Juno News - March 18, 2019


In conversation with leading Brexit economist Andrew Lilico

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Premier Ford's most popular announcement ever? Trudeau appoints a former Liberal MP to investigate LavScam

Episode Stats


Length

31 minutes

Words per minute

182.33

Word count

5,662

Sentence count

303

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

9

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Andrew Lillico, the lead economist for the official Leave campaign and managing director at Europe Economics, joins me to talk about the growing calls for a second referendum on leaving the EU, and the implications for democracy if there were another vote.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 I'm very pleased to be sitting down right now with Andrew Lillico, the lead economist
00:00:07 for the official Leave campaign for Brexit, also managing director at Europe Economics,
00:00:13 where we are right now.
00:00:14 Andrew, good to be with you.
00:00:15 Thanks very much for your time.
00:00:16 Good afternoon.
00:00:17 We've spoken on the radio before.
00:00:19 Very good to be doing it on your turf right now at a very critical time.
00:00:23 Let's talk about where we are right now, because I know that we've had a lot of people, certainly
00:00:28 from the Remain side of the Brexit discussion, try to force another vote.
00:00:33 And I think there seems to be this general sense among that side that if you were to do
00:00:38 this all over again, people wouldn't want the Leave to happen.
00:00:43 Do you think that's actually a valid analysis, that if you were to do this all over again,
00:00:49 the same result wouldn't emerge?
00:00:50 Well, I don't think there's any realistic chance that we're going to have a second vote.
00:00:56 And if we did have a second vote, I think that would, first of all, I mean, that would
00:01:00 be so enormously anti-democratic, it would make a huge change.
00:01:04 I think that people need to understand what's being suggested there.
00:01:08 It's a fairly sacred principle of British democracy, that when you vote for something,
00:01:14 that's the thing that happens.
00:01:15 You can vote later to do something else.
00:01:17 But imagine if we elected an MP and then somebody said, oh, I don't really like that MP.
00:01:23 So we're going to have another election.
00:01:25 But that MP doesn't sit whilst we have the other election.
00:01:28 The original MP sits.
00:01:29 What's being suggested here isn't that we, the objection isn't to we leave the EU and
00:01:34 then sometime in the future we might have a vote on rejoining.
00:01:37 That would be fine.
00:01:38 I mean, I don't think we'd probably want to do that very soon.
00:01:40 But there's no objection in principle to doing that.
00:01:43 But what's being proposed by these people is that even though we voted to leave, we
00:01:47 then shouldn't leave, but instead have another vote.
00:01:51 I think that that would have absolutely enormous ramifications for the whole way that politics
00:01:55 is done.
00:01:56 And I think there would be an enormous boycott by Leave campaigners.
00:02:00 I think it would shatter confidence in British democracy.
00:02:02 I think it would have implications for things like, suppose that a Jeremy Corbyn government
00:02:06 were elected in the future.
00:02:07 Are people saying then that the establishment would say, well, we don't like Jeremy Corbyn,
00:02:11 so we're not going to let him be the prime minister.
00:02:13 We're just going to have another election and another one and another one until the people
00:02:16 pick something else.
00:02:17 I think it's an absolutely extraordinary claim.
00:02:20 And I think it's a very dangerous claim as well.
00:02:23 And that people underestimate what's being proposed here.
00:02:26 I don't think mercifully there's any realistic chance of it happening.
00:02:29 The reality is that we're going to be leaving next March.
00:02:33 That's what's going to happen.
00:02:35 And that means that the entire discussion at this point is coming down to what that looks
00:02:40 like and what that departure from the European Union actually manifests itself as.
00:02:46 And you've got a number of discussions that have happened around this, and I'll talk about
00:02:50 the Chequers proposal in a moment, but where there are a lot of people that are pushing
00:02:54 for suggestions that are not actually what Brexit was supposed to be.
00:02:58 And you've said what I think should be common sense, Brexit means Brexit.
00:03:02 But why has this become so overcomplicated?
00:03:05 And why have people tried to find a lot more of a complicated workaround to what should be
00:03:10 and what, if we go by the referendum, was a very simple and direct premise?
00:03:15 I think there's been a key error in the way that the government has approached the issue
00:03:20 of Brexit, of making the negotiations with the European Union be what Brexit was about.
00:03:25 And so people still, they ask, well, what kind of Brexit do you want, or that kind of language.
00:03:31 Now, to me, what that would mean is, well, once we've left the EU, do we want to have some
00:03:36 new alliance with, say, the United States, or an alliance with Canada and Australia, or do
00:03:41 we want to work together with countries around the periphery of Europe, a kind of ring donut
00:03:45 alliance, or do we just want to stand by ourselves in the world?
