Juno News - April 24, 2023


Government spending $13 billion for 3,000 jobs

Topics
Mentioned
Mother resists mandatory vaccination for her children Striking public servants are blocking infrastructure, and Trudeau doesn't seem to mind

Episode Stats


Length

37 minutes

Words per minute

184.4

Word count

6,930

Sentence count

320

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

6

sentences flagged

Hate speech

10

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Tarek Fattah was a lion of Punjab, a son of Hindustan, a lover of Canada, a speaker of truth, a fighter for justice, a voice of the downtdden underdogs and the oppressed. Tarek's revolution will continue with all who knew and loved him.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:00:05 This is the Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:00:14 Hello everyone and welcome to you all.
00:00:17 This is Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show, the Andrew Lawton Show, here on True North.
00:00:21 Monday, April 24th, 2023.
00:00:25 I think it's 2023, who knows these days.
00:00:28 The last three years has basically been one gigantic blur.
00:00:32 And what a news day today.
00:00:35 Tucker Carlson out at Fox News.
00:00:38 Now, I don't know Tucker Carlson particularly well,
00:00:41 but I've always thought he was a tremendously talented broadcaster,
00:00:46 very shrewd businessman, and also a very principled guy.
00:00:50 So I think we can all read between the lines on what happened here.
00:00:53 And I think that it's safe to say American media will not be the same, at least for the time being.
00:00:59 But I also think he will have no trouble finding a soft landing spot.
00:01:03 I don't know if True North can afford Tucker Carlson or if we're after him, given his promise to invade Canada.
00:01:09 But you know what? Some of us might even just billet soldiers if the U.S. invades Canada. You never know.
00:01:15 And then some guy named Don Orange out at CNN that I was not familiar with, but seems to be, no, it might have been another citrus.
00:01:21 Don Pamelo, Don Tangerine, Don Grapefruit, Lime, anyway.
00:01:27 Some guy at CNN that apparently was seen by tens of people has also been fired today.
00:01:33 So that is the big media landscape here.
00:01:36 But I do want to just start off on, well, I guess I've already started off, so now I'm moving to something else.
00:01:42 But I do want to take a moment on a bit of a more somber note to talk about the passing of a fantastic Canadian media figure.
00:01:51 And someone that I knew very well and have had many, many interactions on air and off air with over the years.
00:01:58 And that is Tarek Fattah, who passed away and it was announced by his lovely daughter Natasha Fattah,
00:02:07 who's been doing a tremendous job caring for him and keeping all the people in his close and far away orbit,
00:02:14 apprised of what's happening.
00:02:15 And Natasha posted on Twitter this morning, it's actually quite a touching message here,
00:02:25 but what Natasha writes is that he was a lion of Punjab, a son of Hindustan, a lover of Canada,
00:02:32 a speaker of truth, a fighter for justice, voice of the downtrodden underdogs and the oppressed.
00:02:39 Tarek Fatah has passed the baton on.
00:02:41 his revolution will continue with all who knew and loved him. Will you join us? 1949 to 2023.
00:02:49 Now, I first met Tarek on The Michael Coren Show, which is a show that itself is a bit dated. It
00:02:56 was back on CTS, a station that's no longer in existence. It's been rebranded as something else.
00:03:02 And Tarek Vittal was one of the panelists on the left. I was one of the panelists on the right.
00:03:07 and we would have some very, very heated debates. 0.88
00:03:11 And I was a young little punk, bull in the china shop type,
00:03:16 and he was a bit of a bull in the china shop himself,
00:03:18 but with a lot more maturity and a lot more, I think, evidence and experience to back it up.
00:03:23 But he was always so respectful, as respectful as he was passionate.
00:03:27 And we sparred on some things, we agreed on others,
00:03:30 we disagreed, of course, as I mentioned, on a few.
00:03:33 But I really valued those interactions.
00:03:36 And years and years ago, about 2010, when I was in the hospital for quite a while and in a coma, I had been reading, before I was hospitalized, his book, The Jew Is Not My Enemy, which was, at the time, a very provocative book from a Muslim saying, no, no, no, our issues are not with Jews. 0.94
00:03:55 And this was something that many people in the Muslim community took issue with, Tarek Fatah's willingness to criticize Islam when he thought it deserved it. 0.84
00:04:06 And he did this while also being a tremendously compassionate and caring figure, which made him such a thoughtful commentator.
00:04:14 And, you know, years later in 2018, I've never told anyone this, when I was running for office provincially and there was a week where just everyone in the world, it felt like was against me.
00:04:24 And there was this bad news story and this bad news story and all of that.
00:04:27 he messaged me and said some very kind things which in that moment were needed and were from
00:04:34 an unlikely source given that he was not at all a conservative i think he voted ndp in that election
