Juno News - March 03, 2022


Freedom Convoy organizer is still behind bars

Topics
Mentioned
The fog of war takes over Ukraine WATCH: Liberal MP loses his mind about freedom convoy

Episode Stats


Length

39 minutes

Words per minute

183.76

Word count

7,281

Sentence count

357

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show, host Andrew Lawton is joined by Franco Terrazzano of the Canadian Taxpayers Federation to discuss the Conservative Party of Canada leadership race, the ongoing saga of the Freedom Convoy, and the ongoing case against Tamara Leach.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:00:17 This is the Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:00:26 Hello and welcome to you all.
00:00:28 it is thursday march 3rd 2022 you are tuned in live to canada's most irreverent talk show here on
00:00:36 true north this is the andrew lawton show going live once again so if you have any questions or
00:00:42 comments do send them along in the comment section on facebook on youtube wherever you may be watching
00:00:47 we'll try to get to a few as the show progresses but we do have a lot of content to get through
00:00:52 some big news coming up today we've got the rules of the race for the conservative party of canada
00:00:58 leadership contest. They're going to decide their leader in September. We don't actually have the
00:01:03 full rules out, but the timeline and the entry fee are the big questions that a lot of people
00:01:08 were keeping an eye peeled for. So we'll talk about that a little bit later on. Also, I want
00:01:13 to talk to criminal defense lawyer, David Amber, who's been doing some fantastic work covering the
00:01:18 convoy from the legal perspective and actually representing some people involved. He's going to
00:01:23 be on the show in just about 15 minutes time, I think, to talk about all that's happening there. 0.83
00:01:28 And also on that note, Tamara Leach, the Freedom Convoy fundraiser and organizer, still behind bars
00:01:35 as a judge decides whether to let her go back home to Alberta on bail. But he's decided he's
00:01:41 going to take his dear sweet time and make a decision come Monday. So she has been, as of I
00:01:46 think tomorrow, behind bars for two weeks, which is quite significant for the alleged crime of
00:01:54 counseling mischief, which was what they arrested her on. She said, hold the line on her way to the
00:01:59 police car. But before we get to all of that, let's talk about something that can unite us all,
00:02:05 which is frustration with CBC, specifically the amount of money that CBC spends, not of its own
00:02:12 money, not of its shareholders. I mean, yes, of its shareholders in a way, you and I, but not with
00:02:17 the shareholders' consent. The Canadian Taxpayers Federation, which has been doing some tremendous
00:02:22 work on this, launched a petition, I think it was just one week ago, to call on the government to
00:02:28 scrap the CBC subsidy, to defund CBC. And this has now reached 52,000 signatures in just a week.
00:02:37 Tremendous work. Franco Terrazzano is the federal director for the Canadian Taxpayers Federation
00:02:42 and joins me now. Franco, I know sometimes getting people to pay attention to
00:02:48 taxpayer spending has been challenging. It's why you work around the clock so tirelessly trying to
00:02:53 get people to pay attention. But have you ever had something with quite this uptake?
00:02:58 Well, we have had some very big petition numbers, but they accumulate over time, right? Like we did
00:03:03 have one petition delivery. It was about 200,000 signatures to scrap the governor general's perks
00:03:10 like the lifetime annual expense account former governor generals get. But what's so different
00:03:17 about this petition, 52,000 signatures in a week. So Andrew, to me, that really shows a strong signal
00:03:25 that there's many Canadian taxpayers that are deeply, deeply concerned, but with the amount
00:03:30 of money that the government that the government is sending to the CBC every year and also that
00:03:35 600 million dollar media bailout. Yeah the media bailout is a big one as well and we've talked
00:03:42 about it at great length at True North because in a lot of ways it raises questions that a lot of
00:03:47 people have as to whether reporters are even fairly covering that because their livelihoods their
00:03:52 businesses longevity depends on it but let me ask you is this to you an issue of content is it an
00:03:58 issue of the fact that we're funding reporting and the fact that we're funding CBC, or is it just
00:04:04 about the funding itself rather than the specific content that's being published? Well, Andrew, I
00:04:09 think there's a lot of people who have a lot of different thoughts when it comes to this matter,
00:04:13 but from the Taxpayers Federation, it really boils down to this. We believe that all Canadians
00:04:19 should be able to keep their own money and decide which media organizations they want to fund with
00:04:25 their own money right taxpayers should not be forced to subsidize certain media organizations
00:04:31 so it really comes down to that let taxpayers decide which organizations we want to support
00:04:36 but then also too on the other hand andreas as you know uh it's it's really not fair for certain
00:04:42 news organizations to have to compete with massive government funded organizations like the cbc
00:04:49 more than a billion dollars every single year or these other news outlets that are getting some of
00:04:54 that $600 million media bailout. So for us, it's all about let Canadians decide which organizations
00:05:01 we want to fund with our own money. Yeah, there is a leveling the playing field issue here because
00:05:07 all of a sudden, first off, you have to have government deciding what constitutes a media
00:05:12 outlet, what constitutes a journalism outfit that's eligible for funding, which raises
00:05:16 significant questions, even if I'm not aware of specific issues where an outlet's applied and has
00:05:22 been denied. But moreover, you're right. It means that the ones who may not take that, there are a
00:05:26 number of outlets like Black Locks Reporter is a great example. They are in the parliamentary
00:05:30 press gallery. They're an official media outlet, even if they don't go along with sometimes the
00:05:35 mainstream media narrative on things. They've said they don't want government funding. Well,
00:05:40 all of a sudden they're at a competitive disadvantage because they have to deal with
00:05:44 things without being able to rely on that subsidy. So it almost incentivizes companies taking it
00:05:50 because they don't want to be at a disadvantage to their counterparts and their opponents.
