Juno News - April 16, 2024


Governor General shills for Liberal "online harms" regulations

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Canada’s Birth Rate is Collapsing Alberta refuses to be bribed by Trudeau

Episode Stats


Length

48 minutes

Words per minute

178.98

Word count

8,750

Sentence count

405

Harmful content

Misogyny

5

sentences flagged

Hate speech

6

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

On this episode of The Andrew Lawton Show, we hear from Joe Oliver, the former finance minister, on his predictions for today's federal budget, and Dan McTagg, a former Liberal MP who used to be the guy when he was in radio and used to find out what tomorrow's gas prices were going to be. We also hear from the Governor General of Canada, Mary Simon, about her campaign to deal with what she believes is the real menace to Canada right now: online harms.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:19 north hello and welcome to you all canada's most irreverent talk show the andrew lawton show here
00:01:29 on true north on this tuesday april 16th 2024 that's ad in case you are really confused and
00:01:36 you've been in a coma for the last well i guess for the last uh you know 2024 plus years it is
00:01:43 great to have you here on budget day i know are you so excited the federal budget's coming down
00:01:47 the pipeline and well i mean not to say a pipeline because the federal government would never use or
00:01:52 support a pipeline under its current form but a federal budget is coming out in just about three
00:01:58 and a half hours i think after the close of markets christia freeland's already gotten her 0.99
00:02:02 fancy budget day shoes which is a tradition that is rather insufferable but it's not a
00:02:08 partisan one specifically other leaders have done it so the mainstream media does their obligatory
00:02:13 write-up of christia freeland's shoes justin trudeau socks and uh maybe you know the member
00:02:17 of uh toronto center's you know bolo tie or something like that although i doubt the member
00:02:22 for toronto center wears a bolo time but nevertheless actually i don't even know who
00:02:26 the member for toronto center is right no matter what they don't wear a bolo tie all right well
00:02:31 all that is uh notwithstanding the fact that we are going to have a banger of a show today we'll
00:02:36 talk to joe oliver i to be fair already yeah no it's marcy ian is toronto center sean's told me
00:02:41 me it's Marcy Ian so Marcy Ian has worn many things I'm sure but a bolo tie I suspect is not
00:02:47 one of them although that might be a good opportunity to like go on to one of those AI
00:02:51 photo generator things and get Marcy Ian wearing a bow tie a bolo tie and actually she could well
00:02:56 she's wearing the bolo tie sing Chris Sims's voice of Alberta song which was AI generated so
00:03:01 then I can just take a take a late lunch and we can just leave the show to the bots that will soon
00:03:06 be our overlords. But anyway, off the bolo tide train, we are going to share my interview from
00:03:12 last week's Canada Strong and Free Network Conference with Joe Oliver, the former federal
00:03:17 finance minister, on his predictions and projections for today. And I also think we'll
00:03:22 check in with our good friend Dan McTagg, who is a former Liberal member of Parliament. He used to
00:03:28 be the guy when I was in radio that I'd go to to find out what tomorrow's gas prices were going to
00:03:32 be, but he has many other talents. And one of them, I think, has been very astutely observing
00:03:36 where the Liberal Party has gone since he was a member of Parliament and through its current
00:03:41 leadership, and why he is not alone if you look at the polling numbers. So we'll talk about that
00:03:46 with Dan McTagg as well. But I do want to begin by talking about this rather absurd symposium
00:03:53 that the Governor General of Canada, Mary Simon, convened to kickstart this campaign to deal with
00:04:00 what she believes is the real menace to Canada right now, online harms. Take a look.
00:04:06 I deserve better.
00:04:24 Je mérite mieux.
00:04:26 I deserve better.
00:04:28 Je mérite mieux.
00:04:31 I deserve better.
00:04:32 I deserve better.
00:04:52 Nous méritons mieux.
00:05:22 general all saying something uncontroversial which is that you know being online being harassed
00:05:28 online is not pleasant I generally speaking can't wake up without having been online harassed over
00:05:33 the night so it's good you get to check in on the harassment in the morning and sometimes you tune
00:05:37 it out other times something may be a little bit more personal I suspect and there are certainly
00:05:41 people who get a torrential amount of abuse that is far worse than what I get and it's terrible I
00:05:46 think we need to have a return to civility in the world but but but here's the problem with a message
00:05:52 like this is that the idea of taking aim at online harm which is what this is doing is an inherently
00:05:58 political one when you have a federal government that is pushing a bill forward called the online
00:06:04 harms act the federal government is using all the things that the people in that video would share
00:06:09 as a pretext for regulating and legislating what you can say and do on the internet now the governor
00:06:16 general is meant to be apolitical she's meant to be above partisanship she is the representative of
00:06:22 King Charles III in Canada. She is meant to, of course, sign off on legislation, but she is not
00:06:28 a legislator. She is a politician. That's the, well, she, I mean, she is now. She's not a
00:06:35 politician though. And that's the problem that we have here is that we have the governor general
00:06:39 stepping way, way, way outside her lane and being an advocate on something that his majesty's
00:06:45 government is now articulating as a political strategy. Now, the federal government, of course,
00:06:52 was all too happy to jump up on this. Arif Farhani, who's the justice minister, he's the guy who is
00:06:58 leading the charge on Bill C-63, which is the Online Arms Act. He was at the Governor General's
00:07:03 Symposium the other day. This was the tweet he shared. We know that online harms have real world
00:07:09 consequences and now is the critical moment to make the digital world a safe space. With industry
00:07:15 experts at the governor general symposium we discussed this and our online harms act to create
00:07:21 a safe experience for everyone so all of a sudden the governor general's symposium the non-partisan
00:07:28 apolitical governor general's symposium has been a campaign opportunity for the liberal government to
