Juno News - January 23, 2024


Federal Court declares use of Emergencies Act UNCONSTITUTIONAL

Topics
Mentioned
Arsonists set Canada on fire. NOT Climate Change. It's official: Trudeau broke the law

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 11 minutes

Words per minute

162.79

Word count

11,586

Sentence count

489

Harmful content

Misogyny

11

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

5

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

A federal court of Canada has struck down the government's ban on freedom of speech and protest in the wake of the 2011 Pandemic. In a landmark decision, the court ruled that the government had overstepped the scope of the Emergencies Act, and that the ban violated the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:20 north hello and welcome to you all this is canada's most irreverent talk show the andrew
00:01:30 lawton show on true north live on this tuesday january 23rd 2024 just after one o'clock eastern
00:01:39 time that makes it just afternoon central if you are in beautiful alberta it is a nice mid-morning
00:01:46 11 a.m. for you on the west coast slightly earlier mid-morning 10 a.m. If you're in
00:01:53 Atlantic Canada I always get confused with the half-hour time zone but some very very good news
00:01:58 for you all if you are supporters of freedom as I suspect many of you I certainly hope many of you
00:02:04 are after several years of doing this show just in hot off the presses from the federal court of
00:02:10 Canada, the Emergencies Act regulations invoked by the federal government just two years less
00:02:17 a month ago were outside the parameters of the Emergencies Act and more crucially were
00:02:24 unconstitutional. This is a lengthy decision that just came out within the last hour, 190 pages from
00:02:31 the federal court. I'll get down to brass tacks here. It is declared that the decision to issue
00:02:39 the proclamation and the associated regulations and order was unreasonable and ultra vires the
00:02:46 emergencies act that means outside the legal bounds of it it is declared that the regulations
00:02:52 infringed section 2b of the charter and declared that the order infringed section 8 of the charter
00:02:59 and that neither infringement was justified under section 1. 2b is freedom of expression part of the
00:03:07 charter sacrosanct human right in this country. And Section 8 is a more interesting one. Section 1.00
00:03:14 8 refers, well, it's illegal rights, but we'll get to that when we talk to Christine Van Gein,
00:03:19 who is the litigation director with the Canadian Constitution Foundation, and joins us now.
00:03:25 Christine, I know you've not had, lawyers are very speedy readers, but I know you haven't had
00:03:30 time to fully digest 190 pages just yet. But what's your early reaction on this case here?
00:03:36 and what was your role in it? So our role, we were one of the parties that brought this. This
00:03:41 was brought by the Canadian Constitution Foundation, which is a national legal charity
00:03:46 that fights for fundamental freedoms in Canada, as well as by the Canadian Civil Liberties
00:03:51 Association, as well as by another organization called Frontline Nurses, and by some individuals
00:03:58 who had been affected by the emergency measures. For example, individuals who were arrested for
00:04:06 breaching, or I guess they actually weren't charged under the emergency measures, but they
00:04:11 did have their bank accounts frozen. So the reaction is I'm absolutely thrilled. I didn't
00:04:21 know what I was expecting. You know, you kind of try to brace yourself when you are dealing with
00:04:26 this complex litigation that goes on for extended periods of time. I mean, I didn't know what to
00:04:33 expect um my my best hope i think was was surpassed with this because we really won on everything
00:04:42 um the the crux of this case is that the invocation of the emergencies act in response
00:04:51 to the 2022 freedom convoy was unreasonable and ultra veras which means outside the scope of the
00:04:59 authority of the government and then the other major issue was whether or not the actual
00:05:06 regulations that were created under the emergencies act which is prohibitions on gatherings that
00:05:12 prohibited people from protesting and a um or going to a prohibited protest and then the financial
00:05:21 the economic measures which ended up freezing people's bank accounts and the court found that
00:05:27 those measures were unconstitutional they violated the canadian charter of rights and freedoms
00:05:31 and there's also some discussion in the case about the bill of rights i i mean i'm only i'm
00:05:37 90 pages into the decision which i got less than an hour ago i'm trying to get through it as quickly
00:05:43 as i can for initial reaction just to see what the big issues are and then i'm going to obviously do
00:05:49 an even deeper dive after this but my initial reaction is this surpassed my my expectations
00:05:55 this is a wonderful day for fundamental freedoms in canada for the right to protest and a wonderful
00:06:02 day on i mean i i think a lot of canadians throughout the pandemic had their faith in our
00:06:08 our justice system really challenged because there were a lot of decisions that didn't come
00:06:15 down the way we had hoped this is a huge exception and i think that in the the context of the
00:06:21 a pandemic, the invocation of the Emergencies Act was the most extreme piece of government
00:06:26 overreach. And here we have a court slapping down the Trudeau government for having done that.
00:06:31 And just to put a finer point on this, and please, if I've misrepresented this,
00:06:36 correct me, but as I understand it from what you said and what I've read so far,
00:06:39 the court has found that there was no emergency, basically, in keeping with what the Emergencies
00:06:45 Act has said. And even if there were, the measures employed were not constitutional.
00:06:50 am i understanding that correctly so i haven't got to the second part of your question yet but
00:06:55 i'll read directly from paragraph 255 for you for these reasons i conclude that there was no
00:07:02 national emergency justifying the invocation of the emergencies act and the decision to do so
00:07:07 was therefore unreasonable and ultra virized should i be found to have aired he then goes on
00:07:12 to discuss uh some of the different threshold requirements um because the the invocation of
00:07:17 emergencies act that piece of extraordinary legislation actually has a number of internal
00:07:22 thresholds like uh threat to the security of canada and a requirement that the law be a law
00:07:28 of last resort now 90 pages in i'm not at those parts yet and i don't uh and i haven't got to the
00:07:34 charter arguments on the actual regulation so i can't comment on that yet but i know the result
00:07:40 which is that they were found to have been a charter breach and and not saved by by section
00:07:46 in one of the charter. Let me just pull ourselves out of this decision for a moment here. And I
00:07:51 just want to, I mean, maybe this is a bit of a civics lesson for people, but we went through
00:07:55 this massive public order emergency commission last year. And at the end of that, Justice
00:08:00 Rouleau or Commissioner Rouleau had concluded that the Emergencies Act was satisfied. That
00:08:06 threshold was satisfied. So which is more important really? And how do we rationalize
00:08:12 and sort of reconcile these two seemingly, well, not seemingly, these two inherently
00:08:17 contradictory findings? This is a really important question. This case is no question
00:08:23 more important. The actual decision from a court has much more weight. The Rouleau decision has
00:08:31 no precedential value. It would be of political consequence. But I don't want to, you know,
00:08:37 invalidate that as an exercise because one of the really important things that was we that helped us
00:08:43 to actually achieve this result in the court case was because the ruleau commission had this extreme
00:08:49 level of transparency and we were able to access all kinds of cabinet documents that we otherwise
00:08:54 would not be able to access which actually we had in this case the government had been fighting us
00:09:01 over the disclosure of these documents that we wanted and we were able to access them because
00:09:05 they ended up becoming public through the Rouleau inquiry. So that, even though I totally disagree
00:09:10 with the result in that inquiry, it still was a really important part of the process that led us
00:09:17 to this result, which has a huge bearing and weight on how this emergency legislation can
00:09:26 be used in the future. I think the long-term impact of this decision is that this will reign
00:09:32 in some of the concerns that we had over the government now having you know unleashed the