00:04:39 and i was the conservative candidate but he was incredibly kind and incredibly thoughtful and i
00:04:44 know he has left a huge mark both in his family and in his work and he will be missed by me and
00:04:51 by many many others so Tarek Fatal we thank you so much for all your work and we miss you and I
00:04:58 will just moving on to the news of the day here of which there is quite a bit to get through I
00:05:03 want to talk about this story which is actually challenging for me in some ways because it's a
00:05:07 local story to a lot of the people in my neighborhood and my immediate circle St. Thomas
00:05:12 Ontario small town about half an hour from here getting a giant giga factory from Volkswagen to
00:05:19 manufacture batteries for electric vehicles. This is costing Canadian taxpayers $13 billion
00:05:26 in subsidies to make 3,000 jobs. That's the claim. Now, they say there are going to be some
00:05:33 indirect jobs in the range of 30,000. Even then, we're talking about a large sum. If you do the
00:05:39 math, that's about $4.3 million per job, which strikes me as something that might have some
00:05:45 better ways to spend it to yield some economic development in southwestern Ontario or beyond
00:05:52 in this country. And this is, to my knowledge, the largest bit of corporate welfare in Canada's
00:05:59 history. Not even Bombardier, I think, has built a plant that got $13 billion worth of government
00:06:05 funding. Aaron Woodrick, who is the director of domestic policy for the Macdonald-Laurier
00:06:11 Institute joins me now. Aaron, let's just talk about the math here. Do you think that we are
00:06:17 going to get $13 billion worth of value from this? Yeah, it's really hard to see how, Andrew. And
00:06:23 look, I empathize. I'm from, like you, I'm from southwestern Ontario. I'm just down the 401 in
00:06:28 KW. All my family lives in London. I got friends in St. Thomas. So look, you can be conflicted
00:06:34 because there are real people in real community that will benefit from this. But when you zoom
00:06:38 out and you ask yourself the amount of money, I mean, just to sort of put the sum into context
00:06:44 here, Andrew, you talk about Bombardier. I mean, they were sort of the champions of corporate
00:06:47 welfare in this country. They managed to get about $4 billion. That was over 50 years,
00:06:52 over dozens of handouts. VW has managed to get more than three times that in one go for a single
00:07:00 plant. And the craziest thing of all, wasn't even brought up in question period by anybody the day
00:07:05 after this news leak, which was just astonishing to me. I mean, the idea that parties like,
00:07:10 you know, the Conservators and the Democrats have nothing to say on this really just kind of floored
00:07:16 me. Yeah. And one of the challenges is that you had the provincial Conservative government that
00:07:21 has been cheerleading this as well. They were there at the announcement. They've been talking
00:07:26 about how great it is. You had the local Conservative MP, Karen Vecchio, who I know
00:07:30 quite well was there and was actually used I think quite cynically by Justin Trudeau as a prop on
00:07:36 this. He was then chiding her for Pierre Polyev not jumping up and down supporting this. So the
00:07:42 idea that we're all just supposed to say it's great for the community so we all rally behind
00:07:46 this without looking at the numbers is I think quite concerning. Yeah and you know the dirty
00:07:51 little secret here Andrew is most of these politicians if you get them in private off the
00:07:55 record they'll all acknowledge that this is a subsidy. They'll all acknowledge that this is not
00:07:59 great stuff what they really should say if they were going to be straight with us is guess what
00:08:03 vw was shopping around they were going to put this plant wherever they got the best deal
00:08:08 so we gave them the best deal you know at least if governments were honest about that and saying
00:08:12 you know it's unfortunate that we have to subsidize this stuff but it's the only way to get these
00:08:17 kinds of plants i would respect that more i still think it's a bad economic argument and people need
00:08:21 to realize that in st thomas for example st thomas a lot of the people that are going to end up at
00:08:27 working at this plant are going to be sucked out of other businesses in St. Thomas. It's not
00:08:31 necessarily folks who are unemployed in St. Thomas that will fill these jobs. It's people who are
00:08:35 working in companies in St. Thomas that won't be able to compete with VW and their federally
00:08:40 subsidized jobs. So it's not all, even for places like St. Thomas, it's not a clear win when you
00:08:46 think of all the other businesses there that don't get that kind of special treatment.
00:08:50 One of the problems with corporate welfare is that it'd be, especially when you compound it
00:08:54 with globalization is that you have this system where companies literally do what you just
00:08:59 described with Volkswagen. They go shopping around. I think it was back in 2017 when Amazon
00:09:04 was remarkably transparent about this. They basically said, we're having a contest on where
