Juno News - November 09, 2023


Feds confirm gun grab won't take place until after next election

Topics
Mentioned
Canadian Anti-Hate Network won't look at left-wing hate Former Muslim explains why she left Islam

Episode Stats


Length

34 minutes

Words per minute

166.54

Word count

5,763

Sentence count

270

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

7

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

On this week's show, Andrew Lawton is back, and he's back with a slightly more normal sounding host. He's back to full force with his usual irreverence, and this week, he's talking about the CBC's $100 million budget shortfall, and the gun control debate.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcribed by ESO, translated by —
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:20 north hello and welcome to you all this is canada's most irreverent talk show the andrew
00:01:30 lawton show here on true north with a slightly more normal sounding host today compared to
00:01:36 yesterday we're not like totally back to full strength irreverence but we are getting close
00:01:40 to it thank you to all of you who sent me kind well wishes after yesterday's program
00:01:45 one of them was my mother who i like hadn't told i was sick and i think she learned it by listening
00:01:49 to the show so uh that was very kind of her to uh to reach out sorry i didn't give you a heads up
00:01:54 there mom but uh we are going to work our way through it the andrew lawton death watch has
00:01:59 commenced but if we can get through the next uh half hour so we are good to go and then i get a
00:02:05 whole weekend to rest up before hitting back actually no i'm off next week so i've got like
00:02:09 lots of time to uh to rest up but we'll try to make the most of it as we close out this week of
00:02:14 the andrew lawton show here for you going to be speaking very shortly with mark milkey of the
00:02:19 Aristotle Foundation about a rather interesting study they've done finding that systemic racism
00:02:25 is not actually a thing in Canada which you may have probably surmised on your own but that is
00:02:31 certainly news to many of the elites and thought leaders of this country so good to have the data
00:02:36 to push back against those. I also want to talk about the firearms file which is one where gun
00:02:42 owners are getting a rare reprieve under this liberal government but before I get there I've
00:02:47 got to point out something here really funny. Catherine Tate, who is the CEO of CBC, the Canadian
00:02:53 state broadcaster, was appearing, doing some speaking event, and she was blaming the CBC's
00:03:00 $100 million budget shortfall on big tech companies. She's saying, oh, well, yes, you know,
00:03:06 we're getting squeezed and suffocated by all these regulations from Meta and Google. And I'm like,
00:03:11 your entire budget comes from taxpayers. If you manage to have a budget shortfall,
00:03:17 it's because you're spending too much. And anyone who's ever seen CBC in action will know that they
00:03:23 spend insane amounts of money. I once was, this was years ago, back when I did my old radio show
00:03:29 in London, Ontario, I was covering a thwarted terrorist attack in Strathroy, which is a town
00:03:35 just about, I don't know, like half an hour west of London. And it was the Aaron Driver incident,
00:03:40 if you'll remember that. So this would have been 2017, I think. And I was on the scene there
00:03:45 reporting on it. And then the next day, I set it up so that I would do my show live from the street
00:03:51 in Strathroy. We have this little mobile kit and I went there. And by this point, it's a national
00:03:56 news story. So you've got national media there. There's a guy from Globe and Mail. CTV's got a
00:04:01 satellite truck. And CBC, I'm going to count it out because I always forget how many crews there
00:04:06 were. They sent CBC National. They sent CBC The National. So that's like the show called The
00:04:13 National. They sent CBC's local Toronto Bureau. They sent CBC's local Windsor Bureau. They sent
00:04:20 someone from the CBC London Bureau. And then they sent also, it was CBC Radio Canada. Yeah,
00:04:27 Sean reminded me, it's the Radio Canada guys. So to do the same thing in French. So that was six
00:04:32 separate crews that they sent to cover one single event. I'm like, maybe you could just get one
00:04:38 person and everyone uses their coverage, but no, that would just be too easy. So if CBC has a $100