00:09:38 kraken and they've now used this piece of extraordinary legislation i think they're
00:09:44 there's going to be a lot more um restraint now because they've really been slapped down for this
00:09:50 this is an absolute loss for the trudeau government they couldn't they couldn't have lost worse like
00:09:57 this yeah that's fair and i know this is not a coveted case i think a lot of times it gets
00:10:01 lumped into the landscape of covid because that was the environment the birth the freedom convoy
00:10:07 which to the government birth the the emergencies act so this isn't a coveted case but i do think
00:10:11 if we look at all of the pandemic challenges that have been uh there in the last couple of years
00:10:16 one thing you and i have talked about i'll say lamented on stage and on this show has been how
00:10:20 deferential uh courts have been to the state over this period including on freedom of expression
00:10:26 issues. So it is, it is really a divergence from what a lot of the jurisprudence has been on some
00:10:33 of these cases of this era over the last few years, is it not? It is. Yes. I think that this
00:10:39 was a case though, where I think one of the issues with the COVID era cases was evidence
00:10:45 and that it was difficult to litigate with the scientific evidence as the basis about,
00:10:52 you know, how dangerous is the virus? And there was a lot of deference given to the government
00:10:59 about that. And there was a kind of a lack of scientific evidence that was in the court cases
00:11:06 themselves. Now, some of the cases, there were some in Manitoba that had some discussion of the
00:11:11 evidence, but for the most part, it was not litigated on the science. So it was, in the end,
00:11:18 the courts ended up having deference to the government. In this case, this is more straight
00:11:23 principles of law. And there actually, in this case, was a huge amount of evidence because of
00:11:31 the Rouleau inquiry. We had all of these affidavits. We had all this evidence from
00:11:34 testimony, from policing experts, from cabinet ministers. So there was a lot here to help the
00:11:42 justice reach this conclusion. And you also had the government attempting to have this dismissed
00:11:49 on mootness grounds, which the judge clearly did not do. And I think we can be very grateful for
00:11:54 that fact. But that was one that I found quite notable that we have such a massive, unprecedented
00:12:00 legislation, incredibly controversial usage of it. And the government didn't even want there to be
00:12:05 a judicial review on it. Yeah, I think that that's such an offensive notion that this piece of
00:12:11 extraordinary legislation that by its very nature is temporary. Anytime you invoke emergencies are
00:12:17 just temporary by nature. That's what makes it an emergency. And the idea that you could never
00:12:23 scrutinize this, the use of this legislation, because by the time you get to court, the
00:12:29 emergency is over. This is like a preposterous type of suggestion by the government. And now
00:12:35 the the judge justice mosley did find that the case was moot i mean the the facts on the ground
00:12:41 were were done but of course courts have the inherent discretion to hear a case in spite of
00:12:49 its mootness so he did proceed to hear the case even though you know the the protests obviously
00:12:54 had resolved and the emergency declaration had been revoked it was only in place for a very
00:13:00 short period of time. And this was a huge issue in the hearing where Justice Mosley just did not
00:13:05 seem to be buying it at the hearing. He said, in what context would a court ever hear
00:13:12 a challenge? Because it's always going to be over. The emergency is always going to be over
00:13:18 by the time it gets to court. And the attorney general really tried to wiggle out of that one.
00:13:25 But I mean, it is what it is. And the judge is right in this case. It's always going to be over by the time you get to court. And we're happy that this absurd mootness argument was rejected.
00:13:38 it. We are going to have you back tomorrow for a deeper dive into this once you've had a chance to
00:13:44 pour over it here. And I know there are going to be a few things that you'll be looking out for
00:13:48 specifically, but I just wanted to ask you, is this effectively a guarantee that the government
00:13:53 is going to appeal this to the federal court of appeal? If I were a betting woman, I would bet
00:14:00 they're going to seek leave to appeal it's they haven't said so yet but i would be absolutely
00:14:08 shocked if they don't appeal i mean i'm interested to see what the government's statement on this is
00:14:13 um because i mean it's a brutal loss for the trudeau government today well and you may not
00:14:19 have seen this they had a bunch of media adherences planned from ministers who have all now gone into
00:14:24 hiding in montreal like bill blair was about to speak and now they've like you know shoved him
00:14:29 the back door and canceled this so one thing i would say though andrew is that i mean i am i'm
00:14:35 certain that the government is going to try to appeal this or they're going to seek leave to
00:14:39 appeal they haven't said it but i would bet that they are and um this is a case that is tremendously
00:14:45 expensive so if your supporters care about this issue and they want to see us successfully fight
00:14:51 an inevitable appeal they can make a donation to our legal fees at the ccf.ca donate yeah there
00:14:58 There was no, I noted in the decision, there was no cost award here.
00:15:01 So it's not even like the government is, you know, forced to give you a token for, you know, having bought this.
00:15:08 We actually typically don't ask for costs.
00:15:10 There's maybe a few exceptions, but I mean, that's taking your and my money, Andrew, because we're always suing the government.
00:15:16 You're taking the libertarian approach.
00:15:18 Let those who support this fight support you.
00:15:20 Well, that website is theccf.ca.
00:15:23 Again, Christine, congratulations.
00:15:25 We will talk to you on the show tomorrow in a bit more depth on this, but well done.
00:15:28 Wonderful.
00:15:28 Thanks, Andrew. Thank you. Thank you so much. That was Christine Van Gein, litigation director for the Canadian Constitution Foundation. Incredibly important decision. Now, I've been working my way through it. Like I said, I can read quickly. The judge has written it in a fairly clear way, but you're still reading in some ways legalese and you're still reading 190 pages of it.
00:15:50 So this is going to take a little bit of time for me.
00:15:53 So I'm learning some things as we go here.
00:15:56 Just a couple of points that I want to stress.
00:15:58 If you're just tuning into this show, the federal court has found the Emergencies Act was unjustified.
00:16:05 The measures invoked with the Emergencies Act were unconstitutional.
00:16:10 So this is crucial because the judge could have found one or the other.
00:16:14 He could have said, yes, there was an emergency, but no, the measures weren't valid or no,
00:16:18 there wasn't an emergency, but these measures were keeping with the Constitution. The judges
00:16:24 said both were wrong. So the federal government found an emergency that in the law did not exist
00:16:31 and more importantly used that emergency to do things that were utterly unconstitutional. What
00:16:36 things, you may ask? Well, freezing people's bank accounts, warrantless seizure of finances,
00:16:42 arresting people for participating in whatever the government deemed was an illegal assembly.
00:16:48 this is massive and as Christine Van Gein just said this is more important than the Public Order
00:16:53 Emergency Commission because in this case we have a decision that is binding we have a decision that
00:16:59 has precedential value we have a decision that is telling the government you broke the law Justin
00:17:06 Trudeau broke the law so no wonder the Liberal government and its ministers right now have gone
00:17:12 into hiding because they how are they going to answer this utter slapdown and look I've had a
00:17:17 fair number of things to say about courts in Canada that have been critical, because I found
00:17:22 courts have been overly deferential to the government, especially on matters of civil
00:17:26 liberties. But this is a case of a judge, and by extension, the court, the judge represents the
00:17:33 court in this decision, doing something that is actually, it looks like, very well rooted in what
00:17:39 the law is supposed to be. Just a few other reactions I'll point out here. Andrew Scheer,
00:17:45 who is the former leader of the Conservatives, and now he is a lieutenant, a house leader for
00:17:51 Pierre Pauliev, has said that Justin Trudeau froze bank accounts and had protesters trampled.