00:05:55 Yeah. And, you know, you touched on this at the beginning of the show, but just that
00:05:58 I think we all agree that one of the most fundamental pillars of a strong and healthy
00:06:03 democracy is an independent press and independence, both in practice, but also perception.
00:06:09 Right. I think there's many journalists out there who are doing a great job, but you can
00:06:14 understand if people perceive that they might have some bias when it's the government who is
00:06:21 is funding their organizations right i think that is a very key problem and we're not the first ones
00:06:26 to bring up that objection right there's we've we've heard it from other journalists in the past
00:06:32 um but also too you talk about how you now have an incentive for organizations to want
00:06:38 to collect these tax dollars well what about us struggling taxpayers the federal government right
00:06:43 What about us struggling taxpayers?
00:06:45 The federal government is already more than a trillion dollars in debt.
00:06:49 You break that down per person, and that's more than $30,000
00:06:52 that each Canadian man, woman, and child is on the hook for, right?
00:06:56 How high of our tax bill does it have to get
00:06:58 before we actually have a federal government that finds some savings?
00:07:02 And Andrew, that $1.4 billion to the CBC,
00:07:06 the $600 million media bailout,
00:07:08 those are perfect areas to find some savings.
00:07:11 One point that I've always raised about CBC, and this, again, should extend even if you love CBC,
00:07:17 I would love nothing more than for people to say, I love CBC so much I'm paying for a subscription
00:07:22 like I do for the Globe and Mail or the National Post or donating to True North or taking out a
00:07:27 subscription to the Western Standard, whatever the case is. People who like that, we're not saying
00:07:32 abolish the CBC. We're saying don't make it reliant on government money. Let it compete
00:07:37 like anything else. And even if, even if we're going to have as a society, this decision where
00:07:42 we believe CBC is important, CBC content's important, why is it not a public good? Why
00:07:48 is its content not free for other people to republish? Why is it competing with private
00:07:53 companies for the rights to carry the Olympics, for example, something that companies pay a lot
00:07:57 of money for? Why are they trying to elbow out private sector media? That kind of defeats the
00:08:03 purpose of CBC, which is to fill a void that they say wouldn't exist in a free market.
00:08:09 Andrew, so many good points that I want to dissect there. Let's start with this. Even if we want to
00:08:15 call this a public good, even if, right, does it really need $1.4 billion every single year? Really
00:08:22 $1.4 billion every single year? And to your earlier point, you said, hey, we're not looking
00:08:28 to abolish the CBC, just remove the government funding, right? The taxpayers' money that has
00:08:34 been forced to go to this organization. Now, we've been doing a lot of digging through the
00:08:39 annual reports just to make sure the numbers are correct. And the last figure that I saw
00:08:44 was that the CBC was able to raise about $500 million in non-government revenue.
00:08:50 So we're not saying abolish the CBC, just defund the subsidies that the government is giving to
00:08:56 the CBC. Now, who knows what would end up happening to the non-government revenue? But like I said,
00:09:02 the last number that we saw was $500 million, not from the taxpayer.
00:09:08 And I think there's an important point there because I don't think most Canadians, even many
00:09:12 who signed that petition of yours, would object to CBC saying, okay, we're going to get rid of the
00:09:17 online news section. We're going to get rid of, you know, Little Mosque on the Prairie or whatever
00:09:22 the 2022 version of is we're going to get rid of all of that we're going to broadcast in northern 0.99
00:09:27 communities we're going to broadcast in indigenous languages we're going to go where there is no
00:09:32 private sector alternative they could probably do that for less than that 500 million dollars you
00:09:37 talked about yeah or certainly less than the 1.4 billion dollars well yeah every single year like
00:09:43 i have to keep going to this right because even if you do want to make the argument that the
00:09:46 government should be funding i think okay like let's we can arm wrestle on over that for about
00:09:51 a week, you and I going back and forth, but $1.4 billion every single year. I think that is
00:09:59 quite unacceptable. And it's not just me. It's not just you. I think that's one of the reasons why
00:10:04 we saw 52,000 signatures on the petition in a week. That shows me that there's many Canadians
00:10:11 who clearly think that this is an issue and clearly think that this is a big issue.