00:04:44 million budget shortfall, I can find at least six crews worth cutting there that could probably save
00:04:50 a few bucks every year. But this is where I go back to, if you're a fan of Pierre Polyev, you'll
00:04:55 no doubt have heard his line that he can't wait until some beautiful Toronto couple goes and 0.97
00:05:00 shows up at their new home, which was formerly the CBC headquarters in Toronto. So they are ripe
00:05:06 for the picking there, CBC's spending. This is a big issue for me. I am a firearms owner, as you
00:05:13 know, doubt have heard me talk about, but even if you're not, I think most people in Canada should
00:05:18 be able to understand the idea of due process and of property rights. These are very important
00:05:23 concepts and things that the government on the gun file has completely and utterly abandoned.
00:05:29 So let's go back to 2020. We have this horrific mass killing in Nova Scotia and it's just a
00:05:36 horrible offense. The guy's firearms that he used were not purchased or owned legally. They were
00:05:41 all smuggled in illegally from the United States, which is true of most guns used in crime in
00:05:46 Canada. Nevertheless, the bodies were not even cold yet and the federal government decided to,
00:05:52 by order and counsel, with the stroke of a pen, ban 1,500 variants of firearms. The most notable
00:05:58 was the AR-15 type of gun. And Justin Trudeau had this way of describing these guns.
00:06:05 We are banning 1,500 models and variants of these firearms by way of regulations.
00:06:12 These weapons were designed for one purpose and one purpose only,
00:06:16 to kill the largest number of people in the shortest amount of time.
00:06:22 Now that was news to the gun owners who owned those firearms and had never killed anyone or
00:06:28 anything with them or those who use the guns legally for hunting people that use them for
00:06:33 sport shooting for collecting for target practice for hunting all of these are legitimate legal
00:06:39 uses for the firearms that with that stroke of a pen on may 1st 2020 the government prohibited
00:06:46 but the government committed to this narrative we heard bill blair who at the time was the public
00:06:51 safety minister make very similar comments around that same time these guns are killing machines
00:06:56 That's the only thing they are, calling them weapons, military-grade assault weapons, military-grade assault rifles.
00:07:02 That was a term that we heard used to describe these things, which were specifically designed for civilians.
00:07:09 They were specifically designed for the civilian market.
00:07:13 But that rhetoric is still important, because if these guns were, as the Liberals pretended in 2020, killing machines,
00:07:21 why have they been so slow to confiscate them?
00:07:23 It has now been well over three years, about three and a half years since that order in council, and there has not been one single firearm bought back as part of the federal government's promised buyback.
00:07:35 It was supposed to be a two-year amnesty wrapping up in 2022.
00:07:39 Eventually, it got kicked back, and then it got kicked back yet again a couple of weeks ago to 2025, we were told.
00:07:45 Now, they've made that official, so it's now going to be after the next federal election, before the amnesty period, which means the period at which I can still continue to own these prohibited guns, will end.
00:07:59 Now, that's actually a big deal for gun owners because it means that now it's not a fait accompli.
00:08:04 There is a federal election in between now and when that eventual gun confiscation will take place, which means a government that wants to commit to a different path could potentially form, and we have a very different landscape.
00:08:19 Now, maybe the liberals think that if the election is won and is fought over guns, they're going to win it.
00:08:24 That's certainly what they tried to do with Aaron O'Toole in 2021.
00:08:27 One, Pierre Polyev has been fairly consistent that he is a supporter of lawful gun ownership
00:08:33 and that he opposes these liberal government measures.
00:08:36 But we also know that the media will buy into that liberal narrative on what these guns
00:08:40 are, as happens time and time again, because gun owners in Canada are a minority.
00:08:46 That is, I think, just a statement of fact.
00:08:48 They are a minority.
00:08:49 So it's difficult to get people who aren't in that community to understand why anyone
