and there's a decline deficit.
00:35:29 But the primary, and I think that those are accelerating right now and have accelerated in the last five years.
00:35:34 But if you want to go back 10, 15 years where the problems with media started, the problems with media started with the collapse of the ad monopolies.
00:35:41 And you need to fundamentally understand that.
00:35:43 And as the collapse, the money got sucked out of the industry, the industry became more and more beholden to a kind of ideological viewpoint.
00:35:52 And that contributed to the trust deficit.
00:35:54 They became more dependent on government money.
00:35:55 That contributed to the trust deficit.
00:35:57 But it doesn't start with the trust deficit.
00:35:59 It starts with the collapse in the ad monopolies.
00:36:01 And this is why you see the same issues affecting mainstream media and legacy media,
00:36:05 regardless of whether or not they're left or right.
00:36:07 Because the reason why these organizations traditionally were able to print money
00:36:11 is because they had an absolute ironclad monopoly on the ad market,
00:36:14 and particularly on classifieds. 0.99
00:36:16 The second newspapers lost classifieds, they were in deep shit. 0.99
00:36:19 Yeah, fair enough. 0.99
00:36:20 Right?
00:36:20 All right, well, that's the first time that word has ever been uttered on True North.
00:36:23 Sorry.
00:36:23 Oh, wow, really?
00:36:24 Well, because we have the clean tag on Apple Podcasts that we forever lose.
00:36:28 I'm so sorry.
00:36:29 She has gone more irreverent than me, which is, I think, a great testament to the work of the line.
00:36:33 So, Jen Gerson, I love the line.
00:36:35 I read the line.
00:36:36 You should as well.
00:36:36 But it's great to talk to you in person.
00:36:38 You too.
00:36:38 Thanks.
00:36:42 Always love connecting with Jen Gerson.
00:36:44 And as I said about that conference, it was great to connect with people in person that I usually see in little Zoom boxes.
00:36:49 I don't know why I needed to, like, illustrate a Zoom box, like the old, like, you know, charades.
00:36:53 Anyway, well, I wanted to pivot from that to a discussion we had yesterday on the program about the normalization of anti-Semitism.
00:37:03 And I've always been clear to point out since October 7th, this is not a new issue.
00:37:06 It is one that I think has a new zeal and one that people have a newfound brazenness.
00:37:12 But a lot of what's happened in the last six months has merely been a ramping up of existing sentiments, existing groups, and really a sense that no one feels they need to hide.
00:37:23 their, what is in many cases, venomous hatred of Jews and the Jewish state. But it's not just
00:37:29 about Israel. It's not just about Zionism. It is about Jewish people. And this has become
00:37:33 abundantly clear in the clip that we played yesterday from Ottawa of them literally defending
00:37:38 October 7th and those attacks. And it's been clear in a lot of the rhetoric that talks about
00:37:43 resistance as though all of what's happened is not just bloodthirst and a murder, but is in fact
00:37:49 just an act of political resistance.
00:37:52 Now, that comment that was made on the weekend,
00:37:56 but we'll comment, plural, in Ottawa, about October 7th,
00:37:59 I wanted to share this clip of Deputy Prime Minister
00:38:01 Chrystia Freeland being asked to condemn it.
00:38:04 Over the weekend, protesters in Ottawa were heard
00:38:08 chanting, among other things,
00:38:10 long live October 7th,
00:38:12 and October 7th is proof that we are almost free.
00:38:15 Is this hate speech?
00:38:16 i wasn't in ottawa over the weekend and i'm not aware of those specific reports and so it would
00:38:27 be just wrong of me to comment on something that i am not specifically aware of um what i will say
00:38:37 is today is a time in Canada
00:38:41 when anti-Semitism and Islamophobia are on the rise.
00:38:48 When we have a lot,
00:38:51 there are a lot of Canadians
00:38:52 who are not feeling safe.
00:38:58 Oh, I wasn't in Ottawa then.
00:39:00 Oh, I was washing my hair that day.
00:39:01 Oh, I must have missed it.
