Juno News - July 19, 2023


“Experts” think Trudeau should get to keep governing if he loses next election

Topics
Mentioned
Trudeau blames "far-right" for Muslims supporting parental rights The Canadian justice system has COLLAPSED

Episode Stats


Length

33 minutes

Words per minute

174.22

Word count

5,844

Sentence count

231

Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

On this week's episode of The Andrew Lawton Show, Andrew talks about his recent trip to a coffee shop with his family, and how he managed to survive it. He also talks about the vaccine mandate in British Columbia, and why it might not be as bad as it sounds.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:00:05 This is the Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:00:11 Everyone, welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show,
00:00:15 the Andrew Lawton Show here on True North on this Wednesday, July 19th.
00:00:20 This is the continued week of Proof of Life.
00:00:23 I was actually at my favorite little coffee shop this morning,
00:00:27 and I was picking up a few things,
00:00:29 And the owner, who's a very, very lovely man,
00:00:32 he and his sister, which own this great business.
00:00:35 I don't want to name the business because I'm worried
00:00:37 that then like all the trolls will descend on them.
00:00:40 So if you guys want the shout out, let me know and I'll give you the shout out.
00:00:43 But he was like a bit worried that I had been away for two weeks
00:00:46 and he had thought like some other people that something had happened.
00:00:49 No, I'm still here. I'm still alive.
00:00:51 I don't have anything with a date on it to hold up.
00:00:54 I have an Air Canada meal voucher from a cancelled flight.
00:00:57 What's the date on that?
00:00:58 No, that's from June 8th, so that doesn't actually give me proof of life.
00:01:03 So you just have to take my word for it when I say it is July 19th and I am here and alive.
00:01:07 And according to my Apple Watch, I'm not even wearing my eyes, so even the Apple Watch can't give me proof of life.
00:01:13 My goodness, this is just a great intro to hopefully a show that can only go up from here.
00:01:19 We're going to talk a little bit later on in the program about the one province that seems to be clinging to its vaccine mandate more than anywhere else.
00:01:28 And if you live in British Columbia, you know I am talking about you, but it is in fact BC, which still has a horrendous vaccine mandate in place for its health care workers.
00:01:38 Now, I should say, it's not the only mandate remaining. There are little pockets of this.
00:01:44 There's actually a township not far from me in southwestern Ontario that has one as well.
00:01:49 But BC is one of the most sweeping, I'd say.
00:01:54 And despite the fact that the health care system is across the country still suffering from gaps in employment because they can't seem to find people, perhaps they shouldn't have fired all the nurses and other workers that they needed.
00:02:06 But I also want to talk a little bit about this strange discourse that's taken hold online in which the so-called experts, in this case the Laurentian elites, have a very different view of Canadian democracy compared to ordinary Canadians.
00:02:24 And I'm going to try to not get too into the weeds here, but it's an important discussion because we have in Canada a Westminster parliamentary system, which means, in effect, that elections are not the sole determinant or technically not the determinant at all of who becomes prime minister.
00:02:40 It is the composition of the House of Commons that decides that.
00:02:44 There is no technical role for the prime minister as a byproduct of Canadian elections.
00:02:50 So theoretically, all of the members of Parliament could be elected and the MPs could get there on the first day and say, you know, we think Cheryl Gallant should be Prime Minister, not Justin Trudeau, not Pierre Polyev, Cheryl Gallant.
00:03:06 They could say, oh, Nikki Ashton, yeah, the NDP MP Nikki Ashton, she's the Prime Minister. 0.62
00:03:12 Now, are they going to do either of these things? No.
00:03:14 But technically, members of Parliament could do that.
00:03:18 Now, this is something that we know exists.
00:03:20 We know there are non-confidence motions.
00:03:22 We know that parliamentarians can get together and oust a prime minister,
00:03:27 as a lot of people have been desperately hoping Jagmeet Singh will find a spine to do with Justin Trudeau.
00:03:32 But no such luck.
00:03:34 That spinal transplant must be way down the list on the waiting list on health care procedures.
00:03:39 This is British Columbia.
00:03:40 They can't find any nurses to give Jagmeet Singh his spinal transplant.
00:03:44 So he's just limping around there, like flopping over.
00:03:46 Hopefully one day he'll be able to stand erect, but it hasn't happened yet.
00:03:50 The reason I bring all of this up is because it's always Andrew Coyne on this issue, by the way.
00:03:55 This is like one of his number one go-to issues.