00:08:54 needs an AR-15, why anyone needs a Mini-14.
00:08:57 And this is why I've tried to make public education a big part of this show whenever the issue arises.
00:09:03 Because what you get from the government is a lot of rhetoric that sounds nice but isn't borne out by the facts.
00:09:09 This was Dominic LeBlanc, one of the Liberal Ministers, weighing in on the extension here.
00:09:14 With respect to your question, Senator, it may not surprise you.
00:09:19 I don't think that Indigenous peoples writ large oppose this bill.
00:09:24 and I don't think to say that hunters or sports groups oppose this legislation.
00:09:31 There is, every time governments or parliament legislate in this area,
00:09:37 a very quick reaction from hunting groups, sports shooters,
00:09:43 many of whom are in my constituency in rural New Brunswick.
00:09:47 That's why I think it's important for us to continue to explain
00:09:52 and to be able to point in the legislation to why these particular legislative measures,
00:09:58 first of all, respect completely Indigenous rights.
00:10:01 That's a part that we amended, we added to the bill,
00:10:05 because I think in an initial version of this legislation,
00:10:08 much of what you identified in your question was a very real concern.
00:10:13 That's why I think the legislative process in our place, I hope,
00:10:17 to a large extent attenuated or diminished those concerns.
00:10:21 So we are entirely respective of Indigenous Section 35 rights, and we're designing legislation that deliberately targets those who use weapons or want to have weapons that are not, in fact, part of a typical hunter or sports person's routine.
00:10:41 So I think that there's broad support in Canada for thoughtful, effective measures to reduce the proliferation and access to military-style assault weapons.
00:10:56 Sorry, I was like getting comfortable there, sitting back watching the show with Dominic LeBlanc.
00:11:01 But there he's saying, you know, military-style assault weapons.
00:11:04 That's the Liberals' word of the day there, military-style assault weapons.
00:11:08 He's saying, oh yeah, no, we're just going to make Canadians aware that this is not going to
00:11:13 cover the average hunter or sports shooter or farmer or anything like that, except it will.
00:11:19 And every time, that was on Bill C-21, which is the bill that's going to cement the handgun ban,
00:11:24 among other things. But that's what the government has done. They've tried to muddy the waters here
00:11:29 and pretend that they're not going after things they're going after. It only takes one example
00:11:34 to prove a negative or to disprove a thesis. So when the government says we're not targeting
00:11:39 hunters and someone can point to one single gun that is used by hunters, the government's line
00:11:45 has been proven to be a lie. When they say we're not going after sports shooters, all you have to
00:11:50 do is say, well, there are sports shooting competitions that involve AR-15s. So therefore,
00:11:54 the government's line is a lie. And this is what's happened time and time again. So he wants to sit
00:12:00 back and pretend to be reasonable. Oh, no, but we're listening in this. Oh, no, we're respecting
00:12:05 indigenous people. We're respecting sport shooters. We're respecting hunters. We're doing all of that.
00:12:10 Well, let me tell you, I've not met a single gun owner in this country who has felt respected by
00:12:15 the liberal government in the last eight years. And it was interesting, behind Dominic LeBlanc
00:12:21 there, you could see just to the left, Terry Bryant. Now, Terry Bryant is the chief firearms
00:12:26 officer in Alberta. Now, the firearms regimes are federal. The regulations, the laws are federal.
00:12:33 But provinces can appoint their own CFO. And this was something I actually brought up with
00:12:39 Terry Bryant when I ran into Terry at the UCPAGM in Calgary. How much authority do provinces
00:12:45 really have? This was our conversation in Calgary on the weekend. Is the landscape for firearms
00:12:52 issues in Alberta so different compared to several other provinces in Canada right now?
00:12:56 Well, I think there's two answers to that, I think. One is it's not as different as you might think because if you go outside a few of the major metropolitan areas, you'll find that the vast majority of the geographical area of Canada thinks that not that much differently than Alberta.
00:13:13 But we do have some specific circumstances in Alberta.