00:17:57 Never again let Trudeau give a lecture about charter rights. We have a post here on X,
00:18:04 formerly Twitter, my colleague Cosman Georgia pulled out here. It is a scathing
00:18:09 indictment of the government and its use of the Emergencies Act here. The highlighted bit
00:18:14 says as follows, the Emergencies Act is a tool of last resort. The government, that's what GIC is,
00:18:22 cannot invoke the Emergencies Act because it is convenient or because it may work better than
00:18:28 other tools at their disposal or available to the provinces. The evidence is clear that the
00:18:33 majority of the provinces were able to deal with the situation using other federal law, such as
00:18:39 the criminal code and their own legislation. So this is a court finding, a court finding what
00:18:46 every police agency and every provincial government except Ontario said, which is that we could have
00:18:52 dealt with this on our own. The federal government put the Emergencies Act in place when it was not
00:18:57 needed and was not requested. And you may say, well, hang on, it worked, they put it in and then
00:19:02 a few days later the convoy was gone. Yeah, but that was because police decisions, police decisions
00:19:09 were not moving towards what the outcome was.
00:19:12 They had a plan in place.
00:19:13 They weren't actioning that plan,
00:19:15 but the judge there really honed in on that
00:19:18 and said, this does not mean
00:19:19 that because it would be convenient,
00:19:21 it is justified or legal.
00:19:24 So what we saw here is that the government took its,
00:19:29 well, the government gave police marching orders.
00:19:31 The government found justification where none existed
00:19:35 and used it to trample on your freedoms.
00:19:39 We see reactions coming from a number of Conservative members of Parliament here.
00:19:44 Blaine Calkins, who is a Conservative MP, says,
00:19:46 Trudeau has no business continuing as the Prime Minister of Canada.
00:19:50 Wedge, stigmatize, and divide the Trudeau way. 0.92
00:19:54 What restitution is owed to those harmed by this abuse of power?
00:19:58 Apologies, Trudeau, millions of Canadians are waiting.
00:20:01 That's a reaction from Blaine Calkins.
00:20:03 Michelle Rempel-Garner, Conservative MP from Calgary, says this is a huge decision.
00:20:08 I have reached out to Conservative leader Pierre Polyev's office,
00:20:12 and they've told me that a statement is coming, although we haven't had it yet.
00:20:16 I'm assuming they're whipping that up post-taste, and we'll get to it now.
00:20:20 Everyone's, like, texting me.
00:20:22 So this is breaking news here.
00:20:24 I hope it's accurate.
00:20:25 It's coming from one colleague.
00:20:26 I'm just going to read it because you're telling me this.
00:20:28 It better be true.
00:20:28 So, Chrystia Freeland has said, oh, and maybe I won't say it.
00:20:33 We're being asked about a source now.
00:20:35 Okay.
00:20:36 Okay, according to CPAC, thank you, Artem.
00:20:39 Chrystia Freeland has said they are appealing the decision.
00:20:43 So, I don't even know if they've read the decision yet,
00:20:45 but the federal government has already determined it is going to be appealing this decision.
00:20:49 So, the federal government, despite this strong rebuke and condemnation,
00:20:53 Condemnation, the federal government, is holding firm on this and saying we did everything right.
00:20:59 So this is quite massive.
00:21:01 We're going to continue to discuss this as the show progresses here.
00:21:05 But just to recap, the Emergencies Act, unconstitutional.
00:21:09 The measures brought into place under the Emergencies Act, unconstitutional.
00:21:14 The federal government, unrepentant.
00:21:16 So a little bit of wordplay for you here on this Tuesday afternoon.
00:21:20 This is so big.
00:21:22 and let me just point out here the obvious well may not be obvious to a lot of you today is january
00:21:27 23rd it was two years ago exactly two years ago to this day that the first convoy of trucks left
00:21:35 from delta british columbia on their way to ottawa for what became known as the freedom convoy this
00:21:40 is the protest that picked up steam in alberta was later joined by groups in saskatchewan manitoba
00:21:46 groups from ontario quebec and atlantic canada came they all converged in uh well basically
00:21:52 january 28th 29th uh we'll do a little anniversary for that as well they converged on ottawa and they
00:21:59 did this because of a message for freedom now you can say that you don't like the tactics you don't
00:22:04 like some of the people involved but this protest about covid restrictions and vaccine mandates
00:22:10 became about something so much more when the government showed the lengths that was prepared
00:22:15 to employ the emergencies act to rein in and clamp down on peaceful protesters that's exactly
00:22:23 what happened and that was why even people who did not support the protest and did not support
00:22:27 the convoy were condemning the emergency exact even paul champ now paul champ is a lawyer
00:22:34 who's representing the people in ottawa in this like absurd multi-gazillion dollar class action
00:22:40 against the convoy even he said he opposed the emergencies act so pete you didn't have to like
00:22:45 the convoy to realize that the government had overreached here want to bring into the discussion
00:22:50 keith wilson who is uh well literally was the most visible and prominent lawyer representing
00:22:57 the convoy organizers uh during the freedom convoy he was stationed in ottawa and thankfully
00:23:03 got out without his bank accounts being frozen uh keith wilson joins us now keith it's good to
00:23:07 to talk to you again. Thanks for coming on today. Thank you. So again, I know this is something that
00:23:13 will take some time to fully digest here, but what's your early reaction to this decision?
00:23:18 And let me just say, given how pessimistic a lot of people who advocate for constitutional
00:23:23 freedoms have been about courts, are you surprised by the decision? I'd say I'm relieved. I was
00:23:29 getting, as you know, Andrew, very, very concerned about the institution of our courts and whether
00:23:35 lady justice blindfold had been pulled down because it certainly seemed like it had with 0.99
00:23:40 a number of the decisions including my case involving former premier peckford on behalf
00:23:45 of six million canadians unvaccinated canadians who lost their mobility rights but this is a great 1.00
00:23:50 day for canada um you know it was clear to anybody who was on the ground in ottawa as i testified
00:23:57 before the public inquiry in the fall of 2022, the Rouleau Commission, that none of the requirements
00:24:05 for the Emergencies Act to be invoked were present on Monday, February 14th, Valentine's Day in 2022.
00:24:15 The borders had all reopened, Windsor-Coutts, there was no protest there. The only protest left
00:24:20 in Canada was the significant protest in downtown Ottawa, which was causing tremendous embarrassment,
00:24:26 quite rightly, to the Trudeau government. And they invoked it to clear out that protest
00:24:33 tragically with brutal, tyrannical force against lawful protesting Canadians.
00:24:41 And it was clear to us that the legal test for the invocation wasn't met. We made public
00:24:46 statements live at the time that the legal test, there had to be threats of serious violence to
00:24:51 overthrow the government. That wasn't the case at all. So I was disappointed in the whole Rouleau
00:25:00 process. It turned out to be political theater, obviously. I was holding out hope that our federal
00:25:05 court would apply the law to the evidence and conclude the obvious that the legal test for
00:25:11 invocation of the Emergencies Act was not met. The actions of the Trudeau liberals in stripping
00:25:17 Canadians of their most basic rights and using violence against them was illegal. And that's
00:25:23 what the court has ruled today. I know it's difficult to concoct an argument on behalf of
00:25:29 the government, which I think has probably shown itself to not be particularly interested in
00:25:33 freedom. But we had the breaking news a few moments ago. Christopher Freeland says the
00:25:36 government will appeal this decision. Do you know, I mean, maybe it's premature, but do you suspect
00:25:42 what grounds they may use to do that? They'll be weak. That's a sign of desperation. The
00:25:52 decision's 120 pages long. I haven't had a chance to read it fully, but I understand the area of
00:25:59 law well. I understand the legal arguments well. I need to congratulate, you'll remember Brendan
00:26:05 Miller from the public inquiry, just so you know, this is his brilliant legal work in action. It
00:26:10 was Brendan Miller, who led the charge with some other lawyers on drafting and crafting this legal
00:26:16 argument and preparing the factum. So another tip of the hat to freedom fighter Brendan Miller.