00:07:35 push its online harms bill but put that tweet up there by the way uh sean the one we just had from
00:07:39 irif rani i like that the one he wants to leave the charge with him is teresa tam so uh public
00:07:46 i mean online harm is now a public safety threat or a public health threat so irif rani and teresa
00:07:51 tam and the governor general are all in lockstep on the fact that we can't be trusted to just have
00:07:57 our own online discourse now i'm not defending harassment here i will say though that sharing
00:08:03 things online is a byproduct of free speech. It's, I would argue, a necessary byproduct of free
00:08:10 speech, which is why all of these social media platforms bake into them tools that you can use
00:08:15 to curate your experience. There are lots of people that have no issue using that block button
00:08:20 liberally. You look at someone block, block, like I've been blocked by people that I've never
00:08:24 interacted with because they just didn't want maybe one day for me to tweet at them, which I
00:08:30 I mean, Jan Arden has blocked me on Twitter, which is terrible, because if I ever want to listen to really crappy music on Twitter, now I'm denied that right.
00:08:37 But the thing about this that is so fascinating is that anyone who agrees with what the governor general has said, anyone who agrees with the liberal legislation has no issue with it.
00:08:46 My issue is one of precedent. I wouldn't want the governor general being out there and having a symposium on how dangerous the carbon tax is, because that is the domain of elected officials.
00:08:57 That is the domain of elected representatives.
00:09:00 Now, I'm not the first person to raise this, and constitutional scholars have, one of whom
00:09:05 was Philippe Lagasse, who's not a conservative or not a partisan by any stretch.
00:09:10 He is a very, very well-regarded constitutional scholar in Canada.
00:09:14 He says, the justice minister is explicitly linking the event to a controversial piece
00:09:19 of legislation that's before parliament.
00:09:21 The governor general's allowed herself to get wrapped up in contentious political debate, 0.98
00:09:26 which he contends i would agree with it but he contends is not right and then you also have on
00:09:33 this peter menzies who we've had on the show and actually met for the first time in person last
00:09:37 week at the canada strong and free network conference he jumps into the we deserve better
00:09:41 tweet he says the governor general has dropped any pretense of non-partisanship and is using
00:09:47 her office to campaign in favor of legislation currently before parliament this is appalling
00:09:52 we certainly deserve better yes in this case we deserve better than a governor general that is
00:09:58 going to be shilling for the liberal government and not just shilling for the liberal government
00:10:01 but shilling for one of the most dangerous and damaging bills this government which has been at
00:10:07 the helm for eight years has possibly and could possibly come up with uh there was another post
00:10:12 i forget what this post is but sean has it on my list here so now i get to react to it in real time
00:10:17 What was Nillie Kaplan-Mirth there? Was Nillie at the, oh, she was. Oh no, hang on. That can't
00:10:22 be Nillie Kaplan-Mirth. I see her face. Therefore, I've never actually seen the full Nillie Kaplan-Mirth
00:10:28 face. So that actually might not be here, but she was at the physician or the panel as well as a
00:10:34 physician and a school board trustee. She says she was grateful and she was looking forward to
00:10:38 hearing about strategies for creating a safe space for us as leaders. It's always great when
00:10:44 they use safe space unironically. Well, this should actually tell you something. So you look
00:10:49 at the guest list for this symposium. You had people like Dr. Nilly Kaplan-Mirth. You had
00:10:54 Rachel Gilmore. You had Faye Johnston, who's a very, very radical activist on a lot of trans
00:11:01 issues and received a lot of government money for her work, by the way. You had people that I have
00:11:07 only ever heard championing regulation, championing legislation. I never heard, and again, I wasn't on
00:11:14 the guest list. That's way too shishi and bougie for the likes of me. But I have not heard of 0.95
00:11:19 anyone being there who was critical of this idea, who said, yes, this is an issue, but we also need
00:11:24 to protect free speech. So it was not just her wading into a political debate and her wading
00:11:30 into a political issue, but it was her doing it in an incredibly one-sided way. And to appropriate
00:11:36 Peter Menzies' response to the Governor General, yes, indeed, we do deserve better. And again,
00:11:41 just imagine if the governor general decided to have a symposium on the budget. Like I said,
00:11:46 I wouldn't want her coming out and saying that we need to ax the tax and here are all the people
00:11:50 that are going to talk about cost of living and affordability. I mean, the governor general should
00:11:55 take on issues, sure. But it should kind of be like the first lady in the United States where 0.99
00:12:00 you are the first gentleman, theoretically, where you take on issues that are uncontroversial. I
00:12:06 mean, you can take on childhood obesity, you can take on literacy, you can take on drugs. But even
00:12:10 then, you don't take those on when you are a non-partisan figure. I mean, if she were to take
00:12:16 on the issue of childhood fitness, for example, which is a great issue, you don't do it when the
00:12:22 government is putting forward legislation on that. That's where you need to make sure that you are not
00:12:26 leading or playing a supporting caste role to what should be squarely in the political realm. And by
00:12:33 the way, on the case of C63, should be squarely and resoundingly chucked out of the political realm
00:12:39 because it's such a terrible piece of legislation.
00:12:42 But it is budget day today,
00:12:43 so let's have a little chat about what we can expect.
00:12:46 Obviously, we'll have more in the way of a debrief tomorrow
00:12:48 once we learn what is in the budget,
00:12:50 but certainly we can pay some attention
00:12:52 to what we expect to be in it
00:12:54 and what we hope is in it
00:12:55 and what we fear might be in it here.
00:12:58 I want to welcome to the show Ryan Mallow,
00:13:00 who is the Vice President of Legislative Affairs
00:13:03 for the Canadian Federation of Independent Business.
00:13:05 Ryan, good to talk to you.
00:13:06 Thanks for coming on today.
00:13:07 Good afternoon. Thanks for having me.