00:39:03 I mean, at that point,
00:39:04 if I was the journalist
00:39:05 and I don't know the format of the press conference,
00:39:06 it would have been, well, I have it on my phone here. Why don't you watch it for yourself? But
00:39:10 that wasn't even necessary. The journalist quoted it. Why could Christopher Freeland not just in
00:39:14 that moment say, well, based on what you've just said, I think this. But she didn't because this
00:39:20 government's default position is cowardice. They only defend the most extreme examples and even
00:39:25 then never write away because they have to think about how it's going to reflect in their polling
00:39:30 numbers. This is what Christopher Freeland wrote on X after the fact. She writes in response here,
00:39:36 I need it up on the screen before I can.
00:39:38 There we go.
00:39:39 Having seen a video from this weekend,
00:39:41 I can only express shock and disgust
00:39:43 at the anti-Semitism and glorification of terrorism
00:39:46 that occurred on Parliament Hill.
00:39:47 This hate speech has no place in Canada, none.
00:39:50 I guess by that time, 529,
00:39:52 the focus groups had come back
00:39:53 and she could safely condemn what had happened.
00:39:56 It's difficult to not get angry about this.
00:39:59 And I also don't think people,
00:40:00 especially members of Canada's Jewish community,
00:40:02 should have to hide this.
00:40:04 My friend Dahlia Kurtz,
00:40:05 I actually met in Israel for the first time in person.
00:40:08 She and I were colleagues for the same radio company some years ago,
00:40:11 and we had the chance to go and travel Israel as part of a delegation of Canadian journalists
00:40:16 and have been friends ever since.
00:40:19 Dahlia was working on a book about something that had nothing to do with politics,
00:40:23 nothing to do with Israel, but was pushed off of that project onto another one.
00:40:28 In the wake of October 7th, that book is called Dear Zionist, You Are Not Alone,
00:40:32 just came out in the last few days.
00:40:34 and Dahlia joins me on the line now.
00:40:37 Dahlia, wonderful to talk to you again.
00:40:39 Thank you so much for coming today.
00:40:40 What's the background?
00:40:42 What is happening here?
00:40:43 I thought you did that.
00:40:44 I do not.
00:40:46 None.
00:40:46 No background.
00:40:48 That was...
00:40:49 There we go.
00:40:50 We're off to a great start.
00:40:51 It was the laser from Zion.
00:40:54 They redirected it in the inappropriate way
00:40:57 they were supposed to use those lasers 0.89
00:40:59 to send them...
00:41:00 I'm not allowed to say.
00:41:02 Andrea, I'm so happy to be on your show.
00:41:04 Well, it's good to have you here. Let's start on that comment by Chrystia Freeland, because
00:41:11 you have always been, and even just now, we're talking about a serious topic, but you've always
00:41:15 been just this ray of sunshine in Canadian media. Back when you did your former show, I know you
00:41:21 always used to highlight good news stories and positive things. I've seen from you a lot more
00:41:26 of an edge since October 7th, and I don't fault you for that, but I was wondering if you could
00:41:31 speak about how what's happened has really pushed the way that you are using your voice?
00:41:36 Well, one, when you're an independent, things change. People don't have to tell you to not
00:41:43 be as Jewish. You could be Jewish, but not a Jew. Ish part is okay. But the other part of it is 1.00
00:41:51 October 7th, I just put everything aside. I dropped everything that I was doing because I immediately
00:41:57 saw where this was going and what this was going to become and I immediately realized I'm going to
00:42:04 be that person that I always thought I would be if something like this happens again and let me tell
00:42:10 you anybody who is a child of the holocaust a grandchild of the holocaust that's what you're 0.90
00:42:16 you're going to think it's going to be in the back of your brain forever to hear Christia Friedland
00:42:23 speak the way that she does i mean the entire thing was absolutely laughable so all i can do is
00:42:29 i i wrote an entire joke about it online but the sad part is it was funny but it was only funny
00:42:37 because it's true so it's actually entirely pathetic i wasn't in ottawa i had heard what
00:42:44 had happened you don't need to be in ottawa she could have asked any one of the hundred plus
00:42:47 people in that room like you said to just play a little clip of the audio there she which she of
00:42:54 course let's all be clear she already heard that audio there's no way that she never did and then
00:43:00 she has to plop in there somewhere let me just say islamophobia is on the rise in canada which 1.00
00:43:07 she forgot to mention in that whole little spiel is about her sweet grandfather who interesting
00:43:14 connection when, you know, he is one of the Nazi newspapers that recruits, hmm, who did we end up
00:43:23 seeing in our parliament? It was the same type of person. There's a lot of direct lines here.