00:03:50 Do we want to, when we do those things, do we want to cut regulation, taxes, do a kind
00:03:54 of Singapore-esque model or something?
00:03:57 Those are the questions, right?
00:03:59 After we've left, how do we conduct ourselves around the world?
00:04:02 What people have tried to do instead is to say, what Brexit's about is what we do with
00:04:06 the EU, I mean, that's, we're not leaving the EU in order to have another relationship
00:04:11 with the EU, that's renegotiating your relationship with the EU.
00:04:14 We had a go at that under David Cameron, it didn't work, and people didn't like the renegotiation
00:04:19 that he'd achieved, and so we then chose to leave.
00:04:22 So then having another renegotiation is just the wrong way of framing the question.
00:04:27 We've chosen to leave the EU.
00:04:28 So although in due course, doubtless, we'll have some sort of trade deal with the EU, it may
00:04:35 not be next year, it might not be in five years' time, but by 2030, we'll certainly
00:04:39 have some sort of trade deal with the EU, it has a trade deal with all of its near partners.
00:04:44 And I don't see why that needs to be controversial at all, make more than page eight of the newspapers,
00:04:50 it doesn't have to be that big a deal.
00:04:53 But what people have tried to do instead is to cling on to as much of EU membership as
00:04:58 they possibly could.
00:04:59 It's just a mistake.
00:05:00 The EU has been our central geopolitical partnership for more than 40 years, and we've done quite
00:05:05 well, out of it as a geopolitical partnership, we faced down the Soviet Union, we absorbed
00:05:10 the post-fascist states of the Iberian Peninsula, we absorbed the post-communist states of Eastern
00:05:15 Europe.
00:05:16 We did all kinds of wonderful things together.
00:05:19 At the same time, we developed in Europe an economic philosophy much more in line with
00:05:23 British traditions.
00:05:25 But that's all over now.
00:05:27 And we've chosen to leave that geopolitical partnership.
00:05:31 So saying, well, we're leaving that geopolitical partnership, but now we're going to have
00:05:35 the EU as our main geopolitical partnership, seems to me to be just absurd.
00:05:39 It's just not what the vote was about at all.
00:05:42 And that seems to me to be the root cause of the problem.
00:05:44 One kind of iconic illustration of this came early on, when even though we were leaving
00:05:49 the EU, we decided that we weren't going to negotiate new trade deals with the US or Canada
00:05:55 or Australia or whoever, whilst we were in the process of leaving.
00:05:59 Well, what did our post-Brexit trading arrangements with the US have to do with the EU?
00:06:06 Nothing to do with them at all.
00:06:08 We should have just said, well, we're doing that.
00:06:10 I mean...
00:06:10 Yeah, something like that could have happened and would have happened irrespective of Brexit.
00:06:14 Even if Remain had won, there still could have been and should have been a trade discussion
00:06:18 with the United States.
00:06:19 Well, there would have been a trade discussion at EU level.
00:06:21 But whilst we're in the EU, we don't have any competence to negotiate our own trade deals.
00:06:26 So what we should have said was, well, we're leaving.
00:06:29 Obviously, we can't negotiate a trade deal that will start before we've actually left.
00:06:32 But if we're negotiating a trade deal that starts after we've left, that's nothing to do with the EU.
00:06:37 It doesn't have any competence over what we do after we've left the EU.
00:06:40 There's been a lot, I think.
00:06:42 In some way, it's been a novelty.
00:06:43 But I think there is a serious discussion to be had about KANZUK, this idea of an alliance between
00:06:48 Canada, Australia, New Zealand, and the UK.
00:06:52 And those countries, obviously, are as geographically disparate as countries can be.
00:06:57 But do you think that is the future of these sorts of trade and other geopolitical relationships,
00:07:02 that geography in this day and age is far less significant than other factors?
00:07:06 I don't really think that's right, no.
00:07:08 Because I think that in the case of KANZUK, that is true. 1.00
00:07:14 But I think that's a fairly unique case.
00:07:16 Because there aren't that many other kinds of arrangements where you have such culturally
00:07:21 similar people, so geographically diverse.
00:07:24 More normally, one needs geographical similarity in order to have the cultural and linguistic
00:07:30 and political traditions similarity, traditions of regulation and so on.
00:07:38 Otherwise, the distance tends to break those things up.
00:07:43 And so I don't think that it's going to be true in general that everybody's going to be
00:07:46 forming alliances of that sort.
00:07:48 I think that it's important that normally geography dominates.
00:07:55 And I'm not even sure that there's room in the world for that many geographically disparate 0.62
00:08:00 arrangements.
