Juno News - October 05, 2023


Inflation forcing Canadians to buy dollar store groceries

Hosted by
Mentioned
Toronto’s Asylum Seeker Crisis Trudeau tightens his grip on online content (ft. Kris Sims)

Episode Stats


Length

47 minutes

Words per minute

175.09

Word count

8,384

Sentence count

370

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

7

sentences flagged

Hate speech

11

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Grocery prices have been on the rise in Canada, and there's no shortage of reasons to complain about it. But the problem is that grocery stores in Canada are not the only ones getting hit by rising prices. They're also being hit by higher taxes, higher fuel prices, and more.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:20 north hello and welcome to you all canada's most irreverent talk show here the andrew lotten show
00:01:30 on true north the end of another week at least insofar as this program is concerned coming to
00:01:38 you live from the nation's capital of ottawa where you see strange things around the problem with
00:01:44 like there are two ottawas there's the real ottawa that is like a municipality like any other in
00:01:49 Canada. And you've got all your suburbs and communities and people with real lives, real jobs.
00:01:54 And then there's downtown Ottawa. And I was very sympathetic when the Freedom Convoy came up to
00:02:00 people saying, listen, I live downtown. But for the most part, it's not normal people that live
00:02:05 in downtown Ottawa. There are some, but it's like, and by not normal, I mean, it's politicians and
00:02:10 bureaucrats and stuff like that. They're humans, but they're like a very strange subset of humans.
00:02:14 And so everywhere you go, you're running into people like there's one guy, Jasraj Singh Hallan, who's the conservative finance critic.
00:02:21 I've interviewed him before. Very nice guy. I've seen him like nine times in four days.
00:02:26 And I had thought like I had seen him enough times. And then last night I was in a meeting with someone and he like came in because he needed to see them.
00:02:34 So that was number nine. So this is Ottawa. And then yesterday I was just walking around Parliament Hill and I saw Jagmeet Singh like riding away
00:02:43 on his bicycle and it was actually to be honest it was impressive because generally speaking I
00:02:50 thought you needed a spine to ride a bike and Jagmeet Singh managed to be riding at a pretty
00:02:55 good clip despite all of the things that he says for example if I'm talking about what's happening
00:03:01 on Twitter or X as it's now called Jagmeet Singh has done it never ceases to amuse me this is the
00:03:07 tweet he shared this morning about the rising grocery prices he puts the blame on justin
00:03:14 trudeau he says it's uh you know the justin trudeau the liberals have been doing this
00:03:18 and only the ndp are the ones that are going to uh call this out only the ndp are going to this
00:03:26 was a tweet from a couple of days ago but the thing that i find most interesting about it
00:03:30 is that he always forgets to include the other part of that you kind of have to really really
00:03:35 squint and you know really look closely to see oh by the way i'm the one that's keeping the liberal
00:03:40 government in power right now so uh maybe he was riding his bike so fast yesterday because
00:03:45 accountability were the things he was was the thing he was trying to flee but nevertheless
00:03:50 the grocery store debate about what to do with them to the liberals is basically just summon all
00:03:56 the ceos to ottawa finger wag and say you must produce a plan the liberal government is actually
00:04:01 unveiling that right now the plan that they demanded by thanksgiving to do something about
00:04:07 rising grocery costs it's not actually going to do anything at all all we're reminded of here
00:04:12 is that grocery stores in canada are really coming down to a five day a five company group it's an
00:04:19 oligopoly aaron woodrick uh posted this tweet here which i i found was quite incisive about the
00:04:25 problem he said philippe francois champagne this morning was talking about the virtues of competition
00:04:30 And this afternoon is talking about the federal government essentially working with this oligopoly to fix prices.
00:04:37 Because the government, and by the way, the NDP, have taken the view that greedy grocery store profiteers are the problem.
00:04:47 That greedy CEOs, the capitalist system, that's the reason that things are so expensive.
00:04:52 Not inflation, which as we've discussed on this show, has a number of influencing factors.
00:04:58 but the carbon tax is a very big one it's not grocery store profits and in fact if you look
00:05:05 at the shrinkage that grocery stores have to contend with if you look at the theft issues
00:05:11 that grocery stores especially now have to contend with if you look at their operating costs which
00:05:16 are driven up by fuel taxes carbon taxes all that sort of stuff and then just general cost of doing
00:05:22 things in Ontario for example the minimum wage is going up quite significantly I think it's now
00:05:27 at $16.55 an hour, which I remember when $15 an hour was seen as a very radical push. And I
00:05:35 remember when businesses were justifiably talking in Ontario about how difficult it was going to be
00:05:40 for them to make a go of things at a $15 an hour minimum wage. Now, a few years have passed, mind
00:05:45 you, that is going up entirely. You may say that even a minimum wage salary today is not enough
00:05:52 to comfortably live, which I am entirely sympathetic to. But those increases to the
00:05:57 cost of labor put a responsibility on employers that they cannot just shoulder. The profit margins
00:06:04 are not thick enough that they can just, with the stroke of a pen, say, okay, yeah, we're paying
00:06:10 everyone more. That money has to go down to customers. And there was a spokesperson, I can't
00:06:16 remember if I mentioned it yesterday, from the Bank of Canada, I did mention it, who had said
00:06:20 we're going to be seeing a feedback loop that inflation is going to cause more inflation which 0.84
00:06:24 sounds like a stupid point and ideally people in the bank of canada would be well aware of this 0.59