00:26:22 So as we talk about the state of the Constitution here, I mean, the Emergencies Act itself is
00:26:28 relatively untested as a law. So this has precedential value for that. Do you think it
00:26:34 advances freedom of expression more broadly or or does it really just pull from what had already
00:26:40 been or was supposed to be the established approach to freedom of expression in canadian law
00:26:45 i don't know yet uh andrew because as you can appreciate this has happened so quickly and i
00:26:50 was in a meeting when it occurred and i had to rush back to my office to to prepare i know i
00:26:54 already had a show planned on something else so i understand i'm sympathetic to that yeah i made
00:26:59 some commitments to someone to have some deliverables up today i said unless something
00:27:02 big happens and little did i know um i don't know yet and i i will be happy to analyze that but what
00:27:08 i can say with certainty is that you know when the government is going to take these extraordinary
00:27:14 steps of arbitrarily freezing hundreds of canadians bank accounts and taking them out of the economy
00:27:21 and isolating them and you know the embarrassment of a mom with the kids at the grocery store and 1.00
00:27:27 the bags are packed and they got to leave an embarrassment without the food the the prescriptions
00:27:32 the mortgage payments and on and on that just we've all realized wow the government can do that
00:27:39 eh and the federal court has just said no actually they can't so uh at least not on such flimsy
00:27:47 grounds so everyone who's had their bank account frozen now has the legal right to sue the federal
00:27:53 government and i think that's very important i i was actually going to ask about the implications
00:27:58 of that so you're you believe that this opens up a liability path that didn't exist up before
00:28:03 absolutely and the reason for it is this the act not only empowered the government to take
00:28:10 extraordinary steps because you know there's an imminent insurrection and the enemy is within the
00:28:16 gate type stuff remember it was called the war measures act and it was only invoked previously in
00:28:21 world war one world war two and then the flq crisis where they were blowing things up killing 0.99
00:28:26 people and and kidnapping diplomats and even then it was seen as controversial and an overwrite by
00:28:31 a lot of people you know this was you know you know if the kids are listening i'm going to say
00:28:36 it bouncy castles you know and road hockey and people with canadian flags singing oh canada
00:28:42 uh so the the act empowered the government to take extraordinary measures against canadians
00:28:51 without due process of law, but it also protected the government with an immunity screen, a shield
00:28:59 for anything they did. Well, when their invocation order is collapsed for being illegal, struck down
00:29:06 by the courts for being unconstitutional, violation of the charter, that immunity screen's
00:29:13 gone too. That shield is gone. So the government's naked. They will bear the consequences
00:29:21 of their abhorrent and outrageous
00:29:23 and now clearly declared illegal actions
00:29:27 against thousands, tens of thousands
00:29:31 of lawful protesting Canadians.
00:29:34 So as we talk about the road forward here
00:29:37 and the federal government's going to appeal this,
00:29:40 we have this path that's opened up
00:29:42 for people to seek liability.
00:29:44 Do you believe that this,
00:29:46 because again, the fact that the federal government
00:29:48 is talking about appealing this
00:29:49 suggests that this decision standing as a warning shot against future overreach has not really
00:29:55 been heeded. They've fallen on deaf ears, has it not? Yeah, and the problem we've had is that
00:30:04 the courts, as I've talked about in other interviews and here, is that they've taken
00:30:08 judicial notice of things related to the pandemic that there was no evidence to support.
00:30:12 You know, the death data, Stats Canada confirmed, were completely exaggerated.
00:30:18 There was no evidence of safety and effectiveness of the vaccine because the clinical phase three trial hadn't been completed for some of them, still isn't complete.
00:30:27 And one of them was only just completed in December.
00:30:29 So this is the first time it appears to me that a court has taken a clear eyed examination of the evidence and the facts before it.
00:30:42 uh and clearly the circumstances that were going on in auto remember we had the the truckers had
00:30:48 negotiated with the mayor to de-escalate the pressure on the residential portions of the
00:30:53 downtown and move all the trucks and consolidate them up onto wellington where the grievance was
00:30:57 with the federal government and that movement was in progress when the emergency act was invoked
00:31:03 and i've said in the past that it was almost as though the government knew that its window was
00:31:07 closing because the footprint of the protest was shrinking they we i have some videos on my phone
00:31:15 that i played recently stumbled across where i was in our remote backup operation center downtown
00:31:22 during the raids and we we knew that they saw our move which was to de-escalate which would then take
00:31:29 away the justification for the emergencies act and that's why they rushed it in they rushed it in
00:31:35 because the prime minister was embarrassed that Canadians had stood up to his tyrannical behavior
00:31:42 and he wanted to punish them and he wanted to hurt them and he wanted to send a message that
00:31:48 this is the new authoritarian Canada in my view and you don't dare question me so he wanted to
00:31:54 move fast and that's why the evidence that came out was it was in part the federal government
00:31:59 that blocked further movements of trucks from us de-escalating and giving the protest more
00:32:05 permanence and staying power. So one thing I'll ask you here in closing, Keith, I mean, what are
00:32:12 you looking for in this decision? When you get a chance to go through it in a bit more detail,
00:32:16 what would you like to see there just as we talk about really securing freedom in the future?
00:32:23 I want to see whether what we all observed with our own eyes is reflected in the decision,
00:32:31 which is that this was a peaceful protest there was no interference with critical infrastructure
00:32:37 because there isn't critical infrastructure involving trade and borders in Ottawa and that
00:32:43 the justification just simply wasn't there I mean clearly the result of the decision is that's the
00:32:49 conclusion and so I'll be interested in looking at and also just there's there's two ways in which
00:32:57 the court can strike it down and it looks like they did both but i have to analyze the decision
00:33:01 more carefully one is on the basis that the legal test wasn't met so assume we had no charter of
00:33:06 rights and freedoms they have the ability to struck it down on the basis that the legal test
00:33:11 for invocation was not met they acted beyond their authority the cabinet did another way is
00:33:17 they met the legal test but they violated canadians charter rights in a way seizing bank
00:33:24 accounts, et cetera, that wasn't demonstrably justified section one in the free and democratic
00:33:30 society Oaks test. It appears from my cursory review of the decision, the 120 some pages that
00:33:36 they struck it on both. So I'm looking forward to seeing both, not so much the jurisdictional
00:33:41 analysis, because I think it's obvious, but more interesting to see the charter analysis.
00:33:46 Yeah, I think that will be fascinating as well. Once I get off air, I'll take a look as well.
00:33:50 But right now we're getting the reaction from our learned friends like yourself, Keith Wilson, Casey, always good to talk to you.
00:33:56 Thanks so much for coming on today.
00:33:58 Thank you, Andrew.
00:33:59 All right.
00:34:00 That was lawyer Keith Wilson continuing our live coverage and analysis of the federal court's decision today, a bombshell decision, one that is, as Keith Wilson says, relieving.
00:34:12 and as Christine Van Gein was saying was positively well I can't remember her exact
00:34:17 word but she was in a very good mood as she should have been about this we have just to
00:34:23 bring you up to speed here the decision that found the emergencies act was unconstitutional
00:34:27 and the measures invoked under it were so freezing bank accounts was illegal freezing
00:34:35 bank accounts conscripting tow truck drivers I believe was illegal we have the government's
00:34:41 declaration of illegalists of public assemblies as illegal, that was actually illegal. They were
00:34:47 breaking the law, not the people who are in Ottawa to protest as part of the Freedom Convoy, which