00:08:01 I think that it is quite likely we will see increased concentration on regional alliances
00:08:05 of various sorts, increased concentration of political union within the European Union.
00:08:11 We have the Russians forming their zone. 0.97
00:08:13 We've got ASEAN and the East Asians, and we've got the new NAFTA II. 0.70
00:08:20 I can't believe it's not NAFTA on there.
00:08:23 But I would see KANZUK as almost like a... 1.00
00:08:30 If you imagined you cut out some felt shapes from a square piece of felt, then you'd have
00:08:37 something, a shape left over at the end.
00:08:39 That's almost what KANZUK's like. 0.99
00:08:41 It's the thing that can be one of those that fills in the world in that kind of way, as
00:08:48 the bit that's left over.
00:08:49 Why is that able to, in your view, overcome those geographical barriers, though?
00:08:56 I think that it is because the political traditions and the ways of approaching things are so similar.
00:09:05 When people from Britain meet people from Australia or Canada or New Zealand, they get along immediately, right?
00:09:13 People understand.
00:09:14 You understand the humour.
00:09:16 We watch many of the same daytime soaps and comedy shows.
00:09:21 And there's a natural sense, even body language and things like that work in much the same way.
00:09:26 People understand each other in a different way.
00:09:28 It's not the same when you're dealing with people, even from continental Europe, who are quite similar, much more similar to people from Britain than people from China or Japan or many other parts of the world are.
00:09:40 But the people from the KANZUK countries, there's a very natural and automatic alignment.
00:09:45 And one of the things about the European Union was, as it's moved towards its deeper political union, we in Britain have found that, although we were happy to go along with it quite a long way, in the end, there was just a little bit too much difference between us.
00:10:00 Some of our constitutional traditions, the ways that they thought of things, the balance between the individual and the state, the attitudes to regulation and freedom, and the balance between diversity of approaches and the level playing field.
00:10:19 It isn't that the Europeans were enormously distant from us.
00:10:22 They're much more similar to us than the Japanese or some others.
00:10:25 But they were different enough that we found that we couldn't quite go along with it.
00:10:29 And if you think, from a British perspective, that that's why we're leaving the EU, that they were pretty happy to be together with medium-sized countries of similar values, and by working together, we can achieve more than we would individually, but found that, in the end, we just couldn't quite go along with it.
00:10:46 The natural thing, from the British point of view, is to think, well, is there anyone else out there that might be more similar to us, that we might not face that particular barrier of finding that, in the end, we couldn't take that final step?
00:10:58 And I think if you frame the question in that way, it answers itself.
00:11:02 There's nobody in the world that's remotely as close to the UK as the New Zealanders, Australians, and Canadians.
00:11:09 So that's the natural thing for us to try doing in that context.
00:11:12 And I think that one important feature of that, relative to the European Union, is because we have natural affinities, it won't be necessary to impose the same kind of one-size-fits-all approach.
00:11:26 Within the European Union, they were trying to force together countries that had quite different political traditions, cultural traditions, in many cases, had been at war with each other historically.
00:11:36 So they had to overcome natural antipathies rather than natural alignments.
00:11:42 And whereas in the case of the Kansak countries, you don't need to do any of that.
00:11:47 And so I don't think we would need to have anything like the same forcing of regulatory convergence, legal convergence.
00:11:55 These things will just happen quite naturally.
00:11:56 That doesn't mean you wouldn't have any institutions at all.
00:11:59 I mean, even the UN has some kind of institutions.
00:12:02 But it does mean that the things that you had wouldn't be anything like the European Union's agenda at all.
00:12:08 To bring it back to that very idea that seemed to drive Brexit for so many people, there was a lot that, certainly in Western press coverage, we were seeing that was framing it as about immigration wholly.
00:12:20 Or about, you know, just this populist wave that we're seeing in other parts of the world really coming home to roost in the UK.
00:12:26 And there were, I think, a number of people that were saying that the arguments for Brexit on the immigration, on the anti-elite, on the populism were in spite of the economics of it.
00:12:37 Whereas there was this entire other stream that I don't think got as much play outside of the UK, and perhaps not even in the UK in some of the media coverage,
00:12:45 which was that it was an economically positive move, or even in some cases economically neutral, but not as catastrophic as some of the Remain alarmists were saying.
00:12:55 And we've now seen a little bit of a bump, I'd say, or I'd say a negative bump immediately in sort of that shock reaction to the Brexit vote, which seemed to rebound in terms of the markets.
00:13:07 But when we look at the economics of this, what's the part of the story that you find is missing from the people that say a leave, a true Brexit is going to be economically disastrous?
00:13:18 OK, so two things there. First of all, just a little point about the immigration.