00:06:28 but it's also at the same time a self-evident point that the rising costs affect everyone 0.99
00:06:33 including people who have to decide what to price things they're selling at and you put this in the
00:06:40 context in which i think it's most important to be viewed in which is the effect on individual
00:06:45 people, not on companies, not on government, but on ordinary people. And it is heartbreaking
00:06:50 how many people are hurting. And this is something that I should actually one day devote a considerable
00:06:57 chunk of time to going through some of the emails I've seen that have been very difficult
00:07:00 on this question. Emails from people who are making very difficult decisions. And I know I'm
00:07:07 starting to do a wind up like I'm some politician on the campaign trail of, oh, well, I met a
00:07:12 constituent in Kelowna who said X, Y, Z. But people are hurting. And governments tend to not
00:07:19 be aware of that in a very real way. They may be aware in an abstract way. People in the general
00:07:25 sense are hurting. But the individual struggles and the commonalities between those individual
00:07:30 struggles, I don't think they're paying attention to. This morning, there was a report that was
00:07:36 released from Dalhousie and we've seen Sylvain Charlebois on the show before he's a probably
00:07:42 the leading scholar and researcher on food supply chain and food pricing issues in Canada and this
00:07:49 survey found that two-thirds of Canadians are concerned about the long-term health implications
00:07:56 of the choices they're making today not because they're making unhealthy choices
00:08:00 just for sake of preference but because they're having to buy less healthy products
00:08:05 less nutritious products because of inflation because they cannot afford fresh food fresh
00:08:14 produce you look further to this and find that half of the respondents of this survey if i think
00:08:20 it was 47 are doing more grocery shopping at the dollar store than they are at the grocery store
00:08:27 for the same reason because of inflation now i want to say first and foremost here i am not
00:08:34 judging anyone for the decisions they make. If you decide, you know what, I can get so-and-so
00:08:38 for cheaper. I don't care about the name brands. And if I want to get like Dr. Broccoli instead
00:08:44 of Dr. Pepper, and I can get it for half the price of the dollar store, great. I'm not talking
00:08:49 about people that are making just frugal decisions for whatever reason, same as some people that
00:08:53 used to load up at the bulk food store and only get some things at the grocery store. That's
00:08:57 not what I'm talking about. I'm talking about people who are only doing it
00:09:02 because of the circumstances of the economy.
00:09:06 People who are only making that choice
00:09:08 because they have no other options
00:09:10 or they feel they have no other option.
00:09:13 And that's something we're seeing so much of right now
00:09:17 in this country.
00:09:18 People that are going to the grocery store,
00:09:20 and we've seen this.
00:09:21 There have been countless studies, polls,
00:09:23 surveys that have showed this.
00:09:24 People that are buying less food,
00:09:26 people who are skipping meals,
00:09:28 people who are compromising on quality,
00:09:30 people who are compromising on freshness, people who are compromising on nutrition.
00:09:37 And all of these decisions are coming about because they cannot afford to otherwise feed
00:09:44 themselves or, in more heartbreaking cases, to feed their families. And this is a crisis.
00:09:51 This is not a problem. This is a crisis. Rishi Sunak, the other day, the Prime Minister of the
00:09:56 UK, was referring in some interview to the inflation tax. And he said the inflation tax
00:10:00 harms the poor and this smug self-righteous interviewer spends the next however many minutes
00:10:07 arguing with him about whether you can call inflation a tax and she's like oh it's not a
00:10:11 tax it's not and he says it is it's absolutely a tax it is a penalty on living that is what
00:10:17 inflation is and that again the fact that it was a debate being held in the UK shows this is not
00:10:22 exclusively a Canadian problem so no I'm not one of these people that looks to Justin Trudeau and
00:10:27 said, you caused this global trend. But I will look to Justin Trudeau and say that you did not
00:10:32 put Canada in the best position to withstand this. You did not. And Justin Trudeau's only answer to
00:10:41 this has been to wag his finger at grocery store CEOs. Take a look at this clip from a few weeks
00:10:48 back. It's not okay that our biggest grocery stores are making record profits while Canadians 1.00
00:10:56 are struggling to put food on the table. So Minister Champagne will be calling on the
00:11:01 heads of large grocers to come to Ottawa with a plan to address the rising cost of food.
00:11:08 We expect to hear from them by Thanksgiving on what their plan is to stabilize prices.
00:11:26 And let me be very clear, if their plan doesn't provide real relief for the middle class and
00:11:32 people working hard to join it, then we will take further action and we are not ruling
00:11:38 anything out, including tax measures.
00:11:43 So obviously the announcement today suggests that the government has gotten what it wanted.
00:11:50 Grocery store CEOs have put their heads together, they've come up with some agreement that they're
00:11:54 going to do, which I'm guaranteeing right now, and I'm not a particularly pessimistic person.
00:11:59 Well, no, who am I kidding? I am. I want to be an optimist. I'm like the middle class seeking to
00:12:04 join it. I'm like the optimist and those seeking to be optimist. But the thing about it is that
00:12:08 I would encourage you to, when you go to your grocery store this weekend, maybe you're doing
00:12:13 a big Thanksgiving turkey dinner. I can't stand turkey. I hate that it's become the default
00:12:18 traditional holiday food for like three holidays every year and some other ones. But nevertheless,
00:12:23 this isn't about my dislike for turkey I just find it boring now it's not there's nothing
00:12:28 objectionable about it it's just like the it's like the Aaron O'Toole of poultry it's like just