00:13:17 For example, we've long had a major role played by agriculture and ranching,
00:13:22 which instilled a sort of sense of individual responsibility and looking after oneself.
00:13:31 And I think firearms have been a part of that because they were so actively used by ranchers and farmers.
00:13:39 obviously provinces have the ability as in your case to appoint their own cfo but so many of the
00:13:45 laws and regulations are federal so how much autonomy do provinces really have and where
00:13:50 are those issues where they can kind of be a bit more independent on firearms issues and respect
00:13:54 gun owners a bit more well i think there's a couple of aspects to that again one it makes a big
00:14:01 difference uh the attitude of the people you have in the office and i can't tell you how many people
00:14:07 You know, I attend gun shows virtually every weekend or other firearms events, and I can't tell you how many people come up to praise my staff for the great work that they're doing because they just have an approach of how can we help you to solve whatever issue you have instead of how can we make your life difficult.
00:14:25 And so that's, I think, one important aspect.
00:14:29 The other important aspect is it is true that this is an area where there is primarily federal jurisdiction,
00:14:35 but that just makes it all the more important for us to seek out every nook and cranny
00:14:39 where there is some opportunity to exercise provincial discretion.
00:14:44 And as part of that process, that also means that we are learning exactly how the whole program works
00:14:53 So that if we do get a change of government in Ottawa, we'll be able to assist in transitioning to a more firearms owner friendly regime, which will, I think, pay huge dividends in terms of public safety for even for non firearms owners.
00:15:09 because there is just so much of what the federal government does that is not focused on public safety.
00:15:15 It is focused on bureaucratic procedures, making life difficult for ordinary firearms owners instead of going after criminals.
00:15:23 And if we were able to refocus a bit on the problem areas and give the law-abiding people a little bit more leeway,
00:15:35 then I think we would get a lot more support for the program all across Canada.
00:15:40 And as everyone in law enforcement will tell you, it was mentioned, I think, by both administers today,
00:15:47 public safety requires public support for all of the aspects of administration and enforcement of the law.
00:15:58 And so if we're able to build better relationships with the public, that will pay great dividends in terms of public safety.
00:16:08 And that, I think, right there is one of the key differences, is that often the firearms approaches that we see are about what can we do to get in the way of Canadians from owning firearms, whereas in Alberta, they've actually taken it.
00:16:22 This is in large part due to Jason Kenney's appointment of Terry Bryant and Terry Bryant's continued work under the Danielle Smith government to make a customer service focus central to the Alberta firearms.
00:16:33 And again, it didn't come up in the interview there, but the Alberta government has said to the federal government, we will not direct any police resources to be used to confiscate these firearms.
00:16:45 So the federal government kind of had its hands tied because they cannot direct Alberta's police officers.
00:16:51 Even when the RCMP is working in Alberta, it's under contract and license to the Alberta government,
00:16:56 so they cannot take their orders from Ottawa.
00:16:58 So, you know, game, set, match right there.
00:17:01 I also spoke about this with Justice Minister Mickey Amory in Alberta
00:17:05 to get more of the government political side of that same discussion I had with Terry Bryant.
00:17:10 This is my chat with Minister Amory.
00:17:13 Why is the firearms landscape for Albertans so different than it is in several other provinces right now?
00:17:18 What's your government been doing to make that happen?
00:17:20 Well, first and foremost, I want to tell you that per capita, Alberta has the highest rate of gun ownership, law-abiding gun ownership in the entire country.
00:17:30 And so guns are near and dear to many Albertans for sport, for survival, for any number of reasons.
00:17:36 I think that's an important component.
00:17:38 We're working on developing the, I think, one of the leading chief firearm offices in the country.