00:03:59 Andrew Coyne wrote a column a few weeks ago in which he stated what is technically a correct point.
00:04:05 It is a technically correct point based on the letter of the law and the unwritten convention
00:04:11 that there is a coming crisis of legitimacy in federal politics.
00:04:15 That's not the one. That's not the one. That's the one he wrote yesterday, which is I'll get to in a second here. But I bring this up because he was saying that you could lose the election and continue to govern, that Justin Trudeau could lose the election to the conservatives and say, you know what, the NDP is going to keep backing us. So we're just going to keep on going.
00:04:36 And this is something that the Laurentian elite think is an entirely appropriate course of action
00:04:42 because it fits the letter of what is constitutional in Canada.
00:04:48 Philippe Lagasse, who's again, I have no issues with Philippe,
00:04:52 but he is like the most technical guy when it comes to his analysis.
00:04:57 And he's very right. He knows his stuff.
00:04:59 But he writes this piece in the line,
00:05:01 ultimately the confidence convention is all that matters.
00:05:04 So it's not about elections, it's not about what we think is legitimate, this is all that
00:05:08 matters, that you have to command the confidence of the House, and if you do that, you're still
00:05:12 there.
00:05:13 Why this is so important is because what the experts are talking about is miles away from
00:05:20 what any ordinary Canadian would think about this if you were to ask them.
00:05:24 A Canadian would think that when they go to the polls, when they cast a ballot in an election,
00:05:28 that that means something.
00:05:29 And that when they vote for the local conservative or the local liberal or the local PPC or the local bloc, that they're actually voting for the person they think is going to be prime minister.
00:05:41 Even though Justin Trudeau's name is not on the ballot in London West, or AS is a real riding name, they still know that the stakes of the election are such that they're voting for or against candidates that are in the running for prime minister.
00:05:58 So when people come along and start to tell people that actually your votes don't matter,
00:06:05 it is causing a significant problem.
00:06:08 And I'm fully on board with the idea that I don't actually think there is such a thing
00:06:13 as a conservative minority government for the foreseeable future.
00:06:17 I think that Pierre Polyev, as the most viable challenger to Justin Trudeau,
00:06:21 needs to win a majority or he's not going to get a chance to govern.
00:06:25 Now, does this mean the election has been stolen?
00:06:29 I would say it's a tricky claim because technically there is nothing preventing Justin Trudeau
00:06:35 from doing exactly what Andrew Coyne and Philippe Lagasse are talking about,
00:06:39 losing the election and saying, you know, and this is again,
00:06:42 assuming that the Conservatives were to win a minority, a plurality, but not a majority.
00:06:48 Them saying, you know, Jagmeet Singh, he's going to keep us in business
00:06:51 and maybe the Bloc Quebecois, we bring them on board as well.
00:06:54 and we're just going to not allow the conservatives to do anything a few years ago when I think it was
00:07:01 the 2015 election Stephen Harper was doing an interview and he mentioned a nonchalant point
00:07:06 that I think most Canadians would agree with he said you know if I cease to if I don't win the
00:07:12 election if I don't win the most seats I will cease to be prime minister and what he was saying
00:07:17 is that if he doesn't win he is not going to keep around he's not going to stay around he's
00:07:23 not going to try to cling to power. And you had a lot of these same people, particularly Andrew
00:07:28 Coyne at the time, talking about this as though Harper was spreading misinformation that, oh no,
00:07:33 no, he absolutely could continue being prime minister after losing the election. And this is
00:07:38 not how Canadians view our system. So yeah, there are many different ways in which I could imagine
00:07:44 this happening. But I'm very much on board with what Ginny Roth wrote in The Hub. And we tried
00:07:50 to get Ginny on the show today but she was uh on holiday so couldn't join us uh and she says in
00:07:55 the minds of Canadians the party with the most seats win the election that's that so if you want
00:08:01 to talk about all these different scenarios in which Justin Trudeau or the liberals could remain
00:08:05 in power you are going to have a crisis on your hand because Canadians who do not care about the 1.00
00:08:12 intricacies of the constitutional convention or the confidence convention are going to see a guy
00:08:17 who lost the election using these antiquated tricks to stay in power and while it won't be
00:08:24 illegal there is no way whatsoever that such a thing would be legitimate and I think it's actually
00:08:30 very concerning and probably very revealing that we have so many different so-called experts that