00:12:33 it has nothing to offer unless you just load it up with gravy and all these other things so I would
00:12:37 just prefer to have the gravy but nevertheless the one thing that I'll point out here is that
00:12:43 I know Canadians are not going to see this stability by Thanksgiving that was promised so
00:12:50 this tough talk we're not taking anything off the table we're doing this and we're doing that and
00:12:56 we're gonna put tax measures if we have to by the way like tax measures how are you going to tax
00:13:03 your way out of a mess that was already caused by increasing prices and increasing costs and the
00:13:11 government has never answered this I mean I remember trying to make sense of this with Aaron
00:13:14 Woodrick whose tweet I showed earlier earlier when this happened and I was like how are we
00:13:19 Like, I'm just, I mean, liberal logic is sometimes difficult to keep up with in general, but oftentimes you can sort of try to figure out at least how they got to the conclusion, even if you realize that it may be a dumb point.
00:13:32 In this one, I'm like, how are tax measures going to penalize grocery stores to bringing their prices down because they will have to pay this, you know, penalty tax because they didn't lower the price of turkey?
00:13:47 And how are they going to recoup that?
00:13:49 Well, they're going to increase the price of turkey or gravy or whatever the case is.
00:13:53 So, like, it literally makes no sense whatsoever.
00:13:56 and when Canadians are buying their groceries at the dollar store they are dispensing maybe
00:14:03 there's a dollarama out there that has a decent selection of romaine lettuce or something but
00:14:07 any dollar store I've seen uh has which by the way I mean how dollar stores have survived now
00:14:12 I have no idea because you know nothing is a dollar so the groceries they're selling
00:14:18 are heavily preserved foods things that are not healthy and I no one is looking at me and being
00:14:25 this is the guy I'm taking health advice from. I'm not giving you health advice. My problems did
00:14:29 not come from buying food at the dollar store, I assure you. But I am making the point here
00:14:34 that when people are making these decisions, not because they're choosing them, but are making
00:14:40 them because the economic realities are forcing them to, this is a problem. And it's not going
00:14:46 to surprise me if we see in five, 10 years, the consequences of this, of children who have been
00:14:53 developmentally delayed who have been malnourished in some way of people that haven't developed in
00:14:58 certain ways because they haven't been eating as much they haven't been eating as right i mean
00:15:02 these are the types of things that are lagging indicators where they take a fair bit of time
00:15:06 to catch up with what the consequences are of the decision uh bill peace has a message he says
00:15:14 turkeys are 46 51 at food basics happy thanksgiving now that actually doesn't seem like a terrible
00:15:20 price for turkey i didn't wait i didn't even know we could put the comments up on the screen there
00:15:25 that's great that's just like i should read comments more often i didn't know we had that
00:15:28 in our uh in our program here i get all excited small things amuse small minds as they say
00:15:32 but that like again food basics they're supposed to be one of the inexpensive
00:15:36 grocers not one of the really high-end ones this isn't like loblaws or sobeys or anything like that
00:15:43 i mean sobeys is a pricey store they they have good quality stuff oftentimes when i've been there
00:15:48 But this is exactly where things are, I think, moving along.
00:15:52 Now, one of the big challenges, and I'm going to be talking about this a little bit more
00:15:56 next week, obviously, once I've had a chance to look through whatever is being proposed
00:16:01 and whatever is being announced here.
00:16:03 But I want to hear from you on this.
00:16:05 And I don't often crowdsource this sort of stuff because my inbox then gets a little
00:16:09 full and it's unwieldy for me to keep up with it.
00:16:12 But I want you to actually report when this change has been announced.
00:16:16 and we'll give it time to sink in or be adopted,
00:16:19 I want you to tell me if you've seen any changes
00:16:22 and if so, what they are.
00:16:25 And it's kind of a two-part assignment, if you will.
00:16:27 Not that I like to be the podcaster giving you homework.
00:16:30 Maybe we can get the CRTC to regulate that out of here.
00:16:33 But what I would encourage you to do
00:16:34 is if you're at the grocery store today or tomorrow,
00:16:37 take a look at the prices of a couple of things.
00:16:39 Pick like two or three items
00:16:40 and then see what they are
00:16:42 after these so-called stabilization measures
00:16:45 are in effect and in force that that's going to be the assignment that's what you have to do here
00:16:50 and i am gonna bet it's not going to make a difference so all of this was theatrical the
00:16:56 government makes it look like it's going tough on these big evil greedy grocery store ceos 1.00
00:17:00 and i'll say on this point by the way the grocery store ceos have done themselves no favors here
00:17:07 when they had that meeting in ottawa a few weeks back and they were all summoned here
00:17:11 and it was all five. It was Sobeys, Costco, and Costco I felt was like, I don't even think of as
00:17:17 a grocery store, but Costco, Sobeys, Loblaws, Metro, and there was one more that I'm forgetting.
00:17:24 But when all of them went there, one of the things that I found interesting about it was that they
00:17:31 all just blew off the media. The media were out there asking them questions, trying to scrum them
00:17:36 as they went in. Only one of them really stopped to talk. And he just gave like this boilerplate
00:17:41 line. Galen Weston, who like the NDP would basically call for the public execution of if
00:17:47 it were within the law, just kind of walks in smugly and gives nothing. If I were one of these
00:17:54 grocery store CEOs, I would be out there with the media going through in painstaking detail
00:18:01 what it is that the government is doing that is causing these problems because it's easy if you
00:18:08 don't know enough about business to look at the bottom line and say oh wow they're making millions