00:34:53 left Delta VC exactly two years ago, which means it was about two years less a month since the
00:34:59 Emergencies Act was put into play here. Conservative leader Pierre Polyev has reacted to this. He's
00:35:05 actually shared a screenshot from a True North story. I think we might have been the first out
00:35:09 the gate here. What Pierre Polyev writes is, Judge Rules Trudeau broke the highest law in the land
00:35:17 with the Emergencies Act. He caused the crisis by dividing people. Then he violated charter rights
00:35:23 to illegally suppress citizens. As Prime Minister, I will unite our country for freedom. And then he
00:35:29 links to a petition to fire Trudeau and unite for freedom. Pierre Polyev's comment there,
00:35:35 Judge rules Trudeau broke the highest law on the land.
00:35:38 And he reiterates a point he's made in the past,
00:35:40 which is that Trudeau caused the crisis that led to that protest.
00:35:44 So that was quite massive here.
00:35:46 Now, Deputy Prime Minister Chrystia Freeland did comment.
00:35:49 The Liberal cabinet right now has been assembled in Montreal,
00:35:53 where they had a retreat earlier this week, which wrapped up today.
00:35:57 But all of the ministers went into, literally, I saw a tweet from,
00:36:01 I think it was Marika Walsh, if I can find it here, with the Globe and Mail.
00:36:04 that major news that has disrupted the PM's cabinet retreat.
00:36:08 Journalists were expecting several scrums on other issues.
00:36:11 All were just postponed.
00:36:12 So they like sent the ministers into hiding.
00:36:14 But Chrystia Freeland decided to make an appearance. 0.98
00:36:17 She was not preoccupied with Disney+.
00:36:19 She canceled her subscription to deal with inflation.
00:36:22 But she had this to say about the federal court decision.
00:36:26 We are aware of the court decision.
00:36:30 We have discussed it with the prime minister.
00:36:33 with cabinet colleagues, with senior federal government officials and experts.
00:36:41 We respect very much Canada's independent judiciary.
00:36:49 However, we do not agree with this decision,
00:36:56 and respectfully, we will be appealing it.
00:37:01 I would just like to take a moment to remind Canadians of how serious the situation was in our country when we took that decision.
00:37:15 The public safety of Canadians was under threat.
00:37:22 Our national security, which includes our national economic security, was under threat.
00:37:30 It was a hard decision to take. We took it very seriously after a lot of hard work, after a lot
00:37:41 of careful deliberation. We were convinced at the time, I was convinced at the time, it was the
00:37:49 right thing to do. It was the necessary thing to do. I remain and we remain convinced of that.
00:38:02 I remain and we remain convinced it was the best thing to do. So it doesn't matter that
00:38:08 it's unconstitutional because Chrystia Freeland's happy with it. And isn't that what the law is 1.00
00:38:12 supposed to be in this country? As long as Chrystia Freeland can sleep at night, the law 1.00
00:38:18 and constitution and rule of law and due process do not matter.
00:38:23 Sorry, Gladys, your bank account got frozen.
00:38:26 Sorry there, Carlos.
00:38:28 We know you have to, you know, go against your will
00:38:32 to tow that truck that you support out of the way.
00:38:36 But fear not, because Chrystia Freeland's happy.
00:38:39 Chrystia Freeland's happy. 0.60
00:38:41 She's like the wicked witch of the banking system or something. 0.83
00:38:43 Like, she's just out there cackling and giddy and saying,
00:38:46 ah, my pretties, I've frozen your accounts. Like this is absolutely brazen. But this government
00:38:52 has gone all in. This government has gone all in on the suppression of your right to free speech,
00:38:59 your right to banking, your right to due process. So absolutely, why should the government care
00:39:04 about the court decision? And it's hilarious. It's not. But I'm going to tell you something
00:39:09 that's amusing anyway. This is a liberal party and a liberal government that over the last
00:39:15 several weeks, months, and quite frankly, over the next several years, will be making these
00:39:21 incessant comparisons between, oh, Pierre Polyev is like Trump. He's Trump-like. You know what
00:39:28 Trump never did? Trump never froze the bank accounts of his critics. Trump never did anything
00:39:34 of the sort. Trump may have fired some verbal pot shots at his critics. Trump certainly had a
00:39:39 terrible choice of character of those around him. But Trump never did what Justin Trudeau did
00:39:44 about his political dissidents and what Christopher Freeland is standing up and unrepentantly
00:39:49 defending, even with this court finding that it was unconstitutional. So this is going to get worse.
00:39:58 And the federal government, as you heard there, has reviewed this. They've managed to just go
00:40:03 through 190 pages in nothing flat, in no time whatsoever. And they've already decided they have
00:40:09 an argument to appeal without even, I mean, the ink isn't even dry on the federal court's decision
00:40:14 And the federal government has somehow found a way to make this a case that they're going to appeal.
00:40:19 So this, to me, is only going to inflame further right now.
00:40:25 And exactly, look, to give the government a little bit of credit here,
00:40:28 there were some instances of very violent, raucous behavior in the convoy.
00:40:35 I captured one of them when I was there.
00:40:44 I mean, literally horrific, horrific stuff.
00:40:59 You do not know who is going to get injured when you jump on ice.
00:41:04 And you also had people sharing, again, to give the government some credit,
00:41:08 people sharing hate symbols with abandon.
00:41:11 This was the sight that awaited me when I arrived in Ottawa
00:41:13 the very first weekend of the convoy to report on it.
00:41:37 Yeah, so there was, it's subtle, you might have missed it,
00:41:40 but there were like, you know, 90 or a hundred of these hate symbols.
00:41:43 It's like a rectangle that has these two red bars on the side.
00:41:48 And in the middle is this like pointy, it almost looks like a tree or a leaf.
00:41:53 But that is a, yeah, Sean says it's a leaf, it's a leaf, not a tree.
00:41:57 That is in and of itself a hate symbol in Justin Trudeau's Canada.
00:42:00 So we can't have people waving Canadian flags.
00:42:03 We can't have people that are dancing in the streets.
00:42:05 We can't have people.
00:42:06 One person tried to serve me a chicken wing.
00:42:08 Do you realize how much chickens have to suffer?
00:42:11 I mean, if that's not a public emergency,
00:42:13 I mean, especially when I'm eating chicken wings,
00:42:15 a lot of chickens have to suffer. 0.64
00:42:16 That is generally why anyone that doesn't
00:42:18 all you can eat wing night loses when I show up.
00:42:20 But this is what the federal government says
00:42:22 was it's emergency.
00:42:24 Now, when you listen to what Chrystia Freeland says
00:42:27 in that clip, which I won't force you to go through again,
00:42:32 she does something that is very, I'll say dangerous
00:42:34 because she makes up the law. 0.97
00:42:36 he talks about how Canada's economic security was under threat. I have read the Emergencies Act
00:42:43 many, many, many times. I have read the Emergencies Act and it does not make a reference to economic
00:42:52 security. It does not make a reference to it. So the federal government tried to talk about war
00:42:57 and insurrection and unrest in the same context as some trucks were held up at the border.
00:43:05 Now, admittedly, I think the border blockades were wrong.
00:43:08 And the border blockades were dealt with using regular powers.
00:43:13 They were dealt with using regular powers.
00:43:16 So when the federal government, and Chrystia Freeland is still holding to this,
00:43:20 says that this was a case of economic security warranting a national emergency,
00:43:25 this is her literally making up the law. 1.00
00:43:29 There is no justification in the Emergencies Act to use economic harm
00:43:33 as being a threat to the security of Canada
00:43:36 that rises to the point
00:43:38 of what the government says was a national emergency.
00:43:42 And I see one of my old Twitter threads on this
00:43:45 is recirculating now.
00:43:47 And I think I had some good stuff here
00:43:48 that I want to pull up
00:43:49 because what the federal government said here
00:43:52 is that there was a threat to the security of Canada,
00:43:54 which is very clearly defined,
00:43:56 it's not subjective, in the Canadian law.
00:43:59 And they defined a public order emergency,
00:44:02 which has a very specific definition.
00:44:04 It requires a national emergency
00:44:05 and it requires all of these other criteria,
00:44:08 which I went through
00:44:09 during the Public Order Emergency Commission