00:08:37 seem invested in this narrative that are piping up now when there could be an election in the
00:08:41 coming months or in the coming year and a half two years all these experts that are talking about all
00:08:46 these scenarios that will conveniently keep Justin Trudeau or his successor in power.
00:08:52 And by the way, I mean, Justin Trudeau is not a popular figure right now. He just isn't. You look
00:08:57 at the polls, he's not a popular guy. So I don't think the NDP would keep Trudeau personally in
00:09:04 power. I think if anything like this were to happen, it would have to be contingent on someone
00:09:09 else. They'd say, okay, we'll back the liberals, but Justin Trudeau has got to go. And ideally,
00:09:15 the NDP will manage to find, you know, something that they can claim has been a concession. Because
00:09:21 this is the problem is that like Jagmeet Singh will go into a room with Justin Trudeau and say,
00:09:25 okay, I'll make you a deal. I'll keep you in power. And then Trudeau is just like sitting
00:09:30 there waiting for the, but you have to do X and it never comes. And then Jagmeet Singh leaves the
00:09:35 room and does his little dance and says, oh yeah, we won. It's great. It's like, if you ever saw
00:09:40 that old episode of Seinfeld when Kramer was trying to get the settlement from the coffee
00:09:46 company. They were about to offer him a lifetime supply of free coffee and a big fat check. And
00:09:51 he said, I'll take it before they announced that they were going to give him money. That's Jagmeet
00:09:55 Singh. He is the Cosmo Kramer of Canadian politics, except Singh didn't even get the lifetime supply
00:10:00 of free coffee. He actually gets nothing and keeps Justin Trudeau in power. So there's a visual for
00:10:07 you. Kramer, Jagmeet Kramer, Cosmo Singh will try to find a little way to make the meme work. But
00:10:12 that's effectively what's happening in Canadian politics. So when you hear this discussion,
00:10:19 be very concerned and very aware of what it's heading towards. There are people that are trying
00:10:24 to start right now crafting a narrative in which the Liberals get to govern virtually indefinitely,
00:10:31 even if they lose the election and I think if you're the conservatives you need to stress this
00:10:37 point that listen this is what these other guys are trying to do the only way you're going to be
00:10:43 guaranteed to get rid of Justin Trudeau is if you elect a conservative majority government now I'm
00:10:48 not a partisan I don't like Trudeau but I am not invested in one particular party I'm merely
00:10:53 offering some unsolicited advice here to the conservatives that that's the narrative they
00:10:58 need to put. Now, Stephen Harper did this because they saw in 2008 when the liberals, the bloc and
00:11:05 the NDP tried to make that unholy alliance with that weird three-way handshake in which they were
00:11:10 basically trying to overturn the results of the 2008 election. And it didn't work. It didn't work.
00:11:17 Stephen Harper, I mean, talk about constitutional tricks. He used propagation, which the folks that
00:11:23 were trying to launch a reversal of the election dared to say was tantamount to an authoritarian
00:11:29 power grab. So this is the type of stuff that's happening here. So be very wary of what the
00:11:36 government is going to do if it comes down to it and they need to cling to power. And to go back
00:11:42 to Jenny Roth's point, the liberals know that they can't just say, well, it's technically
00:11:46 constitutional. They'll need to offer people a little bit more. But my message to all the experts
00:11:51 on this is that you can't just cling to what is technically valid what is technically lawful what
00:11:58 is technically compliant with the constitution while ignoring the fundamental question the most
00:12:05 fundamental question that is facing governments in democratic nations or supposedly democratic
00:12:11 nations and that is is the government legitimate and i don't mean legitimate as in do you agree
00:12:19 with its policies. I mean legitimate in the, does the government have the consent of the governed?
00:12:25 Does the government have legitimacy in the eyes of the people? Because again, I can say, all right,
00:12:30 the guy I didn't vote for won, but that is still the legitimate government of the country. People
00:12:37 are not going to view a liberal government that continues governing after losing an election
00:12:41 as being legitimate. And that is how, I mean, all the commentators in the media in Canada love to
00:12:46 say that the Freedom Convoy was our January 6th incident, that it was our January 6th. And I mean,
00:12:53 setting aside how dishonest a lot of the media's interpretations of January 6th has been,
00:12:58 this would be a January 6th incident. You're going to incident. I can't say the word incident now.
00:13:03 This would be a January 6th incident. I used to actually, believe it or not, have a lisp. And I