00:13:23 So the immigration issue, I think, should be understood as being the most retail or the most everyday life version of the loss of sovereignty.
00:13:33 So when people said, oh, well, we've lost sovereignty, and that means that we don't have the ability to set some obscure piece of financial services regulation,
00:13:41 or some engineering company can't do quite what they want to do, that all might seem, for most people, very distant to them.
00:13:48 They don't quite know what that means or why they would care.
00:13:51 But when the government says, well, we would like to keep immigration to the hundreds of, to the tens of thousands instead of the hundreds of thousands,
00:14:01 and then every year it's the hundreds of thousands, and the government says, well, that's because the EU says we have to let lots of people in.
00:14:06 And actually, for all the talk that much of the immigration, the net immigration from outside the EU is larger than the EU,
00:14:14 it's actually the EU bit, which the government, which hasn't worked out as the government expected,
00:14:20 that tells people what losing sovereignty means.
00:14:23 What losing sovereignty means is you can't, our government can't do what it wants to do.
00:14:29 And people see that. People visibly see that in their neighborhoods and in their communities.
00:14:32 And that, of course, then translates, that then gives them a sense of what that might mean for the businesses and so on and other parts.
00:14:39 So I see the immigration question as just a reflection, a retail version of the sovereignty question.
00:14:45 And that has implications for all kinds of business regulation and lots of other things as well.
00:14:51 Now, the thing that I would say about the economics of Brexit,
00:14:56 I don't think you should assume that Brexit is going to make a large difference economically either way.
00:15:03 So it isn't really about we leave the EU so as to make some enormous, at least in the short term, economic gain.
00:15:11 I think that would be a mistake to imagine that's the point.
00:15:14 The key thing about the economics of Brexit is that they're not sufficiently negative
00:15:18 to deter us from grasping the very considerable self-determination opportunities,
00:15:24 the increased stability of the union, less likelihood of Scotland leaving, for example,
00:15:29 now that we're leaving the EU,
00:15:32 and a greater ability to direct and choose the sort of structure of economy that we want.
00:15:39 So it gives us more control over what we do.
00:15:41 For good or ill, we might well use it to screw up.
00:15:44 We might elect Jeremy Corbyn and do all kinds of catastrophic things.
00:15:48 Absolutely, that's the choice that you make by increasing your freedom.
00:15:53 You increase your freedom to make errors as well.
00:15:56 But that's our call.
00:15:59 I rather like the...
00:16:01 So there used to be a famous saying of Chesterton's that there were two kinds of activities in life.
00:16:08 So one was things like being a polar explorer,
00:16:10 which if somebody did it, you'd rather he did it well.
00:16:13 Whereas another thing he said was like blowing your nose,
00:16:17 that once you're past being a child, we'd rather a person blows his nose for himself,
00:16:21 be he ever so bad at doing it.
00:16:24 And the point of that is that the key things that we would want to do for ourselves,
00:16:31 post-Brexit, the way we manage our economy and our society and so on,
00:16:34 are like that blowing of our nose.
00:16:35 Whether we do it well or whether we do it badly, we want to do it for ourselves.
00:16:39 And when we think of the economics of that, though,
00:16:45 it's a mistake, I think, to imagine that...
00:16:48 First of all, it's a mistake to think that the EU is primarily a trade deal.
00:16:51 It isn't a trading agreement.
00:16:52 It's a political union.
00:16:54 That's the point of it.
00:16:55 And so by leaving the European Union,
00:16:57 the key loss that you make is losing having the EU set your policy for you.
00:17:02 Because the EU is quite good at setting policies in all kinds of ways.
00:17:05 And most of the countries that you benefit from that,
00:17:07 if you're Italy or if you're Poland or lots of other countries,
00:17:10 the fact that the EU overrides your national government
00:17:12 and makes you do various things that your political system wouldn't choose to do for itself
00:17:17 is an enormous gain.
00:17:19 For us, not so much.
00:17:20 At least we hope that we can outperform the EU
00:17:25 in terms of the things which are best for us
00:17:27 by making choices for ourselves.
00:17:29 So one of the things that you should expect is,
00:17:32 it won't happen straight away,
00:17:33 but over time, as new things turn up to do,
00:17:37 we would expect that by doing them our own slightly different way,
00:17:41 we will end up doing them better.
00:17:43 Now, one illustration of that is,
00:17:46 many of the things that the EU has done,
00:17:49 and part of the EU's traditions involved a ratchet.
00:17:52 So once any measure is in place,
00:17:54 it's enormously difficult to undo it, to reverse it.
00:17:57 Because you have to get 28 sets of countries,
00:17:59 28 sets of ducks in a row,
00:18:00 in order to decide to undo it.