00:10:16 And that petition is at taxpayer.com, correct?
00:10:19 Yep, absolutely.
00:10:20 Just head over to taxpayer.com,
00:10:21 click on the petitions tab and you'll find it there.
00:10:24 Franco Terrazano, Federal Director
00:10:25 for the Canadian Taxpayers Federation.
00:10:27 Thanks very much, good sir.
00:10:29 Hey, it was my pleasure.
00:10:30 Thanks for having me on.
00:10:31 Thank you.
00:10:31 Before I get to my next guest,
00:10:33 I do wanna mention very quickly here,
00:10:36 one of the content-related challenges
00:10:38 people have with CBC.
00:10:40 Again, there's a moral position there on government funding
00:10:42 that CBC should have to compete
00:10:44 with other people in the industry
00:10:46 like and go through all of the market realities
00:10:48 And even if you like CBC, you can support that position.
00:10:51 But then you look at some of the coverage they do.
00:10:55 This story came out, I think it was this morning.
00:10:58 Numbers suggest many American protest convoy donors also gave to Trump Republicans.
00:11:04 And they were using that list that leaked purportedly of Give, Send, Go donors.
00:11:09 So the list that was illegally hacked from Give, Send, Go and published online
00:11:13 that has allowed reporters to go through and start doxing anyone who donated,
00:11:17 you know, $10 to the Freedom Convoy because they believed in what the truckers were doing and all
00:11:22 of that. And CBC has taken that list and they've looked at the top 200 American donors and they
00:11:28 found that half of them have names matching to donors of the Republicans and Donald Trump.
00:11:35 So the CBC story is 100 Americans donated to Trump and the Freedom Convoy or 100 people who
00:11:43 shared the same name as Trump and Freedom Convoy donors. And I looked at this and I'm like,
00:11:49 okay, who cares? The fact that 100 people out of the 74 million who voted for Donald Trump,
00:11:56 even when he lost, he had 74 million people vote for him. The fact that they also voted for the
00:12:00 Freedom Convoy doesn't seem newsworthy. But CBC's position on this is that if you were a Trump voter,
00:12:06 you're just like a dirty person that doesn't belong in civil society. That's the premise 0.99
00:12:11 through which they're approaching this now i don't know how many canadians are trump supporters or
00:12:15 republican supporters whatever the case may be but what i do know is that when cbc is content
00:12:22 on really predicating its coverage based on the idea that it is wrong to have a particular
00:12:28 political persuasion perhaps this isn't this grand unifying public broadcaster that we are all
00:12:35 rallying behind as they seem to pretend and certainly as the narrative suggests in them
00:12:39 getting so much taxpayer money each year. So all of that is to say, I understand why people have
00:12:44 frustrations with CBC beyond just the dollar value of it here. But let's talk about the convoy
00:12:50 fundraising here. Tamara Leach, who is the lead convoy fundraiser, she was the one that started
00:12:56 the GoFundMe. She was the one that was in Ottawa, was yelling out, hold the line as she was arrested
00:13:03 by police. Tamara Leach, after a bail hearing yesterday, has been kept behind bars for at least
00:13:09 another five more days. So that'll bring us to Monday when the judge will decide whether or not
00:13:16 she should be released on bail. That will be about two and a half weeks, or if I'm being precise here,
00:13:22 two weeks and three days since she was first arrested for organizing a protest. She was
00:13:29 arrested on the charge of counseling mischief. I've never heard of someone being kept behind bars
00:13:34 with the Crown so fervently trying to keep them there
00:13:36 as is happening in the case of Tamara Leach.
00:13:39 I want to talk about this and much more
00:13:41 about the aftermath of the convoy
00:13:43 with criminal lawyer David Anber,
00:13:45 who, believe it or not, is not a Simpsons character.
00:13:47 On Twitter, you may be mistaken if you thought that,
00:13:49 but he has a real-life identity
00:13:51 and he is sharing it with us today.
00:13:53 David, good to talk to you.
00:13:54 Thanks very much for coming on the program.
00:13:56 Thanks for having me, Andrew.
00:13:58 You and I talked in a Twitter space a couple of weeks back
00:14:01 and I said I wanted to delve into some of these issues
00:14:03 with you further. And of course, this issue has changed. But let me just start with the bail
00:14:08 question here. When Tamara Leach was first asking for bail, I think it was the day after she was 0.98
00:14:14 arrested. Actually, yeah, it's two weeks ago today, because I recall the day after was a Friday.