00:13:09 had to do speech therapy as a child. And I was good for like, you know, the last 30 years. And
00:13:14 then it just all of a sudden came back when I tried to say sixth and incident back to back.
00:13:18 That was what broke it. That was what fried the brain. That makes me as effective a speaker as
00:13:24 Jagmeet Singh is a leader, evidently. But all of this is to say that we are going to have,
00:13:30 when the next election comes, a very critical question, which is, is the result going to be
00:13:36 the result and Canadians are especially those who are only occasional observers of politics
00:13:44 Canadians are going to have some very big and very uncomfortable questions if they vote for
00:13:49 an outcome that is not respected by the people in the halls of power that is it for this but do let
00:13:57 me know what you think in the comments on this and again I am okay with pedantry I'm okay with
00:14:02 zay me well actually uh thing and i'm okay with going well well the letter of the law says this
00:14:07 but i i'm talking about the bigger question here of what it will translate to to voters and what
00:14:14 it will translate to to canadians and if you're if you have the letter of the law on your side if you
00:14:19 have the constitution on your side but no one's respecting it well that piece of paper isn't
00:14:23 really doing anything for you and that's the point about which i am trying to warn people
00:14:28 Because, again, sometimes what's on paper doesn't translate to reality.
00:14:33 This one here is great.
00:14:34 Chrystia Freeland was bragging on Twitter that inflation is the lowest in two years.
00:14:41 She says, ooh, yes, inflation is the lowest it's been in two years
00:14:46 and within the Bank of Canada's target range,
00:14:48 and now it's lower than in any other G7 country.
00:14:52 So to use Chrystia Freeland's old measure for belt tightening, 0.99
00:14:55 This means we can all buy our Disney Plus subscriptions back once again.
00:14:59 So if you cancel Disney Plus to deal with inflation,
00:15:02 now is the time that you can actually get your Disney Plus subscription back.
00:15:06 So you can start binging on Beauty and the Beast and Aladdin
00:15:09 and the CGI reboots thereof
00:15:11 because Christian Freeland says inflation is at an all-time low.
00:15:14 Well, take a look around your grocery store.
00:15:17 When you are paying $8, $9 for butter,
00:15:20 when eggs continue to be a luxury item,
00:15:23 when you can't really afford to churn through all the milk that you normally would to keep your family milked up.
00:15:30 I don't know how many, I used to always have the milk growing up.
00:15:33 I don't know if that's still what families are drinking or if everything's all like organic vegan soy almond chai or something.
00:15:38 But nevertheless, I bet the organic vegan almond soy chai is going up with inflation as well.
00:15:44 So when the finance minister says, oh, well, everything's at a two-year low,
00:15:48 that has not translated to the pricing that you see on grocery store shelves and as Adam Chambers
00:15:55 the conservative MP noted on Twitter a lot of this is about the separation of the technical economy
00:16:02 from the real economy the financial economy from the real economy as you see the volatility of
00:16:09 energy prices notably cause things to go up and down up and down when for Canadians they're just
00:16:15 continuing to go up and up so we'll talk about this a little bit more next week on the show
00:16:21 I want to talk about British Columbia here because this every time I talk about the post-pandemic
00:16:27 era or I talk about restrictions and mandates in the past tense I always get a few emails very
00:16:32 kind thoughtful emails from people in British Columbia saying well you know hate to break it
00:16:38 to you but it hasn't really ended here and this is true British Columbia for a lot of the pandemic
00:16:43 was one of the best provinces for not locking down for keeping businesses open but not perfect
00:16:49 they still had the vaccine passport and it has also been the most stubborn when it's come to the
00:16:54 vaccine mandates especially as they pertain to health care workers so as we see now bc is still
00:17:02 holding to its vaccine mandate for health care workers but they've said that no longer do you
00:17:07 need to provide the proof of your vaccination status to your regulatory colleges. In fact,
00:17:14 there's actually been a bit of a disconnect in how some people were reading this report originally
00:17:19 and how it is now. And ultimately, I want to get to the bottom of this and talk about
00:17:24 some of the legal challenges that are afoot against the British Columbia government over
00:17:28 this. Joining me on the line now is Charlene Lebeau, who is a lawyer with the Justice Centre
00:17:34 for constitutional freedoms.
00:17:36 And I should also just say, by way of disclosure,
00:17:38 I actually sit on the board of the JCCF,
00:17:41 though that had no bearing in setting up this interview.
00:17:44 And I always put that disclosure