00:09:09 to build our second headquarters. And it was basically who's going to give us the most money
00:09:12 and then we'll go there. In this particular case, Canada was competing with the United States,
00:09:18 which is 10 times the size of Canada, has an astronomically larger GDP, more money to work
00:09:24 with so how on earth is canada supposed to compete because there is an argument i don't like the
00:09:28 argument that these are just the rules of the game now and if you want any investment this is how you
00:09:33 have to do it yeah well first of all it's very it's impossible to compete with economy 10 times
00:09:38 your size you're never going to be able to match them on everything dollar for dollar um but i think
00:09:42 the the the unspoken assumption in that is that we have to be in the business of building electric
00:09:46 cars right it's like we absolutely must be doing this one type of thing and really when you zoom
00:09:52 out again there's no there's no argument that economically this is something we have to be in
00:09:56 it's something we want to be in because politically it's popular and it's cool and it's easy to say
00:10:01 this is the sector of the future but I got news for people governments are not very good at
00:10:05 predicting the future you know they're not very good at picking winners and losers which is the
00:10:09 reason they shouldn't do it um so this idea that this is one thing that we absolutely have to be
00:10:14 in I mean what struck me as interesting Andrews if we want to be a part of for example the supply
00:10:18 chain for electric vehicles. Well, guess what? Canada has a lot of rare earth minerals that are
00:10:23 only to be found in Canada. All the subsidies in the world and other countries can't replace that.
00:10:29 So why not worry about finding ways to get that stuff out of the ground, build the infrastructure
00:10:33 to the ring of fire? These are things we could do to make sure that Canada is part of the supply
00:10:39 chain for electric vehicles. But this idea that we have to have this plant in the province or the
00:10:45 sky will fall. There's just no basis for it other than the government saying, well, this is something
00:10:49 we want to be in. Yeah, that's actually a very important point. And I think that Canada has been
00:10:54 certainly under this government very bad at leveraging the things where it naturally has
00:10:59 a comparative advantage. And one example of that is oil and gas. I mean, this is something where
00:11:04 we're sitting on the advantage. We're sitting on something that makes it so Canada is able to do
00:11:09 something that other countries cannot do as easily. Why are we competing with things that
00:11:12 other places could do as easily that could be in you know lithuania or the united states or
00:11:17 berlin or st thomas and really make no difference yeah and the sad answer to the reason we don't do
00:11:23 that andrew is political sexiness there are certain types of jobs that are very attractive
00:11:28 to politicians building airplanes is one of them building vehicles it sounds fancy it sounds
00:11:32 innovative oh it's really good yeah aerospace is the aerospace you know these are sectors that
00:11:37 politicians just love because they sound really, really fancy. Things like forestry and agriculture.
00:11:44 I mean, these sound, it sounds really sort of backwards. And the irony of potash photo op is
00:11:49 not going to be as sexy. I agree. But ironically, these jobs are things we have a comparative
00:11:54 advantage in. They pay very well. They don't require government subsidies. And ironically,
00:11:58 again, in a lot of sectors like agriculture, for example, very, very innovative. Canada has
00:12:02 cutting edge technology in these sectors and continues to develop it. But you never hear
00:12:07 about it because to politicians from big cities like Toronto, Montreal, Vancouver, that sounds
00:12:11 like hayseed stuff. And that's the real tragedy here is that Canada actually can compete and win
00:12:17 in a lot of sectors. It's just not the sectors that all the Laurentian elites want to chase after
00:12:21 because they want to be popular in places like New York and London. And you're not going to do
00:12:26 that by focusing on agriculture. So that to me is the real tragedy here is there are a lot of good
00:12:31 jobs for a lot of Canadians out there, but the sort of elite political class thumbs their nose
00:12:35 at it and does not devote anywhere near the amount of resources and attention to those areas.
00:12:42 Is your view that all corporate welfare is bad, that this is just one line item in federal
00:12:46 programming that we could get rid of? Yeah, generally speaking, yes. I mean,
00:12:50 sometimes people like to come clap back at me and say, well, what about subsidies for oil and gas?
00:12:54 I mean, first of all, there aren't as many as these people claim. Most of the people that say
00:12:58 there's these billions, they're talking about tax credits, which to me is something very different.
00:13:01 When you give someone a tax break or a tax credit, you're letting them keep more of the
00:13:04 of the money they've already earned. That's very different than just handing them a pile of money