00:14:18 And I thought it was bizarre that the judge didn't make the decision right away. And this judge as
00:14:24 well, taking five days to review the bail. Is this normal in a criminal proceeding?
00:14:28 To a certain extent, Andrew, it is normal when judges have decisions that are important. I mean, they're all important. But when they're in the national scrutiny, in the national eye, if they deal with something that's a complicated legal question, I appreciate that there are many who feel that this is a slam dunk.
00:14:48 it's a mischief charge and she should be released. And look, I'm a big believer that the first judge
00:14:55 got it wrong. But I did also believe at the time that it's a much closer call than people think it
00:15:01 is when you apply the rules that apply to bail. And look, the prosecutor who's been arguing the
00:15:07 case has been doing a very good job at advancing the prosecution's theory of the case. So Justice
00:15:13 bourgeois uh wanted to wait until i think it was after the holiday monday uh the tuesdays when she
00:15:19 released her decision so that's that's somewhat normal what happened uh yesterday and it was uh
00:15:25 what's called a bail review which is essentially like an appeal i won't bog down in the minutiae
00:15:29 of what it is it's basically an appeal of uh of the first bail ruling to a higher court judge
00:15:35 it's actually just for those of you who are interested it's a it's a harper appointee
00:15:40 judge the provincial court judge was appointed by the provincial government but this is a superior
00:15:45 court judge a former defense lawyer a very good judge very open-minded judge not a pushover one
00:15:52 way or the other so he heard a full day hearing basically the matter went to close to six o'clock
00:16:01 in the afternoon in the evening and he indicated that he needed some time to reflect on that now i
00:16:09 I think due to scheduling reasons, he's in other courts and other jurisdictions for the
00:16:14 remainder of the week, the Thursday and the Friday.
00:16:17 And so the first opportunity after that that he would have to render a decision would be
00:16:21 on the next Monday.
00:16:22 So certainly nobody likes the idea that you have to wait for justice, especially when
00:16:28 you're in custody.
00:16:29 But I think that there's nothing nefarious going on behind the scenes.
00:16:33 That's just the way everything shook out with the way the bail went all day yesterday.
00:16:38 Not being a lawyer, I typically look at the two considerations that seem to come up in any bail stories I've covered as being the seriousness of the offense or the alleged offense and also whether the person is a flight risk.
00:16:51 Now, again, I'm hoping you can explain what the factors are that go into these decisions.
00:16:56 But on those two points, we're talking about relatively minor charges here.
00:17:00 And also, we're talking about a woman who has had her bank accounts frozen previously, doesn't have a lot of money and isn't vaccinated, so couldn't even if she wanted to get on a plane to flee the country here.
00:17:11 So I don't think we're talking about much of a flight risk here.
00:17:14 What are the factors at play here that have been justifying keeping her detained, not giving her bail, especially when one of her co-organizers, Chris Barber, was given bail by that first judge, Justice Bourgeois?
00:17:26 on. Okay. So Andrew, there are three considerations in bail. The first, as you indicated, is the
00:17:33 flight risk. The second is the substantial likelihood of the repetition of the offense
00:17:38 or further offenses. And the third is the reputation of the administration of justice
00:17:43 as that's perceived in the community. And that normally doesn't play much of a factor into a
00:17:48 typical mischief charge, but it actually is playing a large factor here because it's got such a high
00:17:53 profile because members of the community allegedly were so much affected by what was being framed as
00:18:00 a a blockade as an occupation so on the first consideration uh justice bourgeois did not detain
00:18:09 tamara leach on the first first consideration the first consideration i believe the crown had argued
00:18:14 it was a a factor but that's not been uh the that's not been the consideration it's been the
00:18:20 second and the third that have been in play in this particular case and a lot has been said and
00:18:26 a lot has been made of tamara leach saying the hold the line i mean and again look i put myself
00:18:32 in the shoes of the prosecutor if i were prosecuting this i would be making the same
00:18:36 point as he did it's that the you know the politician said to go home the police said to go
00:18:42 home the emergency act was uh invoked and then as she's being arrested she says hold the line one
00:18:48 more time and so the argument that they're making is that she can't be governed by the rule of law
00:18:54 now again i i believe that the bail judge got it wrong in the first instance there's a heavy onus
00:19:00 in terms of releasing people uh particularly those without a prior record and so um notwithstanding
00:19:07 the fact that that's a concern the conditions of bail could be fashioned in such a way as to
00:19:14 alleviate that. Now in Canada, we don't rely so much on cash bail, although that would have been
00:19:20 an option. I know in Quebec, they're a little more interested in doing that than they are in
00:19:24 Ontario. Ontario places a big emphasis on shirties. That's a person who is willing to step up and sign
00:19:31 for the person and be responsible for the person, like their jailer. So they would turn them into
00:19:36 police if they weren't following conditions. Tamara Leach's first shirtie was not seen as
00:19:42 being suitable. But a different surety testified there was a publication ban on the identity of