00:17:46 just so everyone is aware of where I'm coming from
00:17:49 in my support for the organization.
00:17:51 But I'll ask you, Charlene,
00:17:53 what is the situation in BC now, first and foremost?
00:17:56 Because I think there was a bit of confusion this week
00:17:58 about whether the government was dropping the mandate
00:18:01 or just amending how it's unfolding.
00:18:04 Right. Thanks for having me, Andrew. Yes, the mandate is still in place for the
00:18:09 BC healthcare workers. So any healthcare worker who is employed by a BC health authority
00:18:16 is still required to show proof of having taken two doses of an approved COVID-19 vaccine
00:18:22 in order to be able to work. So this new order that Dr. Bonnie Henry issued on July the 14th,
00:18:29 just this past Friday, essentially cancels an order that she made on June 10th, 2022,
00:18:36 about a year ago, that required regulated healthcare workers to provide proof of vaccination
00:18:42 to their colleges. So really, that order impacted those in private practice, not those that were
00:18:53 employed by a BC health authority. So that's very significant. So cancelling that order means that
00:19:00 those regulated healthcare workers in private practice do not have to show or do not have to
00:19:11 provide proof of vaccination to their colleges. So it doesn't impact our lawsuit. So I'm one of
00:19:17 of the lawyers on a lawsuit in which we're representing 11 BC healthcare workers who
00:19:24 were fired for not having taken the vaccine. So that, that lawsuit is continuing and we have
00:19:31 trial dates set for November of this year. Now just to, how do they define vaccinated? Are they,
00:19:38 is it a two dose definition or a booster definition? It's a two dose definition. There
00:19:43 was some confusion in April of 2023. So April 6, Dr. Bonnie Henry issued two new orders and we call
00:19:52 them the hospital and community care order and the residential care order. And there was some
00:19:57 confusion because people thought that she was changing it to require or changing the definition
00:20:05 of fully vaccinated to mean three doses, but in fact, that's not accurate. Those April 6, 2023
00:20:15 orders, they still only require two doses of the vaccine. The order talks a lot about the booster
00:20:25 and encourages people to get the booster and talks about how good the booster is,
00:20:32 but it doesn't require it. And those orders also essentially captured two new groups of workers, 0.66
00:20:42 not even healthcare workers, but those workers that enter health facilities such as construction
00:20:50 workers and occasional workers who do not have contact with patients. So before the April 6th
00:20:56 orders were granted those two groups of workers did not if they did not show proof of vaccination
00:21:03 they had to physically distance and wear masks so that was an exemption in those orders it wasn't
00:21:10 called an exemption but it it was that they were allowed to enter facilities without
00:21:15 showing proof of vaccination and now that's those that's taken out of the orders so now those two
00:21:21 groups of workers are included. Just to talk about the doses for a moment here, this is so
00:21:28 absurd because even if you take the government's own messaging around vaccine efficacy at face
00:21:34 value, which I think is fraught with challenges, but a healthcare worker who got their first dose
00:21:39 in December of 2020 and maybe their second dose in, say, February of 2021 has gone two and a half
00:21:48 years without ever receiving any dose whatsoever of vaccine which means the effectiveness of that
00:21:56 vaccine again to use the government's own narrative is zero neck is literally nothing so the idea that
00:22:02 that is a requirement to work in health care is absurd when if you got vaccinated in january of
00:22:10 2021 or 2022 even, you are less protected than an unvaccinated person who got COVID a month ago is.
00:22:20 Yes, and that is one of our arguments for sure. So what has the government done, if anything,
00:22:26 in its submissions or in public comments to push back against this, to basically defend
00:22:32 the science of its mandate? Well, they're still repeating the same mantra, which is that
00:22:39 um it the the vaccine is is is safe and effective and you know essentially they're silent on
00:22:48 I mean I guess they say they say two things they do acknowledge that um the vaccine efficacy wears
00:22:57 off over time or wanes quickly really but at the same time they say that um it reduces symptoms
00:23:05 symptoms and that having two doses is certainly better than being unvaccinated. But yes, you
00:23:12 should get a booster as well. So those are the types of things that they say. I saw, I can't
00:23:18 remember the exact number, but I know that the BC Nurses Union just a couple of months ago was
00:23:23 talking about the nursing shortages in BC. And the problem was the ratio of healthcare workers to
00:23:29 patients was concerning and ultimately leading to a lack of adequate patient care. So here we have