00:13:08 from the taxpayer that they never earned. So that's the one difference. The other answer is, yeah, by
00:13:12 all means, end them for every sector. And the reason is, Andrew, there's no way to have a level
00:13:17 playing field otherwise. Governments do not know what the best use of investment or people's social
00:13:23 skills and talent is. And when you pick and choose, you're distorting the economy. You're driving
00:13:29 investment and job choices away from other areas. And that's just not fair. That's not
00:13:34 government's role. So I'm all for government trying to lift people up, trying to create an
00:13:39 environment where any business in any sector can compete. You do that with tax cuts, with better
00:13:43 regulation, things like that. But the idea that governments somehow know better than the
00:13:48 marketplace, you know, what should be the employer or what sector we should be in,
00:13:52 there's simply no basis for it other than the government thinking that they want to be in
00:13:56 certain sectors. I know your focus is obviously on the policy and not the politics here, but I
00:14:02 think the two are somewhat linked in this question of how a future government could do anything about
00:14:08 this, or even if they could. I mean, is this the type of thing where no matter what happens,
00:14:11 if there were an election, say in a year or two years, this is something that now we're on the
00:14:17 hook for? I think so. And I think just the reaction to this is telling. Again, the fact
00:14:23 that you didn't see, you're not seeing opposition parties.
00:14:25 I mean, remember, in politics, if you spend $13 in an orange juice
00:14:30 or $6,000 in a hotel room, you'll hear it for days, right?
00:14:33 Or Galen Weston gets an $11 million pay raise.
00:14:36 You know, the parties will foam with the mouth
00:14:37 over relatively small amounts of money.
00:14:39 But $13 billion, not a peep.
00:14:41 So I think that suggests this is everyone is afraid to touch this.
00:14:44 The other tragedy, Andrew, is as we've seen from other sectors,
00:14:47 whether it's aerospace or traditionally in auto,
00:14:49 all this buys you is the right to get shaken down again in the future.
00:14:52 I mean, people say, well, you know, VW has to meet all these conditions or they're not going to get the money.
00:14:57 Well, let's fast forward 10 or 15 years.
00:14:59 And then someone comes along and says, well, VW, you better shape up or otherwise you're not going to get your money.
00:15:04 And VW says, oh, yeah, is that so?
00:15:07 Well, it would be a real shame if someone closed this plant down and moved it to Alabama.
00:15:11 What do you think politicians' response is going to be?
00:15:13 Of course, they're going to pony up the money again.
00:15:14 So once you start this game, you're just setting yourself up to be taken to the cleaners over and over again.
00:15:20 I'm not speculating.
00:15:21 We've seen it happen. And I fear that that is going to be how this be this, how this story ends
00:15:26 as well. Yeah, I fear you're right. And I mean, there are no certainties in economics or anything
00:15:31 else. And we also sentimentalize jobs for good reason, because, you know, individual people are
00:15:37 not just numbers on a balance sheet, they're human beings. But it becomes a bit of a cudgel
00:15:42 that's used against common sense. I remember like the SNC-Lavalin scandal, for one example,
00:15:47 Here we had a story that involved bribing dictators in Libya and the results is, oh, but Quebec jobs.
00:15:53 And again, here we have, oh, think of the jobs. 0.60
00:15:56 Yeah, and I think some people, sorry, GDLS, again, you know, supplying weaponry to a human rights abusing regime and oh, but the jobs.
00:16:04 Yep. You know, people also need to remember that, you know, in economies, certain sectors come and go.
00:16:09 This idea that we're going to be able to keep, I mean, we might still have, we might still be, you know, horse and buggy economy if people said, well, we can't lose the jobs there.
00:16:16 And I give you an example. My hometown Kitchener-Waterloo has gone through so many different iterations. I mean, it was a rubber producer. Then it was an electronics producer. You know, then they switched over to BlackBerry was a giant. BlackBerry went bust and it was supposed to be the end. But guess what happened? All the people that got laid off from BlackBerry, they started new businesses and now there's a thriving ecosystem there.
00:16:36 So, you know, there's a saying in free market economics called creative destruction.
00:16:41 It sounds bad because there's destruction, but you can't forget the creative part.
00:16:45 People have a lot of ingenuity and a lot of entrepreneurship.
00:16:49 And, you know, if you create the conditions, if you make it easy to start a business and easy to grow it,
00:16:54 you don't have to worry so much about businesses that are dying off because you've got an environment where the next big thing is just around the corner.
00:17:01 Aaron Woodrick is the director of federal policy for the, or domestic policy rather,
00:17:06 for the Macdonald-Laurier Institute. Aaron, always a pleasure. Thanks for coming on today.
00:17:10 Thanks a lot, Andrew.