00:18:13 billions of dollars whatever the case like it's easy to make that claim but when people see how
00:18:18 much it costs them to be in business yes they're making profits but it's the profitability of
00:18:26 companies that makes it worthwhile to invest in those companies and invest in business and invest
00:18:32 in doing things that allow us to have grocery stores in the first place. If it weren't profitable,
00:18:37 they wouldn't do it. And then we're left with just nationalizing grocery stores. And mark my words,
00:18:42 there's going to be a semi-serious push from someone in politics at some point in the next
00:18:47 few years to create a national grocery store chain. And it's probably going to come from the NDP,
00:18:52 but at this point, I'm not convinced the liberal government would be opposing it. So
00:18:56 we'll talk about that more. But I do sincerely feel for all the people that are struggling right
00:19:01 now. And I can't say that I can solve the problem. But I can say that I'm listening. And I'm aware of
00:19:07 it. And I wish lawmakers do as well. And you know, I met a couple of MPs this week who I'm very
00:19:12 grateful listen to this show. So some of them are hearing it that I can tell you. Speaking of MPs,
00:19:19 there's no natural segue from produce to assisted suicide. So I'll just do like the hard stop and
00:19:24 move on here. There is, as you know, this ongoing debate in Ottawa, and it's a debate being under,
00:19:31 well, it's underway across the country, I think, probably more so elsewhere than it is in the
00:19:34 nation's capital, on assisted suicide. The government has committed to a very ideological
00:19:39 approach that is vastly expanding eligibility for what they call MADE, the euphemism,
00:19:46 medical assistance in dying. And one of these expansions includes the ability for someone to
00:19:54 access this when they're dealing not with an irremediable physical medical condition,
00:20:00 but someone who's dealing only with a mental health condition. And that is so key here,
00:20:07 because sometimes the symptom of a mental illness is wanting to end your life.
00:20:11 So how can the so-called cure or treatment to that condition also be ending your life?
00:20:19 And this is near and dear to my heart.
00:20:20 I have shared this on the show before.
00:20:22 For some of you, you may not have heard it.
00:20:23 I am a suicide survivor.
00:20:25 When I was younger in 2010, I had been going through for several years a mental health
00:20:31 struggle, mainly depression, and I very nearly succeeded in ending my own life.
00:20:36 And it was my greatest failure.
00:20:38 and it's a failure I'm tremendously proud of
00:20:41 because all the things I have in life since then,
00:20:43 my career, my life, my friends, my wife,
00:20:47 has come about because I found a path
00:20:50 and a hope that I did not know was possible.
00:20:53 And it is heartbreaking on a very personal level,
00:20:55 set aside the policy of it,
00:20:56 when I see a government so committed to this idea
00:21:00 that ending your life with a state's assistant is a right
00:21:02 that no one has the ability to interfere with
00:21:06 because I know it's a regime that if it were in place in 2010, I would have been very motivated
00:21:12 to avail myself of. And the doctors, the care workers that told me, no, you don't get to end
00:21:19 your life, we're going to help you, would have been compelled to do the opposite, to assist me
00:21:26 with what was a very flawed and ill approach. Now, this is a lengthy windup to a private
00:21:34 Members Bill that's been introduced by Conservative MP Ed Fast. It was introduced in May, but it's
00:21:39 actually this week getting a hearing, which I'm very grateful for. It's called Bill C-314. There
00:21:45 was a press conference about it just a couple of blocks from where I am earlier this week.
00:21:49 Alex Schattenberg is the Executive Director of the Euthanasia Prevention Coalition and joins me now.
00:21:55 Alex, it's good to talk to you. What does this Private Members Bill do?
00:21:59 Well, actually, the private members bill is very clear.
00:22:02 It would just reverse what was already passed by Bill C-7 in March of 2021.
00:22:09 So Bill C-7 was the bill that expanded euthanasia and assisted suicide in Canada we call MAID.
00:22:14 It expanded it to include people who are not terminally ill.
00:22:17 One of the things that bill did is it allowed for euthanasia for mental illness alone, but they put a two-year moratorium on that.
00:22:24 And you might remember last December when the government was getting a lot of heat over the issue of people with disabilities who were dying by MAID because of homelessness and poverty and inability to get medical treatment, etc.
00:22:39 And these stories were coming at them one at a time consistently that they decided to delay the MAID for mental illness until March of 2024.
00:22:49 So Ed Fassbill would actually end that prospect and say that it is not part of the law to allow MAID for mental illness alone.
00:22:59 This has been, I mean, obviously there's an ideological aversion to assisted suicide in general among a lot of social conservatives in Canada and some other people as well.
00:23:08 The mental illness criterion has galvanized a lot of people that do not identify as pro-life, don't identify as social conservative.
00:23:17 We're talking about disability activists, mental health activists, a lot of medical providers that are at the very minimum concerned, at another level, completely outraged by this.
00:23:28 But even so, the government has been unflinching.
00:23:30 It's like they've said, well, we'll consult, we'll talk about it.
00:23:32 But they really haven't shown any signs of walking this back, have they?
00:23:36 No, they haven't.
00:23:37 And in fact, the Canadian Association of the Suicide Prevention Organizations, they're against, you know, made for mental illness. 0.98
00:23:47 In our own press conference, we had two young women give very similar stories to your story, talking about, you know, the times they went through when they were, you know, one was hospitalized for over a month and had constant relapses into deep, deep, deep depression.
00:24:02 And her story was, well, if you had offered it to me then, I would have taken it because I wanted death.