00:23:37 a government that is preventing people from working in its healthcare system. Well, the people
00:23:42 in that system who are vaccinated, who've gone through the protocols are saying, hey, we need
00:23:47 more staff. Oh, yes, absolutely. And I mean, you'll hear Adrienne Dix say, you know, talk about how
00:23:55 they're bringing in workers from overseas and they have a plan to increase the health care workers
00:24:02 by, you know, certain numbers. But yeah, I mean, the fact is that there is a serious health care
00:24:09 shortage and they talk about how they're going to fix it, but it's still, you know, a real problem.
00:24:17 What is the basis of the argument here? Because I know there's always been a bit of a question about
00:24:22 the best avenue to challenge some of these mandates, whether it's on constitutional grounds
00:24:28 or through other means. So what's the, if you can, as much as you can divulge anyway,
00:24:32 what's the strategy that you're taking with your challenges?
00:24:35 Yes, well, part of the challenge is based on constitutional grounds, that it's a violation
00:24:41 of constitutional rights. So yeah, so that's one basis. But, you know, we're also looking at
00:24:46 of challenging the science. So the efficacy of the vaccine, and also adverse reactions and things
00:24:57 like that. So we're looking at the science, and we're definitely incorporating that into our
00:25:00 argument. One of the big things that and this has come up when we've talked about vaccine mandates
00:25:07 in other sectors as well, whether it's the federal public service vaccine, or the airline employee
00:25:13 vaccine and whatever the case is that you know there are a few different categories of people
00:25:17 here there are those who say you know what i'm not going along with this and therefore they lose
00:25:22 their job or they get laid off or fired they're victims of this i i would also say the people that
00:25:27 that get vaccinated against their will to keep their job are victims of of this as well and and
00:25:34 i don't know how you quantify that number but there's a large group here of people that were
00:25:39 literally coerced into this and are still being coerced into this because uh this is the only
00:25:43 way they get to do what for many of them has been a lifelong a lifelong calling working in health
00:25:48 care yes so yes it very it does look like coercion absolutely but the government's answer to that is
00:25:58 it's a choice it's still a choice you're not it's actually not a mandate is what they're saying
00:26:03 it's a choice. So, I mean, it really looks like coercion. But technically, it's still a choice.
00:26:16 And the thing is, is that the right to work is not protected under the Constitution.
00:26:24 How were, how have the, I mean, I'm assuming I know the answer to this, but I'm curious to hear
00:26:30 the way you describe it here. How have the hospitals, how has the healthcare system been
00:26:36 on exemptions? Because I know that technically, people can claim a religious exemption or a
00:26:42 medical exemption to these things under human rights laws, but I know that these have been
00:26:46 next to impossible for people to get reliably in other provinces when they've had these mandates
00:26:52 in place. Well, so the orders actually do not allow for any exemption other than a medical
00:26:59 exemption so naughty they don't even allow the religious uh conscientious exemption wow no no
00:27:05 that's right and the medical exemption really is just the the criteria is it's just such a narrow
00:27:12 um exemption that essentially nobody qualifies you know so um the exemptions require that you
00:27:21 either have to have taken one dose i mean there's there's a whole list but essentially you have to
00:27:26 to have taken a dose and been um you know had a severe allergic reaction almost died you know
00:27:34 gotten really ill from the first dose and and the exemptions really are not true exemptions
00:27:41 they're really just deferrals so very few people have qualified just to drill into that point so
00:27:48 someone could have a very good relationship with their family doctor and the family doctor could be
00:27:53 very pro-vaccine and say, you know, in your case, I think you might have an issue with this vaccine
00:27:59 because of X. And that person might actually have to go through that issue before that medical
00:28:06 advice qualifies them for an exemption. Well, yes. And first they have to go to an allergist
00:28:11 to get that opinion. And the thing is also is many medical professionals were very reluctant to
00:28:18 get involved and to provide those kinds of letters requesting exemptions. So it's very difficult.
00:28:26 Yeah, very difficult for people to obtain that exemption. I don't have much time for the BC
00:28:33 Human Rights Tribunal, but I know that it is a body that does have a fair bit of power on these
00:28:39 things. So how has it not become involved in this when you have exemptions that, as I understand,