00:17:45 It is being led by our resident expert, the Chief Firearms Officer Terry Bryant, who has likely the most experience and probably the most knowledge when it comes to legal gun ownership in the country.
00:18:00 I'm tremendously proud of the way that that office is moving.
00:18:03 It is taking on a leading role both within Alberta and providing services potentially to other provinces across Canada in helping them develop their own offices as well.
00:18:12 And so there are many things that I'm proud about when it comes to our firearms program, the chief firearms office and the firearms officer.
00:18:20 And this is something that I think makes Alberta very unique.
00:18:24 So many of the laws and regulations are federal. So do you feel a bit handcuffed in a way?
00:18:28 I mean, are there enough areas where the province can really exercise a bit of autonomy on this issue?
00:18:33 Yeah, and I fully acknowledge that there are certain barriers and challenges when it comes to our federal counterparts.
00:18:39 But one of the key components here is that we are going to be a voice of reason every time we approach this issue.
00:18:46 A few weeks ago, I wrote to the public safety minister suggesting that we need to put the gun confiscation program on hold for two years.
00:18:57 Immediately after that, we received the wonderful news that they were going to do that.
00:19:01 That suggests to me that the program was not nearly ready, that it was not well-reasoned,
00:19:06 it was not well-grounded in the philosophies that the federal government has providing to Canadians.
00:19:13 That two-year period will allow us to assess our position and assess our strategies going forward.
00:19:20 I will also say this.
00:19:21 We've taken a number of different approaches when it comes to existing court cases
00:19:26 as they relate to the gun programs here in this province and the federal initiatives,
00:19:30 and we'll continue to do that.
00:19:32 We'll continue to assess each and every one on its merits.
00:19:34 will continue to take the approach of Albertans first.
00:19:38 Law-abiding Albertans should be able to own guns
00:19:40 and use them in ways that are appropriate where and whenever they want to.
00:19:45 That extension of the amnesty, I think, delays the confiscation,
00:19:49 but it doesn't do anything about Alberta gun store owners
00:19:51 who have been sitting on tens of thousands of dollars,
00:19:53 hundreds of thousands of dollars of inventory,
00:19:55 gun owners that haven't been able to take their guns to the range
00:19:58 or do anything with them for years.
00:20:00 Is there any message to these people?
00:20:01 Is there anything that can be done apart from waiting for a change
00:20:04 in the federal landscape?
00:20:05 Well, certainly I want all of those individuals
00:20:08 to know, all of those business owners,
00:20:09 all the people that invested a tremendous amount
00:20:11 in their businesses and in their futures,
00:20:14 that we are doing everything we can,
00:20:16 whether it's through political pressure,
00:20:18 whether it's through addressing it through our courts,
00:20:20 whether it's going to Ottawa
00:20:22 and advocating on behalf of gun owners
00:20:24 and business owners relating to that industry.
00:20:27 I am well aware of some of the things
00:20:28 that these business owners are struggling with.
00:20:31 My heart goes out to them.
00:20:32 I want to make sure that all of them know that we're doing everything we can within the realm and the limitations that we have to make sure that their views are being addressed in a constant way to our federal counterparts.
00:20:45 This is a province that prides itself on being business friendly, on promoting and ensuring the growth of businesses in this province.
00:20:54 And we want to continue with that reputation for many decades to come.
00:20:57 that was alberta justice minister mickey amory on the firearms file so the good news is if you're
00:21:03 a gun owner you've got a bit of a reprieve until the next election but you are not out of the woods
00:21:08 just yet and i think it's why property rights in general need to be something we have a much
00:21:13 greater discussion about in this country so we will close the book on firearms talk for today
00:21:18 and move on to an issue that i find to be a fascinating one because internalized hatred of
00:21:24 your own country has become this like real epidemic in Canada. One of the things we love