00:44:11 and I painstakingly parsed for people
00:44:13 and I'm reading through it now.
00:44:15 The Emergencies Act requires
00:44:17 for a public order emergency,
00:44:19 a threat to the security of Canada,
00:44:21 which is defined by the CSIS Act,
00:44:25 specifically section two.
00:44:27 You go to the CSIS Act
00:44:28 and its definition of a threat
00:44:30 to the security of Canada
00:44:31 is activities that are used that were creating threats to serious violence against persons or
00:44:38 property. And that was the section that they pulled up here, 2C. And then even if that were
00:44:45 there, which it wasn't, but even if that were there, it must rise to a threshold where it
00:44:50 seriously endangers the lives, health or safety as Canadians and exceeds the capacity of a province
00:44:57 to deal with. That criterion was not met. And it's why the Emergencies Act was not used in response
00:45:03 to 9-11, floods, ice storms, the OCOS standoff, and the COVID pandemic. So this is where what
00:45:11 the government did was moon, it was just manifest, it was improv. The government was doing improvisation
00:45:17 here to try to find a way to justify this emergency. And look, the Public Order Emergency
00:45:23 Commission was an exhaustive process. And I think it was a fair process, even if I disagreed with
00:45:28 the outcome of it. But it did not have a binding effect on the government. It produced, I think it
00:45:34 was like a 5,000 page report. And at the end of that report, the federal government said, okay,
00:45:38 we're vindicated. And it's funny that now the federal government is doing the opposite with
00:45:43 a court decision, a court decision, which is binding, which is more influential, which does
00:45:48 have precedential power and authority that will bind and I would say hopefully constrain future
00:45:54 governments. So if the federal government chooses to disregard this, it will completely embolden
00:46:00 what was the very attitude behind the Freedom Convoy, which is that we must take a stand
00:46:05 against a government that is thumbing its nose at our freedoms, at our rights, and at our civil
00:46:10 liberties. So I cannot overstate how big a day this is. And yes, this is going to go on for years.
00:46:18 This is going to go before the federal court of appeal, regardless of the federal court of appeals decision, it's going to eventually go to the Supreme Court. So I know this is going to be a long standing process that we will all have to contend with. But let me just first, because I was going to talk about the liberal government's polling in free fall here. And I actually think there's a clip that is worth sharing here from Justin Trudeau, because Justin Trudeau was speaking in Montreal to reporters about, oh, well, you know, governments need a plan.
00:46:48 Yeah. And he was trying to sort of defend how his government has a road forward in this period.
00:46:54 Take a look. We know we're in challenging times right now in the world, and that's why it's so important that we have a government that continues to roll up its sleeves and take responsible, serious, steady decisions as we're there to support Canadians now and to build a strong and prosperous future.
00:47:13 We know the Conservative Party continues to offer only insults and attacks on one side
00:47:19 and cuts to programs that Canadians rely on on the other side.
00:47:23 That's not what Canadians need.
00:47:25 Canadians need a government with a plan, with the capacity and the ability to continue to deliver,
00:47:32 even in these complex, challenging times, and that's exactly what we're doing.
00:47:37 2024 is going to continue to be a challenging year,
00:47:39 but we're also going to see a number of bright spots as we come through the challenges of the past few years
00:47:46 and Canada positions itself with all the advantages we have to lead the way on many, many different fronts
00:47:54 at a time where the world is facing real issues and difficulties as well.
00:47:59 One thing that we always remember is that Canada is the best country in the world
00:48:03 and it's up to us to work hard to make it even better.
00:48:06 And that's exactly what we're gathered here in my hometown to do.
00:48:12 I mean, admittedly, that was a couple of hours before the bombshell that his government was given this incredible rebuke by the federal court.
00:48:22 But he was saying that, I mean, again, the liberals are, I think, 17 points behind the conservatives in the most recent poll I saw from Abacus, which was about last week or so.
00:48:31 the interesting thing here is that the federal government has been incredibly disconnected
00:48:40 from real Canadians for quite some time. We see this on inflation. We see this on, I think, 0.94
00:48:48 general cost of living issues, housing, immigration, all of these things where the government is not
00:48:55 actually in lockstep with anyone but its own priorities. And even then it's unclear what
00:49:00 its priorities are. And then you have a government that has chosen to go all in on very strange
00:49:06 things. A government that's chosen to go all in on the gender ideology stuff that triggered 1.00
00:49:11 parental rights protests, a government that went all in on COVID restrictions, even when people
00:49:16 were really souring on them. Remember the trucker vaccine mandate, which really started the convoy
00:49:21 protest, that came about when places around the world were easing restrictions. That came about
00:49:29 where I think it was the United Kingdom was saying, yeah, you know what? Masks are gone.
00:49:33 Border entry requirements, vaccine mandates are all gone. The UK, which had some insanely
00:49:37 restrictive measures, they were lifting them. European countries were lifting them. And in
00:49:42 Canada, Justin Trudeau was campaigning on them and then layering on more and more restrictions
00:49:47 because heaven help us if we have to deal with the menace of someone in a truck alone,
00:49:52 crossing the border into Canada without getting a vaccine. I mean, we see this and we so
00:49:59 the vindictive rhetoric from the government, the punitive rhetoric. Justin Trudeau famously
00:50:05 at that rally in Calgary during the campaign, shouting, his voice straining as he says,
00:50:10 you don't have to get vaccinated, but you don't have a right to get on a plane or a train and
00:50:15 put people in danger. And he was getting, this was an applause line for him. So all of this leads to
00:50:22 the Freedom Convoy, which a protest that you may or may not like. And I understand it. The longer
00:50:30 it went on, even a lot of people who were enthused and celebratory at the beginning said, okay,
00:50:35 you've made your point, time to go home. You can have that decision. You can have that approach.
00:50:40 That's your choice. But the point that I've stressed in my coverage of this going back two
00:50:45 years now is that you didn't have to support the Freedom Convoy to realize that the federal
00:50:51 government took an incredibly heavy-handed approach to getting rid of it, invoking this
00:50:56 law that has never before been used. And then within that law, using that law of justification
00:51:03 uses insane measures. Again, we're talking about the freezing of people's bank accounts.
00:51:11 The freezing of people's bank accounts. Like that alone has made Canada the embarrassment of the
00:51:18 world. That alone was given the condemnation of people, again, around the world, of European
00:51:26 members of parliament, of foreign heads of government even. And this was something that
00:51:31 the government still defends as necessary. There's been no contrition. There's not even been a sense
00:51:36 of, you know, yes, I concede we could have more, I mean, not that this would have made a difference,
00:51:42 but Christopher Freeland said, you know what, we wrote it quickly. We could have done it more
00:51:46 narrowly because people forget that the federal government only froze a relatively small number
00:51:51 of people's bank accounts. And I'm not defending it. I'm not excusing it, but it wasn't thousands.
00:51:55 It wasn't like anyone who donated got their account frozen. But under the way the regulations
00:52:01 were written, pretty much anyone could have. If you so much as handed a cup of coffee to a trucker
00:52:07 that was pulled over on the side of a highway at some rest stop, you could have been under the law
00:52:12 subject to having your bank account frozen.
00:52:16 It was about, I can't remember the exact wording now,
00:52:19 but it was about providing support.
00:52:21 And the government had no restrictions or constraints on that.
00:52:25 The government's only constraint was that it didn't happen to do it.
00:52:30 So this was a very heavy-handed approach
00:52:32 that should make everyone very nervous.
00:52:34 Now, Tom Marazzo was in the thick of this.