00:13:10 So from a business perspective, going into this budget, I mean, really going into any budget, but this year in particular, what is it you're looking for?
00:13:17 So I think much like people are looking for things around affordability, the cost of living, small business owners across Canada are looking for measures that reduce the cost of doing business.
00:13:28 We've been getting absolutely slammed from all sides over the last number of years.
00:13:33 anything that's going to reduce the cost be that around things like the small business tax rate
00:13:37 things like lowering payroll taxes paying very close attention to what happens on the carbon tax
00:13:42 and whether or not small businesses are going to get their money back that they're owed those
00:13:47 will be the key measures that we're looking out for in addition to what the government's spending
00:13:51 plans are you know one of the things the government has said is that there's not going to be a tax
00:13:56 increase on the middle class but as we know that's a term that's very difficult to define
00:14:00 And to bring it around to small business owners, we've heard in the government in the past, the government use small business owners as an example of the wealthy and governor and really not looking at small businesses as being, you know, really the backbone of middle class employment for people.
00:14:15 So are you concerned about that, that there could be something that, you know, on paper looks like, yes, we're going after the wealthy, but to a small business owner is actually just a pretty big slap in the face from the government.
00:14:27 Yeah, I think our ears always perk up when we hear language like that, because it's one thing to have an intention to go after a certain group. It's quite another thing to see how it actually plays out. And we have seen this play out before, specifically around the small business tax rate and questions around who had access to it.
00:14:44 And what the government had planned to do at the time was fiercely opposed by the small business community because it was really, you know, kind of railroading your general convenience store owner, your dry cleaner, not who the government said they were going after.
00:14:59 So while, you know, the intention may be good, it always comes down to the practicality of how it's implemented.
00:15:05 And that's something that we'll be watching for very closely.
00:15:08 In general, I mean, from an organizational perspective, has the government engaged with
00:15:12 your group in a meaningful way as this budget was put together?
00:15:15 Yeah, we've had some very good back and forth with finance, in particular around, again,
00:15:19 the carbon tax revenue, the $2.5 billion that small businesses in Alberta, Saskatchewan,
00:15:24 Manitoba, and Ontario are all owed. Of course, we've also been engaging with all of the opposition
00:15:30 parties, the conservatives, the NDP, the Block and Greens as well, to really make sure that
00:15:35 the the small business views and desires are heard of course it's really a question of how
00:15:40 that's going to translate on game day we'll find out at four o'clock i think we've got
00:15:44 some optimism on some measures but there is still a lot out there that worries us
00:15:49 not insignificantly what the size of the deficit is going to be and is there actually going to be
00:15:53 a plan to balance something that's been missing the last couple of budgets yeah and let's talk
00:15:57 about that briefly because you know we had this period of general you know economic goodness for
00:16:04 for lack of a better term, when the Liberal government first came in. And there's always
00:16:07 the battling about whether the Conservatives were the ones that, you know, gave it to them or whether
00:16:11 they did it. That's always the fight in politics. But, you know, at the time, the government was
00:16:14 saying, well, things are good right now, we can afford to spend. And then when things weren't as
00:16:18 good, they say, well, now we need to spend because things aren't great. And I'm thinking, well, hang
00:16:21 on, when's the time you don't spend if you spend in good times and spend in bad times? But here we
00:16:26 are with massive deficits and really not what we've seen so far in previous budgets, a realistic
00:16:31 plan to get to balance. Yeah. And that is a serious concern for small business owners across
00:16:38 the country. I mean, any small business owner will tell you that balancing their own books is
00:16:41 something that occupies a lot of brain space throughout the course of the year. But when
00:16:45 governments run deficits, it tends to turn into taxes. It tends to turn into the conversations
00:16:50 that we've seen leading up to this budget about new revenue sources and what that's going to look
00:16:55 like. And unfortunately for small business owners, they often find themselves on the wrong end of
00:17:00 those conversations and those policies. So having a clear plan to get back to balance, a clear
00:17:05 pathway and something that's realistic is something we very much want to see. Whether or not we do,
00:17:10 we're a few hours out from finding out, but something that we are, again, watching very
00:17:14 closely. I know I've spoken to your colleague, Dan Kelly, in the past. And one of the things that
00:17:19 came up in the last few years is just how many businesses did not come out from this end of the
00:17:23 pandemic. It was a very disruptive time. And some of this was a consequence of government relations.
00:17:29 Other was, you know, inflation and interest rates and all of these things.
00:17:32 And some businesses, you know, probably under normal circumstances might not have survived
00:17:36 as well.
00:17:37 But when we talk about where we are now, are there businesses that are still very much
00:17:42 in a recovery mode where, you know, they're kicking, but they still haven't fully gotten
00:17:47 back to pre-pandemic operations?
00:17:50 Absolutely.
00:17:51 In fact, I would venture to say that most businesses find themselves in that circumstance.
00:17:55 I mean, for a lot of businesses, you look at the downtown cores across the country,
00:17:58 the reality is very different between 2019 and 2024. Work patterns are different. We've seen
00:18:04 hybrid work take hold. If you are a dry cleaner or a lunch spot that depended on a nine to five 0.85
00:18:10 rush, you're not necessarily seeing that anymore. And there still is a transition going on in terms
00:18:15 of what the new business model looks like coming out of that. We are also concerningly seeing a
00:18:20 lot more businesses exit the space than we are seeing come in. And part of that is interest
00:18:24 rates but it's also just the the appetite for risk that business owners need to have to jump in