00:24:06 Another one attempted suicide unsuccessfully, thankfully, seven times and said, you know, if you had offered me medical aid in dying, I would have taken it in a second because I thought death was my only option.
00:24:19 I felt like I was caught into this deep, dark place and I couldn't get out any other way.
00:24:25 And yet, of course, now they are both much better.
00:24:27 But the point of it is, is that Ed Fassbill I really like because as much as I'm opposed to euthanasia and assisted suicide in general, he has just carved out this part of the legislation saying no to that because clearly Canadians oppose that.
00:24:42 A recent poll done by Angus Reid showed that 82% of Canadians thought that this should
00:24:49 not happen until we improve mental health supports, but only 28% of Canadians actually
00:24:54 supported the concept of euthanasia for mental illness alone.
00:24:58 Yeah, and actually, you raise an important point there, and I know you don't work for
00:25:02 Ed Fast, you're an advocate on the issue, but Ed has done something very important here
00:25:06 because when C7 came up, the problem was this was really an issue that was being debated
00:25:11 within a broader context of changes.
00:25:14 And that was sort of the excuse to just pass it.
00:25:17 Whereas if you deal with an isolation,
00:25:19 someone who believes that this exception
00:25:22 for mental illness should be taken out or left in, 0.98
00:25:26 like you actually have to defend that issue alone.
00:25:29 You have to defend that slice of it alone.
00:25:31 And it's very difficult for private members
00:25:33 to be able to get a hearing.
00:25:34 This one actually is by virtue of where it is in the queue.
00:25:37 Right, yeah.
00:25:38 So it's having its second hour debate actually today.
00:25:40 The fact is that you might remember the history of it is that Bill C-7, when it came out, originally did not allow MAID for mental illness.
00:25:47 And then what happened is a certain group of senators got together saying that they would not support the changes to the legislation if it didn't include that.
00:25:57 So what happened, it went back to Parliament, and Parliament then passed it.
00:26:01 But I see a lot of them never even debated it.
00:26:03 They didn't even think that this is what they were doing.
00:26:05 They didn't understand.
00:26:06 What I'm also concerned about is this issue of democracy.
00:26:09 You know, why am I saying this? There's a lot of members of parliament who are saying, you know, I agree with Ed Fass, but I have to support with my I have to vote with my liberal party.
00:26:18 Well, this is a private members bill. It's got nothing to do with liberal policy.
00:26:22 It's got nothing to do with a budget or anything like that.
00:26:24 It has to do with a private members business.
00:26:27 So therefore, there should be clearly a free vote.
00:26:29 But the liberals and the NDP, they have been, how would you say, they've been whipping the vote on this issue.
00:26:35 and that to me is ridiculous if you consider the fact of where Canadians are at and how Canadians 0.53
00:26:40 simply oppose this. Let me ask you about the the other issue of this that we see in Canada which is
00:26:48 increasingly stories of made being offered to people who are not dealing with mental illness
00:26:54 or physical illness people that are dealing with housing insecurity people that are dealing with
00:26:58 poverty and and you know I was talking earlier on about rising cost of living problems about
00:27:03 grocery store prices, these are contributing to these broader social ills that we know are at
00:27:10 least in a handful of cases, more than I would say we can call isolated, converting to people
00:27:16 being recommended or seeking out assisted dying. Now, the reason I bring that up is because the
00:27:22 law, as I understand it, and as I read it, does not allow that. This is practitioners of this
00:27:27 going above and beyond what the regulations and the law says. And I'm concerned that we already
00:27:33 have this attitude in parts of the medical community that doesn't really care about legal
00:27:39 restrictions, it seems. And I'm wondering what your take on that is. Well, first of all, there
00:27:44 is a small group of doctors who do a lot of euthanasia, medical aid and dying. There are
00:27:50 some that do a little bit of it, but there's a small group that do very many of them. And you
00:27:55 see that in some of the articles. But what happened is, is that they actually technically
00:27:58 allow this and we the reason is is that they uh bill c7 when it got rid of the uh the type of a
00:28:05 terminal illness requirement it led to the fact that essentially what you need now is to have an
00:28:09 irremediable medical condition because they say you have to be suffering but as you know andrew
00:28:14 i if you tell me you're suffering i can't tell you you're not suffering so there's nothing
00:28:18 objective about it you can't you can't gauge that so yeah men like suffer from like the cold
00:28:23 or the flu in a way that like some would argue is irremediable. Yeah.
00:28:28 Well, you threw that in because your wife probably reminded you of that. But anyway,
00:28:31 the fact of it is, is that, you know, the fact of it is, is that if you have an irremediable
00:28:36 medical condition, essentially means that people with disabilities really do qualify almost all
00:28:41 the time for medical aid and dying in Canada. And that's what's been happening. So these people who
00:28:46 are going through really quite extreme poverty or homelessness, or a lot of them, they had a
00:28:51 situation where they were really having a hard time getting the medical treatment they needed
00:28:56 so that had to do with the access to our medical system which is also a whole nother issue that we
00:29:01 we uh we know is a serious problem anyway they were then saying i have no choice because
00:29:07 i cannot continue living this way so i will ask for euthanasia made they were being approved
00:29:12 based on their disability so they weren't being approved based on their poverty they were
00:29:16 requesting it based on their poverty or their homelessness or the inability to get their
00:29:21 medical treatment. And there's a few other reasons that are all social issues, serious social ills