00:21:29 doing here is importing American cultural battles. So when the George Floyd protests were waging in
00:21:35 the United States, Canada also became very introspective. And we started to see all of
00:21:40 these accusations that were based on these things that didn't quite make sense to a lot of people,
00:21:47 like Canada is a deeply systemically racist country. But this wasn't just being shouted by
00:21:53 bunch of rabid left-wing activists this was actually embedded in justin trudeau's mandate
00:21:58 letters to his ministers in december 2021 he put this following line in his ministerial mandate
00:22:05 letters profound systemic inequities and disparities that remain present in the core
00:22:11 fabric of our society including our core institutions we've had the rcmp commissioner
00:22:17 forced to testify on the stand of a parliamentary committee to the rcmp being filled with systemic
00:22:22 racism. We've seen the Department of National Defense talk about how Canada's foundations
00:22:27 have a white supremacy woven into them, the fabric of Canadian society. So is Canada a
00:22:34 systemically racist country and what does that mean? Well, our friends at the Aristotle Foundation,
00:22:39 specifically Matthew Lau, did a deep dive into it and they looked at a number of key metrics and
00:22:44 found that in fact not at all is this accusation true. Joining me is the founder and president of
00:22:52 the Aristotle Foundation, Mark Mielke. Mark, good to talk to you as always, sir. Thanks for coming
00:22:56 on today. Thanks for having me on, Andrew. So let's start off firstly with why the Aristotle
00:23:01 Foundation went into this issue in the first place and why Matthew did this study.
00:23:06 Sure. Well, for years, as you've pointed out, we've heard this notion that Canada is systemically
00:23:11 racist, institutionally racist, and you have to unpack that. You can meet bigots anywhere,
00:23:17 any age. But I wrote in this some time ago in my last book, The Victim Cult. Matthew wrote about it
00:23:23 in a chapter for the 1867 project, Why Canada Should Be Cherished, Not Cancelled. And you and
00:23:28 I talked about that, as did Matthew a couple of months ago, that chapter. But this accusation
00:23:34 that Canada is systemically racist really needs to be unpacked. And you mentioned American influence
00:23:39 a moment ago. Well, Thomas Sowell has done a lot of great analysis in this United States, right?
00:23:43 But we found that there wasn't a lot of good analysis kind of challenging this narrative, you know, that United States in Seoul's case or Canada in this case is systemic racist.
00:23:53 And I can tell you some of the research I did in my previous book that Matthew has done shows, you know, shows it's nonsensical.
00:24:01 As one example, Ontario in the early 1950s began to pass laws against discrimination based on gender or ethnicity in the early 1950s for accommodation, for employment, that sort of thing.
00:24:13 Prior to the 1950s, if you were black or if you're a woman, you may be denied accommodation or a certain job.
00:24:18 Post early 1950s, 70 years ago, that was outlawed.
00:24:23 So what Matthew has done in a new paper for the Aristotle Foundation is unpack this even more.
00:24:28 Yeah, and I think the one thing that's important to point out here is that no one is saying that racism does not exist in Canada.
00:24:35 There are individual racists, there are individual racism incidents.
00:24:38 But when you say systemic racism, that carries a lot of weight because you're saying that it's embedded in institutions.
00:24:45 It's baked into institutions.
00:24:47 And how do you go about disproving that?
00:24:49 How do you go about proving the negative in a way that, you know, systemic racism is not present?
00:24:54 Well, first of all, start to define it clearly.
00:24:57 So you read the definitions from the federal government at the outset of the show.
00:25:01 And what you have to do is unpack that again.
00:25:03 So systemic racism literally does an institution discriminating against you because of your color, your gender, this sort of thing.
00:25:11 We have clear examples in history.
00:25:13 If you were Jewish at a certain point in Canadian and American history, you might not have been allowed into certain colleges or at least not above a certain percentage of the population.
00:25:22 Chinese people in San Francisco were not allowed at white hospitals because they were white. 0.96