00:18:30 is a lot lower right now as well so again looking at how we reinforce some of the the small business
00:18:36 confidence that we just have not seen in the last four years i think the budget plays an important
00:18:41 role in that but also ensuring that again the the financing options the stability um coming out of
00:18:47 the budget is there for small business owners moving forward i i obviously on this show focus
00:18:52 lot on the politics but you know for businesses they have to take along regardless of who's in
00:18:56 power here so at the end of the day though i was wondering what i could ask you or if i could ask
00:19:01 you here what could the government do that would at least signal a possible return of confidence
00:19:07 or possibly trigger that what what could you hear today if anything that would make people that are
00:19:12 really not feeling like this is the climate to invest in to actually be comfortable doing so
00:19:16 so i i think there's a couple pieces there one the 2.5 billion dollars owed on the carbon tax
00:19:22 This is money that's already been collected. We want to see a plan for that to come back,
00:19:25 and not just a commitment, but a plan to return that money to small business owners.
00:19:30 We'd also like to see a plan for what is the plan for the carbon tax moving forward.
00:19:35 They are continuing to collect money. There's been conversations about what's already been
00:19:39 collected, less about what's happening with dollars moving forward. And again,
00:19:42 some certainty around that would be important. Also, in acknowledging that the cost of doing
00:19:46 business has gone up, what is the government doing to lower taxes overall? Are we going to
00:19:50 going to see any movement on the small business tax rate? Are we going to see any movement on
00:19:53 payroll taxes? CPP and EI are both up this year. Is there going to be any kind of relief on that?
00:19:58 And then I think finally, is the government signaling that they're getting their own house
00:20:02 in order? Is there a plan for the deficit? Is there a plan that business owners can be confident
00:20:08 that is stable moving forward is also going to be, I think, a pretty significant tell.
00:20:12 All right. Well, we'll certainly keep an eye peeled for that. My thanks to Ryan Mallow for
00:20:17 coming on from the Canadian Federation of Independent Business. Thank you, Ryan.
00:20:20 Anytime.
00:20:21 All right. Well, thank you for that. And it wouldn't be a budget day without hearing. I mean,
00:20:26 you get two options. We can hear from Chrystia Freeland, that's an option, or we could hear from
00:20:29 a former finance minister who I find has a much more solid head on his shoulders as it comes to
00:20:34 economics. And by the way, that great economic period of prosperity the Liberal government
00:20:39 inherited in 2015 came on the heels of my next guest in the term in Ottawa, who I had the chance
00:20:46 to catch up with last week at the Canada Strong and Free Network Conference.
00:20:52 Well, anyone who's been following the descent of Canada's economic situation
00:20:57 over the last eight years or so has no doubt missed the glory days
00:21:01 of Canada's economy when we had the gentleman who's sitting next to me
00:21:05 at the helm, former Finance Minister Joe Oliver,
00:21:07 who's also become a tremendous financial post-columnist on occasion,
00:21:11 a national post-columnist in his post-political life.
00:21:14 Joe, it's good to have you back on the show. Thank you.
00:21:16 Great to be on the show with you.
00:21:17 I can just get you talking to your mic there.
00:21:18 There we go.
00:21:19 There we go.
00:21:20 This isn't my first rodeo, so I should know.
00:21:23 He's going to say what he has in financial acumen, he lacks in audio-visual capabilities.
00:21:27 But we'll make it work here.
00:21:29 Okay.
00:21:29 Let's just talk in general about the forecasting here, because this is a forward-looking event,
00:21:33 a lot of optimism about the possibility of replacing Justin Trudeau's government.
00:21:38 If you were a finance minister coming into this, how would you even begin?
00:21:43 Because the Conservatives under Pierre Polyev have talked about balancing budgets, lowering government spending,
00:21:48 but it takes a lot of time to correct the problem before you can do what you want, I would imagine.
00:21:54 Yes, well, it does, and that's why you can't say we're going to balance the budget next year.
00:21:58 That would be draconian and unjustified.
00:22:03 However, you have to set a target, a realistic target.
00:22:07 Hopefully, it would be in the first term of government, you know, let's say within four years.
00:22:12 But I haven't, you know, delved into all the numbers, some of which are not necessarily fully disclosed, shall we say.
00:22:21 But you have to have a target, a realistic target, and start moving to it, towards it.
00:22:26 What you have to do is stop the profligate spending.
00:22:30 That's absolutely crucial.
00:22:32 And then focus on issues which will enhance productivity, because that's been a disaster for Canada.
00:22:40 basically GDP per capita, which measures personal prosperity,
00:22:45 has been essentially flack for what, during the whole Trudeau government.
00:22:51 And that's what people, of course, feel.
00:22:53 They feel the higher prices and the fact that they're not keeping up
00:22:55 in terms of their personal salaries.
00:22:59 And, you know, the OECD has projected that Canada will be the worst
00:23:03 among the 38 wealthy countries in the world over the next 20 years and then 40 years.
00:23:07 So we have to do something about that.
00:23:09 And there are a variety of ways to do it.
00:23:11 I'd say one critical element is start developing our national resources and start exporting them to overseas markets,
00:23:20 which not only will create an enormous amount of revenue, employ people, increase national security, and also help our allies.
00:23:29 Then we have to look at the tax system to make sure it's efficient, that it isn't excessive,
00:23:34 that it encourages entrepreneurship and allows an affordable life for Canadians.
00:23:43 Focus on issues of science and technology to increase productivity that way.
00:23:50 But we've got to get more capital coming into the country.
00:23:54 We have a capital flight problem, the precise opposite of what we want.
00:23:59 It's not that the Canadian workers are lazy or incompetent, quite to the contrary, but
00:24:05 if so little money is being spent to enhance technology and they're having to work harder
00:24:14 than the Americans are and therefore they're less productive. 1.00