00:18:03 Now, that means that either the EU
00:18:06 is sometimes deterred from acting early enough when it should,
00:18:10 or it acts.
00:18:12 And if it's not clear what the right thing to do is,
00:18:14 it can get it wrong and be stuck with that.
00:18:16 Whereas the British political system,
00:18:19 for good or real,
00:18:20 and it leads to lots of political controversy of various sorts,
00:18:25 is very good at U-turns.
00:18:26 So we try something,
00:18:27 we got it wrong,
00:18:28 we'll go back,
00:18:29 we have another go,
00:18:30 we try it again.
00:18:31 So people have a sense of being empowered
00:18:32 to try and experiment to make mistakes.
00:18:35 When the best things to do are obvious,
00:18:37 like reducing tariffs,
00:18:39 or stripping away non-tariff barriers
00:18:41 in well-trailed areas.
00:18:43 Should be obvious, anyway.
00:18:43 Yeah, when the best things to do are obvious,
00:18:47 then there are advantages in the ratchet process.
00:18:49 You don't want the forces of reaction,
00:18:51 once you've finally decided to strip away
00:18:53 that silly agricultural subsidy or whatever,
00:18:55 you don't want the forces of reaction coming in
00:18:57 and saying,
00:18:58 oh, that's going to destroy everything,
00:18:59 we best undo that measure.
00:19:01 Right?
00:19:02 Whereas,
00:19:03 if you don't know what the best thing to do is,
00:19:06 if you're working out how to regulate
00:19:08 something completely new,
00:19:09 commercial exploitation of space,
00:19:12 or artificial intelligence,
00:19:13 or driverless cars,
00:19:15 or vaping,
00:19:17 or green technologies,
00:19:19 or hyperloop systems,
00:19:21 or all kinds of things
00:19:22 that will turn up in the future,
00:19:23 if you don't know what the best way to regulate is,
00:19:26 there are enormous advantages
00:19:27 in being able to experiment,
00:19:28 get it wrong,
00:19:29 and have another try.
00:19:30 And I think that the UK
00:19:32 has a considerable opportunity
00:19:33 over the next decade or 15 years
00:19:36 to become a world leader
00:19:37 in the regulation
00:19:38 of many of these new and emerging technologies.
00:19:40 It will be able,
00:19:41 through experimentation,
00:19:42 through getting it wrong and trying again,
00:19:44 to move faster,
00:19:45 to be more flexible than the EU,
00:19:46 and it will gain from that kind of regulation.
00:19:49 A second set of areas
00:19:51 where we should be able to gain
00:19:52 relative to the EU
00:19:53 is that we will be able to do trade deals
00:19:57 with countries that the EU
00:19:58 would struggle to do trade deals with.
00:20:00 Now, it isn't that the EU
00:20:01 is disastrously bad,
00:20:02 but the EU gets a bit of a bad press
00:20:04 on trade deals
00:20:04 because the EU for many years
00:20:08 was quite a keen supporter
00:20:09 of the global process.
00:20:11 So it was hoping to force things through
00:20:13 at the global level
00:20:14 rather than making specific deals.
00:20:17 Then it switched to doing specific deals later.
00:20:20 But nonetheless,
00:20:21 I think that the fact
00:20:22 that the average US trade deal
00:20:24 takes about 18 months to,
00:20:25 whereas the average EU trade deal
00:20:27 is what, seven years or something,
00:20:28 is rather telling
00:20:29 of the difficulties that you have
00:20:31 when you have to get
00:20:32 so many different interests
00:20:33 to agree in order to do anything.
00:20:36 And so I would expect
00:20:38 that the UK will make
00:20:39 quite a rapid trade deal
00:20:41 with the United States,
00:20:43 with Australia.
00:20:44 Australia,
00:20:45 it may well do trade deals
00:20:47 with Japan,
00:20:48 even though the EU
00:20:49 has already
00:20:50 a draft agreement with Japan.
00:20:52 It may well be
00:20:53 that the UK gets its agreement
00:20:54 through finally with Japan
00:20:55 before the EU does.
00:21:00 As things stand,
00:21:01 even the Canadian deal
00:21:02 is in question
00:21:02 with the Italians
00:21:03 at this stage saying that.
00:21:06 Even when you get
00:21:07 that far down the road,
00:21:08 the EU still looks like
00:21:09 it might reverse
00:21:10 certain trade deals.
00:21:12 You can't really imagine
00:21:13 that happening with the UK.
00:21:14 So the UK will do
00:21:16 extra trade deals
00:21:17 around the different countries.
00:21:18 So a second area,
00:21:19 as well as better regulation,
00:21:20 will be better trade deals.