00:17:11 That was Aaron Woodrick. Great insight on this. And yeah, I think the corporate welfare thing
00:17:17 is one where you have to just sever your sentimental attachments to a particular sector
00:17:23 or even the idea of jobs. And I think it's difficult. And like I said, I mean, I live
00:17:29 in london ontario as many of you know and the uh big one of the big employers just not far from
00:17:35 uh well it's not far from anyone who lives in london because it's not a huge city is general
00:17:39 dynamics land systems which inked a multi-billion dollar deal with saudi arabia to supply light
00:17:45 armored vehicles there and this was a deal championed by the conservatives at the time
00:17:49 the liberals were very muted in their criticism because again here we have oh well i don't know
00:17:53 we don't want to come out against jobs and then when we learned more and more that it sounded like
00:17:58 Saudi Arabia was actually using stuff that Canada was shipping over as part of its human rights
00:18:03 abuses again there was this push from the conservatives to not politicize this and to
00:18:09 focus on the economy the liberals said oh we're outraged we're going to have an inquiry and a
00:18:13 review and nothing has ever come from this so basically the deal still goes on and we because
00:18:19 of jobs which are important and we are talking about real people we stop listening to all of
00:18:25 these other things in us that we probably should listen to, like common sense, economics, human
00:18:31 rights. And that's the problem here. So now you have potentially 3,000 people in St. Thomas that
00:18:36 are going to get jobs. Many of them may be looking for jobs. Many of them may be employed elsewhere,
00:18:41 and they're going to go and work for the Volkswagen plant. But if you're a Canadian
00:18:45 taxpayer who has contributed basically 360 bucks a person, I think that was the math that I didn't
00:18:52 do that math myself, but you know, however much it costs each individual taxpayer, where's your ROI
00:18:58 on that? Are you going to get a discount on your electric Volkswagen? Probably not. We're going to
00:19:03 talk a little bit later on about this historical revisionism that we are seeing from Justin Trudeau,
00:19:09 but I wanted to just take a little bit of a jaunt out to Alberta, because as you may know, there's
00:19:13 an election coming up there in just one month and five days. True North is going to be covering that
00:19:18 election quite extensively and we'll have a bit of a preview in one of the episodes I don't know
00:19:24 if it's Friday or maybe next week about what we are going to be doing to cover that but one of
00:19:28 the big issues in general that I talked about with Premier Danielle Smith on this show about a month
00:19:34 ago is the idea of whether she's really campaigning against the NDP in Alberta or is she campaigning
00:19:40 against Ottawa and this is I think the big conflict the big tension right in Alberta is that Alberta
00:19:46 sees Ottawa as ever increasing in its encroachment on Alberta's terrain, constitutionally, ethically,
00:19:54 politically, morally, and for good reasons. So what Daniel Smith has talked about is the idea
00:19:59 of doing as much in Alberta without the federal government as is possible within the constitution.
00:20:05 And one of the big issues that's come up time and time again is whether it is long overdue to sever
00:20:10 ties with the RCMP to kick them out as the provincial police force and create, like Ontario
00:20:16 and Quebec have, a provincial police force in Alberta. This was articulated quite well in a
00:20:23 comprehensive piece in C2C Journal, which you should definitely add to your reading list. It
00:20:27 was written by longtime journalist Doug Furby, who joins me now. Doug, it is good to talk to you.
00:20:33 Thanks for coming on today. Oh, thanks for the invitation, Andrew. Great to be here.
00:20:37 Now, just for people that don't understand the arrangement, I mean, yes, the RCMP is a national police force, but when it is in a provincial context, it's not operating as such.
00:20:48 That's right. It's actually a two-headed monster, if you'll forgive the term. It's really a national police force, and then it's also a force that does community policing.
00:20:57 It does it at the provincial level, and it also does it at the city level, the community level.
00:21:03 so why is this such an issue in alberta because as we've seen in the firearms debate
00:21:10 where alberta has directed the rcmp to not enforce the federal government's gun grab they ultimately
00:21:15 have oversight on how the rcmp when it's operating that provincial or community mandate does its job
00:21:22 so why does it need to have its own alberta provincial police i think there's a couple of
00:21:27 really important reasons there, Andrew. I mean, first and foremost, this started with
00:21:32 the Fair Deal panel that was struck in 2019 by the previous premier, Jason Kenney, and
00:21:38 that panel recognized in May of 2020 that this would be one of the easiest ways that
00:21:47 Alberta could assert a little more of its independence to get out from under the RCMP.
00:21:53 And there's lots of examples why that's a good idea.
00:21:56 I mean, you think about the floods in High River in which the RCMP swooped in and seized