00:19:48 that surety. So I can't really say much more other than there was a different surety that was put
00:19:53 forward. And there was a debate held over whether or not that person would be appropriate. But
00:20:00 moving now to the third consideration, sort of the public's perception of the administration of
00:20:05 justice, should this person be released? And we're seeing something that we see pretty much in other
00:20:10 areas of of civil society or politics or what have you it's that there are these two different
00:20:16 realities of what was going on in ottawa that are being put forward there's the reality at least the
00:20:22 one that i saw and i drove the streets uh my offices you can see uh right yeah you've got
00:20:28 you had quite a beautiful view of the action and even normally of downtown ottawa there i can i'm
00:20:32 actually quite jealous here being in my little basement office of your view absolutely we're
00:20:37 right downtown and yeah there was some a little bit of additional delays when getting to work but
00:20:43 i i could drive other than wellington i could drive pretty much every street downtown there
00:20:48 was at least one lane of traffic open on every major downtown core street uh you know say what
00:20:54 you will about the the flags that were there on the first day you know one or two flags that were
00:20:59 really really focused on by the media but you know there were hundreds or thousands of canadian flags
00:21:04 every day. It was a very peaceful and a very cordial protest for a very long time. That's
00:21:13 one reality. The other reality is that this was a blockade, an occupation, that there was harassment
00:21:19 going on. We heard a member of parliament even say that there was sexual assaults that were
00:21:24 taking place when there's really no evidence to support that. There was the ongoing honking,
00:21:29 which was a concern, and there was a court order that addressed that. But when you get the
00:21:35 prosecution that puts essentially a package of photos and pieces of evidence together, including
00:21:41 statements from the civil lawsuit that's going on, you get this one reality that makes it look
00:21:47 like it's some kind of hellscape, that Tamara Leach was responsible for visiting upon the city
00:21:53 of Ottawa. And so I think that to a certain degree, that was the perception that was
00:22:00 guiding the first bail judge. And Justice Johnston, he normally sits in Ottawa. He's a little bit
00:22:09 removed from the city of Ottawa and was able to, I think, you know, not necessarily tune into what
00:22:14 the innuendo is in the media, but focus on what the evidence was before him and put it into the
00:22:20 proper context and into the proper prioritization. Because again, you know, people can be released
00:22:25 on any crime in Canada, no matter how heinous. So it's a consideration of all three of those
00:22:31 factors. I think that the lawyer for Tamara Leach did a good job of advancing the argument on a bail
00:22:38 review and getting through some of those technicalities. Because it's not quite an appeal.
00:22:42 There's some, you know, certain issues that are assumed to have been correct by the bail judge.
00:22:49 Other issues can be challenged.
00:22:51 There's this concept of a change of circumstances.
00:22:54 One change of circumstance that I didn't really see argued that much, which I was quite surprised,
00:22:59 is that the protest isn't there anymore.
00:23:01 Yeah, the convoy, the mischief ceases to exist.
00:23:06 Right, exactly.
00:23:06 And I know there's always the argument that it could come back, but I think that the landscape
00:23:10 is very different right now.
00:23:12 It's had the occupation, as they call it, been still there and Tamara Leach was released.
00:23:18 more of an argument could have been made that you know uh she could give moral support or do
00:23:25 something to hinder the police in clearing out the area but the area is cleared out it's it's it's
00:23:30 gone right so that's one change of circumstance from the time the bail hearing was first argued
00:23:35 that i would argue uh makes it such that it's even less of a risk of her re-offending and less
00:23:43 of a concern to the public overall. I want to talk about some of the broader aftermath aspects
00:23:51 of this. I know you're representing the woman who was trampled by the police, the mounted police,
00:23:57 in that famous video now. And again, I'm talking about this as someone who was pepper sprayed at
00:24:01 the protest while doing my job as a journalist. There's another journalist, a photographer with
00:24:06 an agency I can't recall the name of immediately, who was arrested, zip-tied, thrown to the ground
00:24:11 by police and he was later released. There have been a number of incidents like this that have
00:24:16 come up. The only force, the only violence, in fact, I've heard of from anyone came from law
00:24:21 enforcement on that weekend when this was all basically dismantled by police. So just either
00:24:27 generally or on behalf of your clients specifically here, what is the recourse available to people
00:24:32 for this, even with the Emergencies Act having been in effect at that time?
00:24:36 Well, the recourse available, you have more recourse if you've been charged with an offense.
00:24:43 If you've been charged with an offense, you can apply to the court for remedy under the charter.
00:24:48 Your charges can be thrown out.
00:24:50 The court can make determinations and speak about the police's conduct.
00:24:56 The lack of recourse is what often exists when a person isn't charged.
00:25:00 We saw people as even far back as the, you know, the gas can seizures that took place earlier on in the protest where people were arrested, their property seized, and then they were released hours later.