00:29:26 within our country. And of course, the thing of homelessness is just exploded. And there's many
00:29:31 reasons for that. And you could do multiple shows on that one. But the fact of it is, is that when
00:29:36 you're getting such a high level of homelessness, you can see how somebody with a disability who
00:29:40 can't get access to social housing because they have a limited income, they're sick enough that
00:29:45 they can't work, they can't get access to social housing, they're in fear of ending up on the
00:29:50 streets, but they do qualify for euthanasia. So we can't get them a house or a place to live,
00:29:56 but yeah, we can kill you. And that's somehow going to be about freedom, choice, and autonomy, 0.99
00:30:00 which is, of course, the big joke of the whole thing. It's not about freedom, choice, and autonomy
00:30:03 at all. It's really about abandonment when it comes down to it. Yeah, it's heartbreaking all
00:30:08 around. I'm glad Ed Fast is, who, by the way, I mean, look, I don't know Ed Fast all that well.
00:30:13 he's not exactly like a hardline social conservative culture war creator so he crusader
00:30:18 so he's actually probably one of the best people to put this forward because he's fairly moderate
00:30:23 and I uh it's it's unfortunate from what you've said that the other parties are not taking it in
00:30:27 in that uh tone and and working with him on this but uh hopefully if we get the public pressure up
00:30:32 there that might be able to change Alex Schattenburg Euthanasia Prevention Coalition thanks for coming
00:30:37 on Alex thank you so much for having me thank you all right thank you and uh we're just like
00:30:42 rapid firing through topics today. We had a lot going on, all the things we couldn't get to earlier
00:30:46 in the week that we're trying to cram in before the weekend, but trying to give each one a little
00:30:51 open air breathing because some of these are very important topics. And I've said time and time
00:30:56 again, free speech is my hill to die on. And that means, you know, legal free speech that is
00:31:01 to stand up against censorship and regulation of speech by government, but also academic freedom
00:31:07 and cultural free speech, the idea that we must foster in society an attitude that encourages
00:31:13 and welcomes the exchange of ideas and information rather than discourages and cancels.
00:31:20 And I was, of course, very intrigued by this course that was not offered when I was in
00:31:25 university.
00:31:26 I'll read the proper name of it because I don't want to give it a crude summation, but
00:31:31 the proper name of the course is, and it's a study of woke ideology here, and I lost the
00:31:38 thing here. There we go. It is called Woke, the Origins, Dynamics, and Implications of an Elite
00:31:45 Ideology. Now, this is not being offered at a Canadian school, not yet, but it is being offered
00:31:50 at the University of Birmingham by a Canadian professor, Eric Kaufman, who joins me now.
00:31:56 Professor, good to talk to you. Thanks for coming on.
00:31:58 Good to be here, Andrew. I should just one slight correction. It's University of Buckingham,
00:32:03 not Birmingham. I'm so sorry. I get my hams. It was all the Thanksgiving talk. I'm getting my 0.94
00:32:08 hams mixed up here. Buckingham, yes. And I should say University of Buckingham is like a very,
00:32:13 well, you've said it's the only free speech university really in the UK.
00:32:18 It is, yeah. I mean, it has a strange origin because it was founded through Margaret Thatcher
00:32:24 And it sort of, you know, even though most of the staff and students still lean left, it's got more viewpoint diversity than you'll find on a typical British campus.
00:32:32 So it's somewhat more hospitable and the leadership is very much in favor of moving it in this direction.
00:32:38 So what is your class about? I mean, obviously, you've got 15 weeks of material here.
00:32:41 I don't expect you to give it all in a few minutes. But what is this course about?
00:32:45 well it really is sort of begins with the intellectual history the you know the how did
00:32:50 we get to this ideology how does it relate to for example socialism liberalism anarchism and these
00:32:56 other isms that go back earlier into the 19th century and then we kind of look at what happens
00:33:02 in the 60s uh how the left shifts you know from class towards identity and and then how that plays
00:33:09 out into our own time i then move on to looking at public opinion data sort of who supports
00:33:16 something like cancelling jk rowling for example i mean it would tend to be younger people would
00:33:20 tend to be is it more female than male is it more left than right and so on and then how this is now
00:33:26 affecting electoral politics uh the culture wars the politics of the culture wars and speech
00:33:32 boundaries uh you know critical race theory all of that and then finally looking at the philosophy
00:33:37 the questions that it raises, free speech versus so-called equal speech. So that's kind of a very
00:33:44 quick and dirty. I mean, it's certainly there on the website. If you go to my Twitter, you can sort
00:33:48 of see a link. But we're going to do this sort of very empirically. I mean, there's a lot of
00:33:54 academics. There are thousands of papers on the populist right, lots of courses on it.
00:33:59 I've taught in that myself, but there's nothing on the woke left because it's just too uncomfortable
00:34:03 to do. One thing I'm curious about, I years ago sought out to write a book about political
00:34:10 correctness, and I did years of research on this and just ultimately, for a number of reasons,
00:34:15 walked away from it. But one of the things that I found in doing that is that political correctness
00:34:20 as a word or as a term, when it was first introduced, was described and used by the
00:34:27 people that wanted political correctness, and they wanted to be politically correct. And then
00:34:30 it morphed and was only used by people that were decrying it and criticizing it. And am I correct
00:34:37 in saying that woke has kind of gone through a bit of a similar phase where it was introduced as
00:34:41 a very positive, favorable concept by the woke people? And now they've sort of backed off of the