00:22:02 a bunch of people's guns without authorization, ostensibly for safety reasons, but it took
00:22:09 those people months and months to get their rightfully owned legal registered weapons
00:22:14 back.
00:22:15 So there are irritants like that that go on all the time.
00:22:18 But I think there's a much larger issue, and that is that any police force that ultimately answers to the federal government, I think we all believe that it can't be as effective and do as good a job as a locally authorized, locally mandated police force.
00:22:36 this idea is not a really new idea you go back to the alberta firewall letter and this was
00:22:45 one of the things that was put forward that alberta should assert itself and at the time i
00:22:49 think it was to let the contract expire in 2012 if i recall for for the rcmp and set up an alberta
00:22:56 provincial police force but again conservative governments in alberta even ralph klein have not
00:23:01 accepted this they've not actually moved ahead with this so what's been the sticking point is
00:23:05 it just cost is it other people not seeing the need i think it's a matter of political will i
00:23:11 mean when you look at the um polling that's done about the public attitude about the rcmp
00:23:18 a lot of people support the rcmp in polls and i'm going to distinguish between the rcmp officers and
00:23:26 the rcmp leadership because there's very little confidence in the leadership the senior leadership
00:23:32 at the ICMP. But there is a sentimental attachment to the ICMP. And so you've got the Alberta
00:23:39 Municipal Association coming out saying we don't want to have a provincial police force,
00:23:44 we want to stick with the ICMP. So there's a political risk for any government to move ahead
00:23:50 with this proposal because there's so much sentiment that it's almost a nostalgic attachment
00:23:56 to what we thought of as one of the great police forces in the world at one point.
00:24:04 So let's talk about where the current Alberta government is.
00:24:09 Now, obviously, this is a government that, as I mentioned, is seeking re-election.
00:24:12 We don't know if it's going to be a UCP government in six weeks or an NDP government.
00:24:17 But where is the Danielle Smith government on this issue?
00:24:19 well the the government ministers uh who are responsible for this the justice minister
00:24:26 is very closed mouth about it i know that he personally is in favor of replacing the rcmp
00:24:35 with the provincial police force i think mike ellis the safety minister feels the same way
00:24:42 and i think the government if they felt if they saw their way clear to do this would act very
00:24:48 quickly on it. As you know, as you talked about, we've got an election on the horizon. It's not a
00:24:55 good time to take a politically risky move. I think if the Smith government is able to get a
00:25:01 new mandate, a majority government, I would bet that they would move pretty quickly on this.
00:25:08 You know, we've seen in the last couple of years in particular, some profound institutional
00:25:14 failings by the RCMP. I think we can point to the Emergencies Act and a lot of what we learned
00:25:20 during the Public Order Emergency Commission, certainly the Nova Scotia killing, which you've
00:25:25 referenced in your piece here in C2C Journal, just profound failures. We saw evidence of the
00:25:32 RCMP really just running political interference for the Liberal government. So this is not an
00:25:36 institution that when you, again, not talking about the individual frontline officers, it's not
00:25:40 an institution that is without controversy, that's without challenges to its ethics, to its efficacy.
00:25:47 So it shouldn't be, I think, a difficult sell to voters if they care about the issue. And I guess
00:25:54 that's the question. I don't know if this is an issue that matters to a lot of people, or if
00:25:59 their sense is, is it going to be better at solving crime? Is it going to be better at dealing with
00:26:04 the property crime in my city? And is there an argument one way or another about whether
00:26:09 you would get better policing from an Alberta force, or do you think that is relatively equivalent?
00:26:15 Andrew, there's a lot of evidence to suggest that you would get better policing. The devil
00:26:21 is always in the details, but one of the communities that I looked at in that article
00:26:28 that you referenced in the CDC Journal was Grand Prairie. That city has been looking at
00:26:34 getting out of RCMP contracts and doing their own police force,
00:26:39 they've moved ahead with that.
00:26:41 And I talked with one of the counselors who was a leader in that,
00:26:44 and he has spent hundreds of hours looking into this.
00:26:48 And there's a couple of real sore points with the RCMP.
00:26:50 One of them is when the town suggests unusual or unique initiatives,
00:26:58 let's get more officers out into the community, more social interaction.
00:27:02 this then has to go up through the hierarchy in the RCMP
00:27:06 and in one case, one initiative that they proposed
00:27:10 it took 15 years to get that initiative approved
00:27:14 15 years, those criminals have grown up and moved on since then