00:43:29 So, you know, it's not her action that I'm looking at. It's her inaction. And the inaction 1.00
00:43:35 is abundantly clear. There was a mosque that had a break in entry. It was an attempted break in
00:43:42 entry in winnipeg a couple of weeks back justin trudeau drops everything carbon emissions be
00:43:48 damned and he gets himself to winnipeg you could see like this lock was sort of broken and he's 0.80
00:43:55 hand on heart hand on heart nobody should be scared of a place they worship in what about 1.00
00:44:01 the hundred churches that have gone up in what about the jews who 400 000 of us with numbers
00:44:10 dwindling as we're moving away making aliyah more and more what about that what does that mean to
00:44:17 him and it's come to a point where the way i feel about it is everybody keeps saying lead lead and
00:44:23 i mean just yesterday i shared some investigative journalism that i've done where i looked at the
00:44:29 person who had been campaigning for the mayor of toronto olivia chow and this person mozem patel 0.95
00:44:37 i have a video in this tweet where you can see him asking demanding that we kill israel the very 0.90
00:44:43 person who has been campaigning with olivia chow so you know what i think it is absolutely ridiculous 0.50
00:44:50 that we even ask the leaders to do better there's there's nothing to do better because
00:44:55 one they're leaders with air quotes and two they've already failed us so we see what they're
00:45:02 capable of and we see what they're not capable of so the leaders have failed us we will not fail us
00:45:09 and i feel that that it's up to me it's up to people who have a voice it's up to anybody who
00:45:15 will speak up and not be afraid andrew it boggles my mind that people call me outspoken 0.72
00:45:22 why because i say don't kill the jews crazy talk you said something a few moments ago i i wanted to
00:45:31 revisit because you said it, I think almost incidentally, but you had said the type of
00:45:36 person you wanted to be the type of person you thought you'd be if something like this happened
00:45:39 again. And I found that word again, quite jarring because you and I know that terrorism in Israel is
00:45:46 not sadly uncommon. I mean, when you and I were there in 2015, there had been a spate of knife
00:45:51 stabbings on the street and Israelis have a much higher than normal tolerance level for, you know, 1.00
00:45:57 these sorts of things there. It takes a lot for something to rise to front page news in Israel
00:46:01 that elsewhere in the world would be. But when you say never again, you're putting October 7th,
00:46:06 as I understand it, in the same category as the Holocaust, are you not? 0.79
00:46:10 A hundred percent. And that's not even coming from my mouth directly. That's coming from every
00:46:15 hostage who's been released. They have said that was a Holocaust. It's a Holocaust. And so I'm
00:46:22 going to take from the people who are there, I'm going to take from the feeling that it gave me
00:46:27 And that is absolutely a Holocaust. I shared a picture the other day. I was looking at Columbia University and all of the students there who are blocking the Jews from going in. And I juxtaposed that against a picture I saw from 1938 in Vienna, where the students were blocking the Jewish students from entering. 0.82
00:46:47 And I thought, I'm going to find obviously the similarities in this, but what really struck me were not the similarities. It was the dark differences. It was the fact that now in 2024, where it looked worse because you saw more students, population has grown this or that.
00:47:07 The worst part about it is that these students who are now joining in this Kristallnacht, as it was described by the Jewish students at Columbia, they've had the opportunity to see history.
00:47:21 They've had the opportunity to learn from history and they have chosen the side of be less than human from history.
00:47:31 So that choice unto itself makes this much worse than what we experienced before.
00:47:39 And to see the way that Canada has reacted, to see what's happening in the U.S., to see all of these governments fail us,
00:47:47 I can completely understand how you create bonds and you create bonds with people.
00:47:55 it's the entire bond of am yisrael chai you know it's the bond of being one because you know that
00:48:02 not everybody is going to have your back so if they don't have it you will have it but at the
00:48:09 same time there are a bunch of people who are suffering and not everybody has the tools to
00:48:14 cope with this and since october 7th i've been receiving messages because i've been very bold
00:48:20 and I have been blacklisted up the wazoo, Andrew, death threats, blacklisted. My entire mission
00:48:28 has just gone to, okay, fine, I'm just going to pour myself into this. You can't pay rent with
00:48:35 pouring yourself into something. I'll be clear about that. But I will pour myself into this.