00:21:23 A third area,
00:21:24 which is quite important for us,
00:21:25 is I think that by being in the EU,
00:21:28 we tended to destabilise it.
00:21:29 So the EU tried
00:21:31 for far too long
00:21:32 to accommodate
00:21:34 the possibility
00:21:34 that the UK might
00:21:35 eventually join the euro.
00:21:37 And by doing that,
00:21:40 it progressed
00:21:41 political integration
00:21:42 within the eurozone
00:21:43 too slowly.
00:21:44 It should have moved
00:21:45 some years,
00:21:46 a decade and more ago,
00:21:48 towards an elected president,
00:21:50 a treasury function,
00:21:52 debt raising at euro level,
00:21:54 which was properly backed
00:21:56 by the EU,
00:21:57 sorry, by the ECB,
00:21:59 by the European Central Bank,
00:22:01 backing this sovereign debt
00:22:02 off the EU.
00:22:03 And the fact that it didn't move
00:22:05 down those proper governance paths
00:22:07 that were required
00:22:08 to make the currency stable
00:22:09 has led to some of the problems
00:22:11 that you had with the eurozone.
00:22:13 I believe and I hope
00:22:14 that with the UK leaving,
00:22:16 that really strips out,
00:22:17 that guts the non-euro EU.
00:22:22 There's really,
00:22:23 after the UK,
00:22:24 there's really only Poland left 1.00
00:22:26 that's still a serious
00:22:28 non-euro EU member.
00:22:31 Which, no offence to Poland,
00:22:32 doesn't have the same implications
00:22:34 as the UK.
00:22:34 Exactly.
00:22:35 It's not nearly so significant.
00:22:37 It's still big,
00:22:39 but it's not nearly as big
00:22:40 as the UK.
00:22:42 And so I would expect
00:22:43 that what will happen
00:22:44 is now that the UK is left
00:22:46 quite quickly,
00:22:47 say by 2025,
00:22:48 all the countries
00:22:51 who are in the EU
00:22:52 will have to choose
00:22:54 between joining the euro
00:22:55 or being rolled together
00:22:57 with Norway
00:22:58 into a second tier
00:23:00 of EEA slash non-euro EU.
00:23:02 That'll all just become one thing.
00:23:05 Incidentally, by the way,
00:23:07 I think that that would
00:23:07 probably have happened
00:23:08 even with the UK
00:23:10 in the EU.
00:23:12 I think that would have
00:23:12 eventually happened,
00:23:14 which is one reason 0.54
00:23:15 why it's silly
00:23:16 to suggest that we leave the EU
00:23:17 and then go for
00:23:19 a Norway-type model
00:23:20 or a Norway-plus-customers-union
00:23:22 type model
00:23:23 or any of those kind of things.
00:23:24 Being a bit like Norway 1.00
00:23:25 is where we would have ended up
00:23:27 if we remained in the EU.
00:23:28 So it would have come full circle
00:23:29 to had no Brexit happened
00:23:31 in the first place.
00:23:32 Exactly.
00:23:32 So I don't understand
00:23:33 what the point is
00:23:34 of leaving the EU
00:23:35 in order to get us
00:23:37 to where we would have been
00:23:38 if we'd stayed in the EU.
00:23:39 But just coming in terms
00:23:41 of the white-sand-advantage,
00:23:42 so if the EU integrates
00:23:43 better politically,
00:23:44 then I think that
00:23:45 that will enable it
00:23:46 to grow faster,
00:23:47 which is good for us
00:23:48 because we'll be able
00:23:49 to export more to it.
00:23:50 So that's a third area of growth.
00:23:51 Just a couple more quick ones.
00:23:53 Yes, absolutely.
00:23:54 So we obviously won't have
00:23:56 to make our...
00:23:56 send money to the EU,
00:23:58 so that will save us some money.
00:23:59 So although I have
00:24:00 every confidence
00:24:01 that the government
00:24:01 will spend the same money
00:24:03 incompetently,
00:24:04 it will at least spend
00:24:05 the money incompetently
00:24:06 within the UK.
00:24:07 It's like the nose-blowing.
00:24:08 At least they're doing it here
00:24:09 instead of somewhere else.
00:24:10 Exactly.
00:24:11 So the government
00:24:12 will squander lots of money
00:24:13 in the UK
00:24:14 instead of squandering money
00:24:15 in Italy or Bulgaria
00:24:17 or Poland.
00:24:17 Or Poland. 0.88
00:24:19 Quite an important thing
00:24:23 is it'll make the Union
00:24:24 more secure.
00:24:25 So we're less likely now
00:24:27 that over the medium term
00:24:28 Scotland will end up
00:24:29 leaving the United Kingdom.