00:25:11 So for those people, I know, for example, the lady who was trampled by the horse, Candace Saro, she's being represented by Matthew Wolfson in my office, and she wasn't charged with anything, but she is going to be, through the assistance of Matt Wolfson, bringing a professional standards complaint.
00:25:31 so that's a chance for the police to be formally disciplined for their conduct we're going to be
00:25:38 doing the same thing for the lady doreen that you may have seen who was a video recording on her
00:25:44 phone a police officer who walks up to her he walks up to her and says why are you pointing
00:25:49 that in my face uh stop recording and they start grilling her about where she's from
00:25:54 and then they start basically threatening her leave now or we're going to place you under arrest
00:25:59 And I've said this before, but it bears repeating. It's that the Emergency Act did give the police additional powers, but it didn't give the police unlimited powers.
00:26:10 And that's how the police were conducting themselves that weekend, where basically whatever the individual officer or the police force as a whole determined was necessary to do, you needed to do or face being arrested and charged with the same thing as Tamara Leach or anybody else who was there continuing to protest.
00:26:29 Yeah, and one of the more concerning aspects was this reverse onus that police claimed. You needed to prove that you had a lawful purpose, not just to be in front of Parliament Hill, but even as that video you just indicated, which we played on the show last week, shows to just walk down the street three or four blocks from Parliament Hill.
00:26:47 you had to prove to police that you had a reason. And as I understand it, and please correct me if
00:26:52 I'm wrong here, it happens often, but detention has a very broad meaning. It isn't just about
00:26:58 having handcuffs thrown on you. If police are stopping you and questioning you, that is
00:27:02 detainment, is it not? It is. I mean, there's psychological detention. Not every interaction
00:27:07 between the police and the public is a detention, but certainly where the police is taking some
00:27:13 degree of control over you and basically threatening you to say, you know, do as I say,
00:27:18 or we're going to place you under arrest. I would make the argument that the police are
00:27:22 detaining a person. And for all the Emergencies Act's faults, and there are many, it didn't say
00:27:27 you weren't allowed to film a public street. No. And Trudeau even said when announcing the
00:27:33 Emergency Act, he said, this is what it's not. And he said, it is not a restriction of the
00:27:38 Charter of Rights and Freedom. And you go into the Emergency Act, where they set out the so-called
00:27:44 red zone, where they can secure an area. That area, the southern area of that area specified
00:27:51 in the Emergency Act is Wellington Street. The Ottawa Police decided that they were going to
00:27:55 have an expanded red zone, and they treated the rest of that area, which wasn't specified in the
00:28:02 Emergencies Act as their full discretion to determine it to be a red zone and treat people
00:28:09 however they saw fit to treat them. Well, I'm glad you're on this and you've been doing a great job
00:28:16 on Twitter and you have your Twitter handle up on the screen there, David Anber, demystifying
00:28:20 a lot of this for the lay people out there like myself. So I appreciate it very much,
00:28:25 David Anber, lawyer in Toronto. Thank you, sir. Ottawa, thanks for having me.
00:28:29 I knew Ottawa. We were talking about you being in Ottawa. I'm from London. So they're all just
00:28:34 like big cities that go into an amorphous blob to me. But yes, Ottawa lawyer, David Anber. Thank you,
00:28:39 sir. Thanks, Andrew. All right. Well, that was very good. And again, I've had some great
00:28:45 interactions with David and he's been very quick to represent people that I think very much are
00:28:50 in need of that. I mean, that interaction with that woman on Wellington Street. And again,
00:28:55 I'm very pro-police. Police are oftentimes put in very difficult situations. They are very important
00:29:01 to our society. And the problem is when you see a situation like that, you're talking about a
00:29:08 police officer that is obeying an order that is itself, I'm convinced, unlawful. And with all of
00:29:15 the ambiguity out there, you were forced to give just so much discretion. I know I told this story
00:29:21 right after I got back from Ottawa. Bear with me because I think it's important here. The day after
00:29:26 the protest was basically dismantled. So it was a Sunday and it was, I guess, two weeks ago from
00:29:33 the Sunday that's coming up. The time is all just like blending together here. But what happened
00:29:39 was I was walking around and being questioned by police at various points. One of them was actually
00:29:46 at the same point that video was taken. I think it was a different officer though. I tried to walk
00:29:50 east on Albert Street. Police very quickly pounced on the sidewalk and told me I had to go back. I
00:29:55 said, but I'm a journalist. They said, prove it. I said, I mean, there is no universal journalism
00:29:59 credential in Canada. And they said, then turn around. And then I went to another police officer
00:30:05 when I tried to find another way to get to the same place. And he said, okay, can you show me
00:30:11 proof that you're a journalist? And I said, well, there isn't proof. And he was surprised. He said,
00:30:15 oh, I didn't know that. And I said, well, I could show you my Twitter profile. And I pulled up on
00:30:20 my phone, my Twitter profile that just proved that I was in Ottawa reporting. And he looked at it,
00:30:25 he said, oh, you're even verified. Then he waved me right through. And then at another point,
00:30:29 I tried to get into this secure area that was Wellington Street. And at one point I had actually
00:30:35 told them, I said, I'm a journalist. I had a letter from my editor that I was able to provide.