00:48:40 And if people are sending me messages from around the world saying that I'm doing something that's
00:48:45 helping them, well, that's absolutely fantastic. I need to do more of this. So I decided to write
00:48:53 this book, Dear Zionist, You Are Not Alone, 18 Letters of Hope and Light. And the whole idea of
00:49:00 it, first of all, is that this is not about Jews. It's about Jews and our non-Jew supporters. 0.55
00:49:06 The quickest Zionist test anybody could take, and most people don't even realize that they're 0.99
00:49:10 a zionist but the quickest zionist test anybody could take is do you believe israel has a right 0.99
00:49:16 to exist and if you say yes mazel tov you're a zionist and you know i got a message from one of
00:49:23 the readers yesterday and she said to me i finished reading the book and you know this part about you
00:49:28 are not alone when we're getting to that i know that you meant it for jewish people but i have to
00:49:32 say it really made me feel not alone i didn't mean it for jewish people i meant it for people i meant
00:49:39 for anybody who has a shred of humanity in them because i can guarantee you you can be any religion
00:49:46 any color any heritage any ethnicity and this book is going to touch you in some way just be careful
00:49:55 who you sit next to on an airplane because one of the readers was crying next to somebody who
00:50:00 did not quite know how to comfort them through this let me ask you about the hopefulness of it
00:50:09 because one of the challenges in a time like this is that we don't yet see an ended site. I mean,
00:50:15 if anything, you know, the public sympathy for Israel from people that might not identify as
00:50:20 Zionists was at a high point on October 7th, October 8th. And I think it's been in decline 0.99
00:50:25 ever since then. And I think, you know, people often very dishonestly conflate, you know,
00:50:31 oh, I have this little criticism with Benjamin Netanyahu. They use that to sort of shield,
00:50:36 No, you actually have a deep hatred of the Jewish people.
00:50:38 You're just, you know, trying to.
00:50:39 We're talking to a synagogue in Toronto and Benjamin Netanyahu's in his war cabinet.
00:50:44 Yeah, he doesn't even, you know, know what Yonge Street is.
00:50:47 And you're out there and you're in, you know, Forest Hill and all of that.
00:50:51 But where do you see this going?
00:50:54 Because, you know, with any sort of, you know, boiling crisis like this, the fear is that
00:50:59 it has to get worse before it gets better.
00:51:00 But at this point, it is worse.
00:51:03 I mean, we're seeing this.
00:51:03 We're seeing open calls for violence on the street.
00:51:06 And at this point, people are faced with two options.
00:51:09 They can either do something about it or they can literally do the Christopher
00:51:12 Ellen thing, do the ostrich thing, stick your head in the sand and say, oh, 1.00
00:51:15 I wasn't in Ottawa. Like, like at that point, it's you,
00:51:17 you can't make it more apparent than these people already have.
00:51:22 The hiding thing isn't hiding. It's aiding and abetting. That's all it is.
00:51:26 I don't see any other way around it. I think that things,
00:51:30 especially this past weekend,
00:51:31 I saw the surge and I see the surge of violence that's going to get worse.