00:34:46 word and it's only really being used by people that are calling out wokeness. Yeah, you're 0.64
00:34:51 absolutely right about that. I mean, what I would say, I mean, there's no question people abuse the
00:34:56 word and stretch the word to mean anything they don't like. Well, some people just use it as a
00:35:01 stand-in for left, which I don't think is entirely accurate. No, I don't think it's accurate and is
00:35:07 somewhat of a way of devaluing what is actually quite a useful, I think, empirically tight
00:35:13 social scientific term. So I have a one-sentence definition. It's the making sacred of historically
00:35:22 marginalized race, gender, and sexual identity groups. So once you erect these groups as sacred,
00:35:29 anything that might offend the most hypothetically sensitive member of one of these groups
00:35:34 is blasphemy or criticizing anything that's done in the name of helping
00:35:40 such as these groups such as anti-racism or trans affirmation or whatever. If you criticize
00:35:46 any such movement that is also a violation of the sacred and therefore cause for excommunication or
00:35:52 cancellation so there's this very religious quality to it and i think it is a useful term 0.99
00:35:57 and it describes uh something that is very real and has emerged strongly in our time
00:36:02 based on that definition can wokeness be separated from victimhood and this veneration of victims
00:36:08 It very much, it springs from the victimhood culture. So the wider ideology is based on,
00:36:18 you might call it a victimhood culture, and sort of emotional safety, emotional trauma prevention
00:36:24 is sort of the mantra. But of course, that is broader than just race, gender, sexuality could
00:36:31 apply to disability, even potentially class in theory would fit into the victimhood model. But
00:36:38 there is a focus very specifically in wokeness on just race, gender, and sexuality. I think the fat 0.97
00:36:44 stuff, the class stuff, that doesn't have the same pickup. It doesn't seem like there's as much
00:36:49 energy in canceling and pushing for DEI along those axes. So I think it's much more specific
00:36:55 to these three categories. Is your view that the woke, whoever they are, and maybe that's something
00:37:03 you want to define, do they see wokeness as a tool, as a vehicle to get to where they want,
00:37:07 or is it the destination? I think it is the destination. Jonathan Haidt has his moral
00:37:15 foundations theory, and there's really two foundations. One is equal outcomes. So all
00:37:21 identity groups that could be black, white, male, female, et cetera, should have equal outcomes in
00:37:27 terms of income, in terms of honors and esteem and so on. That would be one prong of it. The
00:37:32 other prong is, again, this microscopic, even microaggression, sort of harm protection. So
00:37:39 anything that might offend or upset in any way, somebody's emotional state must be prevented,
00:37:45 which is why they're going after free speech, for example, which speech which might offend,
00:37:49 right? So I think there is something real there and is rooted in these two moral foundations,
00:37:56 but just taken to the extreme. Your description of it as making sacred,
00:38:01 I think is incredibly appropriate because a lot of people have seen that religious-like fervor
00:38:05 from people who, again, would identify as fundamentally anti-religion in a lot of cases
00:38:10 and would talk about the harm of religion against certain groups. And it's interesting how blind
00:38:17 they are to what this does to several groups and people as well. And I guess I wanted to ask a
00:38:23 little bit about that because by making it sacred, you have to elevate it above other things that
00:38:29 have had a level of sanctity in society. Freedom of speech is a notable one. I mean, it used to be
00:38:34 that even people who are fairly progressive would still operate within the parameters of free speech
00:38:40 is important. And, you know, they'd use free speech to make their point. That was, I think,
00:38:44 the dominant force you'd saw in progressives for much of the last 50 years. And now freedom of
00:38:50 speech no longer has any sacred value. In fact, it's viewed as an evil that needs to be dealt
00:38:56 within society by a lot of these people. Yeah, and that's been documented in opinion survey data
00:39:03 in the U.S. going back to the 70s, that there's been a shift from kind of a more moral relativism
00:39:08 toleration to moral absolutism in young people. But I don't want to, I think it's a mistake to
00:39:16 see this as completely new. And I think, you know, if you talk about political correctness in the 80s
00:39:21 and 90s. Was it acceptable to offend minority groups in the late 80s and early 90s? No,
00:39:30 is the answer. They had speech codes at US universities. I actually think you already had
00:39:35 a pretty restrictive speech climate. The doors were kind of, I think, pretty wide open. And
00:39:40 that's why you did see episodes of cancel culture. You know, the UBC political science department in
00:39:46 the mid-1990s was just one episode. It just was less frequent because you didn't have social media
00:39:51 to organize flash mobs. If I could jump in though, Professor, I feel that what happened there,
00:39:58 you're right, the acceptability was already established or the unacceptability. I feel
00:40:02 what happened is the threshold was changed, is that what a fence was, was redefined. And I wonder
00:40:08 if that's the goalpost shift that leads us to where we are now as well, the same idea. I mean,
00:40:13 being a racist has been out of vogue for many decades, but the definition of racism has changed
00:40:20 a lot in that time. True, true. I mean, I think you're right. You know, the idea of hiking being
00:40:25 racist and punctuality being a white thing, you know, that there's no question that they've taken
00:40:30 it to the next level. The only thing I would say, though, is you can find examples, you know,
00:40:36 in the mid 70s, evolutionary psychologists who argued that genetics mattered. And this wasn't
00:40:43 race IQ. This was just genetics mattering for social behavior. They were ostracized. They had
00:40:47 open letters. So I'm, even though you're right that there are some new, there's been some new