00:27:19 and so there's that
00:27:23 there's this stasis, this inability to get anything done
00:27:27 and then I think the other thing is
00:27:29 You know, the RCMP, a lot of the officers who start in the smaller communities are looking to build their careers.
00:27:37 So they'll spend a couple of years in a small Alberta town, and then they're looking to move up and out.
00:27:44 And oftentimes that's out of the province.
00:27:46 So you don't get the officers staying in the community, knowing the people at the same level,
00:27:51 really knowing what's going on in that community as well as you would if you had a local police force.
00:27:57 The other thing is, there's one other thing.
00:27:59 I think that there would be a much higher level of coordination
00:28:01 between Alberta agencies, other Alberta agencies,
00:28:06 such as social service agencies and the police service.
00:28:10 So I think, in effect, we would have more boots on the ground,
00:28:13 that they may not all be sworn officers,
00:28:16 but we've got more people out there looking for public safety.
00:28:20 Well, it's certainly an interesting debate.
00:28:22 You can read the piece here at c2cjournal.ca.
00:28:25 It is called Crime and Mismanagement, Why It's Time to Drop the RCMP and Create an Alberta Police.
00:28:31 Doug Furby is the author, and it's with me now.
00:28:33 Doug, thanks so much for coming on today. Good to talk to you.
00:28:36 My pleasure.
00:28:38 Pleasure to talk to you, Andrew.
00:28:40 Thank you very much, Doug.
00:28:42 This is a story that came up today that I must admit,
00:28:46 when I was just sort of casually bouncing around the internet looking at things to talk about,
00:28:51 and I heard it playing, I was like, oh, that sounded a weird little thing.
00:28:55 I thought it was a deep fake.
00:28:56 I don't know if you know these things.
00:28:58 It's like before AI, it's this technology that lets you just make a video of someone
00:29:05 saying something that they never said.
00:29:07 And some of these things are getting quite convincing.
00:29:10 My whole show actually has been a deep fake.
00:29:12 Like I said in the last show, I'm actually not here.
00:29:14 But this was a video that I saw.
00:29:17 I'm like, oh, there's no way Justin Trudeau could have dared say that.
00:29:20 This must be a deep fake.
00:29:21 But no, it was not a deep fake.
00:29:23 This was him sitting down at a round table at the University of Ottawa with the president of Germany
00:29:29 and engaging in a little bit of a historical revisionist exercise.
00:29:34 Take a look.
00:29:37 And all of the scientists and the medical experts and the researchers,
00:29:43 not just in Canada but around the world,
00:29:47 understood that vaccination was going to be the way through this.
00:29:51 and therefore while not forcing anyone to get vaccinated
00:29:56 I chose to make sure that all the incentives
00:30:00 and all the protections were there
00:30:03 to encourage Canadians to get vaccinated
00:30:05 and that's exactly what they did
00:30:07 we got vaccinated to a higher level
00:30:08 than just about any other of our peer countries
00:30:11 and that's why we had a less deadly pandemic
00:30:14 than most other countries
00:30:16 now I see a lot of people nodding along with that
00:30:20 but boy oh boy you know the comments section on the live stream right now is exploding with people
00:30:27 who are in deep deep disagreement with everything i just said and we have to figure out how
00:30:38 to continue to protect those people because my job as prime minister is to keep people alive
00:30:48 and keep people safe and keep democracy going whether or not they choose to believe that's
00:30:55 what i'm doing or not when he references people in the comment section disagreeing i'm like
00:31:04 hi are you talking i'm not commenting but are you talking about me so he his first claim there that
00:31:09 we have to unpack is that he never forced anyone to get vaccinated he just offered a bunch of
00:31:15 incentives for people who did it. This is a little montage that we have shared clips of
00:31:22 in the past on this show about all of the things Justin Trudeau has said
00:31:27 about the unvaccinated and the stakes of being unvaccinated.
00:31:34 If you don't want to get vaccinated, that's your choice. But don't think you can get on a plane
00:31:40 or a train besides vaccinated people and put them at risk.
00:31:44 The small fringe minority of people who are on their way to Ottawa
00:31:50 or who are holding unacceptable views that they're expressing
00:31:54 do not represent the views of Canadians who have been there.
00:32:00 Concerns expressed by a few people gathered in Ottawa right now
00:32:04 are not new, not surprising, are heard, but are a continuation of what we've unfortunately seen
00:32:12 in disinformation and misinformation online, conspiracy theorists about microchips, about
00:32:19 God knows what else that go with the tinfoil hats. Conservative party members can stand with
00:32:24 people who wave swastikas. They can stand with people who wave the confederate.
00:32:29 that list by the way went on for another i don't know minute or so uh this little montage of his
00:32:40 comments about uh the unvaccinated about people that don't get vaccinated about people that