00:24:31 It's a much bigger step
00:24:33 for it to leave the UK
00:24:34 if we're outside the EU
00:24:36 than it would have been
00:24:37 if we were both inside the EU.
00:24:39 So even though I think...
00:24:41 I mean, we weren't
00:24:42 fairly handily 11% in 2014
00:24:44 to maintain the Union,
00:24:47 it's whatever residual risk
00:24:49 there was that eventually
00:24:50 Scotland might leave
00:24:51 has probably been eliminated
00:24:53 by four, you know,
00:24:55 who can say after 30 years ahead.
00:24:57 But probably for the next 30 years
00:24:59 there's not much chance now
00:25:00 that Scotland will leave.
00:25:02 So that again,
00:25:03 that increased stability
00:25:04 to the Union
00:25:05 is another potentially important
00:25:07 economic gain
00:25:07 quite apart from the political
00:25:09 and other kinds of gains
00:25:10 associated with it.
00:25:11 Those are a few.
00:25:12 There are some other things
00:25:12 we could carry on all day.
00:25:14 But that gives you some sense.
00:25:16 Now, I expect that those...
00:25:17 One thing about that
00:25:18 is it's lots of different
00:25:19 little sorts.
00:25:20 What people want
00:25:21 in economic arguments,
00:25:22 they don't want anything
00:25:23 as complicated as
00:25:24 there are nine ways
00:25:25 you gain or something.
00:25:26 What they want to do
00:25:27 is they want to say,
00:25:28 well, we estimate
00:25:29 that you lose this amount
00:25:30 of trade by leaving the EU
00:25:32 with the EU
00:25:33 and we want the one factor
00:25:34 that balances that.
00:25:35 But it isn't like that.
00:25:36 Brexit isn't.
00:25:37 When you're taking control
00:25:39 of your ability
00:25:40 to execute policy
00:25:42 right across the board,
00:25:43 it isn't about there being
00:25:44 one thing that you object to.
00:25:46 No, and that speaks to,
00:25:48 I think,
00:25:48 how linked
00:25:49 to the point of excess
00:25:51 the EU has become
00:25:52 in all of these different areas
00:25:53 that should be sovereign
00:25:54 United Kingdom areas
00:25:57 and files.
00:25:58 And I guess that brings us
00:26:00 to a question I want
00:26:02 to close on
00:26:02 that I fear the answer to,
00:26:04 but I have to ask it nonetheless.
00:26:06 Are you,
00:26:06 given the current political
00:26:07 and economic climate,
00:26:09 confident or,
00:26:11 dare I say,
00:26:11 optimistic
00:26:12 that what you would like
00:26:14 to see happen
00:26:15 with Brexit
00:26:15 actually happens in March?
00:26:17 What would have been best
00:26:19 would have been
00:26:19 if we'd been able
00:26:20 to do a fairly rapid
00:26:22 free trade agreement
00:26:23 with the EU.
00:26:24 I don't think
00:26:25 it was absolutely crucial,
00:26:26 but that would have been
00:26:26 the best scenario.
00:26:27 I think it's now,
00:26:30 we're now probably looking
00:26:31 at 60 to 70% chance
00:26:32 of no deal at all.
00:26:34 And there's a pretty high probability,
00:26:37 perhaps 25%,
00:26:39 that we just tough out no deal.
00:26:41 And so it's like
00:26:42 both sides decide
00:26:43 that they don't like
00:26:44 each other that much
00:26:45 for the medium term.
00:26:47 Perhaps 35%,
00:26:48 maybe a percent probability.
00:26:50 The single most likely thing
00:26:51 is that we have no deal
00:26:53 and then fairly quickly
00:26:54 we cobble together
00:26:56 some sort of face-saving
00:26:58 just enough
00:26:58 that we get along.
00:26:59 Just to tie this over
00:27:00 even until a bigger deal
00:27:02 could happen.
00:27:02 Well, yeah,
00:27:04 not necessarily committing
00:27:06 to any longer term deal.
00:27:07 Maybe some very vague
00:27:08 political commitment
00:27:09 to seek to have no tariffs
00:27:11 at some point in the future.
00:27:13 But nothing,
00:27:14 but some very minimalist
00:27:15 kind of arrangement.
00:27:17 I think that those
00:27:18 sorts of no deal scenarios
00:27:20 are the most likely now.
00:27:21 And they're not that desirable,
00:27:22 but I didn't know.
00:27:25 To me,
00:27:25 we aren't leaving the EU
00:27:26 in order to have a deal
00:27:27 with the EU.
00:27:27 So if we don't have a deal
00:27:28 with the EU straight away,
00:27:29 I don't think that should be
00:27:30 considered to be
00:27:31 that much of a problem.