00:28:45 should be protected under human rights law at least that aren't being respected by the mandate
00:28:51 yeah i don't know of any um cases at present that are being handled yeah interesting and again i i
00:29:00 mean the the challenge with that body is that i i feel it more often works against individual
00:29:05 choice than for it but uh from what you had just said which i i didn't know that the bc mandates
00:29:10 for healthcare workers don't even allow for the human rights exemptions that other provinces
00:29:15 at least claim to. I found that quite shocking. So just looking forward here, I mean, we've seen
00:29:21 in some of the COVID cases that have come up in different provinces, a fair bit of deference from
00:29:27 courts to governments. And I'm wondering if you're expecting in BC to have a similar challenge afoot,
00:29:34 or if maybe the courts in British Columbia have been somewhat better on this in your view.
00:29:38 I don't think so, no. The courts have been pretty consistent across Canada in
00:29:43 deferring to the government and the government science. So just a little bit more about our case.
00:29:53 Many of our petitioners were administrative workers or who worked remotely anyway,
00:29:58 not even due to the pandemic. And so one of our arguments is that the orders are overbroad
00:30:06 because they are impacting you know so these these workers were fired for not taking the vaccine and
00:30:13 yet they worked in administrative positions and or so they weren't at a risk of infecting a patient
00:30:20 which is basically the argument the government used to justify these things that's right explain
00:30:26 to me if you can and i i mean i know it's difficult to explain the the inexplicable but
00:30:30 But how the government has, to back up here, what it seems like is that the government is trying to filter out a type of person that it doesn't want working for it more than it's trying to prevent against any risk.
00:30:45 And I'm wondering if I'm being perhaps too cynical there, or if that would align with your perspective on this, having now studied this file so extensively.
00:30:54 Yeah, I would agree with that. Yeah, they want a certain type of worker. Yeah. 1.00
00:30:58 So in this particular case, you have a mandate that really serves to just say, you know, you're either on this side of the debate or you're on this side of the debate.
00:31:08 Exactly. Yeah.
00:31:10 Well, I appreciate very much you chatting about this.
00:31:13 I know we'll cover this up in November when the trial comes.
00:31:17 Joining me now is lawyer for the JCCF, Charlene Lebeau.
00:31:21 Charlene, thank you so much for coming on today.
00:31:23 Thank you for having me.
00:31:24 thank you and again i just say so that no one can accuse me of uh going too soft on charlene and the
00:31:31 jccf i'm on the board of that organization but again i was interviewing their folks and talking
00:31:36 about their cases before i joined the board and presumably will do so after i leave whenever that
00:31:41 time comes but uh i haven't been fired just yet which is uh if you get fired from a volunteer
00:31:47 position i think you have to be uh really doing something quite wrong here uh just
00:31:51 funnily enough on the note of mandates i don't know if you've ever been to in and out burger
00:31:56 i've never been because when i'm in like the southern u.s my go-to is chick-fil-a that's like
00:32:01 i was in uh tennessee recently and literally first thing i did before leaving the airport
00:32:05 got to go to chick-fil-a uh so i haven't been to in and out burger uh but people in the u.s
00:32:11 seem to love it i've got friends in the u.s that love it uh in and out burger has put a mask
00:32:16 mandate in place. Now before you go against In-N-Out Burger, you should learn it's actually
00:32:22 a no mask mandate. They've actually banned employees in five states from wearing masks
00:32:28 and they say if you want to wear a mask at work, you need a letter from your doctor saying you
00:32:34 must. So this is Arizona, Colorado, Nevada, Texas, and Utah starting August 14th, no masks allowed.
00:32:42 Now this is not something, Starbucks is like the one place, if you go to a Starbucks, you're going
00:32:46 to see lots of people that are wearing masks no matter where you go like young healthy vibrant
00:32:51 people in the prime of their lives will wear their masks because it's like a status symbol to some of
00:32:57 these folks but if you're looking for a burger in Arizona Colorado Nevada Texas or Utah you won't
00:33:03 have any masks getting in the way of the ordering process at In-N-Out Burger may as well just go
00:33:09 there while you still can I'm sure Biden will find some way to shut them down anyway that does it for
00:33:15 us for today. We will talk to you all on Friday with another special edition of The Andrew Lawton
00:33:20 Show here on True North. Thank you, God bless, and good day to you all. Thanks for listening to The
00:33:25 Andrew Lawton Show. Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.