00:30:41 And I had a phone number for my editor. I said, you can call him. He can prove that I'm here.
00:30:44 Here's my ID. I was very transparent. They rang it up the flagpole to their boss, who rang it up
00:30:50 the flagpole to his boss, who said, no, you need to have a parliamentary press gallery credential.
00:30:56 Which again, has nothing to do with whether you're a journalist or not. That's just whether
00:31:00 you have been accredited to work in a very narrow space in Canadian media. And then I went around
00:31:06 to another entrance and I showed the letter, I showed my ID and he said, okay. And then I was in.
00:31:10 And that was where I took that video of police taking a selfie with their drone and just had
00:31:15 complete free reign over the streets. So all of this is to say that you had police that were not
00:31:21 being given clear direction on this. They've been told by someone that, okay, we'll let journalists
00:31:26 in just this once, but some of them were saying, okay, you need to be able to prove that.
00:31:32 So why is the onus on me to prove that I'm a journalist? And by the way, that is in and of
00:31:38 itself a category that is not particularly useful. If you look at the Charter of Rights and Freedoms,
00:31:43 which contrary to popular belief still does exist, it's still on the books as a law in Canada,
00:31:49 even if people are using it as toilet paper, it still is there. And what happens is you look at
00:31:55 it and section two has freedom of the press listed really as an example of freedom of expression.
00:32:03 There's no special category of freedom for journalists.
00:32:07 Freedom of the press is just one type of freedom of expression.
00:32:11 So that's important.
00:32:12 And obviously walking around, I was functionally using freedom of the press as my credential,
00:32:17 saying I have press freedom.
00:32:18 But realistically, my right, my constitutional right to be there as a journalist is no more
00:32:25 powerful than your constitutional right to be there as someone who wants to partake in
00:32:30 free expression.
00:32:31 and that includes freedom of protest. That includes freedom of assembly.
00:32:37 So that's the great irony here. The very same section that protects journalists
00:32:40 is also the same section that protects protest. And we oftentimes forget this. So when police
00:32:47 were going out and threatening journalists and threatening protesters, at least they were being
00:32:52 consistent. But the upshot of it is that people's constitutional rights were being infringed.
00:32:58 But oh, Justin Trudeau said that was never going to happen. He said this was all about press freedom. This was all about free speech. It was always about the freedom to engage in a peaceful protest. Well, why then after the vehicles were removed from Wellington Street, were people not able to assemble as people do all throughout the year on the front lawn of Parliament Hill?
00:33:17 Why was that form of free assembly, which is a peaceful and lawful activity, why was that not
00:33:25 allowed? There were all sorts of inconsistencies here. And if you watched my interview yesterday
00:33:30 with Candace Bergen, the conservative leader, I asked, is there still going to be accountability?
00:33:36 Can there even be accountability over the Emergencies Act without the emergency? And
00:33:40 she said they're going to keep trying. Not long after that interview, what we saw happened was
00:33:45 the NDP were trying to help the Liberals and are succeeding in helping the Liberals dilute
00:33:50 what the post-emergencies act review process is going to look like, of limiting the ability for
00:33:57 this committee, this special committee that's going to investigate it, to actually do its work.
00:34:01 So the Conservatives and the Bloc Québécois can all day long talk about the need for oversight and
00:34:06 transparency and accountability and all of that, but basically Justin Trudeau skates by.
00:34:10 he skates by in the same way that the NDP backed this and he whipped his liberal votes and even
00:34:16 liberals like Nathaniel Erskine-Smith were like well I don't like it but uh well you know I want
00:34:20 to keep my job so I'm going to vote for it and it was it was remarkable how transparent he was
00:34:25 about that so all of this is to say that we have an issue right now where Justin Trudeau is once
00:34:31 again infringing on your freedoms and all of us are just supposed to go along with it
00:34:39 All of us are supposed to go along with it.
00:34:42 Now, as we wind down here,
00:34:43 I want to talk about some of the big challenges
00:34:45 that are coming up.
00:34:47 And the reason I want to do this
00:34:48 is because I've been getting bombarded
00:34:50 with a lot of people asking me
00:34:52 why I'm not covering a certain bill,
00:34:54 which isn't actually a bill
00:34:57 that is what people are saying it is.
00:34:59 So I want to talk about this.
00:35:01 The message is saying to tell senators
00:35:03 about Bill C-10 and 11, C-36, and Bill S-233.