00:32:44 protest against his vaccine mandates do these sound like just little incentives they're little
00:32:49 incentives it's your choice do what you want but it's all good we're just gonna just try to coax
00:32:54 you in the right direction? No. Justin Trudeau's entire approach was to vilify and demonize
00:33:01 anyone who, for whatever reason, did not want to get vaccinated against COVID. That was his
00:33:08 government's approach. So when he says we never forced anyone, let's talk about what his government
00:33:17 did. His government forced people who were unvaccinated into a two-week-long quarantine
00:33:23 after they entered their own country if, that is, they had been able to leave
00:33:27 because they were not allowed to board a plane in Canada
00:33:30 or to otherwise, in some cases, go into different provinces.
00:33:34 That was a provincial rule, I'll give you on that one.
00:33:37 But to get on a plane, you had to be vaccinated.
00:33:40 To get on a train, you had to be vaccinated.
00:33:43 If you wanted to work in the public service,
00:33:46 why on earth you'd want to work in the public service right now, I have no idea.
00:33:50 But if you did, you would have to get vaccinated.
00:33:52 you wanted to serve your country wearing a uniform, as perhaps you had done around the world,
00:33:57 you would lose your commission if you were not vaccinated. You'd get fired if you were not
00:34:04 vaccinated. So let's stop pretending that people in this country had a choice when the government
00:34:11 manipulated the outcomes and consequences of not making the choice it wanted you to make
00:34:18 to such a point where for some people it was untenable to continue to live without doing
00:34:24 something against their will, something they did not want to do. That is what this was. So no,
00:34:31 you did not remain able to just free of coercion, make up your own mind. People who could not afford
00:34:40 to lose their job had to do it for the sole reason of not being fired. People that would
00:34:46 have been able to afford to put food on their children's dinner plates had to get vaccinated
00:34:52 that is not a choice free of coercion so no justin drew did not protect and preserve the right to
00:35:00 make your own choice while just offering a little incentive you get a little like 50 gift card if
00:35:05 you get vaccinated no he made it so some people could not actually live their lives work visit
00:35:10 their family members visit dying family members on the other end of the country if they were not
00:35:15 vaccinated that justin trudeau is not a choice and by the way it also was not all that effective
00:35:24 he talked about this as though there was an efficacy to this program as though when he put
00:35:29 in all of these mandates and restrictions it got canadians having this really high vaccination
00:35:34 rate canada was on track to have a high vaccination rate in general and it did close to 90 percent of
00:35:40 people got the two doses before they changed the definition and made that no longer fully vaccinated
00:35:46 and the reason i bring that up is because if you look at the chart and i should have pulled it for
00:35:52 today's show i may do this tomorrow if you look at the chart on vaccine uptake in canada it actually
00:35:58 was pretty much at a flat line by the time the really restrictive mandates came into effect so
00:36:04 So that's late fall of 2021 into the winter of 2022.
00:36:08 So when we had the ban on getting on planes,
00:36:12 when we had the ban on working in the public service,
00:36:14 when we had the Freedom Convoy,
00:36:16 which came as a response to this and other aspects of it,
00:36:20 when you had the trucker mandate,
00:36:21 forgot about that one earlier,
00:36:23 vaccination uptake was actually going nowhere.
00:36:27 So these measures were not getting more people
00:36:29 to be vaccinated.
00:36:30 What these measures were doing were demonizing
00:36:33 and vilifying and punishing the unvaccinated.
00:36:37 And you see it in that very first clip we played there of him
00:36:40 at a campaign rally in Calgary,
00:36:42 which is you don't get to sit on a plane beside a vaccinated person.
00:36:47 That was Justin Trudeau's approach.
00:36:49 It had nothing to do with public safety.
00:36:51 It had nothing to do with transmission.
00:36:53 It was I don't want to see when I'm on a plane 1.00
00:36:55 some dirty, nasty, unvaccinated person beside me. 1.00
00:36:59 That was the entire intelligentsia, Laurentian elite, 0.99
00:37:02 Justin Trudeopian liberal approach. 0.95
00:37:05 It was that the unvaccinated 1.00
00:37:06 are disgusting, despicable people. 1.00
00:37:08 And that's why anyone who took a stand 0.99
00:37:10 with the Freedom Convoy 0.92
00:37:11 was a fringe, unacceptable swastika waiver
00:37:14 in Trudeau's eyes.
00:37:16 So you don't get to revise history now
00:37:18 and say that you have always protected
00:37:19 and preserved the right to make your own choices
00:37:22 because that is just a work of fiction.
00:37:25 We've got to end things there.
00:37:27 My thanks to you all.
00:37:28 And we will be back tomorrow
00:37:29 with more of Canada's most irreverent talk show
00:37:32 thank you, God bless, and good day to you all.