00:51:35 somebody in person in person i mean andrew i get death threats i get people have like measured
00:51:41 nooses for my neck i i've had so many horrid things said to me online but there was a person
00:51:50 just near where i live who saw me gave me a dirty look and called me a nazi quick to run
00:51:58 mind you because that's what they do let's i love how defending jews has become nazism in 2024
00:52:07 i mean they show how devoid of historic historic knowledge and just you know basic fundamental
00:52:12 reason these people are and i took the word zionist also for the book because one its meaning
00:52:17 is powerful and true and two they're trying to take the word zionist away from us this has been
00:52:22 an ongoing campaign and this is where the jewish people have failed themselves in fighting something
00:52:29 like this which we've known for many many years has been coming there's been an ongoing palestinian
00:52:35 campaign that is very centralized and everybody has their documents and everybody has their way
00:52:43 of speaking and there's a very clear path and it is being executed exceptionally well it is a very
00:52:51 well-oiled machine meanwhile you have so many different jewish organizations each trying their
00:52:56 own thing not necessarily working together and it's just ending up being a lot of noise instead
00:53:03 of cohesiveness so this entire idea of the war that is not in the field but the war that the
00:53:10 war that is in the real world it needs to change the way that it is fought and for me i look at
00:53:15 at that in a couple of folds one you need to strengthen your people and by my people i'm not
00:53:22 referring to jewish people i'm referring to jewish people and our non-jewish supporters and i think
00:53:28 that the strength that is found in this book from the people who have been at the most bitter bitter
00:53:34 points of darkness in their lives the things that have happened to them a few of them are holocaust
00:53:39 survivors. One is a war hero. Another was on his way to terrorist camp to become a terrorist,
00:53:46 and then everything changed for him. So when you look at what these people have been through,
00:53:51 and also a very special story about my father, because he sacrificed everything to change
00:53:58 Canada so that people could get jobs regardless of religion, which ended up hurting him much more
00:54:03 later on but when you look at the hardships the tragedies the how are they going to get out of
00:54:10 this and these true stories and not only how they made it through but how they made it through to
00:54:16 become exceptional successes who thrived beyond measure and i will say if you've ever seen in 0.93
00:54:27 glorious bastards the last person that i highlight as a holocaust survivor in this book 0.87
00:54:33 dr morris schnitzer it will give you a little bit of that cathartic kick that you could get i'm not 0.98
00:54:42 going to give anything away there but really the whole point of this is i think that's one side of
00:54:48 the battle is helping people empowering people jews and our non-jewish supporters and that is
00:54:55 where this book comes from, and I have greater plans for a bigger series. I had to get this out
00:55:00 as quick as possible. My second edition is going to be longer in audiobook, in paperback, and then
00:55:07 this whole Dear Zionist is going to move on towards other series as well. But first, we have to work 0.59
00:55:14 on strengthening people, and the other side is we have to become more cohesive. We have to create
00:55:20 more of a singular vision in how we're going to tackle this the same way that the PR on the other
00:55:26 side has been working it for years, for years, for years, for years. And that requires a lot
00:55:32 of catching up. But we've also learned from Israelis and Jewish people, we can be very
00:55:37 innovative, especially when our lives are at risk. Yeah, very much so. And I've always been,
00:55:44 you know, I've always tremendously admired the resilience of Israelis, but you have to extend
00:55:48 that to Jewish people now. And, you know, people that go around the world in this day and age and
00:55:53 wear a yarmulke, walk into a synagogue, wear a Star of David. I mean, they're doing that knowing
00:55:56 full well what that attracts. And there you go. You got the, I don't know, it's a super Jew, 1.00
00:56:02 Superman. I don't know. It's a little bit of both there. I love it. Let's, Sean, throw that book
00:56:08 cover up there. The book from Dahlia Kurtz called Dear Zionist, You Are Not Alone. You can get that
00:56:12 over on her website, DahliaKurtz.com. Great to talk to you, Dahlia. Thanks so much for coming on
00:56:17 today andrew can i just mention quickly of course you you bought this book from me i didn't ask for
00:56:23 this conversation i'm happy i'm here usually you send media a book and you know that's just how it
00:56:29 is you didn't even ask me for a copy like everybody else you paid sir worth every penny but i will say
00:56:38 i mean i when i worked in in daily radio i i used you probably did as well in winnipeg i'd get from
00:56:43 publishers like it was it got to the point where it was almost like um you know like the letters
00:56:47 in harry potter and where they just keep coming like all these books like books would just show
00:56:51 up and i've never like asked for them or ordered them and and then once i wrote a book for the
00:56:56 first time i like i was like no i can't afford to just give everyone books and now i always i
00:57:00 always support my friends by buying the books so i want to know from the book at the end you tell
00:57:04 me your favorite quote no pressure to read it okay i'll do yeah it's always you pick one from
00:57:08 the middle so that everyone knows you read it and didn't just read it but i will read it from cover
00:57:12 to cover uh dahlia thank you so much thank you all right we'll get you back on soon that is it
00:57:20 for today we'll be back tomorrow with more of canada's most irreverent talk show here on true
00:57:24 north this is the andrew lawton show thank you god bless and good day to you all thanks for
00:57:30 listening to the andrew lawton show support the program by donating to true north at www.tnc.news
00:57:42 We'll be right back.
00:58:12 We'll be right back.
00:58:42 We'll be right back.