00:35:09 C-10 and 11, this post says, this viral post says, is a media censorship bill that would
00:35:14 eliminate alternative media.
00:35:16 C-36 is a hate speech bill that includes pre-crime and the ability to be taken to court for something
00:35:21 you haven't said.
00:35:22 And Bill S-233, this thing says, is about guaranteed basic income and social credit
00:35:28 score.
00:35:29 Okay, Bill C-10 and C-36 do not exist.
00:35:33 They are not in this parliament.
00:35:34 They were bills that were introduced in the previous parliament.
00:35:37 The liberals have said they're reintroducing them, and they might have actually reintroduced
00:35:41 C10, but I have to check on that.
00:35:44 But they're going to have different numbers.
00:35:45 And we covered those, we'll cover them, we'll continue to cover them.
00:35:48 They are very dangerous.
00:35:49 They aren't going to eliminate alternative media here.
00:35:52 You have to be precise with language.
00:35:54 Otherwise, you're going to get the fake news label slapped on you here.
00:35:57 But what it would do is put the government's regulatory infrastructure over the internet,
00:36:04 over online publishers.
00:36:06 and the government has been back and forth all day long
00:36:09 about what publisher means.
00:36:10 At first, it was anyone that tweets or posts YouTube videos
00:36:14 and then it was, no, no, no,
00:36:15 we're not gonna go against individuals.
00:36:16 And then it was, well, what about online news sites?
00:36:18 And the government said,
00:36:19 well, we're not gonna go after online news sites.
00:36:22 But the problem with that
00:36:23 is that we go back to the age-old question
00:36:25 of government deciding who real journalists are.
00:36:29 Government has not recognized
00:36:30 that True North is a media outlet in several fora.
00:36:34 So they may just say, okay, we regulate True North.
00:36:37 And again, it doesn't shut us down.
00:36:39 I want to be careful here.
00:36:40 It doesn't shut us down, but it would regulate us.
00:36:44 And it would regulate other independent media,
00:36:47 especially those government doesn't like.
00:36:48 So that was the old Bill C-10.
00:36:50 There will be a new one.
00:36:51 Bill C-36, same thing.
00:36:53 This is restoring Section 13 of the Canadian Human Rights Act.
00:36:56 This one is fairly well described in the viral post.
00:37:00 s33 this is the one that's being misrepresented this is a senate bill a senate private members
00:37:07 bill that would put forward a guaranteed basic income as i understand it it's not going to pass
00:37:12 it's not about a social credit score there's a bunch of airy fairy pie in the sky language in
00:37:17 there but it's not a social credit score so if we want to talk about what's happening here in
00:37:22 canadian society we have to do it in a way that is rooted in facts otherwise we don't actually
00:37:27 get anywhere with it. So read the bill for yourself because I was getting, and I have been
00:37:31 for days, bombarded with people asking, why are you not talking about the social credit bill? And
00:37:35 I'm like, trust me, I'm immersed in news every day, but I miss stuff. And then I read the bill
00:37:39 itself and that's not what it does. Do I oppose it? Yes, because I oppose a guaranteed basic income,
00:37:45 but that's not the social credit score. The problems we have are coming from the regulation
00:37:50 of social media. And that's something that Justin Trudeau is doing. We know is doing regulating
00:37:56 online speech and deputizing that's really what they're doing deputizing social media companies
00:38:02 to be the enforcers of the government's speech code and that's something that we know is happening
00:38:07 and will continue to happen but we are going to cover it here on true north as we always do so
00:38:12 thanks to all of you again i enjoy hearing from you i enjoy when people flag these things for me
00:38:16 but oftentimes all of the why aren't you covering this why aren't you covering this why aren't you
00:38:20 covering it stuff more often than not the answer is i have covered it and i can give people a link
00:38:24 or alternatively, I'm looking into it.
00:38:26 This one, just because it's not as it was being presented.
00:38:30 So that's the upshot of that.
00:38:32 We've got to end things here.
00:38:33 My thanks to all of you for tuning
00:38:35 into this live edition of the program.
00:38:37 We've got some great stuff coming up for you next week.
00:38:39 So don't miss that.
00:38:41 And if you can support our work here,
00:38:43 like we were talking about earlier with Franco Terrazano,
00:38:45 we're not getting the CBC subsidy.
00:38:48 We're not getting the $600 million journalism bailout.
00:38:51 We are getting support from people
00:38:52 that value the work that we do
00:38:54 and that donate a few bucks a month, a few hundred dollars,
00:38:57 whatever works for you, whatever makes sense.
00:38:59 We appreciate your support very much.
00:39:01 So thanks to all of you.
00:39:02 We will talk to you soon here on The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:39:04 Thank you, God bless, and good day.
00:39:08 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:39:10 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.
00:39:24 We'll be right back.