Juno News - June 09, 2019


Hate speech should not just be speech that you hate

Topics
Mentioned
Government might shut down social media companies during election Liberals promised "evidence-based" policy, but the evidence says plastic bans don't work

Episode Stats


Length

4 minutes

Words per minute

180.78

Word count

848

Sentence count

57


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

The debate about free speech in Canada is happening again, and it's a little different than it was 10 years ago. I had a minor epiphany the other day, when I was watching Mark Stein, John Robson, and Lindsey Shepard testify before the Justice Committee.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 I had a minor little epiphany the other day. I was watching Mark Stein, John
00:00:13 Robson, and Lindsey Shepard testifying before the Justice Committee when I
00:00:17 realized it's happening again. The debate about free speech in Canada. And I don't
00:00:23 just mean the debate that we have, you know, every six months or once a year or
00:00:27 what have you, when there's somebody on campus who's giving some rather pretty
00:00:31 basic and harmless speech and a bunch of SJWs and Antifa people show up and pull
00:00:36 a fire alarm and riot and so forth. And we all say, no, people should be free to, you
00:00:40 know, say anything aside from slander and libel and death threats and etc. I don't
00:00:44 mean that. I mean the much bigger debate that we had a version of 10 years ago
00:00:49 when Mark Stein and Ezra Levant and others were before the human rights
00:00:52 tribunals. And there were judges, courts, kangaroo courts, quasi-judicial bodies,
00:00:59 politicians, parliamentarians weighing in on basically whether or not people should
00:01:04 be punished for saying things that some people don't like, that other people deem
00:01:08 hateful. It was a really interesting debate to be a part of a decade ago. To
00:01:13 watch it all unfold, there were some great people putting forward some great
00:01:17 arguments. It was a very energetic and exciting time. And the right side won. These
00:01:23 Section 13 laws, which were deemed unpopular by a lot of people, not just
00:01:27 conservative-minded people, but liberals and centrists, people really all across
00:01:32 the board who basically believed in that idea that, well, I may not believe what
00:01:37 you're having to say, I may not believe in the exact things you're saying, that I
00:01:40 will fight for your right to say it. All of those people stood up and they all
00:01:44 stood up together. Andrew Lawton and I were talking about an event that he
00:01:48 recalled being at a number of years ago, where liberal Senator Jerry Grafstein
00:01:52 stood beside Ezra Levant and others who, you know, people who are generally not of
00:01:56 the same opinion and actually standing in the same room in the same event, talking
00:02:00 about why free speech mattered. And I was a little disheartened when I had that
00:02:05 realization just the other day that it's happening again. The debate is
00:02:10 happening again. Because while it was a very vibrant time 10 years ago, and why
00:02:15 more or less the right side won, things are different now than they were 10 years
00:02:19 ago. And there's a lot of people who just view the world and these issues very
00:02:25 differently. And I don't think they're as open and as amenable to a lot of the great
00:02:30 arguments we heard 10 years ago that we are today. Trigger warnings, safe spaces,
00:02:34 microaggressions, all those sorts of things. Those didn't exist 10 years ago. I mean, they don't
00:02:40 exist now. They're all just bizarre figments. But people very, very passionately hold on
00:02:45 to them. And there are things that are out there in the activist square. That's the kind
00:02:49 of stuff that the free speech warriors will be dealing with this time around. And I'm a
00:02:54 little nervous. I'm not necessarily optimistic that things are going to prevail. We've got
00:02:59 Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, who for about a year now has really been harping on about
00:03:02 how there's this awful stuff happening on the internet, and we got to do something about
00:03:06 it and so forth. The platforms are failing their users. And they're failing our citizens.
00:03:15 They have to step up in a major way to counter disinformation. And if they don't, we will hold
00:03:23 them to account and there will be meaningful financial consequences. And you go, look, yes,
00:03:30 there are increasingly people on social media who are just saying mean things and rude things
00:03:35 and spewing their venom and so forth. Govern yourself accordingly, folks. Be polite. Be
00:03:39 well-mannered to others. You know, articulate your opinions well and so forth. Take the high
00:03:45 road rather than the low road. All that kind of stuff. But that's just up to us to be decent
00:03:49 and respectful human beings. Do we need the government? Do we need the nanny state? Do we need
00:03:54 big brother coming in and weighing all of that for us? Because ultimately that was what a lot
00:03:58 of people felt those Section 13 hate speech laws actually were. And there were people who
00:04:03 were actually involved in those human rights commissions. Commissioners who did acknowledge
00:04:07 that the net was cast too wide. This was not precisely defying terms like slander and libel
00:04:14 and so forth and, you know, death threats. This was other stuff. This was basically about
00:04:19 policing people for their speech that you decided you hated. Hate speech should not just be speech
00:04:25 that you hate. So 10 years later, here we are. The conversation is flaring up again.
00:04:31 We're gonna see the debate happen. And I think it's gonna be different than it was 10 years ago.
00:04:37 It's gonna be different in some very interesting and troubling ways.