00:40:54 conceptual stretching, I think quite a bit of that had already occurred. And certainly in academia,
00:40:59 if you look at the published work already in the 70s and 80s and 90s, you know, critical race theory
00:41:06 dates from the 70s, you know, Chris Rufo in his book talks about this. So these ideas were already
00:41:12 there. It's just that they hadn't spread as widely. And yes, there were some innovations,
00:41:18 the trans thing is new, but I would stress the continuities more than the discontinuities.
00:41:24 Social media is more quantitative scaling up rather than a qualitative change in my view.
00:41:30 One of the challenges that I would have, and again, I'm basing this off of how I've used woke,
00:41:37 not necessarily the parameters that you've set for it, is that there's a prevailing theme in it,
00:41:42 and there are commonalities in how it's applied. But is it coherent enough to be an ideology in
00:41:51 the sense that do the woke apply the rules they set equally, in your view? If someone's committed
00:41:57 to wokeness, do you find that they're consistently applying it, or do you think that there are
00:42:02 inconsistencies in that? Well, I think if you narrow it to the sort of sacred categories,
00:42:07 then it's pretty consistently applied. So any time there is a disparity in outcome between
00:42:13 white and black, let's say in terms of entering Harvard or in terms of wealth,
00:42:18 they will be on top of that. If there are more black people being incarcerated or excluded from 0.77
00:42:25 school, they'll be on top of that. Now, what they won't apply that to is, for example, 0.75
00:42:30 So if Jews are doing better than Gypsy and Irish travelers here in Britain or if West Indians or sort of East West Africans are doing better than West Indians within the black group, they don't care about those distinctions.
00:42:45 So because those distinctions aren't the sacred ones. So I'd say they're being inconsistent in ignoring a lot of different social categories where there are inequalities of outcome.
00:42:55 but on their sacred categories, I think they're applying those fairly consistently. So the rules
00:43:03 are simply, yeah. So I'm just like, look, in Canada, as you're well aware, in the last few
00:43:08 weeks, we've had the boiling point in the parental rights movement, where we've had trans activists
00:43:13 and Muslim activists that are in conflict. And generally speaking, I'd say the woke left has
00:43:18 sided with the trans activists, despite the Muslims being their sacred cows for much of the last 0.97
00:43:23 20 years. So I'm just curious with your approach to this issue, how you would explain that
00:43:28 phenomenon? Well, there is a sort of hierarchy of oppression points. You know, there's the top
00:43:34 of the totem pole, and then there's the white male cis hetero type at the very bottom of the
00:43:39 totem pole. Yeah, I don't stand a chance. No. So the question that is, right, is who's got more
00:43:44 points? Is it the Muslims who have more points or is it trans who have more points? And I think it's 1.00
00:43:49 as simple as trans having more points. It's just like trans gets more points than feminist 0.97
00:43:55 and female. And I think it's as simple as that, is who is seen as punching up and who's seen as
00:44:02 punching down. I don't think it's more complicated really than that. And of course, what matters are
00:44:08 those sacred categories, race, gender, sexuality, and it's just who has more points.
00:44:12 So I'm just curious, and I don't know the student profile at the University of Buckingham,
00:44:16 But what would you love to see in your class? What's the enrollment profile of your class you'd absolutely love here? Because I think secretly, or maybe openly, you might like the really like woke, lefty, non-binary with the purple hair student in there, having it out with someone who loves free speech and all of that.
00:44:33 Yeah, exactly. I think it would be ideally it would be 50 50. I mean, a lot of the data we have from fire in the US would show, you know, when you have a roughly 50 50 mix, you've got the least self censorship going on. I'd only want you know, I would want somebody who is was woke and I want plenty of left wingers. I don't want it to be an echo chamber. If we're going to get somebody in there who was woke, but who was willing to defend it in a Socratic style to say, well, I think, you know, equality, Trump's liberty and
00:45:03 this is important for human flourishing, or the speech
00:45:06 boundaries should be much tighter than they are. I mean, I
00:45:08 think that kind of debate would be really interesting. The
00:45:11 problem, of course, is when you get people who just stick a
00:45:15 label on others and think, okay, they're toxic, and I'm going to
00:45:17 be polluted by hanging out with them. And so no, we have to no
00:45:20 platform. I mean, once you're into that or emotional blackmail,
00:45:24 then then it's not productive.
00:45:26 Yeah, or someone who feels unsafe in the climate of ideas,
00:45:30 which is not an issue I hope you'll have to contend with in your new university home here.
00:45:36 Professor Eric Coffin, I wish you the best with the class.
00:45:40 Maybe we'll find some great essays you've done that we can publish over at True North for some of your students.
00:45:46 But thank you so much for coming on.
00:45:48 Thanks, Andrew.
00:45:49 All right. Thank you.
00:45:50 That was Professor Eric Coffin.
00:45:51 What a great idea.
00:45:52 And again, I mean, it's like there's like a class in the U.S. where you can do like the history of Taylor Swift or something.
00:45:57 So, which might actually be enjoyable, but I'd rather do a deep dive academically and empirically into wokeness.
00:46:05 That's more my bag than T-Swizzle.
00:46:07 But nevertheless, hope you all have a wonderful, wonderful Thanksgiving weekend.
00:46:11 We will talk to you all on Tuesday with Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show's return.
00:46:16 This is The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:46:18 Thank you, God bless, and good day to you all.
00:46:20 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:46:23 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.
00:46:53 We'll be right back.
00:47:23 We'll be right back.