00:52:37 He had his accounts frozen.
00:52:39 The Emergencies Act justified the freezing of his accounts,
00:52:42 his ex-wife was affected. His ability to buy medication for his child with special needs
00:52:48 was affected. Tom Marazzo was on the show recently about something else. He joins me again now.
00:52:54 Tom, it's good to have you on here. Obviously a big day. I'm curious how you feel as one of these
00:52:59 people that has effectively been very directly vindicated by this decision. Well, I feel actually
00:53:06 really as excited as everybody else that I've seen on social media this morning, or sorry,
00:53:11 this afternoon already everybody's quite excited and um but i want to sort of temper that with the
00:53:18 fact that um they've already announced that they are going to appeal uh which is you know as to be
00:53:25 expected with the the level of hubris that we've come to know and love from this particular
00:53:31 government uh this is just one more scandal for the liberal government i'm sure that they're going
00:53:36 to do everything in their power to get themselves out of so you know they've agreed to appeal it
00:53:42 um but you know i i still feel pretty good about this and i was just trying to go through some of
00:53:48 the wording myself right now uh reading the document uh it's 190 pages so there's a lot to
00:53:55 digest but yeah this is the story of every guest who's been on we should have just assigned we
00:53:59 should have just assigned everyone like 20 pages so that when they all come on we get the full
00:54:03 picture by the end of the show yes but it's it's really it is good news for canadians and uh you
00:54:09 can see that i mean there's a there's a really good buzz on social media right now and rightly
00:54:15 so it's justified you know this is all stuff that was obvious to us even before justin trudeau
00:54:21 invoked the emergencies act so to see you know almost two years you know the anniversary of the
00:54:27 convoy going to Ottawa, we're seeing now finally this vindication, I think. And I feel good about
00:54:36 this because, you know, one, it says that maybe there is a chance that the courts in Canada are
00:54:43 actually functioning properly or as the citizenry of this country would expect, you know, yet to be
00:54:49 determined in the next round of court decisions, I'm sure. But it is good. It is a positive thing
00:54:55 to see an actual judge applying the law and not just going to something
00:55:00 like judicial notice or something and, you know,
00:55:02 trying to wash this thing all under the rug.
00:55:05 So that's very positive.
00:55:08 But, you know, to go back to your point about the bank accounts and stuff,
00:55:12 and I think that's a very important part of this is that, you know,
00:55:16 I've said this many times in interviews before that, you know,
00:55:20 I was never charged, I was never convicted,
00:55:23 yet they went right to punitive actions where my bank accounts were frozen and many other
00:55:28 bank accounts were frozen but gets even a little bit worse and excuse the appearance
00:55:33 I was just excited to be able to talk about this but there is a special list of people I believe
00:55:40 about 41 people that the police investigated in this list of people actually went around the
00:55:46 entire planet the bank of china india wall street bay street bank of india went around the world
00:55:54 the government said if you're doing business with these 41 individuals stop doing business with them
00:55:59 right now so that's yet one more layer of overreach that the government of canada you know
00:56:05 imposed on canadian citizens who had not been arrested or convicted of a crime
00:56:10 the banking aspect is crucial here and i know i mentioned it a little bit in my my introduction
00:56:16 of you but i was wondering just to bring people up to speed who might not be as familiar with
00:56:20 your story or who might have forgotten what happened and when did you learn for the first
00:56:25 time that you had been swept up in this uh i think it was uh probably about a day or two after the
00:56:35 they invoked the emergencies act and i you know i was um my ex-spouse was trying to access bank
00:56:42 accounts and couldn't um you know in my particular case i wasn't really spending any money while i
00:56:50 was there so i wasn't i that's not something i was monitoring or expecting but i was certainly
00:56:55 feeling the heat from home that uh all of the financial assets that we had were frozen and i
00:57:01 I mean, everything.
00:57:03 And no one ever gave you a call or sent you an email.
00:57:05 It was just you go to spend money and you can't.
00:57:08 Yes.
00:57:08 And we heard that lie being told repeatedly at the Public Order Emergency Commission that,
00:57:13 you know, people were being notified that if they didn't, their accounts were frozen
00:57:17 or when they were frozen, they were notified.
00:57:19 I've never spoken to a single person that was notified that their bank accounts or financial
00:57:25 assets were frozen.
00:57:26 I've never heard that at all.
00:57:28 Not once.
00:57:29 And just to point, you raised this, but it's such a crucial point here that you were not, because again, if someone is charged with a crime, certainly if someone's convicted with a crime, that goes along with losing bits of your liberty. We accept that as a society. If someone's charged with a crime, there are certain circumstances where maybe some measures are appropriate, like pretrial incarceration, although as we've seen with your colleagues, Tamara Leach and Chris Barber, that can be abused in the case of Tamara.
00:57:57 but what you had was a punishment without any charge so you could never beat the rap I mean
00:58:05 you could never really challenge this or appeal this as I understand it the only recourse was
00:58:10 when the banks just decided to stop freezing your account yes and of course nobody ever said that
00:58:16 the bank accounts had been reinstated either I was checking every 30 minutes to see if my account had
00:58:22 come back online after I was already back home when the convoy was concluded rather violently
00:58:29 by the police. So again, you know, they went right to the punishment phase of this.
00:58:36 So we had Keith Wilson on the show a little while ago, and he had said something that I found quite
00:58:42 interesting, that with this decision from the federal government or from the federal court,
00:58:46 people who had their accounts frozen now have legal recourse open to them to do this. I know
00:58:53 it's early, but is that something that you will look into availing yourself of? Yes, I absolutely
00:58:58 will be looking at that. I have discussed that with Keith and I've also discussed that with
00:59:03 Brendan Miller. Brendan Miller, as you remember, was the head litigator that we had during the
00:59:09 commission. He was also one of the original lawyers that was part of the judicial review
00:59:14 for the decision that we're hearing today so it was kind of his strategy um for the judicial review
00:59:21 which is the reason why brendan miller became the head litigator for the public order emergency
00:59:27 commission because he was on both this current decision and also uh was on the public order
00:59:32 emergency commission as our our head lawyer so i have been in discussions with them uh to see what
00:59:39 recourse that i may have available to me uh unfortunately you know in my particular case
00:59:45 finance is going to be an issue if if i do seek some sort of remedy from the federal government
00:59:51 um but one thing i do want to contrast this to because you know i wrote about this extensively
00:59:57 in one of the chapters in my book uh because some of the comparisons that the cbc just wrote today
01:00:03 about the commission versus this judicial review decision um you know they they compared this to
01:00:10 rouleau's decision and tried to kind of give him a little bit of leeway or an out um but the fact
01:00:16 remains that rouleau himself in the commission i was sitting in the audience when he did this
01:00:23 he was he actually admonished one of the lawyers uh during a jccf lawyer for his cross-examination
01:00:31 of the CSIS director and Rouleau himself in the commission admitted that CSIS did not or that the
01:00:38 government did not meet any of the four conditions of CSIS section two he admitted in court and then
01:00:44 he came out and he said you know the government met the very high threshold which is why you know
01:00:49 there was so much anger about the decision of the commission but now we're seeing a different judge
01:00:55 looking at different facts and coming out with a completely different conclusion. Now, this whole
01:01:01 decision, the federal government has said they are going to appeal. So it will go to the federal
01:01:07 court of appeal. And I hope that it's upheld at that appeal level, because if it goes to the