00:24:18 Not because, as I say, they work less hard but because they just don't have the materials
00:24:23 to work with which would make them more efficient.
00:24:26 So one of the challenges, and we saw this especially during the Conservative leadership race,
00:24:31 Pierre Poliev put a fair bit of the blame for inflation on the Bank of Canada and its money printing.
00:24:37 And I know that there was a lot of bristling from the Laurentian elites about this.
00:24:41 And at the same time, if I look back to the Harper government when you were finance minister
00:24:45 and even when your predecessor, Jim Flaherty, was,
00:24:48 I don't recall really any public acrimony between the government and the bank.
00:24:52 And I was wanting to get your thoughts on is that appropriate,
00:24:55 the criticism that was directed there, and what are the implications of that?
00:24:59 How much blame does that institution actually have for what's happened?
00:25:03 Well, we respected the independence of the monetary authority of the Bank of Canada,
00:25:13 but on the other hand, we weren't fighting.
00:25:16 Fiscal policy wasn't fighting monetary policy, and vice versa.
00:25:20 So we were trying to, you know, we're moving in the same direction.
00:25:26 Now we have fiscal policy, which has thrown a huge burden on the Bank of Canada,
00:25:34 which can't shoulder it all on its own.
00:25:36 And, of course, you hear from the governor and the deputy governors about, you know,
00:25:41 now's the time to break the glass because we've got a productivity problem.
00:25:46 We have a debt problem.
00:25:47 And the bank will independently decide based on data when it's time to start reducing rates.
00:25:56 They'll be looking at the inflation numbers.
00:25:58 I suspect they're going to start reducing rates, you know, fairly soon, maybe even within a couple of months.
00:26:09 But, you know, there are implications to that.
00:26:12 there's affordability but there's also the impact on the dollar if the if the
00:26:17 Fed doesn't produce rates as well so it's it's quite complex you know the
00:26:23 Prime Minister doesn't doesn't spend much time apparently thinking about
00:26:27 monetary policy and we know what he's done with fiscal policy so yes it's a
00:26:31 grand zero so far but you know I'm not going to give advice to the to the
00:26:39 monetary authority, but I think the government keeps its distance, but ultimately it's responsible.
00:26:49 So explain to me where a lot of this is going, because I remember when the Bank of Canada said
00:26:54 inflation was going to be transitory, and then we learned it was something that would get quite
00:26:58 severe, and even if it's cooled a little bit, it's still affecting people, and then you have fiscal
00:27:02 policy that is exacerbating affordability problems, such as carbon taxes and so on.
00:27:07 But if we look forward, and I wouldn't say that this has been an entire elephant in the room.
00:27:13 Some people have talked about it.
00:27:14 Canadians who have to renew their mortgages within the next one, two, three years are in for a rude awakening.
00:27:19 And I wonder where this goes.
00:27:21 Well, let me just refer back to Pierre Polyev's frustration, I guess, with monetary policy.
00:27:29 And it goes back to a hearing in the House when he was questioning the governor,
00:27:38 and he said he felt, Pierre felt, that we've got an inflation problem that's there and growing.
00:27:47 And, you know, the governor said, well, it's transitory.
00:27:52 It turned out Pierre was right, and the governor was wrong, and the governor admitted he was wrong.
00:27:56 So it was frustrating for Pierre, who wanted the bank to move in the interest of the economy and everyday citizens.
00:28:09 Well, I think, you know, data has sort of moved the bank, and now you're mentioning some of the critical affordability issues.
00:28:19 I mean, we know housing is really in crisis at this moment, and a dream has been quashed for people wanting to buy their first home.
00:28:28 And there's a lot of fear in the air because some of these mortgages are coming due.
00:28:33 I think, you know, there's going to be a lot of, I guess, political push on the bank to move, but it will move when it thinks it's appropriate.
00:28:43 But I think it will move this year, and I think things will start to get a bit better on the interest rate side.
00:28:50 I wanted to move to a very different issue, but one that I know is near and dear to your heart, which is Israel.
00:28:55 And I think in general, the threats facing the Jewish community in this country, of which you're a member.
00:29:00 And I wanted to ask about whether you saw what's happening coming before.
00:29:05 Because I think anti-Semitism, as many people have said, has not emerged.
00:29:10 It's been exposed.
00:29:11 I think it's always been there and people are being a lot more brazen with it.
00:29:15 But we've now seen the targeting of Jewish businesses, of Jewish neighbourhoods.
00:29:19 It's not just, you know, protesting at the Israeli consulate or embassy,
00:29:22 which I'd say is a legitimate place to protest.
00:29:24 It's protesting Jewish people. 0.99
00:29:26 And is this something that you foresaw in this country?
00:29:31 Well, I knew it was always a potential.
00:29:34 And I just want to say that here at this conference at the Canada Strong and Free,
00:29:38 I've been very heartened, but not in the least surprised, by the terrific support for Israel and for the Jewish people
00:29:46 and the remarks that our leader, Pierre Polly, have made about the Jewish community in Canada
00:29:52 and how he stands with, and we all stand, with all our friends and neighbours.
00:29:59 So, you know, this isn't all a dark story, but, you know, anti-Semitism has been a constant for thousands of years.
00:30:12 You can analyze why and what the rationale or rationalizations are for it, but it always seems to be there lurking.
00:30:22 And what is perhaps new is that it's no longer just a phenomenon of the far right.
00:30:27 In fact, it's less of a problem in the far right because they've been so marginalized.
00:30:32 They're not less hateful, I'm not suggesting that, but they're not as big a threat.
00:30:39 Unfortunately, in the left, the new postmodernism, intersectionality, critical race theory,
00:30:48 the assignment of people to two categories of oppressed and oppressors,
00:30:52 has worked against the Jewish community, which maybe wasn't viewed as an exemplar of whiteness,
00:31:01 is now, you know, we're all together in this, Andrew.
00:31:06 And so Israel is being judged in that context.
00:31:11 And it's been an opportunity, frankly, for some of this ugliness to come out of the sewer
00:31:20 and onto the streets of this country.