00:25:27 The Chinese of San Francisco literally had to set up their own hospitals.
00:25:30 That was institutional discrimination.
00:25:32 pre-1960s in the American South. You could not be on the bus. At the front of the bus,
00:25:37 if you were black, you had to be at the back. The system, the institution literally discriminated 0.74
00:25:42 against you, whether it was a hospital, a busing authority, a landlord, so on and so forth.
00:25:47 But much of that has been outlawed for 60 or 70 years. So that's very different than meeting a
00:25:54 bigot on the street today, who may be anti-Semitic, by the way. That seems to be the latest popular
00:25:59 prejudice out there, which should be attacked. So you can meet bigots, but that's not the same
00:26:04 thing as saying the system is rigged against you. So what Matthew does in his paper for the Aristotle
00:26:09 Foundation, asking about this question, and you can find it at AristotleFoundation.org, is he
00:26:14 compares incomes, for example, and says, okay, if we're actually a systemically racist society,
00:26:20 shouldn't that show up in the data? So as one example, he goes to Statistics Canada,
00:26:26 and he uses the data that tries to equalize for you know people that work full year full time
00:26:30 look at income by ethnicity well what does he find if you've got skin color like me and you
00:26:36 andrew we're in the middle of the pack right males or females and you find um you know some portions
00:26:42 of of ethnic canada if you're japanese canadian or korean canadian if that's your ancestry
00:26:47 you've actually got higher weekly average earnings or median earnings rather so um that matters
00:26:53 Because as Matthew points out in his paper for the Aristotle Foundation, do you say, for example, that if you're, say, Latin American in some cases, and your income is lower than the average white Canadian, does that mean somehow the system is rigged against you as a Latin American, but not as a Korean Canadian or a Chinese Canadian?
00:27:12 So he brings up the absurdity again of this claim.
00:27:15 You'd think, for example, that white Canadians should have incomes that are higher than anybody else. 0.82
00:27:22 if this claim is true.
00:27:24 So what Matthew does is he goes through this
00:27:26 and he also uses some other interesting stats.
00:27:28 So for example, South Asian Canadians
00:27:30 make up about 8% of the working age population,
00:27:33 but he finds they make up something like,
00:27:35 I think it was 19% of physicians in the country
00:27:38 or engineers rather.
00:27:40 And he has other statistics to that effect.
00:27:42 So again, if the claim is that
00:27:44 there's an institutional bias
00:27:46 against certain minority Canadians,
00:27:49 I despise that term,
00:27:50 but certain Canadians who are considered minorities by the government.
00:27:54 You'd expect that consistently in the data for incomes or jobs
00:27:58 that you would find minority Canadians at the bottom of the pack.
00:28:02 But, you know, Asian Canadians, for example, do incredibly well,
00:28:05 which is a good thing in incomes and assets in degrees.
00:28:09 And that's something Matthew tries to point out as well, including, by the way,
00:28:12 for indigenous Canadians, that if you have an education,
00:28:17 a bachelor's degree, for example, as an indigenous Canadian,
00:28:20 you make almost as much as any other Canadian. And if you have a slightly higher than a bachelor's
00:28:25 degree, maybe a master's degree, you will actually make $2,000 more working full year, full time as
00:28:31 an Indigenous Canadian than a non-Indigenous Canadian. So again, Matthew unpacks this notion
00:28:36 that Canada is systemically racist. Again, institutions literally discriminating. And I
00:28:41 think that's an important tight point to make that Matthew does in his paper.
00:28:45 Well, and one of the things that I wondered when I was first started out reading this is if a big
00:28:50 part of the problem has been that equality of outcome has been pushed by a lot of people more
00:28:55 than equality of opportunity. And that, you know, in Canada, we do not have any, you know, direct
00:29:00 systemic racial barriers that work against people of color that unless someone wishes to correct me.
00:29:06 Now, there are some positions that we see that are for jobs that, you know, are specifically for
00:29:11 those people and not for white people. And, you know, whether affirmative action is right or wrong,