01:01:14 Supreme Court, don't forget, we've got the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, which is Wagner,
01:01:19 who during the actual protest went into the media and spoke out against the convoy so now we're in
01:01:28 a situation where if this goes to the supreme court we've got a chief justice who is going to
01:01:33 have to recuse himself from hearing any matters related to the convoy yeah i wouldn't hold i
01:01:39 wouldn't hold my breath for him realizing that but i i recall and i can't remember the exact word but
01:01:44 he I think used it I think it was siege he referred to Ottawa as being under siege or it was some
01:01:49 some similar term about that yeah and I said at the time how on earth can this guy ever adjudicate
01:01:53 any case about this but I again let's we'll cross that bridge when we get to it uh Tom I'll say
01:02:00 congratulations I know you weren't in this action directly but I think you're certainly one of the
01:02:04 beneficiaries of this decision so it's good to talk to you thanks so much for coming on thanks
01:02:08 Andrew thank you very much thank you that was Tom Marazzo I want to go immediately to Eddie
01:02:13 Cornell, who was one of the applicants in this case. Eddie Cornell is on the board of Veterans
01:02:19 for Freedom, and Eddie Cornell looks like the right half of my show logo right now for some
01:02:24 reason. So I don't know if that's just, there we go. So we'll bring in Eddie Cornell on this.
01:02:30 Eddie, good to talk to you. Thanks very much for coming on. And also thank you very much,
01:02:35 sir, for your service to this country. What was your role in this case, first and foremost?
01:02:40 Well, I was one of the litigants, as in the case itself, myself and Vincent Gercees were given standing as we were directly affected having our bank accounts frozen during the emergency act.
01:02:55 So the judge recognized that both of us were harmed during that type of action, as well as many other Canadians.
01:03:03 But both of us were given the standing and came up with a positive decision today.
01:03:08 I think that's an important point here.
01:03:10 I spoke at the beginning of the show with Christine Van Gein from the Canadian Constitution Foundation, and for groups like hers and the Canadian Civil Liberties Association, they have a very, I'll say it's a very academic investment in this case, whereas for you, this was personal.
01:03:23 You were literally prevented from doing something as fundamental as banking because you had tied yourself to this protest.
01:03:30 Now, look, a lot of people may not have seen you or heard of you before.
01:03:34 You weren't one of the most prominent people here that were seen like Tamara Leach and Chris Barber.
01:03:39 So why were you targeted, do you think?
01:03:42 Well, I did speak out quite a bit, and I was one of the people that called veterans to come to Ottawa.
01:03:48 So, you know, I guess that placed a target on my back.
01:03:52 You know, I was visible in that regard.
01:03:54 And, you know, I worked directly with Tom and others during that convoy to support the truckers.
01:04:01 You know, it was pretty disturbing that, you know, you have everything frozen.
01:04:07 you know it's minus 25 in ottawa you can't get gas your vehicle you can't buy food you have
01:04:13 nowhere to stay and you can't get home i live in new brunswick so it was uh pretty difficult if it
01:04:17 really wasn't for the kindness of others i wouldn't have been able to make it back here
01:04:21 what was it that got you involved in this in the first place
01:04:27 well you know i've been speaking out about what the government was doing during covid uh quite a
01:04:34 bit. And when I saw the truckers come forward, I just knew that I had to be there to support them
01:04:40 in any way that I could. And I think that was probably one of the best times of my life in
01:04:46 this country, to see the unity across the country and stand up to draconian measures that, you know,
01:04:53 the government imposed over the course of the COVID pandemic. And to see the reaction,
01:05:00 And, you know, of people when Canadians stood up and said, hey, this is it.
01:05:06 This is enough.
01:05:07 We're not doing this.
01:05:08 I knew I had to be part of it.
01:05:10 Keith Wilson earlier, the lawyer who at one point represented the convoy, had said, and I was just chatting about this with Tom,
01:05:17 that anyone who had their bank accounts frozen or was targeted under the Emergencies Act measures now has some recourse available.
01:05:24 Because we have this legal ruling that you could use to go after the government.
01:05:28 And I wanted to ask you, first off, if you intend to do that, but also what would make you whole?
01:05:33 I mean, the government, you know, they've unfrozen the bank accounts.
01:05:37 What could they do, if anything, that would rectify that to you?
01:05:42 You know, I'm really kind of looking at all my options at this point.
01:05:46 I haven't made a decision moving forward what's going to happen.
01:05:50 I'll be consulting with my legal team and make some decisions very soon.
01:05:55 And I'll go from there.
01:05:57 I think that I don't want to, you know, speak hastily and say something that could counter any possible win that I might have in the future in regards to this.
01:06:09 So, like I say, for now, I think I'll just kind of keep a close eye on this decision.
01:06:15 I know that Christy Freeland has come forward and said the government will appeal.
01:06:19 So I'll speak to my legal team and see what options we have.
01:06:23 you served your country for decades in uniform did you ever imagine you would end up having to
01:06:30 sue that same country no that would be the furthest thing from my mind i never thought
01:06:37 that i could see our government turn on the canadian people and also turn on veterans who
01:06:45 were standing in support of truckers with medals on and be beaten into submission and thrown out
01:06:53 out like yesterday's garbage out in the middle of nowhere after they drove them around for a couple 0.50
01:06:58 of hours and process them and just dump them off in the middle of nowhere it's disgusting
01:07:03 and they should yeah and i mean you had joined uh the military it was in 1975 do i i have that
01:07:09 correct yeah so this was five years after the flq crisis when the war measures act had been
01:07:15 invoked to deal with this very controversially and i'm guessing that even by the time you enlisted
01:07:20 That would have loomed large on why, you know, the using war measures in a domestic capacity for law enforcement was not acceptable.
01:07:28 So you fast forward and then see the emergencies that come into place.
01:07:31 And I think that's why so many veterans were just absolutely shocked and dismayed by this.
01:07:37 That's a good point. I really believe that, you know, veterans recognize probably more so than most people how, you know, a government can abuse its power.
01:07:48 And that's why veterans came to Ottawa and stood up.
01:07:51 Like, we don't speak for, I'm part of B4F, one of the founders of B4F.
01:07:55 And, you know, we don't speak for all the veterans, but the ones that did come and supported the trucker convoy,
01:08:00 they were the people that recognized that this government is overreaching.
01:08:04 And, you know, they were basically power drunk and wanted to squash any dissension from the public.
01:08:13 and they would go to any length
01:08:15 to quell people from speaking out.
01:08:19 All right.
01:08:20 Well, I appreciate very much your service
01:08:21 and I'm glad you were a part of this case.
01:08:24 It's a very important case
01:08:25 and you've certainly cemented your name
01:08:27 in the history books here.
01:08:28 Not that that was your intention,
01:08:30 but congratulations on the win, Eddie.
01:08:31 And thank you so much for joining us on such short notice.
01:08:34 Thanks, Eddie. My pleasure.
01:08:36 Eddie Cornell, one of the applicants
01:08:37 in the now successful fight in the federal court
01:08:41 against the federal government's invocation
01:08:43 of the Emergencies Act.
01:08:45 We could probably do this all day.
01:08:46 We're going to call it here.
01:08:47 I've got to actually read the decision in full
01:08:49 and we'll have a bit more of an academic
01:08:51 and legal analysis on the show tomorrow.
01:08:54 But I wanted to bring you some early reflections
01:08:56 and reactions to what was going on here.
01:08:58 That's all coming up tomorrow
01:09:00 on The Andrew Lawton Show,
01:09:01 Canada's most irreverent talk show here on True North.
01:09:04 Thank you, God bless, and good day to you all.
01:09:08 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
01:09:10 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.
01:09:40 We'll be right back.
01:10:10 We'll be right back.
01:10:40 We'll be right back.