00:27:32 But are you optimistic
00:27:33 that the sovereignty
00:27:34 that the Leave campaigners
00:27:37 sought
00:27:38 will actually be realized?
00:27:40 Well, it does in a
00:27:41 no deal scenario, right?
00:27:42 And apart from no deal scenarios,
00:27:44 there's some probability still
00:27:46 that the EU panics a bit
00:27:48 and we end up with
00:27:49 a Canada Plus.
00:27:51 That's what we refer to
00:27:52 our preferred free trade agreements
00:27:56 as by the model
00:27:57 of the Canadian deal
00:27:58 with the EU.
00:28:00 So there's a non-tribial chance
00:28:01 of that.
00:28:02 There are some,
00:28:03 there's some outside chance
00:28:04 that we end up with
00:28:05 some quite bad thing happening,
00:28:07 like committing to remain
00:28:08 in the customs union
00:28:09 over the long term
00:28:11 or something of that sort.
00:28:13 There's some risks
00:28:15 that we end up with
00:28:16 with those scenarios.
00:28:17 Again, politicians might panic
00:28:18 and we might end up
00:28:19 with an EEA plus customs union
00:28:21 thing for quite a long time.
00:28:25 I think that that would simply
00:28:27 lead to a Brexit 2.0 movement
00:28:29 where we'd have another movement
00:28:31 to try to get us out of that
00:28:32 over the medium term
00:28:33 because it would be
00:28:34 so restrictive.
00:28:35 And as I say,
00:28:35 that would,
00:28:36 all that that would achieve
00:28:37 is to get us
00:28:39 two or three years earlier
00:28:40 to exactly where we would have
00:28:42 ended up if we'd remained
00:28:42 in the EU anyway.
00:28:43 So there's absolutely no point
00:28:45 in committing to an EEA plus
00:28:47 customs union arrangement
00:28:48 over the medium term.
00:28:49 It's just silliness.
00:28:51 I think that,
00:28:52 I think that the likelihood
00:28:55 is that we will end up
00:28:56 with either a no deal
00:28:58 or a Canada plus type deal
00:28:59 in the short term.
00:29:00 That's the vast majority
00:29:01 of the probability.
00:29:02 If we don't do that,
00:29:03 then most of the rest
00:29:05 of the probability
00:29:05 is we end up,
00:29:07 we have a Brexit 2.0
00:29:08 and after another six painful years
00:29:10 of arguing about this,
00:29:11 we finally get ourselves out.
00:29:13 I think that would be quite bad
00:29:16 for British politics
00:29:17 to carry on.
00:29:19 It's been quite bad.
00:29:20 It's a fairly toxic
00:29:21 political environment
00:29:23 we've had for the past
00:29:23 couple of years,
00:29:24 even as things stand.
00:29:26 I've never seen anything
00:29:28 like the unwillingness
00:29:29 of the Remain side
00:29:30 to accept that they lost
00:29:31 in this particular campaign.
00:29:33 I've never seen,
00:29:34 and that's just,
00:29:35 politics doesn't really work
00:29:36 if you don't accept
00:29:37 that the other team can win.
00:29:39 And I don't think
00:29:40 the Remainers have really accepted
00:29:42 that the,
00:29:43 some of them have,
00:29:44 right?
00:29:44 There's been a reasonable number
00:29:45 of had,
00:29:45 but there's been a hard core
00:29:47 of Remainers
00:29:47 who've just refused
00:29:48 to accept that they lost.
00:29:50 And I find that extraordinary.
00:29:52 And if we were to establish that,
00:29:54 if we were to have,
00:29:54 say, a second referendum
00:29:55 or something like that,
00:29:56 that could really poison 0.71
00:29:57 UK politics
00:29:58 for a very long time.
00:30:00 So I really hope
00:30:02 that that doesn't happen.
00:30:03 But as things stand,
00:30:05 I would say the most likely scenario
00:30:07 is no deal
00:30:08 or perhaps a Canada Plus deal.
00:30:10 If there's no deal,
00:30:11 we'll end up with a Canada Plus deal
00:30:13 in a few years' time.
00:30:14 I really hope it doesn't have to make
00:30:15 more than page four of the papers.
00:30:17 And like a true economist,
00:30:18 I ask a yes or no question
00:30:19 and I get an answer
00:30:20 with probabilities,
00:30:21 which I like.
00:30:22 So we've got the options.
00:30:23 Dr. Andrew Lillico,
00:30:24 thank you very much
00:30:25 for your time and insight.
00:30:26 I really appreciate it.
00:30:27 You're welcome.
00:30:29 For the True North Initiative,
00:30:30 I'm Andrew Lutton.
00:30:33 Thank you.