00:31:23 And that's worrying and, you know, a blight, frankly.
00:31:30 And I would take what you've said there and add to it
00:31:33 by pointing out that this exists in the far right.
00:31:36 It exists in the mainstream left.
00:31:38 And this is the challenge, is that you don't actually need to go
00:31:41 to the fringes of the left to find a lot of this venom against Jews.
00:31:46 And that has been...
00:31:48 No, you find it in the universities.
00:31:49 Yes. Well, you'll find it in caucus. I mean, you'll find it in the NDP caucus and to some extent in the Liberal caucus as well.
00:31:56 It's, you know, it's a deep concern and I think, you know, we hope that our friends and neighbours will see it as not only a threat to a community, a minority community, 1.00
00:32:09 but really a threat to Canadian values, an assault on Canadian values,
00:32:15 and a threat to the type of country we want to see Canada continue to be.
00:32:23 Joe Oliver, always a pleasure, sir.
00:32:25 Great to talk to you. Thank you.
00:32:29 That was former Finance Minister Joe Oliver on budgets, finance, and of course on anti-Semitism,
00:32:36 which was not the issue he tackled as finance minister, but certainly has been one on which
00:32:40 he's been very opinionated. And I think rightfully so, given what he's seen happen in his country and
00:32:45 his own city. And he's a Torontonian. And one thing that I find interesting here, just to go
00:32:51 back to the budget side of this, is that, I mean, he was a finance minister for a relatively short
00:32:55 period of time. But, you know, everyone wants to say that, oh, the circumstances have to be just
00:33:00 so they have to be just right if you want to balance your budget. And the conservatives in
00:33:04 2019 under Andrew Scheer. I don't believe they did it in 2021 under O'Toole. They had put in their
00:33:10 platform a law, a balanced budget law, basically a law saying that the conservative government or
00:33:16 any other government would have to balance the budget. Now, part of this is, I'd say, a little
00:33:21 bit superficial in the sense that a government can change a law. So a future government could
00:33:26 just amend the law to say every budget has to be balanced except for this one if it really wanted
00:33:31 to. But even so, it would have to sell that to Canadians. It would have to say that this spending
00:33:35 is so important, we are going to break this law. And I don't think any government spending is
00:33:41 really going to be that important. Now, I've talked about this with Conservative leader Pierre
00:33:45 Polly. I've asked him, look, how quickly are you going to get to balance? And he's not able to give
00:33:50 an answer. And I'm sympathetic to that in part because he's not there yet. So he doesn't know
00:33:54 what he's going to inherit. But at the same time, it also makes it hugely challenging for any new
00:34:00 party to take over any new government to take over and look at i mean again it's like someone
00:34:05 just racking up you know some bazillion dollars of debt on a credit card then handing you the
00:34:10 credit card and saying okay pay it off sure you can be as fiscally prudent as you want and as you
00:34:16 can be but you still are starting from a pretty dismal place and that's what canada is going to
00:34:22 look like for the foreseeable future i fear and again we'll see just how bad things are now but
00:34:27 But the government, remember, is in campaign mode.
00:34:29 So they're going to do all of these things that make it easier for people that are in the designated voting blocs.
00:34:35 And everyone else in the country will have to foot the bill for it.
00:34:39 Pierre Polyev did weigh in on this this morning.
00:34:41 He had a press conference in front of West Block with his, I think it was pretty much the entire caucus behind him.
00:34:46 And he had some choice words for Dustin Trudeau.
00:34:53 Oh, do we not have that?
00:34:57 I thought we had that. Sean says, shoot. I don't know if that means shoot. We don't have it or
00:35:03 shoot. It's late. Oh, we don't have it. Okay. Well, nevermind. Just, uh, you had to, you had
00:35:07 to be there, I guess, but, uh, nevertheless, I do have another interview from last week's
00:35:11 conference. I wanted to share with you the Canada strong and free network conference was
00:35:16 a great time. You saw lots of people from the conservative movement, but some unlikely people
00:35:21 there when you look around and see a former liberal member of parliament. Now, uh, Dan
00:35:26 mctagg is a guy who has been a fairly vocal critic of the liberals in recent years but he
00:35:33 was in their ranks for quite some time this was my chat with him
00:35:37 well we've talked a lot about the changing tides in politics people can become unlikely allies and
00:35:45 unlikely enemies but one of the most stalwart opponents of some of the very damaging and
00:35:52 economically harmful environmental policies we've seen in recent years has been from a former
00:35:57 Liberal member of Parliament, Dan McTagg. Now, I don't want to be reductivist. He's got a long
00:36:01 and storied career outside of his time in Parliament as a Liberal MP. He was like always
00:36:06 the go-to guy when I was in talk radio on gas prices, and now he's the President of Canadians
00:36:10 for Affordable Energy and joins us now. Dan, good to talk to you in the flesh. Thanks for
00:36:14 sitting down today. Finally good to be here and after such a long time, Andrew. Yeah, you know,
00:36:18 There are some people that haven't followed your post-political work
00:36:21 would be surprised when they look at you on Twitter and be like,
00:36:24 former Liberal MP says what?
00:36:26 But you've been such an incredible critic of a lot of this government's
00:36:30 environmental and economic policies.
00:36:32 And I wanted to ask you more broadly how you and the Liberal Party diverge so much.
00:36:37 Well, I think the Liberal Party diverges from where the Liberal Party was.
00:36:41 Members like myself who had the consumer file, the consular file,
00:36:44 people who were always concerned about bread and butter issues
00:36:47 being able to make ends meet, recognizing that the country is a very diverse nation,
00:36:52 not just physically, not just culturally, but in terms of its economy.
00:36:57 Manufacturing, mining, forestry, agriculture, and energy.
00:37:01 And all those things combined have been really at the core of why we're a wealthy nation.
00:37:05 We have in this government, particularly under Justin Trudeau,
00:37:09 a deviation from a significant one to the point where these things are being excluded,
00:37:12 ignored, in some cases reviled, and it's having an impact on the bottom line for every Canadian.