00:29:16 people can determine for themselves. But if there are disparities that are coming about on an
00:29:20 outcome side, they don't seem to be caused by anything that the institutions themselves have
00:29:26 set up. No. And in fact, they're related to other factors such as education or geography.
00:29:32 And a good example is First Nations reserves. The average or median First Nation income,
00:29:37 again, when you don't do the apple to apple comparison, right? Full time, full year,
00:29:41 bachelor's degree, that sort of thing. When you don't do those comparisons, yeah, the average
00:29:45 and medians look a lot lower than other Canadians. But why is that? Because a greater proportion of 1.00
00:29:51 First Nations people or Indigenous people live in remote areas, often on reserves, where there's
00:29:55 not great access to education, at least higher education. There's not great access to great
00:29:59 jobs. That makes a difference, as does the average education level, which is lower for Indigenous
00:30:04 Canadians vis-a-vis other Canadians. So education makes a difference. But the American economist
00:30:10 Thomas Sowell has a wonderful example explaining the folly of saying everyone should have an equal 1.00
00:30:14 outcome or every group should. And if it's not, then it must be due to racism. He talks about how
00:30:19 historically Italians dominated the fishing fleet worldwide, unlike the Swiss. Does this mean the 0.98
00:30:25 fishing industry is systemically biased and racist against Swiss, you know, the Swiss? And Thomas
00:30:31 Sowell makes the obvious point. No, it's because the Swiss don't have coastlines. The Italians have 1.00
00:30:36 coastlines. Of course, growing up around the coast will help you know how to fish and get involved
00:30:40 in the fishing sector. And then you emigrate from Italy over the last 100 years, you're going to 0.87
00:30:44 dominate the fishing fleets around the world because of that experience, at least for a
00:30:48 country that has lots of immigrants, as Italy did for 100 years, outpouring of immigrants.
00:30:53 So that explains again or helps explain that you're not going to have equal outcomes.
00:30:58 Or the other example, as Sowell points out, which Matthew notes as well, and I have in
00:31:02 my work, look, families, I have three siblings.
00:31:07 We don't have equal outcomes.
00:31:08 We had the exact same environment growing up.
00:31:10 but people vary widely in outcomes despite exactly similar similar upbringings so to blame
00:31:17 everything on racism as people do are mostly on racism is simplistic to the extreme the paper you
00:31:24 can read at aristotlefoundation.org and there's also lots of other good stuff there you should
00:31:28 check out the founder of that mark milkey joins us mark always good to talk to you thanks for
00:31:33 coming on today thank you thank you that does it for us for today and that does it
00:31:40 for us for this week. I am off next week on, I'm technically vacation, but I'm working on a book
00:31:47 and I'm woefully behind. So I have to hunker down and get that done. But I just want to say,
00:31:52 because this is the last show before Remembrance Day, I wanted to just say a big thank you. I know
00:31:57 it's a day where we honor fallen soldiers, people who fought and lost their lives in the line of
00:32:02 duty specifically. And my heart goes out to anyone who is family member, fits that category, anyone
00:32:08 who lost a parent, a grandparent, a sibling, a child, all of that in any of the conflicts,
00:32:13 whether it's World War I, II, Afghanistan, it doesn't matter. Their sacrifice is still just
00:32:19 as significant. And in general, to all veterans, I thank you for your service. I've tried to,
00:32:24 as someone who is the son of a father who was in the military, the son of two grandfathers who
00:32:30 fought in the war, I've always tried to make honoring and respecting veterans a key part of
00:32:36 my work and also my life. And that's why, I mean, even yesterday I was so sick, but I left the house
00:32:41 to go and get a poppy because I knew it was important to have representation. And it's
00:32:46 actually quite sad how difficult they are to find in this day and age. So that's why I believe
00:32:52 representation is important, why we need to continue to honor the fallen and say thank you
00:32:57 and lest we forget. Thank you, God bless and good day to you all.
00:33:06 True North at www.tnc.news.
00:33:36 We'll be right back.
00:34:06 We'll be right back.