00:37:18 Is your experience, it's unique to you obviously given that you were an MP, but is your experience
00:37:24 something you've seen reflected in other people you've spoken to where they've gone through a
00:37:27 very similar trajectory to you on these issues or even other ones? A lot of them have simply moved
00:37:32 on. When I was elected I was 31 years of age, 30, 31, I can't remember the time, young guy, just
00:37:37 married a wonderful wife and uh i was the youngest of the uh of the of the group the average age was
00:37:42 55 many of those members of parliament are since deceased moved on or very much in their age so
00:37:47 it's hard for me to calibrate with others yeah that's fair there's no doubt that being in power
00:37:51 has made a lot of people believe hey i just want i'm a liberal i'm always a liberal i'll remain
00:37:55 that way i have never been a member of any other party but uh this is no longer the party that i've
00:37:59 served since 1978 explain to me what they're getting so wrong because it's one thing to say
00:38:05 I don't like the carbon tax because it's going to make things more expensive.
00:38:07 You're actually an expert in this space.
00:38:09 I mean, you know fuel prices better than anyone else,
00:38:11 and you also, by extension, know a lot of the policies
00:38:14 and drivers around those things better than most.
00:38:16 Party used to have something called pragmatism.
00:38:18 It's really the way in which it survived
00:38:20 and became the big tent party that attracted so many,
00:38:23 on the right, on the left, depending on the region of the country,
00:38:26 different languages, different cultures, different backgrounds, agnostics,
00:38:29 whatever the case may be, there was always a place for you in the party,
00:38:32 and you could express those.
00:38:34 You could articulate those.
00:38:35 You could actually make changes, private members' bills.
00:38:38 That's been lost, and it's become very conformist.
00:38:40 It's become very uniform.
00:38:42 It's very rigid, and it's all really under the cult of personality of one individual.
00:38:46 So whatever Justin Trudeau, and the name's important because, of course,
00:38:49 that's why a lot of Canadians put them back in power in 2015,
00:38:53 but they don't represent, I think, the common person as we're currently seeing today,
00:38:58 and a lot of people feel estranged not just from the political process
00:39:01 but this government in particular.
00:39:02 I think it's a dangerous sign, by the way, because as I see this, without any, I have not a member of the party,
00:39:09 I see the Conservatives moving further to the centre, picking up those votes, and they're basically legion.
00:39:14 That's why they will win the next election.
00:39:15 If you were Environment Minister right now, or you were Resource Minister, pick one of those ones that has control over this file.
00:39:22 What would be that vision that you would present, where you get to tackle all of these things that the government says are a problem and a priority,
00:39:28 but in a way that doesn't damage and harm consumers and industries?
00:39:31 I would listen to those consumers first.
00:39:33 I go to Quebec and realize that most people in Quebec support pipelines,
00:39:36 not as the elites are saying.
00:39:37 I would ignore the elites.
00:39:38 The top 20% who have a lot of money and don't care what this is going to cost them
00:39:41 have ignored the bottom 80%.
00:39:43 That's where the middle class was. 0.99
00:39:45 I want to do something tomorrow night, I'd say build a pipeline east, build a pipeline west.
00:39:48 I don't say that because I like the industry.
00:39:50 They don't like me, and I don't like them.
00:39:52 And I've been predicting gas prices.
00:39:53 It's caused them tens of millions of dollars in lost revenue.
00:39:55 By predicting gas prices, by the way, it's going to be up 10 cents a litre between now and next week.
00:39:59 It's already started in Atlanta, Canada.
00:40:00 A number of reasons for that.
00:40:01 You heard it here first, folks.
00:40:02 That's right.
00:40:03 So if you're paying $1.64 in Toronto today, you'll be paying $1.74 next week, Andrew.
00:40:08 The reality is that energy is extremely important.
00:40:10 It permeates our entire life.
00:40:12 To ignore it, to trivialize it, or to create a narrative that says we can get rid of it is insane.
00:40:18 At the end of the day, Canada, I think, increasingly is going to start to get back to those pragmatic ways
00:40:23 and say energy is our future.
00:40:24 We want to maintain our standard of living.
00:40:26 We better reinvest in it and do the things right,
00:40:28 which the rest of the world is knocking on our door and asking for.
00:40:31 And I think what's interesting about that is that oftentimes you hear a debate,
00:40:35 even among conservative politicians, about the value of a consumer carbon price
00:40:39 versus something that's more targeted at industry.
00:40:41 Now, I've always taken the view that that's a bit deceptive,
00:40:43 because no matter what, that's getting trickled down.
00:40:45 A company is not saying, all right, well, we're paying it, therefore it won't be passed down.
00:40:49 The only thing that changes is you don't have the line item on the receipt.
00:40:52 And in that sense, I guess a consumer carbon tax is somewhat more transparent.
00:40:56 Is your view that the mechanism itself is flawed or that there's a better way to do it?
00:40:59 Well, I think what we want, the aspirational goals are important,
00:41:03 but we've done too much aspiration.
00:41:05 We haven't done reality.
00:41:06 And if we want to achieve those things through technology,
00:41:10 then let's by all means do that.
00:41:11 By the way, while we're doing that,
00:41:13 take inventory of the great things that we've done in this country.
00:41:15 As I said, I'm not here to rah-rah for the oil industry,
00:41:17 but Canadians have this tendency of saying,
00:41:19 ah, shucks, we're not great, we have to do more.
00:41:22 Let's do that practically when these things become available.
00:41:25 And it's nice to say no taxes, let's emphasize tech.
00:41:28 We can do that, but let's ensure that we have and respect the laws of physics and thermodynamics.
00:41:34 In all of these things that we want to accomplish, I think we have to be realistic.
00:41:37 The world wants more energy.
00:41:39 They specifically want more Canadian energy.
00:41:42 And as a result of creating another $150, $200 billion in economic activity,
00:41:47 I can create more hospitals in this country.
00:41:49 The Liberals of my time always said we are going to take the measures
00:41:52 of ensuring that we build pipelines, that we get our financial house in order
00:41:56 so we maintain the standard of living that Canadians come to expect.
00:42:00 Unfortunately, this group of Liberals has simply lost their way here
00:42:02 and decided that those are no longer values worth holding.
00:42:05 I believe the rest of the world is finally saying,
00:42:07 as the Europeans are saying today, put a pause on this stuff.
00:42:09 And that's such a crucial point.
00:42:11 And I was speaking about this with Tony Abbott from Australia earlier.
00:42:14 And one of the things that he brought up is that
00:42:15 there are lots of people that say they care about this,
00:42:18 but when push comes to shove and you ask how much they're willing to pay for it,
00:42:21 it's amazing how little they really do
00:42:23 and how a lot of these policies are really luxury items for the elites.
00:42:28 And I think that's a point that's missing in Canada.
00:42:30 I mean, when a lot of these measures are put forward,
00:42:32 it's really saying that things like driving,
00:42:34 which if you live in rural Alberta, rural Ontario,
00:42:37 saying that's discretionary, when for a lot of people it isn't.
00:42:40 No.
00:42:40 Look, carbon taxes are the low-hanging fruit.
00:42:43 But when you start talking about clean fuel standards,
00:42:45 which is not going to be rebated,
00:42:47 which a lot of people don't know about,
00:42:48 which industry is saying, yeah, we'll go along with it,
00:42:50 comfortable in the knowledge they can pass it on
00:42:53 to consumers. Same thing for
00:42:55 all of these other mandates. We want to pursue
00:42:57 them, but I think we need to take a bit of a step back.
00:42:59 Jean-Claude Sainz used to always say, I want to
00:43:01 look before I jump in the pool, make sure there's
00:43:03 water in there. And he was right.
00:43:04 I think what we've wanted to do is
00:43:06 well-intentioned. And that's where Canadians are. They want to be the right
00:43:09 thing, but they also don't want to do it
00:43:11 in a way that's damaging their prosperity
00:43:13 and their future. And as a result,
00:43:15 turning a lot of people away from the very goals
00:43:17 that the environmental movement wants us to
00:43:19 be towards. There is a compromise. It's the Canadian way, but we've become so uniquely
00:43:24 focused on damaging one industry, manufacturing, oil and gas, mining, forestry, that we've done
00:43:31 ourselves a significant economic and social disservice. Dan McTagg, thank you. It's always
00:43:36 a pleasure. Thanks, Andrew. That was Dan McTagg. I think it was the old Reagan line that he
00:43:45 appropriated there i didn't leave the liberal party the liberal party left me but again if you
00:43:50 look at the poll numbers a lot more people in that boat not necessarily all members of parliament but
00:43:54 certainly people who have been lifelong liberal supporters supporters of the ndp uh perhaps non
00:43:59 voters uh that are all coming back i sean says people want to see the polyev clip so he's uh
00:44:05 he's done what the people want and has uh produced this paul i don't know if everyone wants it some
00:44:10 people are for it some people are against it but i'm for the people so let's uh roll that clip now
00:44:15 That's what Paliyev said this morning in front of West Block.
00:44:18 So my message to Justin Trudeau is this.
00:44:22 In one word, stop.
00:44:27 Stop doubling housing costs.
00:44:30 Stop taxing our farmers and food when our single moms and seniors are going hungry.
00:44:37 stop the inflationary deficits that are driving up interest rates and forcing Canadians to lose
00:44:45 their homes stop endangering our social programs and jobs by adding more and more debt for the love
00:44:56 of God Justin Trudeau you are not worth the cost so today will you please stop stop until common
00:45:06 sense conservatives can start governing with common sense for this country
00:45:14 that was pierre polyev his message to justin trudeau is to just stop now i would like to
00:45:21 think that i know a little bit about conservative leader pierre polyev having written a book about
00:45:25 him which is coming out in just a few weeks time but i suspect from his background he is well aware
00:45:31 of William F. Buckley, who was the conservative intellectual in the U.S., the founder of the
00:45:37 National Review. And he had a fantastic quote that I'll share to you today. A conservative
00:45:42 is someone who stands athwart history yelling stop at a time when no one is inclined to do so
00:45:49 or to have much patience with those who so urge it. So standing athwart history and yelling stop
00:45:56 is what conservatives need to do. Pierre Paulyev is saying to the federal government right now,
00:46:00 stop, stop, stop, stop spending, stop doing this. That is, again, I didn't come across in my studies
00:46:06 for the book, whether he was specifically a student of Buckley, but given other people he
00:46:10 did study, it wouldn't have surprised me. So I certainly heard shades of William F. Buckley Jr.
00:46:16 in that little clip we shared there. So glad we got that in. By the way, the book, Pierre Poliev,
00:46:21 A Political Life, comes out, yeah, I'm the author, Andrew Lawton, I'm not Pierre Poliev,
00:46:26 but it comes out on may 28th it's actually let me just check before i get your hopes up
00:46:31 i believe it's yeah amazon has it marked down which normally is a bad sign because it means
00:46:36 they're like just trying to clear out all this inventory that no one wants but the book hasn't
00:46:39 come out yet so i guess they're just marking it down because the algorithm said it was a good
00:46:43 idea but you can get that on sale if you pre-order it now for like basically 10 bucks off so it's on
00:46:50 amazon indigo is going to carry it we've got it from the publisher directly sutherland house and
00:46:54 I will be flogging it.
00:46:56 No, flogging it.
00:46:58 I think flogging is the right word. 1.00
00:46:59 I'll be pushing it nonstop
00:47:00 as the release date nears anyway.
00:47:03 So thanks to those of you
00:47:04 who have sent your kind words about that
00:47:06 and told me you have already pre-ordered it.
00:47:07 That does it for us today.
00:47:08 We'll have a breakdown of the budget
00:47:10 and some more goodies
00:47:11 from the Canada Strong and Free Network Conference tomorrow.
00:47:14 This is The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:47:15 Thank you, God bless, and good day to you all.
00:47:18 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:47:21 Support the program by donating to TrueNorth
00:47:23 at www.tnc.news.
00:47:53 We'll be right back.
00:48:23